c c

EIBE Assignment
Iteration ± II
Group 8
›
 
 
   
 

  
 ›  



c
c

c


 c

c  c c

c
 cc
 V

   V 
c

›

 

c 
c c c c c  c !"c #c c c

c #!c !!c c c c c
!c $c #c c !!
!c
#c #c c $c #c %!c c 

c 
c 
c
&!'c!(c#c!cc)c$c
cc!c$c#c*c
!c c +!#c !c c !c $$c #c #c  !!c c ,-c c

(c !c c 
#c c !#c #!c *!c
!c $c #c

c c !!c c #c !!c c ##c 
c !!c
c#c
c.c!c
c#!cc!
!!(c#c#!c!
c#!c
!c#c$c#c!c$c#c$cc!c#c !c
!
 c c c 
/!c !!c !c #c %c !
c 
c
$!c c #c !!c $c 
c !!
c c !c c c !c 
c $
c c
#c $c *c 
c !#c c c c c #c
!c
!c

c 
c
c 
c !c c c #c %
c c 
(c #c !c c  c
!"c c #!c c #0c 1!c 
!c $c c 
c #c c !!c
#c
!c c !c 
c $$!
c ,c #!c 2c 
(c c
c c *c
c c #c c 
*c c #*c #c !c
cc!! c!cc
c$c!c 
c

























c
c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
m


1. UNDP millennium goals matrix«««««.«««««.«««« 4

a. Importance of MGDs on Nicaragua«««««.«««««.««««4
b. Millennium development goals«««««.«««««.«««« 4
2. Process diary«««««««««««««««««««««««« 15
3. Points of critical reflection««««««««««««««««««« 39
4. Research««««««««««««««««««««««««««« 43
5. Identification of uncertainties««««««««««««««««« 52
6. Uncertainties and plausible outcomes «««««««««««««« 59
7. Clustering of uncertainties ««««««««««««««««««««71
8. Clusters««««««««««««««««««««««««««« 75
a. Impact of judicial system on migration «««««.«««««.«« 75
b. Effect of privatization on the direction of economy ««« 76
c. Role of government on local industry «««««.«««««.««« 77
d. Impact of town planning on health care «««««.«««««.«« 78
e. Impact of regional co ± operation on economy«««««.«««« 79
f. Impact of construction on Nicaragua Canal on Central America «« 80
g. Attitude of U.S. towards Nicaragua¶s international partnerships «« 81
h. Effects of FDI on local economy«««««.«««««.«««««. 82
i. Effects of corruption on national and international relations «««« 83
j. Nature of utilization of aid on socia l welfare projects«««««.««84
k. Role of government in food security «««««.«««««.««« 85
l. Nature of constitutional democracy in the future «««««.««« 86
9. Impact / predictability analysis «««««.«««««.«««««.« 87
10. Framing and scoping scenario end states «««««.«««««.« 88
11. Scenario stories«««««.«««««.«««««.«««««.««« 89
a. Bureaucracy - the epoxy that greases the wheels of progress «« 89
b. Progressing under the wings of the eagle ««««««.««««« 91
c. Marooned on the island called µdebt¶«««««.«««««.««« 93
d. ³NICARAGUA AVANZA´ ± hacia la iquierda«««««.««««« 96
12. Iceberg analysis«««««.«««««.«««««.«««««.««« 99
a. Rise in unemployment««.«««««.«««««.«««««.« 99
b. Reduced cases of water borne diseases««.«««««.« 102
c. Increase in street crime«««««.«««««.«««««...«...«. 104
d. Majority population below poverty li ve«««««.«««««««« 106
13. Implications vs. scenarios«««««.«««««.«««««.«««« 109
14. APPENDIX 1: Early indicators«««««.«««««.«««««.« 111
15. APPENDIX 2: Bibliography«««««.«««««.«««««.««« 112








c 3c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
V 
m m››m







   

 


 

Úhe ³Millennium Declaration´ was unanimously adopted by the 189 member
countries of the United Nations at the conclusion of the Millennium Summit held in
New York in September 2000. In the declaration, all signatory states undertook to
spare no efforts to ³free our fellow men, women and children from the abject and
dehumanizing conditions of extreme poverty´. Úhe declaration incorporated a list of
eight ³Millennium Development Goals´ (MDGs). At the same time, the MDGs include
18 measurable and time-bound targets.
We will attempt to study each MDG and point out the crossroad at which the nation
stands at the moment with respect to achieving these goals.
Úhe four scenarios that we are going to put forward are an amalgamation of two vital
characteristics which are both highly unpredictable and carry a heavy impact on
MDG¶s and the future of the nation. Úhese two characteristics are:

1) Nature of Utilization of Aid in Welfare Projects

2) Attitude of US towards Nicaragua¶s Diverse International Partnerships

Úhese two characteristics will help us develop four future scenarios and how the
MDG¶s would be impacted in each.

   

!

 
 


V
 "

!    

  
   

In Nicaragua, extreme poverty increa sed between 2001 and 2005. Since 2007,
however, the government of President Daniel Ortega has been able to reduce
c 4c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
extreme poverty despite the worst financial and economic crisis since the Great
Depression.

Úhe Nicaraguan government's figure shows that, at present, 14.6% of the population
lives in extreme poverty, which means the country is half way to reaching the first
Millennium Development Goal [MDG1 - to reduce by half the number of people living
in extreme poverty by 2015].

A study financed by Holland and Switzerland and carried out with technical
assistance from the World Bank, however, found in 2009 that only 9.7% of the
population was living in extreme poverty which would imply that Nicaragua had
already met MDG1. Similarly, in their 2010 repor t, the FAO [the UN Food and
Agriculture Organization] and the WFP [the World Food Program], also find that
Nicaragua, in terms of the reduction of malnutrition, has already met MDG1.
As shown in the following table Nicaragua proudly sits among a host of na tions who
have already achieved their MDG1.

c 5c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c

Úarget 1C of the Millennium Development Goals seeks to halve, between 1990 and
2015, the proportion of people who suffer from hunger. Úhe calculation of progress
compares the latest available country c level information on the prevalence of
undernourishment (2005 07) with the rates that existed in 1990 92 (the base year for
the hunger target). Úhe projection for 2015 assumes that the trends between both
periods continue in the future. Source: FAOSÚAÚ ( www.fao.org/hunger)

Õm


 


V 
Since the MDG1 has already been met in Nicaragua, our four scenarios do not impact
MDG1.


#
› ! !



  
  

Perhaps the second most important of the MDGs is to achieve universal primary
education , one of the most recognized pillars of the human development.
Univarsal primary education in Nicaragua remains a challenge at the present, even
though some progress has been made towards reduction in illiteracy. On August 22nd
2009, the 29th anniversary of the end of the historic National Literacy Cruzade, Education
Minister Miguel de Castilla presented a ministerial placard to President Daniel Ortega
declaring Nicaragua as territory free of illiteracy. Nicaragua is now officially the fifth
country in Latin America to be declared free of illiteracy along with Cuba, Venezuela,
Bolivia and Costa Rica.
At the end of June a delegation of experts from UNESCO visited the country to verify the
governent's claim that, as a result of the two year long National Literacy Campaign, the
percentage of illiterates in Nicaragua had fallen below 5%. Úhe delegation was indeed
able to confirm that, Nicaragua had an illiteracy rate of 4.1%. Úhe literacy campaign
continues, however, and by August 15th the rate had fallen to 3.46, according to Minister
Miguel de Castilla.
Examples of the reduction in key indicators include illiteracy which has dropped from 22%
in 2006 to 3.3% in 2009 thanks to a campaign using the successful Cuban model ³Yo Sí
Puedo´ [³Yes, I can´].
Currently the Ministry of Education is coordinating a nationwide consultation process
involving all the people who took part in the national literacy campaign, either as t eachers
or as pupils, as well as education authorities and specialists from diverse institutions and
organizations in order to create the nation's Úen Year Education Plan: 2011 - 2021.
Another important aspect of the government's education policy that has provoked positive
change in the classroom in the new curriculum and the monthly teacher training
workshops known as ÚEPCEs (Planning, Evaluation, Education Úraining Workshops).

Õm


 


# 

$››%&%&››&&Õ

In this scenario, achievement of MDG2 looks like highly ambitious and we peg it at
achievable yet challenging. Úhe huge inflow of foreign aid and the above mentioned
c 6c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
government efforts begin have a positive impact on the primary educati on goal but the pit
falls of a bureaucracy laden with corruption slows down the wheel of progress and
eventually Nicaragua falls short of achieving the MDG2.
m 
&m Õ&›
In this scenario we predict that the Nicaragua will meet MDG2 as the country is slowly but
steadily progressing under the tutelage of aid and guidance from the US.
' m››››(› ›)&›m››mm
›
In this scenario too Nicaragua is able to achieve MDG2, with the help of regional and
leftist allies and diversification of co-operative partnerships.
› 
 &m›
›

$
Úhis particular scenario states that Nicaragua is in the danger of being marooned in an
island of debt causing a situation like the lost decade of debt crisis like the one that
happened in Latin America in the 1980¶s. Achievement of MDG2 is a bleak possibility in
an economy crippled in crisis.


*



 +  



 

Úhe 1987 Constitution of Nicaragua grants equal civil rights to all citizens and prohibits
gender-based discrimination. Úhe new Penal Code (adopted in 2001) introduced laws to
prohibit and criminalize discriminatory acts. A second report on human development in
Nicaragua, produced in 2002, noted significant progress in some areas: it stated tha t
social and cultural behavior was becoming less discriminatory, but domestic and sexual
violence continued to undermine women¶s rights to a significant degree. Poverty is
widespread in Nicaragua, but has the greatest impact on households headed by women
in rural areas (about one-fifth of rural households).
Úhese signs look promising for the achievement of MDG3, but ineffective implementation
of equality laws might again slow down the progress made by Nicaragua in this field.

Õm


 


*

$››%&%&››&&Õ

As we already mention, effective implementation of equality laws will have a huge impact
on whether or not Nicaragua will meet its goal for MDG3. In this scenario Bureaucratic
corruption will have an adverse impact on the economy of Nicaragua. In an unstable
economy, women¶s rights will take a back seat as the primary goal of the policy makers
would be to combat poverty and hunger.
m 
&m Õ&›
Nicaragua meets it s goal of MDG3 as US support helps it to develop a sustainable
economy.
' m››››(› ›)&›m››mm
›
Nicaragua is successful in achieving MDG3 as it has a sustainable economy and has
diversified trade and cooperative relationships with economical ly strong leftist allies. Also,
the Central American region as a whole will move toward achieving its MDG¶s.
› 
 &m›
›

$
In isolation, Nicaragua would not be able to achieve MDG3, as again economic doldrums
and a severe debt crisis will push women¶s empowerment policies to the back seat.

c 7c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c



,
 

  

  
  

As per a comprehensive review of available sources of mortality data, there was a rapid
fall in infant mortality commenced in the earl y 1970s and had continued steadily till the
80s. Úhere might be several different factors leading to this surprising turn of events
including improved access to health services, Nicaraguan cultural attributes, income,
nutrition and breastfeeding practices. Úhis characteristic fall slowed down once the
country went through civil war and unrest again in the 80s, thus creating a cause of
concern for the UNDP and its achievement of the goal to reduce child mortality.
As per the data collected by the World Bank for child Mortality rates across countries,
Nicaragua still has a significant measure of child mortality which needs to be reduced
much further. Úhis is challenging at present since the majority of population in the country
lives below the poverty line and is isolated in rural and marginal areas. Lack of heath care
facilities coupled with basic amenities like availability of food and drinking water has
greatly attributed to the death of infants. Also, the condemnation of abortion has lead to
the birth of many ill infants and sometimes orphans doe to the lack of basic amenities.
Organizations like the UNDP and IMF still have a long way to go before they can declare
achievement of this goal.

Õm


 


, 

$››%&%&››&&Õ

In this scenario, the achievement of the MDG4 looks highly challenging. Our scenario
focuses around the corruption in the government and a rise in unemployment. Úhis would
inadvertently lead to an increased pressure on local health services to ensure the safety
of all the Nicaraguans. Úhis coupled with an unfriendly attitude from the government
would take the country still further down the road to poverty, thus making the end means
of reducing child mortality challenging.
m 
&m Õ&›
As the title suggests, this scenario maps out the benefits that the country would achieve
with forces like an efficient government and friendly ties with the US. Increased
investment in healthcare and education would he lp alleviate the state of the common
man and this lead to social upheaval and thus possible achievement of ruction of child
mortality.
' m››››(› ›)&›m››mm
›
³Nicaragua Moving forward´ talks about the progress that the economy and the societ y
would experience with the combination of an efficient government coupled with increased
aid from foreign sources like Russia, China and Iran. Sustainable economic growth would
help increase the literacy rate among women and increased healthcare investmen ts. Úhis
would help achieve the goal to reduce child mortality.
› 
 &m›
›

$

c c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
Úhis particular scenario states that Nicaragua is in the danger of being marooned in debt
causing a situation like the lost decade of debt crisis like the on e that happened in Latin
America in the 1980¶s. Achievement of this goal is highly challenging in a falling
economy.


-
m

!
   

  
   

Improving maternal health in Nicaragua is currently a challenge. Úhis is d ue to the lack of

healthcare facilities in the rural regions of Nicaragua outside the capital Managua and
also the stringent abortion laws in Nicaragua. Abortion is illegal in Nicaragua and this
leads to many maternal deaths in Nicaragua as abortion is not an option even when a
complicated birth is involved.
According to Amnesty International's report, Úhe Úotal Abortion Ban in Nicaragua, the
2008 complete ban on abortions is a serious obstacle to best practice decision -making by
health care providers when dealing with obstetric complications, which endangers the
lives and health of all pregnant women in Nicaragua. Úhe new legal framework sets
lengthy prison sentences for women and girls who seek abortions for pre -existing health
reasons and health problems that develop due to pregnancy as well as rape and incest
victims who seek abortions.
Úhe new laws also punish health care professionals who perform abortion services as
well as those who unintentionally cause abortion when treating serious pregnancy
complications. Úhe net result of the abortion ban is a severe chilling effect on health care
providers. Out of fear of imprisonment, medical providers delay or deny treatment of
serious pregnancy complications, which risks the lives and health of Nicaraguan wom en
and girls seeking medical care.

Õm


 


 -

$››%&%&››&&Õ

In this scenario, achievement of MDG5 is predicted to be challenging. As the aid given
from US and other foreign countries leads to positive impact on improving MDG5, the
problem is determined by whether the government can fully utilize the aids or not.
m 
&m Õ&›
In this scenario, achievement of MDG5 is also challenging. Úhe aid given by US is
expected to be fully utilized to increase the overall social welfare.
' m››››(› ›)&›m››mm
›
MDG5 is predicted to be achieved in this scenario. Úhe developed society with increasing
literacy rate has better implementation of family planning.
› 
 &m›
›

$
Achievement of MDG5 is again challenging in this scenario. Since the aid from foreign
countries is not being used properly, the poor is increasing then comes the problem of
lack of education. It will influence the achiev ement of MDG5.


.
$›&m(/›m
››m›0&
m›

c 8c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
  
  

HIV pandemic continues to be one of the most important challenges for public health
worldwide in terms of communicable diseases. According to the latest ³Report on the
World Epidemic of AIDS´ for 2007, 33 million people live with HIV, where Sub -Saharan
Africa is the most severely affected region due to a yet inappropriate access to services
for preventing and treating HIV. With only 0.2 percent of the adult population estimated to
be HIV-positive, Nicaragua has one of the lowest HIV prevalence rates in Central
America. Sexual activity is the primary mode of HIV transmission in Nicaragua.
Unprotected heterosexual intercourse is reported to account for 72 perce nt of HIV
infections, and unprotected sex between men is estimated to account for 26 percent,
according to UNAIDS.
Factors that put Nicaraguans at risk include early sexual debut; social pressures for
males to have multiple sexual partners and take sexual risks; widespread poverty;
women¶s and girls¶ inability to negotiate when and under what circumstances to have sex
or use condoms; gender-based violence; and sexual abuse of women and girls.
Compounding these factors, access to HIV/AIDS services and information is limited in
much of the country due to budgetary priorities and limitations. Moreover, conservative
religious and social values make it difficult to talk about sex and ways to protect oneself
from disease or unwanted pregnancy. Looking at the abov e factors it seems that meeting
this goal will be challenging for Nicaragua. Úhe figures below confirm that Nicaragua is
actually much better off in terms of HIV/AIDS infection levels as compared to its
neighboring countries.

c c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c

Õm


 


.

$››%&%&››&&Õ
In this scenario, achievement of MDG6 looks highly challenging and we peg it
achievable yet challenging. Úhe huge inflow of foreign aid and the above mentioned
government efforts begin have a positive impact on the healthcare sector however the
inefficient government laden with corruption slows down the wheel of progress and
eventually Nicaragua falls short of achieving the MDG6.
m 
&m Õ&›
In this scenario we predict that the Nicaragua will meet MDG6 as the country is slowly
but steadily progressing under the tutelage of aid and guidance from the US.
' m››››(› ›)&›m››mm
›
In this scenario too Nicaragua is able to achieve MDG6, with the hel p of regional and
leftist allies and increased awareness among people about the diseases. Increased
investment in healthcare would mean diseases like Malaria and other communicable
diseases are treated and prevented from spreading.
› 
 &m›
›

$
Úhis particular scenario states that Nicaragua is in the danger of being stranded in an
island of debt causing a situation like the lost decade of debt crisis like the one that
happened in Latin America in the 1980¶s. Achievement of MDG6 is a b leak possibility in
an economy crippled in crisis and corruption.


c c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c

1
  ! 

     

  
   

Currently the majority of nicaraguan population li ves at the rural area, which is
undeveloped and not properly connected to the urban areas. People living in the rural
areas are lacking the facility of safe water to dring, good sanitary, which in turn increase
the chances of illness in society.
After the efforts from UNDP & Government, some progress has been witnessed, still a
large proporting of the population is not able to get the safe drinking water. It is also
observed that the number of and proportion of people living in slums has a positive
trend.
In regard to pollution with greenhouse effect and depletion of ozone layer has decreased
slightly.

Õm


 


1 
$››%&%&››&&Õ
Meeting the MDG goal 7 in this scenario is challenging as the international organizations
are pumping money to make ava ilable safe water for rural people and improve the
sanitation condition, but corruption & no transperancy in the government offices will slow
down the speed of any development.
m 
&m Õ&›
Under this scenario the basic require ment of the MDG 7 is being fulfilled as the efficient
government with the help from US can provide the safe derinking water and good
sanitation to people, however on the other side, increased number of industry in the
country can increase the CO2 emission and have the adverse effect on the ozone layer.
' m››››(› ›)&›m››mm
›
Meeting the MDG 7 under this scenario is also very challenging as the good government
with the leftist can help the people by providing safe drinking water and good sanita tion
but again the introduction of industrialization can have the sever negative impact on the
surrounding environment.
› 
 &m›
›

$
Úhere are very less chances of meeting the MDG 7 under this scenario as in -efficient
government will not be able to meet the basic need of water and sanitation to people.


2

!

  
!

  

Úhe importance of achieving MDG8 for a country like Nicaragua is quite evident.
Nicaragua is a country highly dependant on global partnerships for aid, technology and
trade-most notable US. Úhe current President Daniel Ortega, a leftist, has had to walk a
tight rope of diplomacy with US and other Central American neighbours. Plus,
Nicaragua¶s gowing relationship with economically sto ng leftist countries like China and
Russia is putting a straing on the already precarious Nicaraguan -US relationship.

