Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
CREDIT DERIVATIVES
Vaidya Nathan
Outline
Page
Basket Products 26
Synthetic CDO 49
CDS Valuation 87
D E R I V A T I V E S
VAIDYA NATHAN 1
Credit derivatives in the context of financial markets growth
New applications
expanding financial
instruments use
re As
O V E R VI E W
a s
u c t s pa n ex et cl
r od to s ird t
tra ende asses
p
w ging & th cts dit d
e
N er nd du ion bey getti
m o o al o n
e sec pr ma nd g
D E R I VA T I VE S
o n rke
rati ts
ne
ge
C R E D I T
VAIDYA NATHAN 2
Role of Credit Derivatives
Motivations
Motivations for
for use
use of
of Credit
Credit Derivatives
Derivatives
Hedge,
transfer and/or
Synthetically mitigate credit Decompose
create loan- exposure and separate
bond; credit risks
alternative to embedded in
equity financial
derivatives instruments
O V E R VI E W
Generate Proactively
leverage or manage credit
yield risk on a
enhancement Manage portfolio basis
regulatory
D E R I VA T I VE S
capital ratios
C R E D I T
VAIDYA NATHAN 3
Credit derivatives isolate and transfer credit risk
Broad definition
Credit 60 bps
O V E R VI E W
Loan/bond
FX, 6.60 %
Interest yield
D E R I VA T I VE S
Rate
On-balance sheet
C R E D I T
Off-balance sheet
VAIDYA NATHAN 4
Credit derivatives perform a market completion role
Convexity Risk
including callability Credit risk
risk sometimes i.e.
negative convexity
O V E R VI E W
D E R I VA T I VE S
Duration Risk
C R E D I T
VAIDYA NATHAN 5
Efficiency gains arising from disaggregating risk
JOB LOT
O V E R VI E W
D E R I VA T I VE S
C R E D I T
VAIDYA NATHAN 6
Spreads of Credit Default Swaps can be compared to bond yields
Credit Risk
Credit Risk
Funding Risk
O V E R VI E W
VAIDYA NATHAN 7
The simplest instrument: single name credit default swaps
Reference Entity
Risk (Notional)
Fee/premium
B A
Protection Buyer Protection Seller
Contingent Payment
upon a credit event
Buy CDS Sell CDS
O V E R VI E W
VAIDYA NATHAN 8
Indicative Summary Terms of CDS
General
General Terms
Terms Fixed
Fixed Payments
Payments
Effective Date: 23 Nov 2006 Fixed Rate Payer Notional: USD 25,000,000
Scheduled Termination Date: 23 Nov 2008 Fixed Rate Payer Payment Dates: The 23rd
of February, May, August and November,
Floating Rate Payer: X (the “Seller”)
commencing on February 23, 2007
Fixed Rate Payer: Y (the “Buyer”)
Fixed Rate: X% per annum
Business Day: London & New York
Fixed Rate Day Count Fraction: Actual/360
Business Day Convention: Modified Following
Coupon: 6.5%
2. Notice of Publicly Available Information
CUSIP/ISIN: USXXX Applicable
Original Issue Amount: USD 1,000,000,000 Public Source(s): Standard Public Sources
Specified Number: Two
3. Notice of Physical Settlement
C R E D I T
VAIDYA NATHAN 9
Indicative Summary Terms of CDS
Credit
Credit Events
Events Settlement
Settlement Terms
Terms
Credit Events: The following Credit Event(s) Settlement Method: Physical Settlement
shall apply to this Transaction:
Physical Settlement Period: Section 8.5 of the
Bankruptcy
ISDA Credit Derivatives Definitions, subject to a
Failure to Pay maximum of 30 Business Days
Restructuring
Portfolio: Exclude Accrued Interest
Grace Period Extension: Not Applicable
Deliverable Obligation Category: Bond or Loan
Payment Requirement: USD 1,000,000 or its
equivalent in the relevant Obligation Deliverable Obligation Characteristics:
Currency Pari Passu Ranking
Specified Currencies: Standard Specified
O V E R VI E W
VAIDYA NATHAN 10
In reality assumes two names risk
Seller receives a fee in return for making a Contingent Payment if there is a Credit
Event of the Reference Credit which in turn depends on the financial health of the
D E R I VA T I VE S
bank
C R E D I T
VAIDYA NATHAN 11
Replicating a Credit Default Swap
Corporate Asset
Libor
Repo rate (L – x)
O V E R VI E W
$ 100 * ( 1 – haircut )
Repo Market
D E R I VA T I VE S
Credit Default Swap Spread (approx.) = Corporate Spread (Sc) – Swap Spread (Ss)
VAIDYA NATHAN 12
Funding Cost Arbitrage
BBB Asset
L + 25 bp
Lender AA- Rated Institution
L + 40 bp
BBB Asset
O V E R VI E W
25 bp
AA- Rated Institution AAA Rated Institution
L + 40 bp
BBB Asset
VAIDYA NATHAN 13
Outline
Page
Basket Products 26
Synthetic CDO 49
CDS Valuation 87
D E R I V A T I V E S
VAIDYA NATHAN 14
Degrees of leverage in various Credit Derivative structures
Capital protection +
minimum Linear Senior
coupon/interest
Increasing
Yield Capital protection Mezzanine
First-To-Default
VAIDYA NATHAN 15
Ab Initio - Credit-linked notes
Tailored notes
Structured for investor’s required currency, maturity, and coupon needs
Provide solutions for many investors restricted from entering into OTC transactions
Provide investors with yield and minimum ratings requirements through leveraged
high grade structures
B A S K E T
L I N EA R
&
C L N
VAIDYA NATHAN 16
Structure of a Typical CLN
Protection Sale
Proceeds
CDS Premium
CLN Proceeds
Investors
B A S K E T
L I N EA R
&
C L N
VAIDYA NATHAN 17
Linear Baskets
Linear basket swaps allow investors to gain exposure to multiple credits in one
trade
Risk buyer takes on exposure to each credit equal to the 1/N of the notional of the
basket, where N is the number of credits in the basket (assuming equal weighting)
Yield on these structures is additive, since each credit is independent of the other
(the same as yield on first-to-default basket with zero correlation)
trade
L I N EA R
&
C L N
VAIDYA NATHAN 18
Advantages of Credit Linked Notes
CP Risk
CP Risk &
& No
No Direct
Direct
Credit Line
Credit Line Derivatives
Derivatives
Usage
Usage Contract
Contract
No
Nosystem
system Non-issuers
Non-issuers
requisites
requisites reference
reference
CLN Advantages
Canbe
Can be Customized
Customized
listed
listed Maturity
Maturity
Relative
Relative Tailored
Tailored
B A S K E T
Value
Value Exposure
Exposure
L I N EA R
&
C L N
VAIDYA NATHAN 19
Disadvantages of CLNs
Lack of Cheapest to
Liquidity Deliver
Option
Medium
Funded Form
Term
& Lack of
View
Leverage
B A S K E T
L I N EA R
&
C L N
VAIDYA NATHAN 20
Linear Baskets - an illustration
A B C D E Investor
Investor
Contingent Payment
(Par — Recovery on Credit E)
Protection Buyer Protection Seller
A B C D Investor
Investor
Contingent Payment
L I N EA R
VAIDYA NATHAN 21
Linear Basket - Example
300 bps A
100 bps
B Equal weighted Linear Basket Spread
=230 bps
400 bps
C
B A S K E T
150 bps
D
L I N EA R
200 bps E
&
C L N
VAIDYA NATHAN 22
Benefits of CDX
VAIDYA NATHAN 23
CDS indices: CDX and iTraxx
Weekly fixings on three CDS indices: DJ iTraxx Europe, HiVol index and
Crossover index
Just as options are way to trade volatility, tranches are way to trade
default correlations
B A S K E T
VAIDYA NATHAN 24
CDS indices for Asia and Australia
Nonlinearity
Nonlinearity of
of risky
risky duration
duration for
for half
half and
and double
double credit
credit spreads
spreads
iTraxx CJ has 50 Japanese names, with sub-indices for capital goods, tech
