Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
2008
Ananda Silva∗
∗
Ananda Silva, Director of Bank Supervision Department, Central Bank of Sri Lanka.
1
CONTENTS
I. Introduction
IV. Conclusion
2
I. INTRODUCTION
Section I of the paper discusses the interaction between bond development and
macroeconomic stability focusing on the sources of instabilities affecting the bond
market. Section II presents the contribution of the bond market in improving the
efficiency of monetary management and financial stability. Section III provides an
overview of risks associated in new developments in bond markets and Section IV
discusses the policies taken by the Sri Lankan authorities in the areas of monetary
management and financial stability that contribute to bond market development.
1
In developed markets – Europe and the United States., a sub-set of corporate bond market includes
however “High Yield Bonds” which are a source of funds for new or small enterprises that have
outperformed companies in terms of employment growth, productivity and capital investment.
3
.that play an important role in developing corporate bond market as the issuers, mainly
raising subordinated debt to meet capital adequacy requirements, and investors in this
market. In advanced economies, where bond markets are developed, there are derivative
financial products such as collateralized debt obligations (CDOs), and structured credit
products, which expand the depth and liquidity of bond markets.
Malaysia Singapore
Market Capitalization as a % of GDP
250
200 Thailand
Korea
150
100
India
50
Sri Lanka
0
0 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000 30000
Per Capita Income
2
IMF (2005).
3
The corporate bond markets are among the largest in Malaysia, the Republic of Korea and Thailand.
Bond markets in terms of GDP, 38 per cent, 21 per cent and 12 per cent respectively as at end 2004. Size
of bank bond market in the United States is 22 per cent.
4
macroeconomic imbalances, especially misalignment in exchange rates and weak
governance in financial markets and balance sheet weaknesses as a result of currency
mismatches. With the improvement in macro economy, as reflected by the reduction in
inflation and volatility of inflation, stronger fiscal performance, strong current account
performance, output growth and accumulation of foreign reserves, further reforms and
efforts have been made by these countries to strengthen the bond markets. 4 These
included market infrastructures such as secondary markets, create benchmark issues and
remove structural impediments in the markets such as address high costs of debt issuance,
expand the set of institutional investors, improve corporate governance and transparency
to promote the bond markets.
In Sri Lanka, although there have been several improvements in different areas of
macroeconomic management, a significant improvement is yet to be achieved in
containing debt burden, the fiscal deficit, current account deficit in balance of payments
and addressing structural weaknesses in labour and input markets and capacity
constraints, to contain the volatility in inflation. The discussion in this paper is mainly
focused on the need to improving overall macroeconomic stability as well as the need to
address the other structural factors to develop the bond markets.
4
The main purpose of promoting bond markets in these countries is that it is an alternative source of debt
financing for corporations that reduces vulnerabilities of the corporate sector by reducing currency
mismatches and lengthening the duration of debt.
5
A. High and volatile inflation
There are several adverse consequences of high and volatile inflation on the efficient
functioning of bond markets. The rise in inflation requires central banks to adopt a tight
monetary policy stance with a contraction of market liquidity. Money market liquidity,
especially the liquidity in the inter-bank market, facilitates smooth functioning of other
segments in the money market such as secondary market of Treasury bills and private
sector money market instruments such as commercial paper. The reduction in inter-bank
liquidity will therefore negatively affect the liquidity in bonds and raise the volatility of
market rates leading to a reduction in activities of the secondary markets, which provides
price discovery.
High inflationary expectations and volatility of short-term rates also cause the market
participants to have problems in deciding on future path of long-term interest rates.
Uncertainty of future rates causes higher preference in investing in short term paper
shortening the yield curve. From a macroeconomic perspective, inflation affects foreign
currency inflows and country’s competitiveness adversely. If domestic inflation is higher
than those of other countries, a country’s exports will be less competitive and hence in
less demand in international markets. There will also be less foreign currency inflows
through foreign direct inflows and portfolio flows. These again negatively impact on the
overall bond market.
