Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Michele Taylor
History 510
4127633
1
In 1959, Fidel Castro made a five hour television appearance during which
he commented that “revolution and religion are not contradictory but coincide,
Christianity sprung from humble people and was opposed by privileged classes.”1
From the beginning of the revolution Castro’s position on the role of religion has
remained consistent; the conflicts that would occur began with the institution of
the Roman Catholic Church rather than belief itself. Fidel Castro himself may be
a Marxist but it is difficult to name him a true Leninist. As Frei Betto states in
Fidel and Religion: “it was Lenin, not Marx, who made atheism into a
metaphysical tenet rather than a political issue.”2 Castro felt that the Church
should be ministering to the poor rather than the privileged; his sense of justice in
Fidel Castro is a self avowed communist, yet his views on religious freedom
beliefs. Castro’s views on religion and the role of the church within Cuban
society have remained consistent throughout the 1960s and into the 21st Century.
However, how his administration has approached dealing with the Church has
changed within those time frames. The reasons for these changes are simple,
the 1960s were tumultuous, the revolution still in its infancy felt threatened by the
church; by the 1990s the revolution had solidified its power base and could afford
to allow the church more freedom, while the church had by then softened its
1
“Five hour television appearance, 12/21/1959,” Castro Speech Database, University of Texas at Austin;
Http://lanic.utexas.edu/la/cb/cuba/castro.html .
2
Frei Betto, Fidel and Religion (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1987), 18.
2
The purpose in addressing Fidel Castro’s views and dealings on the subject
of religion and the Church, is that hopefully an insight will be provided that will
increase not only an understanding of Castro himself but of the evolution of the
Roman Catholic Church in revolutionary Cuba. It should be noted that due to the
inability to access the records of the Cuban Catholic Church; a clear view of the
interview with Frei Betto, Fidel Castro states “first I come from a religious nation
and, second, that I come from a religious family.”3 His family’s faith was passed
down, not taught by church doctrine; Castro claims that there were no Roman
Catholic Churches in the countryside: “There was not a single church in our
country's entire countryside, not a single Catholic Church. There were some
local churches of other religious denominations but there was not a single
Catholic Church.”4 The population was so small that a priest only came once a
year to baptize children. There was no official religious training for these people.
As a boy Castro was enrolled in the La Salle School, where he was taught
catechism, religion, and biblical history. He treated the religious training as any
small child; it was like any other class, just something that was required. It was in
this school that he saw how money played a role in favoritism. Because Castro’s
father was a large landowner he received special treatment quite often.5 His
was run by Catholic Priests of the Jesuit order. Castro stated that these “were
3
Ibid,. 90.
4
“Comments on Relations with Brazil 3/19/1990” Castro Speech Database.
5
Betto, Fidel and Religion, 118.
3
very rigorous, demanding people, who were interested in their student’s
character and behavior. In other words, I acquired ethics and norms that weren’t
just religious. I got a human influence from the teacher’s authority and the values
they attached to things.”6 So he was to gain his ethics and sense of justice from
these schools, yet he disagreed with the way religion was taught; he viewed it as
contained no reasoning in the mind of Castro: “It seems to me that religious faith,
and feelings. The two things are inseparable.”7 Castro was never to gain a
religious vocation because his religious training was too mechanical and
dogmatic for him to embrace. Castro believes that the ideals of personal dignity
of the Jesuits greatly influenced him. They taught him discipline and
organization; this gave him the basis on which to view abuse and injustice as
inconceivable. It was the Jesuits who introduced him to Marx, and from there he
learned the necessity of understanding the process of historical change and the
For all the religious background and Castro’s failure to embrace religion
himself, he still acquired a deep understanding of men’s need for religious belief.
He explains his connection between the revolutionary and the religious martyr in
6
Ibid,. 122.
7
Ibid,. 123.
