Asset Pareto Analysis Report

Site ID ED

Asset Class BREAKER

Class Description Substation Breaker

Failure Code Failure Description Failure Count Failure % Estimated Gross Actual Gross
Cost Cost

GASLOW Gas Alarm - Low Pressure 1880 27.50% $ 71,362.91 $ 595,620.56

GASNOALR Gas No Alarm 599 8.76% $ 0.00 $ 127,551.58

FAILCLOS Failure To Close 572 8.37% $ 175,805.55 $ 723,159.56

AIRALARM Air Alarm 443 6.48% $ 1.00 $ 266,422.81

 Asset Pareto Analysis Report
Site ID ED

Asset Class BREAKER

Class Description Substation Breaker

Failure Code Failure Description Failure Count Failure % Estimated Gross Actual Gross
Cost Cost

GASSINGL Gas Alarm - Single Pressure 410 6.00% $ 82,315.50 $ 363,458.03

ANIMAL Animal 387 5.66% $ 60,877.79 $ 149,069.66

AIRCMPRE Air Compressor 286 4.18% $ 7,156.18 $ 155,427.81

CNTLCAB Control Cabinet 245 3.58% $ 34.43 $ 88,959.60

OP.CHECK Op. Check 239 3.50% $ 1,310.95 $ 392,526.53

FAILTRIP Failure To Trip 172 2.52% $ 6,528.98 $ 196,219.52

GASHIGH Gas Alarm - High Pressure 140 2.05% $ 58,910.96 $ 433,884.38

AIRLEAKN Air Leak, No Alarm 121 1.77% $ 50,377.61 $ 144,545.91

GAUGE Gauge 110 1.61% $ 8,082.74 $ 34,163.74

EXERFAIL Exercise Fail 92 1.35% $ 1.00 $ 73,516.60

HYDALARM Hydraulic Alarm 89 1.30% $ 501.00 $ 161,971.06

BUSHEXT Bushing Hot Spot External 86 1.26% $ 16,811.07 $ 36,685.17

ACLOWOIL Air Compressor Low Oil Level 80 1.17% $ 0.00 $ 15,392.84

CONTPOWR Control Power 71 1.04% $ 900.00 $ 55,147.41

MOTRCNTL Motor Control 60 0.88% $ 0.00 $ 29,359.96

OILLEAK Oil Leak 52 0.76% $ 31,001.00 $ 75,056.39

BUSHLOW Bushing Low Oil Level/Leak 49 0.72% $ 2.00 $ 60,765.97

INSMEMBR Insulating Member 45 0.66% $ 4.00 -$ 43,037.00

CONTACT Contact 44 0.64% $ 16,002.00 $ 97,180.43

DOBLEAPS Doble Test APS 42 0.61% $ 41,517.84 $ 139,006.81

TRIPFDR Feeder Breaker Trip 41 0.60% $ 0.00 $ 33,116.35

GCLOWOIL Gas Compressor Low Oil Level 41 0.60% $ 0.00 $ 15,858.42

 Asset Pareto Analysis Report
Site ID ED

Asset Class BREAKER

Class Description Substation Breaker

Failure Code Failure Description Failure Count Failure % Estimated Gross Actual Gross
Cost Cost

GAS Low Gas 41 0.60% $ 0.00 $ 6,833.03

FAILOPER Failure To Operate 39 0.57% $ 1.00 $ 26,906.02

BUSHING Bushing Failures 33 0.48% $ 125,390.38 $ 156,014.70

THERMAPS Thermoscan APS 23 0.34% $ 15,900.00 $ 25,074.61

FMSPESET Failure To Meet Specified Setting 18 0.26% $ 1.00 $ 23,906.72

INSYSDET Insulation System Deterioration 17 0.25% $ 5.00 $ 71,542.26

BUSHINT Bushing Hot Spot Internal 17 0.25% $ 18,532.00 $ 58,342.48

INTERRUP Interrupter Erosion 16 0.23% $ 35,001.00 $ 205,760.30

LEAKA Air Leak 15 0.22% $ 0.00 $ 10,887.76

INCTELQY Incorrect Telemetered Quantity 15 0.22% $ 0.00 $ 6,809.38

FALSTRIP False Trip 14 0.20% $ 0.00 $ 22,323.84

YARD Substation Yard 14 0.20% $ 1,683.94 $ 9,687.43

CLOSCOIL Close Coil 13 0.19% $ 0.00 $ 5,034.20

LEAKG Gas Leak 12 0.18% $ 0.00 $ 6,642.14

 Asset Pareto Analysis Report
Site ID ED

Asset Class BREAKER

Class Description Substation Breaker

Failure Code Failure Description Failure Count Failure % Estimated Gross Actual Gross
Cost Cost

