Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Isomorphism in Turkey?
Abstract
countries converging towards this policy. Inflation-targeting (IT) which is a type of monetary
policy was described as one of New Zealand’s most successful exports[ CITATION Bol08 \l
1033 ]. Core features of this policy include active communication, transparency and central
bank independence. Coincidentally, these features are also consistent with the characteristics
of liberal democrats, naturally making them early adopters of IT. However, IT later diffused
systems such as Turkey. In the first part of this paper, I attribute this global spread of IT to
reason for the untimely adoption of this policy in 2001 just as when it faced a crisis. The
policy’s success in dealing with inflation gives rise to the following policy puzzle;
Was Turkey more concerned about the successful implementation of this policy or merely
legitimizing its action as having followed the perceived gold standard policy? In other
The main finding of this paper finds evidences in Turkey’s incrementalism in its decision-
making process. Recognizing that a direct transition to full-fledged IT might lose credibility
of the central bank and the IT policy itself, the Central Bank of the Republic of Turkey
2
(CBT) adopted an implicit IT – acting like an inflation targeter but without formally adopting
one – and used this testing period to slowly establish communication, transparency and
institutional independence. These incremental steps were critical to the success of the formal
adoption of the policy in 2006, dismissing any doubt about Turkey seeking political cover
The paper is divided into two broad themes; policy diffusion and institutional isomorphism
and is organized as follows; section I explores gaps in the existing literatures which provide
isomorphism. Section II describes the data and methodology used to answer the policy
puzzle. Section III briefly introduces the core features of IT as pre-conditions which early
adopters of IT fulfilled. Section IV discusses the global spread of IT using concepts in policy
diffusion such as globalization, international actors and policy learning under the New Public
Management (NPM). In the second part of the paper, section V focuses on a type of
institutional isomorphism which might be present in Turkey. Section VI presents the main
findings followed by conclusion in section VII, acknowledging some limitations which might
Section I: Gaps and Implications of Analyzing Policy Diffusion through the Lens of
Institutional Isomorphism
Although there are numerous literatures on policy diffusion of IT, there is, to the best of my
knowledge, no single paper that analyzes policy diffusion through the lens of institutional
isomorphism, not to mention using Turkey as a case study. Therefore, this paper uniquely
positions itself to fill in this gap within the wider field of public policy. The policy
implication arising from my analysis may provide useful insights for scholars and
practitioners. Similar issues such as policy churn can also be better understood from my
The case study of Turkey provides invaluable lessons for many transition and even low-
income countries such as Vietnam who are considering whether to adopt IT. These new
comers typically faced similar issues as Turkey many years ago. While there are studies
which suggest that pre-conditions are not necessary for a successful implementation of IT
[ CITATION Nic06 \l 1033 ], this paper argues it was precisely because Turkey fail to fulfil
these pre-conditions that made the CBT adopt an intermediate regime instead of an abrupt
transition to full-fledged IT. Therefore, new comers who might not be liberal democrats and
lack central bank independence might have higher chances of initiating IT if they were to
take incremental steps as observed in Turkey. This potentially prevents an invaluable policy
such as IT from becoming a policy churn. This happens when policymakers simply search
for new policies without channeling resources to evaluate why the current policies did not
work [ CITATION Jas17 \l 1033 ]. As a result, policy learning or transfer becomes sub-
4
optimal especially when policymakers learn without transferring or transfer without learning
but just to legitimize their action as having followed the proven policy. While these might be
inherent in the bounded rationality behavior of policymakers, they could be avoided as seen
in this paper.
Section II: Data and Methodology Used to Answer the Policy Puzzle
The paper uses mainly secondary data from books and journal articles in addition to the
author’s working experience in the International Monetary Fund (IMF) on inflation targeting.
The concept which the paper uses to answer the policy puzzle is incrementalism during the
decision-making process in a policy cycle. From the applied problem-solving approach, this
stage is also known as the choice of solution. Quantitative methods include descriptive
statistics analysis of inflation data which was obtained from the Turkish Statistical Institute.
Economic data on monetary policy regime, public debt, inflation expectations, target and
actual inflation rates were taken from the IMF. A total of 42 countries were included in the
sample.1
Part I
1
Albania, Argentina, Armenia, Australia, Brazil, Canada, Chile, Colombia, the Czech Republic, the Dominican
Republic, The Eurozone, Georgia, Ghana, Guatemala, Hungary, Iceland, India, Indonesia, Israel, Japan,
Kazakhstan, South Korea, Mexico, Moldova, New Zealand, Norway, Paraguay, Peru, Philippines, Poland,
Romania, Russia, Serbia, South Africa, Sweden, Switzerland, Thailand, Turkey, Uganda, Ukraine, the United
Kingdom and the United States.