4
a martyr who died for his religious faith. I think that religious martyrs were
generous, selfless men: they were made of the same stuff of which
revolutionary heroes are made. Without those qualities, there can be no
religious or political heroes.8
religion but also the manner in which he addresses the beliefs of the Cuban
people.
Castro’s’ views on religion have not wavered from the time of the revolution
to present day. This may be in part because, although he himself does not claim
stated in 1960 that “the revolution has no reason to prevent any priest from
speeches in the 1960s, Castro stated his belief in freedom of religion. In a 1961
religion. Many of his speeches referred to his belief that Christianity is socialist in
nature, that its origins were among the poor, and that the masses must be served
8
Ibid,. 141.
9
“Clergy and Judges attacked by Castro 12/19/1960” Castro Speech Database.
10
“Meeting of Technical Advisors 02/12/1961” Castro Speech Database.
11
“Clergy and Judges attacked by Castro 12/19/1960” Castro Speech Database.
5
Throughout the 1960s, speech after speech details the same beliefs and
principles: the right of the people to their own religious beliefs. His belief that the
revolution and religion can work side by side is repeated in this 1960 speech:
“We believe firmly that there is no contradiction between aspirations for material
improvement and the spiritual side. We respect all religious creeds.”12 The
consistency of his statements would lend to my theory that this reveals belief
should be respected”13 In looking back to the early years of the revolution Castro
worked with many men and women of faith. “I don’t think that there is any
incompatibility between being a Catholic and being loyal to the Revolution. Take
the case of Father Sardinas, a major in the rebel army, pastor in Havana and a
member of the army staff…a priest who chose the path of revolution as the only
way open to liberate his people.”14 It was only when the Church openly spoke
against the revolution that those of faith were barred from government positions.
Though this effectively excluded the Church from political participation it did not
quite often spoke more to dealings with the Church hierarchy than to basic
religion itself. At this point it is obvious that Castro believes that freedom of
religion is a basic right and says that “Not a single church was closed. No
repressive measures were taken against religious groups. Many churches have
6
and can attest to this.”15 Castro’s main points were always that he believed in the
Before the visit of Pope John Paul II to Cuba; Castro was unsure not because of
who this man was but because of the turmoil that might arise from the proposed
visit. Castro spoke of the brilliance of the man and his respect for him, yet his
dispute lay not with the religion but the Church hierarchy.
There are some political issues associated with our relations with the
Cuban Catholic hierarchy that has influenced the visit one way or another.
We do not want the Pope's visit to be transformed into an instrument of
friction, contradiction, or conflict between the Catholic church -- the
hierarchy not the church -- and the revolution.17
Castro also begins to debate allowing people of faith into the party: “We had a
long time to think and meditate on this and we reached the conclusion that it was
not fair for a person to be denied membership to the party because of his
religious beliefs”.18 Fidel Castro’s acceptance of the rights of the people to their
faith is something that he has spoken of time and again this did not differ
15
“ Interview with Ted Turner 06/29/1990” Castro Speech Database.
16
“Comments on Relations with Brazil 3/19/1990” Castro Speech Database.
17
“Fidel Castro’s visit to New York 10/23/1995” Castro Speech Database.
18
“Castro views political, economic situation 10/25/1991” Castro Speech Database.
19
“Castro Interview for Brazilian Bandeirantes T.V. 3/26/1990” Castro Speech Database.
7
Castro tends to separate religion from the Church; you do not hear anger
when he speaks of religion, yet the church is another matter altogether. Fidel
Castro’s views on the role of the church in the 1960s also remained consistent.
He believed the church had its place, to minister to the souls of the people, yet it
did not have the right to interfere within the material province of the government:
The revolution has no reason to try to deny the right of any citizen to
practice his beliefs or the right of any religious body to preach it. But we can
ask the priests if they consider they have the right to forbid the revolutionary
government to pass revolutionary laws or to act within the social and civil
order in the form it considers in the interests of the people.20
In the same speech Castro continued to explain that anything that divides the
anything that tends to divide the Cubans.”21 The division of the Cuban people,
whether brought on by the church or any other party, was not to be accepted.
