Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 16

CP

Counseling Points
An Official Publication of the National Conference of Gerontological Nurse Practitioners
and the National Gerontological Nursing Association

May 2008

Alzheimer’s Disease: Caring for the Caregiver


Volume 1, Number 3

Part 3 of a 3-Part Continuing Education Series


Sponsored by:

This activity is supported by an educational grant from Eisai Inc.


Faculty:
Virginia Burggraf, DNS, RN, FAAN
Counseling Points™
Professor of Gerontological Nursing Alzheimer’s Disease: Caring for the Caregiver
Radford University School of Nursing
Radford, Virginia
Continuing Education Information
Evelyn G. Duffy, DNP, APRN, BC,
FAANP Target Audience
Assistant Professor This educational activity is designed to meet the needs of gerontological nurses and
Director of the Gerontological Nurse advanced practice nurses who are on the front lines of treating and managing
Practitioner Program
Alzheimer’s disease and related dementias.
Frances Payne Bolton School of
Nursing Learning Objectives
Case Western Reserve University
Upon completion of this educational activity, the participant should be able to:
Cleveland, Ohio
• Discuss ethical issues in caring for the patient with Alzheimer’s disease (AD),
Susan Engel, RN-BC, MSN including end-of-life care
Dementia Care Coordinator
Veterans Affairs Western New York
• Describe the psychosocial, physical, and financial burdens of AD on the family and
Healthcare System caregivers
Buffalo, New York • Review educational counseling for caregivers
Faculty Disclosure Statements: • Name effective techniques and strategies to reduce stress on caregivers
Virginia Burggraf, Evelyn Duffy, and
Susan Engel have nothing to disclose.
Continuing Education Credit
This continuing nursing education activity was approved by the National Con-
Publishing Information: ference of Gerontological Nurse Practitioners. Successful completion of this
Publishers activity awards 1.2 contact hours.
Joseph J. D’Onofrio The National Conference of Gerontological Nurse Practitioners is accredited as a
Frank M. Marino provider of continuing nursing education by the American Nurses Credentialing
Delaware Media Group
Center’s Commission on Accreditation.
66 South Maple Avenue
Ridgewood, NJ 07450 This program expires May 31, 2010.
Tel: 201-612-7676
Fax: 201-612-8282 Disclosure of Unlabeled Use
Website: www.delmedgroup.com This educational activity may contain discussion of published and/or investigational
uses of agents that are not indicated by the FDA.The National Conference of Geron-
Editorial Director tological Nurse Practitioners, the National Gerontological Nursing Association, Eisai
Nancy Monson
Inc., and Delaware Media Group do not recommend the use of any agent outside of
the labeled indications.The opinions expressed in the educational activity are those of
Art Director
James Ticchio
the faculty and do not necessarily represent the views of the National Conference of
Gerontological Nurse Practitioners, the National Gerontological Nursing Association,
Cover photo credit: ©images.com /Veer Eisai Inc., or Delaware Media Group.

©2008, Delaware Media Group, Inc. All Disclaimer


rights reserved. None of the contents may Participants have an implied responsibility to use the newly acquired information to
be reproduced in any form without prior
enhance patient outcomes and their own professional development. The information
written permission from the publisher. The
opinions expressed in this publication are presented in this activity is not meant to serve as a guideline for patient management.
those of the faculty and do not necessarily Any medications, diagnostic procedures, or treatments discussed in this publication
reflect the opinions or recommendations of should not be used by clinicians or other health care professionals without first evalu-
their affiliated institutions, the publisher, the
ating the patient’s condition, considering possible contraindications or risks, reviewing
National Conference of Gerontological
Nurse Practitioners, the National Geronto-
any applicable manufacturer’s product information, and comparing any therapeutic
logical Nursing Association, or Eisai Inc. approach with the recommendations of other authorities.

2
COUNSELING POINTS™
welcome
Dear Colleague,

In the third and final issue of this Counseling Points™ series on Alzheimer’s disease
(AD) and related dementias, we focus on the topic of caring for the caregiver. As the
burden of AD becomes greater with the aging of the American population, the burden
on caregivers also increases. Caregivers are beset by psychosocial, physical, financial,
and ethical challenges attendant to caring for loved ones. In turn, nurses and nurse
practitioners who care for patients with AD must also care for the caregivers, offering
education, counseling, and support services to preserve caregiver health.

Counseling Points™ is an official publication of the National Conference of Geronto-


logical Nurse Practitioners (NCGNP) and the National Gerontological Nursing Asso-
ciation (NGNA).We have been gratified by the response to the first two issues in this
series. We hope you will consider becoming involved with the NCGNP and NGNA,
if you’re not already, to take advantage of the many other educational and networking
opportunities membership affords. Please visit our websites at www.ncgnp.org and
www.ngna.org for information.

Finally, we would like to thank Eisai Inc. for sponsoring this and the other publications
in this series under an educational grant.

