Using a Genetic Algorithm to Design

Improved Storage Area Network Architectures

Elizabeth Dicke, Andrew Byde, Dave Cliff, Paul Layzell
Information Infrastructure Laboratory
HP Laboratories Bristol
HPL-2003-221
November 4th , 2003*
E-mail: {elizabeth.dicke | andrew.byde | dave.cliff | paul.layzell} @hp.com

Designing storage area networks is an NP-hard problem. Previous

work has focused on traditional algorithmic techniques to
automatically determine fabric requirements, network topology, and
flow routes. This paper presents work performed with a genetic
algorithm to both improve designs developed with heuristic
techniques and to create new designs. For some small networks (10
hosts, 10 devices, and single- layered) we find that we can create
networks which result in savings of several thousand dollars over
previously established methods. This paper is the first publication,
to our knowledge, to describe the successful application of this
technique to storage area network design.

* Internal Accession Date Only

Copyright Hewlett-Packard Company 2003

Approved for External Publication



   !" #
$&%'
()* #+
, $ - ./ # 102 354678/9:$ #;< #

=>@?BADCFE5GHJIKL?@MNOGQPSRTVUXWYGZ\[;]XUXG_^OPVK`CbaQGcd>@?fePVCQTVUhgCQiS>'jkCb]lA_G>@>
m;_nJodpfnJDqrvDqr{VsutwOvxJzy_vqz|_{pX}5v~O9-kbQ3zDXn d

q
FDD'Qb:FD_kbb$F'rD_D$Q_Q5_bFDDb'rb
DwOol__zDy3 v_nYr@f_xrn:{Dqz|qrv_z|DvDn${Ovqzn:Dvv_pQnJquv_op__zzyFq5-vx$q;nt'x|sOfvFz|O{;nQ5zqD;~v_pnOq_:t'vznYqrss
x:vpfp*{OnYqnJz-fOndv_~Ozxzn:OznY-nqFnYqo_zy-q_XDpDlvl{:ozDOqnY
QrzDO Of wnO{Ov_nYX_rznYfz'_r_Q-zn{Qndrnnrnqp5vDpo$XpX_n{znYy3qooX_nYqzzr*@yF_Odzn-O:n:z#{3qoDx;qqqnSx|vdL_Onf{QFn nJOqnffxxYnvv_lpQD{-v_zqL{qOxYrzOnDvqqp;nYn3s~Xpfv:nJbqoLnYzn:{O{lnYss
o$qOnDlv{hl{q{OvDq#ppfovzn9x: vnYzxYQzn:zvn qnf_OnYrqupo$_nzyFq|v_3~OopfrOx|n:{*z-nrnY qOpqLF{OfOv _l`vXnYzrn nYqz|vn p
OwzqqOq~Onpfx|x:vqfDndDqq DQq_z$z|yFvD :novpzn:n:{QvDnDO_nYqqu#o$_{OznyrxY{OznY~Xrfn_q nrOxxnr@pXvOpfx:vqD
9XS3L5S9
ER GDRLMQGDJ]XZ3?BHY>@OG>#WJGE5G_CFMTVCFQUTVUGGQHJWYISG9SG ?@>@M]QISGOOGD?@W|MHGCFE5TG_HMQHJMQCQGMVM*G_CQYOTSWJ?@GG_|IVQCQ>@G_WJQGDOOUNlWY?BUSCQTSSCF HYISCS?MPOCF5W>@>@G]FJUXM??@|;GHJTWYL?BH_ESYPdYiSUXHJ?@G_|UHJWY?@CFES9TViXFUHJJGDb?BU H
HYQWJWOCFQGZ3JQIS>@?@iXMHJI?@QUSTC H$CR ?@ WYRG iS?@G_|HJC GDU JGHHJ C JGH B HYQ WVCFO G MQO TSTSGDM: HJ?@TS OCTJZ3GH*IS?MIUSC:HC
?@TS*GHZ;HYQQWYWYG_NU P $SF:ISG OCQT ESWYHY?@ISMG G_>BTSG_XUXGGDTHY*CFTCFU WYG l  SIl]lJ?OM:CF:>@P$>@] Z3MISO?@MTSITSG_WJMOHJiX?@TSHJGUVHJIVCGHYC HJOISW|WYHQ iVQR I >BHJ?@TSIVN G
IVQCQWG C`5MQ?@GWJH9THLCHiVG_JGCOM IG_TVHYQUWCQCFTVQUG-WYC`G>COHYW|G_HU?WYG_HJJISQGiSHYWGMWYGD3?B|TViCQM>XI CQCHIVCFWOUX|ZHCFQWYTSGGCQ>@TV?BTSUN CFR?@THJG_9TVCFCF>@>BTVMZ G
?BTG_WYCQJUVQUXTS?fTVHYG?BO>uP_T WYG_HYJiSE>BHJG_?@?BTSTV?@T*CLOWJGHYQYWMCFCFQ>CFGEVJ>BQG >@iXHY?BOT-HJIVCFH$?*OWJGdGeG_MHJ?@aQGHYIVCFT>BXM_CF>lHYQWCFQGOP

MHJQO|HCFGHJTVe?@MTSG_GM:HYSHY?BISaOiV?G*WYMJSIVQWYCO>@l|iXGDMHYG_Uw?BOYPT ?@PbTVJHJ?BTVHCFMHY>@G3IS>BGDG*|UwO|P9>BHJiXOCQHYWYTV?BOCQU QTVGMQUXST G_WJVJO?@QESQiS>@TSGWYGD G_UU El3CQ]-SG_IVMSCQGWYTVTQH`USWYZ;HY?@-CFQHJWY|G_NiS>B]OVIVPCQOC W|HXR|M5iG_|MGD? M_U CFG_T QU*T E5USGCCFHi CC
=CFWYG_Z C*M?@WYTSGG TVGHMiSZ;] ?@QWJ?G_WY*N CQG_M_TTCFHYT?@9MHJOG|TOH#W|U HCFHYT?B>@H>@?BO?aOJTVGJW93iSGV WJE5UXG_alOM?>B|CQ>?@iVCFQWJT GSWYHJG_RISJTQGiVVWYaQIMG_G_]XW J?@SElM_WY]CF>9C*aM?QMJ?BOOTVTS5|G_?QUXUTSG_G_UXWYTOGDCQH|ES-?@>BQGL TM_CCFCFWYT|QHJ?@Z;OT WYCOCQQHYGG
TSCFTlGH]lZ;Z3QISWYGN WYG WYQ HYISQiVYCFTUSHY ?@>B>@?@QTV* UXQ>@>@CQWY_PUXG5GTVUS?BTSQTHJISGJ?BA_Gh HJIVG
q`o_ x_zrznYrXDl{QnxYn3rDOpf{*~Xn3vD{O{Qznrrn{V






  




  

  
 







 




!



"

$#

%

$&

#

'



( )+*,



!



.&


>BWJ?G OHiVR ?BWYG5RLOYG JT?BHESS >@WJG;FO=dHES]lCQ>@GMIGDIV?O`|JH_CF5PQESUXG_WYMG_?? alMdV?@GDTVMUGQlPQUSElCQG_]TV_UPQSCFWYTVCQUESaWY?CUX?@M;?@UXTSTSGDhXJMUXC WJG3?@>BX?IV|HJCOH?@Q T*C MISHJIVHDHPFG3CPTSC GH>@CZ;?XQH-?BWYN iS UXUSGCFTlalHYiS?C MG__E5PGZ C W
Cb5]*QVWJHYCO9JHJIVHJCFISH#WYQCFiSWYOGLICba?fHDCFPX?@>@MCQCFES>@>@>@G_G3UHJ?BHYCQM_YM GSFH; >@?BTVNl_SPXCFTVISUhG#TVCGHZ;C QXWY?@N9iSUVCHYCQC QiSZ THdWJG OiVUS?BCFWYHYGCHJGIVTCFHH
CFUXWYG_G |HJ?@|TV5CG_HYM?B? OVTGDU USGElal]?@MCGQP9>BCQ?TVHhU C ECFTVUX:P9Z3GD?UlCQHYMII WY G Z3iS?@IVWYG?@MI GT?hH USRG VTSGDU Z El]CbC]JTSQFiVH WYME5GGISWJOO|iXH_HJP;GDUC
HJISWYQiSOIC CQESWJ?M`G>@GGTH#Z3IS?MIUXlG_TSQH3IVCbaQGGTVQiSOIhWYGCF?@TS?@TS*EVCFTVUSZ3?@UlHYI

CVF>@TVQUTSR HJISZ3G3RL?fMHYISIGDCFChUX5GDVG_|CF|?@HQHJIT RLJQ5WG_HJG_MIVCO? VCFMGDIH JiSCSZ >@5?wQHWJHYISGHYISG_CFG3CO?@/M|I 5G_ MCF? VESCFWYGDT?U MCFiXGHY>@Z#GQ_PbGCZ3THYHG_ISU ?@CF>BG3TV YU RCHJ?B?HY UX]GDM?@|OTS?@TSQTSTVHJG_GISMW`GHJ?@?@5al`Q?fHHYWJ] H
MQTHYWYCQ?BTHY_PlEVCFTUXZ3?@UXHJIMOTVHYWYCQ?BTH3CFTVUhTSQT JS>@?fHJHJ?@TS Z#
R USG_J?BOTM_CFTE5G#MQVCQWJGDUHY-HJICH UXGD|?@QT FHYISGWH]5G_


S
I
3
G
S

Y
W
Q

S
E
@
>

G

GaQG_TSW_GP HZdROWJ NX_UXPQG_CQJd?BOZdTG_?@>B>5CQ9QHJWYISGGLUXS? WYQESMiS>@G>B6HHJICFTWYQFiXHYHYIS?BTVGWLUSTSCFGHHYZ;C-QZ3WY?BNhHJISUS?@G_T J?BHYOISTOJSG#WJTSOESGH>@GZdOWJ3NXE5 G_MCQiVZ JG

?BUSThCHHJC IS?3MZ CO|GOWJPOHJISG_ISWJOG-|CFH;WYHJGLISCQWY>@QJiSOHJI ISHYG-CQUSUVGUXal?fHY?@M?BOGQTVPCFHJIV>G`>@?B>@?@*?BHYCF?BHJHJGD?@QUTVTiV E5TSGQWH; E5G?@TSOW|HCF;ESCb>@G`aCQHJ?B>CF|ESV>@G>B?BH#OTC
HJCFISTVG3UTSHYXISUXG GDCQPbMHYH#ISGHJI>B?@CH#?fHYHYISG_GUTSCFGHZdOiSOTWJNH HYQEV5CQQTV>@QUXOZ3] ?Ul?@HJITSFCOHLJJSXWJMG ?CUSHJGGDHJUG_WJZ3?BHJ?@I*TSG_G_U COSMIHTS?XUXG3g CQuTVIUCFW5U QWJHYH_ P
VTVCOU MISHY?@ISTSG GWY]?@HYTSCQ?BNQGCQUS>;CbM]XO;|HHJTSMGOHZ;QSWY>BNGHJPG CQTVOU W3E*GDXHUXuG_NlWYTSCFHJG-Z3TJ?BA_CQG_>BUhOQSWYWJ?fHYOISES>@G-Q THCHJG u HYISG rCFWJH
QUXXG_JHY?B?B#OTG?Z3JWJCF>@G GHJ?@HJiSQH rT?BWYgGHYCQG_MMNG_ISCFTOTSWHU?CFiS#TG_R#UVMMSQCQ?@T Ch5SGiSWYHY ?@G_MdNlGDM:>@Z3]H ?fHY|I 5G_UXIVMG_?COJL]?@QJTVCISHYMZ3QWJ5TGDQCHYHY>@QIVG_OUC] H`ElHJHJ]WICQIlCUSiSH?fHYE?BOCQQTTVHJICF >RYCFC>@HYQ?@O G VWJX?BG_HJISG_W|HJHIV? GM

CFCWYJG-ISQ?BTS>@>@iXGFHYHCF?BOESOT >@iVGCFZ3HYW ?BCFHJTISHY?@iSGT ?G_MUhNl>BHY?B]Tl iXUXVHYGTVG_HJ_GUPwWYHYHJISIS?BGTVG G`OCQXC>BOHJQ?@WY?fJCFHYJIS>?BEVJQ>B`G >@iXSHYWJR?BOGD |T G_VTHJROHJG_LU OC>BElOWY]QG_]OJHJPQiSIVHY>fG HLISG`R#RSHJSSIS?SGC?CTSQGWYCQGDQ>BOUiVQ HJWY ?fESHYISiS?@TV>UU
iV]?@JGCQ>ESU>@GhQlTSXGU HZdTVOGWJHNXZ; QWYQNl>@ >BZ3?@TSISGiSWY?HY?@MhSWYlMG_UXiVWJGDHYIVCHIVCbaQGSWYGal?@QiVJ>B]JISZ3THY

HJSQWJ5XQUX>@iISQMO?@G`?BGDVZdCQG_Z3>B>ISG_W?USMG_I|JG_?BZ3GONXTS?B>@G_>VU HJWYG_JiSG RX>BH9LS?B>@ TQWYE5G FGHYRIZ36Q?@>BWY>?BUXOUSG_?BT?@JY?@CFMQ>XiVT ESYiSi?@|Z;>?@USTSQCFWYESNQ>@GG_iVTSUX|?@GGDTSHY|?@?@M*QCTCF>@QCFORTVWJU*?BHJHJIS?@GSaOWJQ>@aOaQGG RLY GRTHYH

HJSWYGal?@QiVUXGD|?@QTV

MHJWISCQ?fHYUXG_?BMHJG?@HJQiSTVZ3WYCQG_?B>>@>ISZ3|GISISiS?WYMZ ?I HYMHY?@MIVO|CHHGHJHJHYISIVISOG XiVUSYiVCFJPTVG USOW EC]UXOR#OG>BSTS>CFSGW?HJ`C ?M >BGDCQJ>B`IVO?@QHYIVWY?fCFVHYTCQIS UXG_GDWM|?@CF?@Q_T TVP-HJWJGDM|WJHYiSGDIS>BCHhGHYG_?@EUT GDG_H?fHYRIS "GW-QCFEliVW ] W
NESTV?BO>BZ3OQ>BGD?MUXCQQ>BGO>@]PHJ?BTIS|G S?@WYWYG_|U HHJSG_iSMESIV>@TS?M? CiSHY?BGDOT HJ HJ UXRLGD JMWJUX?@G_E5JG?@QHJT ISG JiVM_MG_Y iS>9CFVS>B?MCFHJ?@QT HJIVG_JG
Z3C ?BTV>@>XGUXHISZ;?@YG-QMiWYWJNG_JE5SCFFWY?@HYTVGIalUX?BGO?@WTiV'HJZ;GWYHJQISWY?N`#WJ G_CF>@CF5FHJGHJ?@W#TSIV#G?W*HY|HHJ]lTSWYiVGGDM:HZdHYiSO WYWJG_NUTVUXGCQG_H JZ;?@QQQTWY>@>BNlCQ*Z#TVUCF TSWYUrQTiX?@HYTHJ?BIVTVWYG#GTS> CG HYlUV?BOHLCTHYJC#G_HYMHJ HJIS?@QWY QTRiVZ;QI G

|C5G_QHYMQiS? WWLCFM_QOCFG_G#>@TS>B]CFGlWYHYG_r?@C-MT TSCQ>BGGDOHM:QZdHYWY?BO?fOHYWJT ISN SWJPXOCQZ; TVG`U YZ3MUX?BW?>@CY>wMH?BiVMTI YHYWJCFXHJTVUXIVU iVGMQWYG?@G_aQHYJGISiST G->fHCQ#|T5OG_?BEXTVMHY? S5CQiX?BMLTSHMGD QUT ECVQOSHJiSWYI WGCalZ3HJ?@?@Q?BQHJiVIThJ>@MCF]WYTVG_UXUhCGDHY|UX?B?@OG_QJTTS?BOGD TU
TSGHZ;QWYN G-Z3?@>B>wHYISGTMQTVM>BiVUSG`Z3?BHJI JiSOQG_|HJ?@QT OW iSWJHJISG_W3ZdOWJN









#

 
  






'

'

#

'



'

'

#

'

$&





&

'

&

&
&
&

&

.&

() *

.#

&











&

$



#



#

!

