Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 11

3095mv

0.01
0.02
0.03
0.04
0.05
0.06
0.07
0.08
0.09
0.1
0.11
0.12
0.13
0.14
0.15
0.16
0.17
0.18
0.19
0.2
0.21
0.22
0.23
0.24
0.25
0.26
0.27
0.28
0.29
0.3
0.31
0.32
0.33
0.34
0.35
0.36
0.37
0.38
0.39
0.4
0.41
0.42
0.43
0.44
0.45
0.46
0.47
0.48
0.49

0.1
0.14142136
0.17320508
0.2
0.2236068
0.24494897
0.26457513
0.28284271
0.3
0.31622777
0.33166248
0.34641016
0.36055513
0.37416574
0.38729833
0.4
0.41231056
0.42426407
0.43588989
0.4472136
0.45825757
0.46904158
0.47958315
0.48989795
0.5
0.50990195
0.51961524
0.52915026
0.53851648
0.54772256
0.55677644
0.56568542
0.57445626
0.58309519
0.59160798
0.6
0.60827625
0.6164414
0.6244998
0.63245553
0.64031242
0.64807407
0.65574385
0.66332496
0.67082039
0.678233
0.68556546
0.69282032
0.7

0.10368221
0.1440486
0.17535678
0.20186629
0.22527761
0.24647515
0.26598872
0.28416544
0.30124741
0.3174114
0.33279123
0.34749101
0.36159369
0.37516663
0.38826537
0.4009364
0.41321907
0.42514703
0.43674936
0.44805134
0.45907516
0.4698404
0.48036444
0.49066282
0.50074944
0.51063686
0.52033643
0.52985847
0.53921239
0.54840678
0.55744955
0.56634795
0.57510869
0.58373795
0.5922415
0.60062467
0.60889244
0.61704943
0.62509999
0.63304818
0.64089781
0.64865245
0.65631547
0.66389005
0.67137918
0.67878568
0.68611224
0.69336138
0.70053551

0.09617692
0.13874437
0.17102631
0.19811613
0.22192341
0.24341323
0.26315395
0.28151377
0.29874738
0.31503968
0.33052988
0.34532593
0.35951356
0.37316216
0.38632888
0.3990614
0.41140005
0.42337926
0.43502873
0.44637428
0.45743852
0.46824139
0.47880058
0.48913188
0.49924944
0.50916598
0.51889305
0.5284411
0.53781967
0.54703748
0.55610251
0.56502212
0.5738031
0.58245171
0.59097377
0.59937467
0.60765944
0.61583277
0.62389903
0.63186233
0.6397265
0.64749517
0.65517173
0.66275938
0.67026114
0.67767987
0.68501825
0.69227885
0.69946408

Pgina 1

0.00368221
0.00262725
0.0021517
0.00186629
0.00167081
0.00152618
0.00141359
0.00132273
0.00124741
0.00118364
0.00112875
0.00108085
0.00103857
0.00100089
0.00096704
0.0009364
0.00090851
0.00088296
0.00085946
0.00083774
0.00081759
0.00079882
0.00078129
0.00076487
0.00074944
0.00073491
0.00072119
0.00070821
0.00069591
0.00068423
0.00067311
0.00066252
0.00065242
0.00064277
0.00063353
0.00062467
0.00061618
0.00060803
0.00060019
0.00059265
0.00058538
0.00057838
0.00057162
0.00056509
0.00055878
0.00055268
0.00054678
0.00054105
0.00053551

0.00382308
0.00267699
0.00217877
0.00188387
0.00168339
0.00153575
0.00142118
0.00132895
0.00125262
0.00118809
0.0011326
0.00108423
0.00104157
0.00100358
0.00096946
0.0009386
0.00091051
0.00088481
0.00086116
0.00083931
0.00081905
0.00080019
0.00078257
0.00076606
0.00075056
0.00073597
0.00072219
0.00070916
0.00069681
0.00068508
0.00067393
0.0006633
0.00065316
0.00064347
0.00063421
0.00062533
0.00061681
0.00060863
0.00060077
0.00059321
0.00058592
0.0005789
0.00057212
0.00056557
0.00055925
0.00055313
0.00054721
0.00054148
0.00053592

