Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
MAY 2011
FORUMS REPORT
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Armidale Community Forum............................................................................................................................................. 5
Benefits................................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 5
Challenges & Risks......................................................................................................................................................................................................... 7
Key Principles................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 10
Next Steps........................................................................................................................................................................................................................ 11
Uralla Community Forum.................................................................................................................................................. 13
Benefits............................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 13
Challenges & Risks...................................................................................................................................................................................................... 14
Key Principles................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 15
Priority Next Steps........................................................................................................................................................................................................ 16
Kyabra Landholder Forum............................................................................................................................................... 18
Benefits............................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 18
Challenges & Risks...................................................................................................................................................................................................... 18
Key Principles................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 19
Priority Next Steps........................................................................................................................................................................................................ 19
Walcha Community Forum............................................................................................................................................. 21
Benefits............................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 21
Challenges & Risks...................................................................................................................................................................................................... 21
Key Principles................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 22
Priority Next Steps........................................................................................................................................................................................................ 22
Investor Forum.......................................................................................................................................................................... 24
Benefits............................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 24
Challenges & Risks...................................................................................................................................................................................................... 25
Key Principles................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 26
Priority Next Steps........................................................................................................................................................................................................ 27
Glen Innes Community Forum....................................................................................................................................... 28
Benefits............................................................................................................................................................................................................................... 28
Challenges & Risks...................................................................................................................................................................................................... 29
Key Principles................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 30
Priority Next Steps........................................................................................................................................................................................................ 30
Other Comments (Anonymous)......................................................................................................................................................................... 31
BENEFITS
Financial/Economic Benefits:
• Employment
• Revenues are kept within
• Employment
• local jobs
• Potential for revenue to be returned to the community
• Whole new industry for region
• Jobs
• Tourism
• Economic - return on investment
• A welcome source of income for farmers (rental of land for turbines)
Educational Benefits:
• Community education/learning
• spin-off experience from other projects
• Opportunity to document process and establish a model that can be sold
on to others (i.e. use it for capital gain both financially and socially)
• Education
• Setting example
• Community education
Visual Benefits
• Fits the landscape
• Identity to community & aesthetic appeal
Technical Benefits
• Localised power for total energy independence – ultimately using biogas,
co-generation wind mix. Result: no expensive cable connections to the
biggest power user, the grid.
• Local energy with minimal power lines minimises the line losses of about
50% of coal-fired generation
Miscellaneous Issues:
• Medaway Industrial Park Uralla has grid connections already established
• Link it with solar and Uralla becomes energy independent
• Recycling hydro dam generation as proposed by Zinhi Buzo for the Styx
River would provide base load
Funding Challenges:
• Keeping the fundraising impetus long enough to achieve the goal
• Raising the capital – how many people contributing how much?
• Cost
• Getting investors
• Raising enough money
• Competition from large investors
• Funding
• Raising funds to purchase land
• Getting the right price for sale – for investors to invest
• Raising the money,
• Tax implications of being an energy producer
• Cost
Technical Challenges:
• Technical challenges
• Grid connection – power wasted when grid goes down (same as solar),
need power companies on board
Other Challenges:
• Division of communities
• Takeover by state for later privatisation for profit or loss-offsetting, once
proven successful
• Permission from Transgrid and local power companies
• Time
• Need to have education from people who have lived near windfarms –
they can and do cause major impact on many people’s quality of life
(through ‘infra sound’ etc)
• 20 year lifespan – oil needed to replace them?
KEY PRINCIPLES
• Community consultation to develop blueprint
• Preferential local use/consumption/self sufficiency
• Local decision making
• Role of community organisations
• Mutual structure/cooperative: one person, one vote
• Management of influence
• Energy justice
• Local jobs
• Viable business model
• Security of advance deposits
• Source of funds/who can invest?
• Maximum investment?
• Tax exempt
• Trading ability
NEXT STEPS
• Options paper for comment & critique
• Legal governance framework
• Investment model
• Inform public – education campaign
• Locations/sites – based on research
• Formal approaches to Councils – get some champions
• Experienced others to talk to community.
• Get Tony Windsor and Richard Torbay involved
BENEFITS
Empowerment. Local autonomy, Independence:
• Move towards self-sufficiency
• Innovation generally
• Starting early – just after the first community wind farm in Australia is nearly
established.
• Local power production
• Local control of energy production
• Community satisfaction from ownership/involvement
• Community power and leadership
• Independence from broader, non-sustainable political decision makers
• Opportunity for the community to have a direct financial input into
environmentally beneficial community based programs
• Community input into siting/location of turbines
Visual Benefits
• They look great
Miscellaneous Issues:
• How long is it before the embodied cost of setting up wind farm is
recouped?
• Locating 6 turbines, easier than 100s
• Opportunity for best practice – looking at the whole sustainability picture
Funding Challenges:
• Ability to compete with commercial companies - $10 – 25billion
investments
• Getting the $$$
Technical Challenges:
• Direct supply of electricity to members
Other Challenges:
• Too small to make a difference?
• Community anxiety (personal and property damage)
• Create division in the community
• Comparing wind with alternative energy sources for: cost, embedded
energy, other challenges and risks
KEY PRINCIPLES
• Accessing information from Hepburn and others
• Membership structure is clear and doesn’t change
• Triple Quadruple bottom line: economic, social, environmental, governance
• Getting the right site:
• Close to grid
• Good wind
• Already cleared
• Away from houses
• Not in bird path
• Community support
• Access (all weather)
• Ethical
• Environmental
• Local ownership proportion to be set
• Financing
• Returns to investors plus returns to the is return comparable?