!


V9L

#RMCFiX>@>@HY]QWYGC>CHY?BHJTS?@TS - HYR \ HJUXOG_WYJCQ?BQOG#TR?@dWJGDC-C-WYG#>CGHHJZ;?@aQQG_WY>B]NXTS?GZ >@?BWYG_?BJHJG_G_CQU WYQMrITCFHYWYISG_?@CdCF|TGDM:UHY?BSOWJT?@QZdW9G3ZdZ3OWJ?@>BN*>5|UX5?JG_MMiV? J

WJWJGDG_>@|CFGDHJCFG#WMHYI iS TVRUX G_W|UXHCFG_JNQ?BG_OTT ?BTTSGGZ3HZ;?@>BQ>5WYGN TVMHJQQ5QV>@COQJOd]ZdCFOTVWJN*UWYTVGG>CHZ;HJ?@QTSWYNHJ*WYQEiSQHJ?@HJTSI V PREQHJICQ TVU Z3QISHJIS?MG_I W
H]5G_# TVGHZ;QWYNl;Z3IS?MICb]EGJ?B?@>@CQW3?BT|HJWYiVM:HYiSWYGCQTVUMOTVHYWYCQ?BTH

#$&






  !#"%$&('*)+-,.!/0213465

7iVMIZ;QWYN

HJOWYCQQG cdQTIVHJG_CQTOH E5CQGTVGUTKLUXQ?TVHYGhWJ?@ESEl]iXHY?BHJOIVT G KLKLGG_M?@CFJWJ?BOHJTGTG_HMISZ3TV?fHYQIS>@Q?@T Q?@G_Lg KjkG_VCQCFEVWJHJgG_CFTO>@HRCFT>fHYUVPHJIV?@T G

HQUXZdW?feUXGGWYWUXG?BTHJe5 H-G_WJCQG_HYiXTWJHJG_HOTSCFF>@HYQCIVQHJ`GWY?BCFHJHJISTVISUGh-ZdSWYMGDlCQCFM>BNl>@G_G_TSYU%G_Y8JG_B#F:?@RT 9 HYGWYUXG_JL?@CFQTVT U<V;TVUS$= ?BTSY!IV>?GG ] = IVMQCb?BG_aQ:TOGhPkH-Z3MJQISQT>@?iXMMI HJG?@TQG_HYTVCOWYCFMIHJHJG_hUIVCbHJOIVaOT GG
R CFESWY?M#UXG_J?@QT SWYQEV>BG_ l=9COMIZ3?B>@>5EG`UXG_YMWY?BE5G_U ?BThESWJ?@G P QWdQWYGUXGHCF?@>@_Pl|G_G


S
I
.G @$>@?Z 7GWYQGCF>@QOWJ?BHJIS E5GO?BTV*Z3?BHJI C RL MQTVTSG_MHJ?@TS GDCQMIISO|HHY ?BHY
WJTG iVOiVE5?BWYGG_WU- UXG_alO?@MW|GQHPbalQ?B?@OaQ>@G_CFTHJ?@QCTVJ GH ? G FCZ#TVl US_GdIVIS?CO$M*OT OVWJG;QiV>@?BWYTSCFNXHJ?@QHJT`ICFH]lTSCb?@M_abCFCQ>@?B>B>]CFEVWY>BG_GdJiS>BOHYW|H?BYT bC>@IVCQWJG_OJGG
CFMQWYG*T|O?UXWYCOGUXWYG_iVU CQ>BHJ>@]WYE5G_GUXiV?@TMG_?fU H-El] Z3MT OTVJ?@Z#UXG_|WJG?@H TS?@TV?BHJUXI?@aGD?UXCQiVMICQ> ?fHYGWCHJ?@QT k =dCQHJMIVI G CF>@QZ OWJ??B-HJIS?@TS?BHJP?CFHZ;>@>B]
MHJISQGTVZ#TSTl|G_GiSMHYHd3E5ISCQGWJGW3H;CQG5WYTVQQU WJGDH3U UXG_aHYal?@QQ?@OM>CGG_HJHY;IV?BOCFGTVSWD_SPSPWYMOQISW_VlPlWJO?? JC?BHYTSHYGIV>@C] CFH3OT=d?CQCQTSMSI FSH3WY?BQHJ5G_SOWYWYCFY?@|CFHJ?@?@HJESQG T>@GQCFPSWYG_ESCJWYiSWJ?MGD>BHYUXTSdiVX?BMTUXHJGQ?@CQPVTWYCQG_TV?BUXThUiHJM:>BIS?@HJTSG-?@QNXMTOHY| H
QThHJHJIVISG`GUXUXGDGD||?@Q?@QT TkPSQISW;G`HJIVCFG>@QWYOGWJCF?BHJWYISGL TSMQQTHJHJIS?@G_TlW iSG_9Z#iSTJGHJHY?@>dHYHYISIVGCWYH#GLCQWJCbG] TSE5G-5OYG|WY?@QESG_>@GU ?@SWJaOGGTH
WJ?BDHJISHJ CQ EWYD UwQPwW#GHYZ#HIS3GCF> JJSWYG_CF9CO>@>BU|G_IVCW CFB&Z ?@D WY>BHJ]ISIOG_C|aQHAH_G_P @$TSB&>B>BD] Z?UXHJ7ISG_aWYGQ?WYMiSQGOG*ISTS?@QGHiSZ;OH;TSQHYWYGISNXG-PSTSGDGHJ|HIS5ZdG G_OMWJCO?@N CQ>BHY>@G]hW-HJ5ISGW |GQWYZ3*IV?@?@TSMICFIV>@CbQaO G

HJMhCQJCQGQT PVISHJCQG.ISYG*JFLl?@iSTSM?@??fCFMHYNX?@HJCQGD[d> UiV ?BUXR>GUXalG?WMMGCFQ>@TCOQVQQWYO?BiSHJ?BaOWISCG"THY?BOElCFT]>|?B CTME5J>@GGiVHLOUX?BG_T`CQZ3YJ?BZ HJ?BOITSWJG CiSGT?BRWYH#G HJG_MTOQCTSHV TVCQG_W|#M:HYHY?@?BMZ;TViS G>CFaOG_WGCOW#5M?@IQT WJIVHLHYOISO|?@T H
G_ CQMCFI>@>UXMG_QaTS?MTVG G_VM:HYG_ISUG5MQQWJT HYV O=diSWCQCMHJI?@Q5ThQ?@WJ3HLHJQISWYG_QTiVCQWJ?WCFTVHJISQG_G_T U CF?BTTVHYCQ*>B]X5JQG_WJUH#JQGWYVQCQiVWYVCFHJPXG_>BZ3]hIV?B?@T MIOWYMUSOGTVW3J?@HY| H
UXGHYGWY*IS?@?BTS>@GGG @$CQ>@ESZ?WJ?7M`TSGWYXQUXGGHJWJGG TUSiSL?BWYHJG G_TVTOUH JQ>@iXHJ?@QT#Z3?BHJI CQT]JCF>@>5QWJHLOWJOiSV_PSHJIVG

Z3TSFLGISiSHG?@Z;MThNXQWY[;TSNXG_iSM?@G_>@CFUSYTVJGU*CQWWJCQHY] IS>BOOQJWYG3IS?fHY?HY;ISIV\CFC>@HdQHJQCQGWYWJT?BGUSHJIS* HJO WJHJG#G_TVTVUSUUSGTV;JHYRLG>@]WYG_5MJQQiST V>fVHiSO>@?@CFThiSHJWGDMCUHJH?@QHFLTGiVwe?@Z3G_MMNX?fHJHY[;?@IaQiSG>?@CF>@UXUXWYQG_G_G_JW?@W'Q?9TVOCF W|>JH$Q QW;WY>@CQQCQ|iSWJHJOG_GW

HJSIVWJCQOTES>@HJGIVG 3@$M>@OTV?Z |7?|HJG?@WYTSQGdCF:>@QI QD*WY?BISHJISO|HY3QCQWTV>JU CFWYB!QDEGdDSUXWJOG_aES?>@MGGDY B&D#HJ?@*GDCQ CQ|H OW$HJISG;>@CQWJOG_|H


() * 



#



( )+*,

'
$
, 



 

'



'

'



'

, ( )+*

&

'

!

'

 

$#










K  !#"%$&('2,.(&/#0LMON!PRQOS
TU(VMW+XY[ZA#65

 HJISOGWYWYCQG QGCFSR#5WYG_G_CQCWY*#HYGHZ;EQG WYNX>BL?@J5?fHYG_G_MU ? SM_CFiS>@EV>B]O>B?P'|IVCQG_J?@U UXG Z;QWYWYQN WJG_HY>@IVCFCHJH-?@TSWY G HJG_WJG_TVCQiXMGDHJUOCFCE5HJGDaQU G

UX7G_JiV?BOMTI

HJEISGGUXCQ?YiXMHJiVOY|GDCFU HJGD?@UTUSHJISG_JG ?BOOTh>B>@Z;Z3QWY?@NTSIVCQ|GD#M:EHJ?@G_QGTT UXQTVG QW3FHYISGWH]l5G_3 TVGHZ;QWYNl_PXCFTVUZ3?@>B>

IVMQCbTaQR#GHYCiXWYHJCQHYHY?BQTCOHYMNQCG_HYUL#G_UHYISZ;TS?@G'GaOHSZdGWJWDOOPQESWJHYN>@ISGGUXWYG_GZ3J?@?@Q?B;HJTITSHY?WYFCOTVHYUXISF?BHJH*G?@WQC TVTSCQGTSH>GZdHJZ GDOMWJWYISNG_TSJV?G_OWJCQiVOWYESG_MI_>BG_P VQG_W'>@Z3UTVISG?HMZ;IG_QaQCQWYGNl>@WJCF*>dZ3MWJ?BQHJGDTI-|GDHYaCQCFCQ?BWTWJM]l;IS?@GCQTSW>B >

IVCbaQHJGIVG*CM>B?@QTV?f|HYHJG_WU*CF?@TlTiSHY3SE5>GCQWMG_ U5OQT WJHYTSGCbHZdaCQO?BWJ>CFNESUX>@G G_J?@QQWT MOQTSW TSGD M:RLHJ?@QT$HJF#HYXISUXGWGDTSZ3XUX?BHJGDIV ?BT ? GC HYISRG ]

GCF|G_>@WYGVGCFUSWGGCTQHYHYWYG kGG3IVCFCbMESaQQWYGdTV?@M#|CFHJGTW>@CFGCQ?@YTSJGG_lTUMHY?@CF CFHJTVGD? ULU*G OIVHJCbC ISaOlGLG?@TSJQGiVH Z;G3QM_WYMCFNV?COH9MCOTS?BHJO]JTX_RMES?C? HYiVG_WYZUM_CZ3HJ?fGDiVHYUVI|H HYTSISR#QGHkTV?@WUE5iVGdVJJGTVSOCQ>BR#>B?B>@H]Q>E5|PQGHJPISHZ;G`RG|G_G T H

CFESWY?@M`G_>BG_*G_THY?@TC RL ?TSFH#NlTSZ3T?BTCQUSabCQTVMG
CQQEXHC CF@S?@QT MW;OGMS>@OESCQJ?@*TVG CVHYHY>BQGOWYP Q?@CQS>dCbHJ?@alOX?|CQHJI ?@>LTV?@YGCH9Z;HY?BG QOXWYTSNlWY VG_WJYOJG_ES9>BZdG_HJG_ISaQG`G_CFTSW_TP;GUHCFZ;>BiVHJQJISWYG_ONiSUXQjG_I CFJTS?BOOThWYCbCQalCQTS?TV|QUI GDCFWYhTQiXZdWYHYOG?BTSWJ>CN*SSC?BTHYWYM?BQO>@ESiVT>@UXGHYG_
WJ?BTGDHJHYWJ?COM:MHYM?BOOTViSTH3OTST XTSUXXGUXMGCQVMCQMH-?fH]CFT?UJJiSUXGDlG_PS`COTS;QHJHISGCF>@>BRLZ UXZ#GD|?@QHJTSE5WYGQESJS>@G>@?fHDPw?fH-iVUX|H lG_`TSQHHYCFNOG
HJTS+XISGYGHZ;[Z;ZAQQWY#NWY6N 5 UXUXGDO|,?@TSQ(GT !Z3Z3/?f0HY?BHJI I1 HYOWYCOG TSUX!PG?BHJHJ?@?QM$TVCFCQ.
>@>QHJQ(G_WY0M?BHJIVIS!TS?  iSGDcd PI/#|i#G_aQG GH!WPCFCF" >> WYG_JrG_TCQHJUXG_WYG_MTVYISUXMG_WY?@TSWY?BE5L GIVHJCbZ; aOQG*WY?@N CFH|SUXHJWJG_QTVaOGGXHJiVOGD UT
?B TSK- c 7 G TS#GHJ ?M R R>BO?@QTSWY?@?fHYISCQ>JVHYCF TVTSUX?BGDTV|?@QTHJWYGC GUX?GOCWJG_MG Qr>@M>BGDQM:THJ?@HYQWYTCQ?B TSGDUG_UX*OG_?@TS?@HYIVCCFH>|OV?BCQTTS3TSHJ?@OTSQGHJHYISWJG_G_GW
CFMQ>@>'TaQHYG_WYW|CQHYG?BTSXGDG_U3?@T lCUS? JVGG_HWZ3?@?BHJSI >@?BCGDkHYIV?@TSC?BH$HJiSIV GWYG9|iV? C C Z;X?BG?@QiSI HJGDUTiVG_UXOE5G-GW$abCQ >BiVGDG_UX QGDkISMGOTSUXTSG_GDQM:WYHJGGDG U
HJCFSSC WYOVCOCQMW|ISHY?@G_M3iSHJ>CFhW`K-aQc GWJ7 HJG 5jkUX?BG_NOJG?BOIST G_iSUXWY ?@|TVHJ?FMH-USJG_M_JCF?B>@OGT Zd G_>B> RRLLTSPGHYHWYZ;COQUXWY?fHYN?BOJTV?@ACFG>$?@STVWYMQWJOGDWYCQCQJ*G__PSHJ?@TSIVG
T iVMiSHJ>BIVHkE5GHYGWTSGJHQZd>@MaQOOGWJTVNhZ3|HJ?BZ3HJWI-CF?fHY?@HYISTOWYH?BCOT $UX?BHJ?fTVHYISM?BGOWJGDTVQCQCFG_J>QTSG_QCFG lHJGQIS5PG_QETVQGCHJTHJI ?HJM?aCF CQ_>@>B>B=9]?U TVCFMCFTVXTUUXU?@WJTSGD?B3TlCFa>@HY?@CF|ISHJ>@G9?@?U M;MQS|TSOWYQTS>BiXESGDHYM:>@?BGHYOG_TVUME5CQQG_WJG-MOG_OaQTSOG#>BGaOUXTG_? HU
abQCQWCO>B?UXUCG`|TSHJOG>BHiSZ;HJ?@QXQWYUXTVN?] HJCbIS]GTSE5TSXGGUXJHGDZdGDOPwMWJZ3? NVIVG_?@GThUWYG*OElWY]GDUSCQHJGMISW;IG3HJOTSGXTSUXOCFG*NOIVGGOCQPFHYIS?@T*aG-CQZ3|WJOIV]l>B?@?@iXMTSHYI ?BOM_USThCQGJalQG?WYCFCQGESGT>@GMCXOH|HYTVG|ISHJ?WXCFH9?@STOWYZ3HX ?@M>@>VG_rYE5T _G P
Z3CISab?@CQM>BI?UHYISTSGG]HZ;MQCQWY>BN > #Y Z;GbaQG_W_PX?BH*CQJMSHY# CO:3PCFTCb] GeOG_W#MHJ?@aQCbG-] >@TSXQMCFH#>'EJGG_CQJWYiVMM_IMG_Y G_MiSIV>'CQ?@TST?|S WJXUXOiW3MHJ?@TSIVG
Q GTVMGQHJTS?MTSGDCFM:>@HYQ?BOTSWJh?BHJHJISIV G*SMQTSISTSG GDVM:HJHYTSG_UGDJTSX UXG_GDLCQMHJIhOQJG5HJG_ISMG_? W`VGDCOUhLTVJGHGDZ;M? QVWYG_NU ?@w3H`ZGDCQCQJ iSWJQGDiVUhTVCOU;HYHJIVISCG-HMHJOIV|GH
QcdQQR WYWY?BTSHJMISG QiSI >#Uh5JCQSiS>@JWJS-XSUXiV>@?@iJG_MGUwG`PSC*EVQiXOG_H`TSWJG`GCFHYHQ?@SM#|HJ?@CQQ?@>BTSO? QCQWY>'M_?f|HYCFOIST>B HJiS>@HJ] HY?@QISTV?@UXQdGDISHJ|G_I?@WQCFTThMOK-HJISc G`S7 iXHJHYW CFCQ3HJUS?@_?fQHYPOTV?BISOCQTV>kZ;CFM>GaOGH ?BW
TV ?@?BTTSHJ?JISZ3CFG_HJ>@?BG_?@W;Q3MTCQCOTVCF|GO>U P
HJG_ISM:G_HY] ?BaOiVG>@J]GTCCFQWYG_WJTSZ3Q?@TSG`GHJTVISMG`X|UXGD?BCFTVWMIHJIV|CFVHCOMQG3TSHY>@] 5C-GWYiVM?fHI #QG_QTSWYGG3WCHYCF?BOTVT CQQ G_CQaESCF>@G#>@?Uh|?@ATVG GOHZ;QISWYG_Nl] _PXTVG U
|?@?B>CFW3WYG_JiS>BHY?@ThHYIVCH3HYISG R QiSHJ5GW QWY;QHJISG_WMO*CFWYG_U USG_J?BOThGHYISXUS
*C?@TS#?@C XCF?iS?BUX>kiSCQ|TVVUCQTlTSOiSTSiS?@>TSEHYhG_WJWOHJWY GG G_ USk[QCQOK G_>@J7 M iVQ#TV|GTS kG_C MR HJ?@TSE5R QiSEVCFTiXTlHUX] G_UQHZ;rWLUXUX?CFG_aQJG_?BOW|GHYTSHYG G?@XTSW`G_HJWYCG?@T G*E5Q?HJLiVIVTVGOTSUXQG*G_WU CFZ3SUXISI ??@CF'MIGISIVHJGCOG] W



