Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
CHAPTER-1
BASIC CONCEPTS OF INCOME TAX
TAX - MEANING THEREOF - Every state needs funds to govern the country. The
need of funds can be fulfilled by taking loans from their countries, grants & aids
from other countries, share of profit in govt. run organizations and through taxes.
Therefore, tax is that amount which is borne by the persons and
paid to the state for running the state.
KINDS OF TAXES - Taxes are of two kinds:-
(1) Direct Taxes; and (2) Indirect taxes.
DIRECT TAXES - These are borne and paid by the same person. For example:
Income tax, Wealth tax, Gift tax (Gift tax has been abolished in India) and
Interest tax.
INDIRECT TAXES - These are borne by persons who are different from the
payers. For example: Custom duty, Excise duty, Sales Tax, Entertainment tax,
Octroi etc.
INCOME TAX ACT, 1961 -
The current Income tax Act was regulated from 1.4.1961 and its
rules were brought into working from 1.4.1962. Every year the finance minister
of the country proposes for various changes in the Act through the Finance Bill.
This bill, when gets nod in the parliament, becomes ' The Amendment Act.'
SPECIFIC TERMS TO BE USED IN THE ACT-
PREVIOUS YEAR (SECTION 3): It refers to the year in which a person earns his
income which is taxable in the relevant assessment year. The period of previous
year is normally of 12 MONTHS starting from 1st April to 31st March in the next
calendar year. But in case of NEWLY SET-UP Business/profession or new
source of income the period of previous year may be less than 12 months. Thus
the period of previous year can be of less than 12 months in case of new source of
income but afterwards the period is always equal to 12 months.
ASSESSMENT YEAR [SECTION 2(9)]: It refers to the year in which income of a
person (who has earned his income in the relevant previous year) is charged to
tax. THIS MEANS THAT EACH PREVIOUS YEAR HAS A UNIQUE ASSESSMENT
YEAR. ALSO THE ASSESSMENT YEAR ALWAYS FOLLOWS THE PREVIOUS YEAR
e.g.
a) PREVIOUS YEAR RELEVANT ASSESSMENT YEAR
2004-05 2005-06
(1.4.2004 TO 31.3.2005) (1.4.2005 TO 31.3.2006)
INCOME EARNED INCOME CHARGED TO TAX
b) PREVIOUS YEAR RELEVANT ASSESSMENT YEAR
2009-10 2010-11
(1.4.2009 TO 31.3.2010) (1.4.2010 TO 31.3.2011)
INCOME EARNED INCOME CHARGED TO TAX
This also leads to the conclusion that every financial year (1st April
to 31st March) is :- (1) ASSESSMENT YEAR for preceding Financial year; AND
Mr. X. All these incomes will be shown in the above said Return of Income only.
METHOD OF ACCOUNTING: Under the Act only two accounting methods are
allowed - a) Mercantile system and; b) Cash system.
But these two methods can only be employed for computing income
under head-a) Profit & Gain of Business or profession; & b) Income from other
sources.
The remaining three heads of Income i.e. a) 'Salary; b) House
property and; c) Capital Gain do not recognize any method of accounting
followed by the person/assessee. Under these three heads, income is calculated
as per provisions given in the chapter concerned.
Previous Year for Cash Credits, Investments, Money etc.
1. Cash Credit (sec 68): Where any sum is found credited in the books of an
assessee for any previous year for which the assessee has no satisfactory
explanation then such cash credit is treated as income of the assessee of the
previous year in which such income was credited.
2. Unexplained Investments (sec 69): Where in any previous year the assessee
has made any investments which are not recorded in the books of account
maintained by him and the assessee has no satisfactory explanation about the
source of investment then such unexplained investment is treated as income of
the assessee of the previous year in which such investment was made.
3. Unexplained Money (Sec 69A): Where in any previous year the assessee is
found to be the owner of any money, bullion, Jewellery or other valuable article
which is not recorded in the books of account and the assessee has no
satisfactory explanation about the source of money etc. then such unexplained
money etc. is treated as income of the assessee of the previous year in which the
assessee was found to be the owner.
4. Investments not fully disclosed in the books of account (sec 69B): Where
in any previous year the assessee has made any investments which are recorded
in the books of account maintained by him at an amount less than amount
expended and the assessee has no satisfactory explanation about the source of
excess amount expanded in investment then such excess amount is treated as
income of the assessee of the previous year in which such investment was made.
5. Unexplained Expenditure (Sec 69 C): Where in any previous year an
assessee has incurred any expenditure and the assessee has no satisfactory
explanation about the source of expenditure or part thereof then such
unexplained explained expenditure or part thereof is treated as income of the
assessee of the previous year in which such expenditure was incurred. Also such
unexplained expenditure can not be allowed as deduction under any head of
income.
6. Amount borrowed or repaid on Hundi (sec 69D): Where any amount is
borrowed on a Hundi from, or any amount due thereon is repaid to, any person
otherwise than through an account payee cheque drawn on a bank, the amount
so borrowed or repaid shall be deemed to be the income of the borrower or
repayer for the previous year in which such amount was borrowed /repaid. If
amount borrowed has already been taxed then there will be no tax levied at the
PARTICULARS AMOUNT
TAX LIABILITY
1(g) For Local Authorities: A Local Authority’s normal Income is taxable @ 30%.
(B) On Special Incomes:
1. Short Term Capital Gain u/s 111 A is taxable @ 15%.
2. Long Term Capital Gain u/s 112 is taxable @20%.
3. Winning from Lotteries, crossword puzzles, card games etc. u/s 115 BB is
taxable @ 30%.
SURCHARGE: In case a Company (Domestic or Foreign) has a total income not
exceeding Rs. 1,00,00,000 then there is no surcharge otherwise there is
surcharge of 10% (in case of Domestic Company) and 2.5% in case of foreign
company on income tax less rebate (if any).
In above case there is marginal relief of surcharge.
For other persons there is no surcharge for A.Y. 2010-11.
EDUCATION CESS: Education cess is 2% of total tax (including surcharge) for all
assessees.
SECONDARY & HIGHER EDUCATION CESS: It is 1% of total tax (including
surcharge) for all assessees.
* * *
CHAPTER-2
RESIDENTIAL STATUS
A person may earn/receive his income from a source or at a place
with in India or outside India. Such income is charged to a person on the basis of
Residential Status. Residential Status is different from 'Nationality’ or ‘Domicile.’
Before starting the concept of understanding different types of residential status
it is necessary to understand that:
1) Each and every person has a distinctive residential status for every
relevant previous year. It means that the person can be either '
ORDINARILY RESIDENT' or 'NOT ORDINARILY RESIDENT’ or ‘NON
RESIDENT’:
2) Every person has to consider his residential status in every relevant
previous year. It means that a person Resident in A.Y.2009-10 may be non-
resident in AY 2010-11 according to the rules to be studied later on.
3) It is not necessary that a person, who is resident in India, can't be Resident
in any other country in the same previous year. It simply means that a
person can be Resident in more than one country in the same previous
year.
4) If a person is resident in a particular previous year for one source of
income then he is also resident for other sources of income for that
previous year. This means that a person has same residential status
for incomes of a particular previous year.
The residential status is studied by dividing the persons in following
five categories:-
a) Individual b) H.U.F. c) Firm/AOP or BOI.
d) Company e) every other person.
Chapter-3
INCOME UNDER HEAD "SALARIES"
The first head of Income is ‘Income from Salaries’. First of all let us understand
some important concepts about it:-
a) EMPLOYER-EMPLOYEE RELATIONSHIP: The relationship between payer
and the payee must be that of employer and employee (i.e. master and
servant relationship). Whether the relationship is of master & servant or
not, is decided on case to case basis. The general rule is that a master is a
person who directs the servant WHAT IS TO BE DONE, WHEN IT IS TO BE
DONE, & HOW IT IS TO BE DONE. But this rule can't be applied in all cases.
[for example in case of a teacher or a doctor the above rule fails].
Remuneration received by a Member of Parliament is not chargeable as
salary because the relationship between him and the Government is not of
employer & employee. [It is chargeable under head “Income from other
sources”].
Remuneration received by a partner from his partnership firm is not
chargeable as salary because the relationship between him and the firm is
not of employer & employee. [It is chargeable under head "Profits & Gains
of business and profession"].
b) SURRENDER OF SALARY: Any salary surrendered by the employee to the
Central Government under Section 2 of The Voluntary Surrender of
Salaries (Exemption from taxation) Act, 1961 is not charged to tax. The
employee may be in private, public or Government service.
c) FOREGOING OF SALARY: If any salary is foregone by the employee (not
surrendered as per point (b) then it is to be charged to tax.
d) PLACE OF ACCRUAL OF SALARY: The salary income is accrued where the
employee renders the services. The place of receipt of salary is of NO
IMPORTANCE.
* But there is one exception to this rule. The salary, received by Indian
National Government Employee posted outside India, is deemed to accrue
or arise in India.
e) TAX FREE SALARY: If an employee receives tax free salary from his
employer then it simply means that tax has been paid by the employer.
The tax paid by employer will be added back to find total salary due to the
employee.
f) SALARY PAID BY FOREIGN EMPLOYER: If employee rendering service in
India is paid salary by his foreign employer; it is taxable in India (unless
otherwise stated to be exempt u/s 10).
g) SALARY DUE OR RECEIVED IN FOREIGN CURRENCY: If the employee
earns/receives salary in foreign currency, it will be converted in Rupees by
applying. TELEGRAPHIC TRANSFER BUYING RATE on the last day of the
month preceding the month in which salary is due or paid or is in arrears.
h) DISTINCTION BETWEEN SALARY & WAGES NOT IMPORTANT: The Act
does not make any difference between salary and wages. Both are
chargeable under 'SALARY'.
i) BASIC SALARY IN GRADE SYSTEM: Under this system, the annual
increments to be given to the employee are already fixed in the grade. Let
us take an example of an employee, who joins service on 1.7.2008 and is in
the grade of 15000-500-20000-1000-40000. It means that in the first year
of service i.e. from 1.7.2008 to 30.6.2009 he will get Rs. 15,000 per month.
In the next year from 1.7.2009 to 30.6.2010, his basic salary will be Rs.
15,500 (including increment of Rs. 500). He will get annual increments of
Rs. 500 till his basic is Rs. 20,000. Then his annual increments will be Rs.
1,000 till his basic is Rs. 40,000. After then there will be no increment.
j) SALARY FROM MORE THAN ONE SOURCE: If an employee gets his salary
from more than one employer then all the salary is taxable under head
income from 'SALARIES.'
k) SALARY FROM PAST, PRESENT OR FUTURE EMPLOYER: Any
remuneration received from past, present or future employer is to be
charged under head 'SALARIES'.
l) SALARY WHEN DUE: There are two approaches - i) Salary is due on the
last date of month; and ii) Salary is due on the first date of next month.
m) BASIS OF ACCOUNTING IRRELEVANT: The books of accounts kept by
employee (if any) and accounting method followed by him (cash or
mercantile) are not relevant for calculating salary income of the employee.
GROSS SALARY
Less: Deduction for Entertainment -
Allowance u/s 16 (ii)
Less: Deduction for Professional/ -
Employment tax u/s 16(iii)
INCOME UNDER HEAD SALARY
LEAVE SALARY [Section 10(10)]: The Employees are entitled to various types
of leaves while in service like casual leaves, medical leaves, outstation leaves etc.
The employee can take all these leaves. But if he does not avail all leaves then
some of the leaves may either lapse or be cancelled while some may be earned
(earned leaves). These earned leaves can be encashed by the employee either in
the same year or any other year while he is in service OR he may get earned leave
encashed on retirement or resignation or his legal heirs may get this amount
after his death.
A) If leave Salary is encashed by the employee when he is in service with the
same employer then it is FULLY TAXABLE. However relief u/s 89 can be
claimed.
B) If Leave Salary is encashed by the employee at the time of retirement or
leaving the job then the exemption is as follows:
i) Exemption for Central or State Government Employees [SECTION
10(10AA)(i)]: Leave encashment at the time of retirement/leaving the job
is FULLY EXEMPT.
ii) Exemption for other employees [SECTION 10 (10AA)(ii)]: Leave
encashment at the time of retirement/ leaving the job is exempt to the least of
following:
(a) Leave Encashment actually received;
(b) 10 months X Average Salary;
(c) (Total leave entitlement by taking maximum 30 days for every completed
year of service - Months of leaves availed/encashed) X Average Salary.
(d) Rs 3,00,000/- (Rupees Three Lac only).
NOTE:
1. Salary Means Basic Salary, Dearness Allowance (if the terms of
Employment so provide) and Commission based on fixed percentage of
turnover achieved by the employee.
2. Average Salary means “Salary of 10 months immediately preceding
retirement/leaving the job.
3. Leave salary paid to legal heirs of the deceased employee is not taxable.
4. In case of other employees, maximum amount of leave salary exempt from
tax is Rs. 3,00,000. This is applicable if the employee has more than one
employer in his life.
NOTE:
1) Salary means Basic Salary, Dearness Allowance (if the terms of employment so
provide) and commission based on fixed percentage turnover achieved by the
employee.
2) The receipt of Lump sum amount on Retirement/ resignation on shall be
exempt if:
(a) The employee has completed continuous service for 5 years or more; OR
(b) The employee has been terminated due to employee’s ill health, closure
of employer’s business or other reason beyond control of the employee;
OR.
(c) The employee continues with same Provident fund Account with other
employer.
(3) The receipt of Lump-sum amount on URPF balance shall be treated on
follows:-
(a) Employer’s Contribution (total) + Interest on employer’s Contribution
shall be fully taxable as Salary.
(b) Interest on Employee’s Contribution Shall be fully taxable as ‘Income from
other Sources’;
(4) PPF: Annual contribution by individual/ HUF fully qualifies for Deduction
u/s 80C. The annual Interest on PPF is fully exempt. The Lump sum
amount received is also fully exempt.
ALLOWANCES
Allowance is fixed amount of money paid/payable by the employer
to the employee for meeting some expense-the expense may be official or
personal. All allowances are taxable UNLESS OTHERWISE CLEARLY STATED TO
BE EXEMPT. The taxable allowances are taxed on due or receipt basis whichever
is earlier. The allowances can be studied under following heads –
(a) Fully exempted allowances.
(b) Allowances Exempted UPTO some Limit.
(c) Entertainment allowance.
(d) Fully Taxable Allowances.
Now we shall study them one by one.
FULLY EXEMPTED ALLOWANCES: These are:
(1) Allowances (all) to Indian National Government Employees posted out
side India.
(2) Allowances to High Court Judges under section 22A (2) of the High court
Judges (Conditions of service) Act, 1954.
(3) Sumptuary Allowance to High court and Supreme Court Judges.
(4) Allowances to UNO employees.
official purpose.
(4) Helper Allowance: It is given to meet expenditure of helper for official
purpose.
(5) Academic Allowance: It is given to meet academic/ research/ training
costs in Educational & Research Institutions.
(6) Uniform Allowance: It is given to meet the cost of purchase and
maintenance of uniform for official purpose.
ENTERTAINMENT ALLOWANCE
This allowance is given to entertain various persons while
performing official duty. This is fully taxable. But in case of Central/ State
Government Employees, a deduction u/s 16(ii) can be claimed to the least of the
following:
(a) Actual Entertainment allowance;
(b) 20% of Basic Salary;
(c) Rs 5,000 (Rupees five Thousand only).
PERQUISITES
Perquisites (or perks) are the benefits/ facilities in cash or in kind
provided by the employer to the employee either free of cost or at concessional
rate. The most important feature of perk is that the employee must have a right
to the same and it should not be voluntary or contingent (i.e. may or may not be)
payment.
(f) The value of sweat equity shares or any specified security (like Debentures
or Warrants) allotted or transferred (directly or indirectly) by the employer
either free or at concessional rates to the employee;
(g) The amount of employer’s contribution towards approved
superannuation fund in excess of Rs. 1,00,000;
(h) The value of any other benefit or amenity as may be prescribed.
