Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Mine Pumps
ROBERTW. LAWSON
INTRODUCTION
Prior to 1705, underground mining was limited to
mineral deposits located above or a very small distance
below the water table. The development of the steam-
driven mining pump was motivated by the need to ex-
tract minerals from deposits considerably lower than
the water table. Today, the majority of mine pumps are
driven by electric motors, although some small utility
pumps are driven by compressed air.
Of the numerous types of pumps that might be
applied to mine service, the two types used most fre-
quently underground are the centrifugal and plunger
pumps. Each of these types has its proper application.
In most instances, plunger pumps are best for handling
low water volumes against high heads, while centrifugal
pumps effectively handle either low or high water vol-
umes against low heads or high water volumes against
high heads.
This chapter describes pumps applied to under-
- - -
ground mine service, where the mine service consists of Fig. 1. Cutaway view of a single-stage horizontal split-
mine drainage (removing mine water as it accumulates), case double-section centrifugal pump (courtesy of Inger-
mine dewatering (removing water from a flooded mine), soll-Rand Co.).
and pumping for special applications such as hydraulic
mining and hydraulic hoisting.
section centrifugal pump. Fig. 2 shows a cutaway view
CENTRIFUGAL AND PLUNGER PUMPS of a six-stage medium-pressure split-case diffuser-type
Modern mine pumps are classified as either centrif- centrifugal pump.
ugal (kinetic) or plunger (positive-displacement) Type of Casing: A volute pump has a casing in the
pumps. The following paragraphs describe each of these form of a spiral or volute. A circular-casing pump
classifications. has a casing of constant cross section concentric with
the impeller. A diffuser pump is equipped with a diffuser
Centrifugal Pumps that converts velocity head to pressure head.
Centrifugal pumps may be grouped into various Shaft Position: A horizontal pump normally has
types, depending upon their various features: the shaft in a horizontal position, while a vertical pump
Number of Stages: In a single-stage pump, the total normally has the shaft in a vertical position. Fig. 3 illus-
head is developed by one impeller, while a multi- trates a vertical turbine-type slurry pump.
stage pump utilizes two or more impellers acting in one Suction: A single-suction pump equips the first stage
casing to develop the total head. Fig. 1 shows a cuta- with a single-suction impeller, with fluid entering the
way view of a single-stage horizontal split-case double- impeller on only one side. A double-suction pump equips
Fig. 2. Cutaway view of a medium-pressure split-case six-stage diffusor-type centrifugal pump (courtesy of Ingersoll-
Rand Co.).
1336
ANCILLARY EQUIPMENT
gravity of the mine water, H is the total dynamic head ward rate of water flow should be less than the measured
in feet, E, is the efficiency of the pump, and E , is the settling rate. In a horizontal sump, submerged weirs
efficiency of the motor. improve the effectiveness of solids removal, but such
Suction Sump: The suction sump serves two im- weirs should be designed so they do not hamper clean-
portant functions. First, the suction sump provides stor- ing the residue from the bottom of the sump.
age capacity in the event of a power outage or a The cost of providing adequate sump capacity is
mechanical failure of the pumping equipment. Many recovered many times over through reduced pump main-
mines have established definite minimum storage limits. tenance. The importance of removing abrasive solids
For example, Butte copper mines require that no pump from the mine water increases as the head against which
installation have less than 4 hr storage of water inflow the pump operates increases.
in the sump. In other mines, 45 to 90 min of storage Mine-Pump Motors: Modern mine-pump motors
is considered adequate, with local conditions dictating are predominantly a-c induction motors. The type of
the storage capacity. Furthermore, the capacity of the motor enclosure is dictated by the conditions prevailing
storage sump should be adequate to accommodate any at the pump location. High-voltage current for major
sudden inrush of water. pump installations is transmitted by cables down the
The second function of the suction sump is to pro- shaft or through boreholes and is transformed adjacent
vide adequate residence time for the suspended solids to to the pump station to meet the requirements of the
settle, and the sump must be designed to allow removal pump motor. The pump-motor voltage is selected ac-
of the residue. Many arrangements are in use, and Fig. cording to economic considerations, including the cost
8 illustrates one possible arrangement. of the transforming equipment, the motor-control equip-
The horizontal sump is the most prevalent, and it ment, and the motors.
requires minimum shaft depth. It accommodates a Small utility pumps of approximately 7.6 L / s (120
horizontally split pump located in a dry well with gpm) and 45.7 m (150 ft) total head may operate on
flooded suction. The vertical sump, commonly used in 689 kPa (100 psi) of compressed air, consuming ap-
South Africa, permits the residue to be drained by proximately 0.019 m3/s per kW (30 cfm per hp).
gravity from the bottom of the sump directly into a Ventilation: Ventilation is an important considera-
mud skip used to hoist the residue to the surface. How- tion for any underground pump installation. Some mine
ever, a vertical sump. requires a greater shaft depth waters release noxious gases that must be diluted and
than does a horizontal sump. It is well suited to the exhausted from the mine by means of adequate ventila-
use of a vertical mine pump. tion. More frequently, ventilation must be provided to
To determine the proper residency time in the sump, remove the heat emitted by the pump motors and trans-
a number of mine-water samples should be placed in a formers. The total electrical energy supplied to the
laboratory graduate where the settling can be observed pump motors less the energy required to lift the water
and timed. As a general approximation, a sump should against the head is converted to heat; this may be cal-
have approximately 0.09 m2 (1.0 sq ft) of surface area culated from the equation:
for each 3.79 L (1.0 gal) pumped. This calculates to a
E = (56.92 X P ) -(0.011 X F X L,)
settling rate of 0.68 mm/s (1.6 ipm). In designing
either a vertical or a horizontal sump, an effort normally where E is the heat in British thermal units per minute,
is made to direct the incoming water toward the bottom P is the power in kilowatts, F is the water flow rate in
of the sump, taking the effluent from the top. The up- gallons .per minute, and L, is the static lift in feet.
UNDERGROUND MINING METHODS HANDBOOK
Fig. 8. Diagram of a horizontal sump showing details of the settler section (courtesy of H.L. Monroe).