Õm


 


2 

c 
c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
$››%&%&››&&Õ
MDG8 has the potential to be fulfilled in this scenario and we predict if Nicaragua
chooses US over the other leftist allies, he can be assured of a mutually beneficial
partnership with US and most of the other rightist European countries.
m 
&m Õ&›
Úhis scenario too predicts the achievement of MDG8, as a strong US influence on the
growth of Nicaragua will ensure continued support from US and its allies
' m››››(› ›)&›m››mm
›
Nicaragua can achieve MDG8 if it diversifies its co -operative partnerships and creates
stronger ties with growing economies like China. In addition to that, a reduced
dependence on US will lead to building stronger regional ties and increased participation
in alliances like the Bolivarian Alliance for Americas (ALBA) and the C entral America
Integration System (SICA)
› 
 &m›
›

$
In our last scenario, Nicaragua fails to achieve MDG8 as its ineffective administration
and lopsided policies have led to an international snub from all its former allies includin g
the US and also the leftist allies like China and Russia. 






























c 3c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c

#  
m›%

/
 Vm$3  # 



 ›
4



4 V4
Iteration-2 We did not know which At 1600 Hrs Friday afternoon, All
Day 1, 1st central American country we regrouped at Room 526.
Oct to select for our group? One of things on our agenda
1600Hrs was to decide the country to
work on. Rony drew the map of
the entire central American
region on the white board so
that we could see the location of
each country. Úhen all of us
gave their views on their choices
of country. We had Panama in
our discussion for its strategic
location, and then we had Costa
Rica for its developed tourism
industry and Honduras for
having three neighboring
countries. At the end of the 15
min debate we finally agreed to
work on Nicaragua as it was one
of the poorest countries in that
region and we felt that UNDP
would be very interested in the
upliftment of that country. Apart
from that Nicaragua had two
neighbors: Costa Rica and
Honduras and that would have
given us enough material to
study on the relations it had with
its neighbors.
Iteration-2 We did not know how to Nicaragua was a big country All
Day 1, 1st divide the research work and we had to focus on all
Oct between the six of us? aspects of SÚIRDEEPER. It was
1620Hrs very important that everyone
deeply researched on the
country and that there was no
duplication of research work.
So, we decided that we divide
the SÚIRDEEPER among the
six of us and each would
individually research on his
corresponding area allocated to
him. Úhat would have meant
c 4c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
that every individual person got
an opportunity to go deep into
the specific area and find the
underlying reasons for its
occurrence and at the same
time think about how it
interacted with other areas such
as culture or technology. Úhe
work allocation is shown below :
Rony: Úechnology industry and
trade
Ahmed : Society religion and
education
Rahul : Demographics and
environment, ecology
Kaustubh: Politics, policy and
trade
Pranal: Legal , judicial
environment
Wendy: Economic environment

Iteration-2 We did not know the By 1635, we had decided on the All
Day 1, 1st action items for the country and allocated the areas
Oct weekend in terms of of research to all of us. Once
1635Hrs uncertainties and its done, we all had confusions on
corresponding plausible what was expected out of each
outcomes? one of us. We all agreed to :
V Document the research we did
over the weekend so that we do
not forget what we researched.
#Úo make 150 uncertainties
and that would mean all of us
contributed 25 yellow post -its or
uncertainties corresponding to
his area of research.
*Úo think and make at least 30
uncertainties and document it on
our laptops. Úhe additional 5
was agreed because inevitably
we would have come across
duplications and eliminations of
uncertainties.
,Úo think at least 2 plausible
outcomes of all the uncertainties
we have thought about.
Document even if we had more
than 2 outcomes as they would
c 5c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
anyway be subject to discussion
later on. So, everyone agreed to
come up with 60 pink slips by
Monday morning.
-Apart from working on our
individual allocated areas we
also agreed to study about the
country as a whole which would
help us join missing links when
we had to co-relate our areas
with others such as society or
technology.
Iteration-2 We did not know the We recognized the fact that Rahul
Day 1, 1st timelines for the various there was too little time and too
Oct 1650 tasks for the upcoming much to do. So we decided to
Hrs week? pull up a time table and agreed
that we would definitely meet
those time lines by the End of
day even if it meant stretching
by a few hours in the evening.
We jotted down all the tasks and
then again broke them down
into sub tasks. We then
brainstormed on how much time
should be allocated to each
work. Rahul agreed to make the
time table. We all agreed on the
following time scales :
(Note : All times are mentioned
in BSÚ below)
Mon 0830 : setting up of the
room
Mon 0900-1400 : Brief
presentation by all and
yellow/pink post-its
brainstorming
Mon 1400-1430 : Breather
Mon 1430-17-30 : Clustering,
Validating and linkages
Úue 0900-1100 : Ranking &
selection of two critical items
Úue 1100-1300 : Naming the
polar ends and their critical
characteristics
Úue 1300-1330 : Pasting of pink
post-its
Úue 1330-1400 : Breather
c 6c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
Úue 1400-1500 : First story
creation by the entire group
Úue 1500-1800 : Group to be
divided into three. Creation of
three stories by the three groups
Úue 1800-EOD : Validation of
the three stories by all the three
groups
Wed 0900-1400 : Iceberg
analysis, MDG matrix formation,
feedback loop
Wed 1400-1430 : Breather
Wed 1430-1730 : PPÚ creation
Wed 1730-1800 : Presentation
rehearsals
Úhu 0900-EOD : Presentation
Iteration-2 We did not know whether We agreed that we won¶t be All
Day 1, 1st we had to meet during the meeting over the weekend. We
Oct 1700 weekend? appreciated the fact that the
Hrs week ahead was going to be
very challenging and we all
needed some rest to recharge
our batteries. We decided that
we will settle our personal
commitments over the weekend
and rather not meet. However,
we would be in touch with each
other via emails and group chats
if required.
Iteration-2 We did not know what We all agreed to meet at 0900 Rahul &
Day 1, 1st time to meet on the Hrs. At the same time we Kaustubh
Oct 1710 Monday to start our work? decided that someone would be on Monday
Hrs coming in early each day over
the next week to collect the keys
from downstairs and would start
setting up the room so that we
can start our work at 0900 Hrs
sharp. We needed two people to
come in early as the room had
to be set and flip charts pasted.
Rahul and Kaustubh
volunteered to come in early on
Monday. Ahmed volunteered on
Úuesday and Pranal on the
Wednesday.
Iteration-2 We did not know how and We all wanted to finish of Ahmed
Day 1, 1st when to complete the iteration #1 before the start of
c 7c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
Oct 1720 workbook for iteration #1 the next week. Hence, we
Hrs and how to manage agreed to complete and finish of
version control of our the workbook over the weekend.
workbook? Ahmed agreed to become the
facilitator and allocated work to
each of us. All of us agreed to
complete their bits and send it to
Ahmed and he would then
manage version control of the
workbook. It was also decided
that we all finish our individual
work by Saturday EOD so that
we gave ourselves enough time
to review each other¶s work and
feedback. Ahmed was again
identified to manage the
reviewing work of iteration #1
and all of us agreed to mark in
their comments using the track
changes tool in Microsoft word.
Úhat way he can easily identify
who has changed what in the
document and incorporate the
changes in his master
document.
Iteration-2 How religiously we had to Although we made our time
Day 1, 1st follow the time table we tables allocating time to each
Oct 1720 had just made? task we also agreed that we
Hrs would not compromise on the
quality of the work by following
the time table too strictly. We
agreed that we would keep the
time table in the back of our
minds while working. In case a
task takes too much time we
would ensure that we are not
too much behind in terms of
time and that our EOD goal is
still reachable by adding a
couple of extra hours of work in
the evening.
Iteration-2 How we would get hold of We agreed that we needed the All
Day 1, 1st remarkable people who guidance of remarkable people
Oct 1740 could help us and when who could help us with our
Hrs do we approach them with scenario building. We identified
our queries? two sources of reaching
remarkable people :
c c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
1 Personal connections
2 Academia
We all agreed to invest some
time over the weekend to find
such people and establish
personal relations with them.
We would ask them if they could
give their feedback on our
scenarios later on in the week.
Iteration-2 After the weekend long Monday morning we reached at All
Day 2 Mon research, how do we all 0900 Hours and we all had done
04 Oct come at the same our researches on our specified
1030 Hrs knowledge level? fields. However, before we could
start off with the brainstorming
sessions on the uncertainties
and outcomes it was important
that we all were at the same
level OF understanding and we
all could have contributed
constructively in the discussion.
As per Rahul¶s suggestion we
agreed that we all gave a brief
10 minute presentation on the
field of research allocated and
all of us listened carefully and
noted down the relevant point
discussed in the presentation.
Úhe presentation was very
helpful and we were the n able to
link the various links of the chain
which we all have individually
researched on over the
weekend.
Iteration-2 How could we manage the Before we started over with the All
Day 2 Mon huge information which brainstorming session over the
04 Oct was on our way in the uncertainties and the outcomes
0930 Hrs form of 140 uncertainties we stopped for a while to
and their corresponding discuss on how we are going to
300 outcomes? manage such huge information
which was going to be thrown
on the table in a few minutes
time. Effective management of
information was very important
here. We all had the
uncertainties and the outcomes
on our laptops, so we decided :
VÚo write down the
c 8c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
uncertainties and their outcomes
on yellow and pink post-its
respectively.
# even if we had multiple
outcomes, we would still write
them down on pinks.
*We all agreed to mark each of
our post its with a mutually
agreed code. Eg if someone
had researched on society then
he would mark all his chits as
S1,S2 and so on. And he would
mark their corresponding
outcomes as S1A,S1B,S1C and
so on. However, we later felt
that marking A,B and C is
actually irrelevant as
uncertainties and outcomes
were on different colored post-
its.
,We agreed to paste 6 different
flip charts on the wall and mar k
each of them with a specific field
e.g. Úechnology. So the person
who has researched on
technology will paste his stickies
on this flip chart and that way it
was easier for us to look for
slips containing information
relevant to the field we were
searching for.
-We agreed to stick yellow slip
and its corresponding pink slip
just by its side. Úhat way we can
have a glance at the uncertainty
and its outcomes at one go
rather than searching for
outcomes on a different flip
chart.

We realized that by following the

above protocol we can manage
the vast information and at the
same time cut down time on
brainstorming of the yellow¶s
and the pink¶s.
Iteration-2 How are we going to We realized that have a single All
c
c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
Day 2 Mon conduct the brainstorming facilitator going through each of
04 Oct session of the the chits would consume a lot of
1030 Hrs uncertainties and their time as he would have to read it
plausible outcomes? first from the wall, then take time
to understand the point written
on it and then put it down in
words to the group to discuss
on. So, we decided that the
person who had done the
research act as a facilitator for
his chits under discussion and
then hand over the role to the
next person whose chits would
be subject to brainstorming
then. Úhat way we ensured that
:
V All members got a chance to
facilitate
# Everyone got a break during
the session
* Úhe ideas were put on table
very quickly as that very
member had done the research
and thought about its outcomes
, Everyone contributed towards
the brainstorming. Usually
having a single facilitator means
that he gets less engrossed in
thinking and more towards
managing the energies within
the group effectively
Iteration-2 How long and how many Úhe work involved in EIBE
Day 2 Mon breaks we were going to required us to think a lot and
04 Oct have over the next three hence we often used to get
entire Day days? mentally tired or exhausted. It
was very important for us to be
in the room with a very high
level of energy so that we
contributed towards the
discussion on the most creative
way.
We found that we were getting
exhausted every hour and a
half. So we decided to go for
more number of break however
with shorter duration. More
number of break meant they
c
c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
could go down, have some fresh
air in the sun(if we are lucky),
have an energy bar or smoke
and get the energy level back
up. We also decided that we cut
short on the time of lunch and
break for just getting the lunch
from the café and have it on the
go in the room.
We realized that we were early
on in the week and we needed
to preserve our endurance
levels for the rest of the week
and if we had to stretch it would
had to be the Úuesday when we
stretched.
All these factors meant that we
have short and multiple breaks
over the next three days.
Iteration-2 How are we going to Ahmed was identified to capture Mostly
Day 2 Mon capture the huge the information on yellow and Ahmed. All
04 Oct information in terms of pink post its and collating the contributing
1030 Hrs uncertainties and data into the workbook for .
outcomes in the work iteration #2. However, it would
book have taken a lot of time for him
to start writing them down into
the workbook and we would
have wasted a lot of time when
he would had been
unproductive while writing down
the information in the chits.
Furthermore, a few chits were
paraphrased, clubbed or
removed from the flip charts
which added the complexity. So
we agreed that each individual
make changes to his yellow¶s
and pink¶s which he anyway had
in a soft copy, make the
alterations as discussed in the
brainstorming session and send
it to Ahmed in an email. Úhat
way it would be easy for him to
collate the data into the work
book.
Iteration-2 How we were going to It was initially looking a very All
Day 2 Mon approach clustering of the daunting task as we had almost
c

c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
04 Oct huge amount of 450 slips on the wall and simply
1300 Hrs information present on thereading through them was going
wall? to take ages. So we thought of
some simple strategies to
uncomplicated things. Úhey are :
V Úake a random slip to start
with and then think of the
closest factor we could have
related it to. Once we identified
then we asked the guy who
researched on it to search and
find out that factor from his flip
chart.
#We went round the table and
asked each individual what was
the most important uncertainty
and then we brainstormed on
how that factor related to
culture, demographics, and
society. Once we had that
information it was a matter of
asking the respective person to
identify the chits which most
closely co related with the
information at hand.
*During brainstorming we also
focused on what caused that
event and what event resulted
out of it. Úhat way we got mini
links in our mind and we used
that during creating links within
the clusters.
Iteration-2 We did not know if the As we formed the clusters and All
Day 2 Mon clusters were named well? formed the links we also named
04 Oct it. However, we were aware of
1300-EOD the fact that the names don¶t
Hrs necessarily need to be catchy
but brought out an idea of the
cluster as a whole. Effective
naming meant that we had to
spend less time later on going
through the clusters again and
again to find out what the cluster
was all about. In the first
iteration, we had named the
clusters based on Hollywood
movies. Although the ideas
c
3c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
clearly came out but it was
difficult for someone to make
sense who had not watched that
movie.
Iteration-2 We did not know whether We had almost 140 yellow¶s on All
Day 2 Mon to completely exhaust the the wall and at the end of day
04 Oct yellow slips in cluster we had formed 7 clusters, still
1700 Hrs formation or not? we were left with around 40 -45
yellow slips. We were finding it
very difficult to fit the ideas in
the existing clusters and adding
the remaining abstract ideas into
the existing clusters would mean
that we deviate from the idea we
wanted to project from the
cluster. We decided not to add
any idea onto the existing
cluster rather come back
tomorrow and spend an extra
hour in forming two additional
clusters and using up as much
of the ideas that is left on the
wall.
Úhe next day we came in at
0900 Hrs and formed two more
clusters and used up another 20
ideas from the remaining
yellow¶s.
Iteration-2 We did not know how to In iteration #1 we had a All
Day 3 Úue approach the ranking of facilitator to guide us through
05 Oct the matrices and come to but we still had some conflicts in
1000 Hrs an amicable ranking ? the ranking of the clusters. In
iteration 1 we resorted to voting
to resolve our differences. Úhis
time around we wanted to avoid
that and come to an agreement
based to debate.
We drew the matrix up and
placed all the clusters on the
horizontal axis randomly. Úhen
each one of us gave our
feedback on how big an impact
that cluster would had made.
Once we were through with the
impact analysis we then
discussed on the predictability of
each cluster. We found that a lot
c
4c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
of clusters featured in the high
impact and low predictability
quadrant. So, to differentiate
between them we calibrated our
scale and then started to
compare those clusters with
each other to find out their
relative impact and
predictability. Úhat way we were
able to divide the clusters
across various quadrants. We
chose the two which were there
in the bottom right corner of the
chart. We check for
independency and they were, so
that step was done and we
headed towards creating the
end states of the matrices.
Iteration-2 We did not know when to It was very important for us that All
Day 3 Úue approach George to we were on the right track as
05 Oct critique us on the work we correcting things mid way
0930 Hrs had done so far? invariably would have had a big
impact on our final deliverable.
We decided that cluster
formation was an important
stage of our work and any
redoing of work if at all
necessary would be best
catered at this time. So, we
agreed to call George and
Pranal went to his chamber to
ask him to come to our room
526. We also decided that we
would call George again just
before our ice berg analysis on
the Wednesday.
Iteration-2 We did not know how to On day 2 George looked at our All
Day 3 Úue incorporate and how much 11 clusters and gave us a few
05 Oct to incorporate George¶s comments.
0930 Hrs comments on day 2, the VA few clusters were too large
Úuesday? and were revealing more than
one idea, so George asked us to
split them into two clusters.
#He advised that we rename a
few cluster names that would
project the actual idea of that
cluster.
c
5c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
We had one of our clusters
which had 20 stickies on it so
we decided to split them into
two. However, we did not create
them again but marked them
with pens that they were
independent clusters. Úhis
saved us the time redoing the
work.
We also renamed three of our
cluster names and that was
fairly quick and done within 5 -10
minutes.
Iteration-2 How to approach the end Now that we had selected the All
Day 3 Úue states of the two selected two high impact and low
05 Oct clusters? predictable clusters, it was
1230 Hrs important that we defined the
characteristics of the end states.
So we all sat down and started
thinking what the end points
would look like and come out
with characteristics. Eg we had
in one of our clusters as Attitude
of US towards Nicaragua so on
one end we had a very
favorable attitude of US
characterized by debt relief, low
import duties, relaxed
immigration laws for
Nicaraguans etc and on the
other end point we had cold
shoulder of US towards Nicas
characterized by high interests
on debts and sanctions being
imposed on Nicaraguans.
Similarly we did with the other
axis.
Once we were done with that,
we had to name the two end
states. We all used internet to
come up with more creative
names which would have
projected the idea clearly to the
audience.
Úhen we had to name the four
scenarios characterized by the
two end points. We again had a
c
6c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
tough time with naming the
scenarios. We had multiple
names come up and choosing
one over the other was a difficult
task. We used our reasoning
skills to weigh the various
headings we had and finally
came up with four names for all
four scenarios.
Iteration-2 How do we approach Once we were done with the All
Day 3 Úue forming the stories? scenarios, our next task was to
05 Oct start making the stories. We
1530 Hrs agreed that we would make the
first story with the entire group
and then split up into two
groups. We split up into groups
of three with Rony, Rahul and
wendy in one group and Pranal,
Kaustubh and Ahmed in the
other. Úhe story once formed
can then be critiqued by the
other group. Forming the stories
actually took a lot of time and by
1900 Hrs we were done with
three stories. We were mentally
exhausted and did not have the
strength to come up with the
final story.
We realized that we were quite
tired at that time and hence
went in for a half hour break.
Once we were back we
managed to get the ideas
together and formed the fourth
and the final story. By 2030Hrs
we were done with all the four
stories and decided to call it a
day.
Iteration-2 Úo we need George¶s We were undecided whether to All
Day 3 Úue feedback after story ask George for feedback on the
05 Oct formation? stories we had done. Going
2030 Hrs back to clusters or end states at
that point of time would had
been disastrous for us and
would had set us back in time.
We however decided to get it
reviewed. We agreed that the
c
7c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
next morning 0900 Hrs we
would ask George to critique our
work. Pranal agreed to go to
George the next morning and
call him to our room.
Iteration-2 What did George George was kind enough to All
Day 4 Wed feedback on 5 th Oct? come to our room on receiving
06 Oct our email that day. He was
1030 Hrs relatively happy with the work
we had done but also asked us
to look out on the following
things:
1 Úo keep the client in mind
while presenting
2 Not to mention anything about
the process as the end client is
least interested in it
3 Úo have Yin and Yang in our
scenarios to prevent a good-
good and bad-bad scenario.
4 Úhe presentation should
arouse interest in the client and
he must feel that whatever being
presented is relevant to him and
to achieving the millennium
goals.
5 Úo highlight potential
difficulties that UNDP might face
while achieving its millennium
goals.
Iteration-2 How do we implement We decided that we would make All
Day 4 Wed George¶s feedback? two implication matrices as the
06 Oct client would be most interested
1045 Hrs in it. Úhe first matrix would have
the UNDP goals vs. the
scenarios and the second would
be the scenarios vs. the
implications matrix. We also
decided to spend additional time
in the iceberg analysis as they
would be the pivotal events in
the context of the story
Iteration-2 Úo confirm whether we Although on the very first day All
Day 4 Wed would be making a PPÚ or we decided to go with a PPÚ we
06 Oct a poster presentation? still kept the option wide open
1430 Hrs based on how we progressed
through the days. By
c
c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
Wednesday evening 1430 Hrs
we were all through with the
stories, the feedback loops and
the icebergs. So, it was sure
that we had time to make a PPÚ
and present it. Rony asked all
for our consent for the PPÚ and
we all immediately agreed to it.
Iteration-2 How much time we would Initially we thought that there All
Day 4 Wed have for our PPÚ? won¶t be any time limit on the
06 Oct presentation as we did not have
1450 Hrs any such restriction in our first
iteration. So we thought of
having all four stories and the
four icebergs in our PPÚ.
However, Rony was reading one
of the previous year¶s
workbooks and in one page they
mentioned that George was
going to be pretty strict in terms
of the time limit of 15 minutes.

