Abstract
The amount of natural gas resources has a tendency of quickly increasing both on the
exploration and exploitation in recent years. In addition to natural gas (NG) energy, huge
amount of natural gas hydrate( NGH)deposited resource has also been discovered in Arctic
Pole and under the ocean in the last phase of 20th century. It is estimated the NGH quantity
about two or three times of all fossil fuels being discovered. So, in the following, a series of
most important problems about gas energy will be discussed. In the meanwhile, a series of
using properties of gas hydrate created new processing methods have also been introduced.
Figure 1 Global primary energy substitution, historical development from 1850 to 1990 [1]
1
Of course, the so-called gas energy age (or post-petroleum age) does not mean
petroleum will be stopped to use, but owing to the quick raising price of petroleum, it
will force people to find other more inexpensive, clean and efficient substitutes. So,
more exact to say, the ratio of gas energy will be increased in coming years and the
petroleum will soon pass the dominant position.
From the global point of view, coal, petroleum, nuclear energy and other fossil
fuels will also be in use simultaneously in the gas energy age, but gradually not in
dominant position. In between the mid of 21st century, the importance of gas energy,
especially the gas hydrate, will be gradually increased from a subsidiary to a dominant
role.
However, this is not absolute exact for some local area. In some local area, even
coal is in the dominant position yet; and in some other local area, petroleum is still
abundant enough to support the local economy for a long time period.
From Figure 1, we may expect at the end of 21st century or at early in 22nd century,
nuclear energy and sustainable energies may take over the dominant position, when it
increased to a certain extent.
From historical point of view for human beings, the dominant ages of energies
may be changed step by step. A summary of above-mentioned may be listed in the
following manner: wood energy coal energy petroleum energy gas and
sustainable energy nuclear and sustainable energy.
2
However, some problems [10] or even controversial ideas still exist in using LNG:
(1) low temperature of 161 C is required to transform natural gas into liquid state,
which is an energy-consuming process; and (2) a series of LNG storage tanks at the
receiving station may bring disaster possibilities causing by thundering, mis-operation,
terrorism attack or military attack etc., and it will be difficult to find the rescue
methods when disaster happened [11,12]; (3) it needs a deep chilling system for long
time storage, so it looks like uneasy to use as the mobile engine fuel.
Hence, (1) for the energy consumption, it is necessary to integrate some processes
for recovering the cold energy; (2) for the extra big metropolitan cities, it is better to
select other ways of natural gas storage instead of LNG; (3) for the mobile engine fuel
it can only be used for heavy truck or train for time being.
CNG may be taken as engine fuel with lower price than gasoline, from the
present market price. Some kinds of materials can be used as the CNG container,
where steel or composite materials may be the basic inexpensive materials. However,
a big CNG supporting network system is required to facilitate the users to get CNG
everywhere, when using CNG instead of gasoline as the engine fuel.
LPG may be obtained from two ways, one is from the light hydrocarbons
contained in petroleum or natural gas, and another is from the coal and petroleum
processing gas. It can be directly used as the substitute of gasoline or as raw materials
of chemical industry. It can be stored in liquid form under moderate pressure.
In summary, it should be emphasized that the gas energy is a cleaner energy than
coal and petroleum, but more expensive than coal in most countries. The technical
progresses on improving the efficiency of using gas energy should be advocated for
compensating the price difference.
3
The governments should set up a series of policy to help this double-win business
being realized in order to get a new energy, to reduce the pollution and to avoid the
coal mining disaster. The United Nations should encourage the developed countries to
help the developing countries to recovery CBG as much as possible [14-15]. We
expect this kind of cooperation will be more and more.
4
take the place of LNG, because energy consumption of NGH may be lowered nearly
30 40% than that of LNG and the security problem may easily be solved.
There will be at least two routes for NGH manufacturing, a continuous process to
produce gas hydrate ball [16-18] and a batch process using pressurized tank. For the
later it can be realized from point-to-point connection, i.e. from NGH production
place to the terminal users directly [20].