3095mv

0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1

0.70710678
0.77459667
0.83666003
0.89442719
0.9486833
1

0.70763691
0.77508064
0.83710812
0.89484636
0.9490785
1.00037493

0.70657625
0.77411239
0.8362117
0.89400783
0.94828793
0.99962493

0.00053013
0.00048397
0.00044809
0.00041916
0.0003952
0.00037493

0.00053053
0.00048427
0.00044833
0.00041936
0.00039537
0.00037507

0.045
0.04
0.035
0.03
0.025
0.02
0.015
0.01
0.005
0
0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

Pgina 2

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

3095mv

0.03682207
0.01857744
0.01242284
0.00933146
0.00747208
0.00623059
0.00534287
0.00467656
0.00415802
0.00374299
0.0034033
0.00312013
0.00288047
0.00267499
0.00249688
0.00234101
0.00220345
0.00208117
0.00197174
0.00187325
0.00178412
0.0017031
0.00162911
0.00156128
0.00149888
0.00144127
0.00138793
0.00133839
0.00129227
0.00124922
0.00120895
0.00117119
0.00113572
0.00110233
0.00107086
0.00104112
0.001013
0.00098636
0.00096108
0.00093706
0.00091422
0.00089246
0.00087171
0.00085191
0.00083299
0.00081489
0.00079755
0.00078095
0.00076501

0.0382308
0.01892916
0.01257912
0.00941936
0.00752834
0.00626965
0.00537157
0.00469854
0.00417538
0.00375706
0.00341492
0.0031299
0.00288879
0.00268217
0.00250313
0.0023465
0.00220832
0.00208551
0.00197564
0.00187676
0.00178731
0.001706
0.00163177
0.00156372
0.00150113
0.00144335
0.00138985
0.00134018
0.00129394
0.00125078
0.00121041
0.00117256
0.00113701
0.00110355
0.001072
0.00104221
0.00101403
0.00098733
0.000962
0.00093794
0.00091505
0.00089326
0.00087247
0.00085264
0.00083368
0.00081555
0.00079819
0.00078156
0.0007656

Pgina 3

3095mv

0.00074972
0.0006248
0.00053557
0.00046864
0.00041658
0.00037493

0.00075028
0.0006252
0.00053586
0.00046886
0.00041675
0.00037507

Series1

1.1

Pgina 4

calculos

%Vazo

Vazo
0.04
0.08
0.12
0.16
0.2
0.24
0.28
0.32
0.36
0.4
0.44
0.48
0.52
0.56
0.6
0.64
0.68
0.72
0.76
0.8
0.84
0.88
0.92
0.96
1

dP
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25

5.904813
23.955226
54.194284
96.633603
151.2794
218.1352
297.2036
388.4869
491.987
607.7039
735.6399
875.7945
1028.1693
1192.7653
1369.5824
1558.6204
1759.8809
1973.3649
2199.0707
2436.9999
2687.1522
2949.5282
3224.1284
3510.9523
3810.0003

dP + erro
dP - erro
Vz c/dP+erro Vz c/dP-erro %Vazo
8.762313
3.047313
1.215289
0.721836
0.04
26.812726
21.097726
2.115022
1.877873
0.08
57.051784
51.336784
3.077625
2.920296
0.12
99.491103
93.776103
4.058438
3.94069
0.16
154.1369
148.4219
5.046818
4.95274
0.2
220.9927
215.2777
6.03904
5.960707
0.24
300.0611
294.3461
7.033464
6.966367
0.28
391.3444
385.6294
8.029285
7.970605
0.32
494.8445
489.1295
9.026035
8.973893
0.36
610.5614
604.8464
10.02343
9.976518
0.4
738.4974
732.7824
11.021299
10.978664
0.44
878.652
872.937
12.019522
11.980947
0.48
1031.0268
1025.3118
13.018018
12.981956
0.52
1195.6228
1189.9078
14.01673
13.983253
0.56
1372.4399
1366.7249
15.015614
14.984374
0.6
1561.4779
1555.7629
16.014632
15.98535
0.64
1762.7384
1757.0234
17.013769
16.986208
0.68
1976.2224
1970.5074
18.013007
17.986982
0.72
2201.9282
2196.2132
19.01232
18.987671
0.76
2439.8574
2434.1424
20.011705
19.988287
0.8
2690.0097
2684.2947
21.011148
20.98885
0.84
2952.3857
2946.6707
22.010641
21.989358
0.88
3226.9859
3221.2709
23.010178
22.98982
0.92
3513.8098
3508.0948
24.009754
23.990242
0.96
3812.8578
3807.1428
25.009362
24.990631
1

