Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Purpose......................................................................................................................................... 2
Primary Objectives ............................................................................................................ 2
Operational Objectives...................................................................................................... 2
Definitions ..................................................................................................................................... 2
Legislation..................................................................................................................................... 3
Responsibilities ............................................................................................................................. 4
1. Associate Vice-President (Facilities and Planning)
2. Facilities Management Managers
3. Supervisors
4. University of Regina employees
5. Facilities Management staff
6. Contractors and their employees
7. Health and Safety, Human Resources
APPENDICES:
Appendix 1 – Summary of Restricted & Confined Space Entry Requirements........................... 10
Appendix 2 – Confined Space Entry Work Plan ......................................................................... 11
Appendix 3 – Written Entry Plan Requirements.......................................................................... 21
Appendix 4 – Hazardous Confined Space – Detailed Hazard Assessment................................ 23
Appendix 5 – Common Confined Space Hazards ...................................................................... 29
Appendix 6 – Required and Recommended Confined Space Hazard Controls.......................... 37
Appendix 7 – Confined Space Rescue ....................................................................................... 44
Appendix 8 – Legislation............................................................................................................. 45
PURPOSE
Primary Objectives
1. Maintain, as a minimum standard, compliance with all relevant statutes, regulations and
standards of regulatory authorities representing occupational health and safety
2. Ensure that safety and accident prevention are an integral part of planning, operations
and University activities
3. Promote safe working practices and awareness through training, education and the
implementation of general safety policies and workplace specific procedures, including an
Occupational Health and Safety Program
Operational Objectives
1. To provide information on where confined spaces exist on the University campus
2. To provide information on the level of hazard that exists in the identified confined spaces
as a result of space restrictions, design, location, contents or work activities that create a
dangerous atmosphere
3. To implement procedures that will prevent unauthorized entry into confined spaces
4. To protect the health and safety of those who must enter confined spaces on University
property
DEFINITIONS
Confined Space
Pursuant to The Occupational Health and Safety Regulations,1996, “confined space” means
an enclosed or partially enclosed space that:
(i) is not primarily designed or intended for human occupancy, except for the purpose of
performing work; and
(ii) has restricted means of entrance and exit.”
If you enter the confined space through a standard sized door and go down into the space using
a normal staircase, then the means of entrance and exit is not restricted. Therefore the space is
not a confined space.
Examples of confined space include spaces that can only be entered or exited:
• through a hatch,
• by a ladder,
• by a spiral staircase with a tight radius such that a standard sized stretcher could not
be used to remove an injured employee, or
• by crawling
The regulations define “hazardous confined space” to mean “a confined space that is or may
become hazardous to a worker entering the confined space due to:
(i) the design, construction or atmosphere of the confined space
(ii) the materials or substances in the confined space
(iii) the work activities or processes used in the confined space
(iv) any other conditions relating to the confined space
Some of the hazards that may be present which may render a confined space a hazardous
confined space, include:
• pipes (sewer, steam, gas, etc.) that can make the space hazardous if they burst;
• unexpected atmospheric hazards (methane, hydrogen sulphides, or oxygen deprived
environment) resulting from soil conditions, leaks, or inadequate ventilation,
• insulated pipes in poor condition which may contain asbestos or pose a burn hazard,
• high voltage conductors,
• moving parts of machinery
• stacked or stored material that pose a crushing/engulfment hazard
A confined space that has no apparent hazards may become a hazardous confined space
because of the work activity taking place within the confined space. For example, welding,
painting or work with substances that produce toxic fumes or pose a risk of explosion.
Train means to give information and explanation to an employee with respect to a particular
subject matter and require a practical demonstration that the employee has acquired knowledge
or skill related to the subject matter.
Employee Trained in Confined Space Entry means a University employee who has
successfully completed a training course in confined space entry approved by the AVP Facilities
and Planning.
Competent means possessing knowledge, experience and training to perform a specific duty.
Bump test means a functional test of a gas monitor that involves a brief exposure of the
monitor to a concentration of gas(ses) in excess of the lowest alarm set-point for each sensor
for the purpose of verifying sensor and alarm operation.
Hot Work means any activity that creates sparks, or involves heat, or open flames. Among the
activities covered by the hot work procedure are welding, braising, soldering, abrasive wheel
cutting, paint burning, tarring and thermal bonding.
Entry (vb) means the entry of any part of a person’s body into a confined space.
Supervisor means a person who is authorized by the University to oversee or direct the work of
employees.
Sections 266 through 274 apply to confined spaces. The legislation can be located on-line at
http://www.qp.gov.sk.ca/documents/English/Regulations/Regulations/O1-1R1.pdf
Sections 266-274 are located in Appendix IX of the procedures.
RESPONSIBILITIES
4. University of Regina employees who are responsible to enter and perform work in a
confined space will:
• work in accordance with the University’s confined space entry program.
6. Contractors and their employees required to perform work in a confined space will:
• work in accordance with the University’s confined space entry program.
• notify the Project Manager, or other person designated by the Project Manager, prior to
commencing work in a confined space.
The University of Regina has categorized the types of restricted and confined spaces into the
following three categories.
The location of all Category III Hazardous Confined Space spaces have been mapped by
Facilities Management, Production and are identified in Red on the confined spaces maps.
Facilities Management will lock and secure restricted areas against entry by unauthorized
persons and ensure adequate signs are in place. Staff members given keys to certain
restricted space areas are responsible to ensure that only authorized persons have access
and that persons entering with their key know and understand they may not proceed into the
restricted space beyond their authorized area of access.
Except where entry is for the purpose of travel through or brief inspection, the following
procedures should be employed when working in a low hazard restricted area:
1. If you are alone let a co-employee or Work Control know where you will be and indicate
how long you intend to be in the area
2. Upon leaving the area, immediately notify your contact person to let them know you
have left the space or area
3. Whenever possible carry a two way radio or cell phone
4. Prior to commencing work in the restricted space, assess the hazards in consultation
with your supervisor and implement controls designed to eliminate or minimize the risks.
