3:09-cv-02292 #314

Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document314 Filed12/21/09 Page1 of 17
1 COOPER AND KIRK, PLLC

Charles J. Cooper (DC Bar No. 248070)*
2 ccooper@cooperkirk.com
David H. Thompson (DC Bar No. 450503)*
3 dthompson@cooperkirk.com
Howard C. Nielson, Jr. (DC Bar No. 473018)*
4 hnielson@cooperkirk.com
Nicole J. Moss (DC Bar No. 472424)*
5 nmoss@cooperkirk.com
Jesse Panuccio (DC Bar No. 981634)*
6 jpanuccio@cooperkirk.com
Peter A. Patterson (Ohio Bar No. 0080840)*
7 ppatterson@cooperkirk.com
1523 New Hampshire Ave. N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036
8 Telephone: (202) 220-9600, Facsimile: (202) 220-9601
9 LAW OFFICES OF ANDREW P. PUGNO

Andrew P. Pugno (CA Bar No. 206587)
10 andrew@pugnolaw.com
101 Parkshore Drive, Suite 100, Folsom, California 95630
12 ALLIANCE DEFENSE FUND

Brian W. Raum (NY Bar No. 2856102)*
13 braum@telladf.org
James A. Campbell (OH Bar No. 0081501)*
14 jcampbell@telladf.org
15100 North 90th Street, Scottsdale, Arizona 85260
16 ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT-INTERVENORS DENNIS HOLLINGSWORTH,

GAIL J. KNIGHT, MARTIN F. GUTIERREZ, HAK-SHING WILLIAM TAM,
17 MARK A. JANSSON, and PROTECTMARRIAGE.COM – YES ON 8, A
PROJECT OF CALIFORNIA RENEWAL
18
* Admitted pro hac vice
19
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
20 NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
21 KRISTIN M. PERRY, SANDRA B. STIER,

PAUL T. KATAMI, and JEFFREY J.
22 ZARRILLO, CASE NO. 09-CV-2292 VRW
Chief Judge Vaughn R. Walker
23
Plaintiffs, DEFENDANT-INTERVENORS’
24 NOTICE OF FILING OF
v. PRIVILEGE LOG
25
ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER, in his official
26 capacity as Governor of California; EDMUND
27 G. BROWN, JR., in his official capacity as At-
torney General of California; MARK B. HOR-
28 TON, in his official capacity as Director of the
DEFENDANT-INTERVENORS’ NOTICE OF FILING OF PRIVILEGE LOG

CASE NO. 09-CV-2292 VRW
1 California Department of Public Health and State

Registrar of Vital Statistics; LINETTE SCOTT,
2 in her official capacity as Deputy Director of
Health Information & Strategic Planning for the
3
California Department of Public Health; PAT-
4 RICK O’CONNELL, in his official capacity as
Clerk-Recorder for the County of Alameda; and
5 DEAN C. LOGAN, in his official capacity as
Registrar-Recorder/County Clerk for
6 the County of Los Angeles,
7
Defendants,
8
and
9
PROPOSITION 8 OFFICIAL PROPONENTS
10 DENNIS HOLLINGSWORTH, GAIL J.
KNIGHT, MARTIN F. GUTIERREZ, HAK-
11 SHING WILLIAM TAM, and MARK A. JANS-
SON; and PROTECTMARRIAGE.COM – YES
12 ON 8, A PROJECT OF CALIFORNIA RE-
NEWAL,
13
Defendant-Intervenors.
14
15
Additional Counsel for Defendant-Intervenors
16
17 ALLIANCE DEFENSE FUND

Timothy Chandler (CA Bar No. 234325)
18 tchandler@telladf.org
101 Parkshore Drive, Suite 100, Folsom, California 95630
20 Jordan W. Lorence (DC Bar No. 385022)*

jlorence@telladf.org
21 Austin R. Nimocks (TX Bar No. 24002695)*
animocks@telladf.org
22 801 G Street NW, Suite 509, Washington, D.C. 20001
Telephone: (202) 393-8690, Facsimile: (202) 347-3622
23
* Admitted pro hac vice
24
25
26
27
28

1 TABLE OF CONTENTS
2 Cases Page
3
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES ................................................................................................................ i
4
NOTICE OF FILING........................................................................................................................... 1
5
7 TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
8 Cases Page
9 Perry v. Schwarzenegger, No. 09-17241 slip op. (9th Cir. Dec. 11, 2009) ...........................7-8, 10-12
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
i
1 At the pre-trial hearing on December 16, 2009, the Court requested that Defendant-Intervenors
2 (“Proponents”) submit a log of documents that are responsive to Plaintiffs’ Requests for Production
3
but privileged under the First Amendment or another privilege. Accordingly, Proponents hereby
4
respectfully submit the attached privilege log cataloguing documents privileged under the First
5
Amendment, as attorney-client communications, and/or as attorney work-product. As explained at
6
7 the December 16, 2009 hearing, this log identifies privileged documents that are responsive to
8 Plaintiffs’ discovery requests as those requests were limited by the Court’s October 1 and November
9 11, 2009 orders. See Doc # 214; Doc # 252.

10 Based on Plaintiffs’ representations at the December 16 hearing and in correspondence, it ap-
11
pears that they are now seeking large categories of documents that this Court held were not discov-
12
erable on relevance and/or responsiveness grounds in the October 1 and November 11 orders. Many
13
of these documents are subject to Proponents’ First Amendment privilege assertions, but Proponents
14
15 were not required to log them (and they are not included in the attached log) because this Court’s
16 October 1 and November 11 orders had placed them outside the scope of permissible discovery. We
17 respectfully submit that Proponents would be severely and unfairly prejudiced were the Court to
18 reverse course at this late date—just three weeks before the commencement of trial—and require
19
that documents previously ruled not discoverable on non-privilege grounds be added to the privilege
20
log.
21
In the pages that follow, we detail the relevant procedural history to provide the Court with a
22
23 clear understanding of what has already been produced and what remains potentially at issue, in
24 light of what has already been decided, both by this Court and by the Ninth Circuit.
25 1. In their August 17 case management statement, Plaintiffs stated that they would seek
26
document and deposition discovery into “Prop 8’s genesis, drafting, strategy, objectives, advertising,
27
campaign literature, and [Proponents’] communications with each other, supporters, and donors.”
28
1
1 Doc # 157 at 12. Proponents objected to this sweeping discovery from the start, see, e.g., Doc # 159
2 at 9, and at the August 19 case management hearing “urge[d] the Court to give us an opportunity to
3
fight this out in briefing to the Court before” discovery commenced. Hr’g of Aug. 19, 2009, Tr. at
4
60. Counsel for Plaintiffs opposed such briefing, assured the Court that Plaintiffs would not “have a
5
problem … in limiting discovery,” represented that Plaintiffs “would not be inquiring into” the
6
7 “subjective, unexpressed motivations” of Proponents, and requested that the Court provide the
8 parties the opportunity to “work out among themselves” any discovery disputes about whatever
9 “gray area” remained. Id. at 63-64. The Court agreed and allowed discovery to go forward without
10 initial briefing as to the permissible scope of discovery.
11
2. Two days later, Plaintiffs propounded sweeping document requests that sought virtually
12
all documents in Proponents’ possession. See Doc # 187-3. There was no “gray area” because
13
Plaintiffs sought everything. Proponents objected—on First Amendment, other privilege, relevance,
14
15 burden, and other grounds—to producing many of the documents implicated by Plaintiffs’ request.
16 See, e.g., Doc # 187-4 at ¶ 2 (attorney-client and work-product privilege objection), ¶¶ 4 & 8 (First
17 Amendment privilege objection), ¶ 5 (objecting to producing documents equally available from

18 public sources or third parties), ¶ 6 (relevance objection). Proponents agreed to produce (and have
19
produced) documents that they distributed to large swaths of the electorate, including discrete voter
20
groups. See Doc # 197 at 6; Doc # 214 at 2. That is, both the individual Proponents and Protect-
21
marriage.com have produced the materials they distributed to voters as voters—television adver-
22
23 tisements, radio advertisements, newspaper advertisements, press releases, posters, flyers, event
24 notification flyers, website content, blast emails, and even PowerPoint presentations delivered to
25 small church congregations. To date, Proponents have reviewed in excess of 90,000 documents and
26
have provided Plaintiffs with approximately 2,000 documents constituting communications to voter
27
28
2
1 groups, large and small. Plaintiffs have listed many of these documents on their exhibit list. Doc #
2 283-1.
3
3. But with respect to production objectionable on First Amendment, relevance, and
4
burden grounds, Proponents moved on September 15—well before responses to Plaintiffs’ discovery
5
requests were due—for a protective order limiting the scope of discovery (with respect to both
6
7 documents and testimony). See Doc # 187 (motion); Doc # 187-14 (proposed order). Proponents
8 objected to “Plaintiffs’ demands for disclosure of Proponents’ nonpublic and/or anonymous com-
9 munications, including (but not limited to) the Proponents’ communications targeted to (and/or
10 received from) (i) persons who donated money to or otherwise volunteered to assist the Prop. 8
11
campaign; (ii) agents and contractors of the campaign, including political consultants; and even (iii)
12
family, friends, and colleagues.” Doc # 197 at 6 (footnote omitted). Proponents highlighted as an
13
example Plaintiffs’ Request No. 8, which sought “all correspondence Defendant-Intervenors may
14
15 have had with any ‘third party’ bearing any relationship to Proposition 8 whatsoever.” Doc # 187 at
16 8. Proponents also explained and objected that Plaintiffs “[o]ther Requests are similarly sweeping.”
17 Id. at 8 n.1. Plaintiffs refused to narrow their requests and opposed Proponents’ motion in full. Doc
18 # 191.
19
4. On October 1, this Court “granted in part and denied in part” Proponent’s motion for a
20
protective order. Doc # 214 at 17. The Court explained that, while “communications … about
21
messages” to the electorate “could fairly lead to admissible evidence illuminating the messages
22
23 disseminated to voters,” “‘virtually every communication made by anyone included in or associated
24 with Protect Marriage’ cannot be relevant.” Id. at 15-16. Accordingly, the Court held that “Plain-
25 tiffs’ request no 8, currently encompassing any communication between proponents and any third
26
party, is simply too broad.” Id. at 16. The Court held that “discovery directed to uncovering
27
whether proponents harbor private sentiments that may have prompted their efforts is simply not
28
3
1 relevant.” Id. at 16. The Court also held that “[c]ommunications that took place after the election
2 may … be relevant if they are connected in some way to the pre-election messages conveyed to the
3
voters.” Id. (emphasis added). The Court flatly concluded: “discovery not sufficiently related to
4
what the voters could have considered is not relevant and will not be permitted.” Id.
5
In directing the Plaintiffs to redraft Request No. 8—which, as the Court noted, sought commu-
6
7 nications with “any third party”—the Court explained that a redrafted request would be
8 appropriate to the extent it calls for (1) communications by and among proponents and
their agents … concerning campaign strategy and (2) communications by and among
9 proponents and their agents concerning messages to be conveyed to voters, without re-
gard to whether the voters or voter groups were viewed as likely supporters or opponents
10 or undecided about Prop 8 and without regard to whether the messages were actually dis-
11 seminated or merely contemplated. In addition, communications by and among propo-
nents with those who assumed a directorial or managerial role in the Prop 8 campaign,
12 like political consultants or Protectmarriage.com’s treasurer or executive committee,
among others, would appear likely to lead to discovery of admissible information.
13
Id. at 17. 1
14
15 5. At a telephonic hearing on November 2, 2009, the Court ruled that Proponents may
16 submit for in camera review “a limited number of those documents” Proponents maintain are
17 privileged under the First Amendment from disclosure in response to Plaintiffs’ discovery requests.
18 Hr’g of Nov. 2, 2009, Tr. at 42-43. See also Doc # 247 (minute order). Following that in camera
19
review process, the Court issued an order on November 11 that clarified that “Plaintiffs eighth
20
document request is likely to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence to the extent the evidence
21
relates to messages or themes conveyed to California voters or is otherwise likely to lead to this
22
23 relevant information.” Doc # 252 at 3. The Court explained that only 21 of the 60 documents
24 submitted had to be produced. The other 39 documents were “either not responsive to plaintiffs’
25 request or are so attenuated from the themes or messages conveyed to voters that they are, for
26
1
On October 5, Plaintiffs, “[p]ursuant to the Court’s Order,” propounded a “revised re-
27 quest for production number 8.” Doc # 220-1 at 5. Plaintiffs did not then contend that the
revised request seeks, and Proponents have not read the revised request to seek, more than what
28
4
1 practical purposes, not responsive.” Id. at 4. The Court deemed nondiscoverable documents that
2 “say nothing about campaign messages or themes to be conveyed to the voters,” including docu-
3
ments that “discuss topics that might relate to messages ultimately adopted or considered by the
4
campaign” but do not “discuss voters or their potential reactions.” Id. at 6, 8. The Court protected
5
from disclosure, for example, documents and information relating to:
6
7 “fundraising strategy, polling information or hiring decisions”; “the mechanics of operat-

ing a campaign”; “the petition drive to qualify Prop 8 for the ballot”; “internal campaign
8 strategy”; the “mechanics of the campaign’s internal structure”; “a campaign contribu-
tion”; “polling numbers,” “poll results,” and “musings regarding poll results”; “volunteer
9 coordination and organization”; a “specific volunteer”; “the campaign’s structure and ar-
rangements with other entities”; “draft poll questions”; “potential donors”; “recruitment
10 of a potential staff member”; fundraising letters; “volunteer organization”; “meetings
11 with major donors”; “mechanics of petition drives”; “mechanics of operating a phone
bank”; “a supporter … not officially associated with the campaign”; internal discussions
12 about “recent articles about gay marriage and its effects”; discussions about “proposed
language for Prop 8 [that is] at most marginally pertinent to advertising strategy”; “a po-
13 tential volunteer consultant and ways the volunteer might aid campaign strategies”; dis-
cussions about “disseminating a message but not [about] the message itself”; “the appro-
14 priate language to use for the text of Prop 8”; “a targeted fundraising drive.”
15
Id. at 4, 6-9.
16
6. The upshot of the October 1 and November 11 orders was that Proponents’ discovery
17
obligations with respect to communications with third parties—aside from communications to voters
18
19 as voters—were limited in two significant respects. First, only communications by and among
20 Proponents, the managers and directors of Protectmarriage.com, and their agents were discoverable.
21 Second, only communications concerning messages to be conveyed to voters were discoverable.

22
Other communications—for example, a communication with “a supporter … not officially associ-
23
ated with the campaign” and “the campaign’s structure and arrangements with other entities,” Doc #
24
252 at 6-9—were not discoverable. Thus, under this Court’s rulings, Proponents were not required
25
to produce, or log as privileged, countless e-mails and other communications unrelated to campaign
26
27
28 is permitted under the Court’s orders.
5
1 messaging and advertising strategy. Likewise, it follows that Proponents and their agents were not
2 required to testify about communications and topics that were not discoverable through requests for
3
production.
4
7. Proponents appealed the October 1 and November 11 orders “to the extent they deny
5
Defendant-Intervenors’ Motion for a Protective Order (Doc # 187) and/or require the production of
6
7 documents asserted as privileged under the First Amendment.” Doc # 253 at 3. See also Doc # 222.
8 Specifically, Proponents challenged this Court’s ruling that confidential communications among
9 Proponents and their agents (at the directorial or managerial level) concerning campaign messaging
10 must be produced. Proponents did not challenge (in either this Court or in the Ninth Circuit)
11
Plaintiffs’ request for television advertisements, flyers, blast e-mails, and other communications that
12
went to the public (although Proponents have consistently maintained that these public materials,
13
too, are irrelevant to voter intent). And, of course, Proponents did not challenge this Court’s Octo-
14
15 ber 1 and November 11 order to the extent they limited the scope of discoverable materials. Like-
16 wise, Plaintiffs did not cross appeal these orders to the extent they granted Proponents’ motion and
17 limited the scope of “relevant” and “appropriate” discovery at issue. Indeed, during oral argument
18 before the Ninth Circuit, Plaintiffs’ counsel relied upon the limitations in those orders in urging the
19
Court of Appeals to reject Proponents’ appeal on the internal communications. See Recording of
20
Oral Argument, Perry v. Schwarzenegger, No. 09-17241 (Dec. 1, 2009), available at
21
http://www.ca9.uscourts.gov/media/view_subpage.php?pk_id=0000004515 (this Court did “a very
22
23 commendable job of coming up with a standard in th[e] November 11 order” of what is “not to be
24 produced”; the November 11 order “la[id] down the standards that would govern the balancing
25 going forward as to documents”). Thus, the Ninth Circuit had before it only the twenty-one in
26
camera documents this Court ordered produced—and not the thirty-nine documents this Court held
27
28
6
1 were protected from discovery. See Order, Perry v. Schwarzenegger, No. 09-17241 (9th Cir. Nov.
2 25, 2009).
3
8. Accordingly, in its opinion, the Ninth Circuit recounted the production called for in the
4
October 1 and November 11 orders, Perry v. Schwarzenegger, No. 09-17241, slip op. at 8-9 (Dec.
5
11, 2009), and explicitly stated: “The parties … disagree about what types of evidence may be relied
6
7 upon to demonstrate voter intent. These issues are beyond the scope of this appeal. We assume
8 without deciding that the district court has decided these questions correctly,” id. at 34 n.11. See
9 also id. at 12 (“assum[ing] without deciding” that this Court was “correct” in its rulings on “whether
10 plaintiffs may rely on certain types of evidence to prove that Proposition 8 was enacted for an
11
improper purpose”). In other words, the Ninth Circuit did not have before it, and left in place as law
12
of the case, this Court’s orders restricting the scope of relevant and appropriate discovery and
13
granting Proponents’ motion for a protective order to that extent. With respect to the 21 documents
14
15 and like materials that this Court had ordered produced, the Ninth Circuit held that Proponents’ First
16 Amendment privilege barred discovery of those materials. The Court explained that, “bearing in
17 mind other sources of information” and that “[t]he information plaintiffs seek is attenuated from the
18 issue of voter intent,” Plaintiffs “have not shown a sufficiently compelling need for the information”
19
at issue. Id. at 36-37.
20
9. This procedural history has resulted in the privilege log filed herewith. The October 1
21
order responded to discovery that sought “‘virtually every communication made by anyone included
22
23 in or associated with Protect Marriage’” (including communications with “any third party’) and
24 explained that only a limited universe of such communications could be considered “relevant” or
25 “appropriate” in this case. Doc # 214 at 15-17. The documents Proponents submitted for in camera
26
review were selected because Proponents believed they fell within the metes and bounds of what the
27
October 1 order deemed as “relevant” and “appropriate.” The November 11 order made clear that a
28
7
1 nearly two-thirds of those documents were not, in fact, responsive to what the Court deemed “rele-
2 vant” and “appropriate” areas for inquiry in discovery. Accordingly, the Court stated in the Novem-
3
ber 11 order: “[T]he court hopes that the foregoing affords proponents sufficient and specific
4
enough guidance to cull their inventory of documents and other materials in order to respond to
5
plaintiffs’ document request.” Doc # 252 at 9. The Ninth Circuit held that these materials are
6
7 privileged from disclosure on First Amendment grounds, but that “some form of a privilege log is
8 required.” Perry, slip op. at 7 n.1. The log submitted herewith thus catalogues the documents that
9 this Court has deemed “relevant” and “appropriate” for discovery, but that the Ninth Circuit has
10 deemed privileged from disclosure under the First Amendment.
11
10. This procedural history has also dictated the course of depositions. Despite this Court’s
12
and the Ninth Circuit’s rulings on the permissible scope of discovery (on relevance or privilege
13
grounds), Plaintiffs have sought through testimony at depositions information they are barred from
14
15 seeking through production of documents. Compare, e.g., Doc # 214 at 16 (“[D]iscovery directed to
16 uncovering whether proponents harbor private sentiments that may have prompted their efforts is
17 simply not relevant.”), with Dep. of W. Tam, Tr. 49:11-13 (“Was your goal in writing this letter to
18 encourage people to vote in favor of Proposition 8?”) (attached as Ex. 2). Accordingly, Proponents’
19
counsel objected at depositions to the many questions that seek precisely the information that this
20
Court and the Ninth Circuit have deemed nondiscoverable.
21
11. Unfortunately, despite the protracted litigation over this issue in both this Court and in
22
23 the Ninth Circuit, the discovery dispute does not appear to be at an end. As has been true through-
24 out the discovery period, Plaintiffs are yet again altering their demands, often from day to day and in
25 violation of controlling orders in this case. 2 It now appears to be Plaintiffs’ position that they are
26
2
27 Compare Hr’g of Aug. 19, 2009 Tr. 64 (representing that Plaintiffs “would not be inquir-
ing into” “subjective, unexpressed motivations” “because [Plaintiffs] do not believe that those
28 would actually go to the issues that [they] are presenting to the Court”), and Doc # 214 at 16
8
1 entitled to production, in response to Request Nos. 1 or 6, of precisely the same materials this Court
2 held were not discoverable under the original or revised Request No. 8. Request No. 1 seeks
3
documents “distributed to voters” and Request No. 6 seeks all documents “prepared for public
4
distribution.” Doc # 187-3 at 5. Plaintiffs now contend that these requests encompass (1) all
5
communications, even one-on-one communications to any voter and (2) any documents distributed
6
7 by a Defendant-Intervenor to anyone outside what Plaintiffs call the campaign “control group”—i.e.,
8 “the group identified in [Plaintiffs] revised document request number 8.” Hr’g of Dec. 16, 2009, Tr.
9 (rough) at 30:13; Ltr. from E. Dettmer to C. Cooper (Dec. 14, 2009) at 1 (attached as Ex. 3).
10 12. There are at least two problems with this position. First, it converts Request Nos. 1 and
11
6 into original Request No. 8—the very request that this Court ruled was “simply too broad.” Doc #
12
214 at 16. That is, under Plaintiffs’ newly asserted position, the “voters” in Request No. 1 and the
13
“public” in Request No. 6 include any person residing in California who was not part of the Pro-
14
15 tectmarraige.com “control group.” In other words, it appears Plaintiffs now demand under Requests
16 Nos. 1 and 6 “[a]ll documents … between [Proponents] and any third party”—i.e., exactly what
17 original Request No. 8 sought. Id. at 2. 3 But this Court found the information sought by original
18
Request No. 8 to be overly broad, burdensome, and largely irrelevant, and it directed Plaintiffs to
19
20
(“discovery directed to uncovering whether proponents harbor private sentiments that may have
21 prompted their efforts is simply not relevant”), with Dep. of W. Tam, Tr. 49:11-13 (“Was your
goal in writing this letter to encourage people to raise funds for passing Proposition 8?”)
22 (attached as Ex. 2). Compare Doc # 187-6 at 2 (“I am writing to confirm that Plaintiffs’ First
Set of Requests for Production does not seek internal communications among and between your
23 clients regarding Proposition 8 and the related political campaign.”), with Doc # 220-1 at 5
(seeking “communications … between … Defendant-Intervenors”).
3
24 In a letter dated December 15, 2009 (attached as Ex. 4), Proponents asked Plaintiffs to
“please clarify” whether they were seeking under these requests what they are barred from
25 seeking under Request No. 8. To date, Plaintiffs have offered no response or clarification.
Similarly, in a letter dated December 10, 2009 (attached as Ex. 5), Proponents responded to
26 discovery concerns raised by Plaintiffs in an earlier letter—specifically, to concerns over a
handful of documents identified by Plaintiffs. Having provided a full explanation of why those
27 documents were not produced, Proponents have heard nothing further from Plaintiffs on this
front despite Proponents’ representation that “[w]e are happy to address any legitimate, addi-
28 tional concerns Plaintiffs may have.”
9
1 revise the request according to its instructions. See Doc # 214 at 15-16 (“Plaintiffs request no 8,
2 currently encompassing any communication between proponents and any third party, is simply too
3
broad.”). As the Court noted, “no amount of discovery could corral all of the information on which
4
voters cast their ballots on Prop 8,” and thus the Court restricted the scope of permissible discovery
5
in the October 1 and November 11 orders. Id. at 15. And with respect to Plaintiffs’ revised Request
6
7 No. 8, the Ninth Circuit held “[w]e are not presented here with a carefully tailored request for the
8 production of highly relevant information that is unavailable from other sources that do not impli-
9 cate First Amendment associational interests.” Perry, slip. op. at 37 n.13. Plaintiffs cannot seri-
10 ously contend that reading Requests Nos. 1 and 6 to encompass everything original Request No. 8
11
encompassed is such a “carefully tailored” request. Indeed, if the information at issue before the
12
Ninth Circuit—communications among campaign leaders about messaging and advertising strat-
13
egy—was “attenuated from the issue of voter intent,” id. at 36-37, then it follows a fortiori that the
14
15 materials now demanded by Plaintiffs are utterly irrelevant.
16 Second, Plaintiffs’ current position necessarily suggests that Proponents’ First Amendment as-
17 sociation rights are limited to communications with participants in the specifically denominated and
18 legally recognized campaign committee, and communications with any other known political
19
associates are not protected by the First Amendment. For example, if Gail Knight or Dr. William
20
Tam—who, although official proponents, had virtually nothing to do with Protectmarriage.com’s
21
campaign—nonetheless worked with a neighbor or family member to draft a flyer in favor of
22
23 Proposition 8, it appears to be Plaintiffs’ contention that private communications about that flyer (as
24 opposed to the flyer itself) receive no First Amendment protection. So, too, for any members of the
25 ACLU who might have engaged in private associational and political speech outside the confines of
26
27
28
10
1 that particular organization. Turning their prior representations on their head, 4 Plaintiffs now appear
2 to argue that individuals receive less protection than official groups. 5
3
13. There is no support for Plaintiffs’ position in the caselaw, and the Ninth Circuit here has
4
made clear that “compelled disclosure of political affiliations and activities” must be justified by a
5
compelling state interest, that the “existence of a prima facie case [of privilege] turns not on the type
6
7 of information sought, but on whether disclosure of the information will have a deterrent effect on
8 the exercise of protected activities,” that “[i]mplicit in the right to associate with others to advance
9 one’s shared political beliefs is the right to exchange ideas and formulate strategy and messages, and
10 to do so in private,” and that “[a]ssociations, no less than individuals, have the right to shape their
11
own messages.” Perry, slip op. at 24, 29-30, 31 n.9 (emphasis added). The Court credited Propo-
12
nent Mark Jansson’s statement that “if the personal, non-public communications [he] … had regard-
13
ing this ballot initiative” are disclosed through compulsory process, his speech will be chilled. Id. at
14
15 32 (quotation marks omitted). Mr. Jansson, and some of the other Proponents, engaged in such
16 nonpublic communications not only within the confines of some “control group,” but also with
17 known political associates who banded together to support Proposition 8. Those communications
18
19 4
See Recording of Oral Argument, Perry v. Schwarzenegger, No. 09-17241 (Dec. 1, 2009)
20 (Plaintiffs counsel representing that internal communications of Defendant-Intervenors are
differently situated than those of other persons and groups because “here these are the official
21 proponents” and arguing that “these are the official proponents of proposition 8, they took an
official status, they drafted proposition 8. They then subjected themselves to disclosure laws in
22 California. They subjected themselves to disclosure their identity, their disclosures in their
responsibilities that they took. So they’re in a very different position then the organizations you
23 mentioned and Mrs. McIntyre, in the McIntyre case.”).
5
Third, if Plaintiffs are correct that they are entitled to production under other requests of
24 what they were barred from obtaining under Request No. 8, then it would follow that Plaintiffs
are entitled under Request No. 3, for example, to Protectmarriage.com’s internal drafts of
25 television ads—for that request seeks “all versions” of such ads, including internal drafts that
were never distributed outside a “control group.” See Doc # 187-3 at 5. Plaintiffs have failed to
26 explain how this request, and other similar requests, would not violate the Ninth Circuit’s
ruling. See Perry, slip op. at 30 (recognizing individual and associational right to “formulate
27 strategy and messages, and to do so in private”); Doc # 252 at 4 (showing that one of the
documents protected by the Ninth Circuit’s opinion “discusses edits to a television advertise-
28 ment”).
11
1 are no less protected, and no more public (or made “to voters”) than those that took place between
2 and among the “control group.”
3
14. The Ninth Circuit has already drawn the line between what is and is not within the First
4
Amendment privilege it recognized, and its line differs markedly from that suggested by Plaintiffs.
5
The Court held that Proponents could not “avoid disclosure of broadly disseminated material by
6
7 stamping them ‘private’ and claiming an ‘associational bond’ with large swaths of the electorate.”
8 Id. at 36, n.12. Proponents have adhered to this line, and have produced all communications that
9 went to the electorate at large or to discrete groups of voters, while withholding private communica-
10 tions to their known political associates, whom they communicated with not to implore them to vote,
11
but in a joint (albeit unofficial) effort to campaign for or discuss Prop 8.
12
15. If the Court were to now withdraw the relevance/responsiveness limitations set forth in
13
the October 1 and November 11 orders, many of the additional documents Plaintiffs seek would still
14
15 not be discoverable because they fall within the heartland of the privilege recognized by the Ninth
16 Circuit. Nevertheless, Proponents would be severely prejudiced by such a ruling because it would
17 entail an exponential increase in the size of the privilege log. For example, if the limitations in the
18 November 11 order were removed, Proponents would have to re-review and potentially log upwards
19
of 10,000 additional documents. And if the limitations set out in the October 1 order were removed,
20
Proponents would have to re-review and log upwards of an additional 30,000 documents. It has
21
been our experience thus far in this case that, depending on the nature of the documents at issue, an
22
23 attorney can review and log ten to twenty-five documents per hour. As we head into trial, the
24 number of attorneys and legal assistants available for this task will diminish and the task may be all
25 but impossible. Indeed, even if Proponents devoted three attorneys working full time to reviewing
26
and logging 10,000 additional documents, it would not be possible to accomplish the task before the
27
start of trial.
28
12
1 16. The prejudice to Proponents would be compounded to the extent the Court contemplates
2 the continuation of litigation concerning these discovery disputes after the commencement of trial.
3
While Plaintiffs appear to have an almost limitless reservoir of lawyers from two of the Nation’s
4
largest law firms, Proponents’ resources are far more limited, and necessarily must be devoted to
5
presenting Proponents’ case at trial. Especially when one considers Plaintiffs’ candid admission that
6
7 these materials are not central to their case—indeed, Plaintiffs’ counsel actually suggested that
8 “there would be a way to ensure that any ruling that was favorable to us did not rise or fall on those
9 documents” so as to avoid any appellate exposure that otherwise might arise, Hr’g of Dec. 16, 2009,
10 Tr. (rough) at 44—Proponents should not be forced to divert their attention from the presentation of
11
their case on the merits to further defense of the their First Amendment rights. If the discovery lines
12
are to change at this late date, then the only alternative consistent with fair proceedings is postpone-
13
ment of trial until these discovery matters are settled.
14
15 17. Moreover, it is not only Plaintiffs who have relied on the relevance and First Amend-
16 ment rulings to date. As has been made known to this Court and the Ninth Circuit, both Plaintiffs
17 and Proponents have subpoenaed numerous third-party groups for the same types of documents
18 Plaintiffs have sought from Proponents. If the lines for relevance and production are to change
19
again, all of those groups will have to re-review and produce or log their potentially massive inven-
20
tory of internal documents. And if the Court does deem these communications relevant, Proponents
21
will be severely prejudiced in presenting their case absent the ability to collect and review these
22
23 documents prior to trial. 6
24
6
25 At the December 16 hearing, Plaintiffs raised the issue of disclosure of the identity of the
Doe member of the Protectmarriage.com ad hoc executive committee. As Proponents’ counsel
26 explained to the Court, the Doe member is represented by separate counsel and is asserting his
privilege claim independently through that counsel. We have now been informed by Doe’s
27 counsel that he responded to Plaintiffs’ third party subpoena on November 9, 2009, with an
offer to negotiate the terms of document production and a deposition. Doe’s counsel further
28 informs us that the two parties are now negotiating the issue of disclosure of Doe’s identity.
13
2 Dated: December 21, 2009 Respectfully submitted,

3
4 By: /s/Charles J. Cooper

Charles J. Cooper
5
COOPER AND KIRK, PLLC
6 ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANTS-INTERVENORS
7
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27 Until such time as those negotiations are complete or Doe’s privilege claim is litigated, we are
submitting the attached privilege log with Doe’s name identified as “Doe Executive Committee
28 Member.”
14
Case3:09-cv-02292-JW Document314-1 Filed12/21/09 Page1 of 100
Exhibit 1
Defendant-Intervenors' Privilege Log
Perry, et al. v. Schwarzenegger, et al., Case No. 09-2292
Doc No. Bates Range Priv Call Doc Type Date Author(s) Recipient(s) Copyee(s) Description of Document/Basis of Privilege Priv Type
1 DEF_INT_PRIV_001000- Attorney Email string 10/21/08- Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Doe Executive Committee Member, Gary Lawrence, Does 1-3 Confidential attorney-client communication regarding public AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001001 Client/Attorney 10/22/08 Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Chip White, Frank Schubert messaging
Work Product;
First Amendment
2 DEF_INT_PRIV_001002- Attorney Email string 10/15/08/- Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Doe 2 Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001005 Client/Attorney 10/21/08 questions/issues regarding print advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
3 DEF_INT_PRIV_001006- Attorney Email string 10/17/2008 Bill Criswell Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001008 Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
4 DEF_INT_PRIV_001009 - Attorney Email string 10/09/08- Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Bill Criswell Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001013 Client/Attorney 10/13/08 Frank Schubert questions/issues regarding television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
5 DEF_INT_PRIV_001014 - Attorney Email string 09/11/08- Andrew Pugno, Bill Criswell, Frank Bill Criswell, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001049 Client/Attorney 09/19/08 Schubert questions/issues regarding television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
6 DEF_INT_PRIV_001050 Attorney Email 8/27/2008 Jennifer Kerns Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Ron Prentice Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
Client/Attorney issues/questions regarding public messaging
Work Product;
First Amendment
DEF_INT_PRIV_001051 - Attorney Email string 8/27/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jennfer Kerns Jennifer Kerns, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Mark Confidential attorney-client communication concerning public AC, FA
Case3:09-cv-02292-JW Document314-1
7
DEF_INT_PRIV_001052 Client/Attorney Jansson, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi messaging regarding ballot language litigation
Work Product;
First Amendment
8 DEF_INT_PRIV_001053 - Attorney Email string 6/19/2008 Joe Infranco, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence Confidential attorney-client communication regarding overall public AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001056 Client/Attorney messaging
Work Product;
First Amendment
9 DEF_INT_PRIV_001057 - Attorney Email string 11/8/2006 Joe Infranco, Andrew Pugno Joe Infranco, Ron Prentice, Peter Henderson, Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication regarding overall public AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001059 Client/Attorney messaging
Work Product;
First Amendment
10 DEF_INT_PRIV_001060 - Attorney Email string 02/01/06- Joe Infranco, Andrew Pugno Joe Infranco, Ron Prentice, Peter Henderson, Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication regarding ballot AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001064 Client/Attorney 02/07/06 language
Work Product;
First Amendment
11 DEF_INT_PRIV_001067 - Attorney Email string 4/29/2008 Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal issues AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001068 Client/Attorney surrounding ballot language and overall campaign strategy
Filed12/21/09 Page2 of 100
Work Product;
First Amendment
1 of 99
12 DEF_INT_PRIV_001069 Attorney Email string 8/24/2008 Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Confidential attorney-client communication regarding overall public AC, FA
Client/Attorney messaging
Work Product;
First Amendment
13 DEF_INT_PRIV_001070 - Attorney Email string 11/4/2008 Chip White, Andrew Pugno Chip White, Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication regarding prospective AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001074 Client/Attorney litigation and discussion of related messaging in response to a
Work Product; media inquiry
First Amendment
14 DEF_INT_PRIV_001075 - Attorney Email string 11/3/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Gary Lawrence, Ned Dolejsi, Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001081 Client/Attorney Jeff Flint, Doe 1 Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 2, Chip White, questions/issues regarding television advertisement
Work Product; Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno
First Amendment
15 DEF_INT_PRIV_001082 - Attorney Email string 11/3/2008 Andrew Pugno, Chip White, Doe Andrew Pugno, Chip White, Doe 1, Mark Jansson, Ron Does 2-3 Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001085 Client/Attorney Executive Committee Member Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, issues/questions regarding public statements
Work Product; Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint
First Amendment
16 DEF_INT_PRIV_001086 - Attorney Email string 10/30/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Andrew Andrew Pugno, Sonja Eddings Brown, Megan Waters, Gary Confidential attorney-client communication regarding television AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001088 Client/Attorney Pugno Lawrence, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
17 DEF_INT_PRIV_001089 - Attorney Email string 10/30/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Doe Confidental attorney-client communication regarding public AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001092 Client/Attorney Executive Committee Member, Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert, communications
Work Product; Chip White, Megan Waters, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint
First Amendment
DEF_INT_PRIV_001093 - Attorney Email string 10/28/2008 - Andrew Pugno, Chip White, William Chip White, William Tam, Andrew Pugno, Does 1-2 Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
18
DEF_INT_PRIV_001099 Client/Attorney 10/30/2008 Tam questions/issues regarding radio advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
19 DEF_INT_PRIV_001100 Attorney Email string 10/29/2008 Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence Confidential attorney-client communication regarding aerial AC, FA
Client/Attorney advertising
Work Product;
First Amendment
20 DEF_INT_PRIV_001101 - Attorney Email string 10/29/2008 Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001102 Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding public communications
Work Product;
First Amendment
21 DEF_INT_PRIV_001104 Attorney Email string 10/28/2008 Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Doe 1, Bill Criswell, Jeff Flint William Tam, Does 2-6 Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding radio advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
22 DEF_INT_PRIV_001106 - Attorney Email string 10/27/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Andrew Sonja Eddings Brown, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Chip White Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001113 Client/Attorney Pugno, Flint, Chip White questions/issues regarding an advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
2 of 99
23 DEF_INT_PRIV_001114 - Attorney Email string 10/27/2008 Andrew Pugno, Chip White Andrew Pugno, Chip White, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Michael Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001115 Client/Attorney Sowers, Does 1-3 questions/issues for response to a media inquiry
Work Product;
First Amendment
24 DEF_INT_PRIV_001116 Attorney Email string 10/26/2008 Bill May, Frank Schubert Chip White, Bill May Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
Client/Attorney issues/questions regarding public statements
Work Product;
First Amendment
25 DEF_INT_PRIV_001117 - Attorney Email string 10/23/08- Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Doe Executive Committee Member, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001119 Client/Attorney 10/24/08 Committee Member Mark Jansson questions/issues regarding an advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
26 DEF_INT_PRIV_001120 - Attorney Email string 10/24/2008 Andrew Pugno, Doe 1, Bill Criswell Doe 1, Andrew Pugno, Bill Criswell, Jeff Flint Bill Criswell, Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001124 Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding radio advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
27 DEF_INT_PRIV_001125 - Attorney Email string 10/23/08- Doe Executive Committee Member Doe Executive Committee Member, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno, Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001126 Client/Attorney 10/24.08 Mark Jansson questions/issues regarding an advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
28 DEF_INT_PRIV_001127 Attorney Email string 10/23/2008 Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Confidential attorney-client communication regarding legal support AC, FA
Client/Attorney for campaign messaging
Work Product;
First Amendment
DEF_INT_PRIV_001128 - Attorney Email string 10/23/2008 Doe Executive Committee Member, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Ned Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown, Andrew Confidential attorney-client communication regarding legal issues AC, FA
29
DEF_INT_PRIV_001151 Client/Attorney Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Doe 1, Chip White, Sonja Eddings Pugno, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, surrounding campaign statements and broadcasted advertisements
Work Product; Jeff Flint Brown Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe
First Amendment Executive Committee Member, Mark
Jansson, Doe 1
30 DEF_INT_PRIV_001152 - Attorney Email string 10/22/2008 Andrew Pugno, Sonja Eddings Sonja Eddings Brown, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Gary Frank Schubert Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001155 Client/Attorney Brown, Lawrence, Chip White, Frank Schubert questions/issues regarding a campaign advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
31 DEF_INT_PRIV_001156 - Attorney Email string 10/22/2008 Doe 1, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Mark Does 2-4 Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001157 Client/Attorney Jansson, Doe 1 questions/issues regarding a campaign advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
32 DEF_INT_PRIV_001158 - Attorney Email string 10/22/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Chip White, Sonja Frank Schubert Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001164 Client/Attorney Eddings Brown, Frank Schubert questions/issues regarding a campaign advertisement and press
Work Product; release
First Amendment
33 DEF_INT_PRIV_001165 - Attorney Email string 10/21/2008- Andrew Pugno, Bill Criswell Bill Criswell, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Does 1- Confidential attorney-client communication regarding a television AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001166 Client/Attorney 10/22/2008 2 advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
3 of 99
34 DEF_INT_PRIV_001167 - Attorney Email string 10/21/2008 - Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Sarah Pollo, Doe Executive Does 1-3 Confidential attorney-client communication regarding campaign AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001177 Client/Attorney 10/22/2008 Committee Member, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Chip White, signs
Work Product; Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint
First Amendment
35 DEF_INT_PRIV_001178 - Attorney Email string 10/21/2008 Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Joe Infranco, Gary Lawrence Confidential attorney-client communication regarding vandalism AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001182 Client/Attorney Andrew Pugno against Prop 8 supporters and potential campaign messaging
Work Product; regarding that issue
First Amendment
36 DEF_INT_PRIV_001183 - Attorney Email string 10/17/2008 - Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication regarding television AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001186 Client/Attorney 10/21/2008 advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
37 DEF_INT_PRIV_001187 - Attorney Email string 10/21/2008 Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Sarah Pollo, Doe Executive Does 1-3 Confidential attorney-client communication regarding campaign AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001190 Client/Attorney Committee Member, Ron Prentice, Chip White, Frank Schubert, signs
Work Product; Jeff Flint
First Amendment
38 DEF_INT_PRIV_001191 - Attorney Email string 10/20/2008 Andrew Pugno, Sonja Eddings Andrew Pugno, Sonja Eddings Brown Chip White Confidential attorney-client communication regarding responses to AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001192 Client/Attorney Brown media inquiries
Work Product;
First Amendment
39 DEF_INT_PRIV_001193 - Attorney Email string 10/20/2008 Andrew Pugno, Bill May, Frank Bill May, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno Ned Dolejsi, Chip White Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001195 Client/Attorney Schubert questions/issues regarding campaign advertisements
Work Product;
First Amendment
DEF_INT_PRIV_001196 Attorney Email 10/20/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication regarding responses to AC, FA
40
Client/Attorney media inquiries
Work Product;
First Amendment
41 DEF_INT_PRIV_001197 Attorney Email string 10/19/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding campaign advertisements
Work Product;
First Amendment
42 DEF_INT_PRIV_001199 - Attorney Email string 10/16/2008- Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001200 Client/Attorney 10/18/2008 questions/issues regarding campaign advertisements
Work Product;
First Amendment
43 DEF_INT_PRIV_001201 - Attorney Email string 10/17/2008 Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001205 Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding advertisements
Work Product;
First Amendment
44 DEF_INT_PRIV_001206 - Attorney Email string 10/16/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001208 Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding campaign press conference
Work Product;
First Amendment
4 of 99
45 DEF_INT_PRIV_001210 Attorney Email string 10/16/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication regarding advertisement AC, FA
Client/Attorney
Work Product;
First Amendment
46 DEF_INT_PRIV_001211 - Attorney Email string 10/13/2008 - Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication regarding television AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001279 Client/Attorney 10/14/2008 advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
47 DEF_INT_PRIV_001280 - Attorney Email string 10/13/2008 Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Doe 1, Andrew Pugno Confidential legal communication concerning legal issues/questions AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001281 Client/Attorney regarding billboard advertising
Work Product;
First Amendment
48 DEF_INT_PRIV_001283 - Attorney Email string 10/9/2009 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Doe 1, Bill Criswell, Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001286 Client/Attorney Andrew Pugno issues/questions regarding campaign advertisements
Work Product;
First Amendment
49 DEF_INT_PRIV_001287 - Attorney Email 10/9/2008 Andrew Pugno Bill Criswell Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication regarding television AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001289 Client/Attorney advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
50 DEF_INT_PRIV_001290 - Attorney Email string 10/9/2008 Andrew Pugno, Bill Criswell Bill Criswell, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Doe 1 Confidential attorney-client communication regarding television AC, FA
Work Product;
First Amendment
DEF_INT_PRIV_001295 Attorney Email 10/9/2008 Andrew Pugno Doe 1 Confidential legal communication regarding a campaign billboard AC, FA
51
Client/Attorney advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
52 DEF_INT_PRIV_001296 - Attorney Email string 10/8/2009 Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Bill Criswell, Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001303 Client/Attorney Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint questions/issues regarding television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
53 DEF_INT_PRIV_001304 - Attorney Email string 10/8/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Bill Criswell, Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
Work Product;
First Amendment
54 DEF_INT_PRIV_001307- Attorney Email string 10/8/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint Bill May, Doe 1, Ned Dolejsi Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001310 Client/Attorney Flint issues/questions regarding campaign flyer
Work Product;
First Amendment
55 DEF_INT_PRIV_001311 - Attorney Email string 10/6/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001316 Client/Attorney Jeff Flint questions/issues regarding television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
5 of 99
56 DEF_INT_PRIV_001317 - Attorney Email string 10/3/2008 - Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Gary Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Ned Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001330 Client/Attorney 10/4/2008 Lawrence, Andrew Pugno Dolejsi Member, Mark Jansson questions/issues regarding television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
57 DEF_INT_PRIV_001331 - Attorney Email string 10/2/2008 Gary Lawrence Andrew Pugno Doe 1 Confidential attorney-client communication discussing legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001332 Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding Proposition 8's legal effect as
Work Product; preparation for creating an advertisement
First Amendment
58 DEF_INT_PRIV_001333 Attorney Email string 9/30/2008 Andrew Pugno, Sonja Eddings Andrew Pugno, Sonja Eddings Brown Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
Client/Attorney Brown questions/issues for a statement distributed to the media
Work Product;
First Amendment
59 DEF_INT_PRIV_001334 Attorney Email string 9/30/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
60 DEF_INT_PRIV_001335 - Attorney Email string 9/28/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Richard Peterson, Jeff Flint Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001341 Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding a campaign press conference
Work Product;
First Amendment
61 DEF_INT_PRIV_001342 - Attorney Email string 9/28/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001343 Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding radio advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
DEF_INT_PRIV_001344 - Attorney Email string 9/28/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Richard Peterson Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
62
DEF_INT_PRIV_001346 Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding a campaign press conference
Work Product;
First Amendment
63 DEF_INT_PRIV_001347 - Attorney Email string 9/26/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
Work Product;
First Amendment
64 DEF_INT_PRIV_001356 - Attorney Email string 9/26/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Gary Confidential attorney-client communication regarding materials AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001357 Client/Attorney Lawrence, Jennifer Kerns, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi posted to the internet
Work Product;
First Amendment
65 DEF_INT_PRIV_001358 - Attorney Email string 9/25/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
Work Product;
First Amendment
66 DEF_INT_PRIV_001383 - Attorney Email string 9/24/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Gary Confidential attorney-client communication regarding materials AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001389 Client/Attorney Lawrence, Jennifer Kerns, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi posted to the internet
Work Product;
First Amendment
6 of 99
67 DEF_INT_PRIV_001390 - Attorney Email 9/19/2008 Joe Infranco Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001392 Client/Attorney Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice questions/issues regarding statements distributed to the public
Work Product;
First Amendment
68 DEF_INT_PRIV_001393 - Attorney Email string 9/19/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Nancy Limon, Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001394 Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding campaign flyer
Work Product;
First Amendment
69 DEF_INT_PRIV_001395 - Attorney Email string 9/19/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Frank Schubert Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001398 Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding magazine advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
70 DEF_INT_PRIV_001399 - Attorney Email string 9/19/2008 Joe Infranco Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001404 Client/Attorney Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice questions/issues regarding statements distributed to the public
Work Product;
First Amendment
71 DEF_INT_PRIV_001405 - Attorney Email string 9/11/2008 - Frank Schubert, Bill Criswell, Andrew Pugno, Bill Criswell, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Doe 1 Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001412 Client/Attorney 9/18/2008 Andrew Pugno questions/issues regarding television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
72 DEF_INT_PRIV_001413 - Attorney Email string 9/16/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
Work Product;
First Amendment
DEF_INT_PRIV_001422 - Attorney Email string 9/16/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
73
DEF_INT_PRIV_001425 Client/Attorney Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, questions/issues regarding television advertisement
Work Product; Andrew Pugno, Does 1-3
First Amendment
74 DEF_INT_PRIV_001426 - Attorney Email string 9/15/2008 - Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001428 Client/Attorney 9/16/2008 questions/issues regarding television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
75 DEF_INT_PRIV_001429 Attorney Email string 9/15/2008 Andrew Pugno Joe Infranco, Doe 1 Confidential legal communication regarding legal research for AC, FA
Client/Attorney campaign advertisements
Work Product;
First Amendment
76 DEF_INT_PRIV_001430 - Attorney Email string 9/15/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001432 Client/Attorney Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, questions/issues regarding television advertisement
First Amendment
77 DEF_INT_PRIV_001433 - Attorney Email string 9/13/2008 - Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001442 Client/Attorney 9/14/2008 Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, questions/issues regarding television advertisement

