0982_f_vp4qh003_ceq.

txt
RECORD TYPE: FEDERAL (NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR:Kenneth L. Peel ( CN=Kenneth L. Peel/OU=CEQ/O=EOP [ CEQ ] )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 9-JUL-2003 17:45:02.00
SUBJECT:: [Pwd: vision Document- Printer's version [RESTRICTED]]
inet ( inet [UNKNOWN])
READ:UNKNOWN
TEXT:
1 of 3
---------------------- Forwarded by Kenneth L. Peel/CEQ/EOP on 07/09/2003
05:43 PM ---------------------------
Phil Cooney
07/09/2003 08:10:57 AM
Record Type: Record
To: Kenneth L. Peel/CEQ/EOP@EOP
cc:
subject: [Fwd: vision Document - Printer's Version [RESTRICTED]]
---------------------- Forwarded by Phil cooney/CEQ/EOP on 07/09/2003
08:10 AM ---------------------------
James R Mahoney <James.R.Mahoney@noaa.gov>
07/03/2003 03:13:11 PM
Record Type: Record
TO: CCSP@USGCRP. GOV
cc:
. subject: [FWd: vision Document - Printer's version [RESTRICTED]]
To all - I am sending this a second time. I entered the group address
incorrectly the first time. Jim Mahoney
-------- ori9inal Message --------
subject: Vis1on Document - Printer's version [RESTRICTED]
Date: Thu, 03 Jul 2003 15:05:37 -0400
From: "James R Mahoney" <James.R.Mahoney@noaa.gov>
To: CCSP@USGCRP, James R Mahoney <James.R.Mahoney@noaa.gov>
TO all -
I am attaching a file with the full text and illustrations of the CCSP
Vision document as we sent it to the printer last evening. Please note
that graphics are already embedded in the text on pages 3 and 10. other
color graphics are attached to each of the "research element boxes" that
will be placed as noted in the text when the layout is completed.
Last evening was our latest deadline to get a full color, full layout
document ready for use by secretary Abraham and secretary evans at a
roll out schetluled for July 15. (Note: oo not disseminate this date.
Page 1
003429
GEQ 013387
0 .......
It may change.)
0982_ f _vp4qh00Lteq . txt .
Also, note that we will be able to make a very limited number of edits
(best if they are substitutions of similar amounts of text) during
galley proof review scheduled for July 8 and/or 9.
I.
Jim Mahoney
- Vision Printers copy 7-02-03.doc
================ = ATTACHMENT 1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE: 0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert NSREOP0103:[ATTACH.D49]SREOP01300HQ4PV.001 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
D0CFllEOA1BllAE1000000000000000000000000000000003E000300FEFF090006000000000000
================== END ATTACHMENT 1 ~ = - = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
Page 2
CEQ 013388
. ,
' I
RECORD TYPE! FEDERAL
0984_f_zq4qh003_ceq.txt
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR:Kenneth L. Peel ( CN=Kenneth L. Peel/OU=CEQ/O=EOP [ CEQ J )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 9-JUL-2003 17:45:36.00
SUBJECT:: Main CCSP oocume.nt for concurrence/final edits
inet ( jeffrey.b.clarinUJnlm,.-lco. inet [UNKNOWN J )
READ:UNKNOWN ----
TEXT:
3 of 3
---------------------- Forwarded by Kenneth L. Peel/CEQ/EOP on 07/09/2003
05:44 PM ---------------------------
Phil Cooney
07/09/2003 08:09:38 AM
Record Type: Record
To: Kenneth L. Peel/CEQ/EOP@.EOP
cc:
subject: Main CCSP Document for concurrence/final edits
---------------------- Forwarded by Phil cooney/CEQ/EOP on 07/09/2003
08:09 AM ---------------------------
Phi 1 Cooney
07/01/2003 09:19:20 AM
Record Type: Record
To: ' Quesean R. Rice/CEQ/EOP@.EOP
cc:
subject: Main CCSP Document for concurrence/final edits
please print out attachment -- Strategic Plan concurrence text. thanks
Phil
---------------------- Forwarded by Phil cooney/CEQ/EOP on 07/01/2003
09:18 AM ---------------------------
James R Mahoney <James.R.Mahoney@.noaa.gov>
06/30/2003 07:12:38 PM
Record Type: Record
To: CCSP@.USGCRP.GOV, CCSP_INFO@.USGCRP.GOV
cc: see the distribution list at the bottom of this message
subject: Main CCSP Document for concurrence/final edits
Ladies and gentlemen,
I am attaching a PDF file with the revised text (without annexes) of the
main CCSP scientific strategic plan document, for concurrence or
final edits. The annexes for the document are in final checking at the
.Page l
OU3431
CEQ 013393
I
I
0984_f_zq4qh003_ceq.txt
CCSP office at this time. I will send them to you as soon as their
checkout is completed - expected for early Tuesday. These annexes will
also be on the website https://www.usgcrp.gov/techrvw as soon as
they eted.
