Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Jan J. Nossin
23
Fig 1. 3-D diagram of Pinatubo area (Daag & van Westen, 1996)
The century's greatest volcanic eruption, the 1991 eruption of Mt. Pinatubo, has accumulated approximately 7.0 km of pyroclastic flow deposits on its slopes (Daligdig, et. al., 1991). Mostly dacitic in composition, about 1.3 k m were deposited along the Marella-Sto. Tomas Watershed (Rodolfo, et. al., 1993). Fine particles of ash were deposited around a 50-km radius, on the south, southeast and
2.XXXIX
southwest of the volcano (Fig 2). Approximately, pyroclastic flows and ash deposits cover more than 4000 km ; that includes the eight river basins draining the volcano. The ashes ranged from a few centimeters thickness at 40-50 km from the volcano to roughly half a meter near the crater.
Fig 2 Deposits from the 1991 eruption of Mt. Pinatubo (Daag & van Westen, 1996.) Pyroclastic flow deposits around the crater area reach much greater thickness and fill up whole valleys to overtop the divides (Figs 3, 4 ). At the advent of the rainy season, these soft and unconsolidated fine grained materials are easily eroded and flow down at high speed forming mixtures of volcaniclastic materials and water at various rates that inundate and bring morphologic changes along its route. This phenomenon is evident in the Marella-Sto. Tomas River system on the southwest flank of the volcano, which has been singled out for this study. The eruption and its aftermath have been recorded in great detail in a large number of papers, compiled in Fire and Mud, edited by C.G. Newhall and R.S. Punongbayan (1996). This work serves as standard reference. The present paper deals with the application of remotely sensed data including aerial photos to the monitoring of geomorphic changes brought about by the dynamism of lahar in the Marella-Santo Tomas riverbasin.
2.XL
Available data
Along with field observations, the following sources of information were available: aerial photographs * 1976 pre-eruption vertical photos ( scale 1: 18,000 ) * 1991 post-eruption vertical photos ( scale 1: 15,000 ) * 1992 post-eruption vertical photos ( scale 1: 25,000 ) satellite imageries * SPOT-XS ( 4 Feb 1988, 2 Apr 1988, 18 Dec 1991, 25 Apr 1995 ) * SPOT-PAN ( 12 Feb 1995, 14 Mar 1995 ) * LANDSAT-TM ( 26 Jan 1992 ) maps * topographic maps (1:50,000) * geologic map * land use map The most visible output of this research is the updated temporal morphology of Sto. TomasMarella area, and the change detection map of Marella-Sto.Tomas basin . The development of lahar infilling of the basin from 1991-96 is monitored for areal coverage, thickness and morphological consequences.
2.XLI
Rainfall
Climate in Central Luzon is characterized by well defined wet and dry seasons. Considering the west side of Mt. Pinatubo, the dry season lasts from November to April and the rainy season from May or June to October. About 70 to 80 % of the 3,800 to 3,900 mm of annual rainfall in Zambales area is conveyed by the Southwest Monsoon. In the rainy season, the average daily rainfall is about 24 mm but can exceed 150 mm. August, being the rainiest month, delivers a daily precipitation average of 36 mm to 180 mm. The greatest 24-hour rainfall recorded was 442 mm (May 19, 1966) on the onset of a typhoon prior to the monsoon season. Much of the annual rain is brought by three or four typhoons.
