Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Fifth Edition April 2010 March 2011 Updated 3-15-2011 See Major Revisions History on last page
Case Report Forms, Instructions and Examples are found at www.americanboardortho.com This Guide is a reproduction of the clinical examination webpages on the ABO website. There are no hyperlinks in this Guide. Use the ABO website for hyperlink capability.
The American Board of Orthodontics 401 North Lindbergh Blvd. Suite 308 St. Louis, MO 63141 Telephone: 314.432.6130 FAX: 314.432.8170 Email: info@americanboardortho.com Website: www.americanboardortho.com
CLINICAL EXAMINATION
Any orthodontic question not covered on these web pages can be answered by the ABO Director of your constituent organization.
Examination Process
Pg-4 Pg-5 Pg-6 Exam Components Overview Explanation of the Board Case Oral Exam Types of Clinical Examinations and Requirements Which exam will I take? Initial Certification Examination Beginning Certification Examination Gateway Certification Examination Recertification Examinations Voluntary Recertification Examination Traditional Option I and II (limited) Testing Protocol What to Expect Exam Assignment and Day of Exam Completion and Non-Completion of Exam or Recertification Information Request and Appeal Process
(A11) Pg-28
Pg-33 Pg-34
Appendix of Exhibits
Referenced as in the clinical narrative
A-2
A-3
Options I and II Case Category Specifications for Option I Case Selection by DI for Option I
A-6 A-7
Option for One Case by Mail Case Report Preparation Class II Molar Relationships Construction of Mandibular Plane Supplies Needed for ONE Case Report Notebook
A-11
Records Record Requirements and Identification Dental Cast Guide Example Photo Collage Photo Mount Sheet Example 1 Cephalometric Tracing Reference Example 2 Cephalometric Tracing Example of Composite Tracings
EXAMINATION PROCESS
Exam Components Overview Explanation of the Board Case Oral Exam Types of Clinical Exams and Requirements Testing Protocol
2.
B.
2.
Pathways to Certification/Recertification
EXAMINATION PROCESS
Types of Clinical Examinations
Note: No case may be presented to the Board more than one time Initial Certification Exam Beginning Certification Exam Gateway Certification Exam Recertification Exams Voluntary Recertification Exam Traditional Option I and II (limited)
Of the six cases required, a minimum of three cases must be presented. All cases presented must have been entirely treated, from appliance placement through appliance removal, by the examinee under direct supervision of a clinical instructor in an ADA accredited orthodontic program. Active treatment ends when the same resident removes the appliances and places the patient in retention. In cases of multi-phased treatment, the final phase of full treatment (appliance placement to appliance removal) administered by a single resident is acceptable. A Confirmation of Residency Treated Cases (pdf) from the Program Director and/or Chairperson is required to assure that the cases presented meet these requirements. The balance of case requirements will be collected, either from residency within 24 months of graduation or from post-residency practice, within ten (10) and two (2) more attempts at completion of requirements. 2. Components of the Initial Certification Exam a. b. c. 3. Board Case Oral Examination (BCOE) Case Report Examination (CRE) Case Report Oral Examination (CROE)
The Case Report Examination component requires six (6) Case Reports consisting of a. three (3) cases with a DI of twenty (20) or greater, b. three (3) cases with a DI of ten (10) or greater. The six case presentation must contain: at least one (1) non-surgical case treated with four (4) quadrant extractions that demonstrates effective space closure (identified as Extraction Case). at least one (1) non-surgical case with bilateral end-to-end or greater Class II molar relationship present at the time of appliance placement. A unilateral full-step
Class II molar relationship is also acceptable. The final treatment result should exhibit a Class I molar and canine relationship (identified as Class II Case). no more than one (1) case treated with orthognathic surgery (identified as Surgical Case). Note that a surgical case is not required. Any surgical case needs interim (pre-surgical) records. Banking Process Of the six cases required, a minimum of three cases must be presented via personal appearance at the clinical examination. Of the cases that are presented from residency, cases which are Complete will be banked, or documented, at the ABO central office. The examinee must collect the balance of required cases, either from residency within 24 months of graduation or from post-residency practice, for grading within ten (10) years and two (2) more attempts. If at least three (3) cases are Complete and include at least one (1) case with a DI of 20 or above, and the BCOE is Complete, the examinee may mail the remaining cases to the ABO for grading at a future clinical examination. The examinee must return in person to a future clinical examination to complete the ICE requirements IF: o o o less than three (3) cases are Complete three (3) cases are Complete, but do not include one (1) case with a DI of 20 or above the BCOE is Incomplete
4.
If no cases from residency are Complete, the examinee, when ready, will submit a new registration and take the Beginning Certification Examination. If the examinee does not fulfill ICE requirements within ten (10) years and two (2) attempts, the examinee, when ready, will submit a new registration and will take the Beginning Certification Examination.
Cases treated by the examinee from their clinical orthodontic practice are required. Exception Full-time orthodontic educators may present a maximum of three (3) cases that the educator directly supervised while teaching within an American Dental Association accredited orthodontic graduate program. The supervised cases may not include a case that will be presented to the ABO by a resident of the orthodontic program. 2. Components of the Beginning Certification Exam a. b. c. 3. Board Case Oral Examination (BCOE) Case Report Examination (CRE) Case Report Oral Examination (CROE)
The Case Report Examination component requires six (6) Case Reports consisting of
a. b.
three (3) cases with a DI of twenty (20) or greater, three (3) cases with a DI of ten (10) or greater.