 

( )+*,

, 





&

'



, 



( *

 



'



, (  *



&

&

#







&

,

&





&



! 


&

( *

( *



&



&

&

HISCF]>G|5iShGWY?WJ GDHY?@HYMLTSWJHJ?GM:GDHH`ZdMISHJOTSISWJ?NG_?BPWiSHJG_OIV G?@TSG_WYCFRHJG_?BU QSG>@TVGQGTG_HCHJHJ?@QTQTSM_>@]CFT JQGDiXMHY? ]G_W abOCQWJ>B?/U TVHJISGHG Z;QQHJWYISNlG_ WMO*?fHYI CFHYWYISG_?@U

OCbabiVCQ?BWY?BK>GCFGDEVM|>BQ?@GQTVFTTS[dG_ QMHJHJIK-?@TScS WY7 QTVESl>@US3GG_`CFZ3TVCQISU>@JG_[TWJK GGDO7CQiVMI?BWY3G;TVHJlIS?@USLG#G|?@I?@CQTS?B>?@CF*C W3?YHY>BC?@ HJ?@?fQHYRLTG_U CFUXJGDQ|Q?@QiVG#TTOMH?@T HHJIVaMCQCFOH>BTSiSE5TSG GDFQM:HJRHJI ?@UVQWJUXTG ?
HJUX?@G_QJTV?BOCQTh>B>@]VWJcdOIlESi'>BG_PSGHIVCFCO> 9VCFHYIS>@>@GZ CQUVHJUXISG_GUhS?@WJYXJUXiSiGM: HJ?@QHYTISG US?@CFTlHYabC CQ>B?UhZ TSGHYISHZ;WJOQiSWYNXQIh HJIVG`ZdTVG_GaQHGZ;W;QHYWYISN G X=d RCQM I
IVGMeQCQG_M:Cb5HYa?BQaOCFTSG`?@G_>@CQJTQESH >@>@iXG ?BTHY(?B7OHYTVISQG WYGZ3TS?@aOG>B>HGZdW9TSQOC H;WJN IRCbIaQCQGUXCQ?Bl>BHY>5GDTSdXTVZ3UXFG_TH3;TS>@M?BGOGDTSU?BTSH HYGDQM:HJTE5GDGUHYISHYiSG >B>@G_CF] COMMOIQiSTSFTTSHYH GDISM:G HYW G_(U EV@S
CFiSCTWJFHJUXIS>@Z3?G_Uw?@WJUXPSHJMIOWJHGO?BH P
Z3?fHYI R UXGD|?@QT'PSHJISGJGH3 TSXUXGD?@3TVFH3NlTSZ3Th?@TCQUXaCQTVMG


 



&

 

,

'

&







&

' 3 
rQTQWYHJ?BHJIVIS?@/JG_iM|HJGD?@U QTZ;GGZ3Z3?B?B>@>@>>3HJUXIVG_GYT MWYS?BE5WYG_GhJGHJTISH-GHJ|IS5GG_MWY? G_5JMhiS>B?@HYS >@GG lG5TGHYWYCF?@HJ*?@QG_TTHY `HJHYISGE5FQHYGI TVGiSHJ?W|MHYISCFG> W
QTSXGHHYZ;?BQ?WY|NXG`PR#QSSSHJ??@C*US?YG_CJHJ?BO?@QTVT9CQ TVU*R#HJV*SM?@CWYG_USCG_HYG#J?BOTSTVG_Z?@TSGHZ;JQJWY?BNXEV>BGCFTGU Z3Z;?@>@G>5JMISCQT ZYHJCbIVaQCFG*H aQOG_WdW JYDCQ
>B>
TSGHHYZ;ISQGWYNXQWYk?@Z3Q?@?BTVHJCFI*:> CL@$UX>B?@WY?Z G_M:7H G_MWJQOTSG*TVMG_OM:|HYH?BOT?@TSG?BHJZ3?CF?B>@>@>?@JCFG_>U |JRISPFCFZ >BHJHYIVIVQCiSH-OI-?BHHJ?@ISG55OGYW |?@QESWY>@GCFHYTVMUXGdG_UXJl?BOG_T
TSFG_WJH#?@CF>@GZTCbHY]l;>@G_G COOUSiCFiV>5$HJIVHJCF-H#?@Tl aQGDHJISHYG-?BR#CHJVGdSHJ?@IVCG;?@TCSHJWYiVWJaQGG_UhUXQG_iVJW ?@QVTVHJ TSXGDJIS>GCFTQUSiXJHM_MCFQ5G;GCQ TVUHJIS|OGD>B|iSG-HJ?@G QT
|VCOM GRZ3 ISUS?MG_IhJ?B?O3TG lIVVCQ>BOHWJZ;GDU >VCCQHYW|GHW XHYISGUSGHJG_WJ?@TVCHY?BOT HJISG R HJQ5Q>@QO]QPVCQTVUHJIVG
UXJMGWJHY?@GEWYGD*U ?@TVECFG_HJ>B?@QZ-TP ZdGhHJIVZ3G ?B>@WY>dQUSiXGHYHJ?BG_TSWJ ?@OTSW-G HJHYIVQGh5QUS>@CFQHYOC ] ?@TVZ#UX?@ WJGDM:HJ>@?B] HJIHYISISG G O?@*GTSVO>BG_*G G_Z3THY?BC>@>HY?B|O5TG_MUX? G ]
QCFTSES>@]WY?@MHYISTSG XUXWYQGDiXHY?GCbCabVCQ?BCQ>W|CFHYEV?@M>BG iS>@CQQW W`iV|ZG wJISISQGiS>HYUQ5HYQCQ>@NQQGO]Z3IS?LG_THJISCFG_TT?@CQT WJESG?BWYHJWYWG_CFU WY?@>B]WYQ> CFWYQHYISGG5WJlOQiX>dHJGD
|5G_M? VGDU


 

#

 

 

&

&






 &

 

'

&



'

#



  .
(0 #"% 0 Y '0/



dZEG`OISWJGWJNXOQiXG_HJQTSGDTVQU>B] HY4ISG @SWJOG_OTVW3iSMQG_XI CQUXM?@I RTS >fHYGiZ-WY|TVGDPSCU HJHYIS?BISaOG-GGO>@WY]GGTS?f?HO*>@?BGCb]J?B5HJJGDG_5U MG_? MVHJ? GD]3G Z3HYXIVSISCWJ?H;MGDIJHJJIS?@OQG TST G ZCFEVJZ3WJ?B?TS?@M>@O>5TS>BGTVXuF>UXCbHG-]QEG_?BG`HLWJGDWJ|U IVOiXQTVHJiSGGD>H UU
HJHJISISWYG-QJiSQOiSI*WMCQGTl]CFTVJUZ3?fUXHGDMI'HYPQ?BTVCFCFTHJU?@QHYTISG WYG HJOISWJG G;HYIVZ CHSHYISISGGWYG3CQZ3ES?@WJ>B>S?M`E5TSGXCUXUXG?@WJGDlM:OH9>wM?@QTS?@TSTSGD?BHJM:?HYCF?B>@O?@T*JG_E5UGCHZ;HGHJG_IVT G
Z3H?fCFHYWJIHLHY ISG?@GDWCQMIZ3TWYiSiST TV5? H-iSG;MQ?@USTGHTCFHJ?@TV? MCCFHJT?@QiVT*TlE5iSGWE5 GWDUXPb?BWYeCQGTSWYQG?@TTSHL H]lO5WG_MLQTl aOGTSCQES?@GWJTV?MMG TVlWYUSQG_-BdGDHJCQ MI
 q'lv_XnJzko$nxDOrf{OnYzkquo$;quQXn'_v_~Qzx9OF{On !#"vl$
v_`Fq~n-{OX) (SzrnYqzL_BzD qnvLv_o~Ozqx|xF{QqnDOwznYvnl{hovqQO* nOv_qO-nDxODqLq9qxn;_-v_~Qf{ Ozf"&x3%~lO'YvDFl{O{Qnozq_f{FrOnqzkpqQqlzvXn;qDxrqDnOnq
{Ov~OzO_xdq9OxF_{Onqx:vvFFqOv_fO{OOpOnD~QqOqndFn3OX~_zrqqrnp_v`xJOon:v_qXxJnY z{QqlOv-m;v3:oon nYqx|z:lvLFo{QnDqx|t, + dzrq~l$v_D{Qov3fF{Qq~

'

&

.&

'

'



3ZZ3IS?fHYGIWYG C  CF?ESdWYHJ?ISMGTSTlXiSUXG*ETlG_iSWd E5GWCFES WY?MD

TS@SXUXOWGDG CbSabCFCQ?B>SCF>@EVGQ>BPG ?OR Z;UXG?@WJIVGDCbM:aOH;GMCQTSTVCFG_ESM:WYHY??BMOTTSX?UXG|55G_MO? V>GD U
HZdZdOiS>@JU Z3WJ?BHYG_MSISWJGDGD|PG_TQH;iSCW 5OYZ#J?BES >@CQG9|USOG>BiXVHYTS?BOGDTU?@CQT ;?@TCQES@$>@?@GAQiSBDWYGAPFHYB IS WJCOG_ GOISrT HJHIS?PCFG TVSU*CQ*HZ;V>BGOUXPQG_HYalIS?@GMWYG_GL_PQ?;Z;CG
UX?BWYG_MH#MQTVTSG_MHJ?@QTEGHZdG_GT
 CFTU
  

'

$
#

#



$

q QOznn3_l qlpvol{znquFoOz{Onn- nxnq @_zdv_vz~Oqrz|vzrnOv_-pn;9{QnrDOzD~OpnQnYznvzn

v-n FDOzxYn nYqfvqD vl{Qof{FqdnFOzn:{  
ll::o9o3 __q|q: {O{Onn xxnn_
   "!
#$ "!

ll::&oo9% __q|)q % {O{Onn xxn_n_

'(  "!
*( !+"!

host0 host1 host0 host2

host0 host1 host0 host2

host0 host1 host0 host2

device0 device1 device1 device1 device0 device1 device1 device1 device0 device1 device1 device1

(a)

(b)

(c)

,.0 :-nYo/ $Dlz-n FnYt-ODzr~Xnr-~nv_pnq{ DnOvxzDn-vrnzXn-#nz`xYnQOn:q|zvnY{rqnD Oqf35O_v_ 3~vpnvDrDDp$oOqOnY_znnqv__~Qzn`zqfDxnnOOnFd{Ovnq# Xp{QxnDrp92Dl1 v-_Qzquq|Do~sp{Onn oxoqnDx|O D+5nrn

LOq|vqn:{

3.45768967:;=<?>A@BDCFEHGJIKLMNGOPQ>SRTPVUVCHWDUYX+GCFLZ\[CF]"PVZ^C_Z\`aCF[BKP2bcIdKLMeEFPIdG=GLfKCF[O$GfghX"i)c9gj@Ti)c
X+ZlkmgjUi)n$oAODP=>SLEFC_kpEFCFZDP.KPVRKP>SPVZ$G>qXrkCHKPVU)GAUVLZDZDPUGCFLZs@TPGutqPVPVZpXvODL>wGAX+ZlksXrkPV](CFUVPn(oAOP
kX>SOPYkpEFCFZDP>.X+KPQEFCFZDx(>qGODX+GJUVLZDZPVUGAGLyXfIzX@KCFUQZL(kP&LZ\LZDP&PVZlksLKAGOP?L+GODPKYn{|XU O^EFCFZDx
ODX>=X}UYX+RlX+UVCHGu~^LIJbY"m=n{X+U)O\ODL>wG&X+ZlkmkPV](C_UPvOlX>JGtALXY]XCFE_X@DEFPrRTLKSG>VnDoAODPv>wt.CHGU O
ODX>vbY}X]XCFE_X@EFPfRTL+KSG>VnDZ\PYX+U)O\ZDPGtALKx^$)" QODX>=X}RTLKSG=](CFLE_X+GCFLZLIAb
CF>qLZEH~2EFCFMCFGPVk}GLQGODP.>SBDMLI9@DXZlk(t.C_kGO>SBDRRTLKSGPYky@(~yCHG>qRTL+KSG>Vc(XQO(BD@2ODX>AXkDkCFGCFLZlXE
CFZDUVLMC_Z[y@DXZDkt.C_kGOKPV>wGSKCFUGCFLZ>JGOlX+GAX+KPQEFPV>S>AGODXZsGODP=@lX+Zlkt.C_k(GO^>SBRDRTLKSGPVks@$~2GOP
RTLKSG>Vn

 K )    !0 O $ $H!0



6RCQY|Q?@QGTSTVQG_TOGH|WY5GG_SMWY? G_VJGDGTHCWY?$QiXHJIVHYG GTOMW-OTVG_COHYMWJIiM: HJGDHYU ISG G#MZ#CF T'MR6OTVJ?@lUXUSG_GW>HJIS G3HYTVISGGHZ;TSQGWYHNZ;HJQWYNEG#HYISCQ?@T