Geomorphologic Setting
The Marella-Sto. Tomas River system is the main drainage system in southwest Zambales. The Sto. Tomas Plain, forming part of the geotectonically active Zambales Range, is conspicuously surrounded by polygenetic landforms (Javelosa, R., 1985). The area is dominated by morphostructural diversities of the topography. The mountains that evolved from pre-Quaternary movements are made of the Cretaceous-Paleogene ultramafic complex (peridotite/gabbro). The uplifted peridotites are characterized by relatively high relief and mountainous terrain. The gabbros are associated with fault-designated crest lines and rejuvenated gully heads. A tectonic dike complex of pre-Quaternary age is closely associated with the igneous complex (diabase, basalt and undifferentiated volcanics). Morphologically, the slightly elevated sheeted dike complex strikingly occupies most of the hill zone and rolling topography. The moderately elevated basalts and the strongly elevated assemblages of undifferentiated volcanics and sedimentary rocks are characteristically hilly to mountainous. The interesting aspect in the geomorphic development of Sto. Tomas Plain is in the alluvialfilled graben resulting from Quaternary movement. The accreted alluvial deposits include terraces (relict of an incised alluvial fan), distributary bars/islands, and distributary channel areas. The latter can be considered abandoned distributaries of Sto. Tomas River. The pre-eruption terrace morphology shows pronounced deformations and mismatches, ascribed to neotectonism (Javelosa, 1985, 1994). In the coastal plain, the notable features which are possible evidence of tectonic movements include the uplifted and truncated beach ridges and swales complex, and the blocked drainage of the plain. Even the main rivers (So Tomas and Pamatawan) have great problems maintaining their outlets. An inherent -but not too imaginary- hazard is that flooding of the Santo Tomas Plain may increase as a result of this blocked drainage.
2.XLII
Fig. 3 Pyroclastic flow fill-up of valley system just after eruption; upper Sacobia valley, Mt.Pinatubo in background (from Daag, 1994).
2.XLIII
Fig. 4 Pyroclastic flow field after three years of erosion (1994), upper Marella.
Lahars
Volcanic mudflows (lahars) of great destructive capacity started down the slopes simultaneous with the emplacement of the pyroclastic flow deposits, as the eruption took place in the rainy season and coincided with the passage of a typhoon. The mobilized pyroclastic flow deposits fill up major drainage lines emanating from the volcano, with lahar material. Going westward, the Sto. Tomas riverbed has been completely transformed into lahar channels, from the pyroclastic flow source area at the middle Marella valley along the triple junction of Marella-Mapanuepe-Sto. Tomas River down the Sto Somas valley to the coastal areas. A lahar stream broke out southwestward in the direction of Castillejos, without reaching this town. The pre-eruption Santo Tomas riverbed in its downstream tract was lined by dikes which were not able to withstand the lahar and gave way in several places.
2.XLIV
Pre-eruption morphology of the Marella river is braided in nature, and the channel is lined by terraces with straight, probably fault-controlled edges. After the eruption of Mt. Pinatubo, the channel has aggraded rapidly. The eruption in 1991 and subsequent rapid erosion and degradation of pyroclastic flows during the rainy seasons, has made the Marella River down to the junction of Mapanuepe River, and all the way along the Santo Tomas Rivers, a natural debris basin for lahar deposits.
Fig.5 Lahar deposits of Marella valley joining with Santo Tomas valley. Below the junction, Sto. Tomas River flows along the northern margin of a broad alluvial plain made of fluvial/ fluviovolcanic deposits of the Santo Tomas River, and underlain by mostly ancient lahar deposits. The present (i.e. post-eruption) riverbed of Sto. Tomas is higher than the floodplain, thus overbank spills and channel avulsions are now common along its entire length. The Sto. Tomas Plain is about 13 km wide north to south and 26 km wide west to east (Javelosa, 1985; Fig. 2, 6)
2.XLV
blockage by overtopping lake waters that generated normal streamfloods, sometimes with hyperconcentrated streamflow stages of short duration ( Rodolfo , 1993).
38
Fig. 6 Santo Tomas basin, Dec. 1991; SPOT XS color composite. Note lake Mapanuepe blocked by Marella lahar deposits, and lahar directed to the SW threatehing Castillejos town.
2.XLVI
Fig. 7 Lahar deposits in Marella valley, Feb. 1992 In background, PF deposits (Marella field) and Mt. Pinatubo
2.XLVII
39
Fig. 8 Santo Tomas valley, 1995, SPOT XS colour composite. Note effects of dike and the accumulation of lahar deposits in midstream of Santo Tomas valley.
Change detection as it relates to remote sensing data is based on the assumption that there are measurable radiometric differences between successive dates corresponding to changes on the ground. In this paper, change is used and defined as ..." alteration, not only of the surface components, but the landscape itself ..." ( Milne, A.K., 1992). Therefore, image enhancement for change detection can be defined as finding out or identifying the alteration and then intensifying that observed alteration so that the spatial distribution and amount of actual change can be accurately described and measured.