First Amendment
7 of 99
Work Product;
First Amendment
79 DEF_INT_PRIV_001450 Attorney Email string 9/11/2008 Andrew Pugno Doe 1 Ned Dolejsi Confidential legal communication concerning legal questions/issues AC, FA
Client/Attorney regarding television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
80 DEF_INT_PRIV_001451 - Attorney Email string 9/11/2008 Andrew Pugno, Bill Criswell Bill Criswell, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
Work Product;
First Amendment
81 DEF_INT_PRIV_001473 - Attorney Email string 8/29/2008 - Joe Infranco, Jeff Flint, Frank Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Joe Jennifer Kerns, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001479 Client/Attorney 9/2/2008 Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Gary Infranco Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Joe questions/issues regarding the harassment of Prop 8 supporters
Work Product; Lawrence Infranco and related public messaging
First Amendment
82 DEF_INT_PRIV_001480 Attorney Email string 8/29/2008 - Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Steve Linder, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication regarding (1) an AC, FA
Client/Attorney 9/01/2008 Mark Jansson, Steve Linder, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew agreement between the campaign and another organization and (2)
Work Product; Pugno campaign strategy involving that organization
First Amendment
83 DEF_INT_PRIV_001481 - Attorney Email string 8/29/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001484 Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding campaign strategy and finances
Work Product;
First Amendment
DEF_INT_PRIV_001485 - Attorney Email string 8/28/2008 - Doe 1, Andrew Pugno, Joe Andrew Pugno, Doe 1, Joe Infranco Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
84
DEF_INT_PRIV_001492 Client/Attorney 8/29/2008 Infranco questions/issues regarding statements distributed to the public
Work Product;
First Amendment
85 DEF_INT_PRIV_001493 - Attorney Email string 8/11/2008 - Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001498 Client/Attorney 8/27/2008 questions/issues regarding television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
86 DEF_INT_PRIV_001499 - Attorney Email string 8/27/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jim Garlow Jim Garlow, Andrew Pugno Doe 1, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001500 Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding campaign mailer for the public
Work Product;
First Amendment
87 DEF_INT_PRIV_001501 - Attorney Email string 8/12/2008 Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
Work Product;
First Amendment
88 DEF_INT_PRIV_001503 - Attorney Email string 8/8/2008 Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Joe Infranco, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Confidential attorney-client communication regarding ballot title AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001505 Client/Attorney Jennifer Kerns, Does 1-4 Committee Member, Mark Jansson litigation and related messaging/campaign strategy considerations
Work Product;
First Amendment
8 of 99
89 DEF_INT_PRIV_001506 - Attorney Email string 8/4/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jennifer Kerns Andrew Pugno, Jennifer Kerns Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication regarding question from AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001507 Client/Attorney and potential responses for the media
Work Product;
First Amendment
90 DEF_INT_PRIV_001508 - Attorney Email string 07/31/2008 - Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson, Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001524 Client/Attorney 8/1/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint Executive Committee Member questions/issues regarding campaign brochure
Work Product;
First Amendment
91 DEF_INT_PRIV_001525 - Attorney Email string 7/31/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001529 Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding printed campaign materials
Work Product;
First Amendment
92 DEF_INT_PRIV_001530 - Attorney Email string 7/27/2008 - Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence Confidential attorney-client communication regarding ballot title AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001533 Client/Attorney 7/28/2008 Frank Schubert litigation and related messaging/campaign strategy considerations
Work Product;
First Amendment
93 DEF_INT_PRIV_001534 - Attorney Email string 7/22/2008 - Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Doe Joe Infranco, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Confidential attorney-client communication regarding ballot title AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001558 Client/Attorney 7/23/2008 Jennifer Kerns 1, Doe Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Mark Jansson, Doe 1, Doe Executive litigation and related messaging/campaign strategy considerations
Work Product; Sarah Pollo, Nancy Limon, Gary Lawrence Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Jennifer
First Amendment Kerns, Sarah Pollo, Nancy Limon, Gary
Lawrence
94 DEF_INT_PRIV_001559 - Attorney Email string 7/23/2008 Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Joe Infranco, Does 1-2 Doe 3 Confidential attorney-client communication regarding ballot title AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001567 Client/Attorney litigation and related messaging/campaign strategy considerations
Work Product;
First Amendment
95 DEF_INT_PRIV_001568 - Attorney Email string 7/22/2008 - Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe 2, Joe Infranco Confidential attorney-client communication regarding ballot title AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001594 Client/Attorney 7/23/2008 Schubert Mark Jansson, Doe 1, Doe Executive Committee Member, Jeff litigation and related messaging/campaign strategy considerations
Work Product; Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Sarah Pollo, Nancy Limon, Gary Lawrence
First Amendment
96 DEF_INT_PRIV_001595 - Attorney Email string 7/22/2008 - Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Doe Joe Infranco, Gary Lawrence Confidential attorney-client communication regarding ballot initiative AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001596 Client/Attorney 7/23/2008 Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Jennifer Kerns, language
Work Product; Ned Dolejsi
First Amendment
97 DEF_INT_PRIV_001597 - Attorney Email string 7/21/2008 - Joe Infranco, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Joe Infranco Doe 1 Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001599 Client/Attorney 7/22/2008 questions/issues regarding the harassment of Prop 8 supporters
Work Product; and related public messaging
First Amendment
98 DEF_INT_PRIV_001600 - Attorney Email string 7/22/2008 - Joe Infranco, Andrew Pugno, Ned Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Doe Gary Lawrence, Joe Infranco Confidential attorney-client communication regarding ballot initiative AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001614 Client/Attorney Dolejsi Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Gary language
Work Product; Lawrence, Frank Schubert
First Amendment
99 DEF_INT_PRIV_001615 - Attorney Email string 7/21/2008 Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Doe Executive Committee Member, Andrew Pugno Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001622 Client/Attorney Committee Member Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, questions/issues regarding the harassment of Prop 8 supporters
Work Product; Sarah Pollo, Anne Subia, Steve Linder, and related public messaging
First Amendment Does 1-2
9 of 99
100 DEF_INT_PRIV_001623 - Attorney Email string 7/17/2008 - Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Doe Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001626 Client/Attorney 7/18/2008 Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Nancy questions/issues regarding printed campaign materials
Work Product; Limon, Sarah Pollo, Steve Linder, Does 1-2
First Amendment
101 DEF_INT_PRIV_001627 - Attorney Email string 7/17/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Doe Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001629 Client/Attorney Ned Dolejsi Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Sarah questions/issues regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot argument
Work Product; Pollo, Nancy Limon, Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert, Doe 1
First Amendment
102 DEF_INT_PRIV_001630 - Attorney Email string 7/17/2008 Andrew Pugno, Joe Infranco, Doe Joe Infranco, Doe 1, Andrew Pugno Confidential legal communication concerning legal questions/issues AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001635 Client/Attorney 1 regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot argument
Work Product;
First Amendment
103 DEF_INT_PRIV_001636 - Attorney Email string 7/16/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001650 Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot argument
Work Product;
First Amendment
104 DEF_INT_PRIV_001651 - Attorney Email string 7/16/2008 Andrew Pugno Doe 1, Joe Infranco Confidential legal communication concerning legal questions/issues AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001652 Client/Attorney regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot argument
Work Product;
First Amendment
105 DEF_INT_PRIV_001653 - Attorney Email string 7/16/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
Work Product;
First Amendment
106 DEF_INT_PRIV_001665 - Attorney Email string 7/16/2008 Andrew Pugno Doe 1, Joe Infranco Confidential legal communication concerning legal questions/issues AC, FA
Work Product;
First Amendment
Work Product;
First Amendment
108 DEF_INT_PRIV_001672 - Attorney Email string 7/14/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Doe Executive Committee Member, Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001677 Client/Attorney Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert questions/issues regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot argument
Work Product;
First Amendment
109 DEF_INT_PRIV_001678 - Attorney Email string 7/11/2008 - Doe 1, Andrew Pugno, Joe Andrew Pugno, Joe Infranco, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001703 Client/Attorney 7/14/2008 Infranco, Frank Schubert Jansson, Does 1-2 questions/issues regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot argument
Work Product;
First Amendment
110 DEF_INT_PRIV_001704 - Attorney Email string 7/8/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Sarah Pollo Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001707 Client/Attorney Jeff Flint Andrew Pugno questions/issues regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot argument
Work Product;
First Amendment
10 of 99
111 DEF_INT_PRIV_001708 - Attorney Email string 7/7/2008 Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Nancy Nancy Limon, Sarah Pollo Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001732 Client/Attorney Frank Schubert, Sarah Pollo Limon, Sarah Pollo, Gary Lawrence questions/issues regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot argument
Work Product;
First Amendment
112 DEF_INT_PRIV_001733 - Attorney Email string 7/6/2008 - Frank Schubert, Nancy Limon, Nancy Limon, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Frank Sarah Pollo, Nancy Limon Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001782 Client/Attorney 7/7/2008 Andrew Pugno Schubert questions/issues regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot argument
Work Product;
First Amendment
113 DEF_INT_PRIV_001783 - Attorney Email string 7/3/2008 - Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Frank Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001785 Client/Attorney 7/4/2008 Schubert, Sarah Pollo, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Jennifer questions/issues regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot argument
Work Product; Kerns, Mark Jansson, Nancy Limon, Ron Prentice, Steve
First Amendment Linder, Ned Dolejsi, Does 1-2
114 DEF_INT_PRIV_001786 - Attorney Email string 7/3/2008 - Joe Infranco, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Doe 1, Joe Infranco Confidential legal communication concerning legal questions/issues AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001787 Client/Attorney 7/4/2008 regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot argument
Work Product;
First Amendment
115 DEF_INT_PRIV_001788 Attorney Email string 7/3/2008 Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Gary Lawrence, Ron Prentice Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot argument
Work Product;
First Amendment
116 DEF_INT_PRIV_001789 - Attorney Email string 7/3/2008 Joe Infranco, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Doe 1, Joe Infranco Confidential legal communication concerning legal questions/issues AC, FA
Work Product;
First Amendment
117 DEF_INT_PRIV_001791 - Attorney Email string 7/3/2008 Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Frank Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001796 Client/Attorney Frank Schubert Schubert, Sarah Pollo, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Jennifer questions/issues regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot argument
Work Product; Kerns, Mark Jansson, Nancy Limon, Ron Prentice, Steve
First Amendment Linder, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Does 1-2
118 DEF_INT_PRIV_001797 Attorney Email 7/3/2008 Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Ron Prentice, Gary Lawrence Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot argument
Work Product;
First Amendment
119 DEF_INT_PRIV_001798 Attorney Email 6/25/2008 Andrew Pugno Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding overall campaign messaging
Work Product;
First Amendment
120 DEF_INT_PRIV_001799 - Attorney Email string 6/25/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Committee Confidential attorney-client communication regarding press release AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001800 Client/Attorney Andrew Pugno Member
Work Product;
First Amendment
121 DEF_INT_PRIV_001801 - Attorney Email string 6/25/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Confidential attorney-client communication regarding ballot title AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001803 Client/Attorney Member, Mark Jansson litigation and related messaging/campaign strategy considerations
Work Product;
First Amendment
11 of 99
122 DEF_INT_PRIV_001804 - Attorney Email string 6/17/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication regarding legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001808 Client/Attorney precedent relevant to campaign messaging
Work Product;
First Amendment
123 DEF_INT_PRIV_001809 - Attorney Email string 6/13/2008 Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Confidential attorney-client communication regarding public AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001811 Client/Attorney Member, Mark Jansson, Joe Infranco, Frank statement
Work Product; Schubert, Jeff Flint, Dan Kirby
First Amendment
124 DEF_INT_PRIV_001812 - Attorney Email string 5/23/2008 Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Dan Kirby Confidential attorney-client communication regarding blast email AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001813 Client/Attorney
Work Product;
First Amendment
125 DEF_INT_PRIV_001814 Attorney Email 5/23/2008 Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice Confidential attorney-client communication regarding a AC, FA
Client/Attorney ProtectMarriage.com letter
Work Product;
First Amendment
126 DEF_INT_PRIV_001815 - Attorney Email string 5/23/2008 Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Dan Kirby Confidential attorney-client communication regarding blast email AC, FA
Work Product;
First Amendment
127 DEF_INT_PRIV_001817 - Attorney Email string 1/3/2008 Joe Infranco, Lynne Fishel Lynne Fishel, Joe Infranco Andrew Pugno, Glen Lavy, Ron Prentice Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001819 Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding the contents of ProtectMarriage com's
Work Product; website
First Amendment
128 DEF_INT_PRIV_001820 Attorney Email string 11/19/2007 Andrew Pugno, Dan Kirby Dan Kirby, Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
Client/Attorney questions/issues regarding print advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
129 DEF_INT_PRIV_001821 - Attorney Email 10/14/2007 Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice Lynne Fishel, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Confidential attorney-client communication containing legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001822 Client/Attorney Mike Spence, Peter Henderson, Joe discussion about California's marriage laws and
Work Product; Infranco, Does 1-2 ProtectMarriage.com's initiative efforts for use in communicating with
First Amendment the public
130 DEF_INT_PRIV_001823 - Attorney Email string 10/13/2008 Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Confidential attorney-client communication regarding brochure AC, FA
Work Product;
First Amendment
131 DEF_INT_PRIV_001825 - Attorney Email 2/22/2007 Andrew Pugno Joe Infranco, Lynne Fishel, Mark Jansson, Mike Spence, Ned Doe 2 Confidential attorney-client communication regarding initiative AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001826 Client/Attorney Dolejsi, Peter Henderson, Doe 1 language
Work Product;
First Amendment
132 DEF_INT_PRIV_001827 - Attorney Email 1/23/2007 Andrew Pugno, Peter Henderson Joe Infranco, Doe Executive Committee Member, Andrew Peter Henderson Confidential attorney-client communication regarding legal and AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001832 Client/Attorney Pugno strategy issues surrounding a marriage initiative
Work Product;
First Amendment
12 of 99
133 DEF_INT_PRIV_001833 - Attorney Email string with attachment 11/3/2008 Joe Infranco, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Doe 1 Confidential legal discussions concerning legal questions/issues AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001836 Client/Attorney (draft statement) regarding a ProtectMarriage.com public statement
Work Product;
First Amendment
134 DEF_INT_PRIV_001837 - Attorney Email with attachment (draft 11/3/2008 Andrew Pugno Doe 1, Mark Jansson, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Does 2-3 Confidential legal discussions concerning legal questions/issues AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001842 Client/Attorney statement) Executive Committee Member, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip regarding a ProtectMarriage.com public statement
Work Product; White, Gary Lawrence
First Amendment
135 DEF_INT_PRIV_001843 - Attorney Email with attachment (draft 11/2/2008 Andrew Pugno Joe Infranco, Doe 1 Confidential legal discussions concerning legal questions/issues AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001844 Client/Attorney statement) regarding a ProtectMarriage.com public statement
Work Product;
First Amendment
136 DEF_INT_PRIV_001845 - Attorney Email with attachment (draft 11/2/2008 Andrew Pugno Doe 1, Mark Jansson, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Does 2-3 Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001847 Client/Attorney statement) Executive Committee Member, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip questions/issues regarding a ProtectMarriage.com public statement
First Amendment
137 DEF_INT_PRIV_001848 - Attorney Email with attachment (draft 11/2/2008 Andrew Pugno Doe 1 Confidential legal discussions concerning legal questions/issues AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001849 Client/Attorney statement) regarding a ProtectMarriage.com public statement
Work Product;
First Amendment
138 DEF_INT_PRIV_001850 - Attorney Email with attachment (draft 11/2/2008 Andrew Pugno Doe 1, Mark Jansson, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Does 2-3 Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001852 Client/Attorney statement) Executive Committee Member, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip questions/issues regarding a ProtectMarriage.com public statement
First Amendment
139 DEF_INT_PRIV_001853 - Attorney Email string with 10/30/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001855 Client/Attorney attachments (draft print questions/issues regarding a ProtectMarriage.com newspaper
Work Product; advertisement) advertisement
First Amendment
140 DEF_INT_PRIV_001856 - Attorney Email with attachment 10/28/2008 Doe 1 Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication regarding a radio AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001857 Client/Attorney (nonfinal version of advertisement
Work Product; advertisement)
First Amendment
141 DEF_INT_PRIV_001858 - Attorney Email with attachment (legal 10/27/2008 Andrew Pugno Bill Criswell Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001865 Client/Attorney memorandum) Sonja Eddings Brown questions/issues regarding a television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
142 DEF_INT_PRIV_001866 - Attorney Email with attachment 10/24/2008 Doe 1 Andrew Pugno Bill Criswell, Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication regarding a radio AC, FA
First Amendment
143 DEF_INT_PRIV_001868 - Attorney Email with attachment 10/24/2008 Doe 1 Andrew Pugno Bill Criswell, Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication regarding a radio AC, FA
First Amendment
13 of 99
144 DEF_INT_PRIV_001870 - Attorney Email string with attachment 10/24/2008 Bill Criswell, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Bill Criswell, Jeff Flint Doe 1 Confidential attorney-client communication regarding a radio AC, FA
First Amendment
145 DEF_INT_PRIV_001872 - Attorney Email with attachment (legal 10/24/2008 Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Bill Criswell Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001876 Client/Attorney memorandum) Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Doe 1, questions/issues regarding a television advertisement
Work Product; Gary Lawrence, Chip White, Sonja Eddings
First Amendment Brown
146 DEF_INT_PRIV_001877 - Attorney Email with attachment (legal 10/22/2008 Andrew Pugno Doe 1, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson Does 1-3 Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001884 Client/Attorney letter with supporting questions/issues regarding a ProtectMarriage.com letter
Work Product; exhibits)
First Amendment
147 DEF_INT_PRIV_001885 - Attorney Email string with attachment 10/21/2008 Frank Schubert, Bill May Bill Criswell, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001937 Client/Attorney (compilation of legal questions/issues regarding a campaign advertisement
Work Product; research)
First Amendment
148 DEF_INT_PRIV_001938 - Attorney Email with attachment (draft 10/19/2008 Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001942 Client/Attorney legal memorandum) questions/issues regarding a campaign advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
149 DEF_INT_PRIV_001943 - Attorney Email string with attachment 10/17/2008 Andrew Pugno, Bill Criswell Bill Criswell, Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001953 Client/Attorney (legal memorandum) questions/issues regarding a television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
150 DEF_INT_PRIV_001954 - Attorney Email with attachment (draft 10/17/2008 Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001959 Client/Attorney contract) questions/issues regarding an agreement with a third-party
Work Product; organization for the purpose of creating a video promoting
First Amendment Proposition 8
151 DEF_INT_PRIV_001960 - Attorney Email with attachment (draft 10/13/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence Confidential attorney-client communication regarding a television AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001962 Client/Attorney television script) advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
152 DEF_INT_PRIV_001963 - Attorney Email 10/13/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication regarding a television AC, FA
Work Product;
First Amendment
153 DEF_INT_PRIV_001967 - Attorney Email with attachments 10/10/2008 Doe 1 Andrew Pugno Bill Criswell, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001986 Client/Attorney (legal emails and issues/questions regarding a television advertisement
Work Product; memoranda)
First Amendment
154 DEF_INT_PRIV_001987 - Attorney Email string with attachment 10/8/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Bill Criswell, Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001993 Client/Attorney (legal memorandum) issues/questions regarding a television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
14 of 99
155 DEF_INT_PRIV_001994 - Attorney Email with attachment (legal 10/8/2008 Andrew Pugno Bill Criswell Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_001999 Client/Attorney memorandum) issues/questions regarding a television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
156 DEF_INT_PRIV_002000 Attorney Email 10/8/2008 Bill Criswell Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
Client/Attorney issues/questions regarding a television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
157 DEF_INT_PRIV_002001 - Attorney Email 10/8/2008 Bill Criswell Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002002 Client/Attorney issues/questions regarding a television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
158 DEF_INT_PRIV_002003 - Attorney Email string with attachment 9/29/2008 Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Bill Criswell, Jennifer Roback Morse Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002013 Client/Attorney (legal memorandum) Committee Member, Mark Jansson issues/questions regarding a television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
159 DEF_INT_PRIV_002014 - Attorney Email with attachment (legal 9/29/2008 Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Bill Criswell Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002023 Client/Attorney memorandum) Committee Member, Mark Jansson issues/questions regarding a television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
160 DEF_INT_PRIV_002024- Attorney Email with attachments 9/28/2008 Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Richard Peterson, Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002033 Client/Attorney (legal research) issues/questions regarding a television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
161 DEF_INT_PRIV_002034- Attorney Email string with attachment 9/27-28/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication regarding a AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002036 Client/Attorney (draft radio script) ProtectMarriage.com radio advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
162 DEF_INT_PRIV_002037- Attorney Email with attachment (draft 9/27-28/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication regarding a AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002038 Client/Attorney radio script) ProtectMarriage.com radio advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
163 DEF_INT_PRIV_002039- Attorney Email with attachment (legal 9/26/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002041 Client/Attorney memorandum) issues/questions regarding a television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
164 DEF_INT_PRIV_002042- Attorney Email with attachments 9/26/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002087 Client/Attorney (legal materials) issues/questions regarding a television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
165 DEF_INT_PRIV_002088- Attorney Email 9/26/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002091 Client/Attorney issues/questions regarding a television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
15 of 99
166 DEF_INT_PRIV_002092- Attorney Email with attachment 9/25/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002093 Client/Attorney (nonfinal version of questions/issues regarding a television advertisement
Work Product; television advertisement)
First Amendment
167 DEF_INT_PRIV_002094- Attorney Email with attachment (draft 9/23/2008 Andrew Pugno Nancy Limon Confidential attorney-client communication regarding materials AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002096 Client/Attorney statement) prepared for public distribution
Work Product;
First Amendment
168 DEF_INT_PRIV_002097- Attorney Email with attachment (draft 9/23/2008 Nancy Limon Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication regarding materials AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002099 Client/Attorney promotional materials) prepared for public distribution
Work Product;
First Amendment
169 DEF_INT_PRIV_002100- Attorney Email with attachment (draft 9/19/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno Nancy Limon, Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication regarding materials AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002101 Client/Attorney materials) prepared for public distribution
Work Product;
First Amendment
170 DEF_INT_PRIV_002102- Attorney Email string 9/11-12/2008 Bill Criswell, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Bill Criswell Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002110 Client/Attorney Andrew Pugno questions/issues regarding a television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
171 DEF_INT_PRIV_002111- Attorney Email string with 9/15-16/2008 Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Joe Infranco, Doe 1 Confidential legal communication regarding legal research for AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002148 Client/Attorney attachments (legal campaign messaging
Work Product; research)
First Amendment
172 DEF_INT_PRIV_002149- Attorney Email string with attachment 9/12/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002151 Client/Attorney (draft television script) questions/issues regarding a television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
173 DEF_INT_PRIV_002152- Attorney Email with attachment (draft 9/12/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002154 Client/Attorney television script) questions/issues regarding a television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
174 DEF_INT_PRIV_002155- Attorney Email string 09/11- Bill Criswell, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Bill Criswell Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002160 Client/Attorney 12/2008 Andrew Pugno questions/issues regarding a television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
175 DEF_INT_PRIV_002161 - Attorney Email string 09/11- Bill Criswell, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Bill Criswell Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002165 Client/Attorney 12/2008 questions/issues regarding a television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
176 DEF_INT_PRIV_002166- Attorney Email string 09/11- Bill Criswell, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Bill Criswell Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002169 Client/Attorney 12/2008 Andrew Pugno questions/issues regarding a television advertisement
Work Product;
First Amendment
16 of 99
177 DEF_INT_PRIV_002170- Attorney Email with attachment (legal 8/8/2008 Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson Confidential attorney-client communication regarding ballot title AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002174 Client/Attorney materials) litigation and related messaging/campaign strategy considerations
Work Product;
First Amendment
178 DEF_INT_PRIV_002175- Attorney Email string with attachment 07/28- Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication regarding AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002189 Client/Attorney (draft campaign 31/2008 ProtectMarriage.com's printed promotional materials
Work Product; promotional materials)
First Amendment
179 DEF_INT_PRIV_002190- Attorney Email with attachment (draft 7/28/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication regarding AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002199 Client/Attorney campaign promotional ProtectMarriage.com's printed promotional materials
Work Product; materials)
First Amendment
180 DEF_INT_PRIV_002200- Attorney Email with attachment 7/23/2008 Andrew Pugno Joe Infranco, Does 1-2 Confidential legal communication regarding the Proposition 8 ballot AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002219 Client/Attorney (legislative materials) materials
Work Product;
First Amendment
181 DEF_INT_PRIV_002220- Attorney Email with attachment 7/23/2008 Andrew Pugno Doe 1 Confidential legal communication regarding the Proposition 8 ballot AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002239 Client/Attorney (legislative materials) materials
Work Product;
First Amendment
182 DEF_INT_PRIV_002240- Attorney Email string with attachment 7/23/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Joe Infranco, Doe 1 Confidential legal communication concerning legal questions/issues AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002262 Client/Attorney (legislative materials) Doe 1, Ned Dolejsi Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Sarah regarding the Proposition 8 ballot materials
Work Product; Pollo, Nancy Limon, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Does 1-2
First Amendment
183 DEF_INT_PRIV_002263- Attorney Email with attachments 7/17/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Carol Hogan, Mark Confidential attorney-client communication regarding AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002265 Client/Attorney (draft ballot materials) Jansson, Doe Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Gary ProtectMarriage.com's ballot arguments
Work Product; Lawrence, Steve Linder, Nancy Limon, Sarah Pollo
First Amendment
184 DEF_INT_PRIV_002266- Attorney Email string with attachment 7/16/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002268 Client/Attorney (draft ballot argument) questions/issues regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot arguments
Work Product;
First Amendment
185 DEF_INT_PRIV_002269- Attorney Email with attachments 7/16/2008 Frank Schubert Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002271 Client/Attorney (draft ballot materials) questions/issues regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot arguments
Work Product;
First Amendment
186 DEF_INT_PRIV_002272- Attorney Email string with attachment 7/16/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
Work Product;
First Amendment
187 DEF_INT_PRIV_002276- Attorney Email string with attachment 7/16/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
Work Product;
First Amendment
17 of 99
188 DEF_INT_PRIV_002279- Attorney Email string with attachment 7/16/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Doe 1, Joe Infranco Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
Work Product;
First Amendment
189 DEF_INT_PRIV_002283- Attorney Email string with 7/15/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Ron Prentice Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002285 Client/Attorney attachments (draft ballot questions/issues regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot arguments
Work Product; arguments)
First Amendment
190 DEF_INT_PRIV_002286- Attorney Email with attachment (legal 7/11/2008 Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002289 Client/Attorney memorandum) Mark Jansson questions/issues regarding the Proposition 8 ballot arguments
Work Product;
First Amendment
191 DEF_INT_PRIV_002290- Attorney Email with attachment 7/8/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint Sarah Pollo, Nancy Limon Confidential attorney-client communication regarding AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002292 Client/Attorney ProtectMarriage.com's ballot arguments
Work Product;
First Amendment
192 DEF_INT_PRIV_002293- Attorney Email string with attachment 7/7/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Sarah Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002297 Client/Attorney (draft ballot argument) Pollo, Nancy Limon, Frank Schubert questions/issues regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot arguments
Work Product;
First Amendment
193 DEF_INT_PRIV_002298- Attorney Email with attachment (draft 7/7/2008 Frank Schubert Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Sarah Pollo, Nancy Limon Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002300 Client/Attorney ballot argument) questions/issues regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot arguments
Work Product;
First Amendment
194 DEF_INT_PRIV_002301- Attorney Email string with attachment 7/3/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Sarah Pollo, Doe Executive Committee Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002305 Client/Attorney (draft ballot argument) Member, Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, questions/issues regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot arguments
Work Product; Mark Jansson, Nancy Limon, Ron Prentice, Steve Linder,
First Amendment Andrew Pugno, Does 1-2
195 DEF_INT_PRIV_002306- Attorney Email with attachment (draft 7/6/2008 Frank Schubert Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno Sarah Pollo, Nancy Limon Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002308 Client/Attorney ballot argument) questions/issues regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot arguments
Work Product;
First Amendment
196 DEF_INT_PRIV_002309- Attorney Email string with attachment 7/3/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Sarah Pollo, Doe Executive Committee Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
197 DEF_INT_PRIV_002313- Attorney Email with attachment (draft 7/3/2008 Andrew Pugno Doe 1, Joe Infranco Confidential legal communication concerning legal questions/issues AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002315 Client/Attorney ballot argument) regarding ProtectMarriage.com's ballot arguments
Work Product;
First Amendment
198 DEF_INT_PRIV_002316- Attorney Email string with attachment 7/3/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Sarah Pollo, Doe Executive Committee Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
18 of 99
199 DEF_INT_PRIV_002320- Attorney Email string with attachment 7/2/2008 Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence Doe 1, Joe Infranco, Ron Prentice Confidential attorney-client communication discussing legal analysis AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002324 Client/Attorney (legal research relevant to campaign messaging
Work Product; memorandum)
First Amendment
200 DEF_INT_PRIV_002325- Attorney Email with attachment (legal 7/2/2008 Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Doe 1, Joe Infranco, Ron Prentice Confidential attorney-client communication discussing legal analysis AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002328 Client/Attorney research memorandum) relevant to campaign messaging
Work Product;
First Amendment
201 DEF_INT_PRIV_002329- Attorney Email with attachment (draft 6/25/2008 Andrew Pugno Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Doe Executive Confidential attorney-client communication regarding overall AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002342 Client/Attorney focus group questionaire) Committee Member, Mark Jansson campaign messaging
Work Product;
First Amendment
202 DEF_INT_PRIV_002343- Attorney Email string with attachment 6/17/2008 Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Frank Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication discussing legal analysis AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002352 Client/Attorney (legal news release) Schubert relevant to campaign messaging
Work Product;
First Amendment
203 DEF_INT_PRIV_002353- Attorney Email string with attachment 5/23/2008 Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Dan Kirby Dan Kirby Confidential attorney-client communication regarding blast email AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002355 Client/Attorney (draft blast email)
Work Product;
First Amendment
204 DEF_INT_PRIV_002356- Attorney Email with attachment (draft 1/23/2008 Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno, Lynne Fishel Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002360 Client/Attorney promotional materials) issues/questions regarding potential messages to communicate to
Work Product; the public
First Amendment
205 DEF_INT_PRIV_002361- Attorney Email with attachment (draft 12/17/2007 Andrew Pugno Lynne Fishel Ron Prentice Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002362 Client/Attorney webpage) questions/issues regarding the ProtectMarriage.com website
Work Product;
First Amendment
206 DEF_INT_PRIV_002363- Attorney Email string with attachment 11/28/2007 Andrew Pugno, Lynne Fishel Lynne Fishel, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002366 Client/Attorney (draft blast email) issues/questions regarding blast email
Work Product;
First Amendment
207 DEF_INT_PRIV_002367- Attorney Email with attachment (draft 10/12/2007 Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication regarding brochure AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002369 Client/Attorney brochure)
Work Product;
First Amendment
208 DEF_INT_PRIV_002370- Attorney Email with attachment (draft 10/10/2007 Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002372 Client/Attorney brochure) questions/issues regarding a marriage initiative brochure
Work Product;
First Amendment
209 DEF_INT_PRIV_002373- Attorney Email with attachment 3/29/2007 Andrew Pugno Peter Henderson, David Bauer, Joe Infranco, Lynne Fishel, Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002375 Client/Attorney (confidential legal Mark Jansson, Mike Spence, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice issues/questions regarding initiative language
Work Product; memorandum)
First Amendment
19 of 99
210 DEF_INT_PRIV_0023476- Attorney Email string 1/20-21/2007 Andrew Pugno, Peter Henderson Peter Henderson, Andrew Pugno, David Bauer, Joe Infranco, Confidential attorney-client communication regarding initiative AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002378 Client/Attorney Lynne Fishel, Mark Jansson, Mike Spence, Ned Dolejsi, Ron procedures and overall campaign strategy
Work Product; Prentice
First Amendment
211 DEF_INT_PRIV_002379- Attorney Email with attachment (draft 5/23/2008 Ron Prentice Dan Kirby, Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication regarding AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002381 Client/Attorney blast email) ProtectMarriage.com's website
Work Product;
First Amendment
212 DEF_INT_PRIV_002382- Attorney Email with attachment (draft 9/9/2008 Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002383 Client/Attorney blast email) questions/issues regarding a ProtectMarriage.com blast email
Work Product;
First Amendment
213 DEF_INT_PRIV_002384- Attorney Email with attachments 9/3/2008 Jim Garlow Doe 1, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Does 2-4 Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002387 Client/Attorney (draft flyers) questions/issues regarding Proposition 8 promotional materials
Work Product;
First Amendment
214 DEF_INT_PRIV_002388- Attorney Email with attachment (draft 8/27/2008 Jim Garlow Andrew Pugno Doe 1, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002390 Client/Attorney flyer) questions/issues regarding Proposition 8 promotional materials
Work Product;
First Amendment
215 DEF_INT_PRIV_002391- Attorney Email with attachment 8/22/2008 Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Doe Frank Schubert Confidential attorney-client communication regarding potential AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002394 Client/Attorney (video) Executive Committee Member messages to communicate to the public
Work Product;
First Amendment
216 DEF_INT_PRIV_002395- Attorney Email with attachment (draft 8/20/2008 Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning legal AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002398 Client/Attorney flyer) questions/issues regarding a mailer supporting Proposition 8
Work Product;
First Amendment
217 DEF_INT_PRIV_002399- Attorney Email with attachments 7/2/2008 Frank Schubert Sarah Pollo, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Confidential attorney-client communication regarding AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002406 Client/Attorney (draft ballot materials) Member, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Jeff ProtectMarriage.com's ballot arguments
Work Product; Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Mark Jansson, Nancy Limon, Ron
First Amendment Prentice, Steve Linder, Does 1-2
218 DEF_INT_PRIV_002407- Attorney Email with attachment (legal 7/2/2008 Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Doe 1, Joe Infranco, Ron Prentice Confidential attorney-client communication discussing legal analysis AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002410 Client/Attorney memorandum) relevant to campaign messaging
Work Product;
First Amendment
219 DEF_INT_PRIV_002411- Attorney Email string with attachment 7/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Frank Confidential attorney-client communication regarding AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002413 Client/Attorney (draft ballot argument) Schubert ProtectMarriage.com's ballot arguments
Work Product;
First Amendment
220 DEF_INT_PRIV_002414- Attorney Email string with attachment 6/27/2008 Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint Confidential attorney-client communication concerning overall AC, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002431 Client/Attorney (draft focus group campaign messaging
Work Product; questionaire)
First Amendment
20 of 99
221 DEF_INT_PRIV_002432 - First Amendment Email string 11/12/2008 Mark Jansson, Doe 1 Doe 1, Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging and strategy discussions about FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002433 Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Does 2- lessons learned from the effort to pass Proposition 8
4
222 DEF_INT_PRIV_002434 - First Amendment Email string 11/6/2008 Doe 1, Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Jeff Flint, Doe 2, Andrew Pugno, Frank Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussoins about the contents FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002436 Schubert, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe on the ProtectMarriage.com website
Executive Committee Member, Mark
Jansson
223 DEF_INT_PRIV_002437 - First Amendment Email string 11/6/2008 Doe 1, Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Doe 2, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Ron Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions about the contents FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002438 Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive on the ProtectMarriage.com website
Committee Member, Mark Jansson
224 DEF_INT_PRIV_002439 - First Amendment Email string 11/3/2008 Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Doe 1, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002443 Flint, Doe 1 Gary Lawrence Gary Lawrence, Ned Dolejsi, Sonja Eddings preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
Brown, Frank Schubert, Chip White, Does 1-
2
225 DEF_INT_PRIV_002444 - First Amendment Email string 11/3/2008 Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002444 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com email
226 DEF_INT_PRIV_002445 - First Amendment Email string 11/3/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
227 DEF_INT_PRIV_002446 - First Amendment Email string 11/3/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
228 DEF_INT_PRIV_002447 - First Amendment Email 11/2/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002448 Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Mark Jansson, Nancy Limon, preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com email
Meg Waters, Sonja Eddings Brown, Gary Lawrence, Chip
White, Frank Schubert, Does 1-5
229 DEF_INT_PRIV_002449 - First Amendment Email string 11/2/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002449 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com campaign advertisement
230 DEF_INT_PRIV_002450 - First Amendment Email string 10/30/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Andrew Andrew Pugno, Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown, Meg Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002452 Pugno Waters, Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com campaign advertisement
231 DEF_INT_PRIV_002453 - First Amendment Email 10/30/2008 Gary Lawrence Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002453 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com newspaper advertisement
232 DEF_INT_PRIV_002454 - First Amendment Email 10/30/2008 Frank Schubert Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1, Jeff Flint, Ron Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions about a potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002454 Prentice, Andrew Pugno communication to the public
233 DEF_INT_PRIV_002455 - First Amendment Email string 10/29/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Bill Andrew Pugno, Bill Criswell, Nancy Limon, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002457 Criswell, Nancy Limon preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
234 DEF_INT_PRIV_002458 - First Amendment Email string 10/29/2008 Bill Criswell, Nancy Limon, Frank Frank Schubert, Nancy Limon Andrew Pugno, Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002459 Schubert preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
235 DEF_INT_PRIV_002460 - First Amendment Email string 10/29/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Nancy Limon Bill Criswell, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002461 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
236 DEF_INT_PRIV_002462 - First Amendment Email string 10/29/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Nancy Limon, Frank Schubert Bill Criswell, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
237 DEF_INT_PRIV_002464 - First Amendment Email 10/29/2008 Frank Schubert Chip White, Meg Waters, Sonja Eddings Brown Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002464 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
238 DEF_INT_PRIV_002465 - First Amendment Email string 10/27/2008 Nancy Limon, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Bill Criswell, Gary Lawrence, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002468 Frank Schubert Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
239 DEF_INT_PRIV_002469 - First Amendment Email string 10/27/2008 Andrew Pugno, Nancy Limon, Nancy Limon, Frank Schubert, Bill Criswell, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002471 Frank Schubert Flint, Andrew Pugno preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
240 DEF_INT_PRIV_002472 - First Amendment Email string 10/27/2008 Frank Schubert, Nancy Limon Nancy Limon, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Frank Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
241 DEF_INT_PRIV_002474 - First Amendment Email 10/27/2008 Gary Lawrence Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Andrew Pugno Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
242 DEF_INT_PRIV_002475 - First Amendment Email string 10/26/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002476 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com radio advertisement
243 DEF_INT_PRIV_002477 - First Amendment Email string 10/26/2008 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Nancy Limon, Frank Schubert Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002479 Pugno, Nancy Limon preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com campaign advertisement
21 of 99
244 DEF_INT_PRIV_002480 - First Amendment Email string 10/26/2008 Mark Jansson, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Gary Lawrence, Does 2-5 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002481 Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Chip White, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, ProtectMarriage.com advertisements
Mark Jansson
245 DEF_INT_PRIV_002482 - First Amendment Email string 10/26/2008 Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Nancy Andrew Pugno, Nancy Limon, Frank Schubert Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002484 Limon, Frank Schubert preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com radio advertisement
246 DEF_INT_PRIV_002485 - First Amendment Email string 10/24/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Bill May Bill May, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Chip White, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002486 Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi upcoming campaign debate
247 DEF_INT_PRIV_002487 First Amendment Email 10/24/2008 Bill May Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Chip White, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno upcoming campaign debate
248 DEF_INT_PRIV_002488 First Amendment Email 10/24/2008 Gary Lawrence Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com campaign advertisement
249 DEF_INT_PRIV_002489 - First Amendment Email 10/23/2008 Gary Lawrence Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
252 DEF_INT_PRIV_002495 - First Amendment Email 10/23/2008 Ron Prentice Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ned Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002496 Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Doe preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com campaign advertisement
1
253 DEF_INT_PRIV_002497 - First Amendment Email String 10/23/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002498 Ron Prentice Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Chip White, messages communicated to the media
Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1, Frank Schubert
254 DEF_INT_PRIV_002499 - First Amendment Email 10/23/2008 Ron Prentice Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002499 Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Chip White, messages communicated to the media
Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1
255 DEF_INT_PRIV_002500 - First Amendment Email String 10/22/2008 Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Chip Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002501 White, Sonja Eddings Brown preparation of a ProtectMarriage,com news release
256 DEF_INT_PRIV_002502 - First Amendment Email 10/22/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Andrew Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002502 Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, campaign messaging
Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint,

Nancy Limon, Chip White, Does 1-2
257 DEF_INT_PRIV_002503 - First Amendment Email String 10/21/2008 Frank Schubert, Doe 1, Chip White Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002505 Member, Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, campaign messaging
Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Frank Schubert, Does 1-3
258 DEF_INT_PRIV_002506 - First Amendment Email 10/21/2008 Mark Jansson Sarah Pollo, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002506 Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Chip White, Frank preparation of ProtectMarriage com campaign signs
Schubert, Jeff Flint
259 DEF_INT_PRIV_002507 - First Amendment Email String 10/21/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Doe 1, Frank Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002509 Schubert, Chip White Committee Member, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, campaign messaging
Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Ned Dolejsi, Does 1-3
260 DEF_INT_PRIV_002510 - First Amendment Email String 10/21/2008 Doe 1Frank Schubert, Chip White Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002512 Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, campaign messaging
Nancy Limon, Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Does 1-3
261 DEF_INT_PRIV_002513 - First Amendment Email String 10/20/2008 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Jim Bieber, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002514 Pugno preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com mailer
262 DEF_INT_PRIV_002515 - First Amendment Email String 10/20/2008 Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Jim Bieber, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002516 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com mailer
263 DEF_INT_PRIV_002517 - First Amendment Email String 10/20/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jim Bieber, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002519 Jim Bieber preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com mailer