G?BTXS|WYG_G_aQYG_|WY?@CQQ>T*|HJGHJIVHG#@$S?BISW|G_H_TSPXFZ;H]lGL5UXG GOHJR GWYTSG?BHTVZ;G`QZ3WYNIV?@?MI MWYCFG_ESCFHJWYG_?@MLU TSWYXQUX6GD CWYQQG_6TSQHYISG`G3WYGlSQWY>'G_CQJGWJTGLHYECFG_HJ?B?@TVQT

HJiVWJISG_|SGGDWJU QGDG|HYG_TVIVTQCHJG_HU G-?'?BElHYT ]ISO@HJJIS?@GQGiVHYIVWJOVG CGHTSB OIV *M_Cb#aQG*G Q?@TST >@]Z#@$iV?@'Q|WYiSGDQ#WYiX.G OHYG_TSB UG- CHY LISWYiVHYQ|ISiSGDG LOIHCFZdHJEVIS WJG_'?M-#TS G XlUXHDGDISPGdHJPISTVZ3GGISHTlZ;?BiS>@GQWYHYNE5ISGESGW-iSTS?@ >BGH HZd>@?BWYTVOQNlWJ N
TSWJGOGD UXG_HJU IVG#HJQG_|iSTSVQOG#W|HdJHJGDISMG ? MCFZ#HJ?@dQ?@T FUX GHJHYGISWYG ?BTVZG_U ?@H9@SWJOOWdiXHJGDGDCQUMI UX?BWYG_Z-MHJPO>@]?BHYE5;GVHCFZ;HJGI G_T??fUXHGHYISGWYH9?BCQTSTVGDUU
HJEUXISGGWYalHQZd?MiSG_GQOGPXIhT CC HY>BIS?@TSGCFN ES|WY?5?MLG_MMTVWY? G_lCG_USHYUGQG_PU|HJOISE5iSGGWYHMCQZ;G>BOGCQG_QTVT WYU?fHY?BHYISCQ ESJQWJV?iSWMWMH#TSG`XMUXCFISTVGQGDMP5UhNlHJUX9IG_CHJ|HHJ?@MJTVGCQCG`T HY?B? OJiST HJSIS5G_ WJQGHJWJIVHL?G HYISCFG>@WJZGDECQCFUX?@TVd] UXWJZ3OCiX?>BUlHJ?@TSGDHYIUN
TSMWYGG_GDCUXHYG_G_UU ElE] GHHYZdISG_G GThHJZISG'J QiSHYWISMGG`WYGCFTV?@_U PwHYCFISEVGWJT ?M`HYIVTSXCHUXG >@?BTV@VN QW?->B?@iVTSJN G_UwCQ>BPk>@XFMHJIVCFHJG?@WYQZ3T'?@PlJGZ;G`CZ3TS?@G>@Z6>wQ>@TS?BTS>@] N E5?@G
M@SQQT>@>@HYZ3WYCQ?BTS?BTSGDHJU*IVE?@3]CbaGCFHJIS?@>@XCQESUw>@PXG3HYEVISCFG-TVQUSG_Z3TSQ?@UlHYI GDdZd?@T G#@Z3?@?@Q>@iV>WJ5G GWYBZd?fH;OiS>OU W|H9E5alG-?@QES>iSC?@HY>f?BHOCOTV?BC>@H9>@iVHJISHY?WYdCFHJ|GDHYCQU Q?@G T
@?@QiVWJG
E GCGaTVCQCF>BMWJiVG;HJCF?C#MHJiSGDTSU >GCF'HW3ZdR UXOGDWJ|QN`?@WYQIVTCQiS?@>#E5C QGG?@QaQTW`GThESHJiSISEl?@G ]h>fHDPD= HJbISiVJGd CFHJHJO?@QTOb>B:OB
Q]CFCQTVYUJlWJMO?@iXCFHJHJ?@GDTSU#Z3 ?fHYHJIISG HJISGZ#SWYXMUXCFTiVM:HJHYIS?BOG_TT
Bb
  
 


HJISISG-GDGCQTlHJMiSG_I WJ E G_HJ W3IS G-P MQCFESOPWY?@OM`#TSTSCFGXTVTUXHU G-9$TS5CFGDQWYMWJGGDH3JTSalYOCF?BWJOWY>@]QCFPQCFHJHJ>@?@?ISQJTVGCF_HJTlPS?@QiSCFTVTVUE5 GHJW;PIVWYGG_JCFISOGDM:Q|HHJiS?@FTaQUXH3G_G>Bal]OP:?MHJEVGIVCQG5TVQUXWJZ3QHTS?aUlG?@HJHYQICF>CWYZ3]HY?BISMOO?TVM|_I H P
?@G_CQMWJIG WYiSiS?BT'WYG_PSUCF>@ES>@iSZ H*HJTSIVQG-HWJCbG_a>@CFCFHJ?@>@?@CQaQESG`>@G?B5QIVWJG HYCFMTOMTVGH CFTG_HYCO! MI"wHYGPkWYZ3 IS?HJMIE5CQGWJGMOJT GVH*QCiVHWJGDHYU ISGh|HYCQW|H
EMO] |H CFTISG9aQHYGG?@WYW -rCFCQSSS SWYWY P#XX ?B?B CFP#CHJ HY?@QG_ UTCFTZ3 U$?fHYHJIISCQG_HJWJ?BISW-GdG TSZ;QQOWYWWJH CFiS>@M_?@>@CQJCG_JGUG laHJV`CFWJ>@>BiSGD?@JG;GDJ EG_'UGHZd?BISTG_GG= TGZ;OQD`iWCCFHJHT?@UQM_TCQB;JGEPk]?BUST Q?BTValZ3G?UXHYISCQ?B?TVMWJI]
  P     CQ% TVU   CQWJGLHJISGTliSEG_W; ISHPXUXG_al?@MG__POW Z#9?@ThHJISGSWYQES>@GCQTVU   P
Q W3P 5 Q& PWJH   CFTVU (' ?@3HJISG-QTVGHYCQWJ]MH3 CISHDPVUXGal?MGOP VESWYGMCQES>BGOP CFEVWJ?MTSXUXGQP

  %   *)  
 )  

 *)  &+
-,/.10 2 |

  ,/.10  l|
Q=9CFT>@CQ>BXMHJMIISCFG#MHJOGDUXU*GD|5EV?@QQCFTTVTVGUS TZ3H3HJ?@IVUlGG3>@HYGITSGCQGHWJTZ;G H3QGDWYCQN MbHJIISGIVCG3GaTCQGDiV>BCQiVJCFiSE5HJWJG?@QG_WT GiST5TVHQM:WJ HYH?BOaHYT?@ISQ4GM>CQHY3WYEV?BWYOCOG_TVUXJTSOCFGDTVTVJ USU*9CF HJOiSCiST TMESQHiSTV ?@|>@HJUSWCQCFaOES?@GT>@W GH
|CFOES>BiXWYHY?@M*?BOTSTVX UXG5GQ|WJG_H-ValCF?BWOC>@HYCFG_HJU?@QTVHYIS`GE5G_GMaCQCFiV>@iVJCFG*HJGD?@QCFTWY>B] aQISGWJ?BHOTVQW UXG_HYaIS?MG GUX5?@WJQGDWJM:H*HalM?@OQTS>CTSHJGD?@M:QHJT?@Q TWY?@QTS ?
HJ?CF>@?@JG_U R IVCOUUX? MiS>BH]MWYG_CHY?BTV UXG_J?@QTVZ3IS?MIZdG_WJGhESiS?@>@UVCFES>@G $?BTHJIS?MCO|GOP

#

'









'

'



'





'

'

#

'



 

"



'

 





&

&





&

'



!

 

&

-

&

&

?fH#OZW|H3CQal ?BOQ>@iVCFTVHJ?@U QTVHYIVC>@G_H#COZ;US;G?@HJQIHYE5?BTSGHJ*HJGISWL|HO>BiXUXHYG_?BaO?TVMG`5QWJHal?@Q>CHY?BOTV;IS?BOISGW;HYIVCFT CFESWY?MLTVlUSG



$" T  G#&A$
E  $&0



 

R R CFT*UXG GDS|CQ?@Q*ThVS>BGOWJOPbMESQ>@GTV J?UX|G5W$G_HJMIV? G3G_TSU G?@HTZ;QWYCQNESS>BG ?@MB HJiSWY G_iSUV?@T|@$G`?@QHJiSIWYCG H;HJIS E5G`:ZdPFCQG_?BOC`IJHYQ;>@?BiXTHJ?@= QTiVHJCF`HJHJ?@QIVT G

MGBSOCF|CFHLWYG Z3SIV>@ GQ?@PwMI Z; G? ` Z3 | iS?B>@Vb>9SM>BO ?@G_TVU J?@B UXCQ G_LB!W`D VHJCFISB WJIG H MBDO |XHYH=dISG CQM IGDRCQGM>@IGUXISG_GOJT|?BHOH-T ?@QTWSHJWYUXIVQG_GESa>@TS?GMGG*HZ;HYJQWYGDEN MG? IV(COMB!CFDEHJC?@DVQPT CQrTVJT Z3GHY?fHYCQHISMWJ?@I]
Q T I C DYJDE Z3DSP?BHYCMI >@?BTS( N B  DEIDYDSD P'CG OM_W|HCF>OMiST>CChHYG IV#OHY" |IS
H GHJDSQ P'HYCFC>35QOWJ HTSGQHT CFWY(C]' UXMG_Oa|?HM;G Z3 ISIHJG_ISDYWJ?DSGPwGDTSCFCQGTVMHUIZdOTSCWJX5NUXQG COWJH
* ISOGTSGTSHGCFHWYZd] OMWJN H-?B%T ?
@$M?@OQiSWY SGiX HJGD EU CQIV
!CQHY.ISHJG ISMWYG G$HIV O|HY?BHY_PkG_5COQMWJ
IHY-%&Z3 CO?fUSHYIUXGDQU TVHYG HJOISW|G HDPkMHOZ;|H UXG_a?fH?|MG_GD> P
QTSG- Z3?B|HJ IB!DEOD TSGD O) W|OHD PSQTSJ G-B!DEZ3D ?BHJII HYDYISDQWY GG- 5B&QDYWJD HY_PSI QD TSD G) QJJZ3 ?BHYM I'PVI CQDTVDYUD |G_aQB G_ThD DY>@D ?BTV) Nl O V ISI DG_WJ) G FQWY G
 *) I D




CFESWY?@M`ISGTSWYXGhUXG-?5QQTVWJGH3alUS?BGOal>@CF?@MHJGh?@QTV5QWJ H!al?B*O>@CFDOHJ ?@QTOT

  + 4-BbCQTVUHYISGWYGCFWYGhTV
MGGTVGDJUiSWYISQG_TG*UCQG_HYCOIVMCQIHiSMHYTISQHG 5>@?@TSQEVTSNXCQG_-TVTUXCFH TVZ3U ?UlHJZdIOW|G_GHaQSLG_MW_IGPlCbG_Z3aQUSGISG_UG_TVTFJH-ISESOiSEiS?@G_>@>@UXGU T?@TSECFG>@>BHYCXISMG|CFiSHJTSGDGU HZd OWJHYZ#NhISLGZdHJEVG-ICFCITVHCbUSaQZdZ3G-O?@CFUliS>@HY>@WJU I GDCQiVG UXJ] G
*EVCFOTVWJUSG9Z3EV?@CFUlTVHYUSIZ3G ?@SUlMHYGIG_USHYIVG_UCFT-Z3HY?@IS>B>G;Q>BTS?@TS>@]`NXkEG;ICbC aQGiSCbTVaMCFHJ?@?@Q>@CQTES>@G _HYISGdIVGCQWYG QQiSWYGQTPHkHJ ISGECFCFTVUXOZ3iST?UlHkHY IG CbSaMCFG_?@>G_CFUXESGD>@U G
ZHJ3IS?f?HY#IS?BUXTGD|C ?@QTCFEVZdWJ?GM#IVTSCbXaOUXGG QTS >@?B]TVMiVGJOG_UTS>B]*|Z3Il?BiSHYMEVIVdG_IV_PCbaQG ?BTSD ViX@VHdQEVW CQTViSUXWJHJZ3IV?GUlW#HJIhG l>BV?@>@CQ?fTVHCCHYHY?B?BOOTVT' PX |PG_CQG TVU?@T

#



$ 

 





 

 &

'



$

(  *,

ETS+X]`G4HCFZ;T-"%QWY$NaOGPwW !?BT $HCQ&SQSiV#WYW-0 lG =9S?@CFCQMCI-HYS?BaO>@GQCQT3Pw>BiS Z3G;?@HJ?>BIS>9G_TVE?BWGZZdOOTSTSWYGQ|WYH HJrIVMCFCFCO>@H|?@G$JWJG_aG UCF>@HYiSiS?BG_WY>@G_?BG;-@VE5C QGW'HCQZ;ESGQWJG?TVTM*GHYDTSCQXCQWJUX]`TVG U MB;QHDWElP:]G_HJCQISUSMG9?BalI Zd?UXO?BWYTV|Z H
  %  B!D*,  EDYDO Y@SOWd5QWJH3al?BO>@CFHJ?@QTV_PQHYISG`ZdOWY|HdTSGHZdOWJNZ3?@>B>wE5G`QTSGLHJIVCFH3WJOiXHJGD
G_@SCQQMW I   Z6ZdHJISGWYCQQYiVJQiSIHYG*ISCQG>B> YCFZ#G `CFQESWY?@WYQ?@M?@TVTSCHYXGUXDGQHYPGWYCQTVU?BTVCF]QHJGGH*?@iT |GDHJISGC YiSCFTS? OGiVIVGhO|>@?BH TVN USGalQ?@W*MGG_CQCQMTVI U
G_TSCQFMH-IiVTSJ?BXTV% UXhGIlIViSCQEV#`CQ?@TT CFHY>@IS>B?ZGCFSTVCFMGS>@GQAPG_GWJaOG5TQ?BWJT HY HJIS  GZ;% QW-H-)MCOCF|TG*$U Z; G % Z3.?@>B>)TV GaQ G_?BWLTMiG|GZ;GQCFWYWYGG
EVCFISTVGUSWYGZ3O?@UlWJHYGOI P 0HY/ IVCF TD ?;SCb#aQCQWY?B>CFCFES>@>@?@GLJ?@USTSiSG`CQHJ>B*>aHJCFIS>@GiSG_CFCQTVTVTSUhGWCQS?@T S>@Z3]l?BISTS?MI HJIVHYG`ISGZ;>BG?@TS?@QNXIH9CFWYZ;G`G`CQM_>B>@CFXT MCFHJHJISG_G_U T
MCF>MiV>@CFHJG  D  ED,  ,*)
B  I
D
D! B  IEI ,
1 3~Xnx:vrn`voqxJ + 3~lv_{Qof{Qq p-q|vqD #v_xx_qn:{z#~qX_zrq3~v_{Qs
ov_pfD{Qqz qpf-q|vqf_oxJ v nvpzn:vD{F~Xnnq|vybn x:vzn_9~qOnnYqo_zy~pf{OO


&

.&



'



'

'

) 

,.&"%0 0 / )  Y #M!P $ X+X'  










JHISISCQGLG;Tl] Jl?@AQG>5QMWYOG TOHYISHYCFWJG ES?@ESWYCFiX?M-ESHYWYG_TS?M9XHJUXTS-G_X3HYUXISG;HJGLIV5CQJ?BTA_OG#>lTS?@G_MGDG_HYYISHJGLCFCQESWJJ]OG_>@?@PXCQJWYHJISISMGDIGUJ|CVGDH$CFCQHJWMIVMG IGQ|JHYVCQHYCQISW|MH$G#G- 5ElG_GDQCQM>5OMI?@*9WJGD?BiSTS#T?BHJF?CFiV>@M?IS|IG;GDUESJ?@?BAZ3OG;Q?fHYG_ I W

HJ=IV?BCQHJISTG_W#TSG_Z;MCbG_]OYJPlCQHJWJIS] G ? R HYISIVG CQ5#USO? >?M-iVHJ>fHl] VJTVUXCF?@TS>@> PwHYISG_COG|T ?@ES>@GDGCQJ|?BOEV>BiS>BG HJ?@JQQTV>@iX4HJ?@@SQOTW-HJISGCb] SiSTSWYQH|G GDX?@| H
HJ IS?*CQESVWJCF?5MGTVWDlPkUSHYISG_LGhSJWJ?@AGDG |G_ THLHJ?@IVT G CFTCFEVR#WJS?M V?@TSC XFLUXGiS?@5MNXO[;>diSZ?@>@USCQGWUX|GOHY>BGiXWYHY?BO?BTTSGDHJU hHJWYIVQG"SWYHJQIVEVG >BG_Tl iSVE5>BiVGW

SV|OWJCQ*OYES|GGD>@GUhM/OHJTV|Z3HYHY?BCFISHJTIG H CFTR RQZ3W$S?@HJS>@>IS?CGE5G JJQB >@CQI iX>BHY> ?BOB!TD#ISIS? MI IHDMP OlB!TViSDLJEVUS?@|GHYal3CQ?@TVMU G9S WYQJZ3EV>B?BG_HYIlMiSISEVGD _P HJ ISGP QCQWESJC WYZ3?@M*?fRHTSMISXG_UXUX_GG_PVJCQJ?B?BTVOA_TU G

BUS?BWYG_MHMQTVTSG_MHJ?@QT

A($H&0/$ +XYZ .