5
Section III: Core features of IT as Consistent with the Profile of Early Adopters
Inflation targeting (IT) is one of the monetary policies that aims to control inflation by setting
inflation target. [ CITATION Fre01 \l 1033 ] observed that when central bank adopts this
policy, it usually communicates the inflation target clearly to the public to anchor their
inflation expectations. This is usually done through regular press conferences and reports.
Active communication also helps to increase transparency about their monetary policy
operations in terms of how the target is set and what the central bank will do to achieve it. In
an event where actual inflation deviates significant from the target, central bank has to be
accountable to the government in the country. More importantly, the central bank must be
independent from the government and has full autonomy in deciding on the interest rate.
Having said this, it is generally prohibited from financing government. Coincidentally, these
core features of IT are also consistent with the principles of liberal democrats such as
Australia and Canada [ CITATION Was19 \l 1033 ]. This naturally made them early adopters
of IT (Figure 1).
One might think countries which adopted this policy later should also possess these
resulting in a clustering of similar policies. Early work by Jack Walker 1969 encapsulated
countries tend to have similar characteristics in terms of economic and political and similar
However, a closer look at these countries reveals that IT diffused to a heterogenous group of
countries with distinct differences in their political and economic systems [ CITATION
Was19 \l 1033 ] (Figure 2). Like the global spread of human rights and environmental
standards, IT diffused beyond spatial proximity and clustering of similar policies (Figure 3).
Emerging market (EM) economies in South East Asia and Latin America such as Brazil and
Chile adopted IT in 1999. Even transition countries in Central and Eastern Europe such as
7
Poland and Czech Started to converge towards this policy. To date, close to 40 countries2
have adopted IT with Russia being the newest member in 2015. Surprisingly, by early 2000s,
the share of EM and transition countries were about equal to the advanced economies (also
the early adopters of IT) and the former has since surpassed the latter these days (Figure 4).
2
For a full list of IT countries, please see Appendix A.1.
8
As much as policy making is a domestic affair, involving the government and the citizens, it
is almost impossible to study policy diffusion without considering the international system
within the wider policy subsystem. Globalization and the influential roles of the international
actors are important within the wider policy subsystem[ CITATION Fra94 \l 1033 ].
Contrary to the notion that international system shapes only international policies such as
trade, it sometimes also influences other more domestic policies such as healthcare and
9
pension [ CITATION Sar05 \l 1033 ]. Many literatures point to the role of globalization in
facilitating the medium which information transfers. For example, the effects of events that
happen in others of the world such as financial crisis and geopolitical risks in the Middle East
International actors are also actors (and policy advocates) themselves. When international
organizations such as the International Monetary Fund (IMF) regulates a government under
[ CITATION GBr96 \l 1033 ]. The traditional aid donor with its 189 member countries, has
largely therefore dominated the agenda setting due to financial resources it has [ CITATION
Mar98 \l 1033 ]. Moreover, they are more likely to intervene if there is already an existing
example, Turkey had a total of 19 lending arrangements3 with the IMF since its membership
in 1947. These loans were intended to support Turkey’s adjustment program especially
during a crisis. As part of the program, Turkey had to observe specific terms which were
usually austerity measures and was subject to periodic reviews so that the country continued
to have access to the loans. Therefore, Turkey’s history of fragmented policy subsystem
allowed the IMF to exert influence on various domestic policies especially in public debt
Another reason why the IMF was an agent of policy diffusion is the perceived rich repository
of experts[ CITATION Mic99 \l 1033 ]. Many of them have held key positions in major
3
For a full list of Turkey’s lending arrangements with the IMF, please see Appendix A.2.
10
central banks such as the Federal Reserves (Fed), Bank of Japan (BOJ) and the European
Central Bank (ECB). Hence, many central banks, including the CBT often leverage on this
the opportunity to use their country experiences and sell the policy to others. For example,
the IMF is an advocate of IT regime, given how successful it was in bringing down inflation
in many countries. This is evidence in their annual Article IV Consultation4 with country
authorities and through technical assistance in preparing countries to transit to IT from their
existing regimes. Heeding suggestions from the IMF to adopt IT was seen to be following the
Wasserfallen in 2019 tried to estimate the probability of taking up IT if the country is an IMF
member using a probit model. Therefore, the policy universe ensures constant interaction
between the international system and the policy network in the policy subsystem
While the international system may be at play, NPM scholars and academia researchers
generally agree that institutions actively learn (and even compete) with one another.
