Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
How to cost
a hospital
ISBN 0-11-322712-4
9 780113 227129
www.tso.co.uk
How to cost
a hospital
ISBN 0-11-322712-4
1. Introduction page 2
Appendices page 15
Appendix 1 – Glossary
Appendix 2 – Departmental Cost Allowance Guide forms
Appendix 3 – Schedules of functional content
References page 26
1
HOW TO COST A HOSPITAL
1 Introduction
1.1 This document aims: 1.5 The NHS Plan talks specifically about a vision of a
health service designed around the patient and offering
• to support the NHS in ensuring robust cost a personalised service. This vision is service-led and
information is obtained, to underpin business cases; sets targets as follows:
and
• more information for patients;
• to give guidance to the NHS and private sector
colleagues involved in producing business cases. • greater patient choice;
It is strongly advised that NHS bodies employ fully- • raising standards for the protection of patients;
qualified and health-experienced Chartered Quantity
Surveyors and other equally professionally qualified • introduction of a new patient advocacy service;
consultants when calculating the cost of healthcare
facilities. NHS colleagues will find it useful in • the right to redress when things go wrong;
understanding the issues that need to be covered in
• better patient consultation and representation.
calculating capital costs, and in working with
consultants. 1.6 However, efforts need to be made to translate this
vision with regard to its effects on the quality of
1.2 The Capital Investment Manual (CIM) gives practical
healthcare facilities.
guidance on the technical considerations of the full
capital appraisal process and provides a framework for 1.7 This could range from improvements in first
establishing management arrangements. This ensures impressions of primary and secondary care centres such
that the benefits of every capital investment are as car parking, external signage, grounds, entrances,
identified, evaluated and revealed. It should be noted corridors, to the general facilities which enhance the
that the essential principles can be applied to all capital patients’, carers’ and visitors’ experience of the NHS for
investments irrespective of size or complexity. example catering/retail outlets, and waiting spaces.
1.3 As part of the business planning process NHS 1.8 The above list is not intended to be exhaustive but
bodies need to evaluate investment schemes within the to give an indication of some of the areas that need to
context of the whole business of the NHS body. It is be taken into consideration when producing capital cost
therefore important that NHS bodies discuss the level of estimates.
detail and scope of work required to develop a Strategic
Outline Case (SOC), Outline Business Case (OBC), Full LIFE-CYCLE COSTS
Business Case (FBC) and Public Sector Comparators
(PSC) in private finance initiatives, with the Department 1.9 There is no provision within this document for life-
of Health. cycle costs. Its function is the understanding and basis
of how to generate an initial capital cost allowance for a
1.4 This document is intended to provide guidance on scheme, although the increased importance of the
the production of accurate capital cost estimates at the whole-life costs is recognised.
different stages of cost planning. It will examine the
OBC forms and demonstrate the methodology of 1.10 NHS Estates is developing a model which will allow
building up the cost of a scheme based on a scheme-specific information to be input to generate a
hypothetical District General Hospital (DGH). Each predicted annual cost of running a facility.
element of the business case form is discussed, and
1.11 The model requires detailed information that can
how standard information can be used is demonstrated.
only be produced from scheme-specific details.
A glossary of the terms used is contained in
Appendix 1. 1.12 The information and details of the standard model
will be published separately within the guidance to NHS
ProCure21 by NHS Estates.
2
2 Outline Business Case costings
PRODUCTION OF OUTLINE BUSINESS CASE 2.3 DCAGs are the only source of health building cost
(OBC) COSTS data readily and conveniently available to all NHS bodies
in the country.
2.1 A copy of the relevant capital cost forms for the
DGH used in this guide is contained in Appendix 2, and 2.4 The Healthcare Capital Investment (HCI) document,
should be referred to. The schedules of functional available from NHS Estates, 1 Trevelyan Square, Boar
content used in this example are contained in Lane, Leeds, LS1 6AE, contains comprehensive
Appendix 3. information on an extensive list of DCAGs.
2.2 At the early stage of the production of costs for 2.5 A more detailed description of DCAGs is contained
business cases there may be very little information in Appendix 1.
available to assist in the build-up for the cost of the
scheme. The use of Departmental Cost Allowance
Guides (DCAGs) will assist in the preparation of:
3
HOW TO COST A HOSPITAL
PROCESS
See Appendix 2 for example Calculate individual departmental areas Insert on cost form OB2
2.6 Collection of the following information (if available) • category of work to each department i.e.:
will assist in the calculation of departmental costs: – new build (N);
– existing accommodation adapted for alternative
• departmental functional contents, for example: size, use (A);
number of units, beds, theatres; – existing accommodation upgraded for same
• departmental areas; use (C).
