Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
0LRULêD*RW
67,/,67,&$/,0%,,5201(
(GLWXUD)XQGDêLHL5RP¼QLDGH0¼LQH
(GLWXUáDFUHGLWDWáGH0LQLVWHUXO(GXFDêLHLìL&HUFHWáULL
SULQ&RQVLOLXO1DêLRQDODO&HUFHWáULLëWLLQêLILFHGLQ¨QYáêáP¼QWXO6XSHULRU
'HVFULHUHD&,3D%LEOLRWHFLL1DêLRQDOHD5RP¼QLHL
*270,25,é$
67,/,67,&$/,0%,,5201(0LRULWD*RW%XFXUHìWL
(GLWXUD)XQGDêLHL5RP¼QLDGH0¼LQH
%LEOLRJU
,6%1
n
5HSURGXFHUHDLQWHJUDOáVDXIUDJPHQWDUáSULQRULFHIRUPá
ìLSULQPLMORDFHWHKQLFHHVWHVWULFWLQWHU]LVá
ìLVHSHGHSVHìWHFRQIRUPOHJLL
5áVSXQGHUHDSHQWUXFRQêLQXWXOìLRULJLQDOLWDWHDWH[WXOXL
UHYLQHH[FOXVLYDXWRUXOXLDXWRULORU
81,9(56,7$7($63,58+$5(7
)$&8/7$7($'(/,0%$ë,/,7(5$785$5201à
&RQIXQLYGU0LRULêD*RW
(GLWXUD)XQGDêLHL5RP¼QLDGH0¼LQH
%XFXUHìWL
&835,16
&XYkQWvQDLQWH«««««««««««««««««««««««««««««««
,6WLOLVWLFDúLOLWHUDWXUD«««««««««««««««««««««««««««
6WLOLVWLFDOLQJYLVWLF úLVWLOLVWLFDOLWHUDU «««««««««««««««««««
/LWHUDWXUD&XYkQWWH[WúLFRQWH[W«««««««««««««««««««««
2SHUDOLWHUDW úLFRPXQLFDUHDDUWLVWLF «««««««««««««««««««
(YDOXDUH«««««««««««««««««««««««««««««««
,,6WLOXULVXSUDLQGLYLGXDOH6WLOXULOHIXQF LRQDOH««««««««««««««««
6WLOXO&DOLW LOHVWLOXOXL««««««««««««««««««««««««««
6WLOXULOHIXQF LRQDOH«««««««««««««««««««««««««««
(YDOXDUH«««««««««««««««««««««««««««««««
,,,6WLOXODUWLVWLF5HJLVWUHúLYDORULVWLOLVWLFH«««««««««««««««««
6WLOXOEHOHWULVWLFúLVWLOXOLQGLYLGXDODOVFULLWRUXOXL«««««««««««««««
5HJLVWUHVWLOLVWLFHXWLOL]DWHvQRSHUDOLWHUDU «««««««««««««««««
9DORULVWLOLVWLFHDOHWLPSXULORUYHUEDOH«««««««««««««««««««
9DORULVWLOLVWLFHDOHPRGXULORUYHUEDOH«««««««««««««««««««
9DORULVWLOLVWLFHDOHSHUVRDQHORUJUDPDWLFDOH««««««««««««««««
(YDOXDUH«««««««««««««««««««««««««««««««
,9,PDJLQDUXOSRHWLF6WLOLVWLFDWH[WXOXLOLULF«««««««««««««««««
6WUXFWXUDUHDWH[WXOXLOLULF««««««««««««««««««««««««
6SHFLLDOHJHQXOXLOLULF«««««««««««««««««««««««««
,PDJLQHDDUWLVWLF «««««««««««««««««««««««««««
(OHPHQWHGHYHUVLILFD LH««««««««««««««««««««««««
)LJXULGHVWLOúLSURFHGHHVWLOLVWLFH««««««««««««««««««««
0RGHOGHDQDOL] VWLOLVWLF ««««««««««««««««««««««««
(YDOXDUH«««««««««««««««««««««««««««««««
99DOHQ HVWLOLVWLFHDOHWH[WXOXLQDUDWLY«««««««««««««««««««
(OHPHQWHGHVWUXFWXU úLGHFRPSR]L LHvQWH[WHOHQDUDWLYH««««««««««
7LSRORJLDúLIXQF LLOHQDUDWRUXOXL«««««««««««««««««««««
3HUVSHFWLYDQDUDWLY ««««««««««««««««««««««««««
3HUVSHFWLYHWHPSRUDOH«««««««««««««««««««««««««
2UGLQHDQDUDWLY ««««««««««««««««««««««««««««
0RGDOLW LOHQDU ULL«««««««««««««««««««««««««««
3HUVRQDMXO3RUWUHWXOOLWHUDU«««««««««««««««««««««««
&RQFHSWHVSHFLILFHQDUDWRORJLHL«««««««««««««««««««««
0RGHOHGHDQDOL] VWLOLVWLF ««««««««««««««««««««««
(YDOXDUH«««««««««««««««««««««««««««««««
9,$ERUGDUHDVWLOLVWLF DWH[WXOXLGUDPDWLF««««««««««««««««««
3DUWLFXODULW LVWLOLVWLFHDOHRSHUHLGUDPDWLFH««««««««««««««««
&RQFHSWHVSHFLILFHGUDPDWXUJLHL«««««««««««««««««««««
0RGHOGHDQDOL] VWLOLVWLF «««««««««««««««««««««««
(YDOXDUH«««««««««««««««««««««««««««««««
%LEOLRJUDILHVHOHFWLY ««««««««««««««««««««««««««««
&8917¨1$,17(
5H]XOWDW GLQ H[SHULHQ D GH SHVWH WUHL GHFHQLL DYXW GH DXWRDUH OD
FDWHGU OXFUDUHDGHID VHYUHDXQXWLOPDQXDOGHVWLOLVWLFDOLPELLURPkQHDWkW
SHQWUXWLQHULLVWXGLRúLFkWúLSHQWUXFHUFHW WRULLvQGRPHQLXùLDFHDVWDvQWUXFkW
I U D IDFH UDEDW ULJRULL úWLLQ LILFH DXWRDUHD RSWHD] SHQWUX FRPXQLFDWLYLWDWHD
SURSLFHDFFHVLELOLW LLLGHLORUWUH]LQGFXULR]LWDWHDFLWLWRULORU
&DUWHD VH VWUXFWXUHD] vQ úDVH FDSLWROH 6WLOLVWLFD úL OLWHUDWXUD 6WLOXUL
VXSUDLQGLYLGXDOH 6WLOXULOH IXQF LRQDOH 6WLOXO DUWLVWLF 5HJLVWUH úL YDORUL VWLOLVWLFH
,PDJLQDUXO SRHWLF 6WLOLVWLFD WH[WXOXL OLULF 9DOHQ H VWLOLVWLFH DOH WH[WXOXL QDUDWLY
$ERUGDUHDVWLOLVWLF DWH[WXOXLGUDPDWLF3DUFXUJkQGWLWOXULOHDFHVWRUFDSLWROHVH
SXQHILUHDVFDvQWUHEDUHFDUHHVWHQRXWDWHDúLLQGLYLGXDOLWDWHDOXFU ULLGHID vQ
GRPHQLX"
ÌQ SULPXO UkQG FDUWHD SRDWH IL Y ]XW FD XQ H[FHOHQW FXUV XQLYHUVLWDU GH
WHRULD OLWHUDWXULL QHFHVDU VWXGHQ LORU ILORORJL GDU úL FD XQ SUH LRV DMXWRU RIHULW
WXWXURU SURIHVRULORU GH OLPED úL OLWHUDWXUD URPkQ SHGHRSDUWHFHORUDIOD LOD
vQFHSXWXOFDULHUHLGLGDFWLFHúLSHGHDOW SDUWHFHORUFDUHYRUV VHvQVFULHOD
GLIHULWHOH H[DPHQH GLQ vQY PkQW ± SHQWUX RE LQHUHD XQHL VXSOLQLUL SHQWUX
RE LQHUHD WLWXODUL] ULL SHQWUX RE LQHUHD GHILQLWLYDWXOXL VDX D JUDGHORU GLGDFWLFH
,,úL,
ÌQ DO GRLOHD UkQG FHUFHWDUHD GHVSRY UDW GH SUHMXGHF L úL GH XQHOH
MXGHF L DIODWH vQ Y GLW FRQWUDGLF LH FX UHDOLWDWHD WH[WHORU HVWH I FXW FX XQ
RFKLSURDVS WúLFXLQVWUXPHQWHGHOXFUXPRGHUQH
1X vQ XOWLPXO UkQG FDUWHD GRDPQHL SURI GU 0LRUL D *RW VH VSULMLQ SH R
ELEOLRJUDILHLPSRUWDQW GRYHGHúWHRH[SXQHUHVREU RIUD] VLJXU RDWLWXGLQH
RELHFWLY ID GH DP QXQWXO FRPHQWDW IDSWH FDUH FRQIHU vQWUHJXOXL R LQXW
úWLLQ LILF LUHSURúDELO
6WXGHQ LL ILORORJL SRW IRORVL DFHDVW OXFUDUH vQ SUHJ WLUHD FXUVXULORU GH
WHRULD OLWHUDWXULL GDU úL GH OLPED URPkQ FRQWHPSRUDQ HD DMXWkQGXL vQWUR
PDQLHU ORJLF úL DFFHVLELO VXE IRUP GH ILúH VLQWHWLFH V FXQRDVF
PHFDQLVPXO GH IXQF LRQDUH D OLPELL úL V LQWHUSUHWH]H vQ PRG FRUHVSXQ] WRU
GLYHUVHOH WLSXUL VWLOLVWLFH úL FRPSR]L LRQDOH GH WH[WH 7RW vQ DMXWRUXO VWXGHQ LORU
YLQ WHVWHOH GLQ ILQDOXO F U LL GH ID vQWUR YDULHWDWH D FHULQ HORU D JUDGXOXL GH
GLILFXOWDWHúLDVFRSXOXLXUP ULWSHQWUXDOHIRUPDGHSULQGHULFRUHFWHGHOXFUX
3H GH DOW SDUWH OXFUDUHD GRDPQHL SURI GU 0LRUL D *RW vL VSULMLQ SH
VWXGHQ LODVHPLQDUHOHGHLVWRULDOLWHUDWXULLURPkQHvQLQWHUSUHWDUHDULJXURDV D
WH[WHORUOLULFHHSLFHVDXGUDPDWLFH8QXOGLQWUHRELHFWLYHOHPDMRUHXUP ULWHGH
SURIHVRUXOGHOLWHUDWXUDURPkQ vOUHSUH]LQW IRUPDUHDODHOHYLúLODVWXGHQ LD
GHSULQGHULLGHDUHFHSWDGHDDQDOL]DúLGHDHODERUDDSRLGHDFRPSXQHXQ
WH[WFXvQ HOHV'LQS FDWHDVW ]LH[LVW SURIHVRULGHOLFHXúLGHIDFXOWDWHFDUH
SXUúLVLPSOXQXúWLXV vLvQGUXPHFRUHFWSHHOHYLúLSHVWXGHQ LvQDQDOL]DXQXL
WH[W OLWHUDU UHXúLQG vQ VFKLPE ÄSHUIRUPDQ D´ V vúL SOLFWLVHDVF GH PRDUWH
GLVFLSROLL úL vQ IRQG V vL vQGHS UWH]H GH OLWHUDWXU úL GH OHFWXU vQ JHQHUDO
&DUWHDGRDPQHLSURIGU0LRUL D*RWUH]ROY vQPRGIHULFLWDFHDVW SUREOHP
RIHULQGXQVROLGVXSRUWWHRUHWLFSUHFXPúLDQDOL]HPRGHOGRX WH[WHGH0DULQ
6RUHVFX±XQXOOLULF3RUWUHWXODUWLVWXOXLúLDOWXOGUDPDWLF,RQDXQIUDJPHQWGLQ
URPDQXO ,RQ GH /LYLX 5HEUHDQX úL R SDUDOHO vQWUH SHUVRQDMHOH OLWHUDUH DOH
QXYHOHL0RDUDFXQRURFGH,RDQ6ODYLFLSHQWUXJHQXOHSLF
Ä1RQPXOWDVHGPXOWXP´±LDW SULQFLSLXOFHVW ODED]DOXFU ULLGHID SH
FDUHRUHFRPDQGFXWRDW F OGXUD6XQWFRQYLQVF HDQXGRDUYDLQIRUPDFL
YDúLHGXFDvQVHQVXOPRGHO ULLJXVWXOXLHVWHWLFDOWLQHULORUFXSULQúLvQSURFHVXO
GHvQY PkQW
&RQIXQLYGU9DOHULX0$5,1(6&8
,67,/,67,&$ì,/,7(5$785$
67,/,67,&$/,1*9,67,& ù,67,/,67,&$/,7(5$5
3XV vQ FLUFXOD LH vQ D GRXD MXP WDWH D VHFROXOXL DO ;,;OHD FRQFHSWXO GH
VWLOLVWLF GHVHPQHD] XQGRPHQLXWHRUHWLFFDUHVWXGLD] DVSHFWHOHJHQHUDOHúLFHOH
SDUWLFXODUHDOHVWLOXOXL1RYDOLVGHSLOG GHILQHDVWLOLVWLFDGUHSWÄWHRULHDVWLOXOXL´FDUH
SUHLDSUHURJDWLYHOHUHWRULFLLDQVDPEOXGHFRQFHSWHYL]kQGVWXGLXOYDORULORUH[SUHVLYH
DOH OLPEDMXOXL FH ÄvúL SLHUGXVH DXWRULWDWHD QRUPDWLY úL IXQF LD GH FULWHULX HVWHWLF
VXIRFDW vQ H[FHVXO GH FODVLILF UL úL vQ ULJLGLWDWHD SURSULHL FRQFHS LL´ 'LF LRQDU GH
úWLLQ H DOH OLPELL ÌQ WHRULD PRGHUQ D OLWHUDWXULL VWLOLVWLFD HVWH GHILQLW FD R úWLLQ
FDUH UHXQHúWH GRX GRPHQLL IXQGDPHQWDOH VWLOLVWLFD OLQJYLVWLF DO F UHL FUHDWRU
HVWH &KDUOHV %DOO\ LQWHUHVDW GH VSHFLILFLWDWHD GLVFXUVXOXL UDSRUWDW OD IRUPD
SDUDGLJPDWLF D OLPEDMXOXL ÄO¶pWXGH GH OD ODQJDJH GH WRXW OH PRQGH´ ± 7UDLWp GH
VW\OLVWLTXH IUDQoDLVH úL VWLOLVWLFD OLWHUDU vQWHPHLDW GH /HR 6SLW]HU FDUH DUH vQ
YHGHUHVWLOXOLQGLYLGXDOFDUDFWHULVWLFLOHOLPEDMXOXLILHF UXLVFULLWRU
6WLOLVWLFD OLQJYLVWLF VWLOLVWLFD JHQHUDO VDX FROHFWLY DUH XQ FDUDFWHU GHVFULSWLY
LGHQWLILFkQG L]ROkQG úL DQDOL]kQG ÄIDSWHOH GH H[SUHVLH DOH OLPEDMXOXL RUJDQL]DW GLQ
SXQFWXOGHYHGHUHDOFRQ LQXWXOXLORUDIHFWLY´&K%DOO\ÌQIRUPXODUHDDFHVWHLRS LXQL
GH OLPLWDUH D GRPHQLXOXL H[SORUDW &KDUOHV %DOO\ SRUQHúWH GH OD SUHPLVD F XQ
FRQ LQXW DIHFWLY VH FRPXQLF SULQ PRGDOLW L OLQJYLVWLFH úL YLUWXDOLW L H[SUHVLYH SURSULL
XQHL OLPEL UHSUH]HQWkQG DEDWHUL vQ UDSRUW FX OLPEDMXO VWDQGDUG FDUDFWHUL]DW SULQ
JUDGXO ]HUR DO H[SUHVLYLW LL ÌQ 1RXO GLF LRQDU HQFLFORSHGLF DO úWLLQ HORU OLPEDMXOXL
-HDQ0DULH 6FKDHIIHU GHILQHúWH VWLOLVWLFD OLPELL FD GLVFLSOLQ FDUH DUH GUHSW RELHFW
ÄDQDOL]DPXO LPLLGHP UFLYDULDELOHRSXVHP UFLORUREOLJDWRULLDOHFRGXOXLSURSULLXQHL
DQXPLWHOLPEL´
6WLOLVWLFD OLWHUDU QXPLW úL VWLOLVWLFD JHQHWLF VDXVWLOLVWLFD LQGLYLGXDO DSHOHD]
ODPHWRGDLQGXFWLYGHGXFWLY ÄFHUFXOILORORJLF´±/HR6SLW]HUSHQWUXDERUGDUHDRSHUHL
OLWHUDUH vQ FDUH VH UHYHOHD] XQLFLWDWHD VWLOLVWLF D VFULLWRUXOXL &DUDFWHUXO DSOLFDW DO
VWLOLVWLFLL LQGLYLGXDOH UH]LG vQ FRUHODUHD ÄDEDWHULL H[SUHVLYH´ úL D VW ULL SVLKLFH
SDUWLFXODUHFDUHDSURGXVRGHFLDWU LULORUVLQJXODUHDOHHXOXLDXFWRULDOÄ>@ILHF UHL
HPR LL±DILUP /6SLW]HU±PDLH[DFWILHF UHLDEDWHULGHODVWDUHDQRDVWU QRUPDO vL
FRUHVSXQGH vQ FkPS H[SUHVLY R DEDWHUH GH OD vQWUHEXLQ DUHD OLQJYLVWLF QRUPDO úL
LQYHUVRDEDWHUHGHODOLPEDMXOX]XDOHXQLQGLFLXDOXQHLVW ULSVLKLFHQHRELúQXLWH2
H[SUHVLH OLQJYLVWLF SDUWLFXODU HVWH SH VFXUW UHIOH[XO úL RJOLQGD XQHL FRQGL LL
SDUWLFXODUH D VSLULWXOXL 1XDQ kQG DFHVWH RSLQLL (WXGHV GH VW\OH 6SLW]HU YD
SXQHDFFHQWXODVXSUDDQVDPEOXOXLGHSURFHGHHVWLOLVWLFHUHOLHIDWHvQFRQWH[WXORSHUHL
$QJHOD %LGX9UkQFHDQX &ULVWLQD & O UDúX /LOLDQD ,RQHVFX5X[ QGRLX 0LKDHOD 0DQFDú
*DEULHOD3DQ 'LQGHOHJDQ'LF LRQDUGHúWLLQ HDOHOLPELL(GLWXUD1HPLUD%XFXUHúWLS
&KDUOHV%DOO\7UDLWpGHVW\OLVWLTXHIUDQoDLVH(G:LQWHU+HLGHOEHUJS
/HR6SLW]HU(WXGHVGHVW\OH3DULV*DOOLPDUG
2VZDOG 'XFURW -HDQ0DULH 6FKDHIIHU 1RXO GLF LRQDU HQFLFORSHGLF DO úWLLQ HORU OLPEDMXOXL
(GLWXUD%DEHO%XFXUHúWLS
ÌQSUDFWLFDDQDOL]HLVWLOLVWLFHFHOHGRX GRPHQLLGHYLQFRPSOHPHQWDUHILLQGF
RULFH WH[W OLWHUDU VDX QRQOLWHUDU HVWH R VWUXFWXU OLQJYLVWLF ILQLW FDUH ÄvúL GHILQHúWH
LGHQWLWDWHD SULQ PRGXO VSHFLILF GH FRQYHUJHQ D FHORU SDWUX GLPHQVLXQL FRQVWLWXWLYH
>@ GLPHQVLXQHD IRQHPDWLF GLPHQVLXQHD VHPDQWLF GLPHQVLXQHD VLQWDFWLF
GLPHQVLXQHD VWLOLVWLF ´ 'XPLWUX ,ULPLD ,QWURGXFHUH vQ VWLOLVWLF $QDOL]D FHORU SDWUX
ÄGLPHQVLXQL´ UHOLHIHD] GLQ SHUVSHFWLYH PXOWLSOH ± OLQJYLVWLF VWLOLVWLF HVWHWLF
VWUXFWXUDO KHUPHQHXWLF HWF ± UDSRUWXO GLQWUH DFWDQ LL FRPXQLF ULL DUWLVWLFH VDX
SUDJPDWLFH GLQWUH HPL WRU úL OXPHD UHDO GLQWUH VFULLWRU úL XQLYHUVXO ILF LRQDO GLQWUH
VHPQXOOLQJYLVWLFúLUHIHUHQWGLQWUHWH[WúLPHVDMGLQWUHGLVFXUVúLOLPE
/,7(5$785$&89Æ177(;7ù,&217(;7
'HILQLW FDVXP GHFUHD LLOLQJYLVWLFHVWUXFWXUDWHSHSULQFLSLLHVWHWLFHOLWHUDWXUD
HVWH ÄXQ GRPHQLX DO H[SUHVLHL SHUVRQDOH DO GLPHQVLXQLL UHIOH[LYH D OLPEDMXOXL DO
ILF LXQLL´ HVWH R DUW D FXYkQWXOXL FDUH ÄvQVHDPQ VHOHF LH D PDWHULDOXOXL XWLOL]DUHD
FHORUPDLvQGUHSW LWHSURFHGHHFRPSR]L LHVWLO´*KHRUJKH&U FLXQ
&XYkQWXO HVWH XQ VHPQ OLQJYLVWLF SULQ FDUH VH FUHHD] R UHOD LH GH
LQWHUGHSHQGHQ FRQYHQ LRQDO vQWUHXQVHPQLILFDQWúLXQVHPQLILFDWUHIHUHQWHVWHR
XQLWDWHVHPQLILFDWLY PLQLPDO GHWLSWHUQDUUHDOL]DW VLPXOWDQFD
x XQLWDWHIRQHWLF XQFRPSOH[VRQRUVWDELO
x XQLWDWHJUDPDWLFDO SDUDGLJPDIRUPHORUIOH[LRQDUHDPRGHOHORUFRPELQDWRULL
vQHQXQ
x XQLWDWH VHPDQWLF VHQV GHQRWDWLY VHQVXUL FRQRWDWLYH UHOD LL VHPDQWLFH FX
DOWHFXYLQWH
$FWXDOL]DUHD FXYLQWHORU vQ GLVFXUVXO DUWLVWLF GHWHUPLQ vQYHVWLUHD ORU FX DWULEXWXO
OLWHUDULW LL SH FDUH *pUDUG *HQHWWH R GHILQHúWH FD ÄRUGLQH vQWHPHLDW SH
DPELJXLWDWHDVHPQHORUSHVSD LXOvQJXVWGDUYHUWLJLQRVFDUHVHGHVFKLGHvQWUHGRX
FXYLQWHFXDFHODúLVHQVvQWUHGRX VHQVXULDOHDFHOXLDúLFXYkQWvQWUHGRX OLPEDMXUL
DOHDFHOXLDúLOLPEDM´6HQDúWHDVWIHOOLPEDMXODUWLVWLFÄPLMORFXOSULQFDUHRDPHQLORUOL
VHYRUEHúWHGHVSUHOXFUXULSHFDUHHLOHFXQRVFGDUQXDXFXYLQWHV OHQXPHDVF ´
5REHUW)URVW
5DSRUWXO GLQWUH FXYkQWXO DUWLVWLF VHPQLILFDQW úL UHIHUHQWXO UHDO GHVHPQDW vQ
OLPEDMXO FRPXQ ÄOLPEDMXO LQVWUXPHQWDO´ ± *KHRUJKH &U FLXQ VH PRGLILF Ä3ULQ
DF LXQHD FUHDWLYLW LL HVWHWLFH FXYkQWXO QX PDL GHVFULH OXPHD H[WUDYHUEDO FL
vQWHPHLD] R OXPH VHPDQWLF ´ 'XPLWUX ,ULPLD GH]YROWkQG VHQVXUL QHE QXLWH FDUH
QX VXQW FLUFXPVFULVH QXFOHXOXL GHQRWDWLY Ä2ULFH FXYkQW SRDWH IL IRU DW V vQVHPQH
FHYDFHQXFRQ LQHvQVHPQLILFD LDVDSRWHQ LDO DOWIHOVSXVVHSRDWHPRGLILFDVHQVXO
GHED] DOFXYkQWXOXL´%RULV7RPDúHYVNL
$FHDVW OXPH VHPDQWLF DPSOLILF IXQF LD GH UHSUH]HQWDUH RELHFWXDO VDX
QR LRQDO DFXYLQWHORUvQVSD LXOPDLDPSOXDOHQXQ XULORUDOWH[WXOXLDUWLVWLF
7H[WXO HWLPRQXO ODWLQHVF ÄWH[WXV´ vQVHDPQ HV WXU HVWH GHILQLW FD ÄR XQLWDWH
IXQF LRQDO GH RUGLQ FRPXQLFD LRQDO DYkQG FDUDFWHU DXWRQRP vQFKLV´ +HLQULFK )
3OHWW ÄùWLLQ D WH[WXOXL úL DQDOL]D GH WH[W´ XQ ÄPDFURVHPQ´ (XJHQ &RúHULX
FDUDFWHUL]DWSULQ
x FRH]LXQHVLQWDFWLF PHFDQLVPHOLQJYLVWLFHFDUHDVLJXU XQLWDWHDVHFYHQ HORU
WH[WXDOH
'XPLWUX,ULPLD,QWURGXFHUHvQVWLOLVWLF (GLWXUD3ROLURP,DúLS
x FRHUHQ VHPDQWLF HQXQ XULOH DX DFHODúL UHIHUHQW VXQW ÄFRUHIHUHQ LDOH´
VHQVXO JOREDO DO WH[WXOXL ÄDGXFH vQWRWGHDXQD XQ VXSOLPHQW GH VHPQLILFD LH´ ±
'LF LRQDUGHúWLLQ HDOHOLPELL
7H[WXOÄvúLGHILQHúWHLGHQWLWDWHDSULQPRGXOVSHFLILFGHFRQYHUJHQ DFHORUSDWUX
GLPHQVLXQLFRQVWLWXWLYH´
x GLPHQVLXQHD IRQHPDWLF WH[WXO OLQJYLVWLF DFWXDOL]HD] OLPED VDX SULQ VHPQH
YRFDODUWLFXODWHFDWH[WRUDOVDXSULQVHPQHJUDILFHFDWH[WVFULV
x GLPHQVLXQHD VHPDQWLF RULFH WH[W OLQJYLVWLF DUH ILQDOLWDWH FRJQLWLY úL
FRPXQLFDWLY DUHXQVHQVSULQDFWXDOL]DUHDXQXLUHIHUHQW
x GLPHQVLXQHD VLQWDFWLF RULFH WH[W OLQJYLVWLF HVWH XQ DQVDPEOX RUJDQL]DW GH
VHPQH±XQLW LOH[LFDOHXQLW LVLQWDFWLFH±vQED]DXQRUUHOD LLVLQWDFWLFH
x GLPHQVLXQHD VWLOLVWLF RULFH WH[W OLQJYLVWLF DUH R LGHQWLWDWH VSHFLILF SXUWkQG
DPSUHQWDHPL WRUXOXLúLDFRRUGRQDWHORUSULQFLSDOHDOHVLWXD LHLGHFRPXQLFDUH
±WLPSVSD LXFXOWXU >FI'XPLWUX,ULPLD,QWURGXFHUHvQVWLOLVWLF @
7H[WXO OLWHUDU VH GLIHUHQ LD] GH WH[WHOH QRQDUWLVWLFH SULQ UHIHUHQWXO ILF LRQDO
DXWRQRP vQ UDSRUW FX UHDOLWDWHD RELHFWLY SULQ GHJUHYDUHD OLPEDMXOXL GH VFRSXULOH
SUDJPDWLFH VXEVWLWXLWH GH ILQDOLW L HVWHWLFH SULQ FRQVWLWXLUHD QLYHOXULORU PXOWLSOH GH
VHPQLILFDUH Ä6HPDQWLFD vQ PDL PXOWH WUHSWH´ , /RWPDQ D WH[WXOXL DUWLVWLF VH
UHYHOHD] vQV QXPDL SULQ LQWHUIHUHQ D FRQWH[WXOXL VWLOLVWLF ÄXQ PRGHO >SDWWHUQ@
OLQJYLVWLF vQWUHUXSW GH XQ HOHPHQW FDUH HVWH LPSUHYL]LELO FRQWUDVWXO UH]XOWDW ILLQG XQ
VWLPXO VWLOLVWLF´ ± 05LIIDWHUUH úL D FRQWH[WXOXL FRPXQLFD LRQDO FDUH SUHVXSXQH
FRRSHUDUH vQWUH DFWDQ LL FRPXQLF ULL DUWLVWLFH ÄFRQGXFkQG VSLULWXO GH OD DVSHFWXO
FRJQLWLYUD LRQDOODFHODOUHSUH]HQW ULLDOVHQVLELOL] ULL>@FXOWLYkQGDPELJXLWDWHDúL
DQWUHQDUHD UHFHSWRUXOXL vQWUR SDUWLFLSDUH OD SUREOHPDWL]DUHD VLWXD LLORU SUH]HQWDWH´
%RJGDQ3kUYX'LF LRQDUGHJHQHWLF OLWHUDU
23(5$/,7(5$5 ù,&2081,&$5($$57,67,&
&DWHJRULH VSHFLILF OLWHUDWXULL SRSXODUH VDX FXOWH R S H U D O L W H U D U HVWH R
FUHD LHDUWLVWLF RUJDQL]DW FDVWUXFWXU WH[WXDO FRPSOH[ vQFDUHVLVWHPXOGHVHPQH
±RUJDQL]DWvQVWUDWXULPXOWLSOHGHVHPQLILFDUH±LQVWLWXLHXQXQLYHUVILF LRQDO6LQWDJPD
RSHUDOLWHUDU GHQXPHúWHúLWRWDOLWDWHDFUHD LLORUDUWLVWLFHDOHXQXLVFULLWRU
2 S H U D O L W H U D U HVWHGHWHUPLQDW GHGRX VHULLGHIDFWRUL
D )DFWRULL LQWULQVHFL DX vQ YHGHUH WH[WXO vQYHVWLW FX IXQF LH SRHWLF
5 -DNREVRQ IXQF LH VWLOLVWLF 0 5LIIDWHUUH PRGDOLW LOH GH RUJDQL]DUH D GLVFXU
VXOXLILF LRQDOúLVWUXFWXULOHVSHFLILFHGHSURGXFHUHDVHQVXOXLDLGHLL
E )DFWRUL H[WULQVHFL YL]HD] UHIHUHQWXO FRQWH[WXO FDUH OD JHQHUDW ± FXOWXUDO
LVWRULF VRFLDO HWF ± PRGHOXO HVWHWLF FRGXO GH OHFWXU úL GH LQWHUSUHWDUH SUHFXP úL
WU LUHDHVWHWLF DUHFHSWRUXOXL
$OW FDUDFWHULVWLF D FUHD LHL DUWLVWLFH HVWH FRQYHUJHQ D D GRX SODQXUL VROLGDUH
SODQXOIRUPHLSODQXOH[SUHVLHLDOGLVFXUVXOXLDUWLVWLFÄOXPHDYHUEDO ´±5-DNREVRQúL
FHODOFRQ LQXWXOXLSODQXOVHPQLILFD LLORUÄOXPHDVHPDQWLF ´±5-DNREVRQÌQDFHODúL
WLPS RSHUD OLWHUDU VH VWUXFWXUHD] SH PDL PXOWH SDOLHUH IRQHWLF JUDILF OH[LFR
VHPDQWLF PRUIRVLQWDFWLF VWLOLVWLF LPDJLVWLF WHPDWLF Ä2SHUD VH FRQFUHWL]HD] vQWUR
GHVI úXUDUHYHUEDO GDUHDWU LHúWHGRDUSULQUHDOL] ULPHQWDOHúLHPRWLYH>@)LHFDUH
RSHU HVWHRRSHU GHVFKLV SHUPL kQGPDLPXOWHLQWHUSUHW ULYDULDELOHúLDFHVWHDvQ
IXQF LHGHGLVWDQ DvQWLPSVDXGHSHUVSHFWLYDOHFWXULL´*KHRUJKH&U FLXQ
& R P X Q L F D U H D D U W L V W L F HVWH R IRUP VSHFLILF GH WUDQVPLWHUH D
PHVDMXOXLDUWLVWLFGHODFUHDWRUODUHFHSWRUSULQLQWHUPHGLXORSHUHLGHDUW ÄÌQOHFWXUD
FHOXL PDL VLPSOX HSLVRG GLQWUXQ URPDQ VXQW PHUHX LPSOLFDWH WUHL SHUVRDQH DXWRUXO
OHFWRUXO HURXO´ ± 0LFKHO %XWRU , Q V W D Q H O H F R P X Q L F U L L D U W L V W L F H VXQW
RUJDQL]DWHvQGRX VHULLXQDH[WUDWH[WXDO úLXQDLQWUDWH[WXDO
7LSXO ,QVWDQ HH[WUDWH[WXDOHFRQFUHWHDEVWUDFWH
FRPXQLF ULL HPLWHQW UHFHSWRU
$8725&21&5(7 $8725$%675$&7 &,7,725&21&5(7 &,7,725$%675$&7
FUHDWRUXOLPDJL
,QVWDQ HOH FUHDWRUXOUHDO QDUXOXLDUWLVWLFFX ±SHUVRDQD ±LQVWDQ QDUDWLY SH
FRPXQLF ULL DORSHUHLÄHXO RYL]LXQHRULJLQDO UHDO FXRLGHQ FDUHDXWRUXODEVWUDFWR
QDUDWLYH HPSLULF´ GHVSUHOXPHúLRP WLWDWHVRFLRFXO DUHvQYHGHUHFkQGvúL
SHUVRQDOLWDWH vúLFRQVWUXLHúWH WXUDO SUHFLV FUHHD] RSHUD
FXRELRJUDILH XQLYHUVXOILF LRQDO ±OHFWRUXOUHDO ±GHVWLQDWDUXOVSUHFDUH
FXQRVFXW FX SHED]DXQRULGHL DORSHUHLUHFHS vúLRULHQWHD] VFULLWRUXO
DQXPLWHWU V úLUHSUH]HQW UL WRUDOXQLYHUVX LGHLOHPHVDMXO
,QVWDQ HOH
WXULSVLKRIL]LFH ILORVRILFHDXQRU OXLDUWLVWLF ±OHFWRUXOYLUWXDOSULYLW
FRPXQLF ULL
SULQFLSLLHVWHWLFH 0&RUWLÄGHVWL FDIXQF LHQXFDSHU
OLULFH
:%RRWKÄDXWRU QDWDUH[WHUQ´ VRDQ
LPSOLFLW´
ÄSULQFLSLXOGXEOHLHQXQ UL´$QQH8EHUVIHOG
ÌQ RSHUD GUDPDWLF IRUP VLQFUHWLF Ä3ULQFLSLXO GXEOHL HQXQ UL´ VSHFLILF
GHDUW VHULDHPLWHQ LORUVHPXOWLSOLF RSHUHL WHDWUDOH GHWHUPLQ úL R GXEO
,QVWDQ HOH DXWRUXOXLGUDPDWLFFRQFUHWúLDEVWUDFW UHFHSWDUH
FRPXQLF ULL LVHDGDXJ DFWRUXO±SHUVRDQDUHDO ±UHFHSWRUXOSULPHVWHDFWRUXOGLQVFHQ
GUDPDWLFH FDUH URVWHúWH UHSOLFLOH SH VFHQ ± VSUHFDUHHVWHRULHQWDWGLVFXUVXO
UHXQLQGSULQLQWHUSUHWDUHDVDYL]LXQHD ± UHFHSWRUXO ILQDO HVWH VSHFWDWRUXO GLQ
GUDPDWXUJXOXLúLSHFHDDUHJL]RUXOXL VDO Ä(O HVWH &HO ODOW DO DFWRUXOXL SHU
ODFDUHVHDGDXJ PRGXOSURSULXGHD SHWXXOV XDORFXWRUGHVWLQDWDUXOMRFXOXL
vQWUXFKLSDSHUVRQDMXOGHDMXFDUROXO V X´$QQH8EHUVIHOG
)XQF LLOH FRPXQLF ULL DUWLVWLFH VXQW LQIOXHQ DWH GH ILQDOLWDWHD HVWHWLF D
OLWHUDWXULLúLGHSURFHVHOHUHFHSW ULLúLFXQRDúWHULLDUWLVWLFH
D )81& ,$ 32(7,& 67,/,67,& (67(7,& SUHVXSXQH FHQWUDUHD DVXSUD
PHVDMXOXLWH[WXOXLDFWXDOL]kQGvQPRGSULYLOHJLDWGLPHQVLXQHDHVWHWLF DOLPELLÌQ
FRPXQLFDUHD DUWLVWLF DF LRQHD] QX QXPDL OD QLYHOXO H[SUHVLHL FD vQ FD]XO
FRPXQLF ULLQRQDUWLVWLFHFLúLODQLYHOVHPDQWLFLQVWLWXLQGOLPEDMXOSRHWLFFDVLVWHP
DXWRQRPGHVHPQH
E )81& ,$ (027,9 (;35(6,9 5()/(;,9 HVWH IRFDOL]DW DVXSUD
HPL WRUXOXLFDUHDSDUH±vQRSHUDOLWHUDU ±vQGRX LSRVWD]HVROLGDUH
HXODXFWRULDOGLVFXUVXODUWLVWLFUHIOHFW RÄLPDJLQHDLQGLYLGXDOLW LLFUHDWRUXOXL´
',ULPLD
HXOWH[WXDOGLVFXUVXOSRDUW úLP UFLOHHXOXLQDUDWRUHXOXLOLULFHXOXLURVWLWRU
vQWHDWUX
F )81& ,$ 5()(5(1 ,$/ '(127$7,9 &2*1,7,9 DF LRQHD] SULQ
ÄVXVSHQGDUHD UDSRUWXOXL VHPDQWLF UHIHUHQW H[WUDYHUEDO SUHH[LVWHQW ± PHVDM´
',ULPLDúLSULQLQVWLWXLUHDXQXLUHIHUHQWILF LRQDO2ELHFWXOFXQRDúWHULLDUWLVWLFHHVWH
Ä]RQD FH vQJOREHD] DFHO UHDO FDUH VFDS LQYHVWLJ ULL UD LRQDOH HVWH ÄHVHQ LDOXO GLQ
RPLQDSWSHQWUXORJLF ´(6DEDWRÌQUDSRUWFXUHIHUHQWXOFRQWH[WXOGLVFXUVXODUH
XQGXEOXUROÄGHUHSUH]HQWDUHúLGHQRWDUH´(&RúHULX
G )81& ,$ 0(7$/,1*9,67,& HVWH RULHQWDW VSUH FRGXUL OLQJYLVWLFH FXOWXUDOH
HVWHWLFH ± VHWXUL GH QRUPH GH UHJXOL úL FRQYHQ LL SULQ FDUH VH LQVWLWXLH FRHUHQ D
VHPDQWLF D WH[WXOXL 0HWDOLWHUDWXUD DFWLYHD] SUHSRQGHUHQW DFHDVW IXQF LH
LQWHUWH[WXDOLWDWHD DXWRUHIHUHQ LDOLWDWHD SDURGLHUHD PRWWRXO LPSXQ FRGXUL GH
OHFWXU úL GH LQWHUSUHWDUH VSHFLILFH vQ UHOD LH FX ÄSUHWH[WXO´ úL FX ÄDUKLWH[WXO´
-.ULVWHYD DUWHOH SRHWLFH IDFLOLWHD] GHFRGDUHD VHPQLILFD LLORU RIHULQG ÄFKHL GH
OHFWXU ´
H )81& ,$ &21$7,9 3(568$6,9 5(725,& RULHQWHD] GLVFXUVXO F WUH
OHFWRUXO FDUH GHYLQH SUH]HQ WH[WXDOL]DW QDUDWDU VDX DVFXOW WRU SULQ LQGLFL DL
SHUVRDQHLD,,DSULQIRUPXOHGHDGUHVDUHSULQHQXQ XULLQWHURJDWLYHH[FODPDWLYH
3RDWHILFHQWUDW SHXQGHVWLQDWDUILF LRQDOLQYRFD LDRG HSLVWRO HWFDSHODW
GLUHFWvQWH[W
I )81& ,$ )$7,& YL]HD] FDQDOXO GH FRPXQLFDUH FUHD LLOH SRSXODUH RUDOH úL
FRQWUROXO FRQWDFWXOXL GLQWUH LQVWDQ H DOH FRPXQLF ULL DUWLVWLFH QDUDWRUQDUDWDU
SHUVRQDMSHUVRQDM HXO OLULFLQVWDQ D LQYRFDW OHFWRU 6H DFWLYHD] vQ VHFYHQ HOH
UDP DOHSRYHVWLULLvQFDGUXVDXSULQIRUPXOHPHGLDQHGLQEDVPHWF
0DFURVWUXFWXUDYHUEDO DRSHUHLDUWLVWLFHHVWHGHWHUPLQDW GHIXQF LDGHILQLWRULHD
RSHUHL OLWHUDUH IXQF LD SRHWLF 5 -DNREVRQ IXQF LD VWLOLVWLF 0 5LIIDWHUUH
Ä)XQF LDSRHWLF DEVROXWL]HD] PHVDMXOvQHOvQVXúLVWUXFWXUDOXLYHUEDO SULPHúWHXQ
JUDGPD[LPGHDXWRQRPLH´',ULPLD
&RPXQLFDUHD DUWLVWLF SUHVXSXQH R DWLWXGLQH SDUWLFLSDWLY D OHFWRUXOXL FDUH
DSOLF R JULO SDUWLFXODU GH UHFHSWDUH úL LQWHUSUHWDUH SUDJPDWLF VRFLRORJLF
SVLKRORJLF SVLKDQDOLWLF PLWLF VLPEROLF VWUXFWXUDOLVW WH[WXDOLVW FRPSDUDWLYLVW
HWFÄ)HQRPHQXOOLWHUDUQXHVWHQXPDLWH[WXOFLúLFLWLWRUXOV XúLDQVDPEOXOGHUHDF LL
SRVLELOHDOHFLWLWRUXOXLID GHWH[W³05LIIDWHUUH
&RGXULOHGHOHFWXU úLGHLQWHUSUHWDUHVXQWLQIOXHQ DWHGH
PRGHOHOH FXOWXUDOH DOH HSRFLL Ä)LHFDUH HSRF YHGH vQ RSHU DFHOH DVSHFWH
FDUHVHSRWULYHVFFRVPRYL]LXQLLVDOH´DILUPD&DUORV%DXVRQR
FRPSHWHQ DOLQJYLVWLF úLFRPSHWHQ DFXOWXUDO DUHFHSWRUXOXL
WU LULOHHVWHWLFHúLÄRUL]RQWXOGHDúWHSWDUH´DOOHFWRUXOXL
5HFHSWDUHD RSHUHL OLWHUDUH VH vQWHPHLD] SH GRX FRQYHQ LL DFFHSWDWH GH
ÄSDUWLFLSDQ LLODMRFXOOLWHUDWXULL´3DXO&RUQHDOLWHUDULWDWHDúLILF LRQDOLWDWHD
/,7(5$5,7$7($SRDWHILGHILQLW FDRFDOLWDWHFRQIHULW WH[WXOXLDUWLVWLFGHIXQF LD
SRHWLF VWLOLVWLF D OLPEDMXOXL OLWHUDULWDWHD UHXQHúWH QLYHOXO H[SUHVLHL úL QLYHOXO
VHPQLILFD LLORUJHQHUkQGXQVLVWHPGHVHPQHFRPSOH[
),& ,21$/,7$7($ HVWH DFHD WU V WXU HVHQ LDO D WH[WXOXL DUWLVWLF FDUH QX
GHVHPQHD] UHIHUHQ L UHDOL FL vúL FUHHD] SURSULXO UHIHUHQW LPDJLQDW vQ UDSRUW
PLPHWLFVDXQRQPLPHWLFFXXQLYHUVXOXPDQFXOXPHDIL]LF
&HOH GRX FDUDFWHULVWLFL DOH RSHUHL DUWLVWLFH ± OLWHUDULWDWHD úL ILF LRQDOLWDWHD ±
JHQHUHD] ÄOXPL VHPDQWLFH´ DXWRQRPH úL XQ UHIHUHQW ILF LRQDO Ä8QLW LOH VHPDQWLFH
SURSR]L LLOH úL VLVWHPHOH GH SURSR]L LL VH UHIHU OD RELHFWH FRQVWUXLHVF UHDOLW L
LPDJLQDWLYHFDGHH[HPSOXSHLVDMHLQWHULRDUHSHUVRQDMHDF LXQLVDXLGHL>@FDUH
H[LVW QXPDLvQFDGUXOXQRUVWUXFWXULOLQJYLVWLFH´:HOOHNúL:DUUHQ7HRULDOLWHUDWXULL
$FHVWH VWUXFWXUL OLQJYLVWLFH RJOLQGHVF LQGLYLGXDOLWDWHD úL FUHDWLYLWDWHD VFULLWRUXOXL
SULQFLSLLúLFDQRDQHHVWHWLFHFRQYHQ LLSDUWLFXODULW LDOHVWLOXOXLEHOHWULVWLF
(9$/8$5(
D7HPHSHQWUXHYDOXDUH
6WLOLVWLFDOLWHUDU 3ULQFLSLLúLVWUDWHJLLGHDERUGDUHDWH[WXOXL
&XYkQWWH[WúLFRQWH[W0RGDOLW LVWLOLVWLFHGHUHDOL]DUHDFRH]LXQLL
3HUVSHFWLYHVWLOLVWLFHDVXSUDFRHUHQ HLWH[WXDOH
&RPXQLFDUHDDUWLVWLF ,PSOLFD LLVWLOLVWLFH
2SHUDOLWHUDU úLSDUWLFXODULW LOHVWLOXOXLDUWLVWLF
,QVWDQ HOHFRPXQLF ULLDUWLVWLFHvQRSHUDOLULF GLQSHUVSHFWLYDVWLOLVWLFLL
OLQJYLVWLFH
,QVWDQ HOHFRPXQLF ULLDUWLVWLFHvQWH[WXOQDUDWLYGLQSHUVSHFWLYDVWLOLVWLFLL
OLQJYLVWLFH
,QVWDQ HOHFRPXQLF ULLVSHFLILFHRSHUHLWHDWUDOH5RVWLUHDVFHQLF GLQSHUV
SHFWLYDVWLOLVWLFLLOLQJYLVWLFH
&RGXULGHOHFWXU úLFRGXULGHLQWHUSUHWDUH,PSOLFD LLVWLOLVWLFH
/LWHUDULWDWHúLILF LRQDOLWDWH&RQVHFLQ HvQSODQVWLOLVWLF
E)RUPHGHHYDOXDUH
)LHFDUH VWXGHQW YD VFULH XQ HVHX FX R WHP OD DOHJHUH GLQWUH FHOH HQXQ DWH
DQWHULRU(VHXULOHYRUILSUHGDWHúLHYDOXDWHODVIkUúLWXOVHPHVWUXOXL,
,,67,/85,6835$,1',9,'8$/(
67,/85,)81&é,21$/(
67,/8/&$/,7 ,/(67,/8/8,
6WLOXOODWÄVW\OXV´±FRQGHLFRPSR]L LHÄSRDWHILGHILQLWFDUH]XOWDWXOFRPELQ ULL
GLQWUH DOHJHUHD SH FDUH RULFH GLVFXUV WUHEXLH VR IDF GLQWUXQ DQXPLW QXP U GH
GLVSRQLELOLW L DSDU LQkQG OLPELL úL YDULD LLOH SH FDUH OH LQWURGXFH vQ UDSRUW FX DFHVWH
GLVSRQLELOLW L´ -HDQ0DULH 6FKDHIIHU /LQJYLVWXO , &RWHDQX vO GHILQHúWH FD
ÄDFWXDOL]DUH FRQúWLHQW D XQRU PLMORDFH OLQJYLVWLFH vQ YHGHUHD DWLQJHULL XQRU DQXPLWH
HOXULDOHH[SULP ULL´
3DUWLFXODULW LOH VWLOXOXLVHLGHQWLILF SULQUDSRUWDUHODRFDWHJRULHLGHDO OLPED
MXOVWDQGDUGFDUHSUHVXSXQHÄHOLPLQDUHDDWRWFHvQYRUELUHHVWHWRWDOLQHGLW±YDULDQW
LQGLYLGXDO RFD]LRQDO VDXPRPHQWDQ ±S VWUkQGDVSHFWHOHFRPXQHvQIHQRPHQHOH
OLQJYLVWLFHFRQVLGHUDWHGUHSWPRGHO´(XJHQ&RúHULX6LVWHPQRUP úLYRUELUH
&DOLW LOH JHQHUDOH DOH VWLOXOXL VXQW FODULWDWHD FRUHFWLWXGLQHD SUHFL]LD
SURSULHWDWHDúLSXULWDWHD
D &/$5,7$7($ FRQVW vQIRUPXODUHDOLPSHGHDHQXQ XULORUvQWURVXFFHVLXQH
ORJLF D LGHLORU FDUH WUHEXLH V ILH H[SOLFLWH HYLWkQG WHUPHQL DPELJXL VDX FRQVWUXF LL
VLQWDFWLFH HFKLYRFH GH]DPELJXL]DUHD SULQ FRQWH[W D FXYLQWHORU SROLVHPDQWLFH úL D
FHORUFXVHQVXULFRQRWDWLYH
x 6XSUDOLFLWDUHD FODULW LL H[FHVXO H[SOLFDWLY GHWHUPLQ UHGXQGDQ D VXE
IRUPDWUXLVPXOXLHQXQ DUHDXQRUDGHY UXULDUKLFXQRVFXWHDSOHRQDVPXOXL
12'(; Ä(URDUH GH H[SULPDUH FRQVWkQG vQ IRORVLUHD SDUDOHO D XQRU
FXYLQWH VDX H[SUHVLL LGHQWLFH VDX DSURSLDWH FD VHQV´ VDX D WDXWRORJLHL
JUHúHDO FRQVWkQGvQUHSHWDUHDXQXLFXYkQWVDXDXQXLGHULYDWDOV XFX
VFKLPEDUHDIXQF LHLVLQWDFWLFH
x $EVHQ DFODULW LLJHQHUHD] REVFXULWDWHDHQXQ XULFDUHQXSRWILvQ HOHVH
GLQFDX]DXQRUIRUPXO ULFRQIX]HDXQRUWHUPHQLQHFXQRVFX LVDXDXQRU
FRQVWUXF LL VLQWDFWLFH QHRELúQXLWH QRQVHQVXO FRQWUDGLF LH ORJLF vQWUH
WHUPHQLL HQXQ XOXL SDUDGR[XO DILUPD LH FRQWUDU XQHL RSLQLL JHQHUDO
DFFHSWDWH
x $EDWHULH[SUHVLYHFXIXQF LLVWLOLVWLFHvQSUR] úLGUDPDWXUJLHUHSUH]LQW
VXUVH DOH FRPLFXOXL GH OLPEDM vQ SRH]LH HUPHWLVPXO HVWH FRQVHFLQ D
XWLOL] ULLXQRUPHWDIRUHWRWDOHvQFKLVHDOLPEDMXOXLDXWRUHIHUHQ LDOHWF
E &25(&7,78',1($ UH]LG vQ UHVSHFWDUHD QRUPHORU OLPELL OLWHUDUH DFWXDOH OD
WRDWH QLYHOXULOH RUWRHSLF RUWRJUDILF úL GH SXQFWXD LH PRUIRVLQWDFWLF OH[LFDOVHPDQWLF
úLVWLOLVWLFWH[WXDO
x +LSHUFRUHFWLWXGLQHDKLSHUXUEDQLVPXOVHPDQLIHVW SULQPRGLILF ULIRQHWLFH
JUDILFHVDXIOH[LRQDUHGHWHUPLQDWHGHIDOVHDQDORJLLFXVHULLGHFXYLQWHvPSUX
PXWDWHGLQWURDQXPLW OLPE KLSHUIUDQ X]LVPHOHKLSHUJHUPDQLVPHOHHWF
x $EDWHUL IUHFYHQWH DQDFROXWXO GLVFRQWLQXLWDWH VLQWDFWLF JHQHUDW GH
VXVSHQGDUHD XQHL FRQVWUXF LL LQL LDOH FRQWLQXDWH FX R FRQVWUXF LH GLIHULW
GH]DFRUGXOVDXDOWWLSGHJUHúHDO VLQWDFWLF VROHFLVPXO
x $EDWHUL H[SUHVLYH FX IXQF LL VWLOLVWLFH OLFHQ HOH SRHWLFH VXQW P UFL DOH
XQXLUHJLVWUXVWLOLVWLFSRSXODUUHJLRQDORUDOHWFVDXVXQWGHWHUPLQDWHGH
FRQVWUkQJHULIRUPDOHSUR]RGLFH
F 35(&,=,$ YL]HD] FRH]LXQHD WH[WXOXL UHDOL]DW SULQ VHOHFWDUHD PLMORDFHORU
OLQJYLVWLFHDGHFYDWHSHQWUXH[SULPDUHDFXDFXUDWH HDLGHLORUVDXDVHQWLPHQWHORU
x 6XSUDOLFLWDUHD SUHFL]LHL SRDWH FRQGXFH OD LQGHWHUPLQDUH FRQWH[WXDO D
XQRULGHLFRQFHSWHODHQXQ XULLQFRPSOHWH
x /LSVDSUHFL]LHLDUHFDUH]XOWDWSUROL[LWDWHDHQXQ XULFRPSOLFDWHFXUHOX UL
VDX GLYDJD LL FDUH SLHUG GLQ YHGHUH LGHHD FHQWUDO RUL GLJUHVLXQHD
GHYLHUHD GLVFXUVXOXL GH OD LGHLOH SULQFLSDOH vQORFXLWH FX LGHL GHULYDWH I U
UHOHYDQ
x $EDWHUL H[SUHVLYH FX IXQF LL VWLOLVWLFH OLPEDMXO SUROL[ SRDWH DYHD URO vQ
FDUDFWHUL]DUHD SHUVRQDMHORU LDU GLJUHVLXQL FDUH LDX IRUPD FRQVWUXF LLORU
LQFLGHQWHVDXDQRWD LLORUSDUDQWHWLFHSRWDYHDUROVWLOLVWLF
G 35235,(7$7($ FRQVW vQ UHDOL]DUHD FRQFRUGDQ HL GLQWUH FRQ LQXW úL
H[SUHVLHGLQWUHVFRSXOFRPXQLF ULLúLLQWHQ LLOHHPL WRUXOXLSULQVHOHFWDUHDFHORUPDL
SRWULYLWHPLMORDFHOLQJYLVWLFHFXYLQWHVHQVXULIRUPHVWUXFWXUL
x &DUDFWHUXO LPSURSULX DO WHUPHQLORU DO VLQWDJPHORU VDX DO FRQVWUXF LLORU
VLQWDFWLFH GHWHUPLQ vQWUHEXLQ DUHD QHSRWULYLW vQWUXQ FRQWH[W GDW D XQXL
FXYkQW GLQWUR VHULH VLQRQLPLF D XQRU H[SUHVLL VLQWDJPH VDX D XQRU
FRQVWUXF LL LQDGHFYDWH VSHFLILFH DOWXL VWLO IXQF LRQDO VDX DOWXL UHJLVWUX
VWLOLVWLF
x $EDWHUL H[SUHVLYH FX IXQF LL VWLOLVWLFH vQ WH[WXO OLWHUDU IRORVLUHD XQRU
FXYLQWHVLQWDJPHÄLPSURSULL´vQWUXQDQXPLWFRQWH[WGHWHUPLQ XQWUDQVIHU
GH VHQV FDUH OH FRQIHU YDORDUH PHWDIRULF PHWRQLPLF HWF DPHVWHFXO
YDULDQWHORU IXQF LRQDOH GHWHUPLQ YDULD LD VWLOLVWLF UHOHYDQW SHQWUX
OLWHUDWXUDSRVWPRGHUQLVW GHH[HPSOX
H 385,7$7($DUHvQYHGHUHFRUHFWLWXGLQHDLGHRPDWLF UHDOL]DW SULQXWLOL]DUHD
PLMORDFHORU OLQJYLVWLFH DGPLVH GH OLPED OLWHUDU FRQVDFUDWH SULQ X] SULQ WUDGL LH
OLWHUDU
x $EVHQ DSXULW LLJHQHUHD] HURULIRQHWLFHSURWH]DDG XJDUHDXQXLVXQHW
LQL LDO DO PkL D VFRERUv DIHUH]D HOLGDUHD XQXL VXQHW LQL LDO VDX D XQHL
VLODEH
FRSHULú
IHúWDQLH HSHQWH]D LQVHUDUHD XQXL VXQHW vQ LQWHULRUXO
FXYkQWXOXL LQGHQWLWDWH VLQFRSD GLVSDUL LD XQXL VXQHW PHGLDQ GHOL
FYHQW
HWF/DQLYHOOH[LFDOOLSVDSXULW LLVHPDQLIHVW SULQXWLOL]DUHDXQRUFXYLQWH
LQVXILFLHQW FXQRVFXWH DUKDLVPH DUJRWLVPH QHRORJLVPH FDUH SURGXF
EORFDMHvQFRPXQLFDUH
x $EDWHUL H[SUHVLYH FX IXQF LL VWLOLVWLFH vQ FRPXQLFDUHD DUWLVWLF
FDWHJRULLOHOH[LFDOHLVWRULFRVRFLDOHDXYDORDUHH[SUHVLY PDUFkQGGLYHUVH
UHJLVWUHVWLOLVWLFHDUKDLFDUJRWLFSRSXODUFXOWHWF
x &DOLW LSDUWLFXODUHDOHVWLOXOXLFRQFL]LDFXUVLYLWDWHDRUDOLWDWHDDUPRQLDHWF
D &21&,=,$ YL]HD] R PD[LP FRQFHQWUDUH D GLVFXUVXOXL UHDOL]DW SULQ
VHOHFWDUHDPLMORDFHORUOLQJYLVWLFHVWULFWQHFHVDUHH[SULP ULLLGHLORUVDXVHQWLPHQWHORU
(VWH GHILQLWRULH SHQWUX GLVFXUVXO RUDO VDX VFULV FDUH LOXVWUHD] VWLOXO úWLLQ LILF VWLOXO
RILFLDODGPLQLVWUDWLYúLIUHFYHQWVWLOXOSXEOLFLVWLF
x 0 UFL OLQJYLVWLFH SUH]HQ D XQRU HQXQ XUL HOLSWLFH D IRUPHORU OH[LFDOH úL
JUDPDWLFDOHVLQWHWLFHvQORFXOFHORUDQDOLWLFH
E &856,9,7$7($DUHvQYHGHUHIOXHQ DFRPXQLF ULLUHDOL]DW SULQVXFFHVLXQHD
ORJLF D LGHLORU úL SULQ vQO Q XLUHD VHFYHQ HORU D XQLW LORU IRUPDOH FDUH FRPSXQ
GLVFXUVXO $FHDVW FDOLWDWH SDUWLFXODU SRDWH IL LGHQWLILFDW vQ GLYHUVH WH[WH GH WLS
DUJXPHQWDWLY GHPRQVWUDWLY VDX LQIRUPDWLY vQ GLDORJXUL RUDOH VDX VFULVH LQFOXVLY vQ
GLDORJXOGUDPDWLFvQRSHUHOLWHUDUHGHIRUPXO FODVLF WUDGL LRQDO HWFFDUDFWHUL]DWH
SULQFRH]LXQHODQLYHOVLQWDFWLFúLFRHUHQ vQSODQVHPDQWLF
x 0 UFLWH[WXDOHSUH]HQ DFRQHFWRULORU DUHFXUHQ HLGHWLSDQDIRULF VDX
FDWDIRULFXWLOL]DUHDSDUDIUD]HLDSDUDOHOLVPXOXL
F 25$/,7$7($ FRQVW vQ SUHOXDUHD XQRU IRUPH IRQHWLFH úL OH[LFRJUDPDWLFDOH
vQ XWLOL]DUHD XQRU SURFHGHH GLVFXUVLYH úL H[SUHVLYH VSHFLILFH OLPELL YRUELWH vQWUR
DQXPLW ]RQ OLQJYLVWLF vQWUXQ DQXPLW PHGLX VRFLDO (VWH R FDOLWDWH SDUWLFXODU D
GLVFXUVXOXL FRORFYLDO HVWH GHILQLWRULH SHQWUX UHJLVWUXO VWLOLVWLF XWLOL]DW GH VFULLWRULL FDUH
FUHHD] LOX]LDDXWHQWLFLW LLSULQVHOHFWDUHDúLVWLOL]DUHDYDULDQWHORUYRUELWHDOHOLPELL
x 0 UFL OLQJYLVWLFH XWLOL]DUHD IUHFYHQW D GLVFXUVXOXL GLUHFW LQGLUHFW OLEHU
PDUFDWVXELHFWLYúLDIHFWLYSULQLQWHUMHF LLIRUPXOHGHDGUHVDUHH[FODPD LL
LQWHURJD LL SDX]H H[SUHVLYH HWF SUH]HQ D IRUPHORU VDX D VWUXFWXULORU
IDPLOLDUH SRSXODUH VDX UHJLRQDOH IRUPH IRQHWLFH QHOLWHUDUH HOLGDUHD
DG XJDUHDVDXPRGLILFDUHDXQRUVXQHWHUHJLRQDOLVPHIRQHWLFHHWFIRUPH
OH[LFDOH VSHFLILFH WHUPHQL IDPLOLDUL H[SUHVLL úL ORFX LXQL SRSXODUH
UHJLRQDOLVPH IRUPH DUJRWLFH HWF IRUPH JUDPDWLFDOH YLLWRUXO FRORFYLDO
SUHGRPLQDQ D FRRUGRQ ULL FRSXODWLYH ÄúL´ QDUDWLY WRSLF DIHFWLY JUHúHOL
GHH[SULPDUH±GH]DFRUGDQDFROXWHWF
