Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Douglas R. Nordli, Jr, MD*; Maxine M. Kuroda, PhD, MPH*; Joanne Carroll, MSRD‡;
Dorcas Y. Koenigsberger, RN, MS, CPNP‡; Lawrence J. Hirsch, MD§; Harlan J. Bruner储;
William T. Seidel, PhD¶#; and Darryl C. De Vivo, MD¶
ABSTRACT. Objective. To evaluate the effectiveness, genic diet is a time-tested, effective treatment for
tolerability, and adverse effects of the ketogenic diet in older patients with refractory epilepsy.7 There is,
infants with refractory epilepsy. however, a striking lack of data regarding its efficacy
Methods. A retrospective review of 32 infants who and adverse effects in infants.
had been treated with the ketogenic diet at a large met- The diet is the primary therapy for infants with
ropolitan institution.
Results. Most infants (71%) were able to maintain
pyruvate dehydrogenase deficiency and glucose
strong ketosis. The overall effectiveness of the diet in transporter protein deficiency.8,9 We also believe that
infants was similar to that reported in the literature for the diet is indicated in the treatment of generalized
older children; 19.4% became seizure-free, and an addi- or multifocal infantile epilepsies, including infantile
tional 35.5% had >50% reduction in seizure frequency. spasms, when multiple antiepileptic drugs fail or
The diet was particularly effective for patients with in- produce unacceptable side effects. Accordingly, the
fantile spasms/myoclonic seizures. There were concomi- diet has been a treatment option at Columbia-
tant reductions in antiepileptic medications. The major- Presbyterian Medical Center for ⬎40 years. We used
ity of parents reported improvements in seizure this experience to perform a retrospective review of
frequency and in their child’s behavior and function, all infants who had been treated with the ketogenic
particularly with respect to attention/alertness, activity
level, and socialization. The diet generally was well-
diet to determine its effectiveness, tolerability, and
tolerated, and 96.4% maintained appropriate growth pa- adverse event profile in this young population.
rameters. Adverse events, all reversible and occurring in
one patient each, included renal stone, gastritis, ulcer- METHODS
ative colitis, alteration of mentation, and hyperlipidemia. Information regarding seizure types, seizure frequency, epi-
Conclusion. The ketogenic diet should be considered lepsy syndrome, etiology, weight change, and ketosis was ab-
safe and effective treatment for infants with intractable stracted from the medical records of all infants (age ⬍2 years) who
seizures. Pediatrics 2001;108:129 –133; ketogenic diet, ef- had been treated with the ketogenic diet from October 1, 1983,
fectiveness, safety, adverse effects, intractable seizures, through June 30, 1997. Criteria for treatment included intractable
infants. epilepsy, pyruvate dehydrogenase deficiency, and glucose trans-
porter protein deficiency. Seizure frequency was recorded by En-
gel classification and then grouped into 3 categories: seizure-free
ABBREVIATION. RCF, Ross carbohydrate-free (formula). (Engel I), worthwhile improvement (Engel II and III), or no sig-
nificant change (Engel IV). Cause was divided into idiopathic/
cryptogenic and symptomatic categories. Seizure types were re-
T
he incidence of seizures is higher during the corded by International League Against Epilepsy criteria and also
by a special semiologically based classification scheme tailored to
first 2 years of life than during any other pe- infants.10,11 Ketosis, measured by urine dipstick, was recorded as
riod of childhood.1 Outcome with regard to either none, variable, or consistently moderate to large.
seizure control and development is poor.2– 6 Several Patients’ families were contacted by telephone, and caregivers
severe catastrophic epilepsies present in infancy, in- who were most familiar with the child’s behavior at home were
questioned. The respondent was almost always the patient’s
cluding early myoclonic epilepsy, early infantile ep- mother (the single exception was a patient’s father). The parents
ileptogenic encephalopathy, West syndrome, and se- were asked to rate the effects of the diet on seizure frequency,
vere infantile myoclonic epilepsy. Seizures in these seizure intensity, speech/communication, comprehension/under-
disorders may be difficult to control—sometimes standing, self-care, social interactions (eg, interest in others, play-
only at the expense of multiple and toxic levels of ing), attention span/alertness, activity level, sleeping, motor skills,
endurance, and behavior. These characteristics were rated on a
antiepileptic medications. When these medications Likert scale ranging from much worse (1), somewhat worse (2),
fail, alternative treatments are required. The keto- same (3), somewhat better (4), or much better (5). These ratings
have been used previously to assess the effects of the diet in older
children.12 The interview included questions on changes in anti-
From the *Epilepsy Center, Children’s Memorial Hospital, Chicago, Illinois; epileptic medications while on the diet, the caregiver’s impression
and ‡Pediatric Gastroenterology and Nutrition Division, §Adult Section of of the overall benefit of the diet, and a reappraisal of the decision
the Comprehensive Epilepsy Center, 储Columbia University College of Phy- to try the diet.