Hazard controls include use of suitable equipment (e.g. ladders of appropriate height),
design of and adherence to safe work procedures and using required personal protective
equipment. It is recommended that the hazard assessment be in writing
In the case of restricted space marked in Green on the Confined Space Map, entry is only
permitted by persons specifically trained and authorized to enter the space.
Where entry is for the purpose of performing work then a written hazard assessment in
accordance with Appendix 3 must be completed by a Supervisor. A copy of the hazard
assessment shall be kept at the work site, reviewed and evaluated by the entrants.
Entry into a non hazardous confined space in order to perform work is not permitted until:
1. A hazard assessment is completed and an assessment made by the Supervisor that the
space is not and will not as a consequence of the work being performed, become a
hazardous confined space.
2. Hazards identified in the hazard assessment are addressed (i.e. safe work processes,
appropriate PPE)
3. Arrangements/procedures are in place to communicate or check up on the employees
while in the space from time to time.
4. Arrangements/procedures are in place for the removal of an employee who has become
injured or incapacitated while in the confined space.
When an employee is concerned that the atmosphere in a non hazardous confined space
may not be safe, an employee may require that prior to entry, the air be tested by a
competent person using a properly calibrated and bump tested Multi-Gas Monitor.
When it is determined that the confined space is or may become a hazardous confined
space, then no one shall be permitted to enter until an Entry Permit has been issued by a
Facilities Management Manager or other person designated by the AVP (Facilities and
Planning) as being competent to issue a Hazardous Confined Space Entry Permit that
meets the requirements of Appendix 3.
No Hazardous Confined Space Entry Permit shall be issued to University staff where the
use of a Self Contained Breathing Apparatus (SCBA) is part of either the entry or rescue
plan, or otherwise when the atmosphere in the space can become immediately dangerous
to life or health in the event of a respirator or ventilation failure.
No person may enter a Category III- Hazardous Confined Space unless a Hazardous
Confined Space Entry Permit that meets the requirements of Appendix 3 has been issued
by a Facilities Management Manager or other person designated by the AVP (Facilities and
Planning) as being competent to issue a Hazardous Confined Space Entry Permit.
Prior to commencing work, the contractor shall provide the University with a copy of its
written entry plan that meets the requirements of sections Part XVIII and 369 of The
Occupational Health and Safety Regulations, 1996.
A copy of the written entry plan must be readily available at the entrance of the confined
space. A copy of the plan must also be centrally filed with Facilities Management.
Section 272 of The Occupational Health and Safety Regulations, 1996 requires that where an
employee will be required or permitted to enter a hazardous confined space, a written confined
space entry plan must be implemented that is readily available at the entrance of the hazardous
confined space. The regulation requires that the entry plan include nine separate items.
The items are:
“(a) the tests or measurements necessary to monitor any oxygen deficiency or enrichment or
the presence and hazardous concentration of flammable or explosive substances:
(b) the identification of any other hazards that may be present in the hazardous confined
space and may put the health and safety of employees at risk;
(c) the means, if any, of isolating the hazardous confined space;
(d) the means, if any, of ventilating the hazardous confined space;
(e) the procedures to enter, work in and exit from the hazardous confined space safely;
(f) the availability, location and proper use of personal protective equipment;
(g) the rescue procedures to be followed, including the number and duties of personnel and
the availability, location and proper use of equipment;
(h) the means to maintain effective communication with an employee who has entered the
hazardous confined space; and
(i) the availability, location and proper use of any other equipment that an employee may
need to work safely in the hazardous confined space.”
At the University of Regina, this means that a written entry plan must be prepared for entrance
into any Category III hazardous confined space, and for any Category II confined space where
work is conducted.
All University employees who are required to work in confined spaces, as well as those
University supervisors who authorize work performed in confined spaces shall receive
appropriate training. Instruction shall include the following:
In addition, any University Employee who may be required to enter a Category II or III confined
space to perform a rescue shall receive appropriate training in confined space rescue.
Hazard Assessment
Prior to any entry into a High Hazard Restricted Space or a Moderate to High Hazard Confined
Space, a written Hazard Assessment must first be completed by a competent person that
identifies the potential hazards in the space. Written Hazard Assessments must also be
completed when work (other than inspection) is to be performed in a confined space.
NON-COMPLIANCE
Failure to meet the Confined Space requirements shall be grounds for disciplinary action or
immediate termination of the contract at the discretion of the University.
INJURIES/EXPOSURES
Category II ***Work Notify Supervisor on Yes Awkward entry and exit, that
– Non- entrance/exit may require special rescue
Hazardous plans.
Confined Intermittent check by
Space co-worker Task Generated Hazards.
Cell/Radio Required
*Only Facilities Management staff, persons accompanied by Facilities Management staff, contractors
authorized to enter certain spaces, or University staff authorized to enter certain restricted space areas,
may enter a confined or restricted space and then only in the areas they are authorized to enter.
**No entry by University staff is permitted in spaces with atmospheres that require SCBA or that would
pose an immediate threat to life or health in the event of a respirator or mechanical ventilation failure.
***Work, for the purposes of this document, includes any use of equipment, tools, protective equipment or
special procedures (e.g. Lock-out), while in the process of inspecting, maintaining, or repairing
equipment.
Note: This document must be posted at the point of entry and remain in place until the
work is complete, or points 2 or 4 above occur. If the job exceeds one shift this
form is to be given to the next supervisor who will review it with the crew coming
on.
Classification of Work
Maintenance
Cleaning
Inspection
Other:
Last known substance in the confined Space (obtain and attach MSDS if required):
Communication
Radio
Cell phones (list numbers)
Voice
Horn signals
Hand signals
Other:
Authorized Entrants
Location:
Supervisor’s name(s):
Communication Procedure:
Date: _________________________________
dd/mmm/yy
Project:
Atmospheric Testing
N/A
Test frequency:
Continuous
30 minutes
1 hour
2 hours
4 hours
If the confined space is vacated for a period of time greater than 30 minutes, an atmospheric
test must be completed before re-entry.