Iteration-2 What would be the We knew that getting all four

Day 4 Wed contents of our PPÚ? stories and the four icebergs in
06 Oct 15 minutes was impossible so
1440 Hrs we decided that we would select
a scenario which would be of
most interest to the UNDP in
achieving the millennium goals.
Once we had agreed that we
wanted to go with Scenario #3
Nicaragua Avanza hacia La
Izquierda it was a matter to
creating the relevant slides.
Getting such vital information at
the right time actually helped us
in preparing the PPÚ as now we
only had to create less number
of slides to make.
Iteration-2 How we are going to Creating the PPÚ meant we all All
Day 4 Wed manage creating the had to contribute towards it. So,
06 Oct PPÚ? firstly we found out what were
1435 Hrs the elements involved in
preparing the slide. We came up
with the following points:
Vcreating the soft versions of
the stories which had almost 70
c
8c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
interrelated links in it.
#Creating the soft versions of
the impact/predictability matrix,
end point characteristics, the
two clusters, scenario name
matrix, the scenario vs. MDG
matrix, ice berg analysis, the
scenario vs. implications matrix
and the final implications of the
scenario explained in the PPÚ.
*Someone collating the data
and putting it into PPÚ format
,Someone adding styles to the
final PPÚ.
Once we had the various to-do
list on the table we had to
allocate resources who would
manage his task.
Iteration-2 Allocating work for We assigned the role of collating All
Day 4 Wed preparing the PPÚ? the data into the PPÚ to Rahul.
06 Oct Ahmed had great skills in
1440 Hrs Microsoft word and PPÚ so he
was into creating the soft
versions of scenario matrices.
Rony and Kaustubh were
brainstorming on the implication
vs. scenario matrix and Pranal
and wendy agreed to copy the
storyline into Microsoft word.
Iteration-2 How to select on who and Once we were done with the Ahmed and
Day 4 Wed how many of us would be PPÚ making we had to decide Kaustubh
06 Oct presenting the PPÚ? on who would be giving the
1630 Hrs presentation. We thought that
we let everyone participate in
presentation. As Rony and
Rahul had already presented
the iteration #1 they encouraged
other members to take up the
presentation. Ahmed and
Kaustubh volunteered for the
task and all of us gave their
consent for it.
We thought that having to o
many members in presentation
would distract the audience and
have an adverse effect on the
timelines. Moreover, we had a
c 3c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
lot of information to be delivered
so it was important that we had
limited people doing the
presentation. So, we agreed that
we will limit the number of
persons doing the presentation
to two.
Iteration-2 How Kaustubh and We allowed them about 30 Kaustubh
Day 4 Wed Ahmed were going to minutes of time to decide on and Ahmed
06 Oct approach the what parts they would be
1645 Hrs presentation? presenting. Ahmed volunteered
to take up the initial part and
Kaustubh took up the story, ice
berg and the implication
matrices.
At around 1715 Hrs both of
them had gone through the
PPÚ.
We decided that they rehearse
the presentation with time
limitations. We performed one
rehearsal. We observed that
Kaustubh¶s part required a lot of
explanation and hence we
allotted him 10 minutes and
Ahmed had to complete his part
in 5. In the first rehearsal, both
of them took around 17 minutes
with a 7 + 10 split. We
requested Ahmed to cut down
on his part so that we meet our
target of 15 minutes. Ahmed
had to leave early that day as
there were some engineering
works being done his railway
track to home. He however,
agreed to practice at home and
restrict himself within 5 minutes.
Even Kaustubh assured that he
would rehearse at home and be
within 10 minutes.
Iteration-2 Whether we needed We agreed that we needed All
Day 4 Wed another rehearsal before another rehearsal on Úhursday
06 Oct the Úhursday¶s morning. Fact that we were
1700 Hrs presentation? starting at 0930 meant that we
can get through another timed
rehearsal from 0900-0930. We
c 3c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
all agreed to gather at room 526
at 0900 Hrs on Úhursday. We
also asked Kaustubh and
Ahmed to ask for help in case
they are stuck at any point of
time during the preparation that
very night.
Iteration-2 Deciding on the dress We all agreed to come in All
Day 4 Wed code during the formals not necessarily suits
06 Oct presentation? and ties but in business formals
1710 Hrs such as shirts, trousers and
formal shoes. Wendy was also
asked to come in business
formals. We agreed on this to
make us look like a team.
Iteration-2 How to go about editing We were all very tired at the end Rahul and
Day 4 Wed minor mistakes in the of the day, however on Pranal
06 Oct PPÚ? reviewing we found out a few
1720 Hrs bugs in the story line and a few
mis-spelt words. Rahul agreed
to correct some of them and
then later Pranal agreed to add
some special effects to the
slides later that night. We all
agreed that we would maintain
versioning of the PPÚ and
mention in the email what
exactly we had changed in this
version. Pranal had to complete
the PPÚ and send it to us later
that night and that very PPÚ was
going to be used the very next
day for presentation.
Iteration-2 How did the timed We conducted a timed rehearsal All
Day 4 Úhu rehearsal go ? of the PPÚ at 0905 hrs. We
06 Oct timed Ahmed and Kaustubh
0905 Hrs individually too. Ahmed took
around 05:37 minutes and
Kaustubh another 10:30
minutes. We were still going
over the clock by one minute.
We again asked Ahmed to hurry
up a little with his slides so that
we could handover to Kaustubh
at 05:00 minutes.
We also provided our feedback
that we cut down on the material
c 3
c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
to be presented a little bit as the
pace was a little too fast and it
would have had a adverse effect
on the comprehension of the
client or our class.
Iteration-2 If we were given a chance Presenting at the beginning All
Day 4 Úhu to select our order of meant that we were directly
06 Oct presentation, do we heading from the timed
0920 Hrs present at beginning or rehearsal to the class. We would
later? have done with our presentation
in no time and spend the rest of
the time in listening to other
presentation. However, if we
present last we got the
opportunity to take inputs from
others presentation and
incorporating them into ours. It
was a tough decision but we all
agreed to go at the beginning if
given a chance to select the
order.
Iteration-2 Do we need anyone We thought that it would be All
Day 4 Úhu showing us time in useful if anyone captured the
06 Oct between the presentation? time taken and informed our
0945 Hrs presenters. We agreed that
Wendy would display us the
time at 0400 and 1400 minutes
but later on we found that
George is actually showing us
the time so dropped the idea.
Iteration-2 George¶s Feedback on After the presentation George N/A
Day 4 Úhu our Presentation provided his feedback on our
06 Oct presentation. Úhey were:
1300 Hrs VÚo keep the client in mind
while presenting.
#Úo have an agenda to start in
the presentation
*Úo clearly bring out how the
implications are relevant for
UNDP for achievement of the
millennium goals.
Iteration-2 How to plan for the George suggested that we All
Day 5 Úhu reflection of EIBE and prepare a PPÚ on what we have
07 Oct Learning manager? learnt in our EIBE and Learning
1430 Hrs manager classes and present it
on Friday. Although less taxing
the task had still to be done and
c 33c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
PPÚ prepared. We agreed to
call it a day on Úhursda y and
come to business school on
Friday morning at 0930 Hrs.
Úwo and a half hours were more
than sufficient for us to
brainstorm and summarize the
points in the PPÚ.
Iteration-2 Who was going to present In our group four of us had Wendy and
Day 6 Fri the reflections already been involved in Pranal
08 Oct presentation on the presentations and we wanted all
1030 Hrs Friday? of us to feel that they were a
part of our group so we
encouraged Pranal and Wendy
to go ahead with the
presentation. Úhe content was
relatively straight forward but we
still insisted that we go through
a timed rehearsal of the
presentation. Rahul helped
Pranal and Wendy explaining
the points on the PPÚ. Once
both of them had gone through
with the points they did a
rehearsal. It was within the 12
minutes allotted. By the time we
were done with the presentation
rehearsal it was almost 12PM
and we had to head
towards the class.
Iteration-2 How to distribute the work We all agreed to meet up on the All
Day 7 Sat and complete the work Saturday at 12 PM at room 526
09 Oct book in time for the in the business school. Although
1030 Hrs Monday submission? we all had the points noted
somewhere in our notebooks,
they had to be put in the work
book and the work book had to
be reviewed for errors. At
around noon we all met and
identified what all was required
to complete the workbook. Úhe
entire work was distributed
amongst the six of us and we all
started working on our individual
work till 445PM. At 1645 Hrs we
realized that we had to leave the
room as the business school
c 34c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
was to close at 1645 Hrs. We
were still quite behind in terms
of completing the workbook. We
then decided that we head
towards the library and complete
the work. We went to the
discussions room in the library
and settled ourselves at one
corner of the discussions room.
In the library two of us were not
able to connect to the wireless
network which made our work
somewhat disruptive. At around
1830 Hrs Ahmed and Rahul
agreed to head back home.
Before leaving we all agreed to
complete three things before
meeting again on the Sunday at
1000 at room 526, SBS. Úhey
were :
1 Úo note down all the links
that¶s have been used for our
research
2 Úo provide a write up on the
self reflection of iteration #2
3 Also to bring some notes on
our research which would be
helpful in filling up of the
workbook.
Iteration-2 What did we learn from Learnt how to work with a team All
Day 6 Sat EIBE the subject? of people coming from different
08 Oct industries and cultures having
diverse experiences

Úaking up a problem statement

without prior knowledge about
the same does not mean you
will not be able to do it. Your
success largely depends on the
group of people you are working
with and the group dynamics
within the team.

Level of learning ± Absorbed

humungous loads of information
in a very small period of time.

c 35c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
Progressed on the learning
curve.
Learnt to manage time
efficiently.
Delegation of responsibility
based on our skill sets

Emotional Resilience

Learnt the art of analyzing an

issue in depth to find underlying
root causalities in the structural
levels by using the µIceberg¶
methodology.

Importance of focusing on the

requirements and interests of
the client and working as a team
towards the end goal

Benefits of team work

Importance of personal relations

within the team and creating a
comfortable environment where
everyone can bring their ideas
forward without any inhibitions.

Being creative ± e.g., PPÚ

making

Importance of paraphrasing

Effective utilization of collective

talent

Finding the right answers by

asking the right questions

Intuitive decision making

Importance of check points and

continuous reviews.

Importance of expert guidance

Proper Synthesis of available

c 36c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
resources.

Conflict management - Chose

Debate over Vote
Iteration-2 What did we learn from Úhought about the group All
Day 6 Sat the course- Learning dynamics in a structured
08 Oct manager? manner.

Set some ground rules,

appointed a facilitator and then
left it up to the person appointed
to make sure that rules are
being followed. Helped
effectively curb conflicts.

Set apart time to analyze and

plan for the project. Made it
easier to reach the end goal with
minimum mistakes.

While dealing with the group, we

developed the art of self -control
and this helped curbed the
aggressive side in us.

We tried to debate using logic

rather than convince using
pressure.

Helped understand the

intricacies of behavioral patterns
like being an activist or theorist
and how constructive or
destructive this can be for the
team.

Increased awareness of our

strengths and weaknesses

Developed the skill of

influencing people

Being reflective ± visualized the

macro picture rather than a
microscopic view

Recognized the µpush¶ and µpull¶

c 37c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
techniques and developed skills
to harness and balance a mix of
these in the team.

Realized the importance of

maintaining a personal dossier.

Recognized issues in group

work like free-loading and
miscommunication and learnt
the art of tackling the same.

Learnt the importance of

synthesizing information when
facilitating

Equal opportunity for the entire

team to contribute.

* m Õmm›Õm 


›&


Getting into Iteration ± II seemed less intimidating than iteration ± I in the sense that
now I had more knowledge of the procedure, I actually kn ew which country we were
going to work on and I had full confidence in the group of people I was working with.
But, on the other hand it seemed much more scary because we had only three days
and seemed like that we had a weeks work on our hands. But now w hen I look back at
those three days, I think they were definitely one of the most educational three days,
not just for me but also for the entire team. Úhe whole concept of scenario planning
and thinking about the implications of an event or probable futur es has somewhat
started to grow on me. I have actually started thinking about what will happen, how will
it happen and what should I do right now to achieve a contented outcome in the near
future. Listening to stories of some other groups¶ dynamics I think we worked together
exceptionally well. Most of the people in our group were neither aggressive enough to
be considered as rude nor were they submissive enough to be pushed around without
reason. Overall our group had very healthy, enjoyable and productive group dynamics.
Working together in this course has definitely brought me closer to working in teams
when I get back to the professional world.


›&

Úhis was the first time we were working together in a group and for the first time we
realized the importance of group dynamics. We feel that whatever we learnt in
c 3c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
Learning manager we could have applied the same in our EIBE course. It was an
enriching experience and the fact that we had a great team also helped us a lot. We
were able to channelize our energies towards achieving our final objective. I also feel
that this course enhanced our thought process and I now feel that I take a different
approach in way i think and approach problems in my daily life. We realized that to get
the maximum out of the group it was very important to set up good personal relations
with each other. Úhe time which we initially spent knowing each other was a time well
invested and we cashed in on those good personal relations later on in the next two
weeks.



%

During the 2 nd iteration, it was totally different from the 1 st one since the scope is much
more bigger. We were stunned in front of the wall of yellow and pink post -its. But things
will work out eventually.
Planning in advance is absolutely the most important thing i n 2nd iteration. Since we
had limited time to finish the process, it was important to check the time allotted in each
step to make sure we were on the track instead of spending too much time figuring out
what should we do. Also, taking both internal and ex ternal factors into concern when
developing scenarios is a good learning. We should look for a broader image, not just
see things in detail. Recognizing the casual effects is also a lesson learned after
creating clusters/stories/icebergs.
During this week, our team had a healthy communication. Each of us got the chance to
express themselves. We learnt to listen and think when everyone held diverse
opinions. Although time squeezed, we still took time relaxing and building relationships
as a team.
We know how to cope with complexity after all these processes. At the same time, we
really enjoy the team this week.


› ›

Úaking ahead the learning from iteration 1, as we start work on iteration 2 with
humongous data, we realized that it is more difficult to wo rk with too much information
as getting the right stuff is very critical and important. However, collective team effort, as
learned during the exercise, made the task easier by synthesizing the information after
splitting the country information in differe nt areas. One of the crucial aspects of
attaining the effective outcome is to keep in mind the client and his expectations. Úhis
exercise taught me to present the very precise and to the point information in front of
client, in which he is interested. Wok ing on the very ambitious timelines, we have
realised that without proper timetable and tracking of work Vs timeline, attainment of
goal in stipulated time is very difficult.
One of the very basic learning out of this exercise was to form the efficient tea m while
working on any problem. Úaking small breaks, going out with the team even in very
tough timeline, helps team members to know each other well, which in turn spread the
positive energy in the team. Voting should not be the first point anytime in dec ision
c 38c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
making instead always have the critical discussion among team to derive the final
outcome. Added to this, always have the ³Iceberg´ analysis in every situation, so as not
to overlook the root cause of the issue. I think that it is very helpful to kee p the EIBE
sessions at the very start of MBA program as the learning out of these sessions and
exercise will definitely help me throughout the program and even after graduation.


 %

Úhe feedback from our presentation in iteration 1 clearly showed that we overlooked
the subtle differences between creating a professional presentation meant for a client
and creating a presentation meant for a classroom. Once this was clear to us, it was
slightly easier for us to plan our tasks and spilt -ups for iteration 2. All of us were very
much aware of the µelephant in the room¶ - the overwhelming task at hand of dissecting
the selected country¶s political and economic dynamics and analyzing the underlying
factors behind UNDP¶s interest in the same.

We were lucky to have a team with very commendable group dynamics. We started off
the exercise by debating on the country to choose for the analysis. After a very
interactive discussion which involved the pros and cons of all the countries in the
Central American region, we unanimously decided to go ahead with Nicaragua, the
poorest country of them all. Úhe decision was also triggered by the fact that none of us
knew much about the country and wanted to study about the country in detail.

Reading and analyzing on Nicaragua w as painful at several levels as the country was
predominantly poor and several fields like technology and legislation had little roles to
play in the dynamics of its political working. Our first day of work was overwhelming as
the task of clustering about 140 uncertainties was a hard target to achieve. Úhe team
made it through in spite of the complexities of the process and we realized that we
were indeed lucky to have validated and named the clusters since many of the teams
were still scrambling with their uncertainties on flip charts.

Úhe final piece to the puzzle unraveled in the form of Dr. George Burt, who in his low,
yet convincing tone showed us how observing each of the clusters with a helicopter¶s
view could make a difference. We went on to refine our clusters into further
independent themes and finally came up with twelve clusters that were independent of
each other. Ranking the clusters was as overwhelming as clustering them and we
debated over the impact and predictability of each of them before finalizing on the two
that were in the high impact and low predictability zones. Úhis was another learning
from iteration 1, debating over voting.

Úhe rest of the process seemed smooth and we were on schedule, and were logically
able to come up with factu al scenarios that were directed towards economic and
political assumptions. Our presentation was appreciated by George and the class in
general and many of our fellow classmates congratulated us on a wonderful
presentation with actual facts about Nicaragua .

c 4c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
I have thoroughly enjoyed the intense exercises and realize that although the process
of scenario planning is primarily meant for business management, my experiences of
mapping out matrices would help make quick and vital decisions when required .


›$&

My learning from Iteration 2 was simple and precise. I have learnt to look at a problem
from a Macro view. Úhe most important facet of planning and scenario building is to
always keep the end goal in mind. Úhe client has to be always kept in mind and at every
step, a critical question has to be asked to oneself -Would the client have any use of this
information or is this redundant to his need. Asking this question to myself repeatedly
will eventually imbibe in me the importance of keeping the needs an d requirements of a
client. Úhis learning will help me become a good Business Consultant which is what my
aim is-to be a ³good´ Business Consultant.
Úhis exercise also taught me the importance of team building and not forgetting to have
fun in ample doses between hard work. Úhe long hours we put in this project including
staying up late and getting up early for 2 consecutive weekends gave me a glimpse of
how a Business Consultant¶s life can be. So I realized that it¶s important to unwind and
take breaks. I am certain to retain the learning from EIBE throughout the MBA program
and use it in real world scenarios after I graduate.

c 4c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
, ›&

Nicaragua is a country overwhelmed by its history. Since colonial times, Nicaragua

has suffered from political instability, civil war, poverty, foreign intervention, and
natural disasters. Successive governments have been unable to bring political
stability or significant economic growth to the country. Personal and foreign special
interests have generally prevailed over national interests, and repeated foreign
intervention in Nicaraguan political and economic affairs has resulted in nationalistic
reactions and a legacy of suspicion of foreign governments and their motives.

Úhe Pacific coast of Nicaragua was settled as a Spanish colony from Panama in the
early 16th century. Independence from Spain was declared in 1821 and the country
became an independent republic in 1838. Britain occupied the Caribbean Coast in
the first half of the 19th century, but gradually ceded control of the region in
subsequent decades. Violent opposition to governmental manipulation and corruption
spread to all classes by 1978 and resulted in a short -lived civil war that brought the
Marxist Sandinista guerrillas to power in 1979. Nicaraguan aid to leftist rebels in El
Salvador caused the US to sponsor anti-Sandinista contra guerrillas through much of
the 1980s. Free elections in 1990, 1996, and 2001, saw the Sandinistas defeated,
but voting in 2006 announced the return of fo rmer Sandinista President Daniel
Ortega. Úhe 2008 municipal elections were characterized by widespread
irregularities. Nicaragua's infrastructure and economy - hard hit by the earlier civil war
and by Hurricane Mitch in 1998 - are slowly being rebuilt, but democratic institutions
face new challenges under the ORÚEGA administration

Nicaragua borders both the Caribbean Sea and the North Pacific Ocean, between
Costa Rica and Honduras.

Since the 1950s, Nicaragua has had a persistently high rate of population increase
and rapid urban growth, both of which were expected to continue into the twenty -first
century. Currently the country¶s population stands roughly around 6 million.

In social terms, the country is split into two zones: the economic and political
heartland of the west, encompassing the Pacific lowlands and the central highlands;
and the sparsely settled east or Caribbean lowlands. Úhe west, containing the major
urban centers, is populated by Spanish -speaking whites and mestizos Úhe east,
historically remote from the centers of political and economic decision making on the
other side of the mountains, includes a sizable indigenous and Creole population that
has never identified with the nation or participated in national affairs.

Nicaraguan constitutions have provided for a secular state and guaranteed freedom
of religion since 1939, but the Roman Catholic Church has retained a special status
in Nicaraguan society

According to the CIA World Factbook, Nicaragua has a population of 5,675,356.

Mestizos and Whites make up the majority (86%) of the population of Nicaragua with
approx. 69% Mestizos and 17% White. Úhe remainder of the Nicaraguan population
c 4
c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
is 9% black, and 5% Amerindian. Nicaraguan demographics reflected a different
composition prior to the Sandinista revolution of 1979 since most of the migration
during the years that followed were primarily of upper or middle class Nicaraguans
which were primarily made up of whites. A growing number of these expats have
been returning after, though a vast m ajority remains living abroad for the most part.

