THE TWO HUNDREDTH AND THIRTY-FOURTH ANTLER

David Byfords The Boys from the Trodigal Gang which was the limited palette winner and overall winner in the April competition of the Carradale Camera Club. Other winners were Rachel Grant, Margaret Richardson, Julia Dancer & Alastair Bennett. Photographs on page 5.

NETWORK NEWS
.
Help Make a Difference and Strengthen Your Community!

The Community Heritage Centre Needs You!! Share your Experiences, Interests and Knowledge!!! Many of you will have noticed that a group of volunteers have been working to improve the buildings, including the old school, and surrounding land at the Heritage Centre. The volunteers, the majority of whom are retired or semiretired, have realised that the task before them is too much for such a small group. The tasks identified include: repairs to ensure buildings are watertight and weatherproof, decorate interior and exterior of buildings, joinery, clean and repair drains, clear surrounding land of debris and weeds, repair steps to car park, refurbish wheelhouse, create flower beds and country gardens. . The Heritage Centre belongs to the community and we need your help. So please come along, learn new skills and make new friends. Help us ensure that we leave a heritable legacy for our younger generation. At present we are at the Heritage Centre every Thursday from 10am. For further information please tel. 01583 431581. We will be holding an

FIT THE BEST

UP TO 40% off
WINDOWS and DOORS, CONSERVATORIES, GARAGE DOORS, ROOFLINE PRODUCTS, FLAT ROOFS, DRIVEWAYS,SECURITY SYSTEMS, CCTV.

HORRIBLE HOLIDAY HAZARDS

These photographs were taken by holidaymakers enjoying a brief relaxing Easter walk over Forestry Commission ground in Carradale. Several years ago the Commission were kind enough to allow the placing of a memorial seat on Commission ground to the north of Wellpark, overlooking Arran and Carradale Harbour, but thanks to the prompt action by Forestry Officer Barry Bruce, Bruce Maclean, Peter Maclean and Ian Smith the area has now been restored to its former glory. If you know of anyone who dumped these rather distinctive objects ring 01583 431281 so that the the offender can be apprehended or recycled. Photo by M.C.

FREE QUOTATION NO OBLIGATION

To arrange an appointment, Contact
Sandy McPherson Tel 01586 552776 Mobile 07818874066

OPEN MEETING
in CARRADALE

VILLAGE HALL on

IN THIS ISSUE
P2 Muriel Carrier, a family appreciation. P3 Hydro cheques, Table sale, Marys meals, No Tartan Walk this year. P4 Election, Slim, Diamond celebration. KIWG. P5 Goat, Bunnies, Eagles and Plays. P6 Carradale Village Hall minutes, part one. P7 Carradale Village Hall minutes, part two. P8 The bus, Phytophthora ramorum is here. P9 Carradale Golf Club events and draw. P10 A new wind turbine study. P11 Community Council funding, New moorings. P12 Rainfall, the Mears submerge, Quay attack.

WEDNESDAY 13TH JUNE

at 7.30 pm,
to present the plans for the Heritage Centre and to provide a list of dates for Volunteer Weekends, we hope you will join us. A.C.

CARRADALE GOLF CLUB

THE SECRETARY IS MARGARET RICHARDSON 2, OLD SCHOOLHOUSE CARRADALE PA28 6QJ

TELEPHONE 01583 431788 Further information is on page 9.

NETWORK CENTRE AND TEAROOM

Winter hours 11am- 4pm. Closed Wednesdays &Thursdays.

JULY ANTLER
Closing date Tuesday 12th June at 4pm To print Thursday 14th June at 9am Publishing date Thursday 21st June

MURIEL CARRIER
Muriel Carrier, a long time resident of Carradale, died aged 96 on 12 April 2012, Muriel who lived at Portrigh had a long association with Carradale. Her parents spent holidays in Carradale when Muriel was a little girl and she has been visiting ever since then. Muriel bought Cala Sith, Portrigh in 1966 and when her husband Ken retired in 1977 they moved permanently to Carradale. Unfortunately Ken died after only two years of retirement. However Muriel became very involved with the village life in Carradale. Together with her friend Nan Loudon they got involved with the Carradale playgroup for over ten years. This involved ferrying children and teaching them nursery rhymes among other things. Muriel also contributed to village life assisting with the delivery of Meals on Wheels to the elderly some of whom were younger than Muriel. Muriel was involved with the golf club and acted for a time as secretary for the Ladies Committee. A few years ago Muriel and her great friend, Crystal Paterson, were invited to the Carradale School to recount their memories of life during the Second World War. This was a great success and the children actively participated in the question and answer session learning first hand of the hardships that were endured during this period. About 18 months ago Muriel found it difficult to live in her home alone and moved to live with her daughter, Denise Stewart and her husband Dave in Newport-on-Tay. Early this year Muriel moved to St Serfs Residential Care home a few minutes distant from Denises house. She had only been there a short while when she had a fall and fractured a small bone in her pelvis. She was taken to Ninewells Hospital in Dundee where she died peacefully after being there for about a week. Muriels funeral took place in the Carradale & Saddell Parish Church on Saturday 21 April. The service was conducted by Matthew Ramsay who gave a very personal memory of Muriel. Matthew also read out one of Muriels favorite poems Trees by Joyce Kilmer I think that I shall never see A poem lovely as a tree. A tree whose hungry mouth is prest Against the earth's sweet flowing breast; A tree that looks at God all day, And lifts her leafy arms to pray; A tree that may in summer wear A nest of robins in her hair; Upon whose bosom snow has lain; Who intimately lives with rain. Poems are made by fools like me, But only God can make a tree Readings by Denise Stewart and Gavin Carrier (Muriels younger son from Sydney, Australia) were followed by tributes from Michael Carrier (Muriels older son from Johannesburg, South Africa) as follows Its great to see such a large turnout for Muriels funeral. Thank you all for attending. I would like to say a few words on behalf of Muriels children Denise, Gavin, myself and of course Jill who sadly died four years ago. We always knew that Mum and Dad intended to retire to their cottage in Carradale. Mum had been visiting Carradale since she was a little girl and always had great affection for Carradale. She bought their Portrigh cottage in 1966 and when they did eventually retire to their Cala Sith cottage in 1979 all of us children were delighted with the way they settled in and were accepted by the community. Unfortunately Dad only lived here for two years before he passed away. Even though Mum was left on her own it did not deter her from getting involved in many community activities such as helping with the playgroup, delivering meals on wheels, supporting the golf club and of course enjoying life to the full. During the time she was on her own, apart of course from her beloved dogs and cats, she always enjoyed great support from and friendship with a great many of Carradales people. I would like to take this opportunity to say thank you to all these very special people who came into Mums life and provided great support for her and the many who became her firm friends. Although all of us children lived quite some distance from Mum it was of great
2