4
OUTLINE BUSINESS CASE COSTINGS
The relevant reference in the Healthcare Capital Therefore, the appropriate cost in this instance is:
Investment (HCI) document is 04.01.01 (MIPS 360).
£992,879 ÷ 955 x 860 = £894,111
The DCAG for 12 C/E rooms is £992,879.
Option 3
Example 2
A third option could be to decide that neither of the
A DCAG is needed for an out-patient department with first two options is quite appropriate and therefore a
16 C/E suites. judgement will be needed as to what cost level is
actually required. At this stage experience and
There is no specific DCAG for this functional size, professional judgement may be the only solution.
therefore a simple calculation is required. The aim is to
add the extra over-cost of 4 C/E rooms to the existing
DCAG for 12 C/E rooms.
5
HOW TO COST A HOSPITAL
LINE 2: ON-COSTS
PROCESS
No Yes
ON-COSTS – RELEVANT INFORMATION • number and type of auxiliary buildings for example
gas meter housing, bicycle stores etc.;
2.10 Collection of the following information (if available)
will assist in the calculation of on-costs: • ground conditions survey report;
• scheme drawings showing room and/or departmental • details of any major abnormal costs associated with
layouts as appropriate; works;
6
OUTLINE BUSINESS CASE COSTINGS
2.12 Following a study of the comparison between on- 2.13 A further study of the comparison between the
costs and departmental costs included within past FBC different elements that make up the overall on-cost total
cost forms, the following findings were evident: was also undertaken. The outcome of this study is
detailed in Table 1 Comparison between On-Costs and
• for projects with a Works Cost value of between £1m Departmental Costs, which highlights the typical
and £5m, the average on-cost value as a percentage percentages anticipated for each element if the overall
of departmental costs was between 40% and 50%; on-cost percentage is between 65% and 100%.
• for projects with a Works Cost value greater than 2.14 It should be noted that the information from the
£5m, the average on-cost value as a percentage of two studies is for guidance only, as the sample size
departmental costs was between 70% and 85%. used in the study was not great enough to make the
statistical outcome accurate.
Communications
Abnormals
7
HOW TO COST A HOSPITAL
PROCESS
INDEX SERIES FOR BUSINESS CASES that the base date of any PFI costs is known. This will
enable a fair adjustment of costs if there are delays in
2.16 The following points should be noted when the procurement process.
preparing capital cost estimates for business cases:
2.20 After the base date is confirmed, the Public Sector
• to achieve consistency and avoid confusion, all Comparators (PSC) can be prepared on the same base
business cases are expected to be submitted at a date to enable a comparison to be made. Where the
promulgated index level and not at the quarter of the Outline Business Case costs are used as the PSC they
anticipated tender date for a specific scheme. This must be adjusted using appropriate indices to the
allows all business cases to be compared on a like- correct base date.
for-like basis and avoids the need to constantly
change estimates when the forecast index level used ADJUSTING ESTIMATES FOR TENDER PRICE
is changed; MOVEMENT
• the index levels, which should be used for business 2.21 The following represents the works cost of a typical
case purposes, are published in Quarterly Briefing project at a business case stage.
obtainable from NHS Estates, 1 Trevelyan Square,
Boar Lane, Leeds LS1 6AE, and on the Knowledge Departmental cost £1,000,000
Information Portal (KIP). This is accessed using a
On-costs (70%) £700,000
unique username and password obtained by
completing the application form on the homepage at: Sub total £1,700,000
http://195.92.246.148/nhsestates/knowledge/
knowledge_content/home/home.asp Local adjustment x 1 –
2.17 The Business Case should contain an appropriate Works cost £1,700,000
adjustment to the estimate to take account of future
This estimate is based at current-day costs of 1st
inflation (tender inflation and cost inflation as necessary).
quarter 2002.
2.18 It is the responsibility of the project manager in
2.22 The works cost represents the estimated tender
control of the cost estimate to anticipate the effect of
price to be submitted under a traditional procurement
this adjustment and to ensure that both the trust and
route. Therefore, any adjustment to this estimate for
the Strategic Health Authority are aware of the
tender price movement will need to involve the use of a
implications of this at the early stages of cost planning.
tender price index (that is, the MIPS index).