Sincerely,

Debra Bakerjian, PhD, MSN, RN, FNP


PRESIDENT, NCGNP

Judith E. Hertz, PhD, RN


PRESIDENT, NGNA

3
MAY 2008
Alzheimer’s Disease:
Caring for the Caregiver
Introduction health care providers. Not all clinicians, however, are
According to the Alzheimer’s Association, 5 million familiar with ethical principles that could help families
Americans are estimated to have Alzheimer’s disease find their way through the maze.
(AD), and an additional 360,000 are diagnosed yearly.1
The principles of biomedical ethics provide a
Patients with the disease typically live 8 to 10 years after
diagnosis, but some live as long as 20 years.1
framework for the moral standard for practice.
A majority of the nation’s nursing home residents have
significant cognitive impairment, most likely due to AD. Biomedical Ethics
Most people with the disease, however, live in their own The principles of biomedical ethics provide a framework
homes or with relatives and are cared for by loved ones. for the moral standard for practice. Four key principles
Family members, particularly wives and daughters, are were identified in a classic reference by Beauchamp and
often called upon to assume the role of caregiver, and Childress: respect for autonomy, nonmaleficence, beneficence, and
may spend up to three-quarters of their day looking after justice.5 These principles were first developed in response
a patient.2 The burden becomes greater as the disease to the need for ethical medical research. Once established,
progresses.2 they continued to be the measure used for decision-mak-
ing in complex medical situations such as during the
Caregiver stress is now recognized as a significant course of caring for a demented older adult. Still, it is
byproduct of a diagnosis of AD. crucial for nurses/advanced practice nurses to keep in
mind that even well-established principles have their lim-
These unpaid caregivers are at great risk for stress- itations and that “gut feelings,” intuition, and conscience
related signs and symptoms; indeed, caregiver stress is now should not be ignored.
recognized as a significant byproduct of a diagnosis of AD. Respect for autonomy. Autonomy is central to our
Regardless of gender and approach to patient manage- American life. The freedom to choose without interfer-
ment, nearly all caregivers experience emotional and ence from others is perceived as an essential right in our
physical strain and many suffer from clinical depression, country. The ethical principle of respect for autonomy
anxiety, and other health problems.3 recognizes the individual’s right to these choices.5 The
Given this emerging trend, gerontological nurses and practice of informed consent emanates from this princi-
advanced practice nurses must now not only care for ple. In patients with dementia, however, the capacity to
individuals with AD but also for their caregivers, offering make decisions is compromised, although not all deci-
psychosocial assistance, education, and referrals to organi- sion-making is compromised to the same extent. With
zations and support groups. By improving the health and regard to medical decisions, patients need to be able to
well-being of caregivers, research suggests that nursing understand what a procedure entails and the risks and
home placement of patients with AD may be delayed.4 benefits of refusing or accepting the procedure. Patients
may no longer be capable of making independent med-
Ethical Issues in Caring for the Patient ical decisions because of cognitive impairment (which
with AD tends to affect abstract thinking early in the course of the
Dementia is characterized by an insidious onset and a disease), but they may be capable of making a will as long
slow, continual decline. Because of the nature of the dis- as they can identify to whom they want to leave their
ease, families often are unaware of its development until worldly goods.6 Even in advanced dementia, it may be
patients are no longer mentally capable of participating in possible for patients to make some individual decisions,
decision-making regarding their care and long-term such as what they like or dislike to eat or the type of
plans. As dementia progresses, many issues that families clothing they like to wear.
face present ethical dilemmas that require guidance from When surrogate decision-making is needed, families

4
COUNSELING POINTS™
should consider patients’ beliefs and values and prior tation. Possibilities may extend from “each person an
wishes. When possible, their input should be sought. equal share” to “each person according to their merit.”5
However, families need to realize that a priority must be The principle of justice is central to the issue of provid-
to keep patients safe and prevent them from injuring oth- ing health care to patients with dementia. In America, the
ers. For example, families may feel it is not fair to keep majority of health care services for older adults are paid
patients from driving because it restricts their autonomy, for by the government programs Medicare and Medicaid.
but they need to understand that dementia affects judg- Health care is not provided to each person in an equal
ment, and poor judgment while driving can result not share, but rather to each person according to their merit.
only in harm to patients but to others. They cannot wait If a patient has Medicare but not Medicaid, the govern-
to stop loved ones from driving until patients accept that ment will not pay for long-term care, eyeglasses, hearing
they are no longer capable of driving, or expect patients aids, etc. While more financially secure patients are not
to have the insight necessary to know that it is not safe eligible for Medicaid, they may not have enough
for them to drive. Issues of safety take precedence over resources to afford health necessities that the government
the principle of respect for autonomy. will provide to the indigent. Little assistance is available
Nonmaleficence and beneficence.The principles of non- for help at home, requiring many families to prematurely
maleficence and beneficence are difficult to separate. place patients with dementia in a long-term care facility.
Nonmaleficence has been summarized concisely as “do Family caregivers may be forced to make decisions that
no harm,” while beneficence requires one to do good or go against their moral fiber because they cannot meet
to prevent or remove harm.5 When the intent to do good their obligations. When families must decide between
results in harm, this is referred to as the principle of double buying food or expensive medications for patients that
effect. Examples of this principle are numerous in caring are not covered by Medicare, they are faced with an
for demented older adults. For instance, there is the unfortunate ethical dilemma as a result of our system of
dilemma of allowing severely demented patients to con- health care delivery.
tinue eating solid foods because they enjoy eating them,
despite the risks of aspiration and pneumonia. If families Nurses and families must rely on their best judgment
decide to allow patients to continue to eat solid foods, and “let their conscience be their guide” when
they are intending to do well, but eating such foods may making decisions for patients.
result in harm. Ethical principles do not have a priority
ranking. As Barnes describes it, the application of ethical Patients with dementia may not be highly valued by
principles in a “messy” environment means that there society, but their families still see the spouses they mar-
may not be a clear right or wrong, good or bad, but ried, the parents that lovingly raised them, and the special
rather that nurses and families must rely on their best grandparents. Nurses need to see patients through their
judgment and “let their conscience be their guide” when family members’ eyes to better assist in ethical decision-
making decisions for patients.7 making. In a recent article by Post, she discusses the role
When families have exceeded their capacity to meet of the nurse in taking on some of the responsibility for
the needs of patients with dementia, they may feel guiding families through decision-making.9 She notes that
trapped by a promise they made to always keep patients at it is not helpful for the nurse to ask “What do you want
home. The principles of nonmaleficence and beneficence us to do?” without giving caregivers some options and
may be helpful to guide families who have a prior duty helping them understand how they might rank those
that can no longer be met without causing harm, while options. Post describes leaving families to an autonomous
abandoning that duty will actually result in the good of choice that may haunt them forever as “an act of aban-
improved care for patients.These principles won’t prevent donment.”9 When families are struggling with the idea
families from feeling regret or remorse at the inability to that they may not be doing everything for patients with
keep their promise, but it may help them accept that the dementia, nurses can help them understand that doing
greater good is accomplished by breaking it. everything will not change the end result—and doing
Justice. The fourth principle is justice.5 This is a com- good might actually mean doing less than everything.
plex principle and one with many interpretations. One Dementia is a terminal illness and nurses/advanced
definition is “treating people who are equal in an equal practice nurses can help shift the focus to supporting the
manner.”8 This definition allows for ambiguous interpre- last portion of life in an ethical manner. Both nurses/

