Delivery Reasonin Structur Constructiv

(30)
g (30)
e (15)
e (15)
1 Rio Giovno Setiawan UKSW
20
23
12
10
2 As'ari
STAIN Jember
16
18
9
8
3 Kristo Karya
London School of PR
18
16
10
6
4 Jhendra Samodra
UGM A
26
26
14
14
5 Framita Rahmah
UNHAS B
19
21
9
10
6 Ketherin Rothe SoekiasUKSW
21
20
11
9
7 Marsha Faradina
ITB C
26
23
14
14
8 Gladys Brigita
ITB A
27
22
14
14
9 Widya Lionita
POLSRI
21
17
10
7
10 Angga Wibowo Gultom IM TELKOM A
20
18
10
7
11 Rurri Pramanda
IM TELKOM B
21
23
10
8
12 Dyah Puspitaloka
IPB A
19
18
7
7
13 Ni Komang Triagustini STIKES Bali
19
19
8
8
14 Zaikal Arifin Abbas
PNUP
21
22
10
9
15 Hendy Prihambudi
STAN
23
22
12
9
16 Fiski Aditya
ITB B
19
19
9
7
17 Cillvia Komalakatristya UAD
20
20
12
13
18 Tita Ratna Wulandari Bina Darma A
17
12
7
3
19 Kartini
Bina Darma B
17
12
8
2
20 Annisa
BINUS
16
12
7
2
21 Nadya
Brawijaya A
16
16
8
6
22 Trisakti Agriani
Brawijaya B
15
17
8
2
23 Amelia Dita Tifani
UNDIP A
15
15
10
3
24 Astrid Ayutasari
UNDIP B
21
21
12
6
25 Gray Lawrence
UGM B
20
20
15
7
26 Dian Utami Mas Bakar UNHAS A
10
10
10
5
27 Muh.Yogi Pratama
UNHAS C
18
17
9
1
28 Adlini Ilma Ghaisany
UI A
25
25
15
13
29 Aulia Anggita Larasati UI B
24
22
11
7
30 Egalita Irfan
UI C
23
23
15
12
31 Norsyifa Islamiyah
UNISKA
10
10
7
2
32 Siti Anisah Nayyiroh
UIN Maliki Malang
14
11
7
2
33 Yeni Mujiatin
UNSOED
16
20
10
8
34 Wijaya
Atma Jkt A
16
16
8
3
35 Richard Hanjaya
Atma Jkt B
21
23
14
12
36 Ivana Mary Puspitasari UKSW A
19
22
13
8
37 Kiki Kurniawati
UKSW B
22
23
13
12
38 Riky Novriansyah
Lambung Mangkurat
13
15
10
6
39 Arsyad
UNISMUH
14
11
6
1
40 Dana Kotahatuhaha
UMY A
16
16
8
6
41 Mutiara Putri Pradiphta UMY B
16
16
8
3
42 Helmi Pratiwi
Negeri Makassar
13
16
10
5
43 Aan Frisca
Negeri Malang A
15
20
10
5
44 Karnia Putri Pangestu Negeri Malang B
10
17
10
6
45 Mustika Aji Hertanto
UNNES A
13
16
10
6
46 Wuri Prima KusumastutiUNNES B
10
10
7
5

No

Name

Institution

47 Westra
48 Tiola
49 Gustin Lawis
50 Adria Cemara
51 Juli Adriana Siboro
52 Rhei Tambunan
53 Angga Okta Pria
54 Ervin Chandrawati
55 Faizan Naafi'
56 M. Subhan Fikri
57 Dera Menra Sijabat
58 Edrida
59 Indra Kusuma
60 Sabaruddin
61 Fanny Judistia
62 Cresti Eka
63 Dwita
64 Edwin Dirgantara
65 Elisa Agustin Tanzil

UNPAD
UNPAR
Sanata Dharma A
Sanata Dharma B
USU
LP3I Medan
UMM
ISI Surakarta
UM
UNLAM
UNIMED
LP31 Jakarta
UI
Binus
UNDIP
UNDIP
UNPAR
STAN
UNPAR