and HiVol
iTraxx Asia has 30 names from outside Japan with sub-indices for Korea,
Greater China and rest of Asia
VAIDYA NATHAN 25
Outline
Page
Basket Products 26
Synthetic CDO 49
CDS Valuation 87
D E R I V A T I V E S
VAIDYA NATHAN 26
First To Default (FTD) Baskets
After the first credit event, the first-to-default swap terminates and the investor no
longer bears exposure to the non-defaulted credits
Risk buyer takes on exposure to each credit equal to the notional of the basket,
thus achieving leverage of the number of names in the basket
P R O D U C T S
B A S K E T
VAIDYA NATHAN 27
First To Default (FTD) Baskets — an illustration
X bp per annum
A B C D E
Contingent Payment
Protection Buyer (Par - Recovery on Credit E) Protection Seller
If Credit E defaults, Protection Seller pays Par and receives the Recovery Value on
Credit E
The greater the correlation, the greater the probability of multiple defaults in the
P R O D U C T S
basket
B A S K E T
VAIDYA NATHAN 28
Mechanics of a First To Default Basket Structure
Bank
Market Credit Default
Swaps on
5 CDS on 1st to
Individual Default
Credits
OTC
Investors
P R O D U C T S
B A S K E T
VAIDYA NATHAN 29
From individual default probability to basket default probability
Individual
Individual Basket default probability
default
default Correlation = 0
probability
probability 150 bps A FTD Spread = 575 bps
Correlation
Correlation Taking a leveraged exposure to
of
of a basket is equivalent to
assets
assets trading the correlation
between those names
50 bps
B
Intuition:
Intuition: The
The higher
higher the
the correlation,
correlation, the
the lower
lower the
the
spread
spread on
on the
the leveraged
leveraged piece
piece
100% correlation
200 bps
C
The basket behaves like 1 single credit
Protection Seller will expect to receive the
widest of individual spreads Correlation = 1.0
VAIDYA NATHAN 30
High and Low Correlation – the Tom & Jerry way
High
High &
& Low
Low Correlation
Correlation
P R O D U C T S
B A S K E T
VAIDYA NATHAN 31
Risk illustrated
Correlation = 0
A B
D
C E
Correlation = 1
B
E
C
A
A
B E
C D
B A S K E T
VAIDYA NATHAN 32
Actual FTD trades – Example 1
Background
Background Trade Summary
Trade Summary
Korean client buys FTD loan on six Aggregate bid spread: 537 bps
investment grade credits
FTD Basket coupon: 6.75%
50% of names chosen were local credits
FTD spread over Libor: 335 bps
50% of names were foreign credits
FTD spread over Libor as a % of
Inclusion of foreign credits helps aggregate spread: 62%
reduce correlation of the basket which
FTD spread over Libor as a % of highest
inturn helps increase spread
bid spread: 163%
Non callable
POSCO 53
Hutchison Whampoa 98
Ford 206
Standard Life Assurance 74
B A S K E T
VAIDYA NATHAN 33
Actual FTD trades – Example 2
Background
Background Trade Summary
Trade Summary
Client buys FTD note on five high yield Aggregate bid spread: 950 bps
credits
FTD Basket coupon: 10.60%
Names chosen were high rated (BB)
FTD spread over Libor: 720 bps
high yield credits
FTD spread over Libor as a % of
Clustered spreads
aggregate spread: 75%
Spreads have low correlation to
FTD spread over Libor as a % of highest
maximize spread
bid spread: 335%
Non callable
VAIDYA NATHAN 34
Actual FTD trades – Example 3
Background
Background Trade Summary
Trade Summary
Client buys FTD protection on five high Aggregate offer spread: 795 bps
yield credits
FTD Basket premium: 5.0%
Reduced costs relative to hedging each
FTD spread over Libor as a % of
of the individual credits
aggregate spread: 63%
Sheds substantial portion of the risk
FTD spread over Libor as a % of highest
Credits have high correlation to bid spread: 222%
minimize cost
VAIDYA NATHAN 35
Default Correlation
Default correlations are key determinants of hedge ratios which determine basket
premiums that dealers are willing to pay. The boundary conditions for the basket
premium can be restated in terms of the default correlation as follows:
The most difficult factor to incorporate in the model for pricing basket products is
the estimation of the underlying correlations. Estimating the correlation between
two default events cannot be achieved by standard statistical methods. Instead
B A S K E T
Model the correlation between names as a result of the correlation of each name with
a systemic “market” variable (CAPM)
the probability of default of any given name depends on the market environment
As correlation approaches one: FTD Basket Premium = Highest Individual CDS Spread
in Basket
VAIDYA NATHAN 37
Par spreads for FTD with different betas
Par
Par spreads
spreads for
for FTD
FTD with
with different
different betas
betas
550
Par Spreads with Time for various betas
500
450
400
250
200
Time ( yrs)
150
P R O D U C T S
1.00 2.00 3.00 4.01 5.01 6.01 7.01 8.01 9.01 10.01 12.01 15.01 20.02 25.02 30.02 40.03
Basket of five names each trading at 100 bps. Rate of decrease of spreads is high for high correlation
B A S K E T
VAIDYA NATHAN 38
Expected loss for FTD with different betas
Expected
Expected loss
loss for
for FTD
FTD with
with different
different betas
betas
100.00%
Expected Loss for FTD with time for various betas
90.00%
80.00%
Beta = 10% Beta = 50% Beta = 90%
70.00%
60.00%
50.00%
40.00%
30.00%
20.00%
10.00%
Time (yrs)
0.00%
P R O D U C T S
0.25 1.00 1.50 2.00 3.00 4.01 5.01 6.01 7.01 8.01 9.01 10.01 12.01 15.01 20.02 25.02 30.02 40.03
B A S K E T
VAIDYA NATHAN 39
Dynamic Hedging Of The FTD Basket
The hedging behaviour of a dealer provides some intuition behind the actual basket
premium
A dealer that buys protection on a basket from an investor would normally hedge
this transaction by selling default protection on each individual name in the basket
As the underlying default premiums shift, the deltas will change and the hedges
will need to be rebalanced dynamically
The efficiency with which the hedge can be managed is a key factor that
determines the basket premium
For small movements in the hedge ratio, the dealer may not be able to sell or buy
protection and may instead buy or sell bonds to hedge, thus taking on basis risk
P R O D U C T S
B A S K E T
VAIDYA NATHAN 40
Dynamic Hedging Of The FTD Basket
Protection Buyer Protection Seller
X bp per annum
A B C D E FTD
FTDInvestor
Investor
Contingent Payment
(Par - Recovery on Credit E)
Notional = N
AANotional
NotionalNNAA==Hedge
HedgeRatio
RatioAAxxNN
BBNotional
NotionalNNBB==Hedge
HedgeRatio
RatioBBxxNN
CCNotional
NotionalNNCC==Hedge
HedgeRatio
RatioCCxxNN
P R O D U C T S
DDNotional
NotionalNNDD==Hedge
HedgeRatio
RatioDDxxNN
EENotional
NotionalNNEE==Hedge
HedgeRatio
RatioEExxNN
B A S K E T
VAIDYA NATHAN 41
Dynamic Hedging of FTD Basket
Efficient leverage and limited downside : Investors are able to efficiently leverage
credit risk with a defined downside potential by executing a FTD Basket Swap, since
the swap’s notional amount references a basket that is 5x to 10x its size