comfort to know that she was living in a very caring and supportive community. In particular I would like to thank Archie and Crystal Paterson who on many occasions went way beyond the call of duty to support and help Mum. Both Mum and Crystal became great friends and shared many common interests particularly in animals and nature in general. They shared many happy times together. I know that Mum would want both Archie and Crystal to be thanked for the great contribution they made to her enjoyment of life. I think some of the happiest years of Mums life were spent in Carradale. Without doubt we all thought we had the best Mum in the world. She was unassuming and always put others before herself. She would often go out of her way to help others in any way she could. Although Mum is gone now I think that we will always have many, many happy memories of her. She will be truly missed by all of us. And Garry Stewart (Muriels eldest grandson from London) as follows Id like to say a few words on behalf of all the grandchildren (there are 12 of us and five great grandchildren) and try to tell you how we remember Gran and what she meant to us. I think everyone would agree that she was an exceptionally kind and thoughtful person. For as long as I can remember she always accommodated people and made time for people whether it was a quick chat in the street or on the phone, someone popping in for coffee or someone coming to stay with her. It was never too much trouble for her and people were always made to feel special and welcome. Her house was always busy with people passing through and she was often still eating her lunch late afternoon because of all the unexpected visitors shed had. She loved Carradale, she loved all the friends she had here and she loved her family dearly. In addition to that anyone who knew even remotely knew all about her love for animals. Animals, and dogs in particular played a huge part in her life and in my opinion the hundreds if not thousands of miles she walked with her dogs (and obviously Dusty the cat that used to accompany her over the golf course) played a huge part in keeping her fit and active to a grand old age. Her animals truly were part of her family and she used to sit down with an aperitif and a packet of crisps before dinner and it would be one crisp for one dog, one crisp for another dog, one crisp for the cat and one crisp for her and so it continued until the crisps were gone. It wasnt only her pet animals she loved though. She rescued numerous wayward lambs every spring that managed to get caught in the fence opposite her house and Im sure the birds in her garden were among Scotlands best fed, she was forever putting bread, raisins and other titbits out there for them. I think most of the grandchildren remember gran putting a pair of wellies on them and dragging them up to the reserve and marched around looking for the elusive Carradale goats. Another passion of Grans was her garden, she loved being out there and often sat in her greenhouse with a cup of tea reading the newspaper. She enjoyed gardening and on many occasions was happy to work out there until the infamous midges mounted attack after relentless attack and drove her inside. She was always willing to help and I can remember her helping out with the children at nursery and then going on to deliver meals on wheels. She used to talk about taking who she referred to as her old people to Campbeltown to go shopping as they were too old to drive themselves. It always amused me when I asked how old they were and they were invariably younger than her by quite a margin! For a long time age seemed to pass her by and she had a great ability to relate to all generations young or old. Gran had a great memory and was always a teller of great stories. As far back as I can remember she always had a tale to tell and even though over the years we began to hear stories that wed heard before we never tired of them, she told them so well. She never forgot a birthday and even in her later years we always got a birthday card and a Christmas card. Even when it became difficult for her to write the cards kept coming She always had a sympathetic ear when something weighed heavily on your mind and always gave wise advice when it was called for. She was incredibly approachable and was a very loving and caring grandmother. Well all miss her, a lot. The funeral was followed by the burial at Brackley Cemetery. A lone piper played Mull of Kintyre and Highland Cathederal as Muriel was taken to her final resting place back in Carradale. Without doubt Muriel lived life to the full and thoroughly enjoyed her life in Carradale. She was well liked and respected and had many good friends in the Carradale community.

Jewellery Makers and Shop

WallisHunter Jewellery, International Jewellery Scottish Designer Jewellery, Pewterware Proper Pottery, Tiles, Cards, Baby Presents & other Gifty Things! It just gets better
Web: www.wallishunter-jewellery.com Carradale, By Campbeltown. Argyll

Tel/Fax 01583 431 683

TRIBUTE TO MURIEL CARRIER

I have known Muriel and the family all my life, playing with her children when I was a child and growing up with them, especially in the Sixties which seems an eternity ago. (over 50 years). Muriel and her husband Ken settled in Portrigh at the Row where as she said to her family, she spent the happiest days of her life Muriel played her part in our community life by being involved in many different organizations, she is fondly remembered to this day for her part in the Playgroup, ferrying the children to the hall in the back of her Volkswagen Polo and singing along with them and reading stories. Lots of the children remember her little box of sweets full of dolly mixture. We cannot think of Muriel without mentioning her dogs, who were faithfully looked after and walked by Muriel come rain, hail or snow. It is with pride that she is remembered still today, which speaks volumes of her service. She also played chauffeur to her foursome of friends, namely Margot Ferguson, Christine Paterson, Nan Loudon and Elspeth Reid, sadly she was the last survivor. Muriel was active delivering Meals on Wheels when as a matter of fact she was older than the most people she delivered to. I could go on, but I would need at least half an hour. There is so much to tell which I am sure you already know. Her Faith in her Saviour was shown by her, as she worshipped here faithfully as often as possible and supported our Church. A sad loss to her was the early passing of her beloved daughter Jill, whose ashes were scattered up Rhonadale glen surrounded by her family. Her legacy will live on in our community in Carradale. Matthew M Ramsay.

THE TABLE SALE

With two one-act plays on the evening of Saturday the 21st of April and a seventeen table sale in the morning and early afternoon, Carradale Village Hall should have seen one of its busiest Spring days. Unfortunately the turnout was a little down on earlier events. Crafts-people selling their wares, volunteers supporting charities or residents trying to reduce their carbon commitment, may well have gone home with a feeling that despite only just covering their costs, they had the satisfaction of knowing that every little helps to keep the Hall on a healthy financial footing. Photo courtesy of M.P.