NOTE: The perquisites from (a), (b), (d), (e) and (h) are taxable in the hands of all
employees whether specified or non-specified. In case of specified employees
perquisites mentioned in (c) are also taxable. Perquisites as per (f) and (g) are
taxable only if conditions mentioned therein are fulfilled.
TAXABILITY OF PERQUISITES
Perks are divided into three categories as follows-
1) Perks taxable in case of all the employees.
2) Perks taxable in case of specified employees only.
3) Perk of sweat equity shares or any specified security (like Debentures
or Warrants) allotted or transferred (directly or indirectly) by the employer
either free or at concessional rates to the employee.
4) Perk of employer’s contribution towards approved superannuation fund in
excess of Rs. 1,00,000.
5) Tax-free or exempted perks.
FOR PRIVATE SECTOR & OTHER EMPLOYEES: This category includes those
employees who are not covered under the above category.
i) Where the accommodation is unfurnished.
Population of It accommodation is owned If accommodation
City as per by employer taken on lease or rent
2001 census by the employer
More than 15% of salary in respect of 15% of salary OR actual
25,00,000 period during which the rent paid/payable by
accommodation is occupied by the employer which
the employee. ever is less.
More than 10% of salary in respect of
10,00,000 but period during which Same as above
up to 25,00,000 accommodation is occupied by
the employee.
Any other city 7.50% of salary in respect of
period during which Same as above
accommodation is occupied by
the employee.
NOTE:
- MEANING OF SALARY FOR RENT FREE ACCOMMODATION: For this
purpose, salary includes:-
Basic salary, dearness allowance / pay (if the terms of employment
so provide), Bonus, Commission, fees, all taxable parts of allowances and
all monetary payments chargeable to tax (like leave encashment, pension
of current year).
For this purpose salary does not include:-
Dearness allowance / pay (if the terms of employment do not so
provide), employer’s contribution to PROVIDENT FUND ACCOUNT of the
employee, all allowances or part of allowances exempt from tax, value of
perquisites specified under section 17 (2) of the Act.
- Accommodation includes house, flat, farm house or part there of or
accommodation in a hotel, motel, service apartment, guest house, caravan,
mobile home, ship or other floating structure.
- Hotel includes licensed accommodation in motel, service apartment or
guest house.
- Salary is to be computed an accrual basis.
- Salary from all employers (in case of two or more employers) will be taken
into consideration for the period during which the accommodation is
provided.
- If employee is provided accommodation is a remote area and the employee
is working at mining site or onshore oil exploration site or project
execution site or an offshore site of similar nature then value of such
accommodation in NIL.
- If an employee is transferred from one place to other and he is provided
accommodation at new place while he occupies the old accommodation
also then value of perk will be only for one accommodation having lower
value till first 90 days and thereafter both the accommodations will be
charged to tax.
purposes
2) In any other case Value equal to amount
paid/reimbursed by the employer.
Such perk is to be reduced by
amount recovered from employee.
*The employer: a) has to maintain a complete detail of such expenses; and
b) has to give a certificate in this regard that such expenses are incurred
wholly and exclusively for official purposes.
ix) Valuation of any other benefit, amenity, facility etc. provided by the
employer [RULE 3 (7) (ix)]: The value of such benefit (for example: sale of
goods to employee at concessional rates) shall be cost to the employer under an
arm’s length transaction less employee’s contribution. But this rule does not
apply to perk of telephones and mobiles which is fully exempt.
Note :-
1. Car is used for official purpose wholly only if following conditions are fulfilled:
a) Employer has maintained full detail of journey for official purpose; &
b) Employer gives certificate in this regard.
2. Month means complete month as per English calendar and part of the month is
ignored.
3. If employee is allowed to use more than one car then perk of one of the cars
will be as if car is used partly for official and partly for private purpose and perk
of other cars will be as if these are used wholly for private purpose.
4. If employee pays some amount for the perk enjoyed then such amount shall be
deducted from the value of perk. But in case of car used partly for official &
partly for private purpose nothing will be deducted if car is owned/leased by
the employer.
5. Use of car by employee from residence to office and back is not chargeable to
tax.
6. Conveyance facility to High Court Judges and Supreme Court Judges in not
taxable.
Note:
1. Perk of Free education covered under point (b) is taxable in case of all
employees. Perk covered under point (a) is taxable in case of is taxable in
case of specified employees only.
2. Free education facility and training of employees in not taxable.
3. Fixed education allowance in exempt up to Rs. 100 p.m. per child (for
maximum of two children) and Hostel allowance is exempt up to Rs. 300
pm. per child (for maximum of two children). Excess is taxable.
4. Scholarship to children of employee by the employer solely at employer’s
discretion is not a perquisite.
VALUATION OF PERK OF FREE/CONCESSIONAL JOURNEY IN CASE
is fully exempt.
16. Employer’s Contribution to Staff Group Insurance Scheme is FULLY
EXEMPT.
17. Premium paid by employer on personal accident policy of employee is
FULLY EXEMPT.
18. Transfer (without consideration) of a movable asset (other than computer,
electronic item and car) by the employer to the employee after using it for
10 years or more is FULLY EXEMPT.
19. Tax paid by the employer on non-monetary perquisites of the employee is
FULLY EXEMPT.
20. Leave Travel Concession is exempt upto limits mentioned in the rules of
valuation discussed later on.
(a) For all employees- The LTC received/receivable by the employee from his
present/past employer is entitled for exemption if-
he proceeds on leave to any place in India; or
he proceeds to any place in India after retirement/ termination of his
service.
AMOUNT OF EXEMPTION
IF JOURNEY IS PERFORMED BY AIR EXEMPT UPTO ECONOMY FARE OF
NATIONAL CARRIER BY SHORTEST
ROUTE.
IF JOURNEY PERFORMED OTHER EXEMPT UPTO 1ST CLASS AC FARE BY
THAN BY AIR & ORIGIN & SHOTREST ROUTE
DESTINATION PLACES ARE
CONNECTED BY RAIL
IF ORIGIN AND DESTINATION EXEMPT UPTO 1ST CLASS FAIR OF
PLACES ARE NOT CONNECTED BY RECOGNISED PUBLIC TRANSPORT BY
RAIL SHOREST POSSIBLE ROUTE.
IN CASE OF NO RECOGNISED PUBLIC
TRANSPORT. EXEMPT UPTO 1ST
CLASS AC FARE OF RAIL BY
SHORTEST ROUTE (IMAGINING
JOURNEY PERFORMED BY RAIL)
NOTE: 1The Amount Exempt can never be more than actual amount spent on
Fare.
1. The LTC exemption is allowed 2 times in block of 4 calendar years. If LTC
Exemption is not availed in any block then only one LTC exemption can be
carried forward to first year of next block of 4 years.
2. The other expenses of journey (like boarding, lodging, conveyance) are not
subject to exemption.
3. LTC is for family (including spouse and children of the employee; parents,
brothers and sisters of employee wholly/mainly dependent upon him).
4. From 1st October, 1998, the benefit of LTC is for only 2 children. But
children borne before 1.10.1998 as well as multiple birth after one child
after 30.9.1998 are eligible for exemption.
LTC FOR FOREIGN CITIZENS
Passage money received by foreign citizen is fully chargeable to tax.
6. Any other sum received by the employee form the employer like:-
a) Taxable part of gratuity.
b) Taxable part of pension.
c) Taxable part of RPF
d) Taxable part of approved superannuation fund
e) Taxable part of HRA.
Therefore except terminal and other payments exempt under sec 10
(10) to sec 10 (13A), all other payments received by the employee from
past/present/future employer is taxed as profit in lieu of salary.
infrastructure.
18. Any sum deposited in a term deposit with a scheduled bank for a period
not less than 5 years in accordance with the scheme framed and notified
by the Central Government.
19. Subscription to notified bonds of NABARD.
20. Any sum deposited in an account under Senior Citizen Saving Scheme.
21. Any sum deposited in 5 years term deposit account in Post Office as per
the Post Office Time Deposit Rules, 1981.
STEP 2. NET QUALIFYING AMOUNT
The aggregate of payments from (1) to (21) above is the Gross Qualifying
Amount. The Net Qualifying Amount is determined as follows:
a) Gross Qualifying Amount; or
b) Rs. 1,00,000 whichever is less.
STEP:3 AMOUNT OF DEDUCTION
The net qualifying amount as calculated in step 2 is the amount of deduction
under section 80 C. The point to remembered is that the aggregate of deductions
under section 80 C, 80 CCC and 80 CCD cannot exceed Rs. 1,00,000.
*****
Chapter 4
INCOME FROM HOUSE PROPERTY
property. This also includes a house property which is not actually occupied by
the owner due to employment or business carried on at any other place. If an
assessee is owner of more than one self occupied house properties then only one
house is treated as self occupied and other houses as Deemed to be let out
houses.
A) INCOME FROM LET OUT HOUSE (INCLUDING DEEMED TO BE LET OUT
HOUSE PROPERTY):
It is calculated as under:
Gross annual value ***
Less: Municipal taxes actually paid by owner ***
__________
STEP I: Expected Rent of house is (a) or (b) w.e. is higher subject to maximum of
(c). If step 2 and step (3) are not applicable then expected rent is gross annual
value (It will be so in case of deemed to be let out house).
STEP II: Find out Actual Annual Rent less unrealized rent i.e. [d- e].
STEP III: Find out amount which is higher of amount as per Step 1 or amount as
per step II.
STEP IV: From the amount as per step 3 deduct Loss due to vacancy. This is
Gross annual value. i.e. GAV = Amount as per Step III – (f).
NOTE: If the ownership of such house property is for a period less than 12
months then values as per (a), (b), (c) and (d) shall be calculated for period of
ownership only.
DEDUCTION OF MUNICIPAL TAXES
The municipal taxes levied by the local authority on such house
property are deducted from gross annual value only if these are borne and
actually paid by the owner during the previous year.
The amount after deduction of municipal tax is called NET ANNUAL
VALUE or ANNUAL VALUE.
STANDARD DEDUCTION U/S 24(a): The standard deduction is 30% of Net
Annual Value.
INTEREST ON BORROWED CAPITAL U/S 24(b): The interest on capital
borrowed (for purchase, construction, repair, renewal or re-construction of the
house) is deductible on accrual basis. Interest is divided into two parts:
a) Interest on loan for pre – construction period: It is a period starting
from date of borrowal till 31st March immediately preceding the date of
completion of construction/date of purchase or date of repayment of loan w.e. is
earlier. This is deductible in FIVE EQUAL ANNUAL INSTALMENTS STARTING
FROM THE YEAR OF COMPLETION OF CONSTRUCTION / YEAR OF PURCHASE.
b) Interest on post construction period: It is deductible in the year to
which it belongs on ACCRUAL BASIS.
Note :
1) Interest on unpaid interest is not deductible.
2) Interest on fresh loan taken to repay original housing loan is deductible.
3) It is not necessary that such property must be given as security for availing
such loan.
4) If interest on such loan is payable out of India, it is available for deduction
only if TDS has been deducted on such interest.
that firstly, the unrealized rent which was not allowed as deduction earlier will
be covered and balance if any is taxable. This is taxable as income from house
property whether or not the assessee is owner of the said house in the year of
recovery.
b) Deduction allowed in assessment year 2002-2003 or subsequent year
(Sec. 25AA): If the assessee cannot realize rent during previous year 2001-2002
or any subsequent year (and it is allowed as deduction in that year) and the
assessee realizes such rent, the amount so realized (to the extent it has not been
included in ANNUAL VALUE earlier) shall deemed to be the income of previous
year in which rent is realized whether not the assessee is owner of that property
in that previous year.
ARREARS OF RENT RECEIVED – TAXABILITY THEREOF (SEC. 25B) If
the owner of house property receives arrears of rent not charged to tax in any
previous year then it is taxable in the year of receipt after standard deduction @
30% of such amount under head ‘Income from house property’. It is immaterial
whether or not the assessee is owner of that property in that previous year.
* * *
CHAPTER - 5
INCOME UNDER HEAD “PROFITS AND GAINS OF BUSINESS OR PROFESSION”
BASIS OF CHARGE (SEC. 28): The following incomes shall be charged to tax
under this head:
a) The profits and gains of any business carried on by the assessee at any
time during the year;
b) Any COMPENSATION or other payments due to or received by:
1. any person in connection with termination/modification of his
agreement for managing the whole or substantially the whole of the affairs
of an Indian Company or any other company;
2. any person holding an agency in India for any part of the activities
relating to the business of any other person at or in connection with
termination / modification of the terms of the agency;
3. any person for or in connection with the vesting in the Government (or
in any corporation owned by or controlled by Government) under any law
for the time being imposed, of the management of any property or
business.
c) Income derived by a trade, professional or similar association from
specific services performed for its members.
d) Exports incentives, which include:
1. profits on sales of import licences granted under imports (control) order
on account of exports;
2. cash assistance (by whatever name called), received or receivable
against exports;
3. Duty drawbacks of Customs and Central Excise Duties;
4. Profit on transfer of Duty Entitlement Pass Book Scheme;
5. Profit on transfer of Duty Free Replenishment Certificate
e) the value of any benefit or perquisite whether convertible into money or not
arising during the course of carrying on of any business / profession;
f) any interest, salary, bonus, commission, or remuneration due to or
received by a partner of firm from the firm in which he is a partner. Such
amount shall be adjusted according to provisions of Section 40 (b);
g) any sum received / receivable in cash or in kind under agreement for:
1. not carrying out activity in relation to any business; or
2. not sharing know how, patent, copyright, trade mark, licence, franchise
or any other business or commercial right of similar nature or information
or technique likely to assist in the manufacture or processing of goods or
provision for services.
But the point g (i) above shall not apply where the amount is received /
receivable for TRANSFER / SALE of rights (which is chargeable under head
‘Capital Gains’).
h) any sum received under a Keyman Insurance Policy including the sum
allocated by way of bonus on such policy;
i) where speculative transactions carried on by an assessee are of such a
the question of beneficial ownership and decide who should be held liable for tax.
7. Real profit versus anticipated profits: The profits or losses which may
occur in future are not considered for calculating business or profession income
for previous year. However there is one exception: Stock in trade is valued at
cost or market price which ever is lower.
8. Real Profits versus notional profits: Real profits are charged to tax and
notional profits are not taxable. So no profit can be shown on drawing of goods
by the proprietor by treating them (at sale price) as sale.
9. Mode of book entry is not relevant: The mode of book entry cannot
change the basic character of a transaction. So a trading receipt will remain
trading receipt even if it is shown in the books as capital receipt.
10. Illegal Business: It is immaterial whether business is legal or illegal. Both
businesses are taxable under the law.
11. Business loss or Loss incidental to trade: Business profit is computed
after allowing deduction for business loss. Business loss should be trading loss
and must fulfill following conditions:
a) Loss should be real loss and not notional / fictitious
b) Loss should be revenue in nature.
c) Loss should be incurred during the pervious year.
d) Loss must have actually arisen and been incurred, not merely anticipated
as certain to occur in future.
e) Loss should be incidental to business and profession carried on by the
assessee.
f) There should not be any, direct or indirect, prohibition under the Act
against deductibility of such loss.
The following losses are deductible as business loss:
- Losses of stock in trade as result of enemy action.
- Losses of stock in trade by an act of God.
- Losses arising out of failure on the part of assessee to accept delivery of
goods.
- Losses caused by confiscation of cash from gold smuggler by custom
authorities.
- Depreciation in funds kept in foreign currency for purchase of stock in
trade.
- Loss due to exchange rate fluctuations of foreign currency held on revenue
account.
- Loss arising from sale of short term investments.
- Loss of cash and securities in bank on account of dacoity (with in or after
working hours).
- Loss on realization of amount advanced in connection with business.
- Loss due to embezzlement by the employee.
The following losses are not deductible:
- Loss of capital asset.
- Loss on sale of Trade / Non-trade investment.
