Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
S
Opinion
Studies
For a full list of AEI Public Opinion Studies, please visit here.
1
Contents
Contents .......................................................................................................................................... 2
TARP .............................................................................................................................................. 3
Second Half of TARP and Beyond ............................................................................................... 16
Auto Bailout .................................................................................................................................. 24
Mortgage Help .............................................................................................................................. 30
The Stimulus ................................................................................................................................. 33
Key Events in the Financial Crisis ................................................................................................ 52
2
TARP: This section covers early reaction to the TARP program. In a mid-September 2008 Pew poll,
57 percent thought the government potentially investing billions to try to keep financial institutions
and markets secure was the right thing to do. That dropped to a 45 percent plurality by late
September. In late September CBS News/New York Times poll, people were evenly divided, 43 to 43
percent, on providing money to financial institutions to avoid a crisis, but by mid-October in this poll,
opinion had moved against, with 38 percent in favor and 48 percent opposed. November and
December 2008 Gallup polls showed opinion divided about whether, all in all, the government
provided assistance to the financial institutions was a good idea. The resistance to government help is
interesting because most Americans acknowledged in the fall of 2008 the situation was a crisis, or in
the words of a CBS News poll from late September, a situation in which the “problems with the
financial institutions threaten the entire economy.” Around seven in ten in Pew polls said they were
following news about the economy “very closely” in late September and early October 2008.
In an early October 2008 CNN/Opinion Research Corporation poll, a strong majority, 76
percent, opposed another bill if banks and financial institutions continued to have similar problems. In
CNN/ORC polls in January and February 2009 (shown in the next section of this document), around
six in ten were opposed to providing the remaining half of the TARP money to banks and financial
institutions.
Q: As you may know, the government is potentially investing billions to try to keep financial institutions and markets
secure. Do you think this is the right thing or the wrong thing for the government to be doing?
Q: Do you approve or disapprove of the federal government providing money to financial institutions to avoid a
crisis?
Approve Disapprove
Sep. 27-30, 2008 CBS/NYT 43% 43%
Oct. 3-5, 2008 CBS 36 52
Oct. 10-13, 2008 CBS/NYT 38 48
Q: Do you approve or disapprove of the federal government providing money to banks and other financial
institutions to try to help fix the country’s economic problems?
Approve Disapprove
Dec. 4-8, 2008 CBS News 46% 44%
3
Feb. 2-4, 2009 CBS News 42 47
Feb. 18-22, 2009 CBS News/NYT 39 50
Mar. 12-15, 2009 CBS News 37 53
Mar. 20-22, 2009 CBS News 41 50
Q: Do you approve or disapprove of the economic bailout plan that was passed by Congress and signed into law by
the President?
Approve Disapprove
Oct. 10-13, 2008 CBS/NYT 28% 53%
Oct. 19-22, 2008* CBS/NYT 32 53
Note: * Question wording added “George W. Bush” at the end of the question.
Q: As you may know, this past week the U.S. Senate and House of Representatives passed a bill to address the
problems being faced by U.S. financial institutions. All in all, do you think it is a good thing or a bad thing that
Congress passed this bill?
Q: As you may know, earlier this month Congress and President Bush approved a government program that would
spend up to seven hundred billion dollars to provide assistance to banks and other large financial institutions.
Based on what you have read or heard about this bill, do you favor or oppose it?
Favor Oppose
Oct. 3-5, 2008 CNN/ORC 46% 53%
Oct. 17-19, 2008 CNN/ORC 40 56
(If oppose) Would you have favored a different proposal to provide government assistance to financial
institutions if some major changes were made, or do you think that the federal government should have
stayed out of this matter and let the economy and the financial markets recover on their own?
Q: In the recent financial crisis, do you approve or disapprove of the government’s decision to bail out some
financial institutions that were facing bankruptcy?
Q: Last week, Congress passed a bill that included a seven hundred billion dollar rescue package for financial
institutions. Do you approve or disapprove of Congress passing the rescue plan?
Approve Disapprove
Oct. 8-9, 2008 Fox/OD 34% 53 %
4
Oct. 20-21, 2008* Fox/OD 42 48
Note: *Question wording read, “Recently…”
Q: As you may know, the Bush administration has proposed a plan that would allow the Treasury Department to
buy and re-sell up to $700 billion of distressed assets from financial companies. What would you like to see
Congress do – pass a plan similar to what the Bush administration has proposed, take action but pass something
different from what the Bush administration has proposed or not take any action on this matter?
Q: Do you think the country’s current financial situation is a crisis, a serious problem but not a crisis, a problem
but not a serious one, or not much of a problem at all?
Q: Do you think the problems with the financial institutions threaten the entire economy, or are those problems
something that the economy is strong enough to survive without government involvement?
Q: The government has proposed using up to 700 billion dollars to shore up failing financial institutions on Wall
Street. Some people say it’s a bailout that those companies don’t deserve. Other people say it’s necessary to protect
the broader economy. On balance, do you support or oppose this plan?
Support Oppose
Sep. 29, 2008 ABC/Wash Post 45% 47 %
Q: As you may know, the House of Representatives on Monday voted against a proposed 700-billion dollar bill to
deal with the current financial crisis. What do you think Congress should do now: pass a bill similar to the one that
was defeated, start over and come up with a new plan or not pass any bill addressing this matter?
Q: If banks and other financial institutions continue to have the kind of problems they are currently facing, would
you favor or oppose another bill which would provide additional government assistance beyond the seven hundred
billion dollars in the program that was recently approved?
Favor Oppose
Oct. 3-5, 2008 CNN/ORC 22% 76%
Q: In one specific program, the federal government has provided financial assistance to several major banks, and
exchange the government will own a share of those banks along with other investors. Do you think this is a good
idea or bad idea?
5
Q: As you may have heard, last week Congress passed a bill that provides up to seven hundred billion dollars to
help stabilize the financial markets. Do you think lawmakers did the right or wrong thing for the country when it
passed this financial package?
Right thing Wrong thing
Oct. 10-13, 2008 LAT/Bloomberg 44% 37%
Q: The government has announced a plan to take over bad mortgages and other troubled investments from financial
firms. This plan could cost the government as much as seven hundred billion dollars but would try to stabilize
financial markets, make credit available to business and consumers, and protect some homeowners. Do you
approve or disapprove of this plan?
Approve Disapprove
Oct. 4-5, 2008 NBC/WSJ 40% 38%
Q: In October, the government announced a plan to take over bad mortgages and other troubled investments from
financial firms. The plan was estimated to cost the government as much as seven hundred billion dollars and has
been used to try to stabilize financial markets, make investments in financial institutions, and make credit available
to business and consumers. Do you approve or disapprove of this plan?
Approve Disapprove
Dec. 5-8, 2008 NBC/WSJ 27% 50%
Q: Do you support or oppose the $700 billion government plan to assist failing financial companies?
Support Oppose
Nov. 2008 NEP 39% 56%
Q: The federal government has either already committed to, or is considering, financial aid or loans to several
industries that are in financial trouble. Please tell me whether you approve or disapprove of the government
providing aid and loans to the following types of companies.
Approve Disapprove
Small businesses 82% 15%
Commercial banks 38 56
Mortgage lenders 35 58
Insurance companies 26 68
Investment firms 20 73
Q: We’d like your views about how much the federal government has spent so far to help certain groups affected by
the financial crisis. What about federal spending to help ______. Do you think there has been too much, too little, or
about the right amount?
6
Approval of Policymakers Handling of the Crisis
Q: Do you approve or disapprove of the steps the Federal Reserve and the Treasury Department have taken to try to
deal with the current situation involving the stock market and major financial institutions?
Approve Disapprove
Sep. 29, 2008 ABC/Wash Post 47% 42 %
Q: Next, please say whether you approve or disapprove of the way each of the following has responded to the
problems on Wall Street.
Approve Disapprove
Senator Barack Obama 46% 43%
The Democratic leaders in Congress 39 50
Senator John McCain 37 53
The Republican leaders in Congress 31 58
Treasury Secretary, Hank Paulson 28 51
President George W. Bush 28 68
Q: What is your opinion of how Congress is responding to the recent problems in the financial markets, do you think
they are taking too much time debating the issue, being too hasty, or giving it the right amount of consideration.
Q: Do you approve or disapprove of the job the federal government is doing in handling the current financial crisis?
-----Federal Government-----
Approve Disapprove
Oct. 17-20, 2008 NBC/WSJ 24% 66%
Dec. 5-8, 2008 NBC/WSJ 19 71
Q: And do you approve or disapprove of how this plan has been handled since it passed in October? If you do not
know enough about this to have an opinion, please just say so.