5
MAY 2008
advanced practice nurses and families need to examine ciated with higher levels of stress than is caring for some-
the alternatives available in these difficult situations and one with a functional impairment/chronic illness.16,17
use ethical principles as a framework for determining Max, Weber, and Fox surveyed caregivers to assess the
how they will act. unpaid burden of informal caregiving and found that an
average of 70 hours of care per week, with 62 hours pro-
Caregiver Stress vided by the primary caregiver, was needed for patients
As busy clinicians, we often neglect to ask our adult with dementia. 18 The more severe the dementia, the
patients “Are you caring for an older person/relative?” greater the demands on caregivers’ time.
Frequently during our 5-minute office visits we care for The relationship between immunity and the stress of
the presenting problem whatever that may be without caregiving was investigated in the work of Kielcolt-Glaser
considering that it may be induced by stress. For a care- et al, who compared the immune response to an influen-
giver, that stress-induced symptom may be caused by his za virus vaccine in 32 caregivers and 32 controls.19 Care-
or her caregiving duties. In addition, this stress can often givers had a poorer antibody response to the vaccine than
go on for years without being noted or managed.10,11 controls and lower levels of in vitro virus-specific-
A seminal study conducted by Zarit and Zarit in 1983 induced interleukin 2 and interleukin 1β levels. This
defined caregiver burden as relating to the perception that study supports the need for objective physiologic meas-
physical and/or emotional health, social life, or financial ures of health in order to better understand the health-
status has suffered as a result of caring for someone.12 related consequences of caregiving.These researchers also
Many health professionals refer to caregiver stress as looked at the relationship between the dementia caregiv-
“caregiver syndrome,” a condition of chronic stress er and multiple variables that influence immunity and
accompanied by depression, anger, guilt, and/or deterio- found increased sleeplessness, depression, and a lack of
rating health.13 This stress often contributes to hyperten- social support existed in the caregiver group.
sion, diabetes, compromised immunity, and an increased
risk of death. A 63% greater risk of mortality [was found] among
A number of studies have examined caregiver stress. In unpaid caregivers who characterized themselves as
1990, Pearlin and colleagues were the first investigators to being emotionally or mentally strained by their
address caregiver stress as a consequence of interrelated role versus non-caregivers.
processes, including both the socioeconomic characteris-
tics and resources of caregivers, as well as the emotion- In the landmark trial known as the Caregiver Health
al/psychic strains they experienced.14 Primary stressors Effects Study, Schulz et al used an epidemiologic
were identified as hardships and problems directly related approach to investigate caregiving as a risk factor for
to caregiving. Secondary stressors included the strains mortality over 4 years of follow-up.20 In a population
caregivers experienced outside their role as caregiver and sample of 392 elderly spousal caregivers (ages 66 to 99
intrapsychic strains and the diminishment of self-concept. years) compared with 427 non-caregivers of a similar age
More recently, the PIXEL study conducted in France living with their spouses, they showed a 63% greater risk
investigated the quality of life of caregivers (65.7±12.8 of mortality among unpaid caregivers who characterized
years old) and their demented care recipients (80.2±6.8 themselves as being emotionally or mentally strained by
years old).15 The Alzheimer’s Disease Related Quality of their role versus non-caregivers. Caregivers who did not
Life Scale was used with a neuropsychological inventory, report strain and those with a disabled spouse did not
the Folstein Mini Mental State Examination (MMSE), have increased mortality rates. Half of caregivers reported
Cornell’s depression scale, and the Katz index. Caregiver spending ≥46 hours a week caring for a patient with
quality of life was correlated to the quality of life of the dementia, and more than half said they felt that they were
persons being cared for, their particular behavioral disor- “on duty” 24 hours a day. Caregivers had high levels of
der, and the duration of the illness.Women caregivers had depressive symptoms. Their depression eased within 3
a worse quality of life and were more depressed than male months of the patient’s death, however, and had declined
caregivers in this study. Research by Parks and Novielli significantly by 12 months. Caregivers reported that the
emphasized the value of screening for anxiety and depres- death was a relief to them.
sion in caregivers, while Clipp and George’s findings Like the Caregiver Health Effects Study, the Resources
indicated that caring for someone with dementia is asso- for Enhancing Alzheimer’s Caregiver Health (REACH)

6
COUNSELING POINTS™
study demonstrated early mortality for highly stressed
caregivers:This study showed that 40% of those who cared Table 1. Questions for Assessing Care-
16
for a spouse with AD and who experienced stress from giver Burden During an Office Visit
their responsibilities died sooner than caregivers who did
Screening Question Area of Concern
not report stress.20 These data suggest that a caregiver’s
stress is an independent risk factor for early mortality. Do you feel that you are currently Mental health
under a lot of stress? What aspects of
The Caregiver at Risk your day are the most stressful?

The research we have just reviewed informs us that care- Have you been feeling down or blue Mental health
givers are vulnerable to poor physical and/or emotional lately?
health. Caregivers at risk include those: Have you been feeling more anxious Mental health
• who have been caregiving for a prolonged period of and irritable lately?
time; Do your family and friends visit often? Social support
Do they telephone often?
• are caregiving in their own home versus an institu-
tional setting; Do your friends and family watch your Social support
relative for you so that you have time
• have a chronic illness themselves; for yourself?
• have little or no social support networks; Do you have any outside help? Resources
• utilize resources (social service, respite) sparingly; Is your relative with dementia Behavioral
• are not financially stable or had to give up working displaying any behaviors, such as management
wandering, that are difficult to
to perform caregiving duties;
manage?
• have a lower educational level;
What do you do to relieve your stress Coping
• are caring for a person with dementia, multiple and tension?
symptoms/conditions, or someone with impaired Adapted with permission from American Family Physician.
activities of daily living (ADLs) or instrumental
activities of daily living (IADLs); the result is often the admission of the care recipient to a
• are caregiving full time versus part time; long-term care facility. Hence, when the caregiver can no
• possess inadequate levels of empathy/affect; and longer give care, there is a tremendous loss to the individ-
uals involved, as well as to society.
• are assessed to be in a state of denial.20-22
The value that the family caregiver offers is huge, but
Table 1 offers questions to help clinicians assess care-
what about the cost to families? The financial burden on
giver burden during an office visit, while Table 2 lists
families includes multiple factors. Attempting to put a
resources for caregivers.
dollar amount on the cost of caregiving is difficult
Financial Burden on Families because of the multiple ways of defining the components
of caregiving. A 2006 study of caregivers completed by
Most people prefer to live in their home as long as they
Metropolitan Life Insurance Company estimated the cost
can.23 Informal caregivers make this possible for millions
of caring for a person with AD was between $12,000 and
of older Americans and are the only source of care for
80% of those who remain at home.24 An Association of $60,000 a year.26 A Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation
Retired Persons study conducted in 2006 found that national survey conducted in 1998 of over 1,000 informal
there were 30 to 38 million family caregivers providing caregivers noted that 14% of caregivers spend more than
care to functionally impaired older adults.25 The value of $1,000 of their own funds to meet the care recipient’s
this care was estimated to be worth $350 billion. This needs.27 This out-of-pocket expense represents only a
exceeds the amount spent on either home health care or portion of the financial picture for caregivers; there are
nursing home care.The value of care for older adults with also less specific costs, including time off from work, the
Alzheimer’s-type dementia has been estimated to be 41% need to stop working outside the home entirely, travel
greater than that of caregiving for an adult with a physical expenses, increased mental health issues, and the cost to
illness.26 If the informal caregiver can no longer function physical health, to name a few. One study found that over
in that role because of physical or mental health problems, their lifetimes caregivers lose >$650,000 in salary and