NGH may also be used in the purification and enrichment of CBG and other
processing gases. In CBG, methane is easier to form hydrate than N 2 and O2. The
methane content of CBG may be enriched from 60 70% to 85 95%, in the hydrate
phase.
People need the help of thermodynamic, and also the kinetic data to guide the
process of dissociation or formation of NGH. For the case of NGH formation, people
need to provide the 3-phase of natural gas–water–hydrate co-existence conditions. In
other words, the hydrate crystal should be growing with existence of natural gas at
chilling condition. Otherwise, the water will be changed to ice or only a small amount
of natural gas can enter the crystal cage.
It is well known that NGH will be an inexpensive and safe alternative for gas
storage and transportation in near future. In case it becomes a commercial method, it
might also be an adequate method for the local area or national strategic storage of
natural gas.
5
Another big amount of energy may be come from the recoverable plastic
materials, e.g. wrapping materials, farmer used film, city used plastic bag etc. The
recovered plastic will be the best feed for chemical industry, if it can be separately
recovered. For the iron and steel making industry, in some developed countries, the
recycling feed may arrive or even more than 50%. For the plastic production we also
advocate the recycling feed to enlarge the raw energy resources.
6
8 Energy Saving Strategy for Gas Energy Age
People should understand the gas energy couldn’t only be used as a simple
substitute of coal. Due to high expense of exploration, exploitation and the long
distance transportation, it ought to have higher efficiency of energy electricity
conversion, and also needs to use the exhausted heat as the heat-electricity
co-production.
The coal efficiency of heat-electricity conversion may approach to 30 40% in
some advanced power stations. For the power stations using gas fuel, the efficiency of
heat-electricity conversion ought to arrive to 48 52%. Furthermore, people now
concentrate efforts to approach higher efficiency to 60% by fuel cell joined with gas
turbine [40].
Many cities want to use natural gas instead of coal as directly burning fuel in
order to improve the atmosphere quality. In this case, sometimes people have to pay
fuel fee for natural gas as two times as for coal.
It is possible to lower down the price of final electricity product for the power
station using gas energy by following ways: (1) to build big power stations in-site of
gas field, the fuel price will be lowered 2 3 times than long distance transportation
via pipeline or LNG shipping; (2) to provide the gas fuel in the form of NGH with
point-to-point supply; (3) using some processing gas as combine cycle fuel, e.g. low
grade CBG; coke oven gas; metallurgical processing gas.
It is also possible to recover certain amount of cold energy from LNG with the
well-designed energy recovery system.
The United Nations should advocate people to set up rules to promote the use of
gas energy with high efficiency. And the local government ought to use the tax
measures to guide the gas energy using effectively. If people simply use the gas as
directly burning fuel to provide heat only, it would be added tax to some extent to
advocate the electricity-heat co-production.
7
air conditioning and heating system. The sustainable energies should undertake the
main role gradually with the progress of science and technology.
Some well-developed countries will be the pioneers of using sustainable energies.
Their experience may be used for helping the developing countries. In the
international communication, people ought to appreciate the pioneer’s contribution to
push the progress of using sustainable energies.
A well-developed international society ought to have the long-term plan: (1) to
help all member countries gradually to have a good existence condition; (2) to
develop the sustainable energy technology as fast as possible; (3) to save valuable
clean gas energy as much as possible. The United Nations ought to help people to set
up the scientific perspective view to solve the vigorous competition for limited fossil
energy resources.
Further, the nuclear fusion power station will be growing forward, and the gas
energy will be replaced by the nuclear fusion power and the sustainable energies at the
end of this century or early of next century.
8
References
[1] Nakicenovic, N. Global Prospects and Opportunities for Methane in the 21st Century.
http://www.igu.org/database/2003database/cop6/COP6_global.asp.
[2] Chen, Z-Y, et al. The natural gas hydrate research and the recent progress. Ocean Bulletin
(China). 2002, 21(3): 78-85.