- Depreciation of funds kept in foreign currency for capital purposes.
deduction from income under the head ‘Profits and Gains of Business or
Profession’.
14. No allowance in respect of anticipated losses: Except while valuing the
closing stock (at cost or realisable value whichever is less), no deduction is
allowed for any anticipated loss from income under the head ‘Profits and Gains of
Business or Profession’.
3. Depreciation (sec. 32): One should satisfy the following condition for
claiming depreciation:-
A) Assessee must be the OWNER of the asset;
B) The asset must be used for business or profession;
C) The assets should be used during the previous year;
D) Depreciation is available on tangible as well as intangible assets.
a) Asset must be used for business or profession: The owner is the
person who can exercise the rights of the owner not on behalf of own but in his
own rights. Owner needs not to be registered owner. If the assessee carries on
business or profession from leasehold building then he is entitled to depreciation
on capital expenditure incurred by him. In any other case, the depreciation is
available to the Lessor.
b) Asset must be used for business or profession: The depreciation is
allowed only if the asset is used for business or profession. If asset is used for
business partly and partly for other purposes then depreciation is allowed only
for use for business or profession. When residential quarters are given to
employees for efficient running of business then depreciation is allowed on such
buildings and other assets like fridge, fans etc. given to employees.
c) Asset should be used during the previous year: The asset must be used
at least for some time during the relevant previous year for business purpose to
claim normal depreciation. However 50% of normal depreciation is allowed if
following two conditions are satisfied:-
i) Asset is acquired during the preview year; AND
ii) It is put to use for the purpose of business or profession for less than 180
days during that year.
d) Depreciation is available on tangible assets as well as intangible
assets: i) Tangible assets mean and include building, Machinery, plant and
furniture.
ii) Intangible assets means assets acquired after 31 st March, 1998 and include
know-how, patents, copyright, trademarks, license, franchises or any other
business or commercial rights of similar nature.
NOTE: From assessment year 2002-03 depreciation is available whether the
assessee has claimed deduction for depreciation in computing his income or not.
STEPS FOR CALCULATION OF DEPRECIATION: The depreciation is calculated
on BLOCK OF ASSETS on WRITTEN DOWN METHOD as per RATES OF
DEPRECIATION PRESCRIBED UNDER THE ACT. However from 1.04.1997
ONWARDS, an undertaking engaged in generation OR generation and
distribution of power can claim depreciation on STRAIGHT LINE METHOD.
Now are shall understand the meaning of following terms:-
BLOCK OF ASSETS
WRITTEN DOWN VALUE
ACTUAL COST
1. Block of assets [sec. 2 (11)]: It means a group of assets falling with in a class
of asset namely :-
a) Tangible assets being buildings, machinery, plant or furniture.
b) Intangible assets being know-how, patents, copyrights, trademarks,
licences, franchises or any other business or commercial rights of similar nature.
There are 13 different blocks out of which 1 to 12 are in respect of tangible assets
and block13 is for intangible assets.
BLOCK NATURE OF ASSET Rate of
Depreciation
1. Buildings: Residential other than Hotels and boarding
houses. 5%
2. Buildings: Office, factory etc. not being residential
buildings (it includes hotels and boarding houses but does 10%
not include block I & 3).
3. Buildings –a) Temporary wooden or other structure 100%
b) Buildings acquired on or after 1-09-2002 for installing
plant & Machinery for water supply project or water
reduced by that portion of the cost thereof if any, as has been met directly or
indirectly by any other person or authority.
1) INTEREST TO BE INCLUDED/ EXCLUDED IN ACTUAL COST:
(a) Interest pertaining to the period till the asset is first put to use should be
added to the actual cost of the asset.
(b) Interest incurred relatable to any period after the asset is first put to use,
cannot be included in the Actual Cost. It is to be treated as deduction u/s
36 (i)(iii).
Note: It does not matter whether the business is new or existing one.
2) TRAVELLING EXPENDITURE: For acquiring depreciable assets is a part of
Actual Cost.
3) NOTIONAL ACTUAL COST: In the following cases, the actual cost shall be
a notional cost as follows:
(a) Assets used in Business after it ceases to be used for Scientific Research-
NOTIONAL ACTUAL COST 'NIL'
(b) Asset acquired by gift or inheritance- Actual cost to previous owner MINUS
Depreciation actually allowed till 31.03.1987 MINUS Depreciation
allowable on that asset after 31.03.1987 assuming it is only asset in the
block.
(c) Asset transferred to reduce tax liability by claiming Depreciation at
enhanced cost – Actual cost determined by Assessing officer with approval
of Joint Commissioner. However genuine cases are not covered.
(d) Assets earlier transferred re-acquired by the assessee- Notional Actual
cost will be – (Actual price for which re-acquired) OR (original cost minus
depreciation actually allowed to him till 31.03.1987 MINUS Depreciation
allowable on that asset after 31.03.1987 assuming it is only in the block)
which ever is less.
(e) Asset previously used by any person and on which depreciation was
allowed to him is acquired by another person but leased back to seller-
NOTIONAL ACTUAL COST in the hands of LESSOR shall be equal to W.D.V
of the asset to the seller at the time of transfer thereof.
(f) Buildings brought into use for business purpose subsequent to its
acquisition- NOTIONAL ACTUAL COST shall be. Original Cost of building
MINUS A DEPRECIATION that would have been allowable had the building
been used for business since acquisition.
(g) Assets transferred by holding Company to 100% Subsidiary or vice versa
where the transferee Company is an Indian Company – NOTIONAL
ACTUAL COST to the transferee Company shall be the same value as would
have been to the Transferor Company if it continued to hold it.
(h) Assets transferred under a scheme amalgamation- Notional Actual cost to
the Amalgamating Company shall be same value as would have been to the
Amalgamating Company, if it continued to hold it. This rule is also
applicable if the Amalgamated Company is Indian Company.
(i) Asset transferred to the to the Resulting Company in case of Demerger:
Notional Actual cost to Resulting Company shall be same value as would
business Losses.
NOTE: If separate accounts are not maintained for growing and manufacturing of
tea or coffee or rubber IN INDIA then profits from such tea or coffee or rubber
Business will be calculated as under:
Profit from Tea (or coffee or rubber) Business=
Profit of business x Turnover of tea or coffee or rubber Business / Total turnover.
(ii) Where deduction has been allowed u/s 33 AB, no deduction shall be
allowed in respect of such amount in any other previous year.
(iii) Where a deduction has been claimed and allowed under this section, to an
Association of Persons or Body of Individuals, no deduction shall be allowed to
any member of AOP or BOI in respect of the same deposit.
(iv) Any excess deposit made during a previous year is not treated as a deposit
made in next year or other year.
UTILISATION OF DEPOSITED AMOUNT: The amount standing to the credit of
the assessee in special account of NABARD or TEA OR COFFEE OR RUBBER
DEVELOPMENT Account is to be utilised for the business of the assessee with
respect to the points as per the scheme. But no deduction shall be allowed for the
purchase of:
1. Any machinery or plant to be installed in any office or residential place
(including guest house);
2. Any office appliances (not being computer(s));
3. Any machinery or plant, the whole of the actual cost of which is allowed
as deduction (whether by Depreciation or otherwise) in computing
Income chargeable under head ‘profit & gains of Business or Profession' of
any previous year;
4. Any new machinery or plant to be installed in an Industrial undertaking
for purpose of business of construction, manufacture or production of any
article or thing specified in eleventh Schedule of Income tax (i. e. low
priority items).
WITHDRAWAL OF DEPOSIT: Any amount deposited as above shall not be
withdrawn except for the purposes specified in the scheme. Otherwise it is
allowed to be withdrawn in following circumstances: (i) closure of business; (ii)
Death of the assessee; (iii) Partition of HUF; (iv) Dissolution of firm; (v)
liquidation of Company.
Amount withdrawn for (i) & (iv) reasons in taxable as profits in the year of
withdrawal while for remaining cases such withdrawal is not taxable.
WITHDRAWAL OF DEDUCTION: In following cases deduction is withdrawn:
(a) Any amount withdrawn but not utilised with in same previous year for the
specified purpose shall be treated as income of that year;
(b) Any asset acquired to the scheme, is sold or transferred before expiry of 8
years from end of year of purchase; the cost of such asset relatable to deduction
allowed will be income in the year of sale of asset or transfer of asset.
However these provisions are not applicable in case of conversion of firm into a
company and sale of asset to Government, Local Authority, Statutory Corporation
or government Company.
a) REVENUE EXPENDITURE:
(i) Incurred by the assessee himself relating to his own business;
(ii) As contribution made to outside agencies engaged in scientific work.
b) Capital Expenditure incurred by the assessee himself relating to his own
business.
c) Revenue or Capital Expenditure for approved in-house research.
Now we shall study these in detail.
a)(i) Revenue Expenditure incurred by Assessee himself [Sec 35(1)(i)]:
1. All revenue expenses laid out or expended on scientific research during the
previous year are fully allowed as deduction.
2. It has been further provided that following revenue expenses laid out or
expended during three years immediately preceding the date of commencement
of business shall be deemed to be the expenditure of the previous year in which
the business commences and therefore shall be allowed in that year to the extent
these are certified by the prescribed authority:
i) Payment of salary (except perquisites) to employees engaged in
scientific research; and
ii) Purchase of material used for scientific research
NOTE: It is to be noted that the research must relate to the business of the
assessee.
a)(ii) Contribution made to outsiders [Sec 35(1)(ii), (iia) & (iii)]:
Where the assessee does not himself carry on scientific research but
makes contribution to other the institutions for this purpose then a weighted
deduction is allowed of 125% of any sum paid to a scientific research association
or university, college or other institution (APPROVED BY CENTRAL GOVT.)
NOTE: It is to be noted that the research may or may not relate to the business of
the assessee.
Contribution made to National Laboratory or University or IIT [Sec
35(2AA)]: Where the assessee pays any sum to a 'NATIONAL LABORATORY' or
'UNIVERSITY' or ‘INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY' or a ‘SPECIFIED
PERSON' (means a person approved by prescribed authority), then such sum is
eligible for weighted deduction of 125% of such sum paid.
National Laboratory means a scientific laboratory functioning at national
level under the aegis of Indian Council of Agricultural Research, Indian Council of
Medical Research, The Council of Scientific and Industrial Research, The Defence
Research and Development Organisation, The Department of Electronics, the
Department of Bio-Technology and The Department of Atomic Energy Prescribed
Authority shall be the head of a National Laboratory or a University or an Indian
Institute of Technology as the case may be. In the case of 'specified person' the
prescribed authority shall be The Principal Scientific Advisor to the Government
of India.
NOTE: It may be noted that the research may or may not relate to the business of
the assessee.
b) Capital Expenditure incurred by assessee himself [Sec 35(1)(iv)]:
1. Where the assessee incurs any expenditure of capital nature RELATED TO
THE BUSINESS OF THE ASSESSEE, the whole of such expenditure incurred in any
previous year is allowable as deduction for that previous year.
2. Further capital expenditure incurred during three years immediately
preceding the date of commencement of business shall be deemed to be expenses
of the previous year of the commencement of business and allowed in that year.
Capital Expenditure may be for acquisition of plant or equipment or construction
of Building (excluding cost of Land), acquisition of vehicles for scientific research.
NOTE: 1. No Depreciation is available on an asset used in scientific research.
2. If the asset is sold without having been used for other purposes, surplus (i.e.
sale price) or deduction allowed under section 35 whichever is less shall be
chargeable to tax as business income of the previous year in which the sale took
place. The excess of sale price over cost of acquisition (or indexed cost of
acquisition) is chargeable to tax under head capital gain and the deficiency is
treated as capital loss under the same head.
c) Expenditure on in-house Research & Development by a Company
assessee [Section 35(2AB)]: A weighted deduction of 150% of sum incurred
will be allowed to a COMPANY assessee if:
i) It is engaged in business of manufacture or production any article or thing
except those notified I the Eleventh Schedule; and
ii) It has incurred expenditure (except on Land and Building) on in house
scientific research and development facility approved by the prescribed
authority.
iii) It has entered into agreement with prescribed authority for co-operation in
such research and for audit of the accounts maintained for that facility.
NOTE:1. The expenditure on Building acquisition or construction shall be
allowed @ 100%.
2. No weighted deduction @150% will be allowed to Company assessee after
31.03.2012.
3. If capital expenditure on scientific research can not be allowed due to absence
or inadequacy of profits of the business, the deficiency so arising is to be carried
forward as if it is unabsorbed depreciation.
4. In pursuant to an agreement of arrangement of the amalgamation if the
amalgamating company, transfers to the amalgamated company which is an
Indian company, any asset representing the capital expenditure on scientific
research, the above said provisions of section 35 shall apply to the amalgamated
company as if there is no amalgamation.
2. If a deduction is claimed under this provision it shall not be allowed under any
other provision of the Act for any year.
then such expenditure will be allowed as deduction for the previous year in
which the operations were commenced.
conditions:-
a) The amount payable to employees as bonus or commission should not
otherwise have been payable to them as profit or dividend.
b) Bonus or Commission is allowed as deduction only where payment is
made: i) during the previous year; or
ii) on or before due date or actual date of filing the return
which ever is earlier [As per provisions under section 43 B if assessee follows
accrual basis].
disallowed.
7) First time expenditure on fluorescent lights is treated as fixed asset but all
replacement expenses of tubes are allowed as deduction.
tax is deducted at source after the expiry of time limit given in section
200(1), such sum shall be allowed as a deduction in computing the income
of the previous year in which such sum has been paid;
iii) Any sum paid on account of any rate or tax levied on the profit or gains
of any business or profession or assessed at a proportion of or otherwise
on the basis of, any such profits or gains;
iv) Any sum paid on account of wealth tax under the Wealth Tax Act and
any tax of a similar character chargeable under any law in force in any
country outside India;
v) Salary payable:
a) out of India (to a resident or non-resident);
b) in India to a non-resident;
if tax has not been paid nor deducted at source.
vi) Any payment to provident fund or other fund established for the
benefit of employees of the assessee, unless the assessee has made
effective arrangements to secure that tax shall be deducted at source from
any payments made from the funds, which are chargeable to tax under the
head ‘Salaries’.
vii) Any tax actually paid by employer on non-monetary perquisites
provided to the employees.
B) In case of partnership firm [section 40 (b)]:-
These will be discussed in detail in the chapter ‘Assessment of
partnership firms’. Interest on partners’ capital/loan is allowed up to 12% p.a.
and salary, commission etc. to a WORKING PARTNER is allowed up to certain
limits and as per terms to the partnership Deed.
C) In case AOP/BOI [section 40 (ba)]:-
This will be discussed in detail in the chapter ‘Assessments of
AOP/BOI’. Any amount paid to member of AOP/BOI as salary, remuneration,
bonus or commission is fully disallowed.
sections 30 to 37.
3) It is possible that a person may make different payments (otherwise than
by an account payee cheque or account payee bank draft) at different time
during the day to the same person and none of the payments during the
day to same party exceeds Rs. 20,000/Rs. 35,000*.But if the aggregate
payment exceeds Rs. 20000/Rs. 35,000* then whole of such payment is
disallowed.
4) Section 40 A (3) is applicable only in computing income under head
‘profits and gain of business or profession’ and ‘income from other
sources'.
* Rs. 35,000 in case payment is made on or after 1st October, 2009 for plying,
hiring or leasing goods carriage.
41(5)].
g) Any sum received after the discontinuation of the Business or Profession is
deemed to be the income of the recipient and is charged to tax in the year of
the receipt [section 176 (3A) and 176(4)].
NOTE: The above incomes are taxable in the year of receipt even if in that year
the business is not in existence.
books audited is 30th September of the assessment year in case of all assessees.
The chartered Accountant gives his audit report in form 3 CA (if the assessee in
required to get his accounts audited under any law) or in form 3 CB (if the
assessee is NOT required to get his accounts audited under any other law). The
details of such audit are given in form 3CD.
