Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Introduction.\p=m-\Thepractice of assessing only trauma patients with elevated asurvey of 154 trauma centers treating
blood alcohol concentrations (BACs) or positive drug screens for psychoactive approximately 125 000 patients in 1984,
substance use disorders (PSUDs) was evaluated. clinicians were asked to estimate in what
Methods.\p=m-\Twenty-fourBAC-negative (BAC) (BAC, 0) and 21 BAC-positive percentage of cases alcohol played a role
in their patients' being injured. Two
(BAC+) (BAC, \m=ge\22mmol/L or 100 mg/dL; mean, 41 mmol/L; range, 24.3 to thirds of respondents estimated that al¬
79 mmol/L) adult trauma patients were evaluated for alcoholism and other PSUDs cohol was a factor in more than half of
using the Structured Clinical Interview (SCI) from the Diagnostic and Statistical the cases.16
Manual of Mental Disorders, Revised Third Edition (DSM-III-R). Approximately half Approximately 10% of American
were vehicular crash victims and 78% were men. adults have problems with alcohol abuse
Results.\p=m-\Atotal of 64 PSUDs were diagnosed in 31 (68.9%) of the 45 patients; or alcohol dependence during their
all but one was for dependence (vs abuse). Of the BAC+ patients, 14 (66.7%) met lifetimes.1·17 Although trauma has been
DSM-III-R criteria for alcohol dependence, 11 (78.6%) of whom also had other characterized as a "symptom of alco¬
PSUDs not related to alcohol. Two other BAC+ patients had nonalcohol PSUDs. holism,"18 little is known about the
Of the BAC- patients, 11 (45.8%) had alcohol dependence, six (54.5%) of whom prevalence of alcoholism and other
also had nonalcohol PSUDs. Another four BAC- patients had nonalcohol PSUDs. psychoactive substance use disorders
(PSUDs) among trauma patients.19 In a
Overall, 76.2% of the BAC+ patients and 62.5% of the BAC patients had a diag- study of more than 27 000 trauma pa¬
nosis of psychoactive substance dependence.
Conclusion.\p=m-\Allpatients admitted to trauma centers should be assessed for
tients, only 3.0% had hospital discharge
diagnoses of alcohol or other drug
alcoholism and other PSUDs. abuse problems.20
(JAMA. 1992;267:2756-2759) According to criteria delineated in the
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of
Mental Disorders, Revised Third Edi¬
ALCOHOL use has been linked to all 1982 to 1988, alcohol was estimated to tion {DSM-III-R),21 substance use dis¬
types of injury,1-10 particularly injury sus¬ be factor in 53% of almost 360000
a orders are classified as dependence or
tained in vehicular crashes.11,12 From highway deaths.13 In 1987, alcohol-re¬ abuse. Dependence is characterized by
lated crashes accounted for 57% of the loss of control over substance use. Use
This article is one of a number of articles on violence years of potential life lost owing to road¬ continues despite adverse consequences
that will appear in upcoming issues of The Journal.
The reader is referred to the June 10, 1992, issue, way trauma.13 During that year, trauma regardless of whether physiologic evi¬
which will be dedicated to studies of violence. accounted for 80% of the more than 1.5 dence (development of tolerance and oc¬
From the Department of Surgery, R Adams Cowley million years of potential life lost owing currence of withdrawal syndromes) is
Shock Trauma Center, Maryland Institute for Emer- to alcohol-related causes.14 These fig¬ manifest. The life-styles of dependent
gency Medical Services Systems, Baltimore (Dr Sod- ures are probably low estimates because individuals revolve "around obtaining,
erstrom); the Charles McC. Mathias National Study
Center for Trauma and Emergency Medical Systems, deaths owing to alcohol-related trauma using, and recuperating from" alcohol.21
Baltimore, Md (Dr Dischinger); the Injury Prevention are underreported.15 Abuse is a residual diagnosis given to
Center, The Johns Hopkins School of Hygiene and those who suffer adverse consequences
Public Health, Baltimore, Md (Dr Smith); the Depart-
Alcohol use plays a major role in the
ments of Psychiatry (Drs McDuff and Gorelick) and causation of injuries serious enough to from substance use but do not meet cri¬
Epidemiology and Preventive Medicine (Dr Hebel), require treatment at trauma centers. teria for dependence.