0.05
0.04
Transmissor
Vazo Calculada
Erro Positivo

0.03
0.02

0.03
0.025

Vazo Calculada
Transmissor
Vazo Calculada
Erro Negativo

0.01

% Erro

0.035

0.02
0.015
0.01
0.005

Transmissor
Convencional
Erro Negativo

-0.01
-0.02

Transmissor
Convencional
Erro Positivo

Vazo Convencional

-0.03
-0.04

-0.05
0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5
0.6
% Vazo

0.7

0.8

Pgina 5

0.9

1.1

-0.005

calculos

0.25
0.2
0.25
0.15

0.2
0.15

0.1
0.1
0.05

0.05
0
0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.2

0.25
0.2

0.15
0.1
0.05

0
0

Pgina 6

calculos

2.8575
Transmissor Vazo
Transmissor
Calculada
Vazo
%dP
ErroCalculada
PositivoCoef.
ErroDesc.
Negativo
Dp Convenc. Vz Conv.+e Vz Conv.-e %Vazo
0.215289
-0.278164 0.00154982 0.61574349 6.09599942 1.19891094 0.70702712
0.04
0.057511 -0.0610635 0.00628746 0.61141032 24.3839977 2.09723949 1.86035303
0.08
0.025875
-0.026568 0.01422422 0.60974382 54.8639948 3.05923019
2.901963
0.12
0.0146095 -0.0148275 0.02536315 0.60883381 97.5359907 4.03989116 3.92214488
0.16
0.0093636
-0.009452 0.03970588 0.60825145 152.399985 5.02841197 4.93431118
0.2
0.00650667 -0.00654883 0.05725333
0.6078429 219.455979 6.02097059 5.94260774
0.24
0.00478057 -0.00480471 0.07800619 0.60753849 298.703971 7.01588384 6.94874996
0.28
0.00366062 -0.00367438 0.10196506
0.6073018 390.143963 8.01229818
7.9535792
0.32
0.00289278 -0.00290078 0.12913044 0.60711182 493.775953 9.00973288 8.95755472
0.36
0.002343 -0.0023482 0.15950232 0.60695553 609.599942 10.0078829 9.96093467
0.4
0.00193627 -0.00193964 0.19308132
0.6068244 737.615929 11.0065707 10.9638998
0.44
0.00162683 -0.00158775
0.2298673 0.60671261 877.823916 12.0056587 11.9665509
0.48
0.001386
-0.001388 0.26986069 0.60661601
1030.2239 13.0050647
12.968971
0.52
0.001195 -0.00119621 0.31306173 0.60653161 1194.81589 14.0047266 13.9712157
0.56
0.00104093 -0.00104173 0.35947042 0.60645713 1371.59987 15.0045926 14.9733196
0.6
0.0009145 -0.00091562 0.40908669 0.60639087 1560.57585 16.0046235 15.9753083
0.64
0.00080994 -0.00081129 0.46191096 0.60633148 1761.74383 17.0047979 16.9772098
0.68
0.00072261 -0.00072322
0.5179435
0.6062779 1975.10381 18.0050964 17.9790432
0.72
0.00064842 -0.00064889 0.57718387
0.6062293 2200.65579 19.0054921 18.9808121
0.76
0.00058525 -0.00058565 0.63963247 0.60618497 2438.39977 20.0059769 19.9825327
0.8
0.00053086 -0.00053095 0.70528924 0.60614436 2688.33574 21.0065371 20.9842107
0.84
0.00048368 -0.00048373 0.77415432
0.6066107 2950.46372 22.0071644 21.9858542
0.88
0.00044252 -0.00044261 0.84622786
0.6060725 3224.78369
23.007852 22.9874695
0.92
0.00040642 -0.00040658 0.92150972 0.60604053 3511.29566 24.0085906 23.9890584
0.96
0.00037448 -0.00037476
1 0.60601081 3809.99964 25.0093754 24.9906254
1