Ventilation Procedure:
Authorized Supervisor(s)
I certify that all known precautions have been taken and all necessary equipment is
provided for safe entry and work in this hazardous confined space.
Rescue Team:
Primary:
Secondary:
I CERTIFY THAT ALL ENTRANTS LISTED HAVE VACATED THIS CONFINED SPACE.
Project:
Note: If the confined space is vacated for longer than 30 minutes, it must be tested
again before re-entry.
“(a) the tests or measurements necessary to monitor any oxygen deficiency or enrichment or
the presence and hazardous concentration of flammable or explosive substances;
The written plan should describe how the atmosphere is to be tested and measured, prior to
entry and prior to any re-entry. The plan must also describe how the atmosphere will be
monitored during the entry. Section 10.3 discusses air monitoring of this program discusses
the methods for testing
The regulations require that where ventilation is required to reduce or eliminate a hazard the
testing must take place:
• before a worker enters the space.
• where all workers have vacated, before a worker re-enters the space.
• on the request of a worker required to enter the space; and
• continuously when any condition in the confined space may change and put the worker’s
health or safety at risk.
(b) the identification of any other hazards that may be present in the
hazardous confined space and may put the health or safety of workers at risk;
Completion of the Confined Space Entry Work Plan (Appendix 2) will help identify the
hazards within the confined space, including those generated by the work activity.
When a Hazard has been identified on the Confined Space Entry Work Plan, a description
of the Hazard and the measures in place to control that hazard must appear on the Entry
Plan.
The completion of the Confined Space Entry Work Plan and the assessment and selection
of the hazard controls in place to address the Hazard must be completed by a competent
person. In the case of the University of Regina staff, a competent person is an employee
trained in confined space entry.
Isolate means to physically interrupt or disconnect pipes, lines and sources of energy from a
confined space.
All equipment, energy sources and piping systems in a confined space must be locked out
or isolated if not doing so would put a worker at risk.
The plan should identify all equipment; pipes, lines or energy sources that must be locked
out or isolated and provide a description of the lock out procedures.
The plan should also describe barriers and other devices used to protect the space and
others from persons or other activities in the area that may interfere or be at risk as a
consequence of the confined space entry.
Where toxic or combustible substances are present the plan should describe the method for
purging the substance from the space.
Appendix 6 discusses the methods for purging and ventilating confined spaces.
(e) the procedures to enter, work in and exit from the hazardous confined
space safely;
(f) the availability, location and proper use of personal protective equipment;
Appendix 6 discusses the types of PPE that may be required in a confined space.
(g) the rescue procedures to be followed, including the number and duties of
personnel and the availability, location and proper use of equipment;
(h) the means to maintain effective communication with a worker who has
entered the hazardous confined space; and
The University of Regina requires that an attendant will be stationed at the entrance of a
hazardous confined space during entry. The plan should describe how communication will
be maintained between the attendant and the entrants. Means of communication include
voice, hand signals, radios or other electronic means.
(i) the availability, location and proper use of any other equipment that a
worker may need to work safely in the hazardous confined space.
The equipment needed will be dependent upon the circumstances of the space and the
work being performed and other hazards identified in the Confined Space Entry Work Plan.
A copy of the written entry plan must be readily available at the entrance of the confined space.
A copy of the plan must also be centrally filed with Facilities Management.
A. ATMOSPHERE
Check if HAZARD EXPLANATORY NOTES METHOD OF TEST EFFECTS OF HAZARD EXAMPLES
present
3
Explosive Before entering confined space, Combustible gas detector - Explosion / Fire/ burns / 1. Methane (or natural gas) CH4 -
Atmosphere/Explo tests for presence of an explosive explosive gases must be multiple injuries / death sources - gas line leaks, decaying
sive Flammable atmosphere must be done. It should monitored by equipment that matter. May be found adjacent to
Material be noted that air-borne dust from can detect the lower land fill sites; backed up, sluggish
grain, fine ground metals or other explosives limit (L.E.L.) and sewers.
materials can form an explosive upper explosive limit (U.E.L.). 2. Gasoline and other solvents -
atmosphere. Explosive gases may Residues may have to be Storage tanks and adjacent areas,
displace oxygen. Note: Oxygen disturbed to allow for release sewer systems proximity to
enrichment or deficiency can cause of explosive gases. pipelines, accidental spills may have
error in combustible gas detector definite odor.
readings.
Oxygen Deficient Deficiency - Acceptable breathing Oxygen detection monitor. Could result in slowing Oxygen (02) deficiency can be
Environment air contains between 19.5%-23.4% down of pulse rate, caused by displacement by other
oxygen Air containing less than disorientation, gases, or by biological or chemical
acceptable amounts of oxygen is a unconsciousness, death. reactions (rusting, burning).
hazardous atmosphere.
Oxygen Enriched Enrichment - An atmosphere that Oxygen detection meter. Creates explosive Enrichment may be caused by
Environment contain more than the acceptable Note: Some equipment atmosphere, increases rate improper blanking of oxygen lines,
amount of oxygen (23.0%). Oxygen incapable of detecting for of chemical reaction. leaking fuel gas, welding equipment,
enrichment can cause an error in oxygen enrichment. ventilation with oxygen instead of air
explosive meter readings.
Toxic Gases, Testing with appropriate detection Monitors - specific testers Can cause euphoria / 1. Carbon Monoxide (CO) -
Vapour equipment shall be undertaken to must be used for specific toxic disorienting effect, colorless, odorless, tasteless and
determine the presence of toxic gases, e.g. H2S monitoring. It drowsiness, headaches, very poisonous. Commonest source
gas(es) to create and maintain a may be necessary to disturb weakness, injury, disability, - internal combustion engines and
safe environment. residue / sludge to allow for death. decomposition of organic matter.
