Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 2

Collective bargaining: Who Represents taxpayers?

N#$'=NZ4NGJAP'*&'&1$')*#2*6%6%2'&*)5$g
CDA#86E86:65?:#06789:;95:#3DA#E9F#?D6#7><<:2

$5>A5#GA<<98:#6<6H?#?D6#=AB685I65?#AJH>9<:#?D9?#:>?#
9H8A::#?D6#?97<6#K8AI#?D6I#G@8>5=#HA<<6HLB6#798=9>5>5=

=1:+$'+*8$'2:Y$#%8$%&':Q76*5+'.*%&'&:'2$&'*5:%2'.6&1'
&1$'"%6:%'$895:;$$+'.6&1'.1:8'&1$;'.:#,'$Y$#;3*;

MF#?D6#LI6#?D6#E65:>A5:#D9B6#?A#76#E9>G#?D6#
=AB685I65?#AJH>9<:#3DA#9=866G#?A#?D6I#986#5A#<A5=68#
EF1*&'G<H'!*%'I:E >5#AJH6N#:A#?D6F#986#56B68#D6<G#9HHA@5?97<6

AJK<A/@(L'!<--J!=@MJ'0NALN@(@(L =*]9*;$#+':%5;'7:8$'6%&:'&1$'967&"#$'3D65#>?:#LI6#KA8#
=NOJP'4<-@=@!N-'F@-- 95#6<6HLA5#A8#?A#E9F#?D6#7><<:
!"#"$%#&'&()&!#"**+(+,'-#.,/&#
&0"$1.#"*#+)2 !"##$%&'($)#*+,*'-*.'/"+&'0$'!1*%2$3
"#$%&'(%)*+',(-'(-..(.&/&.0(*1(%*/&)23&2'(42(5&6)-07-(,-0(&89&&$&$('-8:-;&)(
<"#'$5$7&$3':Q76*5+'%$$3'&:'1$*#'?#:8' !
429*3&(%)*+',
"+R'
! 4")567'$895:;$$'+*5*#6$+'*#$'(<=')*+$3'7"##$%&5;':%'.1*&'&1$'$895:;$#'7*%'
*>:#3(<(4'(40(6-0&$(*2(+,-'(40(:)&/-.&2'=
@?';:"'.*%&'&:'+$$'#$*5'#$?:#8S'3:'%:&'
"#$%&'&()*+,-.'*/+&'*+./*0+1'#$+)&'-*+234*/+)35*+6&7/&/+"389:+";32&-#:+&70+
.*6&'&:'7:%&*7&';:"#'P$%*&:#'*%3'&1$' !
<8=+>#.3/=
8$8)$#+':?'&1$'0"+6%$++'*%3'-*):#'
! >#6.49(&3:.*;&&(#24*20(3-7&(-%)&&3&2'0(-2$(9-2(',&2('-7&(',&4)(9-0&('*(-2(
!:886T$$R'
&2?';(9-..&$(',&(!:886++6:%':?'@%3"+&#6*5'A$5*B:%+'C!@AD(-2$(%&'(3*)&(
3*2&;(-2$(6&2&@'0=
F#6&$S'7*55':#'$8*65';:"#'P$%*&:#'*%3'
! ?;*+"@A+$*$(*'/:+&%%#378*0+(9+8;*+B#C*'7#':+&'*+7#8+*)*28*0+(9:+7#'+
&1$'8$8)$#+':?'&1$'0"+6%$++'*%3'
&7/D*'&()*+8#+8&E%&9*'/+F+9*8+8;*3'+0*23/3#7/+3$%&28+./+&+-'*&8+0*&)=+
-*):#'!:886T$$
! 5&6)-07-(40(',&(*2.;(34$+&0'&)2(0'-'&(+4',(:#6.49(&3:.*;&&(9*2')-9'0(
3-2$-?2%(0'-A2%(.&/&.0B(42(0*3&(94?&0(:*.49&(-2$(@)&(9,4&10($*2C'($&'&)342&(
M6+6&'333456789:;9<6=>:<9?@864=AB'
0'-A2%D(',&(#24*2(9*2')-9'($*&0=
*%3'5::,'?:#'U!:886T$$+V'*%3'
UP$%*&:#+V':%'&1$'5$W'1*%3'+63$)*#'&:'
5:7*&$'7:%&*7&'6%?:#8*B:% @/4N!='<('(J0ANPON'=NZ4NGJAP[
\ =1$'!6&;':?'<8*1*'9:567$'7:%&#*7&'#$+"5&$3'6%'&*]'6%7#$*+$+'6%'^_`_
A$+9$7X"55;'*%3'9:56&$5;'+&*&$';:"#' ! @7+G&7.&'9:+HIJJ:+K$&;&+D&/+#'0*'*0+8#+%&9+,'*+,-;8*'/+LH=H+$3))3#7+37+'&3/*/+
:96%6:%'*):"&'7:55$7BY$')*#2*6%6%2' 1#'+HIIM:+*C*7+8;#.-;+8;*+.73#7+;&0+&-'**0+8#+)#D*'+D&-*/=+N<#.'2*O+K$&;&+
#$?:#8 P#')0FQ*'&)0R
! -6%7:5%'a#$'a21&$#+'8*,$'bc_S___'9$#';$*#S':%'*Y$#*2$S')"&'#$7$%&5;'
!*%';:"RRR #$7$6Y$3'de'f'`_e'.*2$'6%7#$*+$+R(N<#.'2*O+>372#)7+G#.'7&)+<8&'R
E&..(-'(.&-0'(F(:&*:.&(-6*#'(',&(',&( ! S&79+<8&8*+*$%)#9**/+;&C*+'*4'*$*78+%)&7/+8;&8+&'*+-.&'&78**0+8#+%&9+#.8+
9*..&9?/&(6-)%-4242%(400#&D(6;(9-..42%D( '*-&'0)*//+#1+$&'5*8+C&).*T+1*0*'&)+-#C*'7$*78+&70+8&E%&9*'/+;&C*+;&0+8#+
&3-4.42%(-2$(G*)(:)42?2%(-2$(,-2$42%( (&3)+#.8+%*7/3#7/+$.)4%)*+4$*/+/372*+HIIU+D;3)*+8;*3'+#D7+VIJ5+(&)&72*/+
*#'(-(1&+(H;&)0I /;'375:+&70+%'32*/+&70+8&E*/+&'*+372'*&/*0+#'+7*D+#7*/+&00*0