SUBMISSION OF AUDIT REPORT: The audit report as per section 44AB is not to
be attached with new return forms. Such audit report should not be submitted to
income tax department before, on or after due date of filing the return i.e. 30th
September. However, the audit report should be obtained on or before due date.
NOTE: - If the date is extended by the income tax department then 30th
September shall replaced by such date.
trucks.
3. The assessee does not own more than 10 goods carriages at any time during
the year. For this purpose, a goods carriage taken on hire purchase or on
installments shall be deemed to be owned by the assessee.
4. The income of a heavy goods vehicle (the unladen weight of which is more
than 12000 kilogram) is estimated at Rs. 3500/- per month (or part of month)
during which the goods carriage in owned by the assessee.
5. The income of a good carriage other than heavy goods vehicle is estimated at
Rs. 3150/- per month (or part of a month) during which the goods carriage
owned by the assessee.
6. The assessee can voluntarily declare higher income.
7. The income as above is after deduction of all expenses from section 30 to 38
including depreciation. But in case of firm, salary and interest on capital to
partners under section 40(b) shall be allowed from such income.
8. Such assessee is not required to keep any books of accounts. He is also not
required to get his accounts audited.
9. Such assessee is eligible for deductions under chapter VI A, if conditions
therein are fulfilled.
10. Such assessee can however claim his income to be lower but he will have
maintain the books of account as per section 44AA and get his accounts audited
under section 44AB.
***
Chapter-6
INCOME UNDER THE HEAD CAPITAL GAINS
BASIS OF CHARGE [SEC 45]: Any profits or gains arising from transfer of capital
asset effected in the previous year, shall be chargeable to tax under the head
‘Capital Gains’ and shall be deemed to be income of the previous year in which
the transfer took place unless such capital gain is exempt u/s 54,54B, 54D, 54EC,
54F, 54G or 54GA. Thus, the following are essential conditions for taxing capital
gains:
(a) There must be a capital Asset.
(b) The capital asset must have been ‘transferred’ by the Assessee. (But in
some cases capital gains arise even if there is no transfer of Capital Asset).
(c) Such transfer must have taken place during the previous year. (But in
some cases capital gain is taxable in a year other than the year in which the
capital asset is transferred).
(d) There must be profits or gains on such transfer, which is called ‘Capital
gains’.
(e) Such profit or gains should not be exempt u/s 54,54B, 54D, 54EC, 54F, 54G
or 54GA.
NOTE: According to section 45 (1A), in case of profits or gains from insurance
claim due to damage or destruction of property by fire or other calamities, there
will be capital gain, although no asset is transferred in such case.
(A) THERE MUST BE A CAPITAL ASSET: Capital Gain arises only on transfer
of a ‘Capital Asset'. Capital Asset means property of any kind (whether FIXED OR
CIRCULATING, MOVABLE OR IMMOVABLE, TANGIBLE OR INTANGIBLE) held by
the assessee. However, the following are not included in the definition of Capital
Asset:
(a) Any stock-in-trade, consumable store or raw material held for the purpose
of the business or profession of the assessee;
(b) Personal effects of the assessee which means movable property including
wearing apparel and furniture held for personal use by the assessee or any
member of his family dependent upon him. However, the following assets
are not treated as personal effects even if these are held for personal use:
Jewellery, Paintings, Drawings, archaeological collections, sculptures or
any work of art.
(c) Agricultural land in India which is not urban agricultural Land. In other
words, it must be a rural agricultural Land;
(d) 6 ½ % Gold Bonds, 1977, 7% Gold Bonds 1980 or National Defence Gold
Bonds, 1980 issued by the Central Government;
(e) Special Bearer Bonds, 1991 issued by the Central Government;
(f) Gold Deposit Bonds issued under Gold Deposit Scheme, 1999.
NOTE: (1) The item as per (d) and (e) do not exist now.
(2) Personal effects include only movable property. Thus personal effect does
not cover the house property in which the assessee lives.
(3) Jewellery Includes - ornaments of gold silver, platinum or any other
PERIOD OF HOLDING FOR BONUS AND RIGHT SHARES: The Holding period
for the purpose of capital gains in case of shares or securities will be determined
as under:
CASE RELEVANT DATE
1. Right shares or any other securities Period shall be from Date of Allotment
(financial assets) purchased by original of such financial asset.
holder.
2. Right shares or any other securities Period shall be from Date of Allotment
(financial assets) purchased by the of such financial asset.
renouncee in whose favour right has
been renounced by original security
holder.
3. Right renounced by original security Period shall be from the date of offer to
holder in favour of renounce. the date of renouncement.
4. Financial Asset allotted without any Period shall be from Date of Allotment
payment (on the basis of holding of of such financial asset.
other financial asset) e.g. Bonus Shares
5. Specific security or sweat equity Period shall be from Date of Allotment
shares allotted/transferred by or transfer of such financial asset.
employer directly/ indirectly to
employee either free of cost or at
concessional rate.
(B) CAPITAL ASSET MUST HAVE BEEN TRANSFERRED: Capital gain arises
only where there is a transfer of capital Asset. If the capital asset is not
transferred, there will be NO CAPITAL GAIN. However, Insurance claim due to
damage or destruction of property by fire or other calamities, there will be
COMPUTATION OF CAPITAL GAIN [Section 48]: Now it has become clear that
the capital gain is of two types-Short Term Capital Gain & Long term Capital Gain.
A Performa to Calculate these Gain is given as follows:
COMPUTATION OF SHORT TERM CAPITAL GAINS:
Full Value of Consideration ***
Less: expenditure incurred wholly and exclusively
in connection with such transfer ***
(i) Cost of acquisition ***
(ii) Cost of Improvement *** ***
Balance ***
COST OF ACQUISITION [SEC 55(2)]: Cost of acquisition of asset is the value for
which it was acquired by the assessee. Expenses of capital Nature for completing
or acquiring the title to the property are included in the cost of acquisition. The
examples are:
1) Interest on money borrowed to purchase asset is part of actual cost of
asset. But in case of asset being used for business or profession refer to
chapter ‘Profits & Gain of Business or Profession’.
2) Litigation expenses incurred by the assessee, who holds shares of a
Company, to acquire better voting rights, in respect of such shares, by
filing suit to get articles of association amended and expenses incurred for
compelling the company to register the shares in the name of the assessee
would from part of cost of acquisition of the shares.
3) Where a mortgage was created by the previous owner during his life time
and the same is subsisting on the date of his death, the successor obtains
____
SHORT TERM CAPITAL GAIN ***_
In situation two the net result may be short term capital Gain or loss. It is also
calculated as above.
NOTE :(1) The transfer of self generated asset not relating to business is not
chargeable to tax . e g. Goodwill of profession, a new formula patented by the
Inventor to grow seedless oranges.
(2) If such asset is purchased before 01-04.1981 then Cost of acquisition shall
be Actual Cost. The option of F.M.V. on 01.04.1981 is not available in such
case.
5. If such asset is self generated then cost of acquisition will be NIL EVEN IF
SUCH ASSET WAS ACQUIRED BEFORE 01-04-1981
Note: The period of holding shall be determined from the date of holding of
membership ticket in the old exchange.
deducted.
c) There is no difference between advance or other money received and forfeited
by the assessee. The other money may be deposit made by proposed purchaser
(but not forming part of purchase consideration) to guarantee the performance
of contract.
Cost of acquisition of previous C.I.I for the year in which the asset was
owner, w. e. is more acquired by the assessee
(b) Indexed Cost of Improvement:
Cost of Improvement incurred by C.I.I for the year in which the asset was
the assessee and previous owner on transferred
or after 01-04-1981 X
trade.
NOTE: 1.To find out whether or not such shares/debentures are long term or
short term capital asset the period of holding shall be determined from the
date of allotment of such new shares/debentures.
2. The benefit of Indexation will be available from the year which such new
shares were allotted. (The benefit of Indexation is not available in case of
Debentures).
3. If preference shares are converted into equity shares, it will be regarded as
transfer of preference shares and capital gain on such transfer shall be on
the date of allotment of equity shares. The full value of consideration shall
be fair market value of the equity shares on the date of allotment of such
equity shares.
7. CAPITAL GAIN ON DISTRIBUTION OF CAPITAL ASSET BY COMPANY IN
LIQUIDATION [SEC 46]: The following points are to be considered:
a) The Company is under liquidation;
b) Such company distributes capital Assets to its shareholders;
c) Calculate the market value of assets received and add cash received to this
figure;
d) From the amount as per point(c) deduct value of dividend (to the extent of
accumulated profit of the company). This net value is ' Full value of
consideration ' on transfer of shares.
e) If such capital asset received by the shareholder as in point (b) above is
subsequently transferred then the Market value of asset on the date of
distribution shall be the cost of acquisition of such asset.
8. TRANSFER OF INTANGIBLE ASSETS [SEC 55 (2)(a)]: The cost of
acquisition of goodwill of business (not of profession), trade mark or Brand
Name associated with Business, Right to manufacture, produce or process any
article/thing or right to carry on any business, tenancy rights, route permits or
loom hours is determined as follows :
CASE COST OF ACQUISITION
1. Such asset is purchased Actual Cost
2. Such asset is Self generated NIL
3. Such asset is acquired in any Actual Cost to Previous owner
mode as per section 49 (1)
NOTE :(1) The transfer of self generated asset not relating to business is not
chargeable to tax . e g. Goodwill of profession, a new formula patented by the
Inventor to grow seedless oranges.
(2) If such asset is purchased before 01-04.1981 then Cost of acquisition shall
be Actual Cost. The option of F.M.V. on 01.04.1981 is not available in such
case.
6. If such asset is self generated then cost of acquisition will be NIL EVEN IF
SUCH ASSET WAS ACQUIRED BEFORE 01-04-1981
____
SHORT TERM CAPITAL GAIN ***_
In situation two the net result may be short term capital Gain or loss. It is also
calculated as above.
10. CAPITAL GAIN IN CASE OF SLUMP SALE [SEC 50B]: In case of slump sale,
the cost of acquisition of capital asset (being one or more under taking) shall be
equal to 'NET WORTH' net worth means aggregate of total assets of the
undertaking as reduced by value of liabilities as appearing in Books of Account.
NOTE:1) To find out whether capital gain is short term or long term, the period
of ownership of undertaking shall be considered.
2) The benefit of indexation shall not be available.
3) A report in form 3CEA shall be submitted along with return of income for
calculation of net worth (certified by a chartered accountant).
11. CAPITAL GAIN IN CASE OF LAND AND BUILDING [SEC 50C]: The following
conditions must be fulfilled:
a) There is transfer of land or building or both. Such asset may be long term or
short term capital asset. It may be depreciable or non-depreciable asset.
b) The sale consideration is less than the value adopted for the purpose of
payment of stamp duty in respect of such transfer of land or building or both.
If the above conditions are satisfied then there can be following three
situations:
Situation 1: If the assessee accepts the value adopted for payment of the
Stamp duty then full value of consideration will be equal to the value adopted for
payment of the Stamp duty.
Situation 2: If the assessee disputes the value adopted for payment of the
Stamp duty then full value of consideration will be equal to the value finally
accepted for payment of the Stamp duty.
Situation 3: If the assessee claims before the Assessing Officer that the
value adopted for payment of the Stamp duty is more than the Fair market value
then full value of consideration will be equal to the value adopted for payment of
the Stamp duty or Fair market value which ever is less (In this case the assessee
has not disputed the value while stamp duty proceedings).
of First-in-first-out method.
NOTE: With effect from 1st October, 2004 securities transaction tax is applicable
if the equity shares or units of equity oriented mutual fund are transferred in a
recognised stock exchange in India.
It is to be noted that exemption u/s 115 F is allowed only on long term capital
gain of Foreign Currency Asset Such asset being specified securities should not be
transferred or converted into money with in 3 years from the date of acquisition,
otherwise the exemption u/s 115 F shall be treated as long term capital gain of
the year in which such new asset is transferred or converted into money.
b) Such land has been used for agricultural purpose during preceding two years
by such individual or his parent or by such HUF;
c) The land may have been compulsorily acquired before 01.04.2004.
NOTE: If a part of original compensation has been received before 01.04.2004
then exemption on original compensation will not be available but enhanced
compensation received on or after 01.04.2004 shall be exempt.
(B) Exemptions u/s 54, 54B, 54D, 54EC, 54ED, 54F, 54G and 54H.
receipt of compensation.
e) The newly acquired Land or building is used for shifting or re establishing
the said undertaking or setting up another industrial undertaking.
AMOUNT OF EXEMPTION: The cost of new land or building (up to maximum of
capital gain) is exemption u/s 54D.
NOTE:1) If such new land or building is sold/transferred within 3 years from the
date of acquisition/completion of construction then exemption allowed
u/s 54D shall be deducted from the cost of acquisition of new land or
buildings.
2. Where the Capital Gain is not utilised by the assessee for
purchase/construction before the due date of furnishing the return, it shall
be deposited by him in Capital Gain Deposit Account'.
3) If the amount deposited in Capital Gain Deposit Account is not utilised
within the stipulated period, then such amount not utilised shall be treated
as short term/long term capital gain (as original gain) of the previous year
in which the period of three years from the date of transfer of original
asset expires.
LONG TERM CAPITAL GAIN INVESTED IN CERTAIN BONDS [Sec 54 EC]: The
following conditions must be satisfied:
a) There must be a long term Capital Asset.
b) The assessee (transferor) may be any person.
c) The assessee (transferor) has invested in following securities within six
months from the date of transfer of the asset -
i) Bonds of National Bank for Agriculture & Rural Development; or
ii) Bonds of National Highways Authority of India; or
iii) Bonds of Rural electrification Corporation Ltd; or
v) Bonds of National Housing Bank; or
vi) Bonds of Small Industries Development Bank of India.
AMOUNT OF EXEMPTION: The cost of above securities (up to maximum of
capital gain) is exemption u/s 54 EC.
NOTE:1) If such securities are transferred/converted into money/loan taken on
security of such securities with in 3 YEARS from the date of their acquisition then
the amount exempted earlier shall be treated as long term Capital Gain of the
previous year in which such new securities are transferred.
2) The cost of specified securities considered for exemption u/s 54EC shall
not be eligible for deduction u/s 80C.
NOTE:
1) If such new residential house property is transferred with in 3 years from
date of purchase or completion of construction or the assessee purchases a
new residential house with 2 years from transfer of original asset or
constructs a new residential house with 3 years from transfer of original
asset then long term capital gain exempted earlier shall be treated as long
term capital Gain in the year of transfer/purchase of new house.
2) The scheme of capital Gain deposit is same as in section 54.
3) If the amount deposited in 'Capital Gain Deposit Account' is not utilised
with in 3 years from the date of transfer of original assets then
proportionate amount as below shall be treated as long term capital gain:-
NOTE:1) If such new asset is transferred with in 3 years from the date of
acquisition/construction then exemption allowed u/s 54GA shall be deducted
from cost of acquisition of such new asset
2) The scheme of Capital Gain Deposit Account is same as in section 54D.
3) The treatment of unutilised amount of capital Gain Deposit Account is
same as in section 54D.
TAX RATE ON LONG TERM CAPITAL GAIN [SEC 112]: The long term capital
gain is charged to tax @ 20%.
NOTE: Deductions under chapter VIA are not allowed from long term capital
gain. But rebate under section 88 E is allowed from Long term capital gain.
OPTIONS FOR TAX ON LONG TERM CAPITAL GAIN ON LISTED SECURITIES &
UNITS: The following conditions must be fulfilled:
a) The long term capital asset is listed shares/ securities in any recognised
stock exchange in India or unit of UTI or a mutual fund.
b) The assessee may be any person.
c) The assessee has two options
OPTION I
The assessee may take benefit of indexation of cost of acquisition and the
tax rate shall be 20%.
OPTION II
The assessee may not take benefit of Indexation of cost of acquisition and
the tax rate shall be 10%.