University of Maryland School of Medicine, Baltimore; Data from six regional trauma centers Screening and structured interview
and the National Institute on Drug Abuse, Bethesda,
Md (Dr Gorelick). in the United States, involving 4063 instruments have been used to study
Reprint requests to Department of Surgery, Mary- trauma patients, indicate that 40.2% of the prevalence of alcoholism among gen¬
land Institute for Emergency Medical Services Sys-
those patients had a positive blood al¬ eral medical populations. The results of
tems, 22 S Greene St, Baltimore, MD 21201-1595 (Dr
Soderstrom). cohol concentration on admission.510 In nine recent studies, which are summa-
Alcohol Other
Drug Other Drug Lifetime Prevalence
Dependence, Dependence With Dependence Without of Any Psychoactive
Total Alcohol Dependence Alcohol Dependence Substance Dependence
Admitting Total No. I-1
BAC Statust of Patients No. C/P No. C/P No. C/P No. C/P
BAC* 21 14 13/1 4/7 § 1/1 til 16 14/2tt
BAC 24 5/6 1/5*1 2/2 # 15 7/8tt 62.5
Total 45 25 18/7 17 6/12 3/3 31 21/1 Ott 68.9
*Met psychoactive substance use dependence criteria based on the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Revised Third Edition (see text). BAC indicates
blood alcohol concentration; C/P, current/past. (Past equals no evidence of dependence for 6 months prior to injury.)
tBAC* indicates »22 mmol/L (2IOO mg/dL) of alcohol; BAC-, 0 concentration of alcohol.
^Dependence on marijuana, cocaine, or other psychoactive substances. Some of these patients had more than one dependency.
§Seven patients were addicted to marijuana, six to cocaine, and four to other substances.
||One patient was addicted to marijuana, two to cocaine, and one to other substances.
TJTwo patients were addicted to marijuana, two to cocaine, and five to other substances.
#Two patients were addicted to marijuana, two to cocaine, and four to other substances.
**One patient with diagnosis of alcohol abuse.
ttFor patients who had both a current and a past dependence, only current status is reflected in these figures.
In both groups, 78% of the patients were COMMENT tients using other health services (Ta¬
men (BAC-, 79.2%; BAC+, 76.2%). The ble l),22-27 as assessed by both screening
mean age was 30.4 years in the BAC+ This study is the first to use stan¬ and structured interview methods. In
group and 42.3 years in the BAC~ group dardized diagnostic criteria to examine addition, it is nine times higher than the
(P<.007; two-tailed t test). However, the prevalence of PSUDs in relation to estimated 6-month prevalence of such
four patients in the BAC~ group were BACs among patients admitted to a problems in the general population as
65 years or older. If those four are ex¬ trauma center. Almost four fifths of assessed by structured interviews.17 The
cluded, there is no significant difference BAC+ patients had a lifetime PSUD. In 57.8% incidence of lifetime alcohol abuse
in the mean age of the AC~ (35.2 years) addition, almost two thirds of the BAC" and/or dependence is almost 4 Va times
and BAC+ (30.4 years) groups. patients had a lifetime history of depen¬ higher than the lifetime prevalence of
dence on a psychoactive substance (pre¬ such diagnoses among the general pop¬
Prevalence of Alcohol and Other
dominantly alcohol). This finding high¬ ulation.17
Drug Use Disorders lights the importance of carefully as¬ In a 5-year follow-up study of 263
Results of the PSUD/SCI interview sessing all trauma patients for PSUDs. trauma patients admitted to a trauma
are presented in Table 2. Thirty-one Thus, the standard practice of relying center in Detroit, Mich, Sims and col¬
(68.9%) of the 45 patients had a lifetime solely on an elevated BAC status to iden¬ leagues37 noted that 44% sustained two
diagnosis of one or more PSUDs. All but tify patients with such diagnoses is in¬ or more subsequent injury episodes re¬
