Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
City of Melbourne, December 2007 PO Box 1603, Melbourne, Victoria 3001 Hotline 61 3 9658 9658 TTY 61 3 9658 9461 Email enquiries@melbourne.vic.gov.au Web www.melbourne.vic.gov.au This is a publication of the Melbourne City Council. The Energy Wise Hotel Toolkit is printed on Monza Satin Recycled. Monza has a high 55% recycled fibre content, including 30% pre-consumer and 25% post-consumer waste and FSC certified pulp. Monza Recycled is sourced from sustainable plantation wood and is Elemental Chlorine Free (ECF). Disclaimer statement The content that appears in this publication is provided for information purposes only. No claim is made as to the accuracy or authenticity of the content. Sustainability Victoria does not accept any liability to any person for the information or advice (or the use of such information or advice) which is provided in this publication or incorporated into it by reference. The information in the Sustainability Victoria publication is provided on the basis that all persons using the publication undertake responsibility for assessing the relevance and accuracy of its content. Sustainability Victoria does not accept any liability for loss or damages incurred as a result of reliance placed upon the content of this publication.
Introduction
The hotel industry is one of the fastest growing industries in the world due to increased tourism and market globalisation. At the same time hotels are providing more facilities and services to customers, leading to increased energy consumption. As the cost of energy in Australia is increasing, and its use is shown to accelerate climate change, the hotel industry is becoming more aware of the impact of their business on the environment. Today most guests are aware of climate change due to the generation and consumption of energy. The Energy Wise Hotels Toolkit has been developed to assist accommodation service providers to reduce their energy consumption. The toolkit also outlines energy consumption patterns in hotels and the impact this has on our environment. This toolkit provides comprehensive recommendations on energy reduction opportunities with technical explanations. Hotel management can use the toolkit to develop the action plans necessary to improve the energy efficiency of the hotel, without sacrificing the comfort of guests. This not only makes the hotel business more profitable but presents a favourable image of hotels that can be marketed.
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank the following organisations for their help and information: Enman Pty Ltd www.enman.com.au EEO, Department of Industry, Tourism and Resources www.energyefficiencyopportunities.gov.au Crowne Plaza, Melbourne www.crowneplaza.com.au Grand Hyatt, Melbourne www.grandhyatt.com.au Hotel Ibis, Melbourne www.hotelibis.com.au Jasper Hotel www.jasperhotel.com.au Saville City Suites, East Melbourne www.savillehotelgroup.com Saville on Russell, Melbourne www.savillehotelgroup.com Melbourne Marriott www.marriott.com.au Sofitel Grand Hotel, Melbourne www.sofitel.com.au Sebel Melbourne www.mirvachotels.com.au Hilton on the Park, Melbourne www.hiltonhotels.com.au This Energy Wise Hotels Toolkit was researched and produced by Enman Pty Ltd.
Before energy use can be reduced in a hotel, motel, serviced apartment or hostel, it is necessary to understand where energy is being consumed. It is also helpful to compare your hotels energy consumption to other similar hotels.
7% Pump 7% Kitchen 10% Electric heating 10% AHU, FCU and ventilation fan 10% Laundry 10% Lighting 3% Refrigeration 13% Space heating 14% Domestic & pool water heating 15% Chiller 1% Miscellaneous
Most of these uses are serviced by electricity (See Figure 2.2), with gas primarily used for hot water and heating (see Figure 2.3).
Figure 2.2: Typical electricity consumption
5.6% Refrigeration 12.0% Pump 18.7% Lighting 17.6% AHU, FCU and ventilation fan 17.2% Electric heating 26.6% Chiller 2.3% Miscellaneous
Energy Wise Hotel TOOLKIT 09
22% Laundry
16% kitchen
Energy use (GJ/m2.year) < 0.95 0.95 - 1.09 1.09 - 1.24 1.24 - 1.38 > 1.38
Note: Benchmark figures are based on surveys conducted on hotels in various regions, and buildings of similar nature by Benchmark Hotel, EEO (Energy Efficiency Office) and IHG Hotels operating results.
To achieve energy savings it is important to monitor and track energy consumption, and generate reports on a regular basis. Such a system forms the basis of any ongoing and sustainable energy management program.