The assessee should opt for that option where the tax incidence is
lower.
NOTE: With effect from 1st October, 2004 securities transaction tax is applicable
if the equity shares or units of equity oriented mutual fund are transferred
in a recognised stock exchange in India. In such case long term capital gain
on transfer of these assets is exempt from tax u/s 10 (38).
*****
Chapter-7
INCOME FROM OTHER SOURCES
As per section 56(1), the following conditions must be satisfied to
tax any income under the head ‘Income from other sources':-
1. There must be an income;
2. Such income is not exempt under the provisions of this Act;
3. Such income is not chargeable to tax under any first four heads of income.
Thus this head ‘income form other sources’ is residuary head of income.
(b) Any dividend paid by a company which is set off by the company against
the whole or any part of loan or advance previously paid by it and which
has been treated as deemed dividend under section 2 (22) (e).
(c) Any distribution to shareholders on liquidation or reduction of capital of
the company under clause (c) or (d) of section 2(22) in respect of any
shares issued for full cash consideration, where the holder of the share is
not entitled, in the event of liquidation to participate in the surplus assets
(d) Any payment made by a company on purchase of its own shares from a
shareholder in accordance with provision of section 77A of the Companies
Act 1956.
(e) Any distribution of shares pursuant to demerger by resulting company to
the shareholders of demerged company.
BASIS OF CHARGE OF DIVIDEND [SECTION 8]:- Method of accounting does not
affect the basis of charge dividend income. Different types of dividends are
taxable as follows:-
a) Normal Dividend: - Dividend declared at annual general meeting is
income of previous year in which it is declared.
b) Deemed Dividend: - Notional dividend under section 2(22) is treated as
income of previous year in which it is paid.
c) Interim Dividend: - Interim dividend is deemed to be income of previous
year in which the amount of such dividend is unconditionally made
available by the company to its shareholders (i.e. date of issue of dividend
warrant).
PLACE OF ACCRUAL [SECTION 9(1) (iv)]:- Dividend paid by Indian company is
deemed to accrue or arise in India.
GROSSING UP OF DIVIDEND: - Dividend is taxable in the hands of a person
whose name appear in the register of members and is taxed on gross amount
where gross amount is calculated as:
= Net Dividend x 100
(100-rate of T.D.S.)
DEDUCTIONS FOR EXPENSES FROM DIVIDEND INCOME [SECTION 57(i) & 57
(iii)]:- The following expenses are allowed as deduction from dividend income:-
a) Collection charges: - Any reasonable sum paid by way of commission or
remuneration to bank or any other person for the purpose of realizing the
dividend.
b) Interest on loan: - Interest on money borrowed for purchasing the shares
can be claimed as deduction. The interest can be claimed even if no income
is earned as dividend on such shares.
Note:-If interest is payable outside India, it shall be allowed as deduction only if
tax has been deducted at source.
c) Any other expenditure: - Any other expenditure wholly and exclusively
for earning such income can be claimed as deduction. For example legal
and traveling expenses incurred for protecting dividend income would be
deductible.
NOTE:- 1. Dividend is chargeable to tax even if the company has declared
securities during the previous year, sells them in such a way that either no
income is received or income received is less than the sum he would have
received if interest had accrued from day to day, then income from such
securities for such year shall be income of transferor and not of the transferee.
NOTE:-The above provisions under section 94(1) or 94(2) are not applicable if
the owner proves that:-
a) There has been no avoidance of income tax; or
b) The avoidance of income tax was EXCEPTIONAL and NOT SYSTEMATIC
and that there was no avoidance of income tax by such a transaction in any
of three preceding years.
LOSS FROM PURCHASE AND SALE OF SECURITIES NOT ALLOWED U/S 94(7):
Where –a) any person buys or acquires any security or unit with in a period of 3
months before the record date;
b) such person sells or transfers such securities with in a period of 3 months
after such record date; OR
sells or transfers such units with in a period of 9 months after such record
date;
c) the dividend or income on such securities or unit is exempt from tax;
then, the loss, if any, arising to him on account of such purchase and sale of
securities or unit (subject to maximum of dividend or income received/
receivable) shall be ignored for computing his income chargeable to tax.
BONUS STRIPPING U/S 94(8): Where –a) any person buys or acquires any unit
with in a period of 3 months before the record date;
b) such person is allotted or is entitled to additional units on the basis of such
units acquired with making any payment;
c) such person sells or transfers such units (while continuing to hold all or any
of additional units) with in a period of 9 months after such record date;
then, the loss, if any, arising to him on account of such purchase and sale of units
shall be ignored for computing his income chargeable to tax.
Further, the amount of loss so ignored shall be deemed to be the cost of
acquisition of such additional units as are held by him on the date of such sale or
transfer.
ANY OTHER INCOME TAXABLE UNDER THIS HEAD: - If there is any income
taxable under this head (other than those discussed above) then deduction will
DEEMED INCOME CHARGEABLE TO TAX [SEC. 59]:- The section 59 has same
provisions as per section 41 (1). Accordingly where any deduction/allowance is
allowed in any year under this head and is recovered later on, then such amount
recovered shall be taxable in the year of recovery under head ‘Income form other
sources'.
*****
CHAPTER 8
CLUBBING OF INCOME
Generally, an assessee is taxed in respect of his own income. But
there are cases where the assessee makes an attempt to reduce his tax bill by
transferring his asset to family member or by arranging his sources of income in
such a manner that tax incidence falls on other but benefit of income is derived
by him directly or indirectly. So the provisions under section 60 to 64 are
provided to counteract these practices of tax avoidance which are as following:
(a) Income of other persons included in an assessee's total Income (Sec 60 to63);
or
(b) Income of other persons included in the Individual’s Total Income (Sec 64).
(A) INCOME OF OTHER PERSONS INCLUDED IN THE ASSESSEE'S TOTAL
INCOME
(1) Transfer of Income where there is no transfer of Assets (Sec.60):
Where there is transfer of an income by a person to another person, without the
transfer of the asset from which the income arises, such income shall be included
in the total Income of the transferor.
(2) Revocable Transfer of Assets (Sec .61): Where there is revocable
transfer of assets by a person to another person, any income arisen/derived from
such assets shall be included in the total income of the transferor.
Revocable transfer of asset-Meaning (Sec. 63): A transfer of asset is revocable
if-
a) it contains any provision re-transfer (directly or indirectly) of the whole or any
part of income or asset to the transferor during the life of beneficiary or
transferee as the case may be; or
(b) it gives the transferor a right to re-assume power directly or indirectly
over the whole or any part of the income or assets during the life time of the
beneficiary or the transferee as the case may be.
NON-APPLICATION OF SEC 61 (SEC.62): In the following cases the provision of
sec 61 shall not apply:
(a) In case of transfer by way of trust, the transfer is not revocable during the
life time of the beneficiary.
(b) In case of any other transfer, the transfer is not revocable during the life
time of the transferee;
(c) In case the transfer is made before 01-04-1961, the transfer is not
revocable for a period exceeding 6 years.
These provisions of exception to section 61 are applicable if the transferor
derives NO DIRECT OR INDIRECT BENEFIT FROM SUCH INCOME.
clubbed.
NOTE :(1) Substantial Interest means if the assessee (individually along with
his relatives) beneficially holds at least 20% of voting power in a company or at
least 20% of profits in a concern company at any time during the previous year.
(2) Relatives means husband, wife, brother, sister or any lineal ascendant/
descendant of that individual
(3) Where both the husband and wife have a substantial interest in the
concern and both receive the remuneration from such concern, the
remuneration shall be included in total income of husband or wife whose
total income, excluding such remuneration, is greater. Once the income is
included in total income of other spouse it shall be clubbed as such in
subsequent years unless the assessing officer is satisfied that it is
necessary to do so.
(2) Income from assets transferred to the spouse (Sec 64 (i)(iv)) : Any
income arising directly or indirectly to the spouse of such individual from
assets (other than house property) transferred directly or indirectly to the
spouse of such individual otherwise than for adequate consideration or in
connection with agreement to live apart shall be included in the income of
such individual.
NOTE :1. This provision is not applicable to house property as in that case
individual is deemed owner of such house property.
2. The income from transferred assets shall not be clubbed if:
(a) the transfer is for adequate consideration; or
(b) the transfer is to live apart (as agreed), or
(c ) the relationship of husband and wife does not exist, either at the time of
transfer of such asset or at the time of accrual of income.
(3) If any property is acquired by the wife out of an allowance given by her
husband for her personal exp (i. e. pin money) then the above provision of
clubbing shall not apply.
(4) If the asset transferred as above has changed shape and identification then
the income from such changed asset shall also be clubbed.
3. INCOME FROM ASSETS TRANSFERED TO SON'S WIFE (SEC .64 (i) (vi)) :
Any income which arises from assets transferred directly or indirectly by an
individual to his son's wife after 01-06-1973, otherwise than for adequate
consideration, shall be included in the income of the transferor.
NOTE : If the asset transferred directly or indirectly an individual to his spouse
or son's wife are invested by such transferee :-
(i) in a firm as capital as capital contribution of partner, them amount to
be clubbed in transferor's hand is :
Amount invested by transferee out of
Interest on capital from assets transferred with out adequate
firm X consideration on first day of previous
year
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total investment by the transferee as on first day of previous year.
ii) in any business (except as point (i) above), then the income to be
included in the hands of transferor is :
Income of from Business Amount invested by transferee out of
X assets transferred with out adequate
consideration on first day of previous
year
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Total investment by the transferee as on first day of previous year.
*****
CHAPTER 9
SET OFF OR CARRY FORWARD & SET OFF OF LOSSES
Income tax is charged on total Income of a person during the previous year. Such
person may have income under 'FIVE' different heads of Income. He may have
income from different sources but under same head of Income. There may be
cases where 'NET INCOME' from a particular source or head of Income may be a
Loss. This loss may be set off against other sources or head as per provisions
given under section 70 to 80 of Income Act.
NOTE:
(1) Inter source adjustment can be made even in case of clubbing of Income
under section 64.
(2) If income from particular source is EXEMPT then loss from such source
cannot be set off against income chargeable to tax.
(B) INTER HEAD ADJUSTMENT (SEC. 71) : If net result of computation made
for any assessment year in respect of any head of income is Loss, then the same
can be set off against income from other heads. But there are certain
EXCEPTIONS as follows:
(a) Loss from speculation Business: Loss from speculation Business cannot
be adjusted from any income under other head (It can be adjusted only from
profit from speculation Business).
(b) Loss under head Capital Gains: Loss under head 'Capital gains' cannot be
adjusted from any income under other head. (Long term capital Loss can be
adjusted from long term capital gains. Short term capital Loss can be adjusted
from Long term as well as short term capital gain).
(c) Loss from business of owning and maintaining race horses: Loss from
business of owning and maintaining race horses cannot be adjusted from any
income under other head. (It can be adjusted only from profit from business of
owning and maintaining race houses).
(d) Loss cannot be set off from wining from lotteries etc: No loss under any
head can be adjusted from lotteries, crossword puzzles etc.
(e) Business or Profession Loss cannot be set off against Salary Income:
With effect from A.Y. 2005-06, loss from business or profession cannot be set off
against income under head ‘Salaries’.
NOTE :(1) Before making inter head adjustment, the assessee must make inter-
source adjustment.
(2) As No order of priority is given in the Act, the assessee should try to first
set off those losses which cannot be carried forward next year.
(C) CARRY FORWARD AND SET OFF OF LOSSES: If a Loss cannot be set off
under same head or under different head (s) in the same assessment year. Then
such loss can be carried forward and set off against income of subsequent
assessment year (s).
ONLY FOLLOWING LOSSES CAN BE CARRIED FORWARD:
(a) House Property Loss (from assessment year 1999-2000);
(b) Business Loss (Speculative or Non-speculative);
(c) Capital Loss (Short term or Long term);
(d) Loss from owing and maintaining race horses.
NOTE: Such losses can be carried forward only if loss has been determined by
the Assessing officer from a return of loss submitted by the Assessee on or before
due date of filing the return under section 139 (1). But Loss under head House
property' and Unabsorbed depreciation can be carried forward return even if
return of Loss is not submitted on or before due date.
CARRY FORWARD AND SET OFF OF LOSS FROM HOUSE PROPERTY (SEC.71
B) : A Loss under the head house property, if could not be set off in the same
assessment year from other heads of income, will be allowed to be carried
forward for EIGHT assessment years and set off from income from house
property. But such loss must belong to assessment year 1999-2000 or
afterwards.
CARRY FORWARD AND SET OFF OF BUSINESS LOSS OTHER THAN
SPECULATION LOSS (SEC-72): The right of carry forward and set off of loss
arising from a business or profession is subject to following restrictions:
1. Loss can be set off only against Business Income: A loss can be carried
forward and set off against the profits of any business or profession in a
subsequent year (not necessarily same business/profession in which loss
has been incurred). For this purpose, business profit would include profit
derived from business activity but assessable under head other then
'Profits and Gains of business or profession. Example: Dividend Income
from shares held as stock in trade.
2. Losses can be carried forward by the person who incurred the loss:
The loss can be carried forward and set off against the profits of the
assessee who incurred the loss. However, this rule has following
exceptions :
(a) Accumulated business loss of an amalgamating company (under section 72
A);
(b) Accumulated business loss of a demerged company ;
(c) Accumulated business loss of a proprietary concern or a firm when its
business is taken over by a company by satisfying condition of section
47(xii)/(xiv);
(d) Loss of business acquired by inheritance.
(3) Loss can be carried forward for EIGHT years: The Loss cannot be
carried forward for more than eight years. But the following can be carried
forward for indefinite period as these are not Business Losses as per
Income Tax Law:
Unabsorbed Depreciation;
Unabsorbed capital expenditure on Scientific Research;
Unabsorbed expenditure on family Planning.
(4) Return of Loss should be submitted in time: The return of loss should
be submitted on or before due date under section 139 (1) for carrying
forward business loss.
(5) Continuity of Business is not necessary: From assessment year 2000-01,
the Loss from a particular business or profession can be carried forward
even if such particular business is discontinued.
(6) Order of set off: The order of set off from profits from business is as
follows:
(a) Current year Depreciation ;
(b) Current year capital exp-on Scientific research and current year
expenditure on family Planning'
(c) Brought forward Business/ Profession Loss;
(d) Unabsorbed Depreciation;
(e) Unabsorbed capital Exp on scientific Research;
NOTE :
1. The loss from Illegal /Banned speculative business cannot be carried
forward to subsequent year.
2. In case of a company (other than investment company and a company
involved in Banking or granting loans / advances) the business of
purchase and sale of shares (with actual delivery or not) shall be treated as
speculative loss.
NOTE : From Assessment year 2003-04, long term capital loss can be set off only
from long term capital Gains. But short term capital loss can be set off against
short term as well as long term capital Gains.
CARRY FORWARD AND SET OFF OF LOSS FROM BUSINESS OF OWNING AND
MAINTAINING RACE HORSES (SEC 74A):-
If any loss from business of owning and maintaining race horses
could not be set off in the same assessment year, then it shall be carried forward
and set off only from income from owning and maintaining race horses in
subsequent assessment years. Such loss can be carried forward for a maximum of
FOUR Assessment years immediately succeeding the assessment year in which
the loss was first computed. Such loss can be carried forward only if the activity
of owning and maintaining race horses is carried on by the assessee in the
previous year. Filing of return on or before due date is necessary for carry
forward of such loss.
NOTE :1) The losses which are eligible to be carried forward must be set off
from income of immediately succeeding year and if there is any balance still to be
set off, it should be set off in immediately next succeeding year(S) with in the
time allowed.
2) Where any person carrying on any business/profession has been
succeeded in such capacity by another person OTHERWISE THAN BY
INHERITANCE, then such other person is not entitled to carry forward and
set off such loss against his income. But if there is succession of firm by a
company as per section 47(xiii), the carry forward and set off of loss is
allowed to such company.