10
25
5
5
9
16
17
5
7
11
15
10
22
20
15
22
24
23
26

10
20
10
10
10
11
14
5
7
12
10
10
23
24
13
22
24
25
27

8
15
10
10
10
7
8
1
5
6
10
7
14
12
10
13
15
13
11

3
6
5
3
4
2
2
1
5
2
3
4
12
10
6
10
13
9
11

Scorin
g (10)
4
3
3
7
4
5
8
8
4
4
8
6
4
7
6
9
6
7
5
6
8
5
2
7
7
6
8
10
10
9
6
4
5
5
9
5
7
4
3
2
5
7
7
5
7
2

Total
69
54
53
87
63
66
85
85
59
59
70
57
58
69
72
63
71
46
44
43
54
47
45
67
69
41
53
88
74
82
35
38
59
48
79
67
77
48
35
48
48
51
57
48
52
34

70%
48.3
37.8
37.1
60.9
44.1
46.2
59.5
59.5
41.3
41.3
49
39.9
40.6
48.3
50.4
44.1
49.7
32.2
30.8
30.1
37.8
32.9
31.5
46.9
48.3
28.7
37.1
61.6
51.8
57.4
24.5
26.6
41.3
33.6
55.3
46.9
53.9
33.6
24.5
33.6
33.6
35.7
39.9
33.6
36.4
23.8

Written
Grade
Score
72 C+
40 T
72 T
92 A
68 C64 T
92 A
80 A
52 T
64 T
72 B
84 T
76 T
70 C+
80 B++
76
68
80
84
76
60
64
72
68
92
60
72
96
84
84
48
68
80
84
96
84
84
64
60
60
60
56
76
64
68
64

Tengah

Highest score..
Plus and minus elaborate ,preAfff talk about violenc
Affirmative have to elaborate more. Background isn't
Below average - Average. 2 clash. Whether it can be g
Below to average. 2 clashes, the government. Technic
Boxing in ring and in media. Clash identified correctly
Responded well, sport can affect people who watched
Tengah, ragu jadi chair
Should bring the debate to the extent of Ban. They ca
A bit too hard to be placed as C- grade adjudicator.
Tengah, agak kepanjangan. Don't be late in respondin
Tengah maks, CHAIR.

1
8
8
6
1
6
9
1
2
7
1
2
8
10
7
7
9
8
10

32
74
38
34
34
42
50
13
26
38
39
33
79
76
51
74
85
78
85

22.4
51.8
26.6
23.8
23.8
29.4
35
9.1
18.2
26.6
27.3
23.1
55.3
53.2
35.7
51.8
59.5
54.6
59.5

76
88
76
76
72
40
60
40
62
60
64
88
88
80
84
88
92
72
92

eAfff talk about violence please. The bad impact for the children. But do explain what is that. Per sepaker analy
more. Background isn't proper. If boxing isn't sport then what. Aneh, tapi lumayan
ash. Whether it can be given to one. Boxing don't see technic, only one parameter not two. No mechanism.. How
he government. Technic. Negative did not negate whether this is wrong. Negative didn't respond to the core of
ash identified correctly. 2 points from the prop. Why boxing is classified as sport. Not good to explain about it to
ct people who watched. The match be held.

extent of Ban. They can't explain why only boxing. Those arguments won't be seen as big. Lack a succesful en
C- grade adjudicator.
on't be late in responding.

at. Per sepaker analysis. Too much talking on the personal details. TV has done an influence

No mechanism.. How the mechanism would go. Why violence can be justified. Only came in Rifan. So no credit
spond to the core of the idea. Boxing did not promote peace and togetherness. IT is then even harder for the ne
to explain about it too much. What is the clashes. Margin 1.