Approve Disapprove
Dec. 5-8, 2008 NBC/WSJ 11% 64%
Who Is to Blame?
Q: When you think about the current economic conditions, do you feel that this is a situation that Barack Obama has
inherited or is this a situation his policies are mostly responsible for?
Situation Obama’s
Situation Obama policies mostly Some
inherited responsible for of both
Feb. 26-Mar. 1, 2009 NBC/WSJ 84% 8% 6%
Jun. 12-15, 2009 NBC/WSJ 72 14 10
Oct. 22-25, 2009 NBC/WSJ 63 20 15
Jan. 10-14, 2010* NBC/WSJ 65 17 16
Note: * Asked of half sample
7
Q: Do you think the Democrats or the Republicans are more responsible for the problems currently facing financial
institutions and the stock market?
Q: Some people are saying that lack of regulation is partly responsible for the current financial and housing crisis,
do you agree or disagree with that?
Lack of regulation is partly responsible
Agree Disagree
Sep. 19-22, 2008 LAT/Bloomberg 62% 24%
Q: As you may know, some big investment banks and mortgage companies, such as Lehman Brothers, Bear Stearns,
and American Insurance Group (known as AIG), have collapsed or gone into bankruptcy and many Americans face
financial crisis. Who or what do you think is primarily responsible for this financial crisis: the Bush administration,
or Wall Street financial institutions, or Congress, or is there another group or thing that you think is primarily
responsible?
Primarily responsible
Wall Street financial institutions 32%
Bush administration 26
All (vol.) 12
Congress 11
Don’t know 11
Other 7
No one in particular (vol.) 1
Q: Who do you think deserves the most blame for the current financial situation?
Q: Regardless of how you usually vote, who do you blame more for the recent problems experienced by financial
institutions – the Republican Party, or the Democratic Party, or do you blame both equally?
8
Q: How much do you think each of the following has contributed to the current problems with financial institutions
and markets?
Q: When elected officials criticize business during this financial crisis – it is justified or it is political
grandstanding?
Justified Grandstanding
Mar. 24-30, 2009 Quinnipiac 42% 49%
Q: Which one of the following do you think is most responsible for the country's financial crisis?...Congressional
leaders, corporate leaders, the Obama administration, the Bush administration
Q: Would you describe yourself as angry or not angry about the role large business corporations have played in the
economic situation?
Angry Not angry
Mar. 26-29, 2009 ABC/Wash Post 68% 31%
Q: Now I am going to read you a series of things President Obama has done on the economy. For each one, please
tell me whether you approve or disapprove of that action?
9
Government’s Responsibility?
Q: Do you think the government should use taxpayers’ dollars to rescue ailing private financial firms whose
collapse could have adverse effects on the economy and the market, or is it not the government’s responsibility to
bail out private companies with taxpayers’ dollars?
Government
should use taxpayers’ Not
dollars to rescue government’s
financial firms responsibility
Sep. 19-22, 2008 LAT/Bloomberg 31% 55%
Q: When you think about the problems on Wall Street is it better for the government to step in and rescue the
financial markets or it better if the government if the government does not rescue the financial markets?
Q: When you think about the problems on Wall Street is it better for the government to bailout the financial markets
or is it better if the government does not bailout the financial markets?
Better for government to step in and bailout the financial markets 42%
Better if government does not bailout the financial markets 51
Q: Do you think the government should use taxpayer money to bail out companies that are facing bankruptcy?
Yes No
Oct. 8-9, 2008 Fox News/OD 11% 82%
Q: Do you . . . ?
Q: If a big company is in danger of going out of business, the federal government may give it financial assistance to
keep it in business and in exchange the government would own a share of that company along with other investors.
Do you think this is a good idea or a bad idea?
10
Q: Which of the following statements comes closer to your view: “The federal government should use taxpayers’
dollars to rescue failing financial institutions,” or “The federal government should let financial institutions fail if
they cannot support themselves”?
Q: Do you think it is the responsibility of the federal government to rescue failing financial institutions or is that not
the responsibility of the federal government?
Q: Do you . . . ?
Q: Do you think it is the responsibility of the federal government to provide financial help to the banks so they can
avoid failing?
Yes, it’s the
government’s responsibility No, it’s not
Feb. 25-Mar. 2, 2009 Quinnipiac 34% 59%
Q: Given the problems the country is facing, do you think the government should or should not exert more control
over the nation’s financial system?
Q: Do you favor or oppose new government regulations that would limit the size and activities of the country’s
largest banks?
Favor Oppose
Jan. 22-24, 2010 CNN/ORC 62% 35%
Q: In responding to the crisis in the financial markets of the last two years, the government has increased regulation
of banks, brokerage house and other financial institutions. Do you think this should be a temporary policy or
lasting policy?
Will It Work?
11
Q: Which comes closer to your opinion? 1. A government bailout of the financial industry would stop a collapse of
the U.S. economy that would cause economic hardship for average Americans or 2. A government bailout of the
financial industry would burden American taxpayers and only help the financial institutions that are failing.
Q: Do you think the new program that Congress and the President recently approved will or will not prevent the
economy from going into a deep and prolonged recession?
Q: All in all, do you think the Congressional financial rescue package will help or hurt the nation’s economy, or will
it not make much of a difference?
Q: From what you know, do you think the economic bailout plan passed by Congress in an effort to lessen the
current economic crisis will make things better, make things worse, or will it have no impact?
Q: As you may know, last fall Congress and President Bush approved a government program that would spend up to
seven hundred billion dollars to provide assistance to banks and other large financial institutions. Based on what
you have read or heard about this program, do you think it has or has not done what it was supposed to do to help
the economy?
Has done what it was Has not done what it
supposed to was supposed to
Jan. 12-15, 2009 CNN/ORC 14% 86 %
Q: The federal government will purchase investments from financial institutions that are in trouble and eventually
sell those investments to different institutions. Do you think the government will eventually get back all of the money
it spends on this program, will get most of it back, will get only a little of it back, or won’t get any of that money
back?
Effects on Individuals
Q: How much do you think your own financial situation has been harmed by the events of the last two weeks – a
great deal, a moderate amount, not much, or not at all?
12
Q: Now, I’d like you to think about the events of the last two weeks and any future problems that might result from
them. How much do you think your own financial situation will be harmed in the long run - a great deal, a
moderate amount, not much, or not at all?
Q: Do you think the problems currently facing financial institutions and the stock market will affect you and your
family immediately, will affect you in a year or so, will eventually affect you, or will never affect you?
Q: How worried are you about the safety of money you have deposited in banks and other financial institutions –
very worried, moderately worried, not too worried, or not worried at all?
Q: As a result of the problems on Wall Street in recent weeks, have you postponed making a major purchase,
seriously considered doing so, or not seriously considered doing so?
Q: As a result of the problems on Wall Street in recent weeks, have you taken money out of the stock market,
seriously considered doing so, or not seriously considered doing so?
Q: As a result of the recent problems on Wall Street, are you now more worried that . . . ?
Q: How much are you personally being affected by the crisis on Wall Street and in the mortgage and housing
markets—a great deal, some, only a little, or not at all?
13
Q: All in all, do you think the Congressional financial rescue package will help or hurt your family’s financial
situation, or will it not make much of a difference?
-------The rescue package will------
Help my family’s situation Hurt No difference
Oct. 8-9, 2008 Fox/OD 16% 28% 47%
Handling the Crisis: Obama v. McCain
Q: Who do you think would be better when it comes to ____ Barack Obama or John McCain, or do you think that
both would be equally good or neither would be good?
NBC/WSJ
Q: Now I’m going to mention a few issues and for each one, please tell me if you think Barack Obama or John
McCain would better handle that issue if they were elected President.
CNN/ORC
Q: If _______ is elected president, are you confident that he and his economic advisors can fix the economy, or not?
Q: Do you approve or disapprove of the way ____ is handling the current economic crisis?
14
Miscellaneous
Q: How important is it to you that any government plan to deal with the financial problems _____?
Q: As I read statements about the current financial situation, please tell me how concerned, if at all, you are about
each. Are you very concerned, somewhat concerned, not too concerned, or not at all concerned that . . . ?
Q: As you may know, the U.S. went through a depression in the 1930s which roughly one out of four workers were
unemployed, banks failed across the country, and millions of ordinary Americans were temporarily homeless or
unable to feed their families. Do you think it is very likely, somewhat likely, not very likely, or not likely at all that
another depression like that could occur in the U.S.?
Q: Regardless of whether you favor or oppose the new government program, do you consider it mostly a bailout for
Wall Street or do you consider it mostly an attempt to rescue the economy in order to help average Americans?
15
Q: Who do you think will benefit from the government money used in the plan – mostly just a few big investors and
people who work on Wall Street, or homeowners and people throughout the country as well?
