Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Posterior chamber intraocular lens (IOL) dislocation or decentration is a well-known complication of cataract surgery, but the exact incidence is not known.1 A retrospective survey published in 2005 indicated that approximately 0.3% required subsequent IOL exchange resulting from IOL dislocation.2 Most cases of early IOL dislocation occur in the rst week after cataract surgery.1 In these cases, the major cause is inadequate support for the IOL resulting from zonular or capsular damage, rupture, or both.3,4 Late IOL dislocation is dened as occurring 3 months or more after cataract surgery and has been reported with increasing frequency in recent years.1,5 Both the relatively long time frame for the presentation of this complication and the large number of people who have undergone cataract surgery have led to concerns of an impending epidemic of IOL dislocations.6 8 Late dislocations are associated with trauma9 or silicone plate IOLs passing through capsular defects, or as a result of progressive zonular dehiscence caused by contraction
2009 by the American Academy of Ophthalmology Published by Elsevier Inc.
of the capsular bag6 many years after an uneventful surgery. The risk for capsule contraction syndrome and zonular weakness seems to be greater in elderly patients.10 Other predisposing factors include pseudoexfoliation syndrome (PEX),7,11,12 high myopia, retinitis pigmentosa,11 myotonic dystrophy, certain connective tissue disorders (i.e., Marfans syndrome), homocystinuria, hyperlysinemia, Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, scleroderma, Weill-Marchesanis syndrome, and previous vitreoretinal surgery.11,13,14 A dislocated IOL often requires explantation or repositioning because of potential complications such as retinal tears, rhegmatogenous retinal detachment, and vitreous hemorrhage.1,14 The purpose of this study was to estimate the cumulative incidence of IOL dislocation, the rate of pseudophakodonesis, and signicant IOL decentration in a population-based cohort of cataract surgery cases, of which 95% received implantation of a 3-piece hydrophobic acrylic IOL. The patients were followed up from before to 10 years after surgery.
ISSN 0161-6420/09/$see front matter doi:10.1016/j.ophtha.2009.05.015
2315
Patients underwent the same eye examination as that performed 10 years previously. In addition, the centration of the IOL was assessed and graded using the pupil as a reference. A decentration of at least 2 mm in any direction was classied as signicant. If there were no obvious signs of pseudophakodonesis, the patients were asked to gaze upward quickly, to wait 5 seconds, and then to gaze downward quickly to induce movements of the IOL. Pseudophakodonesis was assessed by 1 surgeon (EIM) as none, slight or minor (barely discernible), moderate (obvious), or pronounced (looks like it will immediately drop into the vitreous). The records of all 810 patients were checked to determine if any IOL exchange or repositioning surgery had been performed in the 10 years since the surgery.
Statistical Methods
Independent sample t tests were used to compare age-differences between groups. The Fisher exact test was used to analyze the 2-by-2 and 2-by-4 tables regarding the frequency of PEX and need for additional surgery as determined by a surgeon. A chi-square test for trends was used to assess gender-related differences in the degree of pseudophakodonesis. A life table calculation was made to estimate the 10-year cumulative incidence of IOL dislocation requiring surgical attention. Statistical analyses were performed using SPSS software version 17.0 (SPSS, Inc., Chicago, IL).
ECCE extracapsular cataract extraction; ICCE intracapsular cataract extraction; IOL intraocular lens; PMMA polymethyl methacrylate (rigid IOL).
Methods
Patient Cohort 19971998
A total of 898 patients with presenile and senile cataracts who underwent cataract surgery between June 1, 1997, and May 31, 1998, at Norrlands University Hospital in Ume, Sweden, were registered prospectively. Patients who underwent cataract surgery for reasons other than restoring vision or who had surgery combined with other types of ocular surgery were excluded (n 38). Seventeen patients who died before the rst follow-up at approximately 1 month after surgery and 1 patient scheduled before surgery for cataract surgery without IOL implantation also were excluded. Thirty-two patients were lost to follow-up or declined to participate. Therefore, the study included a total of 810 patients. Patients who had undergone surgery in both eyes during the period studied were included as 1 cataract patient, and data from only the rst surgery were included in the analysis. Because of the Swedish Social Security regulations, patients seldom crossed county borders to obtain treatment during the study period. Therefore, the number of residents who underwent surgery in other districts was negligible. All cataract surgeries in the study population were performed at the university clinic, because there are no other public or private eye clinics performing cataract surgery in the area. Four different surgeons performed all the operations. Informed consent was obtained from all patients. The study followed the tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki and was approved by the local ethics committee.