Literatures on policy learning gained traction after Charles Tiebout observed that local
governments offer similar tax policies to residents who will vote according to their preferred
tax rates [ CITATION Cha56 \l 1033 ]. This “race to the bottom” may not necessarily be
beneficial for the governments in the long run. However, most policy learning is welfare-
enhancing especially in the case of IT. Afterall, lessons from dealing with inflation need not
be drawn only from neighboring countries. In fact, many literatures came up with various
4
It refers to the annual IMF visit to assess economic and financial conditions with the respective country
authorities.
11
reasons why central banks should look beyond their borders when making policy choices
However, Paul DiMaggio and Walter Powell argued that not only do governments compete
for resources, but they also vie for political power and institutional legitimacy [ CITATION
Pau83 \l 1033 ]. They concurred with other authors that these electorally-minded politicians
are more concerned about retaining their political power than policy success. Having seen
that IT was unusually successful even when adopted by less liberal democratic countries such
as Kazakhstan, IT was hailed as the gold standard by not just the IMF but also by other
central banks. In the case of Turkey, the government was certainly not a liberal democrat as
shown in their Polity IV score5. Neither did the central bank have transparency,
accountability or independence in their monetary policy. Despite failing to meet most of the
core features (or the pre-conditions) of IT, CBT adopted the policy anyway in 2001 amidst its
banking and public debt crisis. Therefore, its decision to adopt IT could be due to the
institutional isomorphism which was motivated by the need for legitimacy [ CITATION
Isi02 \l 1033 ]. In other words, the CBT might be more concerned about legitimizing its
action as having the followed the gold standard rather than the successful implementation of
the policy. CBT’s decision-making process will be discussed in great details in the second
Part 2
5
Polity IV Scores measure the spectrum of regime authority.
12
Turkey had not been successful in ensuring price stability under its crawling peg exchange
rate regime which subsequently collapsed in 2001 [CITATION Ism12 \l 1033 ]. The country
went into a crisis with inflation surging to 68% due to the depreciation of the Turkish Lira
(Figure 5). Since the currency was losing value rapidly, the CBT had to drop six zeros from
the Lira denomination [CITATION Has08 \l 1033 ]. Moreover, there were significant
structural changes in the economy in 2001. For example, Turkey overhauled its banking
system by borrowing from the CBT. As a result, Turkey’s public debt increased to an
unsustainable level (Figure 6). Hasan Ersel argued that such fiscal dominance and the lack of
Source: Treasury
However, Turkey clearly needed an alternative monetary policy as the CBT had exhausted all
the available options to keep a lid on inflation. This presented an opportunity to open the
policy window to bring IT onto the government agenda. IT was a natural choice given its
success6 and the fact that policymakers have the tendency to model after institutions whom
they perceived to be more successful or legitimate in the field. This is known as mimetic
isomorphism7 which is likely to happen in a country with ambiguous goals or inconsistent yet
The decision-making process thus narrows down to a smaller subset which they perceive to
be politically feasible [ CITATION Her55 \l 1033 ]. Such bounded rationality explains why
Martin Lodge concluded that while policy transfers are never random, they are rarely a result
of sound and rational decision-making [ CITATION Mar03 \l 1033 ]. On the surface, Turkey
seemed to be learning from the success of other inflation targeters. However, only their
decision-making process will reveal if they were simply legitimizing their action by
6
To date, no country has turned back its decision after adopting IT according to the National Bank of Poland.
7
While there are three types of isomorphisms; namely coercive, mimetic and normative isomorphism, this
paper focuses on mimetic isomorphism as it is more relevant to Turkey.
14
searching for a proven template, without caring that the policy will actually work in Turkey
(or hoping that the highly successful policy will work by itself).
When the public policy process arrives at the decision-making stage, the number of policy
actors reduces significantly. The CBT was aware that IT transition does not take place
overnight and adopting the policy prematurely without resolving its current issues could do
more harm than good. For example, new or sudden shift in policy could introduce an
irreversible mistake or uncertainty which might confuse the public and signal that the central
bank was seeking political cover. This makes policymakers unlikely to implement disruptive
policies. Direct transition to full-fledged IT could therefore erode the credibility of both the
central bank and the IT policy itself, potentially leading to policy churn.