7
MAY 2008
retirement benefits, a loss that far exceeds their out-of- partnerships with local Agencies on Aging and communi-
pocket expenses.28 ty services to provide: (1) information about available
When the needs of patients exceed what families can services; (2) assistance in gaining access to services; (3)
offer, paid care is required. Many families as well as health support groups and training; (4) respite care; and (5) serv-
professionals are not familiar with the options for home ices to complement and support the work of family
support services, their costs, and the available resources to caregivers. Support from this program is available to
cover these costs. Support at home often comes from Alzheimer’s caregivers regardless of the age of the patient.
aides who provide personal care or housekeeping services. While not exclusively for caregivers with lower incomes,
Agencies as well as private sources may provide these such applicants receive priority consideration. The ability
aides, but regulation of home health aides is done on a of this program to meet the demand is limited by the
state-by-state basis and aides acquired from private amount of federal funding received in any given year and
sources may not be regulated at all. Another option is the funds provided by the state.
adult day care, where the services offered range from the
provision for all ADLs to meals and activities.The nation- Educating the Caregiver
al average cost of help at home is $19 an hour; the cost
Education about AD and available resources is a critical
for adult day care is $61 a day.29 These costs vary widely
component of caregiver well-being. A study by Walker
from state to state and region to region.
and Dewar reported that there are four markers of satis-
Many families expect that Medicare will pay for the
factory caregiver involvement in the care of older per-
help needed, but coverage by Medicare is very limited
and only provides for home health care for intermittent sons: (1) feeling that information was shared; (2) feeling
or short-term periods. In addition, in order for patients to included in decision-making; (3) feeling that there was
be eligible for Medicare coverage, they must have a need someone to contact if they needed to; and (4) feeling that
for physical therapy or skilled nursing care. Alternatively, the service was responsive to their needs.31 The majority
many families are resistant to utilizing benefits available of caregivers in this study reported feeling dissatisfied
from Medicaid because of a fear of losing their home or with the level of their involvement. Hospital systems and
the stigma of receiving “welfare.” processes and the relationship between nursing staff and
An important resource for family caregivers came as a caregivers were the two main sources of barriers.
result of the Older Americans Act Amendments of In a qualitative study by Bruce and Paterson, it was
2000.30 The National Family Caregiver Support Program found that most caregivers perceived that general practi-
that arose as a result of these amendments established tioners had been late in referring dementia sufferers for

Table 2. Resources for Caregivers


Administration on Aging American Association of Retired Eldercare Locator
202-619-0724 Persons 800-677-1116
www.aoa.gov/eldfam/eldfam.asp 888-687-2277 www.eldercare.gov
www.aarp.org/family/caregiving/
Aging Care: The Community for Family Caregiver Alliance
Caregivers Care.com 800-445-8106 or 415-434-3388
866-627-2467 or 239-594-3200 www.care.com/senior-care-p1006.html www.caregiver.org
www.agingcare.com
Caregiving Online National Council on the Aging
Alzheimer’s Association 773-343-6341 202-479-1200
800-272-3900 www.caregiving.com/ www.ncoa.org
www.alz.org/
Caring Today Magazine Online National Family Caregivers
Alzheimer’s Disease Education and www.caringtoday.com Association
Referral Center, National Institute 800-896-3650
Children of Aging Parents
on Aging www.nfcacares.org
800-227-7294
800-438-4380
www.caps4caregivers.org The Well Spouse Foundation
www.alzheimers.org/
800-838-0879
or www.nia.nih.gov/alzheimers
732-577-8899
www.wellspouse.org

8
COUNSELING POINTS™
community care, despite the fact that the caregiver had
GRECC Dementia-related reported experiencing difficulties with the patient for a
Educational Pamphlets33 considerable period of time.32 Caregivers also complained
that they received too little information about the diag-
Download for caregiver teaching at:
nosis of dementia and how to deal with problem behav-
www1.va.gov/minneapolis/services/grecc iors. Earlier recognition of the caregivers’ problems and
/serv_grecc_care.html the provision of better education and earlier access to
Excellent sources of caregiver information are the support services may lessen the degree of stress experi-
Geriatric, Research, Education and Clinic Centers enced by caregivers. Needs common to caregivers across
(GRECCs), “centers of excellence” that are
all care groups were identified as access to information
designed to improve health care and quality of life
for older veterans through the advancement and (diagnostic, prognostic, and where to obtain help),
integration of research, education, and clinical improved communication with professionals, relief from
achievements in geriatrics and gerontology into the stress, and proactive support.
total Veterans Affairs (VA) health care system and Medication Guidelines for Caregivers
broader communities.33 The VA has long recognized
geriatrics as a priority area because the demographic Antipsychotic medication has routinely been prescribed
imperative of an aging population impacted the VA to manage problem behaviors in patients with AD when
system earlier than it did the general health care nonpharmacologic strategies fail. Families must now be
community in the United States. Below, you will educated that atypical antipsychotics such as aripiprazole
find a list of full-text pamphlets in a GRECC series (Abilify®), olanzapine (Zyprexa®), quetiapine (Seroquel®),
on dementia-related diseases that nurses/advanced and risperidone (Risperdal®) may prolong the QT inter-
practice nurses can share with caregivers.* val, predisposing patients to arrhythmias and sudden car-
GENERAL INFORMATION diac death, sedation, and accelerated cognitive decline,
What is Alzheimer's Disease? and may increase the risk for aspiration, pneumonia,
The Role of the Caregiver
venous thromboembolism, pulmonar y embolism,
MANAGING DAY TO DAY cerebrovascular events, and falls leading to hip frac-
Dealing with Decline in the Patient's Ability tures and premature death.34 The most recent placebo-
Creating a Safe and Workable Environment
controlled study on this topic, published in the April 2008
WORKING WITH... issue of the journal Public Library of Science Medicine, found
Health Care Professionals
that prescription of antipsychotic drugs to 165 people
Bureaucracies:What to Do
Family and Friends with severe AD living in nursing homes led to a signifi-
cant deterioration in verbal ability and didn’t appear to
COMMUNICATION TOPICS
Basic Issues and Techniques provide any benefit.35 These authors suggested that use of
Hearing Problems antipsychotics may be beneficial for some patients with
Vision Problems severe neuropsychiatric symptoms, but the benefits of use
SPECIAL CARE ISSUES must be carefully weighed against the risks of side effects.
Aggressive and Violent Behavior Caregivers need to be educated not only about the
Inappropriate Sexual Behavior different medications used to manage AD symptoms, but
Restlessness,Wandering and Sleep Disturbances also about more subtle issues of adherence and persistence
Bowel Incontinence with medication use. Medication guidelines for caregivers
Urinary Incontinence
may include such assessments as:
FINANCIAL AND LEGAL ISSUES • Can patients take their medications or do they forget
Where to Begin
to take them?
Planning for Now and the Future
Guardianships and Involuntary Treatment • Can patients read the medication label?
Respite Care:When You Need a Break • Can patients hear the instructions of the health care
Choosing a Nursing Home: Institutional Care
provider?
The Move to a Nursing Home:The Planned and
Unplanned Move • Do patients have the dexterity to open bottles, break
*Pamphlets authored by Kenneth Hepburn, Ph.D. tablets, and/or handle medicines such as eye drops or
inhalers?