Úhe most populous city in the country is the capital city, Managua, with a population
of 1.2 million (2005). As of 2005, over 4.4 million inhabitants live in the Pacific,
Central and North regions, 2.7 in the Pacific region alone, while inhabitants in the
Caribbean region only reach an estimated 700,000.[2]

Úhe Census Bureau in Nicaragua is the National Institute of Statistics and Census
(INEC). Úhe institution is in charge of completing censuses and survey s. INEC ran its
first census in 1906, the last census was taken in 2005, it was the eighth to date.

According to the 2005 census, 443,847 inhabitants declared themselves Amerindian

(Indigenous). Over 50% of the population lived in rural areas. With 120,81 7
inhabitants declaring themselves Miskito, they make up 27.2% of the total Indigenous
population, followed by the Caribbean Coast mestizos. In addition to the inhabitants
who declared themselves Indigenous, approximately 13,640 answered "Other"
totaling 3.1%. Another 47,473 responded "Not Sure" and an additional 19,460
responded "Ignore", totaling 15.1%

Relative to its overall population, Nicaragua has never experienced any large scale
wave of immigrants. Úhe total number of immigrants to Nicaragua, both originating
from other Latin American countries and all other countries, never surpassed 1% of
its total population prior to 1995. Úhe 2005 census showed the foreign -born
population at 1.2%, having risen a mere .06% in 10 years.[2] Úhis is not to say that
immigrants were not important to the evolution of Nicaraguan society and the
Nicaraguan nation.

During the Nicaraguan Revolution and the Civil War, thousands of Nicaraguans left
the country. After the 1990 Nicaraguan Elections some people returned, but ma ny
more emigrated during the rest of the decade. In 1998, the Hurricane Mitch killed
almost 4,000 people in the country and destroyed much of the Nicaraguan Economy,
as a result thousands of Nicaraguans received the ÚPS for emigrate to the United
States as "refugees".[3] In recent years, many Nicaraguans had left the country to
escape to the poverty and unemployment.

Nicaraguan emigration is a recent process. During the 1990 -2004 period, more than
800,000 Nicaraguans left the country, compared to 100,000 d uring the 1970-1989
period.[4] According to the World Bank, in 2005 there were 683,520 Nicaraguans
living outside Nicaragua legally. If illegals are counted, some sources cite as many as
1,500,000 Nicaraguans living abroad by the end of 2005.[5] Nicaraguan s are the third
largest community of Central Americans living abroad, after Guatemalans and
Salvadorans. Nicaragua is also the second country in Central America by percentage
of population living abroad.
c 43c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c

Remittances to Nicaragua represent about 15% of the country's GDP.[6] In 2008

Nicaragua received close to one billion dollars in remittances; an increase from the
$750,000,000 received in 2007, according to the World Bank[7]

Úhe most populous city in Nicaragua is the capital city, Managua, with a populati on of
1.2 million (2005). As of 2005, over 4.4 million inhabitants live in the Pacific, Central
and North regions, 2.7 in the Pacific region alone, while inhabitants in the Caribbean
region only reach an estimated 700,000.[2]

According to the UN, Nicaragua has a population of 5,743,000 (2009 estimate) with a
population growth rate of 1.31% and a birth rate of 24.9/1,000 population, third
highest in the region. Úhe life expectancy for Nicaraguans at birth is 72.90 years;
69.99 for males and 76.00 for female s. Nicaragua is the second country in Central
America by immigrant¶s expulsion, 210,000 during the period 2005 -2010, lower only
than that of Guatemala

As both the largest country in Central America and the least populated, Nicaragua
has the opportunity to enforce environmental protection and conserve a relatively
large mount of natural resources. However, a variety of forces are driving
deforestation and rapidly increasing pollution. Úhe conversion of forests to
agricultural land (for commercial agricultur e and cattle pastures) and substantial
logging with little or no government regulation are having a severe environmental
impact. In general, ecological concerns can be concentrated into four main areas:
land rights, water access, deforestation and pesticid e use.

Nicaragua's major environmental problems are soil erosion, caused in part by

cultivation of annual crops on steep slopes, and depletion of upland pine forests for
lumber, fuel, and human settlement. Úhe nation lost an average of 2.5% of its forest
and woodland each year between 1990 and 1995. One contributing factor is the use
of wood for fuel. Excessive or ineffective use of pesticides to control malaria, along
with widespread agricultural use, has resulted in some environmental contamination.
Nicaragua's cities produce about 0.5 million tons of solid waste per year. Industrial
pollutants have contaminated the lakes and rivers. Úhe nation has 190 cu km of
renewable water resource, with 84% used for farming and 2% in industrial activity. As
of 2000, 91% of Nicaragua's city dwellers and 59% of its rural population have
access to safe drinking water. Dumping of sewage and chemical wastes has made
Lake Managua unsuitable for swimming, fishing, or drinking. Primary responsibility for
resource conservation is vested in the Nicaraguan Institute of Natural Resources and
Environment (Instituto Nicaragüense de Recursos Naturales y del Ambiente ²
IRENA), established in October 1979.

In 2001, four of the nation's mammal species were endangered, as were three bir d
species and 29 plant species. Endangered or extinct species in Nicaragua include
the tundra peregrine falcon, four species of turtle (green sea, hawksbill, leatherback,
and olive ridley), the spectacled caiman, and the American crocodile.
c 44c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
Understanding the political environment of a country like Nicaragua had to start with
understanding the history of the nation. So I went right back to the time when
Nicaragua was a Spanish colony and studied the country¶s bloody and highly
intriguing story.

Nicaragua¶s complex relationship and over dependence on US has its roots in the
U.S. occupation of Nicaragua from 1912 to 1933. U.S. motives included differences
over the proposed Nicaragua Canal, Nicaragua's potential as a destabilizing
influence in the region, and President Zelaya's attempts to regulate foreign access to
Nicaraguan natural resources. From 1927 until 1933, Gen. Augusto César Sandino
led a sustained guerrilla war first against U.S. Marines and eventually forced them to
compromise and leave. Úhen rose the Somoza Dictatorship which ruled Nicaragua
from 1936 to 1979. Úhe Somoza¶s ruled Nicaragua with an iron fist and an eventual
revolution led by the current President Daniel Ortega brought about Constitutional
Democracy.

Understanding the implications of the political strife that the Nicaraguans have
undergone helped me realize the importance of a constitutional democracy and
friendly relationship with US for Nicaragua and the entire Central American Region.
As a part of studying the Political Environm ent of Nicaragua, it was important to study
the Business and Úrade agreements of Nicaragua and its foreign policy regarding
US, Central American countries and its ³new allies´ - China and Russia.

Nicaragua is a country which is walking a tight rope between capitalism and

socialism. Daniel Ortega¶s personal political ideology is predominantly leftist, but
leftist policy implementation has been kept in check by the US involvement in
Nicaraguan politics. However, new strategic relationships with China and Russ ia may
have an adverse impact on Nicaraguan-US relationship and may give Daniel Ortega
political support to turn Nicaragua into a part of the leftist block.

My research led me to another highly controversial topic -Úhe Nicaragua Canal.

Originally Nicaragua had the backing of US for a canal to be built through it. A canal
in this region had become a necessity for the growing sea trade economies. In the
eleventh hour, Panama was chosen over Nicaragua as the final site for the
construction of the canal, as US was concerned about the active volcanoes which
pepper the landscape of Nicaragua. Speculation on a new canal continues even
today and the steady increase in world shipping, together with the possibility of
establishing shorter shipping routes, may make this a viable project. If this project
does materialize, it will transform Nicaragua into the richest nations of Central
America. But this project will take roughly US$25 billion, 25 times Nicaragua's annual
budget and about 25 years to construct. Constructio n of the canal will have a
devastating impact of the ecology of the region and this is one of the major reasons
why legislation about the construction is being opposed.

Úo get the knowledge about the legal and judicial system of Nicaragua, it is very
necessary to look into the political system as well. In this country the judicial system
c 45c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c

is very much influenced with the political system and leaders. As the political system
is corrupt majorly, it has a very negative impact on the legal system of the coun try.
Because of this most of the rights provided to the common people/organizations of
the country are suppressed very frequently and regularly.

Nicaragua¶s judicial system generally respected many of its citizens' human rights,
however, serious problems remained prevalent in some area such as : security
forces committed extrajudicial killings, Police continued to beat and otherwise abuse
detainees, torture by authorities, prison & police holding cells are harsh &
overcrowded, decision making at court is subject at times to political influence and
corruption, Violence & discrimination against women, child labor & child prostitution
etc.

Úhe labor law in country has restricted the child under age of 14 to work; however the
Ministry of labor, which has the responsibility of enforcing labor laws, rarely
prosecutes violations of the minimum -age regulation. So young street vendors or
windshield cleaners are a common sight in Nicaragua for child labor. Along with this
children frequently work on family farms at a young age. A National Minimum Wage
Commission establishes minimum wages for different sectors of the economy,
However enforcement of the minimum wage is lax and many workers are paid less
than the law allows. Labor groups have argued that the minimum wage is inadequate
to feed a family of four, which in turn force each member of the family, including
children, to earn the livelihood themselves.

Nicaragua had signed a free trade agreement with most of the southern American
nations. Úhis system allows both the entry of merchandise into the national customs
territory, and the local purchase of goods or raw material without paying any kind of
taxes or duties. Úhis has provided the opportunity to local farmers to grow
commercial crop, so that more profit ca n be generated. Úo lure the international
industries, the country has provided the best mean of transport, road transport, to the
outside organization. However on the other side this has the negative impact
considering the fuel prices in country. Nicaragua n¶s organizational law does not
provide the liberty to foreigner to get the license for media and television
broadcasting. Úhis is totally preserved for the Nicaraguans.

Úhe law system at Supreme Court is very ineffective and highly influenced by the
politics. Because of the corruption and in-transparency decision making process is
time consuming. Looking at this, the local people have less faith in the court system.
Poor enforcement of property rights deters both foreign and domestic investment,
especially in real estate development and tourism. Conflicting claims and weak
enforcement of property rights has invited property disputes and litigation.

c 46c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
Nicaraguan Industry and Export/Import to neighboring countries

¦ After having one of the fastest growing economies in the region in the 50s and
60s, by the mid-90s it had become the country with the slowest economic
growth and one of the most indebted and economically unstable in the world.
Half of the population lived in poverty, with a fifth in extreme pove rty.

¦ Industrial activity in Nicaragua has never progressed much beyond the stage
of light manufacture. Since 1997, influx of Foreign direct investment (FDI)
inflows which were concentrated in mobile telecommunications, maquila
operations and tourism proj ects

¦ Úhere are over 100 companies operating in Nicaragua with some relation to a
U.S. company, either as wholly or partly-owned subsidiaries, franchisees, or
exclusive distributors of U.S. products. Úhe largest are in energy, financial
services, textiles/apparel, manufacturing, and fisheries.

¦ Maquila (offshore assembly for re-export) production has expanded rapidly,

taking advantage of extremely cheap labour costs. Úhe maquila industry is
shifting away from an exclusive emphasis on garments to other secto rs such
as cotton fabric for use in maquila plants, shoes, aluminium and electrical
wiring for cars. Maquila plants are increasingly located in the interior of the
country.

¦ Among the Central American countries, El Salvador is Nicaraguas most

important trading partner, followed by Honduras. In 2007 Nicaragua exported
14% of its exports to El Salvador and bought 4% of its imports from there.

¦ According to ECLAC estimates, the Nicaraguan economy posted 1.5%

negative GDP growth in 2009 after 15 years of uninte rrupted expansion and
compared with 3.2% positive growth in 2008.

¦ Úhe Nicaraguan economy felt the toll of the international financial crisis and,
particularly, of the recession in the United States in 2009. Úhe primary
transmission channels were weaker external demand, a decrease in the flow
of remittances and shrinking foreign direct investment (FDI). Úhe economic
downturn was more acute during the first half of the year; the decline of the
monthly economic activity indicator slowed in the second semester .

¦ In 2009, the first meetings were held to negotiate a free trade agreement with
Chile. Meanwhile, negotiations on an association agreement between Central
c 47c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
America and the European Union were suspended after seven rounds of talks,
pending resolution of th e crisis in Honduras.

¦ Macroeconomic management under the Ortega Administration has remained

broadly favourable. Yet, a succession of external shocks including the
Hurricane Felix, high food prices, and the financial crisis had an impact on
Nicaragua¶s macro aggregates.

¦ Recent indicators suggest that economic activity is starting to turn around. Úhe
economic recovery in United States is particularly relevant in the Nicaraguan
context as 30% of Nicaraguan exports are directed to the United States (the
main export market) and workers¶ remittances (mainly from the United States
and Costa Rica) represent more than 13% of GDP.

¦ Úhere are still great challenges to be met in net primary school enrolment,
chronic malnutrition, access to water and illiteracy, but t he new administration
has committed to focusing on these problems to ensure that they are also
resolved.

¦ Although the Ortega administration has a clear vision of the country¶s

development priorities, its policies have been limited by external factors such
as the effects of the global financial crisis, which are having a direct impact on
the availability of financial resources and the provision of new credits in the
national financial system, the decrease in shipments, a loss of jobs in the duty
free sector and decreased affluence in the tourism sector, as well as the
imminent threat of a drop in exports due to lower demand for certain products
in the country¶s main markets.

¦ Úhe World Bank executes certain projects in Nicaragua to help the economy to
recover from its dependence on its international partnerships. Some of the
projects that were stared a few years back have been detrimental in increasing
economic developments in the country. Úhey are:

1. Rural Electrification Project for Development outside the C entral Grid: Úhe
main objective is to support the Government in providing sustainable
electricity services and other social and economic benefits associated with
these services in selected rural areas of Nicaragua, as well as to
strengthen the Government¶s institutional capacity to execute its rural
electrification strategy.

c 4c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
2. Second Agricultural Úechnology Project: Úhe main objective is to provide
rural households and communities with broader access to sustainable
agricultural, forestry and natural resource management services and
innovations, thereby stimulating higher agricultural productivity.

3. Nicaragua Rural Úelecom Project: Úhe main obj ective is to increase access
to, and reduce costs of telecommunications services in rural areas of
Nicaragua, expanding the infrastructure, and supporting private -sector
operators who will be responsible for installing, operating, and maintaining
the new telecommunications systems on a commercial basis.

¦ Úhe private use of e-mail and the internet remains low relative to the high
costs of the service relative to local incomes. Úhere were fewer than three
Internet users per 100 inhabitants in 2007 (compared with six per 100
inhabitants in Honduras, 11 per 100 in El Salvador and 34 per 100 in Costa
Rica).

¦ Almost all installed telecommunications capacity uses digital technology,

owing to investments since privatization of the formerly state -owned telecoms
company, the Empresa Nicaragüense de Úelecomunicaciones (Enitel). In
February 2004 América Móvil, the mobile -phone arm of Úelmex of Mexico,
purchased the 40% share belonging to a Honduran firm, Megatel, and thus
gained complete control of Enitel. América is rapidly expanding both fixed and
mobile services.

¦ Coverage of fixed telephony is among the lowest in Central America at 4.4

lines per 100 inhabitants in 2007. Cellular coverage far outstrips fixed -line
telephony with 38 phones per 100 inhabitants in circulation.

¦ Regardless of the fast development, the absolute number of the information

network users is still in relatively low level in Nicaragua. Úhe users are clearly
concentrated to the biggest cities, whereas the rural and marginal areas lack
of telecommunications infrastructure and even the basic infrastructure of the
electrical lines and water delivery systems. Úhere are , though, great
necessities to enter to the Internet world in many areas outside the high
populated centres.

¦ Úhe fastest growth rate is seen in cellular networks, since there is clear lack of
fixed line telecommunications infrastructure in Nicaragua. Úher e are places in
Nicaragua without any telecommunications infrastructure, which gives
challenges in offering the Internet services. In these cases, the only option
c 48c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
might be the satellite connection, which results higher operating costs and
thus more expensive prices for the customers compared to the normal
solutions e.g. via cable modem.

¦ If there were more means to use the Internet services, the tourism and local
business would most probably develop. For the tourists, there are excellent
places for spending the vacations in Nicaragua, but in many cases, there is
not yet adequate infrastructure of telecommunications, power lines or water
tubes constructed.

- m
 mÕm›m Õ ›m m

c 5c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
›
 ! 
    


  1. Population growth rate


  2. Extent of urbanization


  3. Ratio of birth rate to death rate


  4. Extent of migration rate


  5. Attitude towards women in the family and in workplace
 (male : female ratio)


 6. Change in literacy rate and its affect


 7. Free mandatory primary education


 8. Capability of education department


 9. Quality of education in the rural areas


 10. Government support for female education


 11. Úhe number of people who are educated in the society


  12. Expatriate community settled in Nicaragua


  13. Population below poverty line


  14. Government schemes to help the poor


  15. Government programs to help the poor in terms of
 providing food


  16. Economic composition of the society


  17. Level of division of society into rich & poor


  18. Social and cultural division


  19. Extent of slave work


  20. Extent of employment black marketing




  21. Diversity of employment offered to locals
c 5c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c


  22. Proportion of population in the working class group

 
 23. Impact of religion on society

 
 24. Level of impact of religious groups on politics

 
 25. Cultural and religion based division

  26. Representation of all ethnic communities in power
 structures

  27. Level of discrimination in the society

  28. Level of support for harnessing the indigenous way of
 life


  // 29. Credibility of the Central Bank of Nicaragua (impact or

  effect)


  // 30. Government access to Domestic Public Debt

 

  // 31. Continuity of Constitutional Democracy

 

  // 32. Continuity of Constitutional Rights

 

  // 33. Úhe right to form and join Úrade Unions

 

  // 34. Sustaining the "Poverty Reduction and Growth Facility"

  plan


  // 35. Maintaining the US-Central America Free Úrade

  Agreement


  // 36. Support and aid to Foreign Radical Regimes

 

  // 37. Enforcement of Stringent Property Rights

 

  // 38. Political Influence on the Judiciary

 

  // 39. Úerritorial Disputes with Neighbors

 

  // 40. Maintaining friendly relations with US

 



  // 41. Maintaining free Úrade Zones
c 5
c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c

 

  // 42. Government Investment in local Human Capital

 

  // 43. Promotion of Foreign Investment Laws

 

  // 44. Future of Soviet weapons Arsenal

 
 
 45. Maintaining Religious Freedom


  // 46. Diversification of Úrade and Cooperative Partnerships

 

  // 47. Participation in Central American Integration System

  (SICA)


  // 48. Regional Cooperation regarding the Common Credit

  Fund


  // 49. Bilateral relations with BRAZIL

 

  // 50. Bilateral relations with RUSSIA

 

  // 51. Bilateral relations with IRAN

 

  // 52. Bilateral relations with CHINA

 

  // 53. State's role in Redistribution of Income

 

  // 54. Innovative Development finance initiatives like the

  PEÚROCARIBE


  // 55. Úhreat of a W-Shaped Recession

 

  // 56. Future Role of Bolivarian Alliance for the Americans -

  ALBA


  // 57. Impact of new common Currency-SUCRE

 

  // 58. Legislation in favor of Nicaragua Canal

 

  // 59. Continued existence of a Multi Party Political System

 

  // 60. Local politics and rural approach to governance

 

  // 61. Relaxation on the tourist emigration process

 


  // 62. Restriction on abortion
c 53c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c

 

  // 63. Absence of policy to address global warming

 

  // 64. Impact of industrial decentralization policy

 

  // 65. Effect of road transport policy on foreign industries

 

  // 66. Change in the minimum wage

 

  // 67. Impact of free trade agreement

 

  // 68. large concentration on the farming of commercial

  commodity


  // 69. Absence of political will & commitment to change

 

  // 70. Exercise of freedom of speech

 
 71. Delay on criminal case decision

 72. Effectiveness of security forces & police in maintaining
 civil order

 73. Effect of minimum age regulation on controlling child
 labor


  // 74. Low labor wages

 

  // 75. Restriction of media and television broadcasting

  licenses to locals


  // 76. Extent of transparency in international aided

  development work

 77. Level of property rights execution

 78. Level of product liability law enforcement

 79. Execution of law in supreme court


  // 80. Impact of commercial food export

 

  // 81. Impact of trans-shipment on drug trafficking

 



  82. Level of emigration of labor work force to Costa Rica
c 54c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c


  83. Impact of High Population growth rate on the
 Nicaraguan economy

  84. Co-existence of ethnic groups


 85. Literacy rate among women

&  86. Impact of health care services in rural community

&  87. Availability of safe drinking water


  // 88. Permitting international companies to set up base

 

  89. Availability of employment opportunities within the
 country


  // 90. Nature of corruption in the government

 
 ! 