B. SAFETY HAZARDS
Check if HAZARD EXPLANATORY NOTES METHOD OF TEST EFFECTS OF HAZARD EXAMPLES
present
3
Entry/Exit (Access Openings that are small, narrow or Visual identification of Delayed rescue 1. Exits at height that could cause
/ Egress) otherwise difficult to negotiate can obstructions that could falls.
be a serious hazard. Where self- interfere with normal Injury, disability, death 2. Constricted openings
contained breathing apparatus is movement or emergency 3. Angled openings
being used, openings must be of a rescue. 4. Exits into traffic and machinery
size to allow worker with equipment 5. Exits at deep depths.
properly worn to pass through.
Access openings less than 700 mm
(28”) are not recommended.
Inadequate Lack of adequate ventilation may Monitoring (anemometer, Explosion, disease, Improper ventilation can result in:
Ventilation cause a build-up of contaminants smoke tubes for air irritation, injury, disability, 1. Oxygen levels variation
etc. Ventilation systems can movement). Toxic monitors death 2. Build up of toxic gases, vapours,
introduce hazards into the work may also be necessary to dusts, mists, fumes (smoke).
area, e.g. carbon monoxide (CO) ensure good quality air. 3. Introduction of biologic agents,
fumes. toxic gases, explosive gases.
Machinery / Make sure equipment is Visual and function testing Injury, disability, death Drive belts, augers, paddles,
Mechanical immobilized (de-energized) so that scrapers, agitators and pumps
Equipment it will not be a hazard to workers
Piping / Contents of pipes and supply lines if Monitoring, visual Chemical poisoning, Steamlines, liquid distribution lines,
Distribution allowed to enter a confined space drowning, burns, injury, feed mills and cement plants
Systems can create a life threatening disability, death
situation for workers.
Temperature Temperature extremes, hot or Thermometer, Heat Stress 1. Cold - Frost bite, loss 1. Working in freezers, extreme
Extremes cold, have definite health and - Wet Bulb Globe of coordination, cold climate conditions.
safety hazards, as well as Thermometer (WBGT) hypothermia, disability, 2. Working in boilers, super-
having a limiting effect on the death. heated areas (cooling towers),
ability of a worker to adequately 2. Heat - heat areas that have steam/ heat
perform tasks. exhaustion, heat stress, distribution pipes running
disorientation, death. through work areas.
Humidity High humidity can aggravate Hygrometer Can cause slips, falls, 1. Boiler rooms
several conditions: physical discomfort, heat 2. Digesters
1. Visibility exhaustion, affect 3. Freezers
2. Can cause all types of performance of tasks.
surfaces to become slippery.
3. Accelerate Heat loss.
4. Increase chill effect.
Noise If sound levels exceed 80 DBA Sound level meters Distraction, stress, Sources include operating
then work practices shall disorientation, equipment, such as jack
conform to requirements of communication hammers, pumps, grinders, other
current regulations respecting problems, hearing loss. work procedures.
Hearing Conservation and
Noise Control in Workplaces.
Height Fixed Ladders more than 6 Measurement Fall from heights
metres high must be equipped
with platforms or fall arrest Falling objects from or
devices into work area.
Vibration Whole body vibration is a Vibration meter White finger disease, Jack hammers, impact hammers/
"general stressor" affecting disorientation, vertigo, drills, shakers.
multiple body parts/ organs. circulation and nervous
system disorders.
Confined spaces vary widely, both in their physical characteristics and in the reasons for which
they are entered. Since the type and magnitude of the hazards posed to entrants varies from
space to space it is essential that individual differences be thoroughly evaluated to assure that
the unique hazard posed by each space is adequately controlled.
It is also important to remember that conditions can change quite rapidly in a confined space
and that activities which seem safe when conducted in an open space can become quite
hazardous when performed in a confined space.
The following are the general categories of hazards which may be encountered in confined
spaces.
• Atmospheric Hazards
• Mechanical and Electrical Hazards
• General Safety (means of access/egress, trips, falls, hot, cold, etc.)
• Engulfment hazard
Oxygen
Oxygen can become a hazard when its concentration in the air is too low to support normal
human breathing or when it is so high that it becomes explosive.
Oxygen deficiency
Oxygen deficiency is probably the most common type of confined space hazard.
When the concentration of oxygen falls below 19.5 per cent by volume, it begins to affect human
health. At first, this may result in impaired judgment. When the concentration falls below 16
percent, the health hazards become more serious. Death can occur when the oxygen content
of the air falls to 6 percent or less. The symptoms of oxygen deficiency may be aggravated if the
person is engaged in strenuous physical activity.
In confined spaces oxygen deficiency may result from either consumption or displacement of
the oxygen present. Activities or processes which can “consume” oxygen include combustion
(welding and cutting torches), decomposition of organic matter (rotting food or plant life) or
oxidation of metals (rusting). Oxygen can be displaced when inert gases such as nitrogen,
carbon dioxide, helium or steam are used to purge a space of residual chemicals, gases or
vapours.
Oxygen deficiency usually develops over time but may occur very rapidly.
Oxygen Enrichment
Oxygen enrichment is the term used to describe a situation where the oxygen concentration is
greater than 22%. It represents a serious fire hazard. An oxygen enriched atmosphere can
cause hair, clothing and other flammable materials to ignite from their own friction and to burn
violently. In addition oxygen enriched atmospheres also permit flammable gases and vapours
to ignite over a much wider range of concentrations.
Oxygen enrichment can result from improper blanking of lines or leaking fuel/gas, or where pure
oxygen has been improperly used instead of air for ventilation, or to power pneumatic hand
tools under the mistaken belief that oxygen and air are the same thing. The leakage of pure
oxygen from oxy-acetylene welding hoses is a common cause of oxygen enrichment.
Fuel
Liquids and solids become combustible when they vaporize to provide fuel and then mix with
the air which provides oxygen for combustion. Substances which vaporize easily are called
volatile. The higher the temperature, the greater the propensity of a volatile substance to emit
vapours. However some liquids can be volatile at low temperature.
The degree of volatility of a liquid is measured by its flash point. The flash point of a flammable
liquid is the lowest temperature at which it can form an ignitable mixture with air. At this
temperature the vapor may cease to burn when the source of ignition is removed. A slightly
higher temperature, the fire point, is defined at which the vapor continues to burn after being
ignited. Neither of these parameters is related to the temperatures of the ignition source or of
the burning liquid, which are much higher.