G $5021,$YL]HD] DFRUGXOSHUIHFWDOXQLW LORUFRPSR]L LRQDOHFDUHDOF WXLHVF
WH[WXO 6H UHDOL]HD] SULQ HFKLOLEUXO S U LORU DO VHFYHQ HORU SULQ IOXHQ GLVFXUVLY
SULQFRHUHQ VWLOLVWLF
x 0 UFL WH[WXDOH SULQFLSLXO VLPHWULHL vQ VWUXFWXUDUHD WH[WXOXL SDUDOHOLVP
VLQWDFWLF QDUDWLY FLUFXODULWDWH ODLWPRWLY UHIUHQ HWF SUH]HQ D XQRU
FRQVWUXF LL VLQWDFWLFH UHFXUHQWH D XQRU WRSRVXUL vQ SRH]LH DUPRQLD VH
UHDOL]HD] úLSULQFDGHQ ULWPULP
&DOLW L SDUWLFXODUH DOH VWLOXOXL EHOHWULVWLF FDUDFWHULVWLFL DOH OLPEDMXOXL
DUWLVWLFDPELJXLWDWHDH[SUHVLYLWDWHDHXIRQLDVXJHVWLDYDULD LDVWLOLVWLF HWF
D $0%,*8,7$7($ GHQRW FDUDFWHUXO ÄGHVFKLV´ DO VSD LXOXL VHPDQWLF DO
GLVFXUVXOXL YDORULILFDUHD YDOHQ HORU GH VHPQLILFDUH PXOWLSO DOH XQXL FXYkQW VDX DOH
XQHL VLQWDJPH DOH XQXL HQXQ VDX DOH vQWUHJXOXL WH[W HVWH R WU V WXU GHILQLWRULH D
OLPEDMXOXL DUWLVWLF ILLQG vQV SUH]HQW FLUFXPVWDQ LDO úL vQ FHOHODOWH OLPEDMH PDUFDWH
FRQHFWRU±FXYkQWVDXVLQWDJP FXUROMRQF LRQDOFRQMXQF LLDGYHUEHFDUHDVLJXU ROHJ WXU
IRUPDO ORJLF úLVHPDQWLF vQWUHVHJPHQWHOHXQXLWH[W
DQDIyUDWH[WXDO ±SURFHGHXPLMORFGHDVLJXUDUHDFRHUHQ HLWH[WXOXLSULQUHOXDUHDXQXLFXYkQW
FXYLQWHWHPDWLFHODvQFHSXWXOXQRUVHJPHQWHWH[WXDOHWHUPHQDQDIRULF±FXYkQWFDUHUHLDRLQIRUPD LH
VDXFDUHHVWHUHOXDWODvQFHSXWXOXQRUVHFYHQ HWH[WXDOH
FDWDIyUD WH[WXDO ± PLMORF GH DVLJXUDUH D FRHUHQ HL WH[WXOXL SULQ DQWLFLSDUHD XQXL FXYkQW D
XQRU FXYLQWH WHUPHQLL FDWDIRULFL VXQW GH RELFHL SURQXPH VDX DGYHUEH GHLFWLFH FDUH SUHFHG
VXEVWDQWLYXOUHIHUHQW
VXELHFWLY 2 FRQVHFLQ D DPELJXLW LL vQ WH[WHOH OLWHUDUH HVWH PXOWLSOLFDUHD QLYHOXULORU
GH VHPQLILFDUH úL D FRGXULORU FXOWXUDOH VDX LQGLYLGXDOH GH LQWHUSUHWDUH Ä'HVFKLGHUHD
VDX DPELJXLWDWHD IXQGDPHQWDO D RULF UXL WH[W OLWHUDU PDL DOHV FkQG HVWH UHOHYDW
SULQWUXQ DFW GH UHOHFWXU G FULWLFLORU SRVLELOLWDWHD V SURSXQ LQWHUSUHW UL WRWDO
FRPSHWLWLYHDOHDFHOXLDúLWH[W´0DWHL& OLQHVFX$FLWLDUHFLWL(PLQHVFLDQD2G vQ
PHWUX DQWLF GH H[HPSOX HVWH LQWHUSUHWDW FD ÄHOHJLH GH GUDJRVWH´ 'LPLWULH
3RSRYLFL FD DUW SRHWLF ÄXQ FkQWHF GH ODXG DGXV LGHLL GH JHQLX SRHWLF´ ±
3HUSHVVLFLXVúLFDHOHJLHH[LVWHQ LDO GHF WUH,RDQD(P3HWUHVFXFDUHRQXPHúWH
ÄUXJ FLXQHGHPkQWXLUHDFHOXLFDUHQXPDLS VWUHD] QLFLRFDUDFWHULVWLF URPDQWLF
GH HURX VDX GH SRHW D FHOXL FDUH UHSUH]LQW SXU úL VLPSOX R LPDJLQH SULQ QLPLF
H[FHS LRQDO DFRQGL LHLXPDQH´
0HFDQLVPHOHGHSURGXFHUHDDPELJXLW LLPDLIUHFYHQWHvQFUHD LLOHSRHWLFHSRW
DF LRQDODPDLPXOWHQLYHOXULGHVWUXFWXUDUHDWH[WXOXL
OD QLYHOXO RS LXQLL HVWHWLFH D VFULLWRUXOXL VLPEROLVPXO HUPHWLVPXO
LQWHUWH[WXDOLWDWHD HWF FXOWLY GHOLEHUDW DPELJXLWDWHD DPSOLILFkQG
ÄSOXULYRFLWDWHD´ VSHFLILF WXWXURU FUHD LLORU DUWLVWLFH Ä$FHDVW SOXULYRFLWDWH
HVWHFDUDFWHULVWLF WH[WXOXLFRQVLGHUDWFDWRWDOLWDWHHDGHVFKLGHRSOXUDOLWDWH
GHOHFWXULúLFRQVWUXF LL´3DXO5LFRHXU(VHXULGHKHUPHQHXWLF
OD QLYHOXO FRQVWLWXLULL YL]LXQLL DUWLVWLFH UHIHULQ D FXOWXUDO VLPEROXUL
UHSUH]HQW UL FRQFHSWH HWF GLQ GRPHQLL GLYHUVH DOH FXOWXULL $UKLPHGH úL
VROGDWXO GH 5DGX 6WDQFD & WUH *DODWHHD GH 1LFKLWD 6W QHVFX HWF VDX
LQGHWHUPLQDUHD UHIHUHQWXOXL ILF LRQDO JHQHUHD] DPELJXLWDWHD DYkQG GUHSW
FRQVHFLQ XQ ÄFXPXO WHPDWLF´ vQ SRH]LD (YRFDUH GH 1LFKLWD 6W QHVFX ±
(DHUDIUXPRDV FDXPEUDXQXLJkQGÌQWUHDSHQXPDLHDHUDS PkQW±
SURQXPHOH HD SRDWH FRQRWD LXELWD LXELUHD DPLQWLUHD LXELULL SRH]LD
WLQHUH HDYLD DHWFFHHDFHGHWHUPLQ VXSUDSXQHUHDWHPHORUWHPDLXELULL
úLWHPDFUHD LHLDH[LVWHQ HLXPDQHDYkUVWHORU
OD QLYHOXO FRQILJXU ULL LPDJLQDUXOXL SRHWLF XWLOL]DUHD XQRU WHKQLFL VDX
SURFHGHH DUWLVWLFH SUHFXP WHKQLFD VXJHVWLHL D FRUHVSRQGHQ HORU VDX D
VLPEROXULORUSOXULVHPQLILFDWLYHIDYRUL]HD] GHVFKLGHUHDÄOXPLLVHPDQWLFH´D
RSHUHL OLWHUDUH VSUH VHQVXUL FRQWH[WXDOH PXOWLSOH VLPEROXO SOXPEXOXL VDX
VLPEROXULOHFURPDWLFHvQSRH]LDEDFRYLDQ GHSLOG
vQVIHUDOH[LFXOXLSRHWLFVHOHFWDUHDXQRUFXYLQWHSROLVHPDQWLFHLQVWLWXLUHD
XQRU MRFXUL GH FXYLQWH JHQHUDWH GH IHQRPHQXO RPRQLPLHL PDL DOHV
PXOWLSOLFDUHDVHQVXULORUFRQRWDWLYHWUDQVIHUXOGHVHQVÄGHFRQVWUXLUHD´ORFX
LXQLORULQRYD LLOH[LFDOHPHWDOLPEDMHWFFRQWULEXLHODFUHDUHDDPELJXLW LL
GHH[HPSOXSRH]LD)UXQ] YHUGHGHDOEDVWUXGH1LFKLWD6W QHVFX
SDOLHUXOVLQWD[HLSRHWLFHDUHFDUHVXUVHGHSURGXFHUHDDPELJXLW LLWRSLFD
DIHFWLY GLVORF ULOHVLQWDFWLFHLQGHWHUPLQDUHDUHOD LLORUVLQWDFWLFHHQXQ XULOH
HOLSWLFHHUPHWLVPXOVLQWDFWLF,%DUEX7LPEUX-RFVHFXQG
VWUDWXO PRUIRORJLF LQGXFH DPELJXLWDWHD SULQ XWLOL]DUHD H[FOXVLY D
VWUXFWXULORU QRPLQDOH FD vQ SULPD VWURI GLQ -RF VHFXQG GH , %DUEX SULQ
LQWHUWH[WXDOLWDWH±SURFHGHXSULQFDUHVHLQVHUHD] vQWUXQWH[WXQHQXQ RVHFYHQ GLQWUXQ
DOW WH[W vQGHREúWH FXQRVFXW I U PDUFDUHD JUDILF D FLWDWXOXL vQ VHQV ODUJ GHVHPQHD] UHOD LD SH
FDUHILHFDUHWH[WRVWDELOHúWHFXWH[WHSUHH[LVWHQWHSHFDUHOHUHPRGHOHD] DEVRUELQGXOHvQSURSULXO
GLVFXUV
PHWDOLPEDM±Ä6LVWHPOLQJYLVWLFFXFDUHVHGHVFULXúLVHDQDOL]HD] HQWLW LOHúLVWUXFWXUDXQHL
OLPELQDWXUDOH´12'(;
SUH]HQ DSURIRUPHORU PDLDOHVDSURQXPHOXLvQDEVHQ DXQXLVXEVWDQWLY
FDUHV LDWULEXLHXQFRQ LQXWQR LRQDOSUHFLV(OvQFHSHFXVLQHúLVIkUúHúWH
FXVLQH1XOYHVWHúWHQLFLRDXU QXOXUPHD] QLFLRFRDG GHFRPHW
± 1LFKLWD 6W QHVFX (OHJLD vQWkLD SULQ VFKLPEDUHD FODVHL PRUIRORJLFH
6DWXUQ FHQWXUDW vQ DSDUWH 8UDQ FD XQ WLY 1HSWXQ DGLWLY ± ,RQ %DUEX
3D]QLFLLHWF
ODQLYHOVWLOLVWLFSUH]HQ DXQRUDOHJRULLPHWRQLPLLVDXPHWDIRUHDEVROXWH
WRWDOH PHWDIRUH ÄvQFKLVH´ FRQVWUXLWH vQ DEVHQ D XQHL FRPSDUD LL LPSOLFLWH
DOHF URUVHPQLILFD LLQXSRWILGHFkWDSUR[LPDWHvQFRQWH[WXOVWLOLVWLFSRDWH
JHQHUD DPELJXLWDWHD ,RQ %DUEX 7LPEUX 'DU SLDWUDQ UXJ FLXQH D KXPHL
GHVSXLDUHùLXQGDORJRGLW VXEFHUYRUVSXQH±FXP"
E (;35(6,9,7$7($ DUH FD SUHPLV GLPHQVLXQHD UHIOH[LY D OLPELL GHQRWkQG
FDSDFLWDWHD OLPEDMXOXL GH D UHIOHFWD GLUHFW VDX LQGLUHFW R UHDOLWDWH LQGLYLGXDO XQ
UHOLHI SVLKRORJLF XQ FRQ LQXW VXIOHWHVF DGLF ÄIRQGXO VXELHFWLY DO YRUELWRUXOXL´ 7XGRU
9LDQX 'XEOD LQWHQ LH D OLPEDMXOXL úL SUREOHPD VWLOXOXL PDMRULWDWHD FRPXQLF ULORU
YHUEDOH H[FHS LD HVWH UHSUH]HQWDW GH WH[WHOH úWLLQ LILFH úL GH FHOH RILFLDO
DGPLQLVWUDWLYH VWDQGDUGL]DWH DUH XQ FRHILFLHQW GH H[SUHVLYLWDWH VSRQWDQ RUL
GHOLEHUDW Ä'LVWLQJHP vQ IDSWHOH GH OLPE XQ QXFOHX DO FRPXQLF ULL úL R ]RQ
vQFRQMXU WRDUH D H[SUHVLYLW LL LQGLYLGXDOH´ ± 7 9LDQX &HUFHWDUHD VWLOXOXL ÌQ FD]XO
FRPXQLF ULL DUWLVWLFH VH PDQLIHVW QX QXPDL OD QLYHOXO H[SUHVLHL FD vQ FD]XO
GLVFXUVXOXL QRQDUWLVWLF FL úL OD QLYHO VHPDQWLF ILLQG DFWLYDW GH IXQF LD SRHWLF D
OLPEDMXOXL([SUHVLYLWDWHDHVWHWLF HVWHGHILQLW GH'XPLWUX,ULPLDGUHSWFDSDFLWDWHD
WH[WXOXL OLWHUDU ÄGH D FRQVWUXL úL UHYHOD XQLYHUVXO VSHFLILF GH VHQVXUL DUWLVWLFH úL
FRQFRPLWHQWGHDGHFODQúDVWDUHDHVWHWLF ´,QWURGXFHUHvQVWLOLVWLF
5HVXUVHOH H[SUHVLYLW LL VH VLWXHD] vQ ]RQD LQRYD LHL VWLOLVWLFH vQ FDUH
VHOHFWDUHD FXYLQWHORU GLPHQVLXQHD SDUDGLJPDWLF úL FRPELQDUHD ORU vQ
HQXQ SODQXOVLQWDJPDWLFVXQWGHWHUPLQDWHGHUD LXQLDUWLVWLFHGHFRPSR
QHQWD LPDJLQDWLYFUHDWLY úL DIHFWLY FDUH GHILQHVF SHUVRQDOLWDWHD VFULLWR
UXOXLDFHHODúLVLPEROFRVPRJRQLF±YkUWHMXODSHORUSULPRUGLDOH±HVWHQXPLW
GH (PLQHVFX FXLEDU URWLQG GH DSH LDU GH 1LFKLWD 6W QHVFX FHUF GHDGXUD
FkQGPDLODUJFkQGPDLDSURDSHFDRVWUkQJHUHGHDSHGHH[HPSOX
,QGLFLWH[WXDOLDLH[SUHVLYLW LLVXQWDVRFLHULQHDúWHSWDWHGHFXYLQWHDWLSLFH
vQ UDSRUW FX OLPEDMXO FRPXQ PRGLILF UL VHPDQWLFH LQGXVH SULQ FRQWH[WXO
VWLOLVWLF VHQVXUL FRQRWDWLYH FRQWDPLQ UL WUDQVIHU GH VHQV DPELJXL]DUH
FXPXO LQWHUWH[WXDO HWF FRQVWUXF LL WRSLFH QHRELúQXLWH VHPQLILFDUHD
HOHPHQWHORU JUDILFH VDX GH SXQFWXD LH DúH]DUH vQ SDJLQ SDX]H WLSR
JUDILFHSXQFWHGHVXVSHQVLHPDMXVFXOHHWFSUH]HQ DLPDJLQLORUDUWLVWLFH
DVLPEROXULORUDILJXULORUGHVWLOÄSXUW WRDUHGHQXPHURDVHYDORULH[SUHVLYH´
79LDQX
F(8)21,$VHPDQLIHVW ODQLYHOXOIRQHWLFDOGLVFXUVXOXLSULQFUHDUHDXQRUYDORUL
DFXVWLFH VXSHULRDUH FX URO vQ UHDOL]DUHD GLPHQVLXQLL HPR LRQDOH D OLPEDMXOXL (IHFWXO
PX]LFDORE LQXWSULQUHSHWDUHDXQRUVXQHWHRULSULQFRPELQDUHDVXJHVWLY DFXYLQWHORU
vQ HQXQ FUHHD] WRQDOLWDWHD GRPLQDQW WLPEUXO VSHFLILF DGHFYDW LGHLL $FHDVW
FDOLWDWH SDUWLFXODU D VWLOXOXL HVWH YDORULILFDW LQWHQVLY SULQ WLSDUXO PHORGLF DO WH[WXOXL
SRHWLF vQ FDUH UH]RQDQ D PHWUXOXL D ULWPXOXL úL ULPHL VH DGDXJ ILJXULORU GH VXQHW
SURIRUPH ± S U L GH YRUELUH DO F URU UHIHUHQW QX SRDWH IL SUHFL]DW GHFkW SULQ UDSRUWDUH OD
FRQWH[WXO OLQJYLVWLF OD R ÄVXUV UHIHUHQ LDO ´ DX YDORDUH GH SURIRUPH SURQXPHOH úL DGMHFWLYHOH
SURQRPLQDOHDGYHUEHGHLFWLFHGHORFVDXGHWLPSQXPHUDOHFXYDORDUHVXEVWDQWLYDO
Ä/H[LFXO SRHWLF VLQWD[D SRHWLF úL HXIRQLD VXQW FHOH WUHL VHF LXQL FDUH HSXL]HD]
SUREOHPHOHVWLOLVWLFLLSRHWLFH´%RULV7RPDúHYVNL7HRULDOLWHUDWXULL
0 UFL WH[WXDOH SUH]HQ D ILJXULORU GH VXQHW úL D XQRU PRGLILF UL IRQHWLFH
QXPLWH GH WHRUHWLFLHQLL *UXSXOXL PHWDSODVPH DVRQDQ D DOLWHUD LD RQR
PDWRSHHD ED]DWH SH DUPRQLL LPLWDWLYH DIHUH]D HSHQWH]D HWF
YDORULILFDUHD VLPEROLVPXOXL IRQHWLF FXYkQWXO ÄSOXPE´ GH H[HPSOX D XQRU
SURFHGHHVSHFLILFHPX]LFLLWHKQLFDUHIUHQXOXLDXQRUÄIDFWRULGHWHPSRUD
OLWDWH PX]LFDO ´ 1LFRODH 0DQROHVFX 'HVSUH SRH]LH D UHVXUVHORU
SUR]RGLFH P VXU ULWP ULP ULP LQWHULRDU vQ SUR] HXIRQLD HVWH
JHQHUDW GHLPDJLQLDXGLWLYHGHDUPRQLLLPLWDWLYHGHUHFXUHQ HúLJUDGD LL
UHWRULFHGHFDGHQ HULWPLFHDOHIUD]HLVLQWD[DULWPLF HVWHVSHFLILF SUR]HL
RUDWRULFH UHOLJLRDVH SUR]HL ULWPLFH SRHPHORU vQ SUR] GH VHOHFWDUHD
PDWHULDOXOXLYHUEDOSHSULQFLSLLDOHHXIRQLHL
(OHPHQWHOH SDUDYHUEDOH ± DFFHQWHOH LQWRQD LD ULWPXO SDX]HOH ± FRQWUL
EXLH úL HOH OD FUHDUHD XQRU VRQRULW L DUPRQLRDVH VDX FRQWUDSXQFWLFH
GL]DUPRQLFHvQDFRUGFXOXPHDVHPDQWLF DWH[WXOXL
Ä(XIRQLD±DILUP FULWLFXO*KHRUJKH&U FLXQ±HVWHRFDOLWDWHFXSUHF GHUH
FODVLF úL FODVLFLVW >@ SRH]LD PRGHUQ SUHIHU GLPSRWULY V úL
SURGXF HIHFWHOHDSHOkQGODHOHPHQWHOHGLVRQDQWHVWULGHQWHDPX]LFDOHDOH
OLPEDMXOXL´,QWURGXFHUHvQWHRULDOLWHUDWXULL
G 68*(67,$ HVWH FDOLWDWHD SDUWLFXODU D VWLOXOXL FDUH FRQVW vQ YDORULILFDUHD
UHVXUVHORUOLQJYLVWLFHGHVHPQLILFDUHLPSOLFLW GHH[SULPDUHDOX]LY SULQFDUHLGHHDQX
VHRIHU GLUHFWFXQRDúWHULLUD LRQDOHFLLQWXL LHLLPDJLQD LHLúLVHQVLELOLW LL
0RGDOLW LOLQJYLVWLFHGHUHDOL]DUHIUHFYHQ DFXYLQWHORUSROLVHPDQWLFHúLD
VHQVXULORUFRQRWDWLYH UHFXUHQ D XQRU FXYLQWH VLQWDJPHFKHLH ODLWPRWLYXO
UHIUHQXO VDX WLWOXO FDUH SRDWH VXJHUD WHPD GRPLQDQWD DIHFWLY FDUDFWHUXO
HYRFDWLY HWF HQXQ XUL HOLSWLFH vQWUHUXSWH VXVSHQGDWH SUH]HQ D XQRU
HOHPHQWHSDUDWH[WXDOHVXEWLWOXPRWWRGHGLFD LHVDXPHWDWH[WXDOHSXQFWH
GHVXVSHQVLHHWF
0RGDOLW L VWLOLVWLFH SUH]HQ D VLPEROXULORU PXOWLVHPQLILFDWLYH D XQRU
LPDJLQL DUWLVWLFH QHFRQYHQ LRQDOH FX VHPQLILFD LL HFKLYRFH SUH]HQ D
PHWDIRUHORUWRWDOHvQFKLVHDXQRUDQDORJLLDOHJRULLHWF
H 9$5,$ ,$ 67,/,67,& UH]LG vQ DVRFLHUHD D GRX VDX PDL PXOWH UHJLVWUH
VWLOLVWLFHVFKLPEDUHDEUXVF DQWLFOLPD[XORULDOWHUQDQ DFRQWUDSXQFWLF DUHJLVWUHORU
HVWHRFDUDFWHULVWLF DPRGHUQLVPXOXLúLSRVWPRGHUQLVPXOXLVHPQDOkQGVFLQGDUHDvQ
ÄYRFL´DOWHULWDWHDUXSWXUDGHQLYHOVDXSDURGLDSDVWLúDLQWHUWH[WXDOLWDWHD
0 UFL LQGLFL WH[WXDOL ± GH QLYHO IRQHWLF OH[LFRJUDPDWLFDO VDX VWLOLVWLF ± DL
PDLPXOWRUUHJLVWUHVWLOLVWLFH
67,/85,/()81& ,21$/(
6WLOXULOH IXQF LRQDOH OLPEDMHOH IXQF LRQDOH VXQW YDULDQWH VSHFLDOL]DWH DOH
OLPELL OLWHUDUH VXSUDLQGLYLGXDOH FDUH DVLJXU FRPXQLFDUHD vQ VIHUH GH DFWLYLWDWH
VSHFLILFH ÌQ PRG WUDGL LRQDO vQ OLPED URPkQ VXQW GHILQLWH úDSWH VWLOXUL IXQF LRQDOH
RILFLDO MXULGLFRDGPLQLVWUDWLY WHKQLFRúWLLQ LILF SXEOLFLVWLF FRORFYLDO EHOHWULVWLF
RUDWRULFúLHSLVWRODU0RGHOXOUHGXFWLYDOVWLOXULORUIXQF LRQDOHDVLPLOHD] VWLOXORUDWRULF
FHOXL MXULGLFRDGPLQLVWUDWLY SOHGRDULLOH DYRFD LORU GH H[HPSOX vQ WLPS FH VWLOXO
HSLVWRODU HVWH LQWHJUDW ILH VWLOXOXL RILFLDO FRUHVSRQGHQ D RILFLDO ILH FHOXL FRORFYLDO
FRUHVSRQGHQ D DPLFDO IDPLOLDO 'XPLWUX ,ULPLD ,QWURGXFHUH vQ VWLOLVWLF
GLIHUHQ LD] vQ WHPHLXO XQRU IDFWRUL GLVFULPLQDWRULL ± QDWXUD úL ILQDOLWDWHD PHVDMXOXL
WLSXO GH FXQRDúWHUH úL GH FRPXQLFDUH ± VWLOXULOH FROHFWLYH LQIRUPDOH VWLOXO
FRQYHUVD LHL úL VWLOXO HSLVWRODU GH FHOH FLQFL VWLOXUL FROHFWLYH IXQF LRQDOH VWLOXO
EHOHWULVWLFFHOúWLLQ LILFVWLOXOSXEOLFLVWLFMXULGLFRDGPLQLVWUDWLYúLVWLOXOUHOLJLRV
'(),1, ,(7,385,63(&,),&('(
67,/8/ 3$57,&8/$5,7 ,
7(;7(
(VWHVWLOXOUHOD LLORURILFLDOHDOQHJR 0 UFLFDUDFWHULVWLFH
FLHULORUúLDOFRUHVSRQGHQ HLRILFLDOH Ö 6WLOQRQDUWLVWLFRELHFWLYQHXWUXLPSHU
6H IRORVHúWH vQ GRFXPHQWH VDX vQ VRQDO FODU SUHFLV DFFHVLELO FUHD LD
H[SXQHUL RUDOH FX FDUDFWHU MXULGLF DGPL OLQJYLVWLF HVWH HOLPLQDW vQ IDYRDUHD
QLVWUDWLYGLSORPDWLFHFRQRPLFSROLWLF VWHUHRWLSLLORUGHOLPEDM
6XEFDWHJRULL OLPEDMXO DGPLQLVWUDWLY Ö 7H[WHOH UHGDFWDWH vQ VWLO RILFLDO VH FD
OLPEDMXOFRUHVSRQGHQ HLGHDIDFHULFHO UDFWHUL]HD] SULQXQLIRUPLWDWHSULQDEVHQ D
SROLWLFMXULGLFGLSORPDWLFDFDGHPLF P UFLORU VXELHFWLYH úL D LQWHQ LLORU
&RPSXQHUL VSHFLILFH VFULVH VXQW VWLOLVWLFH
FHUHUHDDGHYHULQ DLQIRUPDUHDUDSRUWXO Ö (OH DEXQG vQ IRUPXOH FOLúHH WLSDUH
FLUFXODUDQRWDUHIHUDWXOSURFHVXOYHUEDO VLQWDFWLFH RILFLDOL]DWH SULQ X] H[ Ä6XE
GRFXPHQWHOHJLVODWLYHDFDGHPLFHSROLWL VHPQDWXO« GRPLFLOLDW vQ « SRVHVRU DO
FHGLSORPDWLFHFRUHVSRQGHQ DGHDIDFHUL F U LLGHLGHQWLWDWHFXVHULD«QU«Y
FXUULFXOXPYLWDHUHFRPDQGDUHDFDUDFWH URJDPLDSURED«´
UL]DUHD IRUPXODUH VWDQGDUGL]DWH FKLWDQ D Ö )RORVLUH IUHFYHQW D IRUPHORU LPSHU
ERQXOHWF VRQDOH YHUEDOH ÄYL VH FRPXQLF ´ ÄVD
&RPXQLFDUHDDUHFDGRPLQDQW IXQF LD GHFLV´HWFFOLúHHÄDYkQGvQYHGHUHF «´
LQIRUPDWLY WH[WXO MXULGLF DUH úL IXQF LH Ö 6HIRORVHúWHRWHUPLQRORJLHVSHFLILF
QRUPDWLY DGHFYDW YDULDQWHORU DGPLQLVWUDWLY
&RPSXQHUL RUDOH DORFX LXQHD WRDVWXO SROLWLF DFDGHPLF MXULGLF GLSORPDWLF
GLVFXUVXOLQWHUYHQ LD Ö ÌQ FRUHVSRQGHQ D RILFLDO VH DGPLW
IRUPXOH SHUVRQDOL]DWH GH DGUHVDUH GH
vQFKHLHUH
(VWHIRORVLWvQOXFU ULOHFRPXQLF ULOH
0 UFLFDUDFWHULVWLFH
GH]EDWHULOHúWLLQ LILFHúLWHKQLFH
Ö (VWH XQ VWLO QRQDUWLVWLF LJQRUkQG
&RPSXQHUL VSHFLILFH GHVFULHUHD úWLLQ L
GHOLEHUDWRULFHPDUF VXELHFWLY
ILF UHIHUDWXO FRPXQLFDUHD RUDO VFULV
Ö &RPXQLFDUHD HVWH QHXWU OLSVLW GH
DUWLFROXO VWXGLXO SURLHFWXO SURVSHFWXO
DFFHQWH SHUVRQDOH SUHIHULQ SHQWUX
WHKQLFVLQWH]DGL]HUWD LDWUDWDWXOQRWD
ÄSOXUDOXO DXWRUXOXL´ HVWH FDUDFWHUL]DW
7H[WHQRQOLWHUDUHFXIXQF LHLQIRUPDWLY
SULQ UHVSHFWDUHD WXWXURU QRUPHORU OLPELL
6WXGLLOH HVHXULOH GH LVWRULH OLWHUDU GH
OLWHUDUH IRQHWLFH JUDPDWLFDOH GH
FULWLF VDXHVWHWLF DOF WXLHVFRFDWHJRULH
SXQFWXD LH
DSDUWH GH WH[WH úWLLQ LILFH vQ FDUH VXQW
Ö /H[LFXO HVWH OLSVLW GH DPELJXLWDWH
IRUPXODWH DVHU LXQL MXGHF L GH YDORDUH
VLQRQLPLD HVWH UHGXV VH HYLW RPRQL
VXELHFWLYH vQWUXQ GLVFXUV SHUVRQDOL]DW
PLD FXYLQWHOH VXQW PDL DOHV PRQR
FDUH YDORULILF UHVXUVHOH H[SUHVLYH DOH
VHPDQWLFH VH IRORVHVF QHRORJLVPH
OLPEDMXOXL Ä&ULWLFXO SRVWPRGHUQ QX PDL
LQWHUQD LRQDOH úL FXYLQWH FX SUHIL[RLGH úL
YUHD V VWHD vQ DIDUD GLVFXUVXOXL V X
VXIL[RLGH
5HIX] V PDLIRORVHDVF SHUVRDQDD,,,
Ö (VWH XQ VWLO GHQRWDWLY ED]DW SH
D VLQJXODU VDX SHUVRDQD vQWkL SOXUDO
SURSULHWDWHDWHUPHQLORU9DULDQWHOHVXQW
6FULH FX SUHF GHUH OD SHUVRDQD vQWkL
VSHFLDOL]DWH SHQWUX ILHFDUH GRPHQLX GH
VLQJXODU´ ± (XJHQ 6LPLRQ 6ILGDUHD
DFWLYLWDWHúWLLQ LILF PHWDOLPEDMHOHSURSULL
UHWRULFLL
ILHF UHLúWLLQ HVDXWHKQLF
6HIRORVHúWHvQPDVVPHGLD
&RPSXQHUL VSHFLILFH DUWLFROXO GH 0 UFLFDUDFWHULVWLFH
SUHV FURQLFD IRLOHWRQXO LQWHUYLXO Ö 6WLOXO vPELQ HOHPHQWH LQIRUPDWLYH úL
UHSRUWDMXO GH]EDWHUHD SXEOLF PDVD DIHFWLYH DWLWXGLQH PDUFDW VXELHFWLY
URWXQG UHFHQ]LDDQXQ XOUHFODPDHWF H[SUHVLYLWDWH VWULGHQW PHQLW D FDSWD
$UH FDUDFWHU HWHURJHQ ÄvPSUXPX LQWHUHVXO SDOHW OH[LFDO FX DFFHQW SH
WkQG´ WLSXUL GH GLVFXUV VSHFLILFH DOWRU WHUPHQLL GH FXORDUH QHRORJLVPH FXOWLV
VWLOXUL IXQF LRQDOH UH]XOW R PDUH PH UHJLRQDOLVPH DUJRWLVPH WHUPHQL
YDULHWDWH D UHJLVWUHORU VWLOLVWLFH UHIOH[ DO SRSXODULVDXWHUPHQLOLWHUDUDUWLVWLFL
GLYHUVLW LLWHPDWLFHDDFHVWRUWH[WH Ö /H[LFXO IRORVLW HVWH ERJDW úL YDULDW
7H[WHOH SXEOLFLVWLFH DX IXQF LH VLQRQLPLD HVWH ELQH LOXVWUDW RPRQLPLD
LQIRUPDWLY úL SHUVXDVLY LQGXFHUHD SRDWHILYDORULILFDW vQMRFXUL´OLQJYLVWLFH
XQXLFXUHQWGHRSLQLHLQIOXHQ DUHDOHFWR VLQWD[D SRDWH IL PDUFDW VXELHFWLY SULQ
ULORU IXQF LD HGXFDWLY VH DFWLYHD] vQ UHFXUHQ GLVORF ULHOLSVH
WH[WHOH FDUH PRGHOHD] FRPSRUWDPHQWH Ö 7LWOXULOHVXQWGHRELFHLFRQVWUXF LLQR
VRFLDOHLQGLYLGXDOHSR]LWLYH PLQDOHFRQWUDVHLQFLWDQWHFDSDELOHGHD
6XEFDWHJRULH FX P UFL GLVWLQFWLYH VLQWHWL]DLQIRUPD LDLGHHD
VWLOXO SXEOLFLWDU SUHGRPLQ IXQF LD Ö ÌQ VWLOXO SXEOLFLVWLF VH UHJ VHVF PXOWH
SHUVXDVLY VWUDWHJLL WH[WXDOH PHQLWH V HOHPHQWH DOH VWLOXOXL EHOHWULVWLF VWUXFWXUL
FDSWH]H DWHQ LD V FRQYLQJ SRWHQ LDOLL úLFRQVWUXF LLLQHGLWHILJXULGHVWLOIUDSDQ
FXPS U WRULEHQHILFLDULDLVHUYLFLLORU WH IRUPXOH UHWRULFH FXYLQWH úL VLQWDJPH
VLPEROWLWOXULPD[LPHFLWDWHSDUDIUD]H
0 UFLFDUDFWHULVWLFH
Ö 7H[WXO DUH IRU GH VXJHVWLH úL
H[SUHVLYLWDWH VH DGUHVHD] LPDJLQD LHL
úLVHQVLELOLW LLDYkQGFDPDUF GLVWLQFWL
Y ÄOLWHUDULWDWHD´ OLPEDMXO GHJUHYDW GH
IXQF LLOH SUDFWLFH H vQYHVWLW FX YDORUL
6HIRORVHúWHvQRSHUHOHOLWHUDUH
HVWHWLFH
Ö )RORVHúWH VXJHVWLD SULQ LPDJLQH DUWLV
&RPXQLF ULOHVSHFLILFHVXQWVFULVHVDX
WLF PDL PXOW GHFkW H[SOLFD LD IXQF LD
RUDOHIROFORUXOOLWHUDUVSHFWDFROXOWHDWUDO
WUDQ]LWLY D OLPEDMXOXL HVWH FRSOHúLW GH
±IRUP VLQFUHWLF DFRPXQLF ULLDUWLVWLFH
IXQF LDUHIOH[LY
vQWRDWHJHQXULOHúLVSHFLLOHOLWHUDUH
Ö 9DORULILF WRDWH FDWHJRULLOH OH[LFDOH
DUKDLVPH UHJLRQDOLVPH DUJRX MDUJRQ
&UHD LD OLWHUDU DFWLYHD] FD IXQF LH
QHRORJLVPHVHOHFWkQGPDLDOHVWHUPHQL
SULPRUGLDO DOLPEDMXOXLIXQF LDSRHWLF
SROLVHPDQWLFLFDUHFUHHD] DPELJXLWDWHD
QXPLW úL OLULF OXGLF HVWHWLF VDX
GH]YROWkQG VHQVXUL FRQRWDWLYH O UJLQG
UHWRULF DYkQGFDILQDOLW LFRPXQLFDUHD
QHP VXUDW ÄFkPSXO GH GRU DO FXYLQWHORU´
OLWHUDU FXQRDúWHUHD DUWLVWLF úL HPR LD
&1RLFD JHQHUkQG XQ ÄVSD LX LQWHUQ DO
HVWHWLF
OLPEDMXOXL´**HQHWWH)LJXUL
Ö 9DORULILF UHVXUVHOH H[SUHVLYH DOH
'LVFXUVXO OLWHUDU WH[WXO DUWLVWLF HVWH
IRQHWLFLL OH[LFXOXL PRUIRORJLHL VLQWD[HL
FRQVWUXLW SH FRQYHQ LL HVWHWLFH 6WLOXO
JHQHUkQG PHVDMH SROLYDOHQWH )LJXULOH
EHOHWULVWLF ÄUHFXUJH OD LPDJLQL FD
VWLOXOXLVXQWFHOHPDLLPSRUWDQWHPLMORDFH
SURFHGHXGHFRPXQLFDUH´,RQ&RWHDQX
GHH[SUHVLH/DQLYHOVLQWDFWLFSRWDS UHD
GLVORF ULÄvPSOHWLUL´LQHGLWHGHSURSR]L LL
LQYHUVLXQL WRSLFH FRQYHUVLXQL HOLSVH
DIHUH]HLQVHU LLLQFLGHQWDOH
Ö 6WLOXO EHOHWULVWLF HVWH SXWHUQLF PDUFDW
VXELHFWLY FDUDFWHUL]DW SULQ ÄDEDWHUL´
H[SUHVLYHGHODQRUPHOHOLPELLOLWHUDUH
0 UFLFDUDFWHULVWLFH
Ö $UH FDUDFWHU VSRQWDQ QHHODERUDW
VWUXFWXULOLEHUHFDUDFWHULVWLFLDOHRUDOLW LL
6HIRORVHúWHvQFRQYHUVD LDSDUWLFXODU
OH[LF YDULDW QDWXUDO QHSUHWHQ LRV WLFXUL
X]XDO vQ FRUHVSRQGHQ D SDUWLFXODU
YHUEDOH P UFL DOH VXELHFWLYLW LL DOH
VFULVRDUHD ELOHWXO MXUQDOXO QRWL D WHOH
LPSOLF ULLDIHFWLYH
JUDPDHWF
Ö (VWH SXWHUQLF LQGLYLGXDOL]DW UHOLHIkQG
-XUQDOXO OLWHUDU úL PHPRULLOH VXQW
JUDGXO GH LQVWUXF LH FXOWXUD PHGLXO
VFULHULÄGHJUDQL ´WH[WHQRQILF LRQDOHvQ
VRFLRSURIHVLRQDOHWF
FDUHVWLOXOFRORFYLDOFRQIHVLYVHDVRFLD]
Ö /DQLYHOXOUHJLVWUXOXLVWLOLVWLFSDUWLFXOD
FHOXLEHOHWULVWLF
ULW LOH GH OLPEDM SRW LOXVWUD UHJLVWUXO
QHXWUX UHJLVWUXO VROHPQ IDPLOLDU LURQLF
OXGLFXPRULVWLFJQRPLF
(9$/8$5(
D7HVWGHHYDOXDUH
&RQFL]LDHVWHRFDOLWDWHSDUWLFXODU DVWLOXOXLGHILQLW SULQ
DVWLOUHWRULFWRQDOLWDWHGHFODPDWRDUHH[SULPDUHHPIDWLF
EVWLOODSLGDUH[SULPDUHDFRQFHQWUDW HVHQ LDOL]DW
FVWLOHUPHWLFH[SUHVLDDEUHYLDW HOLSWLF
GVWLODOX]LYXWLOL]DUHDVXJHVWLHLDPELJXLWDWH
5HFXQRDúWH L VWLOXO IXQF LRQDO LOXVWUDW vQ HQXQ XO Ä/LPED URPkQ DUH FDOHD
GHVFKLV OD WH]DXUXO LQWHOHFWXDO DO OLPELORU URPDQLFH PRGHUQH LDU SULQ FKHLD OLPELL
ODWLQHDUHDFFHVXOODFLYLOL]D LDDQWLF ´0LKDL(PLQHVFX
DVWLOXOúWLLQ LILF
EVWLOXORILFLDODGPLQLVWUDWLY
F VWLOXOEHOHWULVWLF
GVWLOXOMXUQDOLVWLF
,GHQWLILFD L VHULD FDUH FRQ LQH HQXPHUDUHD XQRU FDOLW L JHQHUDOH úL
SDUWLFXODUH LOXVWUDWH SULQ IUDJPHQWXO XUP WRU Ä6LQJXUXO OXFUX GH FDUHPL DPLQWHVF
IRDUWH ELQH HVWH F OD YkUVWD GH DQL DP GHYHQLW FRQúWLHQW GH PLQH 0LDP GDW
VHDPDF HUDvQPLQHRDQXPLW ILLQ GHFDUHHUDPFRQúWLHQW7RFPDLFLWLVHP%LEOLD
úL'HVFDUWHVSHL]OD]0DULQ3UHGD
DOLPEDMIRUPDOL]DWVWHUHRWLSLLOLQJYLVWLFHRELHFWLYLWDWH
EOLPEDMVSHFLDOL]DWLPSHUVRQDORELHFWLYLWDWH
FOLPEDMSHUVRQDOL]DWVXELHFWLYLWDWHH[SUHVLYLWDWH
GOLPEDMHWHURJHQYDULD LHVWLOLVWLF DPELJXLWDWH
Ä8QLYHUVLWDWHD VLELDQ >«@ D GHFHUQDW WLWOXO GH 'RFWRU +RQRULV &DXVD vQ
PRPHQWHOHHLDVWUDOHOXLùWHIDQ$XJXVWLQ'RLQDúúL1LFRODH%DORW úL]LOHOHDFHVWHD
SRHWXOXL HVHLVW WUDGXF WRU úL F UWXUDU GH UHSXWD LH LQWHUQD LRQDO 0LUFHD ,Y QHVFX
SRHWXOvQGU JRVWLWGHFHWDWH«´7ULEXQD±DSULOLH&RQWH[WXOGHPDLVXVVFULV
vQVWLOSXEOLFLVWLF
D XUP UHúWHLQIRUPDUHDSXEOLFXOXLDVXSUDXQXLHYHQLPHQWFXOWXUDO
E YDOLGHD] IXQF LDHVWHWLF DOLPEDMXOXL
F FRPXQLF XQPHVDMSROLYDOHQWGHRPDUHvQF UF WXU DIHFWLY
G UHDOL]HD] RFRPXQLFDUHGHWLSIRUPDOúLLJQRU GHOLEHUDWRULFHPDUF
VXELHFWLY
,GHQWLILFD LVHULDFDUHFRQ LQHHQXPHUDUHDXQRUFDOLW LJHQHUDOHúLSDUWLFXODUH
FH QX FDUDFWHUL]HD] IUDJPHQWXO XUP WRU ÄÌQ PLQWHD ILHF UXLD GLQWUH QRL úL DGHVHD vQ
VXEFRQúWLHQWXO FROHFWLY DO XQXL SRSRU UXOHD] vQ DQXPLWH PRPHQWH GLIHULWH FLWDWH
VHPQLILFDWLYH FDUH QL VH SDUH F O PXUHVF VDX FHO SX LQ FLUFXPVFULX UHDOLWDWHD DúD
FXPRVLPWHILHFDUH>«@3UREDELOF RDPHQLLPDLFUHGGDF QXvQSXWHUHDFUHDWRDUH
FHO SX LQ vQ FHD RUGRQDWRDUH D FXYkQWXOXL * VHúWL FLWDWXO SRWULYLW úL JDWD WHDL OLQLúWLW
VLWXD LDHFODU &DvQ(PLQHVFX&DvQ&DUDJLDOH&DvQ5 VFRDOD´0RQLWRUXOGH&OXM
DFODULWDWHFRQFL]LHFRUHFWLWXGLQH
EOLPEDMVSHFLDOL]DWLPSHUVRQDORELHFWLYLWDWH
FYDULD LHVWLOLVWLF VXELHFWLYLWDWHH[SUHVLYLWDWH
GSURSULHWDWHSUHFL]LHFXUVLYLWDWH
0 UFLOHWH[WXDOHVSHFLILFHRUDOLW LLVWLOXOXLVXQWHQXPHUDWHvQVHULD
DSDUDOHOLVPVLQWDFWLFFLUFXODULWDWHODLWPRWLYUHIUHQ
ELQWHUMHF LLIRUPXOHGHDGUHVDUHH[FODPD LLLQWHURJD LLSDX]HH[SUHVLYH
FPRGLILF ULIRQHWLFHILJXULGHVXQHWUHFXUHQ JUDGD LHUHWRULF FDGHQ H
ULWPLFH
GDFFHQWHGHLQWHQVLWDWHLQWRQD LDDVFHQGHQW ULWPXOULPDSDX]HOH
Ä5,& &XFRDQ « V SULPL L DVLJXUDUHD vQDOWHL VWLPH úL SURIXQGXOXL
UHVSHFW FX FDUH DP RQRDUHD D IL DO GRPQLHLYRDVWUH SUHD VXSXV úL SUHD SOHFDW «´
,/&DUDJLDOH
ÌQIUDJPHQWXOFLWDWFODULWDWHDVWLOXOXLHVWHvQF OFDW SULQ
DSOHRQDVP
EDIHUH]
F WDXWRORJLH
GVROHFLVP
ÌQ YHUVXO Ä$UJLQW H SH DSH úL DXU vQ DHU´ 0 (PLQHVFX HXIRQLD HVWH
UHDOL]DW SULQ
DUHFXUHQ
EULP LQWHULRDU
F RQRPDWHSHH
GDVRQDQ
Ä(DQXDYHDJUHXWDWHFDUHVSLUDUHD
5k]kQG úLSOkQJkQG FXODFULPLPDUL
HUDV UDW FDVDUHD
VO YLW ODRVSH HGHEDUEDUL´16W QHVFX
ÌQIUDJPHQWXOFLWDWDPELJXLWDWHDHVWHFUHDW SULQ
DWUDQVIHUXOGHVHQV
ELQRYD LDOH[LFDO
FLQGHWHUPLQDUHDUHIHUHQWXOXLILF LRQDO
GXWLOL]DUHDWHKQLFLLFRUHVSRQGHQ HORU
Ä2UFKHVWUDvQFHSXFXRLQGLJQDUHJUD LRDV
6DORQXODOEYLVDFXUR]HDOEH±
8QYDOVGHYRDOXULDOEH
6SD LXLQILQLWGHRWULVWH HDUPRQLRDV ´*%DFRYLD
6WRIDUHSURGXV PDLVXVLOXVWUHD] XUP WRDUHOHFDOLW LDOHVWLOXOXL
DFXUVLYLWDWHYDULD LHVWLOLVWLF
ERUDOLWDWHFRQFL]LH
FVXJHVWLHDPELJXLWDWH
GHXIRQLHFODULWDWH
,,,67,/8/$57,67,&
5(*,675(ì,9$/25,67,/,67,&(
67,/8/%(/(75,67,&ù,67,/8/,1',9,'8$/
$/6&5,,7258/8,
6WLOXO DUWLVWLF EHOHWULVWLF HVWH GHILQLW vQ RSR]L LH FX WRDWH FHOHODOWH VWLOXUL
IXQF LRQDOHWHUPHQLLGHGLIHUHQ LHUHILLQGDUWLVWLFQRQDUWLVWLF
D 7H[WH QRQOLWHUDUH DX FDUDFWHU QRQILF LRQDO UHIHUHQW UHDO FUHGLWDELO VDX
QHFUHGLWDELO SXWkQG IL UDSRUWDW OD FDWHJRULLOH DGHY UDW IDOV )XQF LD SULQFLSDO D
WH[WXOXL QRQOLWHUDU HVWH FHD LQIRUPDWLY LDU VFRSXO FRPXQLF ULL HVWH vQ JHQHUDO
SUDJPDWLF /LPEDMXO FRPXQ DUH URO SUHSRQGHUHQW LQVWUXPHQWDO WHUPHQLL ILLQG XWLOL]D L
PDLDOHVFXVHQVXULOHGHQRWDWLYH6XQWLOXVWUDWHFDOLW LOHJHQHUDOHDOHVWLOXOXLvQWLPS
FHUHJLVWUHOHVWLOLVWLFHVXQWvQPDUHP VXU FRQYHQ LRQDOH
E 7H[WH OLWHUDUH VH UHPDUF SULQ FDUDFWHUXO ILF LRQDO SULQ UHIHUHQWXO LPDJLQDU
GLFRWRPLD DGHY UDW IDOV GHYLQH LUHOHYDQW ,QVWDQ HOH FRPXQLF ULL DUWLVWLFH VXQW
UHDOH DXWRUXO FRQFUHW úL DEVWUDFW OHFWRUXO VSHFWDWRUXO FRQFUHW úL DEVWUDFW úL
ILF LRQDOH ÌQ RSR]L LH FX WH[WXO QRQDUWLVWLF RSHUD OLWHUDU DUH FD IXQF LH SULQFLSDO
IXQF LD SRHWLF LDU VFRSXO FRPXQLF ULL HVWH FHO HVWHWLF /LPEDMXO DUWLVWLF FX URO
SUHSRQGHUHQW VWLOLVWLF VH UHPDUF SULQ VHQVXULOH FRQRWDWLYH FUHDWH GHOLEHUDW úL SULQ
GLYHUVLWDWHDUHJLVWUHORUVWLOLVWLFH
6WLOXO DUWLVWLF VSHFLILF OLWHUDWXULL SRSXODUH DUH XQ SURQXQ DW FDUDFWHU FROHFWLY
ILLQGF UDSVRGXOSRSXODUSDUWLFLS ODDFWXOFROHFWLYGHFUHD LHFDHXQDUDWRUHXSRHWLF
DQRQLP DFWXDOL]kQG WH[WXO IROFORULF SUHH[LVWHQW VDX FUHkQG SULQ DQDORJLH FDUDFWHU
WUDGL LRQDO
ÌQFD]XOOLWHUDWXULLFXOWHFRQVWDQWHOHDEVWUDFWHDOHVWLOXOXLEHOHWULVWLF±GHWHUPLQDWH
GHVSHFLILFXOFRPXQLF ULLúLDOFXQRDúWHULLDUWLVWLFH±VXQWDVXPDWHGHVWLOXOLQGLYLGXDO
FDUH ÄUHSUH]LQW R FRQFUHWL]DUH GLVWLQFW YDULDELO vQ IXQF LH GH (XO FUHDWRU vQ
SURFHVXOGHvQWHPHLHUHSULQFXYkQWDOXPLLVHPDQWLFHDWH[WXOXL´',ULPLD
&DH[SUHVLHDLQGLYLGXDOLW LLVWLOXOHVWHPDQLHUDVSHFLILF vQFDUHVXQWVHOHFWDWH
úL IRORVLWH SRVLELOLW LOH FRPXQLFDWLYH DOH OLPELL vQ FRPXQLFDUHD FRWLGLDQ VDX vQ FHD
DUWLVWLF 6WLOXULOHLQGLYLGXDOHVHFRQVWLWXLHvQPRGHOHYDULDELOHGHDFWXDOL]DUHDOLPELL
VLVWHPvQWHPHLDWHSHYDULDELOLWDWHDFRQVWDQW DRS LXQLLVWLOLVWLFHúLDUDSRUWXOXLGLQWUH
SURFHGHH úL FRQWH[W vQ JHQHUDUHD P UFLORU VWLOLVWLFH´ ' ,ULPLD RS LXQLOH VWLOLVWLFH
DOH HPL WRUXOXL VH PDQLIHVW FRQFRPLWHQW SH FHOH GRX D[H DOH OLPELL D[D SDUD
GLJPDWLF VHULLOH VLQRQLPLFH JHQHUDWH GH YDULDQWHOH LVWRULFH JHRJUDILFH FXOWXUDOH
IXQF LRQDOHHWFDOHOLPELLQD LRQDOHúLFHDVLQWDJPDWLF SRVLELOLW LOHGHFRPELQDUHD
FXYLQWHORUvQVLQWDJPHHQXQ XULVWUXFWXULWH[WXDOH
2S LXQLOHVWLOLVWLFHDOHVFULLWRUXOXLJXYHUQDWHGHIXQF LDSRHWLF úLGHSULQFLSLXO
FUHDWLYLW LLHVWHWLFHVHFRQFUHWL]HD] SHWUHLQLYHOXUL
QLYHOXO H[WHUQ DO (XOXL FUHDWRU FDUH VH GHILQHúWH SULQ P UFL DOH LGHQWLW LL
DXFWRULDOH VRFLRFXOWXUDOH HVWHWLFH VSLULWXDOH HWF GHWHUPLQ VWLOXO LQGLYLGXDO DUKL
VWLOXOVFULLWRUXOXLVWLOXOHPLQHVFLDQVWLOXODUJKH]LDQHWF
QLYHOXO LQWHUQ GH VXSUDID DO RSHUHL FDUH DF LRQHD] UHVWULFWLY LPSXQH XQ
VWLO DO WH[WXOXL vQ IXQF LH GH PDFURVWUXFWXULOH DUWLVWLFH JHQ VSHFLH FXUHQW OLWHUDU
FDWHJRULL HVWHWLFH UDSRUWXO UHDOLWDWHILF LXQH LQVWDQ HOH FRPXQLF ULL DUWLVWLFH WHPH
FRRUGRQDWH VSD LRWHPSRUDOH HWF ÄÌQ RSHUD OXL &DUDJLDOH GH H[HPSOX VH SRW
LGHQWLILFD WUHL YDULDQWH VWLOLVWLFH VWLOXUL LQWHUQH DORVWLOXUL LPSXVH GH WUHL WLSXUL GH
GHVI úXUDUHDvQWUHE ULORUILLQ HLXPDQHVWLOXOOXPLLFRPLFHFRPHGLLVFKL HPRPHQWH
± UDSRUWXO ILLQ HL XPDQH FX OXPHD VH GHVI úRDU vQWUH FRRUGRQDWH WHPSRUDOH úL
VSD LDOH vQFKLVH VWULFW GHOLPLWDWH LVWRULF ± VWLOXO OXPLL WUDJLFH GUDPD 1 SDVWD ±
UDSRUWXO ILLQ HL XPDQH FX OXPHD HVWH HOLEHUDW GH GLPHQVLXQL VSD LDOH úL WHPSRUDOH
ILLQ D XPDQ VH FRQIUXQW FX HD vQV úL SULQ DFWLYDUHD XQRU GLPHQVLXQL LQWHULRDUH
H[LVWHQ LDOH ± VWLOXO OXPLL UHDOLVWH QXYHOH FDUDFWHUL]DW SULQWUR VLWXDUH D ILLQ HL vQWUH
FRPLFúLWUDJLF´'XPLWUX,ULPLD,QWURGXFHUHvQVWLOLVWLF
QLYHOXO LQWHUQ GH DGkQFLPH DO RSHUHL GHWHUPLQ YDULDQWHOH VWLOLVWLFH
LQWHUQH UHJLVWUHOH VWLOLVWLFH vQ IXQF LHGHPLFURVWUXFWXULOHWH[WXOXLUDSRUWXOGLQWUH
(XO WH[WXOXL úL OXPHD ILF LRQDO UDSRUWXO QDUDWRUSHUVRQDMH SHUVRQDMSHUVRQDMH
UHOD LD GLQWUH HXO SRHWLF úL WXXO OLULF GLQWUH XQLW LOH ORJLFH VDX VHFYHQ HOH
FRPSR]L LRQDOH WLSXULOH GH VWUXFWXUL GLVFXUVLYH QLYHOXULOH GH VHPQLILFDUH GH
VLPEROL]DUH HWF ÄÌQ VWUXFWXUD WH[WXOXL LDX QDúWHUH GLVFRQWLQXLW L VWLOLVWLFH >@ vQ
VWUkQV OHJ WXU FXLGHQWLWDWHDVHPDQWLF DSHUVRQDMHORUúLFXSXQFWXOGHYHGHUHDO
(XOXL FUHDWRU úL DO QDUDWRUXOXL >@ vQ DFHVW VHQV UHSUH]LQW LGHQWLW L VWLOLVWLFH
GLVWLQFWHvQWH[WXOOXPLLFRPLFHDOXL&DUDJLDOHVWLOXO&D DYHQFXVWLOXO)DUIXULGLVWLOXO
7LS WHVFXHWF´'XPLWUX,ULPLDRSFLW
5(*,675(67,/,67,&(87,/,=$7(
Ì123(5$/,7(5$5
'HILQLWH vQ 1RXO GLF LRQDU HQFLFORSHGLF DO úWLLQ HORU OLPEDMXOXL 2VZDOG 'XFURW úL
-HDQ0DULH 6FKDHIIHU FD ÄQLYHOXUL VWLOLVWLFH GH FDUH GLVSXQ ORFXWRULL SHQWUX DúL
PRGXOD PHVDMXO vQ IXQF LH GH FLUFXPVWDQ H´ UHJLVWUHOH GH OLPE VXQW FRQVLGHUDWH
VXEFRGXUL OLQJYLVWLFH VHOHFWDWH FRQúWLHQW VDX VSRQWDQ vQ LQWHULRUXO XQHL FRPXQLW L
VRFLROLQJYLVWLFH vQ VFRSXO DGHFY ULL OD VLWXD LD GH HQXQ DUH úL OD FRQWH[WXO
FRQYHUVD LRQDO
6WUDWXULOH VWLOLVWLFH DOH OLPEDMXOXL DUWLVWLF vQJOREHD] úL UHJLVWUHOH VWLOLVWLFH SULQ
FDUHVHWUDQVSXQGLYHUVHOHYDULDQWHDOHOLPELLvQVWLOXOEHOHWULVWLFúLVHFRGLILF UHSHUH
VSD LRWHPSRUDOH DOH XQLYHUVXOXL ILF LRQDO UHJLVWUXO DUKDLF VDX FHO UHJLRQDO UHJLVWUXO
SRSXODU VDX FXOW FRPSRQHQWH SVLKRVRFLDOH úL WLSDUH FRPSRUWDPHQWDOH DOH SHUVR
QDMHORUUHJLVWUXOFXOWRULSRSXODUUHJLVWUXODUJRWLFVDXFXHOHPHQWHGHMDUJRQUHJLVWUXO
FRORFYLDOUHWRULFVDXHPIDWLFHWFVWUDWHJLLGLVFXUVLYHDOHHXOXLURVWLWRUUHJLVWUXORUDO
UHJLVWUXOVFULV
5HJLVWUHVWLOLVWLFHXWLOL]DWHvQFUHD LLOLWHUDUH
5HJLVWUXO &DUDFWHULVWLFLP UFLWH[WXDOH ([HPSOH
5HJLVWUHVWLOLVWLFHJHQHUDOH
8WLOL]DW FD YDULDQW VWLOLVWLF vQ RSHUD OLWHUDU IROFORULF VDX 7ULLQHOHMRVSLFD
FXOW UHJLVWUXO SRSXODU SUHVXSXQH VLWXDUHD QDUDWRUXOXL D 7ULvQJHULOHULGLFD
SHUVRQDMHORU D HXOXL OLULF vQ VIHUD FXOWXULL SRSXODUH SULQWUXQ 7ULvQJHULFXWULELFLXUL
/DWULFRUQXULGHS PkQW
OLPEDMPDUFDWGHVSRQWDQHLWDWHúLLQGLFLDLLPSOLF ULLDIHFWLYH 7RWWU VQHVFüLWRWSOHVQHVF
/D QLYHO IRQHWLF P UFL DOH RUDOLW LL DFFHQWH DIHFWLYH 6 ULGLFHPXQ LLFUXQ L
YDULDQWHIRQHWLFHIDPLOLDUHLJQRUkQGQRUPHOHRUWRHSLFHULPHúL &ROLQGHGLQ$UGHDO
&HVDU L"
ULWPXULVLPSOHDOLWHUD LL
/DQLYHOOH[LFDOVHOHFWDUHDXQRUFXYLQWHúLH[SUHVLLLGLRPD & FLHUDERERFGHWUDQGDILU
WLFH VSHFLILFH XQLYHUVXOXL UXVWLF LQFOXVLY UHJLRQDOLVPH GLQ OXQD OXL PDLX >@ 6DX
IUHFYHQ DPDUHDGLPLQXWLYHORUDEDWHULGHWLSXOSOHRQDVPXOXL FXP VDU PDL ]LFH OD QRL vQ
DOWDXWRORJLHL U QHüWH HUD IUXPRDV GH
/D QLYHO PRUIRVLQWDFWLF SUH]HQ D XQRU IRUPH QHOLWHUDUH PDPD IRFXOXL OD VRDUH WH
IRUPH IOH[LRQDUH QHOLWHUDUH DFX]DWLYXO FX SUHSR]L LH vQ ORFXO SXWHDLXLWDLDUODGkQVDED
ûL GH DFHHD +DUDS$OE R
GDWLYXOXL IRUPH SURQRPLQDOH FRORFYLDOH GH]DFRUGXO HWF
SU S GHDGLQRFKLGHGUDJ
YLLWRUXO SRSXODU SUH]XPWLYXO VXSHUODWLYXO SRSXODU IUHFYHQ D FHLHUD
PDUHDLQWHUMHF LHLPRGHOHVLQWDFWLFHED]DWHSHUHSHWL LLVDXSH ,&UHDQJ
UHFXUHQ DOXLÄúL´QDUDWLYDQDFROXWXOHWF 3RYHVWHDOXL+DUDS$OE
/DQLYHOVWLOLVWLFFDUDFWHUXOWUDGL LRQDODOILJXULORUGHVWLO
5HJLVWUX VWLOLVWLF FDUH GHILQHúWH vQ JHQHUDO FUHD LLOH OLWHUDUH
FXOWH LPSOLF VLWXDUHD LQVWDQ HORU FRPXQLF ULL DUWLVWLFH vQ 8QWkQ UPHWDO
RUL]RQWXO FXOWXULL SULQ DSOLFDUHD QRUPHORU OLPELL OLWHUDUH SULQ WUDQVSDUHQW
VXE LUHFDODPDW LRDV
LQIRUPD LDFXOWXUDO ERJDW W LDRUL]RQWXULFXUEDWHüL
1LYHOXO IRQHWLF H GHILQLW SULQ HXIRQLH vQ SRH]LH ULWPXUL úL OHQWGHVS U HDSULYLUHDGH
ULPHFRPSOH[H RFKLFXYkQWXOGHLGHH
1LYHO OH[LFDO FDUDFWHUL]DW SULQ GLYHUVLWDWH úL ERJ LH UD]DGHVWHDSHFkQGSOXWHD
VLQRQLPLF SULQJUDGXOULGLFDWGHFRQFHSWXDOL]DUHDWHUPHQLORU RIORDUHGHWHL
SULQ YDORULILFDUHD SRWHQ LDOLW LORU PXOWLSOH GH VHPQLILFDUH vQO XQWUXOXQHLJkQGLUL
DPELJXL]DUHGHOLEHUDW DEVWUDFWH
1LYHOVLQWDFWLFIUD] FRPSOH[ HODERUDW
16W QHVFX
6HPQ