DAWN TARTAN WALK

CHRISTIAN AID NEWS

Saddell and Carradale Church had a soup and sandwich lunch following the Church AGM and made 127.50 for Christian Aid; a very good result - thanks to everyone involved.

MARYS MEALS
To date Argyll and Bute Council Meals Service staff have made over 6,700 for Mary's meals with 10p going from every meal - more being generously added by Carradale Primary School Fund. S.R. The organisers and walkers back in 2010 when they raised over 1100. We would like to thank everyone who has sponsored or taken part in The Dawn Tartan Walk in the past few years, unfortunately, due to other commitments, we are unable to organise the walk this year. Irene, Heather and Jos. [Goat note: well done to you all for your hard work and fund-raising over the years for McMillan Cancer Support and Relief]

HYDRO GOODWILL CHEQUES

Residents of Kintyre who were without electricity for more than 48 hours in early January have now received a cheque for 75 pounds as a goodwill payment.

M.PS PROPERTY REPAIRS

01583 431161

Kilbrannan Catering

TORRISDALE CASTLE
Superb self-catering accommodation in Castle or Cottage in absolutely fabulous surroundings Ideal for a relaxed holiday. Bird watchers paradise. Colour brochure from: Carradale Campbeltown Argyll PA28 6QT
Web-site: www.torrisdalecastle.com e-mail: machall@torrisdalecastle.com

Quality catering to arouse your senses We cater for parties large and small, at your home, at your business or other location of your choice we promise you stress free entertaining. Book your Special event with us today you wont be disappointed. Visit our website: www.kilbrannancatering.co.uk

See Smell

Savour

TELEPHONE 01583 431233

Telephone Anne on 01583 431581 or Jennifer on 01583 431632

LOCAL ELECTIONS
The local election on May 3rd returned the same councillors who have served the East Kintyre Area for the past five years. Only one councillor gained a stage one vote, Donald Kelly (Con), others had to go to the fourth, fifth or seventh stage. Significantly South Kintyre had no Labour candidate and this, with Mr Kellys Kintyre First stand, may have made his election unusual given the electorates disenchantment with the Westminster Government. Anne Horn (SNP) and John McAlpine (Ind) had to endure a fourth stage recalculation, John Semple (SNP) went to a fifth and Rory Colville a seventh. What is most unfortunate is that the long-serving councillors have worked hard during the last session and didnt deserve the adverse association with national politics. G.P. HOW YOUR VOTE WAS COUNTED The type of voting system used in this election was a proportional voting system & is called the Single Transferable Vote. WHO IS ELECTED? To be elected a candidate must receive a set amount of votes known as the quota. The quota number depends on how many people voted in your area and the number of seats to be filled. The votes are counted in stages. STAGE ONE: First choices are counted. Anyone who has enough first choices to reach the quota is elected. If all the council seats for your area are filled, there is no more counting. STAGE TWO (if needed): Any votes received over the quota are not needed by the elected candidate and so are transferred proportionally to the second choice on the ballot paper. If not enough candidates have then reached the quota, the candidate with the lowest number of votes is excluded and all of their votes are passed to the next choice on the ballot papers. Anyone who reaches the quota is elected. Further stages (if needed): This process is repeated

SPONSORED SLIM
IN AID OF THE RED CROSS IN CARRADALE: MAY - AUGUST An introductory session was held in Carradale Surgery on Thursday 10th May 2012 8pm. There will be monthly group sessions with advice and support and weekly weigh ins at Carradale Surgery times by appointment. Look after yourself and support the Red Cross. G.McI.

DIAMOND JUBILEE CELEBRATION

A few like-minded villagers are organising an evening to celebrate the Queen Elizabeths Diamond Jubilee. The Village Hall committee are very kindly letting us use the Hall free, as the event is for the whole village to enjoy! We will create posters to go up around the village within a few weeks. Basically it will be held on Tuesday 5th June 2012 ln Carradale Village Hall from 7pm to 10pm. Everyone is welcome to attend and details will be on the village notice boards soon. J.McK.

A SHEENANNEICAN EVENT
It is not often that two Carradale celebrities are seen at opposite ends of a three-foot long cheque, but the Campbeltown Courier of Thursday 4th May carried a photograph of Anne Currie presenting a cheque for 320 from Kintyre Crafters to Sheena Ramsay, Chairwoman of the the Campbeltown Branch of MacMillan Cancer Support - the result of a Craft Fair held in The Argyll Hotel over the Easter weekend. This is not the first time this year that Sheena has had the privilege of accepting a financial donation on behalf of MacMillan Cancer Support; hopefully in the coming months many others will follow. G.P.

KINTYRE INITIATIVE MEETING

EXTRACT FROM THE MINUTES OF FRIDAY, 27 APRIL 2012 KINTYRE WAY John Bakes informed the group of further funding which should enable it to function until September. He reported that a full Business Case had been prepared and submitted to Argyll and Bute Council. A further application had been made to Coastal Communities. John stated that the recent geo-cashing weekend had been attended by approximately 70 people. The path on the Kintyre Way had been diverted Torrisdale Castle Saddell. Alan Galbraith informed the group that Network Carradale now had a mountain bike centre. He put forward the suggestion of liaison with Kintyre Way in regards utilising the bikes and buggies. Alan detailed the recent LEADER funding received and advised on a forthcoming meeting between architects and the Carradale Harbour group to decide on the future development of the harbour in Carradale.

AN ELECTION APOLOGY
The Editor apologises for allocating Saddell (north of the burn) Torrisdale, Carradale and villages up to Tarbert in Ward 1(South Kintyre) & conversely Peninver and Saddell (south of the burn) in Ward 2 (Kintyre & the Islands); they should have been reversed. He also apologises for the absence of other election pamphlets - they didnt arrive!

THE NETWORK PARTY

Following the award of 29,200 grant towards the establishment of the Carradale Cycle Trail and Mountain Bike Hire facility, members and friends of Network Carradale Limited were working hard at the Centre again on Local Election Day, Thursday 3rd of May. Lets hope that the when the new cycle and mountain bike facilities open in 2013 they attract an enthusiastic response from visitors and residents. G.P. See the Phytophthora ramorum warning on page 8.

