Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 25

I

bp

Ma|t13114,2010

C ONFIDENTIAL

BP-HZN-2179MDL01793906
BP-HZN-2179M 1793906 DLo

bp
gru
M

Theintentof this PeerAssist to conduct lineitemreview both: is a of . Removing Horizon the LMRPand running DDll BOPon the Horizon the lowerstack . Running doubleRarnor Valvepreventerfualve top of Hodzon the on FlexJoint. Specifically: 1. Assessthe feasibiliW risksassociated and with bothoperations anddetermine significance theserisks. the of 2. Examine continqsncies confirm thesearesuffcient the and that and effective 3. ldentiffany needed, modelinq. ore-work. trialsandtestsfor pressure, inlerference, patibility com etc. 4. Assessand summarizetherelativemeritsof aboveoptions

oc

ONFIDENTIAL

BP-HZN-217eMDL01793907
BP-HZN-21 DL01 79M 793906

bp
ffi

.fiffrdrF

Mostof the risksassociated theseoperations with were identified the by planning teamand the proposed mitigations described the review in discussion The Reviewteam has not repeated these risksandso this slide pack should not be considered complete a listingof the risksand mrigations Focusof PeerReviewwas to determine installation risksnot e,(amine the wider nor longerterm implications mission to .stopthe flow" is

o
CONFIDENTIAL

BP-HZN-2 179MDL01 793908


BP-HZN-279MDL01793906 1

#
Amazing amountof $brk beendone- greetjob in shorltime Key riEkehad all ben identified- no significantaddilionalrisks idenlified by review Eem Rerriew team believecthat lhe EIOP BOP has a great probabilly of successful on instalhtifi than the ram/valveon Flxjoint Rwiew team believes that lh BOPon BOP operation feasible and can be managed b safdy The Ramis the recommended optionoverthe ballvalvefor the Ram^/alve flexFint on (caie of beingunableto removclhe LMRPfd BOPofi BOPoption) pressures Schedule points necdlo be gi\ren crefulthought and stop points/decision clearlyunderstood Keyoperationalrisks - Remoralof LMRP(lo!,v probability, consequence) high - Dynamics (BOPplacement, wather, timinge*c.) - Subsea visibili$and clce control - Hydrate Managernent Inhibition and Working oplions(BOPon BOP,Ramon Flex-jdntandVah,/e flexjoint)is sketchirE 3 on limited resource and couldcompromEe successot the selcted lhe option

bp

o
CO N F I D E N T I A L BP-HZN-21 79MDL01 793909
BP-HZN-2179DLo 793906 M 1

#
. Ram'scontrolsystemmorecomplex than \ftalve givesmoreoptions but . Valveclosurea simpleroperation (ROV)but re-opening vaMemay be difficult needto assesslikelihood beingunableto re-open of valveand implications. ' Ballvalve couldhydrateafterclosurepreventing opening . Approvalof ballvalve by MMS as pressure coniainmenUBOP systemis likely to be a challenge . TheRamb the recommendedchoiceoverthe valve ball

bp

o
CO N F I D E N T I A L

BP-HZN-21 79MDL01 79391 0


BP-HZN-2179M L01793906 D

#
BOPon BOP ' . ' Usesequiprnent func,tion whichit in for wes advBed BOPon riseris stifferthan Valveon DrilFpipe Hydrate inhibitor be cirdrlated H4 can to connector
Valve/Ram on Flex ioint

bp

Offersalternalivif presEure re{riction is in LMRPor LMRPcannotbe removed Approvd of PressureConlrol syetemby MMSwill be challenging Removdof Flexjoint boltE and making upvalveassembly a unlue operation is gub4ee No hydration inhibilion circulation sysilem Muleghoemeanslhat flangehasto be heldhigherabore connecla than BOP and so more prone to trydrates "O"ringscouldbe pulldout by venturi forcesas systemie landed

o
CONFIDENTIAL

BP-HZN-2179MDL01793911
BP-HZN-2 DLo1 179M 793906

{F
. . Focuson Hydr6{e Rbk3 ard Mitig.tions: - Educate oprations team on generalHydrate risksard isuca (Proximity, timing, chemistry pr6sure, temperdure effec*s) - Decideon which new ideaswe need to ptrrsueard wfrich stror.rld dropped?(e.g. be Nnoud aroundbase of BOP) - Wh* l6sons frorncoflerdam uould help on ROVS, hydrates, SIMOPSetc.? - Quanlifyandmodelthe glycolflorvrate, volumeo, duration neededforefrective placement inhibition and Adjustorganizational druc.tur establish and boundarieG: - Considerseparateteams ior critical work fronls that need to be progre66ed, e.g. ndrate inhibniql - Developresourcphn cbflnlng e66enthl personnelon rlg etc. - Developa (bclslon flou/cfEt thd shou/swtto makesdeclsionsand anfldpates Wlat its- considring rehearsing ihese - Establish boundary the (e.g,regutatory) delermine conditions and ifwe havebest tools,ard chemicals forthe job. - Engage ROVcontradorin hainirg, hidling etc, - Corductcrficaloperalione duringdaylight hours