0 $H&#0
=9|OCQ>BHJiXMIVI HYG?BOQ5TGQTV?SG`WiSCHJ>CISHJ?@HYG_Q?BT OTTW?CFIVTVMCQNQWYdG_G_?BCFU HYHJdG_WJUOaQ/HJGISWWYCFEQ>@>SGDiSMOHI HYHdhCGJZ;aGCFQWY>@?@WiVG_dCH HY G_ ? U GJCOGaQ9HJG_IVUXWYOGDCQJJ>GM|WJHJO?@G_E5GVG_TSUOH*?@@$T GD?@WY` |G_H;Z3MG_HJ?fHYaQ?@IQG_T WJHY]*ISGG>BO=dZ;CQE5G_MG|I WH
SaQWJGGWGCFWY>@G>TVMMOG|H O?BCFaOWYGGTEHJ*GDE5H:G H|9HYGW3G lJQH_>@PiXHHJZ;?@Q TV ORGJE5?BTSGOW>BG u 5QHJ?@ISTGH;M5WJQVJJiS>@aQCFG_HJ?@WQQT 5GCFWWYCGHJOMISW9O?dJGCQTSSZ3>@?B?fGDHYIU
HJ?@-HYHYISISGGLTJGM>@ISG_M|HJG_G_TU CFQH3GTVWYQCQTVUXG_Q Z3?BCQHJ;IhHJC-IVGSWY3 QMEVISCQ?@>ESU ?B>@?BCFHT]U HYISD+G- D I iXHCTSHYG#?BO THYOISGG_WYWYCFG_HJJOiSW;>BHJ??@3TSCFVQSG_>BTS?@G_QUhHYGD
G_CQMIQISG_GTST GCZ3?fHYIiXHYCCFHJV?@WJQOT EVCFlESM_M?@>@iS?fHW] CH-D+C  D4B CFWJHJ?MiS>CFW`>BXMiVP'ChWCFTVUXO TiVE5GW-?`MIVOJGT
E?BTGHCZdTVG_GGTZ DaCQCF>BTViSU G  QPQW3HYC*VWYGCQVW|WJHYGD?@M|iSG_TO>@CQH;WdCOGTSTSG_GZ XWJOISiXGHJWYG G OQWJWGOC PlCZ iSHYR\CHY?BOT iXHZ3CHY?@>B?B>wOThE5G CF>@ZiV|CbH]l9CQ;WJGD>B?@|NQiVG_>f>BH]
HJHJISWYWYQG_iSJOiSI >BHLCF?@TlT ]C UX?@HJWJISGDM:GH`FMHYQISTSGTVW G_M:CFHYEV?BOWJT?MCQTS3X?BUXHLGDZ3 w?@>@R >E5GiXHYH CHYWJ?BGDO|T iV>fH?@THJISHYG*IS>BGXWYMQiViX`HY>@?BCQTVEG_>BGDU HJIV3 ISG O|HD Z
UX @$Gal?BO?iSMEG WYBG B ?@%T EJ@;?@QQiVW
WJ3 G D B @C?@`QiV?@WJGVG B iV CFM_J>@>@ ] >@?BNOG>@] HYWJGD|iS>BH?@TCQG_TSG Z3?BHJICaCF>@iSG 3 B

OSHJIViSiVG>CMTSHJM?@G_G_QZYT|?@aQJ?BGOA_SGLViSCF?>?@CWYQHY`?BTSOCFG`T WY>@GG_?@`YM;ISCFHJT IV|G_CQG T ST CQCQHYMISH`G-3 M|OCF?@lAWY]hG`GT HY HJHJISISCQGTVG*UQ>UhSOWY|XH OUXSSiVH`iSMG>*CHJC G_?@Q3 TME5ISSG?@>W`U IS GiVHY>@TOCOISHYG?BH>$VHYISWJG_GGa?@TVQE5GiGZ W
MWYOOSYiS|>CaOHJG?@WQT ? dG VISG>@??f HY?@G_JTV |iV?3WJGDiVJG_HJISUVG SH|HYG_|HhGEG_W ?TSFHh>BH HYISWYQiSOIiXHYCFHJ?@QT OW
'V 9H
   r 
?@*LISGHJH9G El?@]TSR ?fUXHY?@?@Z;CQWYG_>BCO?M:9JHYG>BHY]*G_GD|CQMHJOMGDI TSUhTSiG_|MG?@HJTS?@TSEG_HZdW?fH9 JUXQHY?BiSe5ISWGG_MWJGG_TOISHSiS?@TSH>C?BHYHJHJ-??@CFQ?f>@TH?@YC|UXHY ?BGDOHJThHYIV?BCFTVH`CFGHJGDHJ?@CQQISMTXI USUX G_SaZ ?MISG WJG QG ViSISW?B?WYHGGGG_HYHYTOISISH`XX?@UU
HJ?@C-ISESCG M_iSCF@$?@>@>@>B>@USGDCQU ?Z ES7>@JGQUSGP?BWYWYHYQG_ISG-MQH-iSCFOM>@QQIOTSWJTV?BQHJG_IVHJM:GHY T?BOHYXT?@CQ>B?@IS>@TS]G?BHJJJ?iSCFG_EM>@?@QYQTVCXHYU?BHYO?BT GCQHYw>VIS|XOISU>B?iS?@HJ?@?@Q-HYTJ?@?B*WJTSO?B?@HJ >?CFCFW`O>@?TSHJ|G-hGGDHJCQISMGHJIIS?@G#TSQ?BGRHJTV?SCFQS>?|CGHJG_CFZ3 >@Q?fHY?@ IT
WJ?BHJIS IS?@$GHYISXU?MCQ>B>@G_U YR#SV?@CL?BTV?fHY?@CQ>B?JCFHJ?@QT _rT*G_COMIMCO|GOP_aOGW$|iVM_MGDJJ?BaOG

!-













  

, 



&

&



'



 

 

'



 "










'

$



&







&

QCFGESTV>@G GWCCFHJES?@WYQ?@TM`TSPXXHYISUXGGD R Z3?@>B>$GaOQ>@aQGTSG_Z TSGHZ;QWYNXPVWJOiXHJ?@TSHYISG Z#3HJIVWJOiSQI CbaCF?@>



'

&



 Q ( ,$&$

ST|O?BISTV>BiXGGHYR#?BUXO?@ST |HJS?@?@?TVCMTSH#SFWYQH WYQTVGDiSG_M:VMH GD JXY=9CFWYCOIV?@MCQ>BI] HJNlOGDTSGTSHG_Z3M_WYTCQCFJHJkGG_=9U'IVCOPCQMC3IC*JOGWJ5H-OOiSY|?@WYESIVCQ>@TVCQG-UXJOQHZd>@iX HYHJ?BG_OJ|T'HGDPlMMHJ? ISCO|OM GDiSMQIVIhMCQ>CQHJWYYIVCO|G-M:? HYVQGG_XWYU ?@HY|?BHJ?BT?MHYCF_ > P
QFHJTSIVGGZ3W-ISZ3?ISMI ?MIWYGM_VCWJHYGDG|QG_OTOWJH?LJG_HJISGHJISTlGiSTliSEG_W-E5G W- ISO|HY-Z#CQLTVE5U GHYHZ;ISGGG_TlT iSIVOE5|GH_W-P'UX G_aUX?MG_Gal?@VMG_CQ_?BWP' CF'TVU ISHJGIVWYGG
ZdISOG_|WJHYG-HJCQISTVWYGU GLB&DEDJJUX?BEVG_>BaG?MMGDCFHJP'GCQOTVQWYU ?BGDI D IS|?@AHG -CFVTVWJO2U ESB&>BG_DYD9USZ3Gal?BHJ?@MI G_ B&'DIVISOG|HYWY;G_CFJTViSUJ>fHB&DSWYUSG_GJalG?@TMHJG_GD_U P ?@TD
HJHJISIS?WY;GG;V>@CFCQ5EGG_W3>@ CFFWYJGVOCFTSW|>@]G OC W GB&ZDTlEliSX] B!E5DGSWWY QES>@GZ# QGIVTVGGWCF>@>BZ#]diSZ;TS? GWYQG#WYHJIV>B]GTUX?@M|IVHJCFWY?@WESCQiXMHJHJGDGUWY?|COGDMUWYOElY]
UX?@|JHJJWY?B?@EVES>BiXG*HJGDISUVO;|H QrUXW3G_Ma>BiV?M|G*HJG_VWJCQGDU?BWY C*PwJUXGTVCFJ>@>wG Tl iSC>CFE5WYGQW3G TliSISEH G_WUXG_ al?@MGLZ#VCQL?BWOGTSMCQG_WJWYWYCQ]>B>@]*iSTSH3? Q WYHJIV>B] G
Z WYISG ?@iSJ?@CQWJG_GGHJTG_|HYH$ JGHZ;CO'CFSV>B?@G_U`HY3HJISG RUXGDJMWJ?@EGDU-CFE5aQGOP?BT-OWYUSGWwHY#G_CQJiSWYG
HJ?fTHISiVGGRe5E5GDGSM:WYSHYG_??BU CaOGSTSWJWYGDO J $GDCFM:B H 5CFHY?@=9 TVCOYHMDIHJISOG;WJOISiSG QSWYV?@GTSWHYWYH CO UXB&D ?fJHYV?BWYOCFGTVWS|CFWYGO>lG_PVCFJMG>@Q>@TiVOH|WJHJ?BVHJG_WJIVWJOGDESUw>BPVG_UXCFGTaOUGZ3>@UXQIVG5TVOG_JJUGGCQSIVTVWYOUQ|EVHYCQ >BSG_SUX>@G_?B#GDaUZ;?MCO?@GDT

HJIV>@COISCbG-aQH GB&CD*C XIVIV?@?BCbOaOISiSG`G WCIVEV?BCFC OTXISUX?@GZ3W3iS?@TlUXiSHJI5EHJGIVWG_MCFW3G_H#THYCFCbO]CGE5l G-?@iVViVJG_:UhQFTZ# =XC*JFV5 CFGWJW3 HJ?@?TVMiVUX? >@?@CQG`alW3?@HYUXISISiOG`CF|>'HJH3ISISQG-W#SH3UXWYG_QOa5W#?QMUXWJGbGHJ al?@VQ?MT G IV G
K !  &
WJG,GDW|C6G_HJTO?@QHYE T?B TV#GZ3C#?BHJ0 ITS0 GCH ZdE &OOWJ#SN 0iSZ3>C
?fHY0HY?BI O &T CQ$ >BJ>d ?BA_UX&G$?BWY& G_MHB&0 DEMDQTVISTSG G_ISMGHJ?@R\QZdTVG_Z; ?BOwCOI9HYH?@`TSZM?BHJCQQ?LWYCFWY>@HJ?@G_ISJJG_G_U TOTVZ3WJUXiV?fHY?@T TSIhOOHJGW TSOB&= DY*DEGDiVDh9CFQWYHJ?@GGQT T

SISB>BO?@Zd|G_H UG_FWJUXCG GHJalJG_G?W3MH G*HJHYIS G-OW|TVH-QWYal ?BO CQ >@CF>B ?HJY?@ CQHJTVD?@Q`Tk? -PlHJCFIS>@B?Z; CbB!HJ]XDE?@GLDYWYDEZdG_D UO WYZ;B&JDYGGDE?@QHYD IVI CFHYB&?BTDYTSDQQ TVG_G*TV|?BZ3TiVM?BWJHJGGDIV;QHYHJISiXIVGH-CFHLISZ;CG?@HQ|OIUX>BHJiSG_?@TSHJa?@?QMTG*? Z35CFQ?fHY WJI H
a?B?@QiS>CHY?BO5TVO_YPOJ?BG_ESaQ>@GG T Tl? iSHYISEGG_W|O >BiXHY?BCQOEST WJZ3?M?BHJTSIhXUXTSGISal?@Q>H CHYUX?BOG_TVal?@MG5ISQG WJH;?UXalG_?@CQ>C?-HJ?@QHYIVTCHIVCOCO9HYJISQG`>@iXHJ?@QC T
iSWJCF?WYTM`GHJTS?@G>XaOHJUXQIVG->@GaQWYG_G UhOW|CFHYH3WYISGalG?@TSQTlQ>iSCTSHJG ?@QETG_dWLTSX >@M_] MISiSHYOISWD|GPSHTCFQTVZ3W`U?@UX>BJ>;GalC Z3?M?BGXHJIM5iVQEWJCFHLQTVTalUX?@Z3QUX>?G_CUlMHYHYWJ?BIGDOCQTVCQJ#TV?BTVUZ3h?@HJ>BHYIS>$ISG_E5G TGTlUXiSGDOMTSWYEGG_HG_CQCFWJWYG_] U MVOCFW|E |H H
*ISO?@TSLGGHG3CFTWWY|CF] iSTWYMG_HJISH3GHJIE5CG_H`R MQHJISQG WG-G_C*COR MMIQZ3TV ?@J>B?> YUXVDGWT|CUVHYCQ?BESOWYTiSJG?@>USSCFWYQESES>@G>@G|O_>BiXP HYE?BDOTVM>@iV|HJWYG|H_WYG_PwU*CFTSUWYQQEVTS>BG_>@]HJ_ISPFG_CFT TU Z3Y?@>BD >
UX|OG>BTViXJHYG`?BOST WJO?BTES>@G
O W;CRHYISB&GDSISWYOQ|ESH_>@PGB&D kUXGalIS?MG_G`WJGSWJZ;OGESWY>@G G hESIViSG?@>USCFR\ES>@G QG_JTSVGCFWWC|HYGG_U JQC>@iXESHJiS?@Q?@T>@USCQP ES>@,G
ESiS?@>@@US?@CQQESiV>@WJGG M>@iV|HYIVGWYZ#G_U*|HJOIS>BGiSHJM?@QIVTVCQ3TSQCQGTVU ?@T OTS>@aQ] GWB&CFD*>@>ESMiSO?@|>USH CFES>@GaQUXGG_W TV|YG-DEJD Q>@QiXGHJTV?@QGTWC HJ?@QT OWHJIVG
GTHJ?@WJG5QSiS>CHY?BOT?@THYISGhWYiSTHJIVCFH*G_aQQ>@aQGDU HJIVGJQ>@iXHJ?@QTS?@MHJiSWYG_UQTHJISG>BG H