Q: As you may know, last fall Congress and President Bush approved a government program that would spend up to
seven hundred billion dollars to provide assistance to banks and other large financial institutions. About half that
money has already been spent. Do you think Congress and President Obama should or should not provide the
remaining money to banks and other financial institutions?
Q: As you may know, about half of the money from last year’s $700 billion financial rescue plan has been used and
President-elect Obama has now asked Congress for the other half to be released. Which would you rather see
happen – for Congress to allow the remaining $350 billion to be released, for Congress to block the release unless
more details are provided about how the funds will be used, or for Congress to block the release of the $350 billion
entirely?
Q: In another program, the federal government has approved using up to 700 billion dollars to help shore up
financial institutions in an attempt to help stabilize the economy. Half of that money has been used. Do you support
or oppose now making the other half available to troubled financial institutions
Support Oppose
Jan. 13-16, 2009 ABC/Wash Post 39% 58%
Q: As you may recall, last October, Congress passed and President Bush signed into law a $700 billion Troubled
Asset Relief Program, referred to as TARP, to aid the financial sector by purchasing failing bank assets. The first
half of that money, $350 billion, was authorized and distributed late last year. Last week, the Senate approved the
second half of that money, which will soon be distributed. In your opinion, was the approval of $350 billion to aid
the financial sector a . . . ?
---Approval of $350 billion---
Good idea Bad idea
Jan. 21-24, 2009 FD/Diageo/Hotline 56% 32%
16
Q: President Obama said he understands public frustration with the government help for private banks. But he said
more than the 700 billion dollars already approved would be needed to keep the banks lending and getting the
economy moving again. Do you support or oppose spending more than the 700 billion dollars on helping banks?
Q: I’d like to read you a list of some government policies that have been considered over the past 12 months. For
each one, I’d like you to tell me whether, overall, you think this policy will help the U.S. economy, will hurt the U.S.
economy, or will it have no impact?
Q: I’d like to read you a list of some government policies that have been considered over the past 12 months. For
each one, I’d like you to tell me whether, overall, you think this policy will your personal financial situation, will
hurt your personal financial situation, or will it have no impact?
Q: Do you think providing government money to banks and other financial institutions was necessary to get the
economy out of recession, or would the economy probably have improved without doing that?
17
Who’s to blame
Q: How much blame do you think ___ deserve(s) for the country’s economic situation – a great deal, a good
amount, only some, or hardly any?
ABC/Wash Post
Great deal Good amount Only some Hardly any
Banks
Mar. 26-29, 2009 56% 24% 15% 4%
Bush administration
Jul. 15-18, 2009 42 20 23 11
Mar. 26-29, 2009 47 23 21 7
Large business corporations
Mar. 26-29, 2009 57 23 14 5
Consumers
Mar. 26-29, 2009 39 33 20 7
Obama administration
Jul. 15-18, 2009 14% 17% 28% 34%
Mar. 26-29, 2009 13 13 27 39
Sept. 10-12, 2009 13 15 33 34
Jan. 12-15, 2010 14 21 36 25
Q: Thinking about the way the federal government has responded to the financial crisis in recent months, generally
speaking, do you approve or disapprove of the expansion of the government’s role in the economy?
Q: How much blame do you think banks and other financial institutions deserve for the country’s economic
situation?
Great deal Good amount Only some Hardly any None
Feb-Mar. 2010 ABC News 33% 27% 30% 8% 1%
Q: Do you think banks and other financial institutions have or have not done enough to make amends for their role
in the financial crisis?
Have Have not
Feb. 26-Mar. 2, 2010 ABC News 15% 77%
Miscellaneous
Q: Do you think the Obama administration's proposals to help the banking system will benefit all Americans by
addressing a broad economic problem, or will it only benefit bankers?
18
Q: Since last fall, the federal government has spent hundreds of billions of dollars to stabilize the nation's economy.
Which of the following statements do you think best describes the actions the government has taken? 1. Government
actions are basically working and without them things could have been a lot worse. 2. Government actions are
basically failing and without them things would be the same as they are today or even better.
Q: Would you like to have the government own and control the banks?
Q: Who do you trust more to decide how money that the federal government provides to banks and financial
institutions should be spent – the federal government or the financial institutions themselves?
Q: Do you think the Obama administration's economic plans would give the federal government too much control
over banks and financial institutions, OR not enough control over banks and financial institutions, OR the right
amount of control over banks and financial institutions?
Too much
govt. control Not enough Right amount
Feb. 18-22, 2009 CBS/NYT 28% 29% 34%
19
Q: As I read a list of some stories covered by news organizations this past week, please tell me if you
happened to follow each news story very closely, fairly closely, not too closely, or not at all closely. Did you follow
the economy very closely? (Pew Research Center)
Q: Are you hearing mostly good news about the economy these days, mostly bad news about the economy or a mix
of both good and bad news? (Pew Research Center)
Dow Jones Industrial Average Close (Dow Jones Averages)
Percent DJIA
90 16000
Hearing mostly bad
80 14000
news
DIJA
70
12000
60
10000
50
8000
40
Following very 6000
30
closely
4000
20
10 2000
0 0
Apr‐2008
May‐2008
Aug‐2008
Dec‐2008
Apr‐2009
May‐2009
Aug‐2009
Dec‐2009
Jan‐2008
Feb‐2008
Mar‐2008
Jun‐2008
Jul‐2008
Sep‐2008
Oct‐2008
Nov‐2008
Jan‐2009
Feb‐2009
Mar‐2009
Jun‐2009
Jul‐2009
Sep‐2009
Oct‐2009
Nov‐2009
Jan‐2010
Feb‐2010
---Followed the economy--- ---Kind of news about the economy--- ---Dow Jones---
Very closely Mostly Mostly A mix of DJIA close
good bad good and
news news bad news
20
Aug. 15-18, 2008 39 - - - 11628.06
Aug. 29-31, 2008 41 - - - 11543.55
Sep. 5-8, 2008 44 - - - 11421.99
Sep. 19-22, 2008 56 - - - 11143.13
Sep. 26-29, 2008 70 - - - 10831.07
Oct. 3-6, 2008 69 - - - 8451.19
Oct. 10-13, 2008 65 - - - 8852.22
Oct. 17-20, 2008 62 - - - 8378.95
Oct. 24-27, 2008 54 - - - 9325.01
Nov.3, 2008 64 - - - 8943.81
Nov. 7-10, 2008 54 - - - 8497.31
Nov. 14-17, 2008 56 - - - 8046.42
Nov. 21-24, 2008 59 - - - 8829.04
Dec. 5-8, 2008 42 1% 80% 19% 8629.68
Dec. 12-15, 2008 51 - - - 8579.11
Jan. 2-4, 2009 42 - - - 9034.69
Jan. 16-19, 2009 43 2 67 30 8281.22
Jan. 23-26, 2009 57 - - - 8000.86
Feb. 2, 2009 52 - - - 8280.59
Feb. 13-16, 2009 55 2 60 37 7365.67
Mar. 2, 2009 56 - - - 6626.94
Mar. 13-16, 2009 48 2 51 46 7278.38
Mar. 20-23, 2009 52 - - - 7776.18
Mar. 27-30, 2009 48 - - - 8017.59
Apr. 9-13, 2009 48 4 39 56 8131.33
Apr. 17-20, 2009 52 - - - 8076.29
May 1-4, 2009 47 - - - 8574.65
May 8-11, 2009 42 4 31 64 8268.64
May 15-18, 2009 44 - - - 8277.32
May 21-24, 2009 44 - - - 8500.33
Jun. 1, 2009 43 - - - 8763.13
Jun. 5-8, 2009 41 - - - 8799.26
Jun. 12-15, 2009 41 4 37 59 8539.73
Jun. 19-22, 2009 42 - - - 8438.39
Jul. 2-5, 2009 38 3 41 56 8146.52
Jul. 10-13, 2009 37 - - - 8743.94
Jul. 17-20, 2009 45 - - - 9093.24
Jul. 24-27, 2009 45 - - - 9171.61
Aug. 3, 2009 46 - - - 9370.07
Aug. 7-10, 2009 42 11 29 59 9321.4
Aug. 14-17, 2009 41 - - - 9505.96
Aug. 21-24, 2009 50 - - - 9544.2
Aug. 28-31, 2009 45 - - - 9441.27
Sep. 3-6, 2009 41 5 27 68 9605.41
Sep. 11-14, 2009 45 - - - 9820.2
Sep. 18-21, 2009 44 - - - 9665.19
Sep. 25-28, 2009 44 - - - 9487.67
Oct. 2-5, 2009 44 - - - 9864.94
Oct. 9-12, 2009 41 5 31 62 9995.91
Oct. 23-26, 2009 44 - - - 9712.73
Nov. 2, 2009 34 5 31 62 10023.42
Nov. 13-16, 2009 38 - - - 10318.16
Dec. 4-7, 2009 41 7 33 59 10471.5
Dec. 11-14, 2009 42 - - - 10328.89
Dec. 18-21, 2009 45 - - - 10520.1
Jan. 8-11 2010 39 5 29 65 10609.65
21
Jan. 15-18, 2010 37 - - - 10172.98
Jan. 22-25, 2010 41 - - - 10067.33
Feb. 1, 2010 45 - - - 10012.23
Feb. 5-8, 2010 43 4 35 61 10099.14
Feb. 12-15, 2010 35 - - - 10402.35
Feb. 19-22, 2010 38 - - - 10325.26
Mar. 1, 2010 31 - - - 10566.2
Mar. 5-8, 2010 40 4 30 66 10624.69
Note: The Dow Jones index numbers listed are the final closing measurements of the Dow at 4 p.m. on the last day
of the corresponding month.