To work around its problems and signal to its citizens that the CBT was indeed concerned
about the successful implementation of the full-fledged IT one day, the CBT adopted an
intermediate regime known as the ‘implicit IT’ in 2001 (Figure 7). During the implicit IT
period, the CBT was acting like an inflation targeter but without formally adopting it. For
example, the CBT announced inflation target without other details of the policy [ CITATION
Ism12 \l 1033 ]. They still held onto the soft peg due to the fear of floating8 and the fact that
the credibility of implicit IT had not been established yet. The CBT tried not to deviate too
much from the current peg system whose costs and benefits were known to the actors
8
It refers to a central bank’s announcement that it allows its exchange rate to float freely but in reality, it
manages its exchange rate to reduce its volatility.
15
[ CITATION Mic09 \l 1033 ]. While the status quo played an important role in the decision-
making process, the CBT intended to use the period of implicit IT in 2001 as testbed to
When these pre-conditions of IT are met and credibility of IT is established, the CBT will be
The incrementalism which was manifested in Turkey, was dated back to the early work of
Yale University Political Scientist Charles Lindblom as he internalized the ideas of bounded
incrementalism accurately reflect how decisions are made by most organizations in reality.
model centers around learning by trial and error to test willingness to tradeoff between self-
initiating full-fledged IT, the CBT’s first task during the testing period of implicit IT was to
16
legalize central bank independence after the crisis in 20019. On 25th April, the Turkish
government and the CBT jointly passed The Central Bank Law, marking a radical
institutional reform in Turkey. The law gave the CBT full autonomy in pursuing its primary
objective of price stability without fiscal dominance. For example, the CBT is prohibited
from financing government deficit10. After the reforms, the CBT was ranked 4th in terms of
central bank independence and 3rd in terms of transparency and accountability among the
The Central Bank Law paved the way to other incremental reforms such as establishing
active communication and accountability. For example, it held various joint press releases
with the government to show coordination between the two parties in setting the inflation
target. Besides conducting regular household survey at the beginning of the implicit IT to
anchor inflation expectations, the CBT also reiterated that inflation was closing in on target,
giving its citizens the much-needed reassurance. Furthermore, Turkey did not cave in to the
pressure of having to increase its interest rate when actual inflation was higher than the target
as suggested by the rule of IT. Instead, the CBT directed its resources to push for fiscal
reforms to bring down the public debt and communicated actively to the public that
fundamentals in the economy were improving. Olivier Blanchard, then an IMF Chief
Economist, commended the CBT on a hindsight for doing the right thing as raising the
interest rate especially when fiscal sustainability was at stake could backfire and increase
inflation expectations even more due to rising default premiums [ CITATION Oli04 \l
1033 ].
9
For a full list of other fully independent countries in the sample, please see Appendix A.3.
10
For a full list of other central banks without fiscal dominance in the sample, please see Appendix A.4.
17
Since the CBT was well on track to its full-fledged IT adoption with its incremental steps
during these five years, its credibility quickly built up. The period of implicit IT saw the CBT
exceeding expectations in bringing down inflation from 68% in 2001 to just 7.7% in 2005
(Figure 8) and anchoring inflation expectations during the implicit IT (Figure 9). Moreover,
uncertainty around the transition period was fading as the local economy expanded for four
consecutive years.
When the CBT eventually adopted full-fledged IT in 2006, Turkey was in a favorable
position to implement the policy successfully, having established all the necessary reforms in
the past five years. Inflation was low and stabilized at 8% while the CBT had fully gained
independence. The CBT had also set up communication channels and formed a credible
Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) who votes11 on interest rate setting and publishes
medium to long term inflation forecasts [ CITATION Nie18 \l 1033 ]. Similar to the Fed’s
dot plot12, the decision of each MPC member is also made known publicly. With the MPC
comprising of both external and internal members that vote, the CBT can capitalize on each
member’s social preference based on their perception of how the economy works (Figure
10). Collective decision-making is also known to reduce idiosyncratic bias associated with
each member’s decision [ CITATION Mic09 \l 1033 ]. Finally, the CBT must submit open
letter to the government if the target is breached. This forces the CBT to be fully accountable
for any unusual deviation from its inflation target. In a nutshell, Turkey’s success story of its
11
Besides voting, other forms of decision-making include consensus and the governor’s decision. For a full list
of countries in the sample, please see Appendix A.5.