During the last few decades, inflation in Sri Lanka has been relatively high and
volatile (Figure 2). The low increases in prices that prevailed in the early sixties, began
6
accelerating and peaked at 26 per cent in 1980. Since 1980 inflation has been declining,
albeit with high volatility. The average inflation during the last three decades was around
10-11 per cent.
30.0
25.0
20.0
15.0
10.0
5.0
0.0
1969 1973 1977 1981 1985 1989 1993 1997 2001 2005
7
Figure 3. The behaviour of inflation and related macroeconomic variables
I n f l a t i o n a nd M o ne y S u pp l y Gr owt h I nf l a t i on a n d B u dg e t D e f i c i t
30.0
40. 0
25.0
30. 0
20.0
20. 0 15.0
10. 0
10.0
5.0
0. 0
0.0
-10. 0
-5.0
Inflation M2 Growth
Inflation Budget Deficit (%of GDP)
35.0
25.0
15.0
5.0
-5.0
Figure 4 clearly shows the impact of rising inflation and building up of inflationary
expectations on the bond market. As inflation increases, the duration of the government
securities declines and investors’ preference shifts to short-term government securities.
8
Figure 4. Duration of government securities and inflation
20.0
3 16.0
Duration
Percent
2 12.0
8.0
1
4.0
0 02 0.0
03
04
05
06
06/
20
20
20
20
20
07
20
T bill T Bond Inflation
Continuing high budget deficits requiring borrowings from banking and non-banking
sources create impediments to developing an efficient bond market. Fiscal deficits are, in
general, financed through domestic and foreign borrowings, and foreign grants. The
relative importance of foreign grants in deficit financing has been declining as the overall
foreign grants received by the country is declining, despite the recent increase due to
tsunami related inflows. As foreign loans are typically tied with projects, the level of
foreign borrowings through loans depends on the progress of the public investment
programme. Therefore, if the deficit is maintained over and above the revenue generated
by the government, additional financing from domestic sources including borrowings
from banking sources will be required, creating inflationary pressures since the available
resources in the non-bank sector is limited.
The imposition of taxes on the financial sector constrains the efficient functioning of
the financial market. First, the relatively high effective tax rate may tend to reduce
effective interest rate paid to depositors and increase effective lending rates thereby
increasing the interest rate spread. Second, the high tax incidence increases
9
administrative costs of financial institutions, again requiring banks to maintain high
margins. Third, it could indirectly favour the unregulated financial sector institutions
while distorting the interest rate structure thereby retarding the development of the
development of the bond market.
Continued higher borrowings, particularly with more maturities at the shorter end,
create difficulties in rolling over maturing debt on a sustainable manner. The resultant
bunching of maturities creates undue pressures on the interest rate structure of the market
as well as on the liquidity position of the debt market. It also creates difficulties in the
debt management process of the government.
High borrowings by government from non-bank sector also crowd out borrowings by
the private sector. At present, a major share of domestic borrowings is made through
market based domestic debt instruments such as Treasury bills/Treasury bonds as
opposed to non-marketable instruments, contributing to debt market development.
However, government borrowings pre-empt the resources available to the private sector.
Exchange rate stability is another factor that has an impact on the bond market. The
most direct effect of exchange rate changes is through domestic inflation. The changes in
exchange rate affect the price of imported goods, which in turn, are important
determinants of the firms' costs and the retail prices of many goods and services.
The volatility in exchange rates also leads to an uncertainty in the foreign exchange
market. This adds to risk premium to the forward market transactions and these
uncertainties adversely affect the foreign participation in domestic bond markets and
10
affect the development of benchmark yield curve. If there are no markets to hedge the
price risks foreign investments may be declined.
In addition to macroeconomic stability, several policy initiatives and targeted reforms are
found to be needed to strengthen the institutional infrastructure and remove impediments
which will foster efficient functioning and sustained growth in the bond market
particularly the corporate bond market. With regard to institutional infrastructure,
establishing rating agencies, trading platforms, clearing and settlement systems,
regulatory environment are some of the major requirements. Policies to develop a
diversified institutional investor base will create ensure sustainable demand for bonds. In
particular, pension funds, mutual funds, not only create demand for fixed income
securities but also contribute to increase financial innovation, corporate governance, and
enhance competition in bond market. Strengthening the disclosure standards and
establishing credit rights and investor protection too help remove the impediments to
smooth functioning of bond markets.