Some vapours have flash points as low as -45°Celsius, while others are as high as +40°
Celsius. This information is available from material safety data sheets. However, MSDS figures
were obtained under controlled laboratory conditions. Flash points may differ in actual confined
space environments. Therefore, the flash point number of a substance can be used only as a
guide.
Here are some other common substances that can cause explosions or fires in confined
spaces:
• Acetylene gas from leaking welding equipment
• Methane gas and hydrogen sulfide (H2S) gas produced by rotting organic wastes in
sewers or tanks
• Hydrogen gas produced by contact between aluminum or galvanized metals and
corrosive liquids
• Wood, grain or coal dusts
• Solvents such as acetone, ethanol, toluene, turpentine, and xylene, which may have
been introduced into the space through spills or by improper use or disposal
Other sources of fuel could include carbon monoxide, natural gas, propane, gasoline, alcohol,
paint, varnish, lacquer, grease or wood products.
Oxygen
Approximately 16 per cent oxygen by volume is sufficient to support combustion, Since normal
air contains 21 per cent oxygen it is more than sufficient to support combustion. In addition as
noted above, oxygen enrichment can dramatically increase the likelihood of combustion. Some
gases have enough oxygen within their make up to support combustion.
Ignition/Heat
Heat is the third part of the fire triangle. Potential sources of ignition or heat that could be found
in a confined space include open flames, arcs from electrical equipment, hot surfaces, static
electricity and frictional sparks, chemical reactions, compressed gases and lights.
Explosive Limit
The explosive limits refers to the vapour concentration range of a combustible or flammable
material mixed with air that will ignite in the presence of an ignition source. When the vapour
concentration level in the air is too low, ignition will not take place because the mixture is too
METHANE CONTENT
0 – 5 % (LEL) Too Lean
5 – 15 % (UEL) Explosive Range
15% - 100 % Too Rich
Section 369 of The Occupational Health and Safety Regulations, 1996 prohibits workers from
being present in any space where the presence of a flammable or explosive substance is at a
level that is more than 20 % of its LEL. In the case of Methane for example, entrance would be
prohibited if the volume of Methane in the atmosphere was measured above 1%
Toxic Substances/Gases
Toxic substances are found in a wide variety of workplaces, but a confined space is particularly
susceptible to their accumulation in the air. Toxins include vapours and gases as well as
airborne particles and biological material. These toxins may enter the air from substances used
in the workplace, or from outside. Work processes within the confined space such as painting
or welding may also generate toxic substances.
Toxic substances on their own can pose serous hazards. But in a confined space, they become
particularly dangerous because of restricted air circulation. This can lead to dangerous
concentrations of individual toxins. And it can contribute to the mixing of substances that are
even more dangerous in combination than on its own. The problem is compounded by the fact
that the worker may not know what substances are present or in what combination.
Asphyxiates
Asphyxiates are gases which can cause asphyxiation by either displacing the oxygen in the
atmosphere or interfering with the body’s ability to use oxygen. Those gases that are
physiologically inert (i.e. produce no effect on the body) and are present in sufficient quantity to
displace the air and therefore an adequate oxygen supply are called simple asphyxiates. Some
examples of simple asphyxiates and their characteristics are:
• Nitrogen: Nitrogen is often used to purge vessels or confined spaces of other harmful
substances. It is odorless and is as heavy as air. Any space purged with nitrogen is
unsafe until it is fully ventilated with fresh air.
• Methane: Methane is highly flammable/explosive gas that is lighter than air. It can be
created by decomposition of organic material.
Substances which incapacitate the body’s ability to utilize an adequate oxygen supply are called
chemical asphyxiates. They are deadly poisons. Some examples of common chemical
asphyxiates and their characteristics are:
• Carbon Monoxide: Carbon Monoxide is an odorless, colourless gas that is as heavy as
air. It is the most common chemical asphyxiant encountered. It is formed by incomplete
combustion wherever fuel containing carbon is burned, such as from fires or internal
combustion engines. Carbon monoxide combines chemically with the haemoglobin in
the red blood cells and is absorbed into the blood stream much more readily than
oxygen. This greatly reduces the ability of the blood to carry oxygen. Carbon Monoxide
accumulates in the body. This means that short but frequent exposures can be harmful
or even fatal.
• Hydrogen Sulfide (H2S): H2S is a very toxic, colourless and combustible gas commonly
found in confined spaces such as sewers, oil and gas refineries and anywhere where
organic matter containing sulphur is decomposing. It is heavier than air and at low
concentrations has a very strong foul odor similar to rotten eggs. This odor cannot be
used as an early warning sign however since hydrogen sulfide can quickly desensitize
the sense of smell. After prolonged exposure, even at low concentrations, an individual
may fail to smell the presence of H2S, even if the concentration suddenly increases.
Hydrogen sulfide enters the blood stream and paralyzes the nerve centre in the brain
causing the lungs to cease to function.
The concentration level at which each gas becomes IDHL varies from gas to gas.
Irritants
Some gases found in confined spaces are irritating to the skin, nervous system and respiratory
system even in low concentrations, while at higher levels they cause death. Hydrogen sulfide is
also an irritant because even at low levels it can inflame the mucous membranes and cause a
condition called pulmonary oedema or chemical pneumonia. These are some toxic gases may
also be irritants at lower levels
Asbestos
Asbestos is a naturally occurring mineral which has commonly been used in a variety of
materials due to its strength and unique fire and chemical resistant properties.
Intact and undisturbed asbestos presents no direct health hazard but does present a potential
exposure hazard should asbestos be released and taken into the body. Asbestos fibres have
been proven to cause disease when inhaled or ingested.
Asbestos at the University has been identified by a map. When work is to take place in a
confined space where asbestos is known or suspected to be present, a visual inspection of the
asbestos material should take place to ensure that the surface is encapsulated or otherwise
secured against the release of dust or fibres.
