Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
GNOBEDD
May 2010
2 Working Paper 1 Table of Contents May 2010
Table of Contents
Section: 01 02 03
Project & Task I Overview Stakeholder Interviews Public Participation
Program
07 12
History of GNOBEDD Key Themes / Issues / 26
Opportunities Early Image-Building
07 Efforts for GNOBEDD
The GNOBEDD
Biosciences District 28
Media Outreach Program
07
The Vision 31
Message Development
07 Plan
The Planning Team
32
07 Advisory Group
The Planning Effort Establishment
08 35
Task I Overview Focus Groups
08 36
Kick-Off Meetings Public Outreach
Activities During the
Planning Process
3
04
Appendices
A
List of Completed
Stakeholder Interviews
B
Stakeholder Interview
Sign-in Sheets
C
GNOBEDD Presentation
to City-wide Stakeholders
D Acknowledgement
Media Outreach
The AECOM Team would like to acknowledge the
E
GNOBEDD Board and staff as well as the stakeholders
Complete Stakeholder
List To-Date that were interviewed during this task for their input
and engagement. This report has also been developed
F in coordination with the entire AECOM Team. The team
Focus Group includes: EDAW I AECOM, AECOM Economics, AECOM
Organization Transportation, Bright Moments, Canon Design, CBRE,
Chester Engineers, and The Ehrhardt Group.
4 Working Paper 1 Project & Task I Overview May 2010
Section 01:
Project & Task I
Overview
5
6 Working Paper 1 Project & Task I Overview May 2010
Biosciences District that identifies a realistic and The morning board meeting was followed by a meeting
achievable framework for economic development within with the management of GNOBEDD and key members
the District. The Biosciences District Plan will identify of the consultant team to review administrative and
and analyze sustainable public realm improvements such communication issues, and informally discuss the
as vehicle, pedestrian, and infrastructure connectivity; project’s planning process, goals, and objectives. A
increasing affordable and market-rate rental and home large focus of the discussion was on conducting and
ownership opportunities; streetscape design; green documenting the stakeholder interviews, including the
space and community space; retail and commercial uses; use of an official sign-in sheet, meeting note template,
and creative ideas to enhance the Biosciences District brochure, and questionnaire. Details on the stakeholder
for future biosciences industry creation and economic interviews can be found in the stakeholder engagement
development. section.
The Greater New Orleans Biosciences Economic Development District. The Louisiana Superdome, New Orleans Arena, and key existing and
proposed institutional developments are shown in blue.
10 Working Paper 1 Stakeholder Interviews May 2010
Section 02:
Stakeholder
Interviews
11
12 Working Paper 1 Stakeholder Interviews May 2010
Stakeholder Interviews
As part of Task I, the consultant team, aided by effort and the potential economic revitalization that
GNOBEDD staff, developed a list of stakeholders to be the biosciences industry can have for the City. Many
interviewed as part of the initial public outreach process stakeholders were also appreciative that GNOBEDD
for development of the Biosciences District Plan. During recognized the importance of their input into this initial
the three weeks of March 15, March 22, and April 12, phase of the planning process. .
the AECOM Team coordinated and conducted over 75
separate meetings with over 160 individual stakeholders. Overall, the Biosciences District is seen as a critical
(See Appendix A for the list of stakeholders interviewed element in this post-Katrina transition period for the
and Appendix B for the associated sign-in sheets.) City, region, and state. The Biosciences District is the
potential catalyst to create higher-paying jobs, housing,
The purpose of these one-on-one and multi-constituent new business and institutional initiatives, spin off to the
interviews was twofold. First, it was for stakeholders economy, linkage and a competitive advantage to the
to meet the planning team and understand the vision community’s convention business in medical programs,
and mission of GNOBEDD. Second, it was for the and improved access to medical care, among other
team to gain an understanding of the various issues, key potential outcomes. Most stakeholders believe
activities, functions, and future plans within the area the Biosciences District offers the potential to leverage
that must be addressed by the Biosciences District Plan, existing neighborhood assets, maximize medical-related
and to identify broad goals and objectives for its future growth opportunities, and provide quality-of-life features
development. In short, the interviews were important that the “Creative Class” and technical community
opportunities for the planning team to listen to and desire.1
learn from stakeholders, while also establishing the
importance of open communication and engagement Key Themes / Issues / Opportunities
during the planning process
Over the course of the interviews, several recurring
Stakeholder groups included community / neighborhood issues, opportunities, and needs were identified that
associations; education, medical and faith-based must be addressed to ensure that GNOBEDD is a
institutions; relevant city, regional, state, and federal success. These include:
agencies; business / commercial entities; industry 1. “Creating a Place” - Developing creative
leaders; and workforce development and job training concepts and ideas for the plan and its
agencies. While many stakeholders on the initial outreach implementation that define the Biosciences
list were interviewed during this task, the team has District as a distinct place reflecting the unique
established a Public Participation Program that will guide character and quality of New Orleans;
stakeholder engagement throughout the duration of the
2. “Public and Civic Leadership” - Using public-
planning effort.
private partnerships with strong business
The stakeholder interview process elicited a generally 1 The “Creative Class” has been identified by the Downtown
Development District of New Orleans as a key group of constituents
positive response, with those engaged feeling very that are important to attract to help foster the economic development
optimistic about the Biosciences District planning of the city. See Downtown Development District of New Orleans
Report: Creative Class Market Research. dated February 15, 2010.
13
leadership that align with the new administration’s District. Community leaders must be engaged
strategic goals; in disseminating the positive message of the
3. “Acting as One” - Funding and incentives for Biosciences District and its potential benefits to
GNOBEDD’s continuing operations, as well as for the community, which will build support among
business attraction and community revitalization; stakeholders.
• Stakeholders are interested in how to provide Biosciences District for appropriations and funding
input into the Biosciences District Plan. This support.
process must clearly define the difference • Several stakeholders expressed the urgency of
between decision making providing input and developing proposals for GNOBEDD to utilize
how stakeholder input can shape and inform the one-time Community Development Block Grants
outcome. (CDBG) funds.
• General desires expressed by the stakeholders • There is a need to establish a Community
for incorporation into the Biosciences District Plan Benefits Agreement that would outline how the
include: improved transit connections; improved surrounding community would benefit from the
streetscape; pedestrian /bike-friendly design; Biosciences District. The agreement would include
public art; sustainable design; open space; retail, the provision of key elements such as affordable
such as a grocery store; historic preservation; housing, employment and economic development,
“branding” of the Biosciences District; improved and job training.
safety; medical mart; reduced dependence on sky
• A need was also expressed for a state loan fund
bridges; and better retail opportunities.
to start up and expand small businesses within
GNOBEDD. The money could be disbursed
Funding
through a local Community Development Financial
• Marketing of infrastructure, urban environment, Institution (CDFI) intermediary like Citizens United
bioscience centers of excellence, and unique for Economic Equity.
quality of life is critical to optimize the range of
• Overall, stakeholders are interested in relevant
funding options for which GNOBEDD is eligible.
benchmarking studies that show how bioscience
• A significant investment is being made in the districts are funded for both development and
Biosciences District for the new VA and UMC operations, in addition to how they will benefit
hospitals; expansion of university facilities local communities.
at Xavier, LSU and Tulane; state-of-the-art jail
complex; and a cutting-edge New Orleans Processes & Procedures
BioInnovation Center, among others. These
• There are numerous government agencies,
investments in facilities, jobs and education
institutions, and community groups that have
opportunities need to be extensively leveraged for
the ability to impact future development of the
the greatest economic development benefit.
District, each with its own sets of information,
• Operational funding for these new facilities and regulations, and procedures. The removal of these
the ability to attract researchers and development information “silos” through enhanced interagency
companies will be a major challenge given the coordination and collaboration is important to the
current economy, state budget constraints, and success of the Biosciences District and the City
the lack of state-level venture capital incentives. overall.
Therefore, it is critical to consolidate and
• Permitting and site control will be challenges for
strengthen political and corporate support for the
15
• The workforce supply for the Biosciences District and state have the opportunity to establish an
will be enhanced significantly by Delgado’s outstanding program.
presence in the District, especially in the fields of • Currently, it appears that most of Tulane and LSU
nursing and related training. faculty are academically oriented, focused on
• Messaging needs to be developed related to medical training rather than translational research,
workforce development opportunities that already which is not as common. The need is to create an
exist and those that can be created as a result environment that fosters and facilitates both.
of GNOBEDD, as well as training programs that • The combined talent, expertise, and resources
need to be established to support the biosciences of the VA, LSU and Tulane have the potential to
industry create multiple centers of excellence by limiting
their redundancy and building upon their excellent
Biosciences Industry scientific research to create a strong economic
• The significant areas of medical research existing cluster. Such a collaboration is the hope of
within the Biosciences District include: vaccines, numerous stakeholders that were interviewed.
neuroscience, sports medicine, and clinical trials. • Through the cooperation of the academic
Tulane’s Primate Center, located outside the institutions within the Biosciences District, new
GNOBEDD area, is also a significant resource for synergies can be realized with the VA and UMC
the development of a biosciences industry in New in neuroscience, orthopedic, cardiovascular, and
Orleans where primary research is conducted in transplants.
the fields of tropical and infectious diseases.
