Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
00
Printed in Great Britain.All rights reserved Copyright© 1989 PergamonPress pie
I. D. A K ( ~ A L I a n d G. D I T T R I C H
~ukurova University, Faculty of Engineering, Mechanical Engineering Department,
Balcali-Adana, Turkey and Institut fiir Getriebetechnik und Maschinendynamik,
Technische Hochschule, 51 Aachen, F.R.G.
Abstraet--A technique called subdomain method has been used in dimensioning mechanisms which are
to approximate a prescribed, continuous path. In this technique the motion domain is divided into
subregions as many times as there are parameters existing within the kinematic structure and the system
of equations, resulting from setting the integrals of a displacement function over selected subintervals
equal to zero, is solved. Here a dyad is considered as the basic structural unit upon which the whole
mechanism design is based. Solutions for 4-parameter dyad and for 4- and 5-parameter four-bars have
been shown. The effectiveness of the technique has been demonstrated on two examples.
45
46 1. D. AK~ALI and G. DITTRICH
discrete values that make up the solution space as Elimination of coupler angle 6 from (1) and (2)
in[20] or the solution may be valid only for a small leads to the displacement equation of dyad QAC,
range of motion as in[13]. Therefore, there is still a Fig. l, as isolated from the four-bar QABM:
need for the development of new approaches.
A technique called subdomain method[21], which H(xl, x4, xs, XT, xs, G, y, x)
was applied to the function generation problem in a = y2 + x 2 _ 2x1( x cos G + y sin G)
previous paper[22] producing better results than
the classical approaches, is extended to the path -- 2XX 7 -- 2yx s + 2XlX7 COS G + 2xlx8 sin G
generation problem in this paper. Thompson[23, + x~ + x~ + x~ - x ,~ - x~ = 0. C3)
pp. 201-203], when reviewing path synthesis tech-
niques, arrives at the judgement that the most real- Since the motion of the dyad is a continuous one,
istic approach to basic path generation is that the there is a basis for using subdomain method. Under
value of the area trapped between the coupler curve definitions:
and the prescribed path assume a least value• Since in
SI = X2"~- X2 dI- X2-- X2-- X 2, $2=X7, $3=X8, (4)
subdomain method the integral or in other words the
continuous sum for all points of an implicit structural the displacement equation assumes the following
error function over the subregions of the prescribed form:
path is zero, it completes this judgement. Through the
geometrical meaning of integral and a few conditions H(st, s:, s 3, G, y, x)
that may be imposed, it embodies both the precision- =y2 + x 2 _ 2xt(x cos G + y sin G)
point and least-squares techniques[22].
From among many mechanisms, the four-bar + 2 s 2 ( - x + x, cos G)
offers suitable characteristics with its displacement
+2s3(-y+xlsinG)+sl=O. (5)
function for convenient treatment by subdomain
method. Besides, the four-bar has a well-founded Subdomain method requires that the integral of the
place in the synthesis and analysis of many multi-link displacement equation over a selected subinterval
mechanisms[4]. Thus, the method is shown on a [x~_ l, x~]of the path domain Ix0, x,] be zero:
four-bar.