When the asbestos containing surface is in good repair, work in the confined space may take
place provided the asbestos containing surface is guarded or otherwise secured against
damage.
PCBs have been used as coolants and lubricants in transformers, capacitors, and other
electrical equipment because they don't burn easily and are good insulators. The manufacture
of PCBs was stopped in the U.S. in 1977 because of evidence they build up in the environment
and can cause harmful health effects. Products made before 1977 that may contain PCBs
include old fluorescent lighting fixtures and electrical devices containing PCB capacitors, and
old microscope and hydraulic oils.
Where it is suspected that PCPs may be present in a confined space, entry should not take
place until testing and safe work procedures are developed by a competent person. Contact
Health and Safety, HR for assistance.
In addition, wherever there are loose, unstable materials that could trap or bury you, a qualified
person must inspect the space and assess the hazards. Do not enter until the hazard has been
eliminated or controlled. Specific training and safety precautions must be in place before you
enter.
If the hazard cannot be eliminated and there is a danger of falling from a height, a fall protection
system (such as guardrails or a harness and lifeline) may be needed.
Falling Objects
In a confined space there may be the danger of being struck by falling objects such as tools or
equipment, particularly if access ports or workstations are located above workers.
Electric Shock
Electrical shock can result from defective extension cords, welding cables, or other electrical
equipment. Work done in metal enclosures or in wet conditions can be particularly dangerous.
Install ground fault circuit interrupters (GFCIs) or use assured grounding where there may be a
danger of electrical shock. All electrical sources that pose a hazard to workers inside the space
must be locked out following the written lockout procedure for the particular confined space.
Substances must be prevented from entering the confined space through piping. This is done by
“isolating” the piping from the confined space. The method often involves disconnecting the
piping or putting solid plates to block off the piping from the confined space. If valves are used
to isolate the piping, a special double-block system must be used so that nothing can leak into
the confined space.
Poor Visibility
Poor visibility increases the risk of accidents and makes it harder for a standby person to see a
worker who may be in distress. If poor visibility results from inadequate lighting, the light levels
should be increased (although area lighting is not always required). If activities such as
sandblasting or welding result in poor visibility, appropriate ventilation may be needed to reduce
harmful substances in the air.
If portable lighting is used where there may be an explosive atmosphere, the lighting must be
“explosion-proof.” (The Canadian Electrical Code has a description of lighting that is approved
for use in explosive atmospheres.)
Temperature Extremes
Confined spaces may be turned into virtual freezers or saunas if the insie and surrounding
atmospheres are not carefully controlled. There are many confined spaces in winter where
frostbite or life-threatening hypothermia could result from cold conditions.
Extreme heat and high humidity are the hazards frequently experienced in confined spaces.
The space can quickly become overheated by the surrounding environment, heat generated by
the work process or a worker’s body. A worker can experience heat exhaustion or other
symptoms within a relative short time. Other symptoms of cold, heat and humidity –
such as impaired movement, reduced alertness and obscured vision – may cause incidents.
Special precautions are needed before workers enter equipment such as boilers, reaction
vessels, and low-temperature systems. A qualified person must provide these procedures. Allow
enough time for cooling of confined spaces that have been steam-cleaned.
Noise
Noise produced in confined spaces can be particularly harmful because of reflection off walls.
Noise levels from a source inside a small confined space can be up to 10 times greater than the
same source placed outdoors. If the noise levels cannot be reduced, proper hearing protection
must be worn where necessary.
Risk Of Drowning
Confined spaces should be fully drained or dry when entered. Spaces that are not fully drained
or dry may pose a risk of drowning. The risk of drowning in a vat or tank with a large amount of
liquid is easily recognized. However, workers have drowned in small pools of liquid. For
example, insufficient oxygen, the presence of a toxic gas, or a blow to the head can make
workers unconscious. Workers who have fallen face-down into a small pool of water have
drowned.
Biological Agents
Bacteria or viruses may be found in confined spaces where animals have potential access. The
urine and feces of rats, squirrels and pigeons for example, are often deposited in confined
spaces. All such agents are potentially hazardous.
Psychological
Confined spaces typically isolate workers from their normal working environment. Some
individuals find this discomforting. The extent of discomfort can range from mild nervousness to
a serious claustrophobic reaction. Training in confined space entry can deal with these
concerns as well as other elements of confined space safety.
Area Control
Warning signs and barriers should be erected to limit access to the area, especially around
maintenance holes, excavations or trenches.
Before entering a confined space the area surrounding the entrance must be cleared of debris
or objects that could fall into the space. Special attention should be given to anything that might
ignite a combustible gas. Equipment should be brought in only when needed and removed from
the site as soon as work is completed.
Test all vertical levels of the space – the top, middle and bottom. Some contaminants will
stratify, particularly if there is no air movement. If only the top level is tested for example, an
individual may be overcome by a heavier-than-air contaminant (such as hydrogen sulfide) near
the bottom of the space. Also, check as much of the space’s horizontal area as possible. If
any test shows the air to be unsafe, the hazard must be controlled before anyone enters the
space.
All air monitoring results must be recorded on the confined space entry permit.
In addition the temperature inside the space must also be measured and recorded. The multi
gas monitor is only certified for use within an ambient temperature range of -20°C to 40°C.
Safe Atmosphere
No entry may take place without respiratory protection unless the following atmosphere ranges
are recorded:
Oxygen (02): 19.5% - 22%
Carbon Monoxide (CO) 35ppm or less
Hydrogen Sulfide (H2S) 10 ppm or less
Lower Explosive Limit (LEL) 20% LEL or less
No entry may take place in an explosive atmosphere under any circumstances. When the
atmosphere is oxygen deficient, the monitor’s LEL reading may be lower than the actual
concentration.
If there is reason to believe that other toxic gases or airborne contaminants may be present in a
quantity that exceeds the TLV, than testing for these contaminants must also be taken. No
entry may take place without respiratory protection if the test show a contaminant present in
excess of the TLV for that contaminant.