/DQLYHOVWLOLVWLFSUHGLOHF LDSHQWUXWURSLúLILJXULGHJkQGLUH
YDULD LHVWLOLVWLF RULJLQDOLWDWH
2UDOLWDWHD YL]HD] GRX VWUDWXUL VWLOLVWLFH XQ VWUDW SULPDU ²+HLKHLF O WRUXOH'DF
LQWULQVHF OLWHUDWXULL SRSXODUH úL WXWXURU FUHD LLORU WHDWUDOH úL XQ LL YRUED GHDüD DL V L
VWUDWGHULYDWVSHFLILFVWUXFWXULORUGLDORJDOHGLQSUR] VDXGLQ UXSL FLRFKLQHOH XPEOkQG üL
WRW QDL V J VHüWL VOXJ
SRH]LH úL VWLOXOXL PDULORU SRYHVWLWRUL D F URU VFULLWXU VLPX FXP FDX L GWD F SHDLFL
OHD] FLUFXPVWDQ HOHFRPXQLF ULLRUDOH VXQW QXPDL RDPHQL VSkQL
3DUWLFXODULW LFRPXQLFDUHGLUHFW SUHSRQGHUHQWFRORFYLDO ûDSRLFkQGHVWHODDGLF OHD
DIHFWLY úLVSRQWDQ FXUHODWLYHOLEHUW LID GHQRUPHOHOLPELL WHDü vQWUHED FD
FH IHO GH
VWDQGDUGGDUFXJUDGULGLFDWGHFRQYHQ LRQDOLWDWHúLVWHUHRWLSLH ] WLFQHDO DL SXWHD V
vQ SURGXFHUHD ÄIDSWHORU GH VWLO´ UHOHYDQ D HOHPHQWHORU vQWkPSLQLGLQSULFLQDDVWD"
,&UHDQJ
SDUDYHUEDOH úL QRQYHUEDOH vQ FRQVWLWXLUHD VHQVXULORU ]RQH GH 3RYHVWHDOXL+DUDS$OE
LQFLGHQ FXUHJLVWUXOVWLOLVWLFSRSXODUGLIHUHQ LHULvQIXQF LHGH
WLSXOGHFXOWXU YDULDQWDRUDOLW LLUXVWLFHYDULDQWDFLWDGLQ ² (L 6 O V P IUD]HOH
0 UFL GLVWLQFWLYH IRUPXOH DOH DGUHV ULL GLUHFWH HQXQ XUL QHQH &D DYHQFXOH $VWHD
H[FODPDWLYH úL LQWHURJDWLYH HOLG UL IRQHWLFH WRSLF DIHFWLY VXQW EXQH SHQWUX JXU
FDVF (X VXQW RPXO SH
IUHFYHQ DXQRUVLQWDJPHH[SUHVLLFRORFYLDOHDVXEVWDQWLYHORU FDUH V O vPEH L FX DS
vQYRFDWLYDYHUEHORUODLPSHUDWLYDLQWHUMHF LLORUDEDWHULGHOD UHFH"6SXQHXQGHV ILH"
QRUP SUHFXPGH]DFRUGXODQDFROXWXOHWF ,/&DUDJLDOH
2VFULVRDUHSLHUGXW
5HJLVWUXO &DUDFWHULVWLFLP UFLWH[WXDOH ([HPSOH
5HJLVWUX VWLOLVWLF VFULV SUHVXSXQH FRPXQLFDUH DUWLVWLF
PHGLDW SULQ SURGXFHUHD XQHL VFULLWXUL DO F UXL FULWHULX YDORULF $PH LQG WRWXO DFHDVW
HVWH RULJLQDOLWDWHD vQWUXQ OLPEDM DXWRUHIOH[LY FRQúWLHQW GH LXELUHvQIORUHDI U VHDP Q
FXP vQIORUHVF V OEDWLF vQ
IRU DVDGHDvQWHPHLDXQLYHUVXULDXWRQRPHGDUúLGHOLPLWHOH OXQD PDL QLPIHOH OXMHULORU
DFHVWRUOXPLVHPDQWLFH GH FULQ &X RFKLL PDUL
1LYHOXOIRQHWLFQXPDLSX LQLPSRUWDQWGHFkWvQUHJLVWUXORUDO DOEDüWUL YLL FD QLüWH vQWUH
DUPRQLL LPLWDWLYH ULWPXUL vQ HXIRQLH VDX UXSWXUL GH ULWP ULPH E ULGHFOHüWDUFXQHDVWkP
FRPSOH[H HWF HVWH GXEODW GH QLYHOXO JUDIHPDWLF ÄH[SORD S UXO WUXSXOXL WkQ U FX
WDUHD UHVXUVHORU SRHWLFH DOH JUDILVPXOXL úL DOH SXQHULL vQ JXUD QHFRQWHQLW XPHG üL
SDJLQ ´ ± * *HQHWWH GH VHPQDOL] ULOH PHWDWH[WXDOH YHUVXO IUDJHG FX R LQWHOLJHQ
DOE YHUVXO VSD LDO HWF FKLDU GDF SLFWRSRH]LD VDX FDOLJUD FDUH LUXPSHD L]YRUkW WRW
DWkW GH PXOW GLQ LQLP FkW
PHOHU PkQIRUPHGHH[SUHVLYLWDWHDUWLVWLF H[SHULPHQWDOH GH VXE IUXQWH HUD XQ
1LYHOXOOH[LFDOHVWHFDUDFWHUL]DWSULQWURRULHQWDUHGHOLEHUDW VSHFWDFROPLQXQDW
DOLPEDMXOXLVSUHSROLVHPLHPD[LP FDUHFRQIHU XQFDUDFWHU &DPLO3HWUHVFX
8OWLPDQRDSWH
GHVFKLV VHPQLILFD LLORU UH HOH OH[LFDOH WHPDWLFH FkPSXUL
VHPDQWLFHWHUPHQLFXRFXUHQ UDU 2GDF QDUILHURDUHD
1LYHOXO VLQWDFWLF VWUXFWXUDUHD ULJXURDV D WH[WXOXL DVWIHO GDF DPILFXUD L
vQFkW ILHFDUH VHFYHQ WH[WXDO V SDUWLFLSH OD UHOHYDQ D &XPVXQWSHüWLLGLQPDUHD
HVWHWLF D VHPQXOXL OLQJYLVWLF SURFHGHHOH úL ILJXULOH GH FHDVIHULF IUD L
FRQVWUXF LH DX URO GHILQLWRULX vQ SURGXFHUHD VHPQLILFD LHL «üLILHFDUHVHFXQG QDUIL
UHFXUHQ DVLPHWULDGLVORFDUHDHOLSVDRSR]L LDUHSHWL LD PHUHXDWUHFXWXOXL«
16W QHVFX
/D QLYHO VWLOLVWLF ÄVXE DF LXQHD SULQFLSLXOXL PHWDIRULF 2GDF
UDSRUWXULOHVLQWDFWLFHVHGH]YROW vQVWUXFWXULLPDJLVWLFHvQVSD LXO
F URUDVHFRQIUXQW XQXQLYHUVUHDOFXXQXOLPDJLQDU´',ULPLD
5HJLVWUHVWLOLVWLFHSDUWLFXODUH
5HJLVWUX VWLOLVWLF FDUH HYLGHQ LD] GLPHQVLXQHD LVWRULF D / SXüQHDQXOSRUXQFLV vPSOH
OLPEDMXOXLVLWXHD] LQVWDQ HOHFRPXQLF ULLDUWLVWLFHvQWUXQRUL]RQW FXOHPQHWRDWHFHW LOH0ROGD
GHWLPSUHYROXWSULQDFWXDOL]DUHDXQXLOLPEDMvQYHFKLWLHúLWGLQX] YLHLDIDU GH+RWLQüLOHDUVH
YUkQG V VWULFH SULQ DFHDVWD
'RPLQDQWD VWLOLVWLF RFXUHQ D DUKDLVPHORU OD WRDWH QLYH D]LOXOQHPXO PL LORUFDULLGH
OXULOH GLVFXUVXOXL úL UHYLWDOL]DUHD XQRU FRQVWUXF LL WLSDUH PXOWH RUL XU]HDX FRPSORWXUL
OLQJYLVWLFHvQYHFKLWH üLD k DXUHYROWH
7LSXUL GH DUKDLVPH OH[LFDOH FXYLQWH LHúLWH GLQ X] VWROQLF &1HJUX]]L
$OH[DQGUX/ SXúQHDQXO
ORJRI W HWF IRQHWLFH IRUPH VRQRUH vQYHFKLWH SUH VDP D
vPSOH D UXPSH O FDú VHPDQWLFH FXYLQWH XWLOL]DWH RGLQLRDU ûWHIDQ OXL 5DUHü ,D FDUWHD
FX DOW VHQV SURVWLPH ± RDPHQL VH UkQG D W E Uv ± D DúH]D DVWD %DJR vQ VkQ ,D
WDE U DFHUWD±DSHGHSVLHWFPRUIRORJLFHIRUPHIOH[LRQDUH VHDPD OD SHFHWLH 3XQH FDLL
YHFKLLQLPHDULSHSDODWXULY ]XPSOkQVXPVDXIRVWGHVFKLV ODXQRODF$OHJHXQXOELQH
HWFVLQWDFWLFH*D]HWDGH7UDQVLOYDQLDGRPQ ULL0ROGRYHL IHUHFDW ûL OD GUXP
6FKLPE FDLL GLQ SRSDV vQ
)XQF LD VWLOLVWLF D DUKDLVPHORU XWLOL]DWH vQ SUR]D GH SRSDV ûL V QX WH RSUHüWL
LQVSLUD LH LVWRULF HVWH DFHHD GH D FUHD XQ WDEORX GH HSRF GHFkWvQ DULJUDG$FRORVR
VDXGHDGLIHUHQ LDGLVFXUVXOQDUDWRUXOXLGHFHODOSHUVRQDMHORU GDLvQPkQ PDUHOXLYL]LU
vQWHDWUXOLVWRULFDUKDLVPHOHFUHHD] LPSUHVLDGHYHURVLPLOLWDWH 'HODYUDQFHD
$SXVGHVRDUH
SULQUHFRQVWLWXLUHDOLPEDMXOXLYUHPLLHYRFDWH
5HJLVWUX VWLOLVWLF FDUH FRQIHU LGHQWLWDWH JHRJUDILFOLQJYLVWLF )UDWHOH FHO V UDF V UDF V
XQLYHUVXOXL ILF LRQDO SHUVRQDMXOXL QDUDWRUXOXL VDX LQVWDQ HL ILH GH S FDWH WRW DYHD üL
OLULFHH[SULPDWH HORSHUHFKHGHERLGDUFROq
SRUXPELODS UWLQHULQDO L
7LSXUL GH UHJLRQDOLVPH XWLOL]DWH vQ VFRS H[SUHVLY OH[LFDOH GH WUXS HSRüL OD FRDUQH
FXYLQWHFXFLUFXOD LHUHVWUkQV ODRDULHJHRJUDILF GLDOHFWDO DPkQGRL FXGDOEL LQWD L vQ
RP WROHDF QL HOS SXúRLFXFXUX]HWFIRQHWLFHSURQXQ LL IUXQWH FLRO QRüL üL JURüL
GLIHUHQ LDWH vQ IXQF LH GH DULD GLDOHFWDO JKLQH FKLDWU V FXP VXQW PDL EXQL GH
VSXLHV SULQ] HWFVHPDQWLFHVHQVXULGLIHULWHDOHDFHOXLDúL vQMXJDW OD FDU GH LHüLW FX
FXYkQWvQ]RQHGLIHULWHPHUHX±ÄvQFHW´vQ%DQDWJUDPDWLFDOH GkQüLLvQOXPHüLGHI FXW
5HJLVWUXO &DUDFWHULVWLFLP UFLWH[WXDOH ([HPSOH
IRUPH VSHFLILFH DQXPLWRU UHJLXQL DLVWD DLDVWD vQ 0ROGRYD WUHDE 'DU SOXJ JUDS
VWD DLD vQ 0XQWHQLD YLLWRUXO PROGRYHQHVF ± RL PHUJH WHOHDJ VDQLH FDU WkQMDO
SUH]HQWXO OXFU PkQF vQ 7UDQVLOYDQLD GH]DFRUGXO VXELHFW FkUFHLH FRDV KUHDSF
SRL JUHEO üL FkWH DOWH
SUHGLFDWvQ0XQWHQLDHWF OXFUXUL FH WUHEXLHVF RPXOXL
9DORDUH H[SUHVLY O UJLUHD VHULHL VLQRQLPLFH FRQIHU JRVSRGDUQLFLF VHDIODXOD
FXORDUH ORFDO UHDOLVP GHVFULSWLY DX URO GH FDUDFWHUL]DUH D FDVDDFHVWXLRPQHVRFRWLW
SHUVRQDMHORU FD HOHPHQWH GH OLPEDM SRSXODUIDPLOLDU ,&UHDQJ
DVSHFWHOH IRQHWLFLL UHJLRQDOH DSOLFDWH XQRU QHRORJLVPH DX ' QLO 3UHSHOHDF
GHFOLúHHúLvQMRFXULVFOLSLWRDUHGHFXYLQWH
5HJLVWUX VWLOLVWLF GHILQLWRULX SHQWUX FUHD LLOH VHFYHQ HOH 9UHPHWUHFHYUHPHYLQH
WH[WXDOH vQ FDUH VXQW IRUPXODWH UHIOHF LL DVXSUD FRQGL LHL 7RDWHVYHFKLüLQRX
&HHU XüLFHHELQH
WRDWH
XPDQH 7XWHQWUHDE üLVRFRDWH
'RPLQDQWD VWLOLVWLF GLVFXUVXO FRQFHSWXDOL]DW SULQ FDUH VH 1XVSHUDüLQXDLWHDP
LQVWLWXLH IRUPXO UL SUHJQDQW VHQWHQ LRDVH XWLOL]DUHD XQRU &HHYDOFDYDOXOWUHFH
'HWHQGHDPQ GHWH
VWUXFWXUL OLQJYLVWLFH LPSHUVRQDOH SHUVRDQH JUDPDWLFDOH FX FKHDP
YDORDUHJHQHULF 7XU PkLODWRDWHUHFH
([SUHVLYLWDWHD DUWLVWLF HVWH GHWHUPLQDW GH OLPEDMXO FX 0(PLQHVFX*ORVV
PDUH YDORDUH FRJQLWLY UHIHUHQW JHQHUDOXPDQ WHUPHQL
FRQFHSWXDOL]D LIRUPXO ULPHPRUDELOHFDUHH[SULP vQLPDJLQL
DUWLVWLFH UDSRUWXO GLQWUH RP úL XQLYHUV RP úL H[LVWHQ
FXQRDúWHUHFUHD LHWLPSHWF
5HJLVWUX VWLOLVWLF VSHFLILF FUHD LLORU FX XQ UHIHUHQW LPDJLQDU &XPVHVSULMLQ QRXULLQHJUL
WUDQVFHQGHQW vQ FDUH HVWH VXUSULQV UHOD LD ILLQ HL FX GHFHUDüDVHVSULMLQ
GLYLQLWDWHD ILRUXO PHWDIL]LF QHOLQLúWHD RQWRORJLF úL VXIOHWXOPHX
GHXPEUDWD'RDPQH
JQRVHRORJLF DVSLUD LD VD VSUH VDFUX QHYRLD GH FHUWLWXGLQL 1LFKLWD'DQLORY3HLVDMFX
HWF OXPkQ ULDSULQVHQYkQW
9$/25,67,/,67,&($/(7,0385,/259(5%$/(
Ä7H[WXOOLWHUDU±RSLQHD] 'XPLWUX,ULPLDvQVWXGLXO,QWURGXFHUHvQVWLOLVWLF ±SRDWH
ILFRQVLGHUDWFDRUHDOLWDWHFXGRX LSRVWD]HFRQVXEVWDQ LDOHVWUXFWXU VWLOLVWLF úL
IXQF LDGHVHPQLILFDUHSRHWLF ÌQSULPDLSRVWD] VWUXFWXUDVWLOLVWLF SRDUW P UFLOH
(XOXLDXFWRULDOvQLSRVWD]DDGRXDVWUXFWXUDVWLOLVWLF JHQHUHD] OXPHDVHPDQWLF D
WH[WXOXLúLSRDUW WRWRGDW P UFLOH(XOXLWH[WXOXL´$PEHOHVHULLGHP UFLVWLOLVWLFH±DOH
HXOXL DXFWRULDO úL DOH HXOXL WH[WXDO ± vúL GHILQHVF LGHQWLWDWHD úL LPSOLFLW RULJLQDOLWDWHD
SULQ PRGXO GH YDORULILFDUH D SRWHQ LDOXOXL H[SUHVLY DO OLPELL D GLYHUVHORU FDWHJRULL
HVWHWLFHVHPDQWLFHPRUIRORJLFHúLVLQWDFWLFH
9(5%8/SULQUHJLPXOV XSULYLOHJLDWGHQXFOHXDOHQXQ ULLUHSUH]LQW RVXUV
PDMRU GH H[SUHVLYLWDWH DUWLVWLF $FHDVWD VH FRQVWUXLHúWH QX QXPDL OD QLYHOXO
FRQ LQXWXOXL VHPDQWLF úL DO VWUXFWXULL OLQJYLVWLFH YHUEH ORFX LXQL YHUEDOH FL úL OD
QLYHOXOFDWHJRULLORUPRUIRVLQWDFWLFHVSHFLILFH±WLPSXULOHPRGXULOHSHUVRDQHOH
Ä7LPSXO FHD PDL FRPSOH[ FDWHJRULH JUDPDWLFDO GH]YROW JUDGXO FHO PDL vQDOW
GH FRPSOH[LWDWH vQ VWLOXO EHOHWULVWLF >@ 6WLOXO EHOHWULVWLF vúL GHILQHúWH VSHFLILFXO SULQ
FRQVWLWXLUHD WLPSXOXL JUDPDWLFDO vQWUR FDWHJRULH QDUDWLY ´ ' ,ULPLD LPSOLFkQG
SHUVSHFWLYHWHPSRUDOHúLFDSDFLWDWHGHVSD LDOL]DUHSULPSODQúLSODQXULGHDGkQFLPH
9DORULVWLOLVWLFHDOHFDWHJRULLORUJUDPDWLFDOH ([HPSOH
35(=(178/HVWHIRUPDYHUEDO FDUHÄGH]YROW UHJLVWUXOVHPDQWLFFHOPDLERJDWDFRSHULQG
IXQF LRQDOWRDWHFHOHWUHLSHUVSHFWLYHWHPSRUDOHWUHFXWSUH]HQWYLLWRUVDXGH]YROWkQGXQVHQV
SDQWHPSRUDO´'XPLWUX,ULPLD
SUH]HQWXO QDUDWLY ± SURSXQH R SHUVSHFWLY
VLQFURQLF vQ FDUH WLPSXO QDU ULL úL WLPSXO HYHQLPHQWHORU ([SOR]LLOHVHVXFFHGRUJDQL]DW8QHOHOHDXGODFk LYD
QDUDWHVHVXSUDSXQWLPSXOOHFWXU ULLLQWU úLHOvQUH]RQDQ SDüLDOWHOHvQPLQH8QYkMkLWVFXUWSHFDUHXUHFKHDvO
FX DFHVW WLPS LQWHJUDWRU JHQHUkQG R WHPSRUDOLWDWH SULQGH FX XQ VRL GH DQWLFLSD LH vQFOHüWH]L GLQ LL FX
FRLQFLGHQW vQ FDUH ÄVH vQWkOQHVF´ QDUDWRUXO HURLL úL PkQD vQGRLW GHDVXSUD FDSXOXL vQWUR FRQYXOVLH
OHFWRUXO ÄVFULLWRUXO DGXFH WLPSXO QDUD LXQLL vQ WLPSXO HSLOHSWLF
FLWLWRUXOXL´',ULPLD &3HWUHVFX
± FDUDFWHULVWLF QDUD LXQLL vQ VLPXOWDQHLWDWH SUH]HQWXO 2PXOVHVFRDO WUH]HüWHFRSLLvQKDP FDLLüLXPEO GH
QDUDLYGLQDPL]HD] DF LXQHDLQGXFHOHFWRUXOXLVHQWLPHQWXO FRORSkQ FRORSULQFXUWH
SDUWLFLS ULLGLUHFWHODHYHQLPHQWHOHLVWRULVLWHFUHkQGLOX]LD 03UHGD
F DFHVWHDVXQWUHODWDWHSHP VXU FHVHGHVI úRDU
± YDORUL H[SUHVLYH PXOWLSOH ÄUHOLHIDUHD GUDPDWLVPXO (O]ERDU JkQGSXUWDWGHGRU
UDSLGLWDWHD SODVWLFLWDWHD ± GDU úL UXSWXUD HYDOXDUHD 3kQ
SLHUHWRWXOWRWXO
0(PLQHVFX
VXUSUL]D´5=DILX
± vQ SRH]LD HSLF úL vQ FUHD LD OLULF vQ FDUH YL]LXQHD 2UHOHSOXWHVFSHOkQJ XP UXOW X
SRHWLF VH vQWHPHLD] SH XQ VFHQDULX QDUDWLY SUH]HQWXO VIHUHDOEDVWUHüLQWUHHOHH6DWXUQ
GHWHUPLQ ÄDQXODUHD KRWDUHORU VHPDQWLFWHPSRUDOH ûLFXPVHGXFVHPLFüRUHD]
VSHFLILFH´ ',ULPLD FRQIHULQG XQ UHOLHI VWLOLVWLF GHRVHELW PDLvQVHUDWüLPDLQRFWXUQ
VLWXD LHL HYHQLPHQWXOXL H[SHULHQ HL GH FXQRDúWHUH 16W QHVFX
VXUSULQVHvQGHVI úXUDUH
SUH]HQWXOLVWRULFGUDPDWLF±DQXOHD] RSR]L LDFDWH 0LKDLVHJU EHüWHWUHFH'XQ UHDvüLvQGHDPQ RüWLOH
JRULDO SUH]HQWWUHFXWSULQDFWXDOL]DUHDXQRUHYHQLPHQWH FDUHQ Y OHVFDVXSUDWXUFLORUüLvLXFLGVDXvLSULQGPDL
DQWHULRDUH vQ SUH]HQWXO QDUDWRUXOXL úL LPSOLFLW DO SH WR L>@ 'DU +DVVDQ3DüD IXJHD vQVS LPkQWDW üL
OHFWRUXOXL QXVHSXWHD LQHSHSLFLRDUHGHJURD]
± vQ DOWHUQDQ FX YHUEH OD WLPSXUL WUHFXWH SURGXFH 1% OFHVFX
ÄLHUDUKLD SODQXULORU GH DGkQFLPH SULQ WHKQLFD 0LKQHDvQFDOHF FDOXOV XWURSRW
EDVRUHOLHIXOXL´ DGXFkQG ILJXUD úL IDSWHOH HURXOXL ÄvQ )XJHFDYkQWXO
FODU OXPLQ DSUH]HQWXOXL´vQFRQWUDVWFXDGYHUVDULLOXLúL '%ROLQWLQHDQX
ÄDF LXQLOH FRQH[H FDUH VXQW vPSLQVH vQ SHQXPEUD
WUHFXWXOXL´79LDQX
9DORULVWLOLVWLFHDOHFDWHJRULLORUJUDPDWLFDOH ([HPSOH
± Ä3UHIHULQ D SHQWUX SHUIHFWXO VLPSOX FD WLPS QDUDWLY vQ 0LUFHDvQVXüLPkQ QOXSW YLMHOLDQJUR]LWRDUH
SUR] úL SHQWUX SUH]HQWXO LVWRULF vQ SRH]LH HVWH vQ &DUHYLQHYLQHYLQHFDOF WRWXOvQSLFLRDUH
VHFROXO WUHFXW VHF DO ;,;OHD QQ SULQFLSDOD GLIHUHQ 0(PLQHVFX
GLQWUH QRUPD QDUDWLY D SUR]HL úL FHD D SRH]LHL´
5=DILX
SUH]HQWXO HWHUQ DWHPSRUDO ± ÄPLMORF DO SRWHQ ULL &HPLLYUHPHDFkQGGHYHDFXUL
UHWRULFH´ 79LDQX SULQ FDUH WLPSXO QDUD LXQLL WLPSXO 6WHOHPLVFkQWHLHSHODFXUL
HQXQ ULL úL DO UHFHSW ULL VH vQVFULX vQWUXQ FRQWLQXXP & GHLYUHPHDUHDVDXEXQ
WHPSRUDO I U vQFHSXW úL I U VIkUúLW SHUFHSXW GLQ 9kQWXPLEDWHIUXQ]DPLVXQ
SHUVSHFWLY FRVPLF VDXPHWDIL]LF 0(PLQHVFX
±GHUHDOL]HD] FDWHJRULDWLPSXOXLFRQVLGHUDW LUHOHYDQW 1XPDLSRHWXO
H[SULPkQG FRQGL LD RQWRORJLF D XQRU HQWLW L FRQVL &DS V ULFH]ERDU
GHUDWH DWHPSRUDOH 'LYLQLWDWHD 1DWXUD &UHD LD $UWD 'HDVXSUDYDOXULORU
,XELUHD/LEHUWDWHDHWF 7UHFHSHVWHQHP UJLQLUHDWLPSXOXL
±YDORDUHDH[SUHVLY YL]HD] vQVFULHUHDIHQRPHQDOXOXL 0(PLQHVFX
vQWUR SHUVSHFWLY XQLYHUVDO vQFDGUDUHD H[SHULHQ HL 3HVWH ]YkUFROLULOH YLH LL YUHPHD YLQH QHS V WRDUH
LQGLYLGXDOHDHYHQLPHQWXOXLSDUWLFXODUvQWUXQWLSDUPLWLF üWHUJkQG WRDWH XUPHOH 6XIHULQ HOH SDWLPLOH
FD ÄPRGDOLWDWH VWLOLVWLF D VXERUGRQ ULL IDSWHORU OD LGHH´ Q ]XLQ HOHPDULVDXPLFLVHSLHUGvQWURWDLQ GXUHURV
79LDQX SUH]HQWXO HWHUQ DUH URO GH UHOLHIDUH D XQRU GH QHFXSULQV FD QLüWH WUHPXU UL SO SkQGH vQWUXQ
FDWHJRULL ILORVRILFH D XQRU FRQFHSWH HWLFH HVWHWLFH VDX XUDJDQXULDü
FRJQLWLYHDXQRUYDORULXPDQHFRQVLGHUDWHDWHPSRUDOH /5HEUHDQX
SUH]HQWXO JQRPLF SDQWHPSRUDO ± DUH FD HIHFW 3VLKRORJLDDUDW F DXRWHQGLQ GHVWDELOL]DUHVW ULOH
VWLOLVWLF VXVSHQGDUHD RSR]L LLORU WHPSRUDOH FRQIHULQG VXIOHWHüWLUHSHWDWHüLF PHQ LQXWHFXYRLQ GXFODR
HQXQ XULORURYDORDUHRPQLWHPSRUDO úLXQJUDGPDUHGH DGHYDUDW QHYUR] 2ULFH LXELUH H FD XQ PRQRLGHLVP
JHQHUDOLWDWH YROXQWDUODvQFHSXWSDWRORJLFSHXUP
± HVWH VSHFLILF HQXQ XULORU VHQWHQ LRDVH DXWRQRPH SUR &3HWUHVFX
YHUEH ]LF WRUL PD[LPH DIRULVPH PHGLWD LLORU ILORVRILFH
FXJHW ULORUGLYHUVHDVXSUDFRQGL LHLXPDQHDVXSUDUDSRU 9UHPHWUHFHYUHPHYLQH
WXOXLRPOXPHRPGLYLQLWDWHILLQ FUHDWRDUH±FUHD LHHWF 7RDWHVYHFKLüLQRX WRDWH
0(PLQHVFX
± vQ SODQ VHPDQWLF LPSULP R GLPHQVLXQH FRJQLWLY
WH[WXOXLúLRYDORDUHPRUDO JHQHUDOXPDQ PHVDMXOXL
± vQ SODQ VWLOLVWLF YDORDUHD H[SUHVLY H JHQHUDW GH 7RDW OXPHDVHXLW SHIHUHDVWU
FRQFL]LDSODVWLF DGLVFXUVXOXLúLIUHFYHQWGHYDOHQ HOH &LWHüWHVSDO LXEHüWHPRDUH
PHWDIRULFHPHWRQLPLFH DOH YHUEHORU OD SUH]HQWXO ûLGLQFkQGvQFkQGG IXJD
JQRPLF vQ FUHD LL QHR SRVWPRGHUQLVWH SUH]HQWXO ûLVHXLW SHIHUHDVWU
JQRPLFHVWHDVRFLDWXQRUUHDOLW LSUR]DLFH 06RUHVFX
SUH]HQWXO OLULF ± UHDOL]HD] XQ GHFXSDM vQ IOX[XO 3XUXULWkQ UvQI üXUDWvQPDQWDPL
WHPSRUDO FRQWLQXX H[SULPkQG LQWHQVLWDWHD WU LULL vQWUR
2FKLLPHLQ O DPYLV WRULODVWHDXD6LQJXU W LL
GXUDW FRQFHQWUDW
&kQGGHRGDW WXU V ULüLvQFDOHPL
±vQSODQXOVHPQLILFD LLORUSUHVXSXQHFRQúWLLQ DOLPLWHORU
RQWLFHDOHILLQ HLúLDVXPDUHDFRQGL LHLH[LVWHQ LDOHH[SULP
-DOQLFDUGGHYLXFKLQXLWFD1HVVXV
± H[SOLFLW VDX LPSOLFLW ± GRULQ D GH D GD XQ VHQV GXUDWHL
IUDJPHQWDUHRULUHIX]XOQHSXWLQ DÄVW ULLSHORF´HWF 2ULFD+HUFXOvQYHQLQDWGHKDLQDL
OD QLYHO VWLOLVWLF SUH]HQWXO OLULF DFFHQWXHD] RSR]L LD )RFXOPHXDOVWLQJHQXSRWFXWRDWH
vQWUH SHUVSHFWLYHOH WHPSRUDOH YDORUL]kQG ÄFOLSD FHD $SHOHP ULL
0(PLQHVFX
UHSHGHFHQLVDGDW´vQFRQWUDVWFXWUHFXWXOVDXFXYLLWRUXO
SUH]HQWXO HYRFDWLY DO UHSUH]HQW ULL ILF LRQDOH ± 'HDWXQFLQHJXUDHWHUQ VHGHVIDFHvQI üLL
DUHRYDORDUHGXUDWLY SURSXQkQGRSHUVSHFWLY DXQXL 'HDWXQFLU VDUHOXPHDOXQ VRDUHüLVWLKLL
WUHFXWFDUHVHGHVFKLGHVSUHSUH]HQWXOQDU ULLDOURVWLULL 'HDOPHXSURSULXIRFP WRSHVFGHDWXQFHD
OLULFHúLDOOHFWXU ULL 'HDOPHXSURSULXFkQWPLVWXLWP PkQWXL
VHPDQWL]DUHD SRHWLF D SUH]HQWXOXL HYRFDWLY 0(PLQHVFX
GHWHUPLQ DQXODUHD VXFFHVLXQLL OLQHDUH D GRX GXUDWH 'HDWkWHDQRS LDXGSORXkQG
SHFDUHOHÄGL]ROY ´vQWUXQIOX[WHPSRUDOFRQWLQXX $XGPDWHULDSOkQJkQG«
YDORDUHD H[SUHVLY D SUH]HQWXOXL HYRFDWLY UH]LG vQ *%DFRYLD
GHVFKLGHUHDSHUVSHFWLYHORUWHPSRUDOHúLLQVWDODUHDHXOXL 6 DLQRURFvQYLD YRUED$XULFKLLDVWDHWRW8QXOVH
URVWLWRUD QDUDWRUXOXL vQWUR GXUDW FRQWLQX ]EDWH GH PLF vQY vüL XPSOH SO PkQXO GH RIWLF üL
GLQDPL]HD] LPDJLQLOH DUWLVWLFHDF LXQHD SULQ UHIHUHQWXO DOWXLDvLSLF PRüWHQLUHDGHDJDWD
WHPSRUDOGHDVSHFWGXUDWLY *& OLQHVFX
9DORULVWLOLVWLFHDOHFDWHJRULLORUJUDPDWLFDOH ([HPSOH
SUH]HQWXODQWLFLSDWLYSURVSHFWLY±LPSXQHRSHUV $üWHSWV vPLDSXQ ]LXD
SHFWLY RULHQWDW VSUHYLLWRU üL]DUHDPHDSOHRDSDV üLvQFKLG
OD QLYHOXO VHPQLILFD LLORU SUH]HQWXO DQWLFLSDWLY DO PLDüWHSWDPXUJXOQRDSWHDüLGXUHUHD
YHUEHORU OD PRGXO LQGLFDWLY H[SULP FHUWLWXGLQHD QDUDWR V PLVHQWXQHFHWRWFHUXO
UXOXLDHXOXLOLULFúLLPLQHQ DHYHQLPHQWXOXLvQYUHPHFH üLV U VDU QPLQHVWHOHOH
SUH]HQWXOFRQMXQFWLYXOXLFUHHD] XQRUL]RQWGHDúWHSWDUH /%ODJD
SHRFRRUGRQDW DSUREDELOLW LL
vQVFULHUHD SUH]HQWXOXL úL D YLLWRUXOXL vQWUR VWUXFWXU &XUJLvQ+LPHULD7HQWRUFLvQWUHJüLPXWüL LYLQHV
YHUEDO D VLPXOWDQHLW LL GHWHUPLQ vQ SODQ VWLOLVWLF R FkQ L OD WURPSHW >@ V QR L SH VXE DS FX RFKLL
GLPHQVLXQH YL]LRQDU R SURLHF LH H[SOLFLW vQ LPDJLQDU GHVFKLüLV GLVSDULvQWUXQQRUVFOLSLFLRV
vQVSD LLLSRWHWLFH 63RSHVFX
9DORULVWLOLVWLFHDOHFDWHJRULLORUJUDPDWLFDOH ([HPSOH
LPSHUIHFWXO LWHUDWLY FRQYHUWHúWH FDSDFLWDWHD VSHFL 3DUWHD GH]DJUHDELO HUD F XUFDP üL FRERUDP I U V
ILF LPSHUIHFWXOXL GH ÄD SUHOXQJL GXUDWD DF LXQLL´ ) üWLPGHFHLDUDVWDQLVHFRPXQLFDVLPSOXGHF WUHFHL
%UXQHWLqUH vQ SRVLELOLWDWH GH D H[SULPD IOX[XO WHPSRUDO vPEXIQD L üL LQL LD L VXPDU >@ ÍPL UHSHWDP
QHFRQWHQLWFDLGLRWL]DW´1DüILFUH]XWRQLFLRGDW vQ
FD vQO Q XLUH D GXUDWHORU FLUFXODUH D VLWXD LLORU
VWDUHV IDF DVWD
UHSHWDELOH
&3HWUHVFX
YDORDUHD H[SUHVLY D LPSHUIHFWXOXL XQRU YHUEHORU FX 3HFDOHQOXPHDQHDJU DPSOHFDW
VHQV LWHUDWLY VDX D YHUEHORU FDUH SULPHVF FRQRWD LL 8PEODPYHGHDPGDUQXP vQFKHJDP
HFKLYDOHQWH SULQ GHWHUPLQ UL DGYHUELDOH VXEVWDQWLYDOH 9HGHDPXPEODPGDUvQF QXHUDP
HWF UH]LG vQ IRU D FX FDUH H[SULP VXJHUHD] R 3ULQDQXOOXQJDKOXQJGHDOW GDW·
GXEO vQVFULHUH D ILLQ HL vQWUXQ FRQWLQXXP WHPSRUDO úL 'HDELDLXELUHDPDvQWHPHLDW
vQWUXQWLSDUUHSHWDELODOH[LVWHQ HL /%ODJD
SHUIHFWXO VLPSOX GHVFULSWLY SUHVXSXQH R GHYLHUH 'HRGDW VH I FX UHFH üL vQFHSX V EDW YkQWXO >@
H[SUHVLY GHODFDUDFWHUXOSULQH[FHOHQ QDUDWLYDODFHVWXL 3ORDLDvQFHSXV FD] vQVWURSLPDULWXQHWHOHvQFHSXU
WLPSYHUEDOXWLOL]DUHDDWLSLF VLWXHD] VHFYHQ DGHVFULSWLY V U VXQH GHD OXQJXO Y LL FX QLüWH ]JXGXLWXUL PDL
vQSULPSODQvQUHOD LHFRQWUDVWLY FXSODQXOGHDGkQFLPH SXWHUQLFHüLWRWPDLSXWHUQLFH
vQFDUHVHvQVFULXvQPRGRELúQXLWYHUEHODLPSHUIHFW ,6ODYLFL
9DORULVWLOLVWLFHDOHFDWHJRULLORUJUDPDWLFDOH ([HPSOH
IXQF LDGLQDPLF VSHFLILF SHUIHFWXOXLVLPSOXFRQIHU &XWXQHWXOVHSU EXüLU üLQRULL
YLYDFLWDWHLPDJLQLORUGHVFULSWLYHRUJDQL]kQGHOHPHQWHOH ÍQvQF SHUHDXQLYHUVXOXLvQFKLV
vQWUR VXFFHVLXQH DOHUW GHVFULHUHD GH DFHVW WLS DUH 9LMHOLDDGXVHFRFRULL
FDUDFWHUOLYUHVF $OELQHOHIUXQ]HOH
7$UJKH]L
3(5)(&78/&20386ÄFRQYHUWLWvQWLPSQDUDWLYSULQFDUDFWHUXOSHUIHFWLYDOWHPSRUDOLW LL
VDOH>@IL[HD] vQWURSHUVSHFWLY GHDQWHULRULWDWHLUHYHUVLELO vQFKHLHUHDLPSODFDELO
DXQRUSURFHVHVLWXDWHvQVXFFHVLYLWDWH´',ULPLD
SHUIHFWXO FRPSXV vQVFULH HYHQLPHQWHOH QDUDWH ,XELUHDS PkQWXOXLODVW SkQLWGHPLFFRSLO9HüQLFD
SURFHVHOH VW ULOH VDX H[SHULHQ HOH OLULFH vQWUR GXUDW SL]PXLW SH FHL ERJD L üL YHüQLF VD vQDUPDW vQWUR
WUHFXW vQFKLV vQWUXQLQWHUYDOGHWLPSDQWHULRUWLPSXOXL KRW UkUH S WLPDü WUHEXLH V DLE S PkQW PXOW
HQXQ ULL WUHEXLH'HSHDWXQFLS PkQWXOLDIRVWPDLGUDJFDR
IXQF LD VWLOLVWLF SULQFLSDO HVWH DFHHD GH D FUHD XQ PDP
GHFXSDM vQ IOX[XO GXUDWHL GHOLPLWkQG R VHFYHQ GH /5HEUHDQX
WHPSRUDOLWDWH VLWXDW vQ DQWHULRULWDWHD LPHGLDW D $SRLVmOEmWLFLDPLDFUHVFXW
SUH]HQWXOXL VDX GLPSRWULY vQWUXQ WUHFXW IRDUWH FkQWmULOHPLDXSLHULW
vQGHS UWDW FXP HVWH FHO DO EDVPXOXL GLQ SHUVSHFWLYD üLImUmVmPLILIRVWYUHRGDWmDSURDSH
PRPHQWXOXL HQXQ ULL DFHVW WUHFXW LUHYHUVLELO HVWH WHDPSLHUGXWSHQWUXWRWGHDXQD
SUH]HQWDW FD DF LXQH vQFKHLDW FD UH]XOWDW DO XQXL vQ UkQ vQIRFvQYm]GXKüLSHDSH
/%ODJD
SURFHV VDX FD HIHFW DO XQHL VW UL DUH URO GH QDUDUH D
XQRU HYHQLPHQWH WUHFXWH LVWRULVLWH vQ VXFFHVLXQH ÍQQRDSWHDDVWDF WU ]RULDDYXWFHOGLQW LVHPQvQ
YLV FDUH D vPSXQVR vQ LQLP üLD WXOEXUDWR üL PDL
FURQRORJLF VDX URO GH HYRFDUH PDUFDW GH LQGLFL DL
PXOW
VXELHFWLYLW LL IRUPHOH LQYHUVDWH GH H[HPSOX Ä2
06DGRYHDQX
DF LXQH WUHFXW DOH F UHL HFRXUL VXQW vQF YLL vQ VXIOHWXO 3HWUHLFRYRDUHGHU FRDUH
QRVWUXRH[SULP PSULQSHUIHFWXOFRPSXV´,,RUGDQ /LQDGRUPLWRUFkQGYHUGHD
DOW IXQF LH VWLOLVWLF HVWH GHOLPLWDUHD SODQXOXL &kQGOkQJ VkQXQULJ VSkQ
QDUDWRUXOXL D F UXL RELHFWLYLWDWH SRDWH IL H[SULPDW SULQ &XHXQXFXOOXLE WUkQ
SHUIHFWXO VLPSOX GH SODQXO SHUVRQDMHORU PDUFDW 9HQLVRvPELHFXGXOFHD
VXELHFWLYSULQSHUIHFWXOFRPSXV ²(QLJHO(QLJHO
VLWXDUHD vQ ILQDOXO WH[WXOXL DO HSLVRGXOXL QDUDWLY vQ LDPDGXVGXOFHD LDF
FRQWUDVWFXWLPSXOQDUDWLYSULQFLSDO±SUH]HQWXOSHUIHFWXO ,%DUEX
VLPSOX VDX LPSHUIHFWXO SRDWH DYHD XQ URO UH]XPDWLY $PUkV$PYRUELW$PSO WLW
VDX FRQFOX]LY UHOLHIkQG DVWIHO FDUDFWHUXO LUHYHUVLELO DO 3HFHUU V UHDXVWHOHOHGHMXF ULH
HYHQLPHQWHORU $0XúLQD
IRUPD vQYHFKLW D SHUIHFWXOXL FRPSXV DYkQG GRX
DX[LOLDUHÄHXODPIRVW] ULW´HVWHRPDUF DUHJLVWUXOXL 3 UHDF SULQWUHQRXULVDIRVWGHVFKLVRSRDUW
VWLOLVWLFDUKDLF 0(PLQHVFX
0$,08/7&$3(5)(&78/ÄVWDELOHúWHFDGUXOWHPSRUDOOLPLWDGHODFDUHXUPHD]
DVHGHVI úXUDHSLVRGXOUHVSHFWLY´ÄDFHDVW QHFRQWHQLW UDSRUWDUHODHYHQLPHQWH
DQWHULRDUHUHDOL]HD] FHHDFHVDUSXWHDQXPLVWLOXOQDUD LXQLLDGLF DFHOPRG
GHSUH]HQWDUHDIDSWHORUFDUHSXQHYLXvQOXPLQ VXFFHVLXQHDORUOHJ WXUDORU
GXS RUGLQHDWHPSRUDO ´79LDQX
PDLPXOWFDSHUIHFWXO vQFDGU ULL FDWDIRULF ± VLWXDW ,DFRY (UDFOLG SRUHFOLW 'HVSRWXO SHULVH XFLV GH
vQ LQFLSLW GHVFKLGH VHULD GH HYHQLPHQWH SULQ HYRFDUHD EX]GXJDQXOOXLûWHIDQ7RPüDFDUHDFXPFkUPXLD DUD
XQRUFLUFXPVWDQ HDQWHULRDUHQDUD LXQLLSURSULX]LVHVFKL GDU $OH[DQGUX / SXüQHDQXO GXS vQIUkQJHUHD VD vQ
HD] IXQGDOXOHYHQLPHQWHORUFDUHXUPHD] DILQDUDWH GRX UkQGXUL GH RüWLOH 'HVSRWXOXL IXJLQG OD
&RQVWDQWLQRSROL]EXWLVHDOXDRüWLWXUFHüWLüLVHvQWXUQD
FD VWUDWHJLH GLVFXUVLY HVWH XWLOL]DW FX SUHF GHUH vQ
DFXPV L]JRQHDVF SUHU SLWRUXO7RPüD
SUR]D WUDGL LRQDO PDUFkQG VXFFHVLXQHD FURQRORJLF D
&1HJUX]]L
HYHQLPHQWHORU RUJDQL]DWH SH GRX SODQXUL XQ SODQ
VHFXQG DO DQWHULRULW LL GRPLQDW GH PDLPXOWFDSHUIHFWXO ÍQSULPDYDUDDQXOXLFDVXEORFRWHQHQWSURDVS W
YHUEHORUúLXQSULPSODQDODFWXDOLW LLDF LXQHDSURSULX vQWkLD GDWD FRQFHQWUDW OXDVHP SDUWH FX XQ UHJLPHQW
]LV UHODWDW FX DMXWRUXO YHUEHORU OD SHUIHFWXO VLPSOX GH LQIDQWHULH GLQ FDSLWDO OD IRUWLILFDUHD Y LL
FRPSXVRULODSUH]HQWXOQDUDWLY 3UDKRYHLvQWUH%XüWHQLüL3UHGHDO
&3HWUHVFX
9DORULVWLOLVWLFHDOHFDWHJRULLORUJUDPDWLFDOH ([HPSOH
± UROXO VWLOLVWLF HVWH DFHOD GH D GLIHUHQ LD WLPSXO 1XPLVHPQXQ LLQRDVWUHXQEXUJ
GLHJHWLF ± VLWXDW vQWUXQ WUHFXW vQGHS UWDW ± GH WLPSXO 6O YLWFXDSHDELDGHFXUJ²
LVWRULVLULLúLDOUHFHSW ULLFUHkQGRWHQVLXQHQDUDWLY SULQ ,%DUEX
UHOD LD FRQWUDVWLY vQWUH SODQXO GH DGkQFLPH DO UHODW ULL 'XS FHDVFXOWDVHFXOXDUHDPLQWHYRUEHOHWkQJXLWRDUH
VLQWHWLFH DO HYRF ULL úL SULPSODQXO HYHQLPHQ LDO vQ DOHOXL%DU]RYLH9RG KDQXOFHOWkQ UI FXVHPQV VH
OLWHUDWXUDVHFDO;;OHDHVWHXWLOL]DWúLFDPLMORFVWLOLVWLF IDF OLQLüWH
,*URúDQ
GHDUKDLFL]DUH
1LFLRGDW IHPHLDDFHDVWDQXP LXELVH5HOXDPWRWFH
PDLPXOWFDSHUIHFWXOQDUDWLYDQDIRULF±vQWUHUXSH DIRVWOD2GREHüWLOD DU üLDFXPVLP HDPF DFROR
VHULD HYHQLPHQWHORU GLQ SULPSODQXO QDUDWLY SHQWUX D DPDYXWGUHSWDWHF DWXQFLY ]XVHPOLPSHGHF VHULD
LQVHUDXQHQXQ RVHFYHQ UHWURVSHFWLY ÄFDXQPLMORF HLDFHHDIXVHVH
GHDIL[DWUHSWHOHWLPSXOXL´79LDQX &DPLO3HWUHVFX
YDORDUHD H[SUHVLY HVWH FRQIHULW GH vQWUHUXSHUHD )DPLOLD 0RURPHWH VH vQWRUVHVH PDL GHYUHPH GH OD
IOX[XOXL WHPSRUDO GH R GLVORFDUH VHPQLILFDWLY vQ RUGL FkPS&kWDMXQVHVHU DFDV 3DUDVFKLY>@VHG GXVH
QHD FURQRORJLF D HYHQLPHQWHORU D VLWXD LLORU VDX D MRVGLQF UX O VDVHSHDO LLV GHVKDPHüLV GHDMRV
VW ULORUFRPXQLFDWHLQWHUIHUHQ DvQWUHPDLPXOWFDSHUIHFWXO XQHOWHOHLDUHOVHvQWLQVHVHSHSULVS
03UHGD
úL WLPSXUL FH H[SULP XOWHULRULWDWHD FUHHD] DFURQLD ÍPSUHMXUvQWXQHULFXOVHvQ VSULVHvQFkWvQ HSDRFKLL
QDUDWLY /5HEUHDQX
Ä5RVWXOPDLPXOWFDSHUIHFWXOXLVHPRGLILF ODVFULLWRULL 7X LDLVWUHFXUDWFkQWHFXOvQPLQH
PDL QRL FDUH QX YRU V H[SULPH SULQ HO DQWHULRULWDWHD ÍQWURGXSDPLD] FkQG
FURQRORJLF FL IRDUWH GHVHRUL úL DQWHULRULWDWHD FDX]DO ´ )HUHDVWUDVXIOHWXOXL] YRUkW ELQH
79LDQX 6HGHVFKLVHVHQYkQW
7$UJKH]L
9,,7258/ÄFRQIRUPGHILQL LLORUFODVLFHRVHFYHQ GHHQXQ XULvQFDUHWLPSXOYHUEHORU
HYLLWRUXOQXDUSXWHDV FRQVWLWXLHRQDUD LXQHvQOLWHUDWXU HOSRDWHWRWXúLGHYHQLXQWLPS
DOUHSUH]HQW ULLXQHLOXPLSRVLELOHGHWLSXOYLVXOXLVDXDOYL]LXQLLFDUHUHGXFHGLIHUHQ D
GLQWUHFDWHJRULLOHUHDOúLLUHDO´5=DILX
0DLDPXQVLQJXUGRU>@
9DJHPHGHSDWHPL
YLLWRUXO FX IXQF LH QDUDWLY HVWH R GHYLHUH H[SUHVLY $OP ULLDVSUXFkQW
FRQYHQ LRQDOL]DW DYkQG FD SXQFW GH UHIHULQ &LHXYRLILS PkQW
SUH]HQWXO HQXQ ULL SH FDUH vO SUHOXQJHúWH vQWUR GXUDW ÍQVLQJXU WDWHPL
LPDJLQDU SURJUHVLD vQ LUHDO QX DUH R OLPLW SRDWH 0(PLQHVFX
FRQGXFHVSUHLQILQLW
SURLHFWDUHD XQHL VXLWH HYHQLPHQ LDOH D XQHL VHULL GH ² &X YRLD P ULHLWDOH ]LVH 6WURLFL YHGHP F PRüLD
VLWXD LL LPDJLQDWH vQ YLLWRU HVWH PDL IUHFYHQW vQ WH[WHOH QRDVWU D V FDG GH LVQRDY vQ F OFDUHD S JkQLORU
SRHWLFH VWUDWHJLLOH GLVFXUVLYH FDQRQLFH VXQW ED]DWH &kQGDVW QHJXU GHWXUFLYDSU GDüLYDSXVWLL DUD
SH FURQRORJLH GLUHFW SUH]HQW ± YLLWRU VDX LQYHUVDW SHFHYHLGRPQLP ULDWD"
DFURQLDPDUFkQGvQSULPXOFD]FRQúWLLQ DLUHDOLW LLLDU
&1HJUX]]L
vQ DO GRLOHD LOX]LD LPLQHQ HL XQXL YLLWRU ÄFH YD V ILH´
/DQRDSWHYD]YkUOLSHFRDVW PDUHD
YLLWRUXODSDUHvQLQFLSLWLQVWLWXLQGFDGUXOLUHDOSUHPLV D
2SDV UHFXFKLSXOIHPHLHVF
XQHL UHDOLW L ILF LRQDOH FDUH GHYLQH WUHSWDW R FHUWLWXGLQH ,DUQRLDIOkQGFXJURD] vQWkPSODUHD
H[SULPDW vQILQDOSULQWLPSXOSUH]HQW 9RPVRFRWLRGUHSWXQVHPQFHUHVF
UROXO VWLOLVWLF SULQFLSDO HVWH FUHDUHD XQHL SHUVSHFWLYH 56WDQFD
YL]LRQDUH UHSUH]HQWDUHD XQXL SODQ LQWHULRU DO UHYHULHL
VDXDOGRULQ HLDODQWLFLS ULLSURIHWLFHRULDOSUHVLP LULORU 3OHüXYHPRüQXWHVSHULD
QHOLQLúWLWH UHIHUHQWXO LOX]RULX SURLHFWDW FD SRWHQ LDOLWDWH & XPEUDWDQDUHV YLQ
VDX FD UHDOLWDWH ILF LRQDO VH FRQVWUXLHúWH IUHFYHQW SH ÍLYRPJ VLSHXQGHYD
VFHQDULL FRQVDFUDWH F O WRULD LQL LDWLF YLVXO GH LXELUH 2PDLPXOWLSO U G FLQ
DVSLUD LDVSUHLGHDOFRQIUXQWDUHDDSRFDOLSVDHWF /'LPRY
IRUPHOHLQYHUVDWHFXDX[LOLDUXOSRVWSXVDXUROXOGHD
DFFHQWXDVWLOLVWLFSODQXOVHPDQWLFDOYHUEXOXLSULQWRSLFD 3DWUXHYDQJKHOLLVFULHYRPGHVSUHF GHUHD
PDUFDW DIHFWLY IUXQ]HLvQWRDPQ
16W QHVFX
9DORULVWLOLVWLFHDOHFDWHJRULLORUJUDPDWLFDOH ([HPSOH
YLLWRUXO FRORFYLDO SRSXODU GLIHUHQ LDW OD QLYHOXO $VW ]LQXPDLFkQW PQXPDL]kPELP
JUDLXULORU 0XQWHQLD 2OWHQLD 'REURJHD R V SOHF P 6WkQGODvQFHSXWGHDQRWLPSIHUPHFDW
0ROGRYD DP DL DUH FRQMXQFWLY ± DP V SOHF vQ DVW ]LQHGHVS U LP
UHVWXO]RQHORUIRUPHRE LQXWHGHODFRQVWUXF LDVWDQGDUG FXPVDXGHVS U LWDSHOHGHXVFDW
D YLLWRUXOXL SULQ DIHUH] SULPHL FRQVRDQH D DX[LOLDUXOXL 1XSHVWHPXOWWXYHLILFHUXOU VIUkQW
RLSOHFDvLSOHFDDSOHFDHWFDUHRPDUHIUHFYHQ OD HXYRLILVRDUHOHQHJUXS PkQWXO
QLYHOXOOLPELLYRUELWHVWLOXOFRORFYLDO 1XSHVWHPXOWDUHV EDW YkQW
YDORDUHD H[SUHVLY UH]LG vQ PDUHD vQF UF WXU 1XSHVWHPXOWDUHV EDW YkQWXO
DIHFWLY vQFRQRWD LLOHGXELWDWLYHúLvQDVSHFWXOPRGDOFDUH ùW$XJ'RLQDú
vODSURSLHGHFRQMXQFWLYIRUPDVDDQDOLWLF PDLFRPSOH[ (XDPV VFULXÅ5RPDQXODGROHVFHQWXOXLPLRSµ'DU
GHFkWDYLLWRUXOXLOLWHUDUDFFHQWXHD] FRPSRQHQWDGXUDWLY DPV OVFULXFDXQ-XUQDODODXWRUXOXL&DUWHDPHDQX
úL R vQFDUF GH XQ FRQ LQXW VXIOHWHVF GLYHUV vQ OLWHUDWXUD YDILXQURPDQFLFRPHQWDULLQRWHVFKL HSHQWUX
FXOW XWLOL]DUHDDFHVWHLIRUPHQXPDLPDUFKHD] H[FOXVLY URPDQ
UHJLVWUXOVWLOLVWLFRUDOúLSRSXODUFLúLXQUHJLVWUXOLULFPDUFDW 0(OLDGH
VXELHFWLYRULXQUHJLVWUXIDPLOLDUGHOLEHUDWSUR]DLF
YLLWRUXO DQWHULRU FRQVWUXLHúWH R VXFFHVLXQH GH
VHFYHQ H DQWLFLSDWLYH VLWXkQG VWDUHD VDX HYHQLPHQWXO 9RLILE WUkQüLVLQJXUYHLILPXULWGHPXOW
0(PLQHVFX
H[SULPDWvQDLQWHDDOWHLDF LXQLVW ULSURLHFWDWHvQYLLWRU 3HXQGH'RDPQHYHLPDLILILLQG"
DEVHQW GLQ OLPED DFWXDO YLLWRUXO DQWHULRU FRQIHU &HYLVFROWHDvQ] SH]LWSHJULQG"
GLVFXUVXOXLXQFDUDFWHUOLYUHVFúLDSDUHQ DGHYHFKLPH &LQHWHDU VWLJQLWvQQHOXPLQ "
vQ FD]XO SDUWLFXODU DO FRQVWUXF LHL GLIHUHQ LDWH SULQ 3OkQJkQGF ERWH]DWXQHDLFXYLQ
XWLOL]DUHDJHUXQ]LXOXLYHLILIRVWYHLILILLQG±FRQVLGHUDW R SHXQGH'RDPQHYHLPDLILILLQG"
IRUP D PRGXOXL SUH]XPWLY YDORDUHD VWLOLVWLF HVWH FHD +% GHVFX
GH H[SULPDUH D LQFHUWLWXGLQLL ORFXWRUXOXL VDX D XQHL
SRVLELOLW LGH]LUDELOHQHVLJXUHRULLUHDOL]DELOH
9$/25,67,/,67,&($/(02'85,/259(5%$/(
([SULPkQGDWLWXGLQHDHPL WRUXOXLID GHDF LXQHDSURFHVXOVDXVWDUHDHQXQ DWH
PRGXULOH YHUEDOH DQJDMHD] HXO URVWLWRU vQ VWUXFWXULOH GLHJHWLFH vQ GLVFXUVXO HSLF OLULF
VDX GUDPDWLF 5HVXUVHOH GH H[SUHVLYLWDWH DUWLVWLF DOH DFHVWHL FDWHJRULL JUDPDWLFDOH
VSHFLILFHYHUEXOXLVXQWDFWXDOL]DWHSULQPDUFDUHDPRGXOXLvQFDUHHPL WRUXOQDUDWRUXO
HXOOLULFSHUVRQDMXOHSLFVDXGUDPDWLFVHUDSRUWHD] ODRELHFWXOHQXQ ULLSULQIHOXOvQ
FDUH vO SHUFHSH úL SULQ LSRVWD]D OXL ± LPSOLFDW VXELHFWLY VDX QRQSDUWLFLSDWLY
RELHFWLY ID GHHYHQLPHQWHOHVLWXD LLOHRULVW ULOHFRPXQLFDWHSULQGLVFXUV
9$/25,(;35(6,9($/(02'85,/259(5%$/( (;(03/(
0 2 ' 8 / , 1 ' , & $ 7 , 9 LPSULP XQ FDUDFWHU RELHFWLY
DF LXQLORUSURFHVHORUVW ULORUSHFDUHOHH[SULP ([SOR]LLOH VH VXFFHG RUJDQL]DW 8QHOH OH
&DPRGDOHQXQ ULLXQRUIDSWHFRQVLGHUDWHUHDOHúLDXQRU DXGODFk LYDSDüLDOWHOHvQPLQH>@$
IRVWGHVWXOV DSDU QHP LLIRFXODGRX
VW UL DSUHFLDWH FD VLJXUH LQGLFDWLYXO DSDUH vQ OLPEDMXO EDWHULL ûL WRWXüL DFXP VRDUHOH HUD VXV
FRPXQFDXQPRGQHXWUXGLQSXQFWGHYHGHUHVWLOLVWLF SULHWHQLLP DüWHSWDX
ÌQ WH[WXO OLWHUDU FDSDFLWDWHD GH D H[SULPD FHUWLWXGLQHD &DPLO3HWUHVFX
ORFXWRUXOXLQDUDWRUSHUVRQDMHHXOOLULFvQUDSRUWFXRELHFWXO
HQXQ ULLFRQIHU UHIHUHQWXOXLDSDUHQ DXQHLUHDOLW LYDOLGDWH 0DL ORYLW GHVWXO SkQDFXP >@ 6HDU
vQXQLYHUVXOILF LRQDO GH VHDU VHFXQG GH VHFXQG GH DQL üL
DQLGH]LOH0DLI UkPL DWPDLMXSXLW
3ULQ SDUDGLJPD VD WHPSRUDO ± PDL ERJDW GHFkW D
PDL GLVWUXV $L I FXW GLQ PLQH R
FHORUODOWH PRGXUL ± SHUPLWH LQVWLWXLUHD XQRU UDSRUWXUL GLYHUVH IDQWRP R IDQWRü PDL XPLOLW VWDL
vQWUH HYHQLPHQWHOH LVWRULVLWH FURQRORJLH ±DQWHULRULWDWH SHUVRQDM"
VLPXOWDQHLWDWH XOWHULRULWDWH± VDX DFURQLH vQWUH WLPSXO QDUDW 09LúQLHF
úLWLPSXOQDU ULLvQWUHPRPHQWHHYRFDWHúLSUH]HQWXOOLULF
9$/25,(;35(6,9($/(02'85,/259(5%$/( (;(03/(
9DORULOH H[SUHVLYH DOH LQGLFDWLYXOXL VXQW GLIHUHQ LDWH vQ LHOXPHDWRDW DFRSHU PkQW
IXQF LH GH IRUPD WHPSRUDO D YHUEXOXL ILHFDUH GLQWUH FHOH 2PLHUO VFRDWHVRDUHOHGLQDS
IDFHUHDOXPLLSRDWHV vQFHDS
úDSWHWLPSXULDOHLQGLFDWLYXOXLDYkQGSURSULLOHYDOHQ HVWLOLVWLFH
DvQIORULWXQYLüLQSHS PkQW
SUH]HQWXOLPSHUIHFWXOSHUIHFWXOVLPSOXSHUIHFWXOFRPSXVúL 1XVSXQHDPIRVWQLFLF YRLILFLVXQW
PDLPXOWFDSHUIHFWXOYLLWRUXOVLPSOXúLYLLWRUXODQWHULRU +% GHVFX
0 2 ' 8 / , 0 3 ( 5 $ 7 , 9 LQVWLWXLH R UHOD LH GH FRPXQLFDUH
GLUHFW H[SULPkQG GRULQ D VDX YRLQ D HPL WRUXOXL GH D ²'HVWXOVWULJ / SXüQHDQXOQXWHPDL
GHWHUPLQDRDF LXQHRULGHDRvPSLHGLFD ERFL FD R PXLHUH ILL URPkQ YHUGH>@
+DLGH OXD LO GHO GD L QRURGXOXL üLL
9DORDUHDVWLOLVWLF DLPSHUDWLYXOXLUH]LG vQFDSDFLWDWHDGH VSXQH LF DFHVWIHOSO WHüWH$OH[DQGUX
H[SULPDUHDXQRUDWLWXGLQLúLWU LULVXELHFWLYHSULQWUXQGXEOX YRG FHORUFHSUDG DUD