If H(sl, s 2 , s 3 , G , y , x ) d x = O , i=1,2,3,4. (6)
i
APPLICATION OF SUBDOMAIN METHOD TO
PATH-GENERATING FOUR-BAR Equation (6) is a system of equations involving
(Go, sl, s2, s3) as unknowns in which Go is the initial
In applying subdomain method to the problem angle of the input link and from which the di-
of generating a desired path by means of a mensions of the dyad (XT,xs, x42+ x~, Go) are to be
four-bar, a dyad is recognized as the basic struc- obtained:
tural unit upon which the design of the whole mech-
anism is based. A dyad is a two-degree-of-freedom, li - J,(Go) + gi(Go)s2 + L/(Go)s3 + Mist = 0;
two-member mechanical arrangement• As the first i = 1,2,3,4 (7)
step in this direction, the design of a dyad has been
handled. where
Given a continuous path of the form y = f ( x )
L(G0) = J: cos G0 + J~' sin Go;
xo <~x <~x,, the coordinates of the coupler point C
are written in x-y-system of Fig. 1: Ki(Go) = - c, + dic cos Go - d~ sin Go;
x = x T + x l c o s G + x4cosfi - xssin 6 (1) Li(G0) = - e , + d~c sin Go + d~ cos Go; (8)
y = x8 + x~ sin G + x4 sin ~ + x5 cos ~i. (2)
J: = 2xl
f; i-I
(x cos G' + Y sin G ') dx;
X°~'~~ B
li = (y2 + x 2) dx;
Xl IIL i-I
g
im
d~, = 2x I
f; i.I
sin G' dx;
X
dir "~ 2Xl COSG' dx;
Fig. I. 4-bar parameters. dXl i]
Path generation by subdomain method 47
with
e~-- 2 y dx;
z.=(x~+x~+x~+x92 2-x~)/2x~x2; z2=x6/2;
z3 = x6/xl; z4= tz2; z s = tz3; t = xg/x6. (13)
c~= 2
f; I.I
x dx;
If fixed pivots M and Q are located on a line
parallel to x-axis, then t = 0 and in accordance with
M~ = dx ; (9) subdomain method (14) is written:
J-I
Mizl -- A~z2 -- B,(60)z3 + F,.(60) = 0; i = 1,2,3,4,
~,=¢0+~'; ¢'=Rx(x-xo); R~=a~,/ax. (10) (14)
In (10) A ~ , A x are maximum changes in where
input link rotation and in the independent variable of
the curve, respectively. By eliminating s~, s:, s3 from B i -~ Bci cos 6 0 -- Bsi sin 60;
(7) an equation that is only a function of ~'0 is F,. = F~icos 60 - F,~ sin 60; (15)
obtained:
P(~k0) = Ds cos 5 ~'0 + (O4 + Ee sin ¢0)cos4 ~'0
+ (D3 + E3 sin ~b0)cos3 if0
Ai =
;;i-I
cos 0 dx; Ba =
f;fx,
i-1
cos 6' dx;
+ (D2 + E2 sin ~k0)cos:~b0 B~ = sin 6' dx; Fc~= cos(6' - ~,) dx;
i -I JXi-I
+ (D~ + El sin ~,0)cos ~0
+ D0 + E0 sin ~'o. (11) F,, =
f;i-I
sin(6' - O) dx; (16)
6 =6'+60; 6'(x) =
(17)
Coefficients Ds-Do and E4-E o are simply constants Above 60, 6' are the starting angle and the amount
that are computed through some steps from (9) and of rotation from that position of the coupler, respect-
(10) assuming a value for each of A~b and xt. The ively. Concerning ( :t: ) signs, the one associated with
roots of equation (11) are found precisely and with the dyad generating a coupler curve closer to the
assurance when 1-deg intervals in which P(~b0) given path should be taken.
changes sign are located between 0 and 360 ° and Equation set (14) is reduced to a single equation
then interpolation and Newton's method are ap- in 60:
plied[24]. With ~k0 determined, s~, s2, s3 are easily
solved from any three equations of the linear system Fcc cos 2 60 - F~s cos 60 sin 6o + F,, sin 2 60 = 0. (18)
of (7).
Once the dimensions of the dyad approximating F,.c, Fc,, F~s are computable constants through
a specified curve are obtained as such, four-bars equations (16), (17). Exact solution of (18) is given
constrained to move in accordance with the pre- by:
scribed dyad motion can be found by the application
of subdomain method. To accomplish this, it is _, (Fcs• ,/F~ - 4F:s,~
sufficient that the displacement function G of the
(6o)~ tan -]. (19)
four-bar be integrated over a selected subdomain
[xi_ ~, xi] of [:Co,x,] and be set equal to zero as many Determination of z 1, z2, z3 follows 60 from (14).
times as there are available parameters in G. Here will x6,x2,x3,x4,x5 are found from z3,z2,zl, 60,
be shown two cases: respectively.