Servicing Motor and Commercial vehicles, Repairing & Servicing Garden machinery & Outboards

JOHNNY DURNAN
Garden maintenance, Grass cutting Hedge trimming & Fencing

ORGANIC TANNERY & CRAFTY SHEEP SHOP

Sweaters, cardigans, belts, handbags, slippers, mugs, soft toys and so much more. A sheepskin rug is a touch of luxury at any time of the year. Try one on your new wooden floor, beside your bed, in your favourite armchair or in the car - pelt up & belt up at the same time!

TORRISDALE CASTLE
ALL YEAR ROUND GIFTS

Small building work undertaken

GIVE ME A CALL ON 431365

CARRADALES ODD JOB MAN
4

TELEPHONE 01583 431233

Need a repair or a small job done? Cant get a tradesman to come out?

Phone KeeF
01583 431614 07786 838996
Your local handy-man who wont let you down & wont charge the earth

DIY Tiling Joinery Fencing Decking Shelving Decorating Path laying Domestic repairs Dry-stone walling Flat-pack assembly

TOMMY MILLAR
TRAVEL
COUNSELLOR

For all your Travel and Holiday Arrangements put your trust in your own Travel Adviser

TOMMY MILLAR Tel: 0845 0587589

e-mail tommy.millar@travel counsellors.com www.travelcounsellors .co.uk/tommy.millar

No job too small

GOAT BUNNY REPORT

The morning weather was a bit wet, but by midday it turned out a lovely sunny day bringing a good turnout to the annual bunny hunt organised by the Forestry Commission. Numbers were up on last year with 121 entrants. Thanks to Barry (forest manager for our area) and his fellow workers and to mention a bit of help from ex forester Jim McAlister. Well done chaps for keeping everyone happy once again and a thanks to Jos in the tearoom who I believe was run off her feet at one stage, must be that lovely home baking and soups. J.D.

The CCC Torrisdale Terrors

Some of the CCC winners and the judge

TWO ONE-ACT PLAYS

Kintyre is fortunate in having a number of very successful drama groups and when two offer a performance in Carradale on the same night, audiences can be assured of first class entertainment. On Saturday 21st April Peninver Players put on Our James by Ros Moruzzi and Carradale Drama Club, with only two thespians available for the winter and spring production, offered The Beach Hut by Mark Rees. Each company has an outstanding record and the performance of the Beach Hut allowed Pauline Burrows, a departing member of the Carradale Club, to demonstrate the full range of her talents for probably the last time in Kintyre. Both plays were comedies, with sexual overtones and inuendos, and both won prizes at recent drama festivals. Our James, performed by Peninver players had a single set of two halves, with a permanent sitting room on one side with the other half changing in time from an office to a Citizens Advice Bureau, a hospital records office and finally a prison probation office as the play progressed. The main character, in search of her sperm donating father, moved seamlessly between the sections, each being lit and unlit as required - until the power cut. Amazingly they carried on regardless finishing in almost complete darkness. The Hall curtains were then drawn back to make use of the fading light, a quick raffle followed and the scene changed to the seaside. With a very striking beach hut and two seaside caricature cut-outs, one on either side of the stage, the two performers put their heads through the traditional apertures to speak asides about their other half. The theme of the play was a couple on their usual seaside holiday reflecting on 40 years of marriage. The mood moved from violent to passive and the ending was very dramatic but perhaps predictable. Both plays received a great ovation from the audience; congratulations are due all round for excellent performances, especially in such adverse conditions. A most enjoyable evenings entertainment. M.P.
5

THE TASTE OF EAGLES

The first white-tailed eagle chick of the year at the Mull Eagle Watch hide has been spotted by rangers. It's hopeful that a second egg is in the nest and that the proud parents, Iona & Fingal, will have another chick to look after in couple of days. For the past 38 days, the adult birds have taken turns in incubating the eggs, sitting very low on the nest. First indications that something had changed was on Tuesday this week when the female was sitting higher up on the nest. She was also fidgeting and fussing with the eggs so it was clear that a new arrival was coming. Sue Dewar, White-Tailed Eagle Ranger with Mull & Iona Ranger Service said: "We are thrilled to bits at the news and we are keeping our fingers crossed that all goes well with the remaining egg. It was on Wednesday afternoon that we first witnessed Iona, the female adult, bending her head down and gently feeding the chick. Tiny morsels of food were torn off by her huge beak and were delicately fed to her new chick. Iona was also very careful to keep her talons well out of the way so as not to put the chick in any danger. The new arrival is great news for the birds but also for Mull as so many people come to witness these massive and magnificent birds." Fingal, the male, was not seen during the afternoon the new chick arrived and was most likely to be off hunting to feed his new family. If the female takes a break from her new duties the male adult will take over until she returns. If there is a second egg it could hatch in the next couple of days, as eagles lay eggs two or three days apart, but sit from the time the first egg is laid. Dave Sexton, RSPB Scotland's Mull Officer added: "Whilst breaking out of the egg is one of the toughest parts of an eagle's life, the next 10 days is also critical as they must be brooded by an adult at all times to avoid hypothermia. So Mull Eagle Watch and the CCTV will still be running 24/7 to ensure Fingal & Iona and their new family are not disturbed in any way" Mull Eagle Watch is run by a partnership consisting of Forestry Commission Scotland, Mull & Iona Community Trust, RSPB Scotland, Scottish Natural Heritage and Strathclyde Police. Part of the income from trips to the hide is put into a fund which is available to the islanders for local community projects. A recent survey reported that the white-tailed eagles alone bring in 5m annually to Mull's economy, which is hugely important to the island. All over the island, Mull Eagle Watch's dedicated team of volunteers have been watching the eagles' nests to ensure that no-one gets too close as the birds will leave the nest if they are disturbed by anyone - deliberately or inadvertently. Because the Mull Eagle Watch are constantly on the lookout for egg thieves, nests are watched for 24 hours a day and this year CCTV is also being used with other high-tech equipment to back up our volunteers. Once the chicks are hatched there are still problems from the very occasional photographer who wants to get closer than is comfortable for the birds, and two such people were prosecuted last year for ignoring instructions not to go too close. Fortunately on that occasion the chick survived, but only because volunteers and police reacted quickly. The hide at Glen Seilisdeir is open Monday to Friday from April to the end of September, running two trips a day. White-tailed eagle rangers will tell the story of the eagles' extinction and subsequent reintroduction, and then escort visitors to an outdoor viewing hide just 300m from the nest. Booking is essential on 01680 812556. Steve Williams Senior Press Officer Forestry Commission Scotland 231 Corstorphine Road Edinburgh EH12 7AT

