Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
perfect and contain a tragic flaw which can lead to his downfall3.
Unlike most tragic protagonists, Lear’s fall occurs early in the play
dividing the kingdom between his three daughters. Firstly, this rash
decision implies Lear’s downfall and prepares the audience for what
large during the reign of Elizabeth 1. However, Lear does not show
many noble attributes before his fall when he loses his temper at
because she refuses to flatter him with praises and love. This is
stages of the play due to killing the rebel, Macdonwald, and fighting
1
Emma Yeoman
Cordelia and not realizing how wicked Goneril and Regan are when
his wife and his flaw develops to the point that it changes the way
death Macbeth questions what he has done but later on in the play,
there is a reduction of soliloquies with his third and last one being in
Act Five, showing how his personality and his mind has changed.
2
Emma Yeoman
especially when Goneril says that she “will not speak to him” and
clash between her and her father. As Lear’s host, Goneril has a duty
to protect her father and behave graciously towards him but instead
protagonist’s flaw. Both the sisters not only anger their father but
noble man who is fighting for his country but when he is first
influenced by the three witches who tell him that he will become
3
Emma Yeoman
Lady Macbeth:
him hereunto; but specially his wife lay sore upon him to
says:
5
Holinshed's Chronicles, Volume V: Scotland, page 269
6
A lecture prepared for English 366: Studies in Shakespeare, by Ian Johnston
______“All this loss of things which made him a great man has come
the architect of his own destruction, and the more he tries to cope
own reasons.”
4
Emma Yeoman
their own fault, the result of free choice, not of accident or villainy or
daughters which led to his downfall which Kent warns him about
suffers too much for it to just be his fault because he trusted his
daughters to take care of him and instead reduce his train asking
him “what need you five and twenty? Ten? Or five?” and he goes
into the storm – something which isn’t necessarily his fault. The
storm shows pathetic fallacy and could mimic Lear’s state of mind
of course, a
7
Butcher, S. H., trans. 1974. Poetics. By Aristotle. In Dukore (1974, 31-55)
8
A lecture prepared for English 366: Studies in Shakespeare, by Ian Johnston
______passionately egocentric, loud, and in many respects
being once one strips away all the extras that help to tell him what
he ______is.”
5
Emma Yeoman
character at this point in the play compared with the beginning due
how Macbeth is aware of moral boundaries but was just led astray
by the three witches and his wife. The misfortune is not wholly
deserved and the fall also contains some sense of awareness, some
gain in self knowledge and some discovery of self9. This term that
shown within Lear who really plays the part of a tragic protagonist
faults and changes his character, even telling Edgar to “take thy
9
Sean McEvoy, Tony Coult and Chris Sandford, Trangedy: A Student Handbook,
6
Emma Yeoman
make amends for it, instead he says, “I will not yield” and continues
that greed and killing someone is wrong. In this sense, Lear is more
has two editions, the Folio and the Quarto. Both editions end with
the deaths of Lear and Cordelia but Folio ends with the possibility
proclaiming “Look on her, look, her lips”. This reduces the bleak
impact of the Quarto edition and the audience feels more pity for
complex than that of his wife. In this way, Macbeth doesn’t contain
analysed. Lear does not have a strong Id but a lack of Ego. He does
7
Emma Yeoman
10
Sean McEvoy, Tony Coult and Chris Sandford, Trangedy: A Student Handbook,
(10 Feb 2009), p.236
Lear goes mad could be because he does not know how to behave
and act when thrown out by his daughters. This could also be the
gives in to his desire for power by doing the “deed” and murdering
8
Emma Yeoman
To what extent you feel that Lear and Macbeth are tragic
Lear are noble people but due to the events they witness and suffer,
their end comes differently between the two of them. Macbeth does
not learn anything from his experiences whereas Lear did. In this
Bibliography
• Sean McEvoy, Tony Coult and Chris Sandford, Tragedy: A
Student Handbook, (10 Feb 2009)
(1974, 31-55)
by Ian Johnston