Castro was trying to build a cohesive society here; his problem was not with
religious belief but with the Church hierarchy itself. The Church of the 1960s was
church:
And now they attack the revolution. They use communism as a pretext.
Christ was a communist, too. Would they be against Christ? Why, in the
name of religion, do they attack political views when no one attacks religion
in the name of political ideas?22
ideas would become a divisive point between him and the Church hierarchy.
Castro reiterates time and again that the revolution has shown great forbearance
20
“Clergy and Judges attacked by Castro 12/19/1960” Castro Speech Database.
21
“Clergy and Judges attacked by Castro 12/19/1960” Castro Speech Database.
22
“Castro says CIA leads Cuba Rebels 03/04/1961” Castro Speech Database.
8
at the continued provocation of Church officials speaking out against communism
and the revolution itself. In 1960 he spoke out against these officials:
That is why some of these cassocked, far from the true preaching’s of
Christ, began giving counterrevolutionary sermons in the churches and
writing parochial pamphlets that the very Catholics, the very faithful,
received with the national anthem on their lips.23
He espoused toleration for the church but in the same breath claimed that “the
revolution will fight against the false individuals who want to turn religion into an
anti-national and antisocial institution”24 It is obvious that Castro believes that the
church is corrupt and uncaring for the Cuban people and accuses material and
The revolution went against privilege, against the privileged classes but
since it was not a matter of religion but a problem of material interests, of
economic problems, all the rest—faith, religion and other things have
served as a pretext to cry out about the wound, not of religion or faith, but
the wound of particular interests, the economic interest.25
In a 1961 speech Castro again criticized the church: “We have not done
anything against the priests. What quarrel do the priests have with us? They are
pastorals blaming the government for lack of guarantees.”26 Castro spoke of the
actions of the church rather than against the religious faith of the people. His
anger was not at religion but rather at those who were fighting the revolutionary
magazine, Castro brought up that things have settled between the Church and
state and Cuba was working for a future of happiness, only those who oppose
23
“Speech: Anniversary of the student martyrs of 187111/28/1960” Castro Speech Database.
24
“ Meeting of Technical Advisors 02/12/61” Castro Speech Database.
25
“Speech: Anniversary of the student martyrs of 1871 11/28/1960” Castro Speech Database.
26
“Castro says CIA leads Cuba Rebel 03/04/1961” Castro Speech Database.
9
the revolution will have problems. So as long as the church stayed out of politics
things would be fine. In a 1968 speech closing the Cultural Congress he talked
about a delegation of Catholic priests who had submitted a paper stating that
they are
This progression of the church to the doctrine of the revolution brings the church
into the fold by supporting the tenets of Christianity in protecting the masses. “A
true Christian loves his neighbor. A real Christian complies with the doctrine of
faith and gives what he has to the poor.”28 Is this not also a socialist ideal? The
continued with his viewpoint that the church had the right to minister to the
people as long as it stayed out of politics. He has always believed that problems
arose within the church hierarchy because it catered to the most affluent sectors
views of the church at that time.29 “In reality, religious groups have had complete
freedom of expression in our country. Certain conflicts came up during the initial
27
“Castro speech closing Cultural Congress 01/13/1968”Castro Speech Database.
28
“Castro bypasses “US controlled OAS 07/19/1960” Castro Speech Database.
29
“Castro says CIA leads Cuba Rebels 03/04/1961” Castro Speech Database.
30
“Interview with Ted Turner 06/29/1990” Castro Speech Database.