0.035

0.03
0.025
0.02
0.015
0.01
0.005
0
-0.005 0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

Pgina 7

0.8

0.9

1.1

calculos

Erro devido preciso Transm. c/ Vazo Calculada


0.25
0.2
0.15

0.1
0.05
0
0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1.2

Transmissor Vazo Calculada Erro Positivo


0.25
0.2

0.15
0.1
0.05

0
0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

Pgina 8

1.2

calculos

Transmissor Convencional
Transmissor Convencional
Erro
%erro
Negativo
C
Erro
%erro
Positivo
V c/C %e Vz c/dP %er C+dP
-0.29297288 0.19891094 0.03237806 0.19891094 0.21816555 0.29523172
-0.06982349 0.04861975 0.01789888 0.04861975 0.05796269 0.07565416
-0.032679
0.0197434 0.01235759
0.0197434 0.02602484
0.0326664
-0.01946378 0.00997279 0.00933824 0.00997279 0.01467752 0.01774503
-0.01313776 0.00568239 0.00740739 0.00568239 0.00940026 0.01098429
-0.00956538
0.0034951 0.00605486
0.0034951 0.00652853 0.00740523
-0.00732143 0.00226912 0.00504829 0.00226912 0.00479581 0.00530554
-0.0058026 0.00153727 0.00426543 0.00153727 0.00367099 0.00397987
-0.00471614 0.00108143 0.00363618 0.00108143 0.00289984 0.00309492
-0.00390653 0.00078829 0.00312001 0.00078829 0.00234831 0.00247708
-0.00328184 0.00059733 0.00268614 0.00059733
0.0019403 0.00203017
-0.00278742 0.00047156 0.00231723 0.00047156 0.00163005 0.00169689
-0.00238685
0.0003896 0.00199831
0.0003896 0.00138864 0.00144226
-0.00205602 0.00033762 0.00171919 0.00033762 0.00119713 0.00124383
-0.00177869 0.00030618 0.00147305 0.00030618 0.00104266 0.00108668
-0.00154323 0.00028897
0.0012546 0.00028897 0.00091626 0.00096074
-0.0013406 0.00028223 0.00105856 0.00028223 0.00081152 0.00085919
-0.00116426 0.00028313 0.00088119 0.00028313 0.00072376 0.00077717
-0.00100989 0.00028906
0.0007208 0.00028906
0.0006495 0.00071091
-0.00087337 0.00029885 0.00057442 0.00029885
0.0005861 0.00065789
-0.00075187 0.00031129 0.00044045 0.00031129 0.00053156
0.000616
-0.00064299 0.00032566 0.00031718 0.00032566 0.00048428 0.00058359
-0.0005448 0.00034139 0.00020325 0.00034139 0.00044304 0.00055932
-0.0004559 0.00035794 9.7798E-05 0.00035794 0.00040686
0.0005419
-0.00037498 0.00037502 -1.7439E-07 0.00037502 0.00037493 0.00053029

0.35

0.3
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
0

0.2

0.4

0.6

Pgina 9

0.8

1.2

VERIFICAO DA RANGEABILIDADE PARA TRANSMISSOR MULTIVARIVEL.

