Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
SOLUTION:
13,700,000
1,500,000
12,200,000
- 200,000
2,345,000
55,000
2,400,000
CASE STUDY
ADVISE TO AMELIA
The basic problem in this case study is whether or not Amelia has entered into a contract with any of
an invitation to treat because Amelia advertised her airplane for sale in Monday’s Daily Chronicle fo
that she invite people to see her and secure best offer’ . At this point, it was necessary to consider the
Billy indicated that he may be prepared to offer a lower sum. Since Amelia has (probably) not made
may be making an offer by post to sell at £19,000 but such an offer was only good upon communicati
£15,000. At this point, the question became whether or not Amelia’s initial statement was an offer – a
was unlikely to be an offer, Billy simply offered to pay £15,000; this was not accepted and no contrac
(assuming the advertisement is an invitation to treat) or a counter offer (if the advertisement is an off
contract can arise. When Charles sends his later email, he has either rejected an original offer (quaer
world can be rejected by only one offeree) and cannot now accept it or he is making an offer which A
any contract arises between the two of them. Doland’s letter seemed to give rise to the postal acceptan
has made an offer by her advetisement, then it seemed unlikely that acceptance by post is impliedly o
an acceptance) is only good upon communication. Before the communication, he withdrew what wou
has no reasonable expectation to protect). The only contract formed is with Eddie with the amount of
sum in cash.
SE STUDY
E TO AMELIA
into a contract with any of Billy, Charles or Doland. The better view was that it was
onday’s Daily Chronicle for ‘£20,000 for quick sale – best offer secures it clearly sees
necessary to consider the communications of Billy, Charles and Dolands in turn.
has (probably) not made an offer, Billy’s statement was really of no effect. Amelia
y good upon communication. Billy, when he received this offer, returned with
statement was an offer – and that it was to take the highest amount available. As it
t accepted and no contract arose. Charles’s email is either an offer at £18,000
the advertisement is an offer). Whatever it is, Amelia does not accept it and no
ed an original offer (quaere, though, if it is an offer whether or not one made to the
s making an offer which Amelia does not accept. On balance, it seemed unlikely that
e rise to the postal acceptance rules but does not really involve these rules. If Amelia
ance by post is impliedly or expressly authorised which means that Doland’s letter (if
on, he withdrew what would have been an acceptance by a faster method (meaning A
h Eddie with the amount of ‘£20,000 which amelia has offer when he provides the
SOLUTION NO.1
SOLUTION NO.2
SOLUTION NO.3
SOLUTION NO.4
3,600,000
600,000
4,200,000
8,400,000
1,200,000
9,600,000
200,000
8,200,000
100,000
8,300,000
1,710,000
300,000
105,000
1,815,000
24,000,000
1,000,000
25,000,000
4,800,000
100,000
2,400,000
500,000
7,800,000
17,200,000
SOLUTION:
SOLUTION NO. 2