264 DEF_INT_PRIV_002520 - First Amendment Email String 10/20/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Frank Schubert, Jim Bieber, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002521 Jim Bieber preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com mailer
22 of 99
265 DEF_INT_PRIV_002522 - First Amendment Email String 10/20/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jim Bieber Jim Bieber, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
266 DEF_INT_PRIV_002524 - First Amendment Email String 10/20/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Jim Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Jim Bieber, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002525 Bieber preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com mailer
267 DEF_INT_PRIV_002526 - First Amendment Email String 10/20/2008 Jim Bieber, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Jim Bieber Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002527 Flint preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com mailer
268 DEF_INT_PRIV_002528 - First Amendment Email String 10/19/2008 Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Doe Gary Lawrence, Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a video FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002529 Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Gary supporting Proposition 8
Lawrence, Sonja Eddings Brown, Frank Schubert, Does 1-3
269 DEF_INT_PRIV_002530 - First Amendment Email String 10/17/2008 Frank Schubert, Bill May, Ned Bill May, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning media FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002532 Dolejsi Frank Schubert appearances
270 DEF_INT_PRIV_002533 - First Amendment Email String 10/17/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Bill May Bill May, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Pugno,Ned Dolejsi Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning media FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002535 Ned Dolejsi appearances
271 DEF_INT_PRIV_002536 - First Amendment Email String 10/17/2008 Bill May, Ned Dolejsi Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Ned Dolejsi Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning media FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002537 Pugno, Bill May appearances
272 DEF_INT_PRIV_002538 - First Amendment Email String 10/17/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Bill May Bill May, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Pugno Ned Dolejsi Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning media FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002539 appearances
273 DEF_INT_PRIV_002540 - First Amendment Email String 10/17/2008 Frank Schubert, Bill May Bill May, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Ned Dolejsi Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning media FA
274 DEF_INT_PRIV_002542 - First Amendment Email 10/17/2008 Bill May Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Pugno Ned Dolejsi Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning media FA
275 DEF_INT_PRIV_002543 - First Amendment Email 10/16/2008 Bill Criswell Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Andrew Pugno, Kristin Amador Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002547 ProtectMarriage.com radio advertisement
276 DEF_INT_PRIV_002548 - First Amendment Email String 10/15/2008 Frank Schubert, Bill Criswell Bill Criswell, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Frank Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002549 Schubert ProtectMarriage.com campaign advertisement
277 DEF_INT_PRIV_002550 - First Amendment Email String 10/15/2008 Bill Criswell, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Bill Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002550 Criswell ProtectMarriage.com campaign advertisement
278 DEF_INT_PRIV_002551 - First Amendment Email String 10/13/2008 Frank Schubert, Bill Criswell Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002552 ProtectMarriage.com media appearances
279 DEF_INT_PRIV_002553 - First Amendment Email 10/13/2008 Bill Criswell Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002553 ProtectMarriage.com media appearances
280 DEF_INT_PRIV_002554 - First Amendment Email String 10/13/2008 Frank Schubert, Chip White, Ron Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Jeff Sonja Eddings Brown, Nancy Limon, Doe 1, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002560 Prentice, Bill May Flint Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Laura Saucedo ProtectMarriage.com press release
Cunningham, Bill May, Jeff Flint, Andrew
Pugno, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice
281 DEF_INT_PRIV_002561 - First Amendment Email String 10/13/2008 Chip White, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Laura Saucedo Cunningham, Chip Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Sonja Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002567 Schubert, Ron Prentice, Bill May White, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Bill May Eddings Brown, Nancy Limon, Mark ProtectMarriage.com press release
Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Laura Saucedo
Cunningham, Bill May, Jeff Flint, Does 1-2
282 DEF_INT_PRIV_002568 - First Amendment Email String 10/12/2008 Chip White, Frank Schubert, Ron Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Chip White, Ron Prentice, Sonja Eddings Brown, Nancy Limon, Doe 1, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002573 Prentice, Bill May Laura Saucedo Cunningham, Bill May, Jeff Flint Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Laura Saucedo ProtectMarriage.com press release
Cunningham, Bill May, Jeff Flint, Andrew
Pugno, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice
283 DEF_INT_PRIV_002574 - First Amendment Email String 10/10/2008 Chip White, Frank Schubert , Frank Schubert, Nancy Limon, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Sonja Nancy Limon, Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002576 Nancy Limon Eddings Brown Brown, Doe 1 ProtectMarriage.com communications to the public
284 DEF_INT_PRIV_002577 - First Amendment Email String 10/9/2008 Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Frank Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Bill Criswell, Gary Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002578 Schubert Lawrence preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
23 of 99
285 DEF_INT_PRIV_002579 - First Amendment Email String 10/9/2008 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Gary Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Bill Criswell, Frank Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002580 Lawrence Schubert preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
286 DEF_INT_PRIV_002581 - First Amendment Email String 10/9/2008 Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Gary Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Bill Criswell, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002582 Lawrence Jeff Flint preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
287 DEF_INT_PRIV_002583 - First Amendment Email 10/9/2008 Frank Schubert Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
288 DEF_INT_PRIV_002584 - First Amendment Email 10/9/2008 Jeff Flint Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
289 DEF_INT_PRIV_002585 - First Amendment Email 10/9/2008 Gary Lawrence Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
290 DEF_INT_PRIV_002586 - First Amendment Email String 10/8/2008 Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a video FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002587 Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, supporting Proposition 8
Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Frank Schubert, Does 2-4
291 DEF_INT_PRIV_002588 - First Amendment Email String 10/8/2008 Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Bill Criswell, Frank Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
292 DEF_INT_PRIV_002589 - First Amendment Email String 10/8/2008 Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
293 DEF_INT_PRIV_002590 - First Amendment Email String 10/8/2008 Nancy Limon, Frank Schubert, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon Jeff Flint, Bill Criswell, Nancy Limon Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002592 Andrew Pugno, Bill Criswell preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
294 DEF_INT_PRIV_002593 - First Amendment Email String 10/8/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Bill Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon Jeff Flint, Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002594 Criswell preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
295 DEF_INT_PRIV_002595 - First Amendment Email 10/8/2008 Frank Schubert Ned Dolejsi Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002595 potential campaign message
296 DEF_INT_PRIV_002596 - First Amendment Email String 10/7/2008 Jeff Flint, Doe 1 Doe, Doe, Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Frank Schubert, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002597 Jeff Flint potential campaign message
297 DEF_INT_PRIV_002598 - First Amendment Email String 10/4/2008 Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Gary Lawrence, Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002599 Andrew Pugno Schubert Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi campaign messaging
298 DEF_INT_PRIV_002600 - First Amendment Email String 10/3/2008 Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002601 Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi campaign messaging
299 DEF_INT_PRIV_002602 - First Amendment Email String 10/3/2008 Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002603 Andrew Pugno Committee Member, Mark Jansson campaign messaging
300 DEF_INT_PRIV_002604 - First Amendment Email String 10/3/2008 Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002604 Committee Member, Mark Jansson campaign messaging
301 DEF_INT_PRIV_002605 - First Amendment Email 10/3/2008 Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002605 Committee Member, Mark Jansson campaign messaging
302 DEF_INT_PRIV_002606 - First Amendment Email String 10/3/2008 Doe Executive Committee Member, Frank Schubert Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002606 Frank Schubert Gary Lawrence, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi potential campaign message
303 DEF_INT_PRIV_002607 - First Amendment Email 10/3/2008 Frank Schubert Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Bill Criswell, Gary Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002607 Lawrence, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive potential campaign message
Committee Member
304 DEF_INT_PRIV_002608 - First Amendment Email String 10/2/2008 Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Andrew Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a video FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002611 Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint supporting Proposition 8
Member
305 DEF_INT_PRIV_002612 - First Amendment Email String 10/2/2008 Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Andrew Bill Criswell, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002613 Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint, Doe 1, Frank preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Schubert
306 DEF_INT_PRIV_002614 - First Amendment Email String 10/2/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Doe Executive Committee Member, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002617 Schubert, Doe Executive Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Committee Member
307 DEF_INT_PRIV_002618 - First Amendment Email String 10/2/2008 Jeff Flint, Robb Wirthlin Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
308 DEF_INT_PRIV_002619 - First Amendment Email String 10/2/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002621 Doe Executive Committee Member Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
24 of 99
309 DEF_INT_PRIV_002622 - First Amendment Email String 10/2/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Frank Schubert, Doe Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002624 Doe Executive Committee Member Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
310 DEF_INT_PRIV_002625 - First Amendment Email String 10/2/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Andrew Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002627 Pugno, Frank Schubert, Doe Committee Member, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Executive Committee Member
311 DEF_INT_PRIV_002628 - First Amendment Email String 10/2/2008 Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Frank Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002630 Schubert, Doe Executive Member, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Committee Member
312 DEF_INT_PRIV_002631 - First Amendment Email String 10/2/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002632 Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Member, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Ned Doljsi preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Committee Member
313 DEF_INT_PRIV_002633 - First Amendment Email String 10/2/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002634 Doe Executive Committee Member Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
314 DEF_INT_PRIV_002635 - First Amendment Email String 10/2/2008 Frank Schubert, Doe Executive Doe Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002635 Committee Member Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
315 DEF_INT_PRIV_002636 - First Amendment Email 10/2/2008 Doe Executive Committee Member Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002636 Jansson, Andrew Pugno preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
316 DEF_INT_PRIV_002637 - First Amendment Email String 10/2/2008 Dennis Hollingsworth, Andrew Andrew Pugno, Dennis Hollingsworth Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002641 Pugno preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com mailer
317 DEF_INT_PRIV_002642 - First Amendment Email String 10/1/2008 Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Doe Executive Committee Member, Andrew Pugno, Ron Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Ron Prentice, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002644 Committee Member, Jennifer Kerns Prentice Andrew Pugno preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
318 DEF_INT_PRIV_002645 - First Amendment Email String 10/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
319 DEF_INT_PRIV_002647 - First Amendment Email String 10/1/2008 Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Doe Executive Committee Member, Andrew Pugno, Ron Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002650 Committee Member, Jennifer Kerns Prentice Andrew Pugno preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
320 DEF_INT_PRIV_002651 - First Amendment Email String 9/30/2008 Doe Executive Committee Member, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002653 Andrew Pugno, Jennifer Kerns Andrew Pugno preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
321 DEF_INT_PRIV_002654 - First Amendment Email String 10/1/2008 Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Doe 1, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
322 DEF_INT_PRIV_002655 - First Amendment Email String 9/29/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
323 DEF_INT_PRIV_002657- First Amendment Email String 9/29/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
324 DEF_INT_PRIV_002658- First Amendment Email 9/29/2008 Jennifer Roback Morse Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002659 campaign messages
325 DEF_INT_PRIV_002661- First Amendment Email String 9/28/2009 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
326 DEF_INT_PRIV_002663- First Amendment Email String 9/27/2008 Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Doe 1, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Jeff Flint, Doe 2 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002663 preparation of website materials
327 DEF_INT_PRIV_002664- First Amendment Email String 9/26/2008 Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002667 Frank Schubert preparation of overall campaign messaging
328 DEF_INT_PRIV_002668- First Amendment Email String 9/26/2008 Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002670 Frank Shubert preparation of overall campaign messaging
329 DEF_INT_PRIV_002671- First Amendment Email String 9/26/2008 Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002672 Frank Schubert preparation of overall campaign messaging
330 DEF_INT_PRIV_002673- First Amendment Email String 9/26/2008 Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002673 Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Mark Jansson, Does preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisement
1-3
331 DEF_INT_PRIV_002674- First Amendment Email 9/25/2008 Ron Prentice Jennifer Kerns, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ned Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002674 Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson preparation of overall campaign messaging
25 of 99
332 DEF_INT_PRIV_002675- First Amendment Email String 9/23/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002676 preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisement
333 DEF_INT_PRIV_002677- First Amendment Email String 9/23/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002677 Doe Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi preparation of overall campaign messaging
334 DEF_INT_PRIV_002678- First Amendment Email String 9/22/2008 Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002678 Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson preparation of overall campaign messaging
335 DEF_INT_PRIV_002679- First Amendment Email String 9/22/2008 Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002679 Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi preparation of overall campaign messaging
336 DEF_INT_PRIV_002680- First Amendment Email 9/22/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002680 Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi preparation of overall campaign messaging
337 DEF_INT_PRIV_002681- First Amendment Email 9/22/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Andrew Pugno, Doe Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002681 Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Doe preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
1
338 DEF_INT_PRIV_002682- First Amendment Email String 9/22/2008 Jennifer Kerns, Ned Dolejsi, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Mark Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002684 Maggie Gallagher Jansson, Doe Executive Committee Member, Andrew Pugno, campaign messages
Jennifer Kerns
339 DEF_INT_PRIV_002685- First Amendment Email String 9/18/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jim Garlow, Does 1 Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Doe 2 Nonpublic, confidential messaging and strategy discussions FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002686 2 Jim Garlow, Doe 1
340 DEF_INT_PRIV_002687 - First Amendment Email String 9/17/2008 Dennis Hollingsworth, Andrew Andrew Pugno, Dennis Hollingsworth Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002689 Pugno preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
341 DEF_INT_PRIV_002690 - First Amendment Email 9/17/2008 Andrew Pugno Dennis Hollingsworth Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002692 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
342 DEF_INT_PRIV_002693 - First Amendment Email 9/16/2008 Gary Lawrence Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002694 preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisement
343 DEF_INT_PRIV_002695 - First Amendment Email string 9/15/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002697 Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Andrew Pugno, Does 1-3
344 DEF_INT_PRIV_002698 First Amendment Email string 9/14/2008 Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Committee Member, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
345 DEF_INT_PRIV_002699 - First Amendment Email string 9/14/2008 Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
346 DEF_INT_PRIV_002701 - First Amendment Email string 9/14/2008 Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
347 DEF_INT_PRIV_002703 - First Amendment Email string 9/14/2008 Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Ron Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002704 Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Ned Dolejsi, Does 1-3
348 DEF_INT_PRIV_002705 - First Amendment Email string 9/14/2008 Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Ron Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002706 Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
349 DEF_INT_PRIV_002707 - First Amendment Email string 9/14/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Ron Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002708 Gary Lawrence Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
350 DEF_INT_PRIV_002709 - First Amendment Email string 9/14/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Ron Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002710 Gary Lawrence Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
351 DEF_INT_PRIV_002711 - First Amendment Email string 9/13/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Ron Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002712 Ned Dolejsi Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
352 DEF_INT_PRIV_002713 - First Amendment Email string 9/12/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
353 DEF_INT_PRIV_002716 - First Amendment Email string 9/6/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint Joe Infranco, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning potential FA
26 of 99
356 DEF_INT_PRIV_002724 First Amendment Email 9/6/2008 Frank Schubert Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint Joe Infranco, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning potential FA
campaign messages
357 DEF_INT_PRIV_002725 - First Amendment Email string 9/4/2008 Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Doe 1 Ned Dolejsi, Doe 1, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002727 Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert
358 DEF_INT_PRIV_002728 - First Amendment Email string 9/4/2008 Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Doe 1 Ned Dolejsi, Doe 1, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002731 Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
359 DEF_INT_PRIV_002732 First Amendment Email 9/3/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice preparation of overall campaign messaging
360 DEF_INT_PRIV_002733 - First Amendment Email string 9/2/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002734 Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
361 DEF_INT_PRIV_002735 - First Amendment Email string 9/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson, Jeff Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002783 Flint, Gary Lawrence, Ned Dolejsi, Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert
362 DEF_INT_PRIV_002784 - First Amendment Email string 8/28/2008 Dennis Hollingsworth, Andrew Andre Pugno, Dennis Hollingsworth Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
364 DEF_INT_PRIV_002793 First Amendment Email string 8/27/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Committee Member, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Mark Jansson, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Ned Dolejsi
365 DEF_INT_PRIV_002794 First Amendment Email 8/24/2008 Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
366 DEF_INT_PRIV_002795 First Amendment Email string 8/12/2008 Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
preparation of a television advertisement
367 DEF_INT_PRIV_002796 - First Amendment Email string 8/5/2008 Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Steve Jeff Flint, Steve Linder Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002804 Linder preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com blast email
368 DEF_INT_PRIV_002805 - First Amendment Email string 8/4/2008 Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002807 Flint, Doe 1 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com brochure
369 DEF_INT_PRIV_002808 - First Amendment Email string 8/1/2008 Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Mark Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002812 Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Gary Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com brochure
Lawrence
370 DEF_INT_PRIV_002813 - First Amendment Email 7/30/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Doe Doe 1, Jennifer Kerns Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002814 Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice campaign messages
371 DEF_INT_PRIV_002815 - First Amendment Email string 7/30/2008 Mark Jansson, Bill May Bill May, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002821 Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark campaign messages
Jansson
372 DEF_INT_PRIV_002822 - First Amendment Email 7/28/2008 Jennifer Kerns Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Jeff Flint, Sarah Pollo, Nancy Limon Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning an FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002823 upcoming press conference
373 DEF_INT_PRIV_002824 First Amendment Email 7/28/2008 Andrew Pugno Jennifer Kerns Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
upcoming media contact
374 DEF_INT_PRIV_002825 First Amendment Email 7/25/2008 Frank Schubert Jennifer Kerns Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
campaign messaging
375 DEF_INT_PRIV_002826 - First Amendment Email string 7/24/2008 Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002832 Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Sarah preparation of ProtectMarriage com print materials
Pollo, Gary Lawrence, Steve Linder, Frank Schubert, Does 1-3
376 DEF_INT_PRIV_002833 First Amendment Email string 7/22/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Jennifer Kerns, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning potential FA
Jeff Flint campaign messages
27 of 99
377 DEF_INT_PRIV_002834 - First Amendment Email string 7/18/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002838 Doe 1 Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Sarah preparation of ProtectMarriage com print materials
Pollo, Steve Linder, Frank Schubert, Does 1-2
378 DEF_INT_PRIV_002839 - First Amendment Email string 7/16/2008 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Frank Sarah Pollo, Nancy Limon Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002841 Kerns Schubert campaign messaging
379 DEF_INT_PRIV_002842 - First Amendment Email string 7/16/2008 Frank Schubert, Jennifer Kerns, Jennifer Kerns, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Sarah Pollo, Nancy Limon Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002843 Andrew Pugno preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
380 DEF_INT_PRIV_002844 - First Amendment Email string 7/13/2008 Joe Infranco, Andrew Pugno, Gary Andrew Pugno, Joe Infranco, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002847 Lawrence Prentice preparation of ProtectMarriage com's ballot arguments
381 DEF_INT_PRIV_002848 - First Amendment Email string 7/13/2008 Dennis Hollingsworth, Andrew Andrew Pugno, Dennis Hollingsworth Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
382 DEF_INT_PRIV_002851 - First Amendment Email string 7/12/2008 Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Gary Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002853 Lawrence preparation of ProtectMarriage com's ballot arguments
384 DEF_INT_PRIV_002857 - First Amendment Email string 7/12/2008 Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Frank Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002862 Ron Prentice Schubert preparation of ProtectMarriage com's ballot arguments
385 DEF_INT_PRIV_002863 - First Amendment Email string 7/10/2008 Bill Criswell, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Bill Criswell Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Sarah Pollo, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002871 Nancy Limon campaign messages
386 DEF_INT_PRIV_002872 - First Amendment Email string 7/9/2008 Andrew Pugno, Doe 1, Ron Doe 1, Andrew Pugno Steve Linder, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002878 Prentice preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com blast email
387 DEF_INT_PRIV_002879 - First Amendment Email string 7/7/2008 Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002883 Frank Schubert Prentice campaign messaging
388 DEF_INT_PRIV_002884 - First Amendment Email string 7/4/2008 Doe 1, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Joe Infranco, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002886 preparation of ProtectMarriage com's ballot arguments
389 DEF_INT_PRIV_002887 - First Amendment Email string 7/2/2008 Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002888 campaign messaging
390 DEF_INT_PRIV_002889 - First Amendment Email string 7/2/2008 Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Patrick Doe 1, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002891 ProtectMarriage.com's website
391 DEF_INT_PRIV_002892 - First Amendment Email string 7/1/2008 Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Gary Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002894 Lawrence campaign messaging

392 DEF_INT_PRIV_002895 - First Amendment Email string 6/27/2008 Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Gary Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002897 Lawrence Jeff Flint preparation for ProtectMarriage.com's focus groups
393 DEF_INT_PRIV_002898 - First Amendment Email 6/25/2008 Bill May Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Ron Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002899 Prentice ProtectMarriage.com's focus groups
394 DEF_INT_PRIV_002900 First Amendment Email string 6/22/2008 Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Jeff Flint preparation for ProtectMarriage.com's focus groups
395 DEF_INT_PRIV_002901 - First Amendment Email string 6/20/2008 Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002908 Frank Schubert, Committee Member preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
396 DEF_INT_PRIV_002909 First Amendment Email string 6/18/2008 Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
campaign messaging
397 DEF_INT_PRIV_002910 - First Amendment Email string 6/17/2008 Ron Prentice, Bill May, Andrew Bill May, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002914 Pugno preparation for upcoming media appearance
398 DEF_INT_PRIV_002915 - First Amendment Email string 6/16/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002918 Schubert preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com news release
399 DEF_INT_PRIV_002919 - First Amendment Email string 6/16/2008 Bill May, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Bill May, Ron Prentice Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
400 DEF_INT_PRIV_002921 First Amendment Email 6/2/2008 Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
preparation of talking points
401 DEF_INT_PRIV_002922 - First Amendment Email string 6/2/2008 Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002924 preparation of talking points
402 DEF_INT_PRIV_002925 First Amendment Email 5/28/2008 Andrew Pugno Everett Rice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
preparation for upcoming media appearance
404 DEF_INT_PRIV_002934 - First Amendment Email string 5/9/2008 Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
28 of 99
405 DEF_INT_PRIV_002937 - First Amendment Email string 5/2/2008 Dennis Hollingsworth, Andrew Andrew Pugno, Dennis Hollingsworth, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
406 DEF_INT_PRIV_002944 - First Amendment Email string 4/30/2008 Joe Infranco, Ron Prentice Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
407 DEF_INT_PRIV_002946 - First Amendment Email string 4/16/2008 Andrew Pugno, Lynne Fishel Lynne Fishel, Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002947 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com blast email
408 DEF_INT_PRIV_002948 - First Amendment Email string 4/14/2008 Andrew Pugno, Lynne Fishel Lynne Fishel, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002949 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com blast email
409 DEF_INT_PRIV_002950 - First Amendment Email string 4/11/2008 Lynne Fishel, Everett Rice, Ron Everett Rice, Ron Prentice, Lynne Fishel Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002953 Prentice, Andrew Pugno preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
410 DEF_INT_PRIV_002954 - First Amendment Email string 4/11/2008 Joe Infranco, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Doe 1, Joe Infranco Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002958 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com message for public distribution
412 DEF_INT_PRIV_002959 - First Amendment Email string 3/17/2008 Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
414 DEF_INT_PRIV_002968 - First Amendment Email string 3/2/2008 Andrew Pugno Dennis Hollingsworth Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
415 DEF_INT_PRIV_002972 - First Amendment Email string 2/25/2008 Andrew Pugno Dennis Hollingsworth Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_002979 Pugno preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com message for public distribution
418 DEF_INT_PRIV_002983 - First Amendment Email string 2/19/2008 Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Dennis Hollingsworth Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
419 DEF_INT_PRIV_002987 - First Amendment Email string 2/18/2008 Dennis Hollingsworth, Andrew Andrew Pugno, Dennis Hollingsworth Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
421 DEF_INT_PRIV_002999 - First Amendment Email string 1/11/2008 Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Doe 1, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
422 DEF_INT_PRIV_003004 - First Amendment Email 1/9/2008 Andrew Pugno Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003005 preparation of a message for public distribution
423 DEF_INT_PRIV_003006 - First Amendment Email string 1/4/2008 Andrew Pugno, Maggie Gallagher Maggie Gallagher, Brian Brown, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential correspondence discussing messaging and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003007 strategy for a fundraising event
424 DEF_INT_PRIV_003008 - First Amendment Email string 12/19/2007 Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
425 DEF_INT_PRIV_003011 - First Amendment Email string 12/18/2007 Dennis Hollingsworth, Andrew Andrew Pugno, Dennis Hollingsworth, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
426 DEF_INT_PRIV_003017 - First Amendment Email string 7/19/2007 Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Ron Prentice, Lynne Fishel, Peter Henderson, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003018 preparation of Proposition 8's language
427 DEF_INT_PRIV_003019 - First Amendment Email string 5/24/2007 Andrew Pugno, Peter Henderson Peter Henderson, Joe Infranco, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Lynne Fishel, Mike Spence, Mark Jansson, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003020 Ned Dolejsi preparation of Proposition 8's language

428 DEF_INT_PRIV_003021 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 11/3/2008 Chip White, Frank Schubert, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Doe 1, Gary Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003026 (draft press release) Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Doe 1 Lawrence, Ron Prentice Gary Lawrence, Ned Dolejsi, Sonja Eddings preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
Brown, Chip White, Does 1-2
29 of 99
429 DEF_INT_PRIV_003027 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 11/3/2008 Jeff Flint, Doe 1 Doe 1, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Frank Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003030 (draft press release) Gary Lawrence Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Ned Dolejsi, preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 2, Chip White
430 DEF_INT_PRIV_003031 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 11/3/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003032 blast email) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com blast email
431 DEF_INT_PRIV_003032 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/30/2008 Frank Schubert Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003035 advertisement) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com newspaper advertisement
432 DEF_INT_PRIV_003036 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/29/2008 Frank Schubert Nancy Limon Bill Criswell, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003038 advertisement) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
433 DEF_INT_PRIV_003039 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/27/2008 Nancy Limon, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Bill Criswell, Gary Lawrence, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003042 (draft advertisement) Frank Schubert Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
434 DEF_INT_PRIV_003043 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/27/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Bill Criswell, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Nancy Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003046 (draft advertisement) Limon, Andrew Pugno preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
435 DEF_INT_PRIV_003047 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/27/2008 Frank Schubert Bill Criswell, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon Andrew Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003049 advertisement) Pugno preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
436 DEF_INT_PRIV_003050 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/27/2008 Nancy Limon, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003052 (draft advertisement) Nancy Limon preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
437 DEF_INT_PRIV_003053 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/27/2008 Frank Schubert Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Nancy Limon Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
438 DEF_INT_PRIV_003055 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/26/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Bill Criswell, Frank Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003057 (draft advertisement) Schubert preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com radio advertisement
439 DEF_INT_PRIV_003058 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/26/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003060 (draft advertisement) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com radio advertisement
440 DEF_INT_PRIV_003061 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/26/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003062 (draft advertisement) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com radio advertisement
441 DEF_INT_PRIV_003063 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/26/2008 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Bill May Jeff Flint, Chip White, Frank Schubert, Bill May Sonja Eddings Brown, Andrew Pugno, Meg Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003066 (draft message) Waters, Jeff Flint preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com statement
442 DEF_INT_PRIV_003067 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/26/2008 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Bill May Jeff Flint, Chip White, Frank Schubert, Bill May Sonja Eddings Brown, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003070 (draft campaign statement) Flint, Frank Schubert preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com statement
443 DEF_INT_PRIV_003071 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/26/2008 Andrew Pugno, Nancy Limon, Nancy Limon, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003076 (draft advertisement) Frank Schubert preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
444 DEF_INT_PRIV_003077 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/25/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Nancy Limon Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
445 DEF_INT_PRIV_003080 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/24/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003081 advertisement) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com radio advertisement
446 DEF_INT_PRIV_003082 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/23/2008 Frank Schubert Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
448 DEF_INT_PRIV_003090 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/23/2008 Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Frank Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003093 (draft advertisement) Schubert preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement

450 DEF_INT_PRIV_003098 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/23/2008 Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Chip Frank Schubert, Chip White, Jeff Flint, Does 1-2 Doe 3, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003102 (draft press release) White preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
30 of 99
451 DEF_INT_PRIV_003103 - First Amendment Email with attachment 10/22/2008 Bill May Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Chip White Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003104 (document considered in messages communicated by ProtectMarriage.com
developing messaging)
452 DEF_INT_PRIV_003105 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/22/2008 Frank Schubert, Bill Criswell Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003106 (nonfinal version of preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com radio advertisement
advertisement)
453 DEF_INT_PRIV_003107 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/22/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
454 DEF_INT_PRIV_003109 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/22/2008 Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Chip White, Sonja Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003115 letter with exhibits) Eddings Brown preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com news release
455 DEF_INT_PRIV_003116 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/22/2008 Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint, Chip White, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003118 (draft letter) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
456 DEF_INT_PRIV_003119 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/22/2008 Ron Prentice, Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003121 (draft message) Member, Doe 2, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Member, Mark Jansson, Does 3-4 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
Jeff Flint
457 DEF_INT_PRIV_003122 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/21/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003128 (draft advertisement) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
458 DEF_INT_PRIV_003129 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/21/2008 Frank Schubert, Bill Criswell, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Bill Criswell Jeff Flint, Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003133 (nonfinal version of preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
advertisement)
459 DEF_INT_PRIV_003134 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/21/2008 Frank Schubert, Doe 1, Bill May Doe 1, Frank Schubert, Bill May Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe 2, Ned Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003137 (draft advertisement) Dolejsi preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com advertisement
460 DEF_INT_PRIV_003138 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/21/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
461 DEF_INT_PRIV_003141 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/20/2008 Andrew Pugno Jim Bieber, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003143 message) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com mailer
462 DEF_INT_PRIV_003144 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/20/2008 Jim Bieber Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003146 flyer) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com mailer
463 DEF_INT_PRIV_003147 - First Amendment Email with attachment 10/19/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Doe Gary Lawrence, Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a video FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003148 (video) Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice supporting Proposition 8
464 DEF_INT_PRIV_003149 - First Amendment Email string 10/17/2008 Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Doe 1, Andrew Pugno, Doe Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003152 Jansson, Doe 1 Executive Committee Member, Ron Prentice, Chip White, Jeff preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
Flint, Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson
465 DEF_INT_PRIV_003153 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/17/2008 Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert, Frank Schubert, Doe 1, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003157 (draft letter) Doe 1 Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Chip White, preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
Jeff Flint, Mark Jansson
466 DEF_INT_PRIV_003158 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/16/2008 Bill Criswell, Frank Schubert, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Bill Criswell, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003161 (nonfinal version of Andrew Pugno preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
advertisement)
467 DEF_INT_PRIV_003162 - First Amendment Email with attachment 10/16/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003163 (nonfinal version of preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
advertisement)
469 DEF_INT_PRIV_003167 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/14/2008 Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003169 letter) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com fundraising letter

471 DEF_INT_PRIV_003173 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/13/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Bill Criswell, Frank Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003176 (draft advertisement) Gary Lawrence Schubert preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
31 of 99
DEF_INT_PRIV_003181 advertisements) preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
474 DEF_INT_PRIV_003185 - First Amendment Email string 10/8/2008 Bill Criswell Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Does 1-2 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003187 ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
475 DEF_INT_PRIV_003188 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/4/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003195 media and messaging plan) Dolejsi, Ron Prentice ProtectMarriage.com's campaign strategy and messaging
476 DEF_INT_PRIV_003196 - First Amendment Email string with 10/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Bill Criswell Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon Jeff Flint, Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003198 attachments (draft preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
advertisements)
477 DEF_INT_PRIV_003199 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003203 (draft print advertisement) Doe 1 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com print advertisement
478 DEF_INT_PRIV_003204 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/1/2008 Doe 1 Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003206 materials for campaign preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com mailer
mailer)
479 DEF_INT_PRIV_003207 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/1/2008 Andrew Pugno Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003211 letter) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com mailer
481 DEF_INT_PRIV_003217 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/1/2008 Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
482 DEF_INT_PRIV_003222 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/1/2008 Andrew Pugno Dennis Hollingsworth Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
483 DEF_INT_PRIV_003231 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/30/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning the FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003233 opinion editorial) preparation of writings distributed to the media
485 DEF_INT_PRIV_003237 - First Amendment Email with attachments 9/29/2008 Frank Schubert Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003248 (draft advertisements) preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
486 DEF_INT_PRIV_003249 - First Amendment Email with attachment 9/28/2008 Frank Schubert Richard Peterson, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging and strategy discussions FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003280 (internal materials for press regarding an upcoming ProtectMarriage.com press conference
conference)
487 DEF_INT_PRIV_003281 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/26/2008 Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003287 website pages) preparation of materials posted on the internet
488 DEF_INT_PRIV_003288 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/26/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003292 letter) Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Does 1-3 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
489 DEF_INT_PRIV_003293 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 9/26/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003303 (draft advertisements) preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
490 DEF_INT_PRIV_003304 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/22/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003306 letter) Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Doe preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
1
491 DEF_INT_PRIV_003307 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/21/2008 Frank Schubert Richard Peterson Bill Criswell, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003311 advertisements) preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
492 DEF_INT_PRIV_003312 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 9/17/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003315 (draft letter) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com mailer
493 DEF_INT_PRIV_003316 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/17/2008 Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
494 DEF_INT_PRIV_003320 First Amendment Email 9/17/2008 Jennifer Kerns Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Jansson preparation of public comments
495 DEF_INT_PRIV_003321 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/16/2008 Mark Jansson Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003323 letter) Committee Member, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
32 of 99
496 DEF_INT_PRIV_003324 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/15/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003328 advertisements) Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Does 1-3
497 DEF_INT_PRIV_003329 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/13/2008 Ron Prentice Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003331 letter) Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
498 DEF_INT_PRIV_003332 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/13/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003336 advertisements) Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Does 1-3
DEF_INT_PRIV_003339 advertisement) Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Does 1-3
500 DEF_INT_PRIV_003340 - First Amendment Email with attachment 9/10/2008 Frank Schubert Bill Criswell, Doe 1, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003345 (confidential campaign preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
research)
501 DEF_INT_PRIV_003346 - First Amendment Email with attachments 9/9/2008 Doe 1 Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003349 (nonfinal phone recordings) preparation of messages for the public
502 DEF_INT_PRIV_003350 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/9/2008 Andrew Pugno Dennis Hollingsworth Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003352 phone script) preparation of messages for the public
503 DEF_INT_PRIV_003353 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 9/3/2008 Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Doe 1, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003358 (draft advertisement) Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Frank Schubert
504 DEF_INT_PRIV_003359 - First Amendment Email String 9/3/2008 Mark Jansson, Doe 1, Frank Doe 1, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003360 Schubert Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Frank Schubert
505 DEF_INT_PRIV_003361 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/2/2008 Frank Schubert Doe 1, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003371 advertisements) Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
506 DEF_INT_PRIV_003372 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/1/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003376 advertisements) Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
507 DEF_INT_PRIV_003377 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 9/1/2008 Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003381 (material considered in Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Ned Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
developing messaging) Dolejsi Mark Jansson
508 DEF_INT_PRIV_003382 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 9/1/2008 Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert, Jeff Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003386 (draft advertisement) Flint, Gary Lawrence, Ned Dolejsi Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Mark Jansson
509 DEF_INT_PRIV_003387 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 9/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Gary Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003391 (draft advertisement) Lawrence, Ned Dolejsi Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Mark Jansson
510 DEF_INT_PRIV_003392 - First Amendment Email with attachments 8/31/2008 Frank Schubert Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Doe Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003400 (draft advertisements) Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
DEF_INT_PRIV_003408 messaging memorandum) Member, Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Mark Jansson preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
514 DEF_INT_PRIV_003416 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 8/12/2008 Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
515 DEF_INT_PRIV_003421 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 8/11/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003423 advertisement) preparation of ProtectMarriage com advertisement

516 DEF_INT_PRIV_003424 - First Amendment Email string 8/8/2008 Jennifer Kerns, Frank Schubert, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Jennifer Kerns Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003426 Jeff Flint preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com news release
33 of 99
517 DEF_INT_PRIV_003427 - First Amendment Email string 8/8/2008 Jennifer Kerns, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Jennifer Kerns Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003429 Flint, Frank Schubert preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com news release
518 DEF_INT_PRIV_003430 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 8/8/2008 Jennifer Kerns Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003432 press release) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com news release
519 DEF_INT_PRIV_003433 - First Amendment Email with attachments 8/7/2008 Jennifer Kerns Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003437 (draft press releases) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com news release
520 DEF_INT_PRIV_003438 - First Amendment Email with attachment 8/4/2008 Frank Schubert Jennifer Kerns, Jeff Flint Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003450 (research materials) Jansson, Ned Dolejsi preparation for an upcoming media meeting
521 DEF_INT_PRIV_003451 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 8/4/2008 Jeff Flint Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003455 flyer) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com brochure
522 DEF_INT_PRIV_003456 - First Amendment Email with attachment 8/4/2008 Jennifer Kerns Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Jennifer Roback Morse Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003467 (research materials) preparation for an upcoming media meeting
523 DEF_INT_PRIV_003468 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 8/4/2008 Jeff Flint, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003472 flyer) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com brochure
524 DEF_INT_PRIV_003473 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 7/31/2008 Jeff Flint Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003477 (draft promotional Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com brochure
materials)
525 DEF_INT_PRIV_003478 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 7/27/2008 Jennifer Kerns Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003485 talking points) preparation of messages for the public
526 DEF_INT_PRIV_003486 - First Amendment Email with attachments 7/24/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003496 (draft promotional Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Sarah preparation of ProtectMarriage com print materials
materials) Pollo, Gary Lawrence, Steve Linder, Does 1-3
527 DEF_INT_PRIV_003497 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 7/23/2008 Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003499 (material considered in Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, preparation of ProtectMarriage com print materials
developing messaging) Nancy Limon, Sarah Pollo, Steve Linder, Does 1-2
528 DEF_INT_PRIV_003500 - First Amendment Email with attachments 7/22/2008 Frank Schubert Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003510 (draft promotional Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Sarah preparation of ProtectMarriage com print materials
materials) Pollo, Steve Linder, Jennifer Kerns, Does 1-2
529 DEF_INT_PRIV_003511 - First Amendment Email with attachment 7/21/2008 Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003512 (material considered in messages communicated to the public
530 DEF_INT_PRIV_003513 - First Amendment Email with attachments 7/17/2008 Frank Schubert Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003520 (draft promotional Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Sarah preparation of ProtectMarriage com print materials
materials) Pollo, Steve Linder, Does 1-2
531 DEF_INT_PRIV_003521 - First Amendment Email string 7/16/2008 Jennifer Kerns, Frank Schubert, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003523 Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Jennifer Kerns preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
Pugno
532 DEF_INT_PRIV_003524 - First Amendment Email string 7/16/2008 Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003526 Pugno, Jennifer Kerns Jennifer Kerns preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
533 DEF_INT_PRIV_003527 - First Amendment Email string 7/16/2008 Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003528 Pugno, Jennifer Kerns Jennifer Kerns preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
534 DEF_INT_PRIV_003529 - First Amendment Email string 7/16/2008 Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003531 Jennifer Kerns, Jeff Flint, Andrew Jennifer Kerns preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
Pugno
535 DEF_INT_PRIV_003532 - First Amendment Email string 7/16/2008 Ron Prentice, Jennifer Kerns, Jeff Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003533 Flint, Andrew Pugno Jennifer Kerns preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
536 DEF_INT_PRIV_003534 - First Amendment Email string 7/16/2008 Jennifer Kerns, Frank Schubert, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003536 Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno Jennifer Kerns preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
537 DEF_INT_PRIV_003537 - First Amendment Email string 7/16/2008 Frank Schubert, Jennifer Kerns, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003539 Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno Jennifer Kerns preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
538 DEF_INT_PRIV_003540 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 7/16/2008 Jennifer Kerns, Jeff Flint, Andrew Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003543 (draft press release) Pugno Jennifer Kerns preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
539 DEF_INT_PRIV_003544 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 7/15/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003545 ballot argument) Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Doe 1 preparation of ProtectMarriage com's ballot arguments
34 of 99
540 DEF_INT_PRIV_003546 - First Amendment Email with attachments 7/12/2008 Andrew Pugno Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003550 (draft letter) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com mailer
541 DEF_INT_PRIV_003551 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 7/12/2008 Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice Frank Schuber, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003553 letter) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
542 DEF_INT_PRIV_003554 First Amendment Email 7/11/2008 Jennifer Kerns Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Sarah Pollo, Nancy Limon Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning media FA
appearance
543 DEF_INT_PRIV_003555 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 7/9/2008 Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Jennifer Jennifer Kerns, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Doe Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Ron Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003560 (draft ballot arguments) Kerns 1 Prentice, Jeff Flint messages to communicate to the media
544 DEF_INT_PRIV_003561 - First Amendment Email string 7/9/2008 Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Jennifer Andrew Pugno, Jennifer Kerns, Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003562 Kerns messages to communicate to the media
545 DEF_INT_PRIV_003563 - First Amendment Email string with 7/9/2008 Doe 1, Ron Prentice, Andrew Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Steve Linder, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003569 attachments (draft blast Pugno preparation of ProtectMarriage com letters
emails)
546 DEF_INT_PRIV_003570 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 7/9/2008 Doe 1, Ron Prentice, Andrew Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Steve Linder, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003573 (draft blast email) Pugno preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
547 DEF_INT_PRIV_003574 - First Amendment Email string with 7/8/2008 Doe 1, Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Steve Linder, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003579 attachments (draft blast preparation of ProtectMarriage com letters
emails)
548 DEF_INT_PRIV_003580 - First Amendment Email with attachments 7/8/2008 Doe 1 Andrew Pugno Steve Linder, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003584 (draft blast emails) preparation of ProtectMarriage com letters
549 DEF_INT_PRIV_003585 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 7/7/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Sarah Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003587 ballot argument) Pollo, Nancy Limon preparation of ProtectMarriage com's ballot arguments
550 DEF_INT_PRIV_003588 - First Amendment Email with attachment 7/7/2008 Gary Lawrence Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003589 (confidential campaign campaign messaging
research)
551 DEF_INT_PRIV_003590 - First Amendment Email with attachment 7/7/2008 Gary Lawrence Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003593 (campaign messaging campaign messaging
memorandum)
552 DEF_INT_PRIV_003594 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 7/7/2008 Frank Schubert Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003600 agenda) messaging and strategy
DEF_INT_PRIV_003602 promotional mailer) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com mailer
554 DEF_INT_PRIV_003603 - First Amendment Email with attachment 7/3/2008 Sarah Pollo Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003608 (minutes from strategy Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Jeff messaging and strategy
meeting) Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Mark Jansson, Nancy Limon, Steve
Linder, Does 1-3
555 DEF_INT_PRIV_003609 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 7/2/2008 Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003613 (draft ballot arguments) preparation of ProtectMarriage com's ballot arguments
556 DEF_INT_PRIV_003614 - First Amendment Email with attachments 7/2/2008 Frank Schubert Sarah Pollo, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003621 (draft ballot arguments) Member, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Jeff preparation of ProtectMarriage com's ballot arguments
Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Mark Jansson, Nancy Limon, Ron
Prentice, Steve Linder, Does 1-2
557 DEF_INT_PRIV_003622 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 7/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Frank Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003624 (draft ballot arguments) Schubert preparation of ProtectMarriage com's ballot arguments
558 DEF_INT_PRIV_003625 - First Amendment Email with attachment 7/1/2008 Gary Lawrence Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
research)
559 DEF_INT_PRIV_003628 - First Amendment Email with attachment 7/1/2008 Gary Lawrence Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
research)
560 DEF_INT_PRIV_003631 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 6/27/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003648 (confidential campaign Gary Lawrence Andrew Pugno preparation for ProtectMarriage.com's focus groups
research)
35 of 99
561 DEF_INT_PRIV_003649 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 6/25/2008 Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003662 (draft of confidential Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert preparation for ProtectMarriage.com's focus groups
campaign research)
562 DEF_INT_PRIV_003663 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/25/2008 Andrew Pugno Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003676 of confidential campaign Committee Member, Mark Jansson preparation for ProtectMarriage.com's focus groups
research)
563 DEF_INT_PRIV_003677 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/25/2008 Gary Lawrence Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003690 of confidential campaign Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert preparation for ProtectMarriage.com's focus groups
research)
564 DEF_INT_PRIV_003691 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/24/2008 Gary Lawrence Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003705 of confidential campaign Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice preparation for ProtectMarriage.com's focus groups
research)
565 DEF_INT_PRIV_003706 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/22/2008 Gary Lawrence Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003728 of confidential campaign preparation for ProtectMarriage.com's focus groups
research)
566 DEF_INT_PRIV_003729 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/22/2008 Andrew Pugno Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003753 of confidential campaign preparation for ProtectMarriage.com's focus groups
research)
567 DEF_INT_PRIV_003754 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 6/22/2008 Frank Schubert, Jim Garlow Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003758 (draft campaign messaging) campaign messaging
568 DEF_INT_PRIV_003759 - First Amendment Email with attachment 6/21/2008 Gary Lawrence Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003780 (confidential campaign preparation for ProtectMarriage.com's focus groups
research)
569 DEF_INT_PRIV_003781 - First Amendment Email string 6/20/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003783 Committee Member preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
570 DEF_INT_PRIV_003784 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 6/20/2008 Andrew Pugno, Bill May Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003786 (confidential messaging campaign messaging
memorandum)
571 DEF_INT_PRIV_003787 - First Amendment Email with attachment 6/20/2008 Bill May Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
memorandum)
572 DEF_INT_PRIV_003790 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 6/19/2008 Andrew Pugno, Bill May Gary Lawrence, Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003795 (confidential talking points) campaign messaging
573 DEF_INT_PRIV_003796 - First Amendment Email with attachment 6/19/2008 Andrew Pugno Gary Lawrence Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
memorandum)
574 DEF_INT_PRIV_003801 - First Amendment Email with attachments 6/18/2008 Andrew Pugno Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003814 (confidential talking points) campaign messaging
575 DEF_INT_PRIV_003815 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/16/2008 Bill May Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003816 talking points) preparation for upcoming media appearance
576 DEF_INT_PRIV_003817 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 6/16/2008 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003824 (draft media advisory) Prentice, Andrew Pugno campaign messaging and media plan
577 DEF_INT_PRIV_003825 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 5/23/2008 Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
578 DEF_INT_PRIV_003828 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 5/16/2008 Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice Dan Kirby Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
36 of 99
581 DEF_INT_PRIV_003837 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 4/22/2008 Lynne Fishel Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003839 press release) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
DEF_INT_PRIV_003845 phone script) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com radio advertisement
DEF_INT_PRIV_003854 phone scripts) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com telephone script
588 DEF_INT_PRIV_003855 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 2/19/2008 Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003857 (draft phone scripts) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com telephone script
590 DEF_INT_PRIV_003864 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 2/13/2008 Lynne Fishel, Joe Infranco, Andrew Joe Infranco, Andrew Pugno, Lynne Fishel Ron Prentice, Does 1-2 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003867 (draft campaign document) Pugno preparation of communications for the public
598 DEF_INT_PRIV_003893 - First Amendment Email string 9/22/2008 Frank Schubert, Jennifer Kerns Jennifer Kerns, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Gary Lawrence, Mark A. Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning an FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003894 Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive internet advertisement
Committee Member, Bill Criswell, Andrew
Pugno, Does 1-2
599 DEF_INT_PRIV_003895 - First Amendment Email string 9/2-3/2008 Mark A. Jansson, Frank Schubert, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003897 Doe 1 Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Gary preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Doe 1
600 DEF_INT_PRIV_003898- First Amendment Email string 9/2-3/2008 Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003899 Doe 1 Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Gary preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Doe 1
601 DEF_INT_PRIV_003900- First Amendment Email 8/5/2008 Mark Jansson Does 1-4 Nonpublic, confidential correspondence regarding campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003901 messaging
602 DEF_INT_PRIV_003902- First Amendment Email string 8/4/2008 Frank Schubert, Jennifer Kerns Jennifer Kerns, Jeff Flint Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003914 Jansson, Ned Dolejsi preparation for upcoming meeting with media
603 DEF_INT_PRIV_003915- First Amendment Email string 8/4/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003916 Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Steve Linder, Mark Jansson preparation of a communication for the public
604 DEF_INT_PRIV_003917- First Amendment Email string 7/22-23/2008 Jennifer Kerns, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Ron Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003921 Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
Doe 1 Nancy Limon, Sarah Pollo, Jennifer Kerns, Steve Linder, Does
1-2
37 of 99
605 DEF_INT_PRIV_003922- First Amendment Email string 7/22-23/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Nancy Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003925 Kerns, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Limon, Sarah Pollo, Jennifer Kerns, Steve Linder, Does 1-2 preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
Schubert, Doe 1
606 DEF_INT_PRIV_003926- First Amendment Email string 7/22-23/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Andrew Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003929 Kerns, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Nancy Limon, Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Doe 1 preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
Sarah Pollo, Steve Linder, Jennifer Kerns, Does 1-2
607 DEF_INT_PRIV_003930- First Amendment Email string 7/17-18/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003931 Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Sarah preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
Pollo, Jennifer Kerns, Steve Linder, Does 1-2
608 DEF_INT_PRIV_003932- First Amendment Email 6/24/2008 Mark Jansson Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential correspondence transmitting draft talking FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003933 points supporting Proposition 8
609 DEF_INT_PRIV_003934- First Amendment Email string 11/3-4/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003936 Andrew Pugno Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings preparation of ProtectMarriage com's public statements
Brown, Gary Lawrence, Chip White, Does 1-3
610 DEF_INT_PRIV_003937- First Amendment Email string 11/3-4/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003938 Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings preparation of ProtectMarriage com's public statements
611 DEF_INT_PRIV_003939 First Amendment Email 11/3/2008 Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Does 2-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Prentice preparation of ProtectMarriage com's public statements
612 DEF_INT_PRIV_003940- First Amendment Email string 11/2/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003941 Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Mark Jansson, Nancy Limon, ProtectMarriage.com blast email
Meg Waters, Sonja Eddings Brown, Gary Lawrence, Chip
White, Gary Lawrence, Does 1-5
613 DEF_INT_PRIV_003942- First Amendment Email string 10/28/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence, Frank Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Ron Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003945 Schubert Prentice, Mark Jansson, Does 1-2 preparation of a Proposition 8 advertisement
614 DEF_INT_PRIV_003946- First Amendment Email string 10/28/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Ron Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003948 Gary Lawrence Prentice, Mark Jansson, Does 1-2 preparation of a Proposition 8 advertisement
615 DEF_INT_PRIV_003949- First Amendment Email string 10/28/2008 Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Ron Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003951 Prentice, Mark Jansson, Does 1-2 preparation of a Proposition 8 advertisement
616 DEF_INT_PRIV_003952- First Amendment Email string 10/28/2008 Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Ron Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
617 DEF_INT_PRIV_003955- First Amendment Email 10/28/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Ron Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
618 DEF_INT_PRIV_003958 First Amendment Email 10/28/2008 Frank Schubert Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Meg Waters, Gary Lawrence, Ron Prentice, Andrew Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Nancy Limon, Sarah Pollo Pugno, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive ProtectMarriage.com's messaging
Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Does 1-2
619 DEF_INT_PRIV_003959- First Amendment Email string 10/25- Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Gary Lawrence, Mark Jansson, Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003960 26/2008 Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Chip White, Jeff Flint ProtectMarriage.com advertisements
620 DEF_INT_PRIV_003961- First Amendment Email 10/26/2008 Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Gary Lawrence, Mark Jansson, Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003962 Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Chip White, Frank ProtectMarriage.com advertisements
621 DEF_INT_PRIV_003963 First Amendment Email string 10/26/2008 Mark Jansson Doe 1 Doe 2 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
preparation of ProtectMarriage com's overall campaign messaging
622 DEF_INT_PRIV_003964 First Amendment Email 10/25/2008 Doe 1 Mark Jansson Doe 2 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding FA
ProtectMarriage.com advertisements
623 DEF_INT_PRIV_003965- First Amendment Email string 10/24/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Bill May Bill May, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Chip White, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003966 Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno preparation for an upcoming media appearance
624 DEF_INT_PRIV_003967 First Amendment Email string 10/24/2008 Jeff Flint, Bill May Bill May, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Chip White, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Sonja preparation for an upcoming media appearance
Eddings Brown
625 DEF_INT_PRIV_003968 First Amendment Email string 10/24/2008 Bill May Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Chip White, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno preparation for an upcoming media appearance
38 of 99
626 DEF_INT_PRIV_003969- First Amendment Email string 10/23- Frank Schubert, Doe Executive Doe Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding a potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003972 24/2008 Committee Member Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert message to communicate to the public
627 DEF_INT_PRIV_003972- First Amendment Email string 10/23/2008 Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Ned Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003974 Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Doe ProtectMarriage.com's advertisements
1
628 DEF_INT_PRIV_003975 First Amendment Email 10/21/2008 Mark Jansson Sarah Pollo, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding campaign FA
Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Chip White, signs
Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint
629 DEF_INT_PRIV_003976- First Amendment Email string 10/21/2008 Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003977 Gary Lawrence, Doe Executive Committee Proposition 8 advertisements
Member, Does 2-3
630 DEF_INT_PRIV_003978- First Amendment Email string 10/21/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003979 Gary Lawrence, Doe Executive Committee Proposition 8 advertisements
Member, Does 2-3
631 DEF_INT_PRIV_003980 First Amendment Email 10/21/2008 Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Gary Lawrence, Doe Executive Committee Proposition 8 advertisements
Member, Does 2-3
632 DEF_INT_PRIV_003981- First Amendment Email string 10/20/2008 Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Gary Lawrence, Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a video FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003982 Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi addressing Proposition 8
633 DEF_INT_PRIV_003983 First Amendment Email 10/20/2008 Doe 1 Mark Jansson Gary Lawrence, Doe 2 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a video FA
addressing Proposition 8
634 DEF_INT_PRIV_003984 First Amendment Email string 10/20/2008 Mark Jansson, Doe 1 Gary Lawrence, Mark Jansson, Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a video FA
addressing Proposition 8
635 DEF_INT_PRIV_003985- First Amendment Email string 10/19/2008 Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Doe Gary Lawrence, Sonja Eddings Brown, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a video FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003986 Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice Does 1-3 addressing Proposition 8
636 DEF_INT_PRIV_003987- First Amendment Email string 10/19/2008 Doe 1, Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions about a video FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003988 promoting Proposition 8
637 DEF_INT_PRIV_003989- First Amendment Email string 10/19/2008 Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003990 Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice messages to communicate to the public
638 DEF_INT_PRIV_003991 - First Amendment Email string 10/19/2008 Doe 1, Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions about a video FA
639 DEF_INT_PRIV_003993 - First Amendment Email 10/19/2008 Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Does 2-3 Nonpublic, confidential correspondence discussing campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003995 messaging and strategy
640 DEF_INT_PRIV_003996 First Amendment Email 10/15/2008 Mark Jansson Ned Dolejsi Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
ProtectMarriage.com flyers
641 DEF_INT_PRIV_003997 First Amendment Email string 10/13/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding potential FA
Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Chip White, Frank messages to communicate to the public
642 DEF_INT_PRIV_003998- First Amendment Email 10/11/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_003999 Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice messages to communicate to the public
643 DEF_INT_PRIV_004000 First Amendment Email 10/11/2008 Mark Jansson Does 1-13 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding potential FA
messages to communicate to the public
644 DEF_INT_PRIV_004001 First Amendment Email 10/11/2008 Mark Jansson Does 1-4 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding potential FA
messages to communicate to the public
645 DEF_INT_PRIV_004002 First Amendment Email 10/11/2008 Mark Jansson Gary Lawrence, Steve Linder, Joe Infranco, Mike Spence, Does Does 5-15 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding potential FA
1-4 messages to communicate to the public
646 DEF_INT_PRIV_004003 First Amendment Email string 10/3/2008 Jeff Flint, Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Gary Does 2-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding a FA
Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Doe 1 ProtectMarriage.com media statement and promotional video
647 DEF_INT_PRIV_004004 First Amendment Email string 10/3/2008 Jeff Flint, Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Gary Does 2-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding a FA
Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Doe 1 ProtectMarriage.com press statement
648 DEF_INT_PRIV_004005 First Amendment Email 10/3/2008 Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Gary Does 2-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding a potential FA
Lawrence, Jeff Flint message to communicate to the public

