Passing a Stadium: It takes bipartisan buy-in Tracking the Twins stadium bill (HF 2480) thru House committees

in 2006 GOVERNMENTAL OPERATIONS & VETERANS AFFAIRS COMMITTEE May 10, 2005 GOP Yes: 10; DFL Yes: 7 GOP No: 2; DFL No: 3 Result: PASSED 17-5 10 of 12 GOP members vote Yes; 7 of 10 DFL members vote Yes LOCAL GOVERNMENT COMMITTEE May 16, 2005 GOP Yes: 6; DFL Yes: 6 GOP No: 4; DFL No: 3 Result: PASSED 12-7 6 of 10 GOP members vote Yes; 6 of 9 DFL members vote Yes TAXES COMMITTEE April 21, 2006 GOP Yes: 7; DFL Yes: 8 GOP No: 8; DFL No: 5 Result: PASSED 15-13 7 of 15 GOP members vote Yes; 8 of 13 DFL members vote Yes WAYS AND MEANS COMMITTEE April 24, 2006 GOP Yes: 12; DFL Yes: 6 GOP No: 9; DFL No: 7 Result: PASSED 18-16 12 of 21 GOP members vote Yes; 6 of 13 DFL members vote Yes Fast Forward to 2012 and the Vikings proposal (HF 2810) GOVERNMENT OPERATIONS AND ELECTIONS COMMITTEE April 16, 2012 GOP Yes: 5; DFL Yes: 1 GOP No: 4; DFL No: 5 Result: DEFEATED 6-9 5 of 9 GOP members vote Yes; 1 of 6 DFL members vote Yes The difference between passage and defeat: 2006: The GOP and DFL put up half of its members as yes votes in all but one committee (Taxes, W&M respectively) and the bill passed. 2012: The GOP put up half of its members as yes votes, the DFL didnt live up to its end of the deal, putting up only 1 of its 6 members as a yes vote. Consequently, the bill failed.

4/16/12

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

STATEOFMINNESOTATHIRTYSIXTHMEETING HOUSEOFREPRESENTATIVESEIGHTYFOURTHSESSION GOVERNMENTALOPERATIONS&VETERANSAFFAIRSCOMMITTEE MINUTES
Note:Ifthereisatelevisionrecordingof themeeting,linkstothatformatwillalsobe available.

RelatedAudio&Video

RepresentativeKathyTingelstad,ChairoftheGovernmentalOperationsandVeterans AffairsCommittee,calledthethirtysixthmeetingtoorder4:47PMonTuesday,May10, 2005inRoom5oftheStateOfficeBuilding. TheClerknotedtheroll. Memberspresent: TINGELSTAD,Kathy,Chair BEARD,Michael CYBART,Lloyd DEMMER,Randy DEMPSEY,Jerry HOPPE,Joe HOSCH,Larry JOHNSON,Ruth JOHNSON,Sheldon KAHN,Phyllis LIEBLING,Tina LILLIE,Leon LOEFFLER,Diane MAHONEY,Tim MCNAMARA,Denny OLSON,Mark PETERSON,Aaron PETERSON,Neil SEIFERT,Marty SEVERSON,Dan WELTI,Andy WARDLOW,Lynn Membersexcused: AQuorumwaspresent. RepresentativeRuthJohnsonmovedtheapprovaloftheminutesofTuesday,April12, 2005.THEMOTIONPREVAILED. HF2480(Finstad)Baseballstadiumdevelopmentprocessprovided,metropolitanstadium authorityestablished,MetropolitanCouncilbondsauthorized,andhostcommunitypowers provided. RepresentativeTingelstadmovedthatHF2480bepassedandberereferredtothe CommitteeonLocalGovernment. RepresentativeTingelstadmovedtheH2480DE1DeleteEverythingAmendment.THE MOTIONPREVAILEDANDTHEAMENDMENTWASADOPTED. Thecommitteerecessedat4:52PM. Thecommitteereconvenedat6:15PM. RepresentativeTingelstadmovedtheH2480A15Amendment.THEMOTION PREVAILEDANDTHEAMENDMENTWASADOPTED. ThefollowingwitnessestestifiedregardingHF2480: RepresentativeBradFinstad RandyJohnson,HennepinCountyCommissioner,ChairmanHennepinCountyBoard DaveSt.Peter,President,MinnesotaTwinsBaseballSite JerryBell,President,MinnesotaTwinSports,Inc. MikeOpat,Commissioner,HennepinCounty JohnKnight,CitizensforStadiumTaxReferendum TomCasey,CitizensProtectingReferendums TimNolan,Director,PeoplesIssues WilliamJewell,RiverfrontCamps TomGoldstein,Publisher,ElysianFieldsQuarterly DanDobson,ExecutiveDirector,NoStadiumTaxCoalition Dr.LauraLehmann,CitizensforaStadiumTaxReferendum SteveLion,PrivateCitizen FrankWhite,PrivateCitizen JohnFroom,Director,CrystalLittleLeague IrvCross,Chairman,MinnesotaTwinsCommunityFundDirectors LorrainePizzella,PrivateCitizen MichaelSamuelson,PrivateCitizen JohnWilliams,President,MinneapolisBuildingandConstructionTradeCouncil RayWaldron,President,AFLCIO BillMcCarthy,President,MinneapolisCentralLaborUnionCouncil JayeRykunyk,President,Local17HotelandRestaurantEmployeeUnion DeborahHopp,Publisher,Minneapolis/St.PaulMagazine DavidSternberg,SeniorVicePresident,BrookfieldProperties

Tuesday,May10,2005 ListenNow orDownloadMP3 Agenda:HF2480(Finstad) Baseballstadiumdevelopment processprovided,metropolitan stadiumauthorityestablished, MetropolitanCouncilbonds authorized,andhostcommunity powersprovided. Televisionarchiveavailable
Viewarchive

GovernmentalOperationsand VeteransAffairsPart1 06:20Gavel. HF2480(Finstad)Baseball stadiumdevelopmentprocess provided,metropolitanstadium authorityestablished, MetropolitanCouncilbonds authorized,andhostcommunity powersprovided. Runs5minutes. Televisionarchiveavailable
Viewarchive

GovernmentalOperationsand VeteransAffairsPart2 04:19Gavel. HF2480(Finstad)Baseball stadiumdevelopmentprocess provided,metropolitanstadium authorityestablished, MetropolitanCouncilbonds authorized,andhostcommunity powersprovided. Runs4hours,52minutes.

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84012&id=40

1/3

4/16/12

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

StevenRosholt,Partner,FaegreandBensen RalphStragish,PrivateCitizen RepresentativeSeversonassumedthegavelat7:47PM. RepresentativeTingelstadassumedthegavelat8:13PM. RepresentativeLoefflermovedtheH2480A25Amendment.THEMOTIONDIDNOT PREVAILANDTHEAMENDMENTWASNOTADOPTED. RepresentativeKahnmovedtheH2480A5Amendment. RepresentativeKahnincorporatedthefollowingchangestotheH2480A5Amendment: Page1,line11,delete12andinsert8 Page1,lines1415,deleteMetropolitanSportsFacilitiesCommissionandinsert authority Page1,line9,beforetheperiod,insertonthesametermsofferedtoanyotherentity RepresentativeMcNamaramovedtoamendtheH2480A5Amendmentasfollows: Line8,afterto,insertaMinnesotabuyer,deletetheentityformedincompliancewith paragraph(b)onthesametermsofferedtoanyotherentity RepresentativeMcNamarawithdrewhisoralamendment. RepresentativeKahnrequestedadivisioncountonthevote. Therebeing11ayesand11nays,with0absentees:THEMOTIONDIDNOTPREVAIL ANDTHEAMENDMENTWASNOTADOPTED. RepresentativeOlsonmovedtheH2480A19Amendment.THEMOTIONPREVAILED ANDTHEAMENDMENTWASADOPTED. RepresentativeMahoneymovedtheH2480A8Amendment. RepresentativeMahoneyrequestedadivisioncountonthevote. Therebeing8ayesand14nays,with0absentees:THEMOTIONDIDNOTPREVAIL ANDTHEAMENDMENTWASNOTADOPTED. RepresentativeLoefflermovedtheH2480A20Amendment.THEMOTIONDIDNOT PREVAILANDTHEAMENDMENTWASNOTADOPTED. RepresentativeLieblingmovedtheLiebling1Amendment.THEMOTIONPREVAILED ANDTHEAMENDMENTWASADOPTED. RepresentativeWeltimovedtheH2480A10Amendment. RepresentativeWeltiincorporatedthefollowingchangetotheH2480A10Amendment: Page1,line4,afterstateinsertwidetaxorgeneralfund THEMOTIONDIDNOTPREVAILANDTHEAMENDEMNTWASNOTADOPTED. RepresentativeOlsonmovedtheH2480A17Amendment. RepresentativeOlsonincorporatedthefollowingchangetotheH2480A17Amendment: Page1,line7,afterelectioninsertoranyregularlyscheduledelection Adivisionwasrequested. Therebeing9ayesand13nays,with0absentees:THEMOTIONDIDNOTPREVAIL ANDTHEAMENDMENTWASNOTADOPTED. RepresentativeKahnmovedtheH2480A16Amendment. RepresentativeKahnincorporatedthefollowingchangestotheH2480A16Amendment: Page1,line5,deleteandinsert.075 Page1,line8,deleteandinsert.075 THEMOTIONDIDNOTPREVAILANDTHEAMENDMENTWASNOTADOPTED. RepresentativeLoefflermovedtheH2480A24Amendment.THEMOTIONDIDNOT PREVAILANDTHEAMENDMENTWASNOTADOPTED. RepresentativeNeilPetersonmovedtheH2480A18Amendment.THEMOTION PREVAILEDANDTHEAMENDMENTWASADOPTED. RepresentativeTingelstadrenewedhermotionthatHF2480bepassedasamendedand berereferredtotheCommitteeonLocalGovernment. RepresentativeKahnrequestedarollcallvote. TheClerktooktherollcall: Thefollowingmembersvotedaye: TINGELSTAD,Kathy,Chair SEVERSON,Dan BEARD,Michael