Table I. Dyad designs for generating y = (I/2)x + 3, 2 ~< x ~< 6 path with 4 par-
ameters. A~k = 60 °. Subdomains: [6.0;5.0],[5.0;4.0], [4.0;3.0],[3.0;2,0]
Design No. ¢0 xl xx/~4:
+ x~ x7 xs
I 86.5618° 1.000 11.1589 -0.5436 14.0867
I1 266.5667 ° 1.000 2 7 . 9 4 7 8 16.0515 - 19.1028
where
1
Di = ~ [cos tp(xi_ ]) - cos t# (xi)]; Yth-Yac 0
Table 2. Four-bar designs for generating y = (l/2)x + 3, 2 <~x ~<6 path with 4 parameters. A~b = 60°. Subdomains:
[6.0; 5.0[, [5.0; 4.01, [4,0; 3.01, [3.0; 2.0]
Design
No. I,~0 t~0 xI x2 x3 x4 x5 x6 x7 x8 x9
I 86.5618" 24.8377° 1.000 3.4496 4.6068 2.0690 --10.9655 7.0950 -0.5436 14.0867 0.0000
It 266.566T~ 16.8112° 1.000 -10.5622 6.4390 -2.0158 27.8750 -5.1669 16.0515 -19.1028 0.0000
Path generation by subdomain method 49
12,5
l xlO"~
e
10.0
1.5
!
5,0
2 N*~---
PIJ
f f N.N. .N. N ~
~
02.0 2.8 3,6 4.4 5.2 6.0 ]ll------
X .~-I~
Example B I
The path given by y = ~ l ~ < x < 4 is to be II
generated within A~, = 90 ° of rotation of input link.
Dyads synthesized by program TFRPT together with
subdomain distribution in the region of interest
are seen in Table 5. The related structural error
18
~0
O
hl.
10
[.-
I I I I I I
2,0 2,8 3.6 4.4 5,2 6.0
X ~
Fig. 4. Structural error distribution for solutions I and III
of Table 3.
MMT 24/I--D
50 I. D, AKt~ALI and G, DITTRICH
l 5
xlO "2
3
/,/~'-.._.." • °
& oooo
¢qcq
'',,\ // v/
1 "~1~ /I ..... V/ I [
¢q
02 I
VJ "F I i i i I I I
+
.0 2,8 3,6 /.,,/-., 5,2 6,0 tc~v%
~b0 = 3 1 1 . 2 2 9 4 ° ; 60 = 1 7 0 . 2 7 5 0 ° ; I--
¢'qoo
x 4 = 4.7843; x5 = -8.2752; x6 = - 1.8538;
x7 = 6 . 9 2 2 3 ; x8 = 6 . 5 1 3 1 ; x9 = 0.0000.
~-t'4
o~e~
I 25 u'~ ¢-4
e
20 c
%,
15 \ / s• "~N J
¢qcq
/\ .,/ ".--"
,:, \ -=
f\x,v . "== 6
0'
2.0
V,
2,8 3.6 L,,,{,, 5,2 6,0
Table 5. Dyad designs for generating y = ~ 1 ~<x ~<4 path with 4 parameters
A~, = 90°. Subdomains: [4.0; 3.8], [3.8; 2.5], [2.5; 1.2], [1.2; 1.0]
2 2
Design No. I//0 xl ~ x7 xs
I 0.6510° 0.6000 23.1162 15.1228 -17.9283
II 52.7214° 0.6000 6.7210 0.0798 7.2274
III 76.2288° 0.6000 5.4030 1.6092 6.3297
IV 311.2294° 0.6000 9.5587 6.9923 -6.5131
Fig. 7. Structural error distribution for dyads generating Acknowledgements--This work was supported by
y = x/~ 1 ~<x ~<4 with 4 parameters. Alexander von Humboldt Foundation.