Limited maximum loss: a $10mm FTD Basket Swap that references a basket of ten
names (aggregate credit exposure of $100mm) still limits the investor’s maximum
loss to the first loss in the basket — or $10mm
Efficient usage of regulatory capital: The notional amount of the swap, rather than
the notional amount of the reference basket, would be used in a risk-based capital
requirement calculation for a US bank. This allows banks to take credit risk to a
reference portfolio that is 5x-10x as large as the notional amount of the swap for
P R O D U C T S
VAIDYA NATHAN 43
Investment rationale for a FTD Basket Swap
Investment grade ratings available: Rating agencies have been willing to provide
investment grade ratings to FTD Basket Swaps that meet rating agency requirements
regarding credit risk and diversification
Fund managers with limits on scope of assets to invest: This has allowed investors
that are limited to specific ratings-based investment guidelines to earn premiums
well in excess of those typically found in the single-name investment grade bonds or
credit default swaps
Executable via swap or funded note/deposit: Investors may elect sell FTD Basket
protection via a swap or funded credit linked note (CLN)
The settlement mechanics of a FTD Basket Swap are identical to a single name
credit default swap (physical settlement of defaulted securities)
P R O D U C T S
B A S K E T
VAIDYA NATHAN 44
First 2 To Default (F2TD) Baskets
Total premium for a F2TD basket should be lesser than for a first to default
After the first credit event, contract settles partially and notional of the trade is
reduced by half
After the second credit event, contract settles fully and the trade terminates
P R O D U C T S
B A S K E T
VAIDYA NATHAN 45
First 2 To Default (F2TD) Baskets
X bp per annum
A B C D E
Contingent Payment
Protection Buyer (Par - Recovery on Credit E) Protection Seller
If Credit E defaults, Protection Seller pays Par and receives the Recovery Value on Credit E
X bp per annum
A B C D
Contingent Payment
Protection Buyer (Par - Recovery on Credit D) Protection Seller
P R O D U C T S
If Credit D defaults, Protection Seller pays Par and receives the Recovery Value on Credit D
Trade terminates
B A S K E T
VAIDYA NATHAN 46
First-to-default vs First-2-to-default
Basket Spreads
200
180 180
170
160 158
BPS
145
140 140
135
125
120
112
100
92
80
4Y 5Y 8Y
VAIDYA NATHAN 47
Other Basket default products
Second to default : The protection buyer is protected only against the second default,
and pays a premium until the occurrence of this event. The premium will be less than for
a FTD, since two defaults are always less likely than one (assuming that the credits are
not perfectly correlated)
Second, third, fourth or fifth to default : The premium for an nth to default decreases
as n increases, since the probability of n defaults becomes more unlikely. The effect of
correlation is to increase the premium, since this increases the probability of multiple
defaults. Relatively speaking, this effect is more dramatic for larger n
Sum of first, second, third, fourth and fifth to default : The total premium for these
five contracts is always greater than the sum of the individual default swap premiums
Quanto basket default swap : Similar to other quanto products. Assume that the FTD
basket is cash-settled. Upon a credit event, observe the reference obligation (presumably
denominated in USD), then protection buyer receives 1-R x Quanto FX i.e. an FX rate
agreed
P R O D U C T S
Actual Quanto Trade: a Taiwanese investor buys protection and pays a running TWD
fee. The basket consists of 5 names with reference obligations denominated in USD.
There is a credit event, recovery on the deliverable is 40. The Taiwanese investor gets
B A S K E T
(100-40) x whatever FX rate that was agreed at the beginning of the trade. For trades in
general, the fee and the payout don't have to be the same currency
VAIDYA NATHAN 48
Outline
Page
Basket Products 26
Synthetic CDO 49
CDS Valuation 87
D E R I V A T I V E S
VAIDYA NATHAN 49
A synthetic tranche is a specific allocation of risk of a synthetic CDO
A synthetic CDO pools the risk of various synthetic assets — corporates, sovereigns,
financials — in the form of a portfolio of CDS
Each tranche exhibits different risk characteristics which reflect its expected share of
portfolio losses as well as its sensitivity to changes in the expected distribution of
losses within the portfolio
An active risk management strategy allows banks to create and offer tranche
protection or exposure on a standalone basis
C D O
S Y N TH E T I C
VAIDYA NATHAN 50
9
Each tranche is defined in terms of pay-off
Example
Example of
of a
a mezzanine
mezzanine tranche
tranche
Tranche
loss
CDS Buyer of CDS Seller of
Protection Protection
Fee
Tranche
loss
Tranche size
Portfolio loss
Tranche size
C D O
S Y N TH E T I C
VAIDYA NATHAN 10
51
Sum of risks (losses) is equal to portfolio risk (loss)
Tranche
loss
Senior
Portfolio loss
Eq. size Mezz. size
Tranche
loss
Mezz. size Mezzanine
Portfolio loss
Mezz. size
Tranche
loss
Eq. size Equity
Portfolio loss
Eq. size
C D O
S Y N TH E T I C
VAIDYA NATHAN 52
11
Risk of a tranche is defined by its position in the capital structure
Second-loss piece
Medium risk
(Mezzanine)
VAIDYA NATHAN 53
12
Synthetic first loss tranche is created by sourcing delta amount of CDS
As in a CDO, risk is sourced from the CDS market; however, the amount of risk
sourced reflects only the risk of the first loss tranche
By synthetically reproducing its specific risk profile, any tranche can be created
without the need to place the remainder of the capital structure
Delta amount
of CDS on SPV Investor
individual
Spread Spread
credits
VAIDYA NATHAN 54
13
Pricing framework for a synthetic tranche is based on expected loss
VAIDYA NATHAN 55
15
To compute expected loss, obtain portfolio loss distribution
Probability of default for each individual name — derived from the credit spread
and recovery rate estimate:
PD = S/(1-Recovery Rate)
VAIDYA NATHAN 56
16
Estimating loss distribution requires tranching, spreads & recoveries
A
A simplified
simplified example
example of
of a
a portfolio
portfolio containing
containing only
only one
one name
name
Tranched structure
Portfolio:
VAIDYA NATHAN 57
17
Probability-weighting loss scenarios gives expected loss of tranches
Portfolio
Portfolio loss
loss distribution
distribution
Eq Mezz Senior
0% 50% 100%
Tranche pricing
Tranche pricing
Not ional Port folio loss Mezz Sr
Scenarios Probabilit y default e d Port folio loss (%) Equit y loss loss loss
1 97. 00% 0 0 0% 0% 0% 0%
2 3. 00% 100 50 50% 10% 30% 10%
VAIDYA NATHAN 58
18
To model loss distribution, we take into account default correlation
Default Correlations
Model
Loss distribution
C D O
S Y N TH E T I C
VAIDYA NATHAN 59
19
Address default correlation in estimating the loss distribution?