There are standard software packages available to monitor and track energy and greenhouse gas emissions. However, hotels and hotel groups can easily create their own simple database. Some of the key features required for tracking energy efficiency are: comparison of energy consumption and key performance indicators; bar graphs of energy use and performance index for 12 months over the past few years as shown in Figure 3.1 and Figure 3.2; and comparison of actual energy use against target consumption (Figure 3.3). The target can be generated according to seasonally adjusted monthly energy use.
Figure 3.1: Bar graph of electricity consumption over three years
120
Electricity Consumptions (MWh/year)
100 80 60 40 20 0
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
2004
2005
2006
Figure 3.2: Bar graph of natural gas consumption over three years
120 100
Gas Consumptions (GJ/year)
80 60 40 20 0
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
2004
2005
2006
120
Electricity Consumptions (MWh/year)
100 80 60 40 20 0
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
Actual
Target
Taking Action
In order to implement successful energy saving you must have a well structured and realistic plan with management support.
The following sections outline each stage of the framework in more detail.
Understanding energy
Note: The power factor (Pf) of electric motors is designed at around 0.8 to 0.9. The Pf decreases as motor load decreases.
2. Single-phase electricity Employs a single circuit of electricity current. kW = Volts x Amps x Pf Example 1: 1 kW motor (full load) operates for 16 hrs/day, 300 days/year Power = 1 kW Energy = 1 x 16 hrs/day x 300 days /year = 4,800 kWh/year
Energy Wise Hotel TOOLKIT 15
Typical cost Energy Peak Off-peak Network Network peak Network off-peak Network standing charge Demand Other E&REC MRET NEMCO ancillary charge NEMCO pool fees Meter provision Retail service fee $6/ kW-month 0.1 c/kWh 0.07 c/kWh 0.05 c/kWh $900 pa 6 c/kWh 3 c/kWh 2.5 c/kWh 0.8 c/kWh
Energy savings equal financial savings. Hotels can deliver a range of energy saving initiatives grouped as either:
Initiatives that require little or no capital. These are the energy management initiatives to consider first in your energy management plan as they require little or no finance and are simple to do. Initiatives that require capital investment. These should be considered based on individual merit. These opportunities are outlined in more detail in the following sections.
Lights
Turn off lights when not required. Lights in common areas are under staff control; therefore staff should turn off lights in common areas when not in use. This can be achieved by conducting a staff awareness program. Dim reception and foyer lights from late night to early morning when there is minimal activity. This can be achieved whilst still maintaining guest safety and comfort. Lights in guest rooms are under guest control. Encourage guests to turn off lights through energy and climate change promotional stickers. Invite guests to join the efforts of the hotel to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and inform them of some of the hotels initiatives. This will encourage guests to reduce their own energy use.
Air conditioning
Similar to lighting, the air conditioning can be turned off when its use is not necessary. Increasing the room temperature during cooling provides energy savings of around five to 10 per cent of the cooling load. It is recommended the cooling temperature is set to 24C.
Energy Wise Hotel TOOLKIT 17
Heating
Decreasing the room temperature during the cooler months can lower the heating load by five to 10 per cent. It is recommended the heating temperature is set at 18C.
Kitchen
Turn off the exhaust fans in the kitchen when not required. Reduce the speed of fans during times of low kitchen activity by using a variable speed drive. Installing a variable speed drive is a wise financial investment, as the reductions in energy bills quickly repay the initial investment.
Hot water
Set hot water temperature to as low as possible. The recommended hot water temperature is around 60C.
Office equipment
Turn off office equipment such as computers, computer screens and printers when not in use, especially after hours. Explain the benefits to staff so they participate in reducing the energy needs from office equipment. Always enable energy star features on office equipment to give it the ability to power down or sleep when they are not being used and wake up when they are needed. For more information refer to the Australian Department of Environment Green Office Guide 2001.
Motors and chillers purchase higher energy efficiency equipment. It is worth paying more for an energy efficient motor (likely to be an increased cost of around 10 to 20 per cent) with an efficiency of between two and four per cent. Over the likely 20-year life of the equipment, the capital outlay is small compared to the cost of running it as shown in Figure 6.1 below.