11
A. Bond market development and monetary stability
A developed bond market reduces the need for governments to finance its budget
deficits from inflationary banking financing. Therefore, bond market is an alternative
channel for mobilizing funding which enhances the flexibility of monetary management.
12
bill and Treasury bond markets therefore contribute for the Central Bank to conduct
monetary policy more effectively.
A liquid corporate bond market may prevent development of asset price bubbles.
Bond markets expand the array of financial instruments available to diverse investors.
Yield curve allows investors to infer more information about market expectations
regarding interest rates and other economic developments. With the expansion of market
players in the market, the herd behaviour will also be restricted.
13
other ancillary intermediaries such as rating agencies can support the overall credit risk
management of financial intermediaries.
C. Importance of derivative markets in bond markets, new risks and their impact
on monetary and financial stability
14
For instance, the securitization which originates as an issue of bonds or securities by
the pooling receivables of capital and interest on loans, are sold to investors so that banks
can raise liquidity without waiting for repayments of the original loans. These
securitization subsequently have become more complex with the involvement of
investment banks, mortgage lending institutions, equity firms, mutual/hedge funds and
credit rating agencies leading to the introduction of innovative financial products
generally known as ‘complex structured finance products’, e.g., asset or mortgage-backed
securities (MBSs) and collateralized-debt obligations (CDOs).
One purpose of these exotic products is to create new securities that could be sold to a
broader group of investors such as pension funds and insurance companies whose
investment horizon better suited depending on their liability structures. These instruments
therefore enabled the transfer of credit risk to a diversified group of investors in the
market. Therefore, these innovative products were generally encouraged, even by
regulators, as a risk management tool. Markets evolved to trade these securities to suit
investors with different risk appetites. Interestingly, during last two years, financial
regulators have been raising concerns over the credit derivative markets boom because
the risks taken by the investors outside the regulatory purview.
Although the derivative markets and hedging instruments facilitate the expansion of
the bond market, the evolution of derivative products has brought in two distinctive
features to the financial market: an increasing complexity of instruments, which combine
an extensive use of derivatives with customization to individual investors’ needs and the
fragility of off-balance sheet structures and vehicles, which was rediscovered during the
recent sub-prime turmoil.
15
required to play a major role indirectly in finance product innovation, in view of the
systemic and economic risks. Regulators are required to ensure that systemically
important banks and financial institutions are not exposed to concentration risks in
specific products or markets. Banks and financial institutions are also required to follow
fair market practices without unduly affecting public confidence.
D. Monetary and financial sector policies in Sri Lanka promoting bond market
The conduct of monetary policy is one of the prime responsibilities of the Central
Bank, since monetary policy is the means by which Central Bank attempts to attain its
one of the core objectives, i.e., the economic and price stability. Monetary Law Act
provided a wide range of instruments that could be used by the Central Bank for
monetary management.
At present, the monetary policy framework places greater reliance on market based
policy instruments and the use of market forces to achieve the desired objectives as they
help achieve a better allocation of resources, reduce associated transaction costs, and
improve the efficiency in monetary management. As a further step in making toward for
more market oriented monetary management system, the Central Bank moved to more
market based active open market operations with effect from 3 March 2003.
Steps were also taken to enhance the transparency, predictability and credibility of
monetary policy. After each decision on required change in monetary policy stance, or
otherwise, a public statement, i.e., a press release, explaining the monetary and economic
conditions that led to the particular decision on the policy change (or otherwise), is issued
to the public. In addition, the monetary policy framework, and monetary projections,
along with the explanatory notes are regularly posted on the Central Bank website.
The independently floating exchange rate regime, which was implemented from
January 2001 served well in reducing the excess volatility in the exchange rate and
16
maintaining the country’s competitiveness vis-à-vis the rest of the world, while allowing
greater freedom in the conduct of monetary policy.