The six case presentation must contain: at least one (1) non-surgical case treated with four (4) quadrant extractions that demonstrates effective space closure (identified as Extraction Case). at least one (1) non-surgical case with a bilateral or unilateral full-step Class II molar relationship corrected to a Class I molar and canine relationship (identified as Class II Case). no more than one (1) case treated with orthognathic surgery (identified as Surgical Case). Note that a surgical case is not required. Any surgical case needs interim (pre-surgical) records.
Cases treated by the examinee from their clinical orthodontic practice are required. Exception - Gateway Examinees, who are not full-time orthodontic educators, may bring one or two cases treated in their residency program. Exception Full-time orthodontic educators may present a maximum of three (3) cases that the educator directly supervised while teaching within an ADA accredited orthodontic graduate program. The supervised cases may not include a case that will be presented to the ABO by a resident of the orthodontic program. 2. Components of the Gateway Certification Exam a. b. c. 3. Board Case Oral Examination (BCOE) Case Report Examination (CRE) Case Report Oral Examination (CROE)
The Case Report Examination component requires six (6) Case Reports consisting of a. three (3) cases with a DI of twenty (20) or greater, b. three (3) cases with a DI of ten (10) or greater. The six case presentation must contain: at least one (1) non-surgical case treated with four (4) quadrant extractions that demonstrates effective space closure (identified as Extraction Case). at least one (1) non-surgical case with a bilateral or unilateral full-step Class II molar relationship corrected to a Class I molar and canine relationship (identified as Class II Case). no more than one (1) case treated with orthognathic surgery (identified as Surgical Case). Note that a surgical case is not required. Any surgical case needs interim (pre-surgical) records.
Three cases treated by the examinee from their clinical orthodontic practice are required.* Cases must be initiated within ones current certification period or within the past ten years. * Exception Full-time orthodontic educators may present cases that the educator directly supervised while teaching within an ADA accredited orthodontic graduate program. The supervised cases may not include a case that will be presented to the ABO by a resident of the orthodontic program. 2. Components of the First Recertification Exam a. b. 3. Case Report Examination (CRE) Case Report Oral Examination (CROE)
The Case Report Examination component requires three (3) Case Reports consisting of a. b. one (1) case with a DI of twenty (20) or greater two (2) cases with a DI of ten (10) or greater
The three case presentation must contain: at least one (1) non-surgical case with a bilateral or unilateral full-step Class II molar relationship corrected to a Class I molar and canine relationship (identified as Class II Case). no more than one (1) case treated with orthognathic surgery (identified as Surgical Case). Note that a surgical case is not required. Any surgical case needs interim (pre-surgical) records.
Two cases treated by the examinee from their clinical orthodontic practice are required.* Cases must be initiated within ones current certification period or within the past ten years. *Exception Full-time orthodontic educators may present cases that the educator directly supervised while teaching within an ADA accredited orthodontic graduate program. The supervised cases may not include a case that will be presented to the ABO by a resident of the orthodontic program.
10
2.
Components of the Second Recertification Exam a. Case Report Examination (CRE) - By Mail and/or Electronic Submission
3.
The Case Report Examination component requires two (2) Case Reports consisting of a. b. one (1) case with a DI of twenty (20) or greater one (1) case with a DI of ten (10) or greater
One case treated by the examinee from their clinical orthodontic practice is required.* The case must be initiated within ones current certification period or within the past ten years. *Exception Full-time orthodontic educators may present a case that the educator directly supervised while teaching within an ADA accredited orthodontic graduate program. The supervised case may not include a case that will be presented to the ABO by a resident of the orthodontic program. 2. Components of the Third Recertification Exam a. 3. Case Report Examination (CRE) By Mail and/or Electronic Submission
The Case Report Examination component requires one (1) Case Report consisting of a. one (1) case with a DI of ten (10) or greater
One case treated by the examinee from their clinical orthodontic practice is required.* The case must be initiated within ones current certification period or within the past ten years. *Exception Full-time orthodontic educators may present a case that the educator directly supervised while teaching within an ADA accredited orthodontic graduate program. The supervised case may not include a case that will be presented to the ABO by a resident of the orthodontic program.
11
2.
Components of the Fourth Recertification Exam a. Case Report Examination (CRE) By Mail and/or Electronic Submission
3.
The Case Report Examination component requires one (1) Case Report consisting of a. one (1) case with a DI of ten (10) or greater
12
EXAMINATION PROCESS
Testing Protocol What to Expect
Protocol for Exam Completion of Exam Non-Completion of Exam or Recertification Information Request and Appeal Process
13
EXAMINATION PROCESS
Testing Protocol (continued)
COMPLETION OF THE CLINICAL EXAMINATION
You will receive notification of successful completion of the Clinical Examination. You will also receive a Diplomate Certificate. For recertifying Diplomates, any remaining time on your current certificate will be added to the new certificate. A first-time Diplomate will receive the ABO lapel pin. The Diplomates name, public contact information and certificate expiration will appear on this websites directory of Diplomates.
