Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 6
B Cyge6nyro konnermio no Aenam 06 anMMHMcTpaTHBHbIX npaBoHapyWweHHaX M Aenam BoeHHocnyxauyx BepxosHoro cyaa MMP, r. Tupacnonb, yn. (OHocTH, 29 Tinyo Koroporo senetca npousBoAcTso no Aeny 06 aaMMHuctpaTusHoM npasoHapywieHnn: Mnewkanos Buktop Muxainoss, SawurTHuk B.M. MnewkaHopa: Nonoscxuii Crenax Teopruesiy, Opra, abinecumi MoctaHosnenue 06 afMuHncTpaTHBHoM npaBoHapyweHnn: e Tupacnonckwit ropoacKoit CyA, cyaba B.B. MepuHos r. Tapacnons, yn. Senna, 26 KANOBA Ha MoctaHosnenne no geny 06 aAMuHUcTpaTMBHOM NpaBoHapyWleHn 10 wiona 2022 ropa cygba TupacnonbcKoro ropopcKoro cyga B.B. Mepunos Beiec [loctaHoanenne no geny 06 apMMHUcTpaTHsHOM npasoHapyweHnu, npeAycMoTPeHHOMy nyskrom 1 craren 20.1 KOAN TIMP, Koropbim HasHauinn B.M. MnewkaHoay HaKasaHne B BMAE QMMHMCTpATHBHOTO apecTa CPOKOM Ha 5 (NATE) CyTOK (8 AanbHeliwem — MocTaHosnenve). C qattbim NoctaHosnernem B.M. Nnewkakos He CornaceH no cnepyrouwm OCHOBaHMAM. 1. CornacHo MocraHoaneHnio cya nepgol vHcTaHyn npMWén «...x BbIBOAY, YTO CBOHMA geiicreuamn [newkanos B.M cosepwnn agmunucTpaTnaHoe npasoHapywenne, TpeAyCMOTpeHHoe nyHKTOM 1 cTaTbH 20.1 KOAM MMP no npisHaKy: «MenKoe XymraHcTBO, TO ecTs HapyuieHne OGueCcTBeHHOrO NOpAAKa, BbIPAKAIOUIee ABHOE HeyBAKeHHE K OGLIECTBY, CconpoBoxjaloujeecs HEYeH3ypHOii OpaHbio B OBLECTBEHHbIX MeCTAX». 1.1. Tipu atom cya nepsoii MHCTaHUMK He ykasan, KaKOe WMeHHO BbIpaxKeHne MM keanncbuunpopanocs, Kak HeueHsypHan Spakb. Tem CaMbiM, Cyd nepsoli uHCTAHUMA He Uicnonkinn CBOE! OGASAKHOCTH, NPeAyYCMOTPEHHON NOgNyHKTOM «t» nyHKTa 1 cTaTen 30.12 KoAN TIMP, o6sanieaioujel CyA ykasbiBars B NOCTAHOBNeHMM «OGCTOATENbCTBA, yCTAHOBNeHHbIe NPM paccmorpeHin mena». B CBO10 Ke OUePEDb, CyA NePEOK MHCTAHUWH AML USNOXMN NOKAgAHHA rpaxKgaH , Take B.M. Mnewkaxosa u O.H. Tlonywiak, opHaKo, He ykasan, Kakve OOCTORTeNLCTBA, yKASAHHbIX AaHHBIMN CBYeTENAMM, CYA Nepsoii MHCTAHUM CHUTAeT YCTAHOBNeHHBIMI. Cneayet npenonoxkuts, 4To HeUeHypHoH Gpanblo cy nocuNTaN, npuBeAeHHEIe B noKasaHvAx caygeTeneli, «esipaxeHuie rpyOoli HeYeHsypHOl Epa @ OTHOUIeHM opraHoB rocygapcraeHHoii GesonacHocTu NpugHecTpoECKol MongaBckon PecnyGniKi». 