  91. Construction of Nicaragua canal

&  92. Spread of SÚDs and HIV/AIDs


  93. Level of Poverty in rural areas


  // 94. Extent of foreign aid received to eradicate poverty and

  providing basic civic facilities


  95. Level of livestock breeding in the plains

&  96. Stability in food supply

 ! 

  97. Impact of high pesticide use in cotton industry

 ! 

  98. Extent of Soil Erosion in the coastal regions

 ! 

  99. Effect of deforestation on environment

 ! 

  100. Farming on the fertile coastal regions of the lake
 Nicaragua and other water bodies

 ! 

  101. Addition of new fish species like tilapia in the Lake

 ! 

  102. Úhe steady expansion of agricultural frontier


 ! 

  103. Unplanned mineral extraction especially gold
c 55c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c

 ! 

  104. Possible extinction of the sea turtles

 ! 

  105. Extraction of huge unexplored potential mineral
 reserves


  106. Involvement of youth in drug related crimes

 ! 

  107. Unchecked tapping of natural resources

 ! 

  108. Impact of Equilibrium on ecosystem



 109. Impact of availability of telecommunications
 infrastructure



 110. Effect of high cost of internet services relative to local
 incomes

  111. Impact of cultural bias towards school autonomy

m  112. Effect of low industrial progress beyond the stage of
 light manufacture

m  113. Impact of reliability on oil imports



 114. Continuity of privatization of telecoms companies


  // 115. Effect of influx of Foreign Direct Investment inflows on

  various domains


  // 116. Impact on relations with the United States for export /

  import

 ! 

  117. Impact of weather conditions



 118. Access to information for effe ctive e-governance


  // 119. Effects of relations with neighboring countries

 



 120. Impact of economic situation on the public


  121. Effect of uneven population distributions across areas

m  122. Effect of health and town planning in rural areas


m  123. Impact of government support toward s local industries
c 56c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c



 124. Extend of investments in research and development on
 the economy


  // 125. Impact of the project µRural Electrification Project for

  Development Outside the Central Grid¶ run by the
 World Bank


  // 126. Impact of the project µSecond Agricultural Úechnolog y¶

  run by the World Bank


  // 127. Impact of the project µNicaragua Rural Úelecom

  Project¶ run by the World Bank




 128. Availability of energy import




 129. External demand fluctuation


  130. Level of unemployment rate




 131. Level of real estate investment




 132. Úourism development


  // 133. Internal transportation connection

 



 134. Private investment from other countries




 135. Possibility in industry transformation


  // 136. Úax imposed (by US) on Nicaragua's exports

 

  // 137. International relationship(especially with USA)

 

  // 138. Salary growth

 

  139. Gender equality in job opportunity


  140. Number of citizens migrate out of Nicaragua


.  ›m m›
›m$

c 57c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
     


  


 
1. Population growth rate Poor quality of education Ample availability of basic
facilities
population growth ra te Large families with limited
means to support them
2. Extent of urbanization Rise in crime rate in the Lack of cheap labor in the
urban areas cities
3. Ratio of birth rate to Population explosion Increases pressure on local
death rate health services and
Civic amenities
4. Extent of migration Increase in urban More job opportunities for
rate population the local
5. Attitude towards Better implementation of Men and women are
women in the family women¶s rights equally prevalent in the
and in workplace workplace
(male : female ratio)
attitude towards Women are mostly seen to
women in the family be in family roles
and in workplace
(male : female ratio)
6. Change in literacy rate People belonging to Úhe illiterate remain
and its affect particular demographics get illiterate and country is in
educated over the coming the hand of the educated
years from generations
change in literacy rate Majority of workforce
and its affect comprises of unskilled
workers leading to poor
wages
7. Free mandatory Increase in skilled Awareness of social and
primary education workforce health issues such as
contraception, birth control
and SÚDs
8. Capability of education Government promotes and Heavy concentration of
department invests heavily in education schools in urban areas
9. Quality of education in Schooling interfering with Increased awareness helps
the rural areas education coping with health issues
10. Government support Leading to high literacy and Awareness of HIV Aids and
for female education Women being employed methods to curb them
government support Educated women will in turn Awareness of family
for female education help bringing up educated planning and its benefits
generation
government support Females seeking legal help
for female education against domestic violence

11. Úhe number of people Educated people are crucial Educated people provide
who are educated in for economic growth integrity and peace in their
c 5c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
the society society
12. Expatriate community Will boost small and Added diversity and culture
settled in Nicaragua medium business industry to the society
within the country
expatriate community Will have a positive impact
settled in Nicaragua on the tourism industry
13. Population below Greater involvement of Increased government
poverty line international bodies like un reforms in rural areas
14. Government schemes Poverty groups will increase More availability of
to help the poor in some areas employment
15. Government programs People dying in rural areas Immunity to disease is
to help the poor in because of lack of food and going down
terms of providing food the lack of ability to afford
food
16. Economic composition Úhe rich dominate and Increase in street crime
of the society exploit the poor
17. Level of division of Government has to spend Will give rise to resentment
society into rich & poor Sizeable portion of total against government and
spending to feed the poor elite in the society
18. Social and cultural Úhe upper class segment is Úhe elite is suppressing the
division looking after the country¶s poor for personal gain
interest by helping the poor
to rise
19. Extent of slave work Increase in population Manipulation of the poor by
working under minimum the elite
wage living in miserable
conditions
20. Extent of employment More employed and Collection of taxes reduced
black marketing unemployed which the
Government does not know
about
21. Diversity of Úhere are numerous In many areas there is only
employment offered to industries local people can one main industry to work in
locals work in
22. Proportion of If large, working class Is small, hampers the
population in the Group is driving the Economic growth of the
working class group economy country
23. Impact of religion on Religious leaders have a Religious freedom results in
society strong input in political harmony within the
Matters Society
impact of religion on Easier to pass social Strict social obligations
society messages with help of hampering growth
these groups

24. Level of impact of Government listens strongly Action on an issue raised

religious groups on to the opinion of strong by one religious community
c 58c

cc c

cc„

c
c
c
c
c
c
 V

 

V 
c
politics
25. Cultural and religion
based division
26. Representation of all
ethnic communities in
power structures
representation of all
ethnic communities in
power structures
27. Level of discrimination
in the society
28. Level of support for
harnessing the
indigenous way of life
29. Credibility of the
central bank of
Nicaragua (impact or
effect)
credibility of the
central bank of
Nicaragua (impact or
effect)
30. Government access to
domestic public debt
31. Continuity of
constitutional
democracy
32. Continuity of
constitutional rights
33. Úhe right to form and
join trade unions
the right to form and
join trade unions
34. Sustaining the
"poverty reduction and
c 6c

cc c
religious groups
Division in society creates
hatred, frustration and
discord
Increased discrimination in
the society
Lack of social and cultural
integration of people
Marginal involvement of
representatives of some
communities in
government, parliament and
the judiciary
No funding available to
maintain the indigenous
way of life
Success or failure in raising
domestic public debt
Success or failure in
fighting inflation
Utilization of excess public
funds
Continuity of peace leading
to economic progress
Freedom of speech
Improved collective
bargaining power of labor in
private sector
Organized labor can go on
strikes disrupting production
Free market and free trade
policies
can have a negative impact
on another religious
community giving rise to
conflict
Division in society renders
frustrated population
unproductive and a burden
on the government
Inadequacy of public
services in areas inhabited
by communities with no
representation
Indicators of health,
education and housing
remain lower for some as
compared to others
Úreatment in the media of
some ethnic groups
reduced as folklore
Government acting to
prevent the wearing down
of indigenous way of life
Success or failure of
monetary policies
Rate of growth of domestic
infrastructure
Continued constitutional
rights for the citizens
Freedom of religion
Job security and stability
leading to increased
industrial output
Maintenance of fiscal
discipline

cc„

c
c
c
c
c
c
 V

 

V 
c
growth facility" plan
35. Maintaining the us-
Central America free
trade agreement
36. Support and aid to
foreign radical regimes
37. Enforcement of
stringent property
rights
38. Political influence on
the judiciary
39. Úerritorial disputes
with neighbors
territorial disputes
with neighbors
40. Maintaining friendly
relations with us
41. Maintaining free trade
zones
maintaining free trade
zones
42. Government
investment in local
human capital
43. Promotion of foreign
investment laws
44. Future of soviet
weapons arsenal
45. Maintaining religious
freedom
46. Diversification of trade
and cooperative
partnerships
47. Participation in Central
American Integration
System (SICA)
48. Regional cooperation
regarding the common
credit fund
49. Bilateral relations with
brazil
Continued exports to us,
amounting to almost 2/3rd
of total exports.
Effect on foreign investment
inflows and international aid
Foreign and domestic
investment in real estate
Level of corruption in the
legal system
Stability/instability in the
Central American region
Increased expenditure on
defense
Continued aid, healthcare
and debt relief
Úax rebates and trade
incentive for foreign
investments
Generation of employment
Well educated, computer
literate workforce
Continued foreign
investment inflow into
Nicaragua
Loss of aid from us and
European allies
Continuity of human rights
Reduced dependence on
us markets for trade.
Regional integration in
Central America
Common source of
additional funding for
Central American
governments
Increase in trade and
commerce
Continued imports from us.
Úrade sanctions and
embargoes
Benefit of foreign
investment to the local
economy
Unchecked power vested in
the hands of the ruling
party.
Úrade embargoes with
neighbors
Continued beneficial trade
relations with us.
Level of competitiveness of
local economy
Skilled workforce for labor
intensive industries
Local industrial and
infrastructural growth
Loss of support of leftist
allies
Communal harmony
leading to sustained local
growth
Benefit of opening trade
relationships with countries
such as Venezuela, China, Iran
Promotion of regional
solutions for regional
problems
Increase in social
infrastructure projects
Proposed Brazilian aid in
development projects to
c 6c

cc c

cc„

c
c
c
c
c
c
 V

 

V 
c
Nicaragua
50. Bilateral relations with Proposed aid in healthcare Proposed sharing of
russia and technology Russian expertise in
Nicaraguan energy projects
51. Bilateral relations with Proposed aid in Healthcare aid in
iran development of major marginalized areas of
hydroelectric plants Nicaragua from Iran
52. Bilateral relations with Establishment of Opening of Chinese
china Nicaraguan- Chinese markets for cash crop
chamber of industry and export
commerce
bilateral relations with Nicaraguan trade fairs and
china exhibitions in china
53. State's role in Change in the inequality Bridging the gap between
redistribution of index - GINI coefficient the have's and the have
income not's
54. Innovative Low interest, long term Maintenance of petroleum
development finance credit resulting in growth and oil supplies to aid rapid
initiatives like the and poverty reduction industrial growth
PEÚROCARIBE
55. Úhreat of a w-shaped Collapse of local industries Collapse of international
recession and increase in trade
unemployment
threat of a w-shaped Decreased tourism Severe impact on exports
recession
56. Future role of Regional economic integration
Bolivarian Alliance for and peace leading to mutual
the Americans - ALBA development
57. Impact of new Reduction of us control on Increased stability of
common currency- Central American regional markets
SUCRE economies
58. Legislation in favor of Revenue from canal might Nicaragua canal could
Nicaragua canal double Nicaragua¶s annual make Nicaragua one of the
GDP richest nations of the region
legislation in favor of Nicaragua canal would Bring Nicaragua on the
Nicaragua canal create thousands of long world map
term local jobs.
legislation in favor of Complete destruction of san Deforestation
Nicaragua canal Juan river
legislation in favor of Damage to ecosystem
Nicaragua canal
59. Continued existence of Continued democracy Continued democracy
a multi party political leading to sustainable leading to sustainable
system growth growth
60. Local politics and rural Local politicians want to Local politicians are being
approach to improve conditions suppressed by ruling party
c 6
c

cc c

cc„

c
c
c
c
c
c
 V

 

V 
c
governance
61. Relaxation on the Increase in the foreign Provide easy access to non
tourist emigration currency due to more social elements
process tourists
62. Restriction on abortion Motivate people to use Punish women, especially
contraception/safety sex worked of added
responsibility of growing a
child without father.
63. Absence of policy to Úourist places have started Non-government
address global deteriorating organization step forward to
warming address the global warming
64. Impact of industrial Distribution of money & Reduced industrial
decentralization policy people in the impoverished investment
area
65. Effect of road transport Road transport is the best Increasing fuel costs raise
policy on foreign mean of goods transport in the industries operating
industries country cost.
66. Change in the Helped to reduce the Negative impact of the
minimum wage poverty among labor global competition
67. Impact of free trade Helped the economy by tax Negative impact on the
agreement free import/export local industry by cheap
commodity imported from
neighbors
68. Large concentration Farmers enjoy more profit Government not able to
on the farming of through export meet the food requirement
commercial for increased population.
commodity
69. Absence of political Negate the impact of reform Existing economic
will & commitment to efforts development will be
change threaded in long run
70. Exercise of freedom of People are free to express Political/government
speech views/thoughts officials suppress the right
of speech whenever
required
71. Delay on criminal case Decision makers are being Continuously increasing
decision blackmailed / threaten / burden on the government
bribed & government officials
72. Effectiveness of Motivated by politics and Violence & discrimination
security forces & corruption against women
police in maintaining
civil order
73. Effect of minimum age Ministry of labor rarely Underemployment cause
regulation on prosecute the violation of extra burden on the family
controlling child labor minimum age regulation
74. Low labor wages Motive people to participate Increase the number of
in drug trafficking & crime child labor

c 63c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
75. Restriction of media Motivation for the local Less investment by the
and television people to participate in global media corporations
broadcasting licenses establishing business
to locals
76. Extent of transparency Increase in corruption Availability of fund through
in international aided among government officials outer organization disrupted
development work
77. Level of property rights Leads to property dispute Decrease credibility of law
execution and litigation system among society
78. Level of product More cases of health issues Lack of law system's
liability law actions lead unrest in
enforcement people
79. Execution of law in Common people stops to Very frequent political
supreme court use law system to get the issues confronted
justice
80. Impact of commercial Large land owner earn Small land owner. Not able
food export more profit though to meet national food
commercial food export requirement
81. Impact of trans- Úrans-shipment of export Increase the drug related
shipment on drug goods flourish the illegal crime
trafficking shipment of drugs
82. Level of emigration of Higher remittance Reduced demands for jobs
labor work force to contributing to economic and public services in the
Costa Rica growth of the country and home country
mitigate trade deficit
83. Impact of high Strains the health and Depletion of natural
population growth rate education system resources e.g. Fossil fuels
on the Nicaraguan
economy
84. Co-existence of ethnic Always a situation of cold Ethnic groups are able to
groups war among ethnic groups interact and trade amongst
and terror prevails them freely
85. Literacy rate among Women seeking legal help Drop in the fertility rates
women against domestic violence amongst women
86. Impact of health care Sharp decrease in the Fall in the child mortality
services in rural maternal deaths cases. cases
community
87. Availability of safe Increase in cases of water Úap water is safe for
drinking water borne diseases like drinking
diarrhea
88. Permitting Offer very less wages and Government benefits from
international little job security to workers the contributions of these
companies to set up foreign companies
base
89. Availability of Youth joining local gangs Working population migrate
employment and rob locals and tourists to other ca countries like

c 64c

cc c

cc„

c
c
c
c
c
c
 V

 

V 
c
opportunities within
the country
90. Nature of corruption in
the government
91. Construction of
Nicaragua canal
92. Spread of SÚDs and
HIV/Aids
93. Level of poverty in
rural areas
94. Extent of foreign aid
received to eradicate
poverty and providing
basic civic facilities
95. Level of livestock
breeding in the plains
96. Stability in food supply
97. Impact of high
pesticide use in cotton
industry
98. Extent of soil erosion
in the coastal regions
99. Effect of deforestation
on environment
100. Farming on the fertile
c 65c

cc c
on streets Costa Rica which has better
employment opportunities
Limits the help the poor International aid does not
people desperately need reach the people it is
intended for
Huge boost to the economy Huge damage to the eco
of Nicaragua and benefit system as water from
from trade passage pacific meet the Atlantic
Negative impact on tourism Government spreading
awareness among people
on contraceptives and
limiting spread of SÚDs
Severe malnutrition among Government providing relief
children resulting in in the form of financial
deficiency diseases or aids/low interest
deaths funds/employment/free
health care services to
people under poverty line
Corruption in the Aid channelized into right
government results in direction and most of rural
money going into wrong people are better off with
hands safe drinking water and
access to healthcare
systems
Overgrazing leading to loss Increased revenues by
of firmness of top soil and exporting meat to us
making it vulnerable to be countries
washed away by wind and
rain
Local merchants hoard Government control the
basic food to increase theirprices of basic food items
profit and keeps hoarding and
corruption in check
Health problems amongst Increased cotton production
workers including in the short term leading to
poisoning, fish kills and higher exports of cotton
deep well contamination adding to GDP
Úop soil guarded by framing Huge productivity loss in
barricades which would coffee, and banana
stem flow of water plantation as fertile top soil
is gone
Erosion of the top soil & Lot of plant and animal
more occurrences of natural species are endangered,
disasters such as rainforests were prime
hurricanes habitat for them
Úhe fertilizers, chemicals, Úhe rich fertile soil provides

cc„

c
c
c
c
c
c
 V

 

V 
c
coastal regions of the
lake Nicaragua and
other water bodies
101. Addition of new fish
species like tilapia in
the lake
102. Úhe steady expansion
of agricultural frontier
103. Unplanned mineral
extraction especially
gold
104. Possible extinction of
the sea turtles
105. Extraction of huge
unexplored potential
mineral reserves
106. Involvement of youth
in drug related crimes
107. Unchecked tapping of
natural resources
108. Impact of equilibrium
on ecosystem
109. Impact of availability of
telecommunications
infrastructure
110. Effect of high cost of
internet services
relative to local
incomes
111. Impact of cultural bias
towards school
autonomy
112. Effect of low industrial
progress beyond the
stage of light
manufacture
113. Impact of reliability on
oil imports
c 66c

cc c
pesticides and insecticides
end up in the lake
contaminating the water
Generates huge amount of
waste which the water has
to adsorb
Deforestation of thousands
hectares of rainforests
Mercury and other wastes
discharged in lakes, ground
water
Loss to the tourism industry
Government guarding and
controlling the extraction of
such mineral reserves
Due to unemployment
majority of youths getting
frustrated and resorting to
drugs and crimes
Depletion of natural
resources
Global temperatures rising ,
melting of polar ice and rise
of sea levels
Lack of availability leads to
challenges in offering
internet services through
economic means like cable
modems
Private use of email and
internet services remains
low
Formal technical and
vocational education is
scarce resulting in an
unskilled workforce when
compared to global
demands
Low in-house production of
goods and electronics
leading to higher costs
incurred on imports
Fluctuating oil prices makes
budget forecasting difficult
a good output of the plant
under cultivation
Increased revenue from
export of fish
Disruption of the ecological
pyramid
Úhe mineral reserves are
explored but not extracted
due to financial restrictions
Government restricting such
crimes by focusing on the ill
effects of drugs and spreading
awareness among masses
Import of natural resources
Extinction of a lot of flora
and fauna
Lack of availability leads to
poor growth of local
business and general
quality of life in rural and
marginal areas
Poor knowledge base in
general public due to lack of
global connectivity and
awareness
Subjects taught in school
and universities are not on
par with international
schools.
Lack of manufacture of
export-oriented products
which would attract foreign
direct investment
International financial crisis
brings about turmoil due to

cc„

c
c
c
c
c
c
 V

 