9
MAY 2008
• Do patients have difficulty swallowing? Rivastigmine modestly improves scores on neuropsy-
• Are patients experiencing difficulty in scheduling chological tests; benefits decrease after 40 weeks of treat-
when to take their various medications? ment. GI discomfort can occur as a side effect of this
• Are patients taking too many medications, including medication.44
over-the-counter drugs and herbs?
Strategies for Reducing Caregiver
For a fact sheet to guide caregivers about medication
Stress
challenges, visit www.caregiver.org/caregiver/jsp/content_
node.jsp?nodeid=1104.36 The vast majority of patients with dementia receive
Evidence is weak that drugs or herbs other than their care in primary care settings. It is a challenge for
cholinesterase inhibitors have important benefits for peo- clinicians to provide optimal care for patients and their
ple with AD, including g inkgo biloba, seleg iline stressed and overburdened caregivers who require time-
(Eldepryl®), vitamin E, and estrogen.37-39 Caregivers need intensive, team-based processes of care. To address this
to be aware of the symptoms of anticholinergic toxicity, issue, Vickrey and colleagues developed a novel disease
which are delirium or confusion, memory impairment, management program for patients with dementia and
and obtundation. 40 They must be aware of over-the- their caregivers seen in primary care. 45 Those in the
counter medications (antihistamines and bladder control control group were assigned a case manager who
drugs) that may be harmful when taking anticholinergics worked with and trained the caregiver, assessed and pri-
for dementia.40 For more information and educational oritized patient and caregiver needs, and recommended
help regarding medications, visit www.fpnotebook.com/ interventions. Quality of care, as measured by adherence
Geri/index.htm to guidelines, was dramatically higher in patients
Vulnerable elders fill an average of 20 prescriptions who received the intervention. Patients’ quality of life
annually.41 Aging can be associated with decreased metab- improved, and caregivers reported improved social sup-
olism and excretion of prescription drugs and their port, mastery of caregiving, and confidence. This inter-
metabolites, placing elderly patients at risk for side effects vention bears many similarities to a collaborative care
and complicating appropriate dosing. Medication reviews approach described by Callahan and colleagues that also
should take place annually to discontinue unnecessary improved the process and outcomes of dementia care.46
medications.41 In this latter study, dementia patients received 1 year of
care management by an interdisciplinary team led by an
Cholinesterase Inhibitors advanced practice nurse working with the patient’s fam-
The cholinesterase inhibitors prescribed for dementia are ily caregiver and integrated with primary care services,
donepezil (Aricept ® ), galantamine (Razadyne ® ), and resulting in a significant improvement in the quality of
rivastigmine (Exelon®). care. The intervention also improved behavioral and
According to research data, donepezil significantly psychological symptoms of patients and the well-being
benefits patients in early-stage AD by improving daily of caregivers.
cognitive functioning.42 It is used to treat mild to moder- Belle tested an intervention to improve the quality of
ate dementia (Folstein MMSE scores of 10-26). Patients life in a multiethnic group of distressed caregivers.47 This
will revert to their prior level of decline when the drug is intervention focused on five domains that are important
withdrawn; therefore, they should be warned not to dis- to caregivers: reducing depression, decreasing burden,
continue without contacting their provider.42 Long-term improving self-care, enhancing social support, and manag-
use has minimal to no effect.42 Donepezil does not pre- ing problem behaviors. The trained care manager assessed
vent nursing home placement and does not protect the caregivers’ needs and functioned as a coach. The
against long-term functional decline.42 innovative features of the intervention included tailoring
Ekinjuntti et al found that galantamine stabilizes and its components to the unique needs and concerns of each
even delays cognitive deterioration among patients with caregiver and emphasizing self-empowerment. More than
vascular dementia as well as patients with AD combined 90% of caregivers reported that the intervention made
with cerebrovascular disease.43 Adverse effects of this their lives easier and improved their ability to provide
drug include gastrointestinal (GI) upset, dizziness, and care. There were also encouraging trends toward lower
bradycardia.43 rates of nursing home placement.The benefits and quality

