Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Objectives: To document and describe the incidence tricians was 2.6 cases per 100 000 person-years. The ra-
and age-specific presentation of early-onset restrictive eat- tio of girls to boys was 6:1, and 47.1% of girls and 54.5%
ing disorders in children across Canada. of boys showed signs of growth delay. Forty-six percent
of children were below the 10th percentile for body mass
Design: Surveillance study. Cases were ascertained through index, 34.2% were initially seen with unstable vital signs,
the Canadian Paediatric Surveillance Program by survey- and 47.2% required hospital admission. Only 62.1% of
ing approximately 2453 Canadian pediatricians (a 95% children met criteria for anorexia nervosa. Although chil-
participation rate) monthly during a 2-year period. dren with anorexia nervosa were more likely to be medi-
cally compromised, some children who did not meet cri-
Setting: Canadian pediatric practices. teria for anorexia nervosa were equally medically unstable.
Participants: Pediatricians and pediatric subspecialists. Conclusions: Young children are seen with clinically sig-
nificant restrictive eating disorders, with the incidence
Main Outcome Measures: A description of clinical exceeding that of type 2 diabetes mellitus. These eating
presentations and characteristics of eating disorders in disturbances can result in serious medical conse-
this population and the incidence of restrictive eating dis- quences, ranging from growth delay to unstable vital signs,
orders in children. which can occur in the absence of weight loss or other
restrictive eating disorder symptoms.
Results: The incidence of early-onset restrictive eating
disorders in children aged 5 to 12 years seen by pedia- Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2011;165(10):895-899
L
ITTLE INFORMATION EXISTS valid estimates of rates in the population
about restrictive eating dis- than clinical case series or registries. How-
orders (EDs) in children and ever, the ability of a study to estimate inci-
adolescents, despite onset dence and prevalence is dependent on the
occurring most commonly number of cases detected. Less common or
between the ages of 10 and 20 years1 and concealed disorders, such as EDs, can pre-
EDs reported in children as young as 5 sent particular challenges. Many population-
Author Affiliations: Eating years old.2 Subsyndromal presentations of based mental health surveys have failed to
Disorders Program, Department
anorexia nervosa (AN), typically referred identify or report any child or adolescent
of Psychiatry (Drs Pinhas) and
Division of Adolescent to as EDs not otherwise specified, have cases of EDs; investigators typically have not
Medicine, Department of higher rates of occurrence but often are attempted to estimate the occurrence of
Paediatrics (Dr Katzman), underreported or misdiagnosed in chil- EDs.10-13
University of Toronto, The dren.3 Adequate data documenting the in- Therefore, North American data fre-
Hospital for Sick Children, cidence and presentation of EDs among quently originate in clinical registries from
Toronto, Ontario, Canada; children in North America are lacking. individual specialized ED treatment pro-
Department of Pediatrics and Policy makers and health care profession- grams. These designs are challenged by se-
Child Health, Children’s als need epidemiologic information in chil- lection bias, whereby nonidentification can
Hospital at Westmead, dren with EDs to improve treatment plan- result from failure to seek treatment. Re-
Westmead, Australia
ning and resource allocation.4 gardless of method used, studies14-18 have
(Dr Morris); and
Neuropsychiatric Research The incidence and prevalence of men- found few cases of EDs in children; re-
Institute, School of Medicine tal health disorders are often estimated using searchers using a clinical registry in a
and Health Sciences, University large community surveys involving inter- United Kingdom database of primary care
of North Dakota, Fargo viewing for specific diagnoses.5-9 Represen- settings reported in 1996 that the inci-
(Dr Crosby). tative population-based studies yield more dence of AN in girls younger than 10 years
ARCH PEDIATR ADOLESC MED/ VOL 165 (NO. 10), OCT 2011 WWW.ARCHPEDIATRICS.COM
895
ARCH PEDIATR ADOLESC MED/ VOL 165 (NO. 10), OCT 2011 WWW.ARCHPEDIATRICS.COM
896