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84012&id=40

2/3

4/16/12
CYBART,Lloyd DEMMER,Randy DEMPSEY,Jerry HOPPE,Joe HOSCH,Larry JOHNSON,Ruth LIEBLING,Tina LILLIE,Leon MAHONEY,Tim MCNAMARA,Denny PETERSON,Aaron PETERSON,Neil WARDLOW,Lynn WELTI,Andy

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

Thefollowingmembersvotednay: JOHNSON,Sheldon KAHN,Phyllis LOEFFLER,Diane OLSON,Mark SEIFERT,Marty Thefollowingmemberswereabsent:

GOP Yes: 10 GOP No: 2 DFL Yes: 7 DFL No: 3

Therebeing17ayesand5nays,with0absentees:THEMOTIONPREVAILEDAND THEBILLWASPASSED. Themeetingadjournedat11:09PM. REP.KATHYTINGELSTAD,CHAIR AliciaDavis CommitteeLegislativeAssistant

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84012&id=40

3/3

4/16/12

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

STATEOFMINNESOTATWENTYSIXTHMEETING HOUSEOFREPRESENTATIVESEIGHTYFOURTHSESSION

RelatedAudio&Video

LOCALGOVERNMENTCOMMITTEE MINUTES RepresentativeMarkOlson,ChairoftheLocalGovernmentCommittee,calledthetwenty sixthmeetingtoorderat4:42P.M.onMonday,May16,2005,inRoom10oftheState OfficeBuilding. TheClerknotedtheroll. Memberspresent: OLSON,Mark(Chair) LANNING,Morrie(VC) ANDERSON,Bruce CHARRON,Mike CORNISH,Tony GAROFALO,Pat HILSTROM,Debra HOLBERG,MaryLiz HORNSTEIN,Frank HOSCH,Larry LENCZEWSKI,Ann MARQUART,Paul PAYMAR,Michael PETERSON,Neil POPPE,Jeanne SAMUELSON,Char SCALZE,Bev THAO,Cy WARDLOW,Lynn Aquorumwaspresent. HOLBERG,MaryLizmovedtheMinutesofApril26,2005,beapprovedaspreparedby theClerk.THEMOTIONPREVAILED. HOLBERG,MaryLizmovedthefollowingtimelimitsbeimposedontestimonyregarding HF2480: 15minutesforthepresentersofthebill onehourforalloftheopponentsand, onehourforalloftheproponents. Further,thepreviousquestionisorderedonallpendingquestionsat10:00P.M. LENCZEWSKI,AnnrequestedarollcallontheHolbergMotion. Thosewhovotedintheaffirmative: ANDERSON,Bruce CORNISH,Tony GAROFALO,Pat HILSTROM,Debra HOLBERG,MaryLiz LANNING,Morrie(VC) PETERSON,Neil SAMUELSON,Char THAO,Cy Thosewhovotedinthenegative: CHARRON,Mike HORNSTEIN,Frank HOSCH,Larry LENCZEWSKI,Ann MARQUART,Paul PAYMAR,Michael POPPE,Jeanne SCALZE,Bev WARDLOW,Lynn OLSON,Mark(Chair) Therebeing9ayesand10nays,THEMOTIONDIDNOTPREVAIL HF2480(Finstad)Baseballstadiumdevelopmentprocessprovided,metropolitanstadium authorityestablished,MetropolitanCouncilbondsauthorized,andhostcommunitypowers provided.

Note:Ifthereisatelevisionrecordingof themeeting,linkstothatformatwillalsobe available.

Monday,May16,2005 ListenNow orDownloadMP3 Agenda:HF2480(Finstad) Baseballstadiumdevelopment processprovided,metropolitan stadiumauthorityestablished, MetropolitanCouncilbonds authorized,andhostcommunity powersprovided. Thosewishingtotestifymust contactCommitteeAdministrator MaryCummins(6512963244 ormary.cummins@house.mn) tobeplacedontheagenda. Televisionarchiveavailable
Viewarchive

LocalGovernment 0:20Gavel,anddiscussion regardingthecommittee's process. 27:25HF2480(Finstad) Baseballstadiumdevelopment processprovided,metropolitan stadiumauthorityestablished, MetropolitanCouncilbonds authorized,andhostcommunity powersprovided. Runs7hours,20minutes.

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84017&id=27

1/8

4/16/12

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

GAROFALO,PatmovedHF2480,thefirstengrossment,berecommendedtopassand berereferredtotheCommitteeonTaxes. ThefollowingprovidedtestimonyonandrespondedtotheCommitteesquestions regardingHF2480andthevariousamendments: RepresentativeAnthonyTonySertichRepresentativeDougMagnusMikeOpat, Commissioner,HennepinCountyBoardofCommissioners,A2400GovernmentCenter, 300SixthSt.S,Minneapolis,MN,55487JerryBell,President,TwinsSportsInc.,34 KirbyPuckettPlace,Minneapolis,MN,55415DaveSt.Peter,President,Minnesota Twins,34KirbyPuckettPlace,Minneapolis,MN,55415. KenZapp,ProfessorandDirectorofGraduatePrograms,MetropolitanStateUniversity, 1611LagoonAv,Minneapolis,MN,554081871JohnKnight(13511MinnetonkaDr, Hopkins,MN,553055190)onbehalfofCitizensforaStadiumTaxReferendum(c/oJohn Knight)RyanWilson,5209LochloyDr,Edina,MN,55436JohnHartwig,3228Humboldt AvS,Minneapolis,MN,554083328HarrySavage,3228HumboldtAvS,Minneapolis, MN,554083328GeraldSavage,3228HumboldtAvS,Minneapolis,MN,554083328 NolanSavage,3228HumboldtAvS,Minneapolis,MN,554083328LeslieDavis(622 LowryAvN,Minneapolis,MN554111441),President,EarthProtector,Inc.,P.O.Box 11688,Minneapolis,MN,55411TomCasey(2854CambridgeLn,Mound,MN,55364 8585),onbehalfofCitizensProtectingReferendums,Inc.(addressunavailablebutthe nonprofit,perpetualcorporationisonfilewiththeSecretaryofState)SteveLyons,4850 AmericanWay,Bloomington,MN,55437DanielDobson(801GoodrichAv,SaintPaul, MN,551053346)ExecutiveDirector,NoStadiumTaxCoalition(c/oDanielDobson)Tom Goldstein,1399SherburneAv,SaintPaul,MN,55104MarkGiga,DirectorofOutreach, TaxpayersLeagueofMinnesota,OneCarlsonPkwy,Suite120,Plymouth,MN,55447 and,RogerKloster,7223LeeAvN,BrooklynCenter,MN,554291335. ChuckLevin,2300MilwaukeeAv,Minneapolis,MN,55404. GregOrtale,PresidentandCEO,GreaterMinneapolisConventionandVisitors Association,250MarquetteAvS,Suite1300,Minneapolis,MN,55401SallyMars,4841 VincentAvS,Minneapolis,MN,55410SusanJ.Spaulding,4352MayroseAvNE,Saint Michael,MN,55376ChuckWaltz,4139BlazedaleAvS,Minneapolis,MN,55409 LorrainePizzella,3746StinsonBlvd#205,ColumbiaHeights,MN,55421George Hunkins,220IsabelleStW,SaintPaul,MN,55107JodiTanaka,4950St.AlbansBay Rd,Greenwood,MN,55331RayWaldron,President,MinnesotaAFLCIO,175Aurora Av,SaintPaul,MN,55103DickAnfang(506HarrisonAv,SaintPaul,MN,55102), President,MinnesotaBuildingandConstructionTradesCouncil,411MainSt#206,Saint Paul,MN,55102JayeTanaka(506HarrisonAv,SaintPaul,MN,55102),President, Local17UNITEHERE(formerlytheUnionofNeedletrades,TextilesandIndustrial EmployeesandtheHotelEmployeesandRestaurantEmployeesInternationalUnion), 312CentralAvSE,Room444,Minneapolis,MN,55414JohnStanoch(President,Qwest Minnesota,200FifthStS#2100,Minneapolis,MN,55402),ChairoftheBoardof Directors,MinneapolisRegionalChamberofCommerce,81NinthStS,Suite200, Minneapolis,MN,554023223JimGraves,ChiefExecutiveOfficer,GravesHospitality Inc.,118GrovelandTerrace,Minneapolis,MN,55403GeoffGlueckstein(6180McKinley Cir,Shorewood,MN,55331),DirectorofBusinessDevelopment,KnutsonConstruction Services,5500WayzataBlvdSuite300,Minneapolis,MN,55416MichaelBrunkow (GeneralManager,HiltonMinneapolis/SaintPaulAirport,3800AmericanBlvdE, Bloomington,MN,55425),ChairelectoftheBoardofDirectors,BloomingtonChamberof Commerce,9633LyndaleAvSSuite200,Bloomington,MN,55420and,Anthony Rimarcik,VicePresident,MastersRestaurantAssociatesInc,107WashingtonAvN, Minneapolis,MN,55401. Therewasnofurtherpublictestimony,proorcon. HOLBERG,MaryLizmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,beamended asfollows: Page16,deletelines3336 Page17,deletelines120 ThefollowingprovidedtestimonyonandrespondedtotheCommitteesquestions regardingtheHolbergMotion: BetsyParker,GovernmentandCommunityRelationsDirector,MNDepartmentof Transportation,395JohnIrelandBlvd,SaintPaul,MN,55155and,JimGraves(see above). TheHolbergMotionPrevailed. LENCZEWSKI,AnnmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seeH2480A31attached) TheLenczewskiMotionDidNotPrevail. LENCZEWSKI,AnnmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seeH2480A32attached) TheLenczewskiMotionDidNotPrevail. LENCZEWSKI,AnnmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seeH2480A33attached) SAMUELSON,Charmovedtoamendtheamendmentasfollows:

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84017&id=27

2/8

4/16/12

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

Page4,line20beforetheperiodinsert,butnotincludingthepowerofcondemnation Attherequestoftheamendmentauthorandwithoutobjection,theamendmenttothe amendmentwasadopted. TheLenczewskiMotionasamendedPrevailed. LENCZEWSKI,AnnmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seeH2480A34attached) CHARRON,Mikemovedtoamendtheamendmentasfollows: Page1,deletelines1114 Attherequestoftheamendmentauthorandwithoutobjection,theamendmenttothe amendmentwasadopted. TheLenczewskiMotionasamendedPrevailed. LENCZEWSKI,AnnmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seeH2480A35attached) TheLenczewskiMotionPrevailed. LENCZEWSKI,AnnmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seeH2480A36attached) Therebeing9ayesand9nays,theLenczewskiMotionDidNotPrevail. LENCZEWSKI,AnnmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seeH2480A37attached) TheLenczewskiMotionDidNotPrevail. LENCZEWSKI,AnnmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seeH2480A40attached) WithoutobjectiontheLenczewskiMotionWasWithdrawn. LENCZEWSKI,AnnmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seeH2480A38attached) TheLenczewskiMotionPrevailed. LENCZEWSKI,AnnmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seeH2480A39attached) WithoutobjectiontheLenczewskiMotionWasWithdrawn. HORNSTEIN,FrankmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seeH2480A26attached) ThefollowingprovidedtestimonyonandrespondedtotheCommitteesquestions regardingtheHornsteinMotion: JerryBell(seeabove)and,JohnKnight(seeabove). LENCZEWSKI,AnnrequestedarollcallontheHornsteinMotion. Thosewhovotedintheaffirmative: ANDERSON,Bruce CHARRON,Mike CORNISH,Tony HOLBERG,MaryLiz HORNSTEIN,Frank LENCZEWSKI,Ann PAYMAR,Michael POPPE,Jeanne OLSON,Mark(Chair) Thosewhovotedinthenegative:

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84017&id=27

3/8

4/16/12
GAROFALO,Pat HILSTROM,Debra HOSCH,Larry LANNING,Morrie(VC) MARQUART,Paul PETERSON,Neil SAMUELSON,Char SCALZE,Bev THAO,Cy WARDLOW,Lynn

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

Therebeing9ayesand10nays,theHornsteinMotionDidNotPrevail OLSON,MarkmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurtheramended asfollows: (seeH2480A69attached) ThefollowingprovidedtestimonyonandrespondedtotheCommitteesquestions regardingtheOlsonMotion: RobertHeise,President,andJasonGrev,LegislativeDirector,AssociatedBuildersand Contractors,10179CrosstownCircle,EdenPrairie,MN,55344. PAYMAR,MichaelmovedtheCommitteerecessthenreconveneatthecalloftheChair aftertheHouseadjournsonTuesday,May17,2005. WithoutobjectionthePaymarMOTIONWASWITHDRAWN. CORNISH,TonyrequestedarollcallontheOlsonMotion. Thosewhovotedintheaffirmative: ANDERSON,Bruce CHARRON,Mike CORNISH,Tony HOLBERG,MaryLiz WARDLOW,Lynn OLSON,Mark(Chair) Thosewhovotedinthenegative: GAROFALO,Pat HILSTROM,Debra HORNSTEIN,Frank HOSCH,Larry LANNING,Morrie(VC) LENCZEWSKI,Ann MARQUART,Paul PAYMAR,Michael POPPE,Jeanne PETERSON,Neil SAMUELSON,Char SCALZE,Bev THAO,Cy Therebeing6ayesand13nays,theOlsonMotionDidNotPrevail. PAYMAR,MichaelmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seeH2480A27attached) TheChaircalledRepresentativeLanningtotheChair. PAYMAR,MichaelrequestedarollcallonthePaymarMotion. Thosewhovotedintheaffirmative: CORNISH,Tony HOLBERG,MaryLiz HORNSTEIN,Frank LENCZEWSKI,Ann PAYMAR,Michael POPPE,Jeanne

Thosewhovotedinthenegative: ANDERSON,Bruce CHARRON,Mike GAROFALO,Pat HILSTROM,Debra

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84017&id=27

4/8

4/16/12
HOSCH,Larry LANNING,Morrie(VC) MARQUART,Paul PETERSON,Neil SAMUELSON,Char SCALZE,Bev THAO,Cy WARDLOW,Lynn

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

Therebeing6ayesand12nays,thePaymarMotionDidNotPrevail PAYMAR,MichaelmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: seeH2480A1attachedandincludethefollowingcorrections: online1oftheamendment,deletedeleteandinsertfirstengrossment online2oftheamendment,deleteeverythingamendment(H2480E1)and online3oftheamendment,delete18andinsert27 ThePaymarMotionascorrectedDidNotPrevail. RepresentativeOlsonresumedtheChair. ANDERSON,BrucemovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (see??/HRDattached) WithoutobjectiontheAndersonMotionWasWithdrawn. ANDERSON,BrucemovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seeH2480A72attached) TheAndersonMotionPrevailed HOLBERG,MaryLizmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: Page4,deletelines1820 TheHolbergMotionPrevailed HORNSTEIN,FrankmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seeH2480A41attached) TheHornsteinMotionDidNotPrevail. LENCZEWSKI,AnnmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seePD/HRDattached) LENCZEWSKI,AnnrequestedarollcallontheLenczewskiMotion. WithoutobjectiontheLenczewskiMotionWasWithdrawn CORNISH,TonymovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: Page6,line7deletetrafficandinsertpeace TheCornishMotionPrevailed LENCZEWSKI,AnnmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seeH2480A55attached) LENCZEWSKI,AnnrequestedarollcallontheLenczewskiMotion. Thosewhovotedintheaffirmative: CORNISH,Tony HOLBERG,MaryLiz LENCZEWSKI,Ann THAO,Cy Thosewhovotedinthenegative: ANDERSON,Bruce CHARRON,Mike GAROFALO,Pat HILSTROM,Debra HORNSTEIN,Frank

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84017&id=27

5/8

4/16/12
HOSCH,Larry LANNING,Morrie(VC) MARQUART,Paul PAYMAR,Michael PETERSON,Neil POPPE,Jeanne SAMUELSON,Char SCALZE,Bev WARDLOW,Lynn OLSON,Mark(Chair)

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

Therebeing4ayesand15nays,theLenczewskiMotionDidNotPrevail LENCZEWSKI,AnnmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seeH2480A59attached) LENCZEWSKI,AnnrequestedarollcallontheLenczewskiMotion. Thosewhovotedintheaffirmative: ANDERSON,Bruce CHARRON,Mike CORNISH,Tony GAROFALO,Pat HILSTROM,Debra HOLBERG,MaryLiz HORNSTEIN,Frank HOSCH,Larry LENCZEWSKI,Ann MARQUART,Paul PAYMAR,Michael POPPE,Jeanne SCALZE,Bev THAO,Cy OLSON,Mark(Chair) Thosewhovotedinthenegative: LANNING,Morrie(VC) PETERSON,Neil SAMUELSON,Char WARDLOW,Lynn Therebeing15ayesand4nays,theLenczewskiMotionPrevailed. LENCZEWSKI,AnnmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seeH2480A61attached) LENCZEWSKI,AnnrequestedarollcallontheLenczewskiMotion. CHARRON,Mikemovedtoamendtheamendmentasfollows: Page1,line15delete20andinsert30 Page1,line19delete20andinsert30 TheCharronamendmenttotheamendmentwasnotadopted. ThequestionreoccurredontheLenczewskiMotiontorecommendHF2480,thefirst engrossment,befurtheramended. Thosewhovotedintheaffirmative: ANDERSON,Bruce CORNISH,Tony LENCZEWSKI,Ann OLSON,Mark(Chair) Thosewhovotedinthenegative: CHARRON,Mike GAROFALO,Pat HILSTROM,Debra HOLBERG,MaryLiz HORNSTEIN,Frank HOSCH,Larry LANNING,Morrie(VC) MARQUART,Paul PAYMAR,Michael PETERSON,Neil POPPE,Jeanne