Sources: PSRA/Pew, latest that of March 2010; Dow Jones Averages.
Q: Do you think individuals in Wall Street banks whose actions helped cause the financial crisis should be punished
by the federal government by limiting their compensation or banning them for working in the industry, or do you
think the banks are best able to address individual issues and government should not be dictating what happens at
this level?
Q: Congress is considering a proposal to increase oversight of consumer credit, including mortgages and credit
cards. To best serve consumers, do you think this should be a new, separate agency, with complete independence
and its own authority to make rules for consumer credit, or would it be better to enhance the existing system to make
sure bank regulators do more to protect consumers?
Q: When President Obama took office, he said he was determined to address the roots of the financial crisis so that
another meltdown would not happen. Do you believe the government has taken enough action to fix what was
wrong in the financial industry, has taken too little action, or do you think the government has gone too far and
taken action that will be harmful down the road?
Q: What about Wall Street banks themselves? Do you think banks have taken enough action to change what they do
to avoid a future meltdown, have taken too little action, or do you think they’ve gone too far and made changes that
will be harmful down the road?
22
Q: Do you think these banks and other financial institutions [those that took government loans to avoid bankruptcy]
owe it to the country to try to help Americans who are struggling with the economy, or do you think it’s not the
responsibility of banks and financial institutions to do that?
Q: How much do you trust the following groups to fix the problems that caused the financial crisis?
Q: Do you think Barack Obama is paying too much attention, not enough attention, or about the right amount of
attention to the concerns of banks and financial institutions?
Q: Do you think Barack Obama has paid more attention to the problems faced by middle class Americans or the
problems faced by banks and other financial institutions?
Q: In his first year in office, do you think Barack Obama has done too much for the nation’s banks and financial
institutions?
23
Auto Bailout: Most polls showed more opposition than support to providing help for the auto
companies. Americans were solidly against providing them with additional funds. Seventy percent
in a December 2008 CNN/Opinion Research Corporation poll said the federal government should let
the companies go into bankruptcy if they asked for more money in 2009. The public’s opposition is
impressive given the fact that a solid majority, 55 percent, felt that if one of the auto companies were
to go out of business, it could have a “major” impact on the country’s economy.
Q: Would you favor or oppose the federal government giving major financial assistance to the big three U.S.
automotive companies if they are close to going broke or declaring bankruptcy?
Favor Oppose
Nov. 13-16, 2008 Gallup 47% 49%
Dec. 4-7, 2008 Gallup 43 51
--(If oppose) Suppose one or more of the three major U.S. automotive companies was certain to fail unless
the government provided assistance. In that case, would you favor or oppose the federal government
providing assistance to the major U.S. automotive companies?
Favor Oppose
Nov. 13-16, 2008 Gallup 18% 79%
Dec. 4-7, 2008 Gallup 18 79
Q: The big three automakers in the United States have asked for a 25 billion dollar loan from the government.
Some people say (it’s a bailout those companies don’t deserve, and that they’d be better off reorganizing under
bankruptcy laws). Other people say (it’s necessary to protect auto workers and save a key part of the U.S.
economy). On balance, do you support or oppose this plan?
Support Oppose
Nov. 19-23, 2008 ABC/Wash Post 35% 57%
Q: The major U.S. auto companies have asked the government for a program that would provide them with several
billion dollars in assistance. The auto companies say they may go into bankruptcy without that assistance. Based
on what you have read or heard, do you favor or oppose this program?
Favor Oppose
Dec. 1-2, 2008 CNN/ORC 36% 61%
Q: The big three automakers in the United States have asked for up to 34 billion dollars in loans from the
government. Some people say it’s a bailout those companies don’t deserve, and that they’d be better off
reorganizing under bankruptcy laws. Other people say it’s necessary to protect auto workers and save a key part of
the U.S. economy. On balance, do you support or oppose this plan?
Support Oppose
Dec. 3-7, 2008 ABC/Wash Post 37% 54%
Q: Do you approve or disapprove of the federal government providing money to the big three automakers if it would
prevent them from going out of business or declaring bankruptcy?
Approve Disapprove
Dec. 4-7, 2008 CBS News 45% 44%
24
Q: If the government provides several billion dollars in assistance to the auto companies, do you think that program
would treat U.S. taxpayers fairly or unfairly?
Fairly Unfairly
Dec. 1-2, 2008 CNN/ORC 29% 70%
Q: The American automobile manufacturers—General Motors, Ford, and Chrysler—have asked Congress for
financial aid and loans to keep the companies from failing and declaring bankruptcy. In exchange, the companies
say they will change how they do business by cutting costs and focusing on producing fuel-efficient vehicles. Would
you approve or disapprove of the federal government providing financial aid and loans to the U.S. automakers? If
you do not know enough about this to have an opinion, please just say so.
Approve Disapprove
Dec. 5-8, 2008 NBC/WSJ 46% 42%
Q: Do you approve or disapprove of the federal government giving the big three U.S. automakers billions of dollars
in loan money?
Approve Disapprove
Dec. 9-10, 2008 Fox/OD 37% 58 %
Q: The federal government is considering loaning up to 14 billion dollars to the Big Three U.S. automakers and
putting in place a government board to oversee their reconstruction. Some people say it’s a bailout those
companies don’t deserve, and that they’d be better off reorganizing under bankruptcy laws. Other people say it’s
necessary to protect auto workers and save a key part of the U.S. economy. On balance, do you support or oppose
this plan?
Support Oppose
Dec. 11-14, 2008 ABC/Wash Post 42% 55%
Q: The federal government will provide some of the major U.S. auto companies with more than thirteen billion
dollars in loans in order to prevent them from going into bankruptcy. In exchange for the loans, the government
wants the auto companies to produce plans by the end of March that show how they would become viable businesses
in the long run. Do you favor or oppose this decision?
Favor Oppose
Dec. 19-21, 2008 CNN/ORC 63% 37%
Q: As you may know, the federal government has taken many steps to deal with problems in the economy in recent
months. Please tell me whether, in general, you favor or oppose the government doing each of the following. How
about ______?
Favor Oppose
Funding new government programs to help create jobs 83% 17%
Giving aid to state governments in serious financial trouble 67 30
Giving aid to homeowners who are in danger of losing their
homes to foreclosure 64 33
Giving aid to U.S. automakers who are in danger of going bankrupt 41 58
Giving aid to U.S. banks and financial companies in danger
of failing 39 59
25
Q: Now I am going to read you a series of things President Obama has done on the economy. For each one, please
tell me whether you approve or disapprove of that action?
Q: In terms of improving the economy, please say whether each of the following is critical for Barack Obama to do
as president, very important but not critical, important, but not important.
Q: We’d like your views about how much the federal government has spent so far to help certain groups affected by
the financial crisis. What about federal spending to help ______. Do you think there has been too much, too little, or
about the right amount?
Q: Do you approve or disapprove of the Obama Administration's recent proposals to deal with the financial
problems of the auto industry?
Approve Disapprove
Apr. 15-20, 2009 CBS/NYT 47% 38%
26
Q: Let me read you a series of actions taken by President Obama since he was inaugurated. For each one, please
tell me whether you approve or disapprove of this action. Dismissing GM’s chief executive and requiring big
changes in the company’s business plans as a condition for federal government loans
Approve of dismissing
GM execs and requiring
changes in business plans Disapprove
Apr. 23-26, 2009 NBC/WSJ 66% 29%
Q: I’d like to read you a list of some government policies that have been considered over the past 12 months. For
each one, I’d like you to tell me whether, overall, you think this policy will help the U.S. economy, will hurt the U.S.
economy, or will it have no impact?