[3] Kvenvolden, K A, Ginsburg, G D and Solovyev, V A. Worldwide distribution of sub-aquatic
gas hydrates. Geo Mar Lett. 1993, 13: 32-40.
[4] Sloan Jr, E D. Clathrate hydrates of natural gases. New York: Marcel Dekker, Inc, 1998.
[5] Li, J-H, et al. The strategic study of energy development. Beijing: Chemical Industry Press,
2004.
[6] Xu, Z-H, Wen, H, et al. The development of green process engineering in 21 st century.
Beijing: Chinese Petrochemical Industry Press, 2002.
[7] Fan, S-S. The technology of storage and transportation of gas hydrate. Beijing: Chemical
Industry Press, 2005.
[8] Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference on Gas Hydrate, vol. 4. Trondheim, 2005.
[9] Westport HPDI-LNG trucks in one-year “clean a corridor” demo.
http://www.greencarcongress.com/lng.
[10] Liquefied natural gas: the wrong choice for California.
http://www.pacificenvironment.org/lng/wrongchoice.htm.
[11] Liquid natural gas: not in anyone's backyard.
http://www.pacificenvironment.org/lng/intro.htm.
[12] Liquefied natural gas (LNG) threatens California's coastal communities.
http://www.sierraclub.org/ca/coasts/lng.asp.
[13] North American coalbed methane resource map, Coalbed gas production from three
emerging U.S. lower 48 basins. http://www.eandpnet.com/cbm/coalbed.html.
[14] The first biggest coal bed gas discovered in Shanxi province, China.
http://finance.sina.com.cn/news/1999-11-22/12829.html.
[15] China-USA cooperation in coal bed gas exploitation.
http://www.sx.chinanews.com/2005-06-16/1/23547.html.
[16] Takaoki, T, et al., Study of NGH carriers (making NGH powder for gas transportation).
Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference on Gas Hydrate. vol 4: 1258-1265,
Trondheim, 2005.
[17] Ogawa, T. Development of a novel hydrate-based refraction system. Proceedings of the Fifth
International Conference on Gas Hydrate. vol 4: 1241-1248, Trondheim, 2005.
[18] Mehta, A P and Klomp, U C. An industry perspective on the art of hydrates management.
Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference on Gas Hydrate. vol 4: 1089-1100,
Trondheim, 2005.
[19] Iwasaki, T. Continuous natural gas hydrate pellet production (NGHP) by process
development unit (PDU). Proceedings of the Fifth International Conference on Gas Hydrate.
vol 4: 1107-1115, Trondheim, 2005.
[20] Xu, Z-H, Ding, L-Y, Wen, H, He, X-F, Zhao, Y-H and Wang, W-H. Using cargo for
transportation, storage, and dissemination of natural gas. Chinese Patent, 200410033959.1,
2004.
[21] Vora, B V and Maker, T. Conversion of natural gas to ethylene and propylene: the
most-profitable option. Natural Gas Conversion V. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 1998: 955-960.
[22] Dautzenberg, F M, Schlatter, J, et al. Catalyst and reactor requirements for oxidative
coupling of methane. Catalysis Today. 1992, 13(4): 508-509.
[23] Methanol to propylene. http://www.cnreagent.com/news/viewnews.php?id=3068.
[24] MTO in UOP. http://www.uop.com/objects/26%20MTO%20process.pdf.
9
[25] The green technology of methanol production in Canada.
http://www.ctiin.com.cn/gjhz/xjsdt/xjsdt0207/xjsdt0711-7.htm.
[26] Han, J-C. The technical progress and development tendency of natural gas chemical industry.
http://www.spc.com.cn/spcspc/Chinese/tep/2002/200201/gn-01.htm.
[27] 120,000 ton/year methanol plant will be built in Shanxi Coking plant.
http://www.pharmnet.com.cn/news-s/02/2003-09-25/00063561.html.
[28] Harbin is now plan to built a 300,000 ton/year methanol plant.
http://www.sinopecnews.com.cn/shnews/2003-10/29/content_68152.htm.