VLVWHP GH VHPQDOH YHUEDOH úL SDUDYHUEDOH DFFHQWHOH &1HJUX]]L
DIHFWLYH SDX]HOH H[SUHVLYH LQWRQD LD VSHFLILF RUGLQXOXL 1XPDLYRUELQXUkGHQXWHJkQGLQX
DPHQLQ ULLvQGHPQXOXLUXJ PLQ LLFRQFHVLHLLURQLHLHWF SOkQJH
&DPDUF WH[WXDO DVWLOXOXLGLUHFWLPSHUDWLYXODUHUROGH 1XPDLYLVD]DGDUQLFHSUHDWkU]LX
DFXP
ÄWHDWUDOL]DUH´ úL vQ DFHODúL WLPS URO GH GLQDPL]DUH D ,3LOODW
GLVFXUVXOXL SHUVRQDMHORU ÄLPSHUDWLYXO GUDPDWLF úL QDUDWLY´ 6WLKXUL]EXUD LDFXPGLQPkQDPHD
DO WXULGHVXEVWDQWLYHOHDGMHFWLYHOHvQYRFDWLYUHSUH]LQW XQ ûLüFKLRS WD LvQDHUXOFXIORDUH
LQGLFH DO RUDOLW LL VWLOXOXL vQ OLPEDMXO SRSXODU SRDWH DS UHD 7$UJKH]L
I U UHIHULUH OD R SHUVRDQ DQXPH ÄLPSHUDWLYXO IRUPDO´ vúL 6D vQWRUV V O FDXWH GDU GXWH FDXW
VXFHüWHWH vQYkUWHüWHWH RPXO SDUF
SLHUGH YDORULOH VSHFLILFH SHUVRDQD D GRXD DYkQG YDORDUH LQWUDVHvQS PkQW
JHQHULF ±1)RU VFX ,&UHDQJ
3UH]HQ D LPSHUDWLYXOXL vQ WH[WXO OLULF VHPQDOL]HD]
GLVFXUVXO GLDORJLF VDX PRQRORJXO DGUHVDW FDUH SRDWH OXD
IRUPDLQYRFD LHLUHWRULFH
0 2 ' 8 / & 2 1 - 8 1 & 7 , 9 H[SULP SRWHQ LDOLWDWHDXQHLDF LXQL
UHDOL]DELOHSRVLELOHSUREDELOHVDXDWLWXGLQHDHPL WRUXOXLID 0RURPHWHvLVSXVHI U PXOW YRUE F
GHDF LXQHDVWDUHDWU LUHDHQXQ DWHLQFHUWLWXGLQHDH]LWDUHD VDWHUPLQDWüLFXLVWRULDOXLFXVWXGLLOH
V VWHDDFDV üLV SXQ PkQDSHVDS
DSUR[LPD LDGHOLEHUD LDGRULQ DSURWHVWXOLQGLJQDUHDHWF 03UHGD
9DORDUHDH[SUHVLY DFRQMXQFWLYXOXLHVWHGDW GHP UFLOH GD LPL YRLH RUL V VH UHYL]XLDVF
DIHFWLYH SH FDUH OH H[SULP vQ FRQWH[WXO VWLOLVWLF DWLWXGLQL úL SULPHVF 'DU V QX VH VFKLPEH QLPLFD
WU LULVXELHFWLYH RUL V QX VH UHYL]XLDVF SULPHVF GDU
ÌQ GLVFXUVXO QDUDWRUXOXL DO SHUVRQDMHORU GLVFXUV GLUHFW DWXQFLV VHVFKLPEHSHLFLSHFROR
LQGLUHFW LQGLUHFW OLEHU RUL DO HXOXL OLULF FRQMXQFWLYXO SRDWH ,/&DUDJLDOH
DYHD UROXO GH D LQVWLWXL XQ QLYHO DO DF LXQLORU DO WU LULORU ûLGHRGDW DPvQFHSXWV üWLX
LQWHULRDUH DO VW ULORU LSRWHWLFH DOWHUQDWLYH RUL DQWLFLSDWLYH vQ PHUVXOOXPLQLLüLDOVWULJ ULL>@
DFHVWXOWLPFD]SUH]HQWXOFRQMXQFWLYXOXLvQGHSOLQHúWHVWLOLVWLF 6 XUOXVIküLDWGHS V ULUHSH]L
IXQF LD LQGLFDWLYXOXL YLLWRU FKLDU GDF QX SDUWLFLS OD V DUGORYLWGHXQPHWHRU
VDGRUPSHJkWXULOXQJLGHOHEH]L
FRQVWUXLUHDYLLWRUXOXLFRORFYLDO
üLGHORSH LGHE UFLL]ELWV PRU
)XQF LDVWLOLVWLF DFRQMXQFWLYXOXLSRDWHILGHHFKLYDOHQ FX 16W QHVFX
FRQGL LRQDORSWDWLYXO SUHVXSXQkQG GHSHQGHQ D DF LXQLL
8QGHV PHUJGHDFXP"
HQXQ DWHGHRDOW DF LXQHVDXGHRVWDUHGHRGRULQ 3HFLQHV PDLDüWHSW"
2 IXQF LH VWLOLVWLF SDUWLFXODU HVWH FHD GH VXEVWLWXLUH D ,3LOODW
LPSHUDWLYXOXLFXUROGHDFFHQWXDUHDVXELHFWLYLW LLvQFD]XO 3LDU PLRFKLLWXOEXU WRULGLQFDOH
VSHFLDODOYHUEHORUODSHUVRDQDD,,,DDFRQMXQFWLYXOXLFkQG 9LQRLDUvQVkQQHS VDUHWULVW
SRDWH DS UHD I U PRUIHPXO ÄV ´ UROXO VWLOLVWLF HVWH GH 0(PLQHVFX
FRPSOHWDUH D SDUDGLJPHL LPSHUDWLYXOXL FDUH QX DUH GHFkW ²6 SUHJ WHüWLFX0LWUHDVDQLDvL]LVH
SHUVRDQDD,,D 9LWRULD6RXPSOLFXIkQV SXLüXQ
ÌQ WH[WXO OLULF PRGXO FRQMXQFWLY UHSUH]LQW GHVHRUL R VDFGHRU]SHQWUXFDL
PDUF WH[WXDO DXQXLSODQDOLPDJLQDUXOXLDYkQGUROXOGHD 06DGRYHDQX
VHPQDOL]DWUHFHUHDGHODGLPHQVLXQHDUHDO ODFHDLGHDO
9$/25,(;35(6,9($/(02'85,/259(5%$/( (;(03/(
02'8/ &21', ,21$/237$7,9 GH]YROW SULQ DFHHDúL $üILSXWXWV VSXQüLHXXQFXYkQW«
SDUDGLJP YHUEDO GRX YDORUL PRGDOH H[SULPDUHD XQHL 2ULFHFXYkQW«'HSLOG DüILSXWXWV
DF LXQL GHSHQGHQWH GH R FRQGL LH H[SOLFLW VDX LPSOLFLW úL VSXQQX«&HVDUILvQWkPSODWGDF Dü
IL VSXV üL HX QX" Í L VSXQ F QX VDU IL
H[SULPDUHD XQHL DF LXQL UHDOL]DELOH LUHDOL]DELOH SUH]HQWDWH vQWkPSODWQLPLF«
FDRS LXQHDVXPDW ODWLPSXOSHUIHFWDF LXQHDHVWHLUHDO 09LúQLHF
)XQF LLOH VWLOLVWLFH VXQW GHWHUPLQDWH GH LQWHUIHUHQ D 1DLO XGDGHQDLüWLLV EOHVWHPL
YDORULORU PRGDOH H[SULPDUHD HYHQWXDOLW LL D SRVLELOLW LL D 6XUkGQXPDLDFHLFDUHVXVSLQ
XQRULSRWH]HVFHQDULLSRVLELOHVDXLPSRVLELOHDXQRUDF LXQL $]LQDLLXELGHQDUILIRVWV JHPL
SUHVXSXVHUHDOL]DELOHVDXQHUHDOL]DWHHWFúLGHDPELJXLWD 'HQDLILSOkQVQDLGXFHQRFKLOXPLQ
WHD FRQRWD LLORU VXELHFWLYH ± GH OD LQFHUWLWXGLQH OD DVHU LXQH 5DGX*\U
IHUP GHODGRULQ FRQFUHW ODDVSLUD LHYDJ HWF 'LQFRQWUDGRDPQ DüGRULWHDüUXJD
9DORUL H[SUHVLYH SDUWLFXODUH DUH RSWDWLYXO FDUH SUHLD IXQF LD V ILLEXQ DPLDFRUGDRSUHOXQJLUHGH
LQGLFDWLYXOXL FD ÄRSWDWLY DO PRGHVWLHL DO SROLWH LL´ ' ,ULPLD WHUPHQ
,/&DUDJLDOH
FkQG QX H[SULP QLFL FRQGL LD QLFL GRULQ D FL DUDW F
DF LXQHDYHUEXOXLHVWHSRVLELO UHDOL]DELO ´(&kPSHDQX 8VFDVDUL]YRDUHOHWRDWHüLPDUHD
2DOW IXQF LHVWLOLVWLF DFRQGL LRQDORSWDWLYXOXLHVWHFHDGH ûLVWLQJHVDUVRDUHOHFDOXPkQDUHD
7$UJKH]L
VXEVWLWXLUH D PRGXOXL FRQMXQFWLY vQ HQXQ XUL LQWHURJDWLYH VDX
6SXQHPLGDF WHDüSULQGHQWUR]L
H[FODPDWLYHYDORDUHDH[SUHVLY HVWHFHDGHDFFHQWXDUHDXQHL
üL LDüV UXWDWDOSDSLFLRUXOXL
WRQDOLW L VXELHFWLYH ± XLPLUHD LQGLJQDUHD VDX DPHQLQ DUHD QXLDüDFDDLüFKLRS WDSX LQGXS DFHHD
YHKHPHQW VSHFLILF EOHVWHPXOXL LPSUHFD LHL vQ DVHPHQHD GHWHDPDV QXPLVWULYHüWLV UXWXO"
HQXQ XUL DSDUH IUHFYHQW IRUPD LQYHUVDW FDUH DPSOLILF UROXO 16W QHVFX
H[SUHVLYDOYHUEXOXLVLWXDWvQDLQWHDDX[LOLDUXOXLVSHFLILF
ÌQ WH[WXO OLULF PRGXO FRQGL LRQDORSWDWLY DSDUH PDL UDU
DYkQG PDL DOHV UROXO GH D H[SULPD R VLWXD LH LSRWHWLF R
H[SHULHQ OLULF LPDJLQDW
02'8/,1),1,7,9HVWHRIRUP YHUEDO ÄFXWU V WXULGXEOHGH 5 ]ERLXO G GX OXL )HOL[ SHVWH Fk LYD
WLS YHUEDO úL QRPLQDO´ 'LF LRQDU GH úWLLQ H DOH OLPELL DQLSULOHMXOGHDVHDILUPDvQF GHWkQ U
QRPLQDOL]DUHD ILLQG LQWHJUDO vQ FD]XO LQILQLWLYXOXL OXQJ *& OLQHVFX
0kQGULDGHDRIHULRÅPDV OXDSURSRU LL
PRúWHQLW GLQ OLPED ODWLQ YHUEHOH OD LQILQLWLY QXPHVF vQ FKLS GH HYHQLPHQW >@ H[FXUVLD OD 0RüL üL
JHQHUDODEVWUDFWDF LXQHDSURFHVXOVDXVWDUHD üWUHQJ ULD GH D QH GD vQ F OXüHL GH D
9DORDUHD H[SUHVLY D LQILQLWLYXOXL HVWH JHQHUDW GH PkQFD IORULFHOH üL D EHD XQ DS GH EHUH
FDSDFLWDWHD OXL GH D PDUFD UHJLVWUH VWLOLVWLFH GLIHULWH FX HUDRUJLH
YDORDUH VHQWHQ LRDV DFHVW PRG GHYLQH LQGLFH DO UHJLVWUXOXL &DPLO3HWUHVFX
JQRPLF vQ WLPS FH YDORDUHD OLYUHVF RE LQXW SULQ & FLHLVHQDVFVSUHDPXUL
ûLPRUVSUHDVHQDüWH
VXEVWLWXLUHD FRQMXQFWLYXOXL GXS R FRQVWUXF LH LPSHUVRQDO 0(PLQHVFX
VDX GXS YHUEXO ÄD SXWHD´ HVWH VSHFLILF UHJLVWUXOXL VWLOLVWLF $SLHUGHWRWFHVHSRDWHSLHUGH
FXOW FRQVHUYDUHD YDORULL YHUEDOH D LQILQLWLYXOXL OXQJ ûLDPFkQWDWGLQFRDVWDPHD
VHPQDOL]HD] UHJLVWUXO VWLOLVWLF DUKDLF VDX UHJLVWUXO SRSXODU GLQYHUWHEUDFDRVWHD
vQFDUHVHXWLOL]HD] úLvQIRUPHOHLQYHUVDWHDOHYLLWRUXOXLDOH GHDQF OHFDUHSHRüD
FRQGL LRQDOXOXL LDU DVRFLHUHD YDORULL LPSHUDWLYH ± FDUH SHRüDGHFDOP LDVWUX
IRDLHYHUGHGHDOEDVWUX
FRQIHU XQWRQLPSHUVRQDO±PDUFKHD] VWLOXORILFLDO 16W QHVFX
)RDUWH UDU IRORVLW vQ OLPED DFWXDO IRUPD GH SHUIHFW D ûWHIDQ9RG DvQFHSXWDLEDWHUHSkQ FH
LQILQLWLYXOXL vQGHSOLQHúWH IXQF LD VWLOLVWLF GH PDUF D LDXWUHFXWGH'XQ UH
QDUDWLYLW LLSULQLQVWLWXLUHDXQHLVXFFHVLXQLWHPSRUDOH ,1HFXOFH
,QILQLWLYXO OXQJ FKLDU GDF HVWH VXEVWDQWLYL]DW vQ OLPED ÍPLHUDDVF SDUHGHGkQVXO
,&UHDQJ
URPkQ S VWUHD] XUPH VHPDQWLFH DOH DF LXQLL QXPLQG
UH]XOWDWXODFHVWHLDDSDUHIUHFYHQWvQWLWOXULOHSRH]LLORU
02'8/ *(581=,8 HVWH VLQJXUXO PRG QHSHUVRQDO FDUH 'DU0RURPHWHSDUF QLFLQXDX]HD>@
FRQVHUY FRQ LQXWXO GLQDPLF VSHFLILF YHUEXOXL VXUSULQ]kQG R FRQGXFkQGPDLGHSDUWHWRUHQWHOHGHDS
DF LXQH vQ GHVI úXUDUH XQ SURFHV R VWDUH GXUDWLY I FkQGXOH ORF FX VDSD üL FRQWLQXkQG
OLQLüWLWüLQHWXUEXUDWV YRUEHDVF
vQVFULHUHD DFHVWRUD vQWUR WHPSRUDOLWDWH I U UHIHULUH OD 03UHGD
9$/25,(;35(6,9($/(02'85,/259(5%$/( (;(03/(
PRPHQWXO HQXQ ULL SHUPLWH H[SULPDUHD RULF UHL GXUDWH ± &DüLFXPDLYHGHDPXQ LLSOkQJkQG
SUH]HQWHWUHFXWHRULYLLWRDUH±vQIXQF LHGHFRQWH[W FDüLFXPDLFHWLvQGHüHUWXULXQJkQG
3ULQFLSDODIXQF LHVWLOLVWLF DJHUXQ]LXOXLHVWHFDSDFLWDWHD FDüLFXPDLILPRUWüLWRWXüLDOHUJkQG
FDüLFXPLHULDUILvQFXUkQG
GH D FUHD LPDJLQL GLQDPLFH IUHFYHQW JHUXQ]LXO GHWHUPLQ DVWIHOVWDXSDOLGüLWULVWIXPHJkQG
FLUFXPVWDQ HOH DF LXQLL H[SULPDWH SULQ YHUEXO UHJHQW VDX vL 16W QHVFX
DGDXJ DFHVWXLD R DOW DF LXQH vQWUXQ ULWP DOHUW DQWHSXV
5X[DQGUDLHüLWUHPXUkQG üLJDOE Q üL
UHJHQWXOXL HO SRDWH DYHD R IXQF LRQDOLWDWH SROLYDOHQW U ]HPkQGXVHGHS UHWHÅ9RLV GD L
H[SULPkQG vQ DFHODúL WLPS WHPSRUDOLWDWHD úL FDX]DOLWDWHD VHDP vQDLQWHDOXL'XPQH]HX]LVH
FHHDFHFUHHD] DPELJXLWDWHVWLOLVWLF VXVSLQkQG
&kQG HVWH DVRFLDW JUXSXOXL QRPLQDO DUH UROXO GH D DWULEXL &1HJUX]]L
VXEVWDQWLYXOXLRvQVXúLUHGLQDPLF DYkQGGHFHOHPDLPXOWH 7XOXPLQ DOHUJkQG
RUL IXQF LD VWLOLVWLF GH HSLWHW DFHDVW IXQF LH HVWH UHvQWRUFkQGXWHDFDV
DFFHQWXDW IUHFYHQW SULQ YDORDUHD DGMHFWLYDO D JHUXQ]LXOXL EUXVF GHYHQLQGIO PkQG
DFRUGDW vQ JHQ úL QXP U FX UHJHQWXO QRPLQDO RFXUHQ D UHFKHPkQGXüLLDUPLUHDV
UHGXV vQOLPEDMXOFXUHQWDJHUXQ]LXOXLFXIXQF LHGHDWULEXWvL 16W QHVFX
9$/25,(;35(6,9($/(02'85,/259(5%$/( (;(03/(
02'8/ 683,1 H[SULP vQFKLSJHQHUDODEVWUDFWDF LXQHD
SURFHVXO VDX VWDUHD Y ]XWH FD SRWHQ LDOLWDWH DYkQG R IRUP /XD LY JkQGXO
YHUEDO LQYDULDELO SUHFHGDW GHXQPRUIHPSUHSR]L LH±FDUH FLQHDIRVWGHYHQLWDYHQLW
&LQHDIRVWGHSOHFDWDSOHFDW
SRDWH FUHD OHJ WXUL VLQWDFWLFH DWkW vQWUXQ JUXS YHUEDO FkW úL &HDIRVWGHWUHFXWSULQGUHSWXOYRVWUX
vQWUR VWUXFWXU QRPLQDO ± VXSLQXO DUH YDOHQ H FRPELQDWRULL DWUHFXW
PXOWLSOHúLLPSOLFLWIXQF LLVWLOLVWLFHGLYHUVH 06RUHVFX
9DORDUHD H[SUHVLY D VXSLQXOXL FDUH vúL PHQ LQH VWDWXWXO ,DU0DQHDRIWD
YHUEDO HVWH PDL DOHV FHD GH HSLWHW DO YHUEXOXL RUL DO ûLVHDSXFD
VXEVWDQWLYXOXL UHJHQW VDX PDL UDU DFWXDOL]DW YDORDUHD =LGXOGH]LGLW
PHWDIRULF VXSLQXO VXEVWDQWLYL]DW DFWLYHD] SUHSRQGHUHQW 9LVXOGHPSOLQLW
IXQF LD PHWRQLPLF LDU VXSLQXO DGYHUELDOL]DW vQGHSOLQHúWH 0 Q VWLUHD$UJHúXOXL
IUHFYHQWIXQF LDVWLOLVWLF GHHSLWHW $HUXOPLURDVHDXPHGDVIkUüLWGHLDUQ
2 YDORDUH SDUWLFXODU D VXSLQXOXL HVWH FHD GH HFKLYDOHQ *$GDPHúWHDQX
FXLPSHUDWLYXOFDúLLQILQLWLYXOVXSLQXOSULQFDUHVHH[SULP R (UD R JRVSRG ULH ERHP FX SULHWHQL
VROLFLWDUHLPSHUDWLY XQRUGLQXQvQGHPQFRQIHU HQXQ XOXL WLQHUL FX V UEDWRUL PLFL LPSURYL]DWH
XQ WRQ LPSHUVRQDO GHYHQLQG XQ LQGLFH WH[WXDO DO VWLOXOXL SOLQHGHYHVHOLHüLGHQHSUHY ]XW
RILFLDO ÌQ WH[WXO OLWHUDU SRDWH VXSUDPDUFD LQVHU LLOH QRQDUWLV &DPLO3HWUHVFX
WLFHÄGHFXSDMHOH´FXYDORDUHGRFXPHQWDU PHQLWHV DPSOLILFH
ÄHIHFWXOGHUHDO´
9$/25,67,/,67,&($/(3(562$1(/25*5$0$7,&$/(
6SHFLILF SURQXPHOXL DGMHFWLYXOXL SRVHVLY úL YHUEXOXL FDWHJRULD SHUVRDQHL
JUDPDWLFDOH SUHFL]HD] UROXO SDUWLFLSDQ LORU vQ DFWXO FRPXQLF ULL SULQ UDSRUWDUH OD
HPL WRU UROXO ORFXWRUXOXL HVWH DVXPDW SULQ SHUVRDQD , LQWHUORFXWRUXO HVWH GHVHPQDW
SULQ SHUVRDQD D ,,D vQ WLPS FH SHUVRDQD D ,,,D HVWH XWLOL]DW SHQWUX XQ UHIHUHQW
QHLPSOLFDWGLUHFWvQVLWXD LDGHFRPXQLFDUH
ÌQ RSHUD OLWHUDU RS LXQHD SHQWUX R DQXPLW SHUVRDQ JUDPDWLFDO QX PDL
UHSUH]LQW GRDU R VHOHF LH IRUPDO GHWHUPLQDW GH UHJXOD DFRUGXOXL FDUH DVLJXU
FRH]LXQHDWH[WXOXLFLGHYLQHRS LXQHVWLOLVWLF PRGDOLWDWHGHVWUXFWXUDUHDGLVFXUVXOXL
úLDSODQXOXLVHPDQWLFÄVHPQúLPRWRUDOGH]YROW ULLVSHFLILFHDSHUVRDQHLQDUDWLYH
SULQ UHRUJDQL]DUHD UDSRUWXOXL HPL WRU ± WH[W ± UHFHSWRU vQ VHQVXO GH]YROW ULL XQRU
SHUVSHFWLYHQDUDWLYHIXQGDPHQWDOHvQVWUXFWXUDWH[WXOXL´',ULPLD
n3 H U V R D Q D , ± H[SUHVLHOLQJYLVWLF DFRQúWLLQ HLGHVLQHDHXOXLURVWLWRU
DÌQGLVFXUVXOQDUDWLY
xLQGLFH
WH[WXDO DO HXOXL QDUDWRU vQ QDUD LXQHD KRPRGLHJHWLF DYkQG UROXO VWLOLVWLF GH D
FRQIHUL
YHURVLPLOLWDWH $P DIODW FX DFHVW SULOHM F RPXO PHX HUD XQ PDUH YU MLWRU GH OXSL
99RLFXOHVFX
YDORDUH H[SUHVLY DFFHQWXDW DUH GDWLYXO HWLF DO SURQXPHOXL VDX
DGMHFWLYXO
SRVHVLY HWLF ûLRGDW PL LO vQüI F FX GLQ LL GH FDS $WXQFL OXSXO QRVWUX vQFHSH D PkQFD
KvOSDY±,&UHDQJ
xSHUVRDQ QDUDWLY FDUHvQJOREHD] HXOQDUDWRUúLHXOQDUDWvQWH[WHOHDXWRGLHJHWLFHGH
JUDQL ´MXUQDOPHPRULLVDXILF LRQDOHFRQIHU XQJUDGULGLFDWGHDXWHQWLFLWDWH6LP HDP
F IHPHLDDFHDVW HUDDPHDvQH[HPSODUXQLFDüDFDHXOPHXFDPDPDPHD±&DPLO3HWUHVFX
xPDUF
DRUDOLW LLFDUHIXQF LRQHD] FDLQGLFHDOUHJLVWUXOXLVWLOLVWLFRUDOFRORFYLDO'DU
LDUP vQWRUFüL]LFPDLüWLLFXPYLQHYUHPHD"±,&UHDQJ
xVHPQ VWLOLVWLF DO SODQXOXL QDUDWRUXOXL GLVWLQFW GH SODQXO SHUVRQDMHORU vQ QDUD LXQHD
KHWHURGLHJHWLF SURLHF LH vQ WH[W D QDUDWRUXOXL FX URO GH GLIHUHQ LHUH vQWUH FHOH GRX
ÄVWUDWXULVWLOLVWLFH´úLGHLQVHU
LHFDUHÄUXSH´úLUXOGHHYHQLPHQWHQDUDWH'DULDFDFHPDP
DSXFDWGHVSXV0DLELQHY
VSXQHDPF WXUWXULFDDMXQVHVHODvPS UDWXO9HUGH±,&UHDQJ
xVHPQOLQJYLVWLFDOGLVFXUVXOXLSHUVRQDMHORUDYkQGUROXOGHDPDUFDVWLOXOGLUHFWúLGHD
FDUDFWHUL]DSHUVRQDMXOSULQOLPEDMXODWULEXLW(XVXQW/LF V P G XO0XOWHVH]LFGHVSUHPLQH
±,6ODYLFL
xSOXUDOXO SHUVRDQHL , SRDWH QXPL ± HPIDWLF SDURGLF ± QDUDWRUXO ÄSOXUDOXO DXWRUXOXL´
'DF
ELQH LL PLQWH P ULWH &HWLWRULXOH ² üL QX YHGHP FH WHDU SXWHD vPSLHGLFD ± ,*URúDQ SRDWH
LQFOXGHQDUDWRUXOúLQDUDWDUXO'DULDV
QXQHGHS UW PFXYRUEDüLV vQFHSDGHS QDILUXOSRYHüWLL±
,&UHDQJ
VDXSRDWHGHVHPQDXQFXSOXXQJUXSGHSHUVRQDMHXQSHUVRQDMFROHFWLY
vQFDUHVHLQWHJUHD]
VDXQXúLQDUDWRUXO1HOXDVHPGLQGUDJRVWHV UDFLDPkQGRL>@6XQWHPFD
QLüWHF O WRULDWDFD LGHOXSLüLWUHEXLHV QHDS U PVSDWHvQVSDWHF FLRULXQGHGHMXUvPSUHMXUHPRDUWHDGH
ILHUüLJORDQ H±&DPLO3HWUHVFX
EÌQGLVFXUVXOOLULF
x PDUF WH[WXDO DHXOXLOLULFGHVHPQkQGLQVWDQ DUHIOHFWRDUHGLQSHUVSHFWLYDF UHLD
FRQVWUXLHúWH YL]LXQHD SRHWLF DFWLYHD] IXQF LL VWLOLVWLFH FRPSOH[H UHOLHIDUHD
VH
OLULVPXOXL VXELHFWLY VWUXFWXUDUHD GLVFXUVXOXL OLULF úL H[SULPDUHD ÄvQWkPSO ULORU´ ILLQ HL D
H[SHULHQ HORU RQWLFHVDXFRJQLWLYHDVW ULORUHPR LRQDOHDVXPDWHGHHXOSRHWLF&D V
SRWPXULOLQLüWLWSHPLQH0LHUHG
P ±0(PLQHVFX
x SHUVRDQD,SOXUDODUHGLVSRQLELOLW LVHPDQWLFHúLVWLOLVWLFHPXOWLSOH
±FD H[SUHVLH D XQXL FXSOX vQ FDUH HXO OLULF VH DXWRLQFOXGH DUH UROXO GH D GHVHPQD
SUH]HQ H OLULFH FRQFUHWH SULQ PRWLYXO GHGXEO ULL SULQ PRWLYXO FXSOXOXL GH vQGU JRVWL L
HWF 1HRP U ]LPD FDSHWHOHXQXO GH DOWXO ûL VXUk]kQG YRP DGRUPL VXE vQDOWXO 9HFKLXO VDOFkP ±
0(PLQHVFX
±FDH[SUHVLHDXQHLLQVWDQ HOLULFHGLVWLQFWHGHHXOSRHWLFPDUFKHD] GLVFXUVXOGLUHFWDO
XQHL
HQWLW L FRQFUHWH VDX DEVWUDFWH SHUVRQLILFDWH DQWURSRPRUIL]DWH ILLQG XWLOL]DW vQ
WH[WHGLDORJLFHÄ5HYHGHUH´
±SRDWH DYHD YDORDUH JHQHULF GHVHPQkQG XPDQLWDWHD D F UHL ÄYRFH´ SRHWLF GHYLQH
HXOOLULFDUHUROXOGHDULGLFDH[SHULHQ
DOLULF ODUDQJGHH[SHULHQ JHQHUDO±XPDQ úL
GHDVHPQDODFDUDFWHUXOUHIOH[LYDOSRH]LHLUHJLVWUXOVWLOLVWLFJQRPLF2GDF
QDUILHURDUHD
GDF DPILFXUD L&XPVXQWSHüWLLGLQPDUHDFHDVIHULF IUD L±16W QHVFX
FÌQGLVFXUVXOGUDPDWLF
x SHUVRDQD,VLQJXODUVDXSOXUDOHVWHGHILQLWRULHSHQWUXGLVFXUVXOWHDWUDOGHVHPQkQG
SHILHFDUHGLQWUHSHUVRQDMHOHLQWHUSUHWDWHVFHQLF0LDPDGXVDPLQWH,RQD(XVXQW,RQD>@
5 ]ELPQRLFXPYDODOXPLQ ±06RUHVFX
p3
3 H U V R D Q D D , , , D ± GHQRW XQUHIHUHQWFDUHSRDWHDYHDWU V WXULVHPDQWLFH
IRDUWHGLYHUVHXPDQQRQXPDQDQLPDWLQDQLPDWFRQFUHWDEVWUDFWUHDOLUHDOHWF
DÌQFUHD
LDHSLF
xSHUVRDQDD,,,DQDUDWLY HVWHSULQH[FHOHQ ÄSHUVRDQDOXPLLQDUDWH´',ULPLDHVWH
XQPHFDQLVPJHQHUDWLYDOHSLFXOXLRELHFWLYDWFDUHSUHVXSXQHGLVWDQ DUHDQDUDWRUXOXLGH
XQLYHUVXO
GLHJHWLF GHVHPQHD] QX QXPDL SHUVRQDMHOH úL HYHQLPHQWHOH FH DOF WXLHVF
WUDPD
FL úL GLYHUVHOH FRPSRQHQWH DOH OXPLL ILF LRQDOH 'DU ELQHFXYkQWDW HUD ORFXO DFHVWD PDL
DOHVGHFkQGYHQLVHU
FkUFLXPDUXOFHOQRXFXQHYDVWDOXLWkQ U üLFXVRDFU VDFHDE WUkQ F FLHLQXSULPHDX
GUXPH FD SH XQ VWU LQ YHQLW GLQ OXPH FL FD SH XQ SULHWHQ DüWHSWDW GH PXOW YUHPH OD FDVD ORU ±
SH
,6ODYLFL
xvQ
QDUD LXQHD KHWHURGLHJHWLF SHUVRDQD D ,,,D HVWH SUH]HQW GHRSRWULY vQ
GLVFXUVXO
QDUDWRUXOXL úL vQ GLVFXUVXO SHUVRQDMHORU UHSUH]HQWkQG XQ IDFWRU GH FRHUHQ
WH[WXDO ² 'DU 9LFWRU DO W X (O QX PDL LHVH OD VDS % ORVXOH" 6DX GH FkQG HVWH YRLDMRU QXO PDL
DUDQMHD] "]LVH0RURPHWH$GLF DGPLWHPFD]XOF ILLQGRFXSDWPDLDG XJ HO±03UHGD
xSHUVRDQD
D ,,,D SRDWH DS UHD vQ PLFURFRQWH[WH FDUH SUHVXSXQ R FRQFHSWXDOL]DUH D
H[SHULHQ
HORU D VLWXD LLORU D WLSRORJLLORU XPDQH DYkQG YDORDUH JHQHULF RUL
GHVHPQkQGRLQVWDQ VXSUDLQGLYLGXDO 7UHEXLHV VHüWLHF üLLXELUHDDUHULVFXULOHHL& DFHL
FDUHVHLXEHVFDXGUHSWGHYLD
üLGHPRDUWHXQXODVXSUDFHOXLODOW±&DPLO3HWUHVFX
EÌQRSHUDOLULF
xvQ
GLVFXUVXO OLULF SHUVRDQD D ,,,D HVWH UHOHYDQW OD QLYHO VWLOLVWLF vQ IXQF LH GH
LGHQWLWDWHD
ILF LRQDO D UHIHUHQWXOXL GHVHPQDW SRDWH JHQHUD R WHQVLXQH OLULF SULQ
RSR]L LDFXSODQXOHXOXLURVWLWRU(XPXWR]LDOE (OPXW R]LQHDJU (XvQDLQWH]XQYLV(O
PLOLDODU ]ERL²06RUHVFX
xvQ
SRH]LD GHVFULSWLY HQXQ XULOH OD SHUVRDQD D ,,,D DX UROXO GH D HVWRPSD SUH]HQ D
HXOXLOLULFDF
UXLDWLWXGLQHQXHVWHH[SOLFLWSDUWLFLSDWLY 5HOLHIkQGVWLOLVWLFUHSHUHOHúL
VLPEROXULOHLPDJLQDUXOXLSRHWLF&XWRWFHOOLPLWHD] üLOOHDJ vPS FDWÍQWRDPQDOXLFRSDFXOVH
QFOLQ F WUH JOLH ± , %DUEX ÄÌQ SODQXO VHPDQWLF DO SHUVRDQHL D ,,,D VH DIO GL]ROYDW úL
SHUVRDQD,DVFULLWRUXOXLúLVHvQJOREHD]
úLSHUVRDQDD,,DDFLWLWRUXOXL´',HUHPLD
vQ
SRH]LD GH WLSXO SRUWUHWXOXL OLULF úL DO SVHXGRSRUWUHWXOXL SULQ SHUVRDQD D ,,,D HVWH
GHVHPQDWVXELHFWXOSHFDUHVHIRFDOL]HD] YL]LXQHDDUWLVWLF (DHUDIUXPRDV FDXPEUDXQXL
JkQGÍQWUHDSHQXPDLHDHUDS PkQW±16W QHVFX
xvQ
SRH]LD UHIOH[LY FD VHPQ OLQJYLVWLF DO RELHFWLY ULL vQ SODQXO VHPDQWLF DO WH[WXOXL
PDUFKHD]
FDUDFWHUXO JHQHUDOXPDQ DO H[SHULHQ HL OLULFH úL UHJLVWUXO VWLOLVWLF JQRPLF
9UHPHWUHFHYUHPHYLQH7RDWHVYHFKLüLQRX WRDWH±0(PLQHVFX
FÌQRSHUDGUDPDWLF
x vQ GLVFXUVXO SHUVRQDMHORU GHVHPQHD] RULFH HOHPHQW XPDQ VDX QRQXPDQ DO
ÄUHDOXOXLHVWHWLF´UHSUH]HQWDWVFHQLF1XPDLHQLPLFGHI
FXWFXHO6DGHVWU PDWKRUDLHOHORU (
RPXO
FDUH D Y ]XW LGHL ² & 3HWUHVFX VDX GHQRWDW QXPDL vQ UHSOLFLOH SHUVRQDMHORU 7UHFH
IO F XO SULQ S GXUH DXGH R PX]LF QHS PkQWHDVF üL YHGH vQ OXPLQLü vQ OXPLQD OXQLL LHOHOH ±
&DPLO3HWUHVFX
x vQ GLGDVFDOLL GUDPDWXUJXO XWLOL]HD] H[FOXVLY SHUVRDQD D ,,,D DYkQG FD UHIHUHQW
LQVWDQ
HOHGUDPDWL]DWHVDXHOHPHQWHOHVSHFWDFROXOXL*HOXHXQE UEDWFDODGHDQLGHR
IUXPXVH HPDLFXUkQGIHPLQLQ >@$UHQHUYR]LWDWHDLQVWDELO DDQLPDOHORUGHUDV ±&DPLO3HWUHVFX
(9$/8$5(
D7HPHSHQWUXSURLHFWH
3DUWLFXODULW LDOHUHJLVWUXOXLVWLOLVWLFSRSXODUvQRUD LLOHGHQXQW
9DULDQWD FLWDGLQ D RUDOLW LL vQ SRH]LD SRVWPRGHUQLVW XQ VFULLWRU OD
DOHJHUH
$VSHFWHDOHUHJLVWUXOXLVWLOLVWLFDUKDLFvQWHDWUXOLVWRULFFRQWHPSRUDQ
9DORDUHDH[SUHVLY DUHJLRQDOLVPHORUvQSRH]LDOXL9DVLOH9RLFXOHVFXvQ
SUR]DVFXUW DOXL0DULQ3UHGD
9DORULILFDUHDHVWHWLF DHOHPHQWHORUGHDUJRXvQSRHWLFDDUJKH]LDQ
0RGDOLW L GH YDORULILFDUH D UHJLVWUXOXL VWLOLVWLF QHRORJLF vQ SRH]LD PRGHU
QLVW XQVFULLWRUODDOHJHUH
6WLOXOSDURGLFvQSUR]DVFXUW SRVWPRGHUQLVW XQVFULLWRUODDOHJHUH
9DORUL H[SUHVLYH DOH WLPSXULORU YHUEDOH vQ SRH]LD URPDQWLF vQ SRH]LD
VLPEROLVW
9DORULVWLOLVWLFHDOHPRGXOXLFRQMXQFWLYvQSRH]LDFRQWHPSRUDQ XQSRHW
ODDOHJHUH
9DORULVWLOLVWLFHDOHSHUVRDQHLvQWkLvQURPDQXOLQWHUEHOLF
E)RUPHGHHYDOXDUH
6WXGHQ LL YRU UHDOL]D XQ SURLHFW FX R WHP OD DOHJHUH GLQWUH FHOH HQXQ DWH
DQWHULRU6HVLXQHDGHVXV LQHUHDSURLHFWHORUYDDYHDORFvQSHQXOWLPDV SW PkQ D
VHPHVWUXOXL,
,9,0$*,1$58/32(7,&
67,/,67,&$7(;78/8,/,5,&
6758&785$5($7(;78/8,/,5,&
*(18/ /,5,& JU O\UD ± OLU LQVWUXPHQW PX]LFDO UHXQHúWH RSHUHOH OLWHUDUH FDUH
VH FRQVWLWXLH SH ED]D FDWHJRULHL HVWHWLFH D OLULFXOXL FD WH[W PRQRORJLF PDL UDU SULQ
GLDORJLVPFXRLQWHQVLILFDUHDIXQF LHLVWLOLVWLFHSRHWLFHúLDFHOHLHPRWLYHH[SUHVLYH
5-DNREVRQDFFHQWXHD] IXQF LDSRHWLF ±ÄRSHUDSRHWLF WUHEXLHvQUHDOLWDWHV ILH
GHILQLW FDPHVDMYHUEDOvQFDUHIXQF LDHVWHWLF HVWHGRPLQDQW ´±DVRFLLQGXLIXQF LD
UHIHUHQ LDO vQFD]XOSRH]LHLHSLFHúLIXQF LDHPRWLY SHQWUXSRH]LDOLULF
/XPHD VRQRU úL ULWPLF D SRH]LHL VH DOF WXLHúWH FD GLVFXUV DXWRQRP vQ FDUH
UHSUH]HQW ULOHLGHLOHFRQFHS LLOHWU LULOHDIHFWLYHúLFRJQLWLYHDOHVFULLWRUXOXLVHFRPX
QLF GLUHFW7U V WXULOHLQWULQVHFLSULQFDUHVHGHILQHúWHSRHWLFLWDWHDVXQWFDUDFWHUXO
VXELHFWLYDOHQXQ ULLRUJDQL]DUHDIRUPDO VSHFLILF SULQFLSLXOYHUVLILFD LHLFDUDFWHUXO
DXWRWHOLFúLFDUDFWHUXOILF LRQDODOUHIHUHQWXOXL
6WUDWHJLLOH GLVFXUVLYH FDUH FRQIHU XQLFLWDWH OLPEDMXOXL SRHWLF VXQW DPEL
JXL]DUHD VXJHVWLD VLPEROL]DUHD WRWDOL]DUHD DFWXO VHPQLILF ULL VH UHDOL]HD] SULQ
vQWUHJXO FRQWH[W VWLOLVWLF GHYLHUHD GH OD QRUPHOH OLPELL OLWHUDUH úL GH OD X]DQ HOH
FRPXQLF ULL SUDJPDWLFH FD PHFDQLVP GH PHWDIRUL]DUH úL GH SURGXFHUH D XQRU QRL
VHPQLILFD LLHWF
'LQWUH WRDWH VIHUHOH OLWHUDWXULL GRPHQLXO SRHWLFXOXL HVWH FHO FDUH VH VXVWUDJH
XQHL GHILQLUL ULJXURDVH HO ILLQG GRDU DSUR[LPDW SULQ GLIHUHQ LHUL VSHFLILFH vQ FDGUXO
ÄDUKLJHQXOXL´FDUHHVWHOLWHUDWXUDúLSULQRSR]L LHFXFHOHODOWHJHQXULOLPEDMHOLWHUDUH
I U FDDFHVWHGHWHUPLQ ULV LGH]Y OXLHVXEVWDQ DLQHIDELO
Ä3RH]LD ± DILUPD 3DXO 9DOpU\ vQ 'LDORJXUL ± HVWH R DUW D /LPEDMXOXL DQXPLWH
FRPELQ ULGHFXYLQWHSRWSURGXFHRHPR LHSHFDUHDOWHOHQXRSURGXFúLSHFDUHQRLR
QXPLPSRHWLF >@$FHVWHOXFUXULúLILLQ HFXQRVFXWH±VDXPDLGHJUDE LGHLOHFDUHOH
UHSUH]LQW ± vúL VFKLPE vQWUXQ DQXPLW IHO YDORDUHD 6H FKHDP XQHOH SH DOWHOH VH
DVRFLD] FX WRWXO DOWIHO GHFkW vQ PRGXULOH RELúQXLWH HOH VH J VHVF PX]LFDOL]DWH
DYkQG UH]RQDQ H XQHOH SULQ DOWHOH úL FRUHVSXQG SDUF DUPRQLF 8QLYHUVXO SRHWLF
DVWIHO GHILQLW SUH]LQW PDUL DQDORJLL FX FHHD FH SXWHP SUHVXSXQH GHVSUH XQLYHUVXO
YLVXOXL´ $FHVW XQLYHUV SRHWLF DOF WXLW GLQ IDQWDVPHOH YLVXOXL LPDJLQHD] R OXPH
O XQWULF I U FRUHVSRQGHQWvQUHDOLWDWHFUHHD] XQVSD LXLQWHULRUúLRGXUDW LOX]RULH
FDUH ILLQ HD] QXPDL SULQ FXYLQWHOH SRHWLFH FDUH OH QXPHVF úL OH IDF V H[LVWH
,PDJLQDUXO SRHWLF HVWH DúDGDU DXWRQRP vQ UDSRUW FX UHDOLWDWHD HO H[LVW QXPDL vQ
OXPHD VHPDQWLF D WH[WXOXL HVWH FRQVWUXLW SH UHSHUH VSD LRWHPSRUDOH SVLKLFH FKLDU
úLDWXQFLFkQGFUHHD] LOX]LDUHDOLW LLúLUHXQHúWHWHPHOHPRWLYHOHúLVLPEROXULOHSH
FDUH VH VWUXFWXUHD] YL]LXQHD SRHWLF LGHLOH UHSUH]HQW ULOH úL VHQWLPHQWHOH
FRPXQLFDWH GH HXO OLULF ÄÌQ WH[WXO SRHWLF OXPLOH LPDJLQDUH VXQW FUHDWH GLQWUR
SHUVSHFWLY VXELHFWLY OLULF úLVXQWL]RODWHVHPQDOL]DWHvQSDUWHFKLDUFRQVWUXLWH
GHSURSULHW LOHIRUPDOHDOHGLVFXUVXOXL´5RGLFD=DILX1DUD LXQHúLSRH]LH
DXWRWHOLF±FDUHFRQ LQHvQVLQHVFRSXOFDUHvúLHVWHVXILFLHQW FXILQDOLWDWHLQWHUQ
7LSXULOHGHOLULVPVXQWJHQHUDWHGHPRGDOLWDWHDGHH[SULPDUHDLGHLORUSRHWLFH
DVW ULORUDIHFWLYHDVXPDWHVDXQXGHHXOOLULF
c /LULVPXO VXELHFWLY HVWH H[SUHVLD FHD PDL GLUHFW D FRPXQLF ULL SRHWLFH
UHDOL]DWH FD OLULF D HXOXL URVWLWRU SRHWXO VH LGHQWLILF FX HXO FDUH YRUEHúWH WLSXULOH
GLVFXUVLYH VSHFLILFH VXQW PRQRORJXO OLULF PRQRORJXO DGUHVDW LQYRFD LD UHWRULF VDX
DXWRDGUHVDWGLVFXUVXOGLDORJLFGLVFXUVXOHYRFDWRUHWF
LQGLFL WH[WXDOL P UFL OH[LFRJUDPDWLFDOH DOH SHUVRDQHL , D ,,D SURQXPH úL
DGMHFWLYHSURQRPLQDOHODSHUVRDQD,D,,DVLQJXODUVDXSOXUDOYHUEHODSHUV,D,,D
P UFL DOH DIHFWLYLW LL LQWHUMHF LL DGYHUEH GHLFWLFH GH ORF VDX GH WLPS DVHU LXQL
UHIOHF LLMXGHF LGHYDORDUHDVXPDWH
d /LULVPXO RELHFWLY GLVLPXOHD] SUH]HQ D HXOXL OLULF VXEVWLWXLQGR FX DOWH
SUH]HQ HOLULFH
±OLULFDP úWLORUSUHVXSXQHH[SULPDUHDLGHLORUúLVHQWLPHQWHORUVXERLGHQWLWDWH
VWU LQ
±OLULFDUROXULORUvQFDUHSRHWXOLGHQWLILFkQGXVHFXXQÄSHUVRQDM´H[SULP
VHQWLPHQWHFDUHQXVXQWSURSULX]LVDOHVDOH
±OLULFDJQRPLF ±PHGLWD LLSHWHPHILORVRILFHSRWILIRUPXODWHODSHUVRDQDD,,,D
VXEDSDUHQ DRELHFWLYLW LLFKLDUGDF UHIOHF LLOHVXQWGHIDSWDOHSRHWXOXL
±OLULFDGHVFULSWLY GHWLSWDEORXVDXGHWLSSRUWUHWGLVLPXOHD] SHUVSHFWLYD
VXELHFWLY DSRHWXOXLVXEDSDUHQ DXQHLYL]LXQLQRQIRFDOL]DWHFKLDUGDF SULQ
HSLWHWHFDOLILFDWLYHVHHYLGHQ LD] SHUFHS LDVXELHFWLY ÄSULPDU ´
e/LULVPXOQDUDWLYHVWHDVRFLDWOLULFLLFRQWHPSRUDQHúLDUHFDSUHPLV LSRVWD]H
DOH RPXOXL PRGHUQ FDUH QX PDL HVWH FRQWHPSODWLYXO URPDQWLF L]RODW RUJROLRV vQ
KLPHULFD VIHU D YLVXOXL FL R SUH]HQ HVHQ LDO DFWLY GLQDPLF WUDYHUVkQG
H[SHULHQ H H[LVWHQ LDOH DYHQWXUL vQ RUL]RQWXULOH FXQRDúWHULL VDX EDQDOH HYHQLPHQWH
FRWLGLHQHFRQIUXQWkQGXVHFXVLQHVDXFXFHLODO LFXWLPSXOFXLXELUHDFXPRDUWHD
Ä1DUDWLYXOSRDWHFRQILJXUDRH[SHULHQ VXELHFWLY OLULF FRQVWUXLHúWHOXPLLPDJLQDUH
GHSHQGHQWH GH WHPSRUDOLWDWH RIHU SRVLELOLW L VSHFLILFH GH DPELJXL]DUH úL
VLPEROL]DUH´ 5RGLFD =DILX 1DUD LXQH úL SRH]LH $FHVW WLS GH OLULVP HVWH GHILQLW GH
+HQU\N 0DUNLHZLF] &RQFHSWHOH úWLLQ HL OLWHUDWXULL FD ÄUHDOLWDWH GLQDPLF SUH]HQWDW
vQWURIRUP VXELHFWLY VDXVLPEROLF ´
LQGLFL WH[WXDOL SUH]HQ D XQXL ÄQXFOHX´ QDUDWLY D XQXL ÄVFHQDULX´ PLWLF VDX
LQL LDWLF IUHFYHQ D YHUEHORU D LQGLFLORU WHPSRUDOLW LL DGYHUEH GH WLPS VXJHUkQG R
VXFFHVLXQH GH VW UL GH VLWXD LL VDX HYHQLPHQWH WLPSXUL YHUEDOH HWF DL
SURFHVXDOLW LLDLVFKLPE ULLHWF
&ODVLILFDUHDFUHD LLORUOLULFHvQFODVHVSHFLILFHVSHFLLHVWHGHWHUPLQDW GHPDL
PXOWHFULWHULL
c FULWHULXO WHPDWLF OLULFD HURWLF LGLO HJORJ URPDQ HOHJLH HURWLF HWF
OLULFD SHLVDJLVW SDVWHO SDVWHO SVLKRORJLF OLULFD FHW LL SRH]LD SDWULRWLF úL SRH]LD
VRFLDO LPQ RG PHGLWD LH VDWLU EOHVWHP HWF OLULFD ILORVRILF DUW SRHWLF
PHGLWD LHHOHJLHH[LVWHQ LDO HWF
dFULWHULXOIRUPDOSRH]LLOHFXIRUP IL[ VRQHWURQGHOJD]HOJORV KDLNXHWF
eFULWHULXOGRPLQDQWHLDIHFWLYHLPQRG GRLQ HOHJLHVDWLU SDURGLHHWF
6WUXFWXUDUHDWH[WXOXLSRHWLF
Ä'RPHQLXOSRHWLFXOXLGLIHULWGHDFHODVHPLRWLFúLGHDFHODVHPDQWLFHVWHXQWH[W
RXQLWDWHIRUPDO GHVLQHVW W WRDUHFDUHSRDUW XQFRQ LQXWLPDJLQDUúLG QDúWHUH
XQHLH[SUHVLL'LVWLQJHPvQHO>@IRUPDWH[WXOXLSHFDUHDPGHILQLWRSHGHRSDUWH
GUHSWRUGLQHDQXPLW DOLPELLSUR]RGLDLDUSHGHDOWDGUHSWRUHOD LHvQWUHVWUXFWXUL
DVHP Q WRDUHUHOD LHGHVXERUGRQDUHID GHXQJHQLQWHUWH[WXDOLWDWHDFRQ LQXWXO
WH[WXOXL DGLF XQLYHUVXO OXL LQWULQVHF úL ILFWLY LQH[LVWHQW vQDLQWHD úL vQ DIDUD IRUPHL
SURSULLSUR]RGLFHúLLQWHUWH[WXDOHvQILQHH[SUHVLDFDUHHVWHIXQF LDWH[WXOXLFHHDFH
IDFH GLQ HO XQ SRHP FRQFUHW VLQJXODU úL QHUHSHWDELO PDQLIHVWDUH D DGHY UXOXL
SDUWLFXODUDOSRHWXOXL´1LFRODH0DQROHVFX'HVSUHSRH]LH
&D ÄDUW D /LPEDMXOXL´ PDL PXOW GHFkW FHOHODOWH JHQXUL JHQXO OLULF DSHOHD] OD
SURFHGHH H[SUHVLYH FDUH HYROXHD] GH OD VLPSOXO VWULJ W HPR LRQDO OD UDILQDWD
XWLOL]DUHDWXWXURUWLSXULORUGHLPDJLQLGHILJXULGHVWLOVDXGHPHWULF úLODRUJDQL]DUHD
vQFHOHPDLGLYHUVHIRUPHGHSRH]LHGHODIRUPHOHFODVLFHODÄVSD LDOLWDWHDSODVWLF ´D
FDOLJUDPHORU
(OHPHQWHOH GH FRPSR]L LH SRHWLF DX vQ YHGHUH XQLW LOH SUR]RGLFH YHUVXO
VWURID úL XQLW LOH ORJLFH ± VHFYHQ HOH SRHWLFH ± FDUH SRW FRLQFLGH VDX QX FX FHOH
IRUPDOH3ULQFLSLLOHFDUHRUGRQHD] WH[WXOSRHWLFVXQWGHPDUHGLYHUVLWDWHUHFXUHQ D
VLPHWULD SDUDOHOLVPXO UHSHWL LD FX URO FRPSR]L LRQDO UHIUHQXO ODLWPRWLYXO DQDIRUD
HSLIRUDDQWLWH]DFRQWUDSXQFWXOHWF
63(&,,$/(*(18/8,/,5,&
63(&,,/,5,&(
([7HVWDPHQWXOOXL,HQ FKL 9 F UHVFX
6HULOH OD 0LUFHúWL GH $OHFVDQGUL (SLJRQLL
ODW$UVSRHWLFDGH+RUD LX 1XPDLSRHWXO«3RHW2GLQúLSRHWXO2G vQ
6SHFLH D OLULFLL ILORVRILFH WUDQVILJXUkQG PHWUXDQWLF6FULVRDUHD,,±(PLQHVFX
vQ LPDJLQL SRHWLFH FUH]XO DUWLVWLF DO 1RDSWHD GH GHFHPYULH GH 0DFHGRQVNL
SRHWXOXL SULQFLSLLOH VDOH HVWHWLFH YL]LXQHD 5XJ FLXQH1RDSWHD3RHWXOGH*RJD3RHWXO
SURSULH GHVSUH VXUVHOH úL DFWXO FUHD LHL GH &RúEXF ,PQ 'H DUW %DFRYLD 3RUWUHW
GHVSUHIXQF LDHLFRJQLWLY GHVSUHPHQLUHD ([ OLEULV 7HVWDPHQW 5XJ GH VHDU ±
úLGHVWLQXODUWHLúLDUWLVWXOXL $UJKH]L
PHVDMXO±SURJUDP DO XQXL DUWLVW (X QX VWULYHVF FRUROD GH PLQXQL D OXPLL
H[SULPkQGFUH]XOV XGHVSUHFUHD LH &kQW UH LLEROQDYL±%ODJD
-RFVHFXQG7LPEUXGH,%DUEX1HFXYLQWHOH
3RH]LD7HVWDPHQW6HPQ±16W QHVFX
± 7LWOX GDW GH $OHFVDQGUL FLFOXOXL GH SRH]LL
LWSDVWHOOR±SLFWXU FXFUHLRDQHPRL SXEOLFDWH vQWUH úL vQ ³&RQYRUELUL
7HUPHQXO GHQXPHúWH QXPDL vQ OLWHUDWXUD OLWHUDUH´
± WHUPHQXO QX DFRSHU vQWUHDJD VIHU GH
URPkQ R VSHFLH D JHQXOXL OLULFR SRH]LH
PDQLIHVW ULDVHQWLPHQWXOXLQDWXULLvQSRH]LH
GHVFULSWLY vQ FDUH VH FRQWXUHD] XQ GH DFHHD VH SRDWH YRUEL GH XQ ÄSDVWHO
WDEORX GLQ QDWXU vQWUR YL]LXQH UHODWLY FRVPLF´ vQ /XFHDI UXO GH XQ ÄSDVWHO
RELHFWLY FODVLF VLPEROLVW´OD0DFHGRQVNLúL%DFRYLDÄSDVWHO
H[SUHVLRQLVW´OD%ODJD
ODWHOHJLD±FkQWHFGHGROLX ± ÌQ OLULFD PRGHUQ DYkQGXO FD PRGHO SH
%DXGHODLUH HOHJLD VH GLYHUVLILF úL VH
6SHFLHDOLULFLLvQFDUHVHQWLPHQWH
QXDQ HD] H[SULPkQG R WULVWH H RQWRORJLF úL
GRPLQDQWHVXQWWULVWH HDQRVWDOJLD PHWDIL]LF 5LONH *DUFLD /RUFD (VHQLQ
UHJUHWXOGRUXOGHPRDUWHHWF (PLQHVFX%DFRYLD,RQ9LQHDHWF
ODWPHGLWDWLR±UHIOHF LH
± FXOWLYDW GH URPDQWLFL PHGLWD LL SH WHPD
VSHFLH D SRH]LHL ILORVRILFH vQ FDUH
WLPSXOXLDLVWRULHLLXELULLPRU LLGLYLQXOXLHWF
OLULVPXO VH ULGLF OD R WUHDSW GH FRQWHP ±([0HGLWD LLOHSRHWLFHDOHOXL/DPDUWLQH
SOD LHLQWHOHFWXDO
63(&,,/,5,&(
IULG\OOH±PLFWDEORXSRHPDWLF
±([%XFROLFHOHOXL9HUJLOLX
6SHFLH GH SRH]LH SDVWRUDO DYkQG FD
±WHPDQDWXULLFDPSHVWUHVHDVRFLD] FX
RELHFW YLD D UXVWLF EXFROLF DUFDGLF WHPDLXELULLFDvQLGLOHOHHPLQHVFLHQH
QDLYVHQWLPHQWDO
ODWK\PQXV±FkQWHFGHELUXLQ ±/DRULJLQHHUDRLQYRFD LHPLVWLF
DGUHVDW XQHLGLYLQLW L,PQXULF WUH$SROOR
6SHFLH VROHPQ D JHQXOXL OLULF FkQWHF
ÄSHDQ´,PQXULF WUHQRDSWHGH1RYDOLV
GH VODY FRQVDFUDW XQXL HYHQLPHQW VDX ±6HDVRFLD] vQF FXPX]LFDLPQXUL
XQHLSHUVRQDOLW LH[HPSODUH QD LRQDOH
IUJURGH
6SHFLH D JHQXOXL OLULF H[SULPkQG R ±1XVHDVRFLD] FXPX]LFDSUHFXPLPQXO
±LQFLSLWXOSRDWHILRLQYRFD LHFDvQLPQ
VWDUH GH MXELOD LH VSLULWXDO XQ HODQ ±H[2GHWULXPIDOHGH3LQGDU2G RVWDúLORU
DGPLUDWLY SHQWUX R LGHH R SHUVRDQ XQ URPkQLGH$OHFVDQGUL2G vQPHWUXDQWLF
HYHQLPHQW
ODWVDWXUDIUVDWLUH±PXVWUDUH ±(OHPHQWHGHILQLWRULL
2SHU OLWHUDU FXFDUDFWHUFULWLF DWLWXGLQHDGH]DSUREDWRDUHPDUFDW GH
VSHFLH OLULF vQ YHUVXUL vQ FDUH VH GLVSUH DDXWRUXOXLDSHOXOODLURQLHVDUFDVP
ULGLFXOL]HD] VDX VH FRQGDPQ YHKHPHQW OLPEDMLURQLFGHSLOG DQWLIUD]DVDXYLUXOHQW
IHQRPHQH QHJDWLYH DOH VRFLHW LL VDX YLFLL DGHFYDWDWLWXGLQLLGHGLVWDQ DUHLURQLF GH
RPHQHúWL SURWHVW
VODYRQ SVDOPX±FkQWHFUHOLJLRV ±&HLGH3VDOPLDLOXL'DYLGDOF WXLHVF
6SHFLHDOLULFLLUHOLJLRDVHFXFDUDFWHUGH XQDGLQWUHF U LOHFDQRQLFHDOH9HFKLXOXL
UXJ FLXQHúLGHRG VDFU 7HVWDPHQWvQOLPEDURPkQ 3VDOWLUHDvQ
SVDOPLL GLQ OLULFD PRGHUQ VXQW PHGLWD LL YHUVXULDOXL'RVRIWHL
ILORVRILFH DVXSUD UDSRUWXOXL GLQWUH RP úL ±([3VDOPLPRGHUQLDLOXL0DFHGRQVNL
GLYLQLWDWHDVXSUDFRQGL LHLXPDQH FLFOXO3VDOPLORUOXL$UJKH]L
HWLPRORJLH FRQWURYHUVDW ' &DQWHPLU
FXYkQW GLQ OLPED GDFLORU OLWXDQLDQXO GDLQD ÌQOLWHUDWXUDFXOW WHUPHQXOHVWHLPSXVGH
FkQWHFSRSXODU 9$OHFVDQGUL
'HQXPHúWH FkQWHFXO SRSXODU HOHJLDF $XFUHDWGRLQHFXOWH$OHFVDQGUL(PLQHVFX
VSHFLLOH OLULFH IROFORULFH vQ vQWUHJXO ORU úL &RúEXFùW2,RVLI$UJKH]L
FUHD LLFXOWHvQWLSDUSUR]RGLFIROFORULF
32(=,,&8)250 ),;
¾3RH]LHFXIRUP IL[ vQVXPkQGYHUVXULFDUHSRWILJUXSDWH
GXS PRGHOXOLWDOLDQ3HWUDUFDFDWUHQHWHU LQH
GXS PRGHOXOHQJOH]FDWUHQHXQGLVWLKILQDOFXYDORDUHGHFRQFOX]LH
6KDNHVSHDUH úLD VFULV VRQHWHOH I U L]RODUHD VWURIHORU SULQ EODQF VSD LX DOE GkQG
GRDURDOW DOLQLHUHGLVWLKXOXLILQDO
¾ 3RH]LHFXIRUP IL[ DOF WXLW GLQYHUVXULFHDSHOHD] ODUHIUHQúLDUHGRDUGRX
ULPH GXS PRGHOXO DEEDEDDEDEDED SULPHOH GRX YHUVXUL UHDSDU vQ SR]L LH
PHGLDQ FD YHUVXULOH SRH]LD vQFKHLQGXVH FX YHUVXO LQL LDO VXQW GHFL LGHQWLFH
YHUVXULOH úL
¾ 5RQVHWXOFUHDWGH+RULD% GHVFXHVWHRFRPELQD LHvQWUHVRQHWúLURQGHO
¾ 3RH]LHFXIRUP IL[ DOF WXLW GLQWURVWURI ±WHP úLWRWDWkWHDVWURIHPHGLDQHFkWH
YHUVXUL DUH VWURIDWHP ILHFDUH VWURI PHGLDQ VH vQFKHLH FX FkWH XQ YHUV GLQ VWURID
WHP DFHDVWDUHDS UkQGvQILQDOFXLQYHUVDUHDRUGLQLLYHUVXULORU
,0$*,1($$57,67,&
,PDJLQHD DUWLVWLF HVWH IRUP FRQFUHW D XQHL LGHL DUWLVWLFH UHSUH]HQWDUH
VXELHFWLY SURGXV GH LPDJLQD LD FUHDWRDUH FX DMXWRUXO FXYkQWXOXL FX UHIHUHQW