649 DEF_INT_PRIV_004006 First Amendment Email 10/3/2008 Frank Schubert Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Gary Lawrence, Mark Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
39 of 99
650 DEF_INT_PRIV_004007- First Amendment Email 10/2/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Andrew Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004008 Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
651 DEF_INT_PRIV_004009- First Amendment Email string 9/27/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004012 Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com advertisement
652 DEF_INT_PRIV_004013- First Amendment Email string 9/27/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004016 Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com advertisement
653 DEF_INT_PRIV_004017 First Amendment Email 9/25/20008 Ron Prentice Jennifer Kerns, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ned Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding potential FA
Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson messaging and media appearances
654 DEF_INT_PRIV_004019 First Amendment Email 9/23/2008 Ned Dolejsi Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
Doe Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint campaign messaging
655 DEF_INT_PRIV_004020 First Amendment Email 9/22/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
Doe Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi campaign messaging
656 DEF_INT_PRIV_004021 First Amendment Email 9/22/2008 Ron Prentice Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi campaign messaging
657 DEF_INT_PRIV_004022 First Amendment Email 9/22/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi campaign messaging
658 DEF_INT_PRIV_004023 First Amendment Email 9/22/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a video FA
Dolejsi, Ron Prentice addressing Proposition 8
659 DEF_INT_PRIV_004024- First Amendment Email string 9/19/2008 - Does 1-2 Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Does 2-27 Nonpublic, confidential correspondence discussing campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004025 9/22/2008 messaging and volunteer communications
660 DEF_INT_PRIV_004026- First Amendment Email string 09/17- Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Jim Garlow, Mark Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004027 18/2008 Ron Prentice Jansson preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
661 DEF_INT_PRIV_004028 First Amendment Email string 09/17- Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Jim Garlow, Mark Jansson, Ron Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
18/2008 Prentice preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
662 DEF_INT_PRIV_004029- First Amendment Email string 09/13- Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004030 14/2008 Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television script
Frank Schubert, Does 1-3
663 DEF_INT_PRIV_004031- First Amendment Email string 09/13- Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004032 14/2008 Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television script
664 DEF_INT_PRIV_004033 First Amendment Email string 09/12- Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
13/2008 Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television script
Jeff Flint, Does 1-3
665 DEF_INT_PRIV_004034- First Amendment Email 9/12/2008 Frank Schubert Mark Jansson, Mark Jansson, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004035 Kerns, Ned Dolejsi, Doe 1-3 campaign messaging
666 DEF_INT_PRIV_004036- First Amendment Email string 9/9/2008 Jennifer Kerns, Mark Jansson Jennifer Kerns, Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004037 communication of messaging to media
667 DEF_INT_PRIV_004038- First Amendment Email string 09/02- Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004040 04/2008 Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television scripts
Jeff Flint, Doe 1
668 DEF_INT_PRIV_004041- First Amendment Email string 09/02- Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Jeff Flint, Doe 1
669 DEF_INT_PRIV_004043- First Amendment Email string 09/02- Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Jeff Flint, Doe 1
670 DEF_INT_PRIV_004046- First Amendment Email string 09/02- Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Jeff Flint, Doe 1
671 DEF_INT_PRIV_004048- First Amendment Email string 09/02- Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Jeff Flint, Doe 1

672 DEF_INT_PRIV_004050- First Amendment Email string 09/02- Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Jeff Flint, Doe 1
40 of 99
673 DEF_INT_PRIV_004052 First Amendment Email 9/3/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice preparation of ProtectMarriage com's overall campaign messaging
674 DEF_INT_PRIV_004053- First Amendment Email string 08/31- Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Gary Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004054 09/02/2008 Lawrence Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
675 DEF_INT_PRIV_004055- First Amendment Email string 08/31- Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson, Jeff Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004057 09/01/2008 Flint, Gary Lawrence, Ned Dolejsi Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Frank Schubert
676 DEF_INT_PRIV_004058- First Amendment Email string 08/31- Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Ned Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004060 09/01/2008 Dolejsi, Frank Schubert Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Frank preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Schubert
677 DEF_INT_PRIV_004061- First Amendment Email string 08/31- Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004063 09/01/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Ned Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Frank preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Dolejsi Schubert
DEF_INT_PRIV_004066 09/01/2008 Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Frank preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Schubert
DEF_INT_PRIV_004070 09/01/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Ned Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Frank preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Dolejsi Schubert
Schubert
681 DEF_INT_PRIV_004074- First Amendment Email string 08/31- Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Schubert
Schubert
DEF_INT_PRIV_004080 09/01/2008 Ned Dolejsi Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Frank preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Schubert
684 DEF_INT_PRIV_004081- First Amendment Email string 08/31- Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ned Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004083 09/01/2008 Dolejsi, Frank Schubert Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
685 DEF_INT_PRIV_004084- First Amendment Email string 08/31- Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004085 09/01/2008 Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Frank preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Schubert
686 DEF_INT_PRIV_004086- First Amendment Email string 08/31- Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004087 09/01/2008 Schubert Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Andrew preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Pugno
687 DEF_INT_PRIV_004088- First Amendment Email string 08/31- Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004089 09/01/2008 Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Frank preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Schubert
688 DEF_INT_PRIV_004090- First Amendment Email string 08/31- Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004091 09/01/2008 Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
689 DEF_INT_PRIV_004092 First Amendment Email string 9/1/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Ned preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Dolejsi
690 DEF_INT_PRIV_004093- First Amendment Email 8/30/2008 Gary Lawrence Does 1-2 Mark Jansson, Ron Prentice, Does 3-7 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding potential FA
691 DEF_INT_PRIV_004095 First Amendment Email 8/30/2008 Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson Gary Lawrence, Doe 2 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding potential FA
campaign messaging
692 DEF_INT_PRIV_004096 First Amendment Email string 08/26- Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
27/2008 Committee Member, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Mark Jansson, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Ned Dolejsi
41 of 99
693 DEF_INT_PRIV_004097- First Amendment Email string 8/24/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Gary Lawrence, Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004098 Dolejsi, Ron Prentice campaign messaging
694 DEF_INT_PRIV_004099 First Amendment Email 8/24/2008 Mark Jansson Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding potential FA
campaign messaging
695 DEF_INT_PRIV_004100- First Amendment Email string 08/19- Frank Schubert Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004103 20/2008 Nancy Limon preparation of ProtectMarriage com print advertising
696 DEF_INT_PRIV_004104- First Amendment Email 08/11- Frank Schubert Mark Jansson, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning television FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004105 12/2008 Member, Steve Linder, Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, advertisements
Gary Lawrence, Doe 1
697 DEF_INT_PRIV_004106- First Amendment Email string 8/11/2008 Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Steve Linder, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning television FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004107 Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Gary advertisements
Lawrence, Doe 1
698 DEF_INT_PRIV_004108 First Amendment Email string 8/11/2008 Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning television FA
Member, Steve Linder, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Ned advertisements
Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Doe 1
699 DEF_INT_PRIV_004109- First Amendment Email string 07/31- Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004110 08/01/2008 Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com brochure
700 DEF_INT_PRIV_004111 First Amendment Email string 7/31/2008 Gary Lawrence Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Doe Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com brochure
701 DEF_INT_PRIV_004112 First Amendment Email 7/30/2008 Bill May Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding potential FA
Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson campaign messaging
702 DEF_INT_PRIV_004113- First Amendment Email string 7/30/2008 Mark Jansson, Bill May Bill May, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004116 Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark campaign messaging
Jansson
703 DEF_INT_PRIV_004117- First Amendment Email string 7/30/2008 Bill May Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004119 Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson campaign messaging
704 DEF_INT_PRIV_004120- First Amendment Email string 7/25/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Steve Linder Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004121 Flint, Sarah Pollo campaign messaging
705 DEF_INT_PRIV_004122 First Amendment Email string 07/24- Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
25/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
Nancy Limon, Sarah Pollo, Gary Lawrence, Steve Linder, Does
1-3
706 DEF_INT_PRIV_004123- First Amendment Email string 7/24/2008 Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004124 Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Sarah preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
707 DEF_INT_PRIV_004125- First Amendment Email string 7/24/2008 Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004126 Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Sarah preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
708 DEF_INT_PRIV_004127 First Amendment Email string 7/24/2008 Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Sarah preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
709 DEF_INT_PRIV_004128- First Amendment Email string 7/24/2008 Jeff Flint, Mark Jansson, Frank Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning the FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004129 Schubert Executive Committee Member ProtectMarriage.com website
710 DEF_INT_PRIV_004130- First Amendment Email string 7/24/2008 Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004131 Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
Nancy Limon, Sarah Pollo, Gary Lawrence, Steve Linder, Does
1-3
711 DEF_INT_PRIV_004132- First Amendment Email string 7/24/2008 Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert, Jeff Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning the FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004133 Flint Executive Committee Member ProtectMarriage.com website
42 of 99
712 DEF_INT_PRIV_004134- First Amendment Email string 07/22- Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004137 23/2008 Kerns, Frank Schubert Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
Nancy Limon, Sarah Pollo, Jennifer Kerns, Steve Linder, Does
1-2
713 DEF_INT_PRIV_004138- First Amendment Email string 07/22- Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Ned Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004140 23/2008 Dolejsi, Frank Schubert Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
1-2
714 DEF_INT_PRIV_004141- First Amendment Email string 07/22- Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Ned Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
1-2
715 DEF_INT_PRIV_004144- First Amendment Email string 07/22- Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004145 23/2008 Flint, Frank Schubert Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
1-2
716 DEF_INT_PRIV_004146- First Amendment Email string 07/22- Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Frank Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004147 23/2008 Schubert Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
1-2
717 DEF_INT_PRIV_004148- First Amendment Email string 07/22- Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ned Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
1-2
718 DEF_INT_PRIV_004150- First Amendment Email string 07/22- Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ned Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
1-2
719 DEF_INT_PRIV_004152 First Amendment Email string 07/22- Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
23/2008 Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials

1-2
720 DEF_INT_PRIV_004153 First Amendment Email string 7/23/2008 Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
1-2
721 DEF_INT_PRIV_004154- First Amendment Email string 07/22- Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004155 23/2008 Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
1-2
722 DEF_INT_PRIV_004156- First Amendment Email string 07/17- Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004157 22/2008 Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
1-2
723 DEF_INT_PRIV_004158- First Amendment Email string 7/22/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Doe Joe Infranco, Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning the ballot FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004159 Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Jennifer Kerns title
724 DEF_INT_PRIV_004160- First Amendment Email string 07/17- Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004161 18/2008 Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Sarah preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
Pollo, Steve Linder, Does 1-2
725 DEF_INT_PRIV_004162- First Amendment Email string 07/17- Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004163 18/2008 Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Sarah preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
Pollo, Steve Linder, Does 1-2
726 DEF_INT_PRIV_004164- First Amendment Email string 07/14- Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Frank Schubert, Sarah Pollo, Nancy Limon Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004165 16/2008 Pugno Executive Committee Member preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
727 DEF_INT_PRIV_004166- First Amendment Email string 07/14- Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Frank Schubert, Sarah Pollo, Nancy Limon Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004167 15/2008 Executive Committee Member preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
43 of 99
728 DEF_INT_PRIV_004168 First Amendment Email string 7/14/2008 Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Frank Schubert, Sarah Pollo, Nancy Limon Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Executive Committee Member preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
729 DEF_INT_PRIV_004169- First Amendment Email 7/12/2008 Gary Lawrence Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004170 preparation of ProtectMarriage com's ballot arguments
730 DEF_INT_PRIV_004171- First Amendment Email string 7/11/2008 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Gary Lawrence, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004172 Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, preparation of ProtectMarriage com's ballot arguments
Jeff Flint
731 DEF_INT_PRIV_004173- First Amendment Email string 7/9/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004175 Jansson, Andrew Pugno campaign messaging
732 DEF_INT_PRIV_004176- First Amendment Email string 7/9/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004179 Jeff Flint Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno campaign messaging
733 DEF_INT_PRIV_004180- First Amendment Email string 7/9/2008 Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004182 Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno campaign messaging
734 DEF_INT_PRIV_004183- First Amendment Email string 6/29/2008 Gary Lawrence, Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004185 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com overall campaign messaging
735 DEF_INT_PRIV_004186- First Amendment Email string 6/18/2008 Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004187 preparation of a press release
736 DEF_INT_PRIV_004188- First Amendment Email string 06/11- Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004191 13/2008 Committee Member, Ron Prentice preparation of ProtectMarriage com's overall campaign messaging
737 DEF_INT_PRIV_004192- First Amendment Email string 6/13/2008 Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004193 Member, Mark Jansson, Joe Infranco, Frank Schubert, Jeff preparation of a messaging document for public distribution
Flint, Dan Kirby
738 DEF_INT_PRIV_004194- First Amendment Email string 06/11- Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004196 13/2008 Committee Member, Ron Prentice preparation of ProtectMarriage com's overall campaign messaging
739 DEF_INT_PRIV_004197- First Amendment Email string 06/11- Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004200 13/2008 Member, Ned Dolejsi preparation of ProtectMarriage com's overall campaign messaging
740 DEF_INT_PRIV_004201- First Amendment Email 06/11- Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004204 13/2008 Dolejsi, Ron Prentice preparation of ProtectMarriage com's overall campaign messaging
741 DEF_INT_PRIV_004205- First Amendment Email 6/6/2008 Andrew Pugno Does 1-2 Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging and strategy discussions FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004206 Committee Member, Mark Jansson concerning preparation of ProtectMarriage.com's overall strategy
742 DEF_INT_PRIV_004207- First Amendment Email string 5/21/2008 - Mark Jansson, Ron Prentice, Chris Chris Clark, Anne Subia, Jim Garlow, Dan Kirby, Everett Rice, Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning potential campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004209 5/24/2008 Clark, Anne Subia, Jim Garlow Miles McPherson, Mark Jansson, Charles LiMandri, Ron messaging and strategies
Prentice, Does 1-3
743 DEF_INT_PRIV_004210 First Amendment Email string 02/21- Joe Infranco, Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Joe Infranco, Lynne Fishel, Ron Prentice, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
22/2008 preparation of ProtectMarriage com's overall campaign messaging
744 DEF_INT_PRIV_004211 First Amendment Email 02/21- Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Joe Infranco, Lynne Fishel, Ron Prentice, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
22/2008 preparation of ProtectMarriage com's overall campaign messaging
745 DEF_INT_PRIV_004212- First Amendment Email with attachment 1/30/2009 Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions memorialized in FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004215 (internal meeting minutes) Member, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Peter meeting minutes
Henderson, Dan Kirby, Everett Rice, Does 1-2
746 DEF_INT_PRIV_004216- First Amendment Email string with attachment 11/3-4/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004219 (draft press release) Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com public statement
747 DEF_INT_PRIV_004220- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 11/3/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004222 press release) Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com public statement

748 DEF_INT_PRIV_004223- First Amendment Email with attachment 10/19/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Doe Gary Lawrence, Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding a video FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004224 (nonfinal version of video) Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron addressing Proposition 8
Prentice
44 of 99
749 DEF_INT_PRIV_004225- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/19/2008 Frank Schubert Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004228 talking points) Cherri Spriggs Hernandez preparation for an election rally
750 DEF_INT_PRIV_004229- First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/17/2008 Does 1-2 Mark Jansson, Does 1-2 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004232 (draft article) messages to communicate to the public
751 DEF_INT_PRIV_004233- First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/7/2008 Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Sonja Eddings Brown Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004240 (draft strategy notes) campaign messaging and strategy
752 DEF_INT_PRIV_004241- First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/7/2008 Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Sonja Eddings Brown Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004248 (draft article) preparation of a draft article regarding Proposition 8
753 DEF_INT_PRIV_004249- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/7/2008 Doe 1 Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004256 article) preparation of a draft article regarding Proposition 8
754 DEF_INT_PRIV_004257- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/4/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004264 strategy memorandum) Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice campaign messaging and strategy
755 DEF_INT_PRIV_004265- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/4/2008 Doe 1 Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004272 strategy memorandum) campaign messaging and strategy
756 DEF_INT_PRIV_004273 - First Amendment Email with attachments 10/3/2008 Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Does 2-28 Nonpublic, confidential correspondence discussing various FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004277 (messaging materials for messaging ideas and volunteer communications
campaign volunteers)
757 DEF_INT_PRIV_004278 - First Amendment Email with attachments 9/21/2008 Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Does 2-3 Nonpublic, confidential correspondence conveying campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004309 (messaging materials for strategy and messaging to volunteers
campaign volunteers)
758 DEF_INT_PRIV_004310- First Amendment Email with attachments 9/18/2008 Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Does 2-27 Nonpublic, confidential correspondence conveying campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004312 (confidential messaging strategy and messaging to volunteers
document)
759 DEF_INT_PRIV_004313- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/17/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Jim Garlow, Mark Jansson Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004314 flyer) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com flyer
760 DEF_INT_PRIV_004315- First Amendment Email with attachments 9/15/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004319 (draft advertisements) Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Does 1-3
761 DEF_INT_PRIV_004320- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/13/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004324 advertisements) Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Does 1-3
DEF_INT_PRIV_004327 advertisement) Member, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Does 1-2
763 DEF_INT_PRIV_004328- First Amendment Email string with 9/3/2008 Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004333 attachments (draft Member, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
advertisements) Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Does 1-2
764 DEF_INT_PRIV_004334- First Amendment Email with attachments 9/2/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004344 (draft advertisements) Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Doe 1
765 DEF_INT_PRIV_004345- First Amendment Email with attachments 9/1/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004349 (draft advertisements) Member, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Does 1-2
766 DEF_INT_PRIV_004350- First Amendment Email string with attachment 8/31- Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004354 (material considered in 9/1/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Ned Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
developing messaging) Dolejsi, Frank Schubert Jeff Flint
767 DEF_INT_PRIV_004355- First Amendment Email string with attachment 8/31- Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004359 (draft advertisement) 9/1/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Ned Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Dolejsi, Frank Schubert Jeff Flint
768 DEF_INT_PRIV_004360- First Amendment Email string with attachment 8/31- Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004364 (draft advertisement) 9/1/2008 Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Schubert Jeff Flint
45 of 99
769 DEF_INT_PRIV_004365- First Amendment Email with attachments 8/31/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004373 (draft advertisements) Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
DEF_INT_PRIV_004377 notes of advertising Member, Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Mark Jansson preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
concepts)
771 DEF_INT_PRIV_004378- First Amendment Email with attachment 8/18/2008 Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Does 2-25 Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning campaign strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004379 (messaging materials for and volunteer recruitment
volunteers)
772 DEF_INT_PRIV_004380- First Amendment Email with attachment 8/11/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Steve Linder, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding television FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004383 (internal campaign research Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Gary advertisements
materials) Lawrence, Doe 1
773 DEF_INT_PRIV_004384- First Amendment Email with attachment 8/4/2008 Jennifer Kerns Ron Prentice, Jennifer Roback Morse, Mark Jansson Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004395 (internal campaign research preparation for an upcoming meeting with the media
materials)
774 DEF_INT_PRIV_004396- First Amendment Email string (attachments 8/4/2008 Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Doe 2 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004405 are publicly distributed materials for distribution to the public
promotional materials which
have already been
produced)
775 DEF_INT_PRIV_004406 - First Amendment Email with attachment 7/25/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004408 (material considered in Flint messages to communicate to the public
776 DEF_INT_PRIV_004409- First Amendment Email with attachments 7/24/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004419 (draft promotional Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Sarah preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
777 DEF_INT_PRIV_004420- First Amendment Email string with attachment 07/22- Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Ned Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004427 (draft promotional 23/2008 Dolejsi, Frank Schubert Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
materials) Sarah Pollo, Jennifer Kerns, Steve Linder, Frank Schubert,
Does 1-2
778 DEF_INT_PRIV_004428- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 7/22/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004438 campaign materials) Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
Sarah Pollo, Jennifer Kerns, Steve Linder, Does 1-2
779 DEF_INT_PRIV_004439- First Amendment Email 7/22/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004440 Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Sarah preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
Pollo, Nancy Limon, Gary Lawrence, Doe 1
780 DEF_INT_PRIV_004441- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 7/18/2008 Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004442 promotional materials) Jansson, Doe Executive Committee Member preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
781 DEF_INT_PRIV_004443- First Amendment Email with attachments 7/17/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004450 (draft promotional Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Sarah preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
materials) Pollo, Steve Linder, Does 1-2
782 DEF_INT_PRIV_004451- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 7/17/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004452 promotional materials) Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Sarah preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
Pollo, Steve Linder, Jennifer Kerns, Does 1-2
783 DEF_INT_PRIV_004453- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 7/15/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004454 ballot argument) Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Doe 1 Sarah Pollo preparation of ProtectMarriage com's ballot arguments
784 DEF_INT_PRIV_004455- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 7/14/2008 Jeff Flint Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Frank Schubert, Sarah Pollo, Nancy Limon Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004456 promotional materials) Executive Committee Member preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
785 DEF_INT_PRIV_004457- First Amendment Email string (attachment is 7/9/2008 Jeff Flint, Mark Jansson, Does 1-2 Mark Jansson, Does 1-3 Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004461 a publicly distributed ballot Doe 4 messages to communicate to the public

argument which has
already been produced)
46 of 99
786 DEF_INT_PRIV_004462- First Amendment Email with attachment 7/1/2008 Gary Lawrence Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004464 (internal campaign ProtectMarriage.com's overall campaign strategy
research)
787 DEF_INT_PRIV_004465- First Amendment Email string with attachment 7/1/2008 Gary Lawrence Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004468 (internal campaign Pugno ProtectMarriage.com's overall campaign strategy
research)
788 DEF_INT_PRIV_004469- First Amendment Email with attachment 6/27/2008 Gary Lawrence Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004483 (internal campaign research ProtectMarriage.com's overall campaign strategy
materials)
789 DEF_INT_PRIV_004484- First Amendment Email string with attachment 6/25/2008 Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004497 (draft research materials) Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert ProtectMarriage.com's overall campaign strategy
790 DEF_INT_PRIV_004498- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/25/2008 Gary Lawrence Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004511 research materials) Committee Member, Mark Jansson ProtectMarriage.com's overall campaign strategy
791 DEF_INT_PRIV_004512- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/24/2008 Gary Lawrence Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004526 research materials) Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson ProtectMarriage.com's overall campaign strategy
792 DEF_INT_PRIV_004527- First Amendment Email with attachment 6/6/2008 Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Nonpublic, confidential messaging and strategy discussions FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004532 (confidential strategy Mark Jansson regarding ProtectMarriage.com's overall campaign messaging and
memorandum) strategy
793 DEF_INT_PRIV_004533- First Amendment Email with attachment 6/5/2008 Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Nonpublic, confidential messaging and strategy discussions FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004567 (internal strategy Mark Jansson regarding ProtectMarriage.com's overall campaign messaging and
memorandum) strategy
794 DEF_INT_PRIV_004568 - First Amendment Email string 10/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential discussion regarding campaign messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004572 for a ProtectMarriage.com print advertisement
795 DEF_INT_PRIV_004573 - First Amendment Email string 10/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential discussion regarding campaign messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004577 for a ProtectMarriage.com print advertisement
796 DEF_INT_PRIV_004578 - First Amendment Email string 9/2/2008- Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning draft FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004579 9/3/2008 Doe 1 Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, scripts for ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Doe 1
797 DEF_INT_PRIV_004580 First Amendment Email string 8/20/2008 Jim Garlow, Jeff Flint Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Jim Garlow Nonpublic, confidential discussion regarding internal campaign FA
strategy for communicating with potential voters
798 DEF_INT_PRIV_004581 First Amendment Email 8/20/2008 Jim Garlow Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential discussion regarding internal campaign FA
strategy for communicating with potential voters
799 DEF_INT_PRIV_004582 - First Amendment Email 8/8/2008 Jennifer Kerns Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Sara Pollo, Nancy Limon, Ron Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning media FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004583 Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Committee coverage of Proposition 8
Member, Steve Linder
800 DEF_INT_PRIV_004584 - First Amendment Email string 8/7/2008 Jennifer Kerns, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004585 Jansson, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, talking points related to the ballot arguments
Jennifer Kearns
801 DEF_INT_PRIV_004586 - First Amendment Email string 8/4/2008 Jennifer Kearns, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kearns Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion regarding upcoming FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004598 Jansson, Ned Dolejsi meeting with the media
802 DEF_INT_PRIV_004599 - First Amendment Email string 7/12/2008 Bill May, Frank Schubert Jennifer Kearns, Andrew Pugno, Bill May Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning messaging and voter FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004603 Ned Dolejsi reaction to media coverage
803 DEF_INT_PRIV_004604 - First Amendment Email 7/3/2008 Doe 1 Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential correspondence discussing overall FA
804 DEF_INT_PRIV_004610 First Amendment Email 8/8/2008 Ron Prentice Jim Garlow, Chris Clark, Jack Hibbs, Miles McPherson, Jim Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning potential FA
Franklin, Bill May, Mary Kuper, Doe 1 talking points related to the ballot arguments
805 DEF_INT_PRIV_004611 First Amendment Email 9/25/2008 Ron Prentice Jennifer Kerns, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ned Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning messaging and FA
Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson polling in relation to media coverage
806 DEF_INT_PRIV_004612 First Amendment Email 5/21/2008 Ron Prentice Dan Kirby, Everett Rice, Anne Subia, Chris Clark, Miles Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning potential messaging FA
McPherson, Jim Garlow, Doe 1, Jack Hibbs, Mark Jansson, to communicate to the public
Charles LiMandri
807 DEF_INT_PRIV_004613 First Amendment Email 7/9/2008 Ron Prentice Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning potential messaging FA
Committee Member, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint to communicate to the public
47 of 99
808 DEF_INT_PRIV_004614 First Amendment Email 7/23/2008 Ron Prentice Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential correspondence discussing campaign FA
messaging
809 DEF_INT_PRIV_004615 First Amendment Email 6/17/2008 Ron Prentice Jim Garlow Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning voter response to a FA
particular ProtectMarriage com messaging point
810 DEF_INT_PRIV_004616 First Amendment Email 8/8/2008 Ron Prentice Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning messaging and FA
advertising strategy in conjunction with other organizations
811 DEF_INT_PRIV_004617 - First Amendment Email 8/16/2008 Ron Prentice Ron Prentice, Steve Linder Nonpublic, confidential messaging strategy concerning fundraising FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004619 for ProtectMarriage com
812 DEF_INT_PRIV_004620 First Amendment Email 1/23/2009 Ron Prentice Robert George, Maggie Gallagher Nonpublic, confidential correspondence discussing messaging for FA
the Proposition 8 campaign
813 DEF_INT_PRIV_004621 First Amendment Email 3/17/2008 Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning a FA
ProtectMarriage.com radio advertisement
814 DEF_INT_PRIV_004622 - First Amendment Email string 5/8/2008- Ron Prentice, Chris Clark, Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Doe 1, Chris Clark, Jim Garlow, Anne Subia, Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning overall campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004625 5/9/2008 Miles McPherson, Charles LiMandri messaging
815 DEF_INT_PRIV_004626 First Amendment Email 5/9/2008 Ron Prentice Does 1-7 Doe 8 Nonpublic, confidential correspondence discussing overall FA
campaign messaging
816 DEF_INT_PRIV_004627 - First Amendment Email string 11/12/2008 Doe 1, Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning overall messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004628 Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Does 2- and campaign strategy
4
817 DEF_INT_PRIV_004629 First Amendment Email 11/3/2008 Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Does 2-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
Prentice preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com public statement
818 DEF_INT_PRIV_004630 - First Amendment Email 10/24/2008 Jim Garlow Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential discussion regarding potential information FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004631 and messaging to send to voters
819 DEF_INT_PRIV_004632 - First Amendment Email string 10/23/2008 Doe Executive Committee Member, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Ned Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown, Andrew Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning potential messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004634 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Doe Pugno for responding to a No on 8 advertisement
1
820 DEF_INT_PRIV_004635 - First Amendment Email string 10/23/2008 Frank Schubert, Doe 1, Ron Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Steve Linder, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning messaging for FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004636 Prentice Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Doe 1, Ned Dolejsi, Andrew potential Proposition 8 advertisement
Pugno, Ron Prentice
821 DEF_INT_PRIV_004637 - First Amendment Email string 10/23/2008 Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning potential messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004638 Jeff Flint Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, for responding to a No on 8 advertisement
Doe 1, Jeff Flint
822 DEF_INT_PRIV_004639 - First Amendment Email string 10/23/2008 Ron Prentice, Gary Lawrence, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Frank Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning potential messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004640 Andrew Pugno Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, for responding to a No on 8 advertisement
Mark Jansson, Doe 1
823 DEF_INT_PRIV_004641 First Amendment Email 10/23/2008 Jim Garlow Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential discussion regarding potential information FA
and messaging to send to voters
824 DEF_INT_PRIV_004642 - First Amendment Email string 10/23/2008 Andrew Pugno, Sonja Eddings Sonja Eddings Brown, Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert, Jeff Chip White Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning potential messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004644 Brown Flint, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee response to media coverage of campaign
Member, Mark Jansson, Doe 1
825 DEF_INT_PRIV_004645 - First Amendment Email string 10/23/2008 Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Frank Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning potential messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004646 Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, for responding to a No on 8 advertisement
Mark Jansson, Doe 1
826 DEF_INT_PRIV_004647 - First Amendment Email string 10/23/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ron Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning potential messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004648 Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark for responding to a No on 8 advertisement
Jansson, Doe 1
827 DEF_INT_PRIV_004649 - First Amendment Email 10/23/2008 Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Ned Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning potential messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004650 Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Doe for responding to a No on 8 advertisement
1
828 DEF_INT_PRIV_004651 First Amendment Email 10/21/2008 Mark Jansson Sarah Pollo, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning potential FA
Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Chip White, campaign signs
829 DEF_INT_PRIV_004652 - First Amendment Email string 10/21/2008 Frank Schubert, Robb Wirthlin Frank Schubert, Robb Wirthlin Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Chip White, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004654 Sonja Eddings Brown, Jeff Flint ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement

830 DEF_INT_PRIV_004655 - First Amendment Email string 10/21/2008 Jim Garlow Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential discussion cocnerning messaging to media FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004659 regarding Proposition 8
48 of 99
831 DEF_INT_PRIV_004660 - First Amendment Email 10/21/2008 Jim Garlow Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning potential messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004661 to communicate to the public
832 DEF_INT_PRIV_004662 - First Amendment Email 10/20/2008 Maggie Gallagher Charles LiMandri, Frank Schubert, Brian Brown Sonja Eddings Brown, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential correspondence discussing messaging and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004664 media coverage of the Proposition 8 campaign
833 DEF_INT_PRIV_004665 - First Amendment Email 10/20/2008 Charles LiMandri Frank Schubert Sonja Eddings Brown, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning messaging and voter FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004667 reaction
834 DEF_INT_PRIV_004668 - First Amendment Email string 10/19/2008- Mark Jansson, Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning messaging for and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004670 10/20/2008 Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive use of internet advertisement supporting Proposition 8
Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi
835 DEF_INT_PRIV_004671 - First Amendment Email string 10/19/2008- Mark Jansson, Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning messaging for and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004672 10/20/2008 Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive use of internet advertisement supporting Proposition 8
836 DEF_INT_PRIV_004673 - First Amendment Email string 10/19/2008 Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning messaging for and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004674 Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive use of internet advertisement supporting Proposition 8
837 DEF_INT_PRIV_004675 First Amendment Email 10/19/2008 Jim Garlow Ron Prentice, Does 1-7 Nonpublic, confidential correspondence discussing a video FA
promoting Proposition 8
838 DEF_INT_PRIV_004676 First Amendment Email 10/14/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning voter reaction to FA
ProtectMarriage.com radio advertisement
839 DEF_INT_PRIV_004677 - First Amendment Email 10/11/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004678 Dolejsi, Ron Prentice messaging to communicate to the public
840 DEF_INT_PRIV_004679 First Amendment Email 10/11/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning messaging FA
Dolejsi, Ron Prentice Does 1-3 related to a ProtectMarriage com press release
841 DEF_INT_PRIV_004680 - First Amendment Email 10/8/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning an internet FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004681 Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, advertisement supporting Proposition 8
Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Does 1-2
842 DEF_INT_PRIV_004682 First Amendment Email 10/8/2008 Mark Jansson Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Jeff, Flint, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning materials that FA
Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno could potentially be used to develop messaging for the
ProtectMarriage.com campaign
843 DEF_INT_PRIV_004683 - First Amendment Email string 10/5/2008 Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004685 messaging strategy in relation to a third party's supporting

Proposition 8
844 DEF_INT_PRIV_004686 - First Amendment Email string 10/3/2008 Doe 1, Jeff Flint Jeff Flint, Doe 1, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Does 2-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004687 Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence potential messaging materials for the ProtectMarriage com website
845 DEF_INT_PRIV_004688 First Amendment Email string 10/3/2008 Doe 1, Jeff Flint Jeff Flint, Doe 1, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Does 2-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence potential messaging materials for the ProtectMarriage com website
846 DEF_INT_PRIV_004689 - First Amendment Email string 10/2/2008 - Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004693 10/3/2008 fundraising campaign for ProtectMarriage.com
849 DEF_INT_PRIV_004696 First Amendment Email 10/3/2008 Doe 1 Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Does 2-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
Jansson, Gary Lawrence potential messaging materials for the ProtectMarriage com website
850 DEF_INT_PRIV_004697 First Amendment Email 10/3/2008 Frank Schubert Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Bill Criswell, Gary Nonpublic, confidential messaging communcation concerning FA
Lawrence, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Committee Member
851 DEF_INT_PRIV_004698 - First Amendment Email string 10/2/2008 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Doe Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Nonpublic, confidential messaging communcation concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004702 Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Member
852 DEF_INT_PRIV_004703 - First Amendment Email string 10/2/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Andrew Nonpublic, confidential messaging communcation concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004704 Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
49 of 99
853 DEF_INT_PRIV_004705 First Amendment Email string 10/2/2008 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice,Gary Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning potential FA
Lawrence, Sonja Eddings Brown messaging points for theProtectMarriage.com campaign
854 DEF_INT_PRIV_004706 First Amendment Email 10/2/2008 Frank Schubert Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice,Gary Lawrence, Sonja Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning potential FA
Eddings Brown messaging points for theProtectMarriage.com campaign
855 DEF_INT_PRIV_004707 - First Amendment Email string 10/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
856 DEF_INT_PRIV_004709 - First Amendment Email 9/27/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004712 Dolejsi, Ron Prentice ProtectMarriage.com's overall messaging and strategy
857 DEF_INT_PRIV_004713 - First Amendment Email 9/26/2008 Jim Garlow Ron Prentice Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning messaging at an FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004715 event supporting Proposition 8
858 DEF_INT_PRIV_004716 - First Amendment Email string 9/26/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004717 Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Does 1-4 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
859 DEF_INT_PRIV_004718 First Amendment Email string 9/25/2008 Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert, Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Does preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
1-3
860 DEF_INT_PRIV_004719 - First Amendment Email string 9/23/2008 Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert, Doe 2 Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004720 Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Doe 1, Jeff preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television letter
Flint, Jennifer Kerns
861 DEF_INT_PRIV_004721 First Amendment Email 9/22/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning overall campaign FA
Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint messaging and strategy
862 DEF_INT_PRIV_004722 First Amendment Email 9/22/2008 Mark Jansson Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Doe 1, Jeff Flint, Jennifer preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
Kerns
863 DEF_INT_PRIV_004723 First Amendment Email string 9/22/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Nonpublic, confidential communication regarding potential message FA
Dolejsi, Ron Prentice for the campaign to communicate to the public
864 DEF_INT_PRIV_004724 - First Amendment Email string 9/22/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Andrew Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004725 Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert potential messaging for responding to a No on 8 argument
865 DEF_INT_PRIV_004726 - First Amendment Email string 9/21/2008 Jim Garlow, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Jim Garlow Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004730 media relations

866 DEF_INT_PRIV_004731 - First Amendment Email string 9/21/2008 Maggie Gallagher Frank Schubert, Brian Brown, Doe 1 Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging communciation concerning draft FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004733 press release
867 DEF_INT_PRIV_004734 - First Amendment Email string 9/21/2008 Frank Schubert, Jim Garlow Frank Schubert, Jim Garlow Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
868 DEF_INT_PRIV_004740 - First Amendment Email string 9/21/2008 Maggie Gallagher, Frank Schubert Maggie Gallagher, Frank Schubert Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004743 potential messaging for the ProtectMarriage.com campaign
872 DEF_INT_PRIV_004757 First Amendment Email 9/21/2008 Frank Schubert Jim Garlow Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
potential media coverage of the campaign
873 DEF_INT_PRIV_004758 - First Amendment Email string 9/18/2008 - Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Joe Infranco, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning messaging in a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004759 9/20/2008 Committee Member, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi ProtectMarriage.com statement
874 DEF_INT_PRIV_004760 - First Amendment Email string 9/19/2008 Frank Schubert, Maggie Gallagher Frank Schubert, Maggie Gallagher Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004762 messaging points for the ProtectMarriage com campaign
875 DEF_INT_PRIV_004763 - First Amendment Email string 9/19/2008 Frank Schubert, Maggie Gallagher Frank Schubert, Maggie Gallagher Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
876 DEF_INT_PRIV_004766 - First Amendment Email 9/19/2008 Maggie Gallagher Frank Schubert Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
877 DEF_INT_PRIV_004769 - First Amendment Email string 9/18/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004771 messaging strategy in relation to a third party event in support of
Proposition 8
50 of 99
878 DEF_INT_PRIV_004772 - First Amendment Email string 9/18/2008 Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004773 messaging strategy in relation to a third party event in support of
Proposition 8
879 DEF_INT_PRIV_004774 - First Amendment Email string 9/15/2008 - Doe Executive Committee Member, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004775 9/17/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Gary preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Does 1-3
880 DEF_INT_PRIV_004776 - First Amendment Email string 9/16/2008 Does 1-2 Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence Does 2-5 Internal confidential messaging communications concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004778 potential messaging to communicate to voters; reveals the identity of
campaign volunteers
881 DEF_INT_PRIV_004779 - First Amendment Email 9/16/2008 Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence Does 2-4 Internal confidential messaging communications concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004780 potential messaging to communicate to voters; reveals the identity of
campaign volunteers
882 DEF_INT_PRIV_004781 - First Email string 9/15/2008 - Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning draft FA, AC
DEF_INT_PRIV_004782 Amendment; 9/16/2008 Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Gary scripts of a ProtectMarriage com television advertisement; also
Attorney-client Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Does 1-3 contains confidential attorney-client communication discussing legal
issues/questions regarding the advertisement
883 DEF_INT_PRIV_004783 - First Email string 9/15/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning draft FA, AC
DEF_INT_PRIV_004785 Amendment; Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Gary scripts of a ProtectMarriage com television advertisement; also
Attorney-client Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Does 1-3 contains confidential attorney-client communication discussing legal
issues/questions regarding the advertisement
884 DEF_INT_PRIV_004786 - First Amendment Email 9/13/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Gary Lawrence, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions about a potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004787 Dolejsi, Ron Prentice message for the campaign to communicate to the public
885 DEF_INT_PRIV_004788 First Amendment Email string 9/12/2008 - Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
9/13/2008 Member, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
886 DEF_INT_PRIV_004789 - First Amendment Email string 9/5/2008 Joe Infranco, Ron Prentice Joe Infranco, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning the communication FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004790 of arguments in support of Proposition 8
887 DEF_INT_PRIV_004791 - First Amendment Email string 9/3/2008 Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Trudy Thomas, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning messaging for FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004794 Trudy Thomas letter discussing Proposition 8
888 DEF_INT_PRIV_004795 - First Amendment Email string 9/3/2008 Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Trudy Thomas, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning messaging for FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004800 Trudy Thomas letter discussing Proposition 8
889 DEF_INT_PRIV_004801 - First Amendment Email string 9/3/2008 Frank Schubert, Trudy Thomas Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Trudy Thomas, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning messaging for FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004805 letter discussing Proposition 8
DEF_INT_PRIV_004812 letter addressing Proposition 8
893 DEF_INT_PRIV_004816 - First Amendment Email 9/3/2008 Trudy Thomas Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning messaging for FA
894 DEF_INT_PRIV_004819 First Amendment Email 9/3/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning overall FA
Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice messaging for the ProtectMarriage com campaign
895 DEF_INT_PRIV_004820 - First Amendment Email string 9/1/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence, Frank Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004821 Schubert Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Jansson
896 DEF_INT_PRIV_004822 - First Amendment Email string 9/1/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno, Frank Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004824 Schubert, Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Jansson
897 DEF_INT_PRIV_004825 - First Amendment Email string 9/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004827 Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Ned Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Dolejsi Jansson
51 of 99
898 DEF_INT_PRIV_004828 - First Amendment Email string 9/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Andrew Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004830 Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
899 DEF_INT_PRIV_004831 - First Amendment Email string 9/1/2008 Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004834 Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Schubert Mark Jansson
900 DEF_INT_PRIV_004835 - First Amendment Email string 9/1/2008 Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004837 Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Mark Jansson
901 DEF_INT_PRIV_004838 - First Amendment Email string 9/1/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004840 Schubert, Ned Dolejsi Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Mark Jansson
902 DEF_INT_PRIV_004841 - First Amendment Email string 9/1/2008 Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Frank Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Mark Jansson
903 DEF_INT_PRIV_004843 - First Amendment Email string 9/1/2008 Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004844 Ned Dolejsi Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Mark Jansson
904 DEF_INT_PRIV_004845 - First Amendment Email string 9/1/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Mark Jansson
905 DEF_INT_PRIV_004848 - First Amendment Email string 9/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004849 Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Mark Jansson
906 DEF_INT_PRIV_004850 - First Amendment Email string 9/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004851 Andrew Pugno Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Mark Jansson
907 DEF_INT_PRIV_004852 - First Amendment Email string 9/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004853 Schubert, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Mark Jansson
908 DEF_INT_PRIV_004854 - First Amendment Email string 8/29/2008 - Anne Subia, Jim Garlow, Chris Jim Garlow, Anne Subia, Chris Clark, Doe 1 Anne Subia, Doe 2, Chris Clark, Ron Nonpublic, confidential discussions about campaign strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004863 8/30/2008 Clark Prentice
909 DEF_INT_PRIV_004864 - First Amendment Email 8/29/2008 Doe 1 Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential discussions about potential messages to FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004865 communicate to the public
910 DEF_INT_PRIV_004866 - First Amendment Email string 8/27/2008 Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004867 Executive Committee Member, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Mark preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Jansson
911 DEF_INT_PRIV_004868 - First Amendment Email string 8/27/2008 Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004869 Executive Committee Member, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Mark preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Jansson
912 DEF_INT_PRIV_004870 First Amendment Email string 8/27/2008 Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Executive Committee Member, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Mark preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Jansson
913 DEF_INT_PRIV_004871 - First Amendment Email string 8/20/2008 Jim Garlow, Jeff Flint, Frank Jim Garlow, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning effectiveness of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004872 Schubert, Ron Prentice messaging strategy for reaching voters
914 DEF_INT_PRIV_004873 - First Amendment Email string 8/19/2008 - Joe Infranco, Ron Prentice Joe Infranco, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning messaging for FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004874 8/20/2008 letter discussing Proposition 8
915 DEF_INT_PRIV_004875 - First Amendment Email 8/14/2008 Jim Garlow Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004877 messaging directed to a particular group of voters
916 DEF_INT_PRIV_004878 - First Amendment Email 8/13/2008 Jim Garlow Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Anne Subia, Chris Nonpublic, confidential correspondence discussing messaging for FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004879 Clark, Miles McPherson, Jack Hibbs, Jim Franklin, Dean media interviews
Broyles, Charles LiMandri, James Griffiths, Brad Dacus, Does 1-
9
917 DEF_INT_PRIV_004880 First Amendment Email 8/9/2008 Doe 1 Jennifer Kerns Miles McPherson, Jim Garlow, Frank Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning messaging for FA
Schubert, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Does 2-5 website supporting Proposition 8
52 of 99
918 DEF_INT_PRIV_004881 - First Amendment Email string 8/7/2008 Doe 1, Jennifer Kerns Doe 1, Jennifer Kerns, Jeff Flint, Miles McPherson Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Does 2-6 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning messaging for FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004882 website supporting Proposition 8
919 DEF_INT_PRIV_004883 - First Amendment Email string 8/5/2008 Dan Kirby, Trudy Thomas, Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Dan Kirby Trudy Thomas Nonpublic, confidential discussions about the effectiveness of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004887 ProtectMarriage.com's messaging
920 DEF_INT_PRIV_004888 - First Amendment Email string 8/5/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint , Doe 1 Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning a draft of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004891 Member, Mark Jansson, Steve Linder ProtectMarriage.com blast email
921 DEF_INT_PRIV_004892 - First Amendment Email string 8/5/2008 Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Steve Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning a draft of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004896 Linder ProtectMarriage.com blast email
922 DEF_INT_PRIV_004897 - First Amendment Email string 8/5/2008 Jeff Flint, Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Steve Linder, Frank Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning a draft of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004900 Schubert ProtectMarriage.com blast email
923 DEF_INT_PRIV_004901 - First Amendment Email 7/30/2008 Jim Garlow Anne Subia, Chris Clark, Ron Prentice, Jim Franklin, Jack Nonpublic, confidential discussion about ProtectMarriage.com's FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004903 Hibbs, Doe 1 messaging
924 DEF_INT_PRIV_004904 - First Amendment Email string 7/28/2008 Jennifer Kerns Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Sarah Nonpublic, confidential communication regarding messaging and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004905 Pollo, Nancy Limon strategy for responding to No on 8 messaging
925 DEF_INT_PRIV_004906 - First Amendment Email string 7/28/2008 Jim Garlow, Chris Clark, Mary Chris Clark, Anne Subia, Mary Kuper, Doe 1, Ron Prentice, Jim Nonpublic, confidential communication regarding campaign strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004912 Kuper Garlow and promotional materials
926 DEF_INT_PRIV_004913 - First Amendment Email string 7/28/2008 Jim Garlow, Chris Clark Chris Clark, Anne Subia, Mary Kuper, Doe 1, Ron Prentice, Jim Nonpublic, confidential communication regarding campaign strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004918 Garlow and promotional materials
927 DEF_INT_PRIV_004919 First Amendment Email 7/23/2008 Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Does 2-10 Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing a potential FA
resource to use in support of Proposition 8
928 DEF_INT_PRIV_004920 - First Amendment Email 7/22/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004924 Dolejsi, Ron Prentice strategy for a specific group of voters
929 DEF_INT_PRIV_004925 First Amendment Email 7/20/2008 Anne Subia Ron Prentice Chris Clark, Jim Garlow Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning draft of flyer FA
supporting Proposition 8
930 DEF_INT_PRIV_004926 - First Amendment Email string 7/17/2008 - Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004927 7/18/2008 Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, ProtectMarraige.com's printed materials
Nancy Limon, Sarah Pollo, Steve Linder, Does 1-2
931 DEF_INT_PRIV_004932 - First Amendment Email string 7/14/2008 Charles LiMandri, Frank Schubert Charles LiMandri, Frank Schubert Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication regarding messaging and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004934 strategy for a Proposition 8-related debate
932 DEF_INT_PRIV_004935 - First Amendment Email string 7/14/2008 Charles LiMandri, Frank Schubert Charles LiMandri, Frank Schubert Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication regarding messaging and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004936 strategy for a Proposition 8-related debate
933 DEF_INT_PRIV_004937 - First Amendment Email 7/12/2008 Gary Lawrence Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004938 ProtectMarriage.com's ballot arguments
934 DEF_INT_PRIV_004939 - First Amendment Email string 7/12/2008 Chris Clark, Jim Garlow, Anne Jim Garlow, Anne Subia Miles McPherson, Ron Prentice, Chris Clark Nonpublic, confidential discussions regarding campaign strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004943 Subia, Doe 1
935 DEF_INT_PRIV_004944 - First Amendment Email string 6/22/2008 - Frank Schubert, Doe 1, Ron Doe 1, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Everett Rice, Nonpublic, confidential discussions regarding coalition coordination FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004948 6/23/2008 Prentice Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno and campaign strategy
936 DEF_INT_PRIV_004949 - First Amendment Email string 7/11/2008 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Gary Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding the ballot FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004950 Lawrence, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Committee Member, arguments
Ned Dolejsi
937 DEF_INT_PRIV_004951 - First Email string 7/11/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding FA, AC
DEF_INT_PRIV_004954 Amendment; Schubert Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson ProtectMarriage.com's ballot arguments; confidential attorney-client
Attorney- communications regarding ProtectMarriage com's ballot arguments
Client/Attorney
Work Product
938 DEF_INT_PRIV_004955 - First Email string 7/11/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding FA, AC
DEF_INT_PRIV_004958 Amendment; Schubert Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson ProtectMarriage.com's ballot arguments; confidential attorney-client
Attorney- communications regarding ProtectMarriage com's ballot arguments
Client/Attorney
Work Product
939 DEF_INT_PRIV_004959 - First Amendment Email string 7/9/2008 Jim Garlow, Ron Prentice Jim Garlow, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004961 strategy and messaging directed to a particular group of voters
53 of 99
940 DEF_INT_PRIV_004962 - First Amendment Email string 7/8/2008 Jim Garlow, Chris Clark Jim Garlow, Chris Clark, Jack Hibbs, Miles McPherson, Jim Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning draft of letter FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004965 Franklin, Anne Subia, Doe 1, Ron Prentice, Dudley Rutherford related to Proposition 8 campaign
941 DEF_INT_PRIV_004966 - First Amendment Email 7/8/2008 Jim Garlow Chris Clark, Jack Hibbs, Miles McPherson, Jim Franklin, Anne Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning draft of letter FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004969 Subia, Doe 1, Ron Prentice, Dudley Rutherford related to Proposition 8 campaign
942 DEF_INT_PRIV_004970 - First Amendment Email string 7/7/2008 Jim Garlow, Ron Prentice Jim Garlow, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004974 strategy and messaging directed to a particular group of voters
943 DEF_INT_PRIV_004975 - First Amendment Email string 7/6/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Sarah Pollo, Nancy Limon Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004977 Jeff Flint ProtectMarriage.com's ballot arguments
944 DEF_INT_PRIV_004978 - First Email string 7/6/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Sarah Pollo, Gary Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding FA, AC
DEF_INT_PRIV_004980 Amendment; Ned Dolejsi Lawrence, Doe Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, ProtectMarriage.com's ballot arguments; confidential attorney-client
Attorney- Jennifer Kerns, Mark Jansson, Ron Prentice, Steve Linder, communications regarding ProtectMarriage com's ballot arguments
Client/Attorney Does 1-2
Work Product
945 DEF_INT_PRIV_004981 - First Amendment Email string 7/2/2008 Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Sarah Pollo, Gary Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions regarding FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004983 Frank Schubert Lawrence, Doe Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, ProtectMarriage.com's ballot arguments
Jennifer Kerns, Mark Jansson, Ron Prentice, Steve Linder,
Does 1-2
946 DEF_INT_PRIV_004984 First Amendment Email 7/2/2008 Bill May Jeff Flint Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Internal confidential messaging communications concerning media FA
Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson interview about the ProtectMarriage.com campaign
947 DEF_INT_PRIV_004985 - First Amendment Email string 7/2/2008 Trudy Thomas Ron Prentice, Chris Clark Nonpublic, confidential messaging communications discussing draft FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004987 of materials to provide to voters regarding Proposition 8
948 DEF_INT_PRIV_004988 - First Amendment Email string 7/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Nonpublic, confidential messaging communications discussing FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004989 Andrew Pugno polling information and effective messaging
949 DEF_INT_PRIV_004990 - First Amendment Email string 6/30/2008 Charles LiMandri, Frank Schubert Charles LiMandri, Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions about drafts of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004991 Proposition 8-related handouts
950 DEF_INT_PRIV_004992 - First Amendment Email string 6/30/2008 Charles LiMandri, Frank Schubert Charles LiMandri, Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions about drafts of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004993 Proposition 8-related handouts
951 DEF_INT_PRIV_004994 - First Amendment Email string 6/26/2008 - Jim Garlow Miles McPherson Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communications concerning campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_004996 6/27/2008 messaging points and focus groups