• With the presence of major professional sports
• There are significant research opportunities teams, such as the New Orleans Saints, there
existing within the Biosciences District. As an are excellent opportunities in sports medicine as
example, LSU’s Hyperbaric Oxygen Therapy can well as potential synergies in the neuroscience,
be used for groundbreaking new treatments in orthopedic, infectious diseases, tropical medicine,
diabetes, autism, heart disease, birth injuries, and integrated medicine fields.
brain injuries, dementia, and infectious diseases,
• Expanding mental health research, development,
among others.
and patient services came up during several
• There is a strong opportunity for the establishment interviews. Many stakeholders suggested this be
of a successful Translational Medicine program one of the cornerstone centers of excellence that
if the institutions work together on clinical trials, GNOBEDD focus on. Given the effects of Katrina
electronic records, and a central database system. and the potential use of the VA Hospital to study
There is an opportunity for Louisiana Economic Post Trauma Stress Disorder (PTSD), the field is a
Development to lead an incentive program to potentially unique specialty that may not be found
get everyone to participate in such efforts. With in other research centers, and there may be a
the Primate Center, Tulane’s clinical research, significantly higher need here for mental health
LSU’s research and clinical base, the city, region services than in other cities.
17
Transportation
Short term:
• Existing and proposed university shuttle services
between institutions and major employment
centers need to be coordinated. This could
be contracted jointly to RTA, as most current
operators have approached RTA.
• Tulane Avenue is considered a major transit
corridor and has recently seen significant
investment in residential development. However,
the street needs major improvements such as
an improved neutral ground, narrow traffic lanes,
A stakeholder identifying key issues within the District. mid-size retail development, bike lanes, increased
parks and green space, and overall increased
• Benchmarking and evaluating the potential for
pedestrian connectivity to serve the core of the
economic development opportunities beyond
Biosciences District. The Tulane Avenue Study,
those in the health sciences industry that may
currently being undertaken by the Regional
result from development of the Biosciences
Planning Commission, is meant to address this
District, including housing, retail, office, hotel,
and calls for:
and other industries, must be done as part of this
planning effort. a. Immediate-term coordination of landscape
and streetscape design to avoid delay of work by
• Providence Community Housing, as well as other
LSU, VA, and the Cancer Center and to contribute
new or planned residential communities in and
to the identity of the Biosciences District; and
around the Biosciences District, can be a valuable
resource in addressing affordable and market-rate b. Immediate coordination of underground utility
housing needs that will be created by the growth needs in the Biosciences District to avoid utility
of the Biosciences District. This may be particularly upgrade following resurfacing of the roadway.
important relative to workforce housing. Interim c. Other issues include (1) the lack of
housing needs must also be addressed through construction funding; (2) sustainability concerns
the planning process. (solar lighting, sidewalk materials, etc.); and (3)
19
the need for at least the portion between S. Avenue, which address the changes in land use
Rocheblave and S. Claiborne completed before that are under construction or planned relative
2014 to provide access to hospitals from the to the new hospitals, the bioscience industry,
west. the criminal justice system, and associated
improvements.
• There is some question on the status of a new
lane from the westbound I-10 Cleveland exit into • The majority of the adjacent uses include portions
the LSU site. Tulane University Hospital and its School of
Medicine, as well as buildings controlled by the
2014 and beyond: State of Louisiana that are currently being studied
relative to their potential future use because they
• There is recognition that travel between the either are vacant or are planned to be vacated
institutions, especially between Tulane, LSU, and within 5 years.
VA will become more time consuming due to the
greater distances. Xavier University expressed • A key issue to be examined are the potential
specific concerns about access to the two hospital future land uses in this area and their resulting
developments and the Xavier campus at the roadway capacity requirements.
western end of the District. The expanded and • As a city street, the Department of Public Works
coordinated existing shuttle system may respond (DPW) must find the funding to study and make
to this problem, at least in part, but it must be determinations of the future design and to
better defined for routes and headways, and fund the improvements that result. It needs to
given greater attention to maintenance. Xavier determined how GNOBEDD can appropriately
recommends exploration of a rapid-transit system assist DPW in these efforts, and how can the
as a possible solution. Department of Parks and Parkways (DPP) also be
• There will be significant additional employment included.
in the Biosciences District based on the existing • DPW and DPP, as the responsible city agencies,
plans alone. This needs to be collected into a should try to include this segment into the design
single dataset. To accomplish this, the team is and construction of the remainder of the street.
coordinating with GCR, the local, independent The funding for the current study is restricted to
economic consultant hired to establish an the US highways, but future funding for future
economic baseline for the Biosciences District. phases may not be restricted in this manner
although informally it appears that the restriction
Tulane Avenue between Loyola Avenue and S. Claiborne does apply to design.
Avenue (I-10 East): • Stakeholders, in addition to Tulane University,
• This segment of Tulane Avenue is not a segment GNOBEDD, and the Downtown Development
of US 61 or US 90. As a result, it is not included District (DDD), need to be identified, which share
in the ongoing process to select, design, and jurisdiction as a development entity over this
construct a revised street cross-section for Tulane segment with GNOBEDD.
Avenue from S. Claiborne Avenue to S. Carrollton
20 Working Paper 1 Stakeholder Interviews May 2010
• As so much of the adjacent real estate will demands principally in the following areas: water,
change ownership in the relatively near future, the wastewater, power, and telecommunications.
definition of the appropriate agency to work with
DPW and Tulane University is a major issue. This Storm Water
may be the most important issue to resolve in the • Storm water is the only utility sector not expected
short term relative to this segment. to see an increase in demand, but must be
carefully reviewed in light of any revisions in storm
Utilities water design requisites or constraints.
• The biggest challenge related to utilities is that • There is sufficient capacity in the City’s
the Biosciences District is almost completely underground main conveyance canal systems,
developed and its utility infrastructure was but many of the feeder drain lines leading from
primarily designed to serve residential customers the catch basins to the canals are undersized
and long-established commercial clients. Now and not regularly cleaned or maintained. The
with its changing needs, the Biosciences District necessary capacity of these feeder lines needs to
must find a way to accommodate the demands of be investigated and sufficient upgrades should be
its intended growth and development. factored into future planning.
• The problem with retrofitting such a developed • The Sewerage & Water Board (SWB) maintains
area is the increased costs associated with all drain lines 36” and greater. The Department
the selective demolition needed to install new of Public Works (DPW) is responsible for
facilities. This must be done while trying to maintenance of lines smaller than 36”, as well as
minimize the disruption caused by construction. all catch basins.
• As the Biosciences District develops, we will • Some flooding could be reduced if the catch
see its utility requirements shift from primarily basins were properly maintained, but DPW’s
residential to a diverse mixture of commercial, resources for this kind of work are vastly
residential, and industrial uses. overextended.
Energy
• Energy, in the form of electricity and natural
gas, appears to be sufficiently adequate in the
Biosciences District and is provided by Entergy.
Entergy can meet all of the hospitals’ reliability
concerns, and there seem to be few issues from
other consumers in the area.
• Chilled water and steam heat are available in a
limited area of the District and are currently very
expensive unless an expanded customer base can
be developed. It is unlikely that many consumers,
apart from the hospitals, will take advantage of
this option.
• Of particular concern for the electric provider
is any unique, specialized, or high demand
application (mainly industrial needs) that must
be accommodated at service levels above what
has typically been required in the Biosciences
District. With the exception of the potential for
centralized plants, the potential development(s)
23
24 Working Paper 1 Public Participation Program May 2010
Section 03:
Public Participation
Program
25
26 Working Paper 1 Public Participation Program May 2010
Key Messages (below is an excerpt of a Times Picayune • This bold initiative is designed to be the first major
guest opinion column by James McNamara). development in the country that will have a zero-
carbon footprint based on sustainable design,
The key messages below were used in 2008 and construction and operation. A related objective is to
2009 and serve as a foundation for developing key drive the commercialization and adoption of these
communication points for 2010 and the completion of the technologies in sustainable energy, carbon
Biosciences District Plan. management, water utilization, and carbon
• GNOBEDD was created in 2005 and is poised to finance. Our goal is the establishment of an
complement the VA and UMC hospitals and the entirely new economic sector of two knowledge-
academic and research missions of LSU, Tulane, based industries in New Orleans.