1.2. B MloctaHosnenun yKasaHo, 470 «.,.NpOTOKON coRep-KUT oNucAHHE ... COObITHA a@qMuHUCTpaTHBHOrO npaBoHapyweHnA B O6béMe, AOCTATOYHOM JIA ero KBaNIMGbUKALMN...». Tpexse Bcero OTMeTMM, 4TO COBbITHe AAMMHUCTPATHBHOrO NPAaBoHAPYWeHHA ONMCAHO B Nporokone 06 apmunnctparueHom npasoHapywieHin Ne 2077509 of 05 anpens 2022 roma, Kak: «.. MnewkaHos BM. ... NPOABNAN slaHOe HeyBaKeHNe K OOUIECTAY, BbIPaKANICA B AApeC TP. HeyeHSypHOH Opanbio ...». BMecTe c Tem, 8 cyAet “co6¢. . vee ™ ue BACCO dUr. Pulyrubaed etc ae ‘TEBACHOL 1 ALCHI LOROACHOH ©. SOMA Ne cama | A TaWKE BCE BBILIE ONPOWeHHbIe CegeTenn nonTsepauny, 4To BLM. NnewkaHos He BbipaKarica HeUeHaypHO!A BpaHbio. B caolo >ke ouepene, McxonA us conepxaHia NoctaHoBneHis, cya nepsoi MicTaHuWn ycTaHoBMn B KaYeCTBe CO6bITMA anMUHuCTpaTMBHOrO nnaROHANVieHia OBcTosTenbctsa, vanoxKeHHbIe cauperensmll , B YacTHocTH: BLM. Mnewkatos «...oKaabiean Ha npoqasua _ AGHKOsMOUHOHANbHOe BosgelicTaMe Banfy HeocBenOMNeHHocTH nocnegHeli 06 oTTeHKax yseToR drara PecnyGmuKH Yxpauity, SbICKASbIBAN HAMEPEHME MOUNTS TaKOBOM CAMOCTOATENLHO, BbIBECHT Ha GaNKON cBoero OXWNUYA, YOTPEGUB NH STOM BbipaKeHHE rpyOOl HeYeHSYpHOM Opal 8 OTHOWeHAN opraHoB rocygapcreennol GesonacHocTa MpugvecTposcKoi Mongasckon PecnyGanki. Tipn stom B Xone cyneGHoro sacenanna B.M. MnewKaHos He Gbin nocTaBneH B MSBECTHOCTe, WTO cy PaccMatpeaeT B KaYecTBe COOLITAA ARMUHUCTPATHBHOTO npaBoHapyuleHnA unbIE OGcTosTenbcrBa HexeNK Te, KoTOpEIe ykKasaHb! B MpoToKoNe 06 aqMHHUcTpATMBHOM Mpapovapywennn Ne 2077509 or 05 anpens 2022 rona. B cnoxknewelica curyaunn cy nepBoit MHCTaHMM HapywMn & oTHOUIeHMN BLM. NnewkaHopa «npaso ObITb HesaMeAAWTeENbHO MU NOAPOGHO YBeAOMNeHHBIM Ha NOHATHOM emy SabIKe © XapaKTepe M ocHoBaHHM MpeABABNeHHOFO emy OGBMHEHHA”, FapalTupopannoro nyHKTom «a» § 3 craTeM 6 EaponelicKoli KOHBeHUMM O sauIMTe npaB Yenopexa W OcHoBHEIx cB0Gon (nanee — KonBeHus). 1.3. _Bmecre ¢ Tem, 8 cao’ Moctaxosnenun cyp nepaoi mcTaHuMM He npuBén AokasaTenbcTB Toro, YTO yKasaHHOe BbIpaxeHve B.M. MnewKAHOBa B OTHOWeHHN OpraHos rocynapcraeHHoli GesonacHoctu no caoeli CemaHTnke OTHOCIITCA K HeLieHaypHo Spann, Npn stom, Henposenenne cyfeSHO! AMHFEMCTUNeCKO! SKCNEpTHSbI Cy NepBO! MHOTAHUMA MoTuBMpoBAN Tem, uO «ynoTpeGneHHOe MTneUiKaHOBbIM B.M. 8 anpec opraHoe rocynapcTBeHHov Sesonachocta MpnanecrposcKol MonqascKon Pecny6nuKi, HOCHT ABHO HeLIeHaypHeili Gann zapakep». CyA Nepeoli uHCTAHUMN He YoMOTPeN NPaBOBLIK 3aTPYAKEHHIi B TOM, WTO yrcHeHNE CmbICnOBOrO sHAYeHMA eANHHY AgbIKA NeXKUT 3a NpeAenamn 