( )+*


'





'



'

'

.&

'





 $





&





,

'



$&
$&



$&

 &



 "

&






#


 )





B!D

@?@QiVWJG

M CFOiW|H3|GDalU?BOEl>@]5CFHJ?@iSQIVTV?@` VSM;O?BWJIST WY?G_HJJISEVGOCFTVTMCQUSUX>@?BMTViSHYh>@CF?@HJJ3GDVUXUCF?WYJMaQG-iVG_YSWY|CQWJGDO>BU>5ESM>@OGiV|W|H;HYISUSBEGiSB W#G?@THY*IS GCG_M>BM?@HJIVQ?@QICFTTVH`QMG#Q>@?@QT iSHYWYISG_GUTEViVCQTVUSE5`GW;CFWY G



 

1000
0

500

overall cost

1500



50

100

150

200

250

300

r,.{Q_-v/qz zrVnnQOzzn_rln~vpnqDn_DL_nF - nYnz|Ln v_p0~XpQnYxzDoqkv__qkXv_ndppOXq-Dfv_OnYp`rpfn:v~X{qnYozDVqOlq{Qn;zn$nqXxYOqDfVxODFOpfovqv nDxYqQ_ { vnJzzky-kDpDv_x|d-n;DfnpODqnYOz|q$vnxYqvDDpDOnYQkz|vz@n:D_{ nz

xYDq:On9rDpf{VFqx|yXF{vzy-pfOn;vxYzDrqn9~X_qrq_ $qOndx_ q_Vqnd-Dq$npqnd- n`~XnJz
generation



Qq{ OznnxYzqd5D xDq*OnqxYqqn _n pxnY@q:zr9zn@vqrnYXz#Dn :O{O_v_D- Dpn9nOnYz|`vfv vq_;OnYOqufXo$x|-yQ_$z_y nY{Qpfq|{OnvnJrzrz*DrOx_n:_p{ Oq;q~DVq#x%n D $0q!_F6V %_n#Qqf v_"p!_nJqurQon:9{zoy*On_qr n
r_pOqDOdxzrznrXD{qrvzrn3Oz_~pn6_
HJIS|G-CQMESCO>BG |GDI MZ3QISGWYVG`CQWJHJGDIS;G HJISG*R CbZaQG_CQWYCQCQQESG>BG|OHY>BiXHYM?BOQTT*HYWJOiVTSMH#GHC*CFWYJ]hQ>@MiXOHY|?BOHT G_COMI CF>@QQWY?BHJISP OW
|O>BiX@HY?B?@OQTViVWJG OWJHJISISZ#|G#wHYM_ISCQGdJG_5G?@WTMG_Z3TISH$??@MISHJWJISG aOGR GTZ;HkCO CFHJESIS>@G GHJ R TV|UOC>BiSJHJQ?@Q>@iXTVHJ?@QTaQG_Z3W'?BHJHJIVISG;?@XT RB&SDYSDE?CD
,.-/

 

BYB

0 OOqfv{O
pff{*rn:SO{ _0 qDX-nYbzr@_vpzzo&rD*v_nJ~XzoDnYnDnYquo$Opfp5v_nv_nh{-q;v n;nYrz|x|Xv_yQ_n$nxlrpfDn:{Op{\QnYzqqdfd_pO_f-_v`z_v_qp_nY-_q|zvzrqD; xnDDvqq @n_z v{QpfOznYnxYkqrfsx{ODOx:vnqxYnqq_O n

'QXn 0   nYz| vDn _q   nYz|v_-_n fFq| v_h{ vz|{ s 0 n  fvq_
FlpOvzqrnYn zn:{ %%*! +'"#_F# _#D % "#_'FF '"D%** ##OD *QDY% us us %F%_ _ " _%_ F%Y Q!F _#__
nrn : DF "!_ :_Q b FY$!F !D DD *__ %!F D_





10

frequency

15

20

250

200

150

100

50

50

100

% improvement

q,.O-n/ p:Vo nYtzdnY_zxwnqOqnvf-dOQz fv n;-Onfx|q'yQ$_V{Qpf{OznJnzxYqr_szdxDOpno&xJ*qf_nJ-zDnxqDfv_qp rn:{ 0  n Dp n:{LnYqo_zyFk nYz

QQGiXTVH G5WCGHJW ?@QQTWY.
wR#G?B>BHJHJISIVG_QW iSO I'PHYHJISISG G RUSS?BWYSG_?MCH-MCFQ>@QTSOTVWJG_?BHJM:ISHY?BOT _P?@TS?BHh?BHJ??CF>@?@CFJEVG_U>BGHYR MUXWYG_lCFG_HJG TVJFQHQG G_TSE5GGWHJCFHJ>@G>@] W
TSGHZ;QWYNXPlG_J5G_M?CF>@>@] QW3SWYQEV>BG_3MICFWCQM:HYGWY?@JG_U CQ3M>@iV|HJG_WJGDUhOW3UXGTVJG

GR#eST G_SM:T ?HYC?B$ aOCQG>B
OZ30 QISWY!?fGHYT$IS?BTV! $H?f_HY&k?@CQ3#>B?0 ?@|>BGD>@iVU |HJZ3ISWG ?BCHJHYI GRHJCISUX?CF_G_SP_JZ;S?BOWYGTO?@COTSZ3M?fIHYIS?@?CQHJM>BI?JG_IVURCQG_` COE5MGI-UXGGDT|?@GQSTWYE5CQalGS?@WUX5 GDG_UCFHJWIVElG9] HJ5QQTVSEGiSG>CHYHJ?BOOIV|T GH
Z3CF>@?fQHYQIWY?BHJHJISISGh MVISG_ISCQG G_WR JQHJ>@iXISHJG_?@TQT GaOSQWY>@XaQUXG_UhiVMGDU XUXEl? ] G_G_U?fHYJISQG>@WiXHJHJ?@ISQG TV_@PS>@WYG_?Z JiS7>BHJG_?@WJTSO G?@QTW G FLiViSCF?M>kNXQ[;W#iS>@?B>ZdUXG_G_WW
GMG_XOCQ|JH G_?@ESTVUX?BJG_>@?B?BJaOH?@]G QTVHYWJ IVG OCFiVrTT?BWYHJGISGCQGTMT]ISHGD CF$5R#G_HYT|ISHG_?@J>@R>BG iVS|MSHJCOW?|C CGDHYJ?BP$aOQGh>@HJiXIVMHJG IV?@QCQTkTSP$R QZ3GhM_IV?BCFT?@TMIVaQTVG_HYWYU?B>@CQ>3>BC >;JCFM|HJOO?|>B iXH VHYGD?BOTHJQISHYWG IVCHJISHGZ?CQ>BOGDTVJ|U H
S|OH >BiX5HYQ?BOST*iS>HJCHY?BMO>@TiV|HJG_GWJGDUE5VGWJWhOES?BT >BG_OTSGB3?WY9iSJT IS Z3T*HJIV?BT G @$?@QR iSWY?@GTS?f HY?@QCQ>B?IVJG_G U SH|Z3HYG_?BHJ|I H9HJIVGG E5@$G>BWd?Z S7 WYG_GJGWYQTGH
?BTR OGTSG_G`WYCFJHJG?@GQTLM>@G_B CQWJ?->@]HYISISGGWYGQWYGPOSHJIVWYG_CFJHGTHJISHCG HJS?@QH|T HYG_|H3QHYISGTVG QOWJ?@GQ?@?@ThTVCQGD>9CQR#MI SVO?@GC TSG_JWYQCF>@HJiX?@HYQ?BTOT JiVM_G_MU G_YHYJ ?BaOHJGIV>@]G










#





#



$

'

#

B

GCQaM:CFHY>@QiVWC3HYG_CF3SVCFH>B?@G_>@U Z;GW3CFTVUh>@ZdG_W;MO|H SISG-EVCQTVUX?@TSXMMiVWY;E5G_MCQiVJG` HYISG-ZdG_?BOIHJ?@TS



0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

overall cost

1.0

1.2

1.4



50

100

150

200

generation

 nYVz&%__lv_DOnDOn#nYz|vq D OnY;z|v_vp@pqnYxz9Doq;_kx|*v_pOp-nY-`O~XznY z n-wnqq$n3XxxDOOzpflvq__zv_q9z;v_xpqnYznD{QzOn#zD ~Opn

,.-/

J CQG_*MHJ@SV?@QQ>BGLWkT HJSISWJGDO|ESG;>@GG ISXG;59ZdGCOWYG_9?B?BO?@T IOG_TOHHY$HIS?BGLTPDZ;UX= ?@G9WYG_iViVM:JCFH3G_HJUM?@QOHYTRTSISTSGB;GDJZ;M:CQHJG*?@WYQGQG TPbEIS?@D#TS?BJZ;HJV?GCFCQaQ>@WY?@G_JJW_GQG_PbUP MEIVG D#XCQMTS5>BQGiVWYGD|?BUHJG_HJWJG GDTUwH PdCFUXTVGDU  J MEWJD#?@E5 UXG_G_UTV?@J T G
B  B&D  B I  Bb _IV?@$SiXH|>@?@QIHJ>@]-QWYG9GSICQJ?@$QTHJISG CQESWJ?MdTSXUXGd5QWJ H a?@Q> CHY?BOTV_P
(aQB G
W#HJISGHJISIVGLOHJ|?@H USG GSal?@MIVGCFH;5Q?_WJPOH?@Tal?BO>@CFHJ ?@QTVHJIS GVEDIS?| CFWR |G#Z;VCOWJ#OESCF>BESG_>@G-HYP BV)TV UHYE5ISGG HJHJYG_DW`MJ>BQiV>@iX|HJHJG_?@QWJGDTU
SSWJWJOOESES>@>@GGPICFCQTVUU RB SS ?C HY|ISOG >BiXCbHYa?BOCFTV?@>@CQESZ3>@G IS?@MDIUXZdGG_TVWJJG G SQWYW*QEV>BiVG_>fHY? >@'Cb]OGISW*GTSWYGGHZ;CFQ?@WYTSNX?@TS B&?@TVDMUXGG_QTViVJGW
HJQMQGTV>@>@?@QG_TSM:?BHYHJG_?G#CFUhWY>@?@GQJSGTWYHJG_?BISJGG STWYHYCFOaQHJS?@G_QiST*>CGQHJT?@TSH3Q>@T]* GZ3RTV?BMHJSIQS?HYCISVG_CQQJYG_GJTSG_GJWQCJ>@?BiXHYTVG_HJQU?@Q>@G#TUSG_>@CbkJ]O?BOGTVWIV GTSWYGGQHWZdQHYOWYISGQWJNXP'G_JHJGISHYG_ISVWJGCFGWYWJG#HJZ?ZMCQiSCQ->CFTVW3TV UXUSG_Z;TVCCbHJ]CG
TSGHZ;QWYNX
RL HYQ5Q>@QQ]

Q
C
S
E
B
>
G

V
I

#
Z


J
H
S
I
G

V
i
F
C

T
J
H
?
V
D
G
U
F
C
S
E
@
?
@
>
f
?

H
*
]

J
H
V
I
G
R
Y
H


Y
W
_
G
X
U
D
G
|

@
?
Q

*
T
Y
H
S
I
G

CFTVUhWJOiXHJ?@TSJHYIVCH3HYISG-QTSGHYCQWJ] MO|H3 HYISG-TSG_Z RL ?@MISG_CQG_W

>B|iXISHY?BZ3OTVTISG_QJWYWGG_CFJ?@ViS*IS>fHV?@`M_WJCFQ>@aOG>B]GTVG?@WT GCFT>@@$>BHY] #?BOiSWYaQWJQGG W#HJCkISG*J>BISR#?@QGSI?@SH-*?CWJVG WJCQCQ>BOaOWJWQGCFWYTV?fHYGQISTGH?BG_TPTO|HLUXiSGD?BT |?@QT CFWYZ#?|aQ`GDG_U?BW`T?BHJT QISWG $UXCFG_RWLEVS>BHYGS?CHYCFCF|NOWYGG
SCQHYUXWJG_OaCQESCFU >@TGH CFQMG9BWJGDHYCCQHJNQCF?@GD>@TSWYG_CQCQCFUSUST ]`abCQCbCOTaUSHYCFUXCF?@?BO>HJCFG-?@ESQTV>@G9CQM>CQOT US?BCbWYG_aOMCFH`TS?@>@GCQMTOESHYTS>B G-TS6GD@SM:CQHJHJW$?@I QG T SHJCQISE*WYGQHViSZd>BOGOG_I PDGC T CFT ChRG ISXJ?@Q|HHJ>@iX?@TSCFHJTV?@QU TJZ3?fHJH?fL`HMJMI'VQP5CQWYWY?BWJTJG G
|5QTVUS?BTSUXGal?MG IVGiVJG CFT CQ>BWYG_COUX]CbabCQ?B>CFEV>BGWJOiXHJG?@`MISG_CQG_WHYIVCFT HJISG*iVJG

 

 






&









) 

&

&



B

'

&
&

frequency

10

15

 O V  D-vzrD~XnYquo$nnv nYz|vDnrDpQqf_-DOnYq|vzr x_q@_z}dOfvqfv_prn:{

0 # lp:o&*nYz_nDSv_{;Ofx|yQ$pf{OnJz?9pD_zqO-
kQXn 0   nYz| v__n  Dq   nYz|v_-_n q| v_hl{O vz|{ s 0 n  fvqD
Q pvzqrnYn zn{ __ "Q'F# ""% % D# QD _!!%#% _##QF! *% _% ' QD _%F! '
FD "%_
F
! #_#
nOrn % _* Q _% _ * O !'' FY%F' fY"' O '%
_Q _'

10

20

30

40

50

% improvement

,.-/q nrS 9tnYOzBxv`n;q9-x|yOOz pfn{O-nYznqz;|p:do&O*fnYv`z_nLqxf_v_pqr n:{ 0 n _p n:{OnYquo$_zyF9 nYzqn3p:onYz

JCbalCQ?@ThTSOiS;TV TSG_M G_ YJD CQWJ]ISHQWUXGal?MG5QWJHCQTVU COUSUX?BHJ?@QTVCQ>5>@?@TSN CFTU ?@T HYIS?@3M_CQJGQPQ?@aQGD
TS|ISXUXZ#G__dHJPISCFZ3G_TWdISR#?@?MSI SSWJ?>BCGDaOCQJG_USQU *>@iXJHYHYQ?BO>@iXT C HY?BCFO*TVTVOUh;WJCGZ3?BWYJ>@G_?B>wOJWJiSTSGD>B? |HJiV?@MTS>fCQHTO?B?@HT MHJSISOWJ|GH aOiVG_JJUCbG`alJ ?@QTS>@OC*iX HJJ?@Q@ST QCQW>B>@QGGiSW;STVTlCFU iSES]E5>@GQGHYUP ISWG@$ ?@QiSRCFWYESG WYO?)MW
*M>@iVOTSHYGGISHWYCFGG_WYU G] XSMWJG_OWJESH#?@>@UXG ?BGeTGHYB WY-GTVUXMGDIVG`JMG*E5WJ?@?@GE5HG_Z;SU GWYG_?BTTaQG_HJHJU ISISG?|OH>BVZ;iXCQHY?BOUXG_T W`G_JiI?BO|CbTVGDaQL;GO MTSQG*T M>BGDGJT -HYWYJCFDZ3HJG_?fHU MI |OWY>BG_G_J>B]iS>BHJO?@T TSh?@TS?@ST iXC H
UXMQG_TJ?B|O?TVUXGWYZ3G_U IV?@MIIVZ;?@GWYIVG COJ?BTS>B?@O>BG ?fHYG_>@CbU]OGiVWY*G_U HY 7 HYISQGWYG G XMSO*>@QWVC>BGHY?BOTiS >fHY?WJG_>>@CbCF]QHJG?@WaQGUX>@]G_J?BJO?BTV-S>@Z;G GWYG RTSLQ H
?BTS#GGDSZ;UXWYGG_aQU aQG_GHJW_PkHJISHJJGISiSGUXSG_5CFJQE5?@WJQHT aQHJG ISUSGG_C WYYG MWYR?BiSE5\?@WJG_GDU QU GWYTVG_GJWiSZ#C>BHYHJGDlUIVH#ElCb?@aQ] GGR#X|SISVGD?@Z3M:CHJTGDHJUHJIVHYUXIVCFG_CH*MH3WJ?@GDTHYCQISJ?G33CFHJMIVTlOG`]|H3M?BCOO|TSGDSGWYHP$CFaQZ;WYG_]*GhMMGOCQT|T HH
Z3?B>@>kCF>JE5G|iHCF?@TSG_UZ3ISG_Th>CFWYQG_W_PlQWYG-MQS>@G hTSGHZ;QWYNX;CQWJGG lV>BOWJGDU