The heat must be dissipated by either ventilation air used for pipelines; and (7) any previous experience with
or transferring the heat to the mine water pumped to materials of construction.
the surface. One method of transferring the motor heat T o accurately assess the performance of various
to the mine water is to enclose the pump motor so that materials, the pump manufacturer may request a sample
the air circulated over the rotor and stator is in a closed of the mine water. When the mine water is corrosive
system. This air then passes over a water-cooled heat and circumstances permit, the most accurate method of
exchanger before being recirculated through the motor, evaluating alloys is to place weighed "tabs" of likely
and the warmed water from the heat exchanger is alloys in a moving stream of mine water. At intervals,
dumped into the pump suction and transported to the the weight loss is determined for each sample alloy.
surface. When the mine water presents a serious operating
Materials of Construction: The materials of con- problem, the most practical solution may be to treat the
struction are critical to the success of a pumping in- water in the sump before it is pumped. Such treatment
stallation. The "wetted parts" in contact with the could involve neutralizing the liquid with lime or some
pumped liquid must be constructed of materials that other additive or increasing the acidity with sulfuric acid
resist corrosion and abrasion. For mine water with a to discourage the deposition of ocher in the pump
neutral pH, a regular fitted pump with a cast-iron casing columns. The economics of such treatment procedures
and a bronze impeller, wearing rings, and shaft sleeve must be analyzed for each individual installation.
is satisfactory. For slightly acid mine water, an all-bronze It has been observed that pump maintenance caused
pump, sometimes called "admiralty metal," is the best by abrasive particles in the mine water has increased
construction. As the corrosive nature of the pumped markedly when a mine has been converted from rail
water increases, it may become necessary to use chrome- haulage to rubber-tire haulage. This is attributed to the
nickel alloy. The pump manufacturer should be con- rubber-tired vehicles constantly agitating the drainage
sulted for recommendations; the information that should water in the haulageways. If rubber-tired haulage is
be supplied to the pump manufacturer for proper selec- used, extra capacity for settling the solids should be
tion of the pump materials includes: (1 ) the liquid to be provided in the sumps and a higher pump-maintenance
pumped; (2) the principal corrosives; (3) the pH and cost anticipated.
specific gravity of the mine water; (4) the undissolved Bid Form: The use of a bid form is suggested when
impurities and other constituents, including the specific requesting quotations from various pump manufacturers.
gravity of the solids, the percentage of solids in the liquid Table 1 lists the items that should be included on such
by weight, and the particle size and distribution; (5) de- a form. The portion of the form listing the design con-
tails of the expected pump service; (6) the materials ditions should be completed by the mine engineer and
ANCILLARY EQUIPMENT
Project: Date:
Purchaser: Ref. No.:
Address:
Dealgn Condltlona
Quantity
Service
Liquid
Temperature, "C ("F)
Capacity, Us (gpm)
Max Discharge Pressure, kPa (psi)
Max Suction Pressure, kPa (psi)
Differential Pressure, kPa (psi)
Specific Gravity
Total Head, m (ft)
Viscosity or Slurry Density
pH Value
Performance
Pump Selection
Speed, radls (rpm)
Efficiency at Design
Power, DesignIMax, kW (bhp)
NPSH, AvailableIRequired, m (ft)
Performance Curve
Construction
Packing or Seal
Gland Type
Piping Seal
Flange Rating, SuctionIDischarge
BearingdLubrication
Trico Oilers
Coupling
Coupling Guard
Bedplate
Gage TapdVentslDrains -1 -1 - -1-1- -1-1-
Rotation (Viewed from Coupling End) - CW CCW CW CCW CW -CCW
Materlala
Casing
Impeller
Shaft
Shaft Sleeve
Wearing Rings, ImpellerICasing
Drlver
TypeIFramelManufacturer -1-1-
Power, kW Iradls (hplrpm) I I I
Rotation (Viewed from Opposite Coupling) -CW -CCW CW -CCW -CW CCW
Furnished ByIManufactured By --I
Conditions
Prlclng
Shipping Weight, PumpIDriver, kg (Ib)
Pump Shipment, weeks
Net Pump Price, Each
the balance of the form should be completed by the may be superimposed as shown in Fig. 10. The system
vendor. The use of such a form facilitates comparing curve consists of the static head plus the friction head.
bids received from various manufacturers, and it assists The point at which the system curve crosses the head-
the purchaser in making sure that the comparison is capacity curve is the operating point for the installation.
between equipment of comparable construction and per- As an example, assume that a two-stage single-
formance. Overall, the use of such a form helps elimi- suction pump is driven by a 56-kW (75-hp) electric
nate misunderstandings. motor at 372 rad/s (3550 rpm). The pump is fitted
Pump Pefiormance Curves: Pump performance with a 241-mm (9.5-in.) diam first-stage impeller and
curves are the most convenient method of indicating the a 216-mm (8.5-in.) second-stage impeller. The static
operating characteristics of a centrifugal pump. Fig. 9 head on the pump is 168 m (550 ft), and pumping is
illustrates the pump performance curve for a typical into a 102-mm (4.0-in.) standard-weight steel pipe. The
two-stage single-suction centrifugal pump. pipe length is a total of 274 m (900 ft), including
If the system curve of the mine-pump installation is equivalent lengths for fittings. Fig. 10 shows that the
plotted with the same ordinate and abscissa scales as operating point is at 15.8 L/s (250 gpm), with 183 m
used for the pump performance curve, the two curves (600 ft) of head [I68 m (550 f t ) of static head plus 15
1342 UNDERGROUND MINING METHODS HANDBOOK
24 24
1000 20 1000 20
+
W +
W IJ.
C
Fig. 9. Pump-performance curve for a typical two-stage Fig. 10. Pump-performance curve with a super-imposed
single-suction centrifugal pump. Metric equivalents: ft X system curve. Metric equivalents: ft X 0.3048= m;
0.3048= m; in. X 25.4= mm; gpm X 0.063 090 2 = in. X 25.4= mm; gpm x 0.063 090 2 = L/s; bhp x
L/s; bhp X 0.745699 9 = kW. 0.745699 9 = kW.
m (50 ft) of friction head]. The pump efficiency is 63% unstable. Too large an impeller in a casing interferes
and the power is 45.5 kW (61 bhp). The pump requires with the flow at the cutwater and reduces the overall
a minimum of 4.0 m (13 ft) net positive suction head efficiency of the pump.