REFERENCES
of path. Free parameters such as length and rotation
of input link and subdomain choice, which are to be 1. R. S. Hartenberg and J. Denavit, Kinematic Synthesis of
Linkages. McGraw-Hill, New York (1964).
found in the formulation, will provide the designer 2. J. A. Hrones and G. L. Nelson, Analysis of the Four-bar
with some means for selecting the most suitable one Linkage. Wiley, New York (1951).
of the resulting designs satisfying the criteria set other 3. J. Hirschhorn, Kinematics and Dynamics of Plane
than the structural error. Mechanisms. McGraw-Hill, New York (1962).
4. A. S. Hall, Kinematics and Linkage Design. Prentice-
Dyads and four-bars are the building blocks for Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J. (1961).
most of the planar mechanisms. Therefore, those 5. A. G. Erdman and J. Turner, Proc. 4th OSU Applied
planar mechanisms that are constructed by joining Mechanisms Conf. 2 (1975).
four-bars and dyads whose movable end follows a 6. K. Hain, Applied Kinematics, (2nd edn). McGraw-Hill,
path with the other end fixed, can be synthesized for New York (1967).
7. F. Freudenstein and G. N. Sandor, Trans. ASME,
multiple purposes with the technique shown. For J. Engng lndust. 81B, 159 (1959).
instance, Stephenson mechanism with three fixed 8. A. V. M. Rao, A. G. Erdman, G. N. Sandor et al.,
pivots can be designed such that in one joint of the Proc. 2nd OSU Applied Mechanisms Conf. 7 (1971).
six-bar, simultaneously a coupler point of the four- 9. R. Kaufman, Proc. NSF College Teachers Workshop in
Mechanisms (1973).
10. R. Loerch, A. G. Erdman, G. N. Sandor and A. Midha,
Proc. 4th OSU Applied Mechanisms Conf. 10 (1975).
11. A. G. Erdman, C. T. Tekse and D. E. Ferguson,
Proc. ~th OSU Applied Mechanisms Conf. 11 (1975).
t 8 12. A. G. Erdman and A. Midha, Proc. 4th Applied
x16' Mechanisms Conf. 3 (1973).
• 6 13. R. G. Mitcbiner and H. H. Mabie, Trans. A S M E J.
Engng lndust. 97B, 322 (1975).
14. J. Tomas, J. Mech. 3, 199 (1968).
15. S. N. Kramer and G. N. Sandor, Trans. A S M E J.
Engng lndust. 97B, 689 (1975).
16. N. Bakthavachalam and J. T. Kimbrell, Trans. A S M E
J. Engng Indust. 97B, 314 (1975).
2 17. F. J. Kay and R. E. Haws, Trans. A S M E J. Engng
lndust. 97B, 702 (1975).
18. H. E. Ladd, Trans. A S M E J. Engng Indust. 98B, 1325
0 (1976).
1,0 1,6 2.2 2.8 3.l. 4,0
X -.-.--..-!~
19. C. Bagci and I. J. Lee, Trans. A S M E J. Engng Indust.
97B, 340 (1975).
Fig. 8. Structural error distribution in 4-bar generating 20. T. W. Lee and Freudenstein F., Trans. ASMEJ. Engng
y = ~ 1 ~<x ~<4 with 4 parameters. lndust. 98B, 1277 (1976).
52 I. D. AK(~ALIand G. DITTR1CH
21. H. S. Crandall, Engineering Analysis. McGraw-Hill, 23. B. S. Thompson, Mech. Mach. Theory 10, 197
New York (1956). (1975).
22. I. Ak~;ali and J. C. Lindholm, Proc. V Wld Congr. on 24. S. D. Conte and C. de Boor, Elementary Numerical
Theory of Machines and Mechanisms (1979). Analysis. McGraw-Hill, New York (1972).