. Lack a succesful engagement. Give a strong engagement to the motion..

in Rifan. So no credit is given. How boxing gave negative impact. Actor per actor per basis, late. To RIfan.. View
ven harder for the negative to engage. Although Rifan rebutted with Sumo and Karate. Unfortunately it's too lat

, late. To RIfan.. Viewer can be dissapointed, gender 75, 76. 73. equality. This is going nowhere. But no extensiv
ortunately it's too late. Negative should have been able to realize this since the beginning. Credit to gov. Impac

here. But no extensive explanation. Clear parameter, gov can explain more on the transfer of value. Options th
Credit to gov. Impact caused by Boxing. Hard to follow negative explanation. Should give more credit to the g

r of value. Options that could be likely chosen. Capitalize status quo is enou
more credit to the govt (why? You didn't show they did it better. Illlegal boxing, equality. It might. Concrete pro

t might. Concrete proposal, don't be too blur. EMphasize the significance point that is being brought. For negati

g brought. For negative prrove the stance

No

Name

1 Adlini Ilma Ghaisany

2 Lutfi Abdurahman
3 Jhendra Samodra
4 Dwita
5 Dito Krista
6 Rakhmat Taufik
7 Marsha Faradina
8 Richard Hanjaya
9 Elisa Agustin Tanzil
10 Karina Patrita
11 Ahdiat Permana
12 Janette Kumalasari
13 Gentur Adi Utama
14 Egalita Irfan
15 Danny Tanuwijaya
16 Lieke Widowiat
17 Indra Kusuma
18 Abdurrahman
19 Gladys Brigita
20 Cresti Eka
21 Sabaruddin
22 Aulia Anggita Larasati
23 Kiki Kurniawati
24 Tiola
25 Gray Lawrence
26 Hendy Prihambudi
27 Zaikal Arifin Abbas
28 Cillvia Komalakatristya
29 Edwin Dirgantara
30 Ivana Mary Puspitasari
31 Rio Giovno Setiawan
32 Astrid Ayutasari
33 Aan Frisca
34 Fiski Aditya
35 Dyah Puspitaloka
36 Yeni Mujiatin
37 Rurri Pramanda
38 Framita Rahmah
39 Ketherin Rothe Soekias
40 Ni Komang Triagustini
41 Muh.Yogi Pratama
42 Fanny Judistia
43 Nadya
44 Mustika Aji Hertanto
45 Karnia Putri Pangestu

Institution
UI A
ITB
UGM A
UNPAR
ITB
STAN
ITB C
Atma Jkt B
UNPAR
ITB
UI
Atmaja JKT
UGM
UI C
UNPAD
Atmaja JKT
UI
STAN
ITB A
UNDIP
Binus
UI B
UKSW B
UNPAR
UGM B
STAN
PNUP
UAD
STAN
UKSW A
UKSW
UNDIP B
Negeri Malang A
ITB B
IPB A
UNSOED
IM TELKOM B
UNHAS B
UKSW
STIKES Bali
UNHAS C
UNDIP
Brawijaya A
UNNES A
Negeri Malang B

Initial
Written Verbal Total
Accreditatio
(30%) (70%) Score
n
28.8 61.6 90.4
A
86
A
27.6 60.9 88.5
A
27.6 59.5 87.1
A
86
A
86
A
27.6 59.5 87.1
A
28.8 55.3 84.1
B
27.6 59.5 87.1
A
86
A
86
A
86
A
86
A
25.2 57.4 82.6
B
86
A
86
A
26.4 55.3 81.7
B
86
A
24 59.5 83.5
B
26.4 51.8 78.2
B
24 53.2 77.2
B
25.2 51.8
77
B
25.2 53.9 79.1
B
26.4 51.8 78.2
B
27.6 48.3 75.9
B
24 50.4 74.4
C
21 48.3 69.3
C
20.4 49.7 70.1
C
21.6 54.6 76.2
B
25.2 46.9 72.1
C
21.6 48.3 69.9
C
20.4 46.9 67.3
C
22.8 39.9 62.7
C
22.8 44.1 66.9
C
25.2 39.9 65.1
C
24 41.3 65.3
C
21.6
49 70.6
C
20.4 44.1 64.5
C
19.2 46.2 65.4
C
22.8 40.6 63.4
C
21.6 37.1 58.7
T
25.2 35.7 60.9
C
18 37.8 55.8
T
20.4 36.4 56.8
T
19.2 33.6 52.8
T