Calculado
Calculado
Calculado
Calculado
erro=
erro=
utilizando-se utilizando-se
utilizando-se utilizando-se
o programa o programa (0,00075*3810) (0,00075*3810) o programa o programa
de clculo
de clculo
de clculo
de clculo
Vazo
(ton/h)
lquido
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25

%Vazo

0.04
0.08
0.12
0.16
0.2
0.24
0.28
0.32
0.36
0.4
0.44
0.48
0.52
0.56
0.6
0.64
0.68
0.72
0.76
0.8
0.84
0.88
0.92
0.96
1

dP
(mmH2O)
5.904813
23.955226
54.194284
96.633603
151.2794
218.1352
297.2036
388.4869
491.987
607.7039
735.6399
875.7945
1028.1693
1192.7653
1369.5824
1558.6204
1759.8809
1973.3649
2199.0707
2436.9999
2687.1522
2949.5282
3224.1284
3510.9523
3810.0003

Coef. Desc.

0.61574349
0.61141032
0.60974382
0.60883381
0.60825145
0.6078429
0.60753849
0.6073018
0.60711182
0.60695553
0.6068244
0.60671261
0.60661601
0.60653161
0.60645713
0.60639087
0.60633148
0.6062779
0.6062293
0.60618497
0.60614436
0.6066107
0.6060725
0.60604053
0.60601081

dP + erro
mmH2O
8.762313
26.812726
57.051784
99.491103
154.1369
220.9927
300.0611
391.3444
494.8445
610.5614
738.4974
878.652
1031.0268
1195.6228
1372.4399
1561.4779
1762.7384
1976.2224
2201.9282
2439.8574
2690.0097
2952.3857
3226.9859
3513.8098
3812.8578

dP - erro
mmH2O
3.047313
21.097726
51.336784
93.776103
148.4219
215.2777
294.3461
385.6294
489.1295
604.8464
732.7824
872.937
1025.3118
1189.9078
1366.7249
1555.7629
1757.0234
1970.5074
2196.2132
2434.1424
2684.2947
2946.6707
3221.2709
3508.0948
3807.1428

Vazo com Vazo com


erro positivo erro negativo
no dP
no dP
(ton/h)
(ton/h)
1.215289
2.115022
3.077625
4.058438
5.046818
6.03904
7.033464
8.029285
9.026035
10.02343
11.021299
12.019522
13.018018
14.01673
15.015614
16.014632
17.013769
18.013007
19.01232
20.011705
21.011148
22.010641
23.010178
24.009754
25.009362

0.721836
1.877873
2.920296
3.94069
4.95274
5.960707
6.966367
7.970605
8.973893
9.976518
10.978664
11.980947
12.981956
13.983253
14.984374
15.98535
16.986208
17.986982
18.987671
19.988287
20.98885
21.989358
22.98982
23.990242
24.990631

OBSERVAES:
1-) Nestes clculos, foi considerada a preciso do transmissor em relao ao span
calibrado (0,00075*3810=2,8575) e no em relao ao alcance mximo do transmissor,
que no caso seria (0,00075*6350=4,7625). Confirmar se devido no estipularmos um
span para o diferencial de presso, devemos considerar a preciso menor (+- 4,7625
mmH2O).

2-) O programa utilizado para o clculo dos dPs foi o FLOWEL Release 2.04.02 da
KENONIC Controls Ltd. (1984-1988). Padro para clculo "General Application" (ASME).
3-) Os dados do fludo so os seguintes: (C4+ lquido), (Dens. @ op.=612 Kg/m3),
(Presso=7,3 Kg/cm2-abs), (Temperatura=15 C), (Viscosidade=0.16 cP).
4-) Os dados para a placa de orifcio so: (D=77.9272 mm - 3" sch 40), (d=45.09615
mm), (Beta=0.057869589).

10

Waldir Claro do Nascimento

3/14/2012

VERIFICAO DA RANGEABILIDADE PARA TRANSMISSOR MULTIVARIVEL.