• Two thirds investors, one third borrowing
• Local investors (individuals) treated same as other investors
• Pay for self and renewal
• Sourcing of materials/practical
• Certainty of wind for investors
BENEFITS
• Clean power, local power
• Benefits – cleaner air
• Money focussed back into our own community, rather than going out in
many directions, in super funds
• Local (independent) energy generation
• People coming together with a common cause, bringing back community
social benefits
• Community taking responsibility for their energy needs in a sustainable way
KEY PRINCIPLES
• Transparency
• Keep it Simple!
• Good board and management
• Spread benefits and risks widely
• Local investors only – e.g. Community Mutual - local $, stay local
• Set a percentage for local funding
• Return of 10% to 12% (cf. stock market 6% to 12%)
• Set a percentage of profit for community purposes
• Voting control
• Keep governance local
• Learn from local government investments (Fanny May etc)
• Low minimum investment per person, say $500.
• Insure risks (e.g damage to sites for roads etc)
• Bring community together
BENEFITS
• Community ownership
• A cooperative scheme would mean the community/investors would feel
they had a degree of control over their investment (as opposed to, say, a
government owned scheme or large commercial operator.
• Community ownership
• Shifting the energy debate from government to taking the lead from the
people – people power.
• Direct sale/use of electricity (e.g. Council, hospital)
• Support and cooperation from local Council
• Jobs for local residents
• Potential to partner with UNE for research projects – extend business
• Keep profits local – diversify income, ownership
• Wind is free, clean and never-ending
• Carbon trading benefits
KEY PRINCIPLES
• To benefit all community, the benefits need to go back via Councils or
other broader, rather than just the shareholders
• Legally incorporated in unlisted public company
• Direct benefits in ? lower electricity costs
• Research and learn from other projects (e.g. Hepburn)
• Council involvement (they have prior history of energy supply)
• Locate close to grid & not near homes
• Open processes
• Structure: public company, transparent
• Take advantage of e.g. carbon trading
• A way to sell/interest people in project
• Work out key objectives e.g. carbon/sustainability/local enterprise
• Majority control to be local, set a %
• Genuinely hearing and responding to people’s concerns
• Building knowledge in the community, starting small.
INVESTOR FORUM
BENEFITS
• Miniturisation
• Get plans and build turbines here
• 18% + ethical
• UNE land for siting
• Ring Main Supply
• “Preferred Place”; EVO Cities; reputation of the region; reputation; lifestyle
• Provide a focus for community energy efficiency an other small scale
cogeneration projects – synergy and partnerships
• Sustainable energy resource; Clean energy; Clean power generation
• Localised electricity production; smaller loss in grid; reduced energy losses
• Employment opportunities; Local employment; creation of jobs
• Research opportunities; development of alternative technology
• Future benefits for the environment are enormous
• Community involvement
• Localised investment; ongoing investments; clean ethical investment;
incentive for investing
• Community-run, self-sustaining electricity; renewable energy source not
reliant on others outside community;
• Government ‘seed project’
• Increased population (?)
• Reduction in GHG emissions; reduction of carbon footprint
• Support and access to expertise not necessarily available to individuals.
• Carbon credit generation; carbon credits?;
• Sustainability
KEY PRINCIPLES
• More people to benefit from NEW then less negative resistance
• Risk spread around and therefore increase chance of getting off the
ground; risk spread.
• Transparency
• KISS information
• Board: business, merit and skills based, technical, corp law, acct (?)
• Governance role for LGA
• ROI and Feel Good; 10% plus return
• Reflect community values
• Balance financial aspects with community values
• Offset rising electricity prices; lock in a price for electricity for a given time
• How do we ‘own’ it? Rates adjustment?
• Ability to sell shares; liquidity and depth in share market
• Carbon ‘franking’ credit
• Prevent foreign investors from buying it out
• Have clear, set mission, purpose, vision, strategy to then drive a marketing
plan
• Dominant ‘local’ community ownership
• Needs a very strong financial underpinning: profit = return
• Idea of having a local price discount and a export price premium (ie. Pay
less for local electricity and more for electricity that has had to travel a
long way)
• Classes of shares
• Local with voting and governance rights
• Structure: separate business from operational arm; authorisation/ investment
arm; business/community arm.
BENEFITS
• A better future – money for community.
• People controlling local power
• Clean power
• If it works, community pride, sense of achievement
• Towers allow land usage as usual
• Long term investment 20 years +
• Clean energy
• Joint venture: public listed company allows shares to be traded
• If the community wind towers could be off the private companies
• Line of sight consultation a ‘must do’
• Are state land reserves etc available rather than ‘private’ land
• Local/regional ownership
• Cooperative, not a profit-oriented structure/framework
• Local employment, IF Govt supports training of locals
• Reduction of greenhouse gases (far more effective than taxing the current
systems to discourage use)
• Potential to continue using the land as before
• Flow-on financial benefits to the community.
• Environmental benefits – less effects into the future than coal
• Financial benefits – cheaper energy source
• Employment benefits
• Great source of renewable energy to be used in conjunction with solar
units
• Clean wind always available
• Community ownership
• More affordable electricity
• Symbol of what community stands for
• Community based – much more preferable
• Eliminates the developer
• $44M 7PA – to latch on to other existing development
KEY PRINCIPLES
• Do it ourselves. Eliminate the developers
• Benefit both sides: community and developers
• Include community right from the beginning
• Line of site communication
• NSW govt training to create local employment
• Get good people for management/board
• Structure: prevent negative influence of a few – ?re voting influence.
• Inclusive/ right to a voice
• Return on investment
• Return a profit to the community—enhance community spirit
• Investigate size/capacity of turbines and maintenance requirements
• Avoid environmentally sensitive areas
• Consider attachment to a commercial wind farm
• Educate the community
• Members
• ?only from New England.
• ? only individuals
• ? Councils
• Councils on side
• Transparency, good & bad
• Independent legal advice