Methodology
Visual interpretation, and three-date color composite overlaying techniques were used. The use of medium scale aerial photographs ( 1:18,000 to 1:25,000 ) and 1:50,000 topographic map proved a vital aid in interpretation of the satellite images. The image processing was done in an ILWIS system (version 1.4.1) (Calomarde, 1997). In general, steps for the analysis include: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Choice of the satellite images to be used Subsetting of the large image data Radiometric and geometric corrections Merging of images to the study area Application of change detection techniques Initial output of result, field data verification, evaluation Final output
2.XLVIII
For this analysis, pre-eruption and post-eruption images are used: SPOT - XS ( 1988, stereopair ), SPOT - XS ( 1991 ), LANDSAT - TM ( 1992 ), SPOT - PAN ( 1995, stereopair), SPOT - XS ( 1995 ). Since the changes that occurred are abrupt and cover a wide area, features for ground control point identification (GCP) are difficult especially in places largely affected by tephra, pyroclastic flows and lahars. To make the search for the GCP's easier, it was best deemed to subset a larger area. Then, after applying radiometric and geometric corrections , a subset of the study area was made.
2.XLIX
Black or white ( achromatic color ) signifies no change whereas the chromatic colors indicate change. This method of three-date color composite is an immediate way to identify change or equate where large scale changes occur.
40
Fig.9 Multitemporal color composite of SPOT Band 3 : 1988 blue, 1991 red, 1995 green.
Image Interpretation
The three-date color composites present major areas of change and no change. The black and white color indicate no change as shown by some portions of the vegetated areas. Chromatic colors such as blue, yellow, cyan, magenta, red and green denote areas of change. Change from 1988 to 1991 is indicated by red and cyan. Red shows the highly silted tailings pond used by Dizon Mines, and the hypercontrated streamflow lahar channels along the Sto. Tomas River. Red also shows the water areas in 1991 that are now replaced by laharic deposits. The adjoining edge of the major debris flows present a viable example. Cyan shows the additional land area and vegetation cover that were submerged due to the growth of the lake. Likewise, it is manifested by the watered agricultural area on the lowlands, some vegetation areas under shadow. Cyan along the edge of the lake represents the growth and expansion from 1988 to 1995. Blue, green, yellow and magenta represent areas that changed twice from 1988 to 1995. Blue is typically represented by land or vegetated areas submerged under water. These are the lands submerged by Mapanuepe Lake in the 1991 rainy season. Green areas show scarce vegetation or bare soil to healthy cogonal grasses and back to scarce vegetation or bare soil. Both green and yellow represent areas with abrupt changes from 1988 to 1995. These changes are represented by the leading edge of the major lahar debris flows along the Sto. Tomas River in 1991 and the thick ash deposits on the scarcely vegetated Mt. Pimmayong. Magenta could be displayed by vegetation in which reflectance response possibly returned to a high value. Other possibilities of magenta could be regrowth areas along the slopes and lowlands, and the pyroclastic deposits on the upper reaches of Marella River.
2.L
colors.
The result is a clear picture of only eight colors: red, green, blue, yellow, magenta, cyan, black and white. (fig. 10) As there are no half-tones in the component images, the resulting image has only these eight colours. The cut-off values have to be chosen with care, based on numerous pixel read-out values, as otherwise these images could be misleading. Care has to be taken that the area or feature of change, in each of the component images, is selected in the same manner, and that the lower cut-off value is just below the DN value of this feature. It is to be noted that by this method, only the changes in that particular selected feature can be monitored with confidence. In the present case, the lahar area is quite extensive and therefore changes show up clearly. The method is described by Nossin (1992 a , 1992 b, 2000).
42
2.LI
Lahar Thickness
Thickness data for the generation of lahar thickness maps are provided by PHIVOLCS. From the measured section lines along the Sto. Tomas-Marella River Valley, points are gathered, carefully plotted and digitized as point file data. The TIN method is applied in areas where data is needed. Another method used is by connecting lines from points of the same elevation. The lines are then digitized, rasterized and interpolated, creating a DEM. The base map used for lahar thickness map generation is at scale of 1:25,000.