A Second Aid Package for Automakers?
Q: If the major U.S. auto companies ask for more money next year, do you think the federal government should give
them any additional assistance, or should the government let them go into bankruptcy?
Q: Changing topics, imagine if one or more of the big U.S. automakers filed for protection under bankruptcy laws
while it reorganized its business structure. Do you think that would be a good thing or a bad thing for the auto
industry in the long run, or would not make much difference either way?
Q: U.S. automakers received billions of dollars of loan money from the federal government in December. Do you
approve or disapprove giving two U.S. automakers—General Motors and Chrysler—billions of dollars in additional
loan money?
Q: As you may know, in December the federal government gave 17 billion dollars in loans to General Motors and
Chrysler to keep those auto manufacturers from going bankrupt. Earlier this week, General Motors and Chrysler
asked the government for 21 billion dollars in additional loans as part of restructuring plans they submitted to the
Treasury Department. Do you think Congress should or should not approve these additional loans?
27
Q: Two of the major U.S. auto companies have asked the government for a program that would provide them with
several billion dollars in assistance. The auto companies say they may go into bankruptcy without that assistance.
Based on what you have read or heard, do you favor or oppose this program?
Favor Oppose
Feb. 18-19, 2009 CNN/ORC 37% 61%
Q: The federal government has given some of the major U.S. auto companies more than $13 billion dollars in loans
to prevent them from going into bankruptcy. Some of those auto companies now say they need more money. Should
the federal government give them additional financial assistance, or not?
Q: The federal government has provided 25 billion dollars in loans to two of the big U.S. automakers and put in
place a government board to oversee their restructuring. These automakers now say they need an additional 14
billion dollars in government loans in order to stay out of bankruptcy. Do you support or oppose providing these
additional government loans to the U.S. automakers?
Support Oppose
Feb. 19-22, 2009 ABC/Wash Post 30% 68%
Q: As you may know, U.S. automobile companies General Motors and Chrysler recently asked the government for
$21.6 billion in loans to help them avoid bankruptcy. This is in addition to their existing $17 billion government
loans. Do you support or oppose providing GM and Chrysler with these funds?
Support Oppose
Feb. 28-Mar. 2, 2009 FD/Diageo/Hotline 28% 66%
Significance of the Problem
Q: If one or more of the big three automakers were to go out of business, how much of an impact do you think that
would have on the nation’s economy? Do you think it would have a major impact, a minor impact, not much impact,
or no impact at all?
Q: If one or more of the major U.S. auto companies went into bankruptcy, what effect do you think that would have
on the U.S. economy? Do you think that would cause a crisis, major problems, minor problems, or no problems at
all for the U.S. economy?
Q: Just your best guess, do you think one or more of the big three U.S. auto companies will go out of business, or
will all three find a way to survive?
28
Who Is to Blame?
Q: Please tell me whether you think each of the following deserves a great deal of blame, some blame, not much
blame, or no blame at all for the problems faced by the three major U.S. auto companies. How about ______?
Q: Which one of the following do you think is most to blame for the U.S. auto industry’s troubles?
Q: Do you think the automakers’ problems are mainly the fault of the bad economy or mainly the fault of their own
management?
Miscellaneous
Q: If the U.S. automakers receive a government loan, how likely do you think it is that they will eventually pay back
the money?
Q: Do you approve or disapprove of the way Obama is handling the situation involving the big U.S. automakers?
Approve Disapprove
Apr. 21-24, 2009 ABC/Wash Post 41% 53%
June 18-21, 2009 ABC/Wash Post 45 50
Q: Do you think the U.S. car companies will 1. Survive on their own—without government loan money 2. Survive
only if the government loans them money 3. Fail – with our without the government loan?
Q: If the government does provide money to the big three automakers, should the government get a say in how these
companies are managed, or should the government not be involved in the companies’ management decisions?
29
Q: If the government does provide money to the big three automakers, should it require these automakers to build
more cars that use alternative fuels or should the government not be involved in deciding what kinds of cars these
companies make?
Q: Do you think it is the responsibility of the federal government to provide financial help to U.S. auto companies so
they can avoid bankruptcy?
Q: Do you think the government should play a role in ensuring that the major U.S. automobile companies do not fall
into bankruptcy?
Yes No
Feb. 28-Mar. 2, 2009 FD/Diageo/Hotline 39% 54%
Q: Do you think the government is treating the financial institutions better than the U.S. automakers, or is the
government treating the U.S. automakers better than the financial institutions, or are they treating neither one better
than the other?
Q: Do you think the federal government should provide financial help to homeowners who are having trouble
repaying their mortgages because their rates went up, or shouldn’t the federal government do this?
Q: Do you favor or oppose the federal government providing assistance to homeowners who cannot pay their
mortgages?
Favor assistance to homeowners Oppose
Oct. 17-19, 2008 CNN/ORC 58% 40%
Feb. 18-19, 2009 CNN/ORC 63 36
Mar. 12-15, 2009 CNN/ORC 56 43
Q: Do you think it is the responsibility of the federal government to provide financial help to homeowners so they
can avoid foreclosure?
30
Yes, it’s the
government’s responsibility No, it’s not
Feb. 25-Mar. 2, 2009 Quinnipiac 43% 51 %
Q: Thinking about the home mortgage crisis, who do you think is more to blame, the homeowners who took out
loans that they may not be able to pay back or the mortgage lenders who loaned the money to people who may not
be able to pay it back?
Homeowners Lenders
Feb. 25-Mar. 2, 2009 Quinnipiac 25% 62%
Q: The Obama administration has a plan to help homeowners refinance their mortgages, avoid foreclosure, and
make more credit available for mortgages. Do you think the federal government should provide this financial help to
homeowners, or shouldn't the federal government do this, or don't you know enough yet to say?
Q: On another economic issue, would you support or oppose the federal government using 75 billion dollars to
provide refinancing assistance to homeowners to help them avoid foreclosure on their mortgages?
Support Oppose
Feb. 19-22, 2009 ABC/Wash Post 64% 35%
Q: Last week President Obama announced a proposal to deal with the housing mortgage situation facing the
country. The program is designed to help homeowners refinance their mortgages and avoid foreclosure. The
government would provide lenders and borrowers with up to seventy-five billion dollars in funds to allow more
homeowners to refinance and renegotiate the terms of mortgages for homeowners who are at-risk of heading to
foreclosure. Do you think that this proposal to deal with the housing mortgage situation is a good idea or a bad
idea? If you do not have an opinion either way, please just say so.
Q: As you know, part of the program is to provide financial assistance to homeowners who are at-risk of defaulting
on their mortgage, but have not yet done so. Do you think that this condition seems fair and provides assistance to
people who have been caught up by the worst conditions in the past fifty years, or seems unfair and rewards people
who have not been financially responsible?
Q: Do you think providing government aid to certain homeowners who cannot pay their mortgage is fair, or unfair?
Fair Unfair
Feb. 20-22, 2009 Gallup/USA Today 46% 51%
Q: Do you approve or disapprove of President Obama's 75 billion dollar plan to help homeowners avoid
foreclosure?
Support Obama’s
homeowner plan Oppose
Feb. 25-Mar. 2, 2009 Quinnipiac 57% 35%
31
Q: Do you think providing government aid to certain homeowners who cannot pay their mortgages is necessary, or
not necessary to help stabilize the U.S. housing market?
Aid to homeowners
is necessary Isn’t necessary
Feb. 20-22, 2009 Gallup/USA Today 59% 38%
Q: And, from what you have seen, read or heard about President Obama’s proposed $75 billion in which the
government would help prevent foreclosures on individual homes, do you support or oppose this proposal?
Support Oppose
Feb. 28-Mar. 2, 2009 FD/Diageo/Hotline 56% 36%
Q: And, putting aside for a moment whether or not you, personally, support or oppose this plan, do you think that it
will help bring stability to the housing market?
Yes No
Feb. 28-Mar. 2, 2009 FD/Diageo/Hotline 57% 33%
Q: As you may know, the government has taken or is considering other steps to address economic problems facing
the nation. Do you think it is the right thing or the wrong thing for the government to spend billions of dollars?
Q: Some people say that President Obama's plan to help homeowners avoid foreclosure isn't fair to mortgage
holders who make payments on time. Do you agree or disagree?
Agree Disagree
Feb. 25-Mar. 2, 2009 Quinnipiac 64% 29%
32
The Stimulus: Majorities favored the stimulus package in most early polls about it. According
to CBS News’s February 2009 poll, 51 percent approved of the federal government plan of about
$800 billion. Still, there was a good amount of skepticism and dissatisfaction with the package. When
Gallup asked about it in their late January-early February survey, only 38 percent wanted to pass the
bill as is. Thirty-seven percent wanted major changes and 17 percent said the bill should be rejected.