Results
Type of Surgery and Intraocular Lens Implanted
The type of cataract surgery performed is shown in Table 1. Eleven (1.4%) of the 790 patients who had undergone sutureless clear corneal phacoemulsication and had a foldable IOL implanted also had a capsular tension ring (CTR) implanted. The CTR implantation was performed routinely when judged necessary by the surgeon, i.e., for intraoperative zonular weakness or zonular rupture to such a degree that the future stability of the IOL was believed
IOL intraocular lens. *Alcon, Inc, Fort Worth, TX. Abbott Medical Optics Inc, Santa Ana, CA. Corneal Laboratories Paris, Chroma Pharma GmbH, Korneuburg, Austria. Bausch & Lomb, Storz Ophthalmics Inc, Heidelberg, Germany.
2316
Mnestam
to be at risk. Nine (82%) of these 11 patients had PEX, a significantly higher percentage than the 39% of the total group (P 0.005, Fisher exact test). Most of the patients (95%) were implanted with a 3-piece Alcon MA60BM AcrySof IOL (Table 2). The complication rates of posterior capsule rupture and vitreous loss were 4.9% and 2.7%, respectively. Four patients (0.5%) had an anterior chamber lens implanted. The size of the capsular opening was not measured during or after surgery, but none of the patients examined at 10 years had capsular contraction syndrome to such a degree that radial yttriumaluminum garnet laser anterior capsulotomy was indicated (an opening of 4 mm).
Figure 1. Flowchart showing the longitudinal 10-year outcome regarding intraocular lens (IOL) dislocation and pseudophakodonesis. Additional surgery refers to all types of IOL suturing and repositioning. ACL anterior chamber lens; CTR capsular tension ring; ECCE extracapsular cataract extraction; ICCE intracapsular cataract extraction; IOL intraocular lens.
2317
Discussion
Population-based studies with a 10-year follow-up are comparatively easy to perform in the Swedish health care system. At the time of the study, the risk of cataract patients being operated on outside of county borders was negligible. In studies to estimate the frequency of complications with a low incidence, it is important to obtain low numbers of dropouts to reduce the selection bias and to increase the validity of the results. The incidence of IOL exchange or repositioning as a result of dislocation or decentration 10 years after surgery was low in this population-based cohort with a high frequency of PEX. Most previous estimations of the incidence ranged between 0.2% and 3%, but most studies were published in 1995 or earlier, when a different cataract extraction technique was used.1517 A more recent retrospective study reported 19 cases (0.29%) of IOL exchange caused by decentration or dislocation in a total of 6630 cataract surgeries between 1998 and 2004.2 All patients included had at least a 3-month follow-up, and the time lapse from the initial implantation to IOL exchange was 1 to 180 months (mean, 65 months). The higher rate found in the present study may be explained by the longer follow-up time of 10 years and the addition of cases requiring IOL repositioning, that is, not only IOL exchange. The visual outcome after the second surgical procedure generally was good, which is consistent with previous studies.1,5 Previously, IOL dislocation typically occurred after decentration and migration of the lens through a rupture of the equatorial capsule or posterior capsulotomy.16 The major cause of early IOL dislocation currently is thought to be zonular rupture during surgery.12 None of the patients experienced an early dislocation, which is consistent with the observation that it now seems to be more common for the IOL to dislocate within an intact capsular bag.5,9 This trend
Figure 2. Graph showing the cumulative (Cum) 10-year odds of not needing surgical attention because of dislocation of the intraocular lens.
both eyes. Signicant decentration ( 2 mm) of the IOL was observed in 1% of the patients (4/287). In 283 (99%) of 287 patients, there was no signicant decentration.
Table 3. Demographic and Clinical Data of the Patients with In-the-Bag Intraocular Lens Dislocation
Case No. 1 2 3 Age (yrs)* 80 75 72 Time from Surgery to Gender Dislocation M M M 9 yrs 2 mos 3 yrs 9 mos 4 yrs Predisposing Conditions (Diagnosis/Associated presentation) Myopia gravis (axial length, 28.63 mm) PEX PEX PEX asteroid hyalosis dislocated with CTR; bilateral case None known PEX Neodymium: Yttrium AluminumGarnet Posterior Capsulotomy No Yes No Intraocular Lens Type/Capsular Tension Ring? 1-piece PMMA Pharmacia 812A 3-piece Alcon MA60BM 3-piece Alcon MA60BM CTR Model x14 Morcher 3-piece Alcon MA60BM 3-piece Alcon MA60BM Final Visual Acuity 20/32 20/28 20/21
Surgical Intervention IOL exchange to sclerally sutured IOL IOL exchange to sclerally sutured IOL IOL exchange to sclerally sutured IOL vitrectomy IOL exchange to sclerally sutured IOL Reposition and suture of the original IOL
4 5
73 72
M M
No No
20/33 20/24
CTR capsular tension ring; F female; IOL intraocular lens; M male; PEX pseudoexfoliation; PMMA polymethyl methacrylate. All patients except case 1 underwent small-incision phacoemulsication (3.2 mm) with implantation of a foldable IOL. Case 1 had his incision enlarged to 5.5 mm because he needed a lens power of 8, which at the clinic at that time only was available in PMMA IOLs. *At the time of cataract surgery. Morcher GmbH, Stuttgart, Germany.
