Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Automatic validation tools do exist and are market, but an efficient Chinese-language
generally fast and convenient, but they cannot screen reader for Web browsing is not
validate all accessibility issues. Human review available yet. Hong Kong-based Web sites
is still required to ensure a Web pages’ routinely contain both Chinese and English
conformance. The W3C thus recommends characters on the same Web page, making a
both automatic validation and human review. screen reader for this market more difficult to
Among the available automatic validation develop. This new (HCI) can deal with mixed
tools, Bobby is one of most well known language content and can be used by very
software packages[2]. young and old segments of the population as
Bobby was developed by a non-profit well as by visually impaired people.
organization called the Center for Applied
Special Technology (CAST). Users can
submit a Web page to Bobby by typing the
URL of the page at CAST’s Web site. Bobby Background information
can then examine the page and report
The Internet is the most well known
accessibility problems. This method will only component (Kalakota and Whinston, 1996)
check one page at a time in order to keep the of the Information Superhighway network
server available to all. A downloadable version infrastructure which spans several continents
of Bobby, which can check Web pages in a and is the backbone of electronic commerce.
whole Web site in batch mode, is also Indeed, Internet use is expanding faster than
available. A Web designer earns the right to any other communication technology in
display a Bobby icon on his/her Web page if it history and has the potential to significantly
passes the Bobby test. impact the major portion of the population in
Even with the protection of ADA and any society. The Internet’s ability to transmit
availability of automatic tools, recent multimedia content overcoming time and
accessibility studies (Jackson-Sanborn et al., space constraints has created exciting and
2001) using Bobby show that the majority of unforeseen opportunities in commerce,
the US-based Web sites do not meet the Web communication, education, science, politics,
Content Accessibility Guideline[3] (Waddell, international relations, and many other fields.
1999). In many developing countries, the lack The Internet has played a major role in
of access to the Internet for disabled persons is stimulating the global economy and has a
even worse. People with disabilities in these profound impact on the quality of life for its
countries are not protected by laws similar to users. However, a digital divide exists. People
ADA in the US. The access problem is simply with disabilities are often left out of this
ignored by Web designers as they do not Internet revolution.
believe that they should make the Web sites In the early stages of Internet, only text
accessible to people with disabilities. It is even information was available on the Internet.
more urgent to find a solution in these The text LineMode Browser (Walsh, 1996) in
countries. 1991 was quite different from the Web
Many governments realize the importance navigation tools that we know at present. It
of Internet and the benefits it can bring to did not support the mouse or graphics and
their populations. These governments have was difficult to use. The first multimedia
invested heavily to promote the use of the browser (MOSAIC) to boast a user-friendly
Internet. However, blind persons cannot graphical user interface (GUI) was released in
receive benefits from these investments as 1993. MOSAIC was considered to be a
they cannot see the information presented via breakthrough software product as it advanced
Internet on a computer screen. It is practically the World Wide Web into a multimedia
impossible for them to use the Internet as they system. At present, the Internet can deliver
cannot position the cursor to a particular text, video, sound, human speech and
location on the screen using the mouse. graphics. The mouse and hypermedia are
This paper presents a new human-computer employed to make it easy to navigate the
interface (HCI) designed to solve the Internet Internet and search for information. The
accessibility problems encountered by the latest Web browsers, Netscape Navigator and
blind people. This project is supported by the Microsoft Internet Explorer, have further
Quality Education Fund of Hong Kong SAR improved on the functions of MOSAIC and
Government. English “screen reader” use similar technologies. Although the mouse
programs for blind people are already on the and hypermedia are great interface tools for
577
Internet surfing for the blind: a prototype The Electronic Library
Alfred Loo, Ming-te Lu and Chris Bloor Volume 21 · Number 6 · 2003 · 576-586
“normal” people, ironically they create barrier converting it to human speech will not solve
for visually impaired persons to access the Internet navigation problems for blind people.