Time limitation to return for completion of the Initial Certification Exam o The examinee has ten (10) years on two (2) separate occasions to present case/s to complete the Initial Certification Exam.
If the examinee does not fulfill ICE requirements, the examinee will submit a new application and will take the Beginning Certification Examination with six entirely new cases after satisfying current fees for the exam.
Beginning Certification Examination Non-Completion Re-examination using the same criteria as applied to the case/s that were incomplete. Source of the re-examination case/s o Case/s solely treated by the examinee in their private practice.
Time limitation to return for completion of the Beginning Certification Exam o The examinee has five (5) years on two (2) separate occasions to present case/s to complete the Beginning Certification Exam.
Option for Re-Examination of One Case by Mail If the examinee does not pass upon re-examination or elects not to return within the five (5) year time limitation for re-examination, the examinee will be required to submit a new registration and will take the Beginning Certification Examination with six entirely new cases after satisfying current fees for the exam.
14
Gateway Certification Examination Non-Completion Exam taken prior to expiration of the time-limited Certificate: 1. One (1) to six (6) of the Diplomates cases is/are unacceptable. If this deficiency occurs prior to the expiration of the current time-limited certificate and there are future clinical exams scheduled before the expiration, the Diplomate may return to present new case/s to replace those deemed unacceptable. The new case/s must meet the criteria for the one/s that were deficient. The Diplomate maintains their time-limited certificate. 2. The Diplomate may retake the Gateway Certification Exam as often as needed as long as the current certificate is unexpired. A fee will be charged for each re-examination. 3. Whenever the Gateway Certification Exam is successfully passed, any remaining time on the current certificate will be added to the new certificate. Therefore, there is no penalty for taking the Gateway Certification Exam prior to expiration of the current certificate. Exam or Re-Exam taken in the year of expiration and no exams are scheduled prior to certificate expiration: 1. THREE (3) TO SIX (6) CASE ARE UNACCEPTABLE a. The Diplomate is no longer certified by The American Board of Orthodontics, and must immediately cease any and all recognition and acknowledgement of ABO certification. The Diplomates name is removed from any ABO listing of board certified orthodontists. b. The former Diplomate will submit a new registration and will take the Beginning Certification Examination with six entirely new cases. The current examination fee will be charged. 2. ONE (1) TO TWO (2) CASES ARE UNACCEPTABLE a. The Diplomate maintains Board certified status for one year (365 days) beyond certificate expiration and must return to a Clinical Examination during that year to present one or two entirely new cases using the same criteria as applied to the case/s that were Incomplete. A fee will be charged for the re-examination. b. Option for Re-Examination of One Case by Mail c. Following passage of the re-examination, the Diplomate will receive recertification for nine (9) years. d. If the Diplomate returns and does not successfully complete one or both re-examination cases, the Diplomate will no longer be board certified. The former Diplomate will submit a new registration and take the Beginning Certification Examination with six entirely new cases. The current examination fee will be charged. Voluntary Recertification Non-Completion A Diplomate may re-examine for the Voluntary Recertification as many times as desired by the Diplomate. There will be a nominal fee for each examination.
Recertification Examination/s Non-Completion Re-examination using the same criteria as applied to the case/s that were Incomplete. Source of the re-examination case/s o Case/s solely treated by the examinee in their private practice.
15
The Recertification Exam may be retaken as often as needed as long as the current certificate is unexpired. A fee will be charged for each re-examination.
Option for Re-Examination of One Case by Mail If the examinee does not successfully complete re-examination or elects not to return, the examinee will be required to submit a new registration and will take the Recertification Exam that follows the last successful exam and bring entirely new case/s. The current examination fee will be charged.
NON-COMPLETION OF RECERTIFICATION
If a Diplomate is no longer certified by The American Board of Orthodontics, s/he must immediately cease any and all recognition and acknowledgement of ABO certification. The Diplomates name is removed from any ABO listing of board certified orthodontists. If a former Diplomate is under investigation for inappropriate use of the designation of Board Certification: a. b. The former Diplomate will be ineligible to participate in the clinical examination until a decision has been made by the Board regarding these allegations. If the allegations of inappropriate use of the designation of Board Certified are proven to be authentic, the orthodontist will be indefinitely prohibited from taking Clinical Examinations to obtain ABO certification.
16
17
Meets case report requirements for patient records at each level of evaluation Especially note those conditions that will cause automatic rejection of a case: a. b. c. Case does not meet exam submission criteria.
Any posttreatment records are obtained beyond 12 months of appliance removal. Interim or Pre-Operative Records are not present for two-phased treatment or for surgical cases.
3.
Submission of measurement instruments to be used in the evaluation of cases. a. See overview of Discrepancy Index Scoring System (pdf) for example records and scoring discussion. b. See Grading System for Dental Casts and Panoramic Radiographs (pdf).
B. Specific areas of observation by the ABO Examiner: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. Treatment complementing facial growth. Facial harmony -- balance and harmony of the soft tissue and proper proportion of facial structures. Maximum esthetics of the teeth and face. Dental health maximum health of the teeth, the supporting tissues and the adjacent structures. Optimal function, free of interferences and trauma. Excellent occlusion. Favorable intercuspation of the teeth. Alignment of permanent second molars. Favorable overjet and overbite relationship.