45
Fig. 11 Thickness of lahar deposits, 1991 (from Calomarde, 1997). From this confluence site, the narrow channel towards the Sto. Tomas River impedes the debris flows. The lateral dispersion of lahars as they enter the Sto. Tomas main river, distributes the sediments at an average of 11m to 20 m thick at the center, thinning out at 10 m to 5 m, as it nears the edge of the hilly terrain north and south of the bank. Further downstream along Sto. Tomas River, the channel bed is up to 5 m higher than its original elevation. At the southern bank, lahars of 1 m to 3 m have invaded a village and township, as the dike gave way. At the northern bank, lahar deposit of 1m to 2 m destroying agricultural lands, is observed.
2.LII
San Felipe
Dizon Mines
San Antonio
Castillejos
19 - 25 m 25 - 30 m 30 - 34 m 34 - 39 m
40 - 45 m > 45 m
0
4 km
R . I. Calomarde 97
ROAD DIKE
2.LIII
1991
Thickness (m) 1-2 3-5 6-9 10-19 20-25 26-30 31-34 35-39 >40 Area (km2) 12.42 17.36 8.96 6.48 1.69 0.78 1.23 0.06 0.12 Area% 25 35 18 13 4 2 3 0.1 0.3
1995
Area (km2) 10.54 15.67 22.84 27.4 31.48 36.73 33.81 14.06 3.9 Area% 20 15 14 13 12 12 9 3 0.8
Change
Area% -5 -20 -4 0 +8 +10 +6 +2.9 +0.5
Table 1 Lahar deposit thickness 1991-95, changes along Sto Tomas-Marella River. The lahar delta into Mapanuepe Lake has prograded in area by 27% from its 1991 configuration with an estimated thickness increase of 3 to 5 metres. The dikes confine the lahar distribution pattern within the Sto. Tomas River bed. Lateral distribution of lahars over the Santo Tomas plain is minimized if not totally prevented, by the construction or reinforcement of the dikes. In the period just after the eruption the existing dikes could not withstand the first lahar onrush. Emergency measures to strengthen the dike with the lahar deposits were at times not effective due to lack of time before the next monsoon and because of lack of coheasion within the lahar material used for the dike. Although dikes are built to prevent the entry of lahars in the low-lying areas, breaching has occurred in several sections, in the period between 1991 and 1995, and lahars have spread laterally. Thus, several villages situated on the edge of the river have been totally buried in > 3m thick of fine sediments. Since there has been a decrease in sediment transport and the dike could be made of sufficient strength, no significant breaching of the dike has occurred after 1995. The solid armoured dike was strong enough to sustain the lahars. Following the west-northwest flow of Sto. Tomas River, lahars have increased the channel elevation to about 10m to 15m above its original level. In 1996 the dike has been reinforced and armoured with concrete. It looks reasonably strong now, but new lahars will further fill in the basin between the dikes and with time, the danger of overtopping will increase. From the lahar deposition and the geomorphic configuration of the So Tomas plain it can now be deduced that the pre-eruption terraces as described by Javelosa (1985), can be attributed to ancient lahars; the higher ones can be ascribed to the Maraunot eruptive period; dating of charcoal in the lahar deposit at a site northeast of Castillejos gives an age between 2800 and 3000 radiocarbon years before present (Newhall et al, 1996). Embedded lower terraces near the present confluence site of Marella and
2.LIV
Mapanuepe rivers have been ascribed to the more recent Buag eruptive period with an age locally of 760 60 14C years BP.
Fig 13 Mapanuepe lake dammed by Marella lahars, 1994. Marella PF field in background.
2.LV
Fig: 14 Mapanuepe dam deposits exposed after first draining of the lake, Feb. 1992 Mt.Pinatubo in background.