 $

"









&



&



'





JH ?CF$>@0 ?@Y'C HYE?BO$T TUCF TV U

TRSS#?C$H&?@TS#?BHJ0 ?CF>@?@YIVCG;HY?BOWYG_TJiS >BHYHJ$IVQG ESHYCFR ?@TSGD?@TVUUXZ3?M?BCFHJIHJGE5HJFIVHJCFIH9UXHJ?@IVWJG GDM:SHHYMTSOG_TSY9TSGD>CFM:THJ?@USQJT*M_CF?@TS5? G


&

qODndF p*nYV*DBqF v_3qqQnn'q:zFpfnJD@q:q:n9_ v9d-p :Ooz {QnYz'nn:r-{D_r_npnY{ Oq|qv~zrD3xq_$\n qqkdn99OD Ofndvh{QnnrpDD:p &oOn:n:*{{nY~~z#_n v qO0v_n pD0 Dz q Oon/#ODqrvn;qn$r{Ov _nprxODq_LDqO_* +
nJz|v_pp5x_q9vzn3r:o _Oznr'Qln-_nYq|vzrx Dq9 v fOD9 DF %_
?@=9dCQSMWYIQEVG CQXES5>BG]*WY?BaQG_WJG_]TOH JSi?B|NlGD] UCJJ?@IS*VZ>BG HJISR?SPXSJ?GC aOGQWGCFTV>SGESWWYC?@HJG GDU G X 5RG/WY?BUXG_GDTO|H?@Q9T Z;GSWYWYG#QEViS>BTG_UXGWJHY CQNQHJGG_T T
IS|Z3O|?BHYHYM_ISPGDHJ3G_T Z;GUXWYG_G`aV?MWJGDalP?UXHZdG_U G_TOQH] W#i|GOZ#PS WJGDCQ|iVTV>fUHY?BTSIS?BO?@I T C*OW|HJJJCF?@ESHJiS>BGWCJHYG_?BCQOWYT MIkJG_VT CQMIlG-iS EV CQB TVU5HJOG_ T
|?@ES>@G-QGTVQG_ 
CZdF>@G_>?BOM@OIO?@|WHH9HD?@Z;P ThCOB!= `DEDM_iVCFDEC>MDYHYiSD?BO>CXTQHYGG_BLTVU QZ;iVG|WYG_?@G TS Zd HJG_IVWJGhG   WYOCQWJTV UX QiS >C  >@]O B MW!WJGDB&CD HY?@G_TOB U HYI WJ:XBb@SUX OiOW=dMG_GDCQU CQMMI ?@IT MQO GGDTSM:OHYO?B*OTST GGTCFH T ISaOGIVH W G
UXMOG|alH?LMG9Z5CQQ`WJHTSOalWJ?@Q>CCFHY>@?B?O|GDTVU P CFCFESCF?@WYTV?M|HLTSX UX C G9Xal?@?@ QiS>C/HY?BOaTVCQ>BiSP_GD aQG_ WJ iVJG_ UECF TVUX Z3 ?Ul HYI'D PDYCQDSTVP U-  QTV GHYCQI WJDV] P
  %  I DVPCFTV
U
 /  B  D  D*, ISGMCQ>@MiS>@CFHJGDUaO G WCF% >@>dMH  G_COMIQG_TS% QG?@
SUX?@WJJOHJSESIS>>@CbG G]QB&GDDYU*PQD HYCOIS9DYG`DECDISaQWYG?CQ|WHJTVCFQUX>@O>OWYM*CQO |>@]Hd?@ OT G@$TSCG_?BOESWYiSiVCFHJWJ?B>GD
G USU,CFEVTS>BGG`H?@Z;TSaQG_QGT*HWYZ;NXHJQISWYZdG`N*G_CFZ3WJE5G-?B>@ESaQ>wG#iVCF?B>@M>Z;USOCbTVCF]XEVUX >B?BGHJ?@5CQQ>BR TV>_E5P G>@OC WZ*QHJWYIVD?fH?@ ]hdlUX #G_JQHJ?BOIVTVT GG
ab CQ>BJiVQG_>@ iXHJ ?@)4QB T  M
*O|3HY_>@?BPG*Z3E5ISGG_HWJZ;G GGT,  
 P I CF TV
U P5CF )*TV) U B  G
MCF T G_HJIVJGGDOMG?CFTS>@O>B] *JGDG#GIVHJCbISaOG*GEVMCFTHUX#?BTV?@T
HJ ISGDG_|COG`MIEVCFMTOUS OWJOTS GTH;>@G MHQHYSWYWY?B?@OJ?@IOTSH-WYHJG_IVJG`GDM_M:CFHJ>?@MaQiSG_>>BC] HYG_UIV?@;aQG_EVWYCQCQTV>B>UXM?@TSO|H ?l=9UXCOiSMGLIHJEVCFTHJISU G`MZdOTVG_?BJO?@|IHYHJ9?@TS
|CFOWY>BGiXUSHY?BiSOG`TVHJ Z3UX?BHJ?BIe5G_HYWJIS?@GTSYCFEVCQTVG#UXTlZ3iS?UlEHJIG_WaQG_W5rQCFWJ>@>@H9lalM_?BCOHY>@?BCFOHJTV?@QdTVCQ TVQUh*ISG#OTSaCQGHWJCF?CWYHY] ?BOMTVH Z3?BHJiISM:?@HJT iC-CHJEV?@QCQTTV U
GaOGWCF>UX?Be5G_WJG_TOH-OGTSO*GD-MCQTJGDM? ] G OiV?BaCF>@GTH-TSGHZdOWJNXCFTVU JGaOGWCF>$TSQT
G?BTiS?@abCFCQTl>B]G_TTSH*OTST GHG ZdiSO?@WJabNXCQ>BG_MTCFHTOGIVTSCbOaQG G_HJISGZ3?BYHJCFIHJG ISGG_aYCFCF>@iVCGHYG_UaQG_WYCQaO>BG>wWMCFO>@>d|H MOcd|H GWJHYCQ?BTISM?HWJ GD| iVCQTV>fHU
HJHJISG_HJWJIVG G`Q?@WYTVGMMWJGGDWJCQHYJCQG_?BUhTTMiVHE5WGCFW3TVQ G_5kOIVYCb|aQ?@ESG>@G`ZQWYCbG#]X;MO WJWYG_MJQOSTVWYUX??@|TS?@TS`*QVGTVCFQWJHJ?MG_iS$>CFHYIVW3CFMTO|FHYHY ISGWUXiVG
HJISG_WJ@SG WYQCQ WJGHJJISGGaOGCFWE5CF>aQUXGO?BPVe5Z;G_WJGG_TMHCQT QG_STSWYQG_JiSGWYGGSJGWYG_aQJG_GWYTCQHY>'CFSHJWY?@QQTV5GWJZ3HJ?@IVG_?@MI WYQG_iVJiSWL>B>HCFTV?BTUVJG M_OCFiV5?BGa#CF>@@$G?@TWYHY|>BH_] P
$ovn~Xqn#v_Xr_rrDrfO~On:p{*nq:oDOnn:_vwxJqoonqqqv_o~Qnzfx3qQOs_F{OnnX_z9rrqf~Opvn{OvrzrnxYDq9-x_nYFOqnxY5qDlVv qfv*l:o
,.-/




'



.&

&

  



 )

$ 





  

 ) )

  



 

 





'

.&



&



& 







BI

80
60
count

40
20
0

cost

,.-/
V mdfq__z|v _5 nYz|v_ppXx_q_:D|D_LDnYD-nYOzF{Qxn:{-~z|vl{O_ _nnYz|vqD

 vQfL X_rr~pn vpfOn3?%!Fln3x_q;vQf9pf-qn:{qD 'Xd_q9r:oDOn3xDq
{Qv_rpxOn`rrvn:qr{F% _O zrqODnYpz9DQz q*nddqnF rq n:{qDOpf_q;qnl{Q f{Ov_p~v_{O-vqrqnYzOdox| vzn

@>MCQOWJ|OHJ GGDG_UMRQTSUVTVGUXUXHZd?f>@HY]QO?BPwOWJTVZ;NXCF G>@>@>B]lGDHYOMISNQQGG_TU SUwWYPOCQG_H5aQQISG_WJT HJZ ?@QQTHJWIS |G|CQO>BiX>B>5iSHYSHJCF?@WYHJQQ?@TVQESwT>@GZ3 IV_?@MChPQI-HYOISCFGG`WYTSGJOG_ESCQiSWYG?@M>@UVI CFCFe5JESGDV>@M:COGHM`?GL HJM_ISiSCFGT?fHYWYG9E5G_JGJiSO>BCQHJiV?@>B?fTS> HY G
TSWJGDG|HG_Z;TOQHYWYG_N UCOaOCGWOCFG>@TS>$OM*O|GOH PSkHY[;ISGGO?BTViXTSHY?BCFTVHJ?@QZ3T?BHJQI5GCQWTCHYR#QW#SSZ?CQCLJCFQS>@iXVHJ>B?@?@QG_UTB!HJD HYDYISDEGDSHJ?@WYQESG_>@LGiVJP'?BTSWYhG C
|ISiXHZ3CT*HJ?@QST-WYGWalC?@HYQGiV J>B]SD+  FD4B IS HJGIVGdaQYGCFWCF>@G9>XMCQ'HJHIV CFHkG_iVCOJMG_IU-O?@GTTSHJOIV*G9GQG_WYTSG>GCHYHY?@M9?BaOCFG9>@QHYQ WYHJ?BISHJISG3\Z;QG WXHG_5WJ?@OY|G?@TESHY>@G
UXaQ?@JGSW>CFCb>@]Q>GDMUO|COH CQW3ISHY?@|ISHJ?O3QWHYCFQ WCF?@QTVG@$J]l?BO|iSHJG_WJG B!MD OFT VISOG_iSWJWYGCFZ;HJ?@QGWYThGSB&WJDOESIliS>@GEVCQZTVCQU3B&M_D-CF>JMZ3iS>?fCHMHYISG_UG_CFCbTVaUhCF?@?@>
CF B&ESD >@G QQWWISi|GHOKLQWiSG3UXHJGal?HYMISGG#Z;OGW|?@H*QIalHJ?B?@OTS>@-CFHJ ?@QTVGD_CQP MIB I MO*OW 5QCQTVESGWYT?@MH TSXHJUXIVGhG#5aQQG_WJHWYCQa>B>X?@QM>CHYH ?BOiVTVTV_P$M:HYCQ?BTVOTU
=QB GaQTVOG_QTW`HYG_ISOQTSiSIVGOCOHIUhCFWYCQHY]ISThGMWYOG*aO|HGZdWCQCFG_TV>@WJ>wUG*MOEaQ|CFH3G_TVW >BUXGDZ3J;P ?DYUlHYDEHYIVD I CFTaCFiXHY>@IVHYiSCFCG_HJH#GD:U PwZ;OHJGIVGTSG|OG_R#GSG_HJSLIV?GSCWJMJXIQUX>@CFiiXWHJMCQ?@G_M:QU'HYT GPwWYQ ?@D+|TSHJ >@B?] M-,EVQ
*CQiSTV W-UXTV?@TSGZ
? G 5R OTSGC OQWWYH?fHZ;] 5QHJWJISH`Gal?@QiX>HYCCFHYHJ?BO?@QTVTVY3PVHYZ3CFNOISG?@>@GHJISHYG-ISGOGWYTSGOCQG-?BTS?B?@TTSHJ HYISiXGHYCFJHJG_GDMU OTVQUG_TSQQW3HYISGD?@WYUWYGEVCQCFTV?@TU
?BWJT GDCQHJJISQG*TV>@JZdiVMG_IWLEVCQCQTVUaQG_wW iVISJG_|UGEVHJCFIVTVCFUSH`Z3WYG?@UlHYICQ?BT'QWPIVUX?BCbe5aOG_GWJG_aTVCFMWYG3?C?@HJT?@QTQTS?@T GHYCFaOWY]GWMCFO>@>|HM OR H QWC QQHJWYIS?fHG_] W
HJISGQGTVQG_3?@THJIVG VWH#EVCQTVUHJICHLCQWJG-TSQH#G iS?@aCF>@GTH#HJHYISGOWJ?@Q?@TVCQ>wQGTVQG
{OOnYxYqn:{Vqn$p~QpfqnYrO _qqzv_n X_ zrFqn::{_ OJDnY_zn rv_ :opfn:pO{qrqz|Ovnhqn:Q{ zDQXzn zr qff__rp _L;~qOfpfnY{Oz v_~n Qpn XnYrzDp-Qqnf_q*xo_Ov_s
pnr9qv_ _#_ Y_DF







$&



$

&





, 



.&






Q I GTV) Q G_3HYISMGQI )ShTWY?@JSG G_Z I
OGTS O*HYISGDG-`TS?BT G_Z HJISQG G_TSQWY|H-GDEVCFSTVWJUXLUXiCQMWJGG_UhES?@iVT?B>USCQ>BCF>EVHY>BISG G-'EVCQISTVG_JUSG ESiS?@>@USCQES>@G

50

100

150

count

200

250

300



0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.0

cost

r,._O-p/ On3$qx DD Ooq9qv+OQf9 q_nY_v_z|z|vvpf ~Xp'nxn_wq#qznQn3qrz Q xYYnYq*Fz|n:wv{pfpqOx n`DF`q9_QD_q|'vq_nD_z|-vqnnLOozvF#{QQxQn:_{5~FvLQfOLq|vqO v_v_pmndfO%f!Fv





QHJ ISTSG`>@]QrJPFT*CQZ;*OG#WYGUSOGGW$TSCQHJG_TS-WYTSCFG_G_HJTVG_Wd|U*CQiVCWJGHJWISCFHYG`ISTV?@UXR#OSZ;VCOPF?@CTSTSQSFT WJH9XuESC`UXiViS?BM>WYUSG_QU'CF5EVPQGES>BWJG#HiS]O?@>GUSTSCFOES>@iSGLGQHYJPCQZ3HY>@?BiXISOHYTV??BMOIT Z;OCOESiVIS?BHJGL>IVUSUXGCF?@TEV|HJ>BWYG#?@iSESJQHYiXC>@HJiXHY?@QHJG_?@UT QT?@ T