After all persons have left the space for any reason (breaks, lunch, to get tools etc.) the space
must be re-tested prior re-entry into the space and the results recorded on the confined space
entry permit.
Air Monitoring
If air in a confined space becomes unsafe after entry – for example, an equipment alarm goes
off, an occupant feels sick or is acting in a strange manner – stop all work immediately, get out
of the space and evaluate the situation from outside of the space. After evacuation, the hazard
must be controlled possibly through additional ventilation. After control measures are taken, the
air must be re-tested prior to re-entry.
Purging means the initial displacement of hazardous gases and vapours by air, steam or an
inert gas forced deep into the space. Inert gases such as nitrogen, carbon dioxide and argon
are frequently used to purge spaces of flammable atmospheres, while steam and air are used to
remove toxic air contaminants.
Ventilating is the process of continuously moving fresh air through the space. Ventilating helps
maintain an adequate level of oxygen in the space, it dilutes or removes toxic air contaminants
that may be found or generated in the space and it also improves comfort levels by controlling
temperature, humidity and nuisance odours.
There are two types of general ventilation systems. Exhaust ventilation draws contaminated
air out of an area. Supply ventilation blows fresh air in. Supply ventilation is best used to
provide fresh air for the occupants and to control low concentrations of materials that are not
highly toxic. Generally, drawing air out of the space (i.e. exhaust ventilation) is better when the
atmosphere could be flammable or toxic.
It is also important to ensure that the space is being ventilated effectively. The ventilation must
provide constant circulation of fresh air through all areas of the confined space. Two problems
to be aware of and to avoid are 1) the recirculation of contaminated exhaust back into the space
and 2) short-circuiting of the air flow (i.e. when the fresh air moves directly from the inlet to the
exhaust outlet, without reaching the other areas of the space).
Some sample scenarios and Confined Space Ventilation Methods are contained in Diagram 9.3
on the next page.
University staff do not perform confined space entry in environments that are IDHL or when
failure of a respirator may prevent an emergency exit. This type of confined space entry is
performed by competent contractors.
The equipment necessary to protect the respiratory system from hazards can be divided into
three general categories based upon intended use and hazard type. These categories are:
The principal advantage of air line respirators is that they provide wearers with a virtually
unlimited supply of breathing air. However, if the primary air supply fails, the user must be able
to escape from the area. This is usually accomplished by providing an escape SCBA. In the
event of an emergency, the user can disconnect from the air line and breath air supplied from
the escape SCBA. As the name suggests, these devices are intended for escape only.
Employees or other entrants who use respiratory protective devices must be trained in the
proper selection, use, limitations, fit testing, care and maintenance of the respirators.
Pre-Job Meeting
Prior to entry into any moderate to high hazard confined space, the site Supervisor must hold a
pre-job meeting. All persons who participate in the entry procedure in any capacity must be
present at the meeting to review the following:
• Each participant’s roles and responsibilities
• Hazards present or potentially present in the space
• Air test and procedures for monitoring and maintaining a safe atmosphere
• Safe work procedures
• Required PPE
• Method of communication between attendants and entrant
• Process for summoning emergency rescue
• Emergency rescue procedures.
• Other conditions or requirements set out in the confined space entry permit
MSDS
Material Safety Data Sheets (MSDS) must be readily available for any controlled product that is
or may be present in the space.
Equipment and frayed electrical cords must never be used. Electrical tools must be double
insulated and grounded. Ground fault interrupter circuits provide extra protection. Depending
on the work involved, mats, gloves and other insulating equipment may be required. All
equipment should be spark proof and explosion proof. Potential fire hazards such as lighters
and matches must not be allowed into a confined space.
Ladders need to be properly secured and checked before use. Ladders can corrode or become
encrusted with slime causing a safety hazard.
Gas cylinders should not be taken into a confined space unless authorization is given in the
permit. In such cases the shut off valves for the cylinders should be within reach of the
entrants.
In addition, in the case of piping systems requiring lock out the closing of a valve is not an
acceptable lock out. In such cases the pipe must be disconnected, blanked or blinded off. This
means a solid barrier is inserted across the open end of a pipe leading into or out of the
confined space. The barrier must be of sufficient strength and secured in such a way to prevent
leakage of the material into the confined space. When required, a gasket shall be installed on
the pressure side of blanks or blinds and flanges shall be tightened to make the blanks or blinds
effective. Where threaded lines are used, threaded plugs or caps shall be used to blank the
lines.
Hot Work
No hot work is permitted unless a Hot Work Permit has been issued in accordance with the
University’s Hot Work Program.
No hot work or any other spark or flame producing operation is permitted on the interior, exterior
or near the opening of a confined space which may contain toxic, flammable or explosive
gases/vapors or materials until the confined space has been properly ventilated and the source
of the gases/vapors or materials has been removed.
Whenever hot work is being performed in a confined space, adequate ventilation shall be
provided.
Whenever hot work is being performed in a confined space, an appropriate fire extinguisher
shall be located nearby.
All gas welding and cutting equipment used in a confined space shall be pre-tested for leaks
prior to entry in the space.
Welding equipment and cutting torches should not be taken into a confined space until needed
and should be removed immediately after use.
Aerosol containers shall not be used in a confined space when hot work or any other spark-
producing work is being performed. If aerosol material must be used, all hot work and any other
spark producing work must be stopped and the confined space adequately ventilated.
In any of these cases the workers in the confined space are in danger and those outside may
have to perform a rescue. The worker to be rescued may be injured or unconscious,
complicating the rescue procedure.
During an emergency, human nature instinctively insists that we try to help; however, rushing
into a confined space unprotected and unprepared is extremely dangerous and will only
complicate the eventual rescue. Failed rescue attempts account for 60% of confined space
fatalities. It is imperative that only workers who are properly trained and equipped for the task
attempt a rescue. Training for others involved is important in order to prevent panic in
emergency situations.
The rescue plans need to be tailored to the particular space being entered.
