Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 4

Project: Diseases Prevention & Screening Center

Reference: Schematic Design 14th January 2011

Consultants: ASTORINO Peddle Thorpe

Subject: MEP Comments

A.

MECHANICAL COMMENTS

Date: 20-01-2011

Sl No

Reference

SEHA Comments

Consultant Clarification

1

09-MEP Codes, Reference and Design Standards

Please add HAAD Guidelines, ADSSC and ADCD Regulations to the General Category

 

2

09-Design Criteria and Allowances

For the temperature allowance shall be ±1°C and RH ±5%

 

3

09-Ventilation Rates

Ventilation rates for various areas seem to be on the lower side. Clarify

 

4

09-Water Consumption

Provide details and standards followed for calculation of 80 liters/day water consumption.

 

5

09-HVAC System

-Avoid using Heat Wheels as a means of ERU. -Since you are planning to use VAV AHU system explain how do you intend to control the outdoor air requirement for various areas. -Explain how pressure relationship is maintained in Isolation Rooms -We prefer rigid fiberglass insulation for all applications. -1 inch thick c. w. pipe insulation is not adequate. Justify. -5.5/14.4°C for Chiller Plant flow and return is NOT economical and not standard. Justify. -Chiller redundancy explanation is not clear. -Name the preferred refrigerant.

 

1

6

09-Plumbing System

-Confirm the concrete water tank is partitioned. Water demand calculations must be submitted. -Explain why the water (domestic and fire) needs treatment. -Confirm 90minute water storage for fire is in compliance with ADCD requirement. -This is a low rise building. Water distribution by gravity may not be the ideal arrangement. Consider pressurized system. -Generally the water storage and distribution system needs further consideration. It is not clear how the water is cooled for domestic purpose. -Justify using central hot water system in this project. Explain why local water heaters cannot be used. -Explain how water pressure of the fixtures shall be maintained between 2.0 and 3.5 bar in a gravity flow system. -Provide justification for the elaborate water treatment system (filters, softeners, UV, anti corrosion, chlorine dosing units etc) for this project. -For Drainage system follow ADSSC regulations (not ADDC). -What are the advantages of using copper piping for hot and cold water system against PPR? -Third Party Independent specialist commissioning agent will be appointed by the Client but the cost will be borne by the contractor.

2

B.

ELECTRICAL COMMENTS

 

Sl No

Reference

SEHA Comments

Consultant

Clarification

1

09-MEP Codes, Reference and Design Standards

Please add HTM 06-01 &02 and latest RBS regulation in the electrical codes and references list. Both should be considered in tandem especially for the network designing.

 

2

09- Electrical system

Determination of the emergency power shall be as per HTM 06-01 clinical and non clinical risk profiling. UPS autonomy to 1 hour and fuel storage on site for the generators to be 24 hours.

 

3

 

Hallways and corridors should have dimming instead of occupancy sensors. Staircases can have both the systems.

 

4

 

Queue management system for the screening area where receipt and delivery of documents shall take place

 

5

 

In general, the descriptions of all the services are of very basic nature and

 

a

full range of design criteria and

other information should be provided to call it as schematic design. For example there must be SLD for

the power , IT and other system networks as proposed .

6

 

The drawings submitted are incomplete (many services not included) and mostly blank architectural floor plan layouts.

 

7

Drawing. E 10

Four ATS panels are used instead of one and placed far from the LV panel/Generator. Please justify

Drawing numbers are random or have some reference /abbreviation

8

E20

LUX level does not match with the design brief section 09

 

9

E100

Description of ducts and ECC layout

 

duplicated .Which one is correct? No power layout items are shown

is

3

   

on the drawing to comment on.

10 E101

 

No power layout items are shown on the drawing to comment on.

 

11 E102, E103 , E104

No power layout items are shown on the drawing to comment on.

 

12 E601 &602

No loads mentioned anywhere. How the sizing of the breakers, transformers, generators were determined? Third ACB panel not connected to the other two through bus coupler? Four ATS panels have been used instead of one with the main generator panel?

 

13 Drawing T101NE,

All the drawings are simply architectural layout and nothing mentioned about communication to comment on them

T101NW,T101S,T102,T103,

T104

14 T106

 

There are Etisalat floor telecom closet on every floor. Please justify.

4