Figure 6.1: Life Cycle Costs of a 55 kW Motor
Lighting buy compact fluorescent lamps instead of incandescent, this can achieve energy saving of around 75 per cent. Refrigeration the energy efficiency of refrigerators varies by 50 per cent even if they meet new stringent minimum energy performance standards (MEPS) introduced in 2005. When purchasing a new refrigerator consider high energy star ratings over cheaper, low star refrigerators as these models will offer greater cost savings.
Regular checking of the damper control many of the air handling units found in hotels have an economy cycle. This allows the fresh air and relief air dampers to open or close depending on ambient weather conditions. The economy cycle can reduce the cooling load by up to 30 per cent. It has been observed previously in other hotels that dampers are often faulty or frozen which causes the system to operate inefficiently.
Cooling towers
New types of cooling towers with condensers are emerging. These are mixed wet and dry types which are more water and energy efficient. These condensing cooling towers operate as air-cooled systems in winter and water-cooled systems in summer. Regular checking of cooling tower performance it is sometimes found that cooling tower capacity reduces due to: unequal water distribution; water not wetting the cooling tower pack; or the spay nozzles not spraying efficiently. As a result, the cooling capacity is reduced along with the energy efficiency of supplied chillers.
Motors
Rewinding motors motors are used for pumps, fans, chillers and a large amount of other equipment. As they fail they are normally rewound. Rewinding a motor is cheaper than purchasing a new motor; however each time a motor is rewound its energy efficiency is reduced. The efficiency of rewound motors drops due to the intense heat applied in the stripping of old windings and from using cheaper, thinner gauge wire. Rewinds are normally priced at between 60 and 80 per cent of the price of a standard new motor. On average, the efficiency of a motor decreases by about one per cent each time the motor is rewound. Supply voltage when the three-phase voltages are not equal, the motor losses increase substantially. This is normally due to unequal distribution of the single-phase loads, such as lighting. A modest phase imbalance of two per cent can increase motor losses by 25 per cent or overall motor efficiency by around 1.6 per cent. When operating at less than 95 per cent of design voltage, motors typically lose efficiency by two to four per cent. Supply voltage over and under the rated voltage can also significantly reduce energy efficiency.
Chiller system chillers are another large energy consumer in the hotel industry. Chiller efficiency can be improved by measures outlined below. Use energy efficient chillers: if chillers are old, replace them with a water-cooled turbo compressor fitted with a VSD. This can improve energy efficiency by up to 400 per cent. Use a different size or capacity of chiller: a smaller capacity chiller should be used in low load conditions and a larger chiller for high load conditions. Operating a chiller at part-load conditions reduces the efficiency of a conventional fixed speed chiller. Electronic expansion valve (for reciprocating compressors): if the expansion valve is electromechanical, replace it with modern electronic valve. This can improve efficiency by around 15 per cent. Use a chiller with remote set point control facility. It is common practice to design the cooling tower with minimum capacity. Increasing the cooling tower capacity can increase chiller efficiency. Therefore, provide adequate cooling capacity for cooling tower. Use a common cooling tower for all chillers with common header and discharge this not only provides the opportunity to save energy but also provides greater reliability of the chiller system. Use variable speed drives for the following areas: - secondary chilled water pump; - primary chilled water pump; - condenser water pump; and - cooling tower fans VSD for a cooling tower fan not only reduces fan energy but also can improve energy efficiency of the chiller compressor. Tune control system to avoid simultaneous heating and cooling. Insulate ducts and chilled water pipes to prevent heat gain. Energy efficient comfort condition of HVAC system the comfort level of air conditioned spaces depends on the following variables: - gender; - activity; - relative humidity and dry bulb temperature; and - air movement. Refer to section 9.2.2 for more information on air conditioning comfort
Glazing and shading glass windows are one of the major contributors to air conditioning load. Appropriate measures must be taken to ensure hotel windows are efficient. Some energy saving measures that can be implemented are: window glazing a double-glazed window will not only reduce the cooling and heating load of the building but also reduces noise levels in the building; use of energy efficient glass that allows less heat to transfer through the glass; use of tinted glass to reduce solar absorption this not only reduces energy consumption but also improves comfort conditions in the hotel. It is especially effective for windows facing north and west. Building insulation building insulation also helps reduce the heating and cooling load of a hotel. The following forms of insulation will be of assistance: roof and wall insulation; roof paint use light or white colour, or specialised solar coating to deflect solar radiation; building shading planting of trees around the sunny side of the building to provide shade for lower levels of the building.
