The American Delegate(s)*
at the First Zionist Congress
yas. Deer
August 1897, Rabbi Dr Schepse Schaffer
(1862-1933) of Baltimore traveled up to New
York to embark for Europe His destination
was Base, Switzerland, where the fst World
Zionist Congress was convening Rabbi
Ug) Scaller’s departure was trumpeted onthe front page
‘of at leat one NewYork Jewish newspaper (see the
sidebar on page 26), and echoes of his trip to Base stil
resonate today
In the pantheon of early American Zionist, Rabbi
Schafer cecupies a special place. Rabbi Schaffer was an
ardent advocate of Zionism throughout his aver In
1895, he became president of the Bakimore Zion
Assocation, Hevrat Zion, which was then one ofthe
largest local Zionist groups in Americ! When the
Federation of American Zionists, predecesor of the
Zionist Organization of Ameria, was organized in
1898, Rabbi Schaffer was chosen as one ots original
vice presidents and when the Mizrachi Religious
Zionists] of America Organization was established in
1913, Rabbi Schaffer was named (its frst Governing
(Council He remained activin the Mizrachi
movement for many years?
Any of thes leadership activites would have been
suficient to ensure Rabbi Schafer’ place of honor in
paseesdagy |
Ja anerce gt
Plast,
3 ered) rn
Ea BePPOTCHER EGS .
at cep Sai ce 17, Pr rier American Zionist history However, during the past
Sn at neers eben ‘century, Rabbi Schaffer’ fame a a Zionist ead has
soe Ca ne Wt ek argos, a, 18 rested mosty on his participation inthe fst World
(Stee owen Mana tt, eat 8
iraZionist Congres where he was the onl “oficial delegate
from the United States representing an existing Zionist
‘organization.
Pioneers (the fist) and singularities ("the ony")
often stand out, and, a a revult ae frequently the suff
of popular history. The fat that Rabbi Schaffer was the
only “ficial delegate fom an American Zionist
organization at the frst World Zionist Congeess has
been repeated in one variation or another for
‘generations, and it is now deeply embedded in Zionist
historiography and in collective memory, expecially
herein Maryland, Ofcourse, decades of imprecise
usage as led to some inaccuracies, In one account,
Rabbi Schafer was the only delegate fom the
United States” in another, he was "the sole American
representative! and in still another, the Rabbi was
“he representative ofthe Zionists of America”
Infact, four participants atthe Fist Zionist,
‘Congress signed in from the United States; we also
know that two of these participants were listed as
“Uelegates Who atended from the Une Sates,
and how did they get there? What, precisely, did it
mean to be a "delegate to the fist World Zionist
Congress! And why i his important, anyway?
‘The Congress Participants
“The frst World Zionist Congress convened in Bass,
‘Switzerland, on August 29,1897. For tree days, the
Congress participant listened to speeches and reports
‘on the condition of world Jewry, debate issuss, adopted
1 program “to establish a home forthe Jewish people
in Palestine." and defined the fundamental structare
‘ofa new World Zionist Organization
Daring the course ofthe Congres, an oficial ist
‘of participants was published, nang 199 men and
‘women, Two-thirds ofthese “partiipants” were there
in their “private capacities” mostly individual with a
strong interest in Zionism and the nationalist ideal
Sinty-nine ofthe partieipants were designated by
asteriks(*) as “delegates” representing Zionist
organizations ot Jewish communities. (Asin baseball,
asterisk do matter) Also on the official list were about
dozen journalist and several guess?
‘Most ofthe participants came fom Europe, as
might be expected given its dense concentration of
Jewish population atthe time andthe expectation that
Zionism would allevite the burden of antisemitism
‘specially in Purope. Only fou people were cited in
the oficial Congress ist of participants as coming
fom Ameria. Davis Treitsch (1870-1938), listed a4
participant from New York City, appears to ave been &
German national who resided in New York for several
years while studying immigration issues. Tetsch, an
advocate for Jewish settlement in Cyprus, the“ateray
to greater Palestine” paid his own way to Basel to
Tobby for his pet scheme sae the sidebar on page 28)
‘A second American participant was the redoubtable
Rosa Sonneschein (1847-1932), editor of The
American ewes, who was preset journalist
(see the sidebar on page 25). Sonneschein, who ad
advocated for a Jewish homeland in Palestine inthe
pages of her journal, came to Europe to caver two
conferences: the Zionist Congress in Base an, in
(October, the Woman's Congess in Brussels?
“The other two Americans atthe Congress were
Rabbi Schafer of Bakimore and Adam Rosenberg
(1858-1928) of New York City both of whom were
marked as oficial delegates in the “participants”
‘ofthe Congress” Adam Rosenberg’ journey othe
Congress was complicated. Bor in Baltimore, the son
‘of an immigrant German rabbi, Rosenberg grew up in
Germany, returned tothe United States around 1886 as
‘young man, and became an attorney in NewYork.
Although he iste remembered today, Rosenberg was
among the leading American Zionists ot his enertion,
{In addition to being active in New York’ Hovevei
Zion, n 1891 Rosenberg founded and presided over
‘Shavei Zion (Returners to Zion, an organization
composed of investors who sought to buy shares of
land in Palestine fr Jewish settlement, and, if ll went‘ll promote agriculture in the new evi colonies *
‘On behalf of Shae: Zon, Adam Rosenberg traveled
to Prope and Palestine in 1991
“Wien Burope heme with
ey Zions ears who had
Ascided in Sepever of hat
year to eal an "International
(Comite In Jaary 18%,
on a subsequent tip to Europe,
Rosenbera participate i the
fist “Work Congres of
Hover Zana which be
proposed establishing "Central
ion Federation” to offet the
fragmentation and duplcstion
of fan ad found among
the Zionist organizations and to
serve asthe singe coordinating
boy fr world Zonim*In
subsequent years, Rosenberg
continued te agitate for
4 Central Commitee of Hoven Tea
Zion inthe United States and eho =i
fora word cen. In this reg,
Rosenberg was forerunner of Theodor Her and
when Hera succeded inexablishng the Zionist
Congres anda Word Zion Organization,
Rosenberg’ leadership role quickly eroded"
‘Whe Her! began organizing he fist Zionist
‘Congress damn Rosenberg was among the leading
figures in American Zionist ciles—and one ofthe
few Zionist leaders who had diet experience of
(Palgrave Studies in International Relations Series) Christopher Daase, Caroline Fehl, Anna Geis, Georgios Kolliarakis (eds.) - Recognition in International Relations_ Rethinking a Political Concept i.pdf
Richard J. Goodrich - Contextualizing Cassian - Aristocrats, Asceticism, and Reformation in Fifth-Century Gaul (Oxford Early Christian Studies) (2008) PDF
(Palgrave Studies in International Relations Series) Christopher Daase, Caroline Fehl, Anna Geis, Georgios Kolliarakis (eds.) - Recognition in International Relations_ Rethinking a Political Concept i