Internet. At present, there are many new First of all, screen reading is usually done in a
applications for the Internet such as Internet batch mode. A real time mode is required for
banking, Internet shopping, Internet voting, Internet navigation. In addition, “reading
Internet telephone and Internet television. aloud” every item on a Web page and asking
Internet is also being used for education and the user to make subsequent choices
for seeking employment. However, visually constitutes a heavy burden on a human’s
impaired persons are not able to obtain the short-term memory (Zetie, 1995) making it a
full benefits of Internet because it is nearly poor HCI technique. Also, most “text
impossible for them to navigate the Internet reading” programs work independently and
with the existing browsers. Thus, new HCIs cannot interact with popular Web browsers
need to be developed to enable them to enjoy such as Internet Explorer and Netscape. In
the benefits of the Internet. order to activate the next Web page, the user
still needs to point to a specific hypertext link
HCI and click the mouse, an action which is nearly
Research in HCIs, an important area of impossible for a visually impaired person.
software design, has been very active and Innovative methods must be developed if
references abound. However, most research visually impaired people are to have
has been based on the assumption that the uninhibited access to the Internet.
user possesses normal eyesight. Research
work on access tools for blind people is Braille printout and Braille devices
lacking. For example, visual design is often Thirty years back, the output of computer
stressed in the design of HCIs with the systems was primarily conveyed to humans via
objective of providing visual attributes that paper printout. As blind computer users
contribute valuable impressions and
cannot read ordinary paper, they had to read
communicate important cues to a user.
computer output by touching paper specially
Various approaches have been suggested, and
indented with a pattern of raised dots called
technologies developed, via which visually
“Braille” (Blenkhorn and Evans, 1988;
impaired persons can access the Internet and
Lightowler, 1994). This technology was
surf the Web. These approaches and their
named after its inventor, Louis Braille. He was
limitations are presented in the following
a blind Frenchman and his blindness was
sections.
caused by an accident in his childhood. Braille
Text browsers is not the only reading and writing system for
To avoid problems of using the mouse and the blind, but it was considered to be the best
hypermedia, most visually impaired persons according to several independent studies
use text-based Web browsers (e.g. Lynx) that (Keeler, 1986). Throughout the years, his
will ignore graphics on Web pages and allows system has been adopted by many countries
the use of the keyboard to activate hyperlinks. all over world. Over 600,000 books,
However, since many Web designers only test newspapers and magazines are printed in
their designs on popular browsers such as Braille every year. However, it is much more
Netscape and Microsoft’s Internet Explorer, expensive than ordinary computer printout
they often use features that are not supported and a special printer is required.
by text browsers; blind users often have A Braille device (CSUN’95, 1995; Kay,
problems accessing such Web sites. Text 1984; Leventhal et al., 1991) is another
browsers cannot completely solve the alternate output device for the blind. A small
problems of Internet surfing for the blind. part of the image of a computer screen can be
generated on the device; a visually impaired
Screen readers person can read it quickly by touching the
Speech synthesis technology (Allen et al., device and does not have to wait for the
1981; Suen, 1981) has been available since generation of the Braille paper. However,
the late 1970s. “Screen readers” (LinuxUser, Braille devices are very expensive. A typical
2000) were developed in 1980s and blind device costs about US$6,000 while the cost of
people can now access most text-based a Pentium-based computer is only US$1,000.
computer displays using speech generated by People with disabilities generally have far
screen readers (Meyers and Schreier, 1991). lower incomes than other citizens (National
However, simply reading the text and Council on Disabilities, 2001). Most visually
578
Internet surfing for the blind: a prototype The Electronic Library
Alfred Loo, Ming-te Lu and Chris Bloor Volume 21 · Number 6 · 2003 · 576-586
Microsoft SAPI technology was the core available from Microsoft, sound wave
technology applied in VocalSurf ’s English manipulation using audio compression
speech engine construction. In constructing techniques and COM technologies were
the Cantonese speech component of adopted to simulate a SAPI for a Cantonese
VocalSurf, since SAPI for Cantonese is not speech engine. Rapid application
580
Internet surfing for the blind: a prototype The Electronic Library
Alfred Loo, Ming-te Lu and Chris Bloor Volume 21 · Number 6 · 2003 · 576-586
development was adopted in software Table I Control keys for the system
development to facilitate continuous
Key combination Function
prototyping.