[29] Yang, Feng. The heated point in new century for natural gas synthesis oil from natural gas
is going on. http://www. economicdaily.com.cn/history/20010418/hgb/hgb52737.htm.
[30] Piga, A and Loannides, T. Synthesis gas formation by catalytic partial oxidation of methane
in a heat-integrated wall reactor. Natural Gas Conversion V. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 1998:
411-416.
[31] Basini, L D and Amore, M. Syngas production by partial oxidation of methane: dependence
of reactivity on catalyst properties and contact time. Natural gas conversion IV. Amsterdam:
Elsevier, 1997: 429-434.
[32] Foster, E P, Tijm, P J A and Bennett, D L. Advanced gas-to-liquids process for syngas and
liquid-phase conversion. Natural Gas Conversion V. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 1998: 867-874.
[33] Solbakken, A. Synthesis Gas Production. Natural Gas Conversion. Amsterdam: Elsevier,
1991: 447-455.
[34] Parmon, V N and Kuvshinov, G G. New catalysts and catalytic processes to produce
hydrogen and syngas from natural gas and other light hydrocarbons. Natural Gas Conversion
V. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 1998: 677-684.
[35] Rostrup-Nielsen, J R and Dybkjar, I. Steam reforming, opportunities and limits of technology.
Chemical reactor technology for environmentally safe reactors and products. Dordrecht:
Kluwer Academic Press, 1993: 249-281.
[36] Moorehead, M. Gas-to-liquid fuels can give us energy independence.
http://www.progressiveengineer.com/PEWebBackissues2003/PEWeb%2034%20Jan%2003-2
/34editor.htm.
[37] Vora, B V and Arnold, E C. Conversion of Methanol to Ethylene and Propylene with the
UOP/HYDRO MTO Process. Petroleum and Natural Gas J. (China). 1997, 26(3): 131-137.
[38] Parkyns, N D and Warburton, C I. Natural gas conversion to liquefied fuels and chemicals:
Where does it stand? Catalysis Today. 1993, 18(4): 385-442.
[39] Leiben Clean and high efficient hydrogen energy.
http://www.newenergy.org.cn/kepu/kp1027~1.htm.
[40] De Simon, G, et al. Simulation of process for electricity energy production based on molten
carbonate fuel cell. http://www.elsever.com/locate/jpowsour.
[41] Hnatow, M A and Happel, J. Process and apparatus for separation of constituents of gases
using gas hydrates. US Patent, US 5434330, 1995.
[42] Elliott D G and Chen J J. Process for separating selected components from multi-component
natural gas streams. PCT Patent, WO 97/09271, 1997.
[43] Max, M D and Pellenbarg, R E. Desalination through methane hydrate. US Patent, US
5873262, 1999.
[44] Max, M D. Controlled cooling of input water by dissociation of hydrate in an artificially
pressurized assisted desalination fractionation apparatus. US Patent, US 6830682 B2, 2004.
[45] Heist, J A. Freeze crystallization. Chem Eng. 1979, 7: 72-82.
[46] Ichijo, T and Nakamura, K. Refrigerating method and refrigerating system utilizing gas
hydrate. UK Patent, GB 2402732 A, 2004.
[47] Zeller, R L, Fritts, S D, Johnson, D V, et al. Method of recovering chlorine from a gas
mixture. US Patent, 5985226, 1999.
10
[48] Kiyono F and Saito T. Method of separating and recovering carbon dioxide from combustion
exhausted gas and apparatus therefore. US Patent, US 6372023 B1, 2002.
[49] Spencer, D F and Currier, R P. Methods of selectively separating CO2 from a
multi-component gaseous stream using CO 2 hydrate promoter. US Patent, US 6352576 B1,
2002.
[50] Oscar, Fr G. Hydrate for deep ocean storage of CO 2. Proceedings of the Fifth International
Conference on Gas Hydrate. vol 4: 1135-1140, Trondheim, 2005.
11