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84017&id=27

6/8

4/16/12
SAMUELSON,Char SCALZE,Bev THAO,Cy WARDLOW,Lynn

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

Therebeing4ayesand15nays,theLenczewskiMotionDidNotPrevail. Withoutobjectionthemeetingwasrecessedat12:00midnight,tobereconvenedatthe CalloftheChairaftertheHouseadjournsonMay17,2005. RepresentativeMarkOlson,ChairoftheLocalGovernmentCommittee,reconvenedthe twentysixthmeetingat2:13P.M.onTuesday,May17,2005,inRoom10oftheState OfficeBuilding. AttherequestofHOSCH,LarryandwithoutobjectiontheGarofaloMotion,asamended, torecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,beamended,andwhensoamendedbe recommendedtopassandberereferredtotheCommitteeonTaxeswasplacedbefore theCommittee. HORNSTEIN,FrankmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seeH2480A29attached) ThefollowingprovidedtestimonyonandrespondedtotheCommitteesquestions regardingtheHornsteinMotion: RepresentativePhyllisKahnJulianLoscalzo,1141PortlandAv,SaintPaul,MN,55104 6942and,JerryBell(seeabove). ThequestionreoccurredontheHornsteinMotiontorecommendHF2480,thefirst engrossment,befurtheramended.TheMotionPrevailed. HORNSTEIN,FrankmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seeH2480A30attached) ThefollowingprovidedtestimonyonandrespondedtotheCommitteesquestions regardingtheHornsteinMotion: JulianLoscalzo(seeabove)RepresentativePhyllisKahnMikeOpat(seeabove)and, DaveLawless(4105GarfieldAvS,Minneapolis,MN,55409),BudgetandFinance Director,HennepinCounty,A2301GovernmentCenter,300SixthSt.S,Minneapolis, MN,55487. ThequestionreoccurredontheHornsteinMotiontorecommendHF2480,thefirst engrossment,befurtheramended.TheMotionDidNotPrevail. HORNSTEIN,FrankmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seeH2480A53attached) LENCZEWSKI,AnnrequestedarollcallontheHornsteinMotion. Thosewhovotedintheaffirmative: ANDERSON,Bruce CORNISH,Tony HILSTROM,Debra HOLBERG,MaryLiz HORNSTEIN,Frank HOSCH,Larry LENCZEWSKI,Ann MARQUART,Paul PAYMAR,Michael POPPE,Jeanne SCALZE,Bev THAO,Cy WARDLOW,Lynn OLSON,Mark(Chair) Thosewhovotedinthenegative: LANNING,Morrie(VC) CHARRON,Mike GAROFALO,Pat PETERSON,Neil SAMUELSON,Char Therebeing14ayesand5nays,theHornsteinMotionPrevailed. HORNSTEIN,FrankmovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows:

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84017&id=27

7/8

4/16/12
(seeH2480A70attached) TheHornsteinMotionPrevailed.

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

ANDERSON,BrucemovedtorecommendHF2480,thefirstengrossment,befurther amendedasfollows: (seeH2480A71attached) TheAndersonMotionPrevailed ThequestionreoccurredontheGarofaloMotionasamended,torecommendHF2480,the firstengrossment,beamended,andwhensoamendedberecommendedtopassandbe rereferredtotheCommitteeonTaxes. LENCZEWSKI,AnnrequestedarollcallontheGarofaloMotionasamended. Thosewhovotedintheaffirmative: CHARRON,Mike GAROFALO,Pat HILSTROM,Debra HOSCH,Larry LANNING,Morrie(VC) MARQUART,Paul PETERSON,Neil POPPE,Jeanne SAMUELSON,Char SCALZE,Bev THAO,Cy WARDLOW,Lynn Thosewhovotedinthenegative:

GOP Yes: 6 GOP No: 4 DFL Yes: 6 DFL No: 3 Scalze: Yes on Twins, No on Vikings (4/16/12)

ANDERSON,Bruce CORNISH,Tony HOLBERG,MaryLiz HORNSTEIN,Frank LENCZEWSKI,Ann PAYMAR,Michael OLSON,Mark(Chair) Therebeing12ayesand7nays,THEMOTIONPREVAILED. Withoutobjectionthemeetingwasadjournedat5:07PM.

REP.MARKD.OLSON,CHAIR

DaveEasterday CommitteeLegislativeAssistant

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84017&id=27

8/8

4/16/12

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

STATEOFMINNESOTAFORTYTHIRDMEETING HOUSEOFREPRESENTATIVESEIGHTYFOURTHSESSION TAXESCOMMITTEE MINUTES

RelatedAudio&Video

Note:Ifthereisatelevisionrecordingof themeeting,linkstothatformatwillalsobe available.

RepresentativePhilKrinkie,ChairmanoftheTaxCommittee,calledthefortythird meetingtoorderat10:19AMonFriday,April21,2006,inRoom200oftheStateOffice Building. CommitteeLegislativeAssistantnotedtheroll. KRINKIE,Phil,Chair SIMPSON,Dean,ViceChair ABRAMS,Ron ANDERSON,Irv ATKINS,Joe BERNARDY,Connie BROD,Laura DAVIDS,Greg DAVNIE,Jim DELAFOREST,Chris DILL,David DORMAN,Dan ERHARDT,Ron HOWES,Larry JAROS,Mike KNOBLACH,Jim KOENEN,Lyle KOHLS,Paul LANNING,Morrie LENCZEWSKI,Ann LESCH,John MARQUART,Paul MULLERY,Joe NELSON,Peter RUKAVINA,Tom SIEBEN,Katie VANDEVEER,Ray WESTERBERG,Andy ZELLERS,Kurt Aquorumwaspresent. HF2480(FINSTAD)Baseballstadiumfinancing,construction,andoperationprovided MinnesotaBallparkAuthorityestablishedandHennepinCountysalestaxauthorized. TheChairmovedHF2480asamended. Testifyingwas: Rep.FINSTAD Rep.ABRAMSmovedtheAH2480PD12amendmenttoHF2480asamended. Testifyingwas: Mr.Sausen,DepartmentofFinance THEMOTIONPREVAILEDANDTHEAMENDMENTWASADOPTED. Rep.DAVNIEmovedtheH2480A57amendmenttoHF2480asamended. Rep.DAVNIErescindedtheH2480A57amendment. Rep.ABRAMSmovedtheAH2480PD13amendmenttoHF2480asamended. Testifyingwas: Mr.Opat,HennepinCountyCommissioner Rep.LENCZEWSKImovedtheH2480A43amendmenttotheH2480PD13amendmentto HF2480.THEMOTIONPREVAILEDANDTHEAMENDMENTTOTHEAMENDMENT WASADOPTED. THEMOTIONPREVAILEDANDTHEAMENDMENT,ASAMENDED,WASADOPTED. Rep.ERHARDTmovedtheH2480A56amendmenttotheHF2480asamended. Rep.SIMPSONassumedthepositionasChairat11:03AM. ChairKRINKIEreassumedhispositionasChairat11:12AM. Rep.ERHARDTrequestedarollcallvoteontheH2480A56amendment. Testifyingwas: Mr.JerryBell,PresidentoftheTwins Thosevotingayewere:

Friday,April21,2006 ListenNow orDownloadMP3 Agenda:HF2480(Finstad) Baseballstadiumfinancing, constructionandoperation providedMinnesotaBallpark Authorityestablishedand HennepinCountysalestax authorized. Televisionarchiveavailable
Viewarchive

Taxesaftertherecess 01:23Gavel,andcontinued discussionofHF2480(Finstad) Baseballstadiumfinancing, construction,andoperation providedMinnesotaBallpark Authorityestablishedand HennepinCountysalestax authorized. Runs2hours,25minutes. Televisionarchiveavailable
Viewarchive

Taxesbeforetherecess 07:55Gavel,anddiscussionof HF2480(Finstad)Baseball stadiumfinancing,construction, andoperationprovided MinnesotaBallparkAuthority establishedandHennepin Countysalestaxauthorized. Runs3hours,2minutes.