46 Tita Ratna Wulandari

Bina Darma A
47 Wijaya
Atma Jkt A
48 Angga Wibowo Gultom IM TELKOM A
49 Dana Kotahatuhaha
UMY A
50 Gustin Lawis
Sanata Dharma A
51 Mutiara Putri Pradiphta UMY B
52 Widya Lionita
POLSRI
53 Kartini
Bina Darma B
54 Angga Okta Pria
UMM
55 Riky Novriansyah
Lambung Mangkurat
56 Amelia Dita Tifani
UNDIP A
57 Kristo Karya
London School of PR
58 Dera Menra Sijabat
UNIMED
59 Helmi Pratiwi
Negeri Makassar
60 Annisa
BINUS
61 Adria Cemara
Sanata Dharma B
62 Westra
UNPAD
63 Siti Anisah Nayyiroh
UIN Maliki Malang
64 Juli Adriana Siboro
USU
65 Edrina
LP31 Jakarta
66 Dian Utami Mas Bakar UNHAS A
67 Wuri Prima KusumastutiUNNES B
68 Trisakti Agriani
Brawijaya B
69 As'ari
STAIN Jember
70 M. Subhan Fikri
UNLAM
71 Arsyad
UNISMUH
72 Rhei Tambunan
LP3I Medan
73 Norsyifa Islamiyah
UNISKA
74 Faizan Naafi'
UM
75 Ervin Chandrawati
ISI Surakarta

24
25.2
19.2
18
22.8
18
15.6
25.2
18
19.2
21.6
21.6
19.2
16.8
22.8
22.8
22.8
20.4
21.6
26.4
18
19.2
19.2
12
18
18
12
14.4
18.6
12

32.2
33.6
41.3
33.6
26.6
33.6
41.3
30.8
35
33.6
31.5
37.1
27.3
35.7
30.1
23.8
22.4
26.6
23.8
23.1
28.7
23.8
32.9
37.8
26.6
24.5
29.4
24.5
18.2
9.1

56.2
58.8
60.5
51.6
49.4
51.6
56.9
56
53
52.8
53.1
58.7
46.5
52.5
52.9
46.6
45.2
47
45.4
49.5
46.7
43
52.1
49.8
44.6
42.5
41.4
38.9
36.8
21.1

T
T
C
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T

Initial
Total
Final
Feedbac
Accreditatio Accreditatio Accrediitatio
k (30%)
A
B
C
T
n (70%)
n Score
n
24.61
63.28
87.89
A
15 11 16
33
26.48
60.2
86.68
A
23.44
61.95
85.39
A
24.38
60.97
85.35
A
24.61
60.2
84.81
A
24.61
60.2
84.81
A
23.54
60.97
84.51
A
25.31
58.87
84.18
A
23.13
60.97
84.10
A
23.67
60.2
83.87
A
23.20
60.2
83.40
A
23.20
60.2
83.40
A
22.97
60.2
83.17
A
25.08
57.82
82.90
A
22.27
60.2
82.47
B
22.23
60.2
82.43
B
24.84
57.19
82.03
B
21.56
60.2
81.76
B
22.50
58.45
80.95
B
23.44
54.74
78.18
B
23.67
54.04
77.71
B
23.44
53.9
77.34
B
21.25
55.37
76.62
B
21.88
54.74
76.62
B
22.50
53.13
75.63
B
22.81
52.08
74.89
B
21.96
48.51
70.47
B
21.38
49.07
70.45
B
16.88
53.34
70.22
B
19.69
50.47
70.16
B
20.94
48.93
69.87
B
22.50
47.11
69.61
B
25.63
43.89
69.52
B
22.50
46.83
69.33
B
21.56
45.57
67.13
B
19.38
45.71
65.09
B
15.63
49.42
65.05
B
19.69
45.15
64.84
C
18.13
45.78
63.91
C
19.38
44.38
63.76
C
21.09
41.09
62.18
C
15
18.38
42.63
61.01
C
21.88
39.06
60.94
C
19.69
39.76
59.45
C
21.88
36.96
58.84
C

18.75
16.56
15.00
20.63
21.88
20.31
16.56
16.56
18.44
17.50
17.19
12.50
20.63
16.25
15.94
20.31
20.63
19.06
19.06
15.31
16.88
19.06
11.56
13.13
14.06
15.00
14.06
15.31
15.63
12.19