ARCH PEDIATR ADOLESC MED/ VOL 165 (NO. 10), OCT 2011 WWW.ARCHPEDIATRICS.COM
897
methods as herein, Canadian data on diabetes indicate an America and is a major strength. It allows for sampling
annual incidence of 1.54 cases per 100 000 person-years of most clinical practices and is not limited to a single
in those younger than 18 years and 0.27 cases per 100 000 setting. A limitation of the study is the omission of binge-
person-years in children younger than 10 years.34 The in- ing as a symptom in the questionnaire. This was done
cidence of restrictive EDs among children is 2 times greater purposefully to avoid confusion with bulimia nervosa,
than the incidence of type 2 diabetes mellitus among all with the primary focus being on restrictive behaviors. As
children younger than 18 years. such, the study provides no information on bingeing be-
In addition, this study confirms that children with clini- havior in this population. However, a current ongoing
cally significant restrictive EDs are seen by pediatri- study on bingeing, using the same methods as those
cians. Children in this study demonstrated food avoid- herein, has failed to identify this behavior in any chil-
ance, and some showed signs of growth delay even without dren younger than 13 years, suggesting that bingeing is
weight loss. They also had unstable vital signs and in- not prominent in this age group.36 Finally, previous lit-
terruption of their normal growth trajectory. Almost half erature has described additional eating disturbances of
of the sample were hospitalized because of medical in- childhood. Cooper et al30 described other restrictive EDs
stability; however, a concerning finding is the number unaccounted for by either of the 2 forms seen herein (AN
of underweight or medically unstable children who were and EDs not otherwise specified). The focus of the present
not admitted to the hospital. Although EDs in children study did not include questions that would allow for iden-
may seem mild, they can be as severe as in adolescents. tification of these other diagnoses.
Caution should be exercised when assessing a child with Restrictive EDs, although uncommon in children, oc-
food avoidance of any kind, especially with associated cur more often than some other chronic illnesses and at
weight loss or growth delay, regardless of whether he or presentation often require multidisciplinary treatment or
she expresses the spectrum of typical psychological find- hospitalization. The use of strict categories for diagnosis
ings commonly seen in adolescents and adults. Pediatri- can limit true appreciation of the severity and differing
cians need to be vigilant about EDs, even if they seem manifestations of pathologic EDs in different popula-
minor, and respond accordingly. tions. Current epidemiologic data on children with EDs
Although most cases looked like typical AN, some chil- are inconsistent and inadequate. It will be crucial for in-
dren lacked cardinal AN symptoms and would typically vestigators to devise strategies that maximize case identi-
be classified as having EDs not otherwise specified. The fication and to develop standardized means to capture and
changes proposed for the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual report data. This will improve comparisons across samples
of Mental Disorders (Fifth Edition) reflect recognition that and enhance our understanding of EDs in children.
the diagnostic categories for EDs are limited for early-
onset EDs.23,35 Children identified in this study and oth- Accepted for Publication: April 1, 2011.
ers2,22,23 would likely meet criteria for the newly pro- Correspondence: Leora Pinhas, MD, FRCPC, Eating Dis-
posed category of food avoidant or restrictive disorder orders Program, Department of Psychiatry, University of
of childhood, which recognizes alternate underlying Toronto, The Hospital for Sick Children, 555 Univer-
causes of food restriction other than weight and shape sity Ave, Toronto, ON M5G 1X8, Canada (leora.pinhas
concerns. @sickkids.ca).
The national sampling strategy used by the CPSP for Author Contributions: Study concept and design: Pinhas,
this study is unique among pediatric EDs in North Morris, and Katzman. Acquisition of data: Pinhas, Mor-
ARCH PEDIATR ADOLESC MED/ VOL 165 (NO. 10), OCT 2011 WWW.ARCHPEDIATRICS.COM
898
ARCH PEDIATR ADOLESC MED/ VOL 165 (NO. 10), OCT 2011 WWW.ARCHPEDIATRICS.COM
899