Xavier, and Delgado. • PowerPoint Presentation: (See Appendix C in
• The Biosciences District will be mastered planned Section 4 of this document.)
as the hub of world-class academic training,
research, and development in state-of-the-art Special Events:
medical technologies/devices and exemplary
healthcare delivery for everyone, regardless of BioInnovation Center Groundbreaking – August 2008
social or economic status. These primary and The groundbreaking for the BioInnovation Center brought
support activities will be the catalyst required to together civic and business leadership, along with the
bring needed jobs and serve as a foundation for local health care leadership, for a ceremony announcing
many displaced New Orleans residents to return the beginning of construction for a center unlike any New
home. Once realized, GNOBEDD will establish Orleans had ever seen. It received significant coverage
New Orleans as a medical center of excellence, from local media, benefitting GNOBEDD.
second to none.
BIO Conference – May 2009
• The investment of $4-$5 billion in infrastructure
GNOBEDD led a delegation of Louisiana officials to
improvements, building construction, equipment
Atlanta to participate in the BIO Conference 2009.
purchases, and technology will create a medical
The goals were to raise awareness of the region’s
complex focused on specialty care, research, and
participation in developing a thriving biosciences
technology that rivals leading institutions across
industry, and to help promote New Orleans to
the United States.
potential entrepreneurs, researchers, and biomedical
• This nationally competitive high-tech industry professionals. GNOBEDD President and CEO, James
will create a minimum of 18,000 permanent, McNamara, participated in a media outreach to local,
well-paying jobs that will require education and regional, and national outlets to promote New Orleans’
training provided by our local universities and other participation in this conference. In addition, the
teaching institutions. GNOBEDD team held a high-profile networking event
for young New Orleans expatriates who were now living
in Atlanta and who might be lured back to participate in
development of the Biosciences District.
28 Working Paper 1 Public Participation Program May 2010
Speed Networking – June 2009 Biosciences District in a manner that is supported by the
GNOBEDD and partners also encouraged young community as a whole while enticing the recruitment
entrepreneurs who reside in the New Orleans region and retention necessary for its success. It is apparent
to attend and participate in a speed networking event from the data-gathering element of Task 1 interviews
designed to help professionals who have a stake in with local community and business leaders that there
the development of the Biosciences District make is vague awareness of the Biosciences District, its
meaningful contacts. boundaries, its history, its accomplishments and its
potential. Moving forward, the Public Participation Plan
BioSciences Conference – October 2009 will help establish GNOBEDD’s identity as the leader and
The President and CEO of BIO International, James convener for bioscience opportunities in New Orleans
Greenwood, was the featured guest and speaker at and as a vehicle for the creation of a district that is
New Orleans’ BioSciences Conference in October, vibrant and essential to the City’s future growth.
2009. GNOBEDD, along with the Horizon Initiative
and other partners, sponsored the event and attracted This Public Participation Program will guide GNOBEDD’s
several hundred civic, business, and health leaders to stewardship of the public information for the biosciences
the luncheon conference. As a postscript to his speech, in Greater New Orleans by building on its identity as
Greenwood penned a letter to the Times-Picayune that the leader of institutional advancement in this arena.
applauded the City, GNOBEDD, and other leaders for It should also continue to offer innovative solutions to
working to position the region as an emerging player in questions about the biosciences raised in the media,
the biosciences industry. grassroots organizations, and within the business
community. Strategically, this Public Participation
Public Appearances by GNOBEDD President Program shall position GNOBEDD to advance a credible
James McNamara and accountable message for the Biosciences District’s
GNOBEDD President and CEO, James McNamara, development through news articles, interviews, panels,
will continue to be the primary spokesperson for the speeches, and at the forefront of event sponsorship for
growing biosciences industry in Greater New Orleans. the biosciences industry.
Since 2008, Mr. McNamara has given presentations and
speeches and made appearances on local media (radio/ Media Outreach Program
TV) to explain the significance of the industry, how it fits
into the economic development infrastructure, and how it The media outreach program will continue to be marked
will use the combined hospitals and healthcare industry. by milestone announcements, as it has since 2008,
regarding the Biosciences District and its components.
Targeting the Biosciences Economic Development For example, in August 2008, the District used the
Industry and Community Support through Proactive groundbreaking of the BioInnovation Center on Canal
Management and Outreach Street to invite key civic and community leaders to learn
more about GNOBEDD and its activities. GNOBEDD’s
The initial stakeholder interviews indicate that increasing
leadership also took advantage of public meetings and
awareness and building image for GNOBEDD remains
hearings about the proposed VA and UMC hospitals
a critical task for the successful development of the
29
to position itself with the public and media outlets. and economic development leaders to the 2009 BIO
The District took advantage of announcements and International Convention (BIO 2009) in Atlanta from May
groundbreaking activities for the Cancer Consortium 18 to May 21 as part of an effort to lay the groundwork
to call attention to the wide-ranging capabilities of a for the expected “boom” in the New Orleans
biosciences district in the midst of a post-Katrina New biotechnology industry.
Orleans. The media outreach program will focus on mass
media as well as targeted niche/trade and social media to Impact: News announcements in advance of and
deliver strategic messages. during this Atlanta convention were channeled back
to New Orleans to demonstrate outreach activities of
Media Research Baseline GNOBEDD and helped to build economic development
identity for the District.
The Public Participation Program will address baseline
research through analysis of previous news coverage, “Yes! to Business” Biotech Luncheon in New Orleans
conducting focus groups with stakeholders, and Objective: Use New Orleans as a setting for an
incorporating a strategic visioning session for GNOBEDD innovative title sponsorship event branded to
members to refine the perceived direction of the GNOBEDD.
planning effort and align the outreach efforts with realistic
expectations. It will also include content analysis of ACG Louisiana, the Horizon Initiative, and New Orleans
GNOBEDD news coverage and results to evaluate past CityBusiness, in association with GNOBEDD and the
and current media perceptions of the organization and its New Orleans BioInnovation Center, present “YES!
mission. (See Appendix D in Section 4 of this document to Business” Biotech. This is the next in the series
for a detailed breakdown of the results of media of industry-specific economic development luncheon
coverage since 2008 for GNOBEDD.) forums, and will focus on the opportunities for business
expansion, retention, and attraction brought on by the
Content Analysis biotech industry in New Orleans and the region. The
The following represent a sample of media coverage “YES! to Business” forum franchise was conceived of as
since 2008 that resulted in significant advancement of a way to increase awareness and open a dialogue within
GNOBEDD, either within the public arena of perception the business community that will result in keeping key
or in affecting policy for the execution of the District. industry sectors strong and in New Orleans.
Each example has a stated objective and impact resulting
from the media activity. Impact: News coverage and attendance at this event
helped brand GNOBEDD as New Orleans’ newest
Bio Boom Program in Atlanta and perhaps most innovative approach to economic
Objective: Use existing professional meetings to development.
promote GNOBEDD.
Groundbreaking for LA Cancer Research Consortium for this project alone over the past three years, and my
(LCRC) in New Orleans voice today is only one that will be added to the nearly
Objective: Use GNOBEDD leadership for third-party 400 residents of the city who have contributed to the
validation of activities, groundbreakings, etc., within dialogue.
the District.
Impact: More than 20 public meetings/hearings have
GNOBEDD president, James P. McNamara, said that been held to examine various issues connected to
the ground-breaking for the Louisiana Cancer Research the construction of the VA facility. GNOBEDD has
Consortium (LCRC) facility is the first of many positive been a leading voice in support of this hospital to
steps to signify the importance of the emerging satisfy post-Katrina health care needs and ignite a
biosciences industry in New Orleans.“ The New Orleans bioscience-based economic development era in the
community continues to recognize the health care and city.
economic benefits of this industry that is vital to our
development in critical life-saving and life-prolonging Master Plan Study
areas,” McNamara said. LCRC in New Orleans will be Objective: Gain media and public attention to the
a shared 150,000-square-foot facility with state-of-the- study and prepare stakeholders for the first phase of
art cancer research equipment. LSU’s Health Sciences engagement.
Center of New Orleans and Tulane University’s Health
Sciences Center will work together to develop cancer GNOBEDD announced the kickoff of a master plan study that
research, education and treatment programs for the will become a road map for the further development of New
region that supporters believe will be internationally Orleans’ Biosciences District.
recognized for excellence.