However, the probability of default of any given name depends on the market
environment
Integrating across all possible market environments yields a loss distribution which
then incorporates the correlation between names
C D O
S Y N TH E T I C
VAIDYA NATHAN 60
20
Probability of default depends on the market environment
1-year default
1-year default probability
probability Specific
Specific market
market scenarios
scenarios
Market Bad Neutral Good
environment
Probability
1/3 1/3 1/3
of market
1 year def. Prob 1 year def. prob 1 year def prob
for “Bad” for “Neutral” for “Good”
(Average over markets)
Name 1 1.0% Name 1 1.90% 1.00% 0.10%
Name 2 2.0% Name 2 3.80% 2.00% 0.20%
Name 3 0.5% Name 3 0.50% 0.50% 0.50%
VAIDYA NATHAN 61
21
Final loss distribution is calculated by averaging over all scenarios
Probability
Probability of
of loss
loss
Bad
market times 1/3
Loss
Neutral
market times 1/3
VAIDYA NATHAN 62
22
Loss distribution changes with spreads, recoveries, and correlation
Probability
Probability of
of loss
loss
Senior
Average loss
C D O
S Y N TH E T I C
VAIDYA NATHAN 63
23
Portfolio loss distributions for two portfolios
Tranche
Tranche loss
loss different
different for
for same
same tranche
tranche size
size for
for two
two different
different portfolios
portfolios
C D O
S Y N TH E T I C
VAIDYA NATHAN 64
23
As loss distribution changes, delta of any specific tranche changes
In a fully-sold synthetic CDO, the risk of changes in the loss distribution is passed
completely to investors
The distribution of losses within the portfolio will fluctuate, but the portfolio
hedge is static
In a synthetic tranche, bank’s hedge must offset the risk position of the specific
tranche
Initial delta reflects the relative proportion of the portfolio loss distribution
which falls within the tranche
Therefore, as the tranche expected loss changes, the delta hedge for that tranche
must also be rebalanced
C D O
S Y N TH E T I C
VAIDYA NATHAN 65
24
Risk management for synthetic tranches is rapidly evolving
New technology allows for the creation of synthetic tranches with a range
of attractive characteristics beyond the original static
Term of tranche credit exposure can differ from the term of the note or
swap
Credit exposure of coupons can differ from the exposure of the principal
VAIDYA NATHAN 66
26
Credit derivatives offer some unique characteristics
Credit derivatives:
VAIDYA NATHAN 67
Outline
Page
Basket Products 26
Synthetic CDO 49
CDS Valuation 87
D E R I V A T I V E S
VAIDYA NATHAN 68
Options on Credit Default Swaps
Options on credit default swaps can be structured into trades that work for various
parties with different objectives
Fund managers can sell options to earn premium while waiting for spreads to
widen to their target investment levels
Hedge funds can sell volatility through options to earn premium
Investors can buy callable CLNs/CDS to earn higher returns than on plain-vanilla
CLNs/CDS
Investors can buy principal protected notes that are linked to spread tightening
or spread widening options or their combinations
Investors can combine CDS options with interest rate or equity products to earn
OP TI ON S
VAIDYA NATHAN 69
Options terminology
A call on a credit default swap is the right to buy risk/sell protection (receiver
option)
A put on a credit default swap is the right to sell risk/buy protection (payer option)
VAIDYA NATHAN 70
Options payout diagrams
Bullish Strategy Bullish Strategy
Short call
Bearish Strategy Bearish Strategy
OP TI ON S
VAIDYA NATHAN 71
Options on single name credit default swaps
Maturity: 3 months
Premium: prices are quoted in cents, premium is paid T+3 business days
Strike: At-the-money-spot spread of the 5yr CDS derived from the current trading
level at the time of the trade
Settlement:
Physical: into the 5yr CDS upon exercise at the pre set strike
OP TI ON S
Cash: option is unwound upon exercise and cash paid out to client
Knock out:
DE R I VAT I VE
Both calls and puts knock out in case of a Credit Event on the Reference Entity
CR E D IT
VAIDYA NATHAN 72
Options on TRAC-X Europe
TRAC-X Europe options are a liquid, standard product to trade credit volatility on a
macro basis
Premium: prices are quoted in cents, premium is paid T+3 business days
Strike: Preset strikes of 30, 35, 40, 45, 50 and 55, chosen to reflect ATM and OTM
forward levels in increments of 5 bps
Settlement: Physical, into TRAC-X Europe 99 Swaps upon exercise at the pre set
strike
DE R I VAT I VE
Knock out: No knock out in case of a Credit Event in TRAC-X Europe 99 Swaps
CR E D IT
VAIDYA NATHAN 73
CR E D IT DE R I VAT I VE OP TI ON S
TRAC-X
VAIDYA NATHAN
74
Trade Idea 1: Long credit trade to earn premium
A fund manager who finds France Telecom too tight compared to his target investment levels
could sell an OTM put on France Telecom to earn premium
Breakeven analysis:
DE R I VAT I VE
Investor receives 15 cents to sell a 3-month European put on France Telecom struck at 76 bps
If France Telecom widens by more than 4 bps (= 15 bps / 4.3 duration) from the strike in 3
months, the investor will lose money on the option (I.e., if France Telecom widens beyond 80
bps, the investor will lose more on the option than the option premium earned)
— However, the manager will be put into France Telecom risk at a strike corresponding to
CR E D IT
VAIDYA NATHAN 75
Trade Idea 2A: Short credit trade
An investor who believes the market will widen in the short to medium term could buy an ATM
put on TRAC-X Europe to benefit from spreads widening
Put strike:
ATM: 45 bps Increasing Price
Decreasing Price
Increasing Spread Decreasing Spread
BE:
53 bps
36 ¢ Investor pays 30 cents
to buy ATM put
Breakeven analysis:
OP TI ON S
Investor pays 36¢ to buy a 3-month maturity European put on TRAC-X Europe struck at 45 bps
If TRAC-X Europe widens by more than 8 bps (= 36¢ / 4.3 duration) from the strike in 3 months, the
investor will make money from exercising his ATM put (i.e., if TRAC-X Europe widens beyond 53
DE R I VAT I VE
bps, the investor will make more on the option than the option premium paid)
If TRAC-X Europe widens to 60 bps in 3 months, the investor will make 64.5¢ (= (60-45) bps x 4.3
duration) from exercising his ATM put. The investor’s payout ratio in this case will be 1.79 (= 64.5¢
payout / 36¢ option premium paid)
CR E D IT
If TRAC-X Europe widens to 70 bps in 3 months, the investor will make 1.1% (= (70-45) bps x 4.3
duration) from exercising his ATM put. The investor’s payout ratio in this case would be 2.99 (=
1.1% payout / 36¢ option premium paid) VAIDYA NATHAN 76
Trade Idea 2B: Short credit trade with capped upside
If the same investor finds the ATM put too expensive and thinks market spreads will widen but
not by too much, he could buy an ATM put and sell an OTM put to subsidise cost of the ATM put
Breakeven analysis:
OP TI ON S
Investor pays 30¢ net to buy a 3-month maturity European put on TRAC-X Europe struck at
45 bps and sell a 3-month European put on TRAC-X Europe struck at 60 bps
If TRAC-X Europe widens by more than 7 bps (= 30¢ / 4.3 duration) from 50 bps in 3 months,
DE R I VAT I VE
the investor will make money on the ATM put he bought (i.e., the upside from buying the
option will be higher than the option premium paid)
Maximum payout on this trade will be 64.5¢, if TRAC-X Europe goes to 60 bps or wider (=
{60 bps – 45 bps} x 4.3 duration). The investor’s payout ratio in this trade is 2.15 (= 64.5¢ /
30¢ option premium paid)
CR E D IT
If investor thinks the market will not widen beyond 60 bps, he should put on the bear
spread (payout ratio of 2.15) instead of buying the ATM put outright (payout ratio of 1.79
when spreads are at 60 bps) VAIDYA NATHAN 77
Trade Idea 3: Short volatility trade
A hedge fund does not have a strong credit view but believes that credit market will
experience little volatility in the short to medium term could trade volatility and
earn premium by selling a 3-month ATM straddle on TRAC-X Europe
36 ¢
Investor receives 36 cents
to sell straddle
Breakeven analysis:
Hedge fund receives 36 cents to sell a 3-month maturity European straddle on
DE R I VAT I VE
VAIDYA NATHAN 78
Trade Idea 4: Callable CDS
A CDS investor with investment targets that are higher than current market levels could sell 10yr France
Telecom protection callable by bank in 5 years that pays more than the 10yr plain-vanilla CDS
Callable CDS
Premium for 10yr FRTEL CDS callable in 5yrs
Breakeven analysis:
5yr France Telecom CDS: 66 bps, 10yr France Telecom CDS: 89 bps
DE R I VAT I VE
10yr France Telecom CDS callable in 5 years pays 95 bps (WHAT IS THE CATCH HERE?)