18
Favorable correction of rotations of all teeth. Favorable axial inclination of all teeth. Complete space closure. Coordinated ideal archform with all the teeth aligned within the supporting structures. Good vertical control. Good stability.
Proof of Treatment
As part of exam registration, all examinees must sign a Rules of Examination Affidavit (pdf) for the ABO affirming that all the professional judgment and treatment was provided by the examinee for each of the patient case reports that are presented to the Board. In addition, the examinee must affirm that patient records have not been altered nor have they been presented to the Board in a previous examination. Finally, the examinee will also affirm that s/he has read the Appeal Process for Adverse Certification Decisions and agrees to the ABO policy on documentation of examination. Additional affidavit, submitted separately, is required under these circumstances: Initial Certification Examination - all recent graduates must have a signed Confirmation of Residency Treated Cases (pdf) by the Department Chairperson and/or Program Director to confirm that each case presented was treated by the examinee under the supervision of a clinical instructor in an ADA accredited orthodontic program. Gateway Offer orthodontists who are certified under the Gateway Offer may present one or two cases treated in their residency program for the First Recertification Examination; a signed Affidavit Two Residency Cases by the Department Chairperson and/or Program Director is needed for confirmation. Full-time Orthodontic Educators (1 FTE per week) - a signed Educator Supervision Affidavit (pdf) by the Department Chairperson and/or Program Director that up to three cases presented by the examinee were treated in the graduate orthodontic clinic entirely under the supervision of the examinee (as a full-time educator). The supervised cases may not include a case that will be presented to the ABO by a resident of the orthodontic program. NOTE: It is the examinees responsibility to obtain patient release for use of records and identification.
19
20
PHOTOGRAPHS
- INTRAORAL
The minimum intraoral photographic requirement for each level of evaluation is one (1) frontal view, one (1) right lateral view and one (1) left lateral view with the teeth in maximum intercuspation and in color. Photographs of maxillary and mandibular occlusal views are recommended. Beginning with the Clinical Examinations of February 2010, maxillary and mandibular occlusal views are mandatory in each photographic series if treatment was initiated on or after May 1, 2009. The intraoral photographs are required for the A, A1 and B Records. They should be oriented to the occlusal plane. The color prints should be as close as possible to a 1:1 ratio with the patients own
21
teeth. If mirror images are used, print them in reverse and mount them if you are looking at the patient. These photographs must fit in a collage photomount or, if computer generated, the photographs do not need to be placed in a photomount, but must be in the same arrangement. Slides are not permitted. The requirements for computer-generated images are found under Digital Record Requirements. Digital photos must be printed on photo glossy paper. The examinee is reminded that all records are legal documents and must not be altered. Intraoral Photograph Requirements 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. Quality standardized intraoral prints in color. Patients occlusal plane parallel with the top and bottom of the mount. One (1) frontal view in maximum intercuspation. Two (2) lateral views (right and left). Maxillary and mandibular occlusal views are mandatory for 2010 and beyond if treatment was initiated on or after May 1, 2009. Free of distractions (i.e., cheek retractors, labels and fingers). Lighting should reveal anatomical contours with minimal shadows. Use two (2) cheek retractors. Free of saliva and/or bubbles. Clean dentition. Photographs should be as close to a 1:1 relationship as possible. If not computer-generated, photographs must fit in the collage photomounts. Digital photos must be printed on photo glossy paper.
22
Post-treatment documentation of similar format must be submitted for comparison of the patients initial and final periodontal status.
EXAMPLE
Three dimensional volumetric assessments produce exact measurements.1. 2. When this type of data is compared to traditional cephalometric information (analogue and digital technology), indiscriminant errors in the actual location of vital landmarks necessary to establish superimpositions are found. In spite of this problem, the Board encourages the continued use of like cephalograms (i.e. cephalograms produced on the same machine), and expects examinees to produce high quality cephalometric radiographs using the ABO measurements to determine diagnostic approaches for patient care and to reveal the final treatment results. Use of these accurately traced cephalograms will give the examinee very valuable information about tooth movement, amount and direction of growth, or lack thereof. While the Board recognizes that magnification errors will always be present unless three dimensional volumetric radiographs are utilized, it does not dismiss the examinees responsibility: A. B. to inform the Board the conditions under which the initial, progress, and final cephalometric radiographs were obtained. to create radiographic superimpositions demonstrating the highest degree of accuracy possible
Where initial and final cephalograms are not performed on the same unit, cephalometric tracings are still required, but superimposition(s) are not required. It is the responsibility of the examinee to explain the reason for the absence of superimposition(s). Also, the examinee must be prepared to explain the changes that occurred during treatment.
1.
Adams G.L. GSA, Miller A.J.,Harrell Jr. W.E., and Hatcher D.C. Comparison between traditional 2dimensional cephalometry and a 3-dimensional approach on human dry skulls. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop 2004; 126:397-409. Harrell WE, Jr., Hatcher DC, Bolt RL. In search of anatomic truth: 3-dimensional digital modeling and the future of orthodontics. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop 2002;122:325-330.