V 
c
114. Continuity of
privatization of
telecoms companies
115. Effect of influx of
foreign direct
investment inflows on
various domains
116. Impact on relations
with the united states
for export / import
117. Impact of weather
conditions
118. Access to information
for effective e-
governance
119. Effects of relations
with neighboring
countries
effects of relations
with neighboring
countries
120. Impact of economic
situation on the public
121. Effect of uneven
population
distributions across
areas
122. Effect of health and
c 67c

cc c
and adversely affects the
GBP growth
Strong investments leading
to rapid expansion of both
fixed and mobile services
Restructuring of traditional
maquila (offshore assembly
for re-export) operations
and manufacture of new
products like aluminum and
electrical wiring for cars
Recession brought about
weaker external demand for
export-oriented goods in the
us
Altered rainfall patterns due
hurricanes brings down
traditional exports
Increase in voting
participation
Increased exports to
Venezuela have helped in
directly stimulating
economic growth
Úerritorial disputes with
Honduras, Costa Rica and
Columbia has directly
affected trading, especially
in petroleum and consumer
goods imports
High bankruptcy rate
Majority of the population
are concentrated in the
capital, Managua, leading
to poor infrastructure and
livelihood in rural and
interior areas
Inadequate planning leads
sharp inflation rates
Monopoly of mobile
services leading to high
tariffs for call and data
packages
Rise in job opportunities for
people with various
vocational skills and
expertise
Export made Nicaragua
vital for the us and
increased the flow of
remittances and foreign
direct investment
Unpredictable weather
patterns adversely affects
agriculture
Government blindfolded in
terms of demographic data
and carrying out reforms in
society
Ongoing negotiations for
free trade agreement with
Chile which would help
boost export and create
jobs
Results in high inflation.
Almost half of the population
lives in poverty, with a fifth in
extreme poverty
Clear danger of social
divide between the wealthy
who would be able to afford
education and information
services and the poor who
would remain illiterate and
unaware of technology
Inadequate planning leads

cc„

c
c
c
c
c
c
 V

 

V 
c
town planning in rural
areas
123. Impact of government
support towards local
industries
124. Extend of investments
in research and
development on the
economy
125. Impact of the project
µrural electrification
project for
development outside
the central grid¶ run by
the world bank
126. Impact of the project
µsecond agricultural
technology¶ run by the
world bank
127. Impact of the project
µNicaragua rural
telecom project¶ run by
the world bank
128. Availability of energy
import
129. External demand
fluctuation
130. level of
unemployment rate
131. Level of real estate
investment
132. Úourism development
c 6c

cc c
to poor living conditions in
many parts of the country
with lack of basic amenities,
power lines and water tubes
Lack of support leads to
increase in the
unemployment rate which
would sink the country
much deeper into poverty
Pumping capital on R&D
projects to bring out more
efficient production models
will increase productivity
and economic performance
of the country
Úhe project would provide
sustainable electricity
services in selected rural
areas
Provides rural households
and communities with
broader access to
sustainable agricultural,
forestry and natural
resource management
services and innovations
Would increase
infrastructure and reduce
costs of
telecommunications
services in rural areas
Energy crisis
Highly affected by external
economic environment
Street crime increase
Increase development of
tourism
Increase job opportunity
to loss of income from
tourism and local
businesses due to lack of
infrastructure and
connectivity across cities
Macroeconomic
management is favorable
for local businesses and
manufacturing industries
leading to some
improvement in GDP
Lack of interest towards
innovation will adversely
affect the growth and
development of the
economy and in turn
encourage social disparity
and poverty
Would strengthen the
government¶s institutional
capacity to execute its rural
electrification strategy
Stimulates higher
agricultural productivity
Support private-sector
operators for installing,
operating, and maintaining
the new systems on a
commercial basis
High expenditure on energy
purchase
Excessive production of
goods
Government expenditure on
social welfare in crease
Real estate price operated by
foreign investors intentionally
Reduced pressure on
agricultural industry

cc„

c
c
c
c
c
c
 V

 

V 
c
133. Internal transportation Link local cities Delay to relief measures to
connection easily(sharing, goods, rural areas
services, information)
134. Private investment Increase job opportunity Facilitate globalization
from other countries
135. Possibility in industry Independent from exporting Stable economic
transformation environment
136. Úax imposed (by us) Low profits for local Economic progress
on Nicaragua's exports companies dependent on other
countries' government
policies
137. International Strong international trading Power to negotiate on
relationship(especially development trading terms(ex. Úax)
with USA)
138. Salary growth Socially well-being Decrease foreign
companies' intention to
invest locally
139. Gender equality in job Increased workforce in the Fair society
opportunity market
140. Number of citizens Loss of highly skilled Negative development in
migrate out of workers in internal job civilization/birth rate
Nicaragua market

c 68c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
1 m Õ ›m m

&  
 
   



¦ Impact of political influence on jud iciary
 ¦ Nature of corruption in government
 ¦ Execution of laws in supreme court
 ¦ Delay in criminal case decisions
 ¦ Impact of industrial decentralization policy
 ¦ Level of effective product liability
m›Õ5
mm› ¦ Level of enforcement of property rights
% m›m  ¦ Level of transparency in government offices
¦ Local policies and rural approach to governance
¦ Effect of minimum age regulation on controlling
child labor
¦ Extent of slave work
¦ Emigration of labor force to central American
countries


 ¦ Continuity of privatization of telecom compani es
 ¦ Permitting international companies to setup base
 in country

¦ Effect of high cost of internet services relative to
ÕÕÕ local incomes
m(›m›m Õ&
¦ Access of information for effective e -governance

mm Õ&
¦ Effect of transport policy for foreign industries
 %
¦ Effect of low industrial progress beyond the
stage of light manufacture
¦ Unchecked tapping of natural resources
¦ Úhreat of a W-shaped recession


 ¦ Government support towards local industry
 ¦ Impact of project µNicaragua rural telecom
 project¶ run by the world bank
 ¦ Impact of project µ Electrification project for
Õ(    development outside the central grid¶ run by the
›m
% world bank
 ¦ Impact of project µ Second agricultural
technology¶ run by the world bank
¦ Extraction of huge unexplored mineral reserves
¦ Level of livestock breeding in the plains
c 7c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
 ¦ Internal transportation connection
 ¦ Steady expansion of agricultural frontier
 ¦ Diversity of employment offered to locals
 ¦ Effects of population below poverty line


 ¦ Change in minimum wage

¦ Involvement of youths in drug related crimes

 ¦ Effect of health and town pla nning in rural areas

 ¦ Internal transportation connection
 ¦ Free mandatory education
m›Õ 
¦ Availability of basic medical facilities and primary
› m Õ&›& health care
›
 ¦ Change in literacy rate
 ¦ State¶s role in redistribution of income
¦ Spread of HIV/AIDS
¦ Level of division of society into rich and poor


¦ Future role of Bolivian Alliance of

 America[ALBA]
 ¦ Participation in central American integration
 system[SICA]
Regional co-operation regarding the common


m›Õm › ¦
›m   credit fund
 % ¦ Impact of new common currency ± SUCRE
c ¦ Innovative development fina nce initiatives like
the PEÚROCARBIDE
¦ Effects of relations with neighboring countries
¦ Possibility of industrial development
¦ Extent of urbanization

 ¦ Legislation in favor of Nicaragua canal

 ¦ Effect of deforestation on environment
 ¦ Úerritorial disputes with neighbors
 ¦ Diversity of employment offered to locals
m›Õ& ¦ Level of contamination in lake Nicaragua
 m Õ ¦ Extent of soil erosion in the coastal region
m›››› ›  ¦ Impact of reliability on oil imports
 ››m› ¦ Impact of economic situation on the public
c ¦ Availability of safe drinking water
¦ Nature of farming on fertile coastal regions of
lake Nicaragua and other water bodies
¦ Impact of high pesticide use in cotton industry
c 7c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
c ¦ Impact of healthcare on rural communities
¦ Possible extinction of sea turtle
¦ Impact of weather conditions
¦ Impact of equilibrium of ecosystem


 ¦ Diversification of trade and co -operative
 partnerships
›m
Õ ¦ Bilateral relations with Russia on technology,
›
 m›››6 energy and healthcare
m  ›m › ¦ Bilateral trade relation with China
› &m ¦ Bilateral relations with Iran on power sector and
c healthcare
¦ Impact on relations with the US for import/export
¦ Úax imposed by US on Nicaragua export

 ¦ Investments from foreign partnerships

 ¦ Impact of telecommunication infrastructure
 ¦ Export of commercial commodity
 ¦ Availability of energy import
ÕÕÕÕ
m › ¦ Impact of healthcare on rural co mmunities
 % ¦ Possibility in industry transformation
c ¦ Effects of influx of FDI inflows on various
domains
¦ Salary growth
¦ Extent of urbanization

 ¦ Nature of corruption in the government

 ¦ Absence of political will & commitment to change
 ¦ Extent of investment in research & development
 of the economy
 ¦ Extent of employment black market
ÕÕÕm  ¦ Impact of credibility of the central bank of
  ›m ››m
›
 Nicaragua
m  ›m › ¦ Private investment from other countries
›m  ¦ Effect of low wages
c ¦ Level of foreign aid received
¦ International relationship especially wi th the US
¦ Level of poverty in rural areas
¦ Emigration of labor force to central American
countries

c 7
c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c

 ¦ Effects of sustaining IMF¶s poverty reduction and

 growth facility plan
 ¦ Government schemes to help the poor
 ¦ Government support for female education
 ¦ Attitude towards women in the family and
›Õmm›m  workplace
Õ›m
m m› ¦ Gender equality in job opportunities
՛5c ¦ Level of discrimination in the society
¦ Free primary education
¦ Investment in the education department
¦ Number of people who are educated in the
society
¦ Quality of education in t he rural areas
¦ Government investment in local human capital
¦ Level of unemployment rate

 ¦ Effects of sustaining the poverty reduction and

 growth facility plan
 ¦ Government programs to help the poor
Õ(  m  ¦ Stability in supply of food
Õ
m% ¦ Impact on economic disparity
 ¦ Extent of urbanization
 ¦ Level of discrimination in the society


 ¦ Continuity of constitutional democracy

 ¦ Continued existence of multi party political
 system

¦ Exercise of freedom of speech
›Õ
 mm › ¦ Community of constitutional rights

›%m &Õ ¦ Co-existence of ethnic groups
c ¦ Importance of a non biased media
¦ Maintaining religious freedom
¦ Impact of religion on society
¦ Social and cultural divisions






c 73c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 2 

  m

3  





m›Õ ›Õ m Õ
›%m 
cmm› m m  ›m  mm ››
m Õ   (   
mm 
5
mm›%





 m›Õ (Õ (Õ
 m
m› ÕÕm(  Õ 

 ›m›m 
 Õ%
  m% m›$mm% m& ÕÕÕ
 m m›
›m  

 m 
 &m
›$ 

›mm
 ›
›
 (Õ
››&
 › › %
( ›   Õ›(
m (  
 ÕÕm





 
 m›m Õ

m›Õ
›$Õ
5
mm›%
  ›
 m›m  ›m› 
 m
 V

   V 
c
   
 ! 7

  






 m m%Õ mm  ÕÕÕ&m& ›Õ
m(›m›m  m  ›m › Õ m Õ›m 

Õ › m m   ÕÕÕm(

› m $›m  (m 8( › 
 & % ›m(
 ›m 




ÕÕÕ ÕÕÕ
›
  m
m›
m%Õ 
 Õm  $%
&
m
m ›Õm&
 › ՛



 ÕÕÕ
 &
 &›Õ›  m(›m›m 
›m
 Õ 8&›

 &
 ›› m 

mm Õ

 & %




c 75c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
  


!
 

  

 m›Õ5
9 m››››

56
  $%&

 $›  m  ›
 › ›m
 m 

 m›Õ5
9›mÕm›m 
m(m%Õ &› m 
 5Õ %  m m›

( m
 ›
% ÕÕ

& ›m
6 
 $%&
$› 
› m Õ ›
 ›m›
 Õ m
 m›Õ5
(   9
 ÕÕ m (( Õ

 ›m› ›m  %&m 

›
› & %6  $(% ›
m
 m 
m
% $%&
$› 
 


 ›m Õ 
& 

 m ›( Õ
 (   

›m
%


 (Õm(
 $
m m &
›m 
c 76c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c

  m


  
   


 m  ›
 › ›m
 m  


m›Õ 
 › m  
 &›&›

 ›(›m›$mm%Õ
 $›m
m›
 ՛mmm›

 m›%&›&
ÕÕÕ › ›
Õ&m(/
 &›&›
 ›m


 › m 
m  ››› 
 &› m 
m›%›






 Õ
 ›
›%

›m 
 ›6m  (Õ
 
mm$m 
m(mm Õ
Õm  m%m 
c m&›
 77c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
  m



8









ÕÕ (  
$m(m›
  ›
›m› Õ
m$m

›m›
$
:›$›;




›mm›m
 m  m›Õ  m (›m( m$mm%Õ  Õ
 ›  
(  m
m› $› m›m 

›m›   % Õm ›  › Õ›m 

m ›m   m mm›m(m

%  &
 :m›; ›m$


 ÕÕÕ
m ›

8›m  ›m m&

›
m & m&$m  
 
m  m
m›Õ
 Õ

 m ›
 8›m 
   %



c 7c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c m›Õ
 m




  
 ›
   ›&
 
mm 


 ÕÕÕ  Õm ›Õ՛m 

Õ›m  m m &  Õm
 ››m 
  (m   ››
 Õ› m›››
m  ›
&›
 $
m


 mm› m›Õ m›Õ&m&

mm& m›$mm%  mm
m 
 m&$ mm  m
%
 m›m m 
 ՛(Õ
 m›››
› ›


m(m%Õ m›Õ
 %   m
 ÕÕ
 m›m  
 › &$m

 

m›Õ& (Õ ›(›m›$mm%Õ m›Õ m› 

  m Õ  ›m ›m  ›Õ
m m  &›&›  mm$mÕ
m › › › %
 m›››› › m›››  mm
   ›
 ›m›

c m$ 78c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c m m Õ
›
 V

   V 
c
  › 
  
 6  
   





›m
Õ
 $m›› ›

›m m& m›››6
 m› 
 & % m  ›m ›
  %›
 › &m
 &›&›



m(mÕm›m  $m›› m›  ›m
$%
 Õ›
›
 ›m m&  
›

 8›m( ›m m& &Õ m››› 
 › &m &m › m/ 





 $m››
 ›m m&
m›  
 ›

 &›&›




c c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
  
Õ
m




 
m›Õ
  m›m 
 m Õ›





 Õ m$mm%m  ÕÕÕ
 m› m
% m ÕÕÕ
m
 
m% › Õ›m  m Õ 
 (›m

›m 
m ( 
 ÕÕm 
 › &m

 ›(›m›$mm%Õ ››%&
  %m





 
  m›Õ  Õ
 &›&›  $› m›m 
ÕÕÕÕ
m  › mm 

› %


c c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
  



 
   

 
 (Õ
 ÕÕÕ Õm ›m


m   m(

 ›m ››


m  ›m › m›Õ
 ›m  
m$mm%Õ
 & ›
$› Õ
 m›››
 m  ›m ›
›Õ ›$ Õ ›m &m

m m  mm›m0 m›%m&
 & m  &

(   &› 

m(›
 m ( 
 Õ&
  m
 (Õ m›m Õ
  Õ (%m  ›$Õ
 m ( m  ›››   ›
 ›&0 ›m› 

(   m
  & %
 ÕÕÕ
 ›



 Õ
 % 
c $›› 
c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
3  
  7

 

  
3 

ÕÕÕ
 ›m m mÕ6
9(%
 
m ›

 &՛mm%6
 › 


 (   (   ›m
 
 (Õ
 & Õ ›
 ›m%m 5$
mmm ›m 
 && Õ›  m &  mm m &m%
  
›m  ՛m%›

›



 Õm›% m ( m  $Õ
 
›m  &
›m  &›

›  
›
m &
m%



  ›m%Õ

›Õ 
›m m 
 &›
 mm›m Õ›m
 ››
 m m›՛
 5

 (   (Õ
m ( m   % 
c ›&›  › 3c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
›m›
 V

   V 
c

  


!
  

  

 
 Õ
 (  m 


Õ
m%



 ›$mm%m 
 %ÕÕ



 ÕÕÕ (    Õ (Õ
 ›m m & › $› m›m 
mmm ›m 
 '(% && m &m%
 
m ›

&
 ՛mm%)› 
 m› 
 m

m›m%







c 4c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c

 

 


    

  m 

 m Õ
 m8›%
mm›

% m› Õ

›  $m›

 
m›

 mÕ
 Õ
Õ
 &

 m m%Õ
 ›m ›m m  m›Õ m›0
 mm › mm mm   ›


›% Õ
 m%
m(mm 
 c
  m%Õ
  mm ›
 m&



 
 8m  ›Õ
 Õ& m
 
 mm ›

›%m &
 Õ
c 5c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
‰ m›/
m›$mm%› ›%m

&     

Õ
(  
m Õ
 m›Õ&
m%  m Õ
c
m›››› ›
  ›
›m› ÕÕÕÕ
m
c

ÕÕÕ  ›
m   c
 %
›m ››

m  ›m ›
›m 



 &  

ÕÕÕ m›Õ 
m(›m›m Õ › m  
&
mm Õ &›&›
Õ & % m›Õ
(   m ›
 › 8›m 
m
%   %


›Õ
mm›m 
›Õ
Õ›m
m 
 mm › m›

›%m  ՛ ›m
Õ
m›Õ &Õ ›

5
5
mm› m›››6
%  m  ›m ›
m›m  › &m
c
c


   
c 6c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
V  Õ›m ›
m  ›m
›

 
8V  
8#

€
$mÕ
€ ›››m 
€ ՛(›$
m›(›
€ &›(%  m Õ   
m››› mm
€ &›m  / ›m m  Õ m

€ (   › 
€ m Õ  € Õmm
mm &
€
m m›%› € ›
 mm›m  › Õ
€ % › m›››  € m(  m  $›m &›&
€  $›m &›& (m
 (m € 
›m%
› ›m  % 5$ mm
 €
 
  › Õ
€
€ m  m( Õ & & Õ 
m (  ››

m m
€ &m& m›m   € $ ›Õm
(  
 › ›m› ›
m  € $
›m ՛mmmÕ
mm( m$m  &$m
€ $ & % 0 &›&

(m›m›  
(mÕ › 
€ › ÕÕm
€ &m&m 
$
 € &m& ›   m››› 
 m
›
€ $m›

m›
€ m  $›m & % ›
&m&›
€ $
m    m m&
m&$
€ m›  / &m  m Õ   
m››› mm
€ m    mm›m  ›
Õ m››› 

 
8,  
8*

c 7c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 VV   ›mm

  $››%&%&››&&Õ


 
 

In a nascent growing economy, bureaucracy of the policy makers has the power to
make or break the future of a nation. In this scenario, we have attempted to
investigate the effect of corruption on a progressing economy where the greed of
government officials and private investors result in acting like an epoxy that greases
the wheels of progress. Úhis scenario is of added interest to us as Nicaragua¶s future
is highly dependent on a few major stake holders.


 

   

Foreign aid is being pumped in from both the right and the left wings into Nicaragua
resulting in Investment in Infrastructure for the country. Úhe Nicaraguan government
wants the welfare of its people and seems to be earnest. Úhe government realizes
that future growth depends on building a strong infrastructural base of the economy
and thus, it invests heavily in local industries, healthcare, providing civic amenities
etc. Úhe future as we see it at this point of time looks bright.

! 
!
 

¦ Continued foreign investment and aid pouring into Nicaragua.

¦ Heavy investment in building local industries.
¦ Substantial investment in providing health care and civic amenities like clean
drinking water.
¦ Movement toward meeting MDGs of gender equality, reduced child mortality,
improved maternal health, and stemming HIV/AIDS and other epidemics.
¦ Entry of multinational companies into a booming Nicaraguan economy.
¦ Increased influence of strong business magnates on Nicaraguan policy
makers and implementers.
¦ Complacency setting in after initial success and euphoria.
¦ Levels of corruption on the rise.
¦ Mismanagement of funds.
¦ Losses in Nicaraguan markets due to a W -Shaped recession in the US.
¦ Rise in unemployment
¦ Increase in Poverty
¦ Government disregard to national plight
¦ Continued disregard of Human and constitutional right s
¦ Increased US interference in Nicaraguan Policy matters
¦ High Dependence on US

/   


   !  

1. Readily available aid combined with effective utilization would lead to

Investments in health care and educational inf rastructure. Increased education
 V

   V 
c
will lead to increased awareness of SÚDs like AIDS/ HIV and increased use of
preventive measures. Úhis would help reduce social and gender discrimination
among masses moving towards meeting some of the major MDG¶s such as
gender equality and women¶s rights and control of HIV/AIDS. Good healthcare
infrastructure coupled with awareness on pregnancy and birth control would
help reduce maternal death cases. At this point of time, Nicaragua would
logically be moving towards achie ving their Millennium Development Goals.

2. On the flip side readily available aid would also fuel corruption from the lower
levels of the governance. Corruption coupled with the possibility of a W -
Shaped recession in the US would inevitably slow down the ec onomy. Úhis will
eventually lead to increase in Inflation which will have rippling effects on all
facets of the economy.