952 DEF_INT_PRIV_004997 - First Amendment Email string 6/26/2008 Jim Garlow, Charles LiMandri, Jim Garlow, Charles LiMandri, Frank Schubert, Anne Subia, Maggie Gallagher, Brian Brown Nonpublic, confidential conmunications concerning messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005003 Frank Schubert Miles McPherson, Chris Clark, Ron Prentice, Does 1-2 strategy and potential campaign advertisements
953 DEF_INT_PRIV_005004 - First Amendment Email string 6/26/2008 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Jeff Flint, Jim Garlow, Doe 1, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging communications discussing FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005008 media coverage of the campaign
954 DEF_INT_PRIV_005009 - First Amendment Email 6/26/2008 Jim Garlow Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice Anne Subia, Chris Clark, Miles McPherson, Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005010 Doe 1 strategy and talking points for a specific group of voters
955 DEF_INT_PRIV_005011 - First Amendment Email 6/23/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Nonpublic, confidential messaging communications concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005012 Dolejsi, Ron Prentice media release discussing Proposition 8
956 DEF_INT_PRIV_005013 - First Amendment Email string 6/21/2008 - Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Nonpublic, confidential communications concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005015 6/22/2008 Prentice campaign messaging
957 DEF_INT_PRIV_005016 - First Amendment Email string 6/21/2008 - Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Nonpublic, confidential communications concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005017 6/22/2008 Prentice campaign messaging
958 DEF_INT_PRIV_005018 First Amendment Email 6/18/2008 Bill May Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
communications with the media
959 DEF_INT_PRIV_005019 - First Amendment Email string 6/17/2008 Andrew Pugno, William Tam Andrew Pugno, William Tam, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Frank Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005022 Schubert potential rally in support of Proposition 8
960 DEF_INT_PRIV_005023 - First Amendment Email string 6/17/2008 Andrew Pugno, William Tam Andrew Pugno, William Tam, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Frank Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005025 Schubert potential rally in support of Proposition 8
961 DEF_INT_PRIV_005026 - First Amendment Email string 6/17/2008 Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential communications concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005028 messaging for the ProtectMarriage com campaign
962 DEF_INT_PRIV_005029 - First Amendment Email string 6/16/2008 Bill May, Andrew Pugno Bill May, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging communications concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005030 messaging for a media appearance

963 DEF_INT_PRIV_005031 - First Amendment Email 6/15/2008 Maggie Gallagher Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Nonpublic, confidential communications concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005032 Dolejsi messaging for the ProtectMarriage com campaign
54 of 99
964 DEF_INT_PRIV_005033 - First Amendment Email 6/13/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Nonpublic, confidential communications concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005036 Dolejsi, Ron Prentice messaging for the ProtectMarriage com campaign
965 DEF_INT_PRIV_005037 - First Amendment Email string 6/6/2008 Doe Executive Committee Member Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential communications concerning campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005039 strategy and messaging development
966 DEF_INT_PRIV_005040 - First Amendment Email 6/6/2008 Andrew Pugno Does 1-2 Doe Executive Committee Member, Ron Nonpublic, confidential communications concerning campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005041 Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson strategy and messaging development
967 DEF_INT_PRIV_005042 - First Amendment Email string 5/21/2008 Ron Prentice, Jim Garlow Ron Prentice, Jim Garlow, Dan Kirby, Everett Rice, Anne Subia, Nonpublic, confidential communications concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005043 Chris Clark, Miles McPherson, Jim Garlow, Doe 1, Jack Hibbs, messaging strategy for ProtectMarriage.com campaign directed to a
Mark Jansson, Charles LiMandri particular group of voters
968 DEF_INT_PRIV_005044 First Amendment Email string 5/21/2008 Ron Prentice Dan Kirby, Everett Rice, Anne Subia, Chris Clark, Miles Nonpublic, confidential communications concerning potential FA
McPherson, Jim Garlow, Doe 1, Jack Hibbs, Mark Jansson, messaging strategy for ProtectMarriage.com campaign directed to a
Charles LiMandri particular group of voters
969 DEF_INT_PRIV_005045 - First Amendment Email string 5/21/2008 Ron Prentice, Jim Garlow Ron Prentice, Jim Garlow, Dan Kirby, Everett Rice, Anne Subia, Nonpublic, confidential communications concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005047 Chris Clark, Miles McPherson, Jim Garlow, Brad Miller, Jack messaging strategy for ProtectMarriage.com campaign directed to a
Hibbs, Mark Jansson, Charles LiMandri particular group of voters
970 DEF_INT_PRIV_005048 - First Amendment Email string 5/21/2008 Ron Prentice, Jim Garlow, Chris Ron Prentice, Jim Garlow, Dan Kirby, Everett Rice, Anne Subia, Nonpublic, confidential communications concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005050 Clark Chris Clark, Miles McPherson, Jim Garlow, Doe 1, Jack Hibbs, messaging strategy for ProtectMarriage.com campaign directed to a
Mark Jansson, Charles LiMandri particular group of voters
971 DEF_INT_PRIV_005051 - First Amendment Email string 5/21/2008 Ron Prentice, Everett Rice Dan Kirby, Everett Rice, Anne Subia, Chris Clark, Miles Nonpublic, confidential communications concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005052 McPherson, Jim Garlow, Doe 1, Jack Hibbs, Mark Jansson, messaging strategy for ProtectMarriage.com campaign directed to a
Charles LiMandri, Ron Prentice particular group of voters
972 DEF_INT_PRIV_005053 First Amendment Email string 5/21/2008 Ron Prentice, Brad Miller Dan Kirby, Everett Rice, Anne Subia, Chris Clark, Miles Nonpublic, confidential communications concerning potential FA
McPherson, Jim Garlow, Doe 1, Jack Hibbs, Mark Jansson, messaging strategy for ProtectMarriage.com campaign directed to a
Charles LiMandri, Ron Prentice particular group of voters
973 DEF_INT_PRIV_005054 - First Amendment Email string 5/9/2008 Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging communications concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005055 overall campaign messaging
974 DEF_INT_PRIV_005056 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 8/11/2008 Ron Prentice Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Steve Linder, Peter Henderson, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005057 letter) Executive Committee Member preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
975 DEF_INT_PRIV_005058 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 8/7/2008 Ron Prentice Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
976 DEF_INT_PRIV_005063 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 8/7/2008 Ron Prentice Jim Garlow Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
977 DEF_INT_PRIV_005068 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 8/7/2008 Ron Prentice Jennifer Kerns Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005069 release) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
978 DEF_INT_PRIV_005070 - First Amendment Email (attachment is a 10/22/2008 Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005072 publicly distributed letter preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
which has already been
produced)
979 DEF_INT_PRIV_005073 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 3/17/2008 Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005074 radio script) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com radio advertisement
980 DEF_INT_PRIV_005075 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 5/1/2008 - Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005077 (draft letter) 5/2/2008 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
981 DEF_INT_PRIV_005078 - First Amendment Email with attachment 4/23/2008 Lynne Fishel Ron Prentice Gina Gleason Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning contents FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005083 (internal talking points) of a ProtectMarriage.com press conference
982 DEF_INT_PRIV_005084 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 8/30/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005088 (internal strategy notes) Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Gary messaging strategy for ProtectMarriage.com campaign
Lawrence, Does 1-3
983 DEF_INT_PRIV_005089 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/23/2008 - Doe 1, Ron Prentice Ron Prentice, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005095 (notes from internal 10/24/2008 campaign messaging
campaign discussions)
984 DEF_INT_PRIV_005096 - First Amendment Email with attachment 10/20/2008 Charles LiMandri Frank Schubert Sonja Eddings Brown, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005103 (material considered in Proposition 8 messaging
55 of 99
985 DEF_INT_PRIV_005104 - First Amendment Email (attachment is a 10/19/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005105 publicly distributed video Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Gary messaging to communicate to the public
which has been already Lawrence, Does 1-3
been disclosed)
986 DEF_INT_PRIV_005106 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/19/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005108 (draft letter) Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
987 DEF_INT_PRIV_005109 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/18/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Robb Wirthlin, Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Sonja Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005112 talking points) Eddings Brown preparation of messaging for a ProtectMarriage.com press
conference
988 DEF_INT_PRIV_005113 - First Amendment Email (attachments are a 10/8/2008 Frank Schubert Jim Garlow, Bill May, Ron Prentice, Laura Saucedo Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005119 publicly distributed press Cunningham, William Tam, Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, preparation for a ProtectMarriage.com press conference
release and television Jeff Flint
advertisement which have
been produced)
989 DEF_INT_PRIV_005120 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning draft of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005128 (draft letter) ProtectMarriage.com advertisement and media strategy
990 DEF_INT_PRIV_005129 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning draft of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005133 (draft flyer) ProtectMarriage.com advertisement and media strategy
991 DEF_INT_PRIV_005134 - First Amendment Email string with 9/26/2008 - Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005137 attachments (materials 9/30/2008 Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ron Prentice, Does ProtectMarriage.com letter
considered in developing 1-3
messaging)
992 DEF_INT_PRIV_005138 - First Amendment Email with attachments 9/26/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005142 (draft letters) Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Does 1-3 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
993 DEF_INT_PRIV_005143 - First Amendment Email with attachment 9/25/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005144 (nonfinal version of Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Does 1-3 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
advertisement)
994 DEF_INT_PRIV_005145 - First Amendment Email with attachment 9/23/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005157 (confidential campaign Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, preparation of a messaging survey
research materials) Does 1-2

995 DEF_INT_PRIV_005158 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 9/22/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005160 (draft letter) Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Doe preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
1
996 DEF_INT_PRIV_005164 - First Amendment Email 9/20/2008 Dan Kirby Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Jennifer Kerns, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005166 Andrew Pugno message for the campaign to communicate to voters
997 DEF_INT_PRIV_005167 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/17/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Jim Garlow, Mark Jansson Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005168 flyer) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com flyer
998 DEF_INT_PRIV_005169 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/16/2008 Mark Jansson Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005171 letter) Committee Member, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
999 DEF_INT_PRIV_005172 - First Amendment Email with attachments 9/15/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005176 (draft scripts) Member, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Does 1-3
DEF_INT_PRIV_005181 (draft scripts) Member, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Does 1-3
1001 DEF_INT_PRIV_005182 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/12/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005184 script) Member, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Does 1-3
1002 DEF_INT_PRIV_005185 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/12/2008 Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Ron Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005187 letter) Prentice, Does 1-2 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
1003 DEF_INT_PRIV_005188 - First Amendment Email with attachments 9/2/2008 Jennifer Kerns Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005206 (confidential research for preparation for meeting with the media
meeting with media)

DEF_INT_PRIV_005217 (draft scripts) Member, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
Does 1-3
56 of 99
1005 DEF_INT_PRIV_005218 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 9/1/2008 Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert, Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Ned Dolejsi, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005222 (draft script) Gary Lawrence Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Member, Jeff Flint
1006 DEF_INT_PRIV_005223 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 9/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005238 (confidential campaign Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint preparation of a messaging survey
research materials)
1007 DEF_INT_PRIV_005239 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 9/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Gary Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Ned Dolejsi, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005243 (draft script) Lawrence, Ned Dolejsi Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Member, Jeff Flint
1008 DEF_INT_PRIV_005244 - First Amendment Email with attachments 8/31/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005252 (draft scripts) Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
1009 DEF_INT_PRIV_005253 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 8/28/2008 Jim Garlow Mary Kuper, Chris Clark, Anne Subia, Ron Prentice, Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005255 talking points) talking points for a speaking engagement
1010 DEF_INT_PRIV_005256 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 8/28/2008 Doe 1 Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential email transmitting a draft of a press FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005257 media statement) statement
1011 DEF_INT_PRIV_005258 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 8/26/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005261 notes of advertising Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint preparation of ProtectMarriage com television advertisements
concepts)
1012 DEF_INT_PRIV_005262 - First Amendment Email with attachment 8/19/2008 Joe Infranco Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005265 (materials relied upon in messaging for the ProtectMarriage com campaign
formulating messaging)
1013 DEF_INT_PRIV_005266 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 8/16/2008 Mark Jansson Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005325 (material considered in resource for developing campaign messaging and strategy
1014 DEF_INT_PRIV_005326 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 8/12/2008 Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
1015 DEF_INT_PRIV_005331 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 8/12/2008 Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Does # 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning potential FA
1016 DEF_INT_PRIV_005333 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 8/11/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005335 script) preparation of television advertisement in support of Proposition 8
1017 DEF_INT_PRIV_005336 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 8/6/2008 Jim Garlow Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005339 letter) preparation of a letter in support of Proposition 8
1018 DEF_INT_PRIV_005340 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 8/5/2008 Jim Garlow Ron Prentice, Anne Subia, Chris Clark, Miles McPherson Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning potential FA
1019 DEF_INT_PRIV_005390 - First Amendment Email with attachment 8/4/2008 Jennifer Kerns Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Jennifer Roback Morse Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005401 (confidential research preparation for meeting with media
materials for meeting with
media)
1020 DEF_INT_PRIV_005402 - First Amendment Email string (attachments 8/4/2008 Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Does 1-2 Nonpublic, confidential communication regarding materials for the FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005411 are publicly distributed campaign to consider providing to voters
have already been
produced)
1021 DEF_INT_PRIV_005412 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 8/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Maggie Gallagher Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Steve Linder, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning overall campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005417 (draft letter) strategy and draft message for the public
1022 DEF_INT_PRIV_005418 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 8/1/2008 Anne Subia Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Jim Garlow, Chris Clark Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005420 flyer) preparation of a flyer supporting Proposition 8

1023 DEF_INT_PRIV_005421 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 7/31/2008 Jeff Flint Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Frank Schubert, Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005425 flyer) Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com flyer
57 of 99
1024 DEF_INT_PRIV_005426 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 7/31/2008 Steve Linder Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Peter Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005427 letter) Henderson preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
1025 DEF_INT_PRIV_005428 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 7/28/2008 Jim Garlow, Chris Clark, Mary Chris Clark, Anne Subia, Mary Kuper, Ron Prentice, Jim Nonpublic, confidential communication regarding campaign strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005435 (draft flyer) Kuper Garlow, Doe 1 and promotional materials
1026 DEF_INT_PRIV_005436 - First Amendment Email with attachments 7/24/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005446 (draft promotional Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Sarah preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
1027 DEF_INT_PRIV_005447 - First Amendment Email 7/22/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning contents FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005448 Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Nancy of ballot materials
Limon, Sarah Pollo, Gary Lawrence, Doe 1
1028 DEF_INT_PRIV_005449 - First Amendment Email with attachment 7/22/2008 Dan Kirby Ron Prentice, Everett Rice, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005450 (internal campaign messaging for the Proposition 8 campaign
messaging document)
1029 DEF_INT_PRIV_005451 - First Amendment Email with attachment 7/21/2008 Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning resource for FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005452 (material considered in potential campaign strategy and messaging
developing campaign
strategy)
1030 DEF_INT_PRIV_005453 - First Amendment Email string (attachments 7/18/2008 - Jim Garlow, Doe 1 Chris Clark, Doe 1-2 Jim Garlow Nonpublic, confidential correspondence regarding campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005466 are publicly distributed 7/19/2008 strategy and recruitment
have been produced)
1031 DEF_INT_PRIV_005467 - First Amendment Email with attachments 7/17/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005474 (draft materials) Executive Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Sarah preparation of ProtectMarriage com's printed materials
Pollo, Gary Lawrence, Steve Linder , Does 1-2
1032 DEF_INT_PRIV_005475 - First Amendment Email with attachments 7/16/2008 Frank Schubert Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Nancy Limon, Sarah Pollo Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005477 (draft ballot arguments) preparation of ProtectMarriage com's ballot arguments
1033 DEF_INT_PRIV_005478 - First Amendment Email with attachment 7/11/2008 Jeff Flint Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Gary Lawrence, Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning ballot arguments FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005483 (materials relied upon in Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi
1034 DEF_INT_PRIV_005484 - First Email string with attachment 7/11/2008 Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA, AC
DEF_INT_PRIV_005487 Amendment; (legal memorandum) Mark Jansson preparation of ProtectMarriage com's ballot arguments; confidential
Attorney attorney-client communications concerning legal issues/questions
Client/Attorney regarding the ballot arguments
Work Product
1035 DEF_INT_PRIV_005488 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 7/10/2008 Jim Garlow Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005489 flyer) preparation of flyer supporting Proposition 8
1036 DEF_INT_PRIV_005490 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 7/8/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint Sarah Pollo, Nancy Limon Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005492 ballot argument) preparation of ProtectMarriage com's ballot arguments
1037 DEF_INT_PRIV_005493 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 7/7/2008 Jim Garlow Chris Clark, Ron Prentice, Anne Subia, Does 1-2 Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning preparation of agenda FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005499 (draft agenda for and messaging for Proposition 8-related event
promotional event)
1038 DEF_INT_PRIV_005500 - First Amendment Email with attachment 7/7/2008 Gary Lawrence Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion regarding overall FA
research)
1039 DEF_INT_PRIV_005502 - First Email with attachment (draft 7/7/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint Sarah Pollo, Nancy Limon Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA, AC
DEF_INT_PRIV_005504 Amendment; ballot argument) preparation of ProtectMarriage com's ballot arguments; confidential
Attorney attorney-client communications concerning legal issues/questions
Client/Attorney regarding the ballot arguments
Work Product
1040 DEF_INT_PRIV_005505 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 7/7/2008 Jim Garlow Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning preparation of agenda FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005511 agenda for promotional and messaging for Proposition 8-related event
event)
58 of 99
1041 DEF_INT_PRIV_005512 - First Email string with attachment 7/2/2008 - Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Sarah Pollo, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA, AC
DEF_INT_PRIV_005515 Amendment; (draft ballot arguments) 7/3/2008 Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, preparation of ProtectMarriage com's ballot arguments; confidential
Attorney Jennifer Kerns, Mark Jansson, Nancy Limon, Ron Prentice, attorney-client communications concerning legal issues/questions
Client/Attorney Steve Linder, Does 1-2 regarding the ballot arguments
Work Product
research)
research)
research)
1045 DEF_INT_PRIV_005538 - First Amendment Email with attachment 6/30/2008 Charles LiMandri Frank Schubert Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning resources for FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005545 (material considered in potential campaign strategy and messaging
1046 DEF_INT_PRIV_005546 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/30/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005548 ballot argument) preparation of ProtectMarriage com's ballot arguments
1047 DEF_INT_PRIV_005549 - First Amendment Email with attachment 6/27/2008 Gary Lawrence Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005563 (confidential campaign preparation of a Proposition 8-related survey
research materials)
1048 DEF_INT_PRIV_005564 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/27/2008 Gary Lawrence Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005576 campaign research preparation of a Proposition 8-related survey
materials)
1049 DEF_INT_PRIV_005577 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 6/24/2008 Jim Garlow Chris Clark, Anne Subia, Ron Prentice, Miles McPherson Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning preparation of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005586 (material considered in messaging points for presentation discussing Proposition 8
1050 DEF_INT_PRIV_005587 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/24/2008 Gary Lawrence Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno. Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005601 campaign research Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson preparation of a Proposition 8-related survey
materials)
1051 DEF_INT_PRIV_005602 - First Amendment Email with attachments 6/23/2008 Jim Garlow Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005606 (internal messaging resource for distribution to the public
materials)
1052 DEF_INT_PRIV_005607 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/23/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Sarah Pollo, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005608 release) preparation of ProtectMarriage com press release
1053 DEF_INT_PRIV_005609 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/22/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning preparation of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005611 ballot argument) Proposition 8 ballot arguments
1054 DEF_INT_PRIV_005612 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 6/22/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning preparation of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005613 (draft ballot argument) Proposition 8 ballot arguments
1055 DEF_INT_PRIV_005614 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/22/2008 Gary Lawrence Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
materials)
1056 DEF_INT_PRIV_005637 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 6/22/2008 Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Gary Lawrence, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005661 (draft campaign research Jeff Flint preparation of a Proposition 8-related survey
materials)
1057 DEF_INT_PRIV_005662 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 6/22/2008 Jim Garlow, Frank Schubert Jim Garlow, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Jeff Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005666 (draft flyer) Flint preparation of Proposition 8-flyers
1058 DEF_INT_PRIV_005667 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/21/2008 Gary Lawrence Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
materials)
1059 DEF_INT_PRIV_005689 - First Amendment Email with attachments 6/17/2008 Doe 1 Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential correspondence transmitting resources for FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005705 (materials considered as a developing campaign messaging
source of messaging)
59 of 99
1060 DEF_INT_PRIV_005706 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 6/16/2008 Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005708 (draft email) preparation of ProtectMarriage com blast email
1061 DEF_INT_PRIV_005709 - First Amendment Email with attachment 6/16/2008 Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Does 1-44 Nonpublic, confidential correspondence transmitting a resource for FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005710 (confidential messaging developing campaign messaging
memorandum)
1062 DEF_INT_PRIV_005711 - First Amendment Email string with 6/15/2008 - Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005718 attachments (draft press 6/16/2008 Pugno preparation of ProtectMarriage com press releases
releases)
1063 DEF_INT_PRIV_005719 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 6/15/2008 - Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005727 (confidential media strategy 6/16/2008 Pugno preparation of overall campaign messaging and media strategy
memorandum)
1064 DEF_INT_PRIV_005728 - First Amendment Email with attachment 6/13/2008 Bill May Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005733 (confidential talking points) preparation of talking points for the ProtectMarriage.com campaign
1065 DEF_INT_PRIV_005734 - First Amendment Email with attachments 6/13/2008 Charles LiMandri Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice Maggie Gallagher Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005746 (confidential messaging preparation of talking points for the ProtectMarriage.com campaign
materials)
1066 DEF_INT_PRIV_005747 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 5/19/2008 Joe Infranco Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005749 article) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com document for the media
1067 DEF_INT_PRIV_005750 - First Amendment Email string 11/4/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Jeff Flint Frank Schubert Chip White, Meg Waters Nonpublic, confidential messaging and strategy discussions about FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005751 messaging for media interviews
1068 DEF_INT_PRIV_005752 - First Amendment Email string 11/4/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Ned Dolejsi, Nancy Limon, Maria Fernanda Laura Saucedo Cunningham, Meg Waters, Nonpublic, confidential messaging and strategy discussions about FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005756 Chip White Janeth Hernandez messaging for media interviews
1069 DEF_INT_PRIV_005757 - First Amendment Email string 11/1/2008 Frank Schubert, Sonja Eddings Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Janssen, Jeff Jeff Flint, Bill Criswell, Meg Waters, Chip Nonpublic, confidential messaging and strategy discussions about FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005761 Brown, Chip White Flint, Gary Lawrence, Doe 1 White messaging in the media and for a press release
1070 DEF_INT_PRIV_005762 - First Amendment Email string 10/31/2008 Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown, Meg Waters, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Sonja Does 1-2 Internal strategy discussion about messaging, media strategy, and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005765 Eddings Brown press releases
1071 DEF_INT_PRIV_005766- First Amendment Email string 10/31/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Janeth Frank Schubert, Chip White, Doe Internal messaging discussion about ProtectMarriage.com's use of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005768 Hernandez, Doe video supporting Proposition 8
1072 DEF_INT_PRIV_005769 - First Amendment Email string 10/31/2008 Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings Brown, Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings Brown Internal discussion about messaging and media strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005770 Meg Waters
1073 DEF_INT_PRIV_005771 First Amendment Email 10/31/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Jim Garlow Internal messaging discussion about video supporting Proposition 8 FA
1074 DEF_INT_PRIV_005772 First Amendment Email 10/31/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Doe 1 Nonpublic messaging discussion about video supporting Proposition FA
8
1075 DEF_INT_PRIV_005773 First Amendment Email 10/30/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Chip White, Meg Waters, Nancy Limon Maria Fernanda, Janeth Hernandez Internal messaging discussion about video supporting Proposition 8 FA
1076 DEF_INT_PRIV_005774 - First Amendment Email string 10/30/2008 Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown Does 1-2 Internal discussion about messaging and potentially distributing a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005776 Frank Schubert news release
1077 DEF_INT_PRIV_005777 - First Amendment Email string 10/30/2008 Chip White, Meg Waters, Sonja Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Meg Waters Meg Waters internal messaging discussion regarding news release FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005779 Eddings Brown
1078 DEF_INT_PRIV_005780 - First Amendment Email string 10/30/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Frank Frank Schubert, Sonja Eddings Brown Jeff Flint Internal messaging discussion about potentially distributing a press FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005781 Schubert release
1079 DEF_INT_PRIV_005782 - First Amendment Email string 10/30/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Jeff Flint Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings Brown Chip White, Meg Waters, Doe 1 Internal messaging discussion about a potential messaging point to FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005786 communicate to voters
1080 DEF_INT_PRIV_005787 - First Amendment Email string 10/30/2008 Frank Schubert, Sonja Eddings Chip White, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Frank Chip White, Meg Waters, doe 1 Internal discussion about public messaging and media strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005789 Brown Schubert, Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1
1081 DEF_INT_PRIV_005790 - First Amendment Email string 10/29/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Frank Chip White, Gary Lawrence, Meg Waters, Jeff Flint, Frank Gary Lawrence Internal discussion about a potential change in public messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005791 Schubert Schubert, Sonja Eddings Brown
1082 DEF_INT_PRIV_005792 - First Amendment Email string 10/29/2008 Bill May, Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Frank Schubert, Chip White, Bill May Sonja Eddings Brown, Frank Schubert, Jeff Internal discussion about messaging and future communications FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005795 Chip White, Frank Schubert Flint, Does 1-2 with the media
1083 DEF_INT_PRIV_005796 First Amendment Email string 10/29/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Frank Frank Schubert, Sonja Eddings Brown Gary Lawrence Internal discussion about a potential change in public messaging FA
Schubert
1084 DEF_INT_PRIV_005797 - First Amendment Email 10/29/2008 Jeff Flint Meg Waters, Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Internal messaging discussion about potential response to media FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005798 coverage regarding Proposition 8
60 of 99
1085 DEF_INT_PRIV_005799 - First Amendment Email string 10/28/2008 Meg Waters, Chip White, Sonja Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Meg Waters Sonja Eddings Brown Internal messaging discussion preparing a response for the media FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005800 Eddings Brown
1086 DEF_INT_PRIV_005801 First Amendment Email 10/28/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Meg Waters Internal messaging discussion preparing a response for the media FA
1087 DEF_INT_PRIV_005802 - First Amendment Email string 10/27/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Frank Frank Schubert, Sonja Eddings Brown Jeff Flint Internal discussion about messaging prepared for publication by a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005805 Schubert media outlet
1088 DEF_INT_PRIV_005806 First Amendment Email 10/26/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Frank Schubert Internal discussion about messaging for media FA
1089 DEF_INT_PRIV_005807 First Amendment Email 10/25/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Frank Schubert Internal discussion about a video for ProtectMarriage.com to FA
consider promoting to voters
1090 DEF_INT_PRIV_005808 - First Amendment Email 10/24/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Jim Garlow Jim Garlow, Sonja Eddings Brown Internal discussion regarding messaging for a future media FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005810 appearance
1091 DEF_INT_PRIV_005811 - First Amendment Email string 10/24/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Frank Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Sonja Eddings Brown Chip White, Meg Waters Internal discussion regarding messaging for a future media FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005813 Schubert, Jeff Flint appearance
1092 DEF_INT_PRIV_005814 - First Amendment Email string 10/24/2008 Bill May, Sonja Eddings Brown, Jeff Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Bill May, Frank Schubert Chip White, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Internal discussion regarding messaging for a future media FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005815 Flint Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno appearance
1093 DEF_INT_PRIV_005816 First Amendment Email 10/24/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Chip White Jeff Flint Internal discussion regarding messaging for a future media FA
appearance
1094 DEF_INT_PRIV_005817 - First Amendment Email string 10/23/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Jim Garlow Jim Garlow, Sonja Eddings Brown Internal discussion regarding messaging for a future media FA
1095 DEF_INT_PRIV_005820 First Amendment Email 10/23/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Frank Shubert, Jeff Flint Internal discussion about messaging responding to a media request FA
1096 DEF_INT_PRIV_005821 - First Amendment Email string 10/23/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Jeff Flint Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings Brown Frank Schubert Internal messaging discussions concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005822 ProtectMarriage.com public statement
1097 DEF_INT_PRIV_005823 - First Amendment Email string 10/23/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Jeff Flint Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings Brown Frank Schubert Internal messaging discussions concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005825 ProtectMarriage.com public statement
1098 DEF_INT_PRIV_005826 First Amendment Email 10/22/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Andrew Internal discussion about voter reaction to campaign messaging and FA
Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, how to adjust the messaging in response
Ned Dolesjsi, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint,
Nancy Limon, Chip White, Does 1-2
1099 DEF_INT_PRIV_005827 - First Amendment Email string 10/22/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings Brown Jeff Flint, Doe 1 Internal discussion about polling and messaging for media FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005832 Frank Schubert
1100 DEF_INT_PRIV_005834 First Amendment Email string 10/22/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1 Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Chip White, Nancy Limon, Sonja Internal messaging discussion concerning a potential messaging FA
Eddings Brown point to consider communicating to voters
1101 DEF_INT_PRIV_005835 First Amendment Email 10/22/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Frank Schubert Internal discussion about messaging appearing in the media and FA
potential responses
1102 DEF_INT_PRIV_005836 - First Amendment Email string 10/20/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Nancy Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown, Internal discussion about messaging for media FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005837 Limon Nancy Limon
1103 DEF_INT_PRIV_005838 First Amendment Email 10/19/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Frank Schubert Internal messaging discussion concerning preparation for a FA
ProtectMarriage.com press conference
1104 DEF_INT_PRIV_005839 - First Amendment Email string 10/19/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Robb Robb Wirthlin, Sonja Eddings Brown Internal messaging discussion concerning preparation for a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005840 Wirthlin ProtectMarriage.com press conference
1105 DEF_INT_PRIV_005841 - First Amendment Email string 10/19/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1 Doe 1, Sonja Eddings Brown Internal messaging discussion concerning preparation of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005844 ProtectMarriage.com signs and banners
1106 DEF_INT_PRIV_005845 - First Amendment Email string 10/19/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Nancy Nancy Limon, Sonja Eddings Brown, Janeth Hernandez Laura Saucedo Cunningham, Maria Internal messaging discussion concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005847 Limon, Janeth Hernandez Fernanda, Sonja Eddings Brown ProtectMarriage.com press release
1107 DEF_INT_PRIV_005848 - First Amendment Email string 10/18/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Derek Sonja Eddings Brown, Derek McCoy Internal discussion about messaging targeted to a particular group FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005849 McCoy of voters
1108 DEF_INT_PRIV_005850 - First Amendment Email string 10/18/2008 Janeth Hernandez, Nancy Limon, Nancy Limon, Maria Fernanda, Sonja Eddings Brown, Laura Nancy Limon, Maria Fernanda, Laura Internal messaging discussion concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005856 Maria Fernanda, Laura Saucedo Saucedo Cunningham Saucedo Cunningham, Sonja Eddings ProtectMarriage.com press release
Cunningham, Chip White Brown
1109 DEF_INT_PRIV_005857- First Amendment Email string 10/17/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1 Doe 1, Sonja Eddings Brown Internal discussion about messaging to be communicated to the FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005859 media
1110 DEF_INT_PRIV_005860 - First Amendment Email string 10/15/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Frank Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Sonja Eddings Brown Chip White, Frank Schubert Internal discussion about media strategy for communicating a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005861 Schubert, Jeff Flint ProtectMarriage.com messaging point
61 of 99
1111 DEF_INT_PRIV_005862- First Amendment Email string 10/14/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Nancy Nancy Limon, Janeth Hernandez, Maria Fernanda, Laura Maria Fernanda, Janeth Hernandez, Sonja Internal messaging discussion concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005863 Limon Saucedo Cunningham Eddings Brown ProtectMarriage.com bumper sticker
1112 DEF_INT_PRIV_005864- First Amendment Email string 10/14/2008 Frank Schubert, Chip White, Jeff Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White Maria Fernanda, Janeth Hernandez, Laura Internal discussion about messaging for a potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005865 Flint, Sonja Eddings Brown Saucedo Cunningham, Frank Schubert, Jeff ProtectMarriage.com press conference
Flint
1113 DEF_INT_PRIV_005866 First Amendment Email 10/14/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Frank Schubert Maria Fernanda, Janeth Hernandez Internal strategy discussion about a future ProtectMarriage com FA
press release
1114 DEF_INT_PRIV_005867 - First Amendment Email string 10/14/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White Janeth Hernandez, Laura Saucedo Internal messaging discussion concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005869 Frank Schubert Cunningham, Chip White, Sonja Eddings ProtectMarriage.com press release
Brown
1115 DEF_INT_PRIV_005870 - First Amendment Email string 10/13/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Frank Chip White, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Sonja Eddings Brown Andrew Pugno Internal discussion about messaging for media and a potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005871 Schubert, Bill Criswell ProtectMarriage.com press conference
1116 DEF_INT_PRIV_005872 - First Amendment Email string 10/13/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Bill May, Sarah Pollo, Laura Saucedo Internal messaging discussion concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005874 Cunningham, Chip White ProtectMarriage.com press release
1117 DEF_INT_PRIV_005875 First Amendment Email string 10/13/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Janeth Laura Saucedo Cunningham, Sonja Eddings Brown, Janeth Maria Fernanda Internal messaging discussion concerning preparation of a FA
Hernandez Hernandez ProtectMarriage.com press release
1118 DEF_INT_PRIV_005876 - First Amendment Email string 10/13/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Jeff Flint, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Frank Schubert Janeth Hernandez, Laura Saucedo Internal messaging discussion concerning preparation of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005879 Maria Fernanda, Nancy Limon Cunningham, Nancy Limon ProtectMarriage.com's printed promotional materials
1119 DEF_INT_PRIV_005880 - First Amendment Email string 10/10/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Frank Nancy Limon, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Frank Schubert, Sonja Doe 1 Internal messaging discussion concerning draft statement for use in FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005881 Schubert, Nancy Limon Eddings Brown discussions with media
1120 DEF_INT_PRIV_005882 - First Amendment Email string 10/10/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Laura Saucedo Cunningham, Sonja Internal messaging discussion concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005883 Eddings Brown, Chip White ProtectMarriage.com press release
1121 DEF_INT_PRIV_005884 - First Amendment Email string 10/10/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Laura Saucedo Cunningham, Sonja Internal messaging discussion concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005885 Eddings Brown, Chip White ProtectMarriage.com press release
1122 DEF_INT_PRIV_005886 First Amendment Email string 10/10/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Laura Saucedo Cunningham, Sonja Internal messaging discussion concerning a potential messaging FA
Eddings Brown, Chip White, Doe 1 point to consider communicating to voters
1123 DEF_INT_PRIV_005887 - First Amendment Email string 10/9/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White Janeth Hernandez, Sonja Eddings Brown Internal messaging discussion concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005888 ProtectMarriage.com press release
1124 DEF_INT_PRIV_005889 - First Amendment Email string 10/9/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Frank Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Sonja Eddings Brown Chip White Internal messaging discussion concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005890 Schubert ProtectMarriage.com press release
1125 DEF_INT_PRIV_005891 - First Amendment Email string 10/9/2008 Bill May, Frank Schubert Bill May, Chip White, Frank Schubert Sonja Eddings Brown Internal discussion regarding messaging for a future media FA
1126 DEF_INT_PRIV_005894 First Amendment Email 10/8/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1 Doe 1, Sonja Eddings Brown Internal messaging discussion about response for media inquiry FA
1127 DEF_INT_PRIV_005895 - First Amendment Email string 10/8/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Frank Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Bill May, Frank Schubert, Sonja Internal discussion regarding overall campaign messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005897 Schubert, Bill May Eddings Brown
1128 DEF_INT_PRIV_005898- First Amendment Email string 10/8/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Chip White, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings Brown, Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1 Internal discussion about messaging targeted to a particular group FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005902 Doe 1 Doe 1 of voters
1129 DEF_INT_PRIV_005903 - First Amendment Email string 10/8/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Chip White, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings Brown, Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1 Internal discussion about messaging targeted to a particular group FA
1130 DEF_INT_PRIV_005908 - First Amendment Email string 10/8/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Frank Sonja Eddings Brown, Frank Schubert Chip White Internal messaging discussion concerning talking points and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005910 Schubert preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
1131 DEF_INT_PRIV_005911 - First Amendment Email string 10/8/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Chip White, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings Brown, Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1 Internal messaging discussion about potential message points to FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005913 Doe 1 Doe 1 consider communicating to voters
1132 DEF_INT_PRIV_005914 - First Amendment Email string 10/8/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Chip White, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings Brown, Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1 Internal discussion about messaging targeted to a particular group FA
1133 DEF_INT_PRIV_005918 - First Amendment Email string 10/8/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown, Internal messaging discussion concerning talking points and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005919 Doe 1 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
1134 DEF_INT_PRIV_005920 First Amendment Email string 10/8/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1 Doe 1, Sonja Eddings Brown Internal discussion about messaging to communicate through print FA
media coverage
1135 DEF_INT_PRIV_005921 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/30/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Meg Waters Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Chip White, Cherri Spriggs Nonpublic, confidential messaging and strategy discussions about FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005924 (draft press release) Hernandez, Sonja Eddings Brown, Meg Waters, Does 1-2 draft Protectmarriage com press release
1136 DEF_INT_PRIV_005925 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/27/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Jim Garlow Nonpublic, confidential messaging and strategy discussion about FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005926 opinion editorial) draft Protectmarriage com opinion editorial
62 of 99
1137 DEF_INT_PRIV_005927 - First Amendment Email with related 1023/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Meg Waters Nonpublic, confidential discussion about Protectmarriage.com FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005936 attachments (internal media strategy and talking points
messaging materials)
1138 DEF_INT_PRIV_005937- First Amendment Email string with 10/23/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Meg Waters Meg Waters, Sonja Eddings Brown Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005944 attachments (internal messaging and containing nonpublic talking points and draft opinion
messaging materials) editorials
1139 DEF_INT_PRIV_005945- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/20/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential discussion about strategy for FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005947 press release) Protectmarriage.com press conference
1140 DEF_INT_PRIV_005948 - First Amendment Email string (attachment is 10/18/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Frank Frank Schubert, Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1 Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential discussion about strategy for final weeks of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005950 a publicly distributed Schubert, Doe 1 Protectmarriage.com campaign and future press conference
promotional flyer which has
been produced)
1141 DEF_INT_PRIV_005951- First Amendment Email with attachments 10/18/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Derek McCoy Nonpublic, confidential discussion about an event supporting FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005953 (draft flyers) Proposition 8
1142 DEF_INT_PRIV_005954- First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/18/2008 Janeth Hernandez, Maria Nancy Limon, Laura Saucedo Cunningham, Maria Fernanda, Maria Fernanda, Sonja Eddings Brown, Nonpublic, confidential discussion about Protectmarriage.com press FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005960 (draft press release) Fernanda, Nancy Limon, Laura Janeth Hernandez Laura Saucedo Cunningham, Nancy Limon conference and draft press release
Saucedo Cunningham
1143 DEF_INT_PRIV_005961- First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/18/2008 Nancy Limon, Laura Saucedo Maria Fernanda, Janeth Hernandez, Nancy Limon, Sonja Janeth Hernandez, Sonja Eddings Brown, Nonpublic, confidential discussion about a Protectmarriage.com flyer FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005967 (draft press release) Cunningham, Maria Fernanda Eddings Brown Laura Saucedo Cunningham and volunteer request
1144 DEF_INT_PRIV_005968- First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/16/2008 - Nancy Limon, Maria Fernanda, Maria Fernanda, Janeth Hernandez, Nancy Limon Janeth Hernandez, Laura Saucedo Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005971 (draft phone script) 10/17/2008 Laura Saucedo Cunningham Cunningham, Maria Fernanda Protectmarriage.com phone script
1145 DEF_INT_PRIV_005972- First Amendment Email with attachment 10/16/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential discussion about messaging for response to FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_005975 (internal talking points) media inquiry
1146 DEF_INT_PRIV_005976- First Amendment Email string with 10/15/2008 Frank Schubert, Bill May Bill May, Frank Schubert Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown Nonpublic, confidential discussion about campaign messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006044 attachments (materials
relied upon in formulating
messaging)
1147 DEF_INT_PRIV_006045 - First Amendment Email with attachments 10/9/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Maria Fernanda Janeth Hernandez Nonpublic, confidential messaging and strategy discussion about FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006049 (materials relied upon in preparting a Protectmarriage com opinion editorial
1148 DEF_INT_PRIV_006050- First Amendment Email string with attachment 9/28/2008 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Sonja Eddings Brown, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential discussion about preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006052 (draft press release) ProtectMarriage.com press release
1149 DEF_INT_PRIV_006053- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/28/2008 Jeff Flint Frank Schubert, Sonja Eddings Brown Nonpublic, confidential discussion about preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006055 press release) ProtectMarriage.com press release
1150 DEF_INT_PRIV_006056- First Amendment Email string with attachment 9/28/2008 Frank Schubert, Nancy Limon, Doe Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Nancy Limon, Doe 1 Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Frank Schubert, Nonpublic, confidential discussion about preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006062 (draft blast email) 1 Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1 ProtectMarriage.com blast email
1151 DEF_INT_PRIV_006063 - First Amendment Email string 4/22/2008 Lynne Fishel, William Tam William Tam, Lynne Fishel Nonpublic, confidential communication regarding campaign strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006064 and media relations
1152 DEF_INT_PRIV_006065 - First Amendment Internal Campaign Meeting 7/18/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential meeting minutes from a ProtectMarriage.com FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006069 Minutes strategy meeting
1156 DEF_INT_PRIV_006085 First Amendment Email string 10/6/2008 William Tam, Mary Kuper Chip White, Mary Kuper, William Tam Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
development of ProtectMarriage.com advertisements
1157 DEF_INT_PRIV_006086 - First Email string 10/9/2008 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Bill Criswell, Andrew Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA, AC
DEF_INT_PRIV_006089 Amendment; Doe 1 Pugno, Doe 1 response to No on 8 advertisements; Nonpublic, confidential
Attorney Client attorney-client communication regarding legal issues/questions
surrounding campaign messaging
63 of 99
1158 DEF_INT_PRIV_006090 First Amendment Email 10/10/2008 Gary Lawrence Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
effectiveness of ProtectMarriage.com advertisement
1159 DEF_INT_PRIV_006091 - First Amendment Email with attachment 10/20/2008 Bill May Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint Ned Dolejsi Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006095 (material considered in ProtectMarriage.com messaging point and supporting
developing messaging) documentation
1160 DEF_INT_PRIV_006096 First Amendment Draft Email Blast Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of an email blast in support of FA
Proposition 8
1161 DEF_INT_PRIV_006097 First Amendment Draft Press Release 10/22/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com press release FA
1163 DEF_INT_PRIV_006099 First Amendment Draft Media Advisory 6/16/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com media FA
advisory
advisory
1165 DEF_INT_PRIV_006101 - First Amendment Draft Press Release 6/16/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com press release FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006102
advisory
advisory
DEF_INT_PRIV_006106
advisory
advisory
1171 DEF_INT_PRIV_006109 First Amendment Draft Press Release Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com press release FA
1177 DEF_INT_PRIV_006115 - First Amendment Draft Press Release Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com press release FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006116
DEF_INT_PRIV_006118
DEF_INT_PRIV_006120
DEF_INT_PRIV_006122
DEF_INT_PRIV_006124
DEF_INT_PRIV_006126
DEF_INT_PRIV_006128
DEF_INT_PRIV_006130
DEF_INT_PRIV_006132
64 of 99
DEF_INT_PRIV_006134
DEF_INT_PRIV_006138
1190 DEF_INT_PRIV_006139 First Amendment Nonfinal Version of Radio Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential nonfinal version of a ProtectMarriage com FA
Advertisement advertisement
1191 DEF_INT_PRIV_006140 First Amendment Draft Ballot Summary Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com ballot materials FA
regarding Proposition 8
1194 DEF_INT_PRIV_006143 - First Amendment Draft Messaging Points Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006144 points
1196 DEF_INT_PRIV_006150 - First Amendment Internal Campaign Media Undated Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential memorandum regarding messaging and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006156 and Messaging Plan strategy targeted for particular groups of voters
1197 DEF_INT_PRIV_006157 - First Amendment Draft Ballot Argument Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com ballot FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006158 arguments regarding Proposition 8
1199 DEF_INT_PRIV_006161 - First Amendment Draft Talking Points Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft talking points for ProtectMarriage.com FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006163 press conference
1201 DEF_INT_PRIV_006169 - First Amendment Draft Campaign Letter Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com letter FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006170
1207 DEF_INT_PRIV_006181 - First Amendment Draft Campaign Letter Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com letter to FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006182 supporters of Proposition 8
1209 DEF_INT_PRIV_006185 - First Amendment Internal Campaign 6/9/2007 Gary Lawrence Doe Executive Committee Member Nonpublic, confidential memorandum regarding messaging and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006187 Research Memorandum results of survey of potential voters
1210 DEF_INT_PRIV_006188 - First Amendment Draft Letter 9/26/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com letter FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006190
DEF_INT_PRIV_006193
DEF_INT_PRIV_006194 - First Amendment Draft Letter 9/26/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com letter FA
1212
DEF_INT_PRIV_006195
DEF_INT_PRIV_006197
65 of 99
DEF_INT_PRIV_006199
DEF_INT_PRIV_006201
DEF_INT_PRIV_006203
1217 DEF_INT_PRIV_006204 First Amendment Draft Campaign Letter Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com letter to FA
supporters of Proposition 8
1218 DEF_INT_PRIV_006205 First Amendment Draft Campaign Letter Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com letter to FA
supporters of Proposition 8
1219 DEF_INT_PRIV_006206 First Amendment Draft Campaign Bulletin Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com bulletin FA
1222 DEF_INT_PRIV_006215 - First Amendment Draft Script for Video Undated Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential draft of a script for a video supporting FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006216 Advertisement Proposition 8
1229 DEF_INT_PRIV_006264 - First Amendment Draft Campaign Letter 2/6/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com letter to FA
1232 DEF_INT_PRIV_006272 - First Amendment Draft Campaign Meeting 6/27/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft agenda for a ProtectMarriage com FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006273 Agenda executive committee meeting
1233 DEF_INT_PRIV_006274 - First Amendment Draft Campaign Meeting 6/27/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft agenda for a ProtectMarriage com FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006275 Agenda executive committee meeting
1234 DEF_INT_PRIV_006276 - First Amendment Draft Email Blast 1/21/2009 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com email blast FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006277
1235 DEF_INT_PRIV_006278 First Amendment Draft Email Blast Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com email blast FA
1236 DEF_INT_PRIV_006279 - First Amendment Email string 7/22/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006284 Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Jennifer Kerns, Gary ProtectMarriage.com media relations and messaging
Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Steve Linder, Doe 1
1237 DEF_INT_PRIV_006285 - First Amendment Email 6/6/2008 Andrew Pugno Does 1-2 Nonpublic, confidential email correspondence regarding overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006286 campaign messaging and strategy
1238 DEF_INT_PRIV_006287 First Amendment Draft Radio Script 10/26/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential working draft of radio script for FA
ProtectMarriage.com advertisement
1239 DEF_INT_PRIV_006288 First Amendment Nonfinal Radio Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential nonfinal version of radio advertisement for FA
Advertisement ProtectMarriage.com
1240 DEF_INT_PRIV_006289 - First Amendment Draft Campaign Meeting 6/17/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com Executive FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006290 Agenda Committee meeting agenda
1241 DEF_INT_PRIV_006291 - First Amendment Draft Print Advertisement Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonfinal, confidential working draft of a ProtectMarriage com print FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006292 advertisement
66 of 99
1242 DEF_INT_PRIV_006293 - First Amendment Draft Script of Television 10/23/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential working draft of a ProtectMarriage.com FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006296 Advertisement television advertisement
1246 DEF_INT_PRIV_006304 First Amendment Draft Promotional Material Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com's printed FA
promotional materials
1250 DEF_INT_PRIV_006308 - First Amendment Draft Promotional Material Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com's printed FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006309 promotional materials
1252 DEF_INT_PRIV_006311 First Amendment Internal Notes about Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential notes discussing ProtectMarriage com's FA
Campaign Advertising advertising efforts to a specific group of voters
1253 DEF_INT_PRIV_006312 - First Amendment Email with attachments 6/12/2008 Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential email correspondence regarding campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006317 (materials relied upon in Committee Member, Jeff Flint messaging and strategy
1254 DEF_INT_PRIV_006318 - First Amendment Internal Campaign Letter Undated Doe 1 Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential letter concerning overall campaign strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006323 Correspondence and messaging
1255 DEF_INT_PRIV_006324 First Amendment Internal Messaging Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential memorandum concerning overall campaign FA
Memorandum messaging
1257 DEF_INT_PRIV_006327 - First Amendment Draft Campaign Letter Sept. 2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006329 letter to Proposition 8 supporters
1258 DEF_INT_PRIV_006330 - First Amendment Email with attachment 6/12/2008 Andrew Pugno Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Nonpublic, confidential email correspondence regarding campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006332 (materials relied upon in Mark Jansson messaging
1259 DEF_INT_PRIV_006333 - First Amendment Draft Campaign Letter 9/12/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006334 letter
1264 DEF_INT_PRIV_006343 First Amendment Draft Campaign Flyer Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com campaign FA
flyer
1265 DEF_INT_PRIV_006344 - First Amendment Confidential Campaign Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential campaign research concerning messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006345 Research
1266 DEF_INT_PRIV_006346 - First Amendment Confidential Campaign Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential campaign research concerning messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006347 Research
1267 DEF_INT_PRIV_006348 - First Amendment Draft Focus Group 6/21/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com focus group FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006368 Discussion Guide discussion guide
1268 DEF_INT_PRIV_006369 - First Amendment Draft Campaign Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft memorandum concerning campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006371 Memorandum strategy and messaging
67 of 99
1269 DEF_INT_PRIV_006372 First Amendment Draft Campaign Flyer Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft campaign flyer to Proposition 8 FA
supporters
1270 DEF_INT_PRIV_006373 - First Amendment Draft Campaign Letter 5/1/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft letter to Proposition 8 supporters FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006375
1272 DEF_INT_PRIV_006377 - First Amendment Draft Campaign Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006381 Memorandum memorandum discussing strategy and messaging
1273 DEF_INT_PRIV_006382 - First Amendment Draft of Internal Campaign 1/29/2009 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of the PrtoectMarriage com Coalition's FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006384 Meeting Minutes meeting minutes
1274 DEF_INT_PRIV_006385 - First Amendment Draft of Internal Campaign 1/29/2009 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of the PrtoectMarriage com Coalition's FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006387 Meeting Minutes meeting minutes
1275 DEF_INT_PRIV_006388 - First Amendment Draft Promotional Materials Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of PrtoectMarriage.com's "myths and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006389 facts" flyer
1276 DEF_INT_PRIV_006390 - First Amendment Internal Messaging and Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential document discussing ProtectMarriage.com's FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006391 Media Plan messaging plan and media strategy for a specific group of voters
DEF_INT_PRIV_006393
1280 DEF_INT_PRIV_006396 - First Draft Legal Letter Undated Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential draft of a letter defending the legality of a FA, WP
DEF_INT_PRIV_006398 Amendment; ProtectMarriage.com advertisement; this draft letter also constitutes
Attorney- attorney work product
Client/Attorney
Work Product
1281 DEF_INT_PRIV_006399 - First Draft Legal Letter (and Undated Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential draft of a letter defending the legality of a FA, WP
DEF_INT_PRIV_006406 Amendment; supporting legal research) ProtectMarriage.com advertisement; this draft letter also constitutes
Client/Attorney
Work Product
1282 DEF_INT_PRIV_006407- First Amendment Draft Press Memorandum 10/16/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com press FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006410 memorandum
1283 DEF_INT_PRIV_006411- First Draft Legal Letter (and Undated Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential draft of a letter defending the legality of a FA, WP
DEF_INT_PRIV_006421 Amendment; supporting legal research) ProtectMarriage.com advertisement; this draft letter also constitutes
Client/Attorney
Work Product
1284 DEF_INT_PRIV_006422- First Amendment Draft Press Memorandum 10/16/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com press FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006425 memorandum
1285 DEF_INT_PRIV_006426- First Amendment Draft Promotional Material Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com's "questions FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006428 and answers" flyer
1286 DEF_INT_PRIV_006429 - First Amendment Internal Campaign 10/10/2008 Doe 1 Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential memorandum concerning research for FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006433 Research for Messaging campaign messaging
1287 DEF_INT_PRIV_006434 - First Amendment Draft Promotional Material Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com's promotional FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006435 "fact sheet"
1288 DEF_INT_PRIV_006436 First Amendment Draft Campaign Letter 8/26/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com letter to FA
Proposition 8 supporters
68 of 99
1292 DEF_INT_PRIV_006440 - First Amendment Draft Campaign Letter Aug. 2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com letter to FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006443 Proposition 8 supporters
1295 DEF_INT_PRIV_006452 First Amendment Draft Campaign Email Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com blast email to FA
1296 DEF_INT_PRIV_006453 - First Amendment Draft Campaign Email Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com blast email to FA
1297 DEF_INT_PRIV_006455 - First Amendment Internal Draft Notes about 8/26/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential working draft of concepts for FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006457 Campaign Advertising ProtectMarriage.com television advertisements
1298 DEF_INT_PRIV_006458 - First Amendment Internal Communications Undated Unknown ProtectMarriage.com Nonpublic, confidential memorandum concerning campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006462 Plan messaging
1299 DEF_INT_PRIV_006463 - First Amendment Internal Campaign Meeting 8/1/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential ProtectMarriage com executive committee FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006464 Notes meeting notes
1300 DEF_INT_PRIV_006465 - First Amendment Draft Campaign Meeting 8/29/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft ProtectMarriage com executive FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006467 Minutes committee meeting minutes
1301 DEF_INT_PRIV_006468 - First Amendment Draft Campaign Letter July-08 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com letter to FA
1304 DEF_INT_PRIV_006477 - First Amendment Draft Campaign Letter (and 9/23/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com letter to FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006493 media clips for potential Proposition 8 supporters
inclusion in letter)
1305 DEF_INT_PRIV_006494 - First Amendment Draft Press Statement Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a press statement responding to FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006495 media coverage
1308 DEF_INT_PRIV_006505 - First Amendment Internal Messaging and Undated Schubert Flint Public Affairs ProtectMarriage.com Nonpublic, confidential document summarizing the messaging plan FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006543 Media Plan and media strategy for the ProtectMarriage com campaign
DEF_INT_PRIV_006545
DEF_INT_PRIV_006547
DEF_INT_PRIV_006555
DEF_INT_PRIV_006567 First Amendment Draft Campaign Letter Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com campaign FA
1316
letter to Proposition 8 supporters
1317 DEF_INT_PRIV_006568 - First Amendment Internal Draft Meeting 6/17/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft agenda of meeting for the FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006569 Agenda ProtectMarriage.com executive committee
69 of 99
1318 DEF_INT_PRIV_006570 - First Amendment Draft Campaign Letter Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com campaign FA
1319 DEF_INT_PRIV_006572 First Amendment Draft Campaign Letter Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com campaign FA
letter to Proposition 8 supporters
1320 DEF_INT_PRIV_006577 - First Amendment Draft Letter 5/18/2009 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com campaign FA
1325 DEF_INT_PRIV_006599 - First Amendment Email 6/15/2008 Maggie Gallagher Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006600 Dolejsi preparation of ProtectMarriage com's overrall campaign messaging
1326 DEF_INT_PRIV_006601 - First Amendment Draft Messaging Notes Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of notes pertaining to FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006604
1328 DEF_INT_PRIV_006605 - First Amendment Internal Campaign Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of an overview discussing the FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006608 Overview messaging and strategy details of the ProtectMarriage.com
campaign
1329 DEF_INT_PRIV_006609 - First Amendment Draft Script for Promotional Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft script for a ProtectMarriage.com FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006610 Call promotional phone call supporting Proposition 8
1330 DEF_INT_PRIV_006611 First Amendment Nonfinal Video Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential nonfinal version of a video supporting FA
Proposition 8
1331 DEF_INT_PRIV_006612 First Amendment Nonfinal Video Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential nonfinal version of a video supporting FA
Proposition 8
1333 DEF_INT_PRIV_006614 - First Amendment Draft Promotional Material Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com's printed FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006615 promotional materials
1335 DEF_INT_PRIV_006617 First Amendment Draft Promotional Material Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com's fact sheet FA
1336 DEF_INT_PRIV_006618 First Amendment Draft Promotional Material Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com's fact sheet FA
1337 DEF_INT_PRIV_006619 - First Amendment Draft Promotional Material Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com's fact sheet FA