(NPSH) . Net Positive Suction Head (NPSH): The NPSH is
For mine drainage or dewatering, a pump should the absolute pressure in meters (feet) above the vapor
have a head vs. capacity curve that rises constantly to pressure of the liquid being pumped. The NPSH is
shutoff. If this curve has a "hump," the pump may surge measured at the pump suction flange on a gage mounted
under certain operating conditions. Since the total dy- at the centerline of the pump. The available NPSH is
namic head of a mine-drainage system is fairly constant, the sum of the suction gage reading and the atmospheric
a reasonably flat curve is desirable. As water accumu- pressure minus the vapor pressure. In equation form,
lates in the pump-section sump, the capacity handled by this is expressed as:
the pump increases because the suction head increases.
That reduces the total dynamic head. NPSH = 2.3 1 (Pa + P, - vp - fs)
For a mine-dewatering pump, where the total dy- where NPSH is the net positive suction head in feet, Pa
namic head increases as the water in the mine recedes, a is the atmospheric (barometric) pressure in pounds per
steep head vs. capacity curve is desirable. As the head square inch, P, is the suction pressure in pounds per
increases, the capacity does not decrease significantly. square inch at the pump suction nozzle corrected to the
In selecting a pump, it is important to pick one with pump's horizontal centerline (if this is a suction lift,
a characteristic curve that permits the anticipated oper- this is a negative value), vp is the vapor pressure in
ating-condition point to be close to the maximum pump pounds per square inch, and fs is the friction loss in the
efficiency. That is for reasons of both mechanical per- suction piping in pounds per square inch. The 2.31
formance and power economy. Continuously operating value is a constant to convert pounds per square inch to
a pump at an extreme above or below the point of maxi- feet of water. The same relationship may be applied
mum efficiency may cause unbalanced dynamic forces to values using metric units.
that can result in excessive flexing of the pump shaft, At sea level, the theoretical maximum suction lift of
an overload on the pump bearings, and separation cavi- a pump is 10.4 m (34 ft) and indicates the distance
tation damage in the impellers. from the surface of the water to the centerline of the
The performance of a centrifugal pump with a given pump. In practice, a suction lift of 6.1 m (20 ft)
impeller design may be altered by changing the periph- should not be exceeded. At altitudes above sea level,
eral or tip speed of the impeller: (1) the capacity the suction lift should be reduced to correspond to the
varies in direct relationship to the peripheral speed, (2) reduction in atmospheric (barometric) pressure. Most
the head varies in direct relationship to the square of the pump performance curves indicate the NPSH required
peripheral speed, (3) the power varies in direct rela- by the pump. The available NPSH calculated from
tionship to the cube of the peripheral speed, and (4) the the equation always must be equal to or greater than
efficiency remains constant for small changes in the the required NPSH.
peripheral speed. The peripheral speed may be changed
by altering the diameter of the impeller or the rpm of Mine-Pump Cost
the pump. After reliability, the cost of the mine pump is the
However, there are some limitations. Only a radial- most important consideration in the selection process.
flow centrifugal pump impeller can be altered, and too The cost considered should be the total cost for the
great a change alters the characteristics so that the per- entire life of the pump. This total cost includes the
formance does not conform to the relations stated. The purchase price, freight, installation costs, power costs,
impeller should not be cut so small that the vanes do and maintenance costs. Over the life of the pump, the
not overlap. Otherwise, the performance may become purchase price is only a small increment of the total
ANCILLARY EQUIPMENT
pipe sleeve to be
three times diameter
' -. of anchor bolt
.. " 0 6 .
C . . .. .
Fig. 13. Cross section of a concrete foundation showing
the arrangement of a foundation bolt.
GATE CHECh
ULM VALVE
CENTRCl REEKER
STRAINER
RADIUS ELBOW
CORRECT
Fig. 16. Cross section of foundation grouting, showing the
position of the wood dam used when pouring grout.
the pump casing and to "suck" water into the casing 11) After a few hours of operation, the pump and
and suction pipe. When this method is used, a foot motor alignment should be rechecked.
valve should not be used. This is the preferred method 12) After several hours of operation, the bearing
of priming a pump and a simple aspirator, operating temperature should be checked; this temperature should
on compressed air, can be assembled from standard not exceed 71 "C (160°F).
pipe fittings. Or, a commercial ejector can be pur- 13) The suction and discharge pressure gages
chased. Fig. 18 illustrates the arrangement for prim- should be checked. If the readings are not at or near
ing with an ejector. the anticipated pressures, the unit should be shut down
Startup Procedure and the problem located and corrected.
14) After running for several days and completing
If properly performed, the startup procedure can a final check of the alignment, the unit should be
prevent time-consuming and costly problems. Fre- doweled. Tapered dowel pins between 6.4 and 25.4 mm
quently, the personnel starting the new pump installa- (0.25 and 1.0 in.) should be installed in diagonally
tion are not the same as those who installed the equip- opposite feet of the pump and motor. It is not neces-
ment. Therefore, the following steps should be taken: sary to dowel small- or medium-size single-stage pumps.
1 ) The entire unit and surrounding area should be 15) When the pump is subject to freezing tempera-
cleaned. tures while not in operation, the casing should be drained
2 ) All main and auxiliary piping should be checked by removing the pipe plugs in the bottom of the casing.
to make certain that the piping has been connected
properly and is free of foreign objects such as rags, Automatic Pump Control
gloves, pieces of wood, welding slag, rocks, and lunch Automatic pump control frequently is installed and
pails. It is prudent to install a conical strainer at the pumps are checked only once a shift. The basic auto-
pump's suction flange before startup. matic control is a sensing device that starts and stops the
3) The pump and motor bearings should be pump as the level of the mine water in the suction sump
cleaned and lubricated. fluctuates. That can be a simple float switch, or it can be
4 ) The level and alignment should be rechecked. an array of electronic probes. If the pump operates with
5) The motor's direction of rotation should be a suction lift, it is important that a device be provided
checked before connecting the coupling. After being to make certain that the pump is primed properly
checked, the coupling should be assembled. before it starts. If clean water is scarce or expensive,
6 ) The discharge valve should be closed. automatic water valves can be installed on the stuffing
7 ) The pump should be primed, making certain box. Highly sophisticated sensing devices of various
that all air is bled out of the casing and suction pipe. types also are available to further safeguard the pump
A pump that is run dry may "seize." and motor. In all cases, an alarm system should be
8) The water to the stuffing boxes should be turned provided to indicate when the water level in the sump
on, and the pump unit started. rises above a predetermined limit.