N'U?"55'*%3'?*6#V'1$*#6%2g'
<%'K$)#"*#;'hS'&1$#$'.*+'*'h'`i^'1:"#'1$*#6%2'?:#'N--'%6%$'8$*+"#$+')$?:#$'
&1$'-$26+5*&"#$j+'0"+6%$++'k'-*):#'!:886T$$
K:#'"93*&$+S'8"71'8:#$'
6%?:#8*B:%':%'&16+'*%3' !:886T$$'!1*6#'P&$Y$'-*&1#:9'6%75"3$3'-0lmhS'&1$')655'1$':9$%5;'+*;+'1$'
:&1$#'6++"$+S'Y6+6&[ .*%&+R'n$'*386&+'-0lmh'>:#A5<F#9#:D6<<#O#39>L5=#?A#76#P<<6G#,*)&%#).&#
=89::8AA?:564HAI .&,%+01#$Y$%'&1:"21'1$'*%3':&1$#+'1*Y$'.:#,$3':%'6&'?:#'8:%&1+R
Getting State and Local Budgets Under Control
!"#$"%&'(")&*$+)(,(-./&0+1123-42&5#$/#(.(./
B%'044%"7%7#905MP0"=
!""#$%&'#
M#L-01</-1#:0K-#.--4#349/6G<;-G#34#9:-#%43;0L-/0E#
(")*+,$*,!
7/676134H#;:04H-1#96#,-./0120N1#E0D1#H6K-/434H#7<.E3;#
-L7E6=--1#O#D:3;:#0/-#.-19P
,-./0120#31#34#
5!67#!-48#34#
:JVVXO&<2=2#1%&")2&>.68%"$(#1&<21#-+.%&#.6&!"#"2&
9:-#;6<49/=
?:=1+@22&0+1123-42&5#$/#(.(./&A3"&#.6&=$+)(,("%&
!"#$%&'%"()*%#
3+1123-42&,#$/#(.(./&,@&/+42$.:2."&2.--2%&(.&B2,$#%C#D&
+,-./#01#
:BTYDEO#A.&=$+=+%26&#:2.6:2."&")#"&'+816&/+&,29+$2&
20&310&'%#
4+"2$%&(.&B+42:,2$&EFGE&"+&:#C2&")2&=$+)(,(-+.&=#$"&+9&
%4$506%7#
86#9()(%#)"7# B2,$#%C#H%&0+.%-"8-+.D
:0')5# :JZVX#[#:BTYDEO&I5JKL&:#C2%&%(/.(M3#."&$29+$:&"+&")2&
;0<%&"4%"(=# '#@&")2&0><&+=2$#"2%N&!2.#"+$%&:#@&,2&=2$%8#626&"+&=#%% &
I5JKL&#.6&12#42&")2&623(%(+.&"+&=$+)(,("&3+1123-42&
>6</;-?#%>#@</-0<# ,#$/#(.(./&"+&")2&=2+=12&(.&B+4D&EFGED
6A#B0.6/#>90C1C;1 BC("#*%3)44&%'*#%DEFGH>%DEIJK>%DELLL>%DEMKF>%DEMKI>%DEMNGO

