Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 4

(Add more items as you see fit.

Make sure you update the Cited Sources portion,


every time you use a new source.)

Question: There is no cure for “crab mentality” in the Philippines.

EVIDENCE
Key Details: What did you find out?
This short-sighted, selfish and non-constructive thinking is called Crab Mentality.
Crab mentality as narrated by Kane Lawless, is a term used colloquially referring
to a person trying to leave an underprivileged-life but is kept from doing so
because of other people who hold them back for they resent that person’s
success. It is an act of keeping others from getting what they want and not
wanting others to be successful. 

Definition of Terms: What do you need to understand?


Term Definition

Short-sighted unable to see things clearly unless they are relatively close to
the eyes.

Colloquial used in ordinary or familiar conversation; not formal or


literary. 

Unprivileged- Someone underprivileged doesn't have the advantages other


life people have. Underprivileged people usually live in poverty.

Opinions: What opinions can you form based on what you found out?
 AFFIRMATIVE: Crab mentality is a psychological thing and it’s profound
to most people the cure isn’t for everybody, and the situation really
differs from every person.

 NEGATIVE: “We cannot change others but we can certainly make good
change for ourselves.” Yes, it is common to us Filipinos to have crab
mentality because of we have been using that since we have been
colonized by Japan and a writer Ninotchka Rosca which is a Filipino citizen
and graduated in U.P. invented the Crab in a bucket. it is impossible to
change others and we can’t dictate someone on how they will think and
act but if the change begins in ourselves eventually, we can change what
we have been entrench.

REBUTTALS
NEGATIVE: Arguments of the Affirmative Side
Argument 1: There is a cure for crab mentality.

Counter Argument 1 Rebuttal 1

 There is no cure for crab  You have said that it depends on


mentality since it’s in already in the person, so your saying that
our system. We cannot change there is really a cure it’s just that
others on how they will think people are neglecting it. It will
and how they will act because it also depend on the person of
is based on how they were he/she wants to be cured or not.
raised by their parents. Be on  Also, if you already put an end
that mindset or not, it will still and said that there is no cure it
depend on the person. means that you will just tolerate
that kind of mentality. Even in
some sickness that still don’t
have cure, doctors or specialists
will never said that there is no
cure for it instead they will say
that there’s no cure for it “YET”
since they haven’t given up on it. 
Argument 2: 
 Some mentalities can cure crab mentality.

Counter Argument 2 Rebuttal 2

 How can you make sure  it takes a good education and some
that those mentalities can mental level for one to know how to
effectively cure the crab realistically analyze and criticize the
mentality if not all will culture and traditions one has
respond, based on what experience and live with for the rest
you have mentioned, not all of his life. According to the Filipino
are paying attention to it? American Psychology, each of us in
this world has a power, power that
can solve any individual issues as well
as the crab mentality. Power, the
ability to change, influence others,
and receive what one desires. 

Argument 3: Misunderstood in the meaning of Crab mentality

Counter Argument 3 Rebuttal 3

 Crab Mentality is  It’s a misunderstood, since we Filipinos are


“Pulling others worried about being equal with each other.
down” and there is We try our best to join others, but we end up
no way you can fix pulling them down. It’s not pulling others
that down; it’s trying to join others but weighing
them down.
CONCLUSION
Base all your entries for this portion on the arguments, counter arguments, and
rebuttals from the previous portion.

(NEGATIVE) This group believes that:


This group believes that no matter what others will say, still, there is a cure for
crab mentality. It is just that not all people are willing to accept their defeat. as
decisions are depending upon their selves and it cannot be controlled by anyone
else.

CITED “RESOURCES

Use the MLA format. You can use this link to generate the citation.
Update this portion as you go through the different portions.

Citation 1
"Filipino crab mentality." Topics, Sample Papers & Articles Online for Free, 30 Dec 2016,
https://studymoose.com/filipino-crab-mentality-essay

Citation 2

https://psychcentral.com/blog/how-do-you-cure-mental-illness/

Вам также может понравиться