9 ) As soon as the pump reaches operating speed, Maintenance
the discharge valve should be opened slowly. If the pump has been installed properly and if the
10) With the pump operating, the stuffing-box suction sump is adequate to allow abrasive solids to
packing should be checked. When the pump is packed, settle, the maintenance of a mine pump usually is
the glands should not be drawn up very tightly, and there quite simple.
should be a considerable amount of leakage when the Rotating Elements: For pumps that are vital to
pump is started so that the packing stays cool and does mine operations, at least one spare rotating element
not glaze. As the pump runs, the stuffing-box gland should be kept on hand, complete with all elements
nuts may be tightened to reduce the leakage, but there
necessary for immediate installation. This includes a
always should be some leakage to lubricate the packing pump-half flexible coupling so that a damaged or worn
and cool the stuffing box. rotating element can be removed and a new rotating
element can be installed quickly. Some mines have a
heavy welded steel box in which the spare element is
placed, lowered into the mine, and stored in the pump
room; the element is not removed from this box until
CCCNTRIC REDUCER
it is installed directly into the pump. The rotating
ONG RADIUS element must be handled with extreme care since the
ELBOW
aligment of the element is critical to proper operation.
To assess the wear on internal pump parts, it is
good practice to install an ammeter that registers the
motor amperage. When the motor amperage falls
below a predetermined lower limit, the pump rotor
should be replaced-such a decrease in amperage in-
dicates that the internal clearances have increased to a
point where excessive internal water recirculation is
occurring. This is particularly important on multi-
stage pumps. The use of the ammeter eliminates the
need for frequently opening the pump casing to inspect
Fig. 18. Typical arrangement for pump-system priming the internal parts; as long as a pump is functioning
by means of an ejector. properly, it is advisable to avoid opening the casing.
ANCILLARY EQUIPMENT 1347
Lubrication: The ideal lubricant for ball bearings time. If a standard vertical pump is installed in the
is a straight well-refined neutral mineral oil, preferably shaft of a flooded mine, it can be mounted on a
of a turbine type. For the majority of applications, crosshead on the old shaft guides and lowered as the
SAE 10 motor oil meets the requirements. Table 2 water recedes. The discharge is connected to the pump
summarizes some suggested oil specifications. It is good column by rubber hose or, in some instances, a tele-
practice to change the oil in the bearing housings once scopic pipe arrangement that allows the lower length
every 600 hr of operation. of pipe to slide out the lower end of the pump column
Record Card: For each pump, a record card or log through a packed stuffing box. Another method of
book should be maintained conscientiously. Table 3 mounting the pump is to secure it to a float or raft
lists the contents of a suggested record card; this in- that follows the level of the water as the pumping
formation greatly assists in diagnosing any problem that progresses.
might develop. Selection of Pumping Equipment
Operating Difficulties: Some 85% of the troubles
The selection of the proper size pump for dewater-
encountered with centrifugal pumps occur on the suc-
ing a mine requires a calculation of the volume of the
tion side. The possible problems may be classified into
flooded mine workings plus estimated water inflow, and
four groups: no water or insufficient water delivered, the total head against which water must be pumped.
insufficient pressure, intermittent operation, and exces- Since the total head varies as the water rece s, selection
sive power consumption. 4e
of the pump frequently depends upon the q t e n t of the
No Water o r Insufficient Water Delivered-Prob-
head variation. In some cases, it is desirable to select a
lems indicated by no water or insufficient water delivered
multi-stage pump capable of pumping against the maxi-
may be caused by: improper priming with the pump
mum head which will be encountered; when the pump is
casing not full of water, too low an operating speed,
too high a discharge head, too high a suction lift, a operating against a lesser head, at the start, remove
plugged impeller passage, an incorrect direction of rota- several stages of impellers, replacing them with spacers.
tion, air leakage into the suction pipe or stuffing boxes, In another approach, the dewatering pumps are
an insufficiently submerged suction-pipe entrance, staged. An initial pump Lowers the water to a predeter-
mechanical defects or worn internal clearances, or too mined level, a permanent pump is installed on that
small an impeller diameter. level, and the initial pump then lowers the water to
Insufficient Pressure-Problems indicated by insuf- the next predetermined level. This method allows a
ficient pressure may be caused by: too low an operating permanent pump to be installed on each level as it is
speed, mine water containing excessive entrained air reached. Frequently, these pumps are horizontal split-
or gas, too small an impeller diameter, or a total head case designs which may be more economical than the
higher than that calculated. vertical dewatering pumps.
Intermittent Operation-Problems indicated by in- It is not practical to propose a specific pump ar-
termittent operation, with the pump operating for a rangement; the best arrangement usually depends upon
while and then stopping, may be caused by: air leakage many different factors that vary from mine to mine.
into the suction line or stuffing boxes with a subsequent Some of these factors include: the quantity of water
loss of priming, an improperly functioning water seal, to be pumped, the time available for the dewatering
mine water containing excessive entrained air or gas, or operation, the depth of the shaft to be dewatered, the
too high a suction lift. depth at which the major water volume is located, the
Excessive Power Consumption-Problems indicated available power supplies, the physical conditions of the
by excessive power consumption may be caused by: mine and shaft, and the purpose of the dewatering
a total head lower than that calculated; too high an operation.
operating speed; mechanical defects such as a binding When dewatering a mine, a formal provision must
rotor, a misaligned pump, or an excessively tight stuffing be made for disposition of the pumped water. The lack
box; or electrical defects such as low voltage or fre- of proper arrangements has delayed a number of mine
quency that cause motor overheating. dewatering projects and has resulted in legal problems.