10
COUNSELING POINTS™
of evidence supporting these interventions considerably quate help on important topics, were more satisfied with
exceed those of currently approved pharmacologic thera- care, and experienced less strain in their relationships with
pies for dementia, according to Schneider.48 other family members. The goal of this initiative is to
These studies illustrate several principles that should offer tools to providers for early identification of AD,
guide how care is delivered to patients with dementia. diagnostic assessment, care management and programs,
First, caregivers need to be a dominant focus of any effec- and materials for the caregiver. A toolbox containing the
tive dementia management strategy because caring for a mater ials used to educate pr imary care and other
loved one with dementia can present enormous physical, providers is available at www.nccconline.org/pdf/CCN-
psychological, and emotional difficulties and is an inde- AD_tools6-03.pdf.
pendent risk factor for early mortality.20,21 For instance, In short, research shows that much of the distress of
the REACH study focused on increasing self-efficacy by families can be prevented when primary care practition-
encouraging caregivers to be less emotional and develop ers work closely with gerontological nurses and nurse
more effective problem-solving skills.21 This was achieved practitioners and form community partnerships with
by teaching caregivers how to manage their time better people with dementia and their families.53 These partner-
and become more assertive in asking for help from others, ships are now the expected norm.
channeling their thoughts more positively, and preparing
for the future. Books for Caregivers
The research on dementia caregivers also emphasizes The 36-Hour Day:A Family Guide to Caring for Persons with
the importance of intrapersonal mediators in affecting the Alzheimer’s Disease, Related Dementing Illnesses, and Memory
outcome of the stress process associated with caregiving. Loss in Later Life
The Savvy Caregiver program, for example, is predicated Nancy L. Mace, MA, and Peter V. Rabins, MD
on the notion that by strengthening caregivers’ knowl- The Loss of Self:A Family Resource for the Care of Alzheimer’s
edge, skills, and outlook for caregiving—in effect, by pro- Disease and Related Disorders
viding training for the role in which they find them- Donna Cohen, PhD, and Carl Eisdorfer, PhD, MD
selves—the deleterious effects of caregiving can be Alzheimer’s Disease:A Guide for Families
ameliorated.49 In another study, it was found that case Lenore S. Powell, EdD, with Katie Courtice
managers at a master’s level of health care could effect sig- The Complete Guide to Alzheimer’s-proofingYour Home
nificant improvements in depression, burden, and reaction Mark Warner and Ellen Warner
to behavior problems in caregivers, which decreased the When Memory Fails: Helping the Alzheimer’s and Dementia
severity of care recipients’ behavior problems.50 It has also Patient
been demonstrated that an in-home skills training pro- Allen Jack Edwards, PhD
gram helps to sustain caregiver effectiveness, according to
Gitlin et al.51 They also conclude that more frequent pro- Summary
fessional contact and on-going skills training may be nec-
As AD becomes an increasingly prevalent health problem
essary to maintain other clinically important outcomes
in the United States, the needs and well-being of care-
such as reduced upset with behaviors.51
givers must be taken into account. Caregivers experience
A project known as the Chronic Care Networks for
physical and psychological stressors, the effects of which
Alzheimer’s Disease Initiative (CCN/AD), national and
may be underestimated or missed. Gerontological nurses
local partnerships of the Alzheimer’s Association and the
and advanced practice nurses can perform a significant
National Chronic Care Consortium members, is one of
service to caregivers by inquiring at routine visits about
the largest demonstrations of Alzheimer’s and dementia
patients’ caregiving status, offering support, and providing
evidence-based care to date, and one of the first to focus
referrals to educational materials, support groups, and
on the coordination of health care and supportive
adult day care programs.
services.52 People with dementia and their family care-
References
givers benefited from the services they received through
1. The Alzheimer’s Association. Alzheimer’s Disease Facts and Figures
this project, and patients, caregivers, primary health care 2007. Accessed October 24, 2007 at www.alz.org/national/documents/
providers, and Alzheimer’s Association chapter staff report_alzfactsfigures2007.pdf.
2. Aguglia E, Onor ML, Trevisiol M, et al. Stress in the caregivers of
reported high levels of satisfaction with these networks. Alzheimer’s patients: An experimental investigation in Italy. Am J
In particular, caregivers reported that they received ade- Alzheimers Dis Other Demen. 2004;19:248-252.