1OpuANMECKOrO aManuea, MANA ene BbiicHeHMA OBcYeHTHOCTH ynoTpeGneHHO! B.M. MnewKaHOBbIM neKcHkH TpeGosanvce cheumanbHble NOSHAHMA B MMHTBMCTIKe, TO eCTb B AeNe, Kak OHO NPeACTaBNeHO cyAOM nepson WHCTaHUMM, Tpe6oBanoch nposegeHve nuxreuctH4eckoH sKkcnepTuaui. Mexay tem, ynorpe6nénHoe B.M. MnewkaHoBbim «abipaxeHie rpy6oli HeLIeHSyPHOM GpaHn B OTHOLUeHMIA OpraHos rocyaapcTBeHHol SesonacHocTH MpugnecrposcKol Mongasckoi Pecny6niku, OMHOHHMUHOe COBY «MCNPAXKHATECAm, WHE NPMMEHUMO K OpraHy rocynapcTseHHol Bact & CFO NPAMOM CMBICNe, a B NepeHOCHOM cMBbICNe (KOTA MB rpYEOM, ORHaKO, He 8 OBCYeHTHOM) CnoBO «o6ocparEca» OsHaYaeT «CRYrATbCAm, sCNbITaTe CNHI CTPAX», UTO HE MOKET BoITb PACUBHEHO, Kak HOCAUGE «BHO HEYEHSypHEIli Span xapaKTep». 1.4. Ha camom gene, cya nepsolt uxcraHyMn ocyuecteun nopmeny co6siTua @AMHHMCTpaTHBHOTO npaBoHapyuleHnA: — © ORHO! cTOpoHtI, cyA nepBor MHCTAH\UNN He ycTaHOBIMN, TO UMeNO MecTO coBEITHE @nuunuctpaTMBHoro npasoHapyuieHna, sacukcnpoBakHoe 8 MpoToKone o6 aaMunuctpaTHeHoM npasoHapyweHin Ne 2077509 or 05 anpena 2022 ropa, a uMeHHO, He yeraHoBvn, Yro B.M. MnewkaHoe «abipaxanca a agpec | HeYeHsypHOr Bpannio .. — © apyroi croporti, cya nepsol utcTaHuMM ycTaHoBun B KayecTBe cobuITHA AQMMHUCTPATHBHOFO NpaBoHapyweHnA He yKasaHHoe B MpoToKone 06 @nMMHUCTpaTHBHOM npaBoHapywexun Ne 2077509 ot 05 anpena 2022 rona: sebipaxeHne rpy6oli HeYeHaypHol Gparn 8 OTHOWeHHM OpraHoB rocygapcrBeHHoit SesonachocTu MpvarecrposcKoli MongascKoli Pecny6nukm, npwuis, cya nepscii 2 WHCTAHYWN He NpHBBN AOKAsATENbCTB Toro, YTO AAKHOe BLIPAKEHHE OTHOCHTCR K oBcueHTHON neKcnKe. Tipu taux oGcTosTenbcTBax, 8 CyAe NepEO! UACTAHUMN He GbINC NopTBePxAeHO COGLITHE a@AMMHVCTpaTHBHOrO NpaBoHapyWeHNA, CTaBUIee OCHOBAHHE ANA CocTaBNeHMA MporoKoNa 06 aAMMHucTpaTHBHOM nnaRoHANuIeHMN Ne 2077509 ot 05 anpena 2022 rona, — a uMeHHO, anpecosanHas ry HeueHsypHan 6palb, — 4TO, B Cuny nyHkTa «a» cTaTeM 24.5 KOAN TIMP, TpeGosano npekpauieHna Aena 06 aaMMHHCTpaTHBHOM npaBoHapyweHHn. Takum o6pasom, CyA nepsoll HHCTAHWMH, NPMMeHHE B OTHOWeHHM B.M. MnewKaHoBa Mepy HakasaHa B BMAe apecta npm OTCyTCTBMM CO6bITHA aAMMHUCTPATHBHOFO npaponapyweHus, Hapywnn npazo B.M. MneuKaHosa Ha caoGoAy 4 mMuHylo HeNPHKOCHOBeHHOCTS B YaCTH «3aKOHHOrO COMepKAHKA NOA CTpaxelt Nya, Ocy>KReHHOTO KOMNeTeHTHbIM cyAOM», FapaHTMpORAHHOrO NYHKTOM «a» § 1 cTaTbH 5 KOHBeHUWM. 