2.19 When preparing Public Sector Comparators (PSC)
2.23 Adjustment of the above estimate to represent
for schemes that have been selected for The Private
current-day costs of 2nd quarter 2004 requires the
Finance Initiative (PFI) procurement route it is imperative
8
OUTLINE BUSINESS CASE COSTINGS
Local adjustment x 1 –
9
HOW TO COST A HOSPITAL
PROCESS
Refer to latest Quarterly Briefing Multiply Line 3 costs by appropriate location Insert on Line 4 of cost form
for up-to-date location factors adjustment factor OB1
10
OUTLINE BUSINESS CASE COSTINGS
LINE 6: FEES
PROCESS
2.35 Line 6 of cost form OB1 contains a figure for fees. • project managers;
The figure included here should include for both in-
• project director;
house and external professional services for planning,
design and execution of the project; examples would • in-house staff resourcing etc.
include:
2.36 Fees for items such as the purchase/disposal of
• architects; property should also be included.
• mechanical engineers;
11
HOW TO COST A HOSPITAL
PROCESS
Transfer to Line 7 of
Summarise total non-works costs
cost form OB1
NON-WORKS COSTS – RELEVANT 2.39 In general, because costs in this section tend to
INFORMATION stand alone and cannot normally by validated against a
known baseline or other guidance, they must be explicit
2.37 Line 7 of cost form OB1 contains a figure for and have as much detail as possible. This maxim is
non-works costs. Non-works cost can be too easily particularly important for costs entered under the
dismissed as not being a very important element of a heading ‘Other’. For example, decanting costs may
business case, especially when viewed in the wider include building and engineering works associated with,
context of a major capital investment, but may still and facilitating, a decant. Decanting costs should also
attract very significant costs that should be given due include the cost of external removal specialists as well
consideration. as the cost of in-house portering and administration/
2.38 Costs entered against the three main headings: management time. Decommissioning and/or
‘land purchase costs and associated legal fees’, recommissioning costs can also be significant if
‘statutory and Local Authority charges’ and ‘Building engineering services, including medical gases, are to be
Regulation and planning fees’ are self explanatory and brought back on-line or made safe.
need not be expanded on. However the costs entered 2.40 Examples of non-works costs include:
must be realistic, with any appropriate tariffs being
thoroughly checked. • land purchase costs;
• decanting costs;
• commissioning;
• decommissioning.
12
OUTLINE BUSINESS CASE COSTINGS
PROCESS
Refer to latest Quarterly Briefing Calculate individual equipment costs for each
Insert on cost form OB2
for up-to-date location factors department
Add equipment costs for ECAs and OASs Insert on cost form OB2
Reasonable transfer rates Abate equipment costs for existing equipment that
Adjust on cost form OB2
should be used can be transferred
Summarise total equipment costs including ECAs Transfer to Line 8 of cost form
and OASs OB1
EQUIPMENT COSTS – RELEVANT INFORMATION 2.43 If any equipment is transferred then this should be
shown as an abatement on cost form OB2 and the
2.41 Line 8 of cost form OB1 is a summary of the total adjusted total carried forward to cost form OB1.
equipment costs contained on cost form OB2.
2.44 Within healthcare facilities, equipment is classified
2.42 The Equipment Cost Allowance Guide (ECAG) into different groups dependent upon its specialist
contained within HCI is based on the listed price of nature and the space implications. There are four
middle of the range items of equipment taken from NHS different groups of equipment:
Estates Activity DataBase room data sheets and are
exclusive of VAT, trade discount etc. It is important to group 1 – items (including terminal outlets) which are
note when using these costings that no contingency supplied and fixed within the terms of the building
allowance has been added to the costs and therefore a contract;
full risk estimate should be undertaken in respect of
estimates for specific projects. It should be noted that group 2 – items which have specific requirements
Quarterly Briefing contains information relating to the with regard to space and/or building construction
current equipment price index that should be used in and/or engineering services and are fixed within the
calculating the adjusted cost for equipment. terms of the building contract but supplied under
arrangements separate from the building contract;
13
HOW TO COST A HOSPITAL
PROCESS
Identify risks
14
Appendix 1 – Glossary
DEPARTMENTAL COST ALLOWANCE GUIDES a. the department will be incorporated into a general
(DCAGs) hospital development;
An allowance for building and engineering costs for an b. the building is a two-storey framed structure;
individual department within a development for a new or
extended general hospital. Costs are given by function, c. the engineering services are readily available, have
for example per bed, per theatre etc. They include: the necessary capacity and are located at the
boundary of the proposed development;
• building and engineering costs;
d. the building will be on a greenfield site.