If Bank calls the CDS in 5 years, investor will have earned 29 bps (44%) more running than the
5yr CDS, and FRTEL 5yr CDS would have to tighten by more than 29 bps for investor to lose
the 29 bps earned in the first 5 years to enter into a new France Telecom CDS
CR E D IT
If Bank does not call the CDS, investor will have earned 6 bps (7%) more running than selling
plain-vanilla 10yr protection
VAIDYA NATHAN 79
Binary (Digital) Credit Swaps
Contingent Payment
(Par)
Clients looking for leverage opportunities on a single name can sell protection in a binary swap
In a plain-vanilla credit swap, the protection seller would receive the recovery value of the
OP TI ON S
In a binary swap, the protection seller receives no recovery value in a credit event
DE R I VAT I VE
Client receives a higher spread to compensate for zero recovery in a credit event
CR E D IT
VAIDYA NATHAN 80
Digital (Binary) Default Swaps
Digital default swaps will demand a higher premium than a standard default swap
Its price will be sensitive to the recovery rate that has been assumed in the
calibration procedure
The higher the recovery rate in the calibration, the higher the calibrated hazard
rates will be
Since a digital default swap depends only on the hazard rates and not on the
recovery rate, it has a price that effectively increases with the assumed recovery
OP TI ON S
DE R I VAT I VE
CR E D IT
VAIDYA NATHAN 81
Digital Default Swaps
Based on run
above the quote
on ABY offers a
recovery bid-
offer of 35-45
with the
underlying ABY
5yr CDS spread at
297bp
An investor who
OP TI ON S
believes the
recovery rate on
ABY will be below
35 in the future
DE R I VAT I VE
VAIDYA NATHAN 82
Digital Default Swaps
Investor will be short protection on a DDS (Digital Default Swap) with a recovery
rate fixed at 35, a spread of 297bps, 5yr maturity
Investor will be long protection on a standard CDS, spread of 297bps, same maturity
date
Profiting in Default:
If ABY defaults and bonds are trading at 20 (i.e. actual recovery is 20) investor
OP TI ON S
On short protection position (DDS) investor loses 65 (100 – fixed recovery rate of 35)
DE R I VAT I VE
On the long protection position (regular CDS) investor earns 80 (100 less cost to buy
bond in market at 20)
CR E D IT
VAIDYA NATHAN 83
Calculate MTM on DDS
Calculate the MTM after one year assuming DDS is now trading at 20 instead of 35
Original positions:
Unwind Positions:
Survival
DE R I VAT I VE
Year Probability
2 0.95
3 0.90
CR E D IT
4 0.85
5 0.80 VAIDYA NATHAN 84
Cancelable Credit Swaps
Y bp per annum
Contingent Payment
(Par — Recovery)
Right to cancel
OP TI ON S
Seller receives a fee in return for making a Contingent Payment if there is a Credit Event of the
Reference Credit
exposure to Seller
Buyer has the right to cancel the trade (European or American option)
CR E D IT
VAIDYA NATHAN 85
Yield Pickup on structured CDS
VAIDYA NATHAN 86
Outline
Page
Basket Products 26
Synthetic CDO 49
CDS Valuation 87
D E R I V A T I V E S
VAIDYA NATHAN 87
Credit Spreads
Credit
Spreads
Credit Spreads
=
Default Probability
x (1-Recovery Rate)
Default Recovery
Probability Rate
VAL U A T I O N
C D S
VAIDYA NATHAN 88
Credit Default Swaps transfer default risk
X bp per annum
Protection Protection
Buyer Seller
Contingent Payment
(Par — Recovery)
Via a Credit Default Swap, the Protection Buyer transfers risk that the
Reference Entity will default
VAIDYA NATHAN 89
Caselet - EuroAutos
VAIDYA NATHAN 90
Measure of default probability is required to price risky cash flow
Historical Analysis
Proprietary
i) Company/Sector expertise
Assumptions
Fundamental Analysis
VAIDYA NATHAN 91
3
Specifications of credit markets are similar to interest rate markets
Yield
Market Details
Curve
Spd to
Currency USD 2
Mid
Trade Date 16-May-06 Swap Maturity Actual Mid Spreads Swap Zero
Days to Spot 2 # Maturity Dates Times yield Bid Mid Ask rates rates
Value Date 18-May-06 1 1D 19-May-06 0.003 3.500% 2.00 0.00 2.00 3.50% 3.56%
Swap Basis 360 4 3M 18-Aug-06 0.252 3.870% 2.00 0.00 2.00 3.87% 3.93%
Swap Days B 5 4M 18-Sep-06 0.337 3.909% 2.00 0.00 2.00 3.91% 3.96%
MMkt DCC Act/365 6 5M 18-Oct-06 0.419 3.948% 2.00 0.00 2.00 3.95% 3.99%
Swap DCC Act/365 7 6M 20-Nov-06 0.510 3.987% 2.00 0.00 2.00 3.99% 4.03%
Swap cpns PA 2 8 9M 20-Feb-07 0.762 4.065% 2.00 0.00 2.00 4.07% 4.08%
Swap BDC M 9 1Y 18-May-07 1.000 4.130% 2.00 0.00 2.00 4.13% 4.13%
MMkt Basis 360 10 18M 19-Nov-07 1.507 4.177% 2.00 0.00 2.00 4.18% 4.22%
MMkt freq. 4 11 2Y 19-May-08 2.005 4.207% 2.00 0.00 2.00 4.21% 4.25%
VAL U A T I O N
Mean Reversion 0.00 12 3Y 18-May-09 3.003 4.254% 2.00 0.00 2.00 4.25% 4.30%
Interpolation type 1 13 4Y 18-May-10 4.003 4.284% 2.00 0.00 2.00 4.28% 4.33%
Libor Holidays GBP 14 5y 18-May-11 5.003 4.319% 2.00 0.00 2.00 4.32% 4.37%
C D S
VAIDYA NATHAN 92
3
Same as money market conventions
Market
Conventions
VAIDYA NATHAN 93
3
Additional aspects
Reference Details Credit
Reference
Currency USD Parameters
Trade Date 16-May-06 Fee Pay Payment Payment Mean Spread Recovery
Days to Spot 3 Interval Accrued Index Day Count Bad Day Reversion Interpolation Rate
Settlement Date 19-May-06 Convention Convention (%)
Q FALSE Q Act/365 M 0.00 1 50.00%
Credit Spreads
Tenors 1D 1M 3M 6M 1Y 2Y 3Y
Dates 22-May-06 19-Jun-06 21-Aug-06 20-Nov-06 21-May-07 19-May-08 19-May-09
Bid-Offer
3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0 3.0
Spread
Bid Spread 98.50 98.50 118.50 138.50 148.50
Credit
Reference
VAL U A T I O N
Volatility
Structure
Tenors 1D 1M 3M 6M 1Y 2Y 3Y
Dates 20-May-06 19-Jun-06 19-Aug-06 19-Nov-06 19-May-07 19-May-08 19-May-09
ATM Volatilities 15.00% 15.00% 15.00% 15.00%
C D S
VAIDYA NATHAN 94
3
Trade Specifications
Trade Summary CDS References
Option (Long / Short) Long CDS Fee payment tlll maturity FALSE
Buyer of protection pays quarterly premium to seller until the earlier of a credit event or maturity
X X X X X
100 - R
VAL U A T I O N
The seller of protection pays par less recovery to the protection buyer if there is a credit event
during the life of the contract
C D S
VAIDYA NATHAN 96
CDS Cashflow due from Buyer and Seller of Protection
N
Risky PVFIXED = ∑ S .DFi .SPi .α i
i =1
i =1
C D S
VAIDYA NATHAN 97
Valuation of any risky cash flow is based on concept of risky PV
VAIDYA NATHAN 98
2
Deriving default probability from CDS spreads
A
A 1-year
1-year default
default swap
swap with
with annual
annual coupon
coupon
(1 − P( ND
0 ,1 ) )
-(1-R)
Period 1
1 ⎡P ND x S - (1 − P ND ) x (1 - R)⎤
0=
(1 + r ) ⎢⎣ ⎥⎦
risk free
VAL U A T I O N
C D S
VAIDYA NATHAN 99
4
By bootstrapping, a term structure of default prob can be estimated
Default
Default probability
probability tree
tree construction
construction
P( 1ND
,2 )
S
S
ND