70 of 99
1345 DEF_INT_PRIV_006636 - First Amendment Draft Promotional Material Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com's "questions FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006638 and answers" flyer promoting Proposition 8
1353 DEF_INT_PRIV_006654 First Amendment Draft Promotional Material Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com flyer FA
1354 DEF_INT_PRIV_006655 - First Amendment Draft Promotional Material Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com flyer FA
1355 DEF_INT_PRIV_006657 - First Amendment Draft Promotional Material Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com flyer FA
1356 DEF_INT_PRIV_006659 First Amendment Draft Promotional Material Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com flyer FA
1357 DEF_INT_PRIV_006660 First Amendment Draft Press Statement Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com press FA
statement
1358 DEF_INT_PRIV_006661 - First Amendment Internal Grassroots Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006698 Campaign Plan ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
1359 DEF_INT_PRIV_006669 - First Amendment Draft Promotional Material Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com's "myths and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006700 facts" flyer promoting Proposition 8
1363 DEF_INT_PRIV_006708 - First Amendment Draft Email Blast Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com blast email FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006711
1364 DEF_INT_PRIV_006712 - First Amendment Draft Phoning Scripts Undated Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com's scripts for FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006714 communicating to voters about Proposition 8
1365 DEF_INT_PRIV_006715 First Amendment Draft of Internal Messaging Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com's messaging FA
Points points for communicating to voters about Proposition 8
DEF_INT_PRIV_006718
1368 DEF_INT_PRIV_006719 - First Amendment Internal Messaging Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential document containing questions and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006720 Memorandum messaging points for communicating to voters about Proposition 8
1369 DEF_INT_PRIV_006721 - First Amendment Internal Messaging and Undated Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential document discussing ProtectMarriage.com's FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_006724 Media Plan messaging plan and media strategy for a specific group of voters
71 of 99
1371 DEF_INT_PRIV_006726 First Amendment Nonfinal Version of Video Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential version of a video supporting Proposition 8 FA
1372 DEF_INT_PRIV_006727- First Amendment Internal Messaging and Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential memorandum of ProtectMarriage.com FA
006733 Media Plan messaging and media plan targeting a specific group of voters
advisory
1374 DEF_INT_PRIV_006735- First Amendment Draft Talking Points 10/27/2009 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com talking points FA
006737
1375 DEF_INT_PRIV_006738- First Amendment Draft Editorial Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com editorial for FA
006739 print media
1376 DEF_INT_PRIV_006740- First Amendment Draft Editorial Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com editorial for FA
006741 print media
1377 DEF_INT_PRIV_006742- First Amendment Draft Editorial 10/1/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com editorial for FA
006743 print media
1380 DEF_INT_PRIV_006746- First Amendment Draft Donation Letter Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com donation FA
006747 letter
006749 letter
006751 letter
006753 letter
1384 DEF_INT_PRIV_006754 First Amendment Draft Talking Points Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com talking points FA
1385 DEF_INT_PRIV_006755- First Amendment Draft Campaign Letter Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com campaign FA
006756 letter to voters
006758 letter to voters
1387 DEF_INT_PRIV_006769- First Amendment Draft Script of Television 9/13/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a script for a ProtectMarriage.com FA
006770 Advertisement television advertisement
1389 DEF_INT_PRIV_006773- First Amendment Draft of Internal Campaign Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com memorandum FA
006779 Research containing research to support the campaign's messaging
1390 DEF_INT_PRIV_006780 First Amendment Draft Promotional Flyer Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com promotional FA
flyer
1391 DEF_INT_PRIV_006781 First Amendment Draft Ballot Argument Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com's ballot FA
argument
argument
1393 DEF_INT_PRIV_006783- First Amendment Email with attachments 6/25/2008 Bill May Ned Dolejsi Nonpublic, confidential campaign strategy and messaging FA
006831 (materials considered in communications with a draft flyer, agenda, and talking points for
developing messaging) event promoting Proposition 8
1395 DEF_INT_PRIV_006833 First Amendment Draft Telephone Script Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com telephone FA
script
script
1397 DEF_INT_PRIV_006835- First Amendment Draft Campaign Letter Mar. 2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com campaign FA
006837 letter
72 of 99
1398 DEF_INT_PRIV_006838 First Amendment Draft Campaign Letter Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com campaign FA
letter
006840 letter
006842 letter
script
006845 letter
argument
script
1405 DEF_INT_PRIV_006848- First Amendment Internal Strategy 6/6/2008 Doe 1 ProtectMarriage.com Nonpublic, confidential document discussing ProtectMarriage.com's FA
006852 Memorandum overall campaign strategy
1406 DEF_INT_PRIV_006853- First Amendment Internal Strategy 5/27/2008 Schubert Flint Public Affairs ProtectMarriage.com Nonpublic, confidential document discussing ProtectMarriage.com's FA
006886 Memorandum overall campaign strategy
1409 DEF_INT_PRIV_006890- First Amendment Draft Campaign Statement Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com campaign FA
006891 statement
1410 DEF_INT_PRIV_006892 First Amendment Draft Campaign Statement Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com campaign FA
statement
1412 DEF_INT_PRIV_006894- First Amendment Draft Ballot Argument Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com's ballot FA
006895 argument
1413 DEF_INT_PRIV_006896 First Amendment Draft Donation Letter Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com donation FA
letter
1414 DEF_INT_PRIV_006897- First Amendment Draft Informational Letter Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com informational FA
006900 letter regarding marriage
1417 DEF_INT_PRIV_006910 First Amendment Draft of Television Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com television FA
1419 DEF_INT_PRIV_006912 First Amendment Draft Script of Television 8/30/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a script for a ProtectMarriage.com FA
Advertisement television advertisement
DEF_INT_PRIV_006919- First Amendment Draft Script of Television 9/13/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a script for a ProtectMarriage.com FA
1424
73 of 99
script
1435 DEF_INT_PRIV_006937 First Amendment Draft Campaign Flyer Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com campaign FA
flyer
1437 DEF_INT_PRIV_006940 First Amendment Nonfinal Version of Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential version of a ProtectMarriage.com television FA
Television Advertisement advertisement
1438 DEF_INT_PRIV_006941 First Amendment Draft Script of Radio 9/27/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a script for a ProtectMarriage.com FA
Advertisement radio advertisement
1441 DEF_INT_PRIV_006944 First Amendment Nonfinal Version of Radio Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential version of a ProtectMarriage.com radio FA
1442 DEF_INT_PRIV_006945 First Amendment Draft Promotional Flyer Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com promotional FA
flyer
1443 DEF_INT_PRIV_007019 - First Amendment Email 10/3/2008 Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007020 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
1444 DEF_INT_PRIV_007023 - First Amendment Email 9/12/2008 Jim Garlow Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning a FA
1445 DEF_INT_PRIV_007054 - First Amendment Email string 6/2/2008 Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007056 preparation of ProtectMarriage com's campaign messaging
1446 DEF_INT_PRIV_007057 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/20/2008 Ron Prentice Doe 1, Dan Kirby Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007058 press release) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
1447 DEF_INT_PRIV_007059 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 2/20/2008 Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007062 (internal phone script) 1 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com robocall to voters
1448 DEF_INT_PRIV_007063 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 5/16/2008 Ron Prentice Doe 1, Dan Kirby Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
1449 DEF_INT_PRIV_007065 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 5/13/2008 Ron Prentice Dan Kirby, Lynne Fishel, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007066 letter) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com donation letter
1450 DEF_INT_PRIV_007067 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 11/3/2008 Derek McCoy, Chip White Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Derek McCoy, Chip White Chip White, Ron Prentice, Nancy Limon Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning the FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007069 (draft media advisory) potential distribution of a press release
1451 DEF_INT_PRIV_007070 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 11/3/2008 Doe 1 Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007071 phone script) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com robocall to voters

1452 DEF_INT_PRIV_007072 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/27/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Jim Garlow Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning messaging for a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007074 statement for promotional ProtectMarriage.com event promoting Proposition 8
event)
74 of 99
1453 DEF_INT_PRIV_007075 - First Amendment Email with attachment 10/26/2008 Cherri Spriggs Hernandez Ron Prentice, Chris Clark, Ned Dolejsi, Jim Garlow Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Anne Subia Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication for a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007078 (internal agenda and talking ProtectMarriage.com event promoting Proposition 8
points)
1454 DEF_INT_PRIV_007079 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/22/2008 Doe 1, Ron Prentice Ron Prentice, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication regarding an FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007080 (draft flyer) event promoting Proposition 8
1455 DEF_INT_PRIV_007081 First Amendment Email 10/16/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Steve Linder, Jeff Flint, preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Nancy Limon, Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Gary
Lawrence, Does 1-2
1456 DEF_INT_PRIV_007083 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/14/2008 Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007085 letter) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com fundraising letter
1457 DEF_INT_PRIV_007088 - First Amendment Email with attachment 10/9/2008 Jeff Flint Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007089 (nonfinal advertisement) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com advertisement
1458 DEF_INT_PRIV_007090 - First Amendment Email with attachment 10/9/2008 Jeff Flint Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007091 (nonfinal advertisement) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com advertisement
1459 DEF_INT_PRIV_007092 - First Amendment Email (attachment is a 10/7/2008 Doe 1 Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning an event FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007093 publicly distributed flyer promoting Proposition 8
which has been produced)
1460 DEF_INT_PRIV_007094 - First Amendment Email string with related 10/2/2008 Doe 1, William Tam Ron Prentice, William Tam, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication regarding an FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007095 attachment event promoting Proposition 8
1461 DEF_INT_PRIV_007105 - First Amendment Email string with related 9/15/2008 Derek McCoy, Ron Prentice Ron Prentice, Derek McCoy Nonpublic, confidential communication and draft flyer regarding an FA
1462 DEF_INT_PRIV_007107 - First Amendment Email with related 9/15/2008 Derek McCoy Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication and draft flyer regarding an FA
1463 DEF_INT_PRIV_007113 - First Amendment Email with attachments 8/25/2008 Doe 1 Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication and draft materials regarding FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007174 (draft promotional an event promoting Proposition 8
materials)
1464 DEF_INT_PRIV_007175 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 8/22/2008 Jim Garlow Does 1-2, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication and draft flyer regarding an FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007178 flyer) event promoting Proposition 8
1465 DEF_INT_PRIV_007179 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 8/21/2008 Doe 1 Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007181 flyer) preparation of a flyer promoting Proposition 8
1466 DEF_INT_PRIV_007182 First Amendment Email string 8/19/2008 Doe 1, Ron Prentice Doe 1, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning campaign events FA
1467 DEF_INT_PRIV_007183 - First Amendment Email with attachments 8/13/2008 Michael Sowers Doe Executive Committee Member, Ron Prentice Steve Linder, Peter Henderson, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007186 (draft promotional ProtectMarriage.com fundraising letter
materials)
1468 DEF_INT_PRIV_007187 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 8/11/2008 Steve Linder Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007189 flyer) ProtectMarriage.com flyer
1469 DEF_INT_PRIV_007190 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 8/4/2008 Jeff Flint Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
1470 DEF_INT_PRIV_007204 - First Amendment Email with attachment 6/30/2008 Charles LiMandri Frank Schubert Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication regarding overall campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007207 (internal talking points) messaging
1471 DEF_INT_PRIV_007208 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/17/2008 Dan Kirby Doe 1 Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication regarding potential message FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007213 letter) for ProtectMarriage com's website
1472 DEF_INT_PRIV_007214 - First Amendment Email with attachment 6/16/2008 Bill May Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential communication regarding campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007215 (internal talking points) messaging for future media appearance
1473 DEF_INT_PRIV_007216 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/3/2008 Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Dan Kirby Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007217 letter) ProtectMarriage.com letter to supporters of Proposition 8
1474 DEF_INT_PRIV_007218 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 5/21/2008 Dan Kirby Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007219 letter) ProtectMarriage.com letter to supporters of Proposition 8
1475 DEF_INT_PRIV_007220 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 5/14/2008 Dan Kirby Doe 1 Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007221 webpage) posting for the ProtectMarriage.com website
1476 DEF_INT_PRIV_007222 - First Amendment Email 8/21/2009 Gary Lawrence Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential discussion about messaging used during the FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007224 ProtectMarriage.com campaign
75 of 99
1477 DEF_INT_PRIV_007225 - First Amendment Email string 11/3/2008 Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe 1, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Does 2-4 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions about directing FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007227 Doe Executive Committee Member, Ron Prentice, Frank particular messaging and promotional materials to a specific group
Schubert of voters
1478 DEF_INT_PRIV_007228 - First Amendment Email string 10/17/2008 Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Mark Jansson, Doe 1, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007231 Jansson, Doe 1 Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Chip White, preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
1480 DEF_INT_PRIV_007235 - First Amendment Email 10/17/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning videos FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007236 Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Chip White, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint promoting marriage and Proposition 8
1481 DEF_INT_PRIV_007237 - First Amendment Email 10/17/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning videos FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007238 Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Chip White, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint promoting marriage and Proposition 8
1482 DEF_INT_PRIV_007239 - First Amendment Email string 10/17/2008 Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson, Mark Jansson, Doe 1, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007240 Doe 1 Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Chip White, preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
1484 DEF_INT_PRIV_007243 First Amendment Email 10/3/2008 Steve Linder Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a video FA
Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, promoting Proposition 8
Peter Henderson, Michael Sowers, Doe 1
1485 DEF_INT_PRIV_007244 - First Amendment Email string 9/27/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Ned Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007245 Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Does 1-3 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
1486 DEF_INT_PRIV_007246 First Amendment Email string 9/27/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Ned Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Does 1-3 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
1487 DEF_INT_PRIV_007247 First Amendment Email string 9/27/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Ned Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Does 1-3 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
1488 DEF_INT_PRIV_007248 First Amendment Email 9/26/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Ned Gary Lawrence, Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member resources for developing campaign messaging
1489 DEF_INT_PRIV_007249 - First Amendment Email string 9/16/2008 Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Ned Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007250 Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
1490 DEF_INT_PRIV_007251 First Amendment Email string 9/15/2008 Doe Executive Committee Member, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Ned Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
Ron Prentice Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Doe preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
1
1491 DEF_INT_PRIV_007252 - First Amendment Email 8/19/2008 Mark Jansson Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential correspondence discussing campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007253 fundraising and strategy
1492 DEF_INT_PRIV_007254 - First Amendment Email string 8/7/2008 Frank Schubert, Jennifer Kerns Jennifer Kerns, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions developing talking FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007255 Jansson, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, points for the ProtectMarriage.com campaign
Frank Schubert
1493 DEF_INT_PRIV_007256 - First Amendment Email 8/7/2008 Jennifer Kerns Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions developing talking FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007257 Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert points for the ProtectMarriage.com campaign
1494 DEF_INT_PRIV_007258 - First Amendment Email string 12/5/2008 Ron Prentice, Bill May Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Nonpublic, confidential discussions about campaign strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007262 Frank Schubert
1495 DEF_INT_PRIV_007263 - First Amendment Email string 9/2/2008 Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Does 1-5 Nonpublic, confidential discussions about a ProtectMarriage com FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007264 Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Chip White, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, public event promoting Proposition 8
Gary Lawrence
1496 DEF_INT_PRIV_007265 First Amendment Email 11/1/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Doe 1, Mark Nonpublic, confidential discussions about a public advertisement FA
Jansson, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence discussing Proposition 8
1497 DEF_INT_PRIV_007266 First Amendment Email string 10/31/2008 Mark Jansson, Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential discussions about a potential public FA
communication supporting Proposition 8
76 of 99
1498 DEF_INT_PRIV_007267 - First Amendment Email 10/31/2008 Doe 1 Cherri Spriggs Hernandez, Chip White, Janeth Hernandez, Jeff Nonpublic discussion concerning messaging strategy about FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007269 Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Laura Saucedo Cunningham, Maria Proposition 8
Fernanda, Mark Jansson, Nancy Limon, Sarah Pollo, Sonja
Eddings Brown, Does 2-146
1499 DEF_INT_PRIV_007270 First Amendment Email 10/30/2008 Doe 1 Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential discussions about a potential public FA
communication promoting Proposition 8
1500 DEF_INT_PRIV_007271 - First Amendment Email 10/28/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ned Nonpublic, confidential discussions about a potential public FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007272 Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Does 1-4 communication promoting Proposition 8
1501 DEF_INT_PRIV_007273 - First Amendment Email string 10/27/2008 Does 1-2 Mark Jansson, Does 1-2 Nonpublic, confidential discussions about messaging for a specific FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007274 group of voters
1502 DEF_INT_PRIV_007275 - First Amendment Email string 10/26/2008 Mark Jansson, Does 1-2 Mark Jansson, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Does 2-4 Doe 5, Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential discussions about messaging and campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007278 strategy
1503 DEF_INT_PRIV_007279 - First Amendment Email string 10/26/2008 Mark Jansson, Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Does 2-4 Doe 5, Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential discussions about messaging and campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007282 strategy
1504 DEF_INT_PRIV_007283 - First Amendment Email string 10/25/2008 Does 1-2 Does 1-3 Does 2, 4-11 Nonpublic, confidential discussion about campaign messaging, FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007285 media coverage of the campaign, and voter reaction
1505 DEF_INT_PRIV_007286 - First Amendment Email string 10/25/2008 Does 1-2 Does 1-2, Mark Jansson Doe 1, Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential discussions about a potential public FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007288 communication promoting Proposition 8
1506 DEF_INT_PRIV_007289 - First Amendment Email string 9/16/2008 Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Ned Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007291 Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, ProtectMarriage.com letter
Gary Lawrence
1507 DEF_INT_PRIV_007292- First Amendment Email string 10/17/2008 - Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007293 10/24/2008 Doe 1, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Chip White, Frank preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com letter
Member Schubert, Jeff Flint, Does 1-4
1508 DEF_INT_PRIV_007294- First Amendment Email string 10/23/2008 - Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning media relations and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007295 10/24/2008 Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Chip White, messaging
Sonja Eddings Brown, Does 1-4
1509 DEF_INT_PRIV_007296- First Amendment Email string 10/23/2008 - Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning media relations and FA
1510 DEF_INT_PRIV_007298- First Amendment Email string 10/23/2008 - Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning media relations and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007299 10/24/2008 Frank Schubert Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Chip White, messaging
1511 DEF_INT_PRIV_007300- First Amendment Email string 10/23/2008 - Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning media relations and FA
1512 DEF_INT_PRIV_007302- First Amendment Email string 10/23/2008 Ron Prentice, Doe 1, Frank Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Steve Linder, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential discussions about a potential public FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007303 Schubert Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Andrew communication supporting Proposition 8
Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe 1
1513 DEF_INT_PRIV_007304- First Amendment Email string 10/23/2008 - Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning media relations and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007305 10/24/2008 Frank Schubert Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Chip White, messaging
1514 DEF_INT_PRIV_007306 First Amendment Email string 10/23/2008 Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning media relations and FA
Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Chip White, messaging
1515 DEF_INT_PRIV_007307 First Amendment Email 10/23/2008 Ron Prentice Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning media relations and FA
Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown, messaging
Doe 1
1516 DEF_INT_PRIV_007308 - First Amendment Email string 10/22/2008 Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Does 2-32 Nonpublic, confidential correspondence with volunteers about FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007309 messaging that could be used to promote Proposition 8
1517 DEF_INT_PRIV_007310 - First Amendment Email 10/22/2008 Doe 1 Maria Fernanda, Mark Jansson, Does 2-3 Nonpublic, confidential discussions about public communications FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007312 that could be used to promote Proposition 8
1518 DEF_INT_PRIV_007313 - First Amendment Email string 10/22/2008 Doe 1, Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning campaign strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007314 Doe Executive Committee Member, Ron and messaging in response to particular media story
Prentice, Does 2-3
77 of 99
1519 DEF_INT_PRIV_007315 - First Amendment Email string 10/22/2008 Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning campaign strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007316 Doe Executive Committee Member, Ron and messaging in response to particular media story
Prentice, Does 2-3
1520 DEF_INT_PRIV_007317 First Amendment Email string 10/22/2008 Does 1-2 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning campaign strategy FA
Doe Executive Committee Member, Ron and messaging in response to particular media story
Prentice, Does 2-3
1521 DEF_INT_PRIV_007318 - First Amendment Email string 10/22/2008 Doe 1, Mark Jansson Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Doe 1, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential discussions in preparation of a letter FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007319 Mark Jansson Member, Mark Jansson, Does 2-3 supporting Proposition 8
1522 DEF_INT_PRIV_007320 - First Amendment Email string 10/22/2008 Doe 1, Ron Prentice, Andrew Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Mark Does 3-4 Nonpublic, confidential discussions in preparation of a letter FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007321 Pugno Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, supporting Proposition 8
Doe 2
1523 DEF_INT_PRIV_007322 - First Amendment Email 10/22/2008 Mark Jansson Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning a video FA
1524 DEF_INT_PRIV_007324 First Amendment Email string 10/21/2008 Mark Jansson, Doe 1 Doe 1, Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning a video FA
1525 DEF_INT_PRIV_007325 First Amendment Email 10/21/2008 Mark Jansson Does 1-7 Robb Wirthlin, Mike Spence, Steve Linder, Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning a FA
Does 8-22 video promoting Proposition 8
1526 DEF_INT_PRIV_007326 First Amendment Email 10/21/2008 Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Chip Nonpublic, confidential communication regarding a FA
White, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ron ProtectMarriage.com letter
Prentice
1527 DEF_INT_PRIV_007327 First Amendment Email string 10/20/2008 Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential discussions in preparation of a letter FA
Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron supporting Proposition 8
Prentice
1528 DEF_INT_PRIV_007328 First Amendment Email string 10/20/2008 Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential discussions in preparation of a letter FA
Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron supporting Proposition 8
Prentice
1529 DEF_INT_PRIV_007329 - First Amendment Email 10/19/2008 Mark Jansson Gary Lawrence, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential discussions about a potential public FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007330 Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Chip White, Frank communication promoting Proposition 8
1530 DEF_INT_PRIV_007331 - First Amendment Email 10/19/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the content of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007332 Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron ProtectMarriage.com press releases
Prentice
1531 DEF_INT_PRIV_007333 First Amendment Email 10/17/2008 Doe 1 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential discussions in preparation of a letter FA
1532 DEF_INT_PRIV_007334 First Amendment Email 10/15/2008 Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Does 2-30 Nonpublic, confidential correspondence among volunteers about FA
public communications promoting Proposition 8
public communications promoting Proposition 8
1534 DEF_INT_PRIV_007336 First Amendment Email 10/14/2008 Gary Lawrence Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential discussions about a public communication FA
Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Frank promoting Proposition 8
Adams, Jeff Flint, Keith Atkinson, Peter Knobloch
1535 DEF_INT_PRIV_007337- First Amendment Email string 10/12/2008 Chip White, Frank Schubert, Ron Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Chip White, Ron Prentice Sonja Edding Brown, Nancy Limon, Doe 1, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning draft of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007341 Prentice Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Laura Saucedo ProtectMarriage.com press release
Cunningham, Bill May
1536 DEF_INT_PRIV_007342- First Amendment Email string 10/12/2008 Chip White, Frank Schubert, Ron Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Chip White, Ron Prentice Sonja Edding Brown, Nancy Limon, Doe 1, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning draft of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007347 Prentice Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Laura Saucedo ProtectMarriage.com press release
Cunningham, Bill May
1537 DEF_INT_PRIV_007348- First Amendment Email string 10/11/2008 - Doe 1, Mark Jansson Doe 1, Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning draft script FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007350 10/12/2008 for a video promoting Proposition 8
1538 DEF_INT_PRIV_007351 First Amendment Email 10/9/2008 Mark Jansson Gary Lawrence, Does 1-5 Mark Jansson, Does 6-26 Nonpublic, confidential discussions about a public communication FA
1539 DEF_INT_PRIV_007352 First Amendment Email 10/8/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential discussions about a public communication FA
Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, promoting Proposition 8
Sonja Edding Brown, Chip White, Does 1-3
1540 DEF_INT_PRIV_007353 First Amendment Email 10/8/2008 Mark Jansson Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential discussions about a public communication FA
Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno promoting Proposition 8
78 of 99
1541 DEF_INT_PRIV_007354 First Amendment Email 10/7/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions about a No on 8 FA
Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, advertisement
Sonja Edding Brown, Chip White, Steve Linder, Does 1-2
1542 DEF_INT_PRIV_007355 - First Amendment Email string 9/30/2008 - Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Member, Andrew Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning advertising FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007357 10/1/2008 Committee Member Pugno messaging points and potential voter responses
1543 DEF_INT_PRIV_007358 - First Amendment Email string 9/30/2008 - Doe Executive Committee Member Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning advertising FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007360 10/1/2008 messaging points and potential voter responses
1544 DEF_INT_PRIV_007361 First Amendment Email 9/27/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Nonpublic, confidential discussions about a public communication FA
Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, promoting Proposition 8
Does 1-3
messaging strategy and a potential public communication
1546 DEF_INT_PRIV_007363 - First Amendment Email string 9/15/2008 - Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential discussions in preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007364 9/23/2008 Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Does ProtectMarriage.com letter
1-3
1547 DEF_INT_PRIV_007365 - First Amendment Email string 9/15/2008 - Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential discussions in preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007366 9/23/2008 Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Does ProtectMarriage.com letter
1-3
1548 DEF_INT_PRIV_007367 First Amendment Email 9/23/2008 Doe 1 Ned Dolejsi Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Andrew Nonpublic, confidential discussions about a public communication FA
Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, promoting Proposition 8
1549 DEF_INT_PRIV_007368 First Amendment Email 9/23/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Andrew Pugno, Doe Gary Lawrence Nonpublic, confidential discussions about a public communication FA
Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice promoting Proposition 8
1550 DEF_INT_PRIV_007369 - First Amendment Email string 9/15/2008 - Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert, Mark Doe 1, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Andrew Doe 2 Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007370 9/23/2008 Jansson Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron ProtectMarriage.com letter
Prentice, Mark Jansson
1551 DEF_INT_PRIV_007371 - First Amendment Email string 9/15/2008 - Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson Doe 1, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Andrew Doe 2 Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007372 9/23/2008 Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron ProtectMarriage.com letter
1552 DEF_INT_PRIV_007373 - First Amendment Email string 9/15/2008 - Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson Doe 1, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Andrew Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007374 9/22/2008 Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron ProtectMarriage.com letter
1553 DEF_INT_PRIV_007375 First Amendment Email string 9/15/2008 - Mark Jansson Doe 1, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Andrew Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning preparation of a FA
9/22/2008 Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron ProtectMarriage.com letter
1554 DEF_INT_PRIV_007376 - First Amendment Email 9/22/2008 Jennifer Kerns Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions about a No on 8 FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007377 Michael Sowers, Steve Linder, Gary advertisement
Lawrence
1555 DEF_INT_PRIV_007378 - First Amendment Email string 9/19/2008 - Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential discussions about messaging and strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007379 9/20/2008 targeted to a specific group of voters
1556 DEF_INT_PRIV_007380 First Amendment Email string 9/16/2008 Mark Jansson, Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Doe 1 Doe 2 Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning preparation of a FA
ProtectMarriage.com letter
1557 DEF_INT_PRIV_007381 - First Amendment Email string 9/15/2008 Does 1-2 Doe 1, Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential discussions about messaging and strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007385 targeted to a specific group of voters
1558 DEF_INT_PRIV_007386 First Amendment Email string 9/13/2008 - Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning preparation of a FA
9/14/ 2008 Committee Member, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert ProtectMarriage.com letter
1559 DEF_INT_PRIV_007387 - First Amendment Email string 9/13/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Gary Lawrence, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential discussions about a communication strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007388 Dolejsi, Ron Prentice that could be used to promote Proposition 8
1560 DEF_INT_PRIV_007389 First Amendment Email string 9/12/2008 - Doe 1, Ned Dolejsi Frank Schubert, Jeff Fint, Doe 1 Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Ron Prentice, Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning preparation of a FA
9/13/ 2008 Does 2-3 ProtectMarriage.com letter