• group 1 equipment;
Schedules of accommodation, found at the back of
• 12.5% for preliminaries; and each HBN, list all the functional areas to which is added
an allowance for circulation space within the
• 2% for variations/contingencies. department. This circulation space includes the
following:
DCAGs are used at an early planning stage to establish
a cost target that ensures developments are designed in • general circulation within the confines of the
an economical manner but without impairing their department;
functional requirements.
• planning provision – a 5% allowance for flexibility of
The cost data has been subjected to a substantial and design;
thorough review in terms of the cost levels reported and
the information upon which they are based. This was • engineering zone – a 200 mm allowance measured
undertaken to improve the accuracy and consistency of adjacent to all external walls to allow for the
the costs produced and to put them in line with normal
15
HOW TO COST A HOSPITAL
distribution of services within the department, and main ducts/shafts, but not those within a
radiators and small vertical ducts; department which are included in the departmental
costs.
• the area occupied by partitions.
External works
Costs for the following are excluded from DCAGs and
should be included in the on-costs: Typically covers all costs associated with works external
to the outer walls of the building but forming an integral
• circulation associated with communications to other part of the scheme, for example roads, paths, drainage,
departments, for example the main hospital street; services etc.
• staircases, lifts and plantrooms; External works also include all the main engineering
supply services, which may include those internal to the
• external works.
building, but which are outside the confines of the
The total DCAG allowance for a scheme is obtained by individual department, for example services in the main
aggregating the cost of all the functional units, Essential corridor or "hospital street".
Complementary Accommodation (ECA) and Optional
Auxiliary buildings
Accommodation and Services (OAS) as appropriate to
the scheme. This includes minor buildings such as bin stores, bicycle
sheds, meter housing etc.
If a DCAG is either unsuitable or unavailable for a
particular department, costs should be allocated on the Abnormals
basis of similar accommodation in another department.
Includes all known exceptional factors that arise from
DCAGs relate purely to the work within the department. the development which increase capital costs on either
the building or the engineering services. Examples are
In addition, the HCI contains schedules of Essential
demolitions, adverse soil conditions and poor bearing
Complementary Accommodation (ECA) and Optional
capacity of ground, alterations to existing buildings, full
Accommodation and Services (OAS). ECAs are essential
air-conditioning. Only known abnormals should be
to the running of the department but could be located
included under this heading. The risk analysis used to
elsewhere, whereas OASs are project options that can
establish the planning contingency should allow for
be selected as required to give a more bespoke
other possible abnormals.
approach to a project.
INDICES
ON-COSTS
All project estimates must be capable of adjustment to
Line 2 of cost form OB1 contains a figure for on-costs.
take account of the effects of historical or forecast
These on-costs are additional capital costs, not included
inflation within the construction industry.
within DCAGs, arising from the interaction of individual
departments within a development, and the relationship For example, an estimate based on current-day
of that development to the particular site and existing construction costs must be able to be adjusted to
buildings. Initially, at early planning stages, they may be reflect construction cost in, say, five years’ time. To
included as a percentage added to the total of the achieve this, the estimate must be linked to a base date
departmental costs. As information becomes available, a or an appropriate index.
more detailed and realistic valuation should be
calculated for on-costs. Before explaining how indices can be used to adjust
project estimates, it is necessary to explain what indices
On-costs include the following: are and what they represent.
• communications; Indices are a list of numbers whose sole purpose is to
reflect the rate of inflation in numerical format. Most
• external works;
indices commence with the number 100, and the next
• auxiliary buildings; number in the series will reflect either an increase or a
decrease in the rate of inflation.
• abnormals.
For example, the following theoretical index series
Communications shows an increase of inflation between the 1st and 2nd
quarters of the year 2004 (that is, (105 – 100) ÷ 100)
Includes all costs associated with space/circulation etc
followed by a reduction in inflation of 2% between the
between departments, for example corridors, lifts, stairs
2nd and 3rd quarters of year 2004.