Given the diverse risks associated with financial conglomerates, it has become
increasingly important to ensure that the activities of financial conglomerates do not pose
risks to the stability of the financial system. In this regard, the Central Bank has
introduced a number of policy initiatives to address the potential systemic risk posed by
financial conglomerates to monitor systemic risks of financial conglomerates and
promote consolidated supervision.
a. Banking sector
The stability of the banking sector, which is the major sub-sector within the financial
sector is crucial for bond market since it provides payment facilities and a major buyer
and issuer of securities and facilitates secondary market activity. In fact, banks are one of
the major investors in government securities market to meet statutory liquidity
requirements and as collateral for repo transactions in managing short-term liquidity.
Accordingly, number of measures continued to be taken promote a competitive, sound
and robust banking sector.
17
There has been a significant improvement in capacity and capability of the banking
system and this is supported by improved earnings, increase in capital funds and
improvements in risk management amidst enhanced regulatory and supervisory
framework. This was further underpinned by the gradual decline in non-performing loans
(NPLs), reflecting general improvements in credit quality and enhanced risk management
standards and practices over the years. The strong financial position has enabled the
banking sector to expand the access to finance.
With a view to further strengthening the efficiency and greater competition among
financial institutions, a number of legal reforms relating to the financial sector were
brought in and regulatory oversight were enhanced to be in line with international best
practices.
b. Money market
The Central Bank has implemented several measures to broaden and deepen the
money market. In order to help pricing money market products, the Central Bank started
providing Sri Lanka Interbank Offered Rate from 1999. The Central Bank also engages in
Repurchase and Reverse Repurchase transactions in order to inject and absorb liquidity
from the market. Further, it disseminates information on market transactions on a daily
basis. Measures have also been taken to further promote and upgrade the payments
system to take effect large value money market transactions through the Real Time Gross
Settlement System and the Scripless Securities System, which will expand and promote
the efficiency of money market transactions.
Another noteworthy development in the foreign exchange market was that the
independent floating of Sri Lanka rupee in 2001. The main players in the foreign
exchange market are the commercial banks. Dealings in the foreign exchange market are
18
mainly in spot and forward transactions. These operations are largely generated by trade
related activities, capital flows, and trading activities of commercial banks.
A number of positive developments have also taken place in the government securities
market supporting bond market development. In an effort to upgrade the market
infrastructure, the Scripless Securities Settlement System (SSSS) was introduced in 2004
to replace the paper-based instrument system with the dematerialized settlement system.
Meanwhile, the Central Depository System (CDS) for GS was introduced to record
trading information for scripless securities. As a result, the settlement and clearing of
government securities has achieved Delivery Versus Payment (DVP), whereby security
delivery and payment will be simultaneous.
With a view to further opening the capital account transactions and to develop the
capital markets by broadening the investor base and increasing competition in the bond
market, foreign investors have been permitted to purchase up to five per cent of rupee
denominated Treasury bonds since November 2006.
19
e. Financial system infrastructure
An efficient and reliable payment and settlement system contributes to the soundness
and the development of the financial system and the smooth functioning of bond markets.
Therefore, the Central Bank moved towards introducing a more advanced payment and
settlement system in 2003. For high value and time critical payments on real time, the
Central Bank implemented the Real Time Gross Settlement System (RTGS) in 2003,
which significantly reduced the settlement risks and improved efficiency.
To further modernize the payment system, measures were also taken by the Central
Bank and Lanka Clear (Pvt.) Ltd to introduce Cheque Imaging and Truncation (CIT) to
the country’s cheque clearing system with the long-term objective of moving towards
electronic cheque transactions.
f. Legal enactments
A number of laws relating to the financial sector have been enacted strengthening the
legal framework for the efficient functioning of bond market. These included the
Payments and Settlement Systems Act, Electronic Transactions Act, Payment Devices
Frauds Act and legislation pertaining to Anti-Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and
Financial Transactions Reporting.
20
1. Monetary policy
21
• Managing expectations: Inflation expectation surveys and constructing leading
indicators are two other areas where work could be developed. Change in
inflationary expectations, which are an indicator of credibility of monetary policy and
inflation inertia, are also variables used in inflation forecasting models.