Impact: Stakeholders were prepared for
Impact: Jim McNamara’s observations were quoted appointments based on advanced knowledge of the
in support of the LCRC construction in local media study and its purposes.
coverage of the event.
The Biosciences District in New Orleans
Support for VA Hospital Construction in New Orleans Objective: Use steady and continuous news media
Objective: Position the construction of the VA Hospital relations to lay the groundwork for branding
as a healthcare solution and economic driver in the GNOBEDD as the leading biosciences advocate in the
development of the District. region.
The Greater New Orleans Biosciences Economic The investment of $4-$5 billion in infrastructure
Development District has supported the construction improvements, building construction, equipment
of a state-of-the-art healthcare facility that will serve purchases, and technology – numbers that are staggering
70,000 veterans of all wars for our nation. This project is in both their size and potential to enhance our quality of
one of the most studied and discussed developments life -- will create a medical complex focused on specialty
in the history of our city. In fact, this forum is the 17th care, research, and technology that rivals leading
31
institutions across the United States. This nationally Ground-breaking of BioInnovation Center in New
competitive high-tech industry will create a minimum Orleans
of 18,000 permanent, well-paying jobs that will require Objective: Use GNOBEDD leadership for third-party
education and training provided by our local universities validation of activities, groundbreakings, etc., within
and other teaching institutions. the District.
GNOBEDD was created in 2005 and is poised to New Orleans BioInnovation Center Director, Aaron
complement these two hospitals and the academic Miscenich, recognized the State of Louisiana’s
mission of LSU, Tulane, Xavier, and Delgado. The District Department of Economic Development for support of the
will be mastered planned as the hub of world-class life sciences. He also recognized the U.S. Department
academic training, research, and development in state- of Commerce. He stressed the mission of helping to
of-the-art medical technologies/devices and top-notch create a bioscience industry in New Orleans. The city has
healthcare delivery for everyone, regardless of social or not been able to make the most of research, and New
economic status. These primary and support activities Orleans BioInnovation Center wants to help explore the
will be the catalyst required to bring needed jobs and commercial value of its research to the benefit of the
serve as a foundation for New Orleans’s fellow residents City, state, and universities.
to return home. It will re-establish New Orleans as a
medical center of excellence second to none. Impact: Jim McNamara’s observations were quoted
in support of the BioInnovation Center construction in
This is a bold initiative, designed to be the first local media coverage of the event.
major development in the country that will have a
zero-carbon footprint based on sustainable design, Message Development Plan
construction, and operation. A related objective is to
drive the commercialization and adoption of these Key Messages to be developed for the Biosciences
technologies in sustainable energy, carbon management, District Plan Study to affirm the basis for New
water utilization, and carbon finance. Our goal is the Orleans’ competitive position
establishment of an entirely new economic sector of 1. The Biosciences District’s mission is to facilitate
these two knowledge-based industries in New Orleans. the creation of high paying jobs in the region
If so, we can reverse the pre-storm brain drain with an by increasing the healthcare and biosciences
infusion of new and returning professionals to the region. infrastructure and related workforce. This study
will identify the most efficient ways to bring
Impact: GNOBEDD has used its news media contacts these resources to fruition, where they create
to become one of the commentators on economic competitive advantages for the city’s investment
development activities in the region while promoting in the biosciences industry.
its own goals and strategies.
2. Since this plan shall lead to the development
of a world-class biosciences industry, the
recommendations and input of local leaders
and constituents will help us produce tangible
32 Working Paper 1 Public Participation Program May 2010
and attainable results for the benefit of New globally competitive economy for the New Orleans
Orleanians. region to diversify our opportunities and build a
3. The biosciences industry is growing steadily in community through innovation that contains the
Louisiana. The state earns more than $160 million healthiest, safest, smartest, and most sustainable
in annual funding from the National Institutes neighborhoods in America by:
of Health, with 70% of this funding for areas 1. Providing the finest 21st Century healthcare
including infectious diseases, peptide research 2. Teaching a new generation of medical
and gene therapy, derived from institutions in the professionals cutting-edge techniques
Greater New Orleans area.
3. Performing globally competitive biomedical and
clinical research in the health and bioscience
Overall Key Messages for the District on its Physical,
workforce
Demographic, and Administrative Structure
4. Growing and attracting research institutions and
1. GNOBEDD is a 1,500-acre area spanning the
life science companies
downtown and mid-city sections of New Orleans.
It is composed of the area bounded by Earhart 5. Expanding employment opportunities at all levels
Boulevard, Carrollton Avenue, Loyola Avenue, 6. Recommending projects, programs, and policies
and Iberville Street, and is focused on the that help the citizens of New Orleans achieve a
development of a life-science industry that will vibrant urban community as a successful outcome
provide world-class biosciences research; local, of this project.
regional and global healthcare delivery; and stable,
high-paying jobs for professionals, managers, and Advisory Group Establishment
workers representing a wide range of skills.
2. The District is governed by a board of The Public Participation Program will target business and
commissioners consisting of 13 members, commercial stakeholders, neighborhood and community
including representatives from LSU, Tulane groups, and institutional interests (universities, state
University Health Sciences Center, Xavier and federal agencies). (See Appendix E in Section 4 of
University, Delgado Community College, the Mayor this document.) The program will also focus on creating
of New Orleans, Greater New Orleans, Inc., New and directing an independent grassroots movement to
Orleans Chamber of Commerce, New Orleans support the Biosciences District Plan.
Business Council, and the Louisiana Department
of Economic Development. The Governor of Concept for engaging independent grassroots
Louisiana also appoints four members to the board. movements to support the GNOBEDD Biosciences
GNOBEDD was created by Act 487 of the 2005 District Plan: targeting Community, Commercial/
Regular Session of the Louisiana State Legislature. Economic Development, and Government/
Institutional interests
The Vision for the District
The Vision of the GNOBEDD District is to: “Build a The first step in building a credible grassroots movement
33
with community and institutional participation to support Members of the Community Subcommittee should
the development of the Biosciences District is to create include:
a series of advisory boards for the GNOBEDD planning • Mid-City Neighborhood Organization
effort.
• Broad Community Connections
One of the most significant insights from the initial • Providence Community Housing
rounds of stakeholder interviews was the fragmentation • New City Group
of information among stakeholders. The Public
• Gert Town Enterprise Economic Development (and
Participation Program shall break through information
other Gert Town groups)
silos in order to move forward with a coherent vision
for GNOBEDD. An important first step would be the • Preservation Resource Center
formation of an advisory board, with a series of sub- • Waggonner & Ball
groups organized around common interests, to advise
• Urban League
the planning team on developing the comprehensive
Biosciences District Plan. • Lower Mid-City Neighborhood Association
• Louisiana Justice Institute
The formation of sub-groups is recommended along
• Family Service of Greater New Orleans
common interests as a natural outgrowth of the
stakeholder interviews and workshops. Our stakeholders
Institutional / Government
largely fall into one of four categories: Community,
The Institutional / Government sub-group will focus
Commercial, Institutional, and Health Sciences.
on helping the AECOM Team to articulate workforce
development opportunities, transit and streetscape
A proposed structure and advisory sub-group
improvement opportunities, utility needs, and economic
composition are listed below:
development opportunities. They will work closely
with the GNOBEDD Board that is currently engaged in
Community
building career paths and jobs inventory for the District. If
The Community subcommittee will focus on residential
warranted, smaller working groups focused on education/
opportunities, concerns, and challenges with a focus on
workforce development, utilities/transportation and
housing, jobs, and sustainability within and surrounding
governance may be formed within this subcommittee.
the District. They will serve as a sounding board in
framing healthcare service needs of the population
Members of the Institutional / Government
and how those can be served by institutions within the
Subcommittee should include:
District. They will also work closely with the Commercial
/ Economic Development subcommittee to help identify • The City of New Orleans (Chief Administrative
workforce development needs among residents. This Office)
group will head the formation of a Public Benefits • The State Facilities Planning Administration
Corporation that will develop a Community Benefits
• Regional Transit Authority
Agreement.
34 Working Paper 1 Public Participation Program May 2010
2. Identify silos of information. Describe key sources gain continuous feedback about the image of the
of information, data, funding, and propaganda. District.