16
APPENDIX 1 – GLOSSARY
17
HOW TO COST A HOSPITAL
PROJECT DIRECTOR.....................................................................................
Cash
Flow: SOURCE £
EFL OTHER GOVERNMENT PRIVATE
18
APPENDIX 2 – DEPARTMENTAL COST ALLOWANCE GUIDE FORMS
19
HOW TO COST A HOSPITAL
Percentage of
Estimated Cost (exc. Departmental Cost
VAT)
%
1. Communications £
a. Space 13,957,759
b. Lifts 3,247,146
17,204,906 17,204,906 20.77%
20
APPENDIX 2 – DEPARTMENTAL COST ALLOWANCE GUIDE FORMS
PROJECT DIRECTOR............................................................ 0
£
2. Non-Works Costs
21
HOW TO COST A HOSPITAL
22
DCAG ECAG AREA BEDS
HCI Add 15% Ess Add 15% Ess m2
DCAG @ 360 Total @ 360 Total @ 395 ECAG 100 Total @ 100 Total @ 111 m2 add E&O no of beds D/ECAG
& op t & opt
15% 1.10 15% 1.11
01 In-Patient Services
01.01B.06 General Wards 224 beds 12,087,524 1,813,129 13,900,653 15,252,105 N/A 0 8,188 9,416 224 100/0
Children
01.02.01 Department 1 dept 157,074 23,561 180,635 198,197 11,656 1,748 13,404 14,879 158 182 93/7
01.02.04 In-Patient Ward 20 beds 1,164,350 174,653 1,339,003 1,469,183 81,067 12,160 93,227 103,482 993 1,142 20 93/7
01.02.12 Day Care Unit 8 beds 400,095 60,014 460,109 504,842 20,756 3,113 23,869 26,495 329 378 8 95/5
Elderly
01.03.01 N ursing Section Type A 96 beds 4,279,592 641,939 4,921,531 5,400,013 261,152 39,173 300,325 333,361 3,508 4,034 96 94/6
01.03.07 Day Hospital 40 places 872,375 130,856 1,003,231 1,100,768 44,898 6,735 51,633 57,312 721 829 95/5
01.03.19 Administrative Centre 200,000 population 124,858 18,729 143,587 157,547 13,689 2,053 15,742 17,474 135 155 90/10
Maternity
01.04B.15 LDRP standard 18 nr 618,966 92,845 711,811 781,015 283,626 42,544 326,170 362,049 702 807 18 68/32
01.04B.18 LDRP disabled 1 nr 38,780 5,817 44,597 48,933 16,427 2,464 18,891 20,969 45 51 1 70/30
01.04B.23 4 bed multi room 2 nr 108,686 16,303 124,989 137,141 13,226 1,984 15,210 16,883 110 127 8 89/11
01.04B.21 Single room 11 nr 189,882 28,482 218,364 239,594 18,315 2,747 21,062 23,379 176 202 11 91/9
01.04B.01 In patient acc Option 1 3,230,379 484,557 3,714,936 4,076,110 1,804,462 270,669 2,075,131 2,303,396 2,445 2,812 64/36
01.04B.26 Neonatal 10 cots 576,615 86,492 663,107 727,576 284,377 42,657 327,034 363,007 424 488 10 67/23
01.05.01 Intensive Therapy 6 beds 1,013,320 151,998 1,165,318 1,278,613 601,201 90,180 691,381 767,433 733 843 6 62/38
01.05.01 Cardiology 1 dept 1,013,320 151,998 1,165,318 1,278,613 601,201 90,180 691,381 767,433 733 843 6 62/38
07 Administration Services
Administration
07.01.01 Offices 225 work stations 2,070,002 310,500 2,380,502 2,611,940 883,986 132,598 1,016,584 1,128,408 3,076 3,537 70/30
07.02.01 Health records 15 work stations 217,888 32,683 250,571 274,932 70,046 10,507 80,553 89,414 235 270 75/25
07.02.02 Health records library 750,000 case notes 793,984 119,098 913,082 1,001,853 11,049 1,657 12,706 14,104 895 1,029 99/1
07.03.01 Main entrance 1 nr 435,890 65,383 501,274 550,008 33,294 4,994 38,288 42,500 353 406 93/7
07.03.03 Snack bar 1 nr 112,351 16,853 129,204 141,765 18,756 2,813 21,569 23,942 90 104 86/14
07.04.01 Departmental entrances 4 nr 603,920 90,588 694,508 762,030 74,136 11,120 85,256 94,635 500 575 89/11
08 Staff Facilities
08.01.01 Catering/dining rooms 300 meals 239,616 35,942 275,558 302,349 0 0 335 385 100/0
08.01.02 Servery 300 meals 161,863 24,279 186,142 204,240 0 0 120 138 100/0
08.03.01 Occupational health centre 1 centre 181,252 27,188 208,440 228,705 23,592 3,539 27,131 30,115 160 184 88/12