10
churches in Cuba had “excellent” relations with the revolution. 31 This further
shows his acceptance of the church within the framework of his views of what the
church should contribute to Cuba. Throughout his speeches in the 1990s the
Church is mentioned less often than in the early years of the revolution,
apparently because there is less dissension between the two. Yet he reiterates
his stance on the Churches freedom to worship. “We gave the Catholic Church
Church and State seemed of one mind in 1959 both Catholic and Protestant
The approach of Fidel Castro’s regime in the 1960s to the Church was much
more harsh and unbending than the same approach in the 1990s. In January
1959 the Catholic Church had rejoiced that Fidel Castro was at the forefront of
the liberating forces. Yet within two years a break between Castro and the
Church seemed imminent. The Church had issues with many of the
socioeconomic reforms that the revolution was enacting, ranging from urban to
large businesses. A second issue was the diplomatic ties that were being built
between Cuba and the U.S.S.R, godless communism which created the fear that
31
“Castro views political economic situation 10/25/1991” Castro Speech Database.
32
“Comments on Relations with Brazil 3/19/1990” Castro Speech Database.
11
“communist” and “atheist”.33 This fear of communism stemmed from a 1949
decree made by Pope Pius XII forbidding Catholics from supporting communism.
The Church would stand against these reforms and thereby refute the rights
of the revolutionary government to impose them. They pushed for religion being
taught in public schools and the right of Christians to private education. This
would become the first major challenge to the young government and the church
would not emerge as the victor. The reforms that would most divide the
revolutionary government from the church would come in the form of agrarian
laws. These reforms went by the basic principle that the land should be given to
those who till it. Large Sugar plantations were nationalized and private estates
larger than 402 hectares were broken up and distributed to landless peasants.
was refused. These reforms would set the church hierarchy firmly against the
government towards the church. Catholic groups began to organize protests and
marches. The church united in its fight over communism; masses were said for
and of the world that are totally opposed to each other, and which it will never be
possible to reconcile”35 The revolutionary government at this point had their back
to the wall, the church is overstepping its role. In December of 1960 the break
33
John M. Kirk. Between God and the Party ( Tampa: University of South Florida Press, 1989) pgs 65-66
34
Kirk, Between God and the Party. pg 81
35
Kirk. Between God and the Party. pg 82
12
between church and government was complete. Speaking on television, Fidel
“What right do they have to meddle with political problems? One of the
things they stress most is communism. In the first place we should tell
them that the government does not have to make any accounting to the
archbishops as to their conduct. One of the writings that they most like
to repeat, is that officials of the government have said that to be anti-
communist is to be a counterrevolutionary and that the government has
not uttered a word. Who told the archbishops that the government must
say what they want the government to say? They want us to reply to
them. Well, simply, we believe to be anticommunist is to be
counterrevolutionary just as it is counterrevolutionary to be anti-Catholic,
anti-Protestant, and to be anti-anything that tends to divide Cubans.”36
By the end of 1960 the Church’s demise as a political force was realized.
Though Castro had hoped to continue forward with his reforms and still be able
to maintain relations with the Church it was not to be. By 1962 the militants
within the church had only two options left to them, exile or confrontation. The
final straw for the revolutionary government was the supposed role played by
Catholics in the Bay of Pigs invasion. Which was purportedly launched by the
United States because the new policies threatened the profits and land holdings
against the government. The government’s policy toward the church would
was occurring with greater frequency, the mass exodus of Catholics and church
leaders was noticeable. Even though Castro’s views on the church’s role in
Cuba were articulated by him often over the years, the stance of his revolutionary
36
“Clergy and Judges attacked by Castro 12/19/1960” Castro Speech Database.
37
Kirk. Between God and the Party. pg 96
13
government was very different. Any threat to the unity of the revolution would not
be tolerated.
The more liberal Catholics would claim that the church’s mission was to
minister to its people, not to run from its responsibility. The church was
confirming Castro’s belief that church leaders were only interested in power and
ministry to the elite. In an attempt to curb church influence after the Bay of Pigs
educational system of Cuba. At this point the Cuban government expelled all
foreign priests, with the exclusion of those that had not been fighting for the
the number of priests in Cuba fell from 723 to 220.39 Under threats from within
desire for refuge from turmoil.”40 The church would keep an official silence for six
years, until 1969 they would use this period for self evaluation.