name:
To reduce the PDF file size all of the graphics for the plan have been
removed from the text file, and are also being posted on the same
website as above (with the same name and password). These graphics
should be available by approximately 8:00 PM this evening.
INSTRUCTIONS: DEADLINE IS COB WEDNESDAY, JULY 2
N.B. REMEMBER THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED
Please review this revised document, and take one of the two following
actions:
1. If you concur with publication of the document, please send an
electroiJiiiiiiic messa e with your concurrence to ERIN WUCHTE email:
ewuchte by COB WEDNESDAY, with a copy to me.
. .
2. If you wish to discuss further revisions to the minimum
feasible), please email me of call me at COB WEDNESDAY.
we need to keep Thursday, July 3 available for us to review and
understand any open edit issues with you. we expect to commit time over
the July 4 weekend to resolve any issues, so that we can reach closure
by midday Monday July 7.
we must be able to release the document for final copy edit, composing
and printing after July 7, so that we can have printea copies available
for the public presentation by secretaries Abraham and Evans currently
schedulea for July 15.
I look forward to receiving the message of your concurrence, or your
list of issues remaining to be addressed, by Wednesday, July 2.
Thank you again for your attention to this.
Jim Mahoney
- attl.htm
- strat Plan Agency Concurrrence TEXT 6-30-03.pdf
James.R.Mahoney.vcf
Message co pi ea .
To:
Kathie L. Olsen/OSTP/EOP@EOP
E. Holly F1tter/OMB/EOP@EOP
Erin Wuchte/OMB/EOP@EOP
sbodman <sbodman@doc.gov>
"Conrad.C.Lautenbacher" <Conrad.c.Lautenbacher@.noaa.goV>
scott Rayder
Robert card
Page 2
C:EQ 013394
t
. (
0984_f_zq4qh003_ceq.txt
==================== ATTACHMENT 1 ============---=====
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE: 0.00:00:00.00
TEXT:
<!doctype html public "-//w3c//dtd html 4.0 transitional/len">
<html>
Ladies and gentlemen,
<P>I am attaching a PDF file with the revised text (without annexes) of
the main CCSP sc1entific strategic plan document, for your concurrence
or final edits.&nbsp; The annexes for the document are in final checking
at the CCSP office at this time. I will send them to you as soon as the1r
checkout is completed - expected for early Tuesday.&nbsp; These annexes
will also be posted on the website <U><A HREF="https://www.usgcrp.gov/techrvw">
https://www. .gov/techrvw</A></U>
as soon completed.
<br>pas -
<P>To r le size all of the graphics for the plan have been
removed le, and are also being posted on the same website
as above th the same name and password).&nbsp; These graphics should
be avail e by approximately 8:00 PM this evening.<u></U>
<P><U>INSTRUCTIONS:&nbsp; DEADLINE IS COB WEDNESDAY, JULY 2</U><U></U>
<P><U>N.B. REMEMBER THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED</U><U></U>
<P>Please review this revised document, and take one of the two following
actions:
<P>l.&nbsp; If you concur with publication of the document, please send
an electronic message with your concurrence to ERIN WUCHTE&nbsp; email:&nbsp;
<U>ewuchte@omb.eop.gov</U>&nbsp;&nbsp; by COB WEDNESDAY, with a copy to
me .
. <P>2. If you wish to discuss further revisiolWMse keep to the minimum
feasible), please emai 1 me of cal 1 me at 202 by COB WEDNESDAY.
<P>We need to keep Thursday, July 3 available o review and understand
any open edit issues with you.&nbsp; we expect to commit time over the
July 4 weekend to resolve any issues, so that we can reach closure by midday
Monaay July 7.
<br>We must be able to release the document for final copy edit, composing
and printing after July 7, so that we can have printed copies available
for the public presentation by secretaries Abraham and Evans currently
scheduled for July 15.
<P>I look forward to receiving the message of your concurrence, or your
list of issues remaining to be addressed, by wednesday, July 2.