Identify where there are possible synergies for
breaking and exposing these silos of information Public Outreach Activities During the
to create better access to information and data, Planning Process
increased and coordinated pools of funding,
and a controlled and more honest message of The following series of tasks identify key public outreach
propaganda about the District. milestones across the phases of the project allocated by
3. Create opportunities to leverage collaboration tasks. In most cases, regular contact with the media will
among stakeholders. Offer roles for community, occur throughout all tasks although much of the public
institutional, and business leaders to participate outreach program will depend on specific media content
in shaping the vision of the District with their to invite public attendance at milestone workshops,
constituencies. Meet with elected officials presentations, hearings, and reviews.
who have the ability to mandate institutional
collaborations where it is necessary. Outreach will also include periodic reviews with officials
who have jurisdiction and enforcement responsibilities
Phase 2: Develop a common message for development and land-use regulations within
GNOBEDD. The public outreach program shall coordinate
1. Meet with the GNOBEDD Board of these contacts to optimize the timely review of and
Commissioners and relay stakeholder interview response to submittals by the team.
themes. Enable the board to understand both the
positive and negative feedback from interviews PHASE I
and focus groups and the potential consequences
Task 1: Project Initiation
for both addressing and neglecting them. Provide
a forum for the board to respond to this feedback • Stakeholder Interviews
internally and gather a commitment from them to • Public Participation Program Preparation
play a role in addressing these issues with their
institutional power. Task 2: Data Gathering
2. Develop a coordinated set of principles and • Focus Groups
policies and a unified message with the
• Workshop Preparation
GNOBEDD Board of Commissioners. Task the
board with developing the political relationships • Advisory Group Convened
necessary to create a District that addresses the
internally agreed up on vision. Task 3: Analysis
3. Distribute the common message in public spaces • Baseline Media Review and Content Analysis for
beginning with an interactive GNOBEDD website Messaging
that captures feedback. Activate grassroots • Meeting with Advisory Groups
networks to distribute the common message and
37
Task 6: Alternative Plan Exploration Task 11: GNOBEDD Plan Draft Report
• Arrange venues and attendance accommodations • Media releases focusing on upcoming public
for charrettes for concept exploration announcements and presentations
• Media Releases focusing on charrette preparation
and outcomes Task 12: GNOBEDD Plan Review
• Advisory Group Meeting
Task 7: Alternative Plan Assessments • Arrange outreach to appropriate agencies and
• Advisory Group Meeting offices for technical reviews of plan
• Arrange outreach to appropriate agencies and • Two workshops to be held across study area
offices for preliminary reviews of alternative plans • Workshops to be organized along blended affinity
groups to assess community input in “real time”
Task 8: Preferred Concept in an open setting
• Workshops to be held across study area
• Workshops to be organized along affinity Task 13: GNOBEDD Plan
groups: Community, Government/Institutional, • Media releases focusing on public presentations
Commercial/Economic Development, Health and hearings
Sciences (may change based on the plan
recommendations and better response by Task 14: Presentations
blending affinities into single sessions) • Media releases focusing on public presentations
• Advisory Group Meeting and hearings
38 Working Paper 1 Appendices May 2010
Section 04:
Appendices
39
Appendix A:
Completed Stakeholder
Interviews to Date
# %$)%" *
#%$)%" **!%"( $*(,
*!%"( $*(, -4
* $
$'+)*))%
.809787
'+)*) ) %
. 8 9787
(" # $(.
*
$(.
* $
$
$*(, -%*%#&"* ($ /* %$%( $ , +" %$**()%$
*
0 0 3
0 03
'-9
',,-#(.>6
# . > :48<49787
()$** %$2;48@487
4 4 ,9(=')/,,9 ),-)/,0960#,(#09
6 --.",&)..0- :48<49787
4 4
()$** %$2
%$2;48@487
;48@487 , ,)& -*, ( &&# &." #0 &!)
,9,)&-*,(6&&#&."#096&!) --.
&,
)),
--.
&,
)), :48<49787
%#&"*1:49;487
4 4 ,,39)&&#,
99"(&&),6
&& " && --..,##
! :48<49787
4 4
()$** %$2
%$2;48@487
;48@487
, (,3 3-
,9(,393- :48<49787
()$**
* * %$2;48@487
;48@487
, & ,)1( ,-#(. ),./( 0&)*'(.
,9&,)1(,-#(.6),./(0&)*'(. :48<49787
()$** %$2
%$2;48@487
;48@487 , 3( #&3 ,-#(. >
",,3
#& )&&!
,93(#&3,-#(.>6
",,3
#&)&&! :48<49787
()$** %$2;48@487
;48@487 . # % # &
,9.,#%/#(&(6"-(,&."3-.'
" &." .
--.()/.
. . :48<49787
% $$%,*
* %$
%#&"*1:48>487
4 4 ,)(
#-(#"6#)#(()0.#)((.,2#,
" ,)(
#-(#"
" :48<49787
4 4
%$""
%#&"*1:48=487 !#)(&&((#(!)''#--#)(;<
%#&"* !#)(&,(-#./."),#.3;<
! 3
/-.#(/!/-.#(
! :48?49787
%#&"*2
" *
6 (9
#"&".6,-#(.>
# " & ". # . > :48=49787
/-.#(
,%6"#
6 ) . :48=49787
4 4
**.%-("$)
"
%#&"* :499487
%#&"*:499487 #.3 ) 1,&(-
#.3) 1 ,&(- ,( . #&
,(. :48?49787
#.3)/(#&;&&<
& ; &&<
+/&#( ,".& &,%-)(
+/&#(,".&&,%-)( :48=49787
# %$)%" *
#%$)%" **!%"( $*(,
*!%"( $*(, -4
* $
$'+)*))%
.809787
'+)*) ) %
. 8 9787
(" # $(.
*
$(.
* $
$
$*(, -%*%#&"* ($ /* %$%( $ , +" %$**()%$
*
,(# #&%)1
,(##&%)1 :48=49787
.3 :48=49787
,#-.#( &',
,#-.#(&', :48=49787
/-( /#,3
/-(/#,3 :48=49787
)"(
)"(-)( :48=49787
%#&"*1:48>487
" :48>487 #. &
#.3&((#(!)''#--#)(
# # #
)&(),#!/4629#,9
! 6 :48>49787
4 4
%#&"* :499487
%#&"*:499487 #, *.
99#,*.9 ",&- ,(.
",&-,(. :49949787
%#&"* ;48:487
%#&"*;48:487 ,%- ( ,%13-
,%-(,%13- ((
)(&: --.8 (,
((
)(&:--.8(, :48?49787
.3
99 .3(,'#..#(!
( ,'#..#(! #(-.)( #
#(-.)(# :49949787
#
99)/-#(!()(
),'(..
0##&'),
# #& :49949787
))3&(3
3 3 0##2)( :48>49787
4 4
%#&"* ;48<487
%#&"*;48<487 !!)((, ( &&
!!)((,(&& 0# !!)((,
0#!!)((,
%#&"* :48?487
%#&"*:48?487 1 ,&(- 0&)*'(. /."),#.3
1,&(-0&)*'(./."),#.3
)3 #&%,-)(
)3#&%,-)( :48?49787
%#&"* :499487
%#&"*:499487 ,( ,/2
,(,/2 :49949787
%#&"*:499487
" * :499487 #
#09) #!"),")).#.#)(
# " " . #&# .#
(.")(3#(
." # :49;49787
,#.9
,.#(62#,.),:",&-
%#&"*;489487
& 4 4 1,!>.,),)
! 99 *))(,
* :49949787
4 4
%#&"* ;489487
%#&"*;489487 )1(.)1( 0&)*'(. #-.,#. ;<
)1(.)1(0&)*'(.#-.,#.;< /,. #!&
/,.#!& :49:49797
)1(.)1().,3;1,&(-).,3&/<5
; & & <5 (,3)1(.,#..,-#(.
:49:49797
4 4
( ))
%#&"*:49=487
,-)(;
< )..#.*"(-)( :49<49787
.
.9''(3;<
;< # .
,(#(,./-2/.#0#,.),
.# # . :49<49787
# %$)%" *
#%$)%" **!%"( $*(,
*!%"( $*(, -4
* $
$'+)*))%
.809787
'+)*) ) %
. 8 9787
(" # $(.
*
$(.