Dichroic lamps: replace dichroic lamps either with compact fluorescent or LED lamps. A 50W dichroic lamp can be replaced by a 7W compact fluorescent or 2W LED. The same fittings can be used for the new lamps, decreasing the installation costs. A 2W LED lamp has a little less light output than a 50W dichroic lamp. Fluorescent lamps: replace 36 W standard fluorescent lamps with 36W energy efficient triphosphor tubes. The triphosphor tube provides around 30 per cent greater light output than the 36W tube. The most efficient fluorescent lamps are T5 lamps. These lamps require new electronic ballasts with a dimming option. They are economically viable when a complete lighting refurbishment is undertaken. High bay lamps: replace mercury vapour lamps by pulse-type metal halide or sodium lamps. Low pressure sodium lamps have an orange colour light output and may not be suitable for some applications. Lighting level: over lighting wastes energy. It is important to measure the lux level of areas and minimise these levels where necessary in order to meet Australian Standards for the activities undertaken. If an area is over lit, de-lamping or dimming may be considered to reduce lighting levels. Australian Standards for lighting levels for different areas are shown in Table 9.3. Lighting control - Use energy saving voltage control for fluorescent lamps. - Use timer control for areas which have set occupancy times. - Use of motion detectors when lighting is not required continuously in areas such as conference rooms. - Use lux controllers in areas that receive ambient daylight through windows. These controllers can turn lamps off and on, or dim them depending on the ambient daylight. This type of control is also called daylight compensation control. Refer to section 9.1 for more information about how much you can save with energy efficient lighting.
3. Guest motivation
Hotel guests can also be motivated to reduce energy use through displays and stickers on energy and climate change and the commitment of the hotel to be green.
Renewable energy
Renewable energy does not produce any greenhouse gas emissions. Renewable energy is energy produced from sources that are considered infinite (will not run out) and are essentially non-polluting. The common renewable energy sources are:
solar power using technologies that convert sunlight into electricity or mechanical power such as photovoltaic cells or solar hot water systems; wind power converting wind energy into more useful forms, such as electricity, using wind turbines; hydro power using the force or energy of moving water in such systems as hydroelectric schemes, tidal power, and wave power; geothermal power generating energy from the heat stored beneath the Earth's surface; and combined heat and power using an engine to simultaneously generate both electricity and useful heat. The Renewable Energy Act 2001 requires a minimum amount of renewable energy to be sold by each electricity retailer within Australia. There is a government rebate available on photovoltaic solar power generation.
Technology discussion
There are four primary energy technologies that hotels need to understand and manage efficiently. These are discussed in more detail in this section:
1. lighting; 2. heating, ventilation and air-conditioning systems; 3. variable speed drives; and 4. energy management systems (EMS).
Advantages:
excellent colour rendering; instant start; lamp life 2000 to 5000 hours; higher lumens than incandescent type; excellent lumens maintenance; and can be dimmed.
Disadvantages:
power loss in transformers create heat loss (50W lamps require transformer of 12W loss). The 12W power used by transformers only transforms electricity to heat in the space; ultraviolet content of light can fade some surfaces; voltage fluctuation can reduce lamp life. A slight increase in main voltage supply can reduce lamp life by 50 per cent; lamp cost is greater than incandescent; and touching of the quartz lamp may lead to premature lamp failure.
Advantages:
they are cheapest of all lamps; and dimmable.
Disadvantages:
they are the most inefficient lamps; and the life of the lamps is very short between 1000 to 2000 hours. The efficiency of these lamps varies from eight to 17 lm/W compared to 85 lm/W for fluorescent lamps with a lifespan of 10,000 hours. Due to its inefficiency these lamps are in the process of being phased out of the market by government regulation. It is worthwhile reorganising your lighting to provide for this inevitable regulatory requirement.
Technology discussion
Advantages:
the anticipated life is 30,000 to 50,000 hours; and a 2W LED lamp can be considered to replace 50W dichroic lamps without change of light fittings.