>?@@ABC9#CA#DEF#9F?GHIG;#J:ADK?H>
G%8&)=3)^=#(20#5)&*%=(#'!P%=#R)<%#966#L<;:#H6K-/4L-49 B0.6/#76D-/#;60E3C641#0F-;9#17-4G34HI#
F%&'%"()*%#01#_0&310&'%#?4$506%7#86#9()(%#0&#50')5#*0<%&"4%"(`
34;/-0134H#13J-#6A#H6K-/4L-49
# ############RST#B34;6E4############O# # UVT#"L0:0
>6</;-?#%>#@</-0<#6A#B0.6/#>90C1C;1 J:ADKIG;#DALLAG#9?G9?#9F?GHIG;#DEF9
7,9/5'(#&%8/*%3).%./9#*+6#+(%'+,%2+)/+%&211/*(#*&%(*$%(/%,)&6)&&%("#&#%P.2*#&%Q%
("#$%&'$%)(%)+542,#&%1234)5%2-4)($%0/*R#*&>%32(%Q%)&+;(%)(%-6#%(/%&('*(%'&R)+.S%=TU%
,/%/2*%#4#5(#,%/V5)'4&%3#4)#9#%W#3*'&R';&%#5/+/6$%&"/24,%*#4$%&/%"#'9)4$%/+% DM&&%"(#=6=(%4#J:ADKIG;#%N0&(=#(0#'M&8#
1234)5%2-4)-#&>%#,25'-/+>%%'+,%&23&),)#&%Q%'44%5/+(*/44#,%3$%./9#*+6#+(X *0<%&"4%"(#=$%"7!"*O

G?JBE9KE#\E9#E#G?EB:a# • *$+4(62%&2738%2%&9+$&1+3#1&/+42$.:2."&+;3(#1%&
b,#JI::IAG#JcH;?C#9\ABC@E:: !"#$%&'$%("#)*%"'+,&%'*#%-#,%)+%+#./-'-/+&%0)("%
1234)5%#614/$##&
B2,$#%C#H%&<2-$2:2."&!@%"2:&O&9:-#H6K-/4L-49#-L7E6=--#
7-41364#A<4G#W#:01#.--4#.03E-G#6<9#1-K-/0E#CL-1#34#9:-#7019#9D6# • :0')5#4M"!'!$)5!(6#)==0'!)P0"=Q#50886!=(=Q#
=-0/1&,23#8%2&:#.@&/+42$.:2."&'+$C2$%H&=2.%(+.%&#$2&.+"&-26& M"!0"=#+80(R#$M85!'#)"7#$&!<)(%/Q#)"7#
"+&:#$C2"&4#182P&")2@&#$2&/8#$#."226&,2.2M"%&$2/#$612%%&+9&")2& $05!P'!)"=#2R0#&%'%!<%#=!*"!S')"(#$0&P0"=#01#
:#$C2"P&8.1(C2&")2&LFGC&=1#.%&9+$&'+$C2$%&(.&")2&=$(4#"2&%23"+$D ')4$)!*"#'0"(&!8MP0"=#1&04#5)80&#M"!0"=#
10&4#)55!)"'%=
I"#0&7%&#(0#d8)5)"'%e#0M&#9()(%#8M7*%(Q#2%#R)<%#()3%"#!"#)#*&%)(#
7%)5#01#@%7%&)5#=P4M5M=#1M"7=P&:+%"&+9&')(3)&'#%&8%26&"+& 744%/8%("#&#%1'*-#&%"'9#%'%+'(2*'4%'9#*&)/+%(/%5'11)+.%
,#(1+8"&")2&=2.%(+.&98.6%P&#%&.+"26&#,+42P&'(")&")2&$2%"&/+(./&"+& ("#%:('(#;&%'3)4)($%(/%&1#+,%,2#%(/%&"'*#,%5/+5#*+&%
2683#-+.&Q%+16&,@&0+./$2%%&#%&R%#4(./&"2#3)2$%H&S+,%TP&#.6& /9#*%0"'(%("#$%&('+,%(/%4/&#<
U26(3#(6D
• TUUV#=$%"7!"*#')$#8)550(#4%)=M&%#W#H?@?EC?H##
86#=)4%#'0)5!P0"#'M&&%"(56#850'3!"*#'055%'P<%#
FB?W9P4M5M=Q#"%)&56#XU.#01#G%8&)=3)^=#8M7*%(#')4%#1&04#
8)&*)!"!"*#&%10&4#
@%7%&)5#1M"7=f#BY+,%/8%P&5'4%$#'*%MZF[ZK[[G%Q%&/2*5#%:('(#%
!*#'&2*#*O =/24,%"'9#%5'11#,%:('(#%&1#+,)+.%3'&#,%/+%1*)/*%
&1#+,)+.%4#9#4&>%)+?'-/+%*'(#>%'+,%1/124'-/+<
J!55=#')"#8%#&%)7#!"#1M55#)(#4-./0120E-H31E09</-QH6K
\%)&!"*=#)&%#"0(#(R%#%"7#01#(R%#!==M%] @'&(%6'A/*)($%/8%("#%/11/&)-/+%5'61').+%
@0&#M$7)(%=Q#4M'R#40&%#!"10&4)P0"#0"# 5/+(*)32-/+&%5'6#%8*/6%1234)5%#614/$##%2+)/+&>%'+,%
&5"//4%3/'*,>%4/5'4>%'+,%5/2+($%./9#*+6#+(%4#'.2#&%
(R!=#)"7#0(R%&#!==M%=Q#<!=!(O '+,%'&&/5)'-/+&<
H/011/66914-Q;6L

Вам также может понравиться