* $
$
$*(, -%*%#&"* ($ /* %$%( $ , +" %$**()%$
*
** % %+ ) $
**%%+
%#&"*:49:487
" * :49:487 # )&%, "#, ) ."),
0#)&%,"#,) ." ), :49949787
)#(!(2/.#0#,.),
)#(!( 2/.#0#,.),
%#&"* ;48:487
%#&"*;48:487 #0#-)( ) '#(#-.,.#)(
#0#-)() '#(#-.,.#)(
,,3
)(-
,,3
)(- :49949787
%#&"*;48:487
" * ;48:487 ##
)/#-#(
",,#- (.,#',.,3
" # . # . :49949787
%#&"*:49;487
& 4 4 )/#-#("()&)!3)/(#&
!3
,%1#- :48?49787
4 4
(.),-:*,-(..#0- ;&&<
(.),-:*,-(..#0-;&&<
*%,
#'/%,
% # % :499497
:49949787
7
..*&%,#(- :49949787
%#&"* ;48=487
%#&"*;48=487 .. * &., !,
..*9&.,!, :49949787
..*9#&,'-)( :49949787
%#&"*;48=487 (9
99
),,&& :49949787
("
99,'3),*-)
(!#(,-
#
)&&0#(
& & # :49949787
%#&"*1:48=487
4 4 )/#-#(..(#0,-#.3
## # # )(,(,
:4 497 7
:48<49787
%#&"* :49;487
%#&"*:49;487 , ,,3 )&&#,
,9,,3)&&#, :48<49787
%#&"*:49;487 ,9
)-*"
),-"", :48<49787
%#&"*2
%#&"*2 , &#-.#, '-3
,9&#-.#,'-3 :48<49787
%#&"*1 :48=487
%#&"*1:48=487 ,9 ."# )(.().
,9."#)(.(). :48<49787
& # "
,&#-"'( :48<49787
%#&"*1:48=487
& 1 4 4 #) "()&)!30&)*'(.
!3 *
'-,36#,9
36 :48<49787
4 4
%#&"*1 :48=487
%#&"*1:48=487 )/(.#)(
)/(.#)( ,. &&
,.&& :48<49787
/&((#09,-#(.=-"#
& # # = "# ) .
)(1&& :48=49787
# %$)%" *
#%$)%" **!%"( $*(,
*!%"( $*(, -4
* $
$'+)*))%
.809787
'+)*) ) %
. 8 9787
(" # $(.
*
$(.
* $
$
$*(, -%*%#&"* ($ /* %$%( $ , +" %$**()%$
*
%#&"*:49<487
& (6"))&)
##( ,9("-6(699
9 :48=49787
%
.
%
./4! :48=49787
%#&"*:49<487
& 4 4 '*/-,"#..
* )&&..,*&&
* :48=49787
4 4
0#,(#0,-#.3
"'&3 :48=49787
%#&"*1:48<487
" * :48<487 ,)& -*,
,)&-*,
&!))''/(#.3)&&!",#.3"))&)
! 3 ! 3 /,-#(!
!
%#&"*1 :48<487
%#&"*1:48<487 .,## !,-
.,##!,-699
99
%#&"*1:48<487
" :48<487 # ".
)(,#!". :48<49787
(#0,-#.3)
3 1,&(-
%#&"*1 :48=487
%#&"*1:48=487 #' 3( "(&&),
#'3(6"(&&), :49949787
%#&"*1:48=487
4 4
),!,%,
% :49949787
).."#..(/,!#"(&&), ),
-,"(*)(-),,)!,'-(
* !
%#&"*1:48=487
& 1 4 4 () .",/."))& :49949787
4 4
!(#** "))&
!(#**"))&
) -""
)-"" :49<49787
% "#
))%,9-"#(!.)("))&
" & &#-'-6*,#(#*&
&# # # & :49<49787
&,.#%,&'(.,3"))&
3 ,#((6*,#(#*&
6* * :49<49787
4 4
# %$)%" *
#%$)%" **!%"( $*(,
*!%"( $*(, -4
* $
$'+)*))%
.809787
'+)*) ) %
. 8 9787
(" # $(.
*
$(.
* $
$
$*(, -%*%#&"* ($ /* %$%( $ , +" %$**()%$
*
4
%#&"*;48;487
& 4 4
#&(.,
/&#.&&#, :48>49787
4 4
%#&"*:49;487
& 4 4 /,/) )0,('(.&-,"
(.)1, :49949787
4 4
&(=,#(6,-#(.
& = # # . :49949787
,(/)&&,6
)-*#.&--)#.#)( #,-#(.) ),% ),0&)*'(. :49949787
)"( &-.,)..
)"(&-.,).. :49<49787
%#&"*:49;487
4 4
)),*-
'&#�,
& & :49<49787
4 4
,,&&
9#&&#'-62/.#0#,.),7
&&
#&&# .# # .
))*,
&),#),.,
& # :49 497 7
:49<49787
09
#"&9
+/-6999),)
0
#"&
+/- ), )
#,.),- "#,
#,.),-"#, :49<49787
%#&"*;48;487
" * ;48;487
. :
.:,')(3%-
% &
&0#(,,#-)(
# # :49<49787
& %
&%)()'#0&)*'(.)/(#&
# & . #&
,()&%,
& % :49:49797
/#."(!, #& :49:49797
#&&#
(0#&&#, :49:49797
,!/-)0#";"#,'(<
! ; < :49:49797
4 4
%#&"* :49<487
%#&"*:49<487 ((#- /-"
((#-/-"
%#&"*:49:487
" * :49:487 # %
,#(% &
&&()1&&2/.#0#,-#(.
& && .# # # . :49:49797
%#&"*;48;487
& 4 4 #,.3(%
3 &(
)(&,-#(.> :49:49797
4 4
#' /-)(
#'/-)(
/(! ).&
/(!).&
)-*" !,
)-*"!, :49<49787
# %$)%" *
#%$)%" **!%"( $*(,
*!%"( $*(, -4
* $
$'+)*))%
.809787
'+)*) ) %
. 8 9787
(" # $(.
*
$(.
* $
$
$*(, -%*%#&"* ($ /* %$%( $ , +" %$**()%$
*
0&)*'(.
* ,,.,,((4 :49<49787
--)#..")&#",#.#-
#'&&3 :49<49787
%#&"*;48;487
" 4 4
)(),'( :49<49787
&
)2& .013,
:49<49787
&&)/."
)/. )
,-"
) - :4
:49<49787
<4 7 7
*(%##+$ * %$(%,
()
*
*)
)
.# .
*.#-.)''/(#.3
#(#-.,#-
#.
# # . #
3,)(,,&&
&& :49;49787
%(%%(%+&)
&
#(0#&&)(.#/&(
#(0#&& )(.# /&()&&),.#0
)&&),.#0 &( ,)1( ( (#. )!,-
&(,)1(((#.)!,- :49;49787
/),!.9
)"(#!"),"))--)#.#)(
.
" # " " # .#
#%
#%,
:49;49787
/&(:(&#!"),"))0&)*'(.),*),.#)(
: ! * * ,9,/.&, :49;49787
4 4
()(,* %$%##+$
%$ %##+$ *.
,,)&&).)(0(/,-,0.#)(&&#(
) ).) / - . )
#')!(
)! :4
:49;49787
4 7 7
"
")/(.#)(
.# ),#-.),#&)/#-#(
# . # & # # ,)&3(((..
& .. :49;49787
% "
+)*
"
+)*
)/#-#(
/-.# (-#./.
)/#-#(
/-.# (-#./. ,# -"#(!.)(
,#-"#(!.)( :49;49787
%#&"*;48<487
& 4 4 '#&3,0#)
3 ,.,1,&(- )(
&#( :49;49787
4 4
%#&"*;48<487
" * ;48<487 . &
,.,1,&(-)/(.#)(
.# &
&,./-!
. :49;49787
/(.-
. /-#-
# :49;49787
$*($" *!%"()
$*($"*!%"()
#!"),1),%-
!
'-)-- :49;49787
4 4
&
1,&(-"#&,(=-&.",)$.
"#& = &." $ .
,9&#(&.(/
&# &. :49;49787
)''/(#.3&#(#-
3 #($)#
$ :49;49787
4 4
%#&"*
%#&"*;48;487
;48;487 )$)/,(, ,/." (.,
)$)/,(,,/."(., ,)& ,.,
,)&,., :49;49787
)/.",((#0,-#.3)
3 1,&(- ,9#.),%*)&)
* :49;49787
.
.*-.)&."#,)/#-#(
. &."# # #
,9'#.)*,(#
#. # :49;49787
",#-.3),-1),."3
3 3 :49;49787
4 4
%#&"*:48@487
& 4 4 ,(!/)
! ,.,1,&(- )&()&&#(- :4
:49;49787
4 7 7
& .