1561 DEF_INT_PRIV_007390 First Amendment Email string 9/12/2008 Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Andrew Pugno, Doe Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential discussions about using a public FA
Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Mark communication to promote Proposition 8
Jansson
79 of 99
1562 DEF_INT_PRIV_007391 First Amendment Email 9/12/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential discussion about potentially using a public FA
Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice communication to promote Proposition 8
1563 DEF_INT_PRIV_007392 - First Amendment Email string 8/29/2008 Does 1-2 Gary Lawrence, Does 3-8 Does 1-2, 9-13 Nonpublic, confidential discussion about potentially using a public FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007394 communication to promote Proposition 8
1564 DEF_INT_PRIV_007395 - First Amendment Email 8/27/2008 Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, Doe Executive Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication about a No on 8 FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007396 Committee Member advertisement
1565 DEF_INT_PRIV_007397 First Amendment Email 8/13/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Jennifer Kerns Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning potential FA
Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Does 1-3 ProtectMarriage.com campaign talking points
1566 DEF_INT_PRIV_007398 First Amendment Email 8/13/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Jennifer Kerns Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning potential FA
Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice ProtectMarriage.com campaign talking points
1567 DEF_INT_PRIV_007399 - First Amendment Email string 8/8/2008 Doe 1, Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential discussions about messaging and strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007401 targeted to specific groups of voters
1568 DEF_INT_PRIV_007402 - First Amendment Email string 8/5/2008 - Mark Jansson, Doe 1 Doe 1, Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning messaging and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007405 8/6/2008 campaign volunteer recruitment
1569 DEF_INT_PRIV_007406 - First Amendment Email string 8/4/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Nancy Limon, Sarah Pollo, Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions about a No on 8 FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007407 Ned Dolejsi, Doe 1, Steve Linder, Doe Executive Committee advertisement
Member, Jennifer Kerns
1570 DEF_INT_PRIV_007408 First Amendment Email 8/4/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, Nancy Limon, Sarah Pollo, Bill Criswell Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions about a No on 8 FA
Ned Dolejsi, Doe 1, Steve Linder, Doe Executive Committee advertisement
Member, Jennifer Kerns
1571 DEF_INT_PRIV_007409 - First Amendment Email string 7/2/2008 Mark Jansson, Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno, Doe Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning draft of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007410 Executive Committee Member public statement in support of Proposition 8
1572 DEF_INT_PRIV_007411 - First Amendment Email 6/17/2008 Mark Jansson Doe 1 Doe 2 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion regarding strategy for FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007412 a ProtectMarriage.com press release
1573 DEF_INT_PRIV_007413 - First Amendment Email 6/13/2008 Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential discussion regarding potential mesaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007415 points and spokesperson for the ProtectMarriage.com campaign
1574 DEF_INT_PRIV_007416 - First Amendment Email string 6/9/2008 Doe 1, Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Doe 2 Nonpublic, confidential discussion about a public communication FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007417 supporting Proposition 8
1575 DEF_INT_PRIV_007418 - First Amendment Email 6/9/2008 Doe 1 Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential discussion about a public communication FA
1576 DEF_INT_PRIV_007420 - First Amendment Email string 5/15/2008 Andrew Pugno Dennis Hollingsworth, Doe Executive Committee Member, Nonpublic, confidential correspondence outlining potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007421 David Bauer, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, William Tam, Bill May, ProtectMarriage.com campaign talking points
Joe Infranco, Ron Prentice, Dan Kirby, Everett Rice, Pete
Henderson, Robert Tyler, Terry Thompson, Does 1-15
1577 DEF_INT_PRIV_007422 First Amendment Email string 2/22/2008 Mark Jansson, Joe Infranco, Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Joe Infranco, Lynne Fishel, Ron Prentice, Mike Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning potential FA
Spence ProtectMarriage.com campaign talking points
1578 DEF_INT_PRIV_007423 - First Amendment Email string 11/3/2008 - Doe 1, Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Ron Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions culminating in a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007425 11/4/2008 Brown Prentice, Doe 2 Ned Dolejsi, Doe 3 working draft of a ProtectMarriage com press release
1579 DEF_INT_PRIV_007426 - First Amendment Email string 10/31/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Janeth Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1, Janeth Hernandez Nonpublic, confidential discussion about the content of a video FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007429 Hernandez, Doe 1 advertisement promoting Proposition 8
1580 DEF_INT_PRIV_007430 First Amendment Email 10/31/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential discussion about content and distribution of a FA
video advertisement promoting Proposition 8
1581 DEF_INT_PRIV_007431 First Amendment Email 10/31/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Chip White Nonpublic, confidential discussion about promotional video in FA
support of Proposition 8
1582 DEF_INT_PRIV_007432 - First Amendment Email string 10/30/2008 - Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Meg Waters, Nancy Limon Meg Waters, Nancy Limon, Maria Nonpublic, confidential discussion about promotional video in FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007433 10/31/2008 Fernanda, Janeth Hernandez support of Proposition 8
1583 DEF_INT_PRIV_007434 First Amendment Email 10/31/2008 Doe 1 Sonja Eddings Brown Nonpublic, confidential discussion about promotional video in FA
support of Proposition 8
1584 DEF_INT_PRIV_007435 - First Amendment Email 10/30/2008 Chip White Sonja Eddings Brown Nonpublic, confidential email containing a draft of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007436 ProtectMarriage.com media advisory
1585 DEF_INT_PRIV_007437 - First Amendment Email string 10/27/2008 - Sonja Eddings Brown, Does 1-2 Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown, Nonpublic, confidential discussions regarding preparation of a video FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007443 10/29/2008 Does 3-5 communicating a particular message to voters
1586 DEF_INT_PRIV_007444 - First Amendment Email string 10/25/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1 Sonja Eddings Brown, Maria Fernanda, Does 1-44 Nonpublic, confidential discussion about promotional video FA
80 of 99
1587 DEF_INT_PRIV_007446 - First Amendment Email 10/20/2008 - Sonja Eddings Brown, Andrew Frank Schubert, Nancy Limon, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion developing a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007449 10/23/2008 Pugno, Ron Prentice, Frank Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson, response to a media inquiry
Schubert Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1
1588 DEF_INT_PRIV_007450 - First Amendment Email string 10/17/2008 - Maria Fernanda, Nancy Limon, Maria Fernanda, Janeth Hernandez, Nancy Limon, Laura Janeth Hernandez, Sonja Eddings Brown, Nonpublic, confidential discussion about the preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007455 10/18/2008 Laura Saucedo Cunningham Saucedo Cunningham Laura Saucedo Cunningham, Maria Protectmarriage.com press release
Fernanda, Nancy Limon
1589 DEF_INT_PRIV_007456 First Amendment Email 10/17/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential email containing a link to a promotional video FA
1590 DEF_INT_PRIV_007459 First Amendment Email 10/15/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential correspondence sending internal campaign FA
messaging
1591 DEF_INT_PRIV_007460 - First Amendment Email string 10/14/2008 Nancy Limon, Janeth Hernandez Janeth Hernandez, Nancy Limon Laura Saucedo Cunningham, Maria Nonpublic, confidential discussion about the preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007462 Fernanda, Sonja Eddings Brown Protectmarriage.com press release
1592 DEF_INT_PRIV_007463 - First Amendment Email string 10/15/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1 Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1 Doe 2 Nonpublic, confidental discussion about the release of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007464 Protectmarriage.com media advisory
1593 DEF_INT_PRIV_007465 - First Amendment Email string 10/8/2008 - Sonja Eddings Brown, Frank Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential discussions about a video promoting FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007466 10/9/2008 Schubert Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Nancy Limon, Sonja Proposition 8
Eddings Brown, Chip White, Frank Schubert, Does 1-2
1594 DEF_INT_PRIV_007467 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 11/6/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential correspondence sending a draft of a FA
1595 DEF_INT_PRIV_007469 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 11/6/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Cherri Spriggs Hernandez Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential correspondence sending a draft of a FA
1596 DEF_INT_PRIV_007471 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 11/3/2008 Chip White, Derek McCoy Derek McCoy, Cherri Spriggs Hernandez, Frank Schubert, Jeff Sonja Eddings Brown, Meg Waters, Doe 3, Nonpublic, confidential correspondence discussing the preparation FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007472 (draft press release) Flint, Chip White, Does 1-2 Nancy Limon of a ProtectMarriage.com press release
1597 DEF_INT_PRIV_007473 First Amendment Email 11/3/2008 Does 1-2 Gary Lawrence Sonja Eddings Brown, Does 2-3 Nonpublic, confidential discussion about a rally promoting FA
Proposition 8
1598 DEF_INT_PRIV_007474 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 11/1/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential discussion about an opinion editorial FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007476 opinion editorial) supporting Proposition 8
1599 DEF_INT_PRIV_007477 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/31/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Janeth Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1 Laura Saucedo Cunningham, Maria Nonpublic, confidential discussion about a draft of a video script FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007478 (draft video script) Hernandez Fernanda, Nancy Limon promoting Proposition 8
1600 DEF_INT_PRIV_007479- First Amendment Email string with 10/31/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1 Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings Brown Nonpublic, confidential correspondence about messaging for a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007481 attachments (draft phone promotional ProtectMarriage.com phone call
scripts)
1601 DEF_INT_PRIV_007482 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/31/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential email correspondence transmitting a draft of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007484 press release) a ProtectMarriage.com press release
1602 DEF_INT_PRIV_007485- First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/30/2008 Meg Waters, Sonja Eddings Brown Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown Meg Waters, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential discussion about a Protectmarriage.com FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007489 (draft press release) press release
1603 DEF_INT_PRIV_007490- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/30/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Meg Waters Nonpublic, confidential correspondence about a draft of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007492 press release) Protectmarriage.com press release
1604 DEF_INT_PRIV_007493- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/30/2008 Cherri Spriggs Hernandez Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Meg Waters Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential correspondence about a draft of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007494 media advisory) Protectmarriage.com media advisory
1605 DEF_INT_PRIV_007495- First Amendment Email with attachment 10/29/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential email correspondence transmitting a draft of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007497 (internal talking points) internal ProtectMarriage com talking points
1606 DEF_INT_PRIV_007498 First Amendment Email (attachment is a 10/28/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Maria Fernanda, Janeth Hernandez Nonpublic, confidential communication regarding a FA
publicly distributed press ProtectMarriage.com media release
release which has been
produced)
1607 DEF_INT_PRIV_007500- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/28/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Jeff Flint, Chip White, Meg Waters, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential correspondence about a draft of a FA
1608 DEF_INT_PRIV_007503- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/23/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Meg Waters Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion about a draft of an FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007505 opinion editorial) opinion editorial
1609 DEF_INT_PRIV_007506- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/23/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Meg Waters Nonpublic, confidential email correspondence transmitting a draft of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007507 message) campaign messaging
81 of 99
1610 DEF_INT_PRIV_007508- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/23/2008 Chip White Sonja Eddings Brown Nonpublic, confidential email transmitting a marked-up draft of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007516 letter) ProtectMarriage.com press release with supporting materials
1611 DEF_INT_PRIV_007517- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/22/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential email transmitting a draft of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007518 media advisory) ProtectMarriage.com media advisory
1612 DEF_INT_PRIV_007519- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/22/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Nancy Limon, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential email discussing campaign messaging and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007523 press release) attaching a draft press release
1613 DEF_INT_PRIV_007524- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/21/2008 Derek McCoy Sonja Eddings Brown Nonpublic, confidential email transmitting a draft of a FA
1614 DEF_INT_PRIV_007529- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/21/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Derek McCoy Nonpublic, confidential email transmitting a draft of a FA
1615 DEF_INT_PRIV_007532- First Amendment Email (attachment is a 10/20/2008 - Sonja Eddings Brown, Mark Sonja Eddings Brown, Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential discussion about ProtectMarriage.com's FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007535 publicly distributed video 10/21/2008 Jansson potential use of a video promoting Proposition 8
which has been already
been disclosed)
1616 DEF_INT_PRIV_007536- First Amendment Email (attachment is a 10/20/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Mark Sonja Eddings Brown, Mark Jansson, Derek McCoy Nonpublic, confidential discussion about the campaign's potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007539 publicly distributed video Jansson use of a video promoting Proposition 8
which has been already
been disclosed)
1617 DEF_INT_PRIV_007540- First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/18/2008 - Sonja Eddings Brown, Frank Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Derek McCoy Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential correspondence transmitting draft talking FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007543 (draft talking points) 10/20/2008 Schubert points for an event promoting Proposition 8
1619 DEF_INT_PRIV_007547- First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/18/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Does 1-2 Sonja Eddings Brown, Mark Jansson, Does 2-32 Nonpublic, confidential discussions among volunteers about a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007548 Protectmarriage.com promotional sign
1620 DEF_INT_PRIV_007549 First Amendment Email 10/20/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Derek McCoy Nonpublic, confidential email transmitting a ProtectMarriage com FA
press release
1621 DEF_INT_PRIV_007550 First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/20/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Doe 1 Doe 2 Nonpublic, confidential email transmitting a draft of a FA
1622 DEF_INT_PRIV_007553- First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/19/2008 Frank Schubert Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint, Chip White, Cherri Spriggs Nonpublic, confidential correspondence transmitting draft talking FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007556 (draft talking points) Hernandez points for an event promoting Proposition 8
1623 DEF_INT_PRIV_007557 First Amendment Email string 10/19/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1 Doe 1, Sonja Eddings Brown Nonpublic, confidential correspondence discussing an event FA
1624 DEF_INT_PRIV_007558 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/18/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Derek McCoy Nonpublic, confidential email transmitting a draft of a flyer for an FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007559 flyer) event promoting Proposition 8
1625 DEF_INT_PRIV_007560- First Amendment Email with attachments 10/18/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Chip White, Doe 1 Nancy Limon, Sarah Pollo, Doe 2 Nonpublic, confidential correspondence discussing the creation of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007564 (draft press releases and promotional materials for events supporting Proposition 8
flyers)
1626 DEF_INT_PRIV_007565- First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/18/2008 Nancy Limon, Maria Fernanda Maria Fernanda, Janeth Hernandez, Nancy Limon Laura Saucedo Cunningham, Sonja Nonpublic, confidential correspondence discussing preparation and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007567 (blast email) Eddings Brown distribution of a ProtectMarriage com blast email
1627 DEF_INT_PRIV_007568- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/17/2008 Chip White Cherri Spriggs Hernandez, Sonja Eddings Brown, Frank Nonpublic, confidential email transmitting a draft of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007570 media booking memo) Schubert, Jeff Flint, Does 1-2 ProtectMarriage.com booking memo
1628 DEF_INT_PRIV_007571- First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/17/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Laura Jeff Flint, Janeth Hernandez, Maria Fernanda Nancy Limon Nonpublic, confidential correspondence regarding the preparation of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007574 (draft phone script) Saucedo Cunningham a ProtectMarriage.com promotional call to voters
1629 DEF_INT_PRIV_007575- First Amendment Email with attachment 10/16/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential email transmitting internal talking points for FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007577 (internal talking points) media interviews
1630 DEF_INT_PRIV_007578 First Amendment Email 10/16/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Chip White Nonpublic, confidential email regarding a ProtectMarriage com FA
event
1631 DEF_INT_PRIV_007579- First Amendment Email with attachment 10/16/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Chip White Nonpublic, confidential email transmitting a draft of internal FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007580 (internal campaign notes) campaign notes
82 of 99
1632 DEF_INT_PRIV_007581- First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/16/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Frank Doe 1, Sonja Eddings Brown Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential communication about a Protectmarriage.com FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007582 (nonfinal version of Schubert television advertisement
television advertisement)
1633 DEF_INT_PRIV_007583- First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/15/2008 - Janeth Hernandez Chip White, Jeff Flint, Sonja Eddings Brown, Laura Saucedo Maria Fernanda, Nancy Limon, Chip White Nonpublic, confidential communication about a Protectmarriage.com FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007586 (draft press release) 10/16/2008 Cunningham press release
1634 DEF_INT_PRIV_007587- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/16/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Chip White, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007590 press statement) Protectmarriage.com press statement
1635 DEF_INT_PRIV_007599- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/15/2008 Nancy Limon Janeth Hernandez, Maria Fernanda Laura Saucedo Cunningham, Sonja Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007600 flyer) Eddings Brown Protectmarriage.com flyer
1636 DEF_INT_PRIV_007601- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/15/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Chip White Nonpublic, confidential communication transmitting a draft of a FA
1637 DEF_INT_PRIV_007604- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/15/2008 Maria Fernanda Nancy Limon Sonja Eddings Brown, Janeth Hernandez Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007608 flyer) Protectmarriage.com flyer
1638 DEF_INT_PRIV_007609- First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/15/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1 Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of an FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007612 (draft opinion editorial) opinion editorial
1639 DEF_INT_PRIV_007613- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/15/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential email transmitting a draft opinion editorial FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007615 opinion editorial)
1640 DEF_INT_PRIV_007616- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/14/2008 Maria Fernanda Nancy Limon Laura Saucedo Cunningham, Sonja Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007618 press release) Eddings Brown, Janeth Hernandez distribution of a Protectmarriage com press release
1641 DEF_INT_PRIV_007619- First Amendment Email with attachment 10/14/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential correspondence discussing talking points FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007623 (internal talking points) and messaging
1643 DEF_INT_PRIV_007627- First Amendment Email string with 10/11/2008 - Nancy Limon, Maria Fernanda, Maria Fernanda, Nancy Limon, Sonja Eddings Brown Sonja Eddings Brown, Laura Saucedo Nonpublic, confidential discussion about draft Protectmarriage.com FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007639 attachments (draft print 10/14/2008 Janeth Hernandez Cunningham, Janeth Hernandez, Maria promotional materials
promotional materials) Fernanda
DEF_INT_PRIV_007642 opinion editorial) Protectmarriage.com print advertisement

1645 DEF_INT_PRIV_007643- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/14/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential email transmitting a draft opinion editorial FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007644 print advertisement)
1646 DEF_INT_PRIV_007645- First Amendment Email string with 10/12/2008 - Maria Fernanda, Nancy Limon Laura Saucedo Cunningham, Maria Fernanda, Nancy Limon, Sonja Eddings Brown, Janeth Fernanda, Nonpublic, confidential discussion about draft Protectmarriage.com FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007657 attachments (draft print 10/14/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Laura Saucedo Cunningham promotional materials
promotional materials)
1647 DEF_INT_PRIV_007658- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/14/2008 Maria Fernanda Laura Saucedo Cunningham Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Janeth Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007660 press release) Hernandez Protectmarriage.com press release
1648 DEF_INT_PRIV_007661- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/13/2008 Doe 1 Sonja Eddings Brown Nonpublic, confidential email transmitting a draft opinion editorial FA
1649 DEF_INT_PRIV_007664- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/13/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Charles Limandri Nonpublic, confidential email transmitting a draft opinion editorial FA
1651 DEF_INT_PRIV_007670- First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/8/2008 - Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1 Doe 1, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Chip White, Doe, Nancy Limon, Laura Nonpublic, confidential discussion about Protectmarriage.com FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007674 (internal talking points) 10/12/2008 Saucedo Cunningham talking points and media strategy
1652 DEF_INT_PRIV_007675- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/10/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Chip White Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
1653 DEF_INT_PRIV_007679 First Amendment Email string 10/10/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Doe 1 Doe 1, Sonja Eddings Brown Chip White Nonpublic, confidential correspondence discussing a FA
Protectmarriage.com press release
1654 DEF_INT_PRIV_007680- First Amendment Email string with 10/6/2008 - Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential discussion about messaging and media FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007691 attachments (internal 10/10/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jennifer Kerns relations

messaging documents)
1655 DEF_INT_PRIV_007692- First Amendment Email with attachment 10/9/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential email transmitting internal talking points FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007695 (internal talking points)
83 of 99
1656 DEF_INT_PRIV_007696- First Amendment Email with attachment 10/9/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential correspondence discussing FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007699 (internal talking points) ProtectMarriage.com's internal talking points
1657 DEF_INT_PRIV_007700- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/8/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential discussion regarding the drafting of an FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007702 opinion editorial) opinion editorial
1658 DEF_INT_PRIV_007703- First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/8/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown, Maria Maria Fernanda, Janeth Hernandez, Sonja Eddings Brown Laura Saucedo Cunningham, Nancy Limon Nonpublic, confidential discussion about Protectmarriage.com FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007707 (draft of internal talking Fernanda talking points and media strategy
points)
1659 DEF_INT_PRIV_007708- First Amendment Email with attachment 10/8/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential email transmitting internal talking points FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007711 (internal talking points)
1660 DEF_INT_PRIV_007712- First Amendment Email with attachment 10/8/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Nancy Limon, Laura Maria Fernanda, Janeth Hernandez Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007715 (internal talking points) Saucedo Cunningham, Doe 1 Protectmarriage.com's talking points
1661 DEF_INT_PRIV_007716- First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/8/2008 Sonja Eddings Brown Bill May, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Chip White, Doe, Nancy Limon, Laura Nonpublic, confidential communications concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007719 (internal talking points) Saucedo Cunningham Protectmarriage.com's talking points
1662 DEF_INT_PRIV_007720- First Amendment Email string with 9/28/2008 Frank Schubert Sonja Eddings Brown, Richard Peterson, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential communications concerning messaging for a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007752 attachments (materials Flint Protectmarriage.com press conference and materials relied upon to
relied upon to develop develop the messaging for that event
campaign messaging)
1663 DEF_INT_PRIV_007753 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/17/2009 Mark Jansson Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential email transmitting a draft of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007755 letter) ProtectMarriage.com letter
1664 DEF_INT_PRIV_007756 - First Amendment Email with attachment 8/18/2009 - Gary Lawrence, Ron Prentice Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Mark Jansson, Ned Nonpublic, confidential discussions regarding messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007758 (Nonpublic, confidential 8/20/2009 Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Andrew Pugno,
messaging memorandum) Does 1-3
1665 DEF_INT_PRIV_007759 - First Amendment Email with attachments 11/25/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Nonpublic, confidential email transmitting drafts of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007761 (draft letters) Dolejsi, Ron Prentice ProtectMarriage.com letters
1666 DEF_INT_PRIV_007762 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 11/6/2008 Frank Schubert Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno, Sonja Eddings Brown, Jeff Flint, Nonpublic, confidential email transmitting a draft of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007764 letter) Mark Jansson, Ron Prentice, Does 1-3 ProtectMarriage.com letter
1667 DEF_INT_PRIV_007765 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 11/4/2008 Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Andrew Nonpublic, confidential email transmitting drafts of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007767 press statements) Pugno, Ned Dolejsi ProtectMarriage.com press statements
1668 DEF_INT_PRIV_007768 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 11/1/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint, Gary Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning a video FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007770 (video script) Lawrence, Doe 1 promoting Proposition 8

1669 DEF_INT_PRIV_007771 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/30/2008 - Mark Jansson, Does 1-2 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Andrew Gary Lawrence, Does 6-8 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007775 (draft talking points) 10/31/2008 Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Chip ProtectMarriage.com talking points
White, Does 2-5
1670 DEF_INT_PRIV_007776 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/30/2008 - Does 1-2 Mark Jansson, Does 2-6 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007780 (draft talking points) 10/31/2008 ProtectMarriage.com talking points
1671 DEF_INT_PRIV_007781 - First Amendment Email string with 10/30/2008 Does 1-2 Mark Jansson, Doe 3 Doe 4 Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning drafts of potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007785 attachments (draft signs) ProtectMarriage.com signs
1672 DEF_INT_PRIV_007786 - First Amendment Email string with 10/28.2008 Mark Jansson Chip White, Sonja Eddings Brown Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussion concerning an event FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007796 attachments (third party promoting Proposition 8
flyers and signs)
1673 DEF_INT_PRIV_007797 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/22/2008 Eric King Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning drafts of a telephone FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007799 phone script and letter) script and letter supporting Proposition 8
1674 DEF_INT_PRIV_007800 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/22/2008 Ron Prentice, Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Does 3-4 Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007803 (draft letter) Member, Doe 2, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, ProtectMarriage.com letter
Jeff Flint
1675 DEF_INT_PRIV_007804 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/22/2008 Ron Prentice, Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Does 3-4 Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007806 (draft letter) Member, Doe 2, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, ProtectMarriage.com letter
Jeff Flint
1676 DEF_INT_PRIV_007807 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/22/2008 Doe 1 Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007809 letter) Member, Mark Jansson, Does 2-3 ProtectMarriage.com letter
1677 DEF_INT_PRIV_007810 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/21/2008 Doe 1, Mark Jansson Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Ned Dolejsi, Chip Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007815 (spreadsheet of campaign White, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ron ProtectMarriage.com letter
research) Prentice, Doe 1
84 of 99
1678 DEF_INT_PRIV_007816 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/19/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007818 letter) Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron ProtectMarriage.com letter
Prentice
1679 DEF_INT_PRIV_007819 - First Amendment Email with attachment 10/19/2008 Mark Jansson Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007820 (nonfinal version of video) video to potentially use in support of Proposition 8
1680 DEF_INT_PRIV_007821 - First Amendment Email with attachment 10/19/2008 Mark Jansson Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007822 (nonfinal version of video) video to potentially use in support of Proposition 8
1681 DEF_INT_PRIV_007823 - First Amendment Email with related 10/17/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Jeff Flint, Gary Nancy Limon, Sarah Pollo Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning strategy and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007828 attachment Lawrence, Doe Executive Committee Member, Does 1-4 messaging for particular issue related to ProtectMarriage com
campaign
1682 DEF_INT_PRIV_007829 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/17/2008 Mark Jansson, Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Doe 1, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007832 (draft letter) Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Chip White, ProtectMarriage.com letter
1683 DEF_INT_PRIV_007833 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/15/2008 Ned Dolejsi Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning resources for FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007839 (email with attachments Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Ron Prentice, developing a potential campaign message
considered as a source of Doe 1
potential campaign
messaging)
1684 DEF_INT_PRIV_007840 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/13/2008 Mark Jansson Doe 1 Doe 2 Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning development of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007842 (draft video script) video promoting Proposition 8
1685 DEF_INT_PRIV_007843 - First Amendment Email string with 10/9/2008 - Frank Schubert, Doe 1, Jeff Flint Mark Jansson, Doe 1, Frank Schubert Does 2-3 Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning campaign strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007864 attachments (internal 10/13/2008 and messaging directed to particular groups of voters
strategy memoranda)
1686 DEF_INT_PRIV_007865 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/11/2008 Mark Jansson Does 1-3 Gary Lawrence, Doe 4 Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning preparation of a video FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007867 (draft video script) to potentially use in support of Proposition 8
1687 DEF_INT_PRIV_007868 - First Amendment Email with attachment 10/9/2008 Doe 1 Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential memorandum concerning campaign strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007873 (internal strategy and messaging directed to particular groups of voters

memorandum)
1688 DEF_INT_PRIV_007874 - First Amendment Email with attachment 10/4/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Gary Lawrence, Does 1-6 Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning ProtectMarriage.com FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007888 (research materials for Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns messaging and media strategy
media strategy)
1689 DEF_INT_PRIV_007889 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 9/28/2008 Doe 1, Maria Fernanda Keith Atkinson, Doe 1, Mark Jansson Janeth Hernandez Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning ProtectMarriage.com FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007898 (internal strategy messaging strategy for particular groups of voters
memorandum)
1690 DEF_INT_PRIV_007899 - First Amendment Email with attachments 9/26/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007903 (draft letters) Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Does 1-3 ProtectMarriage.com letter
1691 DEF_INT_PRIV_007904 - First Amendment Email with attachment 9/23/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Jennifer Kerns, Andrew Pugno, Doe Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing a potential source FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007906 (material considered as a Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice of campaign messaging
1692 DEF_INT_PRIV_007907 - First Amendment Email with attachments 9/20/2008 Ron Prentice Doe 1 Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning development of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007930 (materials considered as a ProtectMarriage.com messaging and campaign strategy
1693 DEF_INT_PRIV_007931 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/16/2008 Mark Jansson Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007933 letter) Committee Member, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint ProtectMarriage.com letter
1694 DEF_INT_PRIV_007934 - First Amendment Email with attachment 9/15/2008 Doe 1 Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential memorandum concerning campaign strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007938 (internal strategy and messaging directed to particular groups of voters
memorandum)
1695 DEF_INT_PRIV_007939 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/15/2008 Mark Jansson Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of a FA
1696 DEF_INT_PRIV_007942 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 9/12/2008 - Mark Jansson, Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Mark Jansson Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Does 2-3 Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007945 (draft letter) 9/14/2008 ProtectMarriage.com letter
1697 DEF_INT_PRIV_007946 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 9/12/2008 - Mark Jansson, Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Mark Jansson Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Does 2-3 Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007949 (draft letter) 9/14/2008 ProtectMarriage.com letter
85 of 99
1698 DEF_INT_PRIV_007950 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/13/2008 Ron Prentice Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Committee Member, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007952 letter) Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint ProtectMarriage.com letter
1699 DEF_INT_PRIV_007953 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 9/12/2008 Mark Jansson, Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Does 2-3 Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007955 (draft letter) ProtectMarriage.com letter
1700 DEF_INT_PRIV_007956 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/12/2008 Doe 1 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Does 2-3 Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of a FA
1701 DEF_INT_PRIV_007959 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 8/31/2008 - Mark Jansson, Frank Schubert, Jeff Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Gary Lawrence, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007963 (draft television script) 9/1/2008 Flint, Gary Lawrence, Ned Dolejsi Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
Mark Jansson
1702 DEF_INT_PRIV_007964 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 8/29/2008 - Mark Jansson, Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Doe 1 Nonpublic discussion concerning campaign strategy and messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007966 (internal strategy 8/31/2008
memorandum)
1703 DEF_INT_PRIV_007967 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 8/20/2008 Jeff Flint, Mark Jansson Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007968 (draft webpage) Executive Committee Member, Bill Evans, Does 1-3 ProtectMarriage.com webpage
1704 DEF_INT_PRIV_007969 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 8/20/2008 Jeff Flint Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007970 webpage) Executive Committee Member ProtectMarriage.com webpage
1705 DEF_INT_PRIV_007971 - First Amendment Email string with related 8/18/2008 Does 1-2 Mark Jansson, Does 3-30 Nonpublic, confidential discussion among volunteers concerning the FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007974 attachment campaign strategy of the opponents of Proposition 8
1706 DEF_INT_PRIV_007975 - First Amendment Email string with related 8/11/2008 - Doe 1, Mark Jansson Mike Spence, Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning messaging and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007977 attachment 8/12/2008 Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice strategy in response to No on 8 event
1707 DEF_INT_PRIV_007978 - First Amendment Email string with related 8/11/2008 - Doe 1, Mark Jansson Mike Spence, Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning messaging and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007980 attachment 8/12/2008 Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice strategy in response to No on 8 event
1708 DEF_INT_PRIV_007981 - First Amendment Email with attachments 7/31/2008 Mark Jansson Does 1-2 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning drafts of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007987 (draft flyers) ProtectMarriage.com flyers
1709 DEF_INT_PRIV_007988 - First Amendment Email string with 6/30/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007992 attachments (materials Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice strategy in response to media coverage of campaign
considered as a source of
messaging)
1710 DEF_INT_PRIV_007993 First Amendment Email 6/26/2008 Doe 1 Doe 2 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning media coverage FA
of campaign
1711 DEF_INT_PRIV_007994 - First Amendment Email with attachments 7/17/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007996 (draft ballot materials) Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Doe 1, Mark Jansson, Gary Proposition 8 ballot materials
Lawrence, Steve Linder, Nancy Limon, Sarah Pollo
1712 DEF_INT_PRIV_007997 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 7/10/2008 Mark Jansson Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of an FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_007998 communication) Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice informational memorandum for ProtectMarriage.com donors and
potential donors
1713 DEF_INT_PRIV_007999 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 7/8/2008 Jeff Flint Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Doe Executive Committee Nancy Limon, Sarah Pollo, Frank Schubert, Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008002 ballot material) Member, Ned Dolejsi, Mark Jansson Gary Lawrence Proposition 8 ballot materials
1714 DEF_INT_PRIV_008003 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 7/2/2008 Gary Lawrence Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008005 ballot material) Proposition 8 ballot materials
1715 DEF_INT_PRIV_008006 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 7/2/2008 Mark Jansson Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008009 letter) Committee Member, Does 1-3 letter supporting Proposition 8
1716 DEF_INT_PRIV_008010 - First Amendment Email string with related 6/27/2008 Ron Prentice, Doe 1 Mark Jansson, Doe, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential discussion recruiting an organization's FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008036 attachments participation in the ProtectMarriage.com coalition
1717 DEF_INT_PRIV_008037 - First Amendment Email with related 6/25/2008 Ron Prentice Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing a potential source FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008040 attachment (materials of campaign messaging
considered as a source of
messaging)
1718 DEF_INT_PRIV_008041 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/14/2008 Bill May Ron Prentice Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno, Nonpublic, confidential discussion about recruiting an organization's FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008046 press release) Doe Executive Committee Member participation in the ProtectMarriage.com coalition
1719 DEF_INT_PRIV_008047 - First Amendment Email with related 6/9/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Joe Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing a potential source FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008050 attachment (materials Infranco, Lynne Fishel, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron of campaign messaging
considered as a source of Prentice, Mike Spence
messaging)
86 of 99
1720 DEF_INT_PRIV_008051 - First Amendment Email string 11/5/2008 Mark Jansson Andrew Pugno, Doe Executive Committee Member, Mark Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008052 Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Chip White, Frank strategy and media relations
1721 DEF_INT_PRIV_008053 - First Amendment Email string 10/19/2008 Mark Jansson Does 1-3 Does 4-12 Nonpublic, confidential discussion concerning the creation of a video FA
1722 DEF_INT_PRIV_008055 - First Amendment Email string 10/30/2008 Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Gary Lawrence, Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008056 Jeff Flint, Does 1-3 ProtectMarriage.com's messaging
1723 DEF_INT_PRIV_008057 - First Amendment Email 10/16/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
1724 DEF_INT_PRIV_008061 - First Amendment Email string 10/16/2008 Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno, Ron Andrew Pugno, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Steve Linder, Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008065 Prentice, Frank Schubert Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Doe Executive Committee Member, White, Nancy Limon, Sarah Pollo ProtectMarriage.com's public messaging, campaign strategy, and
Does 1-2 fundraising
1725 DEF_INT_PRIV_008066 - First Amendment Email 10/11/2008 Chip White Sonja Eddings Brown, Laura Saucedo Cunningham, Frank Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008067 Schubert, Jeff Flint, Nancy Limon, Janeth Hernandez, Maria ProtectMarriage.com press release
Fernanda, Does 1-2
1726 DEF_INT_PRIV_008068 - First Amendment Email 10/6/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing voter reaction to FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008069 Executive Committee Member, Mark Jansson, Chip White, ProtectMarriage.com's messaging
Sonja Eddings Brown, Nancy Limon, Sarah Pollo, Doe 1
1727 DEF_INT_PRIV_008070 - First Amendment Email string 7/11/2008 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Gary Lawrence, Mark Nonpublic, confidential messaging discussions concerning the FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008071 Jansson, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Proposition 8 ballot arguments
Frank Schubert
1728 DEF_INT_PRIV_008072 - First Amendment Email 7/10/2008 Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Steve Linder Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008074 ProtectMarriage.com blast email
1729 DEF_INT_PRIV_008075 First Amendment Email 6/18/2008 ProtectMarriage com Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential email to members of the FA
ProtectMarriage.com executive committee
1730 DEF_INT_PRIV_008076 First Amendment Email 6/16/2008 Bill May Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing coverage of FA
ProtectMarriage.com's messaging in the media
1731 DEF_INT_PRIV_008077 First Amendment Email 6/16/2008 Andrew Pugno Dan Kirby Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com blast email FA
1732 DEF_INT_PRIV_008078 - First Amendment Email 6/15/2008 Maggie Gallagher Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Nonpublic, confidential draft of a press release promoting FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008079 Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno Proposition 8

1733 DEF_INT_PRIV_008080 - First Amendment Email string 5/16/2008 Dan Kirby, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Dan Kirby Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com blast email FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008081
1734 DEF_INT_PRIV_008082 First Amendment Email 4/25/2008 Bill May Lynne Fishel, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing coverage of FA
ProtectMarriage.com's messaging in the media
1735 DEF_INT_PRIV_008083 - First Amendment Email string 4/7/2008 Andrew Pugno, Lynne Fishel Lynne Fishel, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning preparation of a FA
1736 DEF_INT_PRIV_008086 - First Amendment Email 4/7/2008 Lynne Fishel Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning preparation of a FA
1737 DEF_INT_PRIV_008088 First Amendment Email 4/4/2008 Lynne Fishel Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com blast email FA
1738 DEF_INT_PRIV_008089 - First Amendment Email 4/3/2008 Lynne Fishel Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential correspondence regarding FA
1739 DEF_INT_PRIV_008091 First Amendment Email 4/3/2008 Lynne Fishel Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com blast email FA
1740 DEF_INT_PRIV_008092 First Amendment Email 2/28/2008 Lynne Fishel Andrew Pugno, Bill May, Doe Executive Committee Member, Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing coverage of FA
Joe Infranco, Mark Jansson, Ned Dolejsi, Ron Prentice, Mike ProtectMarriage.com's messaging in the media
Spence, Does 1-4
1741 DEF_INT_PRIV_008094 - First Amendment Draft Materials for Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential drafts of materials for a ProtectMarriage com FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008095 Promotional Mailer promotional mailer to supporters
1742 DEF_INT_PRIV_008096 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 11/3/2008 Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert Frank Schubert, Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008098 (draft statement) ProtectMarriage.com press statement
1743 DEF_INT_PRIV_008099 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 11/3/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008101 statement) ProtectMarriage.com press statement
1744 DEF_INT_PRIV_008102 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 11/3/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008103 phone script) ProtectMarriage.com promotional phone call
87 of 99
1745 DEF_INT_PRIV_008104 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/30/2008 - Ron Prentice, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Does 2-3 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008108 phone scripts) 10/31/2008 ProtectMarriage.com promotional phone call
1746 DEF_INT_PRIV_008109 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/29/2008 Bill Criswell, Nancy Limon, Frank Frank Schubert, Nancy Limon, Andrew Pugno Doe 1, Bill Criswell, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008112 (draft script of television Schubert ProtectMarriage.com advertisement
advertisement)
1747 DEF_INT_PRIV_008113 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/29/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Jim Doe 1, Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008116 (draft flyer) Bieber ProtectMarriage.com flyer
1748 DEF_INT_PRIV_008117 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/29/2008 Jeff Flint, Jim Bieber Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008119 (draft flyer) ProtectMarriage.com flyer
1749 DEF_INT_PRIV_008120 First Amendment Email 10/28/2008 Jeff Flint Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of FA
ProtectMarriage.com promotional materials
1750 DEF_INT_PRIV_008121 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 4/3/2008 Doe 1, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008124 (draft letter) ProtectMarriage.com letter to supporters
1751 DEF_INT_PRIV_008125 - First Amendment Email with attachments 4/3/2008 Andrew Pugno Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008128 (draft letters) ProtectMarriage.com letter to supporters
1752 DEF_INT_PRIV_008129 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 3/31/2008 - Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008135 (nonfinal phone recording) 4/1/2008 ProtectMarriage.com promotional phone call
1753 DEF_INT_PRIV_008136 - First Amendment Email string with 3/31/2008 - Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008142 attachments (nonfinal 4/1/2008 ProtectMarriage.com promotional phone call
phone recordings)
1754 DEF_INT_PRIV_008143 - First Amendment Email string with 3/31/2008 - Doe 1, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008148 attachments (draft materials 4/1/2008 ProtectMarriage.com promotional mailer to supporters
for promotional mailer)
1755 DEF_INT_PRIV_008149 - First Amendment Email string with 3/7/2008 Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008152 attachments (nonfinal ProtectMarriage.com promotional phone call
phone recordings)
1756 DEF_INT_PRIV_008153 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 3/3/2008 Doe 1 Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008155 letter) ProtectMarriage.com letter to supporters

1758 DEF_INT_PRIV_008161 - First Amendment Email with attachments 3/3/2008 Doe 1 Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008164 (nonfinal phone recordings) ProtectMarriage.com promotional phone call
1759 DEF_INT_PRIV_008165 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 3/3/2008 Andrew Pugno Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
1760 DEF_INT_PRIV_008168 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/28/2008 Jeff Flint Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
1761 DEF_INT_PRIV_008171 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 3/2/2008 Andrew Pugno Doe 1 Doe 2 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008176 (draft phone scripts) ProtectMarriage.com promotional phone call
1763 DEF_INT_PRIV_008177 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 2/28/2008 Andrew Pugno, Doe 1, Ron Doe 1, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008182 (draft letter) Prentice ProtectMarriage.com letter to supporters
phone recordings)
1766 DEF_INT_PRIV_008208 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 2/26/2008 - Doe 1, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
88 of 99
phone recordings)
phone recordings)
1769 DEF_INT_PRIV_008224 - First Amendment Email string with 2/25/2008 Doe 1, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
phone scripts)
1770 DEF_INT_PRIV_008228 - First Amendment Draft Campaign Flyer Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic draft of a ProtectMarriage com flyer FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008229
1771 DEF_INT_PRIV_008230 First Amendment Email 10/27/2008 Nancy Limon Bill Criswell Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning a FA
Gary Lawrence ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
1772 DEF_INT_PRIV_008231 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 2/21/2008 - Doe 1, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Doe 2 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
1773 DEF_INT_PRIV_008234 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 2/22/2008 Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Doe 1, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
1774 DEF_INT_PRIV_008237 - First Amendment Email string with 2/22/2008 Doe 1 Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008241 attachments (draft materials ProtectMarriage.com promotional mailer to supporters
1775 DEF_INT_PRIV_008242 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 2/18/2008 - Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Doe 1, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008246 (draft letter) 2/19/2008 ProtectMarriage.com letter to supporters
1776 DEF_INT_PRIV_008247 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 2/19/2008 Lynne Fishel Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential discussions concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008249 message) ProtectMarriage.com blast email
1777 DEF_INT_PRIV_008250 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 2/19/2008 Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Doe 1, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008253 (draft phone script) ProtectMarriage.com promotional phone call
1778 DEF_INT_PRIV_008254 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 2/19/2008 Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Doe 1, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
1780 DEF_INT_PRIV_008260 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 2/19/2008 Andrew Pugno Doe 1, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
1781 DEF_INT_PRIV_008264 First Amendment Email 2/18/2008 Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice, Brian Brown Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning a FA
ProtectMarriage.com promotional phone call
1782 DEF_INT_PRIV_008265 - First Amendment Draft Script of Television 10/27/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic draft of a ProtectMarriage com television advertisement FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008266 Advertisement
1783 DEF_INT_PRIV_008267 First Amendment Email 10/23/2008 Jeff Flint Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning a FA
ProtectMarriage.com promotional mailer
DEF_INT_PRIV_008282 (draft materials for ProtectMarriage.com promotional mailer to supporters
promotional mailer)
1789 DEF_INT_PRIV_008286 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 1/24/2008 Andrew Pugno Dan Kirby Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of an FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008287 initiative petition) initiative petition
89 of 99
1790 DEF_INT_PRIV_008288 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 1/24/2008 Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of an FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008291 (draft initiative petition) initiative petition
1791 DEF_INT_PRIV_008292 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 1/24/2008 Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of an FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008295 (draft initiative petition) initiative petition
1792 DEF_INT_PRIV_008296 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 1/15/2008 Lynne Fishel Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning messaging on FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008304 web pages) the ProtectMarriage com website
DEF_INT_PRIV_008310
1795 DEF_INT_PRIV_008311 First Amendment Email 10/23/2008 Jeff Flint Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning a FA
ProtectMarriage.com flyer
promotional mailer)
1799 DEF_INT_PRIV_008326 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 11/28/2007 Lynne Fishel, Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno, Lynne Fishel Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008328 (draft blast email) blast email
1800 DEF_INT_PRIV_008329 - First Amendment Email with related 11/21/2007 Ron Prentice Lynne Fishel, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communications concerning development of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008381 attachments (which include overall campaign messaging
draft talking points)
1801 DEF_INT_PRIV_008382 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/22/2007 Doe 1 Ron Prentice, Chris Clark, Anne Subia, Jim Garlow, Doe 2, Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning print FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008383 print advertisement) Andrew Pugno advertisement
DEF_INT_PRIV_008389
1803 DEF_INT_PRIV_008390 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/23/2008 Jeff Flint Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
1804 DEF_INT_PRIV_008393 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/22/2008 Jeff Flint Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008395 promotional material) ProtectMarriage.com promotional materials
1805 DEF_INT_PRIV_008396 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/21/2008 - Bill Criswell, Doe 1 Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert, Bill Criswell, Does 1- Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008398 (nonfinal version of 10/22/2008 2 television advertisement promoting Proposition 8
television advertisement)
1806 DEF_INT_PRIV_008399 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/20/2008 - Andrew Pugno, Jim Bieber Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008402 (draft flyer) 10/21/2008 ProtectMarriage.com flyer
1807 DEF_INT_PRIV_008403 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/21/2008 Jim Bieber Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
1808 DEF_INT_PRIV_008406 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/21/2008 Jeff Flint, Jim Bieber Jim Bieber, Jeff Flint Andrew Pugno, Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008408 (draft flyer) ProtectMarriage.com promotional flyer
1809 DEF_INT_PRIV_008409 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/20/2008 Jim Bieber Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008411 flyer) ProtectMarriage.com promotional flyer
1810 DEF_INT_PRIV_008412 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/20/2008 Jim Bieber, Frank Schubert, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Jim Bieber Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008416 (draft flyer) Andrew Pugno ProtectMarriage.com promotional flyer
1811 DEF_INT_PRIV_008417 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/20/2008 Jim Bieber Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008419 flyer) ProtectMarriage.com promotional flyer
1812 DEF_INT_PRIV_008420 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/20/2008 Jeff Flint, Jim Bieber Jeff Flint, Frank Schubert, Andrew Pugno, Jim Bieber Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008422 (draft flyer) ProtectMarriage.com promotional flyer
90 of 99
1813 DEF_INT_PRIV_008423 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/18/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice, Robb Wirthlin, Chip White, Andrew Pugno, Sonja Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation for a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008426 talking points) Eddings Brown ProtectMarriage.com press conference
1814 DEF_INT_PRIV_008427 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/16/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning a FA
1815 DEF_INT_PRIV_008431 - First Amendment Email string 10/16/2008 Steve Linder, Andrew Pugno, Ron Ned Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Frank Schubert, Sonja Eddings Brown, Chip White, Nancy Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning fundraising and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008434 Prentice, Frank Schubert Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint, Doe Executive Committee Member, Limon, Sarah Pollo, Steve Linder messaging strategy
Does 1-2
promotional mailer)
promotional mailer)
promotional mailer)
DEF_INT_PRIV_008464 materials for promotional ProtectMarriage.com promotional mailer to supporters
mailer)
1823 DEF_INT_PRIV_008465 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/7/2008 Jeff Flint Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
promotional mailer)
mailer)
1832 DEF_INT_PRIV_008515 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 9/29/2008 Mark Jansson, Andrew Pugno Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Does 1-3 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008526 (internal campaign strategy Committee Member, Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint, Mark Jansson ProtectMarriage.com's messaging and media strategy for a specific
memorandum) group of voters
1833 DEF_INT_PRIV_008527 - First Amendment Email with attachment 9/23/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Ned Dolejsi, Doe Executive Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning the formulation of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008539 (internal campaign research Committee Member, Jeff Flint, Mark Jansson, Gary Lawrence, ProtectMarriage.com's messaging strategy
survey) Does 1-2
91 of 99
mailer)
1835 DEF_INT_PRIV_008543 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/23/2008 Nancy Limon Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
mailer)
1836 DEF_INT_PRIV_008545 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/22/2008 Frank Schubert Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008550 (draft materials for 9/22/2008 ProtectMarriage.com promotional mailer to supporters
promotional mailer)
1838 DEF_INT_PRIV_008551 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/19/2008 Jeff Flint Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008552 print advertisement) ProtectMarriage.com print advertisement
promotional mailer)
promotional mailer)
1844 DEF_INT_PRIV_008574 - First Amendment Email string with 9/9/2008 Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Andrew Pugno, Jeff Flint, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA

phone recordings)
1845 DEF_INT_PRIV_008578 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/8/2008 Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
1846 DEF_INT_PRIV_008580 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/8/2008 Andrew Pugno Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008624 (draft materials for 8/23/2008 ProtectMarriage.com promotional mailer to supporters

promotional mailer)
92 of 99
1856 DEF_INT_PRIV_008625 - First Amendment Email with attachment 8/19/2008 Joe Infranco Ron Prentice Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008628 (material considered in ProtectMarriage.com's messaging and a potential resource for
developing messaging) ProtectMarriage.com to distribute to voters
DEF_INT_PRIV_008644 (draft letters) ProtectMarriage.com letter to supporters
1860 DEF_INT_PRIV_008645 - First Amendment Email string with 8/7/2008 - Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Doe 1, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
1861 DEF_INT_PRIV_008650 - First Amendment Email string 8/7/2008 Frank Schubert, Jennifer Kerns Jennifer Kerns, Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning the FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008651 Jansson, Doe Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, development of talking points
Frank Schubert
1862 DEF_INT_PRIV_008652 First Amendment Email 8/7/2008 Jennifer Kerns Jeff Flint, Andrew Pugno, Ron Prentice, Mark Jansson, Doe Nonpublic, confidential messaging communication concerning the FA
Executive Committee Member, Ned Dolejsi, Frank Schubert development of talking points
promotional mailer)
promotional mailer)
1868 DEF_INT_PRIV_008673 First Amendment Email 7/14/2008 Doe 1 Andrew Pugno Doe 2 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
ProtectMarriage.com promotional mailer to supporters
DEF_INT_PRIV_008680 attachments (draft letter) 7/14/2008 ProtectMarriage.com letter to supporters
mailer)
promotional mailer)
promotional mailer)
93 of 99
1875 DEF_INT_PRIV_008698 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 6/16/2008 Jeff Flint Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Does 1-2 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008699 (draft media advisory) ProtectMarriage.com media advisory
1876 DEF_INT_PRIV_008700 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/16/2008 Jeff Flint Ron Prentice, Andrew Pugno Frank Schubert, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
1877 DEF_INT_PRIV_008702 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/16/2008 Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008704 blast email) ProtectMarriage.com blast email
1878 DEF_INT_PRIV_008705 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 6/16/2008 Andrew Pugno Ron Prentice, Jeff Flint Frank Schubert Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
1879 DEF_INT_PRIV_008707 - First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 5/23/2008 Ron Prentice Dan Kirby, Andrew Pugno Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning preparation of a FA
1882 DEF_INT_PRIV_008719 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 5/16/2008 Trudy Thomas Andrew Pugno, Doe 1 Dan Kirby Nonpublic, confidential communication concerning potential FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008723 (draft message) messaging alterations to the ProtectMarriage com website
promotional mailer)
phone recordings)
1888 DEF_INT_PRIV_008748- First Amendment Internal Campaign Meeting 6/27/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential minutes of a ProtectMarriage com strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008753 Minutes meeting
1890 DEF_INT_PRIV_008759- First Amendment Email String 01/10- William Tam, Doe 1 William Tam, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing newsletter FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008760 17/2008 promoting Proposition 8
1891 DEF_INT_PRIV_008761- First Amendment Email String 09/29/2008- Doe 1, William Tam William Tam, Doe 1 Does 2-3 Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing preparations for FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008762 10/1/2008 recording a Proposition 8 advertisement
1892 DEF_INT_PRIV_008763- First Amendment Draft Promotional Flyer Undated William Tam Nonpublic, confidential draft of a flyer promoting Proposition 8 FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008764
1893 DEF_INT_PRIV_008765- First Amendment Email String 10/22/2008 Doe 1, William Tam William Tam, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing messaging for a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008766 website promoting Proposition 8
1894 DEF_INT_PRIV_008767- First Amendment Email String 10/23/2008 Doe 1, William Tam Doe 1, William Tam Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing voter reaction to a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008768 ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement
1895 DEF_INT_PRIV_008769 First Amendment Email String 10/22- William Tam, Doe 1 William Tam, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication regarding media coverage FA
24/2008 and strategies for promoting Proposition 8
1896 DEF_INT_PRIV_008770 First Amendment Draft Campaign Flyer Undated William Tam Nonpublic, confidential draft of a flyer promoting Proposition 8 FA
1897 DEF_INT_PRIV_008771- First Amendment Email String 12/17/2008 Frank Schubert Ron Prentice Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential email string of a ProtectMarriage com FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008773 discussing campaign messaging and strategy

1898 DEF_INT_PRIV_008774- First Amendment Internal Confidential Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential memorandum discussing campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008775 Messaging Memorandum messaging
94 of 99
1899 DEF_INT_PRIV_008776 First Amendment Email String 7/26-27/2008 Doe 1, William Tam William Tam, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing the drafting of a FA
flyer promoting Proposition 8
1900 DEF_INT_PRIV_008777 - First Amendment Email String 7/26-27/2008 Doe 1, William Tam William Tam, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing the drafting of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008779 flyer promoting Proposition 8
1901 DEF_INT_PRIV_008780- First Amendment Email String 7/26/2008 - Doe 1, William Tam William Tam, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing the drafting of a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008783 8/3/2008 flyer promoting Proposition 8
1902 DEF_INT_PRIV_008784 First Amendment Email 8/6/2008 William Tam Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing the drafting of a FA
1903 DEF_INT_PRIV_008785 First Amendment Email String 8/7/2008 Doe 1, William Tam William Tam, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing the drafting of a FA
1904 DEF_INT_PRIV_008786- First Amendment Email String 8/7/2008 - Doe 1, William Tam William Tam, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing the drafting of a FA
1905 DEF_INT_PRIV_008788 - First Amendment Email String 8/25/2008 - Doe 1, William Tam William Tam, Doe 1 Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing the drafting of a FA
1906 DEF_INT_PRIV_008790 First Amendment Email 8/29/2008 William Tam Does 1- 66 Nonpublic communication discussing potential radio advertisements FA
in support of Proposition 8
1907 DEF_INT_PRIV_008791 First Amendment Email String 8/29/2008 - William Tam, Doe 1 William Tam, Doe 1 Nonpublic communication discussing potential radio advertisements FA
8/30/2008 in support of Proposition 8
1908 DEF_INT_PRIV_008792 - First Amendment Draft Campaign Flyer Undated William Tam Nonpublic, confidential draft of a flyer promoting Proposition 8 FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008793
1909 DEF_INT_PRIV_008794- First Amendment Email String 09/29/2008- Doe 1, William Tam William Tam, Doe 1 Doe, Alison Cheung Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing preparations for FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008796 9/30/2008 recording a Proposition 8 advertisement
1910 DEF_INT_PRIV_008797 First Amendment Internal Chart Containing Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential chart containing campaign strategy for FA
Campaign Strategy reaching a specific group of voters
1912 DEF_INT_PRIV_008803- First Amendment Draft Campaign tinerary Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential campaign itinerary FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008805
1913 DEF_INT_PRIV_008806- First Amendment Draft Campaign Flyer Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a flyer promoting Proposition 8 FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008807
1914 DEF_INT_PRIV_008808- First Amendment Internal Messaging Strategy 7/21/2009 Connell Donatelli ProtectMarriage.com Nonpublic, confidential memorandum discussing messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008815 for ProtectMarriage com strategy for the ProtectMarriage.com website
Website
1915 DEF_INT_PRIV_008816- First Amendment Draft Campaign Flyer Undated William Tam Nonpublic, confidential draft of a flyer promoting Proposition 8 FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008817
1916 DEF_INT_PRIV_008818- First Amendment Internal Strategy 6/8/2009 Doe 1 ProtectMarriage.com Nonpublic, confidential strategy memorandum FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008820 Memorandum
1917 DEF_INT_PRIV_008821- First Amendment Internal Strategy 7/23/2009 Doe 1 ProtectMarriage.com Nonpublic, confidential strategy memorandum FA
1918 DEF_INT_PRIV_008823 First Amendment Internal Chart of Potential Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential chart containing the names of potential FA
Donors/Voters donors/voters to support ProtectMarriage.com
1919 DEF_INT_PRIV_008824 First Amendment Internal Campaign Strategy Undated ProtectMarriage com ProtectMarriage.com grassroots volunteers Nonpublic, confidential memorandum containing campaign strategy FA
Memorandum
1920 DEF_INT_PRIV_008825 First Amendment Internal Campaign Strategy Undated ProtectMarriage com ProtectMarriage.com grassroots volunteers Nonpublic, confidential memorandum containing campaign strategy FA
Memorandum
1921 DEF_INT_PRIV_008826- First Amendment Internal Campaign Strategy Undated ProtectMarriage com ProtectMarriage.com grassroots volunteers Nonpublic, confidential memorandum containing campaign strategy FA
1922 DEF_INT_PRIV_008828- First Amendment Internal Strategy 6/4/2009 Doe 1 ProtectMarriage.com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com strategy FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008830 Memorandum memorandum
1923 DEF_INT_PRIV_008834- First Amendment Internal Media Strategy 7/22/2009 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential memorandum discussing media strategy for FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008843 ProtectMarriage.com
DEF_INT_PRIV_008844 First Amendment Internal Draft Meeting 9/19/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft agenda of meeting for the FA
1924
Agenda ProtectMarriage.com executive committee
1925 DEF_INT_PRIV_008845 First Amendment Internal Draft Meeting 10/10/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft agenda of meeting for the FA
95 of 99
1928 DEF_INT_PRIV_008848 First Amendment Internal Meeting Agenda 7/23/2009 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential agenda of meeting for the FA
ProtectMarriage.com executive committee
1929 DEF_INT_PRIV_008849 First Amendment Internal Coalition Report 7/23/2009 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential ProtectMarriage com report from the FA
coalition's executive director
1930 DEF_INT_PRIV_008850 First Amendment Internal Organizational Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential organizational memorandum containing FA
Memorandum overall strategy and coalition participants
1931 DEF_INT_PRIV_008851- First Amendment Draft Focus Group 10/6/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com focus group FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008854 Discussion Guide discussion guide
1932 DEF_INT_PRIV_008855 First Amendment Internal Memorandum Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential memorandum discussing FA
Discussing Advertising ProtectMarriage.com's advertising strategy
Strategy
1933 DEF_INT_PRIV_008856 First Amendment Draft Strategy Letter Undated Doe 1 Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing FA
ProtectMarriage.com's strategy regarding media and voter outreach
1934 DEF_INT_PRIV_008857 First Amendment Draft Campaign Flyer Undated William Tam Nonpublic, confidential draft of a flyer promoting Proposition 8 FA
1935 DEF_INT_PRIV_008858- First Amendment Draft Messaging Targeting Undated Identity concealed to protect Nonpublic, confidential messaging targeted to a specific group of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008862 a Specific Group of Voters Defendant-Intervenors' privilege voters
1936 DEF_INT_PRIV_008866- First Amendment Draft Letter Undated William Tam Nonpublic, confidential draft of a letter FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008868
1937 DEF_INT_PRIV_008869- First Amendment Draft of Internal Coalition 1/29/2009 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of meeting minutes from a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008871 Meeting Minutes ProtectMarriage.com coalition meeting