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84023&id=43

1/8

4/16/12
ERHARDT,Ron JAROS,Mike LENCZEWSKI,Ann MULLERY,Joe Thosevotingnaywere: KRINKIE,Phil,Chair ANDERSON,Irv ATKINS,Joe BERNARDY,Connie BROD,Laura DAVIDS,Greg DAVNIE,Jim DELAFOREST,Chris DILL,David DORMAN,Dan HOWES,Larry KOENEN,Lyle KOHLS,Paul LANNING,Morrie LESCH,John MARQUART,Paul NELSON,Peter RUKAVINA,Tom SIEBEN,Katie SIMPSON,Dean,ViceChair VANDEVEER,Ray WESTERBERG,Andy ZELLERS,Kurt Thoseabsentwere: ABRAMS,Ron KNOBLACH,Jim

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

With4ayesand23nays,THEMOTIONDIDNOTPREVAILANDTHEAMENDMENT WASNOTADOPTED. Rep.ATKINSmovedtheH2480A10amendmenttoHF2480asamended. Rep.ATKINSrequestedarollcallvoteontheH2480A10amendment. Thosevotingayewere: ANDERSON,Irv ATKINS,Joe BERNARDY,Connie DAVNIE,Jim DELAFOREST,Chris DILL,David DORMAN,Dan HOWES,Larry JAROS,Mike KOENEN,Lyle KOHLS,Paul LENCZEWSKI,Ann LESCH,John MULLERY,Joe NELSON,Peter RUKAVINA,Tom SIEBEN,Katie ZELLERS,Kurt Thosevotingnowere: KRINKIE,Phil,Chair BROD,Laura DAVIDS,Greg ERHARDT,Ron KNOBLACH,Jim LANNING,Morrie MARQUART,Paul SIMPSON,Dean,ViceChair VANDEVEER,Ray WESTERBERG,Andy Thoseabsentwere: ABRAMS,Ron With18ayesand10nays,THEMOTIONPREVAILEDANDTHEAMENDMENTWAS ADOPTED. Rep.ATKINSmovedtheH2480A36amendmenttoHF2480asamended.THEMOTION DIDNOTPREVAILANDTHEAMENDMENTWASNOTADOPTED. Rep.MULLERYmovedtheH2480A2amendmenttoHF2480asamended. TheChairrequestedarollcallvoteontheHF2480A2amendment.

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84023&id=43

2/8

4/16/12
Thosevotingayewere: ANDERSON,Irv ATKINS,Joe BERNARDY,Connie DAVIDS,Greg DAVNIE,Jim KOENEN,Lyle LENCZEWSKI,Ann LESCH,John MARQUART,Paul MULLERY,Joe RUKAVINA,Tom SIEBEN,Katie Thosevotingnaywere: KRINKIE,Phil,Chair ABRAMS,Ron BROD,Laura DELAFOREST,Chris ERHARDT,Ron KNOBLACH,Jim KOHLS,Paul LANNING,Morrie NELSON,Peter SIMPSON,Dean,ViceChair VANDEVEER,Ray WESTERBERG,Andy ZELLERS,Kurt Thoseabsentwere: DILL,David DORMAN,Dan HOWES,Larry JAROS,Mike

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

With12ayesand12nays,THEMOTIONDIDNOTPREVAILANDTHEAMENDMENT WASNOTADOPTED. Rep.ANDERSONmovedtoreconsidertheH2480A2amendmenttoHF2480asamended. Rep.KNOBLACHrequestedarollcallvoteonthereconsideration. Thosevotingayewere: ANDERSON,Irv ATKINS,Joe BERNARDY,Connie DAVNIE,Jim JAROS,Mike KOENEN,Lyle LENCZEWSKI,Ann LESCH,John MARQUART,Paul MULLERY,Joe RUKAVINA,Tom SIEBEN,Katie Thosevotingnaywere: KRINKIE,Phil,Chair BROD,Laura DAVIDS,Greg DELAFOREST,Chris DILL,David ERHARDT,Ron KNOBLACH,Jim KOHLS,Paul LANNING,Morrie NELSON,Peter SIMPSON,Dean,ViceChair VANDEVEER,Ray WESTERBERG,Andy ZELLERS,Kurt Thoseabsentwere: ABRAMS,Ron DORMAN,Dan HOWES,Larry With13ayesand13nays,THEMOTIONDIDNOTPREVAIL. Rep.MULLERYmovedtheH2480A68amendmenttoHF2480asamended.THE MOTIONDIDNOTPREVAILANDTHEAMENDMENTWASNOTADOPTED. Rep.ZELLERSmovedtheH2480A71amendmenttoHF2480asamended. Rep.MULLERYmovedanoralamendmenttotheH2480A71amendment. Line1.7,afterprovide,insertMinneapolislicensed

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84023&id=43

3/8

4/16/12

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

Rep.HOWESrequestedarollcallvoteontheMULLERYoralamendmenttothe H2480A71amendment. Rep.MULLERYincorporatedintotheMULLERYoralamendmenttotheH2480A71 amendment: DeletethewordMinneapolis Rep.HOWESrescindedhisrequestforarollcallvoteontheMULLERYoralamendment totheH2480A71amendment. THEMOTIONDIDNOTPREVAILANDTHEAMENDMENTTOTHEAMENDMENT WASNOTADOPTED. Rep.ERHARDTmovedanoralamendmenttotheH2480A71amendment. Line1.7,afterofficers,insertortheNationalGuard Rep.ERHARDTrescindedhisoralamendmenttotheH2480A71amendment. Rep.HOWESrequestedarollcallvoteontheH2480A71amendment. Thosevotingayewere: ANDERSON,Irv ATKINS,Joe BERNARDY,Connie BROD,Laura DAVIDS,Greg DAVNIE,Jim DELAFOREST,Chris DILL,David DORMAN,Dan ERHARDT,Ron HOWES,Larry JAROS,Mike KOENEN,Lyle KOHLS,Paul LANNING,Morrie MARQUART,Paul MULLERY,Joe NELSON,Peter SIMPSON,Dean,ViceChair VANDEVEER,Ray WESTERBERG,Andy ZELLERS,Kurt Thosevotingnaywere: KRINKIE,Phil,Chair KNOBLACH,Jim LESCH,John SIEBEN,Katie Thoseabstainingfromvotingwere: LENCZEWSKI,Ann Thoseabsentwere: ABRAMS,Ron RUKAVINA,Tom Rep.SIMPSONassumedthepositionasChairat12:33PM. With22ayesand4nays,THEMOTIONPREVAILEDANDTHEAMENDMENTWAS ADOPTED. Rep.ATKINSmovedtoreconsidertheH2480A2amendment. ChairKRINKIEreassumedhispositionasChairat12:36PM. THEMOTIONPREVAILED. Rep.ATKINSmovedtheH2480A2amendmenttoHF2480asamended.THEMOTION PREVAILEDANDTHEAMENDMENTWASADOPTED. Rep.BERNARDYmovedtheH2480A73amendmenttotheHF2480asamended. Rep.HOWESmovedanoralamendmenttotheH2480A73amendment. Line1.5,deleteorrelatedfacilities Rep.HOWESrequestedarollcallvoteontheHOWESoralamendment. Rep.HOWESrescindedhisoralamendmenttotheH2480A73amendment. Rep.VANDEVEERrequestedarollcallvoteontheH2480A73amendment. Thosevotingayewere: ANDERSON,Irv ATKINS,Joe BERNARDY,Connie

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84023&id=43

4/8

4/16/12
DAVNIE,Jim DILL,David DORMAN,Dan JAROS,Mike LENCZEWSKI,Ann MULLERY,Joe Thosevotingnaywere: KRINKIE,Phil,Chair BROD,Laura DELAFOREST,Chris ERHARDT,Ron HOWES,Larry KNOBLACH,Jim KOENEN,Lyle KOHLS,Paul LANNING,Morrie LESCH,John MARQUART,Paul NELSON,Peter RUKAVINA,Tom SIEBEN,Katie SIMPSON,Dean,ViceChair VANDEVEER,Ray WESTERBERG,Andy ZELLERS,Kurt Thoseabsentwere: ABRAMS,Ron DAVIDS,Greg

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

With9ayesand18nays,THEMOTIONDIDNOTPREVAILANDTHEAMENDMENT WASNOTADOPTED. Rep.NELSONmovedtheH2480A55amendment. TheChairrecessedthemeetingat1:15PM. TheChairreconvenedthemeetingat2:23PM. Rep.NELSONrescindedtheH2480A55amendmenttoHF2480asamended. Rep.DAVNIEmovedtheH2480A62amendmenttoHF2480.THEMOTIONPREVAILED ANDTHEAMENDMENTWASADOPTED. Rep.DAVNIEmovedtheH2480A60amendmenttoHF2480asamended. Rep.DAVNIErequestedarollcallvoteontheH2480A60amendment. Thosevotingayewere: KRINKIE,Phil,Chair ABRAMS,Ron ANDERSON,Irv DAVNIE,Jim DELAFOREST,Chris LENCZEWSKI,Ann MULLERY,Joe RUKAVINA,Tom SIEBEN,Katie Thosevotingnowere: ATKINS,Joe BERNARDY,Connie BROD,Laura DILL,David DORMAN,Dan ERHARDT,Ron HOWES,Larry KOENEN,Lyle KOHLS,Paul LANNING,Morrie LESCH,John MARQUART,Paul NELSON,Peter SIMPSON,Dean,ViceChair WESTERBERG,Andy ZELLERS,Kurt Thoseabsentwere: DAVIDS,Greg JAROS,Mike KNOBLACH,Jim VANDEVEER,Ray With9ayesand16nays,THEMOTIONDIDNOTPREVAILANDTHEAMENDMENT WASNOTADOPTED.