2, B cpo&m NocTaosnenun cya nepsolt uHcTaHuMM Aan TonkOBaHHe CTaTbH 27.2 KOAN TIMP, cornacko KoTopomy «npoToKan ABNsETCA OCHOBHOI (bopMOli CbuKCAYMM AOKASATENLCTE 0 enaM 06 afMUHUCTPATHBHEIx NPABOOTHOLIEHHAX, B CBASH C HEM, 2aKOHOAATENECTBOM MOLPOGHO pernamenriposana npouenypa ero cocTasnienns. [pu HapywleHinn yCTaHOBNeHHO! NDOYeAYpe, & cuny nognyxKra r) nyxkra 3 crarby 27.2 KoA MMP, nporoKon He MoxkeT paccmarpusaTEcA & kavecTae fokasaTenbcrea, NOCKONbKy HecoBNoneHHe NPOYeCcyalbHoro NOpAAKa NoMyYeHHNA gokasarenscrea fenaeT ero HEAONyCTUMuIMe. TaKxe cyA yKasan: «CraTeA 29.3 KoAIT [IMP . yeranasnneaer OOsaTenbHble NpaBHNa, KOTOPLIE AOM*HbI Obie COONIOREH’I Np ero cocrasneHii. 2.1. Cornacho nyvikty 2 ctarbn 29.3 KoAN MMP: «B npoToKone 06 anMnHuctpaTHBHOM npasoHapyweHnn yKasbIBaloTCA ... daMUNH, MMeHa, OTYeCTBA, anpeca, MeCTa xuTeNbCTBA cempereneli ..., ecnn umerorca cemgeTenn...». OpHaKO, yNONHOMOUeHHOe AMO cBnAeTeNei HE ykasano 8 MpotoKone 06 anmuHicTpaTusHoM npaBoHapywexun Ne 2077509 or 05 anpens 2022 ropa. COOTBeTCTBEHHO, 8 CMY YKaaHHOrO BbIWe TONKOBAHMA CTaTelt 27.2 w 29.3 KOAN TIMP, rpaxaane f ) | npnenevenbi K yuacTuio B pene B kayectse ceupeTenei B HAPyWeHNM yCTaHOBneHHON NpoYeAyps NPoMsBOACTBA No Reny OO ApMMHMCTpATHBHOM npaBoHapyweHn. Tp Takom nonoxeHi, BbIBOR cyAa NepsoK UHCTAHUMM OG OTCyTCTEHM axwTenbcTea) NOATBEPxMAeT TO, YTO rPaKAaHe, . yMpasOMO'eHHbIM MOM He yCTaHaBNMBaNnce vi He ONpaUiMBaNMc B KaveCTBe CEUpeTeNeH NO Reny 06 agwunveTpaTMBHOM npasoHapyueHMn (nyHkT 1 CTaTeH 25.7 KOAN IIMP), KoTopoe xoTA V1 Guino BOs6yxKeHO ynPABOMOHEHHEIM NMYOM, ODHAKO BOS6yxAEHO GpINC TonbKO OS anpens 2022 roma, 8 TO BPeMA Kak OGRACHEHHA yKAgaHHLIX AMY 6evIN OTOBPaHb! COTPyAHNKAMn Muuctepcraa rocyaapcTseHHoit GesonactHocm MMP (ganee — MIB TIMP) 24 wapra 2022 roa, “TO HemonycTHMo BBNAy «HecOBmogeHMA npoyeccyanbHoro nopsaKa Nonywenua AOKasaTeMbCTBay, A VIMBHHO, CBMQETENLCKHE NOKASAHKA MON GbITe UCTPeGOBAHLI TONKO nocne Boa6yxxneHnA jena 06 AQMMHUCTPATHBHOM NpasoHapyweHHM — nocne cocTasneHHA MporoKona 06 aamincTpaTusHom npascHapyweHnn Ne 2077509 or 05 anpena 2022 ropa u ykasaHna a HéM cBeAeHNA o cBMpETENAX. HecoGniogenve npoyeccyansHoro nopagka npueneyeHna K geny cengereneii, CTaBWIerO pe3ynbTaTOM He3aKOHHOrO BMewlaTenbcTBa CoTpyAHMKos MIB MMP s Pas6npatenbcreo HenogeepoMcTBeHHoro opraHam rocyaapcrseHHol GesonacHocTn jena 06 aAMMHMCTpaTHBHOM NpaBoHapywieHKH, HApPYWHNO B OTHOWeHHH B.M. Nnewkarosa NPHHUHN NpesyMNUWH HEBHHOBHOCTH, 3aKpenmeHHbii B § 2 cTaTbM 6 KOHBeHLMM. 