HARDWARE STORES
15 LONGROW CAMPBELTOWN
Cleaning materials, House wares, Ironmongery & Hardware, Hand tools, Power tools, Key cutting, Locks, Wooden mouldings

mmM m M mm m m Mmm mM mm mM m m mm We make the best Scottish tablet you have ever tasted
Stuck for ideas for a Gift? Then look no further than our

DIY supplies

01586 552954
CARRADALE VILLAGE HALL
ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING WEDNESDAY 18TH APRIL 2012 Attendance List: Committee Members Lindsey Mercer, Jean Campbell, David Mercer, Catriona Trott, Robert Abernethy, Val Cannell, Margaret Gruber, Elizabeth McMillan, Edna Paterson, Sheena Ramsay, Eleanor Sloan, Alan Walker, Isobel Williamson,. Hall keeper, Brian Gee. Members of the Community: 8 (Full attendance list available). 1. APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE; Carol Abernethy, Michael Foreman, Tony and Margaret Leighton, Donald and Mary Macalister Hall, Matthew Ramsay. 2. MINUTES OF THE AGM 6TH MAY 2011/EGM 7TH SEPTEMBER 2011 Minutes of the Annual General Meeting held on the 6th of May 2011 and the Extraordinary General Meeting held on the 7th of September 2011 were read and approved. Proposed: David Mercer Seconded: Margaret Gruber (AGM) Proposed: Alan Walker Seconded: Elizabeth McMillan (EGM) 3. MATTERS ARISING There was a question from the floor about how the recommendation (noted in minutes from the EGM) that a monthly accounting reconciliation be done had been met. The chairperson replied that a monthly reconciliation had been done with Stuart Irvine, (auditor) and the treasurer. Two suggestions from the floor were a) that guidelines for the role of each office bearer would be a good idea to help new committee members and b) that there should be a monthly statement of accounts showing in detail how much each function had made and the part that individuals had contributed. All totals to be made clear. A request was made from the floor that the handle inside the disabled toilet be checked. The answer was that this handle is the same as the one on the outside of the door. 4. CHAIRPERSON'S REPORT BUILDINGS At the beginning of the year a 'Buildings Sub-Committee' was appointed to work with the hall keeper in keeping abreast of repairs and maintenance and they have been kept busy. The exceptionally wet weather that we experienced over the winter months highlighted a number of deficiencies to the fabric of the building which have resulted in a number of incidences of water damage. Wherever possible repairs have been carried out but in a number of cases repairs have been dependent on a prolonged period of dry weather and are therefore ongoing. It is our aim however to have the building completely watertight before winter.

WONDERFUL SELECTION OF HAMPERS & GIFT BOXES Order on-line www.scottishtabletcompany.co.uk or Build your own Hamperfor brochure and order form Telephone: 01583 431581
I would like to propose a vote of thanks to the members of the subcommittee (Tony Leighton, Alan Walker and Donald Macalister Hall) and also to the Hall-keeper, Brian Gee for his vigilance in identifying problems as they arise and for keeping the hall in excellent condition. On a brighter note a number of improvements have been made: (i) the installation of a drain at the entrance to the car park (ii) access to the disabled toilet has been improved with the installation of a sliding door (iii) the lines of the badminton court have been replaced (iv) a new water heater has been installed in the small kitchen and (v) a first aid box has been installed in the large kitchen I am also pleased to report that we have obtained a PRS licence which removes any grey areas there may have been with regard to the playing of music in the hall. CLUBS For the most part the various clubs continue to flourish and there has been a welcome addition in the form of Scottish Country Dancing. This now means that the main hall is in use every weekday evening. With regard to the clubs there is however a possible downside in that some members of the Monday Club are dependent on the Red Cross Ambulance for transport, a service which we are all aware continues to be under threat. PRICE INCREASES As you will see from the accounts the cost of energy for heating and lighting etc. continues to increase. This has meant revision of the pricing structure for the hall. From the first of March this year the price for seniors using the hall rose to 1.50 and the price for juniors to 1. In addition the price for hiring accommodation in the hall has increased by about 15%. EVENTS A number of regular fund raising events have taken place during the year: (I) The Carradale Quiz (ii) The Christmas Quiz (iii) The Christmas Quizzle Between them these events raised over 1400 for hall funds. As you know these events are organised by Tony and Margaret Leighton who put an enormous amount of work in on them every year. I would therefore like to record a vote of thanks to Tony and Margaret for all their efforts on behalf of the hall. In addition a table sale was held in November which was relatively successful and is to be followed up with yet another sale organised for this coming Saturday. I hope I'll see you all there!!! On the subject of fundraising the 100 Club continues to flourish and I would like to record a vote of thanks to Elizabeth McMillan for all her efforts in this respect. I am hoping that Elizabeth will bring us all up to date with the 100 Club later in the meeting.

41 Longrow, Campbeltown Argyll PA28 6ER

Tel: 01586 554727 Fax: 01586 551727

THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND

Where people matter

TOM GRANT
PARTNERSHIP
A R C H I T E C T S

24 Argyll St. Lochgilphead Argyll PA31 8NE

P.O.BOX 13, 11 CASTLEHILL CAMPBELTOWN ARGYLL PA28 6AP

Tel: 01546 603050 Mobile 07770 538 661 Tom Grant Dip.,Arch., R.I.B.A., R.I.A.S
6

CARRADALE BRANCH OPEN THURSDAY 10am - 11am

J. H. Hooper B.Sc., B.V.M & S., M.R.C.V.S

VETERINARY SURGEON
is pleased to provide veterinary care for your pets
Please telephone 01586 552427 for an appointment UGADALE COTTAGE by CAMPBELTOWN

KENNEDYS SHOE SHOP

50-52 Longrow Campbeltown. Tel 01586 552644
Walking shoes, Dress shoes. Walking boots, Dress boots. All your footwear needs under one roof. Ladies & Gents wide fitting specialists. Childrens fitting service.