FRQFUHW VDX DEVWUDFW FX DMXWRUXO VXQHWHORU FXORULORU HWF ,PDJLQHD DUWLVWLF DUH XQ
FDUDFWHU VLQJXODU LUHSHWDELO VXJHUkQG FRPSRQHQWHOH YL]LXQLL DUWLVWLFH UHSUH]HQW UL
PHQWDOHVDXVHQ]RULDOH
ÌQIXQF LHGHFULWHULXOSHUFHS LHLVHQ]RULDOHLPDJLQLOHDUWLVWLFHVHFODVLILF vQ
YL]XDOH Ä/XPLQL VF SDWH GLQ FXSWRU VH ]EDW vQWUH SHUH L´ ± /XFLDQ %ODJD
7 PkLHúLIXOJL
DXGLWLYHÄ$XGPDWHULDSOkQJkQG´*HRUJH%DFRYLD/DFXVWU
ROIDFWLYHÄ&ODUGHQRDSWHSDUIXPDW´*HRUJH%DFRYLD1RFWXUQ
WDFWLOHÄ$]LVXQWQHSXWLQFLRVFDRP WDV ´±(PLO%UXPDUX$VWHQLH
JXVWDWLYH Ä,XELWD PHD GH QHJUX úL GH VDUH´ 1LFKLWD 6W QHVFX 9LD D PHD VH
LOXPLQHD]
GLQDPLFHFKLQHVWH]LFHÄ2KR DOHUJ úL VDOW úL FXUJ´ 1LFKLWD6W QHVFX9LD D
PHDVHLOXPLQHD]
VLQHVWH]LFHÄ)RúQLUHDP W VRDV DP ULORUFXVDUH´,RQ%DUEX7LPEUX
(/(0(17('(9(56,),&$ ,(
(OHPHQWHOH GH SUR]RGLH JU SURVRGLD ± LQWRQDUH DFFHQWXDUH DX IRVW
FRQVLGHUDWH SkQ vQ HSRFD PRGHUQ VHPQ REOLJDWRULX DO SRHWLFLW LL PHWULFD
SUR]RGLD GHYHQLQG R úWLLQ SUH XLW D $QWLFKLW LL úL D HSRFLORU FODVLFL]DQWH
5HQDúWHUHD (SRFD /XPLQLORU VHFROXO &ODVLFLVPXOXL HSRFD PDQLHULVPXOXL D
SDUQDVLDQLVPXOXLHWFúLXQVXELHFWFRQWURYHUVDWSHQWUXSRH LLúLWHRUHWLFLHQLLXOWLPHORU
GRX YHDFXUL 3UR]RGLD VWXGLD] DQVDPEOXO GH SURFHGHH úL WHKQLFL IRUPDOH SH ED]D
F URUD HVWH FUHDW GLVFXUVXO SRHWLF UHJXOL PHWULFH UHODWLY VWDELOH XWLOL]DWH vQ
FRPSXQHUHDYHUVXULORUúLDVWURIHORU
'HVSUH PXWD LLOH VXUYHQLWH vQ SRH]LD PRGHUQLVW GHVSUH VFKLPEDUHD FDQRQXOXL
SUR]RGLF úL UHJkQGLUHD FRQFHSWXOXL GH SRHWLFLWDWH FULWLFXO 1LFRODH 0DQROHVFX DILUP
Ä7LPSGHVHFROHSRH]LDHXURSHDQ DIRVWJXYHUQDW GHXQVLVWHPSUHFLVúLFRPSOH[GH
UHJXOLPHWULFHúLGHXQXOQXPDLSX LQVWULFWGHILJXULGHVHQV>@6LVWHPXOUHWRULFúL
VLVWHPXOPHWULFVDXSU EXúLWDPkQGRX FXPVHúWLHSHODVIkUúLWXOURPDQWLVPXOXLGLQ
FDX]HSUREDELOGLIHULWH>@0RGLILFDUHDLQWHUSUHW ULLIRQLFHúLSUR]RGLFHDSRH]LHLSRDWH
DWUDJH R VFKLPEDUH D FULWHULXOXL SRHWLFXOXL ([LVW QXPHURDVH P UWXULL F S U VLUHD
UHJXOLORU FODVLFHGHYHUVLILFD LHDFUHDWXQIHOGHFUL] DSRH]LHLvQVHúLFDUHVDWUH]LW
SULYDW GHXQXOGLQPLMORDFHOHFHOHPDLVLJXUHGHDVHDXWRLGHQWLILFD1XPDLFkQGúLD
FUHDWRFRPSHQVD LHVXILFLHQW DLHúLWSRH]LDGLQDFHDVW FUL] ´'HVSUHSRH]LH
¾ 5LWPXO SRHWLF UHSUH]LQW R VXFFHVLXQH UHFXUHQW GH XQLW L SUR]RGLFH HFKLYDOHQWH
$FHVWH XQLW L SUR]RGLFH VXQW SLFLRDUHOH PHWULFH GHILQLWH FD XQLW L ULWPLFH vQ FDUH
VLODEHOH DFFHQWXDWH úL FHOH QHDFFHQWXDWH8VHVXFFHGGXS XQDQXPLWPRGHO
8QLW LOHULWPLFHSRWIL
xELVLODELFH WURKHXO 8 &RGUXOH FRGUX XOH úL LDPEXO 8 $ IRVW RGDW FDQ
SRYHúWL
xWULVLODELFHGDFWLOXO88DPILEUDKXO88DQDSHVWXO88
%DUEDOXLIOXWXU QYkQWXULFDQHJXUDFHDDUJLQWLH88888888888
7UHFXWDLFkQGFHUXLFkPSLHVHQLQ 88888888
3ULQWUHFUHQJLOXPLQDSDOLGJOREGHDUJLQW8888888888
xWHWUDVLODELFHFXXQVLQJXUDFFHQWSHRQXODYkQGLQGLFHGXS ORFXOVLODEHL
DFFHQWXDWH
9kQWXULOHYDOXULOHSHRQ888888
6RPQRURDVHS V UHOHSHRQ888888
xWHWUDVLODELFHFXGRX DFFHQWHFRULDPEXO886DUDSHGHDO
¾5LWPXOSRH]LHLPRGHUQHQXPDLXUPHD] VXFFHVLXQHDIRUPDO DSLFLRDUHORUPHWULFH
vQORFXLQG DFFHQWHOH GH LQWHQVLWDWH FX DFFHQWH DIHFWLYH úL VWLOLVWLFH FRQVWUXLQGXúL
FDGHQ HOH FRQWUDSXQFWLF SULQ FRQWUDVWXO GLQWUH FXYLQWHOHFKHLH DFFHQWXDWH úL FRQWH[WXO
FXIOXHQ ILUHDVF DULWPXOXLYRUELULL
¾0 VXUDHVWHWRWDOLWDWHDVLODEHORUXQXLYHUVJUXSDWHvQXQLW LULWPLFH9HUVXULOHFXP VXU
VFXUW SkQ ODVLODEHFRQIHU XQULWPDOHUWGLVFXUVXOXLSRHWLFvQYUHPHFHP VXUDPHGLH
úLFHDOXQJ SHVWHVLODEHLPSXQRFDGHQ ULWPLF JUDY VROHPQ OLWXUJLF HWF
$FHVWH YHUVXUL VXQW PDUFDWH GH R SDX] ULWPLF FH]XU FDUH OH VHJPHQWHD] vQ GRX
HPLVWLKXULGHRELFHLHJDOHGHH[HPSOXDOH[DQGULQXO±YHUVXOGLQVLODEHFXULWPLDPELF
±DUHGRX HPLVWLKXULGHFkWHVLODEH8QHOHPHQWGHPDUHPRGHUQLWDWHFXXQHIHFWVRQRU
GHRVHELW HVWH SODVDUHD FH]XULL vQ LQWHULRUXO XQXL FXYkQW VDX GHFRQVWUXLUHD HL SULP
PXOWLSOLFDUHDSDX]HORUULWPLFH6DXQXRPDLDPFXQRVFXW±7$UJKH]L
¾ 0 VXUD YDULDELO D YHUVXULORU GLQ SRH]LD PRGHUQ VHPQDOHD] JUDILF LPSXOVXULOH
HPR LRQDOHGHLQWHQVLWDWHúLGXUDW GLIHULWHVDXIOX[XOLQWHUPLWHQWDOLGHLORU
¾ Ä3ULQPHWUXVHvQ HOHJHVFKHPDXQHLSRH]LLFDUHH[LVW LQGHSHQGHQWGHUHDOL]DUHDHL
OLQJYLVWLF (OLQGLF >@QXP UXOGHVLODEHDOYHUVXULORUIHOXOSLFLRDUHORUúLQXP UXOORU
ORFXO FH]XULORU DOF WXLUHD IUD]HL SR]L LD ULPHL HYHQWXDO úL IRUPD SRH]LHL´ :ROIJDQJ
.D\VHU2SHUDOLWHUDU
¾ 5LPD HOHPHQW DO YHUVLILFD LHL FODVLFH HVWH FRQVRQDQ D VXQHWHORU ILQDOH D GRX VDX
PDL PXOWH YHUVXUL vQFHSkQG FX XOWLPD YRFDO DFFHQWXDW 5LPHOH PRQRVLODELFH VXQW
QXPLWH ULPH PDVFXOLQH VLODEHOH ILQDOH VXQW DFFHQWXDWH GpV LpV LDU ULPHOH
ELVLODELFH SHQXOWLPD VLODE DFFHQWXDW O~QH V~QH ULPH IHPLQLQH 5LPHOH ERJDWH
VXQW FHOH WULVLODELFH ULPD GDFWLOLF vQFHSH FX DQWHSHQXOWLPD VLODE FDUH H DFFHQWXDW
FOtSHOH DUtSHOH VDX WHWUDVLODELFH ULPD KLSHUGDFWLOLF SHRQLF UHDOL]HD]
LGHQWLWDWHD IRQHWLF D XOWLPHORU SDWUX VLODEH PiOXULOH YiOXULOH 'XS SR]L LD ORU vQ
VWURI ULPHOHVXQW
ULPD vPSHUHFKHDW DDEE 7X HúWL R XQG HX VXQW R ]DUH (X VXQW XQ
UPXUWXHúWLRPDUH7XHúWLRQRDSWHHXVXQWRVWHD±,XELWDPHD
ULPD vQFUXFLúDW DEDE 7RW DVWIHO FvQG DO QRVWUX GRU 3LHUL vQ QRDSWH
DGkQF /XPLQDVWLQVXOXLDPRU1HXUP UHúWHvQF
ULPDvPEU LúDW DEED6WHOHOHQFHU'HDVXSUDP ULORU$UGGHS UW ULORU
3kQ FHSLHU
ULPDvQO Q XLW DEDEFEFGFvQURQGHODEEDDEDEEDEDD
PRQRULPD DDD EEEE 'LQ RFKL O FULPkQG3H FXOPL DOHUJkQG3H WR L
vQWUHEkQGùLODWR L]LFkQG
¾ 5LPD LQWHULRDU GRX FXYLQWH VDX FHOH GRX HPLVWLKXUL GLQWUXQ YHUV ULPHD]
/LQHOHFROLQHOHVWUkQJGHVXVOXPLQLOH±/%ODJDDFFHQWXHD] HXIRQLDYHUVXOXL
¾ 5LPDHFRX FRQFHQWULF VH UHDOL]HD] SULQ UHOXDUHD XQXL FXYkQW vQ ULP GH
H[HPSOX VXEVWDQWLYXO SOXPE vQ SRH]LD OXL %DFRYLD SULQ ULPDUHD XQRU RPRQLPH
RPRIRQH FXYkQWXO FX YkQWXO VDX SULQ ULPDUHD XQRU FXYLQWH GLQWUH FDUH XQXO vO
vQFRUSRUHD] SHFHO ODOWFULVWDOLQ DOLQ
¾ 5LPD LPSHUIHFW QXPLW úL DVRQDQ FRQVW vQ GLIHUHQ H GH VXQHWH GH RELFHL
FRQVRDQH vQ VHJPHQWHOH DFXVWLFH FDUH IRUPHD] ULPD ùL SHQWUX FLQH YUHL V PRUL"
ÌQWRDUFHWHWHQGUHDSW 6SUHDFHOS PkQWU W FLWRU
¾ 6HPLULPDUHSUH]LQW XQPRGHOFRPELQDWvQWUHYHUVXOFODVLFúLFHOPRGHUQFRQVWkQG
vQDOWHUQDQ DYHUVXULORUDOEHFXYHUVXULULPDWHvQFUXFLúDWDEFE2UHOHSOXWHVF
SH OkQJ XP UXO W X VIHUHDOEDVWUH úLQWUH HOH H 6DWXUQ ùL FXP VH GXF VH
PLFúRUHD] PDLvQVHUDWúLPDLQRFWXUQ±16W QHVFX
¾Ä9HUVXO SRDWH IL GHILQLW FD R VXSUDVWUXFWXU >@ D F UHL FDUDFWHULVWLF HVWH GDW GH
IDSWXOF VXEGLYLGHúLUXOVRQRUFRQWLQXXDOWH[WXOXLvQVHFYHQ HHFKLYDOHQWH´+HLQULFK
3OHWWùWLLQ DWH[WXOXL,]RODUHDILHF UXLYHUVVHUHDOL]HD] VRQRUSULQSDX] úLJUDILF
SULQVSD LXODOEFDUHXUPHD] FXYkQWXOXLFHvQFKLGHYHUVXO
¾&D VXSUDVWUXFWXU VSHFLILF SRH]LHL YHUVXO VH FDUDFWHUL]HD] vQ IXQF LH GH SDWUX
HOHPHQWHVWUXFWXUDQWHULWPP VXU ULP úLSDX]HSDX]DGHWLSFH]XU úLSDX]DGH
ODILQDOXOYHUVXOXL
¾9HUVXO DOE S VWUHD] ULWPXO P VXUD úL SDX]D OD VIkUúLW GH YHUV GDU HVWH OLSVLW GH
ULP 2HUDL XQ RP IUXPRV úL VXE LUH IRDUWH SDOLG« 3ULQWUH RFKLL W L FXUJHD XQ
P QXQFKLGHDULSLDOEH16W QHVFX
¾9HUVXO DULWPLF DUH ULP úL SDX] ILQDO GDU P VXUD úL ULWPXO VXQW YDULDELOH
SROLULWPLH 0 ULGLFDP GLQ VRPQ FD GLQ PDUH VFXWXUkQGXPL úXYL HOH F ]XWH SH
IUXQWHYLVHOHVSUkQFHQHOHFULVWDOL]DWHGHVDUHDELVHOH16W QHVFX
¾9HUVXO OLEHU HVWH FDUDFWHUL]DW SULQ ULWP YDULDELO P VXU LQHJDO DEVHQ D ULPHL
DYkQGvQV SDX] ODVIkUúLWGHYHUV6HLDREXFDW GHSLDWU VHFLRSOHúWHFXRGDOW
GHVkQJHVHOXVWUXLHúWHFXRFKLXOOXL+RPHUVHU ]XLHúWHFXUD]HSkQ FXEXOLHVH
SHUIHFW16W QHVFX
¾9HUVXULOHvQO Q XLWHDXFDVHPQGLVWLQFWLYLQJDPEDPHQWXOFDUHGLPLQXHD] RULFKLDU
VXVSHQG SDX]D GH OD VIkUúLWXO YHUVXOXL FRQWLQXkQG HQXQ XO vQ YHUVXO XUP WRU
6HJPHQWDUHD XQLW LL VLQWDFWLFROH[LFDOH DWULEXWXO VDX FRPSOHPHQWXO L]RODW GH
FXYkQWXOUHJHQWDUWLFROXORULSUHSR]L LDGHVXEVWDQWLYHWFvQGRX YHUVXULVXFFHVLYH
DUH FD HIHFW VWLOLVWLF FUHDUHD XQRU ULPH UDUH úL D XQRU FDGHQ H VRQRUH QHRELúQXLWH
6WU EDWHP DPXUJXUL FX FULQL DOEL vQ JXU ÌQFKLGHP vQ QRL XQ VIkUúLW VXE DUPXU
/%ODJD
¾6WURIDHVWHRXQLWDWHFRPSR]L LRQDO VSHFLILF SRH]LHLFDUHFRLQFLGHGHRELFHLFX
XQ HQXQ SURSR]L LH VDX IUD] FDUDFWHUL]DW FD ÄVLVWHP vQFKLV FDUH SRVHG
FRHUHQ JUDPDWLFDO VHPDQWLF úLPHWULF ´'LF LRQDUGHúWLLQ HDOHOLPELL*UXSDMXO
GHYHUVXULFDUHDOF WXLHúWHRVWURI HVWHL]RODWJUDILFSULQVSD LHUHEODQFXUL
¾1XP UXO YHUVXULORU GLQWUR VWURI HVWH YDULDELO vQFHSkQG FX VWURIH GLQWUXQ VLQJXU
YHUV PRQRVWLK úL DMXQJkQG SkQ OD VWDQ H GH GRX ]HFL GH YHUVXUL VSHFLILF
5HQDúWHULL LWDOLHQH 6WURIHOH PDL IUHFYHQW XWLOL]DWH VXQW GLVWLK GRX YHUVXUL WHU LQD
WUHLYHUVXULFDWUHQXOSDWUXYHUVXULFYLQDULDFLQFLYHUVXULVWURIHOHDPSOHVH[WLQD±
úDVH YHUVXUL± VHSWLPD ±úDSWH YHUVXUL± RFWDYD ±RSW YHUVXUL± QRQD ±QRX YHUVXUL±
GHFLPD±]HFHVXQWPDLSX LQIRORVLWH
¾6WURID VDILF 6DSSKR SRHWD GLQ /HVERV XWLOL]DW vQ HPLQHVFLDQD 2G vQ PHWUX
DQWLF HVWH DOF WXLW GLQ WUHL YHUVXUL OXQJL VLODEH ± HQGHFDVLODE úL XQ YHUV ILQDO
VFXUWVLODEH±YHUVXODGRQLFDGRQHXSHQWDPHWUX
¾'LVFXUVXOSRHWLFPRGHUQVHDOF WXLHúWHIUHFYHQWGLQVWURIHLQHJDOHFDUHPDUFKHD]
DVWIHO VHFYHQ HOH SRHWLFH GH OXQJLPL GLIHULWH VDX FD SRH]LH DVWURILF GLVFXUV
FRQWLQXX
),*85,'(67,/ù,352&('((67,/,67,&(
)LJXULOH GH VWLO úL SURFHGHHOH VWLOLVWLFH VXQW FRQVLGHUDWH VXEVWDQ D YLH D
OLPEDMXOXL DUWLVWLF GHVHPQkQG PRGDOLW LOH SULQ FDUH VH PRGLILF H[SUHVLY VDX VH
vPERJ HúWH VHQVXO XQXL FXYkQW RUL VH SURGXFH R DEDWHUH GH OD R FRQVWUXF LH
JUDPDWLFDO X]XDO SHQWUX D FUHD LPDJLQHD DUWLVWLF 7UDQVIRUPDUHD FXYLQWHORU
XWLOLWDUHGLQOLPEDMXOFRPXQQHXWUHGLQSXQFWGHYHGHUHH[SUHVLYvQVHPQDUWLVWLFHVWH
GHWHUPLQDW GH FRQWH[WXO VWLOLVWLF úL GH LQWHQ LRQDOLWDWHD VFULLWRUXOXL PRGLILFDUHD
H[SUHVLY SUHVXSXQH XQ SURFHV GH UHVHPDQWL]DUH GH VHPQLILFDUH úL GH VLPEROL]DUH
FDUH JHQHUHD] PHWDEROHOH Ä9RP QXPL PHWDERO RULFH IHO GH VFKLPEDUH D XQXL
DVSHFWRDUHFDUHDOOLPEDMXOXL>@9RPGLVWLQJHGRX PDULIDPLOLLGHRSHUD LLUHWRULFH
RSHUD LLOH VXEVWDQ LDOH úL RSHUD LLOH UHOD LRQDOH SULPHOH DOWHUkQG VXEVWDQ D vQV úL D
XQLW LORU DVXSUD F URUD VH H[HUFLW FHOHODOWH P UJLQLQGXVH V PRGLILFH UHOD LLOH GH
SR]L LHFDUHH[LVW vQWUHDFHVWHXQLW L´*UXSXO 5HWRULF JHQHUDO
)LJXULGHVXQHWGHQLYHOIRQHWLFPHWDSODVPH
)LJXU GHVWLOGHQLYHOIRQHWLFFRQVWkQGvQVHOHFWDUHDFXYLQWHORUvQFDUHVH
DOLWHUD LHúL UHSHW XQVXQHWRDO WXUDUHGHVXQHWH
DVRQDQ DOLWHUD LD±UHSHWDUHDFRQVRDQHORU3ULQYXOWXULYkQWXOYLXYXLDY
DVRQDQ D±UHSHWDUHDYRFDOHORU$UJLQWHSHDSHúLDXUvQDHUDH
)LJXU GH VWLO GH QLYHO IRQHWLF FRQVWkQG vQ XWLOL]DUHD FXYLQWHORU FDUH
RQRPDWRSHH VXJHUHD] VXQHWH]JRPRWHGLQQDWXU SULQFKLDUFRUSXOORUVRQRUYkMkLQG
FDYLMHOLDúLFDSOHVQHWXOGHSORDLH
)LJXULGHFRQVWUXF LHGHQLYHOVLQWDFWLFPHWDWD[H
)LJXU GH VWLO GH QLYHO VLQWDFWLF FDUH FRQVW vQ PRGLILFDUHD H[SUHVLY D
LQYHUVLXQH
WRSLFLLRELúQXLWHvQSURSR]L LHVDXvQIUD] vQPkQGUXOvQWXQHULF
)LJXU GHVWLOGHQLYHOVLQWDFWLFFHFRQVW vQUHLWHUDUHDXQXLWHUPHQVDXD
XQHLVLQWDJPHvQVFRSH[SUHVLY
x VLPSO YLQHYLQHYLQHFDOF WRWXOvQSLFLRDUH
x DQDIRU ODvQFHSXWXOXQHLXQLW LSUR]RGLFHYHUVXULVWURIHùLWRWQXVH
DUDW FHWDWHDSUHDVIkQW ùLWRW«FRQVWUXF LDDQDIRULF GLQùLGDF «
x HSLIRU ODVIkUúLWXOXQHLXQLW LSUR]RGLFH«GHSOXPE«GHSOXPE
x DQDGLSOR] ODvQFHSXWúLODVIkUúLWGHYHUVODvQFHSXWXOXQXLYHUVúLvQ
UHSHWL LH
ILQDOXOYHUVXOXLXUP WRU0HUHXVHYRUWRWEDWHWXYHLGRUPLPHUHX8QFHU
GHVWHOHGHGHVXEWGHDVXSUDLFHUGHVWHOH
x HSDQDGLSOR] ± OD VIkUúLWXO XQXL YHUVVWURIH úL OD vQFHSXWXO YHUVXOXL
XUP WRU DO VWURIHL XUP WRDUH ùL WRW QX VHDUDW FHWDWHD GLQ YLVH
&HWDWHDGLQYLVHGHSDUWHHvQF «
x FKLDVP UHSHWDUHD D GRL WHUPHQL FX VFKLPEDUHD RUGLQLL &D YLVXO XQHL
XPEUHúLXPEUDXQXLYLV)HPHLHvQWUHVWHOHúLVWHDvQWUHIHPHL
)LJXU GH VWLO GH QLYHO VLQWDFWLF FDUH FRQVW vQ UHDOL]DUHD XQHL FRRUGRQ UL
HQXPHUD LH
VLQWDFWLFHvQVFRSH[SUHVLY& FLHXLXEHVFúLIORULúLRFKLúLEX]HúLPRUPLQWH
)LJXU GHFRQVWUXF LHFDUHFRQVW vQWUHFHUHDWUHSWDW GHODRLGHHODDOWD
SHQWUXDQXD DH[SULPDUHD
x JUDGD LH DVFHQGHQW >FOLPD[@ R VHWH HUD GH S FDWH GH GRUXUL GH
JUDGD LH
DYkQWXULGHSDWLPLRVHWHGHOXPHGHVRDUH
x JUDGD LHGHVFHQGHQW >DQWLFOLPD[@>«@úLDPHDFkQWDUH6DvQ VSULW
VDDGkQFLWVDVWLQV
)LJXU GH VWLO GH QLYHO VLQWDFWLF FDUH FRQVW vQ PRGLILFDUHD DIHFWLY D
GLVORFDUH WRSLFLL RELúQXLWH vQ SURSR]L LH VDX vQ IUD] JHQHUkQG DPELJXL]DUHD úL
VLQWDFWLF LPSOLFLW VSRULUHD H[SUHVLYLW LL WH[WXOXL /DFXO FRGULORU DOEDVWUX 3 V UL FD
vQJHULGHDS S V ULGHDS
3URFHGHX OLYUHVF ILJXU GH QLYHO VLQWDFWLF SULQ FDUH VH vQWUHUXSH
DQDFROXW FRQWLQXLWDWHDVLQWDFWLF vQSURSR]L LHVDXvQIUD] 7XUPDYLVXULORUPHOHHX
OHSDVFFDRLGHDXU
)LJXULVHPDQWLFHGHQLYHOOH[LFRVHPDQWLFPHWDVHPHPH
)LJXU GHVWLOGHQLYHOVLQWDFWLFúLVHPDQWLFFRQVWkQGvQDO WXUDUHDXQXL
GHWHUPLQDQW H[SUHVLY SH OkQJ XQ VXEVWDQWLY VDX YHUE GHWHUPLQDQW FH
VFRDWHvQHYLGHQ RvQVXúLUHQHRELúQXLW DRELHFWXOXLDF LXQLL
x HSLWHWRUQDQWGHPDUHJHQHUDOLWDWHSU SDVWLDP UHD
x HSLWHW FURPDWLF &X R ]DOH DUJLQWLH VH vPEUDF PkQGUD DU OHRDLF
DU PLH
HSLWHW
x HSLWHWPHWDIRULFS GXUHGHDUJLQWS GXUHGHDUDP
x HSLWHW SHUVRQLILFDWRU $XG PDWHULD SOkQJkQG «FRGUXOXL E WXW GH
JkQGXUL«
x HSLWHWKLSHUEROLF*LJDQWLF SRDUWRFXSRO SHIUXQWH
x HSLWHWPRUDODSUHFLDWLYFDOLILFDWLYVXUkVXLFDOG
x HSLWHWVLQHVWH]LF3ULP YDU «2SLFWXU SDUIXPDW FXYLEU ULGHYLROHW
)LJXU GHVWLOGHQLYHOVLQWDFWLFúLVHPDQWLFFHFRQVW vQDO WXUDUHDDGRL
WHUPHQL FRQFUH L VDX DEVWUDF L SH ED]D XQXL UDSRUW GH DVHP QDUH
FRPSDUD LH
HOHPHQWGHUHOD LHFDSUHFXPDVHPHQLvQWRFPDLFDHWF«,HVHOXQDFD
RYDWU GHMHUDWLF
)LJXU GH VWLO FRPSOH[ FRQVWkQG vQ XWLOL]DUHD QXPHOXL XQXL RELHFW
FRQFUHWVSUHDH[SULPDRLGHHDEVWUDFW vQWHPHLXOXQHLDQDORJLLDOXQXL
VLPERO SURFHVDFFHQWXDWGHVHPQLILFDUHVHRE LQHSULQGH]YROWDUHDXQHLPHWDIRUH
VDX SULQ UHFXUHQ D XQHL LPDJLQL (X SRUW vQ PLQH QRDSWHD úLQ EH]QD HL
DGkQF 0LHVXIOHWXOXQYXOWXUvQO Q XLWGHRVWkQF
)LJXU GHVWLOGHQLYHOVHPDQWLFSULQFDUHVHVXEVWLWXLHXQWHUPHQSURSULX
FXXQXOLPSURSULXGDUH[SUHVLYSRHWLFGHRELFHLSHED]DXQHLUHOD LLORJLFH
GHDVHP QDUHPHWDIRUDSODVWLFL]DQW FkQGvQWUHWHUPHQXOSURSULXúLFHO
PHWDIRULF QX H[LVW R DQDORJLH R FRPSDUD LH LPSOLFLW PHWDIRU
UHYHODWRULHFRURODGHPLQXQLDOXPLL
x PHWDIRUD H[SOLFLW ÄLQ SUDHVHQWLD´ SUHVXSXQH SUH]HQ D DPELORU
PHWDIRU
WHUPHQL QX úL D HOHPHQWXOXL GH OHJ WXU R VWUXFWXU GH WLS DSR]L LRQDO
³/HRDLF WkQ U LXELUHD´
x PHWDIRUD vQFKLV WRWDO HVWH JHQHUDW SULQWUXQ SURFHV GH PD[LP
DPELJXL]DUH D UHOD LHL GLQWUH FXYkQWXO PHWDIRULF úL VHPQLILFD LD FH SRDWH IL
GRDU DSUR[LPDW 'DU SLDWUDQ UXJ FLXQH D KXPHL GHVSXLDUH ùL XQGD
ORJRGLW VXEFHUYRUVSXQHFXP"
)LJXU GHVWLOGHQLYHOVHPDQWLFSULQFDUHVHVXEVWLWXLHXQWHUPHQSURSULX
FXXQWHUPHQLPSURSULXGDUH[SUHVLYSRHWLFSHED]DXQHLUHOD LLORJLFHGH
RUGLQ FDOLWDWLY WHPSRUDO VSD LDO FDX]DO FDX] HIHFW HIHFW FDX]
PHWRQLPLH DXWRU RSHU RELHFWXO FDUH FRQ LQH FRQ LQXW ORFXO GH SURYHQLHQ
SURGXVXOVHQWLPHQWXOvQVXúLUHDQXPHOHRUJDQXOXLS U LLFRUSXOXLFXFDUH
VHDVRFLD] RELHFWXOVLPEROXO
'LQWUXQERORYDQFRERDU SDVXOW XGHGRPQLúRDU
)LJXU GHVWLOGHQLYHOVHPDQWLFSULQFDUHVHVXEVWLWXLHXQWHUPHQSURSULX
FXXQWHUPHQLPSURSULXGDUH[SUHVLYSRHWLFSHED]DXQHLUHOD LLGHRUGLQ
VLQHFGRF FDQWLWDWLYVLQJXODUSOXUDOSOXUDOVLQJXODUJHQVSHFLHSDUWHvQWUHJHWF
& FL WRDW IORDUHDY FXQRDúWHùLWRDW IUXQ]DHLY úWLHPLLGHFDSHWH
SOHWRDVH
)LJXU GH VWLO GH QLYHO VHPDQWLF FH FRQVW vQ DO WXUDUHD D GRL WHUPHQL
R[LPRURQ FDUHvQOLPEDMXOFRPXQVHH[FOXGDYkQGVHQVXULRSXVH
«VXIHULQ WXGXUHURVGHGXOFH«QHJXULDOEHVWU OXFLWH
)LJXU GH VWLO GH QLYHO VHPDQWLF SULQ FDUH FRQVWUXF LD RELúQXLW GH
VXSHUODWLY VXSHUODWLY DEVROXW H vQORFXLW FX R H[SUHVLH LQHGLW IUHFYHQW SULQWUR
VWLOLVWLF SHULIUD] PHWDIRULF
«vQRFKLLLXFLJ WRUGHGXOFL$úDVGHQHJULRFKLLW LHUDIUXPRDV GHQHVSXV
)LJXU GH QLYHO VHPDQWLF FDUH HYLGHQ LD] R LGHH DSDUHQW DEVXUG GDU
SDUDGR[ FDUH VH vQFDUF GH R VHPQLILFD LH ORJLF vQ FRQWH[W 'XOFL FXYLQWH QH
Q HOHVHvQV SOLQHGHQ HOHV(PLQHVFXQDH[LVWDW
)LJXU GH VWLO D DPELJXLW LL SULQ FDUH VH DWHQXHD] R H[SUHVLH GXU
HXIHPLVP VXEVWLWXLW FXRDOWDPDLSX LQGLUHFW (UDFDOXOGLQSRYHVWHvQDLQWHGHD
PkQFDWLSVLDFXMDU8FLJ OWRDFD
)LJXU GH VWLO FX FDUDFWHU LURQLF FRQVWkQG vQ XWLOL]DUHD XQXL FXYkQW D
DQWLIUD] XQHL ORFX LXQL FX XQ VHQV RSXV FHOXL GHQRWDWLY %D V YH]L SRVWHULWDWHD
HVWHvQF úLPDLGUHDSW «
)LJXULGHJkQGLUHODQLYHOXOYL]LXQLLDUWLVWLFHPHWDORJLVPH
3URFHGHX VWLOLVWLF úL ILJXU GH QLYHO VHPDQWLF SULQ FDUH VH FUHHD] R
RSR]L LH VWLOLVWLF vQWUH GRX FXYLQWH LGHL FRQFHSWH LPDJLQL ÄSHUVRQDMH´
DQWLWH] OLULFHÌQJHUúLGHPRQ7XYHQHDLGHVXVHXYHQHDPGHMRV
7XYHQHDLGLQYLH LHXYHQHDPGLQPRU L
x DQWLWH]HURPDQWLFHUHDOLGHDOWHOXULFFHOHVWHIHPHUHWHUQYLD PRDUWHHWF
)LJXU VWLOLVWLF GH JkQGLUH FH FRQVW vQ H[DJHUDUHD GLPHQVLXQLORU D
KLSHUERO SURSRU LLORUUHDOHDOHXQXLRELHFWIHQRPHQHWFFXVFRSXOVSRULULLH[SUHVLYLW LL
*LJDQWLF SRDUWRFXSRO SHIUXQWHSR L]LGLROXPHQWUHDJ SR LVRVIDUHPL«
)LJXU VWLOLVWLF GH JkQGLUH FH FRQVW vQ GLPLQXDUHD H[DJHUDW D
GLPHQVLXQLORU D SURSRU LLORU UHDOH DOH XQXL RELHFW IHQRPHQ HWF FX VFRSXO
OLWRW
VSRULULLH[SUHVLYLW LL
ROXPHPLF GHVHP VXU FXFRWXOPLFURVFRSLFHSRSRDUH
)LJXU VWLOLVWLF GH JkQGLUH SULQ FDUH VH DWULEXLH XQRU RELHFWH YLHW L
FRQFHSWH DEVWUDFWH HWF FDUDFWHULVWLFL VDX FRPSRUWDPHQW úL OLPEDM
SHUVRQLILFDUH
RPHQHVF
DXGPDWHULDSOkQJkQGEOkQGDOXQ /XQ WXVW SkQDP ULL
3URFHGHX VWLOLVWLF FRPSOH[ FDUH DSHOHD] OD R VXLW GH VLPEROXUL
PHWDIRUHFRPSDUD LLSHUVRQLILF ULVSUHDIRUPDRLPDJLQHXQLWDU SULQFDUH
VFULLWRUXO FRPXQLF R YL]LXQH SURSULH GHVSUH OXPH vQ HOHVXUL FRQFHSWH
DOHJRULH H[LVWHQ LDOHSURIXQGH
x QLYHOXOILJXUDWLYHGXEODWGHXQQLYHOGHVHPQLILFDUHVXJHUDWSHED]DXQHL
DQDORJLL
x XWLOL]DW vQIDEXOHvQSRHPHDOHJRULFHHWF
)LJXULUHWRULFHODQLYHOXOGLVFXUVXOXLGHDGUHVDUH
)LJXU GHVWLOUHWRULF XWLOL]DW vQVFRSH[SUHVLYFDUHFRQVW vQDGUHVDUHD
LQYRFD LH F WUH XQ SHUVRQDM LPDJLQDU RUL UHDO GDU DEVHQW F WUH R HQWLWDWH DEVWUDFW
UHWRULF SHUVRQLILFDW HWF
«6XIHULQ WXGXUHURVGHGXOFH³&XPQXYLLWX HSHúGRDPQH«"
)LJXU UHWRULF GH DGUHVDUH FRQVWkQG vQ vQWUHUXSHUHD QHDúWHSWDW D
GLVFXUVXOXL SULQ LQWHUSHODUHD XQXL LQWHUORFXWRU VLPEROLF XQHRUL SH XQ WRQ
DSRVWURI
VDUFDVWLF LURQLF DJUHVLY 8UD VWUkQVH UDPXUL QHJUH $X]L IUHDP WXO
vQWXQHULFXOXLVSRULQGSULHWHQH"
)LJXU UHWRULF GH VWLO FH FRQVW vQ IRUPXODUHD XQHL vQWUHE UL FRQ LQkQG vQ
LQWHURJD LH
VLQHU VSXQVXOVDXODFDUHQXVHDúWHDSW U VSXQVXWLOL]DW vQVFRSH[SUHVLY
UHWRULF
$VWIHOGHQRDSWHERJDW FLQHSHHDQXDUGDYLD DOXLWRDW "
)LJXU UHWRULF SULQ FDUH VH H[SULP vQ WRQDOLW L GH EOHVWHP GRULQ D
LPSUHFD LH SHGHSVLULL XQHL SHUVRDQH 2ULXQGH YHL PHUJH V FDOFL R WLUDQH6 FDOFL
SHXQFDGDYUXúLQYLVX LV OYH]L
)LJXU GHVWLOFHFRQVW vQXWLOL]DUHDXQXLFXYkQWMLJQLWRUDXQHLYLROHQ H
GHOLPEDM
LQYHFWLY
3UHDI FXU LQHDPXOQRVWUXGHUXúLQHúLRFDU 3UHDYD LE WXWMRFGHOLPE
GHVWU EXQLGHRELFHL&DV QXVDUDWHRGDW FHVXQWH L±QLúWHPLúHL
02'(/'($1$/,= 67,/,67,&
3RUWUHWXODUWLVWXOXL
GH0DULQ6RUHVFX
$PvQF O DWFXSDQWRILLPHL
'UXPXO
&XSDQWDORQLLDPvPEU FDWFRSDFLL
3kQ ODIUXQ]H
+DLQDLDPSXVRYkQWXOXL
3HXPHUL
3ULPXOXLQRUFDUHPLDLHüLWvQFDOH
,DPSXVvQFDS
3 O ULDPHDYHFKH
$SRLPDPGDWvQDSRL
ÍQPRDUWH
6 P SULYHVF
$XWRSRUWUHWXO
ÍPLUHXüLVHGHPLQXQH
$VHP QDUHDHUDDWkWGHSHUIHFW
ÍQFkWXLWkQGV P LVF OHVF
2DPHQLLDXVFULVHLVLQJXUL
1XPHOHPHX
3HRSLDWU
3RH]LDOXL0DULQ6RUHVFXHVWHRDUW SRHWLF vQFDUHUDSRUWXOGLQWUHHXOFUHDWRUúL
XQLYHUV HVWH VXUSULQV vQWUR PDQLHU LQVROLW 7HPD GHVWLQXOXL DUWLVWXOXL FHD D
H[LVWHQ HL VDOH FUHDWRDUH úL WHPD PRU LL DX FD VXSRUW LPDJLVWLF PRWLYXO OLWHUDU DO
DXWRSRUWUHWXOXLFHODOGUXPXOXLHWF
6XLWD GH LPDJLQL GLQ SULPD VWURI VXJHUHD] LGHHD F DUWLVWXO WUDQVILJXUHD]
UHDOLWDWHDQXDEVRUELQGRvQVLQHúLvQRSHUDVDFLSURLHFWkQGXVHFRVPLFG UXLQGXVH
OXPLL 5HSHWkQG DFWXO GHPLXUJLF SRHWXO UHFUHHD] OXPHD ÄGXS FKLSXO úL
DVHP QDUHD VD´ ,GHQWLILFDUHD GLQWUH FUHDWRU úL XQLYHUVXO FUHDW VH UHDOL]HD] WUHSWDW
vQWUR PLúFDUH DVFHQVLRQDO H[SULPDW SULQ VXFFHVLXQHD GUXPXO FRSDFLL YkQWXO
QRUXOFDUHVXJHUHD] GHPDWHULDOL]DUHDJUDGDW WUDQVIHUXOGLQVSUHWHOXULFVSUHFHOHVW
GLQVSUH UHDO VSUH LPDJLQDU /D QLYHOXO H[SUHVLHL FHOH GRX SUH]HQ H FDUH WLQG V VH
DUPRQL]H]H HXXQLYHUV VXQW GHVHPQDWH SULQ GRX VHULL PHWRQLPLFH DOF WXLWH GXS
DFHHDúL OHJH D PLúF ULL ÄvQ VXV´ GUXPXO FRSDFLL YkQWXO QRUXO SDQWRILL PHL
SDQWDORQLL KDLQD S O ULD PHD $VWIHO FRPXQLFDUHD HX ± XQLYHUV VH UHDOL]HD]
VLPSDWHWLFXQLYHUVXOvQWUHJLPSUHJQDWFXLPDJLQHDVDFXOXFUXULOHFDUHvLÄvPEUDF ´
ILLQ DGHYHQLQGÄ3RUWUHWXODUWLVWXOXL´XQLFXOÄDXWRSRUWUHW´FDUHH[SULPkQGXOGHSOLQvL
YDIL[DQXPHOHÄSHRSLDWU ´
3ULQ FRQFHQWUDUHD HL H[WUHP FDUH FRQWUDVWHD] FX VWURIHOH SROLPRUIH WHU LQD
FRPXQLF XQD GLQWUH LGHLOH HVHQ LDOH DOH SRH]LHL H[SHULHQ D ÄPDULL WUHFHUL´ 0RDUWHD
FHOXLFDUHDGDWYHúPkQWGHFXYLQWHXQLYHUVXOXLHVWHLPDJLQDW FDVFLQGDUHDHXOXLvQ
ILLQ DSLHULWRDUHFDUHFRERDU vQPRDUWHúLGXEOXOV XHVWHWLFFDUHvQFUHPHQHúWHFDXQ
DXWRSRUWUHW vQ FUHD LH /D QLYHOXO H[SUHVLHL DFHDVW GHGXEODUH HVWH H[SULPDW SULQ
UHIOH[LYHOH ÄPDP GDW vQDSRL´ ÄV P SULYHVF´ FDUH vL FRQIHU HXOXL URVWLWRU VWDWXWXO
VLPXOWDQGHVXELHFWúLGHRELHFWDOFRQWHPSO ULL3HUVSHFWLYDGHWDúDW OXFLG DVXSUD
PRU LL HVWH FRQVWUXLW vQWUR H[SUHVLH SRHWLF GH R VLPSOLWDWH GHOLEHUDW vQ DFRUG FX
LGHHDGHLQWHJUDUHILUHDVF DVWLQJHULLvQWUHOHJLOHH[LVWHQ HL0HWDIRUDYHUEDO úLMRFXO
VXEWLO GH FXYLQWH GLQ YHUVXO Ä$SRL PDP GDW vQDSRL´ FUHHD] R DPELJXLWDWH VSHFLILF
GLVFXUVXOXL SRHWLF PRGHUQ SULQ VXSUDSXQHUHD VHQVXOXL XQLWDU DO ORFX LXQLL ÄD VH GD
vQDSRL´ ± D VH UHWUDJH úL D VHQVXOXL SULPDU DO ILHF UXL WHUPHQ 7HQVLXQHD OLULF VH
QDúWH DVWIHO vQWUH QLYHOXO SULP DO WH[WXOXL úL VWUDWXO GH DGkQFLPH GLQ FDUH U ]EDWH R
WULVWH HGLIX] úLRDFFHSWDUHVHQLQ DFRQGL LHLGHILLQ PXULWRDUH
$VRFLDWHVLPEROLVPXOXLPRU LLSULQUHOD LHPHWRQLPLF VHPQLILFD LLOHFRQWH[WXDOH
DOH FXYkQWXOXL ÄSLDWU ´ SRW IL FHD GH SLDWU IXQHUDU GH FUXFH ÌQ FRQWH[WXO VWLOLVWLF DO
DUWHLSRHWLFHVXEVWDQWLYXOSRDWHFRQRWDVWDWXLDvQFKLQDW DUWLVWXOXL&RQWH[WXOSRHWLFvQ
FDUHHVWHXWLOL]DWDGMHFWLYXOÄSHUIHFW´vLFRQIHU YDORDUHDXQXLVXSHUODWLYVWLOLVWLFGHúLvQ
OLPEDVWDQGDUGDGMHFWLYXOQXDUHJUDGHGHFRPSDUD LHH[SULPkQGVHPDQWLFJUDGXOFHO
PDLvQDOWDOFDOLW LL3ULQFRQVWUXF LDFRQVHFXWLY SUHFHGDW GHFRUHODWLYXOÄDWkWGH´VH
FUHHD] RILJXU DLQVLVWHQ HLFDUHUHOLHIHD] GHV YkUúLUHDFRQWRSLULLFXQDWXUD
0RGHUQLWDWHD SUR]RGLF D GLVFXUVXOXL SRHWLF HVWH HYLGHQW vQ XWLOL]DUHD YHUVXOXL
OLEHU P VXU YDULDELO vQWUH úL VLODEH DEVHQ D ULWPXOXL FODVLF úL D ULPHL úL D
VWURIHORULQHJDOH8QDOWDUJXPHQWvQVSULMLQXOPRGHUQLW LLWLSDUXOXLGHYHUVLILFD LHHVWH
SUH]HQ D LQJDPEDPHQWXOXL FDUH IUDJPHQWHD] GLVFXUVXO SRHWLF L]ROkQG vQ YHUVXUL
IRDUWHVFXUWHFXYLQWHFKHLHÄ$SRLPDPGDWvQDSRLÌQPRDUWH´
$OHJRULVPXO SRH]LHL OXL 0 6RUHVFX SRDWH IL PRWLYDW SULQ YDORDUHD ILJXUDWLY
PHWDIRULF D VHULHL GH LPDJLQL SULQ LQWHUPHGLXO F URUD VH VXJHUHD] H[LVWHQ D
DUWLVWXOXL (QXQ XULOH GLQ SULPD VWURI GH H[HPSOX Ä$P vQF O DW FX SDQWRILL PHL
'UXPXO´ DX XQ FRQ LQXW VHPDQWLF ILJXUDW GH WLSXO PHWDIRUHORU vQO Q XLWH DO
ÄPHWDIRUHLILODWH´FDUHvOVXEVWLWXLHSHFHOGHQRWDWLYH[SULPkQGLQGLUHFWLGHHDF HXO
FUHDWRU UHPRGHOHD] XQLYHUVXO ÄGXS FKLSXO úL DVHP QDUHD´ VD $OHJRULVPXO HVWH
GHILQLWúLSULQFDUDFWHUXOXQLWDUDOVXLWHLGHLPDJLQLPHWDIRULFHvQYLUWXWHDVHPQLILFD LHL
XQLFH ÌQ SRH]LD OXL 0 6RUHVFX WRDWH UHSUH]HQW ULOH VXQW FRQYHUJHQWH VXE VHPQXO
DFHOHLDúL LGHL SRHWLFH FUHD LD HFKLYDOHD] FX XQ DFW GHPLXUJLF FX R WUDQVILJXUDUH D
UHDOXOXLFDUHGHYLQHÄSRUWUHWXODUWLVWXOXL´
(9$/8$5(
7HPHSHQWUXFRORFYLXOGHODVIkUúLWXOVHPHVWUXOXL,
6WUXFWXUDUHDWH[WXOXLOLULF
6SHFLLDOHJHQXOXLOLULF
,PDJLQHDDUWLVWLF
(OHPHQWHGHYHUVLILFD LH
)LJXULGHVWLOúLSURFHGHHVWLOLVWLFH
1RW 6XELHFWHOH SHQWUX FRORFYLXO SULPXOXL VHPHVWUX YRU FRQ LQH R SUREOHP
WHRUHWLF GLQ WHPDWLFD PHQ LRQDW úL R DSOLFD LH SUDFWLF DQDOL]D VWLOLVWLF D XQXL
IUDJPHQWGHWH[WOLWHUDUODSULPDYHGHUH
Ä$OHJRULDFDILJXU GHH[SUHVLH>@FRQVW vQWURSURSR]L LHFXXQGXEOXVHQV±XQVHQVOLWHUDO
úLXQXOILJXUDWDIODWHvPSUHXQ SULQFDUHHVWHH[SULPDW RJkQGLUHVXEKDLQDDOWHLJkQGLULFDSDELO V
RIDF PDLVHQVLELO >@(DQXWUHEXLHFRQIXQGDW FXPHWDIRUDFRQWLQX VDXFXDOHJRULVPXOFDUHQX
QHRIHU QLFLRGDW GHFkWXQVLQJXUVHQVVHQVXOILJXUDW´3)RQWDQLHU)LJXULOHOLPEDMXOXL
99$/(1é(67,/,67,&($/(7(;78/8,1$5$7,9
(/(0(17('(6758&785 ù,'(&2032=, ,(
Ì17(;7(/(1$5$7,9(
*(18/(3,&JUHSRVHSLNRVODWHSLFXV±FXYkQWVSXQHUHGLVFXUVSRYHVWLUH
vQVXPHD] FODVHGHRSHUHFDUHDSHOHD] ODQDUD LXQHFDPRGSULQFLSDOGHH[SXQHUH
&RQFHSWXO GH 1$5$ ,81( IU QDUUDWLRQ ODW QDUUDWLR vQVHDPQ SRYHVWLUH
LVWRULVLUH GLHJH] GHVHPQHD] XQ PRG GH H[SXQHUH FDUDFWHULVWLF JHQXOXL HSLF
FRQVWkQG vQ UHODWDUHD GLQ SHUVSHFWLYD XQXL XQRU QDUDWRUL D XQRU vQWkPSO UL
LQVSLUDWH GLQ UHDOLWDWH VDX LPDJLQDUH OD FDUH SDUWLFLS SHUVRQDMH SULQ H[WHQVLH
QXPHúWHRFUHD LHOLWHUDU FDUHDSDU LQHJHQXOXLHSLFWH[WOLWHUDUHSLF
7H[WXO HSLF ÄSUH]HQWDUH PHGLDW D XQRU HYHQLPHQWH´ ( 0 )RUVWHU VH
VWUXFWXUHD] SHGRX QLYHOXUL
$ LVWRULD IDEXOD VXELHFWXO HVWH VWUDWXO HYHQLPHQWHORU SRYHVWLWH UHDOH
SRYHVWLUHIDFWXDO VDXILF LRQDOHSRYHVWLUHGHILF LXQHÄXQLYHUVXOSRYHVWLW´FHHDFH
VHSRYHVWHúWHVHRUJDQL]HD] vQWURVHULHHYHQLPHQ LDO vQFDUHvQWkPSO ULOHUHODWDWH
VXQW GLVSXVH vQWUR VXFFHVLXQH WHPSRUDO ( 0 )RUVWHU vQ SRYHVWLUHD IDFWXDO VH
DGDXJ úL HYHQLPHQWHOH GHQRWDWH DGLF XQLYHUVXO FLWDW vQ SRYHVWLUHD GH ILF LXQH
HYHQLPHQWHOH VXQW R SURLHF LH PHQWDO LPDJLQDU I U HIHFW GH GHQRWDUH D UHDOXOXL
ÄXQLYHUVXOFLWDW´HRDVHU LXQHVLPXODW
% LVWRULVLUH GLVFXUV HQXQ DUH IDEXOD LH PRGXO FXP VH QDUHD] DUH vQ
YHGHUH GLVFXUVXO SULQ FDUH VH SRYHVWHúWH VWUXFWXULOH WH[WXDOH XQLYHUVXO SRYHVWLULL
ÄGLVFXUVXO QDUDWLY´ ± * *HQHWWH vQVXPkQG GLVFXUVXO QDUDWRUXOXL úL GLVFXUVXO
SHUVRQDMHORU HVWH DOF WXLW GLQ GRX VWUDWXUL VWLOLVWLFH SODQXO QDUDWRUXOXL úL SODQXO
QDUD LXQLL vQ SODQXO QDUD LXQLL VXELHFWXO H RUJDQL]DW SH R VFKHP FRPSR]L LRQDO
FODVLF PRPHQWHOH VXELHFWXOXL H[SR]L LXQHD LQWULJD GHVI úXUDUHD DF LXQLL SXQFWXO
FXOPLQDQWGH]QRG PkQWXO
7LSRORJLDQDUD LXQLLDUHvQYHGHUHPDLPXOWHFULWHULL
DFULWHULXOUHOD LHLGLQWUHUHDOLWDWHDRELHFWLY úLUHDOLWDWHDDUWLVWLF
SRYHVWLUHD IDFWXDO HVWH R QDUD LXQH GH HYHQLPHQWH UHDOH SUR]D
PHPRULDOLVWLF
SRYHVWLUHD GH ILF LXQH ± QDUD LXQH GH HYHQLPHQWH ILFWLYH ± WUDQVILJXUHD]
UHDOXO VDX LPDJLQHD] ÄOXPL SRVLELOH´ FUHkQG XQ XQLYHUVXO HSLF ILF LRQDO
SUR]DVFXUW URPDQHOH
EFULWHULXOWLSXOXLGHHYHQLPHQWHQDUDWH
QDUD LXQH GH HYHQLPHQWH H[WHULRDUH ÄHSLFXO SXU´ $ 0DULQR ÄURPDQ GH
FUHD LH´FXPvOQXPHúWHFULWLFXO*DUDEHW,EU LOHDQX
QDUD LXQH GH HYHQLPHQWH LQWHULRDUH HSLFXO DQDOLWLF SUR]D SVLKRORJLF
ÄURPDQGHDQDOL] ´±*,EU LOHDQX
FFULWHULXOSULYLQGUHOD LDGLQWUHQDUDWRUúLXQLYHUVXOQDUD LXQLL
QDUD LXQHD KHWHURGLHJHWLF KHWHUR ± GLIHULW GLHJHVLV ± PRGXO QDUDWLY GH
H[SXQHUH HVWH GLVFXUVXO HSLF vQ FDUH QDUDWRUXO VH VLWXHD] vQ DIDUD
XQLYHUVXOXL SRYHVWLW QDUDWRU H[WUDGLHJHWLF QDUDUHD VH IDFH OD SHUVRDQD D
,,,D SODQXO QDUDWRUXOXL HVWH GLIHULW GH SODQXO QDUD LXQLL QDUDWRUXO QX VH
SURLHFWHD] vQ GLVFXUV SULQ LQGLFL WH[WXDOL HVWH QDUDWRU DQRQLP VDX QDUDWRU
UHSUH]HQWDELORELHFWLYVDXVXELHFWLYSHUVSHFWLYDQDUDWLY HVWHRPQLVFLHQW
IRFDOL]DUH]HURVDXH[WHUQ
QDUD LXQHD KRPRGLHJHWLF KRPR ± OD IHO QXPHúWH FUHD LD HSLF vQ FDUH
QDUDWRUXOVHVLWXHD] vQLQWHULRUXOXQLYHUVXOXLSRYHVWLWQDUDWRULQWUDGLHJHWLF
QDUDUHD VH IDFH OD SHUVRDQD , SODQXO QDUDWRUXOXL VH VXSUDSXQH SODQXOXL
QDUD LXQLL QDUDWRUXO VH SURLHFWHD] vQ GLVFXUV SULQ LQGLFL WH[WXDOL ILLQG R
SUH]HQ FRQFUHW vQVSD LXOGLHJHWLFSHUVRQDMXOQDUDWRUSRDWHILSURWDJRQLVW
VDX PDUWRU DO HYHQLPHQWHORU UHODWDWH SRDWH DS UHD vQ LSRVWD]D QDUDWRUXOXL
DXFWRULDO RUL QXPDL FD PHVDJHU FDUH UHSRYHVWHúWH HYHQLPHQWH DX]LWH
SHUVSHFWLYDQDUDWLY HVWHvQDFHVWFD]LQWHUQ úLSXWHUQLFPDUFDW VXELHFWLY
QDUD LXQHD VXSUDHWDMDW SROLIRQLF DVRFLD] FHOH GRX PRGHOH GLHJHWLFH
DOWHUQkQG SHUVRDQD , QDUDWLY GLVFXUVXO SHUVRQDMXOXL QDUDWRU FX SHUVRDQD D
,,,D QDUDWLY GLVFXUVXO QDUDWRUXOXL H[WUDGLHJHWLF SHUVSHFWLYD QDUDWLY LQWHUQ
úLFHDH[WHUQ RPQLVFLHQW YL]LXQHDVXELHFWLY DOWHUQkQGFXFHDRELHFWLY
3DUWLFXODULW LOHFRPSR]L LHLILHF UXLWH[WQDUDWLYVXQWJHQHUDWHGHFRPELQDUHD
IDFWRULORU HVHQ LDOL DL ÄVLWXD LHL QDUDWLYH´ SHUVRDQD QDUDWLY SHUVSHFWLYD GLQ FDUH VH
IDFHQDUDUHDúLSHUVSHFWLYDWHPSRUDO RUGLQHDQDUDWLY úLPRGDOLW LOHQDUDWLYHDSXG
**HQHWWH
3HUVRDQD QDUDWLY HVWH XQ FRQVWUXFW VSHFLILF JHQXOXL HSLF GHVHPQkQG ÄR
WUDQVSXQHUH D FDWHJRULHL JUDPDWLFDOH D SHUVRDQHL vQ VWUXFWXUD QDUD LHL´ 'LF LRQDU GH
úWLLQ H DOH OLPELL 3HUVRDQD JUDPDWLFDO FDUH SUHGRPLQ vQ UHGDFWDUHD WH[WXOXL HVWH
GHWHUPLQDW GHWLSXOGHQDUDWRUODW1DUUDWRU±SRYHVWLWRUSHQWUXFDUHRSWHD] VFULLWRUXO
7,32/2*,$ù,)81& ,,/(1$5$7258/8,
1$5$7258/ HVWH SULQFLSDOD LQVWDQ vQ FRPXQLFDUHD QDUDWLY ÄYRFHD´ FDUH
UHODWHD] HPL WRUXOVHULHLGHHYHQLPHQWHFDUHDOF WXLHVFVXELHFWXORSHUHLHSLFH&D
LQVWDQ LQWHUPHGLDU vQWUH DXWRUXO DEVWUDFW OXPHD QDUDW úL FLWLWRUXO DEVWUDFW
QDUDWRUXOHVWHRÄILLQ GHKkUWLH´ÄSHUVRDQ ILFWLY ´GLVWLQFW GHDXWRUXOFRQFUHW
)81& ,,/(1$5$7258/8,
IXQF LD QDUDWLY 'ROHåHO IXQF LD GH UHSUH]HQWDUH FRQVW vQ UHODWDUHD
HYHQLPHQWHORU
IXQF LDGHUHJLH'ROHåHOIXQF LDGHFRQWURODUHvQYHGHUHUROXOGHGLULMDUHD
ÄLQWU ULL vQ VFHQ ´ D SHUVRQDMHORU úL FDSDFLWDWHD GH D FLWD GLVFXUVXOHURLORUvQSURSULXO
GLVFXUV VWLOXO LQGLUHFW VHPQDODW SULQ YHUEH GLFHQGL VHQWHQGL ± D ]LFH D VSXQH D
VXVSLQDDVWULJDHWF
IXQF LD GH LQWHUSUHWDUH QX HVWH REOLJDWRULH FD SULPHOH GRX FRQVW vQ
DVXPDUHDXQXLGLVFXUVHYDOXDWLYúLHPRWLYFDUHUHOLHIHD] RSHUVSHFWLY VXELHFWLY R
LPSOLFDUHDIHFWLY
$1$5$725(;75$',(*(7,&+(7(52',(*(7,&QXHPDUFDWSULQLQGLFLWH[WXDOL
QDUDWRU DQRQLP ± UHODWDUH RELHFWLY OD SHUVRDQD D ,,,D UHSUH]LQW R
LQVWDQ QDUDWLY VXSUDLQGLYLGXDO LQGLFLWH[WXDOLHQXQ XULODSHUVRDQDD,,,D
RELHFWLYH QHXWUH GLQ SXQFW GH YHGHUH DIHFWLY GH RELFHL HVWH DVRFLDW
LSRVWD]HLGHQDUDWRURELHFWLYDOF UXLGLVFXUVHVWHLPSHUVRQDO
QDUDWRU UHSUH]HQWDELO HVWH VXELHFWLY H[SULPkQG GLUHFW VDX LQGLUHFW
DVHU LXQLDOHDXWRUXOXLLQWHUSUHWHD] FDOLILF VDXFRPHQWHD] HYHQLPHQWHOH
SHUVRQDMHOH GLQWUR SHUVSHFWLY SHUVRQDOL]DW DVXPkQGXúL R DWLWXGLQH
SDUWLFLSDWLY LQGLFLWH[WXDOLHQXQ XULODSHUVRDQDD,,,DPDUFDWHVXELHFWLYúL
VDXDIHFWLY
% 1$5$725 ,175$',(*(7,& +202',(*(7,& HVWH SURLHFWDW vQ WH[W FD HX
QDUDWRUSULQLQGLFLDLSHUVRDQHL,3RDWHIL
QDUDWRUDXFWRULDO±vúLDVXP H[SOLFLWUROXOGHDXWRUDOWH[WXOXL
SHUVRQDMQDUDWRU ± vúL DVXP XQ GXEOX URO HX QDUDWRU QDUDWRU
DXWRGLHJHWLFúLDFWDQWSURWDJRQLVWLQGLFLWH[WXDOLSHUVRDQD,P UFLOH[LFR
VHPDQWLFHDOHLPSOLF ULLVXELHFWLYHúLDIHFWLYH
QDUDWRUPDUWRU ± MRDF UROXO HXOXL QDUDWRU úL URO GH REVHUYDWRU DO OXPLL
QDUDWHLQGLFLWH[WXDOLVHFYHQ HODSHUVRDQD,DOWHUQkQGFXQDUDUHDODSHUV
DD,,,DLQGLFLWH[WXDOLDLVXELHFWLYLW LL
QDUDWRUPHVDJHU ± FX URO GH WUDQVPL WRU DO XQHL vQWkPSO UL ÄDX]LWH´ VH
SURLHFWHD] vQ SODQ VHFXQG FD HX QDUDWRU LQGLFL WH[WXDOL SUHGRPLQ
SHUVRDQDD,,,DVHFYHQ LDODSDUúLLQGLFLDLSHUVRDQHL,
3(563(&7,9$1$5$7,9
3HUVSHFWLYDQDUDWLY HVWHXQFRQFHSWSULQFDUHVHGHILQHúWHSXQFWXOGHYHGHUH
DOQDUDWRUXOXLvQUDSRUWFXXQLYHUVXOGLHJHWLFFXSHUVRQDMHOHFDUHHYROXHD] vQVSD LXO
ILF LXQLL DUWLVWLFH 0RGHOXO QDUDWLY WUDGL LRQDO DYHD FD SUH]HQ GRPLQDQW QDUDWRUXO