2.
23
COMPOSITE TRACINGS
A minimum of three (3) composite tracings are required comparing cephalometric tracings: 1. 2. 3. Craniofacial Maxillary Mandibular
The three composites are manually traced by the examinee from the individual tracings of the cephalograms. A small diameter (0.5 mm) pencil or pen should be used. The three composites may be on three separate sheets of tracing acetate or they may all be arranged on one sheet. When there is an Interim set of records, separate composites of A and B tracings, A and A1 tracings and A1 and B tracings are required. Digital superimpositions are acceptable if prepared as instructed in the Digital Record Requirements. All tracings must be submitted on transparent media. EXAMPLE OF COMPOSITE TRACINGS The following procedure for composite tracings is required: 1. 2. 3. 1. Craniofacial Composite register on Sella with the best fit on the anterior cranial base bony structures (Planum Sphenoidum, Cribiform Plate, Greater Wings of the Sphenoid) to assess overall growth and treatment changes. 2. Maxillary Composite register on the lingual curvature of the palate and the best fit on the maxillary bony structures to assess maxillary tooth movement. 3. Mandibular Composite register on the internal cortical outline of the symphsis with the best fit on the mandibular canal to assess mandibular tooth movement and incremental growth of the mandible.
24
Examinees must use the same colors for the composite tracings that are used for the cephalometric tracings. Pretreatment tracings must be in BLACK. Interim tracings must be in BLUE. Posttreatment tracings must be in RED. All tracings must be submitted on transparent media. See ABO Policy Statement Regarding Lateral Cephalometric Radiographs and Superimposition of Tracings.
1.
Baumrind S, Miller D, Malthen R. The reliability of head film measurements 3. Tracing superimposition. AM J Orthod 1976; 70:617-644. Doppel D, Damon W, Joondeph D, Little R. An investigation of maxillary superimposition techniques using metallic implants. Am J Orthod Dentofac Orthop 1994; 105:161-168. Bjork A. Variations in the growth of the human mandible: longitudinal radiographic study by the implant method. J Dent Res 1963: 42:400-411.
2.
3.
25
VENDOR SOLUTIONS
Any commercial enterprise offering a product or service intended to aid the examinee in completing the Clinical Examination must accompany the offering with the following statements: This product is compatible with current standards for submission of case reports to The American Board of Orthodontics as published at www.americanboardortho.com. ** **The American Board of Orthodontics has not reviewed or tested this product and does not endorse, guarantee, or warrant its performance or compatibility with ABO standards. Examinees using software to produce digital images for case submission are expected to have thorough knowledge of such programs and should not contact the ABO to address questions regarding the use of the software.
26
DIGITAL CASTS
Digital pre-treatment casts are acceptable provided that the digital format is supported by software to view and measure the digital casts for Discrepancy Index (DI) in compliance with ABO case submission criteria. Digital interim casts are acceptable only between Phase 1 and Phase 2 treatment provided all active appliances are removed prior to taking the impression. For the upcoming clinical exam, the ABO is prepared to accept pretreatment and allowable interim digital casts in the following formats: OrthoCAD Vers 3.25 or later, GeoDigm eModel and Orametrix SureSmile. o Use OrthoCADs built-in DI scoring tool; save your scoring with the digital model. o The examinee using eModel may request DI-scored digital models by contacting GeoDigm directly. o Method for transferring digital SureSmile models to the ABO will be announced at a later date. o The examinee is responsible for all electronic scoring, whether self-scored or company-scored. Submit allowable pretreatment and interim digital via upload at Online Services Clinical Exam Electronic Submission. Digital models will not be accepted on portable media. Note: An accurate and stable occlusal registration (maximum intercuspation) for all digital casts is best achieved by using polyvinylsiloxane (PVS) bite registration material. Digital interim casts are not acceptable for pre-surgical study casts. Post-treatment digital casts are not acceptable at the current time. o Note: The Board requires that final casts be a direct plaster/stone reproduction of the occlusal result, trimmed to ABO specifications, and/or mounted in centric relation, after intraoral impressions are produced. Stereolithic or other reconstructed casts created from computer generated images are unacceptable.
ABO Directors are actively pursuing the implementation of an automatic scoring system for all digital casts.
27
28
History and Etiology Diagnosis Include a brief description of the nature and extent of the anomalies for skeletal and dental and/or facial problems. Examinee may comment on the points used to record the arch widths on the Case Management Form. Specific Objectives of Treatment: a. Maxilla b. Mandible c. Maxillary dentition d. Mandibular dentition e. Facial Esthetics
Treatment Plan Include your diagnostic analysis and reason for choosing a particular treatment plan, extraction or non-extraction, appliances used, anchorage considerations, type of retention, supplemental therapy and prognosis. Appliances and Treatment Progress Include a description of appliances used and of the actual treatment, response to treatment and any complications. Do not record what was done at each visit. Results Achieved a. If differing radiographic units is noted with a checkmark, the examinee may need to elaborate to the examiner the reasons for the lack of superimposition(s) with an explanation of the cephalometric changes during treatment. b. Refer to the objectives stated for the maxilla, mandible, maxillary dentition, etc., and confirm that the objectives were reached or explain why an objective was not realized. Retention Describe appliances and supplementary procedures. Final Evaluation of Treatment Include all pertinent observations and prognosis for stability. Describe posttreatment changes. State what you learned about your specific diagnosis and treatment of the case.