39.34
41.16
42.35
36.12
34.58
36.12
39.83
39.2
37.1
36.96
37.17
41.09
32.55
36.75
37.03
32.62
31.64
32.9
31.78
34.65
32.69
30.1
36.47
34.86
31.22
29.75
28.98
27.23
25.76
14.77

58.09
57.72
57.35
56.75
56.46
56.43
56.39
55.76
55.54
54.46
54.36
53.59
53.18
53.00
52.97
52.93
52.27
51.96
50.84
49.96
49.57
49.16
48.03
47.99
45.28
44.75
43.04
42.54
41.39
26.96

C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
C
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T
T

Feedback

No

Name

1 Adlini Ilma Ghaisany

2 Jhendra Samodra
3 Marsha Faradina
4 Dwita
5 Elisa Agustin Tanzil
6 Ahdiat Permana
7 Janette
8 Lieke Widowiat
9 Gentur Adi Utama
10 Lutfi Abdurahman
11 Dito Krista
12 Karina Patrita
13 Danny Tanuwijaya
14 Abdurrahman
15 Rakhmat Taufik
16 Richard Hanjaya
17 Gladys Brigita
18 Egalita Irfan
19 Indra Kusuma
20 Kiki Kurniawati
21 Tiola
22 Cresti Eka
23 Sabaruddin
24 Aulia Anggita Larasati
25 Edwin Dirgantara
26 Gray Lawrence
27 Hendy Prihambudi
28 Ivana Mary Puspitasari
29 Rurri Pramanda
30 Cillvia Komalakatristya
31 Rio Giovno Setiawan
32 Zaikal Arifin Abbas
33 Astrid Ayutasari
34 Fiski Aditya
35 Katherin Rothe Soekias
36 Yeni Mujiatin
37 Dyah Puspitaloka
38 Framita Rahmah
39 Ni Komang Triagustini
40 Aan Frisca
41 Fanny Judistia
42 Angga Wibowo Gultom
43 Wijaya
44 Kristo Karya
45 Muh.Yogi Pratama
46 Widya Lionita

Round1
1 2
UI A
7 13
UGM A
13 15
ITB C
12 13
UNPAR
14 8
UNPAR
13 14
UI
15 13
Atmaja JKT
13 13
Atmaja JKT
11 13
UGM
11 13
ITB
11 16
ITB
11 15
ITB
12 12
UNPAD
12 14
STAN
9
STAN
12 13
Atma Jkt B
11 16
ITB A
12 14
UI C
12 13
UI
14 12
UKSW B
13
UNPAR
12 14
UNDIP
12
Binus
16 13
UI B
12 12
STAN
8 12
UGM B
13
STAN
13
UKSW A
11
IM TELKOM B
11
UAD
11
UKSW
12
PNUP
11
UNDIP B
11
ITB B
13
UKSW
10
UNSOED
12
IPB A
10
UNHAS B
13
STIKES Bali
10
Negeri Malang A
15
UNDIP
12
IM TELKOM A
9
Atma Jkt A
11
London School of PR
7
UNHAS C
7
POLSRI
10
Institution

Feedback
Round2 Round3 Round4 Round5
1
2 1
2
1
2
1
14 13 16 13 16 13
11 13 9 11 12 16
12 16 12
9 13 13
11 14 12 14 15 16
16 12 15
4
13 13 10 13 10 12
14 14 13
8 15
9
16
8 11 12 12
9 14 14 13 12 12
16 13 15 14 16 12
15 15 11 13 11 14
13 13 12 13 13 13
13
6 11 15 13 11
14 12 12 13 12
5
11 12 13 14 15 15
11 10 16 16 14 14
7 12 9 14 14 14
14 13 15 14 13 13
14 11 13 14 16 12
10
12
11
11
14 13 4 13 15
5
13
12 12 13
13
10 12 11 13 14 12
14 13 11 11 13 14
8 10 6
8 10 10
12
11
12
12
10
12
12
14
12
13
9
9
7
5
8
10
11
13
10
12
12
8
12
13
14
13
7 14
10
12
12
11
13
11
13
12
11
9
10
10
10
10
6
13
9
11
12
8
13
10
10
13
7
11
12
7
9
13
13
14
13
7
10
10
10
7
4
12
11
11
6
10
7
7
5
7
7
11
14
13
SWING
9
12
8
6