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84023&id=43

5/8

4/16/12

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

Rep.DAVNIEmovedtheH2480A52amendmenttoHF2480asamended.THEMOTION PREVAILEDANDTHEAMENDMENTWASADOPTED. Rep.DAVNIEmovedtheH2480A58amendmenttoHF2480asamended. Testifyingwas: GeneRanieri,IGRDirectorfortheCityofMinneapolis THEMOTIONDIDNOTPREVAILANDTHEAMENDMENTWASNOTADOPTED. Rep.ABRAMSmovedtheH2480A66amendmenttoHF2480asamended. Rep.ABRAMSmadethefollowingchangestohisamendment: deletelines1.21,line1.22,andline1.23 THEMOTIONPREVAILEDANDTHEAMENDMENTWASADOPTED. Rep.ABRAMSmovedanoralamendmenttotheadoptedH2480A66amendmentto HF2480. deletelines2.10through2.21 THEMOTIONPREVAILEDANDTHEAMENDMENTWASADOPTED. Rep.RUKAVINAmovedtheA061582amendmenttoHF2480asamended.THE MOTIONPREVAILEDANDTHEAMENDMENTWASADOPTED. Rep.DAVNIEmovedtheH2480A61amendmenttoHF2480asamended.THEMOTION PREVAILEDANDTHEAMENDMENTWASADOPTED. Rep.ABRAMSmovedtheAH2480A8amendmenttoHF2480asamended.THE MOTIONPREVAILEDANDTHEAMENDMENTWASADOPTED. Rep.KRINKIEmovedtheH2480A7amendmenttoHF2480asamended. Rep.KRINKIEmadethefollowingchangestotheH2480A7amendment: Line1.7,afterfacility,deleteallandinsert20percentofthe Deleteline1.8throughfacilityonline1.10 Deletelines1.22through1.27 Deletelines2.1through2.2 Line2.12,deleteallandinsert20percentofthe Line2.14,deleteinproportionthroughtheendofthesentenceonline2.15 Rep.KRINKIErequestedarollcallvoteontheH2480A7amendment. Thosevotingayewere: KRINKIE,Phil,Chair DAVNIE,Jim HOWES,Larry JAROS,Mike KNOBLACH,Jim LENCZEWSKI,Ann MULLERY,Joe RUKAVINA,Tom VANDEVEER,Ray ZELLERS,Kurt Thosevotingnowere: ABRAMS,Ron ANDERSON,Irv ATKINS,Joe BERNARDY,Connie BROD,Laura DAVIDS,Greg DILL,David DORMAN,Dan ERHARDT,Ron KOENEN,Lyle KOHLS,Paul LANNING,Morrie LESCH,John MARQUART,Paul NELSON,Peter SIEBEN,Katie SIMPSON,Dean,ViceChair WESTERBERG,Andy Thoseabsentwere: DELAFOREST,Chris THEMOTIONDIDNOTPREVAILANDTHEAMENDMENTWASNOTADOPTED. Rep.DILLmovedtheA061584amendmenttoHF2480asamended. Rep.DILLrescindedtheA061584amendmenttoHF2480. Rep.LENCZEWSKImovedtheH2480A79amendmenttotheHF2480asamended. Rep.SIMPSONassumedthepositionasChairat4:05PM.

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84023&id=43

6/8

4/16/12

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

ChairKRINKIEreassumedhispositionasChairat4:08PM. Rep.LENCZEWSKIrequestedarollcallvoteontheH2480A79amendment. Thosevotingayewere: KRINKIE,Phil,Chair ABRAMS,Ron ANDERSON,Irv BERNARDY,Connie DAVNIE,Jim JAROS,Mike KNOBLACH,Jim KOHLS,Paul LENCZEWSKI,Ann LESCH,John MULLERY,Joe NELSON,Peter SIEBEN,Katie Thosevotingnowere: BROD,Laura DAVIDS,Greg DILL,David ERHARDT,Ron HOWES,Larry KOENEN,Lyle LANNING,Morrie MARQUART,Paul RUKAVINA,Tom SIMPSON,Dean,ViceChair WESTERBERG,Andy ZELLERS,Kurt Thoseabsentwere: ATKINS,Joe DELAFOREST,Chris DORMAN,Dan VANDEVEER,Ray With14ayesand11nays,THEMOTIONPREVAILEDANDTHEAMENDMENTWAS ADOPTED. Rep.MULLERYmovedtheH2480A76amendmenttoHF2480asamended.THE MOTIONDIDNOTPREVAILANDTHEAMENDMENTWASNOTADOPTED. Rep.MULLERYmovedtheH2480A3amendmenttoHF2480asamended. Rep.MULLERYrescindedtheH2480A3amendmenttoHF2480asamended. Rep.LENCZEWSKImovedtheH2480A33amendmenttoHF2480asamended. Rep.LENCZEWKSImadethefollowingchangestotheH2480A33amendment: Line1.5,deletesections3to12inchapter383Bandinserttheprovisionsofthisact THEMOTIONPREVAILEDANDTHEAMENDMENTWASADOPTED. Rep.MULLERYmovedtheH2480A3amendmenttoHF2480asamended. Rep.MULLERYmadethefollowingchangestotheH2480A3amendment: Changeline1.2toread,Page17,afterline7,delete14andinsert:" THEMOTIONDIDNOTPREVAILANDTHEAMENDMENTWASNOTADOPTED. Rep.BERNARDYmovedtheH2480A80amendmenttoHF2480asamended.THE MOTIONPREVAILEDANDTHEAMENDMENTISADOPTED. Rep.MARQUARTmovedtheH2480A67amendmenttoHF2480asamended. Rep.MARQUARTrescindedtheH2480A67amendment. TheChairmovedtheHF2480asamendedtobepassedandrereferredtotheCommittee onWaysandMeans. TheChairrequestedarollcallonHF2480asamended. Thosevotingayewere: ANDERSON,Irv ATKINS,Joe BROD,Laura DAVIDS,Greg DILL,David DORMAN,Dan KOENEN,Lyle LANNING,Morrie LESCH,John MARQUART,Paul NELSON,Peter RUKAVINA,Tom

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84023&id=43

7/8

4/16/12
SIEBEN,Katie SIMPSON,Dean,ViceChair WESTERBERG,Andy Thosevotingnowere: KRINKIE,Phil,Chair ABRAMS,Ron BERNARDY,Connie DAVNIE,Jim ERHARDT,Ron HOWES,Larry JAROS,Mike KNOBLACH,Jim KOHLS,Paul LENCZEWSKI,Ann MULLERY,Joe VANDEVEER,Ray ZELLERS,Kurt Thoseabsentwere: DELAFOREST,Chris

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

GOP Yes: 7 GOP No: 8 DFL Yes: 8 DFL No: 5

With15ayesand13nays,THEMOTIONPREVAILED. TheChairadjournedthemeetingat4:49PM ___________________________________ REP.PHILKRINKIE,CHAIR ____________________________________ SaraLinert,CommitteeLegislativeAssistant

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84023&id=43

8/8

4/16/12

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

STATEOFMINNESOTAFORTYTHIRDMEETING HOUSEOFREPRESENTATIVESEIGHTYFOURTHSESSION WAYS&MEANSCOMMITTEE MINUTES
Note:Ifthereisatelevisionrecordingof themeeting,linkstothatformatwillalsobe available.

RelatedAudio&Video

RepresentativeJimKnoblach,Chair,calledthefortysecondmeetingtoorderat6:10p.m. onMonday,April24,2006inRoom200oftheStateOfficeBuilding. TheClerknotedtheroll. Memberspresent: KNOBLACH,Jim HUNTLEY,Thomas

Monday,April24,2006 ListenNow orDownloadMP3 Agenda:HF2480(Finstad) Baseballstadiumfinancing, construction,andoperation providedMinnesotaBallpark Authorityestablishedand HennepinCountysalestax authorized. Televisionarchiveavailable
Viewarchive

DEMPSEY,Jerry,ViceChair ABELER,Jim ABRAMS,Ro BEARD,Mike BRADLEY,Fran BUESGENS,Mark CARLSON,Lyndon CLARK,Karen DORMAN,Dan DORN,John ERHARDT,Ron GREILING,Mindy GUNTHER,Bob HAMILTON,Rod HILTY,Bill HOLBERG,MaryLiz KELLIHER,Margaret KLINZING,Karen KRINKIE,Phil LARSON,Dan McNAMARA,Denny NORNES,Bud OTREMBA,MaryEllen PAYMAR,Michael RUKAVINA,Tom RUTH,Connie SEIFERT,Marty SMITH,Steve SOLBERG,Loren SYKORA,Barb VANDEVEER,Ray WAGENIUS,Jean WALKER,Neva

WaysandMeans 04:44Gavel,anddiscussionof HF2480(Finstad)Baseball stadiumfinancing,construction, andoperationprovided MinnesotaBallparkAuthority establishedandHennepin Countysalestaxauthorized. Runs4hours,18minutes.