11
MAY 2008
3. Mahoney R, Regan C, Katona C, et al. Anxiety and depression in family 29. MetLife Mature Market Institute. The MetLife Market Survey of Adult
caregivers of people with Alzheimer disease. Am J Geriatr Psychiatry. Day Services & Home Care Costs. New York, NY: Metropolitan Life
2005;13:795-801. Insurance Company. 2007.
4. Mittelman MS, Haley WE, Clay OJ, et al. Improving caregiver well-being 30. Administration on Aging. National Family Caregiver Support Program.
delays nursing home placement of patients with Alzheimer disease. Neu- Washington, DC: Administration on Aging. 2007.
rology. 2006;67:1592-1599. 31. Walker E, Dewar J. How do we facilitate carers’ involvement in
5. Beauchamp TL, Childress JF. Principles of Biomedical Ethics. 5th ed. New decision making? J Adv Nurs. 2001;34:329-337.
York, NY: Oxford University Press. 2001. 32. Bruce D, Patterson A. Barriers to community support for the dementia
6. American Geriatrics Society. Geriatric Nursing Review Syllabus: A Core carer: a qualitative study. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry. 2000;5:451-457.
Curriculum in Advanced Practice Geriatric Nursing. 2nd ed. New York, NY: 33. Geriatric Research, Education, and Clinical Center. GRECC Pamphlets.
American Geriatrics Society. 2007. Accessed April 4, 2008 at www1.va.gov/minneap9lis/services/grecc/
7. Barnes S. Reflections on the applications of ethical theory. Appendix 14-1. serv_grecc_pamphlets.html.
In: Mauk K (ed). Gerontological Nursing: Competencies for Care. Boston,
34. Gills SS, Bronskill SE, Normand SL, et al. Antipsychotic drug use and
Ma: Jones and Bartlett. 2006.
mortality in older adults with dementia. Ann Intern Med. 2007;146:
8. Stanley M, Blair KA, Beare PG. Gerontological Nursing: Promoting Suc-
775-786.
cessful Aging with Older Adults. 3rd ed. Philadelphia, Pa: FA Davis. 2005.
35. Ballard C, Lana MM, Theodoulou M, et al. A randomised, blinded, place-
9. Post LF. Supporting families in ethical decision-making. LTC Nurs Compan.
bo-controlled trial in dementia patients continuing or stopping neurolep-
2008;6:4-6.
tics (the DART-AD trial). PLos Med. 2008;5:e76 [Epub ahead of print].
10. Musil CM, Morris DL, Warner CB, et al. Issues in caregivers stress and
36. Family Caregiver Alliance. Medications: A Double-Edged Sword.
provider support. Res Aging. 2003;25:505-526.
Accessed April 4, 2008 at www.caregiver.org/caregiver/jsp/content_
11. Lantz MS. Caregiver burden: When the family needs help. Clin Geriatr.
2004;12:29-32. node.jsp?nodeid=1104.
12. Zarit S, Zarit, J. Cognitive impairment of older persons: Etiology evaluation 37. Oken B, Storzback DM, Kaye JA. The efficacy of ginkgo biloba on
and intervention. In: Lewison PM, ed. Clinical Psychology. New York, NY: cognitive function in Alzheimer disease. Arch Neurol. 1998;55:1409-1415.
Pergamon Press. 1983, pp 225-232. 38. Birks J, Flicker L. Selegiline for Alzheimers disease. Cochrane Database
13. American Geriatrics Society Healthcare Professionals Say Signs and Symp- Syst Rev. 2000(2):CD000442.
toms Associated with Caregiver Stress amount to “Caregiver Syndrome.” 39. Asthana S, Baker LD, Craft S, et al. High-dose estradiol improves cognition
Accessed April 10, 2008 from the AGS Web site: www.americangeri- for women with AD: Results of a randomized study. Neurology.
atrics.org/listserv/newsletter_082107.shtml#8. 2001;57:605-612.
14. Pearlin LI, Mullan JT, Semple SJ, et al. Care giving and the stress 40. Moses S. Geriatric Medicine Book. Family Practice Notebook. Accessed
process: An overview of concepts and their measures. Gerontologist. April 10, 2008 at www.fpnotebook.com/Geri/index.htm.
1990;30:583-594. 41. Shrank W, Polinski J, Avorn J. Quality indicators of medication use in
15. Thomas P, Lalloue F, Preux P, et al. Dementia patients caregivers quality vulnerable elders. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2007;55(suppl 2):S373-S382.
of life: the PIXEL study. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry. 2006;21:50-56. 42. Seltzer B, Zolnouni, Nuncz, M, et al. Efficacy of donepezil in early stage
16. Parks SM, Novielli KD. A practical guide to caring for caregivers. Am Alzheimer’s disease: A randomized placebo controlled trial. Arch Neurol.
Fam Physician. 2000;62:2613-2622. 2004;61:1852-1856.
17. Clipp EC, George LK. Dementia and cancer. A comparison of spouse 43. Erkinjuntti T, Kurz A, Gauthier S, et al. Efficacy of galantamine in probable
caregivers. Gerontologist. 1993;35:534-541. vascular dementia and Alzheimers disease combined with cerebrovascular
18. Max W, Webber P, Fox P. Alzheimer’s disease: The unpaid burden of disease: A randomized trial. Lancet. 2002; 359:283-1290.
caring. J Aging Health. 1995;7:179-199. 44. Moses S. Neurology Book. Rivastigmine. Family Practice Notebook.
19. Kiecolt-Glaser J, Glaser R, Gravenstein S, et al. Chronic stress alters the Accessed April 21, 2008 at www.fpnotebook.com/Neuro/Pharm/
immune response to influenza virus vaccine in older adults. Proc Natl Rvstgmn.htm.
Acad Sci USA. 1996;93:3043-3047. 45. Vickrey BG, Mittman BS, Connor KI, et al. The effect of a disease
20. Schulz R, Beach SR. Caregiving as a risk factor for mortality: The care- management intervention on quality and outcomes of dementia care: A
giver health effects study. JAMA. 199;282:2215-2219. randomized, controlled trial. Ann Intern Med. 2006:145:713-726.
21. REACH Principle Investigators. Resources for enhancing Alzheimer’s 46. Callahan CM, Boustani MA, Unverzagt FW, et al. Effectiveness of
caregiver health (REACH): Overview, site-specific outcomes and future collaborative care for older adults with Alzheimer disease in primary care:
directions. Gerontologist. 2003; 43:512-520. A randomized, controlled trial. JAMA. 2006;295:2148-2157.
22. National Center on Elder Abuse, Institute on Aging. A Fact Sheet on Care-
47. Belle SH, Burgio L, Burns R, et al. Enhancing the quality of life of dementia
giver Stress and Elder Abuse. 2002. Accessed April 21, 2008 at
caregivers from different ethnic and racial groups. A randomized,
www.ncea.aoa.gov/ncearoot/main_site/pdf/family/fact_sheet.pdf.
controlled trial. Ann Intern Med. 2006;145:727-738.
23. Feinberg LF, Newman SL. A study of 10 states since passage of the
48. Schneider LS, Tariot PN, Dagerman KS, et al. Effectiveness of atypical
National Family Caregiver Support Program: Policies, perceptions, and
antipsychotic drugs in patients with Alzheimer’s disease. N Engl J Med.
program development. Gerontologist. 2004;44:760-769.
2006;355:1525-1538.
24. Coleman B, Pandya SM. Family Caregiving and Long-Term Care. Fact
49. Hepburn K, Lewis M, Tornatore J, et al. The Savvy Caregiver: The
sheet. Washington, DC: AARP. 2002. Accessed April 21, 2008
demonstrated effectiveness of a tranportable dementia caregiver
at www.aarp.org/research/housing-mobility/caregiving/aresearch-
import-779-FS91.html. psychoeducation program. J Gerontol Nurs. 2007;33:30-36.
25. Gibson MJ, Houser J. Valuing the Invaluable: A New Look at the Eco- 50. Teri L, McCurry S, Logsdon R, Gibbons L. Training community consultants
nomic Value of Family Caregiving. AARP Public Policy Institute Issue to help family members improve dementia care: A randomized controlled
Brief. Washington, DC: AARP. 2007. Accessed February 10, 2008 at trial. Gerontologist. 2005;45:802-811.
www.aarp.org/ppi. 51. Gitlin LN, Hauck WW, Dennis MP, et al. Maintenance of effects of the
26. MetLife Mature Market Institute. The MetLife Study of Alzheimer’s Dis- home environmental skill-building program for family caregivers and
ease: The Caregiving Experience. New York, NY: Metropolitan Life individuals with Alzheimer’s disease and related disorders. J Gerontol A
Insurance Company. 2006. Biol Sci Med Sci. 2005;60:368-374.
27. Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation. The Wide Circle of Caregiving. Key 52. Chronic Care Networks for Alzheimer’s Disease Initiative. Tools for Early
Findings from a National Survey: Long Term Care from a Caregiver’s Identification, Assessment, and Treatment for People with Alzheimer’s
Perspective. New York, NY: Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation. 2002. Disease and Dementia. 2003. Accessed April 2, 2008 at www.ncconline
28. Women’s Institute for a Secure Retirement (WISER). Financial Steps for .org/pdf/CCN-AD_tools6-03.pdf.
Caregivers: What You Need to Know About Money and Retirement. 53. Downs M, Bowers B. Caring for people with dementia. BMJ.
Washington, DC: Women’s Institute for a Secure Retirement. 2004. 2008;336:225-226.

12
COUNSELING POINTS™
CP
Counseling Points
Alzheimer’s Disease:

Caring for the Caregiver


• The majority of people with Alzheimer’s disease (AD) live in their own homes or with
relatives and are cared for by loved ones.

• Unpaid caregivers are at significant risk for stress-related signs and symptoms, clinical
depression, anxiety, health problems, and early death.

• Principles of biomedical ethics can help clinicians guide families through the decision-
making processes attendant to caring for patients with AD.

• Many health professionals refer to caregiver stress as “caregiver syndrome,” a condition


of chronic stress accompanied by depression, anger, guilt, and/or deteriorating health.