3) The profits of a partnership firm are shared by partners and are exempt in
the hands of partners but losses of a firm are not shared among partners.
The firm can only set off and carry forward and set off its own losses (not
the partners). If there is change in constitution of a firm, the firm shall not
be entitled to carry forward and set off so much of the loss proportionate
to the share of retired /deceased partner as exceeds his share of profits, if
any in the firm in respect of previous year.
*****
CHAPTER 10
DEDUCTIONS TO BE MADE IN COMPUTING TOTAL INCOME
The aggregate of income computed under each of five heads after giving effect to
provisions for clubbing of incomes and set off losses is called ‘GROSS TOTAL
INCOME. From G.T.I. certain deductions are made under sections 80 C to 80U to
find out ‘TOTAL INCOME’. However these deductions are not allowed from
following incomes although these incomes are part of ‘gross total income’:-
a) Long term capital gain;
b) Short term capital gain on transfer of equity shares and units of equity
oriented fund on or after 01.10.2004 through a recognised stock exchange
under section 111 A;
c) Winning from lotteries, races etc.;
d) Income referred to in section 115A, 115AB, 115AC, 115ACA, 115AD,
115BBA and 115D.
These deductions are of two types:-
a) Deductions on certain payments and investments (from section 80C to
80GGC).
b) Deductions on certain incomes included in G.T.I. (from section 80-IA to
80U).
10% of his salary) plus Employer’s contribution (i.e. Central Govt.) to the
above pension fund (not exceeding 10% of his salary).
NOTE:
a) If the assessee or his nominee receives any amount on account of closure
of the account or as pension during the previous year then such amount
received will be taxable in the hands of the assessee or his nominee, as the
case may be, in the year of receipt.
b) When deduction has been allowed U/S 80CCD, deduction U/S 80C will not
be available for the same amount.
c) Salary means Basic Salary plus Dearness Allowance, if the terms of
employment so provide.
Limits on deductions under sections 80C, 80CCC and 80CCD[sec 80CCE]: The
aggregate amount of deduction under section 80 C, 80 CCC and 80 CCD cannot
exceed Rs. 1,00,000.
STEP III. Net qualifying amount is eligible for deduction as per column 3 of
the chart below:-
Name/Type of charitable Maximum DEDUTION
funds/Institution limit (AS
PERCENT
OF NET
QUALIFYIN
G
AMOUNT)
(A) a) National Defence fund set up by Not 100%
central Govt. applicable
b) Prime Minister’s national relief fund Not 100%
applicable
c) Prime Minister’s Armenia Not 100%
earthquake relief FUND applicable
d) Africa (Public contribution – Indian) Not 100%
fund applicable
e) National foundation for commercial Not 100%
harmony applicable
f) An approved university/education Not 100%
institution applicable
g) Maharashtra chief Minister’s Not 100%
earthquake relief fund applicable
h) Any fund set up by Government of Not 100%
Gujarat for providing relief to applicable
earthquake victims in Gujarat
i) Zila Saksharta Samiti Not 100%
applicable
j) National/State Blood transfusion Not 100%
council applicable
k) Fund set up by State Government Not 100%
for medical relief to the poor. applicable
l) Army /Air force central welfare fund Not 100%
and India naval benevolent fund. applicable
m) Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister’s Not 100%
cyclone relief fund applicable
AMOUNT OF DEDUCTION
AMOUNT OF DEDUCTION
Assessee Period of %ge of profit as
Deduction deduction
a) Hotel located in hilly/rural area 10 years 50%
or notified place of pilgrimage
b) Any other Hotel 10 years 30%
1) The assessee should derive profits and gains from the business of building,
owning and operating a multiplex theatre.
2) Such multiplex theatre should have been constructed at any time during
the period 01.04.2002 to 31.03.2005 .
3) The business of multiplex theatre should not be formed by splitting up or
reconstruction of a building already in existence.
4) It should not be formed by the transfer to a new business of any building
or of any machinery or of plant previously used for any purpose.
5) The multiplex theatre should not be located at a place with in the
municipal limits of Kolkatta, Chennai, Delhi or Mumbai.
6) The assessee should furnish along with return of income, the report of an
audit in such form and containing such particulars as may be prescribed
duly certified by a prescribed.
AMOUNT OF DEDUCTION: 50% of the profits such business for a period of five
successive years starting from initial assessment year.
E. CONDITIONS FOR CONVENTION CENTRE
1) The assessee should derive profits and gains from the business of building,
owning and operating a convention centre.
2) The convention centre should be constructed at any time during the period
01.04.2002 to 31.03.2005.
3) The business of convention centre should not be formed by splitting up or
the reconstruction of a business already in existence.
4) It should not be formed by transfer to a new business of any building or
any machinery or plant previously used for any purpose.
5. The assessee should obtain a report of an audit in such form and
containing such particulars as may be prescribed from a Chartered
Accountant certifying that deduction has been correctly claimed and
submitted along with the return of income.
AMOUNT OF DEDUCTION: 50% of the profits and gain from such business for a
period of FIVE SUCCESSIVE years beginning from initial assessment year.
F. CONDITIONS FOR ENTERPRISES CARRYING ON SCIENTIFIC AND
INDUSTRIAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT:
1) The enterprises must be a Company registered in India;
2) The company has main object of scientific and industrial research and
development;
3) The company is for the time being, approved by the prescribed authority.
4) The deduction is available from assessment year 1997-98 and if it starts at
a later date, the deduction is available from the year of start of business.
AMOUNT OF DEDUCTION:
a) If Company was approved before 1st April, 1999: 100% of eligible profits
for FIVE YEARS commencing from initial assessment year.
a) If Company was approved on or after 1st April, 2000 but before 1st April,
2007: 100% of eligible profits for TEN YEARS commencing from initial
assessment year.
NOTE: 1) The Initial Assessment year means the assessment year relevant to the
previous year in which the undertaking begins to manufacture or produce
articles or things or commences operation or completes substantial expansion.
2) The total period of deduction shall not 10 assessment years.
3) The provisions of Computation of profits of eligible business, audit of accounts,
restriction on double deduction, adjustment of loss and effects of merger or
demerger are same as in section 80-IA.
income earned from any source outside India) should be enclosed along with
the return of income of the assessee.
Amount of deduction: 100% of such royalty income or Rs. 3,00,000
whichever is less.
However, where a compulsory licence is granted in respect of any patent under
the Patents Act, 1970, the income by way of royalty for the purpose of allowing
deduction under this section shall not exceed the amount of royalty under the
terms and conditions of a licence settled by the Controller under that Act.
Further, where any income is earned from any source outside India, only so much
of the income shall be taken into account for the purpose of this section as is
brought into India by, or on behalf of , the assessee in convertible foreign
exchange with in a period of six months from the end of the previous year in
which such income is earned or within such further period as the competent
authority may allow in this behalf. DEDUCTION IN RESPECT OF PERMANENT
PHYSICAL DISABILITY [SEC80U]:
1) The assessee is individual who is resident in India and is a person with
disability as per Sec 2(i) of The persons with Disabilities (Equal opportunities,
protection of Rights and full participation) Act, 1995.
2) He is certified by the Medical Authority (i.e. any hospital or institution
specified as per section 2(p) of for the purpose of The persons with Disabilities
(Equal opportunities, protection of Rights and full participation) Act, 1995) to be
a person with disability, at any time during the previous year.
3) The assessee furnishes the above said certificate along with the return of
income under section 139, in respect of the assessment year for which the
deduction is claimed.
Amount of deduction: Rs. 50,000* in case of a person with disability.
* Rs.75,000 in case the assessee suffers 80% or more of one or more disabilities.
*****
Chapter -11
AGRICULTURAL INCOME & ITS TAX TREATMENT
Section 10(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 exempts agricultural income from
income-tax. The reason for keeping the agricultural income outside the purview
of Income-Tax Act is the Constitution of India gives exclusive powers to the State
Legislature to make laws with respect to taxes on agricultural income. However,
from assessment year 1974-75 and onwards, net agricultural income is added to
the total non-agricultural income computed as per Income-tax Act, for the
sugarcane, coffee, mangoes, etc. Artistic and decorative value like flowers and
creepers, housing value like bamboo, timber, fuel value medicinal and health
value.
Agriculture income would, however, cover only those incomes which are derived
by human effort.
Agricultural income: Following incomes have been held to be agricultural
income:
(a) Income from toddy is agricultural income when it is received by the actual
cultivator of the trees.
(b) Where the owner himself performs slaughter tapping and then sells the
rubber, the income is agricultural income.
(c) Lease income derived by a Lessor from lease of a coconut garden, to a
lessee who pays rent and takes the coconuts from the trees during the
term of the lease and has to deliver possession of the coconut garden back
to the Lessor at the end of the term, would be treated as agricultural
income in the hands of the Lessor.
(d) Where the requisitioned lands were used by the assessee for agricultural
purposes in the accounting year and also in the earlier years, and those
lands were under cultivation at the time of their requisition by the
Government, the compensation paid for the requisitioned lands which
were used for agricultural purposes by the assessee was held to be
agricultural income.
(e) If the grass is grown by human effort, by tilling, sowing, planting of any
particular kind of seed or cutting, or by any similar operations, basic
operations would have been performed. Consequently, the crop would be
agricultural and any income by sale of grass would be agricultural income.
(f) Income from growing flowers and creepers would be agricultural income.
(g) Interest on capital and share of profit received by a partner from a firm
which is engaged in agricultural operations is agricultural income.
(h) Lease rent received for leasing out land for grazing of cattle required for
agricultural pursuits, is agricultural income.
(i) Compensation received from an insurance company on account of
damaged caused to the crop is an agricultural income.
(j) Seeds are clearly a product of agriculture and the income derived from the
sale of seeds derived on account of cultivation by the assessee is an
agriculture income.
Non-agricultural income: Following incomes have been held to be non-
agricultural income, hence taxable:
(a) Income from sale of forests, trees, wild grass, fruit and flowers grown
spontaneously and without human effort.
(b) Income from salt produced by flooding the land with sea water and then
extracting salt there from.
(c) Income from stone quarries.
(d) Income from breeding of livestock.
(e) Income from dairy farming, butter and cheese making.
******
Chapter-12
ASSESSMENT OF COMPANIES
which at least 50% or more equity shares have been held by one or more
co-operative societies.
(vii) A public limited company: A company is deemed to be a public limited
company if it is not a private company as defined by the Companies Act,
1956 and is fulfilling either of the following two conditions:
(a) Its equity shares were listed on a recognized stock exchange, as
on the last day of the relevant previous year; or
(b) Its equity shares carrying at least 50-% of the voting power (in the
case of an industrial company the limit is 40%) were beneficially held
throughout the relevant previous year by Government, a statutory
corporation, a company in which the public is substantially interested or a
wholly owned subsidiary of such a company.
3. Widely held company: It is a company in which the public are
substantially interested.
4. Closely held company: It is a company in which the public are not
substantially interested.
Burden of proof. The onus is on the revenue to establish that the
public are not substantially interested in a company. [Jayantilal Amritlal
Ltd. v CIT (1965) 55 ITR (SC)]. In other words, the onus is on the
department to establish that the company is a closely-held company. On
the other hand, the Bombay High Court had earlier held that the burden of
proving that a company is one in which the public are substantially
interested is on the company. [P.M. Hutheesingh & Sons Ltd. v CIT (1946)
14 ITR 653 (Bom)].
5. Indian company [Section 2(26))]: Indian Company' means a company
formed and registered under the Companies Act, 1956 and includes-
(i) a company formed and registered under any law relating to companies
formerly in force in any part of India (other than the State of Jammu and
Kashmir and the Union Territories);
(ia) a corporation established by or under a Central, State or Provincial ACt;
(ib) any institution, association or body which is declared by the Board to be a
company;
(ii) In the case of the state of Jammu and Kashmir, a company formed and
registered under any law for the time being in force in that State;
(iii) in the case of any of the Union territories of Dadra and Nagar Haveli, Goa,
Daman and Diu, and Pondicherry, a company formed and registered under
any law for the time being in force in that Union Territory.
Provided that the registered or, as the case may be, principal office of the
company, corporation, institution, association or body, in all cases is in India.
6. Domestic company [Section 2(22A)]: A domestic company means an
Indian company or any other company which in respect of its income, liable to
tax under the Income-tax Act, has made the prescribed arrangements for the
declaration and payment within India, of the dividends (including dividends on
preference shares) payable out of such income.
7. Foreign company [Section 2(23A)]:Foreign company means a company
*****
Chapter-13
BUSINESS REORGANISATION
The business and economic environment of the country has thrown up the
need for rationalization of laws relating to business reorganization for
restructuring of production system and better utilization of resources which
have become necessary with a view to enable the Indian industry to rearrange
itself to become globally competitive. It was in this back ground that tax
concessions to conversion of proprietary concern/firms into company were
consideration is paid for and received in shares and both the merging partners
receive money in future periods of time in the form of future dividends on yields.
No money transaction is usually implied at the time of entering into a merger
agreement. Whether share capital is pooled or assets are pooled, so long as a
share for share exchange takes place between the contracting parties, the
transaction is a merger.
In an acquisition, the consideration is in the form of cash. The
person or the corporation intending to control another corporation pays cash for
the number for shares that give him the control. Thus the seller of the share
receives money in the current period of the transaction and the buyer of the
share also pays in 'today's values'.
(3) Demerger: The term "demerger" signifies spinnings of or hiving off the
existing divisions of the company into a separate company. Thus, demerger is a
split or a division of the company. The division hived off could be transferred to
the new company or it can be sold to an existing company.
The demerger may take place due to various reasons like internal
restructuring or family settlements. It may also be undertaken as a tool of tax-
planning.
(4) Slump sale: Slump sale refers to the sale of the undertaking as a whole
including all the assets and liabilities as a going concern. In this case the
consideration is not fixed for each and every asset separately but a lump sum
consideration is determined for the undertaking/division as a whole.
Legal aspects of amalgamation/merger as per Companies Act
The term amalgamation has not been defined under the Companies
Act but as per section 394 of the Companies Act and various judicial decisions,
amalgamation includes absorption and the meaning of term amalgamation and
absorption is same as described above. The amalgamation under the company
law may be by order of court or by the Central Government if it is in public
interest.
The legal procedure to be followed for the amalgamation of the
companies is as follows:
Procedure:
1. Provision in the object clause: There must be a provision in the
Memorandum of Association of both the Companies to amalgamate with any
other company.
2. Obtaining Government Approval: Under sections 391 and 394 of the
Companies Act, 1956, the Central Government's approval of the merger proposal
is necessary for filing petition before the High Court for the approval of the
merger.
RBI's approval is also necessary under section 29 of the Foreign
Exchange Regulation Act, 1973 for transfer of share involving NRI's or foreign
nationals.
3. Intimation to Stock Exchange: The information on the proposal of the
merger should be given to the Stock Exchange in whose jurisdiction the listed
companies proposing to merger are located. All notices and other resolutions in
the connection are to be sent to the Stock Exchange for their record.
4. High Court's Approval: Under section 391 of the Companies Act, 1956 and
Companies (court) Rules, 1959, each company has to make separate applications
in High Court seeking summons to convene the meeting of the members of the
two companies. Separate meeting of equity and preference shareholders are
required to be convened. Under section 394 of the Companies Act, the court may
sanction a proposed amalgamation. However, the court would do so after hearing
all the parties concerned, e.g., shareholders, creditors, tax authorities, etc. It
would also see that the scheme of amalgamation is reasonable, workable, fair
keeping in view the general conditions, background and object of amalgamation.
Section 396 also gives power to the Central Government to provide
for amalgamation of two or more companies if it is satisfied that it is essential in
public interest.
(ii) R Ltd. and G Ltd. both merge and form a new company say T Ltd. Thus
both R Ltd. and G Ltd. go out of existence, and a new company is formed.
In the above case, the companies which go out of existence are
known as amalgamating companies and the 'merged' company or the newly
formed company will be known as amalgamated company.
