Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 5
Dissipation and displacement of hotspots in reaction-diffusion models of crime Martin Short’, P. Jeffrey Brantingham', Andrea L. Bertozzi’ and George E. Tita’ “ooparmert of athomatc, ney of Cato. (oe Angeles, CA 0095 "Depatmect of Antronlogy, Unverty of Cafe. Los Angele, (Ce S605, Ocpartment of atremtes,Jnversiy of caifoma os Anges, Ck S005, and “Deparment Chmisaagy, Law and Wey, Unioraty of Cafora, Inia, 8687-7080, feted Lc € Ansel. trizora State Unive, Tempe. AD and apeove January S210 Leceined for ie Septem 22 2000) ‘The mechanisms diving the nudeaton, spread, and dissipation of crmehotspots are pootly undestood. Asa consequence, the abi- ity of aw enforcement agencies to use mapped crime patterrs to design crime prevention strategies xoveraly hampered, We alco lack robust expectations about how diferent policing interven ‘tons should impact crime. Here we present amatheratial freme- ‘ork based on reation Cyo/7 (Fig, 2B). Thus, ctime hotspots, will emerge whenever Cwo/y Om Fig 34) see the mie {eation and grovth of crime hotspots fom smal spies incrime die tothe tnar stably ofthe gem, wheres crt farcatons (e = Uin Fig 34) are the eesul of large local spikes i crime that override linear sabi. Referng to Fig 24, fore mpl. crimes are sulcieely spaced such that the sea of inf nce ofa single erine general docs not ovetap vith that of tahers and the ster linear stable witha spay uniform ‘latebution. If one location were to experience adden and extreme sure in crime, however then the eresed isk may suddealy spl ver ito th arca of inucnce of en adacenterine Finding these areas together to create a sberical hotspot. A tcmatvcly, even where al crnes are bound together by the teoad spatial difsion of risk (Fig 2), » lage surge in erie atone location may create nicleation point pulling offenders Jnvay from a unitorm distribution andcavsng asubentealerime otspt to emerae ‘One of our key results is that suka htspots may form under @ wade aay of conditions, paralleling those that form Sipeeritiat houpots (Fig 3B). The parameter combination 1 ceseribes the djs component of crime tis, approximately {he probably ef repeat vetimiation ocarrng at any gen Lo cation Thevarable pa” describes the fxedenvronmentalrsk cf crime, approximately the probability of crimes occuring inde- fendently in space and tine asa est ofa stationary Poisson process. Small values of n4° describe environments characterized 9.2. Theconditonsforctimehotsptfoeation Local afuion ofeleated is romstochatcfctuatonsncrimenuclesteint cme hotspots. 4) Urban ‘pace maybe nought of 5 beigpartioned Into ares uniquely asocaed wt each india! ie Blac Ju), hete SHOWN 9s Vorona ola Oy ines) and dewribedin thePOE mode by average te Cyne cme asoprodice erated isk that aiuses out over an ate (Sashes ces) entered “crive rime cain andes inthe POE model by area y= lhe area encrmpased by diffuang ak trom ore tm doesnot ave seth eres ‘Sting ik generted ty another, then hotspot nt frm anda pata uniform low equltiom citation re ess (ek use over ‘ide sta, ehamogantd inepace ands patil urform high squltriom Strintion of erme result (0 Onkywhen hk bse ue velataly Shot “Sstancs, bring cal cmestgether but not mare ditant ones, do ime hotspots emerge (D) ad (E) Numeral simulations ofthe POE pte nv Qua fegion with vod bourdarycnaivans(C) Parameters ar Sud that ne < ya of ea > Cy lg astable uniform ime dstribaton {6 Parmetes bresueh hat o/h «ma Cur ging satonay care hotioots. the spacing ol hott eterninedby the maximally unstable waeleng™ 4 ~ 2/1 otpots are meatred a: devtons rom a spatally averaged equim valve B1y/ fee with maxtnum isk beng 228 (ee) and minim rik ro up). ty very fow fixed ensironmental risk, Small spikes in crime are casily distinguished against this background and nucleate into supercritical howpots. As n4° increases, environments become inherently more risky and the range of values for the dynam component of sk generating supeteritial hotspots contracts ‘With further increases in pf the system crosses a theshold into linear stability. At this point, small spikes ie crime areinsuficient 1p generate crime hotspots Note, however, that foreach value of Blcapableofeenerating spercitical hotspots there ate values of 14° cescribing marginally stable environments that nonetheless ‘Nill support suberitial hotspos given large enough spike in crime, The implication is that subcritical hotspots may be com- mon in real urban settings, though the proportion of the pars ‘eter space shown in Fig, 36 that is behaviorally realistic is not presenly known (Our analysis also shows that there may te sigsiticant pecspatial Jiferences between supercritical and subsritca crime hotsposs, ‘th important implications forthe response tocrime hotspots of Fy 128 sapecnial bap B / Fi aa 4 ae == aT 05 7 rr OT ot Te Tae, Ser We fig. 3._Crime hotpottypet. Crime hotspot form in bath inery unable an table regime, th cocrespondingly differnt geospatial stctures (A) The ‘Mfrcaton dagram‘or the radaly synmetie POL sytem whee dates ire rereten vote bance! andi ires arestable bane The pare conttos the sanity of te system ne > Ocoresponding tinea unable stems and 030d Ags 0, especivly