Membersexcused: ANDERSON,Irv MARIANI,Carlos OZMENT,Dennis

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84027&id=38

1/7

4/16/12

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

RepresentativeKnoblachbeganthemeetingat6:10p.m.Aquorumwasnotpresent. HF2480Finstad(thirdengrossment)Baseballstadiumfinancing,construction,and operationprovidedMinnesotaBallparkAuthorityestablishedcommunityownership optionprovidedandHennepinCountysalestaxauthorized. RepresentativeKnoblachrequestedthatRepresentativeFinstadbeginhistestimonyon HF2480,thirdengrossment. RepresentativeKnoblachcalledthemeetingofficiallytoorderat6:15p.m.Aquorumwas present. RepresentativeDornmovedthattheminutesofApril18,2006andApril19,2006be recommendedtopass.THEMOTIONPREVAILED. RepresentativeKnoblachmovedthatHF2480,thirdengrossmentberecommendedto passandbesenttotheGeneralRegister. RepresentativeFinstad,Dr.PaulWilson,DirectorofTaxResearch,Minnesota DepartmentofRevenue,MikeOpat,Commissioner,HennepinCounty,DaveSt.Peter, President,MinnesotaTwins,RalphStrangs,Attorney,MinnesotaTwins,JerryBell, President,TwinsSports,Inc.,GenerRenen,Director,InterGovernmentRelations,cityof Minneapolis,DaveLawos,Director,budget&finance,HennepinCounty,TomGoldston, Citizen,PatDalton,HouseResearch,andStephenRosholt,HennepinCounty,testified onHF2480,thirdengrossment. RepresentativeKrinkiemovedthattheKnoblachmotiontosendHF2480totheGeneral Register,beamendedtosendthebilltothecommitteeonrulesandLegislative Administration.OnavoicevoteTHEMOTIONDIDNOTPREVAIL. RepresentativeKnoblachmovedtheH2480A87amendment. RepresentativeKnoblachmovedtoorallyamendtheH2480A87amendmentby: P.1,L.2,afterPageinsert4,afterline,insert21 L.1.10afterPage,insert13,L.28 P.2,L.2.11,change,notonor P2,L.2.19,afterPage,insert,P.14L.7,changetotoand P.2,L2.20,afterPage,insert,15,L.5,delete,6and THEORALAMENDMENTWASINCORPORATED. RepresentativeKelliherorallymovedtostrikeL2.19andL.2.20.THEORAL AMENDMENTWASWITHDRAWN. RepresentativeAbramsmovedtoorallyamendtheH2480A7amendmentby: P.2,L.2.19,after3,deleteto,insert,and P.2.,L.2.20,,delete6andTHEORALAMENDMENTWASADOPTED. RepresentativeAbramsassumedthegavelat7:47. RepresentativeKnoblachassumedthegavelat7:51 RepresentativeKnoblachmovedtoorallyamendtheH2480amendmentby: P.1,Line1.8,deleteandcitycounty L.1.16aftertoadd,and,changeestablishtoestablishes RepresentativeKnoblachmovedtowithdrawtheH2480A87amendment.THE AMENDMENTWASWITHDRAWN. RepresentativeKrinkiemovedtheH2480A83amendment. RepresentativeKrinkiemovedtoorallyamendtheH2480A83amendmentby: P.1,L.1.2,afterPage,insert,12,afterline,insert,20 P.1,L.1.4afterPage,insert,12,afterline,insert,22 Onavoicevote,THEORALAMENDMENTWASINCORPORATED. RepresentativeKrinkierequestedarollcallvote.Theresultswereasfollows. AYES NAYS ABSENT

KNOBLACH,Jim ABRAMS,Ron BESGUENS,Mark

DEMPSEY,Jerry

ANDERSON,Irv

ABELER,Jim

MARIANI,Carlos OZMENT,Dennis SEIFERT,Marty

BEARD,Mike BRADLEY,Fran

CARLSON,Lyndon CLARK,Karen ERHARDT,Ron GREILING,Mindy

DORMAN,Dan DORN,John GUNTHER,Bob

SMITH,Steve

HOLBERG,MaryLiz KLINZING,Karen KRINKIE,Phil LARSON,Dan

HAMILTON,Rod HUNTLEY,Thomas ABSTAIN

KELLIHER,Margaret McNAMARA,Denny

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84027&id=38

2/7

4/16/12
PAYMAR,Michael

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

NORNES,Bud HILTY,Bill

VANDAVEER,Ray WAGENIUS,Jean WALKER,Neva

OTREMBA,MaryEllen RUKAVINA,Tom

RUTH,Connie SOLBERG,Loren SYKORA,Barb

Onavoteof15AYESand17NAYSTHEAMENDMENTWASNOTADOPTED RepresentativeVandaveermovedtheH2480A84amendment. RepresentativeVandaveermovedtoorallyamendtheH2480A84amendmentby: P.1,L.1.2,afterPage,insert6afterline,insert,3 P.1,L.1.6,afterPageinsert,6afterline,insert,4 THEORALAMENDMENTTOTHEAMENDMENTWASINCORPORATED. RepresentativeSolbergmovedtoorallyamendtheH2480A84amendmentby: P.1,L.1.4,change,threetoone,change,yearstoyear THEORALAMENDMENTTOTHEAMENDMENTWASNOTADOPTED. RepresentativeClarkmovedtoorallyamendtheH2480A84amendmentby: P.1,L.1.3,afterofficial,insertortheirstaff THEORALAMENDMENTTOTHEAMENDMENTWASNOTADOPTED. RepresentativeVandaveermovedtoorallyamendtheH2480A84amendmentby: P.1,L.,1.4strike,three,insert,two THEORALAMENDMENTTOTHEAMENDMENTWASINCORPORATED. RepresentativeVandaveermovedthattheH2480A84amendment,asamended,be adopted.Adivisionwascalledforandonavoteof10AYESand21NAYS.THE AMENDMENTWASNOTADOPTED. RepresentativeKnoblachmovedtheH2480A88amendment. RepresentativeErhardtmovedtodividetheH2480A88amendmentby 1stpart,P.1,L.1.1andL.1.2, 2ndpart,P.1,L.1.3thrul.1.5 RepresentativeErhardtmovedthefirstpartoftheH2480A88amendment,L.1.1andL. 1.2,THEFIRSTPARTOFTHEH2480A2AMENDMENTWASNOTADOPTED. RepresentativeDormanrequestedarollcallonthesecondpartoftheH2480A88 amendment,P.,1,L.1.3thrul.1.5.Theresultswereasfollows: AYES NAYS ABSENT

KNOBLACH,Jim ABRAMS,Ron BRADLEY,Fran ERHARDT,Ron

DEMPSEY,Jerry

ANDERSON,Irv

ABELER,Jim BEARD,Mike BESGUENS,Mark

MIRIANI,Carlos

OZMENT,Dennis

HUNTLEY,Thomas KRINKIE,Phil SMITH,Steve SYKORA,Barb

CARLSON,Lyndon

CLARK,Karen DORMAN,Dan

DORN,John GREILING,Mindy

VANDAVEER,Ray

GUNTHER,Bob HAMILTON,Rod HILTY,Bill HOLBERG,MaryLiz KELLIHER,Margaret KLINZING,Karen LARSON,Dan McNAMARA,Denny NORNES,Bud

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84027&id=38

3/7

4/16/12

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

OTREMBA,MaryEllen PAYMAR,Michael RUKAVINA,Tom RUTH,Connie SEIFERT,Marty SOLBERG,Loren WAGENIUS,Jean WALKER,Neva

Onavoteof9AYESand26NAYSTHEAMENDMENTWASNOTADOPTED. RepresentativeCarlsonmovedtheHAD704amendment. RepresentativeCarlsonmovedtoorallyamendtheHAD704amendmentby: L.,1.2,change2to4. Adivisionwasrequestedandonavoteof17AYESto15NAYSTHEAMENDMENT,AS AMENDED,WASADOPTED. RepresentativeKnoblachmovedtoorallyamendHF2480,thirdengrossmentby: P.15,L.14.16,change13to14THEORALAMENDMENTWASADOPTED. RepresentativePaymarmovedtheH2480A93amendment. RepresentativeKrinkierequestedarollcallvote.Theresultswereasfollows AYES NAYS ABSENT

CARLSON,Lyndon DORMAN,Dan DORN,John HILTY,Bill

KNOBLACH,Jim

ANDERSON,Irv

DEMPSEY,Jerry

MARIANI,Carlos OZMENT,Dennis

ABELER,Jim ABRAMS,Ron

KELLIHER,Margaret KRINKIE,Phil LARSON,Dan

BEARD,Mike BRADLEY,Fran BUESGENS,Mark CLARK,Karen ERHARDT,Ron GREILING,Mindy

OTREMBA,MaryEllen PAYMAR,Michael RUKAVINA,Tom WALKER,Neva HAMILTON,Rod HOLBERG,MaryLiz

GUNTHER,Bob

HUNTLEY,Thomas

KLINZING,Karen McNAMARA,Denny NORNES,Bud RUTH,Connie SEIFERT,Marty SMITH,Steve SOLBERG,Loren SYKORA,Barb VANDEVEER,Ray WAGENIUS,Jean

Onavoteof11AYESand24NAYSTHEAMENDMENTWASNOTADOPTED.

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84027&id=38

4/7

4/16/12

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

RepresentativeKellihermovedtheAH2480PD18amendment, RepresentativeAbramsmovedtoorallyamendtheAH2480PD18amendmentby: P.1,L.1.2,delete,section14andinsert,andinsert,deleteL.19.1thru19.3.,L.19.4, deletethejurisdiction P.1,L.,1.8,delete,everythingaftertheperiodthruline1.10 Adivisionwasrequestedandonavoteof19AYESand15NAYSTHEORAL AMENDMENTTOTHEAMENDMENTWASADOPTED.