. President Obama signed the legislation on February 17, 2009. In a mid-February Fox News/Opinion
Dynamics poll, 58 percent said it was necessary for Congress to pass legislation for the economy to
improve, while 34 percent said it would have improved on its own.
People’s enthusiasm about the stimulus package started dimming in the summer. In late
September-early October 2009 Pew poll, people were split about whether they favored or opposed it.
In their February 2010 poll, 38 percent favored it and 49 percent were opposed. Other polls from
early 2010 show more opposition than support. In a February 2010 CBS News/New York Times poll,
just 6 percent said the stimulus had already created a substantial number of new jobs, 41 percent said
it would create a substantial number but had not done so yet, and 48 percent said it would not create
a substantial number of new jobs.
Q: As you may know, the federal government will spend up to 700 billion dollars on construction projects and other
programs. Do you support or oppose this plan? Do you feel that way strongly or somewhat?
Q: Do you favor or oppose Congress passing a new $775 billion dollar economic stimulus package?
Favor Oppose
Jan. 6-7, 2009 Gallup 53% 36 %
Q: As you may know, Congress is considering a new economic stimulus package of at least 800 billion dollars. Do
you favor or oppose Congress passing this legislation?
Favor Oppose
Jan. 27, 2009 Gallup 52% 37%
Feb. 4, 2009 Gallup 52 38
Feb. 17, 2009 Gallup 59 33
Q: When it comes to the economic stimulus plan proposed by the Obama administration, which of these two
statements comes closer to your point of view? Statement A: The economic stimulus plan is a good idea because it
will help make the recession shorter, get people back to work, and provide money for transportation, education, and
Medicaid programs. Statement B: The economic stimulus plan is a bad idea because it will do little to shorten the
recession, the jobs are temporary, and it will significantly increase the deficit.
33
Q: Do you think that the recently proposed economic stimulus legislation is a good idea or a bad idea?
Q: Let me read you a couple of programs that are being discussed right now. For each one please tell me whether
you tend to support this program or tend to oppose this program.
Support Oppose
The program to help some homeowners avoid foreclosure 68% 25%
President Obama's program to help some homeowners avoid foreclosure 67 28
President Obama's economic stimulus package 57 34
The economic stimulus package 57 34
Q: People have criticized a number of things about the stimulus package. Which one or two of the following
criticisms cause you the most concern?
Q: Would you favor or oppose a proposal to attempt to stimulate the economy by increasing federal government
spending on construction projects and economic assistance to some Americans by about eight hundred billion
dollars?
Favor Oppose
Dec. 19-21, 2008 CNN/ORC 56% 42%
Jan. 12-15, 2009 CNN/ORC 58 40
--And if that economic stimulus plan also included tax cuts for individuals and businesses, would you favor
or oppose that proposal?
Favor Oppose
Jan. 12-15, 2009 CNN/ORC 71% 28%
34
Q: As you may know, the U.S. Senate is expected to vote on a bill that would attempt to stimulate the economy by
increasing federal government spending and cutting taxes at a total cost to the government of about eight hundred
billion dollars. Based on what you have read or heard about this, do you favor or oppose the bill that the Senate is
expected to vote on?
Favor Oppose
Feb. 7-8, 2009 CNN/ORC 54% 45%
Q: As you may know, Congress passed and President Obama has signed a bill that will attempt to stimulate the
economy by increasing federal government spending and cutting taxes at a total cost to the government of about
eight hundred billion dollars. Based on what you have read or heard about this, do you favor or oppose that bill?
Q: If that bill does not improve economic conditions, would you favor or oppose another bill that would increase
government spending even further in an attempt to stimulate the economy?
Favor another
Stimulus Oppose
Mar. 12-15, 2009 CNN/ORC 32% 66%
Q: Do you support or oppose Obama’s proposed economic recovery plan that would, among other things, use tax
dollars to increase spending by the federal government by up to nearly one trillion dollars on infrastructure projects
and tax cuts for middle class Americans?
Support Oppose
Jan. 13-14, 2009 Fox/OD 58% 29%
Q: Do you support or oppose the nearly 800 billion dollar economic stimulus and spending plan Congress passed
last week?
Support Oppose
Feb. 17-18, 2009 Fox/OD 51% 40%
--(If support) Which one of the following best describes the main reason you support the economic stimulus
and spending plan?
--(If oppose) Which one of the following best describes the main reason you oppose the economic stimulus
and spending plan?
35
Not enough spending 1
Q: Do you think it was necessary for Congress to pass legislation for the economy to improve or do you think the
economy would have improved anyway?
Q: Barack Obama and his advisors as well as members of Congress has said the nation’s economy is in such bad
shape that a stimulus package of about $775 billion dollars is necessary to keep the economy from getting worse.
From what you have heard or read, do you mostly agree or disagree that a large stimulus package is needed in
order to keep the economy from getting worse?
Agree Disagree
Jan. 11-15, 2009 CBS/NYT 69% 23%
Q: Would you approve or disapprove of the federal government passing a 775 billion dollar economic stimulus
package in order to try to help the economy?
Approve Disapprove
Jan. 11-15, 2009 CBS/NYT 63% 24%
Q: Would you approve or disapprove of the federal government passing an economic stimulus bill costing more than
800 billion dollars in order to try to help the economy?
Approve Disapprove
Feb. 2-4, 2009 CBS 51% 39%
Q: If Congress passes an economic stimulus plan, do you think that the projects that the government will spend
money on will mostly be useful projects that will benefit the economy, or mostly be projects that are included for
purely political reasons and will have no economic impact.
CNN/ORC
----Stimulus projects have been----
Mostly useful/ Mostly political with no
will benefit economy economic impact
Jan. 12-15, 2009 57% 42%
Jan. 8-10, 2010* 36 63
Note: * Question wording in January 2010 was, “Do you think that the projects that the government has spend
money on under the bill have mostly been useful projects that will benefit the economy, or have mostly been
projects that were included in the bill for purely political reasons and will have no economic impact?” In the next
question in the poll when people were asked how much of the money spent under that bill so far has been wasted, 21
percent said nearly all, 24 percent most, 29 percent about half, 21 percent little, and 4 percent none.
Q: Based on what you have heard or read about the stimulus package so far, do you think it is about what is needed
to stimulate the economy, does it go too far, or does it not go far enough?
Q: In response to the economic crisis, do you think Congress will move too quickly, will move too slowly, or will
move at about the right pace?
36
Q: Congress has passed President Obama's economic stimulus package which includes tax cuts and new federal
spending of about 800 billion dollars. Do you support or oppose this economic stimulus package?
Support Oppose
Feb. 25-Mar. 2, 2009 Quinnipiac 55% 39%
Q: Do you think the economic stimulus and spending plan is too large, about the right size, or too small?
Q: With the current stimulus package being considered, the total cost of the economic stimulus could total one
trillion dollars. Is spending this amount of money . . . ?
Q: Do you think that an economic stimulus package is necessary to improve the current state of the economy, or
not?
Q: How much if anything , have you heard about the economic stimulus package being proposed by the President
Obama that might cost $800 billion?
Heard a lot/
Heard a little Heard nothing
Jan. 7-11, 2009 PSRA/Pew 86% 14%
Feb. 4-8, 2009 PSRA/Pew 91 9
Note: The January, 2009 question referred to the “economic stimulus package being proposed by President-elect
Obama.”
(If heard) From what you’ve read or heard, do you think this plan is a good idea or a bad idea?
Q: From what you’ve read and heard, do you think Barack Obama’s roughly 800 billion dollar economic stimulus
plan passed by Congress last month is a good idea or a bad idea?
Stimulus is a
good idea Bad idea
Mar. 9-12, 2009 PSRA/Pew 56% 35%
Q: From what you’ve read and heard, do you approve or disapprove of Barack Obama’s 800 billion dollar
economic stimulus plan passed by Congress in February 2009?
Approve Disapprove
Jun. 10-14, 2009 PSRA/Pew 55% 39%
Sept. 30-Oct. 4, 2009 PSRA/Pew 44 44
Feb. 3-9, 2010* PSRA/Pew 38 49
Note: * Question wording read “…last February?”
37
Q: Do you favor or oppose each of the following as part of a new economic stimulus package?
Q: Now I’m going to read you some areas where federal spending might be increased to try to stimulate the
economy or improve economic conditions over the long term. Please tell me if you would favor or oppose each of
the following spending increases, even if it means raising the federal budget deficit?