P ( 0 ,1)
0 (1 − P( 1ND
,2 ) )
(100-R)
(1 − P( ND
0 ,1 ) ) (100-R)
Period 1 Period 2
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 100
5
Useful Rule of Thumb
Spread Expected
loss
S = P D (1 − R)
Rearranging gives a simple expression for default probability in terms of
CDS spread and recovery rate
S
P =D
(1 − R)
VAL U A T I O N
1
1−
p(t,T ) =
(1 + s(t : t,T )n )
1− θ
C D S
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 101
6
Calculation of default prob is complicated by a number of factors
Recovery assumptions
Recovery amount cannot be known in advance; therefore an assumption
must be made
Assumptions about what will be recovered can vary:
— Recover a flat cash amount
— Recover a percentage of risk free PV
— Recover a percentage of outstanding notional plus accrued interest
Interpolation
Credit default swaps typically pay fee quarterly
Fee accrual
In a standard CDS, only the accrued spread is usually paid at time of
default
VAL U A T I O N
C D S
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 102
7
Effect of recovery assumption on implied survival probability
Higher Default
Probability
High Recovery
Lower Survival
Assumption
Probability
Higher Survival
Low Recovery Probability
Assumption
Lower Default
Probability
VAL U A T I O N
C D S
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 103
Survival probability with time for different recovery rates
Survival
Survival probability
probability with
with time
time for
for different
different recovery
recovery rates
rates (CDS
(CDS Spread
Spread =
= 100
100 bps)
bps)
100.00%
Survival Probabilities with Time
90.00%
80.00%
70.00%
60.00%
50.00%
R= 90% R= 50% R= 10%
40.00%
30.00%
20.00%
10.00%
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
VAL U A T I O N
For low recovery rate assumptions, survival probability decreases approximately linearly
over time. For high recovery rate assumptions, this relationship is more ‘convex’
C D S
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 104
Decline in survival probability with higher recovery rates
Survival
Survival probability
probability with
with time
time for
for different
different recovery
recovery rates
rates (CDS
(CDS Spread
Spread =
= 100
100 bps)
bps)
Maturity R= 90% R= 50% R= 10%
0 99.99% 100.00% 100.00%
1 91.12% 98.09% 98.93%
2 83.02% 96.21% 97.87%
3 75.64% 94.37% 96.82%
4.0027 68.92% 92.56% 95.78%
5.0027 62.80% 90.79% 94.75%
6.0027 57.21% 89.05% 93.74%
7.0027 52.13% 87.35% 92.73%
8.0055 47.50% 85.67% 91.73%
9.0055 43.28% 84.04% 90.75%
10.0055 39.43% 82.43% 89.78%
11.0055 35.93% 80.85% 88.82%
12.0082 32.73% 79.30% 87.86%
13.0082 29.82% 77.78% 86.92%
14.0082 27.17% 76.29% 85.99%
15.0082 24.76% 74.83% 85.07%
16.011 22.55% 73.40% 84.15%
17.011 20.55% 72.00% 83.25%
18.011 18.73% 70.62% 82.36%
19.011 17.06% 69.27% 81.48%
20.0137 15.55% 67.94% 80.60%
VAL U A T I O N
C D S
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 105
Caselet: a typical problem of front & middle office folks
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 106
Survival Probabilities As Weighting Factors
K
MTM = ∑ (Current CDS − ContractCDS).DFi .SPi
i =1
Contract CDS is the CDS spread at which the trade was entered
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 107
Conceptualising CDS Mark-to-Market
ORIGINAL
X X X X X X X
NO CREDIT EVENT
3m 6m 9m 12m 15m 18m ... 60m
X-Y X-Y X-Y
=
15m 18m ... 60m
OFFSET
3m 6m 9m 12m 15m 18m ... 60m
VAL U A T I O N
Y Y Y
C D S
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 108
But the Cash Flows are risky …
ORIGINAL
X X X X X
Nominal Value
CREDIT EVENT
3m 6m 9m 12m 15m 18m ... 60m
Defaulted Obligation X-Y X-Y X-Y
Credit Event
=
15m 18m ... 60m
Nominal Value
Y
C D S
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 109
Forward default probability for different recovery rates
Forward
Forward default
default probability
probability with
with time
time for
for different
different recovery
recovery rates
rates (CDS
(CDS Spread
Spread =
= 100
100 bps)
bps)
10.00%
9.00%
8.00%
7.00%
6.00%
5.00%
R= 90% R= 50% R= 10%
4.00%
3.00%
2.00%
1.00%
For low recovery rate assumptions, forward default probability decreases approximately
linearly over time. For high recovery rate assumptions, it decreases exponentially
C D S
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 110
Increased forward default probability with higher R
Forward
Forward default
default probability
probability with
with time
time for
for different
different recovery
recovery rates
rates (CDS
(CDS Spread
Spread =
= 100
100 bps)
bps)
Maturity R= 90% R= 50% R= 10%
1 8.87% 1.91% 1.07%
2 8.10% 1.88% 1.06%
3 7.38% 1.84% 1.05%
4.0027 6.72% 1.81% 1.04%
5.0027 6.12% 1.77% 1.03%
6.0027 5.58% 1.74% 1.02%
7.0027 5.08% 1.70% 1.01%
8.0055 4.63% 1.67% 0.99%
9.0055 4.22% 1.64% 0.98%
10.0055 3.85% 1.61% 0.97%
11.0055 3.50% 1.58% 0.96%
12.0082 3.20% 1.55% 0.95%
13.0082 2.91% 1.52% 0.94%
14.0082 2.65% 1.49% 0.93%
15.0082 2.41% 1.46% 0.92%
16.011 2.20% 1.43% 0.91%
17.011 2.00% 1.40% 0.90%
18.011 1.82% 1.38% 0.89%
VAL U A T I O N
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 111
Issuer-Weighted Recovery Rate Descriptive Statistics
Mean (1982 -
Priority in Capital Structure 2003) Mean (2004)
Senior Secured 57.4% 80.8%
Senior Unsecured 44.9% 50.1%
Senior Subordinated 39.1% 44.4%
Subordinated 32.0% NA
Junior Subordinated 28.9% NA
All Bonds 42.2% 54.3%
VAL U A T I O N
C D S
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 112
Effect of recovery assumption on risky duration
Higher Default
Probability
High Recovery Lower Survival
Assumption Probability
Lower “Risky
Duration”
Higher “Risky
Duration”
Higher Survival
Low Recovery Probability
Assumption
VAL U A T I O N
Lower Default
Probability
C D S
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 113
Risky Duration for different credit spreads
Risky
Risky Duration
Duration for
for constant
constant term
term structure
structure of
of credit
credit spreads
spreads
8
Risky duration for different credit spreads
Spread 50 bps flat Spread 100 bps flat Spread 200 bps flat
2
VAL U A T I O N
Maturity
1D 1M 2M 3M 4M 5M 6M 9M 1Y 18M 2Y 3Y 4Y 5Y 6Y 7Y 8Y 9Y 10Y
C D S
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 114
Nonlinearity of risky duration
Nonlinearity
Nonlinearity of
of risky
risky duration
duration for
for half
half and
and double
double credit
credit spreads
spreads
Spread 50 Spread 100 Spread 200
Maturity Mat times bps flat Duration bps flat Duration bps flat Duration
1D 0.003 50.0 0.0027 100.0 0.0027 200.0 0.0027
1M 0.077 50.0 0.0764 100.0 0.0764 200.0 0.0763
2M 0.170 50.0 0.1684 100.0 0.1681 200.0 0.1675
3M 0.244 50.0 0.2410 100.0 0.2404 200.0 0.2392
4M 0.329 50.0 0.3245 100.0 0.3237 200.0 0.3220