<p>Thank you again for your attention to th1s.
<p>Jim Mahoney</html>
================== END ATTACHMENT 1 ==================
==================== ATTACHMENT 2 = = = = = = = = = = = = = ~ = = - - - =
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE: 0 00:00:00.00 .
TEXT:
Unable to convert NSREOP0103:[ATTACH.D89]SREOP01300HQ4QZ.002 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
================== END ATTACHMENT 2 ==================
==================== ATTACHMENT 3 ====================
ATT. CREATION TIME/DATE: 0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
begin:vcard
n:Mahoney;Jnmes
Page 3
CEQ 013395

x-mozilla-html:FALSE
org:Nationa1 oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOM)
version:2.1
email;internet:James.R.Mahoney@noaa.gov
title:Assistant secretary of commerce for oceans and Atmosphere
adr;quoted-printable:;;u.s. Department of commerce,=OD=OARoom 5804,
=0D=0Al4th street & constitution Avenue, NW;Washington;oc;20230;
fn:James R. Mahoney, Ph.D.
end:vcard
================== END ATTACHMENT 3 =====----=======-===
Page 4
CEQ 013396
~ : . : ; : l ..:k
i"'"t.:. ...... r
0
0
~
0
00
GJ
Draft CCSP Deliverables 220ct03.doc
Synthesis and Assessment Products
Draft Table of Agency Leads
USDMJSGS (S)
~ ....~ ...~
; .
..1-
' ......
:.
yaws
Draft CCSP Deliverables 220ct03.doc
NASAIUSGSJDOE (S)
NASA/DOE (S) (USGS)
Titus (EPA)
Szabados (NOAA)
UndstromiFriedl
(NASA)
JPL
I I I l I Palmisano (DOE) I I
.. ._ 2-4 State-of-lmowledge of thresholds of change that could NSF (L) ECO NSF contact TBO
, .. :.
.......
.. ;;\....r
GSFC/ARC
GSFC


.. ..
.,,
nme
FQime
,2-4
I
i years
24
years
Draft CCSP Deliverables 220ct03.doc --- - - -- -- - -
Topic Agencies
economic implications of dlffenmt atmospheric NASAIUSGSIEPAINOAAIDOE
concentrations of greenhouse gases. (S)
State-of-the-science of sqcloeconomic and EPA(L)
environmental Impacts of climate varlabiDty. NOAAINASAIDOEIUSAID (S)
Within the transportation sector, a summary of clmate DOT(L)
change and vadabUity sensitivities, potential Impacts, USGS(S)
and response options. DOE(S)

.
Working Contact Point Resources
Group Identified
Grambsch (EPA)
Goodrich (NOAA)
Houghton (DOE)
HCR Scheraga (EPA)
ECO Simpson (NOAA)
Friedl (NASA)
Houghton (obE)
OS Savonts (DOT) 345K(DOT)
Burkett (USGS)
Petty (DOE)
CCSP GoalS E1cp/olo the Identify the limits of evohllng knowledge to manage risks and opportunities related to climate varlabl/lly and
wlthln2 Uaes and limitations of obServations, data, forecaats, NASA(L) HCR Blrkl McPherson sse
years and other projections in decision support for selected EPiVNOAAIUSGSIDOE (S) OS (NASA)
sectors and regions. Blerwagen (EPA)
Livezey (NOAA)
Berenknopf (USGS)
Am1hor (DOE)
wilhln2 Best practice apprnaches for characterizing, NSF/NASA (L) OS O'Connor/Eavey (NSF) sse
years communicating, and Incorporating scientific EPiVNOAAIUSGSIDOE (S) Comm. BlrkiMcPherson
uncertainty In declslonmaldng. (NASA)
Gamble (EPA)
Simpson (NOAA)
Berenknopf (USGS)
Fe11811 fOOEl.
wlthln2 Decision support experiments and evaluations using NOAA(L) OS Nierenberglllvezey
years seasonal to Interannual foracasts and observational NASAIEPAIUSGSIUSAID (S) (NOAA)
data. BirkiHablb (NASA) GSFCIGISS
Gamble (EPA)
BeNnknopf (USGS)
DOE contact TBD
AC Atmospheric Composition eve Climate Variability and Change
we Water Cycle LC Land Use/Land Cover
cc CadMm Cyc;le
HCR Human Contributions Modeling
DS Decision Support OBS Observations
DM COMM Communications
I
# ~ ; " " ~ ..41 ~
~ . . .