24 HOUR EMERGENCY SERVICE

LETTINGS Lettings too continue to flourish, events ranging from dances and discos; fayres; drama performances; music performances; and Community and Family celebrations including a Wedding Reception. I am pleased to report that the hall has been booked for two further weddings this summer, and we also have one booking for 2013. The library has been used on a number of occasions for Home Start Events and Saddell and Carradale Guild have been holding their fortnightly meetings there. Finally I would like to thank all the members of the committee for giving generously of their time and for their support and hard work throughout the year. 5. TREASURER'S REPORT Accounts for this year were audited without problems thanks to Stuart Irvine and Alan Walker. Thanks were extended to Stuart Irvine in particular for whom this may be the last year he will be auditing the accounts. Drawing attention to the balance sheet, it is clear that oil and insurance costs have risen. The income from the Hall has also risen but only slightly. A breakdown of all weekly incomes was produced. Income from Scottish Country Dancing is included in the lets, not in the breakdown mentioned. In summary the income and expenditure are almost equal. Assets are in the sum of 12,372. If there is no major call on funds this will be sufficient but relies on the Wind Farm Trust. Fund raising is also needed. The treasurer produced a table of charges at the meeting. These charges reflect the increase recently implemented. There was an objection from the floor to the amount listed on the table. The committee had agreed to a 15% increase but the charges for dinner and dances seemed to be much more than 15% and there were some errors in the charges for dances and discos. The chairperson interceded and said that a wedding charge allows for three days access to the Hall and exclusive use. The new committee will have to revisit the matter of the Hall charges. 6. ADOPTION OF ACCOUNTS 2012/2013 Proposed: Brian Gee Seconded: Sheena Ramsay 7. 100 CLUB REPORT Elizabeth Macmillan, 100 club secretary, reported that during the year 2010/2011 there were 108 members. For the year 2011/2012 there were 103 members. The profit for 2011/2012 is over 600 allowing for expenses of postage and no expenses for printing which has been done by the treasurer. Each member has paid 12 and 51 is made up of donations in some cases where cheques have not been cashed. To join the 100 club it will be necessary to pay again in July. There was a question from the floor about whether the income from the 100 club could be apportioned to fit in with the financial year. The secretary pointed out that the time was chosen originally to enable visitors on holiday to join the Club.

K CLARKS LOTUS ROHDE

8. ELECTION OF OFFICE BEARERS 2012/2013 Lindsey Mercer and David Mercer stepped down as Chairperson and Treasurer respectively Alan Walker was nominated for the position of Chairman by Jean Campbell. This was seconded by Robert Abernethy. Jean Campbell was nominated for the position of Vice-chairperson by Alan Walker and seconded by Catriona Trott Celia Holgate was nominated for the position of Treasurer by Malcolm Trott and seconded by Jean Campbell. Catriona Trott was nominated for the position of Secretary by Celia Holgate and seconded by David Mercer. At this point in the meeting Lindsey Mercer relinquished the Chair to Alan Walker who extended thanks to Lindsey Mercer and David Mercer for their work as Chairperson and Treasurer. The Chairman stated that the present auditors would need to be approached to ascertain whether they wished to continue as auditors. If they did not wish to be re-appointed further election for auditors would need to be done. The meeting mandated to trust the committee to appoint auditors if necessary. 9. ANY OTHER BUSINESS: TABLE SALE 21ST APRIL 2012 17 tables have been booked and the craft table will be added to the list. Arrangements to be confirmed for refreshments to be served on the day, (discussion arranged for after this meeting). 10. NEXT COMMITTEE MEETING Meeting arranged for 2nd of May 2012 at 18.30 (nominees needed to form village hall committee). This meeting concluded at 20.22

COMMUNITY COUNCILS
COMMUNITY PLANNING FUNDING (Extract) As part of the budget agreement for 2012/13 additional financial support of 10,000 per annum has been allocated to community councils. This report sets out proposals for the disbursement of this additional discretionary funding. A supplementary grant to be paid in addition to the existing administration grant, at a rate of 0.10p per elector, upon submission of the previous years financial accounts. Assuming full take-up, this would cost approximately 6,830 per annum. 2.(a) The remainder of the additional funding, 3,170 would be used to fund the payment of mileage costs associated with attendance at the LACPG meetings at a rate of 0.45p and/or reimbursement of any public transport fares (subject to budget being available, and to appropriate guidance being put in place to give regard to use of video conferencing and car sharing). 2.(b) The first 20 miles of any round trip not being liable to payment of expenses.

Logs For Sale

The Complete Service
HAMILTON BROS. (ENGINEERING) LTD. Groundcare & Agricultural Equipment Sales,Service & Hire. MOT & MOT Repairs
Local Service Depot - Roading, Campbeltown. Tel: 01586
MASSEY FERGUSON

BROTHERS

Bulk loads, bags & kindlers,

cut, split & ready for the fire
Contact Rob Jones on: 01586 830133 after 6pm mobile: 07507327410 7am - 6pm e-mail: robamod@hotmail.co.uk

Head Office: Greenock Road, Bishopton PA7 SAP Tel: 01505 862010. Fax: 01505 862221 Email: info@hamiltonbros.co.uk Web Site: www.hamiltonbros.co.uk

PATERSONS BAKERY & POST OFFICE

Licensed Grocers, Bakers & Newsagent

Carpet, Upholstery & Window Cleaning Service

Have your favourite photographs enlarged to A3 or A4 size

Try our freshly baked morning rolls, crusty bread, tea bread and cakes, all baked in our old-fashioned stone oven

TELEPHONE 01583 431725

THE SHOP IS OPEN
Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Friday & Saturday 8am to 1pm & 2pm to 5pm. Thursday 8am to 1pm. Sundays: One hour only from 10am to 11am THE POST OFFICE IS OPEN Monday to Saturday 9am-1pm
game, but most seemed to prefer the disembarking ease and comfort afforded by lower deck seats. The retiring driver thanked regular travellers from Grogport for their attempt to keep passengers mentally alert and helping to keep the bus on the road, and, unlike last year, the driver and conductor were warmly commended for seeing the company through a difficult period. Once again the hand-working depot inspector gained plaudits for the manner in which he ensured the smooth running of facilities, and for his watchful eye on the buss road-worthiness. The bus companys safety representative, added a report on the 100mph Club which invites investments from those who wish to accelerate their credit worthiness; she, in turn, thanked a previous booking agent for her help in running the lottery. The new driver, signing off duty at 8.22pm, asked for timetable and rota preferences, inviting village organisations to confirm the names of representative passengers as, last year, at least one had physical problems in mounting the bus and enjoying the ride.