In arid country, allowing even clean mine water to
MINE-DEWATERING PUMPS flow onto a rancher's property can result in trouble-
Most mine-dewatering pumps are of a vertical de- particularly if the rancher sees an opportunity to profit
sign. They may be hung in a shaft to follow the water from litigation. On occasion, it may be possible to
level down, or they may be installed as submerged make a deal with such an individual prior to com-
pumps in a shafts or boreholes that intersect the mine mencing the dewatering operation, allowing that in-
workings. When dewatering a mine, the pumped water dividual to buy the water for some nominal amount,
is usually free of solids because the water has been but making him feel that he outsmarted the mining
standing (and settling) for an appreciable period of company.
Inlet Steam, psi. ga. - Total Temp. "F - Exhaust, psi. ga. -
INSPECTION 8 REPAIRS
Costs of Dewatering Power Cost: The cost for the power needed to
The costs of a dewatering operation are dependent dewater a flooded mine is a function of the water
upon many local factors, making it impractical to volume, the pumping height, and the volume of ground
attempt a definition of dollar costs. Instead, it is helpful water that continues to flow into the mine as the
to describe the various items that affect the costs. residual water is removed. For most purposes, the
Fist Cost: The first cost can be calculated only water inflow may be assumed to equal the inflow ex-
after the contributing factors previously listed have perienced prior to the mine being flooded.
been determined. An important consideration in evaluat- Cost Determinations: T o estimate the cost of pump-
ing the first cost is to establish the source of power ing the residual water from the flooded mine, a map
necessary to operate the pumps. If the mine has been of the mine workings may be used to calculate the
shut down for an appreciable length of time, the power volume and the average head. T o facilitate the calcula-
lines and electrical distribution system often have tion, arbitrarily divide the workings into logical units,
deteriorated to a point where a major expense is in- calculating the volume of water and an estimated
volved in reestablishing power supplies. average lift for each unit. Then integrate the individual
ANCILLARY EQUIPMENT
Customary Allowable
Lift, m (ft) Submergence, % Best Submergence, %
and a high-capacity, low-lift jet. In either case, water Fig. 27 illustrates the use of a jet pump for draining
forced under pressure down the passage at the right a passageway. The jet is stationed in a low spot and
enters the Venturi throat at high velocity and draws is equipped with a float-operated valve. The operating
water from below. The two streams merge in the water is obtained from a pressure line or from a
gradually widening Venturi and they are propelled up- centrifugal pump.
ward into a discharge pipe. HYDRALlLlC MINING
Fig. 26 illustrates the use of a jet pump for draining
a sump. In this case, a motor pump (centrifugal) used Modern underground hydraulic mining in the United
for dewatering the sump may provide the high-pressure States began in 1948 with the mining of gilsonite by
water to operate a jet pump at a lower level. the American Gilsonite Co. near Salt Lake City, UT.
* In the well, use the smallest diameter air line possible without producing excessive friction.
In mining gilsonite, a 6.4-mm (0.25-in.) water jet the Soviet Union had reported success in hydraulically
having a pressure drop of 15 860 kPa (2300 psi) across mining and transporting coal as early as 1936. A
the nozzle will cut 23 to 27 t / h r (25 to 30 stph). The greater emphasis was placed on developing coal-mining
6.4-mm (0.25-in.) nozzle will pass approximately 6 techniques in the Soviet Union, Japan, and European
L / s (100 gpm) of water. Approximately 22 L/s (350 countries because those countries relied heavily upon
gpm) of low-pressure water is used to flume the ore to a coal, while the United States relied heavily on cheap
receiving pocket where it is sized and crushed to 19 mm oil and gas.
(0.75 in.) and then pumped 244 m (800 ft) vertically Since 1971, Kaiser Resources, Ltd., Sparwood, BC,
to the slurry preparation plant on the surface. On the has been operating a successful hydraulic coal mining
surface, a 40% slurry is pumped through 116 km (72 and transport system, using Soviet and Japanese meth-
miles) of pipe to the refinery. ods and equipment. The "hydraulic monitor" used
Interest in the use of hydraulic techniques for coal in that operation breaks coal at a rate of 4 to 9 t/min
mining began in the United States in 1958. However, (5 to 10 st per min).
ANCILLARY EQUIPMENT
In the Kaiser Resources' operation, the main high- pressure obtained through a reducing valve from the
pressure pump is located on the surface. This is a monitor's 1 1 030-kPa ( 1600-psi) supply line. This
seven-stage pump that is driven by a 1860-kW (2500- monitor can break coal at a distance of up to 21 m (70
hp) motor and delivers 95 L/s (1500 gpm) at 13 790 ft) from the nozzle.
kPa (2000 psi). The high-pressure water is carried un- Assisted by a small remote-controlled auxiliary
derground through a 203-mm (8-in.) pipeline to the monitor with a 12.0-mm (0.47-in.) nozzle, the broken
sublevels, and the water is delivered to the monitor coal is sluiced to a breaker that reduces the coal to
through a 152-mm (6-in.) pipeline. The monitor is approximately -152 mm (-6 in.). The breaker is
fitted with either a 23.0-mm (0.91-in.) diam nozzle or located downslope from the monitor, but upslope from
a 28.3-mm (1.1 1-in.) diam nozzle. The nozzle selec- the control console. Behind the breaker, the coal and
tion depends upon the hardness of the coal in the water enter a steel flume that carries the coal down
area being mined. The pressure drop across the nozzle the sublevel and into the mainline roadway flume that
is approximately 11 030 kPa (1600 psi). The monitor leads to the treatment plant on the surface. This has
is controlled from a remote-control console positioned proven to be an efficient method of mining thick coal
11 m (35 ft) downslope from the monitor. The monitor seams with a steep dip.
is positioned by two hydraulic cylinders, with one for Hydraulic mining systems also are being developed
the swing and the other for the dump. The hydraulic for use in some of the uranium mines in the western
cylinders are actuated by 2760 kPa (400 psi) of water United States. Where deposits of uranium ore are con-
LlNDERGROLlND MINING METHODS HANDBOOK
240-
220-
P 20
PUMPED CAPACITY IN GALLONS PER MINUTE
P i s c h a r g e Line
-
Jet
-
Fig. 27. Method of using a jet pump for draining a mine passageway.