2.2. Cyn nepsolt wHcTaHUWn He Aan OUeHKH PACXOKTeHHAM B NoKagaHHAX cengeTenei, A@HHbIX UMM COTpyAHHKam MIB TIMP 24 mapra 2022 roga u noKasaHiam, KoTOpbIe Goin AaHHbIMH CeMAETENAMH 8 CyAeOHOM saceAaHin. B YaCTHOCTH, KAXKAbIM Hs CBYgeTeNel OTPHYAN, uTO B.M. MnewkaHios Bbipakanca HeyeH3ypHOli 6paHbto. 2.3. Hapywenne npouenypsi npusnevenva ny 8 KauecTBe cBMpeTenei no peny O6 @QMUHVCTPaTMBHOM NpaBoHapyWeHMM CTaNO cneAcTBMeM HecObmiogeHnAa Muuucrepcraom rocynapcTsenHol GesonactHoctw MMP tpeGosanuii nogsenomctsenHoctn jena. Bmewarenbcteo MIB NMP 8 npovsBogcreo no Aeny 06 anmnductpaTueHom npasoxapyweHin Mo crate 20.1 KoAN TIMP cya nepeoii nicTanumi onpasaan CcbINKoli Ha nyHKT 8) YacTh nepeoli craTen 9 GakoHa TIMP «O rocyaapcreeHHoi cny>xKGe GSesonacHoctn MpwavectpoBcKoii MongascKoi Pecny6nuxw, oTHeca cop moKasatenbcTe no Aeny 0 MenKOM xynuraHcTBe K «Gopb6e ¢ MpecTyMHOCTHIO HM SKCTPEMUsMOM», MOCKONbKY «gelicTBA UM BbICKaSbIBAHIIA AnewkaHoBa B.M. uMenn sBHo abipaKeHHyio MeXKAYHAPORHO-NONUTHMECKYIO NOGONAeKY» Wi nip yeasaHtbix OGcTORTeNbCTBaX AeMCTBUA COTPYDHMKOB rocypapcTBeHHON GesonacHocT umenn Yenbio HenonyweHue «qecTabunuzayun o6uecTBa uM npeceYeHuA yrpos GesonacHocTi. Onwako, geiictana BM. Mnewkalosa He nonnanaiot nog npusHaKu «npectynHoctn u SKCTPEMMSMa», COREPKAWIMECA B CTaTbe 12 ykagaHHOrO SaKoHa, a NOTOMY elicTBKA cotpyaHukos MIB IMP, cassatibie c BMewaTenbcTBOM B MpovsBoACTBO no aeny 06 @AMMHCTpaTHBHOM npasoHxapyweHun B.M. ManewKaHora no cratee 20.1 KoAN TIMP, He G6binu OcHOBaHbI Ha saKoHe. Eeponelicknit cya no npagam venoseka sananan, uo cornacHo TpeGonakism § 2 crate 6 KOHBeHuMM cya OMKeH NpWsHABATe OGEMHAeMOTO BMHOBHBIM TONbKO Ha OCHOBAHUK AoKasaTenbeTB, «AOCTaTOUHO yGeaMTeNnbHEIX 8 rnasax 3aKOHa ana ycTaHosnenna BMHOBHOCTH» (Hanp., MoctaHoaneHne ECM no geny «Austria v. Italy», 6YB 740, 784 (1963), Com. Rep., CM Res DH (63) 3). Mpw ykasanHex apie o6ctosTenbcTsax HesakoHHoro c6opa Aoka3arenbcrs coTpyAHukamu MP6 TIMP 6 otHoweHnm B.M. MnewKkanosa HapywieH APMHUMN NpesymMnuynn HEBMHOBHOCTH, 3aKpenneHHbii B § 2 cTaTbu 6 Koxpenymn. 