29
All Case Report forms and worksheets, can be downloaded at Case Report Forms and Instructions
30
3.
For your convenience, the ABO has available for purchase a Calibration Kit. The ABO highly recommends the use of its Calibration Kit for cast and radiographic evaluation. It contains information that can assist you in making a quantitative assessment of the records that you plan to use for the clinical exam. The Directors will be using the same grading system contained in this kit to evaluate your treatment results. The Calibration Kit can be found at the eStore.
The following worksheets are for print use only. For electronic forms submission requirement, use ABO Case Report Work File (pdf) at Clinical Forms and Instructions
Discrepancy Index Worksheet for print (pdf) Discrepancy Index Instructions (pdf) For an overview, see Discrepancy Index Scoring System (pdf)
31
Cast-Radiograph Worksheet for print (pdf) Cast-Radiograph Reference Sheet (pdf) For an overview, see Grading System for Dental Casts and Panoramic Radiographs (pdf)
Case Management Worksheet for print (pdf) Case Management Instructions (pdf)
32
Radiographs Ceph Tracings Periodontal Record/s Interim Records (A1) Posttreatment Records (B) Composite Tracings Copy of Case Report Forms
33
Electronic Submission
Case reports and allowable pretreatment digital models must be submitted to the ABO electronically prior to your exam date. Case report data consists of four reports: Written Case Report (WCR), Discrepancy Index (DI), Cast-Radiograph Evaluation (C-R Eval), and Case Management forms (CMF). All reports and instructions required for one case have been combined into a downloadable PDF Case Report Work File. You have the option of uploading reports from one or more Case Report Work Files. Alternately, you may enter your reports directly to the ABO electronic submission site. Or, you may use a combination of both methods. Choose how you will begin your case reports: OR 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. Start at Step 1 - Enter case report data to a work file on your local hard drive. Start at Step 4 - Enter case report data directly to the ABO electronic submission site. Download CaseReportWorkFile.pdf from the ABO Download Webpage. Adobe Reader, Version 9 or later, is required. * We recommend you use Save-As with a descriptive filename for each case. Enter case report data to each work file at your convenience. In the year prior to your intended clinical exam, register for the exam and you will be informed by email when the ABO electronic submission site is available to you. Login at Online Services Clinical Exam Electronic Submission. Follow prompts to upload each Case Report Work File from Step 3 or to enter case reports directly. ABO case numbers will be assigned automatically according to ascending sequence of DI value (or Category number). Your data will be verified against the current years exam specifications. ** You may return to update your data as many times as needed before the submission deadline.
10. If you have allowable pretreatment digital models to submit, you will upload by selecting Submit Model in the Action column. 11. When finished, mark the reports for each case as Complete and select SUBMIT TO ABO. 12. After submission, use the Print PDF feature to save a read-only copy of your case reports. Print pgs 2-8 and insert in the back pocket of your case report notebook.
* Other PDF viewers are not fully functional and should not be used. Work at the same local hard drive to insure you are always using the same version of Adobe Reader. ** Currently published ABO exam specifications apply to each year's exam, no matter when the examinee began gathering records. If you upload a former years Case Report Work File, you will be alerted if any data has not transferred. You are encouraged to login early and verify your case reports against current year specifications.
34
The CaseReportWorkFile contains all required case forms and instructions for one case: Written Case Report, Discrepancy Index, Cast-Radiograph Evaluation and Case Management Forms. You may choose to upload data from the CaseReportWorkFile and/or you may enter data directly into the ABO electronic submission webpages. See Electronic Submission. We recommend you use Save-As and a descriptive filename for each case report work file. Adobe Reader, Version 9 or later, is required.
Case Report Work File including Instructions Print only version DI, C-R Eval, and CMF Title Page for Case Report Notebook Affidavit - Initial Certification Affidavit Two Residency Cases Affidavit - Educator Supervision Cases
CaseReportWorkFile (pdf) Measurement Instruments Template (doc) Form (pdf) Form (pdf) Form (pdf) Instructions (pdf) Additional, as required Additional, as required Additional, as required
35
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
36
VOLUNTARY RECERTIFICATION
Voluntary Recertification Board Case Exam - enter here
Upon registration, you will receive a case report notebook and a measuring gauge with instructions for submitting your case records by mail. You will also receive a login and instructions to submit your case reports online and to take the Board Case Test online. As a not-for-profit organization, it is necessary to charge a nominal fee for this process. Once you are recertified, you will receive a certificate indicating your accomplishment. To register for voluntary recertification, go to Register for Clinical Examination.