2.LVI
3. References
Calomarde, 1997, Lahar, An attribute of change in the morphology of Sto Tomas Marella River; Mt. Pinatubo, Zambales, Luzon, Philippines, MSc thesis, ITC, Enschede, the Netherlands Daag A.S. 1994 Geomorphic Development and Erosion of the Mt. Pinatubo 1991 Pyroclastic Flows in the Sacobia Watershed, Philippines: a Case Study using Remote Sensing and GIS, 106 p. ITC MSc thesis. Daag, A.S., 2000 (in prep.) A study of lahar triggering factors at Mt. Pinatubo; Ph.D thesis Daligdig A., Besana G.M and Punongbayan R.S., 1991 Overview and Impacts of the 1991 Mt. Pinatubo eruptoin: Geocon 91 Proeceedings Geol Soc. Philippines, p. 29 -55. Daag, Arturo, and Cees J.van Westen, 1996, Cartographic modelling of erosion in pyroclastic flow deposits of Mount Pinatubo, Philippines; ITC Journal 1996-2, p 110 - 124. Javelosa R.S. 1985 Morphogenesis and Tectonism of Sto Tomas Plain, southwestern Zambales, Luzon, Philippines, a study based on Airphoto interpretation and Remote Sensing. 102 p ITC MSc thesis. Javelosa R.S. 1994 Active Quaternary Environments in the Philippine Mobile Belt, 178 p. ITC-PhD thesis. Milne A.K. 1992 Land Cover Analysis and Change Detection Introd. To Rem Sensing and GIS: PhilAustr. Rem Sensing Project, Univ. of the Philippines, Quezon City, p. 73 -80. Newhall C.G., Daag A.S., Delfin F.N., Hoblitt R.P., Mc Geehin J., Pallister J.S., Regalado M.T.M., Runbin M., Tubianosa B., Tamayo R.A., Umbal J.V. 1996 Eruptive History of Mt. Pinatubo; In Fire and Mud, p. 165 -197. Newhall, C.G, A.S. Daag,F.G. Delfin, R.P. Hoblitt, J. McGeeghin, J.S. Pallister, M.Th.M. Regalado, M. Rubin, B.S. Tubianosa, R.A. Tamayo, J.V. Umbal, 1996: Eruptive History of Mount Pinatubo; in Fire and Mud, ed by C.G. Newhall and R.S. Punongbayan, p 165 -197. Newhall, Christopher S. and Raymundo Punongbayan (editors), 1996, Fire and Mud; 1126 pags; Philippine Institue of Volcanology and Seismology, Quezon City, and University of Washington Press, Seattle and London. Nossin Jan J. and Ricarte S. Javelosa, 1996; Geomorphic Risk Zonation Related to 1991 Eruptions of Mount Pinatubo ; in: Geomorphic Hazards, ed. Olav Slaymaker, Ch 6 pag 69-94; John Wiley and Sons. Nossin, J.J. ,1993-a: Monitoring hazard development by time-sequential analysis of scanned aerial photographs and satellite imagery; Proc. U.N / Indonesia Regional Conf. Space Science & Technol. for Sustainable Devt, Bandung, paper RS 26. Nossin, Jan J.,1992-a: A Method for Monitoring Hazard Development with Aerospace Imagery; Proc. Eurisy-92 Conference Mnich (CEC-ESA_DARA), p. 605 - 610. Nossin, Jan J., 1992-b : A Method for Sequential Image Analysis of Hazard Areas; Ier Simp. Internacional sobre Sensores Remotos y Sistemas de Informacin Geogrfica para el Estudio de Riesgos Naturales. Memorias, p. 61-78, IGAC, Bogot, Colombia Nossin, Jan J., 2000, Monitoring of hazards and urban growth in Villavicencio, Colombia, using scanned air photos and satellite imagery, Geojournal, in press. Ollier C., 1969 Volcanoes, an Introduction to Systematic Geomorphology Vol 6, 177 p, MIT Press Cambridge
2.LVII
Phivolcs: Update reports 1991, 1993, 1996. Rodolfo K.S., Alonso R.A., Umbal J.V., 1993 A Rational Analysis of the Sto Tomas -Pamatawan Plain and lahar system of southwestern Mt. Pinatubo. USGS Professional Paper, 80 p. Tao Q., Lewis A.J., and Braud D.H. Jr. 1993 Change Detection using Multi-temporal Feature Space with digital TM data, Proc. 1993 ACSM/ASPRS Ann. Conv. and Expos. ASPRS Technical Papers vol 2, p. 364 -372. Tayag J.C., 1991, Pinatubo Volcano Wakes from Four Century Slumber, Phivolcs 36 p.
2.LVIII