2.4. TipwHuman 80 BHUMaHHe KMO4es0h XapaKTep elicTeui coTpyAHMKOB rocynapcrsexHoh GesonacHoctu O.A. SyGuHa m E.Q SloraHosa no yctaHosnenimo Npasovapywenns u cOopy RokasaTenscrs nporus B.M. MnewkaHoBa, gonpoc panHbix CompyAHKOB MCB OMPoumensnoiianieossHavenne ANA pena. B vactHocTu, camperenn NoKasann cyay nepsoli uNCTAHYMM, YTO HUIKTO 13 Hux He O6pauanca 6 MIB MMP B ceasn c AelicTevamn B.M. MnewkaHopa. Taxxe COTPYAHMKU MIB AMP mornn 6p NOACHUTb, KaKM O6Pa30M MM CTaNnO Vi3BeCTHO oO nMuHOCTY BLM. Nnewkarosa po nonyueHns noKasaHuih oT aro nonTaepxnaercA cororpacueli_8 MaTepvanax nena, KoTonWO coTpyaHKn MIB FMP npencrasunu Npw Aonpoce nocnepKux. Mloxasanis corpyaHakos MI TIMP Morn Gel BHeCTH ACHOCTs 8 BOnpoc o CKpETOM Mpecnenosannn B.M. MnewkaHowa, KoTOpoe Takxe noATBepxKAaeTcA eLIs onHuMA MaTepnanamm agMulcrpatueHoro nena no nyHKTy 1 crate 20.1 KoAN TIMP, sos6yxqeHHoro Mporokonom 06 aaMnnucrparnaiom npasonapywennn Ne 2105815 or 12 wan 2022 rona npn ananorMutibx O6cToRTeNbCTEaX noceweHuA maraguHa B.M. MnewkaHoBbim uv aHanormuHoro 6opa HoKasaTentcTs corpyaHiikamn MIB TIMP. Ovako, cya nepsoit mHcTaHUAN AMUN BM. 4 Nnewxatiosa «npasa Ha To, 4To6bI 9TH cBMAeTenM GbinM AONPOWeHbI», Hem HapyWinn npoueccyanbuble rapaHTun nyHkra «d> § 3 craTbu 6 KoHBeHUMM. 2.5. Cyn nepsot wictanyan He npusén yOeanTenbHbix AOBOAOB, OnpaBALIBAOLANx ocrasnenue xogataiictsa sautHiKa C.P. MonoscKoro 0 Bbisope B Ka4eCcTBe cBugeTenei COTpyAHHKOB rocynapcTBeHHo GezonacHoct O.A. Sy6uHa n E.f\ NlormHosa NOSBONAET CyAY BBIACHUTH MHeHMe pykKoBoAcTeA MIB TIMP 0 spigone yKasaHHbix cBugeTenei. Take fevicTeua cyfa nepsof MHCTaHUMM Hapywinnn B oTHoweHn B.M. MnewkaHopa «npaso Ha cnpaseannace pas6upatenbcrso ... AeNa ... HegaBiicumbiM 4 GecnpucTpacTHbIM CyAOM ...», rapaHTMpoBaHHoe § 1 cTaTbn 6 KonBeHUMn. 3. B Moctanosnexun ormeuexo: «B nporoKone MnewkaHoe B.M. YononHinn sanuce 0 TOM, ATO OMY HE PASBACHEHEI ero NPABA, OAHAKO CYA K STOMY OTHOCHTCA KDUTHYECKH, NOCKONDKY 8 npoToKone e rpacbax 06 OsHaKOMNeHHIH ¢ NpabaMn, NDEAYCMOTPEHHbIMH CraTeAMH 25.2, 26.1, 1.4 cr. 29.3 u cr. 30.1 KoAM TIMP. copepxares nognicu, npnHagnexHocTe KOTOpsIX cBoeMy asropcray Mnewkaroe B.M. nogTeepgun 8 cyfe6HoM saceganiim. C AaHHbIM BbIBOROM cyna CornacmTecs Henb3A, NOCKONbKY CyA NepBO! MHCTAHUNH He yoTAHaBNMBAN, PAsvACHANUCE AM Ha camom gene B.M. Mnewkaxosy ero npasa n oGagaHHocTH. Mph TakOi cuTyaum, Koraa B.M TnewKalos ueTko u scHO ykasan B MporoKone 06 aAMMHuCTpaTHIBHOM