By the 1990s the revolutionary government had relaxed much of its distrust
of the church. In his speeches, Castro admitted that it has been a discriminatory
38
“Meeting of Technical Advisors 2/12/1961” Castro Speech Database.
39
Margaret Short. Law and Religion in Marxist Cuba (New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers, 1993) pg
146
40
Margaret E. Crahan. Salvation through Christ or Marx: Religion in Revolutionary Cub. in Churches and
Politics in Latin America, ed. Daniel H. Levine. (Beverly Hills: Sage Publications, 1979) pg 261
14
practice not to allow Christians within the communist party. The difference in the
government’s view is clear in a 1991 speech: “As the years went by we were able
to see that there were many believers who were magnificent revolutionaries,
needed to be good communists.”41 The reasons for this softening were in large
broadening the space and freedom of action of the Catholic church and asked
freeing at least 300 prisoners”42 Other factors included the fact that the
government consolidated their power and were confident of their control. The
1990s would become an era of fence mending, the tension surrounding the
initiatives with more tolerance.43 The combination of the church’s soft approach
The reasons behind the break of church and state are quite simple, yet
Adding to this was the diplomatic ties being solidified with the Soviet Union. Too
much drastic change, too quickly and then the addition of godless communism
41
“Castro views political, economic situation 10/25/1991” Castro Speech Database.
42
Bureau of Public Affairs, Cuba, Profile. U.S. Department of State. 9/01/2001
www.state.gov/outofdate/bgn/c/13238.htm.
43
Kirk, Between God and the Party. pg 111
15
(forbidden by Pope Pius) was too much for the plodding church. Used to being
involved in the political arena, sure of their power, and with the support of
imperialist ideals, they stood up against the revolution. They did not receive the
response that they expected; rather than backing down the government removed
gentlemen have departed from serving the interests of the masses. They have
dominate class.”44 Whatever the reasoning behind the actions, it would take
In the 1990s the talks between the two had progressed to the point that it
obligation to the Cuban people and realized that to minister to the people they
must work within the reality of the revolution. “The Catholic leadership’s maturity
in seeking fresh dialogue has been more or less matched by its government
counterpart.”45 With Fidel Castro spurring the government towards ever more
society. The prevailing feel of church-state relations during this time period is
one of hope.
The struggle between the Church and the revolutionary government was at
44
“Castro says CIA leads Cuba rebels 3/04/1961” Castro Speech Database.
45
Kirk, Between God and the Party. pg 170
16
the beginning a power struggle which the Church found they could not win.
Castro would say that the Church had lost sight of its mission among the Cuban
people. In catering to the rich and the bourgeoisie, they had placed themselves
Fidel Castro’s background played a large part in the way that religion was to
Throughout the forty years that he has been in power, he has always claimed
that freedom of religion was a right of the people and that he fervently believed
Through the early years of the revolution the issues that would separate
Church and State caused a deep mistrust. It would take decades before even
rudimentary dialogue would be held between the two. Even so Castro’s views on
religion and the Church remained consistent throughout the last forty years.
The problems of the Church in Cuba are also the same debates that have
of faith in the context of the modern era and of disparate traditions and
world is in the throes of the same theological question asked in Cuba for the last
forty years. What place does religion hold? Throughout his speeches Fidel
46
Kirk. Between God and the Party. Pg 175.
17
Bibliography
Frei Betto, Fidel and Religion. New York: Simon & Schuster, 1987.
Hageman, Alice L., Philip E. Wheaton. Religion in Cuba Today, New York:
Association Press, 1971.
Kirk, John M. Between God and the Party. Tampa: University of South Florida
Press, 1989.
18
Short, Margaret I. Law and Religion in Marxist Cuba. New Brunswick:
Transaction publishers, 1993.
19