Email addresses for DOE eontacts:
Jeff Amthor:
Rick.Petty:
Anna Palmisano: Anna Nnjiiji'i
J()b.n Houghton: - - -- .
Wanda Ferren:
Email addresses for DOT CODtads:
Michael. Savonis michael.savouis
Diaft CCSP Deliverables 220ct03.doc
Roger Dahlman: Roger.Dahlmam
PeterLunn:
(b) (6)
I
From: Hannegan, Bryan J.
Sent: Thursday, December 30, 2004 3:02PM
To: Ahsha Tribble
Cc: Phil; Olsen, Kathie L.; Wuchte, Erin; Schwab, Margo
SubJect: RE: [Fwd: CCSP Guidelines Announcement]
Page 1 of1
Ahsha - please find attached a redline with my comments, using language from the letter Jim posted on the web
site to accompany the release of the S&A Guidelines. Please call if questions, t_hanks, Bryan
------ Original Message
Subject:CCSP Guidelines Announcement
17 Dec 200412:20:19-0500
From:Ahsha Tribble <Ahsha.Tribble@noaa.gov>
OrganJzation:NOAA
CCSP EOP Principals,
The NOAA Office of Legislative Affairs would like to have a
communications document to give to the Hill and other constituents
regarding the release of the Guidelines for Producing CCSP Synthesis and
.Assessment Reports. The draft is attached for your review. We invite
comments, if any, next week prior to sending this document out.
Thank you,
Ahsha
********************************************
Ahsha N. Tribble, Ph.D.
Technical Chief of Staff
Office of Assistant Secretary of Commerce
For Oceans and Atmosphere
HCHB/Room 5804
14th & Constitution Ave, NW
DC 20230
(DOC)
(Fax)
*******************************
file://G:\FOIA - Climate\2004\Deliberative\12.04\RE Fwd CCSP Guidelines Announceme... 4/12/2007
CEQ 016224
FW MahoneyRevkin interview
From: Holbrook, William F.
sent: Monday, March 07, 2005 4:09PM
To: Cooney, Phil; Hannegan, Bryan J.; Hopkins, Robert
subject: FW: interview
FYI
-----original Message-----
From: Kent Laborde [mailto:Kent.Laborde@noaa.gov]
sent: Monday, March 07, 2005 3:42 PM
To: Holbrook, william. F. .
subject: Mahoney/Revkin interview
Bill.
Andy Revkin has requested an interview with or. Mahoney to discuss CCSP deliverables
and "apparent issues on the chain thru which they'll be approved." He said the
discussion is not solely about Rick Piltz resignation from ccsP, but is related to
the topic. He is avai 1 able tomorrow afternoon for a phone interview ..
I think th.is interview is chiefl for background, but may lead to a separate article
solely on this subject. I'm clar1fying this now with Andy and trying to get more
specifics. Is there any specific language we should use? .

Page 1
..-;: '!'"'> -
\. 'l.i 1\. '
CEQ 016282
.v u.s. Government Review of J:PCC Fourth Assessment Report - Mitigation of climate change -- ADDEND!
From: Connaughton, James
sent: 2006 3:27 PM
To: WatsonH
subject: FW: nment Review of IPCC Fourth Assessment .Report -
Mit1gation of climate change -- APDENDUM
Please give me a ring to discuss.
-----original
From: curtis,
To: Garman,
conrad.c.
wehrum.
Beth.J
Lyn
CC:
Fryberge
mclean.b
watsonhl
whoh
j ku 1
Jeff.
Judy.
carmen
sent: Fri May 12 14:38:13 2006
Subject: u.s. Government Review of IPCC Fourth Assessment Report - Mitigation of
climate change -- ADDENDUM
Dear climate change Technology Program Principals:
I apologize for the multiple email messages on this subject. However, several points
have been raised from my previous email that deserve clarification, which are
presented below.
1. In order to ensure a comprehensive review of the Report and the comments
received
1
it is hoped that there are about 4-6 members will be on each
sub-comm1ttee, resulting in a total of 28-42 participants on the entire review
committee.
2. For planning purposes, the participants should assume a total of about 1 *weeks
for review and meetings. During this time, the participants will review their
respective chapters, comments and participant in reviewing meetings lasting about 3
days in washington D.c. It is anticipated that the reviews and meetings will occur
in the late August through early September.