npasoHapyweHMM Ne 2077509 or 05 anpena 2022 roga 0 TOM, 4TO eMy He PaSBACHEHBI NPaBa HM OOASAHHOCTH, HeyCTpaHMMBIe COMHEHMA B TOM AOMKHbI ObINN paspewaTecA He yCTaHoBneHnem npvnagnexHoctu nognucu B.M. MnewkaHosy, a npumeneHnem o6wero npasuna, saxpennéxvoro 8 nyrikte 4 crarbv 1.5 KOAN TIMP 0 Tom, 4To HeycTpaHMMbie COMHeHMA 8 BVHOBHOCTH NMua, NPHBNeKAeMOrO K ANMMHUCTPATHBHON OTBETCTBEHHOCTH, TONKYIOTCA B NONbSy storo nia. Takum o6pasom, cyA nepsow WCTaHWMM HapyWMn npAHUMN npesymnunn HeBMHOBHOCTH, rapaHTMpoRaHibli § 2 crate 6 KoHBeHYH. 4. Kak ykasaHo BbIMe, CYA NepBON VHCTAHUMN NpUsHAN, 4TO «RelicrENNA M BbICKasbIEAHHA Tnewxatosa B.M Men spKo BbipaKeHHylo MeXxAYHEpOAHO-nonuTHYECKyIO nog“ONNeKy». Dlelicreurensxo, noxynaa TkaHM rony6oro v >kéNTOrO YBeTOB ANA NyGNM4HO saRBNeHHO! YeNn TOWMBKH ykpaMHcKOrO (bara W abICTABNeHMM ero Ha GanKoHe coBcTBeHHO! KBapTupbl, BM. MnewKarios suipasin cao’ mHeHe © noAep>kke YkpaMHbi 4 yKpaMHCKOrO Haposa B OTPAKeHMM BOeHHO arpeccun Poccun (cm. Pesoniounio TeHepanbHol accam6nen OOH 3314 «O6 arpeccum» or 14.12.1974r.). CoorsercTseHHo, cnenys anropuTmy aHannsa, npumeHsiemomy EeponeiicKum cynom no npasam enoseka np HapyuleHnAx cTatbn 10 KoHBeHUMM, CocTasneHMe npoToKona o6 @AMMHUCTpATHBHOM npaBoHapyweHun Ne 2077509 or 05.04.2022r. npeacrasnaet coon «eMewaTenscTeo» B npaso B.M. MnewkaHoza Ha csoGony BbIPaKeHNA MHEHUA. TIpvnuimaa Bo BHUMAHNe yKagaHHbIe BbIe HApyWeHHiA MaTepnanLHoro H NPoYeCcyaNsHoro npasa np npovssoncrae mena 06 ANMMHMCTPATHBHOM NpAaBCHAPyWeHHM, MOXHO saKNIOUNTE, UTO AaHHOe BMeUIATENCTBO He 6eiNO «OCHOBAHO Ha sakoHer (MNoctaHoBneHMe ECMY no peny «Hashman and Harrup v. the United Kingdom», N 2594/94, §34, ECHR 1999-VIll), a cneposarencio, 8 oTHoWeHHH B.M. MnewkaHoBa HapywieHa cTaTbA 10 KoHBeHunn. Vicxona us usno>xeHHoro, pykosoqcTaysct cr.cr. 24.5, 31.1-31.3, 31.7 KAM MMP, npocum: oTMeHMT MoctaHosnekwe no feny 06 aAMMHMCTpATHBHOM npaBoHapywieHMK B oTHoweHin B.M. MnewkaHopa, npeaycmotpeHHoro YacTbIo 1 cTatbu 20.1 KoAN TIMP, 4 NpexpaTutb npovssoAcTse no Aeny 06 anMMHNCTpATHBHOM NpasoHapyuleHWn & BUAY OTCYTCTBNS COGEITHS aNMMHUCTPATHBHOTO NPaBoHapyuleHAs. «13» won 2022 ropa SauTHuk B.M. NnewkaHosa: C.P. NonoscKnin SIayo, npusneKaemoe k aNMMHNCTPATHBHO; OTBETCTBEHHOCTH: B.M. MnewxKaxos Apunonecruce ! KOnRW EL Dokepenncomy om C8, OL dh,

Вам также может понравиться