Mobile 07799395709

HALLING INTO 2013

THE BUS
THE ANNUAL GENERAL, A RETIRED CONDUCTORS DELIRIUM As is often the case in cities, waiting for a bus can be a frustrating business. Even with a highly organised transport system and the best will in the world, much depends on outside factors - heavy traffic, accidents, road closures and, with marathons and certainly more than one nations fair share of Olympic events, there are bound to be diversions and transport chaos in 2012. Last years Hall AGM was rather like waiting for a bus, - you wait ages for one and then two come along in the same year. This years outing was somewhat different. Compared with the rumoured problems on last years journeys, everything was well time-tabled, calmly driven and the Hall bus returned to the depot undamaged, without litter and with a minimum of fuss. However it must be said that the proposals to alter fares seemed like asking for trouble from passengers on the top deck, with comments from a respected peripatetic caterer and a senior member of the caring profession, but further consideration may be given to ticket prices by management in the coming months. A decision by last years driver and conductor not to take the bus out again this year, meant there was an opportunity for the traditional AGM game of musical chairs. Although the company secretary tried to move from her seat, tempted to enter the world of high finance by becoming the conductor, she was discouraged by a new terpsichorean passenger from Torrisdale who thought that standing at the foot of the stairs gave her a firmer control of afares; the company secretary remains in her post. The vice chair also stays in her position as relief driver and watches goings-on upstairs and down from a seat at the top of the outside staircase. Fortunately a retiring local lawyer, following the example set at the time of the 1926 General Strike by ladies, students and volunteering professionals, offered to act as temporary driver until a permanent replacement is found. Other passengers were tempted to join the

PHYTOPHTHORA RAMORUM IN CARRADALE

It will come as no surprise to readers of the Antler, and to residents with affected palm and other trees, that the Forestry Commission is at last issuing information for those who use forestry roads. Stuart Irvine has been asked to publicise the following guidance. Ed. Forestry Commission Scotland has discovered a plant disease called Phytophthora ramorum in Rhododendrons in Carradale. It has also been found in needles under some Larch trees. This disease can and will kill trees so we will be removing the infected Rhododendrons quickly and developing a plan to remove the infected area of Larches over the summer. Forestry Commission Scotland would like to reassure you that: Phytophthora ramorum is not harmful to humans or animals Public Access can continue However, the disease can be spread via footwear and bicycle wheels. Therefore, you can help contain the disease by: Staying on the paths and tracks (dogs too!) and away for any areas which are taped off Brushing off any loose mud and dirt from your footwear, clothing and bike before you leave Thoroughly cleaning your footwear (and bike) at home before your next visit Leaving wood and plant material where it is Forestry Commission Scotland aim to minimise the disturbance from this unfortunate outbreak to a minimum and look forward to your assistance with this matter. Many thanks! More information on Phytophthora ramorum can be found at: http:// www.forestry.gov.uk/pramorum If you need further information please contact: Forestry Commission Scotland, Whitegates, Lochgilphead, Argyll, PA31 8RS email: west.argyll.fd@forestry.gsi.gov.uk Tel: 01546 602518

Landscaping and maintenance Patios and Paving Drainage and Fencing Turfing and Monoblocking All tree work
Free estimates All excavations undertaken

Tel: 01583 431362 Mobile: 07814767813

Established

1989

CARRADALE GARDEN SERVICES

8

CARRADALE GOLF CLUB

Welcomes visitors
Juniors Adult

Round 8.00 17.00 Daily 10.00 20.00 Weekly 80.00 Two weeks 105.00 Country 40.00 132.00 (May play in Club Competitions) Local Member 150.00 Affiliated Club Members 8.00

For further information contact The Secretary, Margaret Richardson, 2 Old Schoolhouse Carradale, PA28 6QJ Tel: 01583 431788

CARRADALE GOLF CLUB EVENTS

THE CORDINER CUP
Carradale Golf Club recently held a very successful Easter Texas Scramble which is now to be known as The Cordiner Cup and will be held annually. The competition has been sponsored by Dr Carolyn Cordiner and family in memory of her late husband Dr Jim Cordiner, who was an ardent supporter and member of the club. Fourteen teams of four players took part in the 9 hole competition and the winners of The Cordiner Cup were Stuart Walker, Jack Hally, Laura McGeachy and Murray Headrick. M.R.

INTERCLUB DAY
Carradales Interclub Day, an annual event, was played on a sunny blustery day. Twenty six ladies representing Machrihanish, Dunaverty, Tarbert and the host club enjoyed an excellent afternoons golf with Ailie McBrayne (Dunaverty) and Margaret Robertson (Machrihanish) winning the Scratch competition, scoring 82. The Handicap competition was won by Margaret Campbell (Carradale) and Margaret Barr (Dunaverty) with a net 63. Carradale Ladies provided sandwiches and cakes prior to the start of the competition, and Carradale Hotel was the venue for the after-match meal. Scratch Winners Ailie MCBrayne and Margaret Robertson Handicap Winners Margaret Barr and Margaret Campbell

APRIL MEDAL
Winner: Anne Storm 37 points; Runner Up: Isobel White 32 points

MONTHLY DRAW
The prizes in the monthly draw for March and April are as follows:March April 1st 30 Colin Campbell Ryan McConnachie 2nd 18 Emma Neilson Gillian Kitson 3rd 12 Shannon Donnelly Evan McConnachie 4th 6 Bill Naismith Ann Storm J.S.I

MORTON TROPHY
Winner: Margaret Richardson; Runner-Up: Sylvia Irvine M.R.

LADIES GOLF TASTER DAY

This was a great success with 16 ladies of all ages coming along to have a go. Dede Robertson, the captain, welcomed everyone and handed over to Margaret Campbell who gave them a short lesson on how to swing a club. The ladies then had a chance to go out on the course and hit some balls. This proved to be great fun and some very impressive shots were hit! The weather was perfect and the afternoon was rounded off with fruit punch, kindly donated by the Hotel, and a glass of wine provided by the Ladies Section of the Golf Club. We hope to have a similar afternoon in the near future. D.R.