• Inflation Targeting: In recent years, there has been an increasing focus on inflation
targeting as a framework for implementing monetary policy. The rationale behind
inflation targeting is that inflation targets may help provide a clear path for the
medium term inflation outlook, reducing the size of inflationary shocks and their
associated costs. Since long-term interest rates fluctuate with movements in inflation
expectations, targeting a low rate of inflation would lead to a more stable and lower
long-term rates of interest.
2. Fiscal policy
22
should take necessary adjustments in the areas of enhancing revenue through
additional measures and improved tax administration, rationalization of current
expenditure and improvements in the government debt management to meet this
target since large deviations of government borrowings affect the smooth
implementation of the borrowing programme. It is also important that the medium-
term fiscal targets announced in the FMRA are achieved effectively so that there
would be less pressure in the conduct of monetary policy as well.
23
The VAT and corporate tax are payable by institutions. Withholding taxes on interest
income, debit taxes on withdrawals, stamp duties and VATs on fee-based activities
are paid by customers.
24
supply condition along with the improvements to productivity, removing bottlenecks
in infrastructure and inputs markets.
25
and capability of the banking institutions, promote overall risk management and
reinforce the resilience of the banking sector
• Expanding investor base: A broad investor base has several advantages for
developing the bond market through enhanced market stability, promoting financial
innovation and contributing to expanding liquidity. Accordingly, measures need to be
taken for the development of a group of private institutional investors especially
developing pension funds, mutual funds. An initial boost could be given for bond
market development by participating in bond issues by relaxing the restrictions on the
investment policies of the EPF, the ETF, and the NSB as regards their ability to invest
in private securities and allowing foreign investors to invest in fixed-income
securities.
• Promoting investment banking: The investment banks could function as a catalyst to the
development of vibrant and efficient bond market. These banks facilitate the issuing of
corporate bonds in several ways such as advising on the timing and terms of the
issuers. In addition, underwriting of bond issues are some of the services that could
be provided.
26
• Disclosure of information to build market credibility: Information disclosure plays
a key role in building market credibility. Developing proper disclosure standards
based on consolidated accounts and well established auditing and accounting
standards will help market and supervisors. In this regard, the adoption of IAS
standards and move to consolidate listed companies, through strict enforcement of
free float requirements, will also have a positive impact on information disclosure.
• Improve the financial literacy and awareness among investors about the
characteristics of new capital products. Enhanced understanding of the capital
markets by issuers, investors (both institutional and retail), will allow them to make
educated decisions would contribute enormously to the long-term development of the
capital markets.
III. CONCLUSION
27
needed to strengthen institutional infrastructure and remove impediments which will
foster efficient functioning and sustained growth in the bond market particularly the
corporate bond market. With regard to institutional infrastructure, establishing rating
agencies, trading platforms, clearing and settlement systems, regulatory environment are
some of the major requirements. Policies to develop a diversified institutional investor
base will create ensure sustainable demand for bonds. In particular, pension funds,
mutual funds, not only create demand for fixed income securities but also contribute to
increase financial innovation, corporate governance, and enhance competition in the bond
market.
28
REFERENCE
Bank Negara Malaysia, The Corporate Bond Market in Malaysia, Muhammad bin
Ibrahim and Adrian Wong.
Bank for International Settlements (2007). CGFC Papers No.28 Financial Stability and
Local Currency Bond Markets, June.
IMF (2000). International Capital Markets: Developments, Prospects, and Key Policy
Issues, World Economic and Financial Surveys, September (Washington D.C.).
_____ (2001), International Capital Markets: Developments, Prospects, and Key Policy
Issues, World Economic and Financial Surveys, August (Washington D.C.).
_____ (2004), Global Financial Stability Report, World Economic and Financial Surveys,
April (Washington D.C.).
_____ (2005), Global Financial Stability Report, World Economic and Financial Surveys,
April (Washington D.C.).
The World Bank and IMF (2001). Developing Government Bond Markets, A Handbook,
(Washington D.C.).
29