CTRL Focus on URL input
SHIFT B Begin reading
Mechanisms implemented SHIFT S Stop reading
Figure 3 shows the overall architecture of the SHIFT L List the current ten hyperlinks
sound engine. SHIFT = Move on to the next
End-users interaction with VocalSurf by ten hyperlinks
means of user interface using the keyboard SHIFT - Return to the previous ten
and control keys are summarized in Table I. hyperlinks
Messages are then carried forward to the SHIFT 0...9 Select a particular hyperlink in
VocalSurf Sound Engine, which parses the the current ten hyperlink listing
requested Web page for meaningful content. (if the current ten hyperlink
The engine also determines if the reading listing is from 11 to
content is Chinese or English. English content 20, 0 will be 20,
is directed to an API wrapper for SAPI to 1 will be 11, 2
process. If the content is Chinese, every word will be 12, etc.)
will be matched against a database for the Backspace Go back
corresponding wave compressed files. When ALT ! Go to a page ahead
processing by either Database-WAV or SAPI is of the current page
complete, the VocalSurf sound engine
produces the audio output.
Classes and objects in the sound engine are Internal testing of VocalSurf consisted of three
described in Figure 4. The most important phases: unit testing, module testing and
class in Figure 4 is the “PlaySound” which system testing. Internal testing was carried out
produces human voice. Its components are by our research staff while the user testing was
described in Figure 5. conducted by our research partner – users
from the Hong Kong Blind Union. During
Testing unit testing, each event or function of
The strategies adopted in testing VocalSurf VocalSurf was tested. In module testing,
included internal testing and user testing. VocalSurf was grouped into three modules:
581
Internet surfing for the blind: a prototype The Electronic Library
Alfred Loo, Ming-te Lu and Chris Bloor Volume 21 · Number 6 · 2003 · 576-586
582
Internet surfing for the blind: a prototype The Electronic Library
Alfred Loo, Ming-te Lu and Chris Bloor Volume 21 · Number 6 · 2003 · 576-586
583
Internet surfing for the blind: a prototype The Electronic Library
Alfred Loo, Ming-te Lu and Chris Bloor Volume 21 · Number 6 · 2003 · 576-586
applications for these kind of users are applications in kindergartens and primary
discussed in the following sections. schools.
584
Internet surfing for the blind: a prototype The Electronic Library
Alfred Loo, Ming-te Lu and Chris Bloor Volume 21 · Number 6 · 2003 · 576-586
the system could also be used by secondary built as small as a walkman. Incorporating the
school students, regardless of their eyesight. knowledge-based HCI system described
The proposed system could open up a new above into such a small network computer
world on the World Wide Web for any would enable Web browsing while travelling
non-English speaking population. or commuting.
585
Internet surfing for the blind: a prototype The Electronic Library
Alfred Loo, Ming-te Lu and Chris Bloor Volume 21 · Number 6 · 2003 · 576-586
Biographies
Alfred Loo works in the Department of Information Systems, Lingnan University, Hong Kong.
His research interests include Peer-to-peer technologies and distributed processing. He can be
contacted at: Alfred@ln.edu.hk
Ming-te Lu is Chair Professor of the Department of Information Systems and Chief
Information Officer, Lingnan University, Hong Kong. His research interests include e-
commerce and IT issues in developing economies. He can be contacted at: lumt@ln.edu.hk
Chris Bloor is a Principal Lecturer in Computing at the University of Sunderland, UK. His
research interests include computing for people with disabilities and accessibility issues. He can
be contacted at: Chris.Bloor@sunderland.ac.uk
586