LADIES POLICE TASTER DAY

Saddell and Carradale Guild members had a conducted tour of Campbeltown Police Station on Tuesday 8th May, assisted by two of the stations twelve female police officers. After seeing all that the station had to offer, they resisted the opportunity to enjoy an overnight stay and one of the delicious pre-packed meals offered to guests, and resorted to high tea at the upgraded Ardshiel Hotel. The following day two police officers were seen visiting a number of local houses making informal enquiries about something heavy falling from the sky. While there is obviously no connection, one wonders if............. Ed.

R.N.L.I. BONUS BALL WINNERS

7th April C. Mckinnon 14th April M. Jeffrey 21st April R. Grant 28th April R. Somerville May I thank everyone who has played, won or lost since April 2011 until April this year,we have managed to raise 1,220. My thanks to The Semples,Tom Adams, and Janeta King for all their help. M.O.

The new Diesel/electric 3008 Hybrid 4 is in at the Campbeltown Motor Company. Tel: 01586 553200
9

A WIND TURBINE STUDY

AN EXTRACT FROM AN ABC EXECUTIVE MINUTE OF APRIL 19TH Members will be aware of the continued demand to site wind energy projects of various scales in Argyll and Bute. To assist the consenting process work has now been completed on a wind energy landscape capacity study for Argyll and Bute, excluding the National Park. This study has been undertaken by professional landscape consultants also contains a design guide for the siting of smaller scale turbines. Jointly commissioned by the council (5k) and SNH (60k) the study will be used to inform the policy of the emerging LDP that will be subject to extensive public consultation. A workshop on how to use the study is planned to be held on the 20th of April in Inveraray. A wide range of stakeholders have been invited including renewable energy industry representatives, landowners and community representatives ARGYLL & BUTE LANDSCAPE WIND ENERGY CAPACITY STUDY SUMMARY 1.1 The Council together with Scottish Natural Heritage has commissioned Consultant Landscape Architects to prepare an Argyll and Bute Landscape Wind Energy Capacity Study. The study provides technical information which will be used to help develop the wind-farm/wind turbine policies and associated spatial framework in the proposed Local Development Plan (LDP). In addition the study provides new guidance on the siting of smaller scale (up to 50 metres) turbines throughout Argyll and Bute. An executive summary of the study is attached as Appendix A. RECOMMENDATIONS 2.1 That the Council adopts the Argyll and Bute Landscape Wind Energy Capacity Study as a technical background document. 2.2 That the aforementioned study be used to help inform decision making in relation to planning applications submitted for wind energy proposals; and also inform the development of new policy contained in the proposed Local Development Plan including spatial guidance for on shore Wind energy developments. 2.3 That it should be noted that any new policy in relation to wind energy be subject to further Council approval and extensive consultation as part of the Local Development Plan process. 2.4 That approval be given to hold a workshop after the May elections to help introduce the study to a wide range of stakeholders including potential developers, landowners and community representatives. BACKGROUND 3.1 Scottish Planning Policy requires Local Development Plans to include a spatial framework of wind energy developments over 20 megawatts, as well as give consideration as to how developments of less than this will be assessed against development plan policy. The SPP and associated Scottish Government Advice Notes requires consideration to be given to landscape and cumulative impacts as part of this process. 3.2 This study considers the sensitivity of landscape character types on the mainland of Argyll and Bute in relation to wind turbines up to 130m height. The sensitivity of larger islands and National Scenic Areas (NSAs) within Argyll and Bute has also been assessed for wind turbines up to 50m height. The assessment considers key sensitivities related to landscape character, visual amenity and on the value placed on the landscape in the form of scenic designations and other recognised interests. The NSAs are assessed on the basis of their identified Special Qualities. The sensitivity assessment considers potential cumulative issues associated with existing and consented wind farm developments. 3.3 The aim of this study is to identify landscape and visual sensitivities at a Council wide scale for use in the consideration and determination of further proposals for wind farm developments in Argyll and Bute. It is important to stress that this capacity study considers only landscape and visual issues, a range of other environmental and technical issues will also require to be considered in order to draw up a spatial framework and Supplementary Planning Guidance (SPG) for wind farm development. 3.4 The study has involved adopting a systematic approach to the consideration of landscape, the key tasks of which included: Identifying existing, consented and proposed windfarm developments Review of existing landscape character studies and definition of landscape character types to be used in the assessment. Defining the landscape and visual sensitivity criteria to be used. Defining landscape values such as designations and other recognized landscape and visual interests to be used in the study. Fieldwork to assess the sensitivities Providing guidance on siting of smaller turbines, as well as generic guidance on siting and design of wind energy developments. Providing an overview of landscape and visual sensitivities across the region and recommendations on strategic landscape and visual considerations 3.5 The capacity study has principally been based on the landscape characterisation work set out in the Landscape assessment of Argyll and the Firth of Clyde (1996) undertaken by Environmental Resources Management for SNH. Review of this study was undertaken in the field and some revisions were made to landscape character types and their classi-

Telephone 01583 431725

fication for the purposes of this capacity study. Separate sensitivity assessments have been undertaken for the National Scenic Areas (NSAs) lying wholly within Argyll and Bute. 3.6 Five scales of wind turbine developments have been considered; Large Scale (80 to 130 metres high to blade tip), Medium (between 50 and 80 metres), Small medium (35 to 50 metres) and Small where blade tip is between 20 and 35 metres high. The sensitivity of the various landscapes, to the different scales of wind turbine developments was scored on a five point scale of High, High-medium, Medium, Medium-low and Low against landscape, visual amenity and landscape values categories. An overall judgement of sensitivity for each landscape character type/NSA was then reached following consideration of landscape, visual and values ratings. 3.7 It is evident that the existing pattern of larger scale commercial wind-farm development in Argyll and Bute is mainly found in the more extensive and less settled upland landscape character types of the Upland Forest Moor Mosaic (6) and the Craggy Upland (7), and to fairly limited sites within the Steep Ridgeland and Mountains (1) character type and the Knapdale Upland Forest Moor Mosