Consequently, the NLRC granted the Motion for Reconsideration of petitioners and reinstated the

Labor Arbiter's Decision dated May 4, 2006 dismissing respondent's complaint against
petitioners and SAENCO."  24

In a subsequent Resolution dated January 30, 2009, the NLRC denied respondent's Motion for
Reconsideration  as it raised no new matters of substance which would warrant reconsideration
25

of the NLRC Resolution dated November 11, 2008.