Disadvantages:
energy efficient LEDs are expensive; and require constant voltage transformer. This technology is expected to increase in popularity and usage in the near future.
Area Office work Store rooms and stock rooms Kitchen Entrance areas and waiting rooms Corridors Toilets
Technology discussion
9.2.1 Heating
Heating can be provided by three different means: Hot water (or steam) system the lowest energy cost system if natural gas is available and the most common heating system in older hotels. Electric heating elements the most energy inefficient and high energy cost system. Many hotels use electric heating systems which were historically installed as a convenient low capital cost system. Heat pumps relatively new technology that is energy efficient. The energy cost is similar to or slightly higher than gas-heated hot water systems. Considering maintenance and auxiliary equipment, heat pumps are one of the most overall cost-effective systems.
9.2.2 Cooling
There are different types of air conditioning systems. Each type of system has its own advantages and disadvantages. Therefore they are selected based on their application, capital cost and energy performance. However, in the past very little consideration was given to energy efficiency. Capital cost is normally the dominant factor in selecting and designing air conditioning systems. The most common types of air conditioning systems are: single zone systems; reheat systems; multi-zone systems; dual duct systems; induction systems; variable air volume systems; water source heat pump systems; and air cooled heat pumps. The cooling can be provided by: Refrigeration system: this is the cooling media and requires a compressor for mechanical compression or an absorber for an absorption-type cooling system. Electrical energy is being used for a compression-type system and thermal energy as heat is required for an absorption system. Evaporative cooling: this is a low energy intensive cooling system ideally suitable in dry weather condition. It cools air by humidifying air and does not need any refrigerant. Although it is around 80 per cent more energy efficient than a refrigerated cooling system, it does not provide comfort levels as easily as a refrigeration system and can be noisy and inconvenient. Some HVAC systems do not have cooling towers. The condenser cooling is done by blowing air over the condenser tubes. These are called air-cooled systems.
Energy Wise Hotel TOOLKIT 35
CONDENSER
COMPR E SSOR
AIR F ILTERS
INSUL A TED RE TURN A IR DUC TING AIR OUTLETS CONDI TONED SPACE
Figure 9.2 is a typical guest room air conditioning system. This is a four pipe system, with two pipes for chilled water and two pipes for hot water (the hot water piping is not shown). Chilled water is circulated by chilled water pumps and hot water is circulated by hot water pumps. In some hotels the guests rooms are heated by electric heating elements replacing the hot water coils in the fan cool unit. Economy cycle Economy cycle reduces energy costs. The energy saving can be in the order of 25 to 30 per cent in Melbournes climate. Since an economy cycle brings in more fresh air, the system may require slightly more cleaning of air filters. The cost of an economy cycle can be as low as $3000 plus additional costs for duct modification, if required. For more information about an economy cycle refer to Appendix E.
Technology discussion
Economiser It is possible to cool the fresh air by exhaust air with an air-to-air heat exchanger. Types of heat exchangers are: rotary heat exchange wheel; plate heat exchanger; and heat pipe system. Expected energy savings from this system are between three and 15 per cent. The higher the amount of fresh air used in the HVAC system, and the more extreme the weather conditions, the higher the energy savings will be.
Figure 9.3 - Typical economiser Return Air 22 C
Fresh Air 30 C
Spill Air 27 C
Fresh Air 25 C
Size (kWr) 7 26 32
COP is the ratio of power output to input and is the efficiency of the refrigeration cycle. Higher the COP more energy efficient it is.
20
Dew Point Temperature,C
0.012
Humidity Ratio
15
10 5 0 -5 -10
38
13
16
18
21
24
27
29
32
35
Operative Temperature,C
Technology discussion
120 100
Damper control
Fan Power %
80 60
Speed control
40 20 0
0 20 40 60
Volume flow rate %
80
100
120
Variable speed drives are one of the biggest and most economically viable energy saving opportunities in HVAC systems for supply and return air fans, chilled and condenser water pumps and chiller compressors.