Suber hotspot (<0) ate formed onl by lage petubstions m crime anéshow ony 2 bump solton. Te ‘Solin vexponen of suprercal ond sbercalhotipte under uppreion ne shown by atten ae tex fer aceon) (8) Parameter ssc forthe fr ‘ation of sperertal ar beta! ime hotspot forth ame sytem, As meanre oie tie aca) enavonmentalSk, wheres Feresers ‘erent etilorium alec forthe nam: compan of ri. Parameter reqimar generating suber crim hots frm an envelope sounding te ‘uperctal regimes suggesting that tipping of atineaty unable regime ito anear abit may sl facia cme Bipot formation cme events ot India locations suse in sae andor Frequency. Araya in both cases based on a system wth fd = 02 stemancs cine pong Fig. sos tucation diagram sor OBES tem ina rally ymmeri oor. whet eo) false Fnteosty aa unser tat alls us eXamine How system behavior changes is one moves fom Hneaty UNL 10 binway stable puameter regimes fase Mf Metis). There ‘re two spi anuxments of crime paterns under lineal un Stable onultions (>I: stsymmctrcl “bump saan (cay Aso 09) > Mh veennizel tains holy. end ving Shia (aus ole Dy Tat rise pte ay em “ht Fins arora isatan sed in ay discal ssogriphic pring ppc to etme (81. Rut ssh paltry we no type mapped ingens erie dbibuions Cam “erly ieay ale reine (©) exhbit only the burp Inti, which compels tn totioal betel pier ‘We furthermore expect supers andsubeitical rime hot spat to reap ferent dete posing at, su Thnspet potting, Fi. ilcas tit Suppression sf super {ial etme hott though pace actions tht rie the ol Hoxgpet mens) yoo) 19 ato, wil Fit guneeate ot vgs that nabsegecnty be to form hotspots a the same ne sin tlative spats sangument those prior ko sappresson Conversely oe capt that suberticl eink opts al fe Seated hy dnecld police action that fs tong enough to deve Ags) an the gry rekinn eho the unsaid ting) of the solution shown io Fi an tha these pots wl remtn suppress en ater the rem of ple presure wal Sach tine ava fae spke inerime overrides the neat stat the spe to fore ow pnt The he Terence occ relletthe at that fxuned hospot suppression des nt impact the sale Huctstions im crme occuring Through the ensironment. fn ney unsae reins, the sl Meta tos me expete to ged tate nto new sper it ‘pets sien Tneatly table tegimes the expectation that they wit Toke our theoretical epovtaton., we performed extensive computer ‘imultions invahing Sipe a both supe tical and subeitiel rime folspets sing the POE: el {Gee 8/ Medes) rine Suppresion bined ster ling A ne, {or the development of sible erime patierns using parameter ‘eominations kn sen io be either superior suberitis. Sup pression is mexdled by instantancoasly driving the crime ite fst} to zero at the locations of current crime hotspots maintaining this suppression for a xed time perio. In Fig. ‘ve show that ifleren ype ferme hotspots regen iferenty {0 suppresion as predicted by theory. Suppression «f supererit ‘ea hotspots only temporary reals the disruption of th crime pattern with new hotspots merging quel, vo replace thexe Sup rosea hy simulated police actin (Fig 1, Moros, saul tions show clearly thi suppression over the ental ans of 8 time horspot drives the elevate risk ini Ting sures the ana of suppression, corresponding to the ring soluion in four nontincaranalyss. The spliced hot ring then breaks Gp ty form independent hotspots of the stable Kump solaion the monsymmetic eae, Conversely. suppression 1) subsrtieal rime hotspots docs not produce displacement of etime into a fing or any other structure (Fig 48) sd, expect crime ha spots net reemerge afl the cession of crime Suppression ia this case Discussion Our research has dircet implications forthe study of rime pat- {erm formation snd the mechanistic impact of policing interves- tions on crime. The dsteeminisié moles developed here sgeest thatthe empirically observed reduitions in crime tht fll i= ‘Hlomntation of hotspot policing strategies (32. 32) are mot Satistic atta! ut ater mas elect suppression of erm rk Felew some thaesholl level necessary 10 sustain subetitial ime hotspot. Cine shoul seman suppressed in such situations ‘en alter the removal of kaw enfecement pressure, unl sit {ime 3s signiticant cluster of crimes pusius the system towards iy. Conversely our models alt suggest that dsplagement ‘ferme should wesull rom poling ston direst at supererit fal holspos, consistent with criminological theory” (34. 5h, However, displacement is not commonly absewed in empirical is af howspot poling (8, 6, 8. 32) F.&. criehospet suppression Suppreson rept forthe PDE system sth parameters chon tageneatesupecritaor sublime hatipot ie Clim suppemon rime suppressants ten strodued Oe the area ofeach wb hepa, lea tothe eradication othe oigiol hotspots bt tion fee orignal entra hespat Bye tinea he net suptensen a 27pe3" ths ase etal spre eds * 200» new steady state featuring hotspets in postions adecent the aga ‘ves ha boon achieved (8 Supreson of asia cme hott Shown ea orl uberis Reet SSppresson ime sippresion shen nttaaued ve he ares of te hotaot,lsangto te eradeation of the nats hy 200 ar thesster qui adopts tre Nontogenos steady Slate. Calor Sale atexpaned Fig 2 (One possible explanation for the infrequent oberation of

Вам также может понравиться