08.04.02 Staff changing – semi-auto 1000 places 500,789 75,118 575,907 631,898 54,969 8,245 63,214 70,168 767 882 90/10
On-call accommodation 7 rooms 168,364 25,255 193,619 212,443 N/A 0 147 169 100/0
09 Service Facilities
09.01.01 CSSD 2 sterilizers 1,969,327 295,399 2,264,726 2,484,908 198,513 29,777 228,290 253,402 1,320 1,518 91/9
Telephone service
09.02.01 Operators' suites 3 cabinets 66,591 9,989 76,580 84,025 3,283 492 3,775 4,191 80 92 95/5
09.02.03 Telephone equipment 1000 extensions – 0 302,635 45,395 348,030 386,314 – – 0/100
Catering
CFPU 1 dept 3,005,329 450,799 3,456,128 3,792,141 160,234 24,035 184,269 204,539 1,600 1,840 95/5
End Kitchen 600 meals 1,504,425 225,664 1,730,089 1,898,292 77,905 11,686 89,591 99,446 685 788 95/5
TOTAL 65,648,282 9,847,242 75,495,524 82,835,367 15,166,633 2,274,995 17,441,628 19,360,207 52,803 60,724 418 81 / 19
Add On Costs 70% 57,984,757
Sub Total 140,820,123
Fees 16% 21,827,119
Non-works costs 1% 1,408,201
Equipment costs 19,360,207
Planning contingency 12% 18,200,745
Total 201,616,396
+ On-costs 140,820,123
Cost/m2 2,319
Cost/bed 336,890
References
The Capital Investment Manual Quarterly Briefing (four issues per year). NHS Estates.
Overview. NHS Management Executive, (contains Departmental Cost Allowance Guides)
The Stationery Office, 1994. (http://www.nhsestates.gov.uk/publications_guidance/
Project organisation. NHS Management Executive, content_set.asp?content_ID=quarterly_briefing)
The Stationery Office, 1994.
Private finance guide. NHS Management NHS PROCURE21
Executive, The Stationery Office, 1994. http://www.nhs-procure21.gov.uk
Business case guide. NHS Management Executive,
The Stationery Office, 1994.
Management of construction projects.
NHS Management Executive, The Stationery Office,
1994.
Commissioning a healthcare facility.
NHS Management Executive, The Stationery Office,
1994.
IM&T guidance. NHS Management Executive,
The Stationery Office, 1994.
Post-project evaluation. NHS Management
Executive, The Stationery Office, 1994.
26
About NHS Estates guidance and
publications
The Agency has a dynamic fund of knowledge which it Procurement & Property
has acquired over 40 years of working in the field. Our
unique access to estates and facilities data, policy and These are documents which deal with areas of broad
information is shared in guidance delivered in four strategic concern and planning issues, including capital
principal areas: and procurement.
Design & Building Examples of titles published under this heading are:
27
Core guidance feedback
Please complete this feedback form and return it to NHS Estates. The information
provided will help in the assessment of the value of this document and in the
planning of future Agency guidance.
Title:
.....................................................................
Series and series number if applicable (eg Health Building Note 57):
.....................................................................
1. How useful is this document to you/your organisation?
1 2 3 4 5 6
Not at all useful Very useful
2. Are you aware of other sources of the information contained in this document?
Yes No
If Yes, please state below:
.....................................................................
3. Did you feel the content was:
Too prescriptive?
Too ambiguous?
About right?
4. Was the amount of technical content in the document:
Too high?
Too low?
About right?
5. How would you rate the length of the document?
Too long
Too short
About right
Please return this form to:
Standards and Knowledge Management
NHS Estates
Windsor House
Cornwall Road
Harrogate
HG1 2PW Thank you