RPQLVFLHQW GH OD &LRFRLL YHFKL úL QRL GH 1LFRODH )LOLPRQ OD ,RQ DO OXL 5HEUHDQX GH
H[HPSOXvQWLPSFHSUR]DPRGHUQ RSWHD] SHQWUXYL]LXQHLQWHUQ DXQXLSHUVRQDM
QDUDWRU ùWHIDQ *KHRUJKLGLX HURXO OXL &DPLO 3HWUHVFX GH SLOG RUL SHQWUX IRFDOL
]DUHDPXOWLSO DVRFLLQGSXQFWHOHGHYHGHUHDOHPDLPXOWRULQVWDQ HQDUDWLYHQDUDWRU
úL SHUVRQDMH ± 3 GXUHD VSkQ]XUD LORU GH /LYLX 5HEUHDQX (QLJPD 2WLOLHL GH *HRUJH
& OLQHVFX 0RURPH LL GH 0DULQ 3UHGD HWF ± VDX QXPDL SHUVRQDMH FD vQ 3DWXO OXL
3URFXVW GH &DPLO 3HWUHVFX &DUDFWHULVWLFLOH ILHF UXL WLS GH SHUVSHFWLY QDUDWLY
QXPLW úLYL]LXQHQDUDWLY VDXIRFDOL]DUH±**HQHWWHVXQW
cSHUVSHFWLY RPQLVFLHQW IRFDOL]DUH]HURSRYHVWLUHQRQIRFDOL]DW
QDUDWRUXO HVWH RPQLVFLHQW úWLH WRWXO GHVSUH SHUVRQDMHOH VDOH ± LQIRUPD LL ELR
JUDILFH UHIOHF LL LQWHULRDUH WU LUL SVLKRDIHFWLYH HWF HO GHVFULH LQWHUSUHWHD]
PRWLYHD] WU LULOHFRJQLWLYHúLDIHFWLYHVW ULOHGHFRQúWLLQ DOHSHUVRQDMHORUVDOH
LQIRUPD LLOHGDWHGHF WUHQDUDWRUGHS úHVFLQIRUPD LLOHGH LQXWHGHILHFDUH
SHUVRQDMvQSDUWH
VH UHODWHD] HYHQLPHQWH H[WHULRDUH úL LQWHULRDUH XWLOL]kQGXVH WHKQLFL
DQDOLWLFHLQGLUHFWHREVHUYD LDúLDQDOL]DSVLKRORJLF UHWURVSHF LDHWF
GHVWLQHOH HURLORU VXQW GLULMDWH ULJXURV GH F WUH QDUDWRUXOGHPLXUJ SUR]D
UHDOLVW GHREVHUYD LHVRFLDO úLGHSUREOHPDWLF PRUDO
dSHUVSHFWLY LQWHUQ ÄGLQLQWHULRU´IRFDOL]DUHLQWHUQ
QDUDWRUXO DGRSW SXQFWXO GH YHGHUH DO XQXL SHUVRQDMQDUDWRU VDX SHUVRQDM
IRFDOL]DWRU ÄQDUD LH FX SXQFW GH YHGHUH FDUH SUH]LQW R RPQLVFLHQ
VHOHFWLY ´±**HQHWWH
UHDOLWDWHDHVWHSHUFHSXW úLLQWHUSUHWDW VXELHFWLYGLQSXQFWXOGHYHGHUHDO
SHUVRQDMXOXLFHYHGHFHDXGHFHJkQGHúWHHURXO±SHUVSHFWLYDÄDYHF´
VH UHODWHD] ÄHYHQLPHQWH´ LQWHULRDUH XWLOL]kQGXVH WHKQLFL DQDOLWLFH GLUHFWH
DXWRVFRSLH LQWURVSHF LD PRQRORJ LQWHULRU FRQIHVLXQH VXQW IUHFYHQWH vQ
SUR]DGHDQDOL] SVLKRORJLF
eSHUVSHFWLYDH[WHUQ ÄGLQH[WHULRU´IRFDOL]DUHH[WHUQ
QDUDWRUXO VH VLWXHD] vQ SHUVSHFWLYD GH REVHUYDWRU LPSDU LDO RELHFWLY DO
HYHQLPHQWHORU
QDUDWRUXOÄúWLH´PDLSX LQGHFkWSHUVRQDMHOHVXUSULQ]kQGXLGRDUFRPSRUWDPHQWXO
VXQWQDUDWHHYHQLPHQWHH[WHULRDUHVHQRWHD] XQHRULUHDF LLOHPDQLIHVWH
DOH WU LULORU SVLKRDIHFWLYH XWLOL]kQGXVH WHKQLFL DQDOLWLFH LQGLUHFWH REVHU
YD LHFRPSRUWDPHQWDO
QDUDWRUXOQXvúLDVXP MXGHF LGHYDORDUHRSLQLL
XQHRULVHWH[WXDOL]HD] LSRVWD]DXQLVFLHQW DQDUDWRUXOXLSULQWUXQÄMRFDODSUR[L
P ULORU´SULQVXSR]L LLLSRWH]HSUR]DPRGHUQ ÄURPDQXOFRPSRUWDPHQWLVW´
fSOXULSHUVSHFWLYLVPIRFDOL]DUHPXOWLSO YDULDELO GLIX]
PXOWLSOLFDUHDSHUVSHFWLYHORUHVWHJHQHUDW GHSUROLIHUDUHDÄYRFLORU´QDUDWLYH
DHXULORUQDUDWRU
WUHFHUHDGHODXQWLSGHIRFDOL]DUHODDOWXOSURGXFHRUXSWXU GHSHUVSHFWLY
H[WHUQ oLQWHUQ VDX R DPELJXL]DUH SULQ WUDQVIHUXO GH SHUVSHFWLY
SXQFWXOGHYHGHUHDOQDUDWRUXOXLHVWHvQORFXLWGHSHUVSHFWLYDXQXLSHUVRQDM
IRFDOL]DWRU FKLDU GDF GLVFXUVXO QXúL PRGLILF LQGLFLL ± GLVFXUV U PkQH DO
QDUDWRUXOXLGDUSXQFWXOGHYHGHUHHVWHDOSHUVRQDMXOXL
VHFRPELQ vQIRUPXOHGLYHUVHSHUVSHFWLYHFRQYHUJHQWHFRPSOHPHQWDUH
GLYHUJHQWHUH]XOWDQWDILLQGRSHUVSHFWLY GLIX] FDUHUHODWLYL]HD] HURLLúL
OXPHDORUÄGHKkUWLH´
3(563(&7,9(7(0325$/(
3HUVSHFWLYHOH WHPSRUDOH FDUH VWUXFWXUHD] WH[WXO QDUDWLY VXQW GHWHUPLQDWH GH
UHOD LD LQVWLWXLW vQWUH WLPSXO QDUDW GXUDWD ILF LRQDO D HYHQLPHQWHORU FDUH DOF WXLHVF
WUDPD úL WLPSXO QDU ULL DO LVWRULVLULL &D HOHPHQW FRQVWLWXWLY VSHFLILF GLVFXUVXOXL HSLF
WHPSRUDOLWDWHD JHQHUHD] WUHL PRGHOH QDUDWLYH SULQFLSDOH GLQ FRPELQDUHD F URUD
UH]XOW PDL PXOWH IRUPXOH QDUDWLYH QDUD LXQHD vQ UDP SRYHVWLUHD vQ SRYHVWLUH
MXUQDOXOFRPHQWDWHWF
c 1DUD LXQHD XOWHULRDU vQ FDUH HYHQLPHQWHOH VXQW UHODWDWH GLQ SHUVSHFWLYD
IDSWHORUSHWUHFXWHGHMDRULHQWHD] D[DWHPSRUDO VSUHWUHFXWPRPHQWXOQDU ULLHVWH
VLWXDWGXS WLPSXOLVWRULVLWQDUDWRUXOúLUHFHSWRUXOVHVLWXHD] SVLKLFvQGXUDWDWUHFXW
DHYHQLPHQWHORU6XQWIUHFYHQWHWLPSXULOHYHUEDOHWUHFXWHLPSHUIHFWSHUIHFWVLPSOX
VDX FRPSXV PDLPXOWFDSHUIHFWXO (UD vQFHSXWXO YHULL )DPLOLD 0RURPHWH VH
vQWRUVHVHPDLGHYUHPHGHODFkPS03UHGD0RURPH LL
d1DUD LXQHDVLPXOWDQ DQXOHD] KRWDUXOGLQWUHWLPSXOQDUD LXQLLWLPSXOQDU ULL
úLWLPSXOOHFWXU ULLPRPHQWXOQDU ULLSDUHVLPXOWDQFXWLPSXOGHVI úXU ULLvQWkPSO ULORU
LDU QDUDWRUXO SDUH D LVWRULVL IDSWHOH SH P VXU FH HOH VH GHVI úRDU 3ULQ DFWXO
FRPXQLF ULLODSUH]HQWWLPSXOQDUD LXQLLHVWHDGXVvQWLPSXOFLWLWRUXOXL&DWLPSQDUDWLY
HVWH SUHGRPLQDQW SUH]HQWXO 'LFRPHVLHQLL UHYLQ D GRXD ]L úL LQYDGHD] LQVXOD >«@
&DLLVHVSHULHGHIRFúLIXJ«ùWHIDQ% QXOHVFX&DUWHDPLOLRQDUXOXL
e 1DUD LXQHD DQWHULRDU HVWH XWLOL]DW SH VSD LL PDL UHGXVH ILLQGF PRPHQWXO
LVWRULVLULLDQWLFLSHD] WLPSXOXQRUHYHQLPHQWHQHvQWkPSODWHvQF SURLHFWDWHLSRWHWLFvQ
YLLWRU SULQ FRPXQLFDUHD QDUDWLY DQWHULRDU WLPSXO QDUD LXQLL úL FHO DO UHFHSW ULL VH
GHVFKLG VSUH R GXUDW SRWHQ LDO D XQRU HYHQLPHQWH SRVLELOH D[D WHPSRUDO ILLQG
RULHQWDW VSUH YLLWRU QDUD LXQHD GH WLS ÄSUHGLFWLY´ H[LVW GRDU FD H[SHULPHQW vQ PRG
RELúQXLWSUR]DWRULLUHFXUJkQGODVHFYHQ HQDUDWLYHGHWLSÄSURIH LH´7]HWDQ7RGRURY
LQVHUDWHvQQDUD LXQHDDQWHULRDU RULVLPXOWDQ 0RGXULOHúLWLPSXULOHYHUEDOHIUHFYHQW
XWLOL]DWH VXQW LQGLFDWLY YLLWRU SUH]XPWLY FRQMXQFWLY FRQGL LRQDO FX YDORDUHD
YLLWRUXOXL SUH]HQWXO RQLULF FD YL]LXQH Ä'XS YUHR ]HFH PHWUL YH L PHUJH úL PDL
UHSHGHFXSULQVGHDQ[LHWDWHQXVH] UHúWHLHúLUHDùLvQVIkUúLWYH LVWDSHORFSX LQ
RERVLW vQWUR SHQXPEU URúLDWLF S WUXQV GH DHUXO UHFH FDUH WUHFH GH QXVHúWLH
XQGHVSUHQXVHúWLHXQGH (YLGHQW QX VH YD PDL ] UL QLFL LQWUDUHD³ ,RDQ 3HWUX
&XOLDQX,PSDV
f1DUD LXQHDLQWHUFDODW FRPELQ PRGHOHOHSULPDUHvQWUHVHFYHQ HOHQDUDWLYH
H[LVWkQGGLIHUHQ HGHSHUVSHFWLY WHPSRUDO IRUPXOHOHQDUDWLYHJHQHUDWHDVWIHOVXQW
YDULDWHSRYHVWLULvQVHUWDUSRYHVWLUHDvQSRYHVWLUHSRYHVWLULvQUDP MXUQDOFRPHQWDW
URPDQHSLVWRODUHWF
25',1($1$5$7,9
2UGLQHDQDUDWLY VHUHIHU ODFRQVWUXF LDQDUD LXQLLODPRGHOXOGLHJHWLFvQFDUH
VHFYHQ HOH QDUDWLYH SDX]HOH GHVFULSWLYH VDX H[SOLFDWLYH VHFYHQ HOH GLDORJDWH RUL
PRQRORJXULOH VH vQO Q XLH DOWHUQHD] VXQW LQVHUDWH VDX MX[WDSXVH HWF 0RGHOHOH
GLHJHWLFHSULQFLSDOHVXQW
c 1DUD LXQHD FURQRORJLF HVWH PRGHOXO SULPDU DO HSRVXOXL VWUXFWXUDW SH
SULQFLSLXOFURQRORJLFHSLVRDGHOHVHFYHQ HOHQDUDWLYHvQWkPSO ULOHVHVXFFHGOLQHDUSH
D[D WHPSRUDO vQ FURQRORJLH GLUHFW VDX PDL UDU vQ FURQRORJLH LQYHUV /D QLYHOXO
GLVFXUVXOXLPRGHOXOHVWHPDUFDWSULQSUH]HQ DXQRUVLQWDJPHWHPSRUDOHFDUHH[SULP
VHPDQWLFLGHHDGHVXFFHVLXQHDHYHQLPHQWHORUvQWLPS $ GRXD ]L )HOL[«>@ ÌQ]LXD
XUP WRDUH)HOL[«>@3HODvQFHSXWXOOXQLLDXJXVW>«@&kQGSHWRDPQ WkU]LX)HOL[
>«@ÌQPDUWLH)HOL[>«@3HODVIkUúLWXOOXLVHSWHPEULH*& OLQHVFX(QLJPD2WLOLHL
d 1DUD LD VLQFURQ WLQGH V H[SULPH vQ HSLVRDGH QDUDWLYH FDUH VH VXFFHG
DF LXQLVLPXOWDQHGXUDWHHYHQLPHQ LDOHSDUDOHOH&DUDFWHUXOVLPXOWDQDOvQWkPSO ULORU
HVWHVHPQDODWSULQVHFYHQ HOLQJYLVWLFHSUHFXPvQWRWWLPSXODFHVWDvQDFHODúLWLPS
PRPHQW« HWF 6D UXSW GLQ ORFXO V X GH VXV 3LHULQG PDL PXOWH ]LOH ÌQ YUHPHD
DVWD& W OLQ0(PLQHVFX/XFHDI UXO
e 1DUD LXQL SDUDOHOH FRQWUDSXQFWLFH VXQW IUHFYHQWH vQ SUR]D URPDQWLF úL vQ
FHDPRGHUQLVW ILLQGFDUDFWHUL]DWHSULQDOWHUQDQ DXQRUVHFYHQ HHSLVRDGHGLQSODQXUL
QDUDWLYH GLIHULWH DOWHUQDQ D UHDO LUHDO GH H[HPSOX vQ SUR]D IDQWDVWLF DOWH PRGHOH
GLHJHWLFH DOWHUQHD] GRX SDOLHUH WHPSRUDOH WLPS UHDO RELHFWLY GXUDW LQWHULRDU
VXELHFWLY /D QLYHOXO GLVFXUVXOXL HVWH IUHFYHQW DEVHQ D FRQHFWRULORU VH XWLOL]HD]
WLPSXULYHUEDOHGLIHULWHHYHQWXDOFRQWUDVWLYHSUH]HQWSHUIHFWFRPSXVGHH[HPSOX
f 1DUD LXQHD GLVFRQWLQX UHSUH]LQW XQ WLSDU QDUDWLY PRGHUQ VXJHUkQG OLSVD
GH VHQV GH FRHUHQ D OXPLL VDX ÄGH]RUGLQHD´ PHPRULHL LQYROXQWDUH SULQ
VXVSHQGDUHD GHOLEHUDW D RUGLQLL WHPSRUDOH (SLVRDGHOH QDUDWLYH DFWXDOL]HD]
DOHDWRULXPRPHQWHFDUHQXVHVXFFHGFURQRORJLFVDXVHUHDOL]HD] SULQDFURQLLGH
DFURQLH ± ÄIRUP GH GLVFRUGDQ WHPSRUDO vQWUH VHFYHQ D HYHQLPHQWHORU UHDOH VDX ILFWLYH
SRYHVWLWHúLRUGLQHDLQFOXGHULLORUvQWH[W´'LF LRQDUGHúWLLQ HDOHOLPELL
WLSXO DQDOHSVHL DPkQDUH UHODWDUH XOWHULRDU D XQXL HYHQLPHQWFDX] HYHQLPHQW
DQWHULRU DO SUROHSVHL DQWLFLS UL SULQ HOLSVH WHPSRUDOH VXSULPDUHD XQRU GXUDWH
LQWHUPHGLDUHvQWUHHYHQLPHQWHRULSULQIUDJPHQWDULVPXOGLVFXUVXOXL
02'$/,7 ,/(1$5 5,,
0RGDOLW LOHPRGXULOHQDUDWLYHFRQVWLWXLHXQHOHPHQWIXQGDPHQWDODOVWUXFWXULL
HSLFHYL]kQGRUJDQL]DUHDLQIRUPD LHLQDUDWLYHFDGLVFXUVSULQFLSLLúLWHKQLFLQDUDWLYH
SURFHGHHGHRUJDQL]DUHDLQFLSLWXOXLúLDILQDOXOXLDHSLVRDGHORUQDUDWLYHQDUD LHSULQ
UHODWDUH D VHFYHQ HORU GLDORJDWH VDX PRQRORJDWH QDUD LH SULQ UHSUH]HQWDUH D
VHFYHQ HORU UH]XPDWLYH RUL D SDX]HORU GHVFULSWLYH ULWPXO QDUDWLY HWF 0RGDOLW LOH
QDUDWLYH LQFOXG úL YRFLOH QDUDWLYH FRQVWUXF LD SHUVRQDMHORU PRGXO GH UHGDUH D
GLVFXUVXOXLHURLORUVWLOGLUHFWLQGLUHFWLQGLUHFWOLEHUUHJLVWUHVWLOLVWLFHHWF
c3ULQFLSLLOHFRPSR]L LRQDOHRUJDQL]HD] PDFURVWUXFWXULOHWH[WXOXLFRQIHULQGXL
FRH]LXQH FRHUHQ ORJLF DUWLVWLF vQ WLPS FH WHKQLFLOH QDUDWLYH VXQW SURFHGXUL GH
RUJDQL]DUHWH[WXDO ODQLYHOXOXQLW LORUFRPSR]L LRQDOH$VWIHOFDvQURPDQXO,RQDOOXL
/LYLX 5HEUHDQX SULQFLSLXO FURQRORJLF VH PDWHULDOL]HD] SULQ WHKQLFD vQO Q XLULL
PRGDOLWDWH QDUDWLY GH D FRQVWUXL VXELHFWXO SULQ VXFFHVLXQHD OLQHDU D HSLVRDGHORU
RUGRQDWH FURQRORJLF úL SULQ WHKQLFD DOWHUQDQ HL PRGDOLWDWH QDUDWLY GH D UHODWD
DF LXQLHYHQLPHQWHFDUHVHSHWUHFVLPXOWDQvQSODQXULGLIHULWHvQVHFYHQ HDO WXUDWH
SHD[DWHPSRUDO ÌQSUR]DFODVLF DFHVWSULQFLSLXVHDVRFLD] IUHFYHQWFXSULQFLSLXO
VLPHWULHL úL FX FHO DO FLUFXODULW LL DQDORJLD SODQXULORU D HSLVRDGHORU QDUDWLYH
UHFXUHQ DPRWLYXOXLWHPHLVHFYHQ HLGLQLQFLSLWvQILQDOXOWH[WXOXLJHQHUHD] PRGHOXO
RSHUHL vQFKLVH HFKLYDODWH GH 5HEUHDQX FX XQ ÄFRUS VIHURLG´ 3ULQFLSLXO PRGHUQ DO
PHPRULHLDIHFWLYHDSOLFDWGH&DPLO3HWUHVFXvQURPDQXO8OWLPDQRDSWHGHGUDJRVWH
vQWkLDQRDSWHGHU ]ERLGHYLQHRSHUDQWSULQWHKQLFDLQVHU LHLúLWHKQLFDIODVKEDFNXOXL
PRGDOLW LQDUDWLYHSULQFDUHHVWHVXVSHQGDW©SUH]HQWXOªQDUD LXQLLSULQFLSDOHVSUHD
LQWHUFDODRQDUD LXQHVHFXQGDU RvQWkPSODUHUHPHPRUDW 0RGHUQHVWHúLSULQFLSLXO
SDUDOHOLVPXOXL HSLF FRQFUHWL]DW SULQ DOWHUQDQ SULQ WHKQLFD VLPHWULHL QDUDWLYH
DQDORJLD XQRU HSLVRDGH VHFYHQ H VDX SULQ WHKQLFD QXPLW D FRQWUDSXQFWXOXL
HSLVRDGH VHFYHQ H PRWLYH FRQWUDVWLYH vQ VLPHWULH LQYHUV SUHFXP úL SULQFLSLXO
GLVFRQWLQXLW LL QDUDWLYH FDUH G DSDUHQ D GH]RUJDQL] ULL GHOLEHUDWH D WH[WXOXL DOF WXLW
SULQ WHKQLFD GHFXSDMXOXL VDX SULQ FHD D FRODMXOXL FRQVWUkQG vQ IUDJPHQWDULVPXO
GLVFXUVXOXL vQ MX[WDSXQHUHD XQRU VHFYHQ H WH[WXDOH FDUH SDU D QX DYHD R OHJ WXU
WHPDWLF VDXORJLF
d,QFLSLWXOúLILQDOXOGHVLQLWXOVXQWÄSXQFWHVWUDWHJLFH´vQWH[WXOOLWHUDUDYkQG
UROXO GH D PHGLD vQWUH OXPHD UHDO úL XQLYHUVXO ILF LRQDO ,QFLSLWXO FODVLF GH WLS
GHVFULSWLYUH]XPDWLYVDXHQXQ LDWLYIRUPXOHD] HQXQ XULGHRULHQWDUHUHSHUHVSD LR
WHPSRUDOH LQVWDQ HOH QDUDWLYH VLWXD LD LQL LDO HWF FDUH SURGXF ÄHIHFWXO GH UHDO´
DWHQXkQG SUDJXO GLQWUH UHDOLWDWH úL ILF LXQH ,QFLSLWXO PRGHUQ IL[HD] IUHFYHQW XQ
ÄSURWRFROGHOHFWXU ´SULQVHPQDOHPHWDWH[WXDOHFDUHH[SOLF DFWXOSURGXFHULLWH[WXOXL
(O SRDWH IL GH WLSXO SXQHULL vQ DELV IRUPDOL]HD] GLVFXUVXO QDUDWLY GH WLSXO ÄSUHIH HL
SUDJPDWLFH´ VHQHJRFLD] FRQYHQ LDQDUD LXQLLRIHULQGFLWLWRUXOXLXQFRGFRGXULGH
DQDOHSV QDUD LD UHWURVSHFWLY HVWH XQ WLSDU QDUDWLY IUHFYHQW vQ SRYHVWLUH VDX vQ URPDQXO
SVLKRORJLFVWUXFWXUDWSHSULQFLSLXOPHPRULHLLQYROXQWDUH
LQFLSLW±VHFYHQ WH[WXDO SULQFDUHOHFWRUXOHVWHLQWURGXVvQXQLYHUVXOILF LXQLLDUHGLPHQVLXQL
YDULDELOHGHODSULPXOHQXQ ODSULPXODOLQHDWVDXODSULPXOJUXSDMGHDOLQHDWHFDUHDGXFHRLQIRUPD LH
QRX UHPDGLVFXUVXOXL
OHFWXU GH WLSXO H[ DEUXSWR VH SUH]LQW HOHPHQWH WH[WXDOH FD úL FkQG DU IL GHMD
FXQRVFXWH OHFWRUXOXL GH WLSXO GHFXSDMXOXL R IRUPXODUH D[LRPDWLF XQ IUDJPHQW GH
GLVFXUV LQVHUDW XQ ÄGHVHQ´ VLPEROLF FDUH FRGLILF PHVDMXO WH[WXOXL HWF VDX
FRPELQkQG PDL PXOWH PRGHOH GH WLSXO ÄLQWU ULORU PXOWLSOH´ SHQWUX D VXSUDPDUFD
vQFHSXWXO GLVFXUVXOXL QDUDWLY )LQDOXULOH WH[WHORU OLWHUDUH UHOLHIHD] R GLYHUVLWDWH
FRPSR]L LRQDO úLVLPEROLF WRWDWkWGHDFFHQWXDW FDúLLQFLSLWXULOH5HOD LDGLQWUHFHOH
GRX VHFYHQ H FRPSR]L LRQDOH HVWH GHWHUPLQDW GH OLQHDULWDWHD WUDGL LRQDO D
GLVFXUVXOXL QDUDWLY PRGHOXO vQFKLGHULL IRUPDOH FX URO UH]XPDWLY VDX FRQFOX]LY DO
vQFKLGHULL FLUFXODUH ± FX UHOXDUHD WHPHL VDX UHPHL GLQ LQFLSLW ± PRGHOXO ILQDOXOXL
GHVFULSWLY RUL PRGHOXO vQFKHLHULL FRQFHSWXDOH FX FDUDFWHU JQRPLF VDX PRUDOL]DWRU
VDX GH PRGHUQLWDWHD DFHVWXLD 6WUDWHJLLOH PRGHUQH GH FRQVWUXLUH D ILQDOXOXL YL]HD]
FRPXQLFDUHDDUWLVWLF SDFWXOQDUDWLYFDUDFWHUXOILFWLYDOÄOXPLLGHFXYLQWH´UHIHUHQWXO
LPDJLQDU HWF 7LSXUL PRGHUQH GH ILQDOXUL VXQW vQFKLGHUHD SUDJPDWLF ILQDO
PHWDGLVFXUVLY FX UHIHULUH OD VIkUúLWXO SRYHVWLULL VDX OD XQ QRX vQFHSXW vQFKHLHUHD
GH]Y OXLUH ILQDO vQ SRDQW FDUH ÄGHWXUQHD] ´ VHPQLILFD LLOH FRQVROLGDWH GHD OXQJXO
WH[WXOXL úL PDL DOHV ILQDOXO GHVFKLV FDUH SRDWH VXVSHQGD UH]ROYDUHD FRQIOLFWHORU
SRDWHDPELJXL]DVLWXD LDILQDO VDXRSRDWHSURLHFWDLSRWHWLFvQWUXQYLLWRULQFHUW
e (SLVRDGHOH QDUDWLYH VH GHILQHVF FD XQLW L FRPSR]L LRQDOH HVHQ LDOH vQ
VWUXFWXUDUHD GLHJH]HL HOH DVLJXU SURJUHVLD WHPDWLF D GLVFXUVXOXL SURJUHVLD
FRQIOLFWXOXL FRQIOLFWHORU úL GH]YROWDUHD VXELHFWXOXL &RQFHQWUkQG VXEVWDQ D HSLF D
WH[WXOXLvQWURVXLW GHDF LXQLGHHYHQLPHQWHFDUHVHFRQVWLWXLHFDRXQLWDWHQDUDWLY
HSLVRGXO HVWH FDUDFWHUL]DW SULQ FRHUHQ WHPDWLF úL FRH]LXQH IRUPDO $F LXQLOH
HSLVRGLFHDXXQUHOLHIVWLOLVWLFHYLGHQWvQ HV WXUDQDUDWLY FRQVWLWXLQGVSD LLGHPDUH
GHQVLWDWH D VHPQLILFD LLORU HSLVRGXO XFLGHULL FHORU GH ERLHUL vQ $OH[DQGUX
/ SXúQHDQXOGH&1HJUX]]LHSLVRGXOV UXW ULLS PkQWXOXLvQ,RQHSLVRGXOSHUPLVLHL
OD&kPSXOXQJ>FDSLWROXO8OWLPDQRDSWHGHGUDJRVWH@DOE W OLHLGHOD6 V Xú>FDSLWROXO
1HDDFRSHULWS PkQWXOOXL'XPQH]HX@vQSULPXOURPDQDOOXL&DPLO3HWUHVFXHWF
f 6HFYHQ D HVWH FHD PDL PLF XQLWDWH FRPSR]L LRQDO vQ DUKLWHFWXUD RSHUHL
UHXQLQG HQXQ XUL FX DFHOHDúL FDUDFWHULVWLFL WH[WXDOH QDUDWLYH GHVFULSWLYH GLDORJLFH
DUJXPHQWDWLYHH[SOLFDWLYHDVHUWLYHHVHLVWLFHHWFFDUHIRUPHD] RVWUXFWXU VROLGDU
vQ DQVDPEOXO WH[WXDO 9DULHWDWHD WLSXULORU GH VHFYHQ H HVWH JHQHUDW GH FDUDFWHUXO
LQWHJUDWRU DO GLVFXUVXOXL QDUDWLY FDUH vúL VXERUGRQHD] úL GHVFULHUHD GLDORJXO VDX
PRQRORJXOÄDEVRUELQGXOH´ÌQDF LXQHDURPDQXOXLWUDGL LRQDOHXDú]LFHGRULFH[LVW
PRPHQWH ÄSOLQH´ IDSWH LQWURGXVH JUDPDWLFDO SULQ SHUIHFWXO VLPSOX RUL SHUIHFWXO
FRPSXV OHJDWH vQWUH HOH SULQ VSD LL ÄJRDOH´ GHVFULS LL HYRF UL SRUWUHWH FRPHQWDULX
DQDOLWLFLQWURGXVHSULQLPSHUIHFW$FHDVWDHVFKHPDRULF UHLQDUD LXQLFODVLFH3URXVW
U VWRDUQ VSHFWDFXORV UDSRUWXO FHHD FH SUHGRPLQ OD HO ILLQG ÄJROXULOH´ GHYHQLWH
FHQWUDOH úL OHJDWH SULQ ÄSOLQXUL´ 1LFRODH 0DQROHVFX $UFD OXL 1RH (VHX GHVSUH
URPDQXO URPkQHVF Ä3OLQXULOH´ GHVSUH FDUH YRUEHúWH FULWLFXO 1 0DQROHVFX VXQW
VHFYHQ HOHQDUDWLYHFDUHVHRUJDQL]HD] vQWURUH HDDOF WXLQGHSLVRDGHOHÄ*ROXULOH´
VXQWVHFYHQ HGHVFULSWLYHGHWLSWDEORXVDXGHWLSSRUWUHWFRPHQWDWLYHHVHLVWLFHHWF
ÌQWUHUXSkQG IOX[XO HSLF vQFHWLQLQG ULWPXO QDUDWLY DFHVWH VHFYHQ H IRUPHD] SDX]HOH
GHVFULSWLYH FDUH DX UROXO GH D SUHJ WL XQ PRPHQWFKHLH vQ GHVI úXUDUHD HSLF
WHKQLFD DPkQ ULL D VXVSDQVXOXL GH D IL[D UHSHUH VSD LRWHPSRUDOH VHFYHQ HOH
H[SR]LWLYH PDL DOHV GH D VFKL D GHWDOLLOH SVLKRIL]LFH DOH XQXL SHUVRQDM GH D
GHWHUPLQDRÄUXSWXU GHQLYHO´HWF5XSWXUDGHQLYHODVWIHOFUHDW HVWHDFFHQWXDW úL
SULQ VFKLPEDUHD ULWPXOXL QDUDWLY 'DF SDX]HOH GHVFULSWLYH VXVSHQG WLPSXO QDUDWLY
vQFHWLQLQGULWPXOUHODW ULLVHFYHQ HOHQDUDWLYHPDLDOHVFHOHGHWLSUH]XPDWLYVDXGH
WLSXO HOLSVHL LPSXQ XQ WHPSR QDUDWLY DOHUW ÌQWUH FHOH GRX WLSXUL GH VHFYHQ H VH
VLWXHD] VHFYHQ HOH GLDORJDWH PRQRORJDWH QDUDUH SULQ UHSUH]HQWDUH FDUH
UHSUH]LQW XQULWPQDUDWLYFDQRQLFILLQGF WLPSXOQDU ULLFRLQFLGHFXWLPSXOQDUDW
g0RGXULOHSULQFLSDOHGHQDUDUHVXQW
9 1DUDUHD SULQ UHSUH]HQWDUH HVWH R VWUDWHJLH WH[WXDO SULQ FDUH VH LPSXQH
GLVFXUVXO SHUVRQDMHORU FH VXEVWLWXLH SH VSD LL DPSOH GLVFXUVXO QDUDWRUXOXL FRQIHU
QDUD LXQLLFDUDFWHUVFHQLFGHWHUPLQkQGSUHGRPLQDQ DVWLOXOXLGLUHFW9RUELUHDGLUHFW
DSHUVRQDMHORUHVWHPDUFDW VXELHFWLYDIHFWLYúLVWLOLVWLFSULQSUH]HQ DLQGLFLORUOH[LFR
JUDPDWLFDOLDLSHUVRDQHL,úLD,,DDVXEVWDQWLYHORUúLDGMHFWLYHORUvQFD]XOYRFDWLYD
YHUEHORU OD LPSHUDWLY SULQ P UFL DIHFWLYH H[SULPDWH SULQ LQWHUMHF LL VDX DGYHUEH
H[FODPDWLYH SULQ GHOLPLWDUHD VLQWDFWLF D GLVFXUVXOXL QDUDWRUXOXL GH YRUELUHD
SHUVRQDMHORU SURSR]L LL SULQFLSDOH LQGHSHQGHQWH DYkQG IUHFYHQW VWDWXW GH
LQFLGHQWDOH SULQ XWLOL]DUHD GLDORJXOXL úL PRQRORJXOXL úL D XQRU UHJLVWUH VWLOLVWLFH
YDULDWH 0HGLHUHD QDUDWRULDO VH UHDOL]HD] SULQ SUH]HQ D YHUEHORU GLFHQGL D ]LFH D
VSXQH D U VSXQGH D vQWUHED D H[FODPD D UHSOLFD HWF úL D XQRU VHPQH GH
SXQFWXD LHVSHFLILFHGRX SXQFWHOLQLHGHGLDORJVDXVHPQHOHFLW ULLJKLOLPHOH
±+PVSXVHHDDU JRVúLFXXQJODVU JXúLWvQV IRUWH(úWLIO F XvQOHJH>«@
$VFXOW &RVWDFKHODFLQHRV VWHDÄE LDWXO´"
±/DQRLH[SOLF 2WLOLD*HRUJH& OLQHVFX(QLJPD2WLOLHL
9 1DUDUHD SULQ UHODWDUH HVWH PRGDOLWDWHD WUDGL LRQDO GH LVWRULVLUH LPSXQkQG
GLVFXUVXO QDUDWRUXOXL vQ FDUH HVWH LQVHUDW úL YRUELUHD SHUVRQDMHORU 7UDQVSXQHUHD
GLVFXUVXOXLHURLORUvQGLVFXUVXOQDUDWRUXOXLDFWXDOL]HD] VWLOLQGLUHFW0 UFLWH[WXDOHDOH
YRUELULL LQGLUHFWH VXQW LQGLFL DL SHUVRDQHL D ,,,D SHUVRDQD , úL D ,,D FDUDFWHULVWLFH
VWLOXOXL GLUHFW VXQW WUDQVIHUDWH OD SHUVRDQD D ,,,D VXERUGRQDUHD HQXQ XULORU GLQ
YRUELUHD WUDQVSXV D SHUVRQDMHORU SUH]HQ D YHUEHORU GLFHQGL VDX D VXEVWDQWLYHORU
QXPH GH DF LXQL FX URO GH UHJHQW DO VXERUGRQDWHORU XWLOL]DUHD FRQHFWRULORU GH
VXERUGRQDUH F V GDF XQGH FkQG HWF VXEVWLWXLUHD LPSHUDWLYXOXL FX YHUEH OD
PRGXO FRQMXQFWLY SUH]HQ D LQWHURJD LLORU LQGLUHFWH FDUH QX VXQW PDUFDWH JUDILF SULQ
VHPQXO vQWUHE ULL HWF 6W QLF VH vQVXU FX *HRUJHWD FX FDUH QX DYX ©ILLª GDU DYX
SURWHFWRUL DVLGXL I FX SROLWLF GHFODU F VLPWH ©XQ ULWP QRXª IX FKLDU SUHIHFW vQWUR
VFXUW JXYHUQDUH*& OLQHVFX(QLJPD2WLOLHL2DOW VWUDWHJLHWH[WXDO GHDVRFLHUH
D GLVFXUVXOXL QDUDWRUXOXL úL D YRUELULL SHUVRQDMHORU HVWH XWLOL]DUHD VWLOXULORU PL[WH
GHULYDWH VWLOXO GLUHFW OHJDW úL VDX VWLOXO LQGLUHFW OLEHU $FHVWHD UHSUH]LQW IRUPH
LQWHUPHGLDUHvQWUHGLVFXUVXOGLUHFWúLFHOLQGLUHFWDYkQGFDHIHFWVWLOLVWLFVXSUDSXQHUHD
YRFLORU QDUDWLYH ± D QDUDWRUXOXL úL D SHUVRQDMXOXL FLWDW 6WLOXO GLUHFW OHJDW VSHFLILF
YRUELULLIDPLOLDUHQHOLWHUDUHVHFDUDFWHUL]HD] SULQGHSHQGHQ DVLQWDFWLF DGLVFXUVXOXL
FLWDW GH YRFHD QDUDWRUXOXL SUH]HQ D FRQHFWRUXOXL GH VXERUGRQDUH vQWUH VHFYHQ D
WH[WXDO DVXPDW GHQDUDWRUúLGLVFXUVXOUDSRUWDWDOSHUVRQDMXOXLSUHFXPúLPHQ LQHUHD
SHUVRDQHL,D,,DvQYRUELUHDUHSURGXV VXQWSULQFLSDOHOHVHPQDOHWH[WXDOHDOHDFHVWXL
VWLOGHULYDW>@LQWUDúLG GHDEXQ VHDUDQXPDL&DWULQHLVSXQkQGGHILHFDUHGDW F OD
SURúWLL LODO LQXGDXEXQ VHDUD0DULQ3UHGD0RURPH LL6WLOXOLQGLUHFWOLEHUDUHúLHO
HIHFWSROLIRQLFGDUGLVFXUVXOQDUDWRUXOXLúLFHODOSHUVRQDMXOXLVXQWMX[WDSXVHGLVS UkQG
H[SUHVLLOH GLFHQGL VHPQHOH GH SXQFWXD LH VSHFLILFH VWLOXOXL GLUHFW VDX FRQHFWRULL GH
VXERUGRQDUH QHFHVDUL vQ VWLOXO LQGLUHFW 1LO PRUP L FHYD FDUH SXWHD V vQVHPQH F
WDW O V X YRUEHúWH V QX WDF 2 OX SH OkQJ JDUGXUL F OFkQG vQ DFHODúL IHO FX
PRUP LWXUDDGLF VLJXUV QXVHGXF QLPHQLGDUXLWHF VHGXFHúLWHVLOHúWHúLSH
WLQHV WHGXFL03UHGD0RURPH LL
HOLSVDHVWHXQSURFHGHXQDUDWLYFDUHUHFXUJHODXQVDOWvQWLPSWUHFkQGVXEW FHUHRSDUWHD
HYHQLPHQWHORURGXUDW vQFDUHGHRELFHLQXVHSHWUHFvQWkPSO ULGHRVHELWH
3(5621$-8/32575(78//,7(5$5
3HUVRQDMXO OLWHUDU SHUVRQD ODW± PDVF GH WHDWUX URO DFWRU HVWH R SUH]HQ
SULQLQWHUPHGLXOF UHLDVFULLWRUXOvúLH[SULP LQGLUHFWFRQFHS LLOHUHSUH]HQW ULOHLGHLOH
vQ RSHUD HSLF VDX GUDPDWLF &D LQVWDQ QDUDWLY SULQFLSDO SHUVRQDMXO UHSUH]LQW
XQ HOHPHQW HVHQ LDO vQ VWUXFWXUD WH[WXOXL HSLF VDX GUDPDWLF 5HSUH]HQWkQG RDPHQL
WUDQVILJXUD L DUWLVWLF ILLQ H LPDJLQDWH GH VFULLWRU GHYHQLWH DFWDQ L DL vQWkPSO ULORU
QDUDWHVDXSUH]HQWDWHFDDF LXQLVFHQLFHSHUVRQDMHOHDXIRVWQXPLWHvQFKLSGLIHULWGH
WHRUHWLFLHQLL DUWHL OLWHUDUH ÄILLQ GH KkUWLH´ 5%DUWKHV ÄILLQ ILF LRQDO ´ 7RPD
3DYHO DFWDQW $ - *UHLPDV DFWRU - /LQWYHOW HURX 0 %DKWLQ - /LQWYHOW ÌQ
'LF LRQDUGHWHUPHQLOLWHUDULFULWLFXO0LUFHD$QJKHOHVFXGHILQHúWHSHUVRQDMXOOLWHUDUFD
ÄSHUVRDQ SUH]HQWDW GXS UHDOLWDWH VDX URG DO ILF LXQLL FDUH DSDUH vQWUR RSHU
HSLF VDX GUDPDWLF ILLQG LQWHJUDW SULQ LQWHUPHGLXO OLPEDMXOXL vQ VLVWHPXO GH
LQWHUDF LXQLDODFHVWHLD
)XQF LLOHSHUVRQDMXOXLVXQWGHWHUPLQDWHGHVWUXFWXULOHVSHFLILFHWH[WXOXLQDUDWLY
úLGHRS LXQLOHHVWHWLFHDOHVFULLWRUXOXL
9 SHUVRQDM RELHFWLY DFWDQWXO HVWH XUP ULW vQ SODQXO HYHQLPHQ LDO DYkQG
QXPDL IXQF LH DFWDQ LDO vúLMRDF UROXOvQDF LXQHDQDUDW VDXUHSUH]HQWDW VFHQLF
HVWHWH[WXDOL]DWSULQLQGLFLDLSHUVRDQHLD,,,D
9 SHUVRQDMXOUHIOHFWRU UDLVRQQHXU HURX vQYHVWLW FX IXQF LH UHIOH[LY GXEODW
IUHFYHQW GH IXQF LD DFWDQ LDO REVHUY IRUPXOHD] MXGHF L GH YDORDUH FXJHW UL vQ
GLVFXUVDVHUWLYVDXDSRGLFWLFSHUVRDQDD,,,D,
9 SHUVRQDMIRFDOL]DWRU ÄSHUVRQDM GLQ DO F UXL SXQFW GH YHGHUH VH SUH]LQW
VLWXD LLOHúLHYHQLPHQWHOHQDUDWH´*3ULQFHDUHIXQF LHGHREVHUYDWRUFDUHSRDWHIL
DVRFLDW IXQF LHLDFWDQ LDOHÄSHUVRDQDD,,,DFDSURWDJRQLVW´±10DQROHVFX
9 SHUVRQDMQDUDWRU HURXO GHYHQLW ÄYRFH´ QDUDWLY DYkQG IXQF LL QDUDWLYH
PXOWLSOH
UHODWHD] HYHQLPHQWH HXO QDUDWRU QDUDQW WH[WXDOL]DW FD QDUDWRU
KRPRGLHJHWLFGRPLQDQWDSHUVRDQD,
DUHURODFWDQ LDOHXOQDUDWQDUDWRUDXWRGLHJHWLFGHFLSURWDJRQLVWFDUHÄVH
SRYHVWHúWHSHVLQH
SRDWH DYHD IXQF LH DFWRULDO ÄMRDF ´ PDL PXOWH UROXUL LQWHUSUHWHD] R
SDUWLWXU SHPDLPXOWHYRFL
DUH URO GH UHJLH ÄUHJL]HD] LQWU ULOH vQ VFHQ ´ DOH FHORUODO L HURL OH FLWHD]
GLVFXUVXOvQSURSULXOGLVFXUV
9 SHUVRQDMQDUDWRU DXFWRULDO HVWH FHO F UXLD vL HVWH DWULEXLW UROXO GH FUHDWRU DO
WH[WXOXLHURXVFULLWRUvQURPDQXOGHVSUHURPDQURPDQLQGLUHFWvQURPDQXOMXUQDOvQ
URPDQXOHSLVWRODUúLvQWRDW SUR]DSRVWPRGHUQLVW
9 SHUVRQDMQDUDWRUPDUWRUDUHURO QDUDWLY úLIXQF LH GH UHJLHQHILLQGLPSOLFDW
vQFRQIOLFWSHUV,D,,,D
9 SHUVRQDMQDUDWRUPHVDJHUIXQF LHQDUDWLY úLGHUHJLHÄYRFH´QDUDWLY FDUH
UHODWHD] HYHQLPHQWH DX]LWH GH OD XQ DOW SRYHVWLWRU UHODWDUHD OD SHUVRDQD D ,,,D
SUHYDOHD] DVXSUDSHUVRDQHL,
7LSRORJLD SHUVRQDMHORU OLWHUDUH HVWH GHILQLW FDÄUHSUH]HQWDUHFRQYHQ LRQDO D
XQHLFDWHJRULLXPDQHVRFLDOHVDXSVLKRORJLFHvQWUXSDW vQWUXQSHUVRQDMOLWHUDUFDUH
FRQFHQWUHD] DQXPLWHFDUDFWHULVWLFLVWDELOHSHUPDQHQWHGHILQLWRULL0$QJKHOHVFX
'LYHUVLWDWHD WLSRORJLF D HURLORU OLWHUDUL DUH FD SUHPLV GLYHUVLWDWHD WLSXULORU XPDQH
ILLQG vQ DFHODúL WLPS PRWLYDW GH RS LXQLOH HVWHWLFH GLIHULWH DOH ÄúFROLORU OLWHUDUH´ DOH
ILHF UXL VFULLWRU 3HUVRQDMXO WLSRORJLF HVWH HURXO UHSUH]HQWDWLY SHQWUX R ODUJ
FDWHJRULHXPDQ VDXHVWHWLF
9WLSRORJLLOH JHQHUDOXPDQH VXQW FRQILJXUDWH vQF GLQ OLWHUDWXUD $QWLFKLW LL úL
SHUIHF LRQDWH GH FODVLFL HURXO DYDUXO LSRFULWXO IDWD E WUkQ FRFKHWD QDLYXO
YLV WRUXOFXJHW WRUXOHWF
9WLSRORJLLOH VRFLDOH UDQXO VROGDWXO DULVWRFUDWXO EXUJKH]XO SDUYHQLW
LQWHOHFWXDOXO DUWLVWXO HWF VXQW ÄRELHFWXO GH REVHUYD LH´ DO UHDOLúWLORU LDU vQ YHUVLXQL
SDURGLFHDOSRVWPRGHUQLúWLORU
9WLSRORJLLOH HVWHWLFH YL]HD] FDQRQXO LPSXV GH R úFRDO OLWHUDU GH XQ FXUHQW
DVWIHOVHSRDWHYRUELGHVSUHSHUVRQDMXOFODVLFWLSRORJLFSODWVWDWLFVDXGHVSUHHURXO
URPDQWLF DWLSLF FRPSOH[ GLQDPLF GHVSUH SHUVRQDMXO UHDOLVW WLSRORJLF ÄURWXQG´
GLQDPLF RUL GHVSUH FHO PRGHUQ LQGLYLGXDOL]DW GLOHPDWLF FRQWUDGLFWRULX UHODWLYL]DW
HWF ÌQ OLWHUDWXUD VHFROXOXL DO ;;OHD OLWHUDWXUD PRGHUQLVW H[LVWHQ LDOLVW OLWHUDWXUD
DEVXUGXOXL QHRPRGHUQLVW SRVWPRGHUQLVW HURLL QX PDL VXQW FRQVWUXL L FD
LQGLYLGXDOLW L ÄFRHUHQWH´ DYkQG R LGHQWLWDWH YDJ ILLQG VXUSULQúL vQ F XWDUHD VLQHOXL
1RLOH PRGHOH VXQW SHUVRQDMHOH ÄSXOYHUL]DWH´ vQ ÄYRFL´ FDUH vúL FHUWLILF H[LVWHQ D
QXPDL SULQ DFWXO GH OLPEDM VDX UROXUL P úWL SHUVRQDMHOH FRQWUDGLFWRULL ÄFRQWUD
SXQFWLFH´FXGXEO PXOWLSO SHUVRQDOLWDWHÄRPXOI U vQVXúLUL´LQVDEVXUGQRQHURX
SHUVRQDM ÄVXFLW´ EXIRQ QHEXQ SDURGLF HWF ,GHQWLWDWHD WH[WXDO HVWH FRQIHULW SULQ
QRPLQDOL]DUH VLPEROLF VDX ÄGH VHULH´ RUL SULQ DEVHQ D QXPHOXL SULQ UDSRUWDUH OD
SURSULDH[LVWHQ PHPRULDDIHFWLY ODOLPLWHOHH[LVWHQ LDOHODLGHHDGHOLEHUWDWHHWF
$OWHWLSXULGHSHUVRQDMHVXQW
9SHUVRQDMHOH ÄFDUDFWHUH´ SHUVRQDMH XQLWDUH FX WU V WXUL FRPSOH[H IRFDOL]DWH
SHRGRPLQDQW PRUDO GXS PRGHOXOSHUVRQDMHORUEDO]DFLHQH
9SHUVRQDMXO DUKHWLSDO SHUVRQDM FX JUDG PDUH GH FRQYHQ LRQDOLWDWH UHSUH
]HQWkQGXQPRGHORULJLQDUXQHURXH[HPSODUPLWLFOHJHQGDUGHEDVP
9SHUVRQDMXOVLPEROLFHURXGHQDWXU FDWHJRULDO vQYHVWLWFXSXWHUQLFHVHPQL
ILFD LLPRUDOHVDXSVLKRORJLFH
9SHUVRQDMXODOHJRULFYLHW LSODQWHRELHFWHFRQFHSWHSHUVRQLILFDWHFXYDOHQ H
DFFHQWXDWHGHVHPQLILFDUH
9SHUVRQDMSDURGLFSHUVRQDMFRQVWUXLWvQWUXQUHJLVWUXFDULFDWXUDOLURQLFOXGLF
DQWLHURXORPXOÄVXFLW´
3RUWUHWXOOLWHUDU0LMORDFHGHFDUDFWHUL]DUHDSHUVRQDMXOXL
3RUWUHWXO OLWHUDU IU SRUWUDLW ± GHVFULHUH D XQHL SHUVRDQH HVWH XQ SURFHGHX
OLWHUDUúLXQWLSGHGLVFXUVGHVFULSWLYFDUHFRQVW vQSUH]HQWDUHDXQXLSHUVRQDMOLWHUDU
SULQ UHOLHIDUHD HOHPHQWHORU GHILQLWRULL WU V WXUL IL]LFH PRUDOH SVLKLFH PRGHO
FRPSRUWDPHQWDOUDSRUWFXUHDOLWDWHDFXDOWHSHUVRQDMHYL]LXQHDDXFWRULDO VDXFHD
D XQXL SHUVRQDM D XQHL FRPXQLW L DVXSUD OXL VLVWHPXO GH VHPQH VWLOLVWLFH SULQ
FDUH HVWH GHVHPQDW LQGLYLGXOL]DW SHUVRQDMXO Ä3ULQ FDUDFWHUL]DUH D SHUVRQDMXOXL
vQ HOHJHPVLVWHPXOGHPRWLYHOHJDWQHPLMORFLWGHSHUVRQDMXOGDW%RULV7RPDúHYVNL
3RUWUHWXOSRDWHILvQSUR] vQYHUVXULODUHDOL]DUHDOXLVHSRDWHDSHODODRULFDUH
PRGGHH[SXQHUHQDUD LXQHGLDORJPRQRORJ
9 )XQF LLOHSRUWUHWXOXLOLWHUDUVXQW
IXQF LD GH LQIRUPDUH UHIHUHQ LDO VH UHDOL]HD] SULQ HQXPHUDUHD FDUDFWH
ULVWLFLORU FDUH SHUPLW LGHQWLILFDUHD LQGLYLGXDOL]DUHD úL GLIHUHQ LHUHD XQXL
SHUVRQDM IUHFYHQW DFHDVW IXQF LH HVWH DFWLYDW SULQWUXQ SRUWUHW LQL LDO
DVRFLDW SULPHL DSDUL LL vQ VSD LXO ILF LXQLL D SHUVRQDMXOXL ± WLS GH SRUWUHW
LPSXVvQURPDQXOUHDOLVWGH%DO]DF
IXQF LD DQWLFLSDWLY SRUWUHWXO H FRQVWUXLW FD XQ FXPXO GH SUHPLVH FDUH
MXVWLILF HYROX LDHURXOXL
IXQF LD VLPEROLF HVWH DFWLYDW PDL DOHV GH SRUWUHWHOH XQRU SHUVRQDMH FH
VXQWSXUW WRDUHDOHXQRUYDORULHWLFHHVWHWLFHRQWRORJLFHJQRVHRORJLFHSRW
DS UHDvQSRYHVWLULPLWLFHvQQDUD LXQLDOHJRULFHvQSDUDEROH
IXQF LD DVHUWLY HVWH DOHDWRULH H VHPQDOL]DW OD QLYHO WH[WXDO SULQ LQGLFL DL
LPSOLF ULLDIHFWLYHvQGLVFXUVXOSRUWUHWLVWLFFDUHILJXUHD] XQPRGHOXPDQXQ
LGHDORULXQDQWLPRGHO
IXQF LH GH VWUXFWXUDUH D LPDJLQDUXOXL DUWLVWLF SRUWUHWXO SRDWH GHYHQL XQ
PRWLYRUGRQDWRUDOYL]LXQLLFDvQ'RPQLúRDUD&KULVWLQDGH0(OLDGHRULvQ
6 UPDQXO'LRQLVDOOXL(PLQHVFX3RUWUHWXORYDOGH($3RH
IXQF LH GH SDURGLHUH D XQRU FOLúHH SRUWUHWLVWLFH GHVWUXFWXUDUH D XQRU
WRSRVXUL DQWLSRUWUHWHOH OXL 8UPX] ÄLDX QDúWHUH SULQWUR FRQGHQVDUH
FDULFDWXUDO >«@ SRUQLQG GH OD VXJHVWLLOH XQXL QXPH >«@ 3ULQ SURFHGHXO
OHFWXULL OLWHUDOH D LPDJLQLORU úL D PHWDIRUHORU 8UPX] FUHHD] VXEVWDQ D
LPDJLQDU DSHUVRQDMHORU´±&RULQ%UDJD
7LSXULOHGHSRUWUHWOLWHUDUSRWIL
3RUWUHWXO IL]LF HVWH FRQVWUXLW SH R GRPLQDQW H[WHULRDU DFHVW WLS GH SRUWUHW
vQVXPHD] FDUDFWHULVWLFL DOH vQI Lú ULL SHUVRQDMXOXL WU V WXUL OHJDWH GH IL]LRQRPLH
SRDWHGHVFULH LQXWDYHVWLPHQWD LDHWFODQLYHOXOGLVFXUVXOXLWHUPHQLFRQFUH LGHWLS
DQDWRPLFFkPSXULOH[LFDOHFDUHQXPHVFSHUFHS LLVHQ]RULDOH
3RUWUHWXOPRUDOGHWDOLD] FDOLW LOHVXIOHWHúWLGHIHFWHOHWU V WXULOHGHFDUDFWHU
VLVWHPXOGHYDORULSULQFLSLLHWLFHGXS FDUHVHFRQGXFHSHUVRQDMXOVSHFLILFURPDQXOXL
UHDOLVW WUDGL LRQDO ÄGRULF´ 10DQROHVFX Ä3UHSRQGHUHQ D PRUDOXOXL DVXSUD
SVLKRORJLFXOXLVXELHFWXOVHSLHUGHvQRELHFW&DUDFWHULRORJLHWLSLFLWDWH´VHUHDOL]HD]
SULQHQXQ XULFDUHGH]YROW FRQFHSWHHWLFHFDWHJRULLDOHFRQúWLLQ HLúLDOHDIHFWHORU
3RUWUHWXO SVLKLF VXUSULQGH FDUDFWHULVWLFL DOH SHUVRQDOLW LL HURXOXL DSWLWXGLQL
vQQ VFXWH Ä]HVWUHD´ JHQHWLF VDX GREkQGLWH QDWXU LQWURYHUWLW H[WUDYHUWLW
WHPSHUDPHQWLPSXOVLYFROHULFPHODQFROLFH]LWDQWILUHUD LRQDO OXFLG SUDJPDWLF
SDVLRQDO YLV WRDUH úRY LHOQLF FRQWUDGLFWRULH LPSUHYL]LELO JkQGLUH ORJLF
DVRFLDWLY LPDJLQDWLY FUHDWLY SUDFWLF HWF HVWH XWLOL]DW IUHFYHQW vQ SUR]D
PRGHUQ ÄLRQLF ´ vQ FDUH ÄYDORULOH GRPLQDQWH VXQW GH RUGLQ SHUVRQDO $XWHQWLFLWDWH
LQWHULRULWDWH LQWLPLWDWH´ 1 0DQROHVFX WH[WXDOL]DW PDL DOHV SULQ YRFDEXODU DEVWUDFW
WHUPHQL VSHFLDOL]D L VDX QX GLQ VIHUD JkQGLULL D FXQRDúWHULL D SVLKRORJLHL
SVLKDQDOL]HLGLQVIHUDPDQLIHVW ULORUFRPSRUWDPHQWDOH
3RUWUHWXOFRPSOH[PL[WvQVXPHD] WU V WXULIL]LFHWU V WXULGHFDUDFWHUúLGH
SHUVRQDOLWDWH
3URFHGHHGHFDUDFWHUL]DUH
&DUDFWHUL]DUHD GLUHFW HVWH R PRGDOLWDWH FODVLF IRUPDOL]DW PDL DOHV FD
GLVFXUV GHVFULSWLY GH WLS SRUWUHW VH SRDWH UHDOL]D SULQ FRQYHUJHQ D XQRU IRFDOL] UL
SHUVSHFWLYHGLIHULWH
GLQSHUVSHFWLYDQDUDWRUXOXLIRFDOL]DUH]HURVDXH[WHUQ GLVFXUVKHWHURGLHJHWLF
ODSHUVRDQDD,,,D
GLQ SHUVSHFWLYD H[WHUQ D DOWRU SHUVRQDMH RELHFWLY VDX VXELHFWLY GLVFXUV
DGUHVDWVDXQRQDGUHVDWODSHUVRDQDD,,DVDXODSHUVRDQDD,,,DSRDWHFRQGXFHOD
SOXULSHUVSHFWLYLVP LQWUDGLHJHWLF DFHVWH SHUVSHFWLYH PXOWLSOH SRW IL FRQYHUJHQWH
GHWHUPLQkQG XQ SHUVRQDM XQLWDU úL FRHUHQW VDX GLYHUJHQWH DYkQG FD HIHFW
UHODWLYL]DUHDSHUVRQDMXOXLGLVWUXJHUHDFRHUHQ HLSkQ ODÄSXOYHUL]DUHD´SHUVRQDMXOXL
SULQDXWRFDUDFWHUL]DUHSHUVSHFWLY LQWHUQ VXELHFWLY GLVFXUVKRPRGLHJHWLF±
PRQRORJLQWHULRU
&DUDFWHUL]DUHDLQGLUHFW YDORULILF WHKQLFDVXJHVWLHLVSUHDFRQILUPDVDXLQILUPD
FDUDFWHUL]DUHDGLUHFW vQSUR]DFRPSRUWDPHQWLVW HVWHXQLFDPRGDOLWDWHGHVXJHUDUH
DUHOLHIXOXLPRUDOúLSVLKLFDOSHUVRQDMXOXL
SUHQXPHOHSRUHFODFRJQRPHQXO±QLYHOFXPDUHSRWHQ LDOGHVHPQLILFDUH
GHVLPEROL]DUH
PRGHOXO FRPSRUWDPHQWDO IDSWH DWLWXGLQL ID GH YDORULOH H[LVWHQ LDOH UHDF LL
IL]LRORJLFH
FDUDFWHULVWLFL FRJQLWLYH H[SHULHQ H GH FXQRDúWHUH UHSUH]HQW UL LGHL JkQGXUL
GLOHPHPRUDOHHWF
FDUDFWHULVWLFLDOHSHUVRQDOLW LLDFWHGHYRLQ PDQLIHVW ULDOHWHPSHUDPHQWXOXL
LQWHUHVHDSWLWXGLQL
DFWHOH GH FRPXQLFDUH YRUELUH OLPEDM FOLúHH YHUEDOH DFFHQWH ULWP JHVWLF
PLPLF WLFXULQHUYRDVH
UHJLP DIHFWLY úL LQVWLQFWXDO VW UL HPR LRQDOH VHQWLPHQWH DILQLW L WU LUL
HPSDWLFHSHUFHS LLLQVWLQFWH
UDSRUWVXSUDHX±HX±VLQHHXOFRQúWLHQWVXEFRQúWLHQWLQFRQúWLHQWLSRVWD]H
HYROX LH
LGHQWLWDWHDVRFLDO UDSRUWFXUHDOLWDWHDLQWHUDF LXQHFXFHOHODOWHSHUVRQDMH
GHVFULHUHDPHGLXOXLIDPLOLDOVRFLDOGHVFULHULGHLQWHULRUGHVFULHULGHQDWXU FX
UROvQFDUDFWHUL]DUH
&21&(37(63(&,),&(1$5$72/2*,(,
&21&(37 '(),1, ,$ 2%6(59$ ,,(;(03/(
7RWDOLWDWHD UHSUH]HQW ULORU VFULLWRUXOXL ± (VWH UHDOL]DW FX DMXWRUXO WXWXURU
GHVSUHXQLYHUVGHVSUHVWUXFWXULDOHH[LVWHQ HL VWUXFWXULORU RSHUHL WHPH PRWLYH
úLFRQGL LDXPDQ GHVSUHGHVWLQXOFUHD LHLúL VXELHFW SHUVRQDMH VWUXFWXUL QDUDWLYH
DO DUWLVWXOXL DYkQG ILQDOLWDWH FRJQLWLY úL GUDPDWLFH VDX OLULFH LPDJLQL DUWLVWLFH
HVWHWLF vQRSHUDOLWHUDU WURSL
ODWVWUXFWXUD±FRQVWUXF LH
0RGDOLWDWH GH FRQILJXUDUH D XQLYHU
VXOXL ILF LRQDO GXS R ORJLF DUWLVWLF ± *UDGXO GH FRPSOH[LWDWH D VWUXFWXUL
LQWHUQ GHWHUPLQkQGSRODUL]DUHDXQHLXQRU ORU QDUDWLYH HVWH HOHPHQW GH GLIHUHQ
DULL WHPDWLFH úL D XQHL UH HOH GH PRWLYH SH LHUHvQWUHVSHFLL
XQXOVDXPDLPXOWHSODQXULDFHVWHDSRWIL SUR]D VFXUW IDEXOD VFKL D DQHF