47 Mustika Aji Hertanto

UNNES A
48 Tita Ratna Wulandari
Bina Darma A
49 Kartini
Bina Darma B
50 Nadya
Brawijaya A
51 Amelia Dita Tifani
UNDIP A
52 Angga Okta Pria
UMM
53 Annisa
BINUS
54 Riky Novriansyah
Lambung Mangkurat
55 Karnia Putri Pangestu Negeri Malang B
56 Helmi Pratiwi
Negeri Makassar
57 Trisakti Agriani
Brawijaya B
58 Dana Kotahatuhaha
UMY A
59 Mutiara Putri Pradiphta UMY B
60 As'ari
STAIN Jember
61 Edrida
LP31 Jakarta
62 Gustin Lawis
Sanata Dharma A
63 Siti Anisah Nayyiroh
UIN Maliki Malang
64 Dian Utami Mas Bakar UNHAS A
65 Adria Cemara
Sanata Dharma B
66 Dera Menra Sijabat
UNIMED
67 Juli Adriana Siboro
USU
68 Westra
UNPAD
69 M. Subhan Fikri
UNLAM
70 Wuri Prima KusumastutiUNNES B
71 Arsyad
UNISMUH
72 Rhei Tambunan
LP3I Medan
73 Norsyifa Islamiyah
UNISKA
74 Faizan Naafi'
UM
75 Ervin Chandrawati
ISI Surakarta

13
10
9
11
5
9
9
7
11
9
6
11
8
8
9
10
9
11
11
8
11
14
7
13
7
12
8
6
5

13
13
10
12
8
11
8
9
10
10
5
13
13
6
8
11
10
6
11
10
8
10
8
12
9
10
9
9
6

7
9
11
13
11
11
9
10
11
7
9
9
10
7
4
12
9
12
8
11
11
11
7
6
7
5
4
9
4

6
9
5
11
7
12
8
9
14
9
8
12
13
4
7
13
9
4
13
9
9
5
7
9
7
7
9
6
9

12
12
9
11
13
8
10
12
11
9
5
10
10
8
11
11
11
11
10
13
10
14
8
12
9
4
10
10
4

Final
Round5 Round6
Feedback
Average
2
1
2
Score
13.13
82.03
12.50
78.13
13
12.56
78.47
13.00
81.25
12.33
77.08
12.38
77.34
12.38
77.34
11.86
74.11
12.25
76.56
14.13
88.28
13.13
82.03
12.63
78.91
11.88
74.22
15
11.50
71.88
13.13
82.03
13.50
84.38
12.00
75.00
13.38
83.59
13.25
82.81
11
11.33
70.83
15
11.67
72.92
12.50
78.13
12.63
78.91
12.50
78.13
9.00
56.25
12.00
75.00
12
12.17
76.04
9
10.50
65.63
9
8.33
52.08
11.40
71.25
10
11.17
69.79
13
11.71
73.21
13
12.00
75.00
12
12.00
75.00
9
9.67
60.42
12
10.33
64.58
15
11.50
71.88
10
10.50
65.63
13
10.33
64.58
14
13.67
85.42
WISUDA
9.80
61.25
5
8.00
50.00
8
8.83
55.21
7
6.67
41.67
SWING
11.25
70.31
8
8.83
55.21

12
7
9
12
11
8
7
9
13
8
4
11
11
9
10
13
13
10
12
15
12
12
8
9
9
7
9
10
11

10.50
10.00
8.83
11.67
9.17
9.83
8.50
9.33
11.67
8.67
6.17
11.00
10.83
7.00
8.17
11.67
10.17
9.00
10.83
11.00
10.17
11.00
7.50
10.17
8.00
7.50
8.17
8.33
6.50

65.63
62.50
55.21
72.92
57.29
61.46
53.13
58.33
72.92
54.17
38.54
68.75
67.71
43.75
51.04
72.92
63.54
56.25
67.71
68.75
63.54
68.75
46.88
63.54
50.00
46.88
51.04
52.08
40.63