3. Úhe rise in unemployment caused by the economic slowdown and inflation

would lead to pitfalls like the majority of youths resorting to drugs and crime,
increased food prices, increased pressure on local health services and civic
amenities leading to the devaluation of the local currency. Úhe government in
all probability would not be able to meet national food requirements locally and
would have to request for additional aid. Additional aid in a struggling economy
would lead to a vicious cycle of corruption thus hampering any growth seen
previously.


 

Õ 

Úhe rising inflation would hamper the growth of the ec onomy. Úhis coupled with the
fear in the common man due to increased street crime and drug related incidents
would lead to a collapse in law and order and existing social norms. Úhe lack of
political motivation in the government due to the crippling recess ion would lead it to
turn a deaf ear to the national plight.
Continued disregard of human and constitutional rights would bring down the
credibility of the local government and in turn would lead to the deteriorating US
confidence on the Nicaraguan government and fuel its interference on all policy and
decision making of the government. Úhe capitalist impact of Nicaragua would lead to
the loss of support from other strong leftist allies like China and Russia, thus creating
a high dependence on US for politi cal and economic matters.

m
 

    7
 

¦ Interference of the US in Nicaraguan policy matters
¦ Deterioration of relations with the Leftist powers
¦ Disbursable aid available when required
¦ Social plight among masses still exist
¦ Improved availability of basic amenities
Increased dependence on US for all social and economic matters 

  m 
&m Õ&› 
c 8c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c

 
 

As the title suggests, this scenario is closely interlinked with strong bilateral trade
relations with the US and the benefits that the Nicaraguan economy would potentially
reap from this partnership. Increased support from the US combined with a
government working towards economic progress could result in growing much closer
to the accomplishment of a few of the major Millennium Development Goals related
to poverty and education.


 

   

At present, Nicaragua has strong bilateral trade relations with the US. Úhis has
helped pump in more aid in the form of funds from the US, h elping Nicaragua relieve
previous debts. Úhe attitude of the government looks quite promising in terms of
working efficiently to disburse available funds towards investments in education and
healthcare. Although corruption exists at all levels of governanc e, the government as
a whole has been able to keep it in check so that the utilization of aid is funneled
through the right channels aimed at the well -being of the economy.

! 
!
 

¦ Useful utilization of excess public funds
¦ Government promotes and invests heavily in education and healthcare
¦ Rise in literacy rate leading to lesser discrimination against women
¦ Reduced cases of HIV/AIDs and other SÚDs
¦ Increase in employment opportunities
¦ Nicaraguan imports vital for the US leading to increased fl ow of remittance and
FDI
¦ Government provides incentives for growth of local industries
¦ Moving towards the achievement of major MDGs like poverty and education

/   


   !  

¦ Úhe support and aid from the US in conju nction with the increased investment
in education and healthcare would lead to a number of positive outcomes for
the Nicaraguan economy. Úhe increase in literacy rate would help causes
related to women rights and would help build an educated generation of
women who are aware of aspects related to family planning, child birth and the
spread of AIDS/HIV and other SÚDs.

¦ Improvement in healthcare and the availability of healthcare facilities like

vaccines for infants would help reduce child mortality. Also, th ere would be a
sharp decrease in maternal deaths due to the availability of appropriate
medication and nurses in medical camps.

c 8c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
¦ Initiatives for the growth of local industries would promote jobs in the skilled
labour sector and encourage entrepreneurs to s et up businesses of their own.
Úhis in turn would lead to a high rate of growth of domestic industries.

¦ All these factors would help reinforce the Nicaraguan government¶s

commitment towards boosting the economic well-being. Úhis would help
promote the confidence that the US government would have over Nicaragua
and would help bring in more aid.


 

Õ 

Úhe efficiency of the government in investing in required infrastructure would lead to
economic upheaval. Better infrastructure imp lies better sanitation in the rural areas,
leading to reduced cases of water borne diseases which is one of the major
Millennium Development Goals.

Better education would help control gender discrimination and empower women to
take up equally important ro les in the workplace. Úhis would also lead to the
increased awareness of social and health issues such as contraception and birth
control and help curb the ever increasing issues of single mothers and SÚDs like
HIV/AIDS and gonorrhea. Úhis helps in achiev ing important Millennium Development
Goal s related to gender discrimination, women rights and spread of HIV/AIDS.

Úhe increase in the number of employment opportunities across local and private
sector industries would help reduce poverty among the labor force. Úhis would also
lead to ample availability of basic facilities, thus painting a positive picture of the
economy, leading to an increase in the tourism industry.

Good ties with the US would imply good media coverage on Nicaragua, thus creating
a better image of the country to the outside world and generating help in the form of
aid and support. Úhe strong ties with the US would also help keep the Leftist
ideologies in check, thereby leading to a neutral economy.

m
 

    7


¦ Improved availability of basic amenities
¦ Increased dependence on US for all social and economic matters
¦ Improved educational facilities helping in increasing integrity and peace in
society
¦ Continued bi-lateral relations with the US
¦ Increased awareness leading to reduction in HIV/AIDS and ep idemic diseases




  › 
 &m›
›

$

c 8c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
 
 

Úhe word ³marooned´ in the title Marooned on the Island of Debt signifies the global
financial isolation that Nicaragua could experience in the future. Úhis scenario starts
off with a combination of dependence for aid on China and Russia leading to
unhealthy ties with the US. Úhis situation gets complicated due to the corrupt nature
of governance in Nicaragua making the leftists tiresome of the never ending
demands put forward. Úhis sequence of events could lead to an economic slowdown
in Nicaragua and severe any aid coming into Nicaragua making it truly marooned in
debt resulting in a crisis like the ³lost decade´ debt crisis of Latin America.


 

   

Nicaragua is heavily dependent on the economically strong leftist allies who also led
to unhealthy ties with the US and loss of aid from US supported organizations like the
World Bank and IMF. Úhe Nicaraguan government is convoluted with corruption with
policy makers filling their pockets rather than utilizing the aid pumped in to help the
citizens. Úhe current economic situation is not healthy with poverty, health and
education being the major hurdles in the path to progr ess.

! 
!
 

¦ Continued foreign investments into Nicaragua from leftist allies like China and
Russia.
¦ Reduced aid from the US
¦ Increased level of corruption in the government
¦ Increasing gulf between the rich and the poor leading to a rise in t he GINI
coefficient
¦ Unhealthy economy leading to increase in street crime
¦ Resentment and disillusionment among the citizens towards the government
and elite in society.
¦ Úhe use of extreme measures by the government to combat social unrest
¦ A single party rule leading to the Death of Democracy
¦ Restrictions on availability of aid from all strategic partners
¦ A debt crisis similar to the Lost Decade of Debt Crisis of Latin America

/   


   !  

1. Úhe influence of leftist ideology in policy making would have an adverse effect
on existing bilateral relationship with the US. Úhis could lead to impositions on
Nicaraguan imports and end up with trade embargoes with the US. Úhe US
soil would become unfriendly for Nicaraguan emigration which would reduce
the chances of chances of employment opportunities of the Nicaraguan in the
US. Úhis would lead to a fall in the foreign currency through remittances
further adding to poverty as Remittances from US are one of the major
contributors of the GDP.

c 8
c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c

2. Reduced aid from the US will mean increased dependency of aid on China
and Russia. Úhis combined with corruption in the government would lead to a
series of events that will further hamper the growth of local industry and
general quality and social progress of the society. Úhe lack of tolerance of the
citizens towards the policies of the government would lead to social unrest and
culminate to stricter government law which in turn will lead to a single party
rule.


 

Õ

Úhe increased level of corruption in the government would eat up all the resources
provided by the foreign allies. Úhere would be strong disparities between the rich and
poor. Weak labor laws will lead to low wages resulting in poor living conditio ns of the
lower classes. Úhis would hamper any progress made towards social upliftment as
mentioned in the Millennium Development Goals. Úhe social disparity created would
deprive the poor from education which is against the goal to achieve universal
primary education. Úhis also results in substantial rise in unemployment leading to
the rise of street crime. Úhis vicious circle would add to the growing poverty and
unrest in the country.

Úhe reduced aid from the US would lead to a strong bias in the attitu de of the US
media towards Nicaragua. Úhe blatant mismanagement of allocated funds by the
government officials would enrage the privately owned media houses of Nicaragua
leading to attempts to expose these corrupt practices to the public. Úhe government
which is already tiled towards the left will not take this attempt lightly and move
towards silencing the media houses resulting in eventual nationalization and
censorship of Nicaraguan Media. At this point, the resentment against the
government and the elite of the society would boil over and people will resort to
taking the law in their own hands. Úhe extreme measures taken by the government to
combat such social unrest would eventually lead to the abolishment of the
constitutional rights. Úhis complex situation can only lead to one outcome: Úhe fall of
the Nicaraguan Democracy and the return of the Single Party Rule. Russia and
China would eventually lose patience with the region and stop further financial aid to
Nicaragua.

Unhealthy ties with the US which hampered trade and the loss of potential
remittances would result in the slowdown of economy and a rise in inflation.
Eventually hyperinflation will lead to a loss in earning power leading to a crisis like the
³lost decade of debt crisis´ which occurred i n Latin America in the early 80¶s.

m
 

   
 7


¦ Interference of Leftist elements in policy matters
¦ Cessation of constitutional democracy
¦ Decrease in international aid
¦ Suspension of constitutional rights
c 83c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
¦ Poverty remains largely perpetual
¦ Adverse effects on bi-lateral trade relations with the US
¦ Rise in debt leading to financial crisis in the Nicaraguan economy












































c 84c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
  ' m››››(› ›)8&›m››mm
›
c

c

c cc 

 
 

³Nicaragua Avanza´ is the nation slogan of Nicaragua which translates to Nicaragua
moving forward. Úhis scenario is about US giving a cold shoulder to Nicaragua
because of its partnership to the leftist and how these partnerships combine d with a
reduced dependence on the US and a government leads to sustainable economic
growth in Nicaragua. Úhis scenario also talks about the vested interests of the leftist
allies in Nicaraguan politics and the possibility of the creation of a strategic le ftist
base in Central America. Hence, the complete title ³Nicaragua Avanza´ Hacia La
Isquierda meaning Nicaragua ³moving forward´ to the left. Úhis scenario also
showcases the impact of the tug of war of the capitalists and the socialists on
Nicaragua.


 

   

At present Nicaragua is heavily indebted to the US for aid and trade. Although the
Millennium Development Goal of Eradicating Extreme Poverty seems to have been
met; the majority of the population lives in the rural and the m arginal areas under
poverty. Úhe Nicaraguan government has undertaken numerous projects for the
social and economic upliftment of its people, but achievement seems highly
ambitious due to the internal corruption leading to mismanagement of funds. Úhe
quasi leftist government is contemplating increased ties with strong economic powers
like China and Russia to help achieve economic growth.

! 
!
 

¦ Diversification of trade and co-operative partnerships.
¦ Deteriorating relationship with the US
¦ Increases emphasis on regional partnerships
¦ Impact of the new common currency on sustainable growth of the economy
and overall well being of the community.
¦ Vested interests of Russia and China

/   


   !  

1. Availability of funds from various sources meant for aid, combined with
existing corruption in the government and different forms in which the
International Monetary Fund (IMF) interferes in the economic, social and
political life of Nicaragua leads to a gross mismanagement of funds. Úhis in
turn leads to a vicious circle of poverty where the majority of citizens continue
to live below the poverty line. Úhis induces request for additional aid from the
leftist allies having an adverse impact on the Nicaraguan relat ionship with the
US.
c 85c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c

2. Diversification of trade leads to a reduced dependence on the US which in turn

pushes Nicaragua towards stronger regional ties and advocating regional
solutions for regional problems. Úhis results in increased Nicaraguan
participation in regional alliances like the Bolivarian Alliance for America
(ALBA), Central American Integration system (SICA) and Common Credit
Fund. On the other hand, diversification of co -operative partnerships leads to
strategic ties with strong leftist Economic Powers like China and Russia.

3. Sharing of Russian and Chinese expertise for Nicaraguan energy and

agricultural projects, and an assured supply of petroleum from ALBA led
schemes like PEÚROCARIBE would boost small and medium scale industries
and leading to economic and political stability in Nicaragua.

4. Úhe strong dependency that Nicaragua will have with Russia and China will
have the cold shoulder from the US, would influence decision making and
implementation leading to a strong hold of Nicaraguan poli tics by the leftists.


 

Õ 

Úhe economic growth that Nicaragua would experience through its regional and
political allies would lead to heavy investments in Education and Healthcare. Úhe
allies will stem the growth of corruption in the Nicaraguan government leading to a
substantial improvement in the health of man and machine. Improvement in
education facilities would lead to an increase in literacy rate among people, moving
towards achieving one of the major Millennium developm ent Goals of Universal
Primary Education. Education will also help curb discrimination towards women,
increasing awareness about using contraceptives and family planning measures
which will curb the rising growth rate of population and also stem the spread of
diseases like AIDS/HIV and other SÚD¶s. Nicaraguan society will move towards
gender equality and promotion of women rights, which is again one of the major
Millennium Development Goals.

Overall growth of a sustained economy will lead to better domest ic employment

opportunities for the Nicaraguan citizens. Úhe Nicaraguan society is now moving
toward a state where the GINI Coefficient is continually on the fall and the Gross
National Happiness (GNH) in on the rise. GINI coefficient is a measure of stati stical
dispersion developed by the Italian statistician Corrado Gini. It is a measure of the
inequality of a distribution and is commonly used as a measure of inequality of
income or wealth. Gross National Happiness is a concept that was developed in an
attempt to define an indicator that measures quality of life or social progress in more
holistic and psychological terms than gross domestic product (GDP).

Every coin has two sides. Úhe increased help provided by the economically strong
leftist allies comes with a flip side. Since there are no free lunches in Economics, the
aid and support provided by Russia and China would make Nicaragua indebted to
c 86c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
their ³so called new friends´. In the long run, this would re -create a strategic leftist
block in the Central American region, which would be against the interest of the US
and unfavorable for the stability of the region and could result in a conflict like the
Cuban Missile Crisis.

m
 

   
 7


¦ Increased awareness leading to reducti on in HIV/AIDS and epidemic diseases
¦ Reduced dependence on US for foreign aid
¦ Stable economic environment in Central America
¦ Good bi-lateral trade relationships with China would benefit Nicaragua in the
absence of the US
¦ Society moving towards gender equality
¦ Improvement in rural health care and education
¦ Improved maternal health
¦ Sustainable economic growth with social equality leading to a better sense of
content
¦ Increased vested interests of China, Russia and Iran towards Decision and
policy making in Nicaragua.

























c 87c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 
V#  m$› ›%m

     


   mm 
  % 

 mm  m›m 


 ›Õ& m››
(›m ›
›m 


 ›Õm ( m m
m› 


 m ›m ››m $m 
 % 


  &›&% %›
m ›Õm



››
m›
%m m Õ› 



 ›m m 
 ›&



¦ Úhe common man
 ¦ UNDP / IMF
mm m Õ›m 
 ¦ US and other foreign
 countries providing aid
In Nicaragua, a large number of people are jobless, which forces them to live in poor
conditions. In spite of influx of money from international organi zations, foreign help in
the form of technology, professional education and investment in the rural areas, the
government is not able to generate sufficient job opportunities for the people.

(mmm

¦    

Soaring commodity prices in the country reduce the
purchasing power of the common people. Úhis has an adverse impact on the
job market as small and medium size industries try to compensate their losses
because of high prices by reducing the number of employees.
¦ 

"


Úhe increasing number of people in the country
intensifies the pressure in the job market and consequently increases the ratio
of unemployed people.
¦  
  
Natural disasters such as
volcanoes, cyclones etc. ruin the exi sting infrastructure and slow the progress
of new developments. Úhis in turn would discourage entrepreneurs from
starting new ventures in the country.
¦   


 



 

A poor economy will
not able to provide good facilities to tourists in country, which would fail to lure
the attraction of tourists towards Nicaragua¶s tourist attractions. Reduced
inflow of tourists in the country would lead to the loss of income of those who
are dependent on the tourism industry for their li velihood.
¦  
  






Poor
economy would fail to provide basic facilities to multinational organizations,
which would discourage them to further invest in the country and consequently
wrap up their operations.
¦ 
 !
     

Úhe lack of investments by the
government for the progress of the industrial sector along with the disinterest
shown by many international organizations to expand their business in
Nicaragua would hamper any gro wth in the economy. Hence government
would not be able to meet the job requirement for the growing population of
the country.
¦ 
  !



 Úhe lack of technical or
professional education among the workforce in the country can keep away
from obtaining relevant jobs.
¦  




Úhe ban imposed by the neighboring countries on
the emigration of Nicaraguan labor coupled with the global economic
slowdown would increase the number of unemployed workers in the country.

›&


¦ Úhe common man

¦ UNDP/IMF
¦ US & other foreign countries providing aid
¦ Central American neighboring countries
¦ Úhe Nicaraguan government
¦ International organizations
 V

   V 
c
m$ m 

Úhe discussed vicious circle factors along with stakeholder s have a negative impact
on the efforts made to decrease the unemployment rate in the country. 

c c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
   

   


 

›Õ›
 $ 
m› 
 


 $› m›m m Õ››
›› 


 m(
m m & m›
m mm ›m Õ
 &›Õ
m›Õ%m ›


 ›5›m Õ› m›››



 
m›Õ› m››››


 m ›
›› ››$
 ›Õm›m & m m›m ›m 


 mm ›m Õ› 

m›Õm
m››
 ›&


 mm ›m Õ
› m Õ Úhe common man
 ¦
m
m/mÕm m ¦ Nicaragua government
››%Õ›$
m ¦ UNDP / IMF
›
&›   ¦ Industries
¦ Local law enforcers
Úhere is a very high prevalence of water borne diseases in Nicaragua despite th e
huge amount of funds being provided to Nicaragua, improvements made in the health
care system from Government investment and doctors & nurses being provided by
US. We wanted to go deep into this issue and found out the root causes of the high
occurrences of water borne diseases. In our ice berg analysis we came out with the
following factors which contributed to the above mentioned scenario:

(mmm

¦ m

!      
 
  
   
An
improvement in health care services and the construction of healthcare
infrastructures will reduce the number of people affected by water borne
diseases. Investments in health care will also include spreading awareness
among people about the do¶s and the don¶ts to prevent them from getting
affected by such diseases.
¦ $ 
   
A majority of the people do
not have access to proper sanitation facilities. Over the time this leads to
polluting the ground water, lake water and the soil. Better sanitation facil ities
will lead to reduction in the pollution of water and in turn the water borne
diseases.
¦ m

!
  +   
 


 
  



 
 Often Mercury is used in mining of Gold in Nicaragua.
However, improvement in the way the mining wastes are disposed can reduce
the water pollution it used to cause and in turn the cases of water borne
diseases among masses.
¦ 


  
Industrial wastes, domestic wastes and the
wastes from Oil refineries all end up in the lake Nicaragua and this lake water
is used by people inhabiting on the coastal areas. Úreatment of this water is
very important to make it again fit for human utilization and drinking.
¦ 
 



Animal carcasses need to be properly
disposed before it starts decaying in wide open especially near water
resources like well or a lake.
¦ m  



 
 + 
 

Even if the source of water is polluted, people can still avoid
water borne diseases to a large extent by using techniques such as filtration
and calcinations. So, an increased awareness among people about the
techniques which can be used to treat water has had a knock on effect on the
number and severity of water borne diseases among the masses.

›&

¦ Úhe common man
¦ UNDP/IMF
¦ Local law enforcers
¦ Industries
¦ Úhe Nicaraguan government

m$ m 

Úhe discussed vicious circle factors along with the stakeholders have a positive
impact on the number and severity of water borne diseases among the masses.
   m  
 

 m ›m  
 m


Õ›
m%


  m
 

 mÕ
›


 m ›m  % 


 $
$  m&$›
m $

(  › m8m› 


 › Õ m Õ 
$%›Õm›


 m ›


 Õ%& 
 



 mm›%m(›
(m  
 ›&


  m
m›m% 
 ¦ Úhe common man
¦ UNDP / IMF
& m
mmm ›m  ¦
¦
Úhere is an increase in street crime, which cause extra burden to the family and
society. Government is not able to provide proper educa tion for the poor to prevent
crimes. Úhis causes huge impact on the economic environment.

(mmm

¦ Õ
 
 Corruption of the government arouses the
dissatisfaction of the society. Growing number of people conduct anti -social
behaviours(e.g. crime) 
¦ 





Fewer job opportunities provided under the economic
slowdown. People lives in poor condition and have no access to food/money. 
¦  

 As drug spread through the country, increasing
number of drug users create social disorders. 
¦ 


    
 





!
 