±SODQQDUDWLYvQFDUHVHFULVWDOL]HD] XQILU GRWD EDVPXO SRHPXO EDODGD VH
HSLF XQ ÄGHVHQ´ HSLF DOF WXLW GLQ ILUH VWUXFWXUHD] SHXQVLQJXUSODQQDUDWLY
HSLFH SODQ ÄVXSUDHWDMDW´ H GLQDPL]DW GH vQ FDUH VH VFKL HD] úL XQ FURQRWRS
FRQWH[WVLWXD LRQDODODF LXQLLUHGXVOD
XQXOVDXPDLPXOWHFRQIOLFWH UHSHUHVFKHPDWLFHFRQYHQ LRQDOH
±SODQDQDOLWLFvQFDUHVHGHWDOLD] XQLYHUVXO SUR]DQXYHOLVWLF VHVWUXFWXUHD]
O XQWULF DO HURLORU FRQúWLHQW VXEFRQúWLHQW vQQXYHO SHGRX SODQXUL
LQFRQúWLHQWSVLKRORJLDWU LULOHUHIOHF LLOH ± QXYHOD LVWRULF DO WXU SODQXOXL
GLOHPHOH OD QLYHOXO UD LXQLL DO FRQúWLLQ HL DO QDUDWLY XQ SODQFDGUX vQ FDUH VH
DIHFWHORUFRQIOLFWHLQWHULRDUH VFKL HD] XQWDEORXGHHSRF
±SODQHVHLVWLFDOFRPHQWDULLORUQDUDWRUXOXL ± QXYHOD IDQWDVWLF DVRFLD] GRX
DO DVHU LXQLORU VDOH DO DVRFL LLORU OLEHUH GH SODQXUL QDUDWLYH XQXO DO UHDOXOXL DOWXO
LGHLDOGLYDJD LLORU DO LUHDOXOXL DO IDQWDVWLFXOXL FDUH
±SODQFDGUXSODQPRQRJUDILFFDUHvQVX IX]LRQHD] vQILQDO
± QXYHOD SVLKRORJLF VH FRQVWUX
PHD] PDFURVWUXFWXUL DOH XQLYHUVXOXL LHúWH SULQ DOWHUQDQ D vQWUH SODQXO
ILF LRQDOUHSHUHVSD LRWHPSRUDOHHOHPHQWH HYHQLPHQ LDO úL SODQXO DQDOLWLF DO
GHILQLWRULLDOHXQHLVRFLHW LFODVHHWF FRQúWLLQ HLDOSVLKLFXOXL
± SODQXO DXFWRULDO SRDWH GXEOD SODQXULOH URPDQXODUHRVWUXFWXU FRPSOH[
FRQILJXUDWH vQ WH[W vQGHSOLQLQG IXQF LLOH DG XJkQG SODQXULORU QDUDWLYH XQ SODQ
PHWDWH[WXOXL DQDOLWLFúLXQXOPRQRJUDILF&3HWUHVFX
WLSDU SDUDGLJP PDWULFH FDUH JHQH FRQVWUXLHúWH úL XQ SODQ DXFWRULDO
UHD] R VFKHP R UH HD LQWHUQ D L]RODWvQQRWHOHGHVXEVRO
HOHPHQWHORU HVHQ LDOH DOH WH[WXOXL OLWHUDU
Y ]XWFDXQÄFRUSXV
IUFRPSRVLWLRQ ± DVDPEODUH D S U LORU XQXL
vQWUHJ
0RG GH RUJDQL]DUH LQWHUQ D WH[WXOXL
UHIOHFWDWvQ ± /HJLOH FODVLFH DOH FRPSR]L LHL VXQW
± DOF WXLUHD IRUPDO D RSHUHL YROXPH DOH ED]DWH SH HFKLOLEUX DUPRQLH VLPH
XQXL FLFOX S U L FDSLWROH HSLVRDGH QDUD WULHFLUFXODULWDWHFURQRORJLH
WLYHVHFYHQ H ± ÌQ SUR]D PRGHUQ SULQFLSLXO FRP
SR]L LRQDO DO FURQRORJLHL HVWH vQORFXLW
± IRUPXOD QDUDWLY WLSDUXO HSLF ÄSRYHVWL FX FHO DO PHPRULHL LQYROXQWDUH
UHD vQ SRYHVWLUH SRYHVWLUHD vQ UDP DIHFWLYH FX WHKQLFD SDUDOHOLVPXOXL
MXUQDOXOFRPHQWDWHWF HSLF D VLPXOWDQHLW LL D GLVFRQWLQXL
± SULQFLSLLOH FRPSR]L LRQDOH FULWHULLOH GH W LL D FRODMXOXL D GHFXSDMXOXL D
RUJDQL]DUH D WH[WXOXL H[ RUJDQL]DUHD vQ FRQWUDSXQFWXOXLDSOD\EDFNXOXLHWF
FURQRORJLH OLQHDU vQ VLPXOWDQHLWDWH vQ
GLVFRQWLQXLWDWH D HYHQLPHQWHORU WHKQLFL
QDUDWLYHULWPXOHSLFVWUDWHJLLGLVFXUVLYH
02'85,'((;381(5(
ODWQDUUDWLR±SRYHVWLUHLVWRULVLUH
0RG GH H[SXQHUH GH RUJDQL]DUH WH[
WXDO FRQVWkQGvQUHODWDUHDXQRUHYHQLPHQ ± (VWH IXQGDPHQWDO vQ HSLFD WUDGL
WH vQWUR VXFFHVLXQH GH VHFYHQ H WHPSRUDOH LRQDO
VWUXFWXU VLQWDJPDWLF ± ÌQ RSHUD PRGHUQ vúL SLHUGH UHOH
± vQVXPHD] ÄIDEXOD´ ÄSRYHVWHD´ ÄLVWRULD´ YDQ DGHYHQLQGDGHVHDXQSUHWH[W
úLUXO GH vQWkPSO UL úL ÄGLVFXUVXO´ WH[WXO 1DUD LXQHDFDGLVFXUVFXSULQGH
PRGDOLW LOHQDU ULL ± QXFOHHOH QDUDWLYH HSLVRDGH HYHQL
PHQWH
±FDWHJRULLOHQDUD LXQLLOLWHUDUHVXQW ± LQGLFLL GHVFULHUHD SHUVRQDMHORU D
WLPSXOSRYHVWLULLDOGLVFXUVXOXL FDGUXOXLúLDÄRELHFWHORU´
DVSHFWHOH QDUD LXQLL PRGXO vQ FDUH VH ±FDWDOL]HOHGHVI úXUDUHDIDSWHORU
UDSRUWHD] QDUDWRUXOODGLVFXUV ±LQIRUPD LLOHFXUROGHDVLWXDDF LXQHDvQ
PRGDOLW LOH QDUD LXQLL PRGXO vQ FDUH WLPSúLVSD LXFRQWH[WXOXLVLWXD LRQDO
QDUDWRUXO H[SXQH IDEXOD SULQ UHSUH]HQWDUH ±SHUVRQDMHOHDFWDQ LLGXS 5%DUWKHV
GLDORJ PRQRORJ SULQ UHODWDUH QDUD LXQH
KHWHURGLHJHWLF VDXKRPRGLHJHWLF 7]7RGRURY
&DWHJRULLOHQDUD LXQLLOLWHUDUH
± Ä2 VHFYHQ GH VXSUDID FDUH VH
ODWGHVFULSWLR±]XJU YLUH RSXQH GLDORJXOXL SRYHVWLULL HWF´ $ -
0RGGHH[SXQHUHVHFYHQ WH[WXDO FX *UHLPDV
URO GH SDX] QDUDWLY FRQVWkQG vQ VXEVWLWXL ±VXVSHQG WHPSRUDOLWDWHDILLQGVWUXFWX
UHD GLVFXUVXOXL GLHJHWLF FX XQ GLVFXUV UDW PDL DOHV VSD LDO úL VLQFURQLF
ODWFRQIOLFWXV FLRFQLUHúRF ± &RQIOLFWH H[WHULRDUH GH LGHL GH
6WUXFWXU WH[WXDO VSHFLILF RSHUHL HSLFH LQWHUHVHHFRQRPLFVRFLDOSROLWLFPRUDO
GUDPDWLFH GHVHPQkQG OLQLLOH GH IRU DOH UHOLJLRVHWQLFHURWLFH[LVWHQ LDOHWF
DF LXQLL vQWUH FDUH VH LQVWLWXLH R RSR]L LH R ± FRQIOLFWH LQWHULRDUH GH QDWXU PR
WHQVLXQHFXIXQF LHGHFDWDOL] UDO SVLKRORJLF YROLWLY LQWHOHFWXDO
± GH]DFRUG vQWUH LQWHUHVH IDSWH FDUDFWHUH FRJQLWLY FUL] GH LGHQWLWDWH GHYDORUL
SHUVRQDMHSULQFLSLLLGHLSDVLXQLFDUHJHQHUHD FUL] GH FRQúWLLQ FUL] H[LVWHQ LDO
] VLWXD LDFRQIOLFWXDO úLPRWLYHD] DF LXQHD HWF
6HFYHQ WH[WXDO GH PD[LP WHQVLXQH D ± ÌQ Ä0LRUL D´ QX H[LVW XQ SXQFW
FXOPLQDQW vQ UHJLVWUXO HSLF FL XQ
FRQIOLFWXOXL vQ FDUH HYROX LD XOWHULRDU D PRPHQWGHWHQVLXQHPD[LP vQUHJLVWUXO
SHUVRQDMHORUHVWHJUHXSUHYL]LELO OLULFFHOHEUDDOHJRULH
LWVFKL]]DUH DFUHLRQDIXJLWLY
)RUPDFHDPDLFRQFHQWUDW GHQDUD LXQH ¾ 6LQRQLPFX³PRPHQWXO´&DUDJLDOH
vQ SUR] DYkQG XQ QXP U UHGXV GH SHUVR ¾ $F LXQH OLQHDU FRPSR]L LH ULJXURV
QDMHLQVWDQWDQHXHSLFFXDF LXQHHSLVRGLF GLULMDW VSUHGH]QRG PkQWVWLOFRQFLV
VLPSWRPDWLF ¾ 6HOHFWHD] YHULGLFXO VHPQLILFDWLYXO úL
6XUSULQGH XQ VLQJXU HSLVRG GLQ H[LVWHQ D WLSRORJLFXO
SHUVRQDMHORU
ODWIDEXOD SRYHVWLUH ¾3HUVRQDMHOH VXQW DQLPDOH SODQWH
6XFFHVLXQHD GH IDSWH DQHFGRWLFD OXFUXULSXVHvQVLWXD LLRPHQHúWL
IDEXOD LDGLQFDUHVHFRQVWLWXLHDF LXQHDXQHL ¾3RDWH IL vQ SUR] VDX vQ YHUVXUL
RSHUHOLWHUDUH DGHVHDHVWHGUDPDWL]DW
¾$UH FDUDFWHU PRUDOL]DWRU VDWLUL]kQG
6SHFLH D JHQXOXL HSLF VFXUW QDUD LXQH
DQXPLWHWU V WXULGHFDUDFWHUVDXIRUPH
DOHJRULF GHFRPSRUWDPHQW
IUQRXYHOOHLWQRYHOOD QRXWDWHQXYHO ¾&ODVLILFDUH URPDQWLF UHDOLVW
1DUD LXQH vQ SUR] FX XQ VLQJXU ILU QDWXUDOLVW LVWRULF IDQWDVWLF
ILORVRILF SVLKRORJLF DQHFGRWLF
HSLFIDEXODWLY XUP ULQG XQ FRQIOLFW XQLF ¾$UH IUHFYHQW XQ FDUDFWHU RELHFWLY
FRQFHQWUDWúLRLQWULJ ULJXURVFRQVWUXLW SUH]HQWkQGIDSWHYHURVLPLOHWHQGLQ GH
SHUVRQDMHSXWHUQLFFRQWXUDWH RELHFWLYDUH
IUURPDQ ¾ &ODVLILFDUHPHGLHYDOURPDQWLFEDURF
1DUD LXQH vQ SUR] GH PDUH vQWLQGHUH FX UHDOLVW QDWXUDOLVW PRGHUQ URPDQIUHVF
DF LXQH FRPSOH[ GHVI úXUDW SH PDL HSRSHLF URPDQFURQLF LVWRULF VDX GH
PXOWH SODQXUL FX LQWULJ FRPSOLFDW FX IDPLOLH SVLKRORJLF LQWHOHFWXDO DOHJRULF
IDQWDVWLF PLWLF DEVXUG VDWLULF SDURGLF
SHUVRQDMHQXPHURDVH
HSLVWRODU URPDQXO FRPSRUWDPHQWLVW DPH
Ä5RPDQXO H XQ VXEVWLWXW DO PRU LL YUHD V ULFDQ URPDQMXUQDO URPDQSDUDERO
IL[H]H XQ GHVWLQ«5RPDQXO D vQORFXLW LGHHD URPDQHVHX6)DQWLURPDQXOHWF
GH HWHUQLWDWH 5RPDQXO PRGHUQ H R FUHD LH ¾ VWUXFWXULOH úL SHUVSHFWLYHOH QDUDWLYH
FDUH VH IRORVHúWH GH R SRYHVWLUH SHQWUX D VXQW IRDUWH GLYHUVH GH OD ÄSXQFWXO GH
H[SULPD DOWFHYD (O FRQWLQX V UHSUH]LQWH YHGHUH RPQLVFLHQW´ WUDGL LRQDO OD QDUD
WRWDOLWDWHD RPXOXL PRGHUQ´ 50$OEpUqV LXQHD LPSHUVRQDO FRPSRUWDPHQWLVW
,VWRULDURPDQXOXLPRGHUQ RUL PHGLDW GH FRQúWLLQ D XQXLSHUVRQDM
GH OD FURQRORJLH OD PHWDPRUIR]H DOH
WLPSXOXL GH OD WRSRV UHDO OD DOHJRUL]D
UHDVSD LXOXLHWF
IUHVVDL vQFHUFDUH ¾ WHUPHQ SXV vQ FLUFXOD LH GH 0RQWDLJQH
&UHD LH ÄGH JUDQL ´ FRQ LQkQG GLYHUVH ³(VHXUL´ vQ OLWHUDWXUD URPkQ $O
UHIOHF LL vQWUR vQO Q XLUH VXELHFWLY GH PDUH 2GREHVFX³3VHXGRN\QHJKHWLNRV´
OLEHUWDWHDVRFLDWLY ¾ ©2SHU DSDU LQkQG XQXL ÄJHQ VHPLOL
WHUDU´ OD LQWHUVHF LD VWUXFWXULORU LPDJLV
)RUP GH QRWD LH D XQRU REVHUYD LL
WLFHúLLGHRORJLFHRLQWHUIHUHQ GHOLULVP
SHUVRQDOH FX FDUDFWHU UHIOH[LY FX R GHSOLQ úLUHIOH[LHª$0DULQR
OLEHUWDWHDDVRFLD LLORUúLDIRUPHL
02'(/('($1$/,= 67,/,67,&
D Ä*ODVXO S PkQWXOXL S WUXQGHD Q YDOQLF vQ VXIOHWXO IO F XOXL FD R FKHPDUH
FRSOHúLQGXO6HVLP HDPLFúLVODEFkWXQYLHUPHSHFDUHOFDOFLvQSLFLRDUHVDXFDR
IUXQ] SHFDUHYkQWXORYkOWRUHúWHFXPvLSODFH6XVSLQ SUHOXQJXPLOLWúLvQIULFRúDW
vQID DXULDúXOXL©±&kWS PkQW'RDPQH«ªÌQDFHODúLWLPSvQV «VHVLP HDDWkW
GHSXWHUQLFvQFkWV GRPQHDVF SHVWHWRWFXSULQVXO´/LYLX5HEUHDQX,RQ
)UDJPHQWXO DSDU LQH FDSLWROXOXL DO ,,OHD =YkUFROLUHD WLWOX VLPSWRPDWLF SHQWUX
GLOHPD VXIOHWHDVF D OXL ,RQ 3ULQ WHKQLFD GLVSXQHULL DQWLQRPLFH D XQRU VFHQHFKHLH
PHWRGD PRGHUQ D FRQWUDSXQFWXOXL DFHVW HSLVRG DUH R ÄSHUHFKH FRQVWUXLW SULQ
VLPHWULHLQYHUV vQFDSLWROXODO,;OHD6 UXWDUHDFkQG,RQVHVLPWHFDXQXULDúFDUHD
ELUXLWEDODXUXO7H[WXOFLWDWDUHIXQF LHGHFDUDFWHUL]DUHVXUSULQ]kQGHURXOSULQFLSDOvQ
UHOD LD VD FRPSOH[ FX S PkQWXO $FHVWD DSDUH FD R ]HLWDWH vQ ID D F UHLD RPXO
WU LHúWH VHQWLPHQWXO QLPLFQLFLHL 7U LULOH O XQWULFH DOH HURXOXL VXQW HYLGHQ LDWH GLQ
SHUVSHFWLYD QDUDWRUXOXL RPQLVFLHQW FDUH VXUSULQGH UHDF LLOH VXIOHWHúWL DQWLWHWLFH
'HWDOLHUHD DFHVWRUD VH UHDOL]HD] SULQ FRPSDUD LL FX VLPEROXUL VHOHFWDWH GLQ SODQXO
QDWXULLILJXUkQGGHUL]RULXOúLHIHPHULWDWHDYLHUPHIUXQ] SULQHSLWHWXOGXEOXPLFúL
VODEXPLOLWúLvQIULFRúDWSULQPHWDIRUDSHUVRQLILFDWRDUHJODVXOS PkQWXOXLXULDúXO
3ULPD PHWDIRU FDUH G úL WLWOXO S U LL vQWkL DUH IXQF LH GHILQLWRULH SHQWUX RUL]RQWXO
LQWHULRUDOSURWDJRQLVWXOXLÄ9RFHD´FDUHYLQHGLQDGkQFLPLLQVRQGDELOHDOHLQFRQúWLHQ
WXOXL FROHFWLY GHILQHúWH DUKHWLSXO Ä3 WUXQ]kQG Q YDOQLF vQ VXIOHWXO IO F XOXL FD R
FKHPDUHFRSOHúLQGXO´HDDSDUHFDRYRFHDIDWDOLW LLDXQXLGHVWLQSXVVXEVHPQXO
K\EULVXOXL &KHPDUHD S PkQWXOXL PDL SXWHUQLF GHFkW FHD D LXELULL PRGHOHD]
FRPSRUWDPHQWXO úL RS LXQLOH OXL ,RQ 6XVSLQXO ÄXPLOLW úL vQIULFRúDW´ H[SULP QX QXPDL
FRQúWLLQ D QLPLFQLFLHL XPDQH vQ UDSRUW FX GLYLQXO úL FX S PkQWXO ULGLFDW OD UDQJ GH
GLYLQLWDWH FL úL XQ WUDJLF SUHVHQWLPHQW DO IDWDOLW LL $FHVWD YD IL vQV DQXODW GH
vQILRUDUHD RUJROLRDV D RPXOXL FDUH SULQ JHVWXO ULWXDOLF DO U VWXUQ ULL EUD]GHL DUH
VHQWLPHQWXOL]EkQ]LLDOSXWHULLVDOHGHDVFKLPEDID DS PkQWXOXL7RDWHDFHVWHWU LUL
DOH SHUVRQDMXOXL VXQW GHVFULVH vQWUXQ OLPEDM IDPLOLDU FXYLQWH GLQ YRFDEXODUXO
IXQGDPHQWDO vQF UFDW vQV GH R VXUSULQ] WRDUH SRH]LH L]YRUkW GLQ VHQWLPHQWXO
DXWHQWLFDOQDWXULLúLGLQFXQRDúWHUHDILULLXPDQH
E3DUDOHO vQWUHSHUVRQDMHOLWHUDUH
0RDUDFXQRURF
GH,RDQ6ODYLFL
3UH]HQ H LQGLVSHQVDELOH vQ VSD LXO HSLF VDX vQ FHO VFHQLF SHUVRQDMHOH OLWHUDUH
VXQW LQVWDQ H QDUDWLYH SULQ FDUH VFULLWRUXO WUDQVILJXUHD] DUWLVWLF GLYHUVH WLSXUL úL
LSRVWD]H XPDQH )LLQ HOH LPDJLQDWH GH DXWRUXO HSLF VDX GUDPDWLF GHYLQ DFWDQ L DL
vQWkPSO ULORU FDUH DOF WXLHVF VXELHFWXO RSHUHL $VWIHO vQ XQLYHUVXO ILF LRQDO DO RSHUHL
SULQGYLD ÄILLQ HGHKkUWLH´5%DUWKHVDFWDQ LL$-*UHLPDVDFWRULL-/LQWYHOW
HURLL0%DKWLQ-/LQWYHOWÌQWUHSHUVRQDMHOHGLYHUVHDOHRSHUHLVHLQVWLWXLHRUH HD
GH UHOD LL FDUH GHWHUPLQ VWUXFWXUL GH WLSXO FXSOXOXL VDX DO WULXQJKLXOXL $VHPHQHD
VWUXFWXULRUJDQL]HD] XQLYHUVXOGLHJHWLFúLvQQXYHODÄ0RDUDFXQRURF´GH,RDQ6ODYLFL
3XEOLFDW vQYROXPXOÄ1RYHOHGLQSRSRU´Ä0RDUDFXQRURF´HVWHRQXYHO
GH DQDOL] SVLKRORJLF úL GH SUREOHPDWLF PRUDO FDUH VH vQVFULH vQ HVWHWLFD
UHDOLVPXOXL SULQ LPDJLQHD YHULGLF D XQHL OXPL GH VIkUúLW GH YHDF DO ;,;OHD SULQ
REVHUYD LD VRFLDO PLQX LRDV úL SULQ FRPSOH[LWDWHD SHUVRQDMHORU $FHVWHD VXQW
VXUSULQVHSUHGRPLQDQWGLQSHUVSHFWLYDXQXLQDUDWRURPQLVFLHQWIRFDOL]DUH]HURGDU
úLGLQDOWHSHUVSHFWLYH±H[WHUQH±DOHFHORUODO LDFWDQ L
7HPD GHJUDG ULL XPDQH SURYRFDWH GH SDWLPD vQDYX LULL IRFDOL]HD] GLVFXUVXO
QDUDWLYDVXSUDOXL*KL SHUVRQDMFRPSOH[úLGLOHPDWLFFDUHDUHUROXOSURWDJRQLVWXOXL
&HDGHDGRXDWHP FHDDGHVWLQXOXLvORSXQHOXL/LF 6 P G XODQWDJRQLVWXOFDUH
H[HUFLW DVXSUD VD R VWUDQLH IDVFLQD LH D U XOXL $úDGDU SULQFLSDOXO FXSOX GH
SHUVRQDMH DO QXYHOHL HVWH GH WLS FRQIOLFWXDO RSXQkQGXO SH *KL FL]PDUXO FDUH D
DUHQGDW KDQXO Ä0RDUD FX QRURF´ OXL /LF SRUFDUXO FDUH VW SkQHúWH SULQ IRU SXVWD
DU GDQ 7LWOXOQXYHOHLIL[HD] SULQFLSDOXOUHSHUVSD LDODODF LXQLLúLvQDFHODúLWLPS
XQPRWLYOLWHUDUIUHFYHQWvQSUR]DURPkQHDVF KDQXOÄ0RDUDFXQRURF´HVWHQXPHOH
KDQXOXL DúH]DW OD U VFUXFH GH GUXPXUL ILJXUkQG U VSkQWLD FH ÄvQWRDUFH´ GHVWLQXO
HURLORU VSUH ]RGLD WUDJLFXOXL VFKLPEkQG ÄOLQLúWHD FROLEHL´ vQ ]EXFLXP QHIHULFLUH
vQVLQJXUDUH WU GDUH úLPRDUWHÄ1RURFXO´OXL*KL VHGRYHGHúWHHIHPHUúLvQúHO WRU
LVSLW VFRDV vQ FDOHD RPXOXL VODE $F LXQHD QXYHOHL HVWH VLWXDW vQWUXQ VSD LX
JHRJUDILF UHDO vQ SXVWD DU GHDQ )XQGXUHQL ,QHX 2UDGHD VXQW WRSRQLPLFH UHDOH
vQWUR]RQ GHU VFUXFHV OEDWLF SOLQ GHPLVWHU'HVFULHUHDORFXULORUFDS,,HVWH
PDUFDW GHVLPEROXULWKDQDWLFHFXUROSUHPRQLWRULX$F LXQHDVHGHVI úRDU SHGXUDWD
XQXLDQ³$QXOWUHFXW3DúWLOHF ]XVHU WRFPDLvQWLPSXOPXW ULLORUOD0RDUDFXQRURF´
7LPSXO UHDO RELHFWLY HVWH FRQVHPQDW ODFRQLF Ä«DVWIHO WUHFX WRDPQD úL YHQL LDUQD
WUHFXúLLDUQDúLVRVLSULP YDUD´&DúLVSD LXOvQFDUHVHvQWkOQHVFORFXOELQHFXYkQWDW
úLORFXOÄU X´FDWHJRULDWLPSXOXLHVWHúLHDGXEOXYDORUL]DW Ä6 SW PkQLLOXPLQDWH´vL
FRUHVSXQGH FRQWUDSXQFWLF R GXUDW PDOHILF XQ WLPS VLPEROLF DO ÄWkU]LXOXL´ HUD
WkU]LXvQWUXQWkU]LXWkU]LXGXS PLH]XOQRS LL1XvQWkPSO WRUMDIXOFULPDWU GDUHD
XFLGHUHD $QHL úL VLQXFLGHUHD VH SHWUHF QRDSWHD vQWUXQ WLPS DO VWLKLLORU GH]O Q XLWH
&RQVHFLQ HOHQHIDVWHSHFDUHVHWHDGHvPERJ LUHOHDUHDVXSUDIRQGXOXLVXIOHWHVFúL
PRUDO DO RPXOXL DVXSUD GHVWLQXOXL V X VXQW XUP ULWH SULQWUXQ GHVHQ HSLF GH PDUH
WHQVLXQH6LWXD LDLQL LDO VXUSULQGHQHPXO XPLUHDOXL*KL ID GHFRQGL LDVDVRFLDO
6 U FLD SUH XLW GH VRDFUD VD SHQWUX SXWHUHD PLUDFXORDV GH D PHQ LQH HFKLOLEUXO
VXIOHWHVF DO RPXOXL GHYLQH SHQWUX *KL FL]PDUXO PRWLY GH SXWHUQLFH IU PkQW UL
GkQGXL XQ VHQWLPHQW GH LQIHULRULWDWH (O LGHQWLILF V U FLD FX OLSVD GH GHPQLWDWH úL
GRUHúWHV VHvPERJ HDVF SHQWUXDRIHULIDPLOLHLRH[LVWHQ PDLEXQ úLSHQWUXDIL
UHVSHFWDW ÌQ FLXGD UH]HUYHORU H[SULPDWH GH VRDFUD VD KRW U úWH V DEDQGRQH]H
ÄOLQLúWHD FROLEHL VDOH´ úL V LD vQ DUHQG FkUFLXPD GH OD 0RDUD FX QRURF /D vQFHSXW
WRWXOPHUJHELQHúLIDPLOLDSURVSHU 'DUvQOXPHDvQFDUHvúLGRUHúWHV ILHQXVOXJ
FL VW SkQ *KL VH FRQIUXQW FX /LF 6 P G XO VW SkQXO WHPXW DO DFHVWRU ORFXUL
$SDUL LD OD KDQ D V P G XOXL FRQVWLWXLH PRPHQWXO LQWULJ GHFODQúkQG FRQIOLFWXO úL
vQWUHDJD GHVI úXUDUH D DF LXQLL $VWIHO vQ FDSLWROXO DO ,,,OHD VH FRQVWLWXLH FXSOXO GH
SHUVRQDMHFDUHLDvQF GHODvQFHSXWIRUPDXQHLVWUXFWXULFRQIOLFWXDOH$QDQHYDVWD
OXL *KL FX XQ VLP IHPLQLQ FDUDFWHULVWLF LQWXLHúWH F /LF HVWH ÄRP U X úL
SULPHMGLRV´ ÌQ VLQHD OXL úL *KL DUH DFHHDúL E QXLDO GDU vQ HOHJH FD SHQWUX D
U PkQH OD 0RDUD FX QRURF WUHEXLH V GHYLQ RPXO V P G XOXL &RQIOLFWXO SVLKR
ORJLF VH DPSOLILF WUHSWDW SH P VXU FH *KL LQWU vQ PHFDQLVPXO QHFUX WRU DO
DIDFHULORU QHFLQVWLWH DOH OXL /LF 0RPHQWH GH PDUH WHQVLXQH VXQW FHOH vQ FDUH HVWH
MHIXLW DUHQGDúXO úL HVWH XFLV IHPHLD vQ QHJUX úL FRSLOXO HL 3URFHVXO OD FDUH *KL
GHSXQHP UWXULHIDOV FRQWULEXLQGODFRQGDPQDUHDOXL6 LO %RDUXOúL%X] 5XSW vQ
ORFXO OXL /LF UHSUH]LQW PRPHQWXO FKHLH FDUH PDUFKHD] GHILQLWLYD UXSWXU vQ
FRQúWLLQ D HURXOXL $FXP VH PRGLILF UHOD LD GLQWUH DQWDJRQLVW úL SURWDJRQLVW LDU
SU EXúLUHDOXL*KL HVWHLQHYLWDELO 6W SkQLWGHVHWHDGHEDQL*KL VHYDvQVWU LQD
WUHSWDW GH $QD úL VH YD O VD PDQHYUDW GH /LF GHYHQLQGXL FRPSOLFH 7HQVLXQHD
GUDPDWLF VH DPSOLILF QHP VXUDW IDSWHOH VH SUHFLSLW VSUH SXQFWXO FXOPLQDQW ÌQ
GXPLQLFD 3DúWHOXL *KL vL vQWLQGH R FXUV OXL /LF KRW UkQG V O GHD SULQV
MDQGDUPXOXL 3LQWHD 2UELW GH JHOR]LH úL GH GRULQ D U ]EXQ ULL SOHDF GXS MDQGDUP
GDUODvQWRDUFHUHvQ HOHJHF úLDGLVWUXVLUHPHGLDELOF VQLFLD'H]QRG PkQWXODGXFH
UH]ROYDUHD FRQIOLFWHORU SULQ PRDUWHD HURLORU FD vQ WUDJHGLD DQWLF ,QWUDWH VXE ]RGLD
XQHL VWUDQLL IDWDOLW L GHFODQúDWH GH YLQD WUDJLF SHUVRQDMHOH FH DOF WXLHVF FXSOXO úL
DSRL³WULXQJKLXO´GHIRU DOWH[WXOXLWUHFPDUJLQLOHUD LXQLLvQVSUHSDVLXQHDSDUR[LVWLF
úL GH DFROR vQ PRDUWH *KL vúL XFLGH VR LD úL HVWH OD UkQGXO OXL XFLV GH 5 X GLQ
SRUXQFDOXL/LF 2UJROLRVSkQ ODFDS WDFHVWDQXVH³G SULQV´OXL3LQWHDúLDOHJH
VLQXFLGHUHDL]ELQGXVHFXFDSXOGHXQVWHMDU+DQXOORFXODúH]DWVLPEROLFODKRWDUXO
GLQWUH%LQHúL5 XHVWHSXULILFDWSULQIRF,PDJLQHD³RDVHORUDOEHLHúLQGSHLFLSHFROR
GLQFHQXúDJURDV ´GHYLQHVLPERODOLGHLLF QLPHQLQXHPDLSUHVXVGHOHJHDPRUDO
úLF vQF OFDUHDDFHVWHLFRQGL LLHVHQ LDOHDH[LVWHQ HLOXPLLVHSO WHúWHFXYLD D
'HD OXQJXO FHORU FDSLWROH I U WLWOX FDUH DOF WXLHVF QXYHOD úLUXO vQWkP
SO ULORU HVWH XUP ULW vQ VXFFHVLXQH FURQRORJLF úL GHWHUPLQ GRX SODQXUL ILHFDUH
GLQDPL]DWGHXQFRQIOLFW3ODQXOUHDOLW LLH[WHULRDUHHVWHXQSODQQDUDWLYvQFDUHVH
DFXPXOHD] vQWkPSO UL úLPRPHQWHGH PDUH WHQVLXQH$LFLHVWHVXUSULQV H[LVWHQ D
VRFLDO D HURLORU FDUH OH LQIOXHQ HD] IHQRPHQRORJLD YLH LL VXIOHWHúWL $O GRLOHD SODQ
HVWHGHWLSDQDOLWLFSODQXOLQWHULRUvQFDUHVXQWXUP ULWHGLOHPHOHPRUDOHúLPLúF ULOH
VXIOHWHúWL FH PRWLYHD] DFWHOH SHUVRQDMHORU &HOH GRX SODQXUL VXQW vQ HFKLOLEUX OD
vQFHSXW FkQG *KL UHVSHFW FRGXO HWLF DO FROHFWLYLW LL úL DS U YDORULOH PRUDOH
vQFHUFkQGV VHvPSRWULYHDVF GHPQOXL/LF &XUkQGvQV VHLQVWDOHD] XQSXWHUQLF
FRQIOLFWH[WHULRUvQWUH*KL úLV P G XJHQHUDWQXQXPDLGHLQWHUHVHPDWHULDOHFL
úL GH R FRQIUXQWDUH D RUJROLLORU E UE WHúWL 3H SODQ LQWHULRU VH SURGXFH R JUDY
VFLQGDUHO XQWULF GHWHUPLQDW GHXQFRQIOLFWPRUDOvQWUHYDORULOHHWLFHSHFDUHúLD
VSULMLQLW SkQ DFXP H[LVWHQ D *KL úL LVSLWD U XOXL F UHLD QXL SRDWH UH]LVWD úL
SVLKRORJLF UD LXQH SDVLXQH FDUH RSXQH GRULQ HL GH D U PkQH RP FLQVWLW VHWHD
PHUHX PDL DU] WRDUH GH vPERJ LUH 9LD D O XQWULF D FHORU GRL HURL FDUH DOF WXLHVF
FXSOXOSULQFLSDOGHSHUVRQDMHHVWHXUP ULW SULQSURFHGHHDOHDQDOL]HLSVLKRORJLFH
DGHFYDW PRWLY ULL VRFLDOH úL SVLKRORJLFH D GUDPHL QDUDWH 7HKQLFLOH SULQ FDUH VXQW
VXUSULQVHVHLVPHOHO XQWULFHDOHSHUVRQDMHORUVXQWGLYHUVHGHODDFXPXODUHDOHQW D
IDSWHORU OD GHVFULHUHD FHORU PDL ILQH PXWD LL VXIOHWHúWL GH OD QRWDUHD UHDF LLORU
IL]LRORJLFH OD PRQRORJXO LQWHULRU úL GLDORJXO FRQIOLFWXDO OD LQVWLWXLUHD XQXL DFRUG vQWUH
FUL]DVXIOHWHDVF úLFDGUXOQDWXUDO
6XUSULQ]kQG YLD D úL PRUDYXULOH XQHL OXPL 6ODYLFL vúL FUHHD] FHOH GRX
SHUVRQDMH PDVFXOLQH VXE VHPQXO FRPSOH[LW LL SVLKLFH úL DO UHOD LLORU VRFLDOH
YHURVLPLOHÄ(YROX LDSHUVRQDMXOXLHSUH]HQWDW GLQWURSHUVSHFWLY UHDOLVWSVLKRORJLF
9L]LXQHD GH DQVDPEOX FDUH SULYHúWH GHVWLQHOH WXWXURU HURLORU H FODVLF ´ $QGUHL
%RGLX 'HVWLQXO SHUVRQDMHORU SDUH GLULMDW GH SXWHUHD GH VHGXF LH D EDQLORU úL GH
IDVFLQD LD SXWHULL 'LQFROR GH DFHDVW DSDUHQ vQV SULQ ILHFDUH HURX VH vPSOLQHúWH
XQ GHVWLQ SXV VXE VHPQXO K\EULVXOXL FD vQ WUDJHGLD JUHDF &XYLQWHOH GLQ ILQDO DOH
E WUkQHL H[SULP FRQYLQJHUHD F QLPHQL QX VH SRDWH VXVWUDJH VRU LL 5HOD LLOH GLQWUH
FHOH GRX SHUVRQDMH DQWDJRQLFH VH FRQVWUXLHVF úL HOH SH VLPHWULL FODVLFH &XSOXOXL
PDVFXOLQ OHJDW SULQ RUJROLL E UE WHúWL LUHSUHVLELOH vL FRUHVSXQGH XQ FXSOX IHPLQLQ vQ
FDUH E WUkQD UHSUH]LQW RPXO PRUDO LDU $QD ILLQ D GLOHPDWLF DOXQHFkQG GLQVSUH
OHJHDPRUDO VSUHvQF OFDUHDHL
$QWLWHWLFH OD vQFHSXW UDSRUWXULOH GLQWUH *KL úL /LF GHYLQ WUHSWDW
FRPSOHPHQWDUHLDUGHVWLQHOHORUVHvQFUXFLúHD] VHvPSOHWHVFVHXQHVFvQPRDUWH
3URWDJRQLVWXO QXYHOHL *KL HVWH FHQWUXO GH LUDGLHUH D VHPQLILFD LLORU GHVWLQXO
V X LOXVWUkQG WRDWH FHOH WUHL VWUDWXUL WHPDWLFH DOH QXYHOHL VRFLDO SVLKRORJLF úL
PRUDOLOXVWUkQGÄWH]DPRUDO ´DWH[WXOXLIRUPXODW GHSHUVRQDMXOUDLVRQQHXUDOF U LL
E WUkQD&HOFHSRDUW QXPHOHGHVDFUDOL]DWDO6IkQWXOXL*KHRUJKHQXSRDWHILGHFkW
DQWLHURXOFHVHODV vQYLQVGHEDODXU6FHQDULXODUKHWLSDOSHFDUHOUHHGLWHD] WUDVHXO
V XH[LVWHQ LDOQXHVWHGHFkWRDOW ³LVSLWLUHúLF GHUHvQS FDW´'LQDPLFDSVLKLF D
SHUVRQDMXOXL UHOLHIHD] vQV QX R LQYROX LH OLQHDU R GHJUDGDUH FRQWLQX FL R
WUDLHFWRULH VLQXRDV JHQHUDW GH FUL]D PRUDO (URXO OXL 6ODYLFL HVWH DúDGDU XQ
SHUVRQDM FRPSOH[ GLOHPDWLF GH PDUH IRU vQ UHSUH]HQWDUHD RPXOXL FDUH VH ODV
GRPLQDW GH VO ELFLXQHD VD 3URFHVXO GHYHQLULL OXL *KL HVWH VXUSULQV SULQ PLMORDFHOH
PRGHUQH DOH DQDOL]HL SVLKRORJLFH SULQ PRQRORJXO LQWHULRU úL GLDORJXO SROHPLF SULQ
IDSWHOH úL JkQGXULOH SURWDJRQLVWXOXL SULQ vQVXPDUHD RSLQLLORU MXGHF LORU GH YDORDUH
DOH FHORUODOWH SHUVRQDMH 'HYHQLUHD VD WUDJLF VH DGkQFHúWH SULQ ÄF GHUHD´ GLQWUR
LSRVWD] vQDOWDGLQVSUHRPXOPRUDOVSUHFHOLPRUDO
3ULPD LSRVWD] HVWH FHD GH RP PRUDO FDUH UHVSHFW FRGXO HWLF DO
FRPXQLW LL úL LQH OD UHVSHFWXO RDPHQLORU &D DGHY UDW SDWHU IDPLOLDV HO PDQLIHVW
LXELUH úL UHVSRQVDELOLWDWH ID GH DL V L GRULQ D GH DL SURWHMD úL GRULQ GH
DXWRGHS úLUHVSUHPDLELQHOHIDPLOLHL$FHVWXLPRGHOXPDQLVHDVRFLD] GLPHQVLXQLOH
HURXOXLFLYLOL]DWRUFHYUHDV SXQ RRUGLQH±FHDDOHJLLPRUDOH±vQOXPHDV OEDWLF
DIODW VXE VW SkQLUHD 6 P G XOXL Ä'DU ELQHFXYkQWDW HUD ORFXO DFHVWD PDL DOHV GH
FkQG YHQLVHU FkUFLXPDUXO FHO QRX FX QHYDVWD OXL WkQ U úL FX VRDFU VD FHD
E WUkQ ´ + UQLFLD úL SULFHSHUHD HURXOXL GHVWRLQLFLD úL VSLULWXO SUDFWLF VH Y GHVF vQ
UDSLGLWDWHD FX FDUH WUDQVIRUP KDQXO vQ UXLQ vQWUXQ ORF F XWDW GH GUXPH LL FDUH QX
PDL YRUEHDX GH 0RDUD FX QRURF FL GH ÄFkUFLXPD OXL *KL ´ ,PDJLQHD FDVQLF D
VHULORU GH VkPE W FkQG *KL QXP UD FkúWLJXO GH SHVWH V SW PkQ FX $QD úL FX
E WUkQD HYLGHQ LD] UHJLPXO VXIOHWHVF FH VH DVRFLD] DFHVWHL SULPH LSRVWD]H
PXO XPLUHLQWHULRDU HFKLOLEUXRSWLPLVPvQFUHGHUHvQVLQHIHULFLUHFDOP vPS UW úLW
FX IDPLOLD VD &kQG OLQLúWHD FHORU FLQFL HVWH WXOEXUDW GH DSDUL LD OXL /LF 6 P G XO
*KL vQFHDUF V LVHvPSRWULYHDVF IHUPúLGHPQ1XPDLF SULPDHURDUH±DFHHD
GHDQXUHQXQ DODDUHQGDKDQXOXLFkQGvQ HOHJHF QXSRDWHU PkQHDFRORvPSRWULYD
YRLQ HLOXL/LF ±GHFODQúHD] VLWXD LDGHFUL] Ä(OHUDRPFXPLQWHúLvQ HOHJHDFHOH
FHVHSHWUHF>«@vQ]DGDUWHvQ HOHJLFXDUHQGDúXOvQ]DGDUWHSXLELQHFXVW SkQLUHD
F FLSHQWUXFDV SR LVWDOD0RDUDFXQRURFPDLWUHEXLHV WHIDFLúLRPDOOXL/LF
,DU *KL YRLD FX WRW GLQDGLQVXO V U PkLH OD 0RDUD FX QRURF SHQWUX F L PHUJHD
ELQH´ &HD GHD GRXD LSRVWD] DGXFH vQ SULPSODQ RPXO GLOHPDWLF FDUH
SHQGXOHD] vQWUH GRULQ D GH D U PkQH RP FLQVWLW úL LVSLWD FkúWLJXOXL QHPXQFLW
7HQWDWLYD HúXDW GH D VH vPSRWULYL OXL /LF H XUPDW GH DOXQHFDUHD WUHSWDW VXE
LQIOXHQ DV P G XOXLGHDFFHSWDUHDFRPSURPLVXOXLPRUDOÌQWUHFHLGRLE UED LHXQ
FRQIOLFWGHLQWHUHVHúLRFRQIUXQWDUHGHYRLQ HúLRUJROLLE UE WHúWLÄ«HLVWHWHU W FX L
ID vQ ID KRW Uk L DPkQGRL úL VLP LQG ILHFDUH F úLD J VLW RPXO´ 9RLQ D úL IRU D
O XQWULF D OXL *KL VH Q UXLH vQV WUHSWDW VXE LVSLWD Q YDOQLF GH D ÄYHGHD EDQLL
JU PDG vQDLQWHDVD´úLVXEIDVFLQD LDIRU HLPDOHILFHDOXL/LF 6IkúLDWGHLPEROGXUL
úL WU LUL VXIOHWHúWL FRQWUDGLFWRULL *KL VH vQFKLGH vQ VLQH UHIX]kQG FRPXQLFDUHD FX
$QDGHYLQHWDFLWXUQVXPEUXLUDVFLELOÌQOXSWDVLQHOXLFXVLQHOHWHDPDVXVSLFLXQHD
VHQWLPHQWXO vQVWU LQ ULL DOWHUQHD] FX UHPXúF ULOH úL VHQWLPHQWXO FXOSDELOLW LL ÌQ
UDSRUWFXIDPLOLDJULMDWDQGU úLGXLRúLDVXQWWRWPDLGHVvQORFXLWHGHU FHDO úLYRUE
U VWLW HO DMXQJkQG V úL GRUHDVF ÄV QDLE QHYDVW úL FRSLL´ ÌQ UDSRUW FX OXPHD
F UHLDvLDSDU LQH*KL DOHJHGXSOLFLWDWHDYUkQGÄV SDU RPFLQVWLW´GDUGHYHQLQG
FRPSOLFH úL S UWDú OD IDSWHOH QHFLQVWLWH DOH 6 P G XOXL $XWRUXO VXUSULQGH GLQWUR
GXEO SHUVSHFWLY ± FHD D QDUDWRUXOXL RPQLVFLHQW úL FHD D SHUVRQDMXOXL vQVXúL ±
IU PkQW ULOHOXL*KL RVFLOD LLOHGHOXPLQ úLXPEU PRPHQWHOHGHvQVLQJXUDUHGDUúL
FHOH GH RPHQLH FkQG vúL DGXFH DPLQWH GH QHYDVW úL FRSLL P FLQDW GH UHPXúF UL
6FHQDSURFHVXOXLFDS;,UHSUH]LQW XQPRPHQWFKHLHvQGHYHQLUHDSHUVRQDMXOXLXQ
PRPHQW GH FXOPLQD LH D FUL]HL PRUDOH 'HúL FRQYLQV GH YLQRY LD V P G XOXL vQ
MHIXLUHD DUHQGDúXOXL úL GXEOD FULP GLQ S GXUH *KL GHSXQH P UWXULH IDOV FH
FRQWULEXLH OD GLVFXOSDUHD OXL /LF úL OD FRQGDPQDUHD OXL 6 LO %RDULX úL %X] 5XSW
2S LXQHD HURXOXL HVWH GHWHUPLQDW QX GH IULF FL GH FRQúWLLQ D IDSWXOXL F /LF DUH
VW SkQL SXWHUQLFL FDUH vO SURWHMHD] Ä/LF QX H RP VLQJXU FL XQ vQWUHJ UkQG GH
RDPHQLGLQFDUHXQLLVHU ]EXQ SHDO LL´*KL HVWHDVWIHOQXQXPDLYLFWLPDSDWLPHL
GH vPERJ LUH FL úL vQYLQVXO XQXL GHVWLQ WUDJLF 8OWLPD LSRVWD] HVWH FHD D RPXOXL
LPRUDO F ]XW GLQ GHPQLWDWHD ILLQ HL PRUDOH vQ ]RQHOH REVFXUH DOH LQVWLQFWHORU
O FRPLH RUJROLX úL VHWH GH U ]EXQDUH RDUE JHOR]LH ÌQ VXIOHWXO HURXOXL VH SURGXF
PXWD LLHVHQ LDOHFDUHvOvQVWU LQHD] LUHPHGLDELOGHDLV L*UDYXOGH]HFKLOLEUXLQWHULRU
HVWH JHQHUDW GH DFFHSWDUHD VO ELFLXQLORU D YLFLXOXL O FRPLHL úL GH MXVWLILFDUHD
DFHVWRUD Ä&H V PL IDF GDF DúD PD O VDW 'XPQH]HX"´ PRQRORJ LQWHULRU 6XE
FRPSOLFLWDWHD DFFHSWDW WDFLW vQWUH *KL úL /LF DUH ORF R FRQIUXQWDUH VXEWHUDQ SH
YLD úLSHPRDUWHÄ7XHúWLRPFLQVWLW*KL úLDPI FXWGLQWLQHRPYLQRYDW>«@7X
HúWLRP*KL RPFXPXOW XU vQVXIOHWXOW XúLHúWLRPFXPLQWHGDF WHDúDYHD
WRYDU ú SH WLQH Dú UkGH úL GH GUDFXO 0 VLPW FKLDU HX PDL YUHGQLF FkQG P úWLX
DO WXUHDFXXQRPFDWLQH´±DILUP /LF vQYUHPHFH*KL JkQGHúWHÄ7HFUH]LPDL
WDUHGHFkWPLQH"6 YHGHP7HGXFODVSkQ]XU WRDUHFKLDUGDFDUWUHEXLV PHUJúL
HX GH K FX WLQH´ FDS ;,, $FHDVW vQIUXQWDUH GH YRLQ H úL LQWHUHVH YD VIkUúL SULQ
KRW UkUHD OXL *KL GH DL DGXFH OXL 3LQWHD GRYH]LOH YLQRY LHL V P G XOXL 'HFL
RS LXQHD ILQDO D SURWDJRQLVWXOXL HVWH DFHHD GH D VH VLWXDFXVDFULILFLXOVXSUHPGH
SDUWHD /HJLL 8OWLPHOH VFHQH ± SXWHUQLF LPSUHJQDWH GH YL]LXQHD IROFORULF D SUHGHV
WLQ ULL±VXQWGHXQLQWHQVGUDPDWLVPÌQ HOHJkQGF úLDGLVWUXVLUHPHGLDELOF VQLFLDúL
YLD D *KL UHQXQ OD MRFXO GXEOX úL OD GLVLPXODUHD JHOR]LHL úLD XULL úL DF LRQHD]
vQWkLDRDU FXIHUPLWDWH5HYHQLUHDODYDORULOHPRUDOHDXWHQWLFHQXLvQV FXSXWLQ úL
HURLL YRU SO WL FX YLD D DEDWHUHD GH OD QRUPD HWLF 'HVWLQHOH FHORU SHUVRQDMH VH
vQVFULXVXEVHPQXOXQHLIDVFLQD LLDU XOXLFDGUDPHDOHDEGLF ULLGHODGHPQLWDWHúL
PRUDOLWDWHGUDPHDOHLQFRPXQLF ULLúLvQVLQJXU ULLFDHúHFXULH[LVWHQ LDOHJHQHUDWHGH
VO ELFLXQLúLYDQLWDWHGHDPEL LLI U GHP VXU
/LF 6 P G XO HVWH XQ SHUVRQDM WRW DWkW GH FRPSOH[ FD úL *KL (O HVWH
ÄV P G XO´ DGLF ÄSRUFDU úL HO GDU RP FX VWDUH DVSUX úL QHvQGXU WRU >«@ GH FDUH
WUHPXU WRDW OXQFD´$FHVWHSUHFL] ULDOHQDUDWRUXOXLGHVSUHVWDWXWXOVRFLDOúLUHJLPXO
SVLKLF DO V P G XOXL SUHJ WHVF ÄLQWUDUHD vQ VFHQ ´ D OXL /LF 6LPEROLF DFHVWD VH
LYHúWHODKDQXOOXL*KL ÄvQWUR]LGHOXQL´6SUHGHRVHELUHGHFHLODO LHURLFDUHQXVXQW
LQGLYLGXDOL]D LSULQWUXQSRUWUHWIL]LFSURSULX]LVOXL/LF LVHVFKL HD] vQOLQLLIHUPHXQ
SRUWUHW LQL LDO FDUDFWHUL]DUH GLUHFW GLQ SHUVSHFWLYD QDUDWRUXOXL Ä3HVWH SX LQ VRVL úL
6 P G XOYHVWLWXO/LF 6 P G XOOD0RDUDFXQRURF/LF XQRPFDGHGHDQL
vQDOWXVF LYúLVXSWODID FXPXVWD DOXQJ FXRFKLPLFLúLYHU]LúLFXVSUkQFHQHOH
GHVH úL vPSUHXQDWH OD PLMORF´ 'HWDOLLOH IL]LFH DX ILHFDUH XQ URO VHPQLILFDWLY vQ
DQWLFLSDUHD FDUDFWHULRORJLF VXJHUkQG XQ RP GH PDUH YRLQ ÄVSUkQFHQHOH GHVH úL
vPSUHXQDWH OD PLMORF´ DJHU YLFOHDQ úL SOLQ GH U XWDWH ÄFX RFKL PLFL úL YHU]L´ FX
WHPSHUDPHQW HQHUJLF úL YLD D GLQDPLF ÄvQDOW XVF LY úL VXSW OD ID ´ 'HWDOLLOH
YHVWLPHQWDUHvOVLQJXODUL]HD] vQUDSRUWFXSRUFDULLGHUkQGSHFDUHvLVW SkQHúWHSULQ
YRLQ úL IRU Ä/LF HUD SRUFDU vQV GLQWUH FHL FH SRDUW F PDú VXE LUH úL DOE FD
IORULFHOHSLHSWDUFXEXPELGHDUJLQWúLELFLGHFDUPDMLQFXFRGLULúWHDGHRVvPSRGRELW
FXIORULW LDWHúLFXJKLQWXOH HGHDXU´$VHPHQLXQXLKDLGXFPRGHUQFDUHDVFKLPEDW
vQV IOLQWDFXELFLXOVLPERODOSXWHULLDOVW SkQLULLSULQIRU úLYLROHQ /LF UHSUH]LQW
RPXO FDUH vúL IDFH VLQJXU OHJHD (O LOXVWUHD] R WLSRORJLH UHDOLVW VRFLDO ±
UHSUH]HQWkQG 6 P G XO ± GDU úL R WLSRORJLH JHQHUDOXPDQ GH FXORDUH URPDQWLF
3ULQFKLSXOV XGHPRQLFÄ7XQXHúWLRP/LF FLGLDYRO´HOH[HUFLW DVXSUDWXWXURUR
IDVFLQD LH FDUH SDUDOL]HD] YRLQ D úL DVSLUD LD VSUH HWLF $XWRULWDWH VXSUHP D
ORFXULORUHVWHXQFDUDFWHUSOLQGHFRQWUDGLF LLILLQGGkU]úLKRW UkWGDUvQDFHODúLWLPS
VDGLF úL DPHQLQ WRU VDX FX L]EXFQLUL GH DXWHQWLF GXLRúLH &DUDFWHUL]DW GLUHFW GH
F WUHFHOHODOWHLQVWDQ HQDUDWLYH$QD«HRPU XúLSULPHMGLRVDVWDVHYHGHvQRFKLL
OXLGLQUkQMHWXOOXLúLPDLDOHVGLQF XW WXUDFHDUHFkQGvúLURDGHPXVWD DFXGLQ LL(
RP S WLPDú *KL úL QX H ELQH V WH GDL SUHD DSURDSH GH HO VDX LQGLUHFW SULQ
IDSWHOLPEDMJHVWXULDWLWXGLQLPHGLXYHVWLPHQWD LHHWFHODSDUHvQ]HVWUDWFXFDOLW L
FHUWH SUHFXP LQWHOLJHQ D QDWLY OXFLGLWDWH WHPHULWDWH FDSDFLWDWH GH D LQWXL
SVLKRORJLD úL FDUDFWHUXO RDPHQLORU FDSDFLWDWH GH GLVLPXODUH DELOLWDWH GDU DFHVWH
FDOLW LVXQWSXVHvQVOXMEDU XOXL&kQGDSDUHODKDQLQWU SHXúDGLQGRVVXJHUkQG
DVWIHOF HOHVWHDGHY UDWXOVW SkQDOORFXULORUÄ$FLOD0RDUDFXQRURFQXSXWHDV
VWHD QLPHQL I U YRLD OXL /LF DIDU GH DUkQGDú úL DIDU GH VW SkQLUH PDL HUD úL
GkQVXO FDUH VW SkQHD GUXPXULOH úL vQ ]DGDU WH vQ HOHJL FX DUHQGDúXO vQ ]DGDU WH SXL
ELQHFXVW SkQLUHDF FLSHQWUXFDV SR LVWDOD0RDUDFXQRURFPDLWUHEXLHV WH
IDFLúLRPDOOXL/LF ´&KLDUGHODSULPDGLVFX LH/LF vLSXQHvQYHGHUHOXL*KL F
WUHEXLH V FRODERUH]H FX HO Ä2UL vPL YHL IDFH SH SODF RUL vPL IDF UkQG GH DOW RP OD
0RDUD FX QRURF´ GH]Y OXLQGXúL EUXWDOLWDWHD úL FLQLVPXO Ä(X VXQW /LF V P
G XO«WXYH]LXQOXFUXF XPEOX]LXDQDPLD]DPDUHSHGUXPXOGH DU úLQLPHQLQX
P RSUHúWHvQFDOHF P GXFvQRUDúúLVWDXGHYRUE FXGRPQL%XQSVLKRORJ/LF
LQWXLHúWHVO ELFLXQHDFkUFLXPDUXOXLÄ7HúWLXRPFDUH LQHODEDQL´3HQWUXDSDUDOL]D
RULFHLQWHQ LHGHQHVXSXQHUH/LF LDWR LEDQLLFkUFLXPDUXOXLVXEIRUP GHvPSUXPXW
)DSWHOH OXL /LF GH]Y OXLH ODWXUD vQWXQHFDW D QDWXULL XPDQH VHWH GHYRUDWRDUH GH
SXWHUH vQúHO FLXQH IXUW FULP (O VH FRQGXFH GXS XQ FRG SURSULX vQ DIDUD OHJLORU
PRUDOH úL OHJLORU VWDWXOXL ÌQ UDSRUWXULOH FX *KL vúL FDOFXOHD] FX DELOLWDWH ILHFDUH
PLúFDUHORYLQGvQGHPQLWDWHDRPXOXLvQPkQGULDE UEDWXOXLvQDXWRULWDWHDVDGHVR
úL S ULQWH GH VW SkQ DO KDQXOXL vQ LPDJLQHD VD GH RP FLQVWLW &kQG SR]L LD VD vQ
OXPHD SH FDUH R VW SkQHúWH SULQ YRLQ FUX]LPH úL LQIOH[LELOLWDWH HVWH DPHQLQ DW
V P G XOJ VHúWHvQHOSXWHUHDGHDVHVLQXFLGHÌQWUHFHLGRLE UED L$QDVR LDOXL
*KL HVWH R YLFWLP D LQFDSDFLW LL GH DúL DS UD YDORULOH PRUDOH úL IDPLOLD GDU úL
HURLQ WUDJLF YLFWLP D XQHL IDWDOLW L REVFXUH ,SRVWD]D LQL LDO VH FULVWDOL]HD] GLQ
SHUVSHFWLYD OXL *KL FDUH R SULYHúWH FX RFKL GH vQGU JRVWLW ÄúL LQLPD vL UkGH FkQG
$QD FHD vQ HOHDSW úL DúH]DW GHRGDW vúL SLHUGH FXPS WXO úL VH DUXQF U VI DW
DVXSUD OXL F FL $QD HUD WkQ U úL IUXPRDV $QD HUD IUDJHG úL VXE LULF $QD HUD
VSULQWHQ úLPO GLRDV ´ÄÌQ HOHDSWD´$QDYHGHvQ/LF XQÄRPU XúLSULPHMGLRV´úLvO
DYHUWL]HD] SH *KL Ä$QD FHD vQ HOHDSW úL DúH]DW ´ VH YUHD VR LH DGHY UDW
S UWDú OD ELQH úL OD U X VR XOXL HL úL VXIHU FkQG *KL WRW PDL vQVLQJXUDW úL
]EXFLXPDW VH vQVWU LQHD] (D vQFHDUF FX GLVSHUDUH V VDOYH]H HFKLOLEUXO IDPLOLDO
DSRL DVLVW QHSXWLQFLRDV OD FRQWLQXD HURGDUH D DUPRQLHL úL LXELULL GLQ F VQLFLD ORU
&kQG*KL RvPSLQJHvQEUD HOHV P G XOXL±IRUP VXSUHP DXPLOLQ HL±$QDVH
VLPWH WU GDW úL vQFHSH V úL GLVSUH XLDVF VR XO LQWUkQG WUHSWDW VXE IDVFLQD LD OXL
/LF Ä&RSLOXOXLPLW´FHPDLV O úOXLHúWHvQHD$QDHVWHODYkUVWDODFDUHFkQWHFXOúL
MRFXO VXQW vQF EXFXULL DOH YLH LL JHQHUkQG HPR LL VLP PLQWH úL YLEUD LL SXUH HVWH
LPSUHVLRQDW GH FDUDFWHUXO SXWHUQLF úL GH YRLQ D V P G XOXL &kQG LXELUHD SHQWUX
*KL VH Q UXLH SX LQ FkWH SX LQ $QD GHYLQH FRQúWLHQW GH SULPHMGLD SLHUGHULL
LQRFHQ HLGHWHQWD LDF GHULLvQYkUWHMXOSDWLPLLGHYDVWDWRDUHÄ7XP RPRUL*KL P
VHFLGHYLD P FKLQXLHúWLP ODúLV P RPRUHXGLQPLQH´8OWLPHOH]YkFQLULGLQ
ILQDO FkQG HVWH XFLV GH *KL H[SULP R FRSOHúLWRDUH VHWH GH YLD úL vQ DFHODúL
WLPSVHWHDGHU ]EXQDUH
'HILQLWRULHSHQWUXDUWDUHDOL] ULLSHUVRQDMHORUOXL6ODYLFLHVWHúLGHVFKLGHUHDVSUH
SVLKRORJLF SULQ FDUH VH GHPRQVWUHD] F VXIOHWXO RPXOXL GH UkQG HVWH XQ XQLYHUV
FRPSOH[GHPQGHLQWHUHV6FULLWRURELHFWLY6ODYLFLXUP UHúWHJUDGDWLQVWDODUHDFUL]HL
VXIOHWHúWLúLHYROX LDHLGHODSULPHOHVHPQHSkQ vQID DGH]QRG PkQWXOXLLPSODFDELO