tained in loosely consolidated sandstone, some mining In the South African operation, the run-of-mine ore
has been done through a borehole with a high-pressure is screened. The -6.4 mm (-0.25 in.) material is
water jet that knocks down and sluices the uranium- passed through a ball mill in which it is reduced t o a
bearing sandstone to a vertical submersible pump. The sludge consisting of -65 to +200 mesh material (80% )
slurry then is pumped to the surface. This technique and -200 mesh material (20%). The oversize ore
still is undergoing development-mechanical mainte- goes from the screening operation to the conventional
nance problems have been quite persistent as a result hoist. In the past, the fines in the ore caused delay
of the abrasive nature of the sandstone. problems in conventional hoisting as a result of the
sticky nature of the ore; removing the fines from the
HYDRAULIC HOISTING conventional hoisting system has increased its hoisting
Under certain conditions, hydraulic hoisting of ore capacity.
has proven to be practical. This method is particularly PUMP INFORMATION SUMMARY
applicable when a large quantity of water must be
pumped to keep a mine dry, or when a hoisting shaft Table 8 summarizes the pump-system parameters
is operating at full capacity while additional ore must and features for various mines operating in the United
be hauled without sufficient justification for the installa- States. The table includes references to numbered notes
tion of a new mechanical hoisting system. that are as follows:
Several important hydraulic hoisting installations Note 1
are working satisfactorily. At the Devillaine coal mine Information concerning the AMAX operations at
near St. Etienne, France, a demonstration hydraulic Climax, CO, was obtained from Al Smith, chief engi-
hoist was installed in 1960. It hoisted 45 to 54 t / h neer. Information on the Henderson mine was ob-
(50 to 60 stph) of -82.6 mm (-3.25 in.) coal up a tained from D. E. Julin, chief engineer. Information on
180-m (590-ft) shaft and through a 76-m (250-ft)
AMAX Lead Co.'s Buick mine in Missouri was ob-
horizontal pipeline t o the treatment plant. That lift tained from AMAX Lead Co. of Missouri and Home-
required a total of 48.5 kW (65 hp), of which 12.7 stake Lead Co. For the Buick mine, the pumping cost,
kW (17 hp) was used for the horizontal transport. including power and maintenance, is $0.62 per 100
In Czechoslovakia's Kutna Hra district, lead-zinc
L / s ($0.39 per 1000 gpm). The approximate cost of the
ore is lifted 460 m (1500 ft) with an hydraulic system. pumps at the time of purchase in 1968 was $20,800
At the Lengede Broistedt iron-ore mine in West Ger-
each, including the pump, motor, and starter.
many, the conventional mechanical hoisting system has
been replaced by an hydraulic system that handles up Note 2
to 4540 t/d (5000 stpd) from a depth of 120 m (395 At Anaconda Co.'s Butte mines, underground water
ft). from the surrounding mines is collected in the Kelley
One of the most interesting hydraulic hoist installa- mine. The collected water is pumped to the surface
tions is at Anglo-American Corp.'s Vaal Reefs gold mine from pump stations located on the 4000 level [elevation
near Klerksdorp, South Africa. This system is pumping = 664 m (2177 ft)] and the 3900 level [elevation = 710
gold-bearing quartzite from the 2190-m (7200-ft) level m (2328 ft)] of the Kelley mine. The elevation at the
to the surface. Using MarsT" reciprocating pumps, collar of the Kelley mine shaft is 1820 m (5970 ft)
22 700 t [(25,000 st) dry tonnage] are pumped per above sea level, and the elevation at the bottom of the
month through four lifts. The installation of an hy- shaft is 353 m (1 159 ft) above sea level. At present
draulic hoisting system was prompted by the fact that (19781, the Butte mines are flooded to the 4000 level.
the shaft already was operating at its maximum capacity Approximately 290 L/s (4600 gpm) of mine water
of 136 000 t (150,000 st) per month, and it was neces- is produced underground at the Butte mines, and this
sary to hoist additional ore. amount must be pumped to the surface. As of 1978,
1356 UNDERGROUND MlNllVG METHODS HANDBOOK
145 L/s (2300 gpm) are pumped from the 4000-level tion = 1890 m (6200 ft)] where the mine water is mixed
pumping station and the remaining 145 L/s (2300 gpm) with concentrator tailings and additional milk of lime.
flow by gravity through a drain tunnel to the 3900-level The tailings, salts, and other solids settle out in the pond,
pumping station. The 145 L / s (2300 gpm) pumped and the water is reused in the copper concentrator. The
from the 4000 level goes to a drain tunnel above, where estimated cost of pumping mine water for all three
it joins the mine water at that level. The total mine pumping stations is $1220 per 100 L/s per day ($770
water [290 L/s (4600 gprn)] flows through two vertical per 1000 gprn per day).
settlers that remove silt and into two pump sumps Both underground pumping stations have been pro-
located at the 3900-level pumping station. From those vided with additional pumping capacity to accommo-
sumps, the water is pumped to the surface through four date underground sloughs, which can occur and trap
250-mm ( 10-in.) ID 3 16 stainless-steel pipe columns. mine water. When the water finally breaks through,
At the surface level of the shaft, each pipe column additional pumping capacity is required to prevent the
connects to a 305-mm (12-in.) mild-steel pipe that is pumping stations from being flooded. The temperature
lined with polyvinyl chloride (ParalineT" RD coating of the underground mine water averages 29.4"C (89°F)
applied by Barber Webb Co.). These four lines extend and the water is extremely corrosive. The water carries
for an additional 930 m (3050 ft) to a final elevation cupric and ferric sulfates and basic iron sulfate in solu-
of 1880 m (6168 ft) above sea level before discharging tion, and it has a pH of approximately 4. Sulfuric acid
into a wooden flume. From the flume, the mine water is added to bring the acidity close to a pH of 2, thus
flows by gravity through two 406-mm (16-in.) Para- holding the materials in solution and preventing deposi-
lineT'-lined steel pipes to a rubber-lined steel tank that tion on the pipe walls. All pumps, pipelines, and other
measures 4.9 m (16 ft) high and 12 rn (40 ft) diam. components that comc into contact with the mine water
This tank serves as a sump and a control tank for the must be constructed of materials capable of withstand-
surface pumping station. From the tank, the water is ing the corrosive action.