Background
In February 1999, in order to establish guidelines and procedures relative to the recertifying process, all current ABO directors were required to complete a recertification examination. This examination, while voluntary, required that each director present one case report of a patient who had been treated recently and to treatment plan a case they had not seen previously. The current directors were examined by former ABO directors. In February 2000, all former directors who continued as examiners and each newly appointed director were required to recertify in the same manner. At present, the ABO is encouraging all Diplomates who are not required to recertify to do so voluntarily. While the ABO feels that a recertification examination should not be as extensive as the initial Clinical Examination, the Board does believe that such examination must involve diagnosis and treatment planning of clinical records, and have structured the Voluntary Recertification Exam accordingly.
37
1.
Components of the Option I and II Exams a. Board Case Oral Examination (BCOE) b. Case Report Examination (CRE) c. Case Report Oral Examination (CROE)
2.
Case Criteria for the Option I and II Exams The Option I presentation must include ten case reports according to Category or ten case reports according to DI. Case Category Specifications for Option I Case Selection by DI for Option I. Two (2) cases may be used from orthodontic training program with affidavit from Program Director confirming individual care by examinee. Full-time orthodontic faculty may use three (3) clinically supervised cases. Additionally, the remainder of cases from private practice may contain two category substitutions (from categories 1-8) with no more than two cases in any one category.
The Option II examinee may present any six (6) completed case reports, including post-treatment records, of the initial twelve (12) approved sets of records previously presented to a Director of the Board. These six (6) case reports will be examined in the same way as the ten category cases are examined under the Option I. The examinee may withdraw from the Option II at any time and take the Option I. 3. Incomplete examinees who did not pass one or more cases at the Clinical examination Continue your original path with two more attempts to return with the incomplete case(s) within 5 years from your original Clinical Examination. 4. Certificate time-limits If you applied prior to January 1, 1998, successful passage of the Clinical Exam will earn a NON TIME-LIMITED certificate. Therefore, no recertification will be required, but voluntary recertification is encouraged. If you applied after January 1, 1998, successful passage of the Clinical Exam will earn a 15 YEAR TIME-LIMITED certificate.
38
Appendix of Exhibits
Referenced as in the clinical narrative
A-2
2. Adult Malocclusion
A surgically or non-surgically treated adult over the age of 21 at the beginning of treatment that fulfills all of the category requirements from one of the case categories #3 through #8. Pre- and post-treatment periodontal charting, and pre- and post-treatment periapical and bitewing radiographs are also recommended.
Substitution: If a candidate is in a restricted practice and is unable to fulfill the requirements for adult malocclusion, an alternate assignment may be made at the discretion of the Board. Generally, the alternate assignment will be a growing patient whose malocclusion fulfills all of the category requirements from one of the case categories #4 through #8. A request for substitution must be submitted in writing to the ABO office at least three (3) months before the examination.
3. Class I Malocclusion treated with bilateral extraction of permanent teeth in the maxillary and mandibular arch 4. Deep Overbite Malocclusion
A malocclusion with retroclined maxillary central incisors, anterior teeth in 100 percent overbite or greater, and an FMA not greater than 22 degrees and/or an SNa Go-Gn angle not greater than 29 degrees.
8. Transverse Discrepancy
A posterior crossbite malocclusion that requires complete appliance treatment. Prior to treatment, at least one (1) posterior quadrant must be in complete lingual or buccal crossbite.
9. Optional
The case selected for this category must have a Discrepancy Index score of 7 or greater. This category does not apply to Voluntary Recertification.
10. Optional
The case selected for this category must have a Discrepancy Index score of 7 or greater. This category does not apply to Voluntary Recertification.
*For the malocclusion to satisfy the Class II category requirement, the mesiobuccal cusp of the maxillary permanent first molar must occlude, at least on one side, in the embrasure between the mandibular second premolar and the mandibular permanent molar, or farther to the mesial. If the maxillary or mandibular permanent first molar is missing, the buccal cusp of the maxillary second premolar must occlude in the embrasure between the mandibular first and second premolars, or farther to the mesial. ** For the malocclusion to satisfy the Class III category requirement, the mesiobuccal cusp of the maxillary permanent first molar must occlude, at least on one side, in the distobuccal groove of the mandibular permanent first molar, or farther to the distal. If the maxillary permanent first molar is missing, the buccal cusp of the maxillary second premolar must occlude in the mesiobuccal groove of the mandibular permanent first molar, or farther to the distal.
A-4
Select cases according to the following scoring system: two (2) cases must have a DI of twenty-five (25) or greater six (6) cases must have a DI of sixteen (16) or greater two (2) cases must have a DI of seven (7) or greater.
The ten case presentation must contain: at least one (1) case started in the mixed dentition and identified as mixed dentition. at least one (1) full-step Class II molar relationship* and identified as Class II Case. at least one (1) full-step Class II molar relationship* which requires four (4) quadrant extractions and identified as Class II/Extraction Case. at least one (1) adult case (21 years or older), which may be surgical or other and identified as Adult Case. no more than two (2) combined surgical-orthodontic cases and identified as Surgical Case. All surgery cases need interim (pre-surgical) records.
* See illustration and definition of Full-Step Class II molar relationship under the Clinical
Examination, Selecting Cases for Presentation section of the ABO website.