bp

o
CO N F I D E N T I A L

BP-HZN-279MDL0'17 2 1 9391
BP-HZN-2179M 1793906 DLo

bp
ffi

Documnl requeted Statusof HorizonBOP on DP sptem - needTO analysis and report AssessWatchcircletightness Welheadstressweightand bending calculations required Loopcurrentstudylor leauing stackon stack- to be modelled - to BOPTest requirementsy'certification be defined(fimingissue) Evaluate of anchorwinch7 to Dullofi location aryoid use to clashissues To manageGa6aroundveaaels consider Waterspraying moonpool area Reviewinhibition systemto confirmadequacy and buildin additions if needed

CO N F I D E N T I A L

BP- HZN- 21 79M D L01 79391 3 BP-HZN-2 DLo1 I 79M 793906

bp
ffi

potential pathof RiserFillupvalve Manage leak Decide whetherGlycolor methanol be usedfor Hydrateinhibition will Confirm whetherhot water couldbe used- ref. Enterprise study ldenti! crificalpartsthat couldbe hydrated and couldcausea problemif hydrates expan6 or preventing locking/unlocking connector of - Assessadequacy/o rtunityfor backu ppo Hydrate brtion inhi p Determine ,vlongcanwe canoperate the plume hc in areawhilewaitrng for hydratesto dbassociate opportunity gas diverteron baseon of BOP- flat platewith Evaluate for guide funnel CheckInterference lines with

CONFIDENTIAL

BP-HZN-2179MDL0179391 4
BP-HZN-2179M 1793906 DLo

{F
Determine what is likelyto be mostsuccessful way of pu{ingLMRp (Winch, Q4000crane, denick)?

bp

CONFIDENTIAL

BP-HZN-21 79MDL01 15 7939


BP-HZN-21 DL01 79M 793906

#
. Enterprise interference confirmstandoff distance (multiple SlMOps) . Approach pathto be evaluated (currentissues)

bp

CONFIDENTIAL

BP-HZN-21 79MDL01 79391 6


BP-HZN-21 DLo1793906 79M

#
What if LMRPalreadyreleased?Confirmit's bcked whencuttirp riser Da/elopunlalchplan (hssonsfromROVoperations duringinilialresponse) - Capabilitie functionality e4{D0 runyellowpod and of to activate connecior?Line distancelSlMOPS - Explore opportunity accessbluepod? to Consider liftirp LMRPwith Q40m? Riskof rctivatingwrongfunclions frompod. Aceumulator back-up

bp

Lessons fromunlatch incidents Checking hydraulics Assessoperatimof ROVaroundplumewith diamond saw Drill pipe felling could car.rse problem,seal face damage- considerleavingAX ring to a protectseal face E\aluateLMRPstability with podwhichwif,up6et\nalue? ROVringremoval plume- visibility, in liftingforceswhenlned, ROVTsling reternce points,modelorlrial ring dacemenland ringplacement (horsestroe)? tool

CONFIDENTIAL

BP-HZN-2 179MDL0 93917 17


BP-HZN_2179M 1793906 DLo

#
De^relop decisiontree on rigil vs. hydraulicrelenseof nng gasket Hydrabs in diverbr joint - Could glycol be inl:cted inlo diverlerjoint? Pumpdorut b@st lire? Riekof riserplugging with hydratee Progre6sdesign of externalgrip ring g6l(e{ removaltool EvaluatefeGibilityfvalue ot snubbingin the stack wrth clump weight/oompen6ated clane Landing EDP- consiler designfunnelon baseof BOPto hetpcentralize Oetermine how ldE lo u/ait beforelatchir to gir/etime for warmirE/dissociation Evaluate of shroudto hold hydrate use inhibitor methanol if used? Degreof control\ryith stack placemenl? Leesthan 1 fool - clooeris better for hydrate ternpmanagement needto land BOPquid<V (temperalure and shouldhelpon-\renturi effect) Guidance syatem suchthat BOPis positively placebeforelandinq in assumino loss of visibility, involving ROVoperators consider and horr Horizon stack;ould be udlised? LaleEl movementis a iak with cunenis - use markerto rehearseaccuracyof phcefnent l-lowto manageloss of Msibilig when hnding BOP? Referencing betweenstacks? DDll is the rightrb for his workbut needrig DPOoperators in involved procedurcg

bp

o
CONFIDENTIAL

BP-HZN-21 79MDL01 79391 I


BP-HZN-2179 DL01793906 M

#
Hydratepotential there is a smallleakat the connector? f Methanol Pressure Buildup whenwdl shut-in howto managebieedof pressure, risksto rig, Develop Ext strategyilthings go awry an