BUSHPF Bushing Power Factor (Doble) 10 0.15% $ 50,000.00 $ 80,381.19

FT Failure to Trip 9 0.13% $ 0.00 $ 3,650.68

DOBLFAIL Doble Fail 8 0.12% $ 56,083.82 $ 79,422.49

AIRCOMPR Air Compressor Drive Motor 8 0.12% $ 0.00 $ 6,919.01

RLYACCES Relay Access 8 0.12% $ 1.00 $ 3,420.01

CT Current Transformer Failures 7 0.10% $ 7,004.00 $ 36,505.17

FAILTARG Failure to Target 7 0.10% $ 0.00 $ 3,790.13

PCBCLEAN PCB Clean-up / Spill 7 0.10% $ 0.00 $ 724.46

BUSPROBL Buss Problem 6 0.09% $ 0.00 $ 44,997.65

NOCONTRL No Control 6 0.09% $ 0.00 $ 2,438.92

FC Failure to Close 5 0.07% $ 0.00 $ 2,208.98

INCSTAPO Incorrect Status Point 4 0.06% $ 0.00 $ 7,425.81

BUSHHIGH Bushing High Oil Level/Leak 4 0.06% $ 0.00 $ 4,766.68

SWCGEAR Switch Gear, Cell Heater Check 4 0.06% $ 0.00 $ 2,036.84

CLOSPILT Close Pilot Valve 4 0.06% $ 0.00 $ 1,090.51

GASARMSP Gas Alarm Single Pressure 4 0.06% $ 0.00 $ 248.57

BUSHING6 Bushing PF (Doble) 3 0.04% $ 0.00 $ 32,300.28

HOTSPOT Hot Spot 3 0.04% $ 1.00 $ 32,052.14

BLOWFUSE Blown Fuse 3 0.04% $ 0.00 $ 4,650.19

TRIPCOIL Trip Coil 3 0.04% $ 0.00 $ 2,683.52

BUSHHIPT Bushing Hi-Pot 3 0.04% $ 0.00 $ 1,887.11

FAILURE Failue 3 0.04% $ 0.00 $ 1,199.14

 Asset Pareto Analysis Report
Site ID ED

Asset Class BREAKER

Class Description Substation Breaker

Failure Code Failure Description Failure Count Failure % Estimated Gross Actual Gross
Cost Cost

VACUMBOT Vacuum Bottle Failure 2 0.03% $ 0.00 $ 10,166.21

BUSHING7 Bushing Hi-Pot 2 0.03% $ 0.00 $ 9,448.74

BUSHCAP Bushing Capacitance (Doble) 2 0.03% $ 0.00 $ 6,216.49

ANUNCTOR Annunciators 2 0.03% $ 0.00 $ 5,345.65

HYDCHECK Hydraulic Check Valve 2 0.03% $ 0.00 $ 3,561.49

AIRCOMP Air Compressor Fail 2 0.03% $ 0.00 $ 3,370.18

AIRPRESS Air Pressure Switch 2 0.03% $ 0.00 $ 2,580.36

LEAKH Hydraulic Leak 2 0.03% $ 0.00 $ 807.29

BADREAD Bad Readings 2 0.03% $ 0.00 $ 627.33

SF6HEATR SF6 Gas Heater 2 0.03% $ 0.00 $ 363.23

CONTBRKR Control Breaker 2 0.03% $ 0.00 $ 115.18

COARREPL CUTOUT/ARRESTER REPLACE 1 0.01% $ 1.00 $ 12,465.93

DOBLELOW Doble Low 1 0.01% $ 0.00 $ 5,515.30

GASCOMP Gas Compressor Fail 1 0.01% $ 0.00 $ 961.77

DC Damage Claims 1 0.01% $ 0.00 $ 841.38

SPRNGMTR Spring Charge Motor 1 0.01% $ 0.00 $ 810.57

LOSSCOMM Loss of Communications 1 0.01% $ 0.00 $ 431.58

1 0.01% $ 0.00 $ 329.03

 Asset Pareto Analysis Report
Site ID ED

Asset Class BREAKER

Class Description Substation Breaker

Failure Code Failure Description Failure Count Failure % Estimated Gross Actual Gross
Cost Cost

BDCONNEC Bad Connect 1 0.01% $ 0.00 $ 278.66

BUSHING1 Bushing Low Oil Level 1 0.01% $ 0.00 $ 226.90

BUSHING5 Hot Spot - Connector 1 0.01% $ 0.00 $ 113.45

INCDKWHQ Incorrect DKWH Quantity 1 0.01% $ 0.00 $ 30.54

DRIVEGER Drive Gear 1 0.01% $ 0.00 $ 23.92

DRIVEBLT Drive Belt 1 0.01% $ 0.00 $ 0.00

Total Gross Cost $ 939,109.65 $ 5,476,225.63