Favor Oppose
To build and repair roads, bridges, and other infrastructure 75% 23%
To provide loans and other financial support to U.S. industries
hurt by the mortgage crisis and problems on Wall Street 36 58
To develop new clean energy technology 74 23
To make health care more accessible and affordable 76 21
Q: Do you think Congress should pass Obama’s economic stimulus plan basically as Barack Obama has proposed
it, pass it but only after making major changes, or reject this plan?
Q: Would you favor or oppose Congress passing a smaller economic stimulus package that would cut the size by up
to 200 billion dollars?
Favor Oppose
Feb. 4, 2009 Gallup/USA Today 48% 41%
Q: As you may know, Congress is considering a new economic stimulus package of at least $800 billion. Do you
favor or oppose Congress passing this legislation?
Favor Oppose
Feb. 10, 2009 Gallup 59% 33%
Q: Congress has passed President Obama's economic stimulus package which includes tax cuts and new federal
spending of about 800 billion dollars. Do you support or oppose this economic stimulus package?
Q: Which one of the following three statements best describes your opinion of the 800 billion dollar stimulus
package recently signed into law by the President? It’s the right amount of government spending to help turn the
economy around. Or, it’s a good start, but more spending will be needed for it to be effective. Or, it won’t work and
government should not be spending money for economic stimulus.
38
Q: We’d like your views about how much the federal government has spent so far to help certain groups affected by
the financial crisis. What about federal spending to help ______. Do you think there has been too much, too little, or
about the right amount?
Q: Which of these do you think is more important right now – increasing federal spending to try to improve the
economy, even if it sharply increases the federal budget deficit, or avoiding a big increase in the federal budget
deficit, even if it means not increasing federal spending to try to improve the economy?
Q: In general do you support or oppose Congress and the President passing an $825 billion economic stimulus plan
to jumpstart the economy, even if it means increasing the federal deficit in order to do so?
Support Oppose
Jan. 21-24, 2009 FD/Diageo/Hotline 54% 34%
Q: As proposed , the $825 billion economic stimulus package would include $550 billion in new spending for
alternative energy technology, roads and bridges, state governments, and local school districts, and increasing
benefits for the unemployed. The remaining part of the stimulus package contains $275 billion in tax cuts and
credits for individuals and for business to help generate more jobs. In general, do you support or oppose Congress
and the President passing this $825 billion economic stimulus plan to jumpstart the economy, even if it means
increasing the federal deficit in order to do so?
Support Oppose
Jan. 21-24, 2009 FD/Diageo/Hotline 66% 27%
Q: I’d like to read you a list of some government policies that have been considered over the past 12 months. For
each one, I’d like you to tell me whether, overall, you think this policy will help the U.S. economy, will hurt the U.S.
economy, or will it have no impact?
39
Will It/Has It Work?
Q: Do you think that bill will or will not result in a significant improvement in the nation’s economy?
Q: And, when thinking about the economic stimulus package passed by Congress and signed into law by the
president, how confident are you that it will be successful in turning around the economy?
Q: If the Senate bill becomes law, do you think that would help the economy a lot, some, not much, or not at all?
Q: From what you know, what impact will the stimulus package have on the current economic crisis – will it make
things better, make things worse, or will it have no impact?
Q: From what you know so far, do you think the economic stimulus package will create a substantial number of
new jobs, or won't it create a substantial number of new jobs, or don't you know enough yet to say?
Q: Do you think that bill will or will not result in a significant improvement in the nation's economy?
Q: All in all, do you think Barack Obama’s proposed $825 billion dollar economic recovery plan will help or hurt
the nation’s economy, or will it not make much of a difference?
Q: So far, do you think the federal government’s stimulus package has made the economy better, made the economy
worse, or has it had no impact on the economy so far?
40
Dec. 4-8, 2009 CBS News/NYT 32 15 46
Apr. 5-12, 2010 CBS News/NYT 32 18 44
Q: In the long run, do you think the federal government’s stimulus package will make the economy better, will make
the economy worse, or will it have no impact on the economy in the long run?
Q: From what you know so far, which comes closest to your own view?
CBS/NYT
Q: So far, do you think the economic stimulus program has helped _____ , hurt, or hasn’t made much difference?
ABC/Wash Post
Helped Hurt No difference
The national economy
Apr. 21-24, 2009 33% 16% 49%
June 18-21, 2009 28 19 52
Sept. 10-12, 2009 32 19 47
Nov. 12-15, 2009 37 23 39
Your personal financial situation
Apr. 21-24, 2009 14 12 73
Your local community
Apr. 21-24, 2009 24 10 65
Q: Assuming, for a moment, that this stimulus package is passed by Congress and the President and becomes law,
how confident are you that the stimulus package will be effective in turning around the economy?
Q: What impact do you think the economic stimulus package _______ on our nation’s economy ?
41
Q: And what impact do you think the economic stimulus package _______ on you personally?
Q: Do you think the economic bill being negotiated by the President and Congress will shorten the length of the
recession, or not? If Yes, will the economic stimulus bill shorten the recession significantly, or not significantly?
Q: In terms of improving the economy, how important do you think it is that the government pass an economic
stimulus plan – critically important, important, but not critical or not that important?
Q: Do you think the economic stimulus bill recently passed by Congress and signed by the President will shorten
the length of the current recession, or not? IF YES: Will the economic stimulus bill shorten the recession
significantly, or not?
Yes, shorten Yes, shorten No, will not
significantly not significantly not shorten
Feb. 18-22, 2009 CBS/NYT 19% 17% 50%
Q: How confident are you that this economic stimulus plan will make the current economic downturn less severe
than it would be otherwise – very confident, somewhat confident, not so confident or not confident at all?
Q: Do you think the economic stimulus plan will help or hurt the local economy in your area? Do you think it will
help/hurt a great deal or just somewhat?
Q: Do you think the economic stimulus plan will help or hurt your own personal financial situation? Do you think it
will help/hurt a great deal or just somewhat?
Q: And thinking about the next twelve months, how much do you think the economic stimulus package will help the
American economy––a great deal, quite a bit, only a little, or not at all?
42
Jul. 24-27, 2009 NBC/WSJ 8 20 47 20
Q: And thinking about the next two to four years, how much do you think the economic stimulus package will help
the American economy––a great deal, quite a bit, only a little, or not at all?
Q: Has the economic stimulus and spending plan that was passed in February been more or less effective than you
expected it would be, or has it been about as effective as you expected?
Q: Do you think that the recently passed economic stimulus legislation is beginning to help improve the economy,
will help improve the economy in the future, or will it not help improve the economy?
Q: How effective do you think the economic stimulus and spending plan that was passed in February has been –
very effective, somewhat effective, not very effective or not at all effective?
Q: Regardless of whether you favor or oppose the economic stimulus bill that Congress passed, do you think it
would have been better for the government to have spent more money to stimulate the economy, better for the
government to have spent less money to stimulate the economy, or was the amount of spending in the bill about
right?
Q: Next, we’d like you to think about the 787 billion dollar economic stimulus plan passed earlier this year and its
effect on the U.S. economy, both in the short term and in the long term. First, in the short term do you think the
economic stimulus plan has made the economy better than if the stimulus plan was not passed, has it not had an
effect, or made the economy worse than if the stimulus plan had not passed?
Q: In the long term, do you think the economic stimulus plan will make the economy better, not have an effect, or
make the economy worse?
43
Q: Do you think that without the economic stimulus legislation that the U.S. economy would have gone into a
greater economic downturn than it did, or not?
Yes No
Sept. 17-20, 2009 NBC/WSJ 46 43
Mar. 11-14, 2010* NBC/WSJ 45 46
Note: *Asked of half sample.
Q: Many economists say that using standards they apply, the recession probably is over. Thinking about your own
experience of economic conditions, would you say that from your point of view the recession is over, or not over?
Q: Regardless of whether or not the recession is over, in terms of your own personal experience, do you feel the
economy has or has not begun to recover?
Q: Do you think that the projects that the government has spent money on under that bill (stimulus) have mostly
been useful projects that will benefit the economy, or have mostly been projects that were included in the bill for
purely political reasons and will have no economic impact?
Q: How much of the money spent under that bill so far do you think has been wasted – nearly all of it, most of it,
about half of it, only a little of it, or none of it?
Q: Do you think the economic stimulus package passed by Congress last year is helping the economy, is keeping the
economy from getting worse, is having no effect, or is hurting the economy?
Q: Think about the economic stimulus passed by Congress last year do you think the stimulus has helped the job
situation, or has it not helped the job situation?
44
Q: And thinking about the loans the federal government provided to troubled banks and financial institution, which
statement comes closer to your view?
Approval of Policymakers Handling of the Crisis
Q: Do you approve disapprove of the way each of the following has handled the government’s efforts to pass an
economic stimulus bill? How about _____?