bp

CONFIDENTIAL

BP-HZN-21 79MDL01 79391 I


BP-HZN-2 DL01 179M 793906

#
Operation different usingmuchequipment is with whichcrewsare unfamiliar Hydrates moreof a problem thanfor BOPon BOP- landed higher, lessinhibitor "O" fing sealscouldbe a problem.Recordof suchissuesnot good- venturiforces on nngs. Stabbing overobetruction oncecut ofi horizontally a risk is Riskof drillpipe stub havinglateralforcethat prevents of centering flange Boltloosening shearingis a risk as is numberof tools and Timeframe and resources carrythree options to Significantly lowerprobablyof success lhan BOPon BOP Lookstobe doable not recommended firstchoice but a Involves holdingpressure E/Etemnot normdly usedfor this (flex-joint in and riser connectbelowram/Valve) ok as diverter stembut more risk as cappng system E

bp

oc

ONFIDENTIAL

BP-HZN-2179MDL017e3e2o
BP-HZN-2 179M DL01 793906

bp
# frdtt

Failure removeall bolts- what are loadimptications not all the boltsare to if repacedbecause studblocking of hole . Operation breaking and making flange of out up boltssubseahasnot been donebefore (normally surface a operation). Nwvtoolsand procedure and onlylwo toolavailable.

'

CONFIDENTIAL

BP-HZN-2179MDL01793921
BP-HZN-279MDL01793906 1

#
Statusof wear bushing Flex-joint latchmechanism in and needsto be confirmed

bp

CONFIDENTIAL

BP-HZN-2179MDL01793922
BP-HZN-2179 DL01793906 M

#
Capping stack certifcation/MMS bsue Emergency disconnec't

bp

Needto understand schematic controlsystem of Opportunity havebothfull BOPand capfing stackin watersimultaneously not been to has evaluated.

CONFIDENTIAL

BP-HZN-2179MDL01793923
BP-HZN-2179M 1793906 DLo

#
Systemnot set up to provideglycolinhibition ROVhot stab/choke and kill injection Potential muleshoeto damagesealingface for Evaluate engineering dernal funneUguide assisting an for alignment planfor cuftingmuleshoewithoutcreatinga seal area Deltelop contingency problem Levelof confidence ROV probing potential of on stickup objects

bp

O
CO N F I D E N T I A L

BP-HZN-2179MDL01793924
BP-HZN-2179M 1793906 DLo

#
. Needto understand (normally closing volumes control and sequencing oubidesealfirst)

bp

o
CONFIDENTIAL BP-HZN-2179MDL01793925
BP-HZN-2179M 1793906 DLo

#
' Connectorreleasefluid volumes

bp

o
CONFIDENTIAL BP-HZN-2179MDLO 93926 17
BP-HZN_2179M 1793906 DLo

Pressure lock of ballvalveas it is partiaily cloed?Torquetestsbeen conducted indicating OKto closeunderflow Hydrate couldcollectaboveballvalvein the valvecavity,whichwill make opening valvevery difficult wateringress? of MMSacceptance ballvalvelikelyto be a challenge of

CONFIDENTIAL

BP-HZN-2179MDL01793927
BP-HZN-21 DL01 79M 793906

#
StationKeeping Making Flange up Hydrates BOP/Seals on Flex-joint conneclion Slabbing/Pressure integrity What,sinLMRP What happens LMRPRelease on Connecto( Oamage Latching Bendingmoments & Makingit work Failure undeGtand to downGides Reconnecting Stack SealDamage Disturbance something stack of in Whatwedon'tknow ROVCameraMsib'ility Plume Safetyof '176Psopleon Rig Equipment Unableto Re-connect

bp

CONFIDENTIAL

BP-HZN-21 79MDLO 1793e28


BP-HZN-2179M 1793906 DLo

#
1 JonTurnbull Bp 2 GaryWlf-Bp i AndyFrzelle - BP , Joe DeanThcmp6on WWC 5 LarryTalley- ExonMobil :. MarioLugo, EoonMobil 7 BobbyMohan- E{onMobil 5 lvafi Maetla - Bp S. William Stringfellw- TO 1D MikeBlue-TO 11 JessRichar&-TO 12 SterenWalker- TO - Mt 13 LarryWitliamson S 14 Kdl Lebhrc -Ooearefing 15 Gein Krdd- BP 16 Chadie Holt- BP 1l StereWalker- CfW 1n CodyEaLart-CtW -CtW 19 Johnnie Kctria :O Charles Cudb - CIW R.vlw Tam tol Rarwdve on Flexlolnt I MarioLugo(E)Kn Mobil) .1 KarlLeblanc (Oeaneering) 3 Lary Talley(Ercn Mobit) 4 Joc Dean TfEmpstr (WildWeil Conhot) 5 GaryWutf{BP) 6 Andy Frrelle (BP) 7 JonTmbLll GP)

bp

t
CONFIDENTIAL BP-HZN-2179MDL01793e2s
BP-HZN-2179M 1793906 DLo