A-5
The American Board of Orthodontics Option for Re-Examination of One Case by Mail
Applicable only if the examinee has passed the Board Case Oral Examination. If eligible for re-examination, the examinee may elect to submit a new case by mail that meets the criteria for the previously Incomplete case. The examinee must complete the online registration for Re-Examination of One Case by Mail. Refer to the ABO website to view Exam Dates and Fees for registration deadline and the reexamination fee. Collect affidavit(s) if required for the type of clinical exam. See Proof of Treatment on the ABO website for relevant affidavits. Ship the hard copy Case Report and casts, along with affidavit(s) if required, to the ABO central office no later than two weeks prior to your clinical exam. There will be no face to face oral exam for the One Incomplete Case Option. However, the ABO examiners may contact the examinee for any needed elaboration concerning the presented case.
A-6
ILLUSTRATION 1 of 2: FULL-STEP CLASS II MOLAR RELATIONSHIP For the malocclusion to satisfy the ABO definition of a full-step Class II molar relationship, the mesiobuccal cusp of the maxillary permanent first molar must occlude, at least on one side, in the embrasure between the mandibular second premolar and the mandibular permanent first molar, or farther to the mesial. If the maxillary or mandibular permanent first molar is missing, the buccal cusp of the maxillary second premolar must occlude in the embrasure between the mandibular first and second premolars, or farther to the mesial. If the maxillary permanent first molar has drifted mesially due to premature loss of the deciduous second molar, that is not considered a Full-Step Class II molar relationship.
A-7
ILLUSTRATION 2 of 2: END-TO-END CLASS II MOLAR RELATIONSHIP This example demonstrates an end-to-end molar relationship which satisfies ABO criteria for Initial Certification only. It is to be distinguished from the full-step Class II of the preceding illustration.
A-8
A-9
2 (3 if Interim Recs)
For digital or non-digital photo collage, and composite tracings. For all radiographs and cephalometric tracings
A - 10
#1 14-7
#1
Records to be marked for each level of evaluation include dental casts, photographic collage, all radiographs, all cephalometric tracings and composite tracings. Doctors name, if present, should not be visible. Adhesive labels, not embossed tape, must be used to identify hard copy records. Color marker or color printer may be used for DOT on label.
ID#69088
#6
2-14-02
12-3
ID#69088
#6
2-14-02
12-3
P
A - 11
A - 12
A - 13
A - 14
A - 15
A - 16
(use the composite tracing of Case #3 of the example cases on the website)
A - 17
12/20/06 Radiographs policy. Beginning 2009, bitewings and periapicals mandatory for adults 21 and over. 3/8/07 Exam protocol. BCOE review time changed from one hour to one-half hour. 6/22/07 Clinical Exam option. Option for Re-examination of One Case by Mail added. 7/9/07 Discrepancy Index Form. More treatment complexities specified under OTHER; Cephalometrics scoring guide is revised for clarity, BUT CALCULATED POINTS REMAIN THE SAME. 12/17/07 Electronic Guidelines. In-person exam digital records clarification; future electronic submission format policies published. 4/3/08 Traditional Option I and II. Eligibility is limited to those who received valid extentions. 6/1/08 DI and CMF Ceph Measures. Go-Gn measure changed to MP measure in DI and CMF. Electronic submission of Synopsis, DI, CE, CMF. These forms will not be included in case report notebook. Case report notebook. Notebook assembly revised. Examinee Kit is no longer offered.
6/1/08 (continued) Radiographic policy. Documentation required for adults 18 years of age and older and for periodontically-involved adolescents if treatment was initiated on or after March 2007. Cast-Radiograph Evaluation. Root angulation scoring will omit maxillary and mandibular canines. Digital Cast guidelines. One digital format acceptable in 2009 for pretreatment and certain interim casts; occlusal registration for digital casts is best achieved with PVS material. Discrepancy Index. DI scoring system with examples are provided for download; clarification on scoring for crowding, anomalous morphology, and missing teeth. Selecting Cases for Presentation. More detail provided on board expectations and required completeness of records and reports. 9/22/08 Discrepancy Index. Revision to scoring for Anterior Open Bite. 11/21/08 Mandibular Plane. New exhibit to demonstrate construction of MP for completing measurements in DI and CMF. 4/1/09 Photographic occlusal views date change. Beginning 2010, maxillary and mandibular occlusal views are mandatory if treatment was initiated on or after May 1, 2009. 4/1/09 Superimpositions. If differing radiographic units, ceph tracings are required but superimposition(s) are not required.
4/1/09 Final Casts clarification. Stereolithic or other reconstructed casts created from computer generated images are unacceptable as final casts. 6/1/09 Case Report Work File. All case report forms and instructions are combined into one downloadable file. Option to upload as an electronic forms submission. Option to print submitted forms. Initial implementation 2009-2010. 10/1/09 Emodel pretreatment digital models are acceptable. 4/1/10 ICE Banking Process published. 4/12/10 C-R Eval Buccolingual Inclination Exception: Do not score the mandibular 1st premolars nor the distal cusps of the second molars. 7/19/10 Enhanced Case Report Work File released. Allowable pretreatment models will be submitted via upload to ABO electronic submission site. 12/8/10 DI clarification on scoring for Overjet and for Anterior and Lateral Open Bite. 3/15/11 Recertification Exam requirements announced for 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th Recertifications. Exam renamed to Gateway Certification Examination.
A - 18