)&/(.,-) ',#
# #
#.),'&.4
. &. :49;49787
Appendix B:
Completed Stakeholder
Sign-In Sheets
Appendix C:
GNOBEDD Presentation:
Meeting of City-wide
Stakeholders
Meeting of
Citywide Stakeholders
GNOBEDD
Greater New Orleans Bioscience Economic Development District
G t New
Greater N Orleans
Ol Bioscience
Bi i Economic
E i
Development District
Down 34.46%
Challenges
• Development
e e op e t o
of co
cornerstone
e sto e facilities
ac t es
• Development of an bioscience industry
i f t t
infrastructure
• Attract, maintain and grow new
bioscience businesses
• R
Recruiting
iti andd retention
t ti off
bioscience\healthcare students, faculty &
professionals
f i l
• Workforce: development,
development recruitment
recruitment,
training, and housing
LifeScience Park
LifeScience Park
6,000 1,500 6,000 - 7,000 3,500 ++
Building Partnerships
• S h l (U
Schools (Universities,
i ii college,
ll charter)
h )
• Clinical and Research Facilities
• Government Agencies
• Business Support Organizations
• Business Community
• Neighborhood Organizations
Organizations, ii.e.,
e Mid City
City,
Lafitte/Treme
Qatar Pharmacy Pavilion
Xavier University
University
Education
New Orleans
BioInnovation Center
Business Incubation
and
Research
LCRC C
Cancer C
Center
t
Cutting Edge
Research
Interdisciplinary Research
• S i
Services
• Lawyers, accounts, wellness
• Neighborhood retail
• C f
Cafes
• Dry cleaners
• Card shoppes
• Cl thi
Clothing
• Flowers
New City
Domain Properties
40 one-bedroom
b d apartments,
t t 30 two-bedroom
t b d units
it and
d ttwo th
three-bedroom
b d units,
it
with a total of 104 off-street parking spaces.
Mi i St
Mission Statement
t t
3) A
Apply
l for
f an EDF Grant
G t from
f th City
the Cit in
i the
th amountt off $500,000
$500 000
2 year commitment
8) Begin financing study and Master Plan Request For Qualifications process
6 Months
5)) Identification of p
preliminaryy funding/granting
gg g sources
Completed
Page 1 of 2
BIO BOOM: 2009
WWL-TV (CBS-4) Television 5/23 Interview re: Bio Boom/Healthcare Live interview with Lee Zurik
WWL-TV (CBS-4) Television 5/20 Satellite interview re: Bio Boom Morning Show
WVUE-TV (FOX-8) Television 5/20 Satellite interview re: Bio Boom Morning Show
WWL-TV (CBS-4) Television 5/14 Interview re: Bio Boom/Healthcare Interview on morning show
WWL AM/FM Radio 5/14 Interview re: Bio Boom/Healthcare Live intervied with Spud
Associated press Print 5/13 Mention of Bio Boom Interview with Becky Bohrer
WWL/AM/FM Radio 5/18 Story on Bio Boom WWL First News
Bayou Buzz Online 5/18 Story on Bio Boom
One Med Place Online 5/15 Story on Bio Boom
Times Picayune Print 5/14 Mention of Bio Boom Story written by Staff Writers
City Business Print 5/11 Interview re: Bio Boom/Healthcare Story written by Stephen Maloney
VA HEARING: 2008
New York Times Print 11/26 Interview re: VA/LSU Hospitals Interview with Adam Nossiter
WWL-TV (CBS-4) Television 11/25 5:00 News Interview re: VA/LSU Hospitals Taped Interview with Meg Farris
WWL-TV (CBS-4) Television 11/25 9:00 News Interview re: VA/LSU Hospitals Taped Interview with Meg Farris
WDSU-TV (NBC-6) Television 11/25 9:00 News Interview re: VA/LSU Hospitals Taped Interview with Reporter
WVUE-TV (FOX-8) Television 11/25 5:00 News Interview re: VA/LSU Hospitals Taped Interview with Reporter
WVUE-TV (FOX-8) Television 11/25 6:30 News Interview re: VA/LSU Hospitals Taped Interview with Reporter
WVUE-TV (FOX-8) Television 11/25 9:00 News Interview re: VA/LSU Hospitals Taped Interview with Reporter
Page 2 of 2
Appendix E:
Complete Stakeholder
List To Date
"#!!!( (#"&!""#"" !
+"&#)
!! !
0..
)(-27(#0&.#)(-<076/&( --.."&((. C>BFDCC@CG 0!&%*7+,#%4,3CA@@=@D
"&!
$"
!#)(&&((#(!)''#--#)(9:
!#)(&,(-#./."),#.39:
/-.#(/!/-.#( C>BEF@FAAG
,*+ %4,,*+ %7&# )%*'&)++ &%4&$
3),;- #
")(),&73!#(
#.3)/(#&9&&:
+/&#(,".&&,%-)(
,(##&%)1
.3
#.3&((#(!)''#--#)(
)&(),#!/4627#,7
<
-&#&&36*/.3#,7
+"&#)
/-#(--.(.#)(<2*(-#)( ,(-..",-6#,7
77#,*.7
77)&#*.7 ,,(#&3
77 .3(,'#..#(!
77)/-#(!()( ),'(.
))3&(3 0##2)(
!!)((,(&& 0#!!)((,
?AB>)3,-.,.6
1,&(-0&)*'(./."),#.3
'-#(!&.)( /#.D>>1,&(-6
)3#&%,-)(
,(,/2
#07) #!"),")).#.#)(
*.7 )''/(#.3/&#.3) #
)1(.)1().,3
#.3)()'#0&)*'(. 3(."#3&0#(
!!
,-)( )..#.0(-)(
.7''(3
""
#!
#0#-)() '#(#-.,.#)(
,,3
)(-8
,%
)--
',%#(-
)/#-#(
(.),-8*,-(..#0-9&&:
*%,
#'/%,
..(7",3&,30(-
..*&%,#(-
..*7&.,!,
..*7,(,.,,.,-)(
..*7#&,'-)(
..(7 /,,3
=
77,'3),*-) (!#(,-
+"&#)
,,#-
,,3)&&#, #&##7#*,*4,3@AC??;;
,7
)-*"
),-"",
,7&#-.,'-3
,7."#)(.().
,&#-"'(
)/(.#)( ,.&&
6 ((()-6 '%&*7+,#%4,3CA@@=;<
#(#0#-#)(-.,'#(30..
)(- #(#0#-#)(-
%
./4!
/&(;-,#'.-,"(.,
0#,(#0,-#.3
,7),'(,(#-
"'&3
&!))''/(#.3)&&!8&&#.",'*/-
)(,#!".
%,)(.
),!,%,
).."#..(/,!
<A;;%#+)+2, + C>BCAGG@G@
"()&)!3(.,*,#-(., &#((3 A=;.)#%*2 "%%07,%&4,
#&&,(#0,-#.3 ,0&(/!"-
)0,3"))&#-.,#. /&&&-
>;<D%#+)+
,,(-.)(#!""))& &2#(
&3 .)#%*2B;<<D C>BA@BEB>> #/ %6$#07%&'*4"<=4&)
!(#**"))&
??;B))&##+&%-
-*,(4#!""))& .3,,3 .)#%*2B;<<D C>BAEAD@E@
))%,7-"#(!.)("))&
&,.#%,&'(.,3"))&
>
+"&#)
#&(.,
/&#.&&#, !,# 4+## )7-4&-
((#(!.)(#)'#&-,")/(.#)(
"-(,&."(., ,7.,#%/#(&#(
1,&(-)&-(.)-*#.&
#(3,)'",4
/,/) )0,('(.&-,"
%+&.)
&(;,#(
)-*#.&--)#.#)( ,()&&,
)"(&-.,)..
& )-.
,.,1,&(- (7
CC=@ )# % .0
))*,
,3- )/!0(-
,)0#()''/(#.3)/-#(!8 #..
.8,')(3%-
&%)()'#0&)*'(.)/(#& ,()&%,
/#."(!, #&
(0#&&,
?;;&0)*+42+ C>BBA>@@CF8CD?>CAB " ++7&$
8
)/(.#)( #."1#."&& <B;;.
1,&(-)(0(.#)((.,
77#(.-9)1,-,)$.-8(.,,.#('(.)'*&2 )'(-)(
#((#&#,'-
"#.(3(%
)"()*6,-#(.8
#,-.,/-.),*7<,#(!%77
)-*"7(#4,)
)/#-#(/(?
)-*")0..
)'#%,-)(
?
*#.& #",
)(.!)',3
+"&#)
"#.(3(%
)"()*
,#(% &&()1&&
*#.&((%
'(#(% 3&.,-8
#'/-)(
)'',#.#)( .0/&'(-
),', %)7,%&4,
(,/-'( ((&&
,)(#,%-
/(!).&
)-*"!,
0&)*'(. ,,.,,((4
)'#()'*(#- .."1,.4
--)#..")&#",#.#-
#'&&3F@?E@@@ !"##07) &*%&4&)
#..,(13),,#),,)$.'