  
 
 
 Nicaragua situated between Costa
Rica & Honduras. Úherefore, illegal forces could easily cross the borders into
Nicaragua.
¦ m   
 
 

 Due to lack of education,
young people addict to drugs easily and can¶t get rid of them. Úhey could
only commit crime to gain money buying drugs. 
¦ 


   
 
 Mafia interferes the
political power to enforce legal action in maintaining the society order. 
¦ m   


 
 Lack of job opportunity in Nicaragua results in
people living in poor condition. Úhis in turn leads to increase of crimes. 
¦ 
  

 !!
 
 people motivated or supported by the
political leaders get involved in the street crime. 
¦ 


  
 Úhe rich dominates and exploits the poor. Úhe poor
would need to struggle to survive and they don¶t receive education. 
¦   


 Social inequality affects common people¶s
contentment with the society hence caused social problems. 

›&

¦ Úhe common man
¦ UNDP/IMF
¦ Central American neighboring countries
¦ Úhe Nicaraguan government

m$ m 
Úhe vicious circle factors resulting in increasing street crimes a re mostly because of a
corruptive government, which can not be solved immediately.











›5m%›m 
  3
 



!  
$(%m 


m 
 &m&›Õ
 m›m 
  (m  ›
 ›$
m ›m  m ›m m/
 $Õ
›Õmm /
 0m  m ›
› › 
 & $ m&
 ›


›Õ
 m ( m 
 ›Õm ( 
&› ›m›  %   & %0
 ›Õm(m
& m›
 
 › mm
m Õm m Õ›

mmm ›m 
 m(m%
 $ mm ›Õ ›
Õ&m(/
 
›m  ›m
/m
m
›Õ
 ›Õ
&m›
 &
›Õ
 ›ÕÕ› m ( m 
 m›%›

 m  mÕ6
mm ›m%
 ›
m ›m

$m›
 ›
› ›&


  › 
 mm   ¦ Úhe common man
$m ¦ UNDP / IMF
m (  ¦ US and other foreign
countries providing aid
In spite of all the aid that the government was receiving from international
organization and all the schemes that were being undertaken by the government, a
majority of the population is still under the poverty line and a significant amount of
this majority was under the extreme poverty line.

(mmm

¦ mÕ  
 
       $  
  
  
 

   
 !
 
IMF is providing the fund with
some clauses attached to it, such as :
1) Úhe strict control over fiscal performance i.e. setting inflexible goals in
relation to government spending, pub lic deficit, the amount of resources
the government should transfer to the central bank, the accumulation of
international reserves.
2) It spreads over a reformulation of the legal framework that regulates
municipalities and determines the scope of local g overnments and the
system of budget transfers directed towards them, as well as over a
comprehensive review of the ³Úax Code´ that was recently approved with
broad consensus following extensive consultation at the National
Assembly.
3) It demands reforms to the ³Energy Stability Law´ in order to prevent it from
having control over fuel prices (Nicaragua¶s margins on fuels double the
regional average - and this in the poorest country within the area) and to
other regulations constraining the exercise of mon opoly power by oil
companies that import, refine, store and distribute fuels.
All these factors were pegging back the development and prosperity of the
country and in turn had a knock on effect on the poverty levels in
Nicaragua.
¦ 


Corruption has a major impact on the uplift of the society. No
matter how much of aid is being provided by the IMF or the leftists, unless
that fund is channelized properly by the government, the poverty level will
not diminish in Nicaragua. In our storyline, a major p art of the aid was
being blown away either by corrupt government officials or by inefficient
management.
¦ 
 !
   
   
 Government is not investing on
human capital to improve the condition of society. 
¦  


 
 Unemployment rate of country is still very high, which
forces the people to fall in the dearth of poverty. 
¦ m 
 
 !      
 Úhe lack of proper connectivity
inside the country refrain people to avail the facilities provided by
government, such as schools, hospitals & job opportunities. It keeps the
people to live in poverty.
¦ 
 


Due to the insufficient number of schools, more of the

people remain illiterate and not able to earn the decent livelihood.
¦ 
 
 
Illiterate women cannot help the family with
some earning, so the whole pressure of taking care of the family remains
with the earning men. Hence family has to survive on whatever is available.
¦ 
 " 

lacking in sex education, people cannot opt the
family planning policies and end up with the number of children, they can
 V

   V 
c
feed. Úhis increases the financial burden on family and family becomes
poor.
¦    


Gender discrimination will cause the women of
family to refrain out of job, which b ring the poverty in family.
¦ 
 ! 
  
In the absence of basic civic amenities, such as
clean water, food, hospitals, primary schools, people keep living in the
poverty.
¦ 
 &
 
 Lack of hospital many times causes the permanent
illness/death of the earning head of the family, which in turn cause the fall
in the trap of poverty.
¦ 
 !
 
 

 0   
Lack of
technology refrain the people to use the latest advancement in the world,
which can be used to earn more money and eradicate poverty.
¦ 
&m(/›m
/ 

Úhe diseases such as HIV/AIDS and the
spread of epidemic caused the death in the family, which increase the
pressure on the family to feed the left ones.
¦ m   
/   / 
Úhe continuous poverty
motivates the youth of country to trap in the street crime/drug
trafficking/gangs to earn the livelihood.
¦ m     


Úhe gap between rich and poor is

restricting the growth of poor as rich use d to take the advantage of poor by
offering them low wages.
¦ Increase in number of sex worker and single mother: Absence of male
earning hand forced the women to involve in sex work so that they can
feed their children and keep living their life under pove rty.
¦ Environmental abuse: Úhe deteriorating environment, because of careless
human act, is decreasing the productivity of land and hence decreasing the
yield. Also the deteriorating tourist palaces attract less number of tourists,
on which a significant po rtion of country¶s population is dependant.
¦ &  



Unemployment caused people to migrate in the
neighboring countries to earn the living. Many of these people leave their
family back at home, which have to support themselves, which cause s
poverty in the family. 

›&


¦ Úhe common man

¦ UNDP/IMF
¦ Central American neighboring countries
¦ Úhe Nicaraguan government

m$ m 

Úhe discussed vicious circle factors along with stakeholders have a negative impact
on the efforts made to decrease the poverty in society.

c 7c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
V*  mm›m ( ›m




When the implications from the scenarios were mapped out to each of the scenarios,
we observe that certain implications are associable to at least three of the four
scenarios. Úhese implications or plausible outcomes are the essence of this report
and would be play vital roles in determining the progress towards achieving the
slated Millennium Development Goals.

1.
 !   +  ± Nicaragua is one of the poorest

countries of Central America. Although there have been opportunities of
improvement in the social and economic systems of the country, little has
been done to fully utilize the aid and support received from its international
partnerships on this front. Nicaragua would progress towards social upheaval
and achievement of major Millennium Development Goals with a strong
combination of abundant disbursable aid when required and an efficient
government whose priorities are towards the people of the country.

2. m

!!   
 
   ± Úhe majority of Nicaraguans live
in poverty with one-fifth living in extreme poverty. No matter which direction
c c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
the country is taken through, improvement in the standard of living of the
people living is imperative to the p rogress of the country. Availability of basic
amenities like toilets, hospitals, drug stores, schools, shelter etc. plays a vital
role in helping the lower classes to sustain and earn for their bread and water,
thereby directing the country towards achievi ng the Millennium Development
Goals.

3. m      

 
  &m(/›m
    

  ± In order to curb the spread of the life -threatening and
discriminative diseases like HIV/AIDS, it is of at most importance that the
people of Nicaragua are taught about matters relating to basic sex education,
the use of contraception, the concept of family planning and the plight of single
mothers in the society. Úhis awareness alone can save the country from falling
into the pits of epidemic diseases and SÚDs and help progress towards
achieving major Millennium Development Goals like curbing the spread of
HIV/AIDS and other diseases and increasing women rights in the society.

4. m

!
         
- Education, primary or
otherwise, is the key to sustaining human life. Without knowledge, we are as
brain-dead as the animals we see around us. Healthcare is another vital piece
of the jigsaw puzzle. For Nicaragua to step out of the social plight and poverty
it now experiences, it is essential to make sure that adequate education and
health care projects are taken up and invested upon. Úhe future of a country
depends on the future of its people. Úhe right medical care coupled with the
right knowledge can drive the country forward towards achieving most of the
slated Millennium Development Goals.


















c 8c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
V,  ›
mV
›%m
m›

*c#c#cc*c!cc#c#*c$c#c,%9c
%!c$c#c$c#c$
c!!(cc!cc! c$c
#c!c!c#c#!c$!c!!c$c# cc*cc$c
$c#c$
c#!c:##c!*cc*;c#ccc
c!
c*c
c
















c c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c

V-  ›
m#
$m$m›&%

Government of Nicaragua (2000) A Stre ngthened Poverty Reduction Strategy

Retrieved on 02/09/10
¦ http://www.imf.org/external/np/prsp/2001/nic/01/073101.pdf


Bradshaw, S & Linneker B (2002) Civil Society Responses to Po verty Reduction
Strategies in Nicaragua
Retrieved on 02/09/10 
¦ http://www.cisas.org.ni/prsp/PDF/pid_csr.pdf


Úransparency International (2004) Stealing the future: Corruption in the classroom
Retrieved on 03/09/10
¦ http://www.transparency.org/global_priorities/education.html


Wilson, J-P (2009) Church, State, and Society during the Nicaraguan Revolution
Retrieved on 02/09/10
¦ http://redalyc.uaemex.mx/pdf/162/16212429007.pdf


Nicaragua ± Úhe society
Retrieved on 02/09/10 
¦ http://www.mongabay.com/reference/country_studies/nicaragua/GEOGRAPH
Y.html


General information on Nicaragua
Retrieved on 02/09/10 & 03/09/10
¦ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicaragua
¦ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicaraguan_Revolution


Population statistics
Retrieved on 02/09/10 & 03/09/10
¦ https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/index.html
¦ https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the -world-
factbook/fields/2046.html?countryName=Nicaragua&countryCode=nu&region
Code=ca&#nu
¦ https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the -world-factbook/geos/nu.html

Education and health statistics

c c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
Retrieved on 02/09/10 & 03/09/10
¦ http://hdr.undp.org/en/media/HDR_2000_EN.pdf

Ethnic diversity research

Retrieved on 02/09/10 & 03/09/10
¦ http://www.ohchr.org/EN/countries/LACRegion/Pages/NIIndex.aspx
¦ http://www.ethnologue.com/show_country.asp?name=ni

General culture and society information

Retrieved on 02/09/10 & 03/09/10
¦ http://www.photius.com/countries/nicaragua/society/index.html
¦ http://www.nicaliving.com/

U.S Department of State (2009) Background Note: Nicaragua

Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.state.gov/r/pa/ei/bgn/1850.htm

Economic Intelligence Unit - Country Report: Nicaragua

Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://country.eiu.com/FileHandler.ashx?issue_id=837411468&mode=pdf

Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC) ± Country
Detail: Nicaragua
Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.eclac.org/publicaciones/xml/3/38063/Nicaragua.pdf

World Bank ± Latin America and the Caribbean Section ± Country Brief: Nicaragua
Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://web.worldbank.org/WBSIÚE/EXÚERNAL/COUNÚRIES/LACEXÚ/NICAR
AGUAEXÚN/0,,contentMDK:22255024~pagePK:1497618~piPK:217854~theSi
tePK:258689,00.html

Maps of World.com ± Nicaragua ± Economy and Business

Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.mapsofworld.com/nicaragua/economy-and-business/

Guillermo Perry, J. Humberto López, William F. Maloney, Omar S. Arias (2006)

Poverty reduction and growth: virtuous and vicious circles
c 
c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://siteresources.worldbank.org/EXÚLACOFFICEOFCE/Resources/870892 -
1139877599088/virtuous_circles1_complete.pdf

FAO Hunger Úarget (2010) Progress on Millennium Development Goal 1 (MDG1 ) ±

Hunger Úarget
Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.fao.org/fileadmin/templates/es/Hunger_Portal/MDG_Progress_per_
country.pdf

Úhe New York Úimes (2009) Úhe Many Stories of Carlos Fernando Chamorro
Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.nytimes.com/2009/03/22/magazine/22Nicaragua -t.html?_r=1

Fas Online (2004) Nicaragua Brigh tens as Prospect for U.S. Export Growth
Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.fas.usda.gov/info/agexporter/1996/December%201996/nicaragu.ht
ml

Úim Merrill (1993) Nicaragua: A Country Study

Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://countrystudies.us/nicaragua/

U.S Department of State (2009) Background Note: Nicaragua

Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.state.gov/r/pa/ei/bgn/1850.htm

Paul Oquist Kelley (2010) Úhe Millennium Goals in Nicaragua and the rest of the
world.
Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.tortillaconsal.com/paul_oquist_en.html

Karla Jacobs (2009) Nicaraguan Foreign Policy: Úhe threat of a good example,
again?
Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.tortillaconsal.com/nica_f oreign_policy.html

Adolfo Acevedo Vogl (2006) IMF conditionality in Nicaragua

Retrieved 02/10/2010 from

c 3c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
¦ http://www.eurodad.org/whatsnew/articles.aspx?id=1294

Retrieved on 02/10/2010 f rom

¦ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Úimeline_of_United_States_military_operations

Linn Hammergren (1998) : Centre for diplomacy and governance bureau for global
programs, field support, and research U.S. agency for International development
Retrieved on 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://pdf.usaid.gov/pdf_docs/PNACD023.pdf

Source: US department of states published on juris t legal intelligence

Retrieved on 02/10/2010
¦ http://jurist.law.pitt.edu/world/nicaragua.htm

Retrieved on 03/10/2010
¦ http://countrystudies.us/nicaragua/36.htm

CIA world fact book on Nicaragua (2010)

Retrieved on 03/10/2010
¦ https://www.cia.gov/
¦ https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/bh.html

Nicaragua international trade

Retrieved on 03/10/2010
¦ http://www.nationsencyclopedia.com/economies/A mericas/Nicaragua-
INÚERNAÚIONAL-ÚRADE.html

Alvarado Y Asociados (2010) : Guide to doing business in Nicaragua 2010

Retrieved on 03/10/2010
¦ http://www.lexmundi.com/images/lexmundi/PDF/GuidesÚoDoingBusiness/Gui
de_Nicaragua.pdf

IMF factsheet on Úhe poverty reduction and growth facility (PRGF)

Retrieved on 03/10/2010
¦ http://www.imf.org/external/np/exr/facts/prgf.htm

Retrieved on 03/10/2010

c 4c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
¦ http://www.incb.org/pdf/annual-
report/2008/en/AR2008_Chapter_III_Americas.pdf

Introduction to 2008 country repor ts on human rights practices (2009) by US

department of states
Retrieved on 03/10/2010
¦ http://www.america.gov/st/texttrans-
english/2009/February/200 90225132124ihecuoR0.5270001.html

Cia World Factbook 2007: Nicaragua"

Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the -world-factbook/index.html

Cesar Garcia,(2002) Context for Nicaraguan Immigration

Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.immigrantinfo.org/kin/nicaragua.htm

Demographics of Nicaragua
Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.nicaragua.com/demographics/

Nicaragua Demographics Profile 2010

Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.indexmundi.com/nicaragua/demographics_profile.html

Demographics of Nicaragua - Most Nicaraguans have both European and Indian

ancestry
Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.fact-index.com/d/de/demographics_of_nicaragua.html

Development Beyond Economics

Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.iadb.org/publications/search.cfm?query=&context=&filter=publicatio
n_topic%3D%3DDemographics--DEMG%0Acountry%3D%3DNicaragua--
NI&lang=en

Health For All- Health care for the people of Nueva Vida

c 5c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.jhc-cdca.org/health.html

Nicaragua Healthcare- Úhe socio-economic condition of Nicaragua

Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.mapsofworld.com/nicaragua/healthcare/

Nicaragua's health system

Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.access2insulin.org/html/nicaragua_s_health_system.html

Health - Like education, health care was among the top priorities
Retrieved 02/10/2010 from
¦ http://countrystudies.us/nicaragua/27.htm

Healthcare in Nicaragua: overcoming the legacy of neglect

Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.tortillaconsal.com/health_nicaragua.html

Nicaragua Health News

Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://health.einnews.com/nicaragua/

NICARAGUA ± COUNÚRY OVERVIEW

Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.nationsencyclopedia.com/economies/Americas/Nicaragua.html

Population - Since the 1950s, Nicaragua has had a persistently high rate of
population
Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://countrystudies.us/nicaragua/23.htm

At a glance: Nicaragua
Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.unicef.org/infobycountry/nicaragua_statistics.html

c 6c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c

Population - Since the 1950s, Nicaragua has had a persistently high rate of
population
Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.paho.org/english/dd/ais/cp_558.htm

PAHO Basic Health Indicator Data Base

Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://countrystudies.us/nicaragua/23.htm

Nicaragua - Environment
Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.nationsencyclopedia.com/Americas/Nicaragua -
ENVIRONMENÚ.html

Environmental Issues in Nicaragua

Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.fsdinternational.org/ntlopps/country/nicaragua/environment

Nicaragua Infant mortality rate

Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.indexmundi.com/nicaragua/infant_mortality_rate.html

At a glance: Nicaragua
Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.unicef.org/infobycountry/nicaragua_statistics.html

Controversy Over Pregnancy-Related Death Úoll

Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://ipsnews.net/news.asp?idnews=51141

Resources and power

Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/413855/Nicaragua/40977/Resourc
es-and-power

Sea Úurtles in Nicaragua

Retrieved 03/10/2010 from

c 7c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
¦ http://www.vianica.com/go/specials/4-sea_turtles_nicaragua.html

Nicaragua¶s largest lake has several names: the indigenous tribes called it Cocibolca
Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.vianica.com/go/specials/18-lake-nicaragua.html

El Lake Nicaragua or Lake Cocibolca (8624 km2),

Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.edicioneslupita.com/nicaragua/lagoi.html

Shmoop.com (2010) Úype of Economic Systems

Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.shmoop.com/economic-systems/types.html

Index mundi (2010) Nicaragua GDP - real growth rate

Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.indexmundi.com/nicaragua/gdp_real_growth_rate.html

Index mundi (2010) Nicaragua Inflation rate (consumer prices)

Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.indexmundi.com/nicaragua/inflation_rate_(consumer_prices).html

ECLAC (2009) Nicaragua

Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.eclac.org/publicaciones/xml/3/38063/Nicaragua.pdf

Encyclopedia of the Nations Nicaragua (2000) Infrastructure, power, and

communications
Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.nationsencyclopedia.com/economies/Americas/Nicaragua -
INFRASÚRUCÚURE-POWER-AND-COMMUNICAÚIONS.html

Úrista Winnie (2007) Úop 5 Investment Opportunities in Nicaragua

Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.nuwireinvestor.com/articles/top-5-investment-opportunities-in-
nicaragua-51147.aspx

c c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c

IMF (2010) Úhe IMF and the Millennium Development Goals

Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://www.imf.org/external/np/exr/facts/mdg.htm

FenixRetreat.com (2010) Nicaragua¶s Economy Continues on Upward Úrend

Retrieved 03/10/2010 from
¦ http://fenixretreat.com/2010/07/nicaraguas -economy-continues-on-upward-
trend/

Retrieved on 10/10/2010 from

¦ http://www.wikigender.org/index.php/Gender_Equality_in_Nicaragua

Karla Jacobs (29/08/2009) : Education in Nicaragua

Retrieved on 10/10/2010
¦ http://www.tortillaconsal.com/education29 -8-09.html

Peter Sandiford - Why Do Child Mortality Rates Fall?

Retrieved on 10/10/2010
¦ http://ajph.aphapublications.org/cgi/reprint/81/1/30.pdf

Retrieved on 10/10/2010
¦ http://www.indexmundi.com/nicaragua/millennium -development-goals.html

Retrieved on 10/10/2010
¦ http://www.cepal.org/MDG/noticias/paginas/6/35596/Ficha_ODM_7en.pdf

Millennium Development Goals Indicators,(2008)

Retrieved 10/10/2009 from
¦ http://www.eclac.org/MDG/noticias/paginas/4/35594/Ficha_ODM_6en.pdf

Retrieved on 10/10/2010
¦ http://www.amnestyusa.org/demand-dignity/maternal-health-is-a-human-
right/nicaragua/page.do?id=1021224

Amnesty International Publication (2009)

Retrieved on 10/10/2010

c 8c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c
 V

   V 
c
¦ http://www.amnestyusa.org/uploads/Nicaragua_abortion_ban_report_%20Engl
ish.pdf

c 
c

cc c
 cc„

c
c
c
c c
c