sicians and Surgeons, ¶Division of Pediatric Neurology, and #Pediatric
Section of the Comprehensive Epilepsy Center, Columbia-Presbyterian
Medical Center, New York, New York. Statistical Analyses
Received for publication Sep 13, 1999; accepted Jan 1, 2001. Patients were grouped into the 3 categories of the Engel clas-
Reprint requests to (D.R.N.) 2300 Children’s Plaza, Box 29, Chicago, IL sification described previously. Differences in proportions were
60614. E-mail: dnordli@childrensmemorial.org evaluated by 2; P ⬍ .05 was considered to be statistically signif-
PEDIATRICS (ISSN 0031 4005). Copyright © 2001 by the American Acad- icant. Multiple logistic regression evaluated the risk of infantile
emy of Pediatrics. spasms to seizure improvement versus no improvement on the
they would put their child on the diet (Table 3); the with triglycerides over 9000 mg/dL that resolved
reason given most often was that they would be after switching to the medium-chain triglyceride
willing to try anything that may be helpful for their diet, and 1 developed ulcerative colitis. All of the
child. complications were reversible and occurred in pa-
Six of the 32 infants (18.8%) developed complica- tients who were begun on the diet after 12 months of
tions possibly related to the diet (Table 4). One had age. The majority of patients with treatment-emer-
severe vomiting, 1 developed renal stones with he- gent adverse events had been on the diet for ⬎1 year,
maturia, 1 had gastrointestinal bleeding from erosive and 2 were on the diet as of July 1, 1997. In addition
esophagitis believed to be attributable to a chronic to these events, 1 patient became comatose with hy-
nasogastric tube, 1 developed type I hyperlipidemia poglycemia and acidosis after initiation of the diet.
ARTICLES 131
TABLE 3. Parental Assessment of Overall Benefit to Child TABLE 4. Treatment-Emergent Adverse Events
(n ⫽ 31)
Gender Start Age Time on Diet Event
Question Yes No Unsure (Month) (Month)
(n [%]) (n [%]) (n [%])
M 14 7 Severe vomiting
Overall, did your child benefit 14 (50.0) 13 (46.4) 4 (3.6) M 16 17 Renal stones
from the diet? F 17 18 Gastrointestinal bleeding
If you had to decide again, 21 (75.0) 6 (21.4) 4 (3.6) M 18 23 Type I hyperlipidemia
would you put your child M 21 26 Ulcerative colitis
on the diet? F* 11 8 days Coma
* Excluded from analyses of seizure frequency/severity and be-
havior because of short time on diet.
This patient had been on the diet for only 8 days, and
the effects fully resolved after cessation of the diet. (activity level and alertness) were the same domains
Three patients died, 2 while on the diet. One had a identified previously with the use of the same ques-
severe multisystem disease with nephrotic syn- tionnaire in a survey of parents with older children.12
drome, small bowel malrotation, blindness, deafness, This effect is consistent with basic scientific observa-
hypertension, autonomic crises, and multiple pulmo- tions that the diet is not sedative and, in fact, in-
nary infections. She was on the diet from 17 months creases brain energy reserves18 and quantity of brain
until her death at 35 months of age. She died at home adenosine 5⬘-triphosphate.19 Although it was not
as a result of another pulmonary infection. One in- possible to determine whether behavioral and func-
fant had congenital heart disease that required 2 tional improvements were related to seizure control,
surgical procedures, a hypoplastic lung, a paralyzed decrease in anticonvulsant medication, or other fac-
hemidiaphragm and vocal cord with stridor, and tors (eg, maturational), most parents seemed to note
severe cerebral anoxic injury related to the second changes within 6 months, suggesting that the keto-
cardiac surgery. He was on the diet from 20 months genic diet may have played some role in improving
of age until his death from respiratory failure at 25 the child’s behavior in these areas. The previous
months, probably as a result of aspiration. The third survey of older children reported that changes in
patient had pyruvate dehydrogenase deficiency, was these domains were evident within 4 weeks of start-
on the diet from 4 months to 10 months of age, and ing the diet.12 Time to improvement in the current
died 2 months later (off the diet) from complications study seemed to be longer, possibly because changes
related to her underlying metabolic disorder. may be more easily ascertained in older children.