Thus, in order that an amalgamation may fall under the above
definition, the following conditions must necessarily be fulfilled:
(i) All the property of the amalgamating company should be vested in the
amalgamated company.
(ii) All the liabilities of the amalgamating company should be vested in the
amalgamated company.
(iii) Shareholders holding not less than ¾th in value of the share in the
amalgamating company should become the shareholders of the
amalgamated company. However, shares already held by or by a nominee
for the amalgamated company or its subsidiary immediately before the
amalgamation shall be excluded.
Example: Where "A" merges with another company "B" in a scheme of
amalgamation, and immediately before the amalgamation, company "B" held 20
per cent of the shares in company "A", the above-mentioned condition, will be
satisfied if shareholders holding not less than ¾th in value of the remaining 80
per cent of share in company "A" i.e. 60 per cent thereof ( ¾ th of 80), become
shareholders of company "B" by virtue of the amalgamation.
Merger which will not be called an amalgamation: The last paragraph of this
definition excepts the following two cases where the element of merger exists,
but yet there is no ' amalgamation' within the meaning of this clause:
(a) where the property of the company say 'A' which merges is sold to the
other company say 'B' and the amalgamation comes about by virtue of a
transaction of sale;
(b) where the company 'A' which merges is wound-up in liquidation and the
liquidator distributes the property of company 'A' to the company 'B' and the
amalgamated company 'B' receives the property of company 'A' (the
amalgamating company) from the liquidator as on liquidation.
Tax concessions/incentives in case of amalgamation
If any amalgamation takes place within the meaning of section
2(1B) of the income-tax, the following tax concession shall be available:
(1) Tax concession to amalgamating company.
(2) Tax concession to shareholders of the amalgamating company.
(3) Tax concession to amalgamated company.
a) Tax concession to amalgamating company
(i) Capital Gains tax not attracted: According to section 47(vi), where there is
a transfer of any capital asset in the scheme of amalgamation, by an
amalgamating company to the amalgamated company, such transfer will not be
regarded as a transfer for the purpose of capital gain provided the amalgamated
company, to whom such assets have been transferred, is an Indian company.
(ii) Tax concession to a foreign amalgamating company [Section 47 (via)]:
Where a foreign company holds any shares in an Indian company and transfers
the same, in the scheme of amalgamation, to another foreign company, such
transaction will not be regarded as transfer for the purpose of capital gain under
section 45 of the Income-tax Act if the following conditions are satisfied:
1. Atleast 25% of the shareholders of an amalgamating Foreign company
should continue to remain shareholders of amalgamated foreign company, and
2. Such transfer does not attract tax on capital gains in the country, in
which the amalgamating company is incorporated.
b) Tax concessions to the shareholders of a amalgamating company
[Section 47(vii)]: Where a shareholder of an amalgamating company transfers
his shares, in a scheme of amalgamation, such transaction will not be regarded as
a transfer for capital gain purposes, if following conditions are satisfied:
(i) the transfer of shares is made in consideration of the allotment to him of
any share or shares in the amalgamated company, and
(ii) the amalgamated company is an Indian company.
installments.
(ii) Where such licence is sold by the amalgamated company, the treatment of
the deficiency /surplus will be same as would have been in the case of
amalgamating company.
(3) Treatment of preliminary expenses [Section 35D(5)]: Where an
amalgamating company merges in a scheme of amalgamation with the
amalgamated company, the amount of preliminary expenses of the amalgamating
company, which are not yet written off, shall be allowed as deduction to the
amalgamated company in the same manner as would have been allowed to the
amalgamating company.
(4) Amortisation of expenditure in case of amalgamation {Section 35DD] :
(1) Where an assessee, being an Indian company, incurs any expenditure, on or
after the 1st day of April, 1999, wholly and exclusively for the purposes of
amalgamation or demerger of an undertaking, the assessee shall be allowed a
deduction of an amount equal to one-fifth of such expenditure for each of the five
successive previous years beginning with the previous year in which the
amalgamation or demerger takes place.
(2) No deduction shall be allowed in respect of the expenditure mentioned in
sub-section (1) under any other provision of this Act.
(5) Treatment of expenditure on prospecting etc. of certain minerals
[Section 35E(7A: Where an amalgamating company merges in a scheme of
amalgamation with the amalgamated company, the amount of expenditure on
prospecting, etc. of certain minerals of the amalgamating company, which are not
yet written off, shall be allowed as deduction to the amalgamated company in the
same manner as would have been allowed to the amalgamating company.
(6) Treatment of capital expenditure on family planning [Section
36(1)(ix)]: Where the asset representing the capital expenditure on family
planning is transferred by the amalgamating company to the Indian amalgamated
company, in a scheme of amalgamation, the provisions of section 36(1)(ix) to the
amalgamating company shall become applicable, in the same manner, to the
amalgamated company consequently:
(i) The capital expenditure on family planning not yet written off shall be
allowable to the amalgamated company in the same number of balance
instalments.
(ii) Where such assets are sold by amalgamated company, the treatment of
the deficiency/surplus will be same as would have been in the case of
amalgamating company.
(7) Treatment of bad debts [Section 36(1) (vii)]: Where due to
amalgamation, the debts of amalgamating company have been taken over by the
amalgamated company and subsequently such debt or part of the debt becomes
bad, such bad debt will be allowed as a deduction to the amalgamated company.
[CIT v T. Veerabhadra Rao, K.Koteswara Rao & Co. (1985) 155 ITR 152 (SC)].
(8) Deduction available under section 80-1A or 80-1B or 80-IC: Where an
undertaking which is entitled to deduction under section 80-IA/80-IB/80-IC is
transferred in the scheme of amalgamation before the expiry of the period of
*****
Chapter-14
Concepts of Tax-Planning and Specific Management Decisions
Taxes are what even an honest citizen despises the most as human being
by very nature is selfish. He would like to have first of all every good thing for
himself and he would hardly like that the fruits of his labour are enjoyed by
others and particularly by those with whom he has no relationship. He will try
his best to see to it that his hard earned money is not taken away by others
forcibly whether it is by snatching or by the rule of law. But it is also a duty of the
individual to save legally from payment of taxes so that the same may be
available with him to make him and his dependants to be good and honorable
citizens. On the other hand, the practical concept of taxation laws is to realize the
revenue by way of tax to the maximum. Therefore, the perceptions of the tax
payer and the tax collector are different. The tax payer spares no efforts in
maximizing his profits and attracting the least incidence. The tax-collector, on the
other hand, tries to maximize revenue within the framework of law. It is here
that the tax planning has assumed far-reaching importance in the confounded
complexities of the taxation laws. The primary objective of tax planning is to save
the hard labour of the taxpayer in enjoying the fruits of his income and wealth to
the maximum possible extent.
Methods commonly used by tax payers to minimize tax liability
As discussed above, the goal of the tax payers is to minimize his tax liability. To
achieve this goal the following three methods are commonly used by him:
1. Tax evasion
2. Tax avoidance
3. Tax planning
Tax evasion
Unscrupulous citizens evade their tax liability by dishonest means. Some of
which are:
(a) Concealment of income;
(b) Inflation of expenses to suppress income;
(c) Falsification of accounts
(d) Conscious violation of rules.
These devices are unethical and have to be condemned. The courts
also do not favour such unethical means. Evasion, once proved, not only attracts
heavy penalties but may also lead to prosecution.
Such an evader of tax is not a good citizen and tax evasion as a
means to reduce tax liability cannot be advocated by any one.
Tax avoidance
Tax avoidance is minimizing the incidence of tax by adjusting the
affairs in such a manner that although it is within the four corners of the taxation
laws but the advantage is taken by finding out loopholes in the laws. The shortest
definition of tax avoidance is that it is the art of dodging tax without breaking the
law.
In the case of tax avoidance, the tax payer apparently circumvents
the law, without giving rise to a criminal offence, by the use of a scheme,
arrangement or device, often of a complex nature but where the main purpose is
to defer, reduce or completely avoid the tax payable under the law.
In the words of Justice O. Chinnappa Reddy of Supreme Court in
McDowell & Co. Ltd. v CTO (1985) 154 ITR 148 (SC) at p. 160 the evil
consequences of tax avoidance are manifold and may be summarized as under:
(a) Substantial loss of much needed public revenue, particularly in a welfare
State like ours.
(b) Serious disturbance caused to the economy of the country by piling up of
mountains of black money directly causing inflation
(c) Large hidden loss to the community by some of the best brains in the
country being involved in the perpetual war waged between tax avoider
and his expert team of advisers, lawyers and accountants on one side,
and the Tax Officer and his perhaps not so skillful advisers on the other
side.
(d) Sense of injustice and inequality which tax avoidance arouses in the
breasts of those who are unwilling or unable to profit by it.
(e) Ethics (or lack of it) of transferring the burden of tax liability to the
shoulders of the guideless, good citizens from those of artful dodgers.
As to the ethics of taxation, the learned judge observed: We now live
in a welfare State whose financial needs, if backed by the law, have to be
respected and met. We must recognize that there is behind taxation laws as much
moral sanction as behind any other welfare legislation and it is pretence to say
that avoidance of taxation is not unethical and that it stands on no less moral
plane than honest payment of taxation.
Tax planning
Tax planning is the arrangement of financial activities in such a way
that maximum tax benefits are enjoyed by making use of all beneficial provisions
in the tax laws. It entitles the assessee to avail certain exemptions, deductions,
rebates and relief's, so as to minimize his tax liability. This is permitted and not
frowned upon.
Tax planning is permissible even after McDowell's case. There might be a
difference of opinion in various quarters in respect of tax avoidance, as these
days Judges have started thinking in the interest of the State with a firm
determination to leave the age-old accepted thinking of 1936 and to look into
future. But tax planning is still not touched by these judgments and in the words
of Ranganath Mishra, J. of Supreme Court in McDowell's case itself, it is
permissible provided it is within the frame work of law. He observes:
Tax planning may be legitimate provided it is within the framework
of law. Colourable devices cannot be part of tax planning and it is wrong to
encourage or entertain the belief that it is honorable to avoid the payment of tax
by resorting to dubious methods. It is the obligation of every citizen to pay taxes
honestly without resorting to subterfuges.
Distinction between tax planning, tax avoidance and tax evasion:Tax
planning, tax avoidance and tax evasion are three different approaches to the
same objective viz., to reduce tax liability. However, they have different
characteristics. Tax planning is perfectly legal as the object of tax reduction is
achieved by making use of the beneficial provisions in the tax laws. On the other
hand, tax avoidance is also legal though technically satisfying the requirements of
law. Tax evasion is a method of evading tax liability by dishonest means like
suppression, conscious violation of rules, inflation of expenses, etc.
Tax planning imply compliance with the taxing provisions in such a
manner that full advantage is taken of all exemptions, deductions, concessions,
rebates and relief's permissible under the Act so that the incidence of tax is the
least. Tax planning, therefore cannot be equated to tax evasion or tax avoidance.
Tax planning may be regarded as a method of intelligent application of expert
knowledge of planning corporate affairs with a view to securing consciously
provided tax benefits on the basis of the national priorities in keeping with the
interest of the State and the public.
The cases covered under "Tax avoidance' are those where the tax
payer has apparently circumvented the law, without giving rise to a critical
offence by the use of a scheme arrangement or device often of a complex nature
whose sole purpose is to defer reduce or completely avoid the tax payable under
the law. In other words tax avoidance is a method of reducing incidence of tax by
taking advantage of certain loopholes in tax laws.
Tax evasion is a dubious way of attempting to solve tax problems by
suppression of income, conscious violation of rules inflation of expenses, etc. Tax
evasion, therefore, cannot be construed as tax planning because it amounts to
breaking of law whereas tax planning is devised within the legal framework by
availing of what the legislature intended.
There is no dispute in accepting tax avoidance is different from tax
planning but the subtle difference between tax avoidance and tax planning is
often over looked.
Thus, any legitimate step taken by an assessee towards maximising
tax benefits keeping in view the intention of law will not only help him but
the society also. All those who do the tax planning could help themselves in
efficient and economic conduct of their business affairs without getting entangled
in the controversy of tax avoidance or evasion.
35.4b Tax Management:
Tax management refers to the compliance with the statuary
provisions of law. While tax planning is optional, tax management is mandatory.
It includes maintenance of accounts, filing of return, payment of taxes, deduction
of tax at source, timely payment of advance tax, etc. Poor tax management may
lead to levy of interest, penalty, prosecution, etc. In some cases it may lead to
heavy financial loss if proper compliance is not made, e.g. if a loss return is not
filed in time it will result in a financial loss because such loss will not be allowed
to be carried forward.
35.5 Objectives of tax planning
The prime objectives of tax planning may be summarized as follows:
(i) Reduction of tax liability.
(ii) Minimisation of litigation.
(iii) Productive investment
(iv) Healthy growth of economy.
(v) Economic stability
(i) Reduction of tax liability: One of the supreme objectives of tax planning
is the reduction of the tax liability of the taxpayer and the resultant saving of the
earnings for a better enjoyment of the fruits of the hard labour. By proper tax
planning, a taxpayer can oblige the administrators of the taxation laws to keep
their hands off from his earnings.
(ii) Minimisation of litigation: Where a proper tax planning is resorted to by
the taxpayer in conformity with the provisions of the taxation laws, the chances
of unscrupulous litigation are certainly to be minimized and the tax-payer may be
saved from the hardships and inconveniences caused by the unnecessary
litigations which more often than not even knock the doors of the supreme
judiciary.
(iii) Productive investment: The planning is a measure of awareness of the
taxpayer to the intricacies of the taxation laws and it is the economic
consciousness of the income-earner to find out the ways and means of productive
investment of the earnings which would go a long way to minimize his tax
burden. The taxation laws offer large avenues for the productive investment of
the earning granting absolute or substantial relief from taxation. A taxpayer has
to be constantly aware of such legal avenues as are designed to open floodgates
of his well-being, prosperity and happiness. When earnings are invested in the
avenues recognized by law, they are not only relieved of the brunt of taxation but
they are also converted into means of further earnings.
(iv) Healthy growth of economy: The saving of earnings is the only basement
upon which the economic structure of human life is founded. A saving of earnings
by legally sanctioned devices is the prime factor for the healthy growth of the
economy of a nation and its people. An income saved and wealth accumulated in
violation of law are the scours on the economy of the people. Generation of black
money darkens the horizons of national economy and leads the nation to
avoidable economic destruction. In the suffocating atmosphere of black money, a
nation sinks with its people. But tax planning is the generator of a superbly white
economy where the nation awakens in the atmosphere of peace and prosperity, a
phenomenon undreamt of otherwise.
(v) Economic stability: Under tax planning, taxes legally due are paid without
any headache either to the taxpayer or to the tax collector. Avenues of productive
investments are largely availed of by the taxpayers. Productive investments
increase contours of the national economy embracing in itself the economic
prosperity of not only the taxpayers but also of those who earn the income not
chargeable to tax. The planning thereby creates economic stability of the nation
and its people by even distribution of economic resources.
accrual because in that case it will not be treated as received in India. It will be
called as remitted to India.
The same holds good in case of not ordinarily resident in India
provided such income is not from the business or profession which is set up or
controlled from India.
(ii) Heads of Income: Before the tax-planner goes in for his task, he has to
have a full picture of the sources of income of the taxpayer and the members of
his family. Though total income includes all income from whatever source
derived, the scope of tax planning is not similar in respect of all sources of
income. The assessee can avail the benefits of exemption and deduction under
each head of income. Further, he can avail the benefit of rebate and relief under
the Act. A consolidated tax planning may be attempted only after the tax-
planning in respect of the different heads of income and a failure to do so may
jeopardize the tax planning and may not achieve the desired result. Similarly, the
tax-planner should know which assets are liable to Wealth tax and what are the
exemptions allowable in case of such assets to avail the maximum benefit and
reduce the Wealth tax liability.