Vazo=
0.405021*
RAIZ(dPe+)
Transmissor
Vaz. Calc.
%Vazo
Erro Positivo
%
0.04
0.08
0.12
0.16
0.2
0.24
0.28
0.32
0.36
0.4
0.44
0.48
0.52
0.56
0.6
0.64
0.68
0.72
0.76
0.8
0.84
0.88
0.92
0.96
1

0.215289
0.057511
0.025875
0.0146095
0.0093636
0.006506667
0.004780571
0.003660625
0.002892778
0.002343
0.001936273
0.001626833
0.001386
0.001195
0.001040933
0.0009145
0.000809941
0.000722611
0.000648421
0.00058525
0.000530857
0.000483682
0.000442522
0.000406417
0.00037448

Vazo=
0.405021*
RAIZ(dPe+)

Vazo com
Vazo com
Transmissor
erro positivo erro negativo
Vaz. Calc.
no dP
no dP
Erro Negativo
convencional convencional
%
ton/h
ton/h
-0.278164 1.198910939 0.707027122
-0.0610635
2.09723949 1.860353028
-0.026568 3.059230189 2.901963001
-0.0148275 4.039891157 3.922144881
-0.009452 5.028411972 4.934311185
-0.006548833 6.020970586 5.942607737
-0.004804714 7.015883843
6.94874996
-0.003674375 8.012298182 7.953579198
-0.002900778 9.009732884 8.957554719
-0.0023482 10.00788287 9.960934668
-0.001939636 11.00657068 10.96389977
-0.00158775 12.00565869
11.9665509
-0.001388 13.00506475 12.96897101
-0.001196214 14.00472663 13.97121569
-0.001041733 15.00459264 14.97331962
-0.000915625 16.00462352 15.97530826
-0.000811294 17.00479788 16.97720975
-0.000723222 18.00509638 17.97904323
-0.000648895 19.00549207 18.98081212
-0.00058565 20.00597693
19.9825327
-0.000530952 21.00653706 20.98421071
-0.000483727 22.00716442 21.98585422
-0.000442609 23.00785202 22.98746951
-0.000406583 24.00859063 23.98905842
-0.00037476 25.00937542 24.99062542

(dPconvec.dPcalculado)
dPcalculado
Transmissor Transmissor Erro devido
Vaz. Conv.
Vaz. Conv.
considerar
Erro negativo Erro positivo
coef.
%
%
desc.=K %
-0.29297288
-0.06982349
-0.032679
-0.01946378
-0.01313776
-0.00956538
-0.00732143
-0.0058026
-0.00471614
-0.00390653
-0.00328184
-0.00278742
-0.00238685
-0.00205602
-0.00177869
-0.00154323
-0.0013406
-0.00116426
-0.00100989
-0.00087337
-0.00075187
-0.00064299
-0.0005448
-0.0004559
-0.00037498

0.19891094 0.03237806
0.04861975 0.01789888
0.0197434 0.01235759
0.00997279 0.00933824
0.00568239 0.00740739
0.0034951 0.00605486
0.00226912 0.00504829
0.00153727 0.00426543
0.00108143 0.00363618
0.00078829 0.00312001
0.00059733 0.00268614
0.00047156 0.00231723
0.0003896 0.00199831
0.00033762 0.00171919
0.00030618 0.00147305
0.00028897
0.0012546
0.00028223 0.00105856
0.00028313 0.00088119
0.00028906
0.0007208
0.00029885 0.00057442
0.00031129 0.00044045
0.00032566 0.00031718
0.00034139 0.00020325
0.00035794 9.7798E-05
0.00037502 -1.7439E-07

INCERTEZA NA VAZO (%)

VERIFICAO DE ERRO PARA MEDIO DE VAZO COM


TRANSMISSOR MULTIVARIAVEL E CONVENCIONAL
0.05
0.04
0.03
0.02
0.01
0
-0.01 0
-0.02
-0.03
-0.04
-0.05

Transmissor Vaz. Calc. Erro


Positivo
%
Transmissor Vaz. Calc. Erro
Negativo
%

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

Transmissor Vaz. Conv. Erro


negativo
%

Transmissor Vaz. Conv. Erro


positivo
%

VAZO (%)

11

Waldir Claro do Nascimento

3/14/2012