When University staff are not prepared, equipped or trained to perform a rescue, such as in
Category III confined spaces then a competent contractor will be engaged to perform the
confined space entry. Rescue from these types of spaces typically require self-contained
breathing apparatus (SCBA), safety harness and rope, mechanical hoists, suitable reviving
apparatus outside the space and a trained rescue team who have performed regular drills in the
emergency rescue procedures.
In Category I or II confined spaces where rescue does not require a SCBA or other equipment
not available at the University, then University staff can be trained and designated to participate
in the rescue. The rescue procedures for such spaces should address:
• the means by which the entrant can call for assistance.
• identification of the rescue team.
• the means by which the attendant can alert the rescue team and call for assistance. At
minimum if rescue team members are not present outside the confined space they
should be notified when an entry is about to commence and remain on call and readily
available during the entry procedure.
• the rescue equipment required. Rescue equipment could include, full body harness,
retrieval lines, sleds and/or stretchers, winches and mechanical lifting devices, flashing
beacons, and blankets.
• the location of the rescue equipment. Generally, it should be readily available outside
the confined space.
• a description of how incapacitated persons will be removed.
• the role of the attendant. As noted above the attendant should not attempt to perform
an emergency rescue unless it is part of the rescue plan and they are adequately trained
and equipped.
• the means of providing emergency first aid. (e.g., location of emergency showers or
eyewash, first aid attendant)
Interpretation
266 In this Part:
(a) “confined space” means an enclosed or partially enclosed space that:
(i) is not primarily designed or intended for human occupancy, except
for the purpose of performing work; and
(ii) has restricted means of entrance and exit;
(b) “hazardous confined space” means a confined space that is or may become hazardous
to a worker entering the confined space due to:
(i) the design, construction or atmosphere of the confined space;
(ii) the materials or substances in the confined space;
(iii) the work activities or processes used in the confined space; or
(iv) any other conditions relating to the confined space;
(c) “isolate” means to physically interrupt or disconnect pipes, lines and sources of energy
from a confined space.
4 Oct 96 cO-1.1 Reg 1 s266.
(2) An employer shall take all reasonably practicable steps to prevent any unauthorized
entry into the confined space.
4 Oct 96 cO-1.1 Reg 1 s268.
(2) In making alterations pursuant to clause (1)(b), an employer shall ensure that the
structural integrity of the confined space is maintained.
4 Oct 96 cO-1.1 Reg 1 s269.
(2) When testing the atmosphere of a confined space pursuant to clause (1)(b), a competent
person shall use appropriate and properly calibrated instruments that have been tested
to ensure that the instruments are capable of operating safely and effectively.
(3) A competent person who carries out the activities described in clauses (1)(a) to (c) shall
prepare a report in writing that sets out:
(a) the results of the assessment, tests and determinations;
(b) recommended special precautions and procedures to reduce the risk to a worker that
are to be followed by a worker entering into, exiting from or occupying the confined
space; and
(c) recommended personal protective equipment to be used by a worker entering the
confined space.
4 Oct 96 cO-1.1 Reg 1 s270.
Entry plan
272(1) Where a worker will be required or permitted to enter a hazardous confined space, an
employer, in consultation with the committee, shall develop a hazardous confined space
entry plan to ensure the health and safety of workers who enter or work in the hazardous
confined space.
(2) A hazardous confined space entry plan must be in writing and must include:
(a) the tests or measurements necessary to monitor any oxygen deficiency or enrichment or
the presence and hazardous concentration of flammable or explosive substances;
(b) the identification of any other hazards that may be present in the hazardous confined
space and may put the health or safety of workers at risk;
(c) the means, if any, of isolating the hazardous confined space;
(d) the means, if any, of ventilating the hazardous confined space;
(e) the procedures to enter, work in and exit from the hazardous confined space safely;
(f) the availability, location and proper use of personal protective equipment;
(g) the rescue procedures to be followed, including the number and duties of personnel and
the availability, location and proper use of equipment;
(h) the means to maintain effective communication with a worker who has entered the
hazardous confined space; and
(i) the availability, location and proper use of any other equipment that a worker may need
to work safely in the hazardous confined space.
(3) An employer shall ensure that the following workers are trained in and implement a
hazardous confined space entry plan:
(a) a worker who is required or permitted to enter the hazardous confined space;
(b) a worker who attends a worker in the hazardous confined space pursuant to subsection
274(4) or (5);
(c) a worker who may be required or permitted to implement the rescue procedures
mentioned in clause (2)(g).
(4) An employer shall make a copy of a hazardous confined space entry plan readily
available at the entrance to the hazardous confined space.
4 Oct 96 cO-1.1 Reg 1 s272.
(2) Where ventilation is used to reduce or eliminate a hazard pursuant to subsection (1), an
employer shall ensure that a competent person tests the atmosphere to determine that
the confined space is safe for entry by a worker:
(a) before a worker enters the confined space;
(b) where all workers have vacated the confined space, before any worker re-enters the
confined space;
(c) on the request of a worker who is required or permitted to enter the confined space; and
(d) continuously where any condition in the confined space may change and put the
worker’s health or safety at risk.
4 Oct 96 cO-1.1 Reg 1 s273.
(2) An employer shall ensure that a competent person continuously monitors the
atmosphere in a hazardous confined space.
(3) An employer shall ensure that a worker is provided with and required to use a respiratory
protective device that meets the requirements of Part VII if:
(a) the airborne concentration for any substance meets or exceeds the permissible
contamination limit mentioned in clause 307(1)(a);
(b) oxygen deficiency or enrichment is detected; or
(c) the airborne concentration of any other substance may be harmful to the worker.
(4) An employer shall ensure that a worker in a hazardous confined space is attended by
and in communication with another worker who:
(a) has been adequately trained in the rescue procedures mentioned in clause 272(2)(g);
(b) is stationed and remains at the entrance to the confined space unless replaced by
another adequately trained worker; and
(c) is equipped with a suitable alarm to summon assistance.
(6) If any flammable or explosive dusts, gases, vapours or liquids are or may be present in a
hazardous confined space, an employer shall ensure that all sources of ignition are
eliminated or controlled.