2318
Mnestam
may be a result of the modern standard technique for cataract surgery with continuous curvilinear capsulorrhexis and in-the-bag placement of the IOL. The type of posterior chamber IOL may affect the risk for in-the-bag IOL dislocation. A 1-piece polymethyl methacrylate IOL with rigid haptics provides better centration in the bag compared with the 3-piece IOLs with exible haptics.11,12,18 One-piece polymethyl methacrylate IOLs also are believed to have greater resistance against the development of postoperative bag shrinkage and subsequent decentration.19 Among the various types of foldable IOLs, the acrylic hydrophobic IOL induces less capsule contraction, offers more resistance to contraction of the bag, or both compared with 1-piece acrylic IOLs.1,19,20 Most patients in the present study had a 3-piece hydrophobic acrylic IOL implanted (Alcon MA60BM; AcrySof), which may explain the comparatively low number of dislocations. Trauma and PEX are the most frequent predisposing conditions associated with IOL dislocation.1 Of the 5 cases that needed IOL exchange or repositioning in the present study, 4 had PEX, a long axis, or both. The percentage of cataract cases with PEX is high in many parts of the world. In our population from northern Sweden, 39% to 42% of cataract surgery cases have PEX.21 In PEX cases, it is important to be aware of the possibility of progressive loss of zonular integrity after surgery.7 Several reports recommend placing a CTR in the bag together with the IOL, in cases with zonular weakness.2224 In the present study, 11 (1.4%) of 800 patients had a CTR implanted during surgery, which is a low number considering the high frequency of PEX in the population. A CTR probably reduces, but does not prevent or eliminate, the degree of capsule contraction and spontaneous late IOL dislocation within the capsular bag.25,26 The CTR maintains the circular contour of the capsular bag and distributes forces circumferentially, which improves capsule xation and avoids focal stress on compromised zonulae.9,27 In the absence of signicant zonular dehiscence, routine CTR implantation in cases at risk is believed to reduce the incidence of postoperative IOL dislocation.1 Some surgeons have recommended implanting a CTR in all eyes with PEX,28,29 but the use of CTRs increases the cost of surgery. It is important to identify those patients with a preoperative risk for compromised zonulae who, in the absence of obvious intraoperative complications, should have routine planned insertion of a CTR at surgery. However, currently, it is unknown whether the cost of implanting a CTR in all at-risk eyes is justied by the potential decrease in incidence of dislocations. Consistent with previous studies, a male preponderance in cases needing IOL exchange or repositioning was found.5,12 This is difcult to explain especially because more women than men undergo cataract surgery30 and more women than men have PEX.31 Thus, there may be a genderrelated difference that results in weaker zonulae in men with PEX. Another cause may be that males are more prone to ocular trauma that might have happened decades earlier and has been forgotten by the time of cataract surgery. There is
References
1. Gimbel HV, Condon GP, Kohnen T, et al. Late in-the-bag intraocular lens dislocation: incidence, prevention and management. J Cataract Refract Surg 2005;31:2193204. 2. Jin GJ, Crandall AS, Jones JJ. Changing indications for and improving outcomes of intraocular lens exchange. Am J Ophthalmol 2005;140:688 94. 3. Schneiderman TE, Johnson MW, Smiddy WE, et al. Surgical management of posteriorly dislocated silicone plate haptic intraocular lenses. Am J Ophthalmol 1997;123:629 35. 4. Wilson DJ, Jaeger MJ, Green WR. Effects of extracapsular cataract extraction on the lens zonules. Ophthalmology 1987; 94:46770. 5. Hayashi K, Hirata A, Hayashi H. Possible predisposing factors for in-the-bag and out-of-the-bag intraocular lens dislocation and outcomes of intraocular lens exchange surgery. Ophthalmology 2007;114:969 75. 6. Jehan F, Mamalis N, Crandall AS. Spontaneous late dislocation of intraocular lens within the capsular bag in pseudoexfoliation patients. Ophthalmology 2001;108:172731.
2319
Department of Clinical Sciences/Ophthalmology, Norrlands University Hospital, Ume, Sweden. Presented in part at: European Society of Cataract and Refractive Surgeons (ESCRS) Annual Meeting, September 2008, Berlin, Germany. Financial Disclosure(s):
2320