Figure 9.6 - Power VS fan speed of a typical AHU fan
8 7 6
Power (kw)
5 4
Power Factor
3 2 1 0
50 45 40 35 30
Speed (Hz)
0.2 0.1 0
25 20 15
14 12 10 08
Power (kw)
06 04 02 0
50 45 40 35
Speed (Hz)
30
25
20
70 60 50 40
Power (kw)
30 20 10 0
50 45 40 35
Speed (Hz)
30
25
20
Technology discussion
Optimal pump control. Optimal pump control is useful when multiple pumps are used for chilled water, hot water or domestic water supply to the hotel. It involves installing a VSD on one of the pumps and selecting the number of pumps to operate, therefore controlling the supply pressure. Energy savings of 20 to 40 per cent are achievable through this technique. Hot water boiler - optimal start/stop of boiler. Demand management system - demand and energy monitoring; - demand control; and - energy sub-metering.
A corporate policy should be set to meet corporate goals and standards. An example of a corporate policy is set out below.
Energy is one of our organisations major ongoing costs. Its impact on climate change is a great concern to us. As a good corporate citizen we as a company set the following policies: 1. Reduce energy consumption of each hotel by 10 per cent per year for the next three years. 2. Energy efficiency should be considered in purchasing and maintaining all equipment. It is the responsibility of each individual employee to use energy wisely and efficiently.
Increased used of fossil fuels The increase in greenhouse gases within the atmosphere traps more heat, and raises the Earths surface temperature.
2. Global warming
Some of the effects of global warming are: a rise in sea level causing coastal damage; an increase in the likelihood of extreme weather conditions such as droughts, floods and cyclones; health impacts because of the spread of tropical-borne diseases, the increase of flooding and other such climate changes; damage to ecosystems and species diversity; and damage to agricultural output and food supply, and an increase in the earths surface temperature causing heat stress and other damage.
kg CO2-e/GJ kg CO2-e/GJ
100 80 60 40 20 0
Petrol Diesel Fuel Oil LPG
For more information about the measurement of greenhouse gases refer to the AGO Factors and Methods Workbook. Global warming potential (GWP) 1. Carbon dioxide CO2 2. Methane CH4 3. Nitrous oxide N2O 4. Hydro fluorocarbons (HFCs) 5. Per fluorocarbons (PFCs) 6. Sulphur hexafluoride GWP = 1 GWP = 21 GWP = 310 GWP = 140 - 11,700 GWP = 65,000 9,200 GWP = 23,900
kVAR
kVA 1
The causes of reactive power are inductive devices such as AC motors, induction furnaces, arc welders, fluorescent and mercury vapour lighting. These cause a time lag between current and voltage cycles which causes large reactive currents.
A typical luminaries or fixture for fluorescent lamps is shown in the figure below. This consists of:
housing; reflector; lamps; ballast; and shielding.
Figure D.1 - Typical luminare of a fluorescent lamp
The type of reflector, lamps and shielding can all contribute to light efficiency. In a fluorescent lamp there is no filament as in incandescent lamps. Instead, cathodes at each end send currents through mercury vapour sealed in the tube. Ultraviolet radiation is produced as electrons from the cathodes knock mercury electrons. The tubes are lined with phosphor to turn the radiation to visible light. This requires ballasts which are in every fixture and regulate the voltage during start up. The light output of these lamps varies from 69 to 104 Lumens/W. TL5 is the latest fluorescent lamp technology and with electronic ballasts produces 3300 lumens with 33W. There are two types of ballasts: electromechanical the standard ballast loss is around 10W; and electronic which can be fixed or dimmable ballasts. The electronic ballasts losses are generally less than 2W.
When the ambient air enthalpy is less than that for return air it is economical to introduce as much fresh air as possible to cool the building. However, this is restricted by the return air duct filter.
Therefore a motorised damper is required to regulate the fresh air make-up. An increased supply of fresh air is more hygienic and comfortable. The economy cycle of an air conditioner reduces energy costs. The energy saving can be in the order of 25 to 30 per cent in the Melbourne climate. Since the economy cycle brings in more fresh air, the system may require slightly more cleaning of air filters. The cost of an economy cycle can be as low as $3000 plus additional costs for duct modification, if required.
Figure E.1: Economy cycle
There are two types of economy cycle which are: temperature-based; and enthalpy-based. The enthalpy-based economy cycle provides better control with higher precision and provide more energy saving. This requires an energy management system.