3. The committee will be responsible for: (1) reviewing and on
the chapters to wh1ch are assigned as well as the for Pol1tymakers and
the Technical summary; (2 reviewing all public comments on the chapters
they are assigned; and (3 participate in a 3 day meeting in washington oc to
discuss and reach consensus on all comments.
Thank you again for your kind support in helping us develop a comprehensive review
document.
Mike
Page 1
004:176
CEQ 017683
Government Review of IPCC Fourth Assessment Report - Mitigation 9f climate change -- ADDEND!
Dear climate Change Technology Program Principals:
As you may be aware, the Intergovernmental Panel on climate change (IPCC) is
completing its Fourth Assessment Report (AR4)i and soon there will be a Government
and Expert Review. The climate change Techno ogy Program (CCTP), at the request of
the Department of state, is coordinating the review of the working Group III second
order Draft, Mitigation of climate change. The Government and Expert review will
take -place from 24 July 2006 to 15 september 2006.
A committee will be formed to evaluate the merit of submitted public comments and
prepare the official u.s. Government submission to the IPCC. As chair, I am
requesting your nomination of a9ency representatives to serve on this review
committee. Please directly to me at
by Monday, May 22,
2006.
The AR4 --Mitigation of climate change is.organized as shown below. I anticipate
will be grouped together and sub-committees formed.around
spec1f1c expert1se, such as:
1, 2 and 3 (introduction, framing issues,, issues related to mitigation in the
long-term context)
4 (energy supply)
5 (transportat1on and infrastructure)
6 (residential/commercial)
7 and 10 (industry and waste management)
8-9 (agrjculture, forestry)
Page 2
CEQ 017684
v u.s. Government Review of IPCC Fourth Assessment Report.- Mitigation of climate change --ADDEND!
11-13 (mitigation from cross-sectoral, sustainable development, policies)
Much of our work will be performed in the sub-committees where the members will be
reviewing the collected public comments. In addition, ali committee members will be
asked to review and participate in evaluation of the summary for Policymakers and
the Technical summary.
A preliminary schedule for the review is as follows:
24 July - 23 August: comments received on Draft AR4 Mitigation of climate change
24 August: Comments collated forwarded to
25 August: CCTP sends to review committee members
6 september - 8 september: committee meeting (venue TBD but likely to be held at DOE
HQ in washington DC) .
11 September: Final collation and summary transmitted to state and ccsP.
12-14 september: state finalization of official USG position
15 september: state transmittal to IPCC secretariat
This schedule is tight with little slack; however we need to conform to the IPCC
Rules and Procedures that stipulate an eight week Government and expert review time
period.
Thank you for your support of this very important review process. If you have any
questions or concerns, please do not hesitate to contact me.
Mike
Michael R. curtis Ph.D.
u.s. Department of Energy
office of Policy and International Affairs
science and Technology Policy, PI-45
1000 Independence Ave, sw
washin 20585

(b) (6)
T: 202
F: 202 (b) (6)
outline of AR4 Mitigation of climate change
summary for Policymakers
Technical summary
Page 3
CEQ017685
~ u.s. Government Review of IPCC Fourth Assessment Report - Mitigation of climate change -- ADDENQI
INTRODUCTION AND FRAMING ISSUES
1. Introduction
2. Framing Issues
,_.
ISSUES RELATED TO MITIGATION IN THE LONG-TERM CONTEXT
3.. Issues Related to Mitigation in the Long-term context (summary)
Emission.scenarios, mitigation and stabilization scenarios, costs,-
socio-economic implications .
Development pathways
Role of technologies
Interaction of mitigation and adaptation
Linkages between short and medium term mitigation and long-term
stabi 1 i zati on
SPECIFIC MITIGATION OPTIONS IN, THE SHORT AND MEDIUM TERM
4. energy supply
5. Transport and its infrastructure
6. Residential/commercial
7. Industry
8. Agriculture
9. Forestry
10. Waste management
CROSS SECTORAL, NATIONAL AND INTERNATIONAL DIMENSIONS
11. Mitigation from a cross-sectoral perspective
Introduction
cross-sectoral mitigation options
Technology research, development, deployment, diffusion and transfer
synergies and trade-offs with other policies
overall mitigation potential and costs
Macroeconomic effects
Spill-over effects
Page 4
CEQ 017686
v u.s. Government Review of IPCC Fourth Assessment Report - Mitigation of climate change --
Assessment of bottom-up and top-down analysis
Mitigation and adaptation
12. sustainable development and
13. Policies., instruments,. and co-operative arrangements
Page 5
CEQ 017687