(iii) Latest legal position: It is the foremost duty of a tax-planner to keep
himself fully conversant with the latest position of the taxation laws along with
the allied laws and also the judicial pronouncements in respect thereof. For this
purpose, he must have a thorough and up-to-date understanding of the annual
Finance Acts, the Taxation law Amendments, the amendments, if any, of the other
allied laws, the latest judicial pronouncements of the High Courts and the
Supreme Court, various Circulars of the Central Board of Direct Taxes which seek
to clarify the legal position in so far as the Revenue is concerned. A successful tax
planning can be attempted only if the tax-planners knowledge of legal principles
is up-to-date.
(iv) Form v Substance: A tax-planner will have to thoroughly understand the
true nature of any transaction which relates to income- plus or minus. In this
connection, he will have to bear in his mind the following principles enunciated
by the Courts on the question as to whether form or substance of a transaction
should prevail in Income-tax matters:
(a) Form of transaction: When a transaction is arranged in one form known to
law, it will attract tax liability while, if it is entered into another form which is
equally lawful, it may not. In considering, therefore, whether a transaction
attracts tax or not, the form of the transaction put through by the taxpayer is to
be considered and not the substance thereof. But this rule applies only to genuine
transactions. Where statutorily the parties have to reduce a certain transaction
into writing, it is not open to Courts or any other authority to permit oral
evidence to be adduced by the parties or to entitle them to go behind the
statement document. A citizen can not be taxed merely with a view to swell the
revenues, ignoring the legal position by regarding the substance of the
transaction. It is not open to the Income Tax Authorities to deduce the nature of
document from the purported intention by going behind the document or to
consider the substance of the matter or to accept it in part and reject it in part or
to rewrite the documents merely to suit the purpose of the revenue. [CIT v Motors
& General Stoeres (P) Ltd. (1967) 66 ITR 692 (SC)].
(b) Genuineness transaction: In deciding whether the transaction is a genuine
or colorable one because in such a situation, it is not the question of form and
substance but of appearance and truth it will be open to the authorities to pierce
the corporate veil and look, behind the legal façade, at the reality of the
transaction. The taxing authority is entitled and indeed bound to determine true
legal relation resulting from a transaction. If the parties have chosen to conceal
by a device the legal relation, it is open to the taxing authority to unravel the
device and determine the true character of the relationship. But the legal effect of
a transaction cannot be displaced by probing into the substance of the
transaction. The true legal relation arising from a transaction alone determines
the taxability of a receipt arising from the transaction. [CIT v B.M.Kharwar(1969)
72 ITR 603 (SC)].
(c) Expenditure: In the case of an expenditure, the mere fact that the payment
is made under an agreement does not preclude the department from enquiring
into the actual nature of the payment. [Swadeshi Cotton Mills Co. Ltd. v CIT (1967)
63 ITR 57 (SC)]. In order to determine whether a particular item of expenditure
is of revenue or capital nature, the substance and not merely the form should be
looked into. [Assam Bengal Cement Co. Ltd.v CIT (1955) 27 ITR 37 (SC)].
Areas of tax planning
Tax planning may be effective in every area of business management.
Some of the important areas where planning may be attempted are:
(i) Location of business.
(ii) Nature and size of business.
(iii) Form of business organization and the pattern of its ownership.
(iv) Specific management decisions like make or buy, own or lease, capital
structure, renew or replace, etc.
(v) Employees remuneration.
(vi) Mergers/Amalgamation of companies.
(vii) Double Taxation Relief.
(viii) Non-residents.
(ix) Advance Ruling.
Location of Business
Tax planning is relevant from location point of view. There are
certain locations which are given special tax treatment. Some of these are as
under:-
1. Full exemption under section 10B for ten years in the case of a newly
established 100% export oriented industrial undertaking in free trade
zones, etc.
2. Full exemption under section 10A for ten years in the case of a newly
established industrial undertaking in free trade zones, etc.
3. Full exemption under section 10BA for 10 years in the respect of profits
from the export of eligible article or things.
4. Deduction under section 80-IB in the case of newly set up industrial
entire block of assets is sold or there will be short term capital gain if the
part of the block is sold for a price more than the W.D.V. of the block.
Repair/Renewal or Replacement of an asset: The old and worn out
assets need to be either repaired/renewed or replaced at regular intervals.
Sometimes, even a good machine requires up gradation or replacement so
as to compete in the market. The main tax consideration in these cases
shall be whether the assessee, while computing his business income, shall
be allowed deduction on account of such expenditure or not.
Repairs/Renewal: Deduction for expenditure on repairs/renewal will be
allowed as revenue expenditure in computation of business income ass under:
If the building is a rented building, any expenditure on repairs shall
be allowed as deduction. On the other hand, if the building is owned, only current
repairs shall be allowed as deduction.
As regards plant & machinery, only current repairs shall be allowed
as deduction.
However, the accumulated repairs in the above cases can be claimed
under section 37(1).
For detailed discussion of what is current repairs refer to sections
30, 31 and 37(1).
It may be noted that if the repairs expenditure are of capital nature
it shall not be allowed as deduction either under section 30,31,or 37.
Replacement of assets: If the asset has to be replaced, the
expenditure incurred on replacement shall be capital expenditure and the
asessee shall only be entitled to depreciation on such assets and as such, the
entire expenditure cannot be claimed as deduction which was allowed in case of
repairs. The capital expenditure incurred on construction of super structure on
rented building is also eligible for depreciation under section 32.
*****
Chapter-15
Double Taxation Relief
with the result that the same item becomes liable to tax in more than one
country. It is to prevent this hardship that the provisions in the present Chapter
are primarily intended.
Relief against such hardship can be provided mainly in two ways: (a)
Bilateral relief, (b) Unilateral relief.
Bilateral relief
The Governments of two countries can enter into double taxation avoidance
agreement to provide relief against such Double Taxation, worked out on
the basis of mutual agreement between the two concerned sovereign
states. This may be called a scheme of ‘bilateral relief’ as both concerned
powers agree as to the basis of the relief to be granted by either of them.
Agreement for ‘bilateral relief’ may be of following two kinds-
(a) Exemption method: Agreement, where two countries agree that income
from various specified sources which are likely to be taxed in both the
countries should either by taxed only in one of them or that each of the
two countries should tax only a particular specified portion of the income
so that there is no overleaping. Such an agreement will result in a
complete avoidance of double taxation of the same income in the two
countries. This is known as exemption method of relief.
(b) Tax credit method: The agreement that does not envisage any such scheme
of single taxability but merely provides that, if any item of income is taxed
in both the countries, the assess should get relief in a particular manner.
Under this type of agreement, the assessee is liable to have his income
taxed in both the countries but is given a deduction, from the tax payable
by him in India of a part of the taxes paid by him thereon, usually the lower
of the two taxes paid. This is known as tax credit method of relief.
In practice the former type of agreement also works in the same way as the later.
Bilateral agreements ensure that either country is to refrain from taxing
the whole or part of the income only if the other country has kept to its
part of the bargain. This can be only proved by producing the assessment
order in that country which will, naturally, take time. Moreover, even in
these agreements, there is a provision that if any item (not being covered
by specific provisions) is chargeable to tax in both countries, each country
should allow abatement to the doubly taxed income. Thus, even in an
avoidance agreement, generally, the income may get taxed in both places
but the assessee is able to get the benefit of the collection of the
appropriate tax being kept in abeyance or by way of relief in the form of
deductions later, on proving that he has paid tax thereon in the other
country as well. The relief under either of these types of agreement
depends on an agreement between the countries concerned.
Unilateral relief
The above procedure for granting relief will not be sufficient to
meet all cases. No country will be in a position to arrive at such agreement as
envisaged above with all the countries of the world for all time. The hardship of
the taxpayer, however, is a crippling one in all such cases. Some relief can be
provided even in such cases by home country irrespective of whether the other
country concerned has any agreement with India or has otherwise provided for
any relief at all in respect of such double taxation. This relief is known as
unilateral relief.
Double Taxation Relief Provision In India
In India the relief against the double taxation is provided under
sections 90 and 91 or the Income –tax Act.
Where there is agreement with foreign countries [Section 90] [Bilateral relief]
The Central Government may enter into an agreement with the Government of
any country outside India to provide for the following:
(a) granting of relief in respect of –
(i) income on which income-tax has been paid both in India and in that
country; or
(ii) income –tax chargeable in India and under the corresponding law in force
in that country to promote mutual economic relations, trade and
investment, or
(b) the type of income which shall be chargeable to tax in either country so
that there is avoidance of double taxation of income under this Act and
under the corresponding law in force in that country.
In addition the Central Government may enter into an agreement to
provide:
(i) for exchange of information for the prevention of evasion or avoidance of
income-tax chargeable under this Act or under the corresponding law in
force in that country, or investigation of cases of such evasion or
avoidance, or
(ii) for recovery of income-tax under this Act and under the corresponding law
in force in that country
In the above cases, the Central Government may, by notification in the Official
Gazette, make such provisions as may be necessary for implementing the
agreement.
Provisions of income-tax laws are subject to provision of DTAA: The liability to tax
arising under provisions of sections 4 and 5 of Income –tax Act are subject to
provisions of Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements between India and foreign
country. Thus Treaty provisions shall prevail over income-tax provisions. [CIT v
P.V.A.L. KULANDAGAN Chettiar (2004) 137 Taxman 460]
But, situations could arise where due to subsequent amendments, the
statute law is more beneficial than the provision in the treaty. Since the tax
treaties are intended to grant tax relief and not to put residents of a contracting
country at a disadvantage, vis-à-vis other taxpayers, sub-section (2) was inserted
by the Finance (No.2) Act, 1991 with retrospective effect from Ist April, 1972, to
clarify that any beneficial provision in the law will not be denied to a resident of a
contracting country merely because the corresponding provision in the tax treaty
is less beneficial.
Effect of double taxation avoidance agreement: If an agreement is entered
into under this section, the effect of the same shall be as under:
(i) If no tax liability is imposed under our Act, the question of resorting to the
agreement would not arise. An agreement cannot impose any tax liability
where the liability is not imposed by the Act. [CIT v R.M. Muthaiah (1993)
202 ITR 508 (Kar) affirmed in UOI v Azadi bachao Andolan (2003) 263 ITR
706 (SC)].
(ii) If a tax liability is imposed under one Act, the agreement may be resorted
to for negating or reducing it.
(iii) In case of difference between the provision of the Act and of an agreement
under section 90, the provisions of agreement prevail over the provisions
of the Act and can be enforced by the appellate authorities and the court.
However, as per sub-section 2, the provisions of this Act apply to the
assessee in the event these are more beneficial to the assessee.
(iv) Where there is no specific provision in the agreement, it is the basic law i.e.
Income-tax Act which will govern to taxation of income.
(v) Where the Government of State certified that a person is a resident of that
state or has a permanent establishment in the State, the certificate is
binding on the other Government [UOI v Azadi Bachao Andolan (2003)
263 ITR 706 (SC) and Arabian Express Line Ltd., V UOI (1995) 212 ITR 31
(Guj)].
Method of giving relief from double taxation: Relief from double taxation is
provided by abatement on the basis of mutual agreement between two states
concerned whereby the assessee is given relief by credit/ refund in a particular
manner even though he is taxed in both countries. Relief may be in the form of
credit for tax payable in another country or by charging tax at lower rate.
The procedure to be adopted by the authorities for granting relief is
to determine in the first place, the total income of the person liable to tax in India
in accordance with the provisions of the Income-tax Act, and then allow relief as
per the terms of the tax treaty entered with the other contracting country where
the income has suffered double taxation.
Almost every treaty provides that the tax paid in the contracting
country should be deducted from the tax payable by the assessee in the assessing
country on the income taxable in both the countries. The treaty generally
stipulates which country will grant relief and the manner and extent of the relief
on the various heads of income. For example income from immovable property is
taxed in the source country where it is situated, but the country of residence of
the owner can also tax the same income unless the tax treaty between the
countries expressly provides for exclusion of the property income from being
taxed in the country of residence of the assessee. Relief can however be claimed
and given in terms of tax treaty on providing proof of payment or at least proof of
assessment.
Relief cannot be granted unless the income which has been taxed in
one of the contracting countries has also suffered tax in the other contracting
country. Proof has to be provided of the income having suffered double taxation.
If there is no tax treaty with the country levying double tax, then relief can be
granted unilaterally under section 91.
Various models of treaties: Although treaties entered into by various countries
cannot be exactly identical, a certain amount of uniformity is desirable in its
framework: with this in view, tax treaties have been based on models such as:
OECD model (Organisation of Economic Co-operation and Development).
U.N. Models Double Taxation Convention between developed and developing
countries, 1980.
Most of India’s treaties are based on OECD models
Concept of business connections and permanent establishment: The liability
to tax in the source country generally arises out of “ business connection” or
through what is called “Permanent establishment”. Most of the agreements spell
out what they regard as “Permanent Establishment” as this is of utmost
importance while fixing the tax liability. These agreements also lay down
maximum limits of tax that can be levied or withheld and the manner which it
can be levied.
The term “business connection” has not been defined in the Act. It admits
of no precise definition and a solution to the problem whether there is any
business connection would depend upon facts of each case.
Types of agreements: Agreements can be divided into two main categories-
(1) Limited agreements
(2) Comprehensive agreements
Limited agreements are generally entered into to avoid double taxation
relating to income derived from operation of aircraft, ships, carriage of cargo and
freight.
Comprehensive agreements, on the other hand are very elaborate
documents which lay down in detail how incomes under various heads may be
dealt with.
Limits under various heads like income from immovable property, capital
gains, dividends, interest, royalties, fees for technical services, etc. and the
manner of taxing the same are generally laid down in the comprehensive
agreements. Some of the agreements provide for taxation of annuities and
pensions.
Countries with which no agreement exists [Section 91] [Unilateral Relief]
If any person who is resident in India in any previous year proves
that, in respect of his income which accrued or arose during that previous year
outside India (and which is not deemed to accrue or arise in India), he has paid in
any country with which there is no agreement under section 90 for the relief or
avoidance of double taxation, income-tax, by deduction or otherwise, under the
law in force in that country, he shall be entitled to the deduction from the Indian
income-tax payable by him of a sum calculated on such doubly taxed income at
the Indian rate of tax or the rate of tax of the said country, whichever is the lower,
or at the Indian rate of tax if both the rates are equal.
In other words, where section 90 does not apply, unilateral relief will be
available, if the following conditions are satisfied:
(1) The assessee in question must have been resident in India in the previous
year.
(2) That some income must have accrued or arisen to him outside India during
the previous year and it should also be received outside India. Such income
must not be deemed to accrue or arise in India.
(3) The income should be taxed both in India and in a foreign country and
there should be no reciprocal arrangement for relief or avoidance from
double taxation with the country where income has accrued or arisen.
(4) In respect of that income, the assessee must have paid by deduction or
otherwise tax under the law in force in the foreign country in question in
which the income outside India has arisen.
If all the above conditions are satisfied, such person shall be entitled to deduction
from the Indian income-tax payable by him of a sum calculated on such doubly
taxed income-
(a) at the average Indian rate of tax or the average rate of tax of the said
country, whichever is the lower, or
(b) at the Indian rate of tax if both the rates are equal.
Average rate of tax means the tax payable o total income, after deduction of any
relief due under the provisions of this Act but before deduction of any relief due
under this Chapter, divided by the total income.
Steps for calculating relief under this section
Step 1 Calculate tax on total income inclusive of the foreign income on
which relief is available. Claim any relief allowable under the
provision of this Act including rebates available under section 88E
but before relief due under sections 90 and 91.
Step II Calculate average rate of tax by dividing the tax computed under
step 1 with the total income (inclusive of such foreign income).
Step III Calculate average rate of tax of the foreign country by dividing
income-tax actually paid in the said country after deduction of all
relief due but before deduction of any relief due in the said country
in respect of double taxation by the whole amount of the income as
assessed in the said country.
Step IV Claim the relief from the tax payable in India at the rate calculated at
Step II or Step III whichever is less.
*****