5M 0.416 50.0 0.4100 100.0 0.4087 200.0 0.4061
6M 0.496 50.0 0.4869 100.0 0.4851 200.0 0.4816
9M 0.748 50.0 0.7297 100.0 0.7261 200.0 0.7190
1Y 1.000 50.0 0.9693 100.0 0.9634 200.0 0.9517
18M 1.496 50.0 1.4316 100.0 1.4194 200.0 1.3955
2Y 2.000 50.0 1.8893 100.0 1.8687 200.0 1.8285
3Y 3.008 50.0 2.7721 100.0 2.7330 200.0 2.6604
4Y 4.005 50.0 3.5954 100.0 3.5253 200.0 3.3929
5Y 5.003 50.0 4.3756 100.0 4.2687 200.0 4.0663
6Y 6.003 50.0 5.1179 100.0 4.9708 200.0 4.6947
7Y 7.005 50.0 5.8222 100.0 5.6303 200.0 5.2733
8Y 8.014 50.0 6.4956 100.0 6.2596 200.0 5.8261
VAL U A T I O N
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 115
Outline
Page
Basket Products 26
Synthetic CDO 49
CDS Valuation 87
D E R I V A T I V E S
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 116
Framework
Every credit default swap is documented in a contract based on the ISDA format -
called the Confirmation
The terms used in the Confirmation are defined in the 2003 Credit Derivatives
Definitions (formerly 1999 Definitions)
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 117
Key Contract Terms
Obligations - Borrowed Money, Bonds or Loans are types of obligations that the
protection covers
such agreement is not provided for under the terms of that Obligation) with respect to
reduction of interest or principal, postponement of payment of interest or principal, change
of currency (other than “Permitted Currency”) and subordination
DE R I VAT I VE S
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 118
Key Contract Terms - Deliverable Obligations
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 119
2003 Definitions - Why Introduce and Key Changes
Why Introduce
To consolidate market experience - the 2003 Definitions represent a development
of the 1999 Definitions.
Too many supplements (now incorporated)
Modified Restructuring was not adopted in Europe
Time to overhaul and clean up definitions
Key Changes
Modified Modified Restructuring for Europe
R O ADMAP
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 120
CDS Structural Roadmap
REFERENCE ENTITY Underlying credit risk transferred?
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 121
Caselet: Armstrong World Industries
US
US company
company Armstrong
Armstrong World
World Industries
Industries missed
missed payments
payments on
on its
its debt
debt
Many market participants had treated the parent and principal subsidiary
interchangeably and had hedged positions with offsetting contracts in the
other entity
The lesson here is that there may be substantial credit basis risk between
different entities in the same group
R O ADMAP
referred
CR E D IT
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 122
Caselet: National Power
National
National Power
Power PLC
PLC demerged
demerged certain
certain assets
assets and
and subsidiaries
subsidiaries into
into two
two entities
entities
become a Successor
DE R I VAT I VE S
CR E D IT
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 123
Non Sovereign Decision Tree
Non-Sovereign
Non-Sovereign Successor
Successor Summary
Summary Decision
Decision Tree
Tree
Does New Entity have >75% of It is the Sole Successor for the for the Entire
Obligations? Credit Derivative Transaction
YES
NO
YES YES
Does New Entity have <25% of Does Reference No Change to
R O ADMAP
NO
DE R I VAT I VE S
NO
New Entity Taking
Each Successor Assigned New Largest % of
Credit Derivative Transaction – Relevant Obligations
Includes Reference Entity >25% is Successor
CR E D IT
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 124
Caselet: Xerox Corporation
Xerox
Xerox extended
extended the
the date
date for
for repayment
repayment of
of principal
principal
This was in respect of a major syndicated bank facility that was due for
repayment in September
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 125
Caselet: Argentina
Obligation
Obligation Exchange
Exchange requirements
requirements
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 126
Caselet: Railtrack
Bankruptcy
Bankruptcy Credit
Credit Event
Event
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 127
Caselet: Railtrack CTD Obligation
“Widows
“Widows and
and orphans”
orphans” clause
clause
Most of the market took the view that, provided the bond is
exchangeable or convertible at the option of the holder, the bondholder
should be the beneficiary and the exchange or conversion option within
its control
the trustee the right to force conversion of the bond on the holder in
certain circumstances where it was viewed as being in the interests of
the investor
DE R I VAT I VE S
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 128
Caselet: Marconi
Somewhat
Somewhat unusual
unusual guarantee
guarantee structure
structure
bonds, so as to avoid the risk that the guarantee structure would render
the bonds undeliverable (under 1999 Definitions)
The main exception to this, was where the bond in question was stated as
DE R I VAT I VE S
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 129
Caselet: Xerox Syndicated Bank Loan extension
Pressure
Pressure on
on Mod-R
Mod-R
In this case the maturity limitation requirements of Mod-R did not really
insulate Sellers of protection from the “cheapest-to-deliver” risk
This was because, although not long dated, Xerox’s yen bonds were
trading about 15-20 points lower than where the dollar bank loans were
quoted
R O ADMAP
DE R I VAT I VE S
CR E D IT
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 130
Modified Modified Restructuring
New features:
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 131
Modified Modified Restructuring
You can deliver (1) restructured bonds maturing before mid 2011 and
(2) non restructured bonds maturing before 2010
30 month 60 month
Maturity Maturity Maturity
Cap Floor Cap
R O ADMAP
DE R I VAT I VE S
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 132
Modified Modified Restructuring - US and Europe
Obligations covered: At least three holders and At least three holders and in the
DE R I VAT I VE S
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 133
New Settlement Fallbacks
To avoid failed contracts, parties now have an indefinite period of time to settle
the contract
Buyer must attempt scheduled settlement but if this fails, fallbacks will apply
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 134
New Settlement Fallbacks - Bond Delivery
Buyer has 30 Business Days + 5 Business Day fallback to effect delivery of the Bonds
If Delivery has not occurred by this date, Seller may buy the Bond in at the lowest
offer. Seller has 4 Business Days to complete the process
If Seller fails to complete the process, Buyer may continue to attempt delivery.