one of the 64 diagnoses were for depen¬ adequate. In this study, it would have quiring hospitalization. Alcohol abuse,
dence. There was no significant differ¬ missed almost 30% of those with cur¬ ascertained by review ofmedical records,
ence in lifetime PSUD prevalence be¬ rent psychoactive substance depen¬ BACs, and death certificates, was iden¬
tween BAC- (62.5%) and BAC+ (76.2%) dence. tified in 67% of those patients sustain¬
patients or between vehicular (63.9%) The overall 68.9% lifetime prevalence ing recurrent injury. Concerning the
and nonvehicular (69.6%) accident vic¬ of PSUDs diagnosed in this study is over large economic burden of alcohol-related
tims. Lifetime dependence on substances two times higher than that found in the trauma, Enoch Gordis, MD, director of
other than alcohol was more likely in pa¬ study by Silverman and colleagues the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse
tients with lifetime alcohol dependence (32.1%).31 Their study, which also em¬ and Alcoholism in Bethesda, Md, re¬
(17 [68.0%] of 25) compared with other pa¬ ployed DSM-III-R criteria, involved a cently stated,19 "Perhaps if patients at
tients (six [30.0%] of 20) (P<.01; OR, 4.96; population of predominantly inner-city risk for alcohol-related problems were
95% CI for OR, 1.18 to 22.05. Lifetime assault victims. In contrast, approxi¬ identified before repeated traumas or
prevalence of alcohol dependence also did mately half of the patients in the cur¬ health problems occur, these costs might
not differ significantly between BAC+ rent study were injured in vehicular be reduced." The study design at our
(66.7%) and BAC" (45.8%) patients crashes, and most of the remaining pa¬ shock trauma center did not allow for
(P<0.2; OR, 2.36; 95% CI, 0.60 to 9.56). tients were victims of unintentional evaluation of outcome with respect to
Twenty-one (46.7%) of the 45 patients trauma. This population is more repre¬ referral for treatment of substance use
had a current (6 months prior to injury) sentative of the profile of patients ad¬ problems. However, a small, yet signif¬
PSUD, with greater prevalence in the mitted to most trauma centers in the icant, study of 17 trauma patients by
BAC+ patients (66.7%) than in the BAC" United States. The incidence of current Gentilello and colleagues3* demonstrated
patients (29.2%) (P<.01; OR, 4.86; 95% alcohol or other drug abuse and/or de¬ that those identified as alcoholics are
CI, 1.17 to 2.37). Looking at current al¬ pendence disorders documented in the receptive to treatment. Obviously, the
cohol dependence alone, those who were current study is over 15 times higher prerequisite to treating PSUDs is iden¬
BAC+ had a significantly greater prev¬ than that reported by MacKenzie and tification of patients with such problems.
alence (61.9%) than those who were associates.20 Their study, which involved This study clearly demonstrates that
BAC- (20.8%) (P<.01; OR, 6.18; 95% recorded discharge diagnoses in a large both BAC+ and BAC" patients admit¬
CI, 1.40 to 29.06). cohort of patients treated in trauma cen¬ ted to trauma centers should be assessed
A BAC+ status was not a clinically ters, indicates that current clinical prac¬ for PSUDs.
useful predictor of the presence or ab¬ tices substantially underdiagnose
sence of current alcohol dependence. The PSUDs. Research for this study was supported by funds
contributed by Greek Leaders Against Drunk
predictive value of BAC+ for current The 42.2% incidence of current alco¬
Driving and by Towson State University, Towson,
alcoholism was 61.9%. Conversely, the hol abuse and/or dependence in this Md (1989-1990).
predictive value for BAC- status for no study's trauma population was almost Dr Smith is supported by First Award
alcoholism was 79.2%. two times higher than that among pa- R29AA07700 from the National Institute on Aleo-