pumped to a mixing tank at the tailings pond [eleva- According to Anaconda, the pumps working against
ANCILLARY EQUIPMENT 1357
an 84-m (275-ft) head cost (in 1971) approximately tion cost, pump-room excavation, electric cables and
$8000 each, the motor cost $3530, and the motor con- transformers, and the pump column.
trol center for all of the pumps cost $37,500. The pumps For winze No. 6, the original purchase cost of the
working against a 1250-m (4100-ft) head cost (in 1961) pumps, motors, and starters was $1800 for the 335-kW
approximately $52,000 each, the motors cost $18,000 (450-hp) units purchased in 1973 and $24,000 each for
each, and the motor control center for all of the pumps the 186-kW (250-hp) units purchased in 1976. The
cost $101,000. The pumps mounted on the surface and total cost of the pump installation, including the equip-
working against a total head of 76 m (250 ft) cost (in ment, installation costs, pump-room excavation, electric
1971) approximately $8000 each, the motors cost $3530 cables and transformers, and pump column was $140,-
each, and the motor-starting equipment was available 000 for the 335-kW (450-hp) units and $70,000 for
from another project and was supplied at no cost. the 186-kW (250-hp) units.
Note 3 For winze No. 4, the pumps, motors, and starters
Homestake Mining Co. estimates that the cost of had purchase costs of $1 1,000 for the 186-kW (250-
pumping water at Homestake is $0.42 per 1000 L hp) unit and $8000 for the 93-kW (125-hp) unit. The
($1.60 per 1000 gal). This includes power, labor, and total costs of pump installation, including equipment,
mechanical maintenance, but it excludes equipment de- installation cost, pump-room excavation, electric cable
preciation. and transformers, and pump column, were $60,000 for
At the time of purchase, pumping equipment for the the 186-kW (250-hp) installation and $90,000 for the
Ross shaft cost approximately $56,000 for each unit, 93-kW ( 125-hp) installation. The 186-kW (250-hp)
including the pump motor and the starting gear. The system was installed in 1961, and the 93-kW (125-hp)
total cost of the pump installation at the Ross shaft is system was installed in 1966.
estimated to be $210,000, including equipment, installa- Information on Homestake Mining Co.'s pump in-
UNDERGROUND MINING METHODS HANDBOOK
Depth of Shaft. 41 1
(ft) (1348)
Total water pumped, 252
Us (gpm) (4Ow
Pump level interval, None
m (ft)
No. pumps on each
level
Capacity, each 63
pump, Us (gpm) (1
Total head, each 317
pump, m (ft) (1040)
Motor power, each 298
pump, kW (hp)
Motor current, 60
(a)
2300 v,
Hz, 3-phase 96 amp
Pump control Automatic Automatic Automatic Automatic Automatic
Year installed 1967 and 1969 1967 1973 1975 1978
Pump manufacturer Peerless Peerless Peerless Ingersoll-Rand BJ
Motor manufacturer US Motors US Motors US Motors AC US Motors
Suction lift or Flooded Flooded Flooded 69-11 (20-ft) lift Flooded
flooded
Pump type Vertical Vertical Vertical Horizontal Vertical
Sump retention time 8 hr 8 hr 8 hr 7.4 hr 45 min
Pump column diam 305 (12) [one] 254 (10) [one] 305 (12) [one] 203 (8) [one] 203 (8')[one]
[mm (in.)] and steel steel steel steel steel
material
Casing material Cast iron Cast iron Cast iron Cast iron Cast iron
Impeller material Cast iron Cast iron Cast iron Bronze Bronze
Wear-ring material Bronze Bronze Bronze Stainless steel Bronze
Notest 8 9 10 11 12
' Information either not provided or not applicable.
t S e e text for meaning of notes.
the pumps, motors, and starters was $56,033,and the installation cost, pump-room excavation, electric cables
estimated cost of the pump installation, including equip- and transformers, and pump column, was $82,500.This
ment, installation cost, pump-room excavation, electric information was supplied by the Engineering Dept. of
cables and transformers, and pump column was $555,- Sunshine Mining Co.
000. This information was supplied by the Mining Note 12
Research Dept. of St. Joe Minerals Corp.
The estimated cost of the pumps, motors, and start-
Note 10 ers at UV Industries operation in New Mexico was
The estimated pumping costs at St. Joe Mineral $18,000. This information was supplied by R. C.
Corp.'s Brushy Creek mine are $0.029 per 1000 L Weagle, vice president in charge of operations.