,).,.,(.,)$.'
)2&
(.,!3
&)
,# ',-
"!
,"#)-) 1,&(-
3,)(,,&& <?@;&0)*+42, + C>BCGA@A@A
*.#-.)''/(#.3
#(#-.,#- <@@;.)#%*2
>B;;%#+
,*#-)*& 07,,3#&&#'- .)#%*2B;<<D C>BBF@C@B@ .+))0==<B7&$
#..-#(.-)/(#& .,##")'-
44&/BD;<=>.
@
##.3#!"),"))--)#.#)(
((# ,#-"/*. )#%*2B;<BD C>BBFDD@DD ')* %+7$%&4&)
+"&#)
,)((.,.#!"),"))--)#.#)(
)/&#!(3 '*,)0'(.--)#.#)(
)/&#!(3#0,-##!"),"))--(7
,)')), '*,)0'(.--)#.#)(
,)')),0&)*'(.),*),.#)(
/,."0#&&--)#.#)() #!"),-
(.,&#.3,.(,-"#*
(.,&#.3(#--(&&#(
#.#4(-) **,,)')),
&#'(#!"),"))--)#.#)(
)&#-/'+/,#!),"))--)#.#)(
)..)( #&&
&"#-#!"),"))--)#.#)(
/)/,!&"#-#!"),"))--(7
/)/,! 3..#!"),"))--(7
/)/,! ,(!)#!"),"))--(7
,,./-#(--<,)*,.#-1(,;---(7
,,.#!"),-(#.
,(#-.,#.#!"),"))--)#.#)(
,.)1((.,*,#-)()'#0&)*
/-.)'--#(.-)/(#&
#-.),#&/)/,! 3..--)#.#)(
) '(,#(!&#!"),"))--)#.#)(
,#-""((&#!"),"))--)#.#)(
3..+/,#!"),"))--)#.#)(
)1, !4#(.7)')1(,---(7
#&(#!"),"))--)#.#)(
&'3,,,.(,-
#0, ,)(.#0#--)#.#)(
.7",&-0(/--)#.#)(
)(#.+/,--)#.#)(
)/,))/&#!(3--)#.#)(
,")/-,/-#(--&&#(
#)(#.3#!"),")) '*,)07--(7
**,#%,0#&&#!"),"))--(7
! $"#"&
<===)%+)+ C>BC@@CG>> !#&%7#&%%*& #,4&$
,,)&&).)(0(/,-,0.#)(&&#(
#')!( .)#%*2B;<<C
44&/B<==<
)''#...))*(",#.3)-*#.& ,.. .)#%*2B;<B= C>B@DGBGC? )+)&+$ #4&$
D=>&,' +&,#*+
.#)(&,/-. ),#-.),#,-,0.#)( &.,&&- .)#%*2B;<>;
@>> *'#% -4 +4 C>BDADA>BF .#+)6##*7%+'4&)
.
',.,)1.")/#-#(
%0#-6#&&)," )#%*2B;<<A C>BGBBB>?> %&7*$)+)&.+#4&)
&/D;C
")/(.#)( ),#-.),#&)/#-#( ,)&3(((.. +&%&,2B;C=< @@CAFE@BDB2?D )�%%%++7#4&)
D=>&,' +&,#*+
A
,-,0.#)(-)/,(., ..#3 .)#%*2B;<>; C>BDADA>C> '07')%&4&)
+"&#)
,.,1,&(- (7
<;@@+4)#*-2
,.,1,&(-)/(.#)( &,./-! +<;;.)#%*2 C>BCGFBDDA #)+7%&4&)
=<B4) ,)+4
1,&(-),%,-;(., ),#&
/-.# %.)(# .)#%*2B;<<= C>BA>GC?DC *"+*&% 7&+$ #4&$
=B<?%#++4>;A
1,&(- (., #."),%,
/-.# ,)(&#, .)#%*2B;<<D C>B@DEBDFC ")&%# )7$ #4&$
" " !
=><A#$0) C>BECB@?GF & )&)*7$ #4&$
)1,
##.3
#&#-.,#. )#)!,- .)#%*2B;<<D
0#,(#0,#-.3",'3"))&
,3)1&&
<>?;) &, +<;;; C>BDCFB@GG8AF@GFAG
#!"),")),0#-(#&#.#- "-.,0&- .)#%*2B;<<=
<@<@&0)*+
#!"),1),%-
'-)-- .)#%*2B;<<= C>BC@BF?FC !)&**7%.4&)
<?>;,#%-2>B
1,&(-"#&,(;-&.",)$. ,7&#(&.(/ .)#%*2B;<<= C>BGFF>CBC %&'7+,#%4,
)''/(#.3&#(#-
=?B@%#+8?;;
1,&(-)/(#&)(!#(! )1,)!,- .)#%*2B;<<D C>BF@?B?@?
==;; +++)+
)$)/,(,,/."(., ,)&,., .)#%*2B;<<D C>BF@EGGDA )+)7) &*%&4&)
)/.",((#0,-#.3) 1,&(-
.*-.)&."#,)/#-#(
=@<@%#+)+ C>BF@@CCB> ),+$7,% +.0%&)
(#.3#-.,#.D /."
3,- .)#%*2B;<<D
=?B@%#+42, + C>BF@?BBGD2.7?>E8 $"#7,% +0%&4&)
) ,.,1,&(-
,."!& >;;. GC@AABF
=>==%#+)+ C>BD@>@AA@
,(!/) ,.,1,&(- )&()&&#(- .)#%*2B;<<D %)&## %*7,)%#,%.&)#%*4&)
)/(!,-"#*)/(#&
?<@=%#+)+.
)&/(.,-) ',# #.),'&.4 )#%*2B;<<D C>BBF@@?A> -*$#+17-&%&4&)
B
Appendix F:
Focus Group Organization
+ -
!&$#!&"$+&!#"#2010
%!##!&"$
&$%! !&%
" %#!&%! $/%% "!"!!#%
"
#
!
"
"#
""
!#
"
!"%
#&
"
"""
"
%
*% "
"
%
)" (*(.##,%!)"!#%%%&$!&%$$&$% %#+! !
'!" % !$ $ (# $
"
%
#
#
%
#
"
#"
%
"%
"
"
%
"
"
"#
"
"
%
#
&!
"
&
'"
%
'%
#&"$,(# $$ % $%*!%%%&$!&%%%*
2. What do you consider to be the most important issues facing New Orleans?
Public safety
Health care
Schools
Streets
Transportation
Economic development/jobs
Recreation/parks
Historic Preservation
1
3. Are you aware of economic development activities in biosciences and health care in the
city?
Yes
No
If yes, then ask: Can you tell me briefly what you know about these activities and
where they might be focused?
4. The District runs from Carrollton Avenue (West) to Bienville Street (North) to Loyola
(East) to Earhart (South). Are you familiar with this area? What parts of this area have
changed the most post Katrina? For better or for worse?
How changed?
Why?
Personal observations/anecdotes?
Quantitative ways to document?
# $%! ,
* $$&
#"%!
5. What image does the area project to residents and visitors? Is this the image you feel
the area should project? What do you feel the Greater New Orleans Biosciences
Economic Development District has to offer that is unique? (What can we capitalize
on?)
6. What would you consider the most valuable aspect of living in a BioSciences Economic
District? Why or why not?
Safety
Rent/ Realty Prices
Schools
Convenience
Transportation
Recreation/parks
Availability of entertainment/retail
Access to health care
Jobs/Employment
7. In thinking about a Biosciences District, what do you feel could be opportunities to build
upon?
Economic
Social
2
Redevelopment
Historic preservation
Public Realm (e.g. sidewalks, streetscapes, etc.)
Transportation
Utilities
Parks
Sustainable Living (e.g. air & water quality, energy generation &
conservation, storm water management, etc.)
* $$&$,
8. What services or amenities would you like to see most in the study area (retail,
recreation, parks, supplemental street cleaning, others)?
Be specific.
Rate the need for these services or amenities.
Would these services or amenities impact other areas of concern?
9. What groups or organizations should direct or play a role in shaping Greater New
Orleans Biosciences Economic Development District?
10. What would you expect to see as a result of this plan to feel that your interests and
needs - or those of your stakeholders - have been met?
%#
**%
"
"
#
%
("
$
")
#""
12. Is there anything else you would like to add beyond the issues covered in the proceeding
questions?