RepresentativeKellihermovedthattheAH2480PD18amendment,asamended,be adopted.THEAMENDMENTWASADOPTED. RepresentativeKrinkiemovedtoreconsidertheH2460A83amendmentandrequesteda rollcallvote.Theresultswereasfollows: AYES NAYS ABSENT

KNOBLACH,Jim ABRAMS,Ron BESGUENS,Mark

DEMPSEY,Jerry

ANDERSON,Irv

ABELER,Jim

MARIANI,Carlos OZMENT,Dennis SMITH,Steve

BEARD,Mike BRADLEY,Fran

CARLSON,Lyndon CLARK,Karen ERHARDT,Ron GREILING,Mindy

DORMAN,Dan DORN,John GUNTHER,Bob HAMILTON,Rod HILTY,Bill

HOLBERG,MaryLiz KLINZING,Karen KRINKIE,Phil LARSON,Dan PAYMAR,Michael SEIFERT,Marty

HUNTLEY,Thomas KELLIHER,Margaret McNAMARA,Denny NORNES,Bud OTREMBA,MaryEllen RUKAVINA,Tom

VANDAVEER,Ray WAGENIUS,Jean WALKER,Neva

RUTH,Connie SOLBERG,Loren SYKORA,Barb

Onavoteof16AYESand18NAYSTHEMOTIONDIDNOTPREVAIL. RepresentativeDormanmovedthereconsiderationoftheadoptionoftheAH2480PD18 amendment,asamended.THEMOTIONWASWITHDRAWN. RepresentativeAbramsmovedthereconsiderationoftheadoptionoftheAH2480PD18 amendment,asamended.THEMOTIONPREVAILED. RepresentativeAbramswithdrewhisoralamendmenttotheAH2480PD18amendment. ArollcallwasrequestedbyRepresentativeDormanontheAH2480PD18amendmentas originallypresented. AYES NAYS ABSENT

ABELER,Jim BEARD,Mike

KNOBLACH,Jim

ABRAMS,Ron

BRADLEY,Fran

ANDERSON,Irv MARIANI,Carlos

CARLSON,Lyndon CLARK,Karen DORMAN,Dan DORN,John

BESGUENS,Mark

HOLBERG,MaryLiz KLINZING,Karen KRINKIE,Phil

OZMENT,Dennis SMITH,Steve

ERHARDT,Ron

SEIFERT,Marty

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84027&id=38

5/7

4/16/12
GREILING,Mindy GUNTHER,Bob HAMILTON,Rod HILTY,Bill

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

VANDAVEER,Ray ABSTAIN

DEMPSEY,Jerry

RUKAVINA,Tom

HUNTLEY,Thomas KELLIHER,Margaret LARSON,Dan McNAMARA,Denny NORNES,Bud OTREMBA,MaryEllen PAYMAR,Michael RUTH,Connie SOLBERG,Loren SYKORA,Barb WAGENIUS,Jean WALKER,Neva Onavoteof23AYESand8NAYSTHEAMENDMENTWASADOPTED. RepresentativeKellihermovedtheH2480A97amendment.THEAMENDMENTWAS ADOPTED. RepresentativeKnoblachmovedthatHF2840,asamended,berecommendedtopass. RepresentativeKrinkierequestedarollcallvote.Theresultswereasfollows. AYES NAYS ABSENT

DEMPSEY,Jerry ABELER,Jim BEARD,Mike BRADLEY,Fran DORMAN,Dan DORN,John

KNOBLACH,Jim ABRAMS,Ron

ANDERSON,Irv

MARIANI,Carlos OZMENT,Dennis

BUESGENS,Mark

CARLSON,Lyndon CLARK,Karen ERHARDT,Ron

GOP Yes: 12 GOP No: 9 DFL Yes: 6 DFL No: 7

GUNTHER,Bob HAMILTON,Rod HILTY,Bill

GREILING,Mindy

ABSTAIN

HOLBERG,MaryLiz OTREMBA,MaryEllen

KLINZING,Karen KRINKIE,Phil

HUNTLEY,Thomas KELLIHER,Margaret McNAMARA,Denny NORNES,Bud RUKAVINA,Tom RUTH,Connie SMITH,Steve SOLBERG,Loren SYKORA,Barb

LARSON,Dan PAYMAR,Michael

SEIFERT,Marty VANDAVER,Ray

WAGENIUS,Jean WALKER,Neva

Onavoteof18AYESand16NAYSTHEMOTIONPREVAILED. Themeetingwasadjournedat10:27p.m.

____________________________________________ JimKnoblach,Chair

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84027&id=38

6/7

4/16/12

Committee Meeting Minutes Minnesota House of Representatives

____________________________________________ ShirleyKoderick,CommitteeLegislativeAssistant

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/comm/minutes1.asp?comm=84027&id=38

7/7

4/16/12

Roll Call on H.F. NO. 2480 CALENDAR FOR THE DAY Passage, as amended Minnesota House of

*UnofficialRecordedRollCallFloorVote
H.F.NO.2480 CALENDARFORTHEDAY Passage,asamended 76YEAand55Nay Date:4/26/2006 JournalPage7142*PleaseseetheJournaloftheHouseforofficialrecordedrollcallvotes. Thosewhovotedintheaffirmativewere: Abeler Anderson,I. Bradley Brod Davids Demmer Dorn Eastlund Fritz Garofalo Haws Heidgerken Hosch Huntley Koenen Lanning Magnus Marquart Murphy Nelson,M. Pelowski Penas Rukavina Ruth Sertich Severson Slawik Solberg Thissen Tingelstad Westerberg Thosewhovotedinthenegativewere: Abrams Clark Ellison Greiling Holberg Johnson,S. Krinkie Loeffler Paulsen Ruud Wagenius Anderson,B. Cornish Emmer Hackbarth Hornstein Kahn Larson Mullery Paymar Seifert Walker Bernardy Davnie Erhardt Hansen Howes Klinzing Latz Newman Peppin Smith Westrom Buesgens Dean Erickson Hausman Jaros Knoblach Lenczewski Olson Peterson,S. Soderstrom Wilkin Carlson DeLaForest Goodwin Hilty Johnson,J. Kohls Liebling Otremba Powell Vandeveer Zellers Atkins Charron Dempsey Eken Gazelka Hilstrom Johnson,R. Lesch McNamara Nelson,P. Peterson,A. Sailer Sieben Sviggum Urdahl Beard Cox Dill Entenza Gunther Hoppe Juhnke Lieder Meslow Nornes Peterson,N. Samuelson Simon Sykora Wardlow Blaine Cybart Dorman Finstad Hamilton Hortman Kelliher Lillie Moe Ozment Poppe Scalze Simpson Thao Welti

GOP Yes: 38 GOP No: 29 DFL Yes: 38 DFL No: 26 Simon, Scalze Yes on Twins, No on Vikings (4/16/12)

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/votes/votes.asp?ls_year=84&session_number=0&year=2005&id=658

1/2

4/16/12

Roll Call on H.F. NO. 2480 CALENDAR FOR THE DAY Passage, as amended Minnesota House of

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/votes/votes.asp?ls_year=84&session_number=0&year=2005&id=658

2/2

4/16/12

Roll Call on H.F. NO. 2480 CONFERENCE COMMITTEE REPORT Repassage, as amended by Conf

*UnofficialRecordedRollCallFloorVote
H.F.NO.2480 CONFERENCECOMMITTEEREPORT Repassage,asamendedbyConference 71YEAand61Nay Date:5/20/2006 JournalPage8192*PleaseseetheJournaloftheHouseforofficialrecordedrollcallvotes. Thosewhovotedintheaffirmativewere: Atkins Beard Charron Cox Dill Dorman Finstad Fritz Hamilton Haws Hortman Hosch Koenen Lanning Lieder Lillie McNamara Meslow Nornes Ozment Peterson,N. Poppe Scalze Sertich Simpson Slawik Thao Thissen Westerberg Thosewhovotedinthenegativewere: Abeler Carlson Dean Erhardt Hansen Howes Kahn Lenczewski Murphy Paymar Sailer Wagenius Zellers Abrams Clark DeLaForest Erickson Hausman Huntley Klinzing Liebling Newman Peppin Seifert Walker Anderson,B. Cornish Eken Goodwin Hilty Jaros Knoblach Loeffler Olson Peterson,S. Smith Welti Bernardy Cybart Ellison Greiling Holberg Johnson,J. Kohls Mariani Otremba Powell Soderstrom Westrom Buesgens Davnie Emmer Hackbarth Hornstein Johnson,S. Krinkie Mullery Paulsen Ruud Vandeveer Wilkin Blaine Davids Dorn Garofalo Heidgerken Johnson,R. Larson Magnus Moe Pelowski Rukavina Severson Solberg Tingelstad Bradley Demmer Eastlund Gazelka Hilstrom Juhnke Latz Mahoney Nelson,M. Penas Ruth Sieben Sviggum Urdahl Brod Dempsey Entenza Gunther Hoppe Kelliher Lesch Marquart Nelson,P. Peterson,A. Samuelson Simon Sykora Wardlow

GOP Yes: 38 DFL Yes: 33 GOP No: 31 DFL No: 30 Simon, Scalze Yes on Twins, No on Vikings (4/16/12)

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/votes/votes.asp?ls_year=84&session_number=0&year=2005&id=846

1/2

4/16/12

Roll Call on H.F. NO. 2480 CONFERENCE COMMITTEE REPORT Repassage, as amended by Conf

www.house.leg.state.mn.us/votes/votes.asp?ls_year=84&session_number=0&year=2005&id=846

2/2