12
A dot plot refers to the forecast of interest rate of each member in the Federal Open Market Committee
(FOMC).
19
The paper aims to analyze policy diffusion through the lens of institutional isomorphism
using Turkey as a case study. Inflation-targeting policy, which was thought to be conducive
to liberal democrats (who were also the early adopters), diffused to a heterogenous group of
countries with distinct differences in economic and political systems with the aid of
globalization, international actors and policy learning. The adoption of IT in Turkey could
therefore be a result of institutional isomorphism given how the highly politicized country
might be more concerned about legitimizing its action as having followed the gold standard
rather than the successful implementation of the policy itself. This policy puzzle is answered
using incrementalism in the decision-making process of the CBT. During the period of
implicit IT between 2001 and 2005, there were concrete evidences that the CBT was
committed to making IT a successful policy rather than seeking political cover to fight its
inflation crisis. Though the concept of bounded rationality in incrementalism might carry a
negative connotation, this paper proves that it was instrumental in Turkey’s transition to full-
fledged IT in 2006. Finally, policy diffusion and institutional isomorphism will continue to
One limitation of the paper is the lack of data to analyze the contemporary setting in Turkey.
This comparative analysis would greatly complement this paper as a possible extension. As
Turkey is already a full-fledged inflation targeter and it has worked relatively well (Figure
12), all the reforms and laws are supposed to shield the CBT from fiscal dominance and
government intervention in monetary policy. However, this is not the case in the
contemporary Turkey. The era of the current Turkey’s President, Recep Tayyip Erdogan,
marks a drastic shift away from a parliamentary system, which has formed the foundation of
21
the modern Turkish 95 years ago. The appointment also gives him the power to appoint
ministers and intervene in the legal system. Within a year, President Erdogan made his son-
in-law, Berat Albayraka, the Finance Minister in the highly controversial cabinet shuffle and
went on to sack the central bank governor, Murat Cetinkaya, earlier this year for defying his
order to cut the interest rate to stimulate the economy. The President’s decisions certainly
have serious repercussions on both economic and political front. For example, Turkish Lira
depreciated by as much as 3% following the dismissal of the CBT head as inflation shot up
above its target (Figure 13). Policymakers and analysts fear that central bank is losing its
independence and nepotism in the country might destroy democracy. Will President Erdogan
undo all the good effort by the CBT in the past 20 years?
Figure 13: Inflation Surged Following the Dismissal of Central Bank Governor in 2019
Appendices
A.2: Turkey’s History of Lending Arrangement with the IMF in Thousands of Special
Source: IMF
A.4: Central Banks that are Prohibited from Financing Public Debt
BIBLIOGRAPHY (APA)
Bakir, C. (2007). Bank in the center: The Central Bank of the Republic of Turkey and a
Berry, F. S. (1994). Sizing Up State Policy Innovation Research. Wiley Online Library, 442-
456.
Blanchard, O. (2004). Fiscal Dominance and Inflation Targeting: Lessons from Brazil. The
Bollard, A. (2008). Flexibility and the limits to inflation targeting. BIS Review 95/2008, 4.
273-294.
Frederic S. Mishkin, K. S.-H. (2001). One Decade of Inflation Targeting in the World: What
Research.
26
Hasan Ersel, F. O. (2008). Fiscal Dominance and Inflation Targeting: Lessons from Turkey.
Kara, A. H. (2006). Turkish Experience With Implicit Inflation Targeting. Central Bank
Review.
79-88.
Lodge, M. (2003). Institutional Choice and Policy Transfer: Reforming British and German
Institution, 159-178.
Melissa Marschall, P. S. (2005). Keeping Policy Churn Off the Agenda: Urban Education
Michael Howlett, M. R. (2009). Studying Public Policy : Policy Cycles and Policy
Organization, 699-732.
Nicoletta Batini, D. L. (2006). Under What Conditions Can Inflation Targeting Be Adopted?
The Experience of Emerging Markets. Working Papers central Bank of Chile, 406.
Paul J. DiMaggio, W. W. (1983). The Iron Cage Revisited: Institutional Isomorphism and
160.
University Press.
Economics, 99-118.
416-424.
Walker, J. L. (1969). The Diffusion of Innovations among the American States. The