Of the noted adverse events, we believe that 5 may
DISCUSSION have been associated with the use of the diet, includ-
We found the effectiveness of the diet in infants to ing severe vomiting, renal stones, hyperlipidemia,
be similar to the rates reported in the literature for ulcerative colitis, and coma. Ballaban-Gil et al20 re-
older children.13 This is noteworthy given the pro- viewed complications of the diet in older children
pensity for intractability in this age group. The effec- and noted similar adverse events. Alteration of men-
tiveness of the diet was independent of the cause of tation may occur in patients with inborn errors of
the epilepsy and seizure type, with the exception that metabolism, particularly pyruvate carboxylase defi-
children with infantile spasms/myoclonic seizures ciency,21 but our patient did not have any abnormal-
responded better than other children. This perhaps is ities on detailed metabolic testing before initiation of
comparable to the experience described by Living- the diet.
ston et al 14, who reported that 80% of children with We believe that the deaths were related to the
myoclonic seizures showed improvement with the underlying disease processes and not to the use of
ketogenic diet. the diet itself. Nevertheless, because infants with
Most children maintained strong ketosis. Impor- intractable epilepsy may experience a variety of oc-
tant factors in this regard may be the high ratios of cult etiologies, strong caution is advised to exclude
fat to nonfat (often above 4:1) and calories to body inborn errors of metabolism, such as pyruvate car-
weight (often above 90 kcal/kg) used in our patients. boxylase deficiency and organic acidurias, before
We speculated that these infants required relatively starting the diet.
large amounts of ketone bodies to supply the neces-
sary substrates for cerebral metabolic functions. This CONCLUSION
is in keeping with the scientific observations show- We believe that the ketogenic diet is an effective,
ing a greater ability of the brain to extract ketone well-tolerated, and beneficial treatment for appropri-
bodies in infancy.15–17 ate conditions in infants. The current study was ret-
The dietary prescriptions were designed specifi- rospective, and efficacy rates from retrospective
cally to provide adequate calories and protein to studies may differ from that of prospective stud-
sustain infants along their weight-height percentiles, ies13,22; thus, data from prospective studies of infants
and therefore it is not surprising that the infants who are on the ketogenic diet also are needed to
maintained good growth and height gain. establish the diet’s efficacy in this age group. We
Consistent with the observations of the usefulness found that complications may be observed and ap-
of the diet in older children, parents of infants often propriate candidates must be selected carefully.
cited improvements in behavior and function. In fact, Treatment and meticulous follow-up by personnel
the 2 domains most frequently noted as improved who are familiar with the use of the diet in this age
MODERN PARENTING
If you walk through the parenting section of your local bookstore, you’ll find
such titles as Building Healthy Minds, Baby Minds: Brain-Building Games Your Baby
Will Love, and Right From Birth: Building Your Child’s Foundation for Life. If you go to
an upscale toy store, in addition to innocent playthings you will find sophisticated
development tools designed for fetus and infant cultivation. Even parents who
didn’t buy WombSong Serenades, a musical collection designed to stimulate babies’
fetal brain activity, can probably still raise a perfect child if they fill the first weeks
of his or her life with full doses of Mozart. My local Buy Buy Baby, the infant-
oriented megastore, offers at least half a dozen selections, including Mozart for
Babies’ Minds (featuring the Violin Concerto No. 3), Mozart Playtime (with the
Minuet in F Major), the Parents Magazine Classical Music for Baby Mozart collection
(Serenade No. 13 in G Major), and Mozart for Toddlers (Symphony No. 35). Parents
just have to choose which one will produce the best synaptic responses in their
child’s cerebral cortex.
Submitted by Student
ARTICLES 133