LINDERGROLIND MINING METHODS HANDBOOK
Magma Copper Magma Copper Magma Copper Magma Copper Magma Copper
Co., San Manuel Co., San Manuel Co.. San Manuel Co., San Manuel Co., San Manuel
Shaft 5, Shaft 5, Shaft 5, Shaft 1, Shaft 1,
2950 Level, 3530 Level, 4123 Level, 820 Level, 1475 Level,
Item San Manuel, AZ San Manuel, AZ San Manuel, AZ San Manuel, AZ San Manuel, AZ
Depth of Shaft,
f7-I (ft)
Total water pumped,
Us (gpm)
Pump level interval,
f7-I (ft)
No. pumps on each
level
Capacity, each
Pump, Us (gpm)
Total head, each
pump, m (ft)
Motor power, each
Pump, kW (hp)
Motor current, 60
Hz, 3-phase
Pump control Automatic Automatic Automatic Automatic Automatic
Year installed 1973 1974 1974 1953 1955
Pump manufacturer Pacific Pump B & J and B&J Pacific Pump Pacific Pump
Ingersoll-Rand
Motor manufacturer General Electric General Electric B&J General Electric General Electric
& US Motors & US Motors & US Motors
Suction lift or Flooded Flooded Flooded Flooded Flooded
flooded
Pump type Horizontal Horizontal Submersible Horizontal Horizontal
Sump retention time 5 min 5 min 60 min Booster pumps 25 min
Pump column, diam 203 (8) [onel 305 (12) [two] 203 (8) [two] 305 (12) [two] 305 (12) [two]
[mm (in.)] and 305 (12) [one] 203 (8) [one] 203 (8) [one]
material
Casing material Carbon steel Iron Iron Steel Steel
Impeller material Stainless steel Bronze Bronze Bronze Bronze
Wear-ring material Stainless steel Stainless steel Bronze Bronze Bronze
Notest 14 14 14 14 14
Magma Copper Magma Copper Magma Copper Magma Copper Magma Copper
Co., San Manuel Co., San Manuel Co., San Manuel Co., San Manuel Co., San Manuel
Shaft 1, Shaft 1, Shaft 1, Shaft 1, Shaft 5,
2075 Level, 2375 Level, 2675 Level, Bottom Sump, 1055 Level,
Item San Manuel, AZ San Manuel, AZ San Manuel, AZ San Manuel, AZ San Manuel, AZ
Depth of Shaft, 863 863 863 863 1257
In (ft) (2830) (2830) (2830) (2830) (4123)
Total water pumped, 189 50 91 3 240
Us (9Pm) (3000) w"3 (1450) (50) (3800)
Pump level interval, 200 91 91 47 322
(ft) (600) (300) (300) (155) (1055)
No. pumps on each 12 3 6 2 7
level
Capacity, each 38 38 38 95 50 [5] 8. 57 [21
Pump, Us ( 9 ~ m ) (600) (600) (600) (1500) (800 8. 900)
Total head, each 191 94 191 61 322
Pump, In (ft) (625) (310) (625) (200) (1055)
Motor power, each 149 75 149 56 and 67 224
Pump. kW (hp) (200) (100) (200) (75 and 90) (300)
Motor current, 60 2300 v 2300 v 2300 v 2300 v 2300 v
Hz, 3-phase
Pump control Automatic Automatic Automatic Automatic Automatic
Year installed 1958 1968 1968 1973 1970
Pump manufacturer Pacific Pump Pacific Pump Pacific Pump Fly@ B 8. J and
Ingersoll-Rand
Motor manufacturer General Electric General Electric General Electric Flygt General Electric
& US Motors & US Motors & US Motors
Suction lift or Flooded Flooded Flooded Flooded Flooded
flooded
Pump type Horizontal Horizontal Horizontal Submersible Horizontal
Sump retention time 10 min 5 min 5 min 2.25 hr Booster pump
Pump column, diam 305 (12) [two] 305 (12) [one] 305 (12) [one] 102 (4) [one] 305 (12) [two]
[mm (in.)]and 203 (8) [one] 152 (6) [one]
material
Casing material Steel Steel Steel Aluminum Steel
Impeller material Bronze Stainless steel Bronze Steel Bronze
Wear-ring material Bronze Stainless steel Bronze Stainless steel
Notest 14 14 14 14 14
Sloping Area
1450 LEVEL
Z.~.RZMRV.~H.P..*~V. - 4
%---'I-O-'.+-l t
I
1 0 . m 11to Mullan
2300LEVEL
1 2500LEVEL ADIT(Y0RNINQ NO. 6)
r..l - - - - - :. + ---- -- -*
2-1.R.ZMRV.SOH.P.,440V. - I ZWLEVEL
2lWLEVEL
l-l.R.ZRVH.20H.P..440V.
i (Elev. 3250 11)
WLEVEL
-0-..--J ,
I
t
L--+
+l u a f t *
---
t
4000 LEVEL
I
+
!
I
I
I
I I
I I
Sloplng ~ i e a
t
w
r
z - i . k . z v r ~ v n , m ~ . ~ . , * o v, . 2 3-1.R. 4HMTA-@
I
I I
Sloping Area
Water to I
7300 LEVEL
7MLEVEL
2-1.R. ZRVH,J)H.P.
77W LEVEL
7W7 LEVEL
(THICKENER)
8fW LEVEL (Elev. 2350 It)
~CLYGT81804; 7% H.P.
DUPLDC YUDPUWP
Fig. 28. Pumping system at the Star-Morning mine of Helca Mining Co. at Wallace, ID. Metric equivalents: ft X 0.3048 =
hp X 0.7456 699 9 = kW.
1364 UNDERGROUND MINING METHODS HANDBOOK
REFERENCES AND BIBLIOGRAPHY solidated Mine, Eureka, Utah," Trans. AZME, Vol. 184,
pp. 229-234.
Bogeat, J.R., 1963, "Naica Battles Water and Costs as Lead- Hydraulic Institute, 1975, Hydraulic Institute Standards.
Zinc-Silver Mining Goes Deeper," Mining World, Loofbourow, R.L., and Lehmann, E.K., 1968, "A Mine
Aug . Flood, Vancouver Island," Preprint 68AG346, SME
Brookes and Murdock, 1977, "Application of High Capacity, Fall Meeting, Minneapolis, MN.
High Head Pumps for Mine Drainage Using a Flood Miller, H.W., and Jolley, D.H., 1964, "Flooding and Re-
Protected Pump Station," Fifth Technical Conference o f covery of the Jefferson City Mine," Mining Congress
British Pump Manufacturers' Association. Journal, Jan.
Clarke, C.D., and Reinberg, G., 1956, "Corrosion Problems Monroe, H.L., 1965, "Design of a Water Settler at Pea
in Pumping Acid Mine Water," Trans. AZME, Vol. 205, Ridge," Mining Engineering, Dec., pp. 81-84.
pp. 821-825. Saul, H., 1978, "Current Mine Drainage Problems," Trans-
Corbett, R.P., and Ralph, F.E., 1968, "Dewatering with a actions, Institution of Mining Engineers, Sec. A, pp.
4,100-Ft Head Pumping Plant," Mining Congress le-9e.
Journal, Sept., pp. 33-43. Westaway, C.R., and Loomins, A.W., 1977, "Cameron
Ferguson, C., and Morris, M., 1970, "Mine-Water Treat- Hydraulic Data," Ingersoll-Rand Co.
ment, Inco Sudbury Operations," Ontario Water Re- Wiles, G.M., 1943, "Development and Dewatering Practices
sources commission. at Park City Consolidated Mines," Trans. AZME, Vol.
Hall, J.G., 1949, "History of Pumping at the Chief Con- 153, pp. 115-120.