Approve Disapprove
President Barack Obama 67% 25%
The Democrats in Congress 48 42
The Republicans in Congress 31 58
Q: In drafting the economic stimulus and spending plan, do you think Barack Obama has sincerely tried to reach
out to Republicans and be bipartisan, or not?
Q: And do you think Republicans have sincerely tried to be helpful to Barack Obama and be bipartisan in drafting
the economic stimulus and spending plan, or not?
Q: Regardless of how you feel about the bill itself, how do you feel about the fact that this bill was passed by
Congress within the first month of Obama's presidency? Do you consider the passage of this bill to be a major
victory for Obama, a minor accomplishment for Obama, or not a positive achievement at all?
Effect on Individuals
Q: Do you think the economic recovery plan will help or hurt your personal financial situation, or will it not make
much difference?
Will help my situation Hurt No difference
Feb. 17-18, 2009 Fox/OD 24% 19% 54%
Q: Do you think that bill will or will not result in a significant improvement in your own personal financial
situation?
Bill will result in
significant improvement Will not
Feb. 18-29, 2009 CNN/ORC 31% 67%
45
Q: Next, please think about the effect of Barak Obama’s stimulus plan will have on your family’s financial situation
in the short and long therm. First, up until now, do you think Obama’s economic stimulus plan has made your
financial situation better, not had an effect, or made your financial situation worse?
Q: In the long term, do you think Obama’s economic stimulus plan will make your financial situation better, not
have an effect, or make your financial situation worse?
Q: Do you think that bill (stimulus) has helped, hurt, or had no effect on each of the following groups . . .?
Q: Which of the following statements comes closest to your view of the effect of that bill (stimulus) has had on
economic conditions in the country?
Q: Which of the following statements comes closest to your view of the effect that bill has had on your personal
financial situation?
--------Country-------- --------Personal--------
It has improved economic conditions 12% It has improved your situation 7%
Economic conditions have not, Your situation has not improved,
improved but it prevented conditions but it prevented conditions from
from becoming worse 46 becoming even worse 25
It had no effect on economic It had no effect on your situation 48
conditions 22
It has made economic conditions It has made your situation worse 20
worse 19
46
Miscellaneous
Q: How confident are you that the federal government will put in place adequate controls to avoid waste and fraud
in the use of federal money in the economic recovery effort?
Q: In your opinion which will do more to get the U.S. out of the current recession: increasing government spending,
or reducing taxes on business?
Q: What do you think is the most effective way to help the economy out of recession – spending by individuals and
businesses or spending by government?
Q: Many different ideas are being considered for how best to stimulate the economy. Do you think the economic
stimulus plan should focus mainly on using taxpayer dollars to increase government spending on new programs and
infrastructure project or mainly on cutting taxes for businesses and individuals?
Q: Does the news about stimulus packages and the federal government giving financial aid to several major
corporations make you feel like the country is drifting away from capitalism and more toward socialism or don’t
you feel that way?
Yes No
Jan. 13-14, 2009 Fox/OD 50% 37%
Q: Do you think the press is portraying the economic crisis to be worse than it really is, not as bad as it really is, or
is the press giving a fairly accurate portrayal of the economic crisis?
Q: Under one economic stimulus plan, most taxpayers would have their taxes cut by at least five hundred dollars. If
your taxes were cut by that much, what would you do with that money—spend it, save or invest it, pay off bills, or
donate it to charity?
47
Q: In general, do you think the federal government is doing too much to try to stimulate the economy at a time of
recession, not enough, or about the right amount?
Q: How confident are you that the following elements of the proposed economic stimulus package will improve the
economy? What about _____?
Q: Elected officials in Washington are trying to come up with ways to improve the economy – do you think they are
part of the problem or part of the solution?
Q: Do you think it is important for the economic stimulus bill to have the support of both Democrats and
Republicans in Congress, or do you think it is okay for the Democrats to pass the economic stimulus bill without
getting Republican support?
Q: In response to the current economic crisis, do you think Congress is moving too fast, moving too slowly, or
moving at about the right place?
Moving too fast Too slowly Right pace
Feb. 2-4, 2009 CBS 16% 38% 39%
Q: What do you think will do more right now to stimulate the economy and create jobs?
Q: Thinking about both the tax cuts and new government programs in the Senate bill, do you think the bill will result
in the government spending too much money, not enough money, or about the right amount of money?
Q: Do you think the economic recovery legislation that passed last week is better described as a stimulus bill or a
spending bill?
48
Q: Recently New York Senator Chuck Schumer said “the American people really don’t care” if the economic
recovery bill includes “porky amendments.” Do you care if the economic recovery bill includes earmarks or pork –
that is, spending items that only benefit certain Congressional districts or pet projects in elected official’s home
state?
Yes, I care No
Feb. 17-18, 2009 Fox/OD 79% 15%
Q: When talking about the economic situation, Barack Obama says a failure to act now will turn crisis into a
catastrophe and guarantee a longer recession – do you think this description is too negative and Obama is
intentionally overstating how bad things are, or is he giving what he thinks is an accurate description of the
country’s economic situation?
Q: In general, the stimulus package provides tax cuts for individuals and businesses, extends unemployment benefits
and tries to create jobs by spending money on technology and infrastructure programs like building highways. From
what you know, do you think the package is large enough to stimulate the economy or will more money be needed in
the months ahead to stimulate the economy?
Q: From what you know so far, what do you think about the number of tax cuts for businesses and individuals
included in the economic stimulus package -- are there too many tax cuts, too few tax cuts, about the right amount of
tax cuts, or don't you know enough yet to say?
Too many cuts Too few About right Don’t know enough
Feb. 18-22, 2009 CBS/NYT 9% 20% 17% 51%
Q: From what you know so far, what do you think about the government spending on technology and infrastructure
projects included in the economic stimulus package -- is there too much spending on technology and infrastructure
projects, too little spending on technology and infrastructure projects, about the right amount of spending on
technology and infrastructure projects, or don't you know enough yet to say?
Q: In your opinion, which will do MORE to protect or create jobs: increased government spending on
infrastructure, health care, education and other fields, OR tax cuts that would put more money in the hands of
individuals and businesses?
Q: Most Republican members of Congress opposed the stimulus package. Do you think they opposed it mostly
because they thought it would be bad for the economy or mostly for political reasons?
49
Q: In terms of ______, do you think the stimulus package goes too far, does not go far enough, or is it about right?
Q: Would you support or oppose additional federal spending above the 787 billion dollars already set aside to try to
stimulate the economy? Do you feel that way strongly or somewhat?
Support Oppose
Jul. 15-18, 2009 ABC/Wash Post 35% 61%
Q: If the Congress had not passed the economic stimulus and spending bill and instead done nothing, do you think
the nation’s economy would be in better shape than it is today, worse shape, or would the economy be in about the
same shape as it is today?
Q: Since the crisis in the financial markets last fall, how much progress has the government made in fixing the
problems that caused the crisis?
PSRA/Pew
Sept. – Oct. 2009 Apr. 2010
A great deal of progress 2% 3%
Some progress 26 28
Just a little progress 46 42
No progress 23 25
Q: Which do you think would do more to help create jobs right now – cutting taxes on individuals and small
businesses, or passing a new government stimulus plan focused on job creation?
Q: What do you think should happen with the estimated two hundred billion dollars that is left over from the federal
government’s bank bailouts – should it be used to pay for other government programs, to reduce the federal deficit,
or should it be returned to taxpayers?
50
Stimulus and the Deficit
Q: Which of the following concerns you more? That the federal government will spend too much money trying to
boost the economy and as a result will drive up the budget deficit, or that the federal government will spend too little
money trying to boost the economy and as a result the recession will be longer?
51
Key Events in the Financial Crisis
• September 15, 2008: Lehman Brothers files for bankruptcy protection; Dow falls 504 points
• September 20, 2008: President Bush proposes $700 billion bailout plan
• September 29, 2008: House rejects Wall Street bailout plan; Dow falls 778 points.
• October 3, 2008: President Bush signs bailout bill
• December 1, 2008: News of official recession sends Dow down 680 points
• December 11, 2008: New jobless claims reach 26-year high
• January 20, 2009: Barack Obama inaugurated
• February 17, 2009: President Obama signs $787 billion stimulus package
• February 18, 2009: Obama announces the Homeowner Affordability and Stability Plan
• March 6, 2009: Unemployment rate hits 25-year high
• June 1, 2009: General Motors files for bankruptcy
• July 24, 2009: “Cash for Clunkers” program begins
If you’d like to be added to the mailing list, please feel to contact Andrew Rugg at
Andrew.Rugg@aei.org.