3HUVRQDMHOHOXL6ODYLFLQXVXQWVFKHPDWLFHVLPSOHSULPLWLYHFLVXQWLQGLYL]LvQ]HVWUD L
FXRERJDW YLD LQWHULRDU FDSDELOLGHWU LULSURIXQGHGHRUGLQPRUDOVDXDIHFWLY(L
DX FRPSOH[LWDWH SVLKRORJLF DX DFHO ÄDPHVWHF GH ELQH úL U X FH VH DIO OD RDPHQLL
DGHY UD L´ GXS FXP REVHUYD * & OLQHVFX ,OX]LD YLH LL DGHY UDWH HVWH VXV LQXW úL
GHOLPEDMXOSHUVRQDMHORU'LDORJXULOHDXRPDUHSXWHUHGHFDUDFWHUL]DUHSVLKLF (OH
FRQIHU YL]LXQH VFHQLF úL GHILQHVF OXPHD RDPHQLORU VLPSOL D F URU YRUELUH HVWH
PDUFDW GH RUDOLWDWH GH VSRQWDQHLWDWHD FRPXQLF ULL IDPLOLDUH &DUDFWHUXO JQRPLF DO
DFHVWXLOLPEDMHVWHHYLGHQWvQFXJHW ULOHFXUROPRUDOL]DWRUDOHE WUkQHLFDUHUHSUH]LQW
RDYHUWL]DUHDVXSUDIRU HORUFRQIOLFWXDOHvQLQFLSLWWHUPHQLLFRQIOLFWXDOLVXQWÄV U FLD´
ÄQX ERJ LD´ ÄOLQLúWHD FROLEHL´ ÄQRURF QRX´ úL URO GH UHIOHF LH WUDJLF DVXSUD
GHVWLQXOXLvQILQDO³6LP HDPHXF QXDUHV LDV ELQHGDUDúDOHDIRVWGDWD´
1DUD LXQHDHVWHDVWIHOSXV vQÄUDPD´FXJHW ULORUE WUkQHLÄYRFH´FDUHH[SULP
PHQWDOLWDWHD XQHL OXPL PRUDOH FDUHúL vQWHPHLD] H[LVWHQ D SH YDORUL DXWHQWLFH úL SH
FUHGLQ DvQVRDUW ÌQYLUWXWHDDFHVWHLPHQWDOLW LFHLFDUHVHDEDWGHODFRGXOPRUDO
SLHUG úDQVD PkQWXLULL DúD FXP R SLHUG *KL úL /LF SHUVRQDMH GH PDUH IRU
DUWLVWLF PHPRUDELOHSULQJUDGXOPDUHGHH[SULPDUHDQDWXULLJHQHUDOXPDQH
(9$/8$5(
7HPHSHQWUXFRORFYLXOGHODVIkUúLWXOVHPHVWUXOXL,
(OHPHQWHGHVWUXFWXU úLGHFRPSR]L LHvQWH[WHOHQDUDWLYH
7LSRORJLDúLIXQF LLOHQDUDWRUXOXL
3HUVSHFWLYDQDUDWLY
3HUVSHFWLYHWHPSRUDOH
2UGLQHDQDUDWLY
0RGDOLW LOHQDU ULL
3HUVRQDMXO3RUWUHWXOOLWHUDU
&RQFHSWHVSHFLILFHQDUDWRORJLHL
1RW 6XELHFWHOH SHQWUX FRORFYLXO FX FDUH VH YD ILQDOL]D SULPXO VHPHVWUX YRU
FRQ LQHRSUREOHP WHRUHWLF GLQWHPDWLFDPHQ LRQDW úLRDSOLFD LHSUDFWLF DQDOL]D
VWLOLVWLF DXQXLIUDJPHQWGHWH[WOLWHUDUODSULPDYHGHUH
9,$%25'$5($67,/,67,&à$7(;78/8,'5$0$7,&
3$57,&8/$5,7 ,67,/,67,&($/(23(5(,
'5$0$7,&(
*(18/ '5$0$7,&UHSUH]LQW RIRUP FRPSOH[ GHDUW vQFDUHRSHUHLOLWHUDUH
VFULVH FX VFRSXO GH D IL UHSUH]HQWDW VFHQLF L VH DGDXJ HOHPHQWH PRGDOLW L GH
H[SUHVLH VSHFLILFH DUWHL WHDWUDOH VSUH D GHYHQL XQ VSHFWDFRO 9L]LXQHD GHVSUH OXPH
LGHLOHFRQFHS LLOHVHQWLPHQWHOHVFULLWRUXOXLGUDPDWLFVXQWRELHFWLYDWHSULQLQWHUPHGLXO
SHUVRQDMHORU DO DF LXQLL VFHQLFH úL DO PRGDOLW LORU VSHFWDFROXOXL 'LVFXUVXO GLUHFW DO
VFULLWRUXOXLVHOLPLWHD] ODGLGDVFDOLL±WH[WQRQOLWHUDUFXIXQF LLSUDJPDWLFHFDUHDUHURO
GLUHFWLYvQPRQWDUHDVSHFWDFROXOXL&UHD LDGUDPDWLF HVWHRIRUP GHDUW VLQFUHWLF
DYkQG XQ GXEOX VLVWHP GH VHPQLILFDUH GXDOLWDWH VHPLRWLF GLVFXUVXO GUDPDWLF
GLDORJXULOHúLPRQRORJXULOHURVWLWHSHVFHQ úLOLPEDMHOHVFHQLFHIRUPHQRQYHUEDOH
VSHFLILFH GH VHPQLILFDUH MRFXO VFHQLF DO DFWRULORU GHFRUXO UHFX]LWD IXQGDOXO VRQRU
MRFXOGHOXPLQLHWF
2SHUD GUDPDWLF vQVXPHD] WH[WXO OLWHUDU SURSULX]LV GLVFXUVXO GUDPDWLF
FRQFUHWL]DW FD GLDORJ úL PRQRORJ GUDPDWLF SDUDWH[WXO UHSUH]HQWDW GH GLGDVFDOLL
FXSULQ]kQGOLVWDGHSHUVRQDMHúLSUHFL] ULOHFDUHvQVR HVFQXPHOHDFHVWRUDLQGLFD LLOH
VFHQLFHSURSULX]LVHúLQRWD LLOHSULYLQGXQLW LFRPSR]L LRQDOH±DFWHVFHQHWDEORXUL
úL PHWDWH[WXO DOF WXLW GLQ HOHPHQWHOH VSHFWDFROXOXL GUDPDWLF DQVDPEOXO P UFLORU
SDUWLFXODUHDOHDUWHLGUDPDWLFHUHJLHVFHQRJUDILH±GHFRUFRVWXPHUHFX]LW FRORDQ
VRQRU OXPLQLHWF±úLMRFXOVFHQLFDODFWRULORU
(OHPHQWHOH VSHFWDFROXOXL YL]HD] DUWD OLWHUDWXULL úL DUWD GUDPDWLF UHXQLQG
SHUHFKL DOH LQVWDQ HORU WHDWUDOH VXE UHJLPXO XQXL SULQFLSLX VSHFLILF FHO DO ÄGXEOHL
HQXQ UL´$QQH8EHUVILHOGSHFDUHVHFRQVWUXLHVFÄSHUHFKL´PXOWLSOH
GXDOLWDWHDXFWRULDO GUDPDWXUJXOúLUHJL]RUXOVXQWHPL WRULLFDUHvúLDVXP
SDWHUQLWDWHDVSHFWDFROXOXL
GXDOLWDWHVFULSWXUDO GLVFXUVXOVFHQLFWH[WXOSURSULX]LVúLGLVFXUVXOGLGDVFDOLF
GXDOLWDWHDFWRULDO DFWRUXOHVWHSHUVRDQDUHDO vQYUHPHFHSHUVRQDMXOSH
FDUHvOLQWHUSUHWHD] HVWHSHUVRDQ ILF LRQDO
GXDOLWDWHVHPLRWLF ±GLVFXUVXOGUDPDWLFHVWHGXEODWGHOLPEDMHOHVFHQLFH
FDUHDXúLHOHUROGHVHPQLILFDUH
6SHFWDFROXOWHDWUDOVHVWUXFWXUHD] SHWUHLSDOLHUH
c 'LVFXUVXO GUDPDWLF GLDORJXO úL PRQRORJXO VFHQLF DUH FD UHIHUHQW ILF LRQDO
XQLYHUVXOÄSRYHVWLW´vQUHSOLFLOHSHUVRQDMHORU
d$F LXQHDGUDPDWLF UHXQHúWHWUHLHOHPHQWH
9 HYHQLPHQWHOHSHWUHFXWHSHVFHQ úLHYHQLPHQWHUHODWDWHVXELHFWÄLVWRULD´
ÄIDEXOD´
VHPLRWLFD ± úWLLQ FDUH VWXGLD] VLVWHPHOH GH VHPQH vQWUHEXLQ DWH vQ VIHUD YLH LL VRFLDOH
Ä2ULHQWDUHODUJU VSkQGLW vQJkQGLUHDWHRUHWLF FRQWHPSRUDQ FDUHVWXGLD] IHQRPHQHOHúLvQVSHFLDO
IDSWHOH GH FXOWXU FD VLVWHPH GH VHPQLILFDUH úL SURFHVH GH FRPXQLFDUH IU VpPLRWLTXH FI JU
VHPHLRWLNHVHPHLRQ±VHPQ´±'LF LRQDUGHQHRORJLVPH
9VLWXD LLOH VXUSULQVH SULQ OLPEDM VFHQLF VLPEROXUL DXGLRYL]XDOH PHWDIRU
SDUDERO DOHJRULHVFHQLF
9VWUXFWXULOHGUDPDWLFHSULQFLSLLOHÄGHVHQXOXLHSLF´
e /LPEDMHOH VFHQLFH DX vQ YHGHUH HOHPHQWH VSHFLILFH DUWHL GUDPDWLFH MRFXO
VFHQLF DO DFWRULORU SDQWRPLP FRVWXPH GHFRU PRELOLHU UHFX]LW HIHFWH VRQRUH
OXPLQLHWF
&RPSR]L LD RSHUHL GUDPDWLFH DUH FD VHPQ GLVWLQFWLY XQLW LOH FRPSR]L LRQDOH
VSHFLILFHDFWHWDEORXULVFHQHSULQFLSLLOHúLWHKQLFLOHFRPSR]L LRQDOHDXHYROXDWGH
ODWHDWUXODULVWRWHOLFvQFDUHVFHQDHUDXQVSD LXDOPLPHVLVXOXLLDUGUDPDWXUJXOFUHD
XQ DQDORJRQ LGHDOL]DW DO UHDOLW LL OD WHDWUXO VHFROXOXL DO ;;OHD GHYHQLW VSD LX DO
H[SULP ULL SULQ FRQYHQ LLOH WHDWUDOLW LL D XQHL YL]LXQL GHVSUH OXPH úL GHVSUH FRQGL LD
XPDQ XQ ORF DO GH]EDWHULORU JHQHUDWH GH FRPSOH[LWDWHD YLH LL UHDOH úL GLOHPHOH
RPXOXLPRGHUQSUHFXP
vQ WHDWUXO FODVLF ± SURJUHVLD DF LXQLL SULQ vQO Q XLUHD HYHQLPHQWHORU SURFHGHXO
DFXPXO ULL H[SRQHQ LDOH D HYHQLPHQWHORU WHKQLFD ÄEXOJ UHOXL GH ] SDG ´
FRQVWUXF LDSLUDPLGDO DÄIDEXOHL´SURFHGHXOU VWXUQ ULLVSHFWDFXORDVHGHVLWXD LH
ÄGHXV H[ PDFKLQD´ WHKQLFD TXLSURTXRXOXL VXEVWLWXLUH GH SHUVRDQH WHKQLFD
WUDYHVWLXOXL DSHO OD GHJKL]DUH OD ÄPDVF WHKQLFD LPEURJOLRXOXL vQFXUF WXUL
FRQIX]LLGHSHUVRQDMHWHKQLFDVLPHWULLORUDUHSHWL LHLVLWXD LLORUGUDPDWLFH
vQ WHDWUXO PRGHUQ ± QXPLW úL ÄGUDPDWXUJLH I U HYHQLPHQWH´ ± VLWXD LLOH
GUDPDWLFH VH VXFFHG SULQ DVRFLD LL GH LGHL SULQ DJOXWLQDUHD vQWkPSO ULORU
P UXQWH FDUH VXQW DGXVH OD QLYHOXO FRQúWLLQ HL GH IOX[XO PHPRULHL /RJLFD
ÄDF LXQLL LD PRGHOXO XQHL FXUEHL LPSUHYL]LELOH D YLH LL LQWHULRDUH IDEXOD LD VH
ED]HD] SH XQ GHVHQ HSLF SULPRUGLDO FRPSR]L LD HVWH FLUFXODU VDX
VLQXVRLGDO vQIRUP GHVSLUDO VDXDWHFWRQLF
&RQVWUXF LD VXELHFWXOXL vQ RSHUD GUDPDWLF HVWH LQIOXHQ DW GH LPSHUDWLYXO
GXUDWHLOLPLWDWHDVSHFWDFROXOXLRUHúLGHFHODOFRQYHQ LLORUWHDWUDOH
([SR]L LXQHD HVWH FRQFHQWUDW ILLQG vQORFXLW XQHRUL SULQ SURORJ ÌQ WHDWUXO
PRGHUQ SURSXQH R VLWXD LH VLPEROLF VROLWXGLQHD RPXOXL vQ XQLYHUV
FRQIUXQWDUHDILLQ HLFXDEVXUGXOFXWLPSXOFXOLPLWHOHFRQGL LHLXPDQHHWFVDX
R LSRVWD] XPDQ VHPQLILFDWLY DUWLVWXO vQVLQJXUDWXO ILLQ D DOLHQDW RPXO vQ
F XWDUHD'LYLQLW LLDVHQVXOXLH[LVWHQ HLHWF
,QWULJD SXWHUQLF HYLGHQ LDW VXUSULQGH HYHQLPHQWXO FHO PDL LPSRUWDQW VXE
DVSHFWXO FDX]DOLW LL UHOLHIkQG FRQIOLFWXO GUDPDWLF GH PDUH LQWHQVLWDWH 7HDWUXO
FRQWHPSRUDQ SURSXQH QX XQ HYHQLPHQW FL R VLWXD LHOLPLW FRQILJXUDW SULQ
OLPEDMVILGDUHDGHVWLQXOXLVHQWLPHQWXOWUHFHULLWLPSXOXLGHH[HPSOX
'HVI úXUDUHDDF LXQLLHVWHFRQILJXUDW WUDGL LRQDOFDVXFFHVLXQHFURQRORJLF
OLQHDU GHHYHQLPHQWHFDVHULLSURJUHVLYHGHVLWXD LLGUDPDWLFHFOLPD[VDX
PRGHUQ FD SURJUHVLH JHQHUDW GH ÄHYROX LD VSLULWXDO D SHUVRQDMHORU GH
VXFFHVLXQHDVW ULORUGHFRQúWLLQ REVHVLLDQJRDVHFRúPDUXUL
3XQFWXO FXOPLQDQW HVWH IRDUWH ELQH PDUFDW VSUH HO FRQYHUJkQG WRDWH
HYHQLPHQWHOHÄIDEXOHL'UDPDWXUJXOPRGHUQPXOWLSOLF PRPHQWHOHGHPD[LP
vQFRUGDUHDUHOD LLORUGLQWUHSHUVRQDMHRULGHLUHSUHVLELO WHQVLXQHvQFRQúWLLQ D
SURWDJRQLúWLORUGLVSHUVkQGDFHVWHPRPHQWHGXS XQGHVHQHSLFVLQXVRLGDO
'H]QRG PkQWXO LD IRUPD DQWLFOLPD[XOXL VDX D HSLORJXOXL XUPkQG UDSLG
SXQFWXOXL FXOPLQDQW RUL ILLQG FKLDU VROLGDU FX DFHVWD ÌQ WHDWUXO PRGHUQ
GH]QRG PkQWXO OLSVHúWH IUHFYHQW VDX UHLD VLWXD LD LQL LDO ILQDOXO GHVFKLV
VXJHUkQGDEVHQ DRULF UHLVROX LLGHUH]ROYDUHDFRQIOLFWHORUVDXLQFDSDFLWDWHD
RPXOXLPRGHUQGHDUHFXSHUDFHUWLWXGLQLGHDRSWDSHQWUXYDORULDXWHQWLFHGH
DDF LRQD
7HDWUXO PRGHUQ GHFRQVWUXLHúWH QX QXPDL VXELHFWXO WUDPD FL úL VWUXFWXULOH
ORJLFH úL FRQYHQ LLOH GUDPDWXUJLHL FODVLFH Ä2 XOWLP LSRVWD] D WUDJLFXOXL vQ FRQWHP
SRUDQHLWDWH FDUH QX SRDWH IL RFROLW VH GDWRUHD] WHDWUXOXL DEVXUG VDX DO GHUL]LXQLL
OXL(XJHQ,RQHVFX6DPXHO%HFNHWW$UWKXU$GDPRYVRFRWL LDXWRULLUHSUH]HQWDWLYL>«@
6SUH GHRVHELUH GH H[LVWHQ LDOLúWL vQ WHDWUXO DEVXUG QX H[LVW UHYROW QX H[LVW
DF LXQHD SHUVRQDMXOXL QX DIO P SRVLELOLWDWHD XQHL RS LXQL 1X H[LVW FRQIOLFW )DWDOL
WDWHDQXSURYRDF FRQIOLFWXOWUDJLFvLHVWHFRQVHFLQ D>@)DWDOLWDWHDLDORFXOWLPSXOXL
vL DQXOHD] VFXUJHUHD ( YHúQLF 9HúQLF HVWH VXSOLFLXO PRDUWHD´ -XVWLQ &HXFD
(YROX LDIRUPHORUGUDPDWLFH
7($758/&/$6,& 7($758/02'(51
± VSD LXO VFHQLF H FRQVWUXLW VSD LXO VFHQLF FRQVWUXLW SULQ DSHOXO OD VLPEROXUL
GXS PRGHOXOÄFXWLHLGHVFKLVH ODELULQWXO PDWULFH D H[LVWHQ HL vQ OXPHD FRQWHP
± VXJHUDW SULQ GHFRU úL SULQ SRUDQ VSD LXO vQFKLV GHVFKLV DUWLILFLDO QDWXUDO
LQGLFD LLVFHQLFH HWF PXOWLSOLFDUHD SODQXULORU VSD LDOH ÄLQYDGDUHD
± XQLWDWH GH VSD LX vQ WUDJHGLD VSD LXOXL VSHFWDWRUXOXL HWF WHQWDWLY GH IX]LRQDUH D
DQWLF FDWHJRULLORUUHDOLW LLÄVSD LDOL]DUHDWLPSXOXL´
± WLPS UHDO OLPLWDW DO VSHFWDFR PXOWLSOLFDUHDSODQXULORUWHPSRUDOH
OXOXL ±WLPSRELHFWLYSHUFHSXWFDWUHFHUHLUHYHUVLELO WLPS
± WLPSXO FD HYROX LH D UHSUH VXELHFWLY UHYHUVLELO UHPHPRUDWH VDX SURLHFWDW vQ
]HQW ULL HVWH VXJHUDW SULQ YLLWRU
LQGLFD LLVFHQLFH ±WLPSSHUFHSXWFDvQFUHPHQLUHvQSUH]HQWFDVXLW
± WLPS IL]LF OLQHDU WLPS LVWRULF GHÄDFXPFDWLPSELRORJLFFDGXUDW LQWHULRDU FD
VXFFHVLXQHGHHYHQLPHQWHUHDOH WLPSLPDJLQDUPLWLFHWFWLPSXOFDSHUVRQDMLQYL]LELO
± XQLWDWH GH WLPS vQ WUDJHGLD
DQWLF
± HOHPHQW GH PDUH IRU GH
FODQúDWRU GH HYHQLPHQWH FRQIOLFWXO HYLGHQ LDW VFHQLF SULQ GLDORJXO
FRQVWUXLW IUHFYHQW SH RSR]L LD FRQIOLFWXDO DUH OD ED]D RSR]L LD GLQWUH HX úL VLQH
vQWUH GRX SHUVRQDMH VDX GLQWUHLQGLYLGúLH[LVWHQ GLQWUHLQGLYLGúLVLVWHP
JUXSXULGHSHUVRQDMH
6WUXFWXUD WLSRORJLF D SHUVR (URLL QX PDL UHSUH]LQW LQGLYLGXDOLW L FL YDORUL
QDMHORU LGHL DWLWXGLQL VXSUDLQGLYLGXDOH SHUVRQDMH JHQHULFH
x WU V WXULJHQHUDOXPDQH 6ROGDWXO0DPDHWF
x 6XQW FDUDFWHUH DUKHWLSXUL 1X HVWH XQ ÄFDUDFWHU´ FL XQ ÄLQV FX LGHQWLWDWH
DOHSURVWLHL]JkUFHQLHLO XG UR YDJ DIODW vQ F XWDUHD VLQHOXL LQV DPRUI QRQHURX
úHQLHLLSRFUL]LHL ÄVXFLWEXIRQQHEXQOLULFHSLFHWF
x ÌQP VXUDvQFDUHDUKHWLSXOH ,GHQWLWDWHD VFHQLF H FRQIHULW SULQ OLPEDM úL
úLHOFRQVWUXLWGLQDFWHúLJHVWXUL FRPSRUWDPHQW VFHQLF SULQ QRPLQDOL]DUH GH VHULH
PHUHX UHSHWDELOH SRDWH V DEVHQ DQXPHOXLSULQUDSRUWDUHODSURSULDH[LVWHQ
DSDU FD XQ VWHUHRWLS OD VSD LX úL WLPS Ä3ULYDW GH GLPHQVLXQL WUDJLFH
1RUWKRS)U\H DXWHQWLFHQRQHURXOGLQWHDWUXOFRQWHPSRUDQHULGLFRO
x ,QGLYLGXDOL]DUHDUHDOL]DW SULQ SULQ SUH]HQ D VD úL WUDJLF SULQ UH]RQDQ D
QRPLQDOL]DUH VXJHVWLY GDWH LPSOLFD LLORU´5RPXO0XQWHDQX
FDUDFWHULRORJLFHSURILOSVLKROR /LPEDMXO H PRGDOLWDWHD SULQFLSDO GH FHUWLILFDUH D
JLF GHWDOLL YHVWLPHQWDUH FRP H[LVWHQ HL úL D OXSWHL vPSRWULYD OLPLWHORU H[LVWHQ LDOH
SRUWDPHQWDOH LHUDUKLH VRFLDO DOHJRUL]DUH VLPEROL]DUH PLWL]DUHGHPLWL]DUH SDUR
UDSRUWDUHODDOWHSHUVRQDMHHWF GLHUHVFLQGDUHvQÄYRFLHWF
&21&(37(63(&,),&('5$0$785*,(,
&21&(37 '(),1, ,$ 2%6(59$ ,,(;(03/(
JU GLGDVFDOLD FDLHW FX LQGLFD LL GHVWLQDW ± ,QGLFD LLOH GH UHJLH VXQW QRWD LL
DFWRUXOXL SDUDQWHWLFHUHIHULWRDUHODGHWDOLLOH
7RWDOLWDWHD QRWD LLORU GUDPDWXUJXOXL VFULVH WHKQLFH DOH PRQW ULL VSHFWDFROX
&21&(37 '(),1, ,$ 2%6(59$ ,,(;(03/(
&DWHJRULH HVWHWLF GLQ FDUH IDF SDUWH
VLWXD LL UHSOLFL WLSXUL XPDQH PRUDYXUL FDUH ±7LSXULGHFRPLF
SURYRDF UkVXO xGH PRUDYXUL LPRUDOLWDWHD FR
± HVWH JHQHUDW GH UHJXO GH XQ FRQWUDVW UXS LDHWF
vQWUH DSDUHQ HVHQ IUXPRV XUkW xGHVLWXD LH
$ULVWRWHO YDORDUH QRQYDORDUH VFRS xGH LQWULJ VLWXD LDLQWULJ HVWH
PLMORDFH YLX PHFDQLF + %HUJVRQ KLODU
LQWHQ LHILQDOLWDWHHIRUWUH]XOWDWXOGHUL]RULX xGHFDUDFWHU
DODFHVWXLD.DQW xGHOLPEDM
± IRUPH DVRFLDWH XPRUXO VDWLUD LURQLD xFRPLFXOQXPHORUSURSULL
VDUFDVPXOJURWHVFXO
± Ä&HHD FH FRQWHD] vQ WUDJHGLH
H XQ FRQIOLFW UHDO DO OLEHUW LL
VXELHFWXOXL FX QHFHVLWDWHD RELHF
JUWUDJRGLD FkQWHFXO DSXOXLIUWUDJpGLH WLY FDUHFRQIOLFWQXVHVIkUúHúWH
6SHFLH D JHQXOXL GUDPDWLF ED]DW SH FX vQIUkQJHUHD XQXLD VDX DOWXLD
UHSUH]HQWDUHD vQ DF LXQH D FDWHJRULHL FL FX DSDUL LD ORU VLPXOWDQ vQ
HVWHWLFH D WUDJLFXOXL RSHU GUDPDWLF vQ FRPSOHW LQGHSHQGHQ FXYLFWR
FDUH VXQW UHSUH]HQWDWH SHUVRQDMH HURLFH vQ ULD úL vQIUkQJHUHD DPkQGXURUD´
VLWXD LL FRQIOLFWXDOH I U LHúLUH DO F UXL ) : 6FKHOOLQJ Ä6XELHFWXO
GH]QRG PkQW HVWH vQIUkQJHUHD VDX SLHLUHD WUDJHGLHLHROXSW vQWUHH[LVWHQ D
XQRU YDORUL XPDQH vQP VXU V WUH]HDVF H[WHULRDU ILQLW úL DVSLUD LD
VSDLPDFRPSDVLXQHDPLOD LQWHULRDU LQILQLW ´)6FKOHJHO
± FRQIOLFW WUDJLF LPSRVLELO GH
DQXODWI U VROX LH
K\EULV YLQDWUDJLF
Ä3ULYDW GH GLPHQVLXQL WUDJLFH
DXWHQWLFH QRQHURXO GLQ WHDWUXO
ODWWUDJLFRPRHGLD
FRQWHPSRUDQ H ULGLFRO SULQ
6SHFLH D JHQXOXL GUDPDWLF vQ FDUH
SUH]HQ D VD úL WUDJLF SULQ UH]R
WUDJLFXOúLFRPLFXOVXQWOHJDWHvQDFHHDúL
QDQ DLPSOLFD LLORUúLDVRFLHULORUSH
VWUXFWXU OXPLQkQGXVHUHFLSURF
FDUH GHVWLQXO V X H[LVWHQ LDO OH
VXEVSHFLHIDUVDWUDJLF
SRDWH WUH]L vQ FRQúWLLQ D VSHFWD
WRUXOXL´5RPXO0XQWHDQX
JUGUDPD DF LXQH
± &ODVLILFDUH GUDP URPDQWLF
3LHVD GH WHDWUX vQ FDUH XQ FRQ LQXW
UHDOLVW EXUJKH] PRGHUQ
VHULRV XQHRUL WUDJLF HVWH SUH]HQWDW vQWUR
GUDP LVWRULF PRUDO GUDP
IRUP IDPLOLDU FKLDU FRPLF DUH XQ WRQ
GH LGHL GUDP H[SUHVLRQLVW
PDLSX LQHOHYDWGHFkWWUDJHGLDSUH]HQWkQG
GUDP H[LVWHQ LDOLVW DEVXUG
R DF LXQH YLROHQW VDX GXUHURDV vQ FDUH
PHORGUDP HWF
FRPLFXOVHSRDWHvPSOHWLFXWUDJLFXO
02'(/'($1$/,= 67,/,67,&
7HDWUXOSDUDERO ,RQDGH0DULQ6RUHVFX
Ä7UDJHGLD vQ SDWUX WDEORXUL³ VFULV GH 0DULQ 6RUHVFX ÄVFULLWRU FX R VFOLSLWRDUH
SHUVRQDOLWDWH FDUH SRVHG DWkW SURIXQ]LPHD ILOR]RILF D OXL %HFNHWW FkW úL R YL]LXQH
DSDUWHFXWRWXOSHUVRQDO DVXSUDQHSXWLQ HLGHFRPXQLFDUH´*UHWD%URWKHUXVDIRVW
MXFDW FXU VXQ WRUVXFFHVSHPDULOHVFHQHDOHOXPLL,QFOXV DO WXULGH3DUDFOLVHUXO
úL0DWFDvQWULORJLDÄ6HWHDPXQWHOXLGHVDUH´WLWOXOWULORJLHLHVWHRPHWDIRU DVHWHLGH
DEVROXWDRPXOXLSDUDERODGUDPDWLF ,RQDLOXVWUHD] SHUIHFWWHDWUXOPHWDIRULFVDX
©PHWDIL]LFªFXPODQXPLWSRHWXOGUDPDWXUJ
&HOH WUHL SLHVH VXQW ÄPRQRGUDPH VDX WUDJHGLL FROHFWLYH´ 0DULQ 6RUHVFX
([WHPSRUDO GHVSUH PLQH SH WHPD GHVWLQXOXL XPDQ GUDPH DOH F XW ULL VSLULWXDOH
VHWHDGHDGHY UGHFXQRDúWHUHGHOLEHUWDWHúLGHPQLWDWHVXQWSHQWUXHURLLWUDJHGLLORU
PRGHUQHDOHOXL0DULQ6RUHVFXF LGHDLHúLGLQDEVXUGXOYLH LL
6XQW LQVSLUDWH GLQ PLWXUL IXQGDPHQWDOH ELEOLFH PLWXO OXL ,RQD PLWXO SRWRSXOXL vQ
0DWFD VDX IROFORULFH PLWXO PHúWHUXOXL 0DQROH vQ 3DUDFOLVHUXO SH FDUH GUDPDWXUJXO
OHSDUDIUD]HD] DGRSWkQGIRUPXODPRQRORJXOXLDEVXUGvQFDUHWUDJLFXOúLFRPLFXO
JURWHVFXOúLOLULVPXOVHvPSOHWHVF
3HUVRQDMHOH VXQW SURLHF LL DOH HXOXL HVHQ LDO úL SURIXQG Ä'DF ,RQD úL
3DUDFOLVHUXOVXQWHXWRWHXVXQWúLWHDWUXOPHXLVWRULF´
,RQD VFULV vQ SXEOLFDW vQ HVWH R WUDJHGLH vQ SDWUX WDEORXUL R
SLHV ÄGHVSUHXQRPVLQJXUQHPDLSRPHQLWGHVLQJXU´7HPDFRQGL LHLRPXOXLvQWU
XQXQLYHUVFRQILJXUDWFDVSD LXYLVFHUDOvQFKLVVXSUDSXVVHGH]YROW FDRGH]EDWHUH
GHVSUH OLEHUWDWH úL QHFHVLWDWH GHVSUH UDSRUWXO GLQWUH LQGLYLG úL FROHFWLYLWDWH GLQWUH
LQGLYLG úL VLQHOH HVHQ LDO GHVSUH VLQJXU WDWH úL PRDUWH GHVSUH VHQV úL QRQVHQV
H[LVWHQ LDOÌPLYLQHV VSXQF ,RQDVXQWHX«&HOFDUHWU LHúWHvQ DUDGH)RFHVWH
WRW,RQDRPHQLUHDvQWUHDJ HVWH,RQDGDF PLSHUPLWH,RQDHVWHRPXOvQFRQGL LDOXL
XPDQ vQID DYLH LLúLvQID DPRU LL
7LWOXO SLHVHL FDUH QXPHúWH XQLFXO SHUVRQDM FH GLDORJKHD] FX VLQH vQ VFHQ
VWDELOHúWH R UHOD LH GLUHFW FX PLWXO ELEOLF GHVSUH ,RQD ILXO OXL $PLWDL $FHVWD HVWH
vQJKL LW GH XQ FKLW ILLQGF vQ ORF V SURSRY GXLDVF FXYkQWXO 'RPQXOXL vQ FHWDWHD
1LQLYHIXJHFXRFRUDELHVSUH7DUVLV'XS WUHL]LOHúLWUHLQRS L,RQDHVWHHOLEHUDWGLQ
SkQWHFXOPRQVWUXOXLPDULQ
3RYHVWHDVDFU FRQVWLWXLHSHQWUX0DULQ6RUHVFXGRDUXQGHVHQHSLFSULPRUGLDO
SHFDUHVHED]HD] IDEXOD LDGUDPHL'H]YROWDUHDVFHQLF DSDUDEROHLRPXOXLvQJKL LW
GH R EDOHQ HVWH IRDUWH PRGHUQ SROHPLF úLSDURGLF DSURSLLQGXOSH6RUHVFXGH
PDULL DSRORJH L DL VLQJXU W LL 1LHW]VFKH FDUH IRUPXODVH DIRULVPXO 6ROLWXGLQHD PD
vQJKL LWFDREDOHQ &DPXV6DUWUH+HLGHJJHU(PLO&LRUDQ)RDUWHPRGHUQ HVWHúL
IRUPXODGUDPDWLF DOHDV GHSRHWXOGUDPDWXUJ&HOHSDWUXDFWHVHvQO Q XLHvQWUXQ
PRQRORJ DSURDSH LPSRVLELO GH VXEvPS U LW FDUH SRDWH FRQVWLWXL SURWRWLSXO XQXL WH[W
GHVFKLV
8QLYHUVXOGUDPDWLFDOSLHVHLVHFRQVWUXLHúWHWUHSWDWQXSULQDFXPXODUHGHIDSWH
SULQSURJUHVLDDF LXQLLFLSULQGLDORJXOFRQIOLFWXDO7UHSWDWSHUVRQDMXOXQLFDOSLHVHL
VH GLYLGH vQ ÄYRFL´ H[SULPkQG ILHFDUH R FRPSRQHQW D HXOXL VFLQGDW ,RQDSHVFDUXO
RPXOSUDJPDWLFY ]XWPDLDOHVvQLSRVWD]DVDGHILLQ VRFLDO ,RQDJKLQLRQLVWXO
WU LQGvQRUL]RQWXOQHQRURFXOXL,RQDYLV WRUXOQ ]XLQGvQVRPQVDXWUHD]V SULQG
SHúWHOHFHOPDUH,RQDYLFWLPDRPXOFDSWLYvQVIHUHOHFRQFHQWULFHDOHGHWHUPLQ ULORU
FDUHvLDQXOHD] OLEHUWDWHD,RQDF XW WRUXOSURSULXOXLDGHY UDOLGHQWLW LLVLQHOXLGH
DGkQFLPH RPXO OXFLG FDUH PHGLWHD] DVXSUD FRQGL LHL VDOH H[LVWHQ LDOH ,RQD
OXSW WRUXO FDUH VH RSXQH DEVXUGXOXL H[LVWHQ HL ,RQDDUKHXO FDUH UHIDFH VLPEROLF
WRDW LVWRULDRPHQLULLQ ]XLQGV VHQDVF LDU úLúLLDU úL,RQDDVFHWXOFXEDUE FDD
VFKLYQLFLORU GH SH IUHVFH ,RQDLOXPLQDWXO FDUH KRW UkW V U ]EDW OD OXPLQ
GHVFRSHU F OLEHUWDWHDHvQO XQWUXOV XvQVSLULW
)RUPXOD GLDORJXOXL FX VLQHOH ÄPRQRORJ GLDORJDW´ HVWH MXVWLILFDW vQ
GHVFKLGHUHDSLHVHL&DRULFHRPVLQJXU,RQDYRUEHúWHWDUHFXVLQHvQVXúL«
6LWXD LDLQL LDO DFWXO,vQFDUHHVWHVXUSULQVHURXOHVWHRPHWDIRU DDEVXUGXOXL
OXPLL &X ID D VSUH PDUH vQWUXQ RUL]RQW DO DúWHSW ULL SHUSHWXH FD úL HURLL GLQ
Ä$úWHSWkQGXO SH *RGRW´ GH 6DPXHO %HFNHWW ,RQD VH DIO I U VR úWLH vQ JXUD
LPHQV D EDOHQHL GHFL vQWUR VLWXD LH QHIDVW $FHVW DIDU LQL LDO HVWH LOX]RULX F FL
,RQD HVWH FDSWLY vQ SODVD UXWLQHL FRWLGLHQH vQ DXWRPDWLVPHOH GH ILLQ VRFLDO DOH
SURIHVLXQLL ± 6XQW SHVFDU úL WUHEXLH V VH J VHDVF RULFkQG XQ SHúWH vQ FDVD PHD
$OWIHOFHDU]LFHOXPHD"±úLDOHUHVSRQVDELOLW LORUGHFDSGHIDPLOLH6R LDPHDP
LXEHúWHGDUQXFkQGVWDXúLP XLWODSHúWL&RQWHPSODUHDHOVW FHDVXULvQWUHJLV
SULYHDVF SHúWLLGLQDFYDULXúLYLVXOFDúLHURXOGLQ% WUkQXOúLPDUHDGH+HPLQJZD\
,RQD YLVHD] GH R YLD V SULQG SHúWHOH FHO PDUH VXQW WHQWDWLYH DOH HYDG ULL GLQ
PHGLRFULWDWHD úL DEVXUGXO UHDOLW LL 6H FRQILJXUHD] DVWIHO XQ SULP FRQIOLFW
H[LVWHQ LDOvQWUHUHDOLWDWHÄDIL´úLYLVÄDYRL´vQWUHUHDOúLÄLGHDO´1XPDLF YLVXO
SHVFDUXOXL ,RQD HVWH XQ SVHXGRLGHDO ILLQGF YLVDUHDHvQFKLV vQÄFHUFXOVWUkPW´DO
RUL]RQWXOXLV XH[LVWHQ LDOFDúLDS GXUDUXOXLFDUHYLVHD] FRSDFL(OQXHYDGHD]
FXDGHY UDWGLQFRWLGLDQúLGHVXE]RGLDQHQRURFXOXLÌQFHDUF vQV V OHGHS úHDVF
SULQ MRF SULQ VLPXODUHD XQHL DOWH UHDOLW L SHVFXLHúWH vQ DFYDULXO DGXV GH DFDV
vQWUH LQkQGXúLVSHUDQ DF JKLQLRQXODEVXUGXOvQVFULVvQGHVWLQXOV XSRDWHILDQXODW
-RFXO DUH IXQF LH FRJQLWLY F FL SULYLQG SHúWLL GLQ DFYDULX ,RQD LQWU vQWUR QRX
UHDOLWDWH GHVFRSHULQG VLPLOLWXGLQHD vQWUH GHVWLQXO V X GH SHVFDU JKLQLRQLVW úL FHO DO
SHúWLORU 0HWDIRUD RPXOXL±SHúWH UHOLHIHD] GXDOLWDWHD LUHPHGLDELO D I SWXULL FDUH vL
DSDUHvQDFHODúLWLPSFDYkQ WRUúLYkQDWFDÄvQJKL LWRU´ úL vQJKL LW´ Ä « 1RL SHúWLL
vQRW PSULQWUHQDGH9LVXOQRVWUXGHDXUHV vQJKL LPXQDELQHvQ HOHVSHFHDPDL
PDUH´VSXQH,RQDúLFXYLQWHOHÄURVWLWH´SXQXQVHQVúLXQURVWvQOXPHDDEVXUG SkQ
DFXP Ä9LVXO´ GH D SULQGH SHúWHOH FHO PDUH VH UHYHOHD] DFXP FD IDOV LGHDO FD R
QDG FH DVFXQGH SULPHMGLD PRUWDO SHQWUX RP GH D Q ]XL VSUH YDORUL PDWHULDOH
/LPEDMXO YRUE ULH I U úLU OD vQFHSXW DYkQG DSDUHQ D XQHL LPSURYL]D LL GHYLQH
WUHSWDW IRUP D WU LULL FRQúWLHQWH PLMORF GH LQYHVWLJDUH RQWRORJLF LQVWUXPHQW DO
FXQRDúWHULL 'H FkQG VSXQ FXYLQWH I U úLU VLPW F PL UHFXSHUH] DQLL IUXPRúL GH
YLD
,]RPRUILVPXO SHVFDU SHúWH úL FLWDUHD SURYHUEXOXL SRSXODU GHVSUH SHúWHOH FHO
PDUHFDUHOvQJKLWHSHFHOPLFGHYLQVXSRUWXOWH[WXDODOQRLLVLWXD LLGUDPDWLFHSURSXVH
vQDFWXODO,,OHDÌQJKL LWGHEDOHQDvQJXUDF UHLDVHDIODvQF GHODvQFHSXW,RQDvúL
vQFHSH F XWDUHD LQL LDWLF úL DYHQWXUD FXQRDúWHULL 3ULPHOH FXYLQWH VSXVH GH ,RQD
vQDLQWH GH D VH GHVFRSHUL SUL]RQLHU vQ SkQWHFHOH FKLWXOXL VXQW VHPQXO LQWU ULL vQWUR
DOW GLPHQVLXQH WHPSRUDO 0L VH SDUH PLH VDX H WkU]LX" (URXO WU LHúWH PDL vQWkL OD
QLYHO DIHFWLY 6HQWLPHQWXO ÄWkU]LXOXL´ HVWH XUPDW GH FHO DO UHVHPQ ULL ÌQFHSH V ILH
WkU]LXvQPLQH8LWHVDI FXWvQWXQHULFvQPkQDGUHDSW úLQVDOFkPXOGLQID DFDVHL
>«@±7UHEXLHV GRUPL±'HFHWUHEXLHV VHFXOFHWR LRDPHQLLODVIkUúLWXOYLH LL"±
+DL SXQH FDSXO MRV 0HWDIRUD PRU LL Y ]XWH FD VRPQ VXEOLQLD] VWHUHRWLSLD FH
GHILQHúWHvQF JkQGLUHDOXL,RQD0RPHQWXOLHúLULLGLQFOLúHXOUHSUH]HQW ULORUFROHFWLYH
FDúLGHS úLUHDDIHFWHORUSULQJkQGLUHHPDUFDW SULQHIHFWXOVFHQLFDOOXPLQLLÄ' V
VH FXOFH ÌQ DFHVW PRPHQW OXPLQD VH DSULQGH EUXVF ( FD R LGHH FDUH LD YHQLW OXL
,RQD±$VWDHUD±3HúWHOH0DvQJKL LWGHYLXVDX«GHPRUW
&RQIOLFWXO FDUH VH HYLGHQ LD] DFXP vQWUH WU LUH úL JkQGLUH HVWH XQXO
SVLKRORJLF 5LGLFkQGXVH SH WUHDSWD UD LXQLL ,RQD vúL vQYLQJH WHDPD GH PRDUWH úL
UHVHPQDUHD vQ ID D HL (URXO VH LQVWDOHD] DVWIHO OXFLG vQWUXQ ÄWLPS DO UXSWXULL
GHWHUPLQDWGHGRX IRU HSULPDHVWHIRU DRSUHVLY DPHPRULHLFDUHvODVDOWHD] FX
DPLQWLULOH DXWRPDWLVPHORU FH LDX DOF WXLW YLD D DIDU FHDODOW H IRU D GH HOLEHUDUH
FDUH vO PkQ vQDLQWH GLVWUXJkQG SURJUHVLY QHHVHQ LDOXO LQVWDXUDW vQ H[LVWHQ D
H[WHULRDU ´7UHSWDW,RQDVHvQGHS UWHD] GHPRGHOXOYLH XLULLLQFRQúWLHQWHÄYHúQLFD
PLVWXLUH´ ÄGHYHQLUH vQWUX GHYHQLUH´ ILJXUDW SULQ LSRVWD]D SHVFDUXOXL FDUH vúL YHGH
SUDJPDWLF GH ÄWUHEXúRDUD OXL´ 6H HOLEHUHD] GH VWHUHRWLSLL úL DGHU OD XQ
FRPSRUWDPHQW PLWLF HVHQ LDO (YROX LD VSLULWXDO D SHUVRQDMXOXL HVWH PDUFDW SULQ
UHDFWXDOL]DUHDÄSRYHúWLLFXXQXOFDUHDIRVWvQJKL LWGHXQFKLW´1XPDLF ,RQDOXFLGXO
VH RSUHúWH DFXP OD MXP WDWH QHvQ HOHJkQG vQF VROX LD PLWLF D SDUDEROHL ,QVWDODW
GHSOLQ vQ VIHUD UD LXQLL ,RQD LD SURJUHVLY vQ VW SkQLUH FD XQ DGHY UDW H[SORUDWRU
VSD LXOYLVFHUDODF UXLOHJHXQLF HVWHOXSWDSHQWUXVXSUDYLH XLUHÄYHúQLFDPLVWXLUH´
$UPHOHVDOHVXQWORJRVXOFDIRUP GHOLEHUWDWHSULQFDUHvQYLQJHVLQJXU WDWHDIL]LF
)DFFHYUHDX9RUEHVF6 YHGHPGDF SRWV úLWDF±ÌQFHDUF ±1XPLHIULF
DF LXQHD PHUVXO F XWDUHD XQHL LHúLUL VXQW QHLVWRYLWH WLQ]kQG V FRQúWLHQWL]H]H
OLPLWHOH3RWV PHUJXQGHYUHDX±0HUJHvQWURGLUHF LHSkQ VHL]EHúWHGHOLPLW
DVXPDUHD FRQúWLHQW D SURSULHL H[LVWHQ H GHVFRSHULUHD FX LWXOXL FX FDUH vQFHSH V
VSLQWHFH EXUWD EDOHQHL úL PDL DOHV UD LXQHD ,RQD YLVHD] DFXP V vQWHPHLH]H XQ
VSD LX DO FXJHW ULL R EDQF GH OHPQ vQ PLMORFXO P ULL >@ O FDú GH VWDW FX FDSXO vQ
PkLQLvQPLMORFXOVXIOHWXOXL/DELULQWXOSHFDUHOVWU EDWHvORULHQWHD] SH,RQDVSUHXQ
PHUHXDOWvQFHSXW(OVSLQWHF EXUWDEDOHQHLGDUVHYDUHJ VLSUL]RQLHUvQWUXQVSD LX
YLVFHUDO PDL DPSOX $FWXO DO WUHLOHD VH FRQVXP PHUHX ÄvQ XQWUX´ SHúWHOH ,, úL
SHúWHOH ,,, FHL WUHL SHúWL VSLQWHFD L DPLQWHVF GH FHOH WUHL SUREH LQL LDWLFH GHS úLWH GH
HURXO GLQ EDVPH (úHFXO UHSHWDW DO vQFHUF ULL GH D LHúL GLQ FDSWLYLWDWH GLQ EDOHQD
vQJKL LW GHRDOWDPDLPDUHUHSUH]LQW WHQWDWLYDGHDGHS úLFRQúWLLQ DQHIHULFLULLD
VLQJXU W LL D FRQGL LRQ ULORU PXOWLSOH DOH H[LVWHQ HL XPDQH (URXO vQFHDUF V LD vQ
VW SkQLUHSULQFRQúWLLQ úLSULQDF LXQHVSD LXOH[LVWHQ LDODODEVXUGXOXLDOGH]RUGLQLL
(OGHYLQHÄRPXOUHYROWDW´FDUHUHIX] V VHODVHSULQVvQYkUWHMXOÄPRULORUGHYkQWDOH
]HLORU´ VDX vQ FDSFDQD LOX]LLORU GRQTXLMRWHúWL $SDUL LD SHVFDULORU , ,, vQ FHO GHDO
GRLOHD SHúWH QXO VDOYHD] SH ,RQD GHFkW GH VLQJXU WDWHD IL]LF ,PSRVLELOLWDWHD
FRPXQLF ULL FX FHL DVHPHQL OXL vO SURLHFWHD] vQWUR VLQJXU WDWH PHWDIL]LF vQ
DMXWRUXO RPXOXL DIODW vQWUR VLWXD LHOLPLW QX YD V UL QLPHQL GLQ VDW 1LPHQL GH SH
S PkQW1LPHQLGLQFHU$VDOWDWGHFRQúWLLQ DDFHVWHLVLQJXU W L,RQDVHUHIXJLD] vQ
ÄSRYHVWH´ vQ PLW $FWXDOL]DUHD PLWXOXL 0XPHORU HVWH VXSRUWXO XUP WRDUHL DYHQWXUL
LQL LDWLFHDOXL,RQDUHJUHVLDvQVSUHXQWLPSPLWLFDORULJLQLORU$FHDVWDVHV YkUúHúWH
SULQ LHúLUH GLQ GHVWLQ LQGLYLGXDO HFKLYDOkQG FX VSLQWHFDUHD EXU LL SHúWHOXL ,, úL
UHIDFHUHDvQVHQVLQYHUVDvQWUHJLLLVWRULLDXPDQLW LL,QWU PXQGHYUHPúLLHúLPFkQG
YUHP7UDYHUVkQG VLPEROLF GH]DVWUH 1D PDL J VLW ORFXO FD YHQLW XQ FXWUHPXU úL
PXULQG ÄFkWH SX LQ´ vQ U ]ERDLH U ]ERLXO SOHFDP OD U ]ERL 1H VFDS PHUHX FkWH
FHYDvQYLD 6ROGD LORUOHVFDS PDLDOHVSDFHD«ODSULPDOLQLúWHGHVFKLGRFKLLDWkW
GHODUJvLGHVFKLGF LQWU vQHLLDUEDúLS V ULOHFDvQFUDWHUHOHYXOFDQLORUVWLQúL,RQD
GHYLQH DUKHWLSXO DUKHXO FH VH QDúWH LDU úL LDU 0DP PL VD vQWkPSODW R PDUH
QHQRURFLUH0DLQDúWHP RGDW ±7XQXWHVSHULDGLQDWkWDúLQDúWHP PHUHX6H
LQVWDOHD] DVWIHOXQFRQIOLFWRQWRORJLFvQWUHYLD úLPRDUWHFHQXVHSRDWHUH]ROYD
vQDEVHQ DOXL'XPQH]HX&HSXVWLHWDWH«$úYUHDV WUHDF 'XPQH]HXSHDLFL'DU
vQ ORFXO GLYLQLW LL vQ RUL]RQWXO vQWXQHFDW DO EXU LL SHúWHOXL ,,, VHDUDW GRDU SXLL
QHQ VFX LDLPRQVWUXOXLVLPEROXULDOHXQXLYLLWRUDPHQLQ WRU9LVXOGHDDYHDXQYLLWRU
VH WUDQVIRUP DFXP vQ FRúPDU SRVLELO DUJXPHQW SHQWUX LQWHUSUHWDUHD SLHVHL FD
SDUDERO SROLWLF ÌQWUXQ XOWLP HIRUW DFWXO DO ,9OHD ,RQD DSDUH vQ VS UWXUD EXU LL
XOWLPXOXLSHúWH3DUHvPE WUkQLWFXEDUEDGHPXFHQLFIOXWXUkQG3ULYHúWHvQ]DUHFD
vQWUR RJOLQG 'HVFRSHU FX GLVSHUDUH F RUL]RQWXO H GRDU XQ úLU QHVIkUúLW GH EXU L
1RXDUHYHODUHRUHDOLW LLFDúLUGHGHWHUPLQ ULGLQFDUHQXVHSRDWHLHúLFULVWDOL]HD]
XQ QRX FRQIOLFW H[LVWHQ LDO GLIHULW vQV GH FHO GLQ SULPXO DFW $FXP LGHDOXO DIODW vQ
UDSRUW FRQIOLFWXDO FX UHDOXO HVWH XQXO DXWHQWLF DVSLUD LD VSUH OLEHUWDWH D RPXOXL
UHSUH]HQWDW SULQVLPEROXOOXPLQLL
'HFL]LD ILQDO H VXUSULQ] WRDUH vQV vQWUR SHUIHFW ORJLF D GLVFXUVXOXL
GUDPDWLF 1HGHVFRSHULQG QLFLR FDOH GH VDOYDUH GLQ XQLYHUVXO vQFKLV vQ FDUH HVWH
LUHPHGLDELO FDSWLY HO FDXW LHúLUHD vQ VHQV LQYHUV DGkQFLQGXVH vQ SURSULXO RUL]RQW
O XQWULF $VXPkQGXúL FRQúWLHQW SURSULXO GHVWLQ DPLQWLUH SURJUHVLY D YkUVWHORU úL D
FHORU GUDJL GLQ IDPLOLH DVXPkQGXúL LGHQWLWDWHD (X VXQW ,RQD úL UHFXSHUkQG
XQLWDWHDILLQ HLVDOHDOWHUHJRXULOHOXL,RQDVHUHFRQFLOLD] vQWUXQÄQRL´DOVROLGDULW LL
vúL VSLQWHF SkQWHFXO VSUH D U ]EL FXPYD OD OXPLQ *HVWXO QX ILJXUHD] QHDS UDW R
VLQXFLGHUH FL SRDWH IL R VXJHVWLH úL R UH]ROYDUH VFHQLF D FRQIOLFWXOXL ,RQD vúL
FRUHFWHD] DVWIHOWUDLHFWRULDGHPHUVXOXLFRJQLWLY0RDUWHDULWXDOLF DHURXOXLDSDUHFD
LQWUDUHvQDOW HWDS H[LVWHQ LDO VXSHULRDU vQRUGLQHDFXQRDúWHULL(DHFKLYDOHD] FX
úDQVDHOLEHU ULLWRWDOHFXRQRX QDúWHUHFDILLQ VSLULWXDO FDUHWUDQVFHQGHSURSULD
PDWHULH (URXO SRDWH DVWIHO DWLQJH YLVDWD OLEHUWDWH XQ ÄDIDU ´ DGHY UDW DFHD SDOP
GH ORF SH FDUH V úL vQWLS UHDVF WDOSD DUV GH QRDSWH XUP D WUHFHULL VDOH SULQ
OXPHDYLH LLWU LWHFDÄGHYHQLUHvQWUXILLQ ´
3HUVRQDMVLPERO ,RQD H R YRFH D XPDQLW LL H XQ HURX WUDJLF FH VH UHYROW
VXSHULRU vPSRWULYD OLPLW ULORU RQWRORJLFH Ä8FLJkQGXúL´ HXO PDWHULDO HO HOLEHUHD] HXO
VSLULWXDOFHOGLYLQ(URXOVRUHVFLDQILLQ HD] PDLDOHVSULQOLPEDM,URQLDXPRUXOQHJUX
SDUDGR[XO DEVXUGXO SDUDEROD VLPEROXO DOWHUQHD] FX PHGLWD LL GHVSUH RDPHQL úL
OXFUXUL GHVSUH VHQV úL QRQVHQV vQ OXPH GHVSUH YLD úL PRDUWH 2ULJLQDO HVWH úL
DVRFLHUHD VWLOXOXL FRORFYLDO FX FHO LQWHQV SRHWLF GH R XOXLWRDUH DGkQFLPH ILORVRILF
$GHY UDW RSHU DQWRORJLF Ä,RQD´SRDWHILFRQVLGHUDW FDSRGRSHUDGUDPDWXUJLHLOXL
6RUHVFX SULQ IRUPXOD DUWLVWLF RULJLQDO SULQ SUREOHPDWLFD H[LVWHQ LDO D RPXOXL DIODW
vQF XWDUHDDGHY UXOXLGHVSUHVLQHvQDYHQWXUDGHVFRSHULULLOLEHUW LL
(9$/8$5(
3DUWLFXODULW LVWLOLVWLFHDOHRSHUHLGUDPDWLFH
&RQFHSWHVSHFLILFHGUDPDWXUJLHL
1RW 6XELHFWHOH SHQWUX FRORFYLXO SULPXOXL VHPHVWUX YRU FRQ LQH R SUREOHP
WHRUHWLF GLQ WHPDWLFD PHQ LRQDW úL R DSOLFD LH SUDFWLF DQDOL]D VWLOLVWLF D XQXL
IUDJPHQWGHWH[WOLWHUDUODSULPDYHGHUH
%,%/,2*5$),(6(/(&7,9
$GULDQ0DULQR,QWURGXFHUHvQFULWLFDOLWHUDU %XFXUHúWL(7ID
$GULDQ0DULQR+HUPHQHXWLFDLGHLLGHOLWHUDWXU &OXM1DSRFD(GLWXUD'DFLD
$OEHUW7KLEDXGHW)L]LRORJLDFULWLFLL%XFXUHúWL(3/8
$QJHOD %LGX9UkQFHDQX &ULVWLQD & O UDúX /LOLDQD ,RQHVFX5X[ QGRLX 0LKDHOD
0DQFDú *DEULHOD 3DQ 'LQGHOHJDQ 'LF LRQDU GH úWLLQ H DOH OLPELL %XFXUHúWL (GLWXUD
1HPLUD
%DUWKHV 5RODQG *UDGXO ]HUR DO VFULLWXULL 3RHWLF úL VWLOLVWLF %XFXUHúWL (GLWXUD
8QLYHUV
%RXVR R&DUORV7HRULDH[SUHVLHLSRHWLFH%XFXUHúWL
&RUWL0DULD3ULQFLSLLOHFRPXQLF ULLOLWHUDUH%XFXUHúWL(GLWXUD8QLYHUV
&HVDUH%UDQGL7HRULDJHQHUDO DFULWLFLL%XFXUHúWL8QLYHUV
&KDUOHV%DOO\7UDLWpGHVW\OLVWLTXHIUDQoDLVH+HLGHOEHUJ(GLWXUD:LQWHU
'LUHF LLvQFULWLFDúLSRHWLFDIUDQFH] FRQWHPSRUDQ ,DúL(GLWXUD-XQLPHD
'XPLWUX ,ULPLD 6WUXFWXUD VWLOLVWLF D OLPELL URPkQH FRQWHPSRUDQH %XFXUHúWL (GLWXUD
ùWLLQ LILF úL(QFLFORSHGLF
'XPLWUX,ULPLD,QWURGXFHUHvQVWLOLVWLF ,DúL(GLWXUD3ROLURP
(UZLQ+XIQDJHO,QWURGXFHUHvQKHUPHQHXWLF %XFXUHúWL8QLYHUV
(/RYLQHVFX,VWRULDFLYLOL]D LHLURPkQHPRGHUQH9RO±%XF
*LDQQL9DWLPR(WLFDLQWHUSUHW ULL&RQVWDQ D3RQWLFD
*DEULHOD3DQ 'LQGHOHJDQFRRUG'LF LRQDUGHúWLLQ HDOHOLPELLHGL LDD,,D%XFXUHúWL
(GLWXUD1HPLUD
* & OLQHVFX 7HRULD FULWLFLL úL D LVWRULHL OLWHUDUH úL ,VWRULD FD úWLLQ LQHIDELO úL VLQWH]
HSLF vQ3ULQFLSLLGHHVWHWLF %XFXUHúWL(3/
+HQU\N0DUNLHZLF]&RQFHSWHOHúWLLQ HLOLWHUDUH%XFXUHúWL8QLYHUV
+5-DXVV([SHULHQ DHVWHWLF úLKHUPHQHXWLF OLWHUDU %XFXUHúWL8QLYHUV
,RQ &RWHDQX 6WLOLVWLFD IXQF LRQDO D OLPELL URPkQH 6WLO VWLOLVWLF OLPEDM YRO ,±,,
%XFXUHúWL(GLWXUD$FDGHPLHLúL
,RQ&RWHDQX6WLOXULOHPRGHUQHDOHOLPELLURPkQHOLWHUDUHvQ/5,;
,RQ&RWHDQX5HIOHF LLDVXSUDVWLOLVWLFLLIXQF LRQDOHvQ6WXGLLGHOLPE OLWHUDU úLILORORJLH
,,%XFXUHúWL(GLWXUD$FDGHPLHL
,RDQ3kQ]DUX3UDFWLFLDOHLQWHUSUHW ULLGHWH[W%XFXUHúWL3ROLURP
-HDQ6WDURELQVN\5HOD LDFULWLF %XFXUHúWL8QLYHUV
/HR6SLW]HU(WXGHVGHVW\OH3DULV*DOOLPDUG
0DWHL& OLQHVFX$FLWLWDUHFLWL%XFXUHúWL3ROLURP
0LFKHO)RXFDXOW+HUPHQHXWLFDVXELHFWXOXL%XFXUHúWL3ROLURP
0LUFHD0DUWLQ6LQJXUDFULWLF &DUWHD5RPkQHDVF
0XUU\.ULHJHU7HRULDFULWLFLL%XFXUHúWL8QLYHUV
1RUWKURS)U\H$QDWRPLDFULWLFLL%XFXUHúWL8QLYHUV
1RUWKURS)U\H'XEODYL]LXQH%XFXUHúWL(GLWXUD)XQGD LHL&XOWXUDOH5RPkQH
3DXO&RUQHD,QWHUSUHWDUHúLUD LRQDOLWDWH%XFXUHúWL3ROLURP
3DXO &RUQHD &RQFHSWXO GH LVWRULH OLWHUDU vQ FXOWXUD URPkQHDVF 6WXGLX úL DQWRORJLH
%XFXUHúWL(GLWXUD(PLQHVFX
3DXO5LFRHXU(VHXULGHKHUPHQHXWLF %XFXUHúWL+XPDQLWDV
3LHUUH)RQWDQLHU)LJXULOHOLPEDMXOXL%XFXUHúWL(GLWXUD8QLYHUV
3OHWW+HLQULFKùWLLQ DWH[WXOXLúLDQDOL]DGHWH[W%XFXUHúWL(GLWXUD8QLYHUV
5HQH:HOOHN,VWRULDFULWLFLLOLWHUDUHPRGHUQHYRO,,9%XFXUHúWL8QLYHUV
5RODQG%DUWKHV3O FHUHDWH[WXOXL&KLúLQ X&DUWLHU
2VZDOG'XFURW-HDQ0DULH6FKDHIIHU1RXOGLF LRQDUHQFLFORSHGLFDOúWLLQ HORUOLPEDMXOXL
%XFXUHúWL(GLWXUD%DEHO
2YLGLX*KLGLUPLF+HUPHQHXWLFDOLWHUDU URPkQHDVF &UDLRYD6FULVXO5RPkQHVF
6HUJH'RXEURYVN\3HQWUXFHQRXDFULWLF 8QLYHUV
8PEHUWR(FR2SHUDGHVFKLV %XFXUHúWL(3/8
8PEHUWR(FR/LPLWHOHLQWHUSUHW ULL%XFXUHúWL8QLYHUV
5HGDFWRU$QGUHHD',18
7HKQRUHGDFWRU)ORUHQWLQD67(0$7(
&RSHUWD&RUQHOLD352'$1
%XQGHWLSDU&ROLWLSDU
)RUPDW[
(GLWXUD)XQGDêLHL5RP¼QLDGH0¼LQH
%XOHYDUGXO7LPLìRDUD1U%XFXUHìWL6HFWRU
7HO)D[ZZZVSLUXKDUHWUR
(PDLOFRQWDFW#HGLWXUDURPDQLDGHPDLQHUR