WJOaQiSGWQCFIS>@>@>k] MOC|H HYLD+ ?@`?BUXT?HY|GSWY>abCbCQ]Q>@GD U ?BZ3T IS@?M?@IQiVMWJQGWYWJBEGDB |55R#QTUSCF?@T HJZdG*CFT|G_GCOUSHYUXIS?BGHJ?@MQIVTVCQCQWY>dCOIVM:HYOG|WYH ?@|USHJ?GMalEV?@MCFG TUX5?BQTVWJ H
aB ?@ DQ>C#HY?BOZ;TG5aOGRWDLP?@?BTT HJ@IS?@Q?iVWJM_G CQJB!
G DS,PV HJIS G
WYCQ TSQHJG-IVG MSOWJ|XHYUXiCQM>BG_>U Z3M?BOHJIV|H?BTaCFHJ>@IViSG GDJP5CQUX*lG*G_LEVCQTSTVFUHG CQS`MGHJGDIVU G
Q) WY?BD O*?BTV)`CQCF>lWYQGdGG TVSQCQM:HG M$QSaQ?@G_GWCF >@>OHJMIVOG3|H QWY?BO?BTVHJISCQGD> |GOjkHP G_B Cbal ?BTVEDLGCFB WY Gd ,TS
G_Z3 >B]TSQG_GZTVGOWGCTSHJOGD*UGDO$GTSQOiX*H|GD?UXGPCQHJTVIVU G
?@# CQM?B>BTh|EVGLCFHJTU HYISG-MaQG_HWY CQl>B>ISM?dH3?@ S>@HY?BISGDG-;HJQIVWY?BCFOHd?BTHYISCF>GQG_aQTSGQWCF>@>G MO|Hd O|H;iXHYCFHJGDU QG_TSQGD
QMIVGTVCFTSQOISGLG_G3J?@MTG3CFHC*T*Z;EVWYG_CQJG UhiSX>f5QHG_G?@TSWYT?BQC-GUXG`TWYHHJCO9G_TV?@HYT ?@USM_;CF>@HJ>BiS]-HYCWYZ;G_HYQ?BJOWiST|>BH$H3J?BISTaOGZC*WCFQHJ>@>lGIVTVMCFOQHd|GHaOGGGaZ3T CF?f>@CHYiVIC|HYC?BOCFJT'>@?B>PFMCF?@I>@>BCQHJCFIVWTSQOiSG#aQOG?BI*WThCFCC>@>JQMlOX|CQH >BU >

IS|O?B>@*G-> MGCQHJISTh?@TS?@THJG_WJSQWYWYGGH;>@HJ?@NQIVG?@#CCO;aQG*WY] GDCFJTSS?@WJTSGDCQU HJIVQCFiXH3CH HJIS7 G CQSTSHYIVTSCFG_H|YHYCQ>TCFTVJUSNlY] MuCQ>@?BTVG GW?@CTlHYaQISG_GWYWJG`HYIVMOCFT|HdWJO>@>B>@O?@TSNX

$&



$ 





 "







&



B)

300
250
200
150

count

100
50
0

2.3

2.4

2.5

2.6

2.7

2.8

2.9

cost

Oz,.nYD-/Qqrsz$~OflxJqln:pf{{m;vq~pqn3DQD _nz|DOv_D-_nD znYDz|v_lpp3vpxD_nOq*D-`n3_nvD_{-xn_q;OzAF{O%$O '_x$n:!{ DF~5 z|Ov_n#lx{QDDO/Fqd`vQOq|9vqlDvd~X_n`nYv

d | l9 
rGT aQO >BaOGDGLM:HJEV?@QiST ?B>USCQZ;ES>BG G-TVOGiSHTVZ;U QWYHJNlIV CFH-QCW#JR CF>@Z3>P
ISB!?@D*MI ISOG|TVH3MlEUS]JG_B&U DJUX?@TSGQal>@?GMG>CbS]QWYG_QWJESGD>@UGTSG HSZ;QISWYG_NXJG-M|QOiS>Bi>U
HJQ?@QWYTV\_POHYISZ3GIVR#GTSSGaO?C Q>@@$aQ>@GDU ?Z 7WJOG WYQCGd|USO?BWY>BiXG_HYM?BHJO>@]TV_MP_QESTSiSTVHG_M_M:CFHYG_T'UPbCFTSE5GQHZdiXH$OWJIVNCFPQ> US TSHJISQH9GdQHJ?@G_TSGGQWPbCFQ>@iX>B]HYQG_iXW HYOWJG_ W
HJ|ISO>BGGiXHYFL?BOiST'?MPNX?B[;TiS?B>UXOG_|W#H|M_OCQ>BJiXG_HY?BO?fTVH MCQ#T Z;iSGaO?MGNWD>@P]Z3GIVaOGQT>@aQHJG ISG C E5RGH|HY?@G3W ?@TSJ?BQHJ>@?iXCFHJ>@?@?@JQG_T U$Z3?BISHJGIWYCFG_TJiSR>fHS*S?C
HJ|ISIVGDCQ|G G H ZdHJISG GX5|OGWY>BiS?BHJ?@GQTTHhJVCQCQWJMG G MQTVG J?HYOGiSTTVHhU Z3S?BWYHJGI\al?@HJQISiVG J>B]USCFHJHYIVCCFHCZ3HYISISGG_WYTG_U SWYMG_QJGTVTMHJGGDWYUTS?BTVZ3?fHYIHJIVCG
TSSQ>BG_T ESGiST?@HY>CFUSHJCF?@QEST>@G HYGTVRUV6$HJUX`G_SJ?@WJQXT UXiJQMG>@iXUXHJ?@G_QJT ?BOTVHJISG* JiS?BHYC?@>@HYCQ?BOWT lOQW G_WYCFiVHJCQQ>BWL?BHiV] bJG_UIS??@T ?@$HYISWY?G GDM:R HJGDU?@ ?@T
HJISISGG WYG_JR iS>fH?BThQHJEXISH?3CF?@MTSCOG_|U G`Z3IVCOIS3GThUX? HJIVGMiS>fHR ] VZTVCQUXd?@TSWYiSThQlZ3X?BHJU IJUXQ?@>@WJiXGDHJM:?@QH#TMOPSTSCQTSTVGDU M:HJZ3?@QISThG_T?BTV?f?fHYH#?@CQUX>Bl?JG_CF HJ?@QTVT U
QTSGO#PX?fH#Z;?#GaQ|G_HJW_?@>BP5>'Z3TVISFH3G_T QTSCG-ES iV?BHY>USISCFG-EVE>BG GDJH Q>@iXHJ?@QT?iXHCHJGDU CQ?@THJISG RSS?C?BTV?fHY?@CQ>B?|GDU
HJGR#ISXSGDS|G_G?WJC?@Z3?@TS?@G>B?f>'THYE5HY?@CQG>B:?PJYQC|HJO?@*QGTkG PlJHJQISHY>@ISG iXG HJ?@QGR TZ L?3HJVIVGWJCFeXHUXG_MCFiVHJWYM?@G G_aQU G_O>B] CFiSWYTVCOGUM:HYMEl?B>@TSO]JG*HJCOIV?@3G T CS>@HJR XTVMG_CQCQY;>'|?BHJGDCFSWHJWYMIVIhGaQCFG_Q>@QWYO?BGOWJT?B?BHYTVHJ IVCQ>PwCQ?fTVHYIU
CWJFGDQ|GhiSk>BCFHWYG_?@JT CiSJTSQG>@HiXZdCFHYWYO?B?@OWJJTVNXGQPQZdZ3iVG#|IS?@I?TSMCbIaQGC VWJJQISG_alTS?Z3UXGT*HYG*?@MhHJJIV?@QCFCFTS>@HdQ? O?BHdWJM?BCQ?HJTIS5H OY|O?@TSESISG>@G G3HCFHJiWY*|] GhUXMG_ J?@QHG_T ?fYHYCbISMalG?BWTSH uHJGGD`e5MISGDaQM:TSHYG? ?BOW-aOiVG#RGhSHYMSQCQ?W TC
UXG_J?BOTSG_UhTSGHZdOWJNX






$&
.&

 

 

&





&

'



 

&





B)

&

E|VG3COHMCFGONOISPDGGZ;TWYG;G?@TCFWYHJCOGISUXJG GGaOCLiSGJHJWiSCFWYGD>GMUS? ?f@eM?@GWUXWYGG_H9TM?@?@H;TJ?@USQHJ?BG_TWYWJG_HYMIVHJ?@CQH TVZ;9HJGd?BISTh>@G#?BZ3VISWJ?BHO?@MESI >BG_JHJ JIS?@GLESWY>BGZdGVOJWJWJQGDN*|>@iXG_SHJTOWY?@HQG_CTVJHYGk?BTOHJHJT*GDCQU?@TVTVISMU>@GiVWY|UXGOG;>BMiSQQHJiSTV?@Q>>BUT]

*TS|?@GTSOHQWJZ;Gd>@GQQWY>XNXCbHY]Q?BGWCQTS>GJHQZd>@iXOHJWJ?@NXQ T X!@VISiS?@W|#HYISGCbW$]hZ;SQWYWYNLGaQZ3G_T?@>BH;>GHYXISSG >@QWYR G ?@RLS >BG_OW$GUSTG_HYJCF?BOHJ?@TSQ?BT TVWJO iV>fHYV? T>@CbUX]O?BTVGWY G_UC

WJ|G_SlWJFGD|HYG-G_I TYXHYCbCZH#HY?B?BOT TCb] CQG_TVEMUG-HJ?@Q5T aQOG_YJWY?BCQHYES>BIV>'>@G`CMHHJO|HYHISWYG GiSSSTVWYHJG_MTSJHJGDG?@QJTT H;>HJiCFIST|G-GDUSU JSM_WYCFQQ5W3EVG`>BHYG_ISMQGWY?BOWJTGDG|TSC*5GQHJ?TMCFUXTSCF?BTVTV>@QGOWHJWJ*HJ?BHJIISHYCIS H3GSZ;QWYGCOTVa3Q?TSUXQGDGH

HJCg WY|GCQal?@l?BUOFiV?@HYT wISGZ;HJWdISQ>@WYG CQN TVUSUS?@ YYMMP CQaOI GG P WYY]B @SiVIVW|CQHYESISiSG|?@WdIV>@UVG Z3CFXESST>@>@G QHJIVWTSCCFGHJH H?@QZdTORWJ NXZ3VISWJQOG_WESWJG>B>@G_CQHY WJISOG9GWYOWGVG TSWJRGDO| G_TOG9HUXCFCG_TVHYJ?BU?@OQT*?BT HYSWYCbQ]*iSESHYS>@CGWYHY?BOaQ T G
Q5CbG]hWCCFHJ>O|WY*kSZdWYG_WJaQG9GL>B?@HJ?fE5HYG_G-UiVHJ|G ViSWJ>'XGUXe5iVGDMM:GdHJ?@OaQTSG->@]`UXGDa|CQ?@>BQ?TUTS GH>ZdCFWYOQWJG`NXTSMGCFHZ;TQQWY?@NXaQG9OllUWJGD|iS>BHY bIS?@
?@dQW`HJIrQTCXH HYHJ?BIV?@?Z |Y?@CFTSWYGhG`CQiS>B?@JWYWJG_G_G_MCO*HJUX?@G_Q]TThHYUXdZdG_JIVG?@CbQCFaQTS>G|GD*UC-UXTSHYGGGTVHZ;UXOG_QTVTVWYNXHYMWY] CFHJHJGDUTSMGIVHJIVCF CFTSHOHJGHJISISG*G aOSGWYWdQR HJESIS>@Z;GG`CO>B?dLG CQ?BuTT HJ?@G eRGG_M HJ?@UXaQC GDGL|HJ?@RQlT'Q >P

?B| TOR>BTSiXLG_HY?BG_OUSZ3T OISGTIVIVGG HJWYISG GRQWYWYGGQSPlWYiSG_HYISJ?@WJGG G_THJGDRGU*T HYISGTVWYMGG#IVG_|CQUVIVTSQQHJiSGO >P$UE5?@TVCFGM>|WY>B-iVG_USUSE5G_?BGTSJ?B CFOTTSCFG_TGUhe5?@GDHJTVM:hMHJWY?@CQaQG_MG#COM|QHJGhlQ?BT> XQHJUSISWCGWYHYG GTlrUXiSCG_JME?@IVQG_CFTSWTS?@TSO G
Z# IS?@`Z;QWYNhICQCQUSUSWJGDJJG_UOTS>@] |O*G HYISG?B5QWJHYCQTOH?JJiSG_L R UXGD|?@QT
CFISiSG>BHWYG-HJQCF>@WYGGWCFCQT>@JMGdHJMQTE|G?UXESGiVW?BC>BHHY?B?BOTTVHY; C CFRLiS >BH3|HJiVOM>BIG_WYHJCQITVCMHG G_CO MQI GHYZ?BIVGDCQ#CHZ;M>@L?BG_5TOOH#YZ3|?@?@ES>@>'>@GWJG WJOiSiXHJG_GD|H
?BUXT G_JM_?BCQOJTG3CQ SSCQWYO?B>@COiSMWYI G#?BZ3T ?@>BC >'TVCFGESG_WYU ?@M#HJG>@GHCFNOGG`T?@H TlHJCQEM_MGDOMOiS*TH;GHY*ISG_OJWJG GiVCF|iSG >BH3iSHJ>uOPQ>BHYG_ISWYGLCQTCQHiXHJVOWJOCFG_HJW|GDHYU ?BGD R

k k  
_mdLrfODx:Fvlqv DdODnYq o0 Fzyt'z{OnYn-ryQ_O svv_z: Dv_n-{ zx:v_v_p5smdqrln{Q *_QkVq n#0 nvxYnYqq_zxdv_qpDvzqqQ-lnY@_xzn#xYXDnYzrss
@%_DzQ_v_OxnD 

      %    

%     OJ #Fb  %_ '"!%" *F$ #DOn
% v__smdrfnY F 0 twzn-yFvz: vznY _5v_l{%#Dfv_'&_ F Qlv_-x-{QnYs
2 z3nnx_457qr68z|6:v_9 O2 n:{* ;O* nY qu<o$_ zy ,={Q)nrD % ,  9 _ n:nY
qx->
vp% D _ z qO ? 
v_O @O1@*z b*v xJ*V< A6% 68()6CB: *+v_*+_, n- /. 0Q ! 1
F3Q'YbzpDbQ&v_v_x|Y~X*nYnY*q*Qy  v_ qnYxJz yb+ n_ qnYnrrfDSdO- nYqz_rz|v_q_n`_vzQn:Ovrrn nJSquoVQznyFQqno`q~XnJvz ~O%f_DpDDFDx:v5ppF~XsnLrOOz~np{ rvnO{ s
vQ3$;Cn &:vv_*pnmp t 0 }5v v~rV9 5n5x|DOXf_xpv_DpVDdx:nvXp`{Q zrq:nrD_LxD-OOqnYzx_-`Ox:vqDOnYquo$_zyFsqOn
V*nY*"z|%v pp#{Onr DOz_~pnE  %F '* HG/ %/  IJ1K4L'*    MN$* O* #"FQ #_ Y" *"! !%F
#P #D_rFlvh3O:opfnYv_l{ v f{ znD  nYo n DpOq_lvzr vQzbv_x| q qn*{OnznnYs
x
_qr
z|%vfO n:{ O-lO%D` O %#@!lrl_vQR#_Opqrz%nDn#_OQzD~Opn 
E
   Q < ) %   M 



&



&



( *

( * ( *





 "

'



&






&



'



'





B,



'F 0

nYv qwpf_Ov__FpzqOqn:nY{Ozd q_@_z:zw;()qvO Bn${Q*p~X+v*D,lO-{l {Q. $n:zr{QFs1 v{Of"

vqQ*-#
nYqnY#DzO-pf qr
Oz_ fL
0 >rzFln n:v{F%/OfOndQ qrzznnq8fOxYMz _v_*~,<pn{
v_>  
n % 0 D-p _O}5._qvDl-vvDDzrn q
!$!@!(!#%F7%%DF
!P#DOpfn vz|{VD*x|lv_nYp + QOpfp v_z:Qlv _-fv_VQv_l{ #DDO pybndOfvv_Qq_s
*
v*qfxd q_ z|QvDD*Pn3v z,n:vOnY qu@o$. _* zy`;* #"v_/~Q Mzfx +{O. n *rDlV v_D nYQ (% D" *!(+*%F, Y -!F . I#bvQ1  v"'zr*\  %_ _"R%


 O1@* 5