Buyer can not deliver whilst the buy-in process is in operation
Seller may try to buy the Bond in again, but must wait at least 8 Business Days
before restarting the process
R O ADMAP
DE R I VAT I VE S
CR E D IT
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 135
New Settlement Fallbacks - Bond Delivery
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 136
New Settlement Fallbacks - Loan Delivery
Buyer has 30 Business Days + 5 Business Day fallback to effect delivery of the Loan
If Delivery has not occurred by this date, Buyer may deliver a Transferable Bond
or an Assignable Loan instead provided that Buyer provides certification from a
Managing Director that reasonable efforts were used to get consent
If Buyer has not delivered anything for a further 15 Business Days, Seller may
nominate an Assignable Loan or a Transferable Bond and require Buyer to purchase
and deliver
R O ADMAP
DE R I VAT I VE S
CR E D IT
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 137
New Settlement Fallbacks - Loan Delivery
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 138
New Guarantee Provisions
Users can now select what type of guarantees can trigger the contract and what is
deliverable
where it owns more than 50 percent of the voting shares of that affiliate
DE R I VAT I VE S
CR E D IT
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 139
New Guarantee Provisions
Europe and Asia –
covers all these
Qualifying Guarantees
Parent
Company
50%
50% Guarantee
Operating Reference
Company Guarantee Entity Guarantee
Guarantee
Affiliate Guarantee – 50%
downstream with a
holding of at least 50% Subsidiary
DE R I VAT I VE S
CR E D IT
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 140
Other Key Changes
Public Sources broadened to include Australian Financial Review et al plus the main
R O ADMAP
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 141
Other Key Changes
Modified Following replaced with Following as standard convention for all trades
Valuation provisions restructured so that all Firm Bids are used regardless of
Quotation Size, with zero only deemed for the no bid portion
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 142
Outline
Page
Basket Products 26
Synthetic CDO 49
CDS Valuation 87
D E R I V A T I V E S
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 143
Applications for credit derivatives in the global market
Motivations
Motivations for
for using
using Credit
Credit Derivatives
Derivatives
2. Product structuring
3. Hedging trading
instruments
5. Management of
individual credit lines
DE R I VAT I VE S
6. Management of
regulatory capital
7. Management of
economic capital
CR E D IT
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 144
Rankings for application of Credit Derivatives
Trading/market making 1 1
Product structuring 2 2
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 145
Credit Derivatives positions
Credit
Credit Derivatives
Derivatives positions
positions
1997 180
1998 350
1999 586
2000 893
2001 1189
2002
U PDAT E
1952
2003 3548
DE R I VAT I VE S
2004 5021
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 146
Comparative Interest rate derivatives growth
Interest
Interest Rate
Rate Growth
Growth (USD
(USD billion)
billion)
141,991
121,799
101,658
89,955
77,568
67,465
64,125 64,668
60,091
54,072
50,015
42,368
U PDAT E
DE R I VAT I VE S
Jun-98 Dec-98 Jun-99 Dec-99 Jun-00 Dec-00 Jun-01 Dec-01 Jun-02 Dec-02 Jun-03 Dec-03
CR E D IT
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 147
Breakdown of market participation
Market
Market Composition
Composition
24%
42%
34%
U PDAT E
DE R I VAT I VE S
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 148
Institutions using credit derivatives to buy protection
Buyers
Buyers of
of credit
credit protection
protection
3% 3% 1%
2006 (Expected) Other 2003
7% Banks
Pension fundsAgencies 3% Securities houses
2%
Mutual funds 5%
Hedge funds
5%
Corporates
Insurance 16%
51% Insurance Companies
Companies
9% Mutual funds
Pension funds
Banks
Corporates 43% Other Agencies
4% 16%
1% 1% 1%
1999 7%
U PDAT E
6% Banks
Securities houses
3%
Hedge funds Hedge funds
DE R I VAT I VE S
17% Corporates
Insurance Companies
15%
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 149
Sellers of credit protection
Institutions
Institutions using
using credit
credit derivatives
derivatives to
to sell
sell protection
protection
4% 1%
4%
2006 (Expected) 2003
Other Banks
Banks
Securities houses
Hedge funds
DE R I VAT I VE S
Other Agencies
16%
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 150
Credit Derivatives by region
Credit
Credit Derivatives
Derivatives by
by region
region in
in 2006
2006 (Expected)
(Expected)
3%
39% 43%
U PDAT E
10% 5%
DE R I VAT I VE S
CR E D IT
2003 1999
45%
44%
41%
40%
U PDAT E
DE R I VAT I VE S
9% 8%
6% 5%
1% 1%
CR E D IT
London Europe ex- Asia/Australia US Other London Europe ex- Asia/Australia US Other
London London
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 152
Credit Derivatives booked by region
Credit
Credit Derivatives
Derivatives booked
booked by
by region
region
14%
6%
14%
66%
U PDAT E
DE R I VAT I VE S
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 153
Credit Derivatives Market Size by region
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 154
Global Credit Derivatives Product Usage
Global
Global Credit
Credit Derivatives
Derivatives Product
Product Usage
Usage
2% 1% 1%
4%
4% 51%
Single-name credit default swaps
4%
Synthetic CDOs – full capital
Synthetic CDOs – partial capital
6%
Full index trades
Tranched index trades
2%
Credit linked notes
Total return swaps
U PDAT E
9% Basket products
Asset swaps
DE R I VAT I VE S
6%
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 155
Current Product Usage
Global
Global Credit
Credit Derivatives
Derivatives Product
Product Usage
Usage –– 2006
2006 (Expected)
(Expected)
3%
3% 1%
3%
42%
5%
Single-name credit default swaps
4% Synthetic CDOs – full capital
Synthetic CDOs – partial capital
Full index trades
6%
Tranched index trades
Credit linked notes
Total return swaps
5%
U PDAT E
Basket products
Asset swaps
DE R I VAT I VE S
5%
11%
CR E D IT
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 156
Underlying reference entity
Category
Category of
of underlying
underlying reference
reference entity
entity
64% 1999
3%
U PDAT E
6% Corporate assets
9%
Financials
DE R I VAT I VE S
Sovereign assets
Corporate assets 60% (emerging markets)
22%
Financials Sovereign assets (non-
Sovereign assets (emerging markets) emerging markets)
CR E D IT
Other
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 157
Credit rating of underlying reference entity
Credit
Credit rating
rating of
of the
the underlying
underlying reference
reference entity
entity
19%
65%
3%
Below B A – BBB
16%
13%
4% 63%
Below B A – BBB
1999 BB – B
17% AAA – AA
U PDAT E
DE R I VAT I VE S
17%
66%
0%
BB – B Below B A – BBB
17%
CR E D IT
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 158
BB – B
Tenor distribution
Maturity
Maturity
1999 5% 9%
U PDAT E
9%
Under 1 year
5 years 1 – 5 years
1 – 5 years
DE R I VAT I VE S
18% 52%
5 years
41% 5 – 10 years
36%
Over 10 years
CR E D IT
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 159
Market Constraints
Constraints
Constraints in
in using
using Credit
Credit Derivatives
Derivatives
1. Lack of client
knowledge of the product
2. Regulatory constraints
3. Systems / Infrastructure
5. Lack of agreed
accounting conventions
DE R I VAT I VE S
6. Lack of homogenous
documentation
V A I D Y A N A T H A N 160