DEF_INT_PRIV_008879
1941 DEF_INT_PRIV_008880- First Amendment Internal Conference Call 1/21/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential conference call notes discussing overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008883 Notes campaign strategy
1942 DEF_INT_PRIV_008884- First Amendment Draft Messaging Targeting Undated Doe 1 ProtectMarriage.com Nonpublic, confidential draft of messaging that reaches out to a FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008887 a Specific Group of Voters specific group of voters
1943 DEF_INT_PRIV_008888- First Amendment Draft Operating Plan Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com operating FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008892 plan discussing overall strategy
1944 DEF_INT_PRIV_008893 First Amendment Internal Chart of Overall Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential chart discussing details of FA
Campaign Plan ProtectMarriage.com's overall campaign strategy
1945 DEF_INT_PRIV_008894 First Amendment Internal Notes on Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential internal notes discussing messaging and FA
Messaging and Media media strategy
1946 DEF_INT_PRIV_008895 - First Amendment Internal Campaign Meeting 8/1/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential minutes of a ProtectMarriage com executive FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008896 Minutes committee meeting
1947 DEF_INT_PRIV_008897- First Amendment Draft of Internal Campaign 8/29/2008 ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential minutes of a ProtectMarriage com executive FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008899 Meeting Minutes committee meeting
1948 DEF_INT_PRIV_008900- First Amendment Internal Roster of the Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential roster of ProtectMarriage.com's leadership FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008901 ProtectMarriage.com
Leadership
1949 DEF_INT_PRIV_008902- First Amendment Internal List of Campaign Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential list of participants in the ProtectMarriage.com FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008903 Participants campaign

1950 DEF_INT_PRIV_008904- First Amendment Draft Coalition Letter Undated Ron Prentice Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com letter to FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008905 supporters
96 of 99
1951 DEF_INT_PRIV_008906- First Amendment Internal Coalition Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential memorandum assessing the overall FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008909 Memorandum marriage debate and discussing campaign research and strategy
1952 DEF_INT_PRIV_008910- First Amendment Draft Communications Plan Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008914 communications plan discussing messaging and campaign strategy
1953 DEF_INT_PRIV_008915- First Amendment Draft Strategy Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential memorandum discussing strategies and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008918 Memorandum messaging to educate voters about the marriage issue
1954 DEF_INT_PRIV_008919 First Amendment Draft Coalition Commentary Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of commentary about Proposition 8 that FA
the Coalition considered distributing to the public
1955 DEF_INT_PRIV_008920 First Amendment Draft Press Release 10/19/2008 William Tam Nonpublic, confidential draft of a press release promoting FA
Proposition 8
1956 DEF_INT_PRIV_008921 First Amendment Draft Press Release 10/19/2008 William Tam Nonpublic, confidential draft of a press release promoting FA
Proposition 8
1957 DEF_INT_PRIV_008922 First Amendment Draft Campaign Flyer 9/28/2008 William Tam Nonpublic, confidential draft of a flyer promoting Proposition 8 FA
1958 DEF_INT_PRIV_008923- First Amendment Draft Strategy Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential memorandum discussing the history and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008924 Memorandum strategy of ProtectMarriage com's campaign
1959 DEF_INT_PRIV_008925- First Amendment Internal Media Strategy Undated Doe 1 ProtectMarriage.com Nonpublic, confidential notes discussing ProtectMarriage com's FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008926 Notes media strategy for a specific group of voters
1960 DEF_INT_PRIV_008927- First Amendment Draft Campaign Flyer Undated William Tam Nonpublic, confidential draft of flyer promoting Proposition 8 FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008928
1961 DEF_INT_PRIV_008929- First Amendment Internal Grassroots 7/21/2008 Doe 1 ProtectMarriage.com grassroots volunteers Nonpublic, confidential memorandum discussing FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008930 Memorandum ProtectMarriage.com's grassroots strategy
1962 DEF_INT_PRIV_008931 First Amendment Internal Grassroots 9/5/2008 Doe 1 ProtectMarriage.com grassroots volunteers Nonpublic, confidential memorandum discussing FA
Memorandum ProtectMarriage.com's grassroots strategy
1963 DEF_INT_PRIV_008932- First Amendment Draft Flyer Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com flyer FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008933
1964 DEF_INT_PRIV_008934 First Amendment Draft Press Statement Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a ProtectMarriage com press FA
statement
1965 DEF_INT_PRIV_008935 First Amendment Internal Schedule of Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential schedule of ProtectMarriage com's FA
Grassroots Activities grassroots activities and discussions of strategy
1966 DEF_INT_PRIV_008936- First Amendment Internal Notes on Phone Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential notes discussing ProtectMarriage com's FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008937 Banking phone banking efforts
1967 DEF_INT_PRIV_008938- First Amendment Draft Flyer Undated William Tam Nonpublic, confidential draft of a flyer promoting Proposition 8 FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008939
1968 DEF_INT_PRIV_008943- First Amendment Nonpublic Memorandum Undated Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential memorandum discussing FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008947 Discussing ProtectMarriage.com's activities and strategies
ProtectMarriage.com's
Activities
1969 DEF_INT_PRIV_008948 First Amendment Draft Campaign Notes Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential notes outlining ProtectMarriage.com's overall FA
campaign strategy
1970 DEF_INT_PRIV_008949 First Amendment Internal Agenda for Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential agenda for a ProtectMarriage com executive FA
Executive Committee committee meeting
Meeting
1971 DEF_INT_PRIV_008950 First Amendment Internal Agenda for Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential agenda for a ProtectMarriage com executive FA
Executive Committee committee meeting
Meeting
1972 DEF_INT_PRIV_008951- First Amendment Internal Agenda for Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential agenda for a ProtectMarriage com executive FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008952 Executive Committee committee meeting
Meeting
1973 DEF_INT_PRIV_008953- First Amendment Internal Agenda for Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential agenda for a ProtectMarriage com executive FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008954 Executive Committee committee meeting

Meeting
1974 DEF_INT_PRIV_008955 First Amendment Draft Statement of Unity Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com's statement of FA
unity
97 of 99
1975 DEF_INT_PRIV_008956 First Amendment Draft Campaign Notes Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential notes outlining ProtectMarriage.com's overall FA
campaign strategy
1976 DEF_INT_PRIV_008957- First Amendment Draft Letter Undated Ron Prentice Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint Nonpublic, confidential draft of a letter from Ron Prentice to FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008959 Schubert Flint Public Affairs discussing strategic issues
1977 DEF_INT_PRIV_008960 First Amendment Draft Script of 10/5/2008 William Tam ProtectMarriage.com Nonpublic, confidential draft of a script of an advertisement FA
Advertisement promoting Proposition 8
1978 DEF_INT_PRIV_008961- First Amendment Confidential Memorandum 11/23/2008 Frank Schubert, Jeff Flint ProtectMarriage.com Nonpublic, confidential memorandum discussing campaign FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008971 messaging and strategy
1979 DEF_INT_PRIV_008972 First Amendment Draft Statement of Unity Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential draft of ProtectMarriage.com's statement of FA
unity
1980 DEF_INT_PRIV_008982- First Amendment Internal Campaign Notes Undated ProtectMarriage com Nonpublic, confidential communication discussing FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008983 ProtectMarriage.com's public relations issues and strategy
1981 DEF_INT_PRIV_008984- First Amendment Draft Promotional Letter Undated William Tam Nonpublic, confidential draft of a letter promoting marriage and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008992 Proposition 8
1982 DEF_INT_PRIV_008995- First Amendment Nonpublic Draft Notes Undated Mark Jansson Nonpublic, confidential draft notes discussing strategy and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008996 messaging for enacting Proposition 8
1983 DEF_INT_PRIV_008997- First Amendment Draft Promotional Letter Undated William Tam Nonpublic, confidential draft of a letter promoting marriage and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_008999 Proposition 8
DEF_INT_PRIV_009003
DEF_INT_PRIV_009007
DEF_INT_PRIV_009010
DEF_INT_PRIV_009012
1988 DEF_INT_PRIV_009015- First Amendment Email string 11/24/2008 William Tam, Frank Schubert Brian Brown, Ned Dolejsi, Bill May, William Tam, Doe 1, Anne Nonpublic communication about media request for interview FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009016 Subia
1989 DEF_INT_PRIV_009021 First Amendment Email string 10/26/2008 - William Tam, Doe 1 William Tam, Does 1-68 Nonpublic communication concerning campaign strategy and FA
10/27/2008 messaging for reaching potential voters in support of Proposition 8
1990 DEF_INT_PRIV_009022 First Amendment Email string 9/27/2008 William Tam Does 1-59 Nonpublic communication concerning available resources FA
supporting Proposition 8 for use in communicating with potential
voters
1991 DEF_INT_PRIV_009023- First Amendment Email string 7/24/2008 William Tam Does 1-82 Nonpublic communication concerning campaign strategy and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009025 messaging for reaching particular group of voters
1992 DEF_INT_PRIV_009026- First Amendment Email string 6/25/2008 William Tam, Doe 1 William Tam, Does 1-85 Nonpublic communication concerning messaging strategy in support FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009027 of Proposition 8
1993 DEF_INT_PRIV_009028 First Amendment Email string 5/17/2008 - William Tam, Doe 1 William Tam, Does 1-84 Nonpublic communication concerning messaging points and draft FA
6/14/2008 memorandum in support of Proposition 8
1994 DEF_INT_PRIV_009029 First Amendment Email 5/17/2008 William Tam William Tam, Does 1-84 Nonpublic communication concerning messaging points and draft FA
memorandum in support of Proposition 8
1995 DEF_INT_PRIV_009030 First Amendment Email 5/17/2008 William Tam William Tam, Does 1-84 Nonpublic communication concerning messaging points and draft FA
memorandum in support of Proposition 8
1996 DEF_INT_PRIV_009031 First Amendment Email 4/30/2008 William Tam Does 1-11 Nonpublic communication concerning campaign strategy and FA
effectiveness in communicating to a particular group of voters
1997 DEF_INT_PRIV_009051- First Amendment Email with attachment 10/20/2008 William Tam Frank Schubert, Cheri Spriggs Hernandez, Jeff Flint, Sarah Does 14-15 Nonpublic communication concerning campaign strategy and efforts FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009052 (email) Pollo, Nancy Limon, Chris Clark, Chip White, Sonja Eddings to communicate message to potential voters
Brown, Ned Dolejsi, Laura Saucedo Cunningham, Gary
Lawrence, Janeth Hernandez, Maria Fernanda, Anne Subia, Bill
May, Does 1-13
1998 DEF_INT_PRIV_009062- First Amendment Email string with related 10/13/2008 William Tam William Tam Nonpublic email communication transmitting a recording promoting FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009063 attachment Proposition 8
1999 DEF_INT_PRIV_009067- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 10/11/2008 Doe 1 William Tam, Does 2-7 Nonpublic communication concerning preparation of FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009082 flyers) ProtectMarriage.com's print materials promoting Proposition 8
2000 DEF_INT_PRIV_009083- First Amendment Email string with attachment 10/7/2008 - Doe 1, William Tam William Tam, Doe 1 Nonpublic communication concerning preparation of flyer supporting FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009085 (draft flyer) 10/8/2008 Proposition 8
98 of 99
2001 DEF_INT_PRIV_009096- First Amendment Email with attachment (third 9/27/2008 Doe 1 Does 2-15 Nonpublic communication concerning campaign strategy and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009098 party flyer) messaging material to distribute in support of Proposition 8;
disclosure of the promotional materials or name of the sender would
violate Defendant-Intervenors' associational rights
2002 DEF_INT_PRIV_009099- First Amendment Email with attachment (draft 9/26/2008 Doe 1 William Tam Nonpublic communication concerning review of material to consider FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009101 flyers) for distribution in support of Proposition 8; disclosure of the
promotional materials or name of the sender would violate
Defendant-Intervenors' associational rights
2003 DEF_INT_PRIV_009102- First Amendment Email string with attachment 8/29/2008 - Does 1-2, William Tam Does 1-2 William Tam Nonpublic communication concerning preparation of and messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009105 (draft flyer) 8/31/2008 for materials promoting Proposition 8
2004 DEF_INT_PRIV_009106- First Amendment Email string with attachment 8/29/2008 - Does 1-2 Does 1-2 William Tam, Does 3-4 Nonpublic communication concerning preparation of and messaging FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009108 (draft flyer) 8/30/2008 for materials promoting Proposition 8
2005 DEF_INT_PRIV_009109- First Amendment Email string with attachment 8/29/2008 Doe 1, William Tam William Tam, Does 1-86 Nonpublic communication concerning draft of radio script promoting FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009110 (draft radio script) Proposition 8
2006 DEF_INT_PRIV_009111- First Amendment Email string with attachment 8/29/2008 Doe 1, William Tam William Tam, Does 1-86 Nonpublic communication concerning draft of radio script promoting FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009114 (draft radio script) Proposition 8
2007 DEF_INT_PRIV_009115- First Amendment Email string with attachment 8/25/2008 Doe 1, William Tam Doe 1, William Tam Nonpublic communication concerning preparation of flyer promoting FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009116 (draft flyer) Proposition 8
2008 DEF_INT_PRIV_009117- First Amendment Email string with attachment 8/13/2008 Doe 1, William Tam Doe 1, William Tam Nonpublic communication concerning preparation of flyer for an FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009118 (draft flyer) event promoting Proposition 8
2009 DEF_INT_PRIV_009119- First Amendment Email with attachments 8/13/2008 Doe 1 William Tam Nonpublic communication concerning preparation of flyers FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009121 (draft flyers) promoting Proposition 8
2010 DEF_INT_PRIV_009126- First Amendment Email string with attachment 7/26/2008 - Doe 1, William Tam Doe 1, William Tam Nonpublic communication concerning preparation of flyer promoting FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009130 (draft flyer) 8/1/2008 Proposition 8
2011 DEF_INT_PRIV_009131- First Amendment Email string with 7/27/2008 - Doe 1, William Tam Nonpublic communication concerning preparation of flyers FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009133 attachments (draft flyers) 7/30/2008 promoting Proposition 8
2012 DEF_INT_PRIV_009134 - First Amendment Email with attachments 7/18/2008 William Tam Does 1-7 Nonpublic communication concerning preparation of a letter FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009140 (draft letter and related supporting Proposition 8

materials)
2013 DEF_INT_PRIV_009141 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 7/3/2008 - Doe 1, William Tam Doe 1, William Tam Nonpublic communication concerning preparation of a video FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009143 (nonfinal version of video) 7/9/2008 promoting marriage between one man and one woman
2014 DEF_INT_PRIV_009144 - First Amendment Email string with attachment 7/3/2008 - Doe 1, William Tam Doe 1, William Tam Nonpublic communication concerning preparation of a video FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009146 (nonfinal version of video) 7/9/2008 promoting marriage between one man and one woman
2015 DEF_INT_PRIV_009147 - First Amendment Email string with 6/16/2008 Doe 1, William Tam Doe 1, William Tam Nonpublic communication concerning campaign strategy and FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009152 attachments (campaign coordination with other organizations
strategy memoranda)
2016 DEF_INT_PRIV_009156 - First Amendment Email with attachment 6/16/2008 William Tam William Tam Nonpublic communication transmitting a memorandum discussing FA
DEF_INT_PRIV_009158 (campaign strategy campaign strategy
memorandum)
Filed12/21/09 Page100 of 100
99 of 99
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document314-2 Filed12/21/09 Page1 of 3
Exhibit 2
Hak-Shing William Tam December 1, 2009
San Francisco, CA
Page 1
1 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

2 NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
_________________________________________________
3
KRISTIN M. PERRY, SANDRA B. STIER, PAUL )
4 T. KATAMI, and JEFFREY J. ZARRILLO, )
Plaintiffs, ) Case No.
5 vs. ) 09-CV-2292
ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER, in his official ) VRW
6 capacity as Governor of California; )
EDMUND G. BROWN, JR., in his official )
7 capacity as Attorney General of )
California, MARK B. HORTON, in his )
8 official capacity as Director of the )
California Department of Public Health )
9 and State Registrar of Vital Statistics; )
LINETTE SCOTT, in her official capacity )
10 as Deputy Director of Health Information )
& Strategic Planning for the California )
11 Department of Public Health; PATRICK )
O'CONNELL, in his official capacity as )
12 Clerk-Recorder for the County of Alameda; )
and DEAN C. LOGAN, in his official )
13 capacity as Registrar-Recorder/County )
Clerk for the County of Los Angeles, )
14 Defendants. )
and )
15 PROPOSITION 8 OFFICIAL PROPONENTS DENNIS )
HOLLINGSWORTH, GAIL J. KNIGHT, MARTIN F. )
16 GUTIERREZ, HAKSHING WILLIAM TAM, and MARK )
A. JANSSON; and PROTECTMARRIAGE.COM - YES )
17 ON 8, A PROJECT OF CALIFORNIA RENEWAL, )
Defendant-Intervenors. )
18 _________________________________________________
19 DEPOSITION OF HAK-SHING WILLIAM TAM
20 December 1, 2009
21 San Francisco, California
22
23 Reported by:
24 EMI ALBRIGHT
25 RPR, CSR No. 13042
Alderson Reporting Company

1-800-FOR-DEPO
Hak-Shing William Tam December 1, 2009
San Francisco, CA
Page 49
1 day would not come. The choice is yours. Talk to
2 the leaders of your church. Your actions would
3 change the history in either direction.
4 Do you see that paragraph there?
5 A Yes.
6 Q Do you believe that to be true?
7 MS. MOSS: I object and instruct you
8 not to answer.
9 A No answer.
10 BY MR. DETTMER:
11 Q Okay. Was your goal in writing this
12 letter to encourage people to raise funds for
13 passing Proposition 8?
14 MS. MOSS: I am going to -- again I am
15 going to object to the extent that you are asking
16 him about a document that he has specifically said
17 was intended for private communication. And I am
18 going to instruct him not to answer.
19 A No answer.
20 BY MR. DETTMER:
21 Q Was your goal in writing this letter to
22 encourage people to vote in favor of
23 Proposition 8?
24 MS. MOSS: Same objection. Same
25 instruction.
Alderson Reporting Company

1-800-FOR-DEPO
Exhibit 3
GIBSON. DUNN &CRUTCHERLLP
LAWYERS
A REGISTERED LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP
INCLUDING PROFESSIONAL CORPORATIONS
555 Mission Street, Suite 3000 San Francisco, California 94105-2933

(415) 393-8200
www.gibsondunn.com
EDettmer@gibsondunn.com
December 14, 2009
Direct Dial Client No.

(415) 393-8292 T 36330-00001
Fax No.
(415) 374-8444
VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL
Charles 1. Cooper, Esq.
Cooper & Kirk PLLC
1523 New Hampshire Ave., N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20036
Re: Perry v. Schwarzenegger, et at., N.D. Cal. Case No. C-09-2292-VRW
Dear Mr. Cooper:
In light ofthe Ninth Circuit's Order of this past Friday, I am writing in an effort to reach
agreement regarding discovery issues in advance ofthis Wednesday's pretrial conference. While
the Ninth Circuit's Order provides that certain documents being withheld by your office require a
heightened showing of relevance before their production can be compelled, other documents and
testimony being withheld by your office-most particularly, communications with potential
voters-are not privileged from disclosure and must be produced. We believe an agreement
among the parties could be centered around the following principles:
First, as to the proper scope of the First Amendment privilege, the Ninth Circuit has
made clear that the privilege "is limited to private, internal campaign communications
concerning the formulation of campaign strategy and messages." Perry v. Schwarzenegger, No.
09-17241 (9th Cir. Dec. 11, 2009), slip op. n.12. In order to reach an agreement, we will need to
agree upon a methodology of identifying "private, internal campaign communications." We
believe that this can be most efficiently accomplished if you identify the persons that have
managerial or strategic responsibility for the Yes on 8 Campaign, and if we jointly agree that the
communications between and among only those persons concerning messaging or campaign
strategy comprise the "private, internal campaign communications," subject to the privilege. We
expect that this managerial group will be something like the group identified in our revised
document request number 8, but would like to discuss this with your office today, if possible,
along with a schedule for production of the documents that need to be produced in light of the
Ninth Circuit's Order. In any event, it is clear from the Ninth Circuit's ruling that Plaintiffs are
LOS ANGELES NEW YORK WASHINGTON, D.C. SAN FRANCISCO PALO ALTO LONDON
PARIS MUNICH BRUSSELS DUBAI SINGAPORE ORANGE COUNTY CENTURY CITY DALLAS DENVER
GIBSON,DUNN &CRUTCHERLLP
Charles J. Cooper, Esq.

December 14,2009
Page 2
entitled to responsive documents that are not "private, internal campaign communications
concerning the formulation of campaign strategy and messages," and we hope and expect that
Proponents will product those responsive documents right away.
Second, whether or not we reach an agreement as to the precise scope ofthe privilege, the
Ninth Circuit has held that you must produce a privilege log that describes any documents you
claim to be privileged. See slip op. n.l. As we have previously requested of your office, such a
privilege log must be sufficiently detailed to enable "the litigant seeking discovery and the court
to evaluate whether each of the withheld documents is privileged." Burlington Nort. & Santa Fe
Ry v. Dist. Ct., Mt., 408 F.3d 1142, 1149 (9th Cir. 2005); Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(b)(5).
We are aware of your previous representations that production of such a privilege log
would impose a severe burden upon your office and your clients. It may be that, if we can reach
an agreement as to the scope of the privilege, we can work together to find ways to reduce that
burden.
Third, as you are aware, all of the depositions that have taken place to date have gone
forward without the benefit of the documents you have been withholding, and in numerous
instances, deponents were instructed not to answer questions on the basis of privilege. As part of
our agreement on discovery issues, we would need to reach an agreement on the limited
reopening of at least some of those depositions because of newly-produced documents or
instructions not to answer that exceeded the agreed-upon scope of the privilege. In the absence
of such an agreement, we reserve the right to reopen any depositions upon production of
previously-withheld documents, should that appear necessary in light of the documents
produced, or as necessary to obtain testimony as to which objections were made but that fall
outside the scope of the privilege as recognized by the Ninth Circuit.
Finally, and relatedly, the Ninth Circuit's Order does not provide any privilege protection
for individuals' personal moral or political beliefs, which has been the basis for repeated
instructions by your office and your co-counsel to your clients not to answer deposition
questions. See, e.g., Hollingsworth Rough Dep. Tr., 56:5-57:6, 98:19-100:4, 132:19-134:10.
Given that the Ninth Circuit's decision does not endorse this conception of the privilege, we
would seek to reach, as part of our global agreement, an understanding that this privilege and
instruction will not be asserted at the depositions coming up this week, or any depositions that
are reconvened.
GIBSON, DUNN &CRUTCHERLLP
Charles J. Cooper, Esq.

December 14, 2009
Page 3
We firmly believe that it would be in the best interest of all parties and the Court if we
could reach agreement on these identified matters prior to the pretrial conference on Wednesday.
Please let us know when you are available to discuss these matters, and thank you.
cc: Counsel of record

Exhibit 4
Cooper & Kirk

Lawyers
A Professional Limited Liability Company
1523 New Hampshire Avenue, N.W.
Jesse Panuccio Washington, D.C. 20036 (202) 220-9600
jpanuccio@cooperkirk.com Fax (202) 220-9601
December 15, 2009
VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL
Ethan D. Dettmer
555 Mission Street
Suite 3000
San Francisco, CA 94105-2933
Re: Perry v. Schwarzenegger, et al., N.D. Cal. Case No. C-09-2292-VRW
Dear Mr. Dettmer:
Thank you for your letter to Mr. Cooper of yesterday, December 14, 2009. We appreciate your
attempts to bring our discovery disputes to a close as we head toward trial in this matter. You raise
several points in your letter, to which I respond in turn below.
First, you state that “as to the proper scope of the First Amendment privilege, the Ninth Circuit
has made clear that the privilege ‘is limited to private, internal campaign communications concerning
the formulation of campaign strategy and issues.’ ” Dettmer ltr. of Dec. 14, 2009 at 1 (quoting Perry v.
Schwarzenegger, No. 09-17241 (9th Cir. Dec. 11, 2009), slip op. n.12). You further assert that
Plaintiffs are thus “entitled to responsive documents that are not ‘private, internal campaign
communications concerning the formulation of campaign strategy and messages.’ ” Id. I must admit
to some confusion. Is it Plaintiffs’ contention that following the Ninth Circuit’s ruling , Plaintiffs are
entitled to documents that the District Court has already ruled irrelevant to this case and thus
nondiscoverable? For example, is it Plaintiffs’ position that they are now entitled to the 39 documents
the district court held Proponents do not have to produce because they do not relate to “the formulation
of campaign strategy and messages”? See, e.g., Doc # 252 at 6 (finding that 26 documents need not be
produced because they “say nothing about campaign messages or themes to be conveyed to the
voters”). If so, Proponents do not agree with this reading of the Ninth Circuit’s opinion.
In particular, I note that the full sentence at the beginning of footnote 12 reads: “Our holding is
limited to private, internal campaign communications concerning the formulation of campaign strategy
and messages.” Perry v. Schwarzenegger, No. 09-17241 (9th Cir. Dec. 11, 2009), slip op. n.12
(emphasis added). The Ninth Circuit’s holding relates to the matters that were actually before it—
namely, the District Court’s rulings regarding what Proponents must produce. Plaintiffs did not cross-
appeal the District Court’s rulings to the extent they granted Proponents’ motion and limited the scope
of discoverable materials and information at issue in this case. Indeed, as I have noted previously,
Plaintiffs repeatedly represented to the Ninth Circuit that the discovery limitations in the District
Court’s orders were proper. See Panuccio ltr. of Dec. 7, 2009 at 2-3. Accordingly, please clarify what
Cooper & Kirk

Lawyers
Ethan D. Dettmer, Esq.

December 15, 2009
Page 2 of 3
you mean by your reference to “responsive documents” that are “being withheld” by Proponents. In
our correspondence last week, you identified a handful of documents that you believed should have
been produced in response to Plaintiffs discovery requests. I responded in a letter explaining why all
but one of the documents was not responsive. As always, we will be happy to consider any other
concerns you have over specific documents.
As to your request that we “agree upon a methodology of identifying ‘private, internal

campaign communications,’ ” Dettmer ltr. of Dec. 14, 2009 at 1, we think the Ninth Circuit’s opinion
provides the proper and controlling definition: Proponents may not claim that “broadly disseminated
materials” conveyed to “large swaths of the electorate,” slip. op. n.12, are protected as private internal
campaign communications. Proponents have not done so.
Second, you cite the Ninth Circuit’s statement that “some form of a privilege log is required”
with respect to responsive documents over which Proponents are asserting the First Amendment
privilege. Slip op. n.1 (cited in Dettmer Ltr. of Dec. 14, 2009 at 2). We are laboring to assemble such
a log, and, as you rightly note, this process is “severe[ly] burden[some]” and requires very large
expenditures of time and resources. We appreciate your offer “to work together to find ways to reduce
that burden.” Dettmer ltr. of Dec. 14, 2009 at 2. If you have specific ideas in mind, please let us
know.
Third, you complain again about our assertion of the First Amendment privilege in depositions
to bar inquiry into the deponent’s “personal moral or political beliefs.” Id. at 3. You state “that the
Ninth Circuit’s decision does not endorse this conception of the privilege.” Id. We disagree; the Ninth
Circuit “endorse[d]” precisely this conception of the privilege. In concluding that compelled
disclosure of the documents at issue “would have the practical effect of discouraging political
association and inhibiting internal campaign communications that are essential to effective association
and expression,” slip op. 33, the Ninth Circuit relied on Mark Jansson’s declaration that he “will
drastically alter how [he] communicate[s] in the future” if his “personal political and moral views …
are ordered disclosed through discovery in this matter,” id. at 32. And the District Court, even though
it rejected Proponents’ claim of First Amendment privilege, held that “discovery directed to
uncovering whether proponents harbor private sentiments that may have prompted their efforts is
simply not relevant.” Doc # 214 at 16. Mr. Boutrous even represented to the Ninth Circuit panel at
oral argument that the District Court “said the subjective motivations and thinking of the proponents
were not discoverable,” and that the District Court’s orders were drawn “very carefully” and were
“very commendable.” Indeed, Plaintiffs’ representations in this regard date all the way back to the first
time we raised this discovery dispute with the District Court, when Mr. Boies assured the Court that
Plaintiffs “would not be inquiring into” “subjective, unexpressed motivations.” Hr’g of Aug. 19, 2009,
Tr. 64. As I noted in my letter of December 7, much of the questioning at depositions to date have
been along these lines. Proponents have asserted the First Amendment privilege appropriately in the
face of such questions and will continue to do so. Accordingly, we will not agree to reopen
depositions for the purpose of further questioning along these lines.
Cooper & Kirk

Lawyers

December 15, 2009
Page 3 of 3
Cc: Counsel of record

Exhibit 5
Cooper & Kirk

Lawyers
A Professional Limited Liability Company
1523 New Hampshire Avenue, N.W.
Jesse Panuccio Washington, D.C. 20036 (202) 220-9600
jpanuccio@cooperkirk.com Fax (202) 220-9601
December 10, 2009
VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL
Ethan D. Dettmer
555 Mission Street
Suite 3000
San Francisco, CA 94105-2933
Re: Perry v. Schwarzenegger, et al., N.D. Cal. Case No. C-09-2292-VRW
Dear Ethan:
I write in response to your letter of December 8, 2009.
First, with regard to the “What If We Lose” document, my letter of December 7, 2009,
adequately explains the reasons the document was not previously produced. We disagree with your
characterization of the document as “self-evidently … not in the nature of correspondence between
friends, but rather was a campaign letter to voters as voters.” Dettmer Ltr. of Dec. 8, 2009 at 2. The
“What If We Lose” document is self-evidently—and as testified to by Dr. Tam—a communication to
his known political and religious associates about a matter of political and moral conviction to him. As
it exists in his files, it is not an exhortation to voters qua voters.
You also state that it was appropriate for Mr. Boutrous to represent to the Ninth Circuit Court
of Appeals that the “What If We Lose” document was “sent to thousands of people” or “transmitted to
hundreds of thousands of people.” As explained in my December 7 letter, Dr. Tam did not distribute
this letter to hundreds of thousands, or even thousands, of people, so Mr. Boutrous’s contrary
representations to the Court of Appeals in that regard are inaccurate and most unfortunate. Had
Plaintiffs approached Proponents with their concerns in advance, these erroneous representations could
have been avoided.
Further, you state that Proponents’ claim of privilege is “constantly-evolving.” Dettmer Ltr. of
Dec. 8, 2009 at 1. That is not so; the scope of Proponents’ claim has not shifted. To be sure, as in the
case of the “What If We Lose,” document, we have withdrawn the claim of privilege when we have
learned that a document has been publicly disclosed. But that hardly represents a change in the nature
of our privilege claim. What has been evolving, however, are Plaintiffs’ claims with regard to the
scope of requested—and permissible—discovery in this case. For example, as has been documented
elsewhere, your position regarding the scope of internal documents sought has changed often during
the discovery period. Moreover, your letter of December 8 represents a sharp departure from Mr.
Boutrous’s representations to the Ninth Circuit that that the November 11 order “laid down the
Cooper & Kirk

Lawyers

December 10, 2009
Page 2 of 5
standards that would govern the balancing going forward as to documents,” and that the November 11
order “does narrow and lay down standards for production that we think are consistent with the First
Amendment.”
Second, we disagree with your position that you may obtain through discovery requests other
than revised Request No. 8 that which the District Court has ruled irrelevant to any issue in this case.
See Doc 214 at 15-18 (describing, with respect to nonpublic documents, the scope of “all relevant
discovery”); Doc. 252 at 3 (describing what discovery might “lead to this relevant information”). By
your reading of Request No. 1, any document sent by any Proponent to any California resident (i.e., a
voter) is responsive and should be produced. Just as with Plaintiffs’ original Request No. 8, this would
sweep in virtually every document in Proponents’ possession, would violate Proponents’ First
Amendment privilege, would exceed the bounds of relevant discovery, and would represent an
unacceptable discovery burden. See Doc. 214 at 15 (“[T]he request itself is broader than necessary to
obtain all relevant discovery. Proponents point out that even if some of the discovery sought by
plaintiffs might be relevant, ‘virtually every communication made by anyone included in or associated
with Protect Marriage’ cannot be relevant. Proponents’ undue burden objection is thus well-taken.”)
(emphasis added). In any event, to the extent you are relying on the October 1 and November 11
orders’ denial of Proponents’ claim of First Amendment privilege, the Ninth Circuit has now stayed
those orders, and we object to your attempts to circumvent and relitigate in the District Court the
appellate process that is still pending. The Ninth Circuit has promised to issue its guidance on the
privilege issue “promptly,” and while their schedule may not fit within the “demand[s]” of your letter,
Proponents believe the proper course is to await that Court’s guidance.
Third, you state that your “partner Matt McGill informs [you] that … Ms. Moss agreed during a
telephone call on November 20 that Chief Judge Walker’s November 11 Order addressed
responsiveness only in connection with request number eight.” Dettmer Ltr. of Dec. 8, 2009 at 2. I
have consulted with Ms. Moss and our understanding of the call is as follows. The call was initiated to
discuss negotiations over the attorneys-eyes-only protective order that has been the subject of dispute
among the parties. Mr. McGill expressed the view that just because one of the documents Proponents
submitted for in camera review is not responsive to Request No. 8, that does not mean the document is
not responsive to another request. He asked if Ms. Moss agreed with his interpretation of the Court’s
orders. Ms. Moss explicitly responded that it depended on what Mr. McGill meant because Proponents
did not interpret Plaintiffs’ requests to allow Plaintiffs to obtain under a different request that which the
Court found irrelevant or overly burdensome under Request No. 8. Ms. Moss clearly stated
Proponents’ position that the other Requests had to be read and interpreted consistent with the Court’s
limiting order. When Ms. Moss asked Mr. McGill for an example of what he was referring to, he cited
Request No. 11, which asks for “[d]ocuments sufficient to show the title of everyone employed by
Protect Marriage, at any time, including but not limited to organizational charts.” Doc # 187-3. Ms.
Moss informed Mr. McGill that, yes, in theory if there are documents that are responsive to Request
No. 11 separate and apart from Request No. 8, we would not view the Court’s orders as preventing
their production if they were not otherwise subject to a claim of privilege. Request No. 1 was not
discussed. Plaintiffs’ current view that all communications with “voters” (voters being defined so
Cooper & Kirk

Lawyers

December 10, 2009
Page 3 of 5
broadly as to be essentially no different from Plaintiffs’ request for all communications with “third-
parties”) was not raised by Mr. McGill or agreed to by Ms. Moss.
Fourth, you identify in your letter several additional documents that you believe are responsive,
nonprivileged, and not subject to any valid objection—namely, Exhibits 4, 10, 12, 14 and 31
introduced at Dr. Tam’s deposition. I address each exhibit in turn:
• Exhibit 4 is a document that was posted on a church website on May 27, 2009, well after
the Proposition 8 election. It mentions Prop 8 in passing, and then only with regard to
subsequent litigation over the enacted constitutional amendment. It is, both in substance
and by the logic of its date of production, not a communication to voters or Protect
Marriage donors in the Prop 8 election. The document is not responsive to any of
Plaintiffs’ requests.
• Exhibit 10 is a newsletter, dated Jan-Feb 2006. It does not discuss Prop 8, for which the
signature-gathering phase did not even begin until November 2007. The proposed
constitutional amendment mentioned in the newsletter was a failed attempt to place a
measure on the June 2006 ballot, well prior to the November 2008 election over Prop 8.
The document is not responsive to any of Plaintiffs’ requests.
• Exhibit 12 was described by Dr. Tam at his deposition as “written to churches and other
Christian leaders informing them that ProtectMarriage.com was trying to put in a
Constitution amendment petition drive, signature petition drive and asking the Chinese
churches it to help in collecting signatures for putting a ballot in the 2006 election. So [it]
has nothing to do with Prop 8.” Tam Dep. Tr. 84:6-11. Accordingly, the document is not
responsive to any of Plaintiffs’ requests.
• Exhibit 14 is Dr. Tam’s biography, available on his personal website. It provides his
general biographical background and contains one mention of the phrase “Prop 8”:
“Working with ProtectMarriage.com, he coinitiated the California Marriage Amendment,
Proposition 8.” In other words, the biography states the historical fact that Dr. Tam was an
official Proponent of Prop 8, the very fact announced on the face of every pleading in this
case. It could be argued that this single reference to Prop 8 brings the document within the
outermost technical bounds of Plaintiffs’ Request No. 6. We regret the oversight.
• Exhibit 31 is a letter that, according to your own office’s translation, is addressed to

“Pastors and Spiritual Followers” and discusses “a motion to amend the Constitution
through a June 2006 proposal to California voters.” Once again, Prop 8 was on the ballot in
November of 2008, and the signature-gathering phase with respect to Prop 8 did not begin
until November 2007. The document is not responsive to any of Plaintiffs’ requests.
Accordingly, save for Dr. Tam’s website biography’s passing reference to his status as an official
Proponent, it appears that every other document you have specifically identified as the source of your
Cooper & Kirk

Lawyers

December 10, 2009
Page 4 of 5
concern over production is not responsive to any document request Plaintiffs have propounded. If you
disagree, please explain your theory for how those requests would encompass the documents identified
in your letter.
Finally with regard to document production, as I stated in my letter of December 7, in any large
scale production—especially requiring review of tens of thousands of documents and occurring on an
expedited basis—it is possible, indeed inevitable, that occasionally responsive documents will be
overlooked despite diligent, good faith efforts at identification and production. Whenever we have
become aware of such a circumstance, we have supplemented our production pursuant to the Federal
Rules, and we will continue to do so should that prove necessary.
Fifth, with respect to deposition testimony, you state that “[u]nsurprisingly, [my] quotation to
authority is highly selective.” Dettmer Ltr. of Dec. 8, 2009 at 2. It is not clear what is meant by this
statement, as you do not actually refute or otherwise provide additional context for the authority cited.
In any event, your position appears to be that so long as a deponent has discussed something in public,
all of his or her thoughts about that matter are open to discovery—including that which the deponent
chose to leave unsaid, as well as the deponent’s subjective purposes and understanding of that which
was said. We disagree with that argument and have contested it every time you have raised it,
including before the Ninth Circuit.
You specifically cite “questions about the process of drafting the language of Prop 8” as ones
you would like to present at depositions. Dettmer Ltr. of Dec. 8, 2009 at 3. I refer you to the District
Court’s order of November 11. See Doc # 252 at 8 (holding that “an internal memorandum discussing
proposed language for Prop 8 in a way that is at most marginally pertinent to advertising strategy” is
“not relevant”). Such internal and nonpublic discussions are also subject to Proponents’ claim of
privilege. 1
Sixth, you “demand” that Proponents’ “provide [Plaintiffs] with a meaningful privilege log with
respect to any and all documents withheld on the basis of privilege.” Dettmer Ltr. of Dec. 8, 2009 at 3.
Again, as you are aware, both Proponents’ privilege and relevance objections are pending before the
Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, as are Plaintiffs’ contentions regarding the scope and necessity of a
privilege log in this case. That Court has promised to issue further guidance as to these matters
“promptly,” but until such time it has stayed the District Court’s orders relating to them. I reiterate
Proponents’ objection to Plaintiffs’ attempt to relitigate these issues in the District Court while matters
subject to the Ninth Circuit’s stay are still pending in that Court. In any event, as we have previously
explained, compilation of a privilege log in this context would be enormously burdensome and would
not assist “the litigant seeking discovery and the court to evaluate whether each of the withheld
documents is privileged,” Burlington North & Santa Fe Ry. Co. v. United States Dist. Court for the
District of Montana, 408 F.3d 1142, 1150 (9th Cir. 2005). See also, e.g., Doc # 238 at 2. Such an
1
The portion of Mr. Gutierrez’s deposition that you cite (Tr. 33:20-35:15) does not even appear to contain a
question “about the process of drafting the language of Prop 8.” I also note that your attachment only provides the
transcript up to 34:22.
Cooper & Kirk

Lawyers

December 10, 2009
Page 5 of 5
effort would only serve to unnecessarily delay proceedings without significantly assisting the Court or
counsel in their respective assessments of Proponents’ privilege claims.
Thank you for continuing to explain your concerns regarding discovery. We are happy to
address any legitimate, additional concerns Plaintiffs may have.
Cc: Counsel of record

3:09-cv-02292 #314

Загружено:

Сведения о документе

Авторское право

Доступные форматы

Поделиться этим документом

Поделиться или встроить документ

Параметры публикации

Этот документ был вам полезен?

Это неприемлемый материал?

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

3:09-cv-02292 #314

Загружено:

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document314 Filed12/21/09 Page1 of 17

1 COOPER AND KIRK, PLLC

9 LAW OFFICES OF ANDREW P. PUGNO

12 ALLIANCE DEFENSE FUND

16 ATTORNEYS FOR DEFENDANT-INTERVENORS DENNIS HOLLINGSWORTH,

21 KRISTIN M. PERRY, SANDRA B. STIER,

DEFENDANT-INTERVENORS’ NOTICE OF FILING OF PRIVILEGE LOG

1 California Department of Public Health and State

17 ALLIANCE DEFENSE FUND

20 Jordan W. Lorence (DC Bar No. 385022)*

DEFENDANT-INTERVENORS’ NOTICE OF FILING OF PRIVILEGE LOG

9 11, 2009 orders. See Doc # 214; Doc # 252.

17 Amendment privilege objection), ¶ 5 (objecting to producing documents equally available from

23 disseminated to voters,” “‘virtually every communication made by anyone included in or associated

7 “fundraising strategy, polling information or hiring decisions”; “the mechanics of operat-

21 Second, only communications concerning messages to be conveyed to voters were discoverable.

28 is permitted under the Court’s orders.

15 materials now demanded by Plaintiffs are utterly irrelevant.

23 documents prior to trial. 6

2 Dated: December 21, 2009 Respectfully submitted,

4 By: /s/Charles J. Cooper

Work Product; Andrew Pugno, Does 1-3

First Amendment Does 1-2

First Amendment Andrew Pugno, Does 1-2

Ned Dolejsi, Gary Lawrence, Jeff Flint,

DEF_INT_PRIV_002519 Jim Bieber preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com mailer

Pollo, Gary Lawrence, Steve Linder, Frank Schubert, Does 1-3

DEF_INT_PRIV_002894 Lawrence campaign messaging

DEF_INT_PRIV_002982 preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com message for public distribution

DEF_INT_PRIV_003020 Ned Dolejsi preparation of Proposition 8's language

DEF_INT_PRIV_003062 (draft advertisement) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com radio advertisement

DEF_INT_PRIV_003097 advertisement) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement

DEF_INT_PRIV_003172 advertisement) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement

DEF_INT_PRIV_003423 advertisement) preparation of ProtectMarriage com advertisement

Lawrence, Jeff Flint message to communicate to the public

Jeff Flint, Doe 1

DEF_INT_PRIV_004133 Flint Executive Committee Member ProtectMarriage.com website

Nancy Limon, Sarah Pollo, Jennifer Kerns, Steve Linder, Does

Brown, Gary Lawrence, Chip White, Does 1-3

DEF_INT_PRIV_004461 a publicly distributed ballot Doe 4 messages to communicate to the public

DEF_INT_PRIV_004654 Sonja Eddings Brown, Jeff Flint ProtectMarriage.com television advertisement

DEF_INT_PRIV_004685 messaging strategy in relation to a third party's supporting

DEF_INT_PRIV_004730 media relations

DEF_INT_PRIV_004961 strategy and messaging directed to a particular group of voters

DEF_INT_PRIV_004996 6/27/2008 messaging points and focus groups

DEF_INT_PRIV_005030 messaging for a media appearance

research materials) Does 1-2

meeting with media)

DEF_INT_PRIV_005420 flyer) preparation of a flyer supporting Proposition 8

DEF_INT_PRIV_006633 promoting Proposition 8

DEF_INT_PRIV_007071 phone script) preparation of a ProtectMarriage.com robocall to voters

9/13/ 2008 Does 2-3 ProtectMarriage.com letter

DEF_INT_PRIV_007642 opinion editorial) Protectmarriage.com print advertisement

DEF_INT_PRIV_007691 attachments (internal 10/10/2008 Andrew Pugno, Jennifer Kerns relations

DEF_INT_PRIV_007770 (video script) Lawrence, Doe 1 promoting Proposition 8

DEF_INT_PRIV_007873 (internal strategy and messaging directed to particular groups of voters

DEF_INT_PRIV_008079 Dolejsi, Andrew Pugno Proposition 8

DEF_INT_PRIV_008155 letter) ProtectMarriage.com letter to supporters

DEF_INT_PRIV_008256 (draft phone script) ProtectMarriage.com promotional phone call

DEF_INT_PRIV_008383 print advertisement) Andrew Pugno advertisement

DEF_INT_PRIV_008577 attachments (nonfinal ProtectMarriage.com promotional phone call

DEF_INT_PRIV_008624 (draft materials for 8/23/2008 ProtectMarriage.com promotional mailer to supporters

DEF_INT_PRIV_008773 discussing campaign messaging and strategy

DEF_INT_PRIV_008877 Meeting Minutes ProtectMarriage.com coalition meeting