• Caregivers at greatest risk for poor physical and/or emotional health include those who
have been caregiving for a prolonged period of time; are caregiving in their own home
versus an institutional setting; have a chronic illness themselves; have little or no social
support networks; utilize resources (social service, respite) sparingly; are not financially
stable or had to give up working to perform caregiving duties; have a lower education-
al level; are caring for a person with dementia, multiple symptoms/conditions, or a
someone with impaired activities of daily living or instrumental activities of daily living;
are caregiving full time versus part time; possess inadequate levels of empathy/affect;
and are assessed to be in a state of denial.

• Caregivers need to be educated about the different medications used to manage AD


symptoms, but also about more subtle issues of adherence and persistence with
medication use.

• Most patients with dementia receive their care in primary care settings.

• Research shows that much of the distress of families can be prevented when primary
care practitioners work closely with gerontological nurses and nurse practitioners and
form community partnerships with people with dementia and their families.

• Caregivers need to be a dominant focus of any effective dementia management strategy.

13
MAY 2008
Counseling Points™
Alzheimer’s Disease: Caring for the Caregiver
Continuing Education Posttest
To receive credit, read the newsletter in its entirety and answer the posttest and program evaluation questions
using the answer key on page 15. Fax the form to Delaware Media Group at (201) 612-8282. A certificate
will be awarded for a score of 80% (8 correct) or better and will be mailed within 4-6 weeks.There is no charge
for CE credit.

1. Research suggests that improving caregiver well- 6. A study by Walker and Dewar found that markers of
being can delay nursing home placement of satisfactory caregiver involvement include:
patients with Alzheimer’s disease (AD). A. feeling that information was shared
A. True B. feeling included in decision-making
B. False C. both A and B
D. neither A or B
2. Which of the following is NOT one of the four
biomedical ethics principles identified by 7. A placebo-controlled study published in Public
Beauchamp and Childress? Library of Science Medicine found that prescription of
A. Respect for autonomy antipsychotic drugs to people with severe AD
B. Nonmaleficence living in nursing homes led to:
C. Double effect A. a significant deterioration in verbal ability
D. Justice B. a significant deterioration in memory
C. a significant improvement in verbal ability
3. The PIXEL study found that caregiver quality of D. a significant improvement in memory
life was correlated to:
A. the quality of life of the person being cared for 8. Nonprescription drugs that can be harmful when
B. the particular behavioral disorder of the person being patients are using cholinesterase inhibitors for
cared for dementia include:
C. the duration of the illness A. multivitamins
D. all of the above B. antihistamines
C. decongestants
4. The Caregiver Health Effects Study found that eld- D. analgesics
erly spousal caregivers who characterized them-
selves as being emotionally or mentally strained by 9. In a study by Vickrey and colleagues, it was found
their role had what percent greater risk of mortali- that a novel disease management program for
ty than non-caregivers? patients with dementia and their caregivers seen in
A. 35% primary care led to all BUT which of the following?
B. 48% A. improved caregiver social support
C. 63% B. improved caregiver mastery of caregiving
D. 75% C. improved caregiver confidence
D. improved caregiver time management
5. An Association of Retired Persons study conducted
in 2006 found that there were between ___ and ___ 10. The Savvy Caregiver program is predicated on the
million family caregivers providing care to func- notion that by strengthening caregivers’ knowledge,
tionally impaired older adults. skills, and outlook on caregiving:
A. 20-26 A. the deleterious effects of caregiving can be ameliorated
B. 30-38 B. the deleterious effects of caregiving can be eliminated
C. 40-42 C. the positive effects of caregiving can be increased
D. 48-51 D. the positive effects of caregiving can be decreased

14
COUNSELING POINTS™
Fax form to (201) 612-8282
EVALUATION FORM
Counseling Points™
Alzheimer’s Disease: Caring for the Caregiver
To assist us in evaluating the effectiveness of this activity and to make recommendations for future educational offerings, please take a few minutes to
complete this evaluation form. You must complete this evaluation form to receive acknowledgment for completing this activity.

Please answer the following questions by circling the appropriate rating:

1 = Strongly Disagree 2 = Disagree 3 = Neutral 4 = Agree 5 = Strongly Agree


Extent to Which Program Activities Met the Identified Objectives (After completing this activity, I am now better able to):

1. Discuss ethical issues in caring for the patient with Alzheimer’s disease (AD), including end-of-life care.......................................... 1 2 3 4 5
2. Describe the psychosocial, physical, and financial burdens of AD on the family and caregivers.......................................................... 1 2 3 4 5
3. Review educational counseling for caregivers......................................................................................................................................... 1 2 3 4 5
4. Name effective techniques and strategies to reduce stress on caregivers................................................................................................ 1 2 3 4 5
Overall Effectiveness of the Activity (The content presented):

5. Was timely and will influence how I practice.......................................................................................................................................... 1 2 3 4 5


6. Enhanced my current knowledge base..................................................................................................................................................... 1 2 3 4 5
7. Addressed my most pressing questions ..................................................................................................................................................... 1 2 3 4 5
8. Provided new ideas or information I expect to use ................................................................................................................................ 1 2 3 4 5
9. Addressed competencies identified by my specialty ................................................................................................................................ 1 2 3 4 5
10. Avoided commercial bias or influence .................................................................................................................................................. 1 2 3 4 5
Impact of the Activity
Name one thing you intend to change in your practice as a result of completing this activity: ________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Please list any topics you would like to see addressed in future educational activities: ________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Additional comments about this activity: ____________________________________________________________________________________________________________

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Follow-up
As part of our continuous quality improvement effort, we conduct postactivity follow-up surveys to assess the impact of our educational interven-
tions on professional practice. Please indicate if you would be willing to participate in such a survey:
❒ Yes, I would be interested in participating in a follow-up survey. ❒ No, I’m not interested in participating in a follow-up survey.
If you wish to receive acknowledgment for completing this activity, please complete the posttest by selecting the best answer to each question,
complete this evaluation verification of participation, and fax to (201) 612-8282.

Posttest Answer Key 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

Request for Credit

Name _________________________________________________________________ Degree ________________________________________


Organization___________________________________________________________ Specialty ________________________________________
Address_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
City _____________________________________________________________________________ State __________ ZIP ________________
Phone _____________________________ Fax _____________________________ E-mail __________________________________________

Signature_________________________________________________________________ Date ______________________________________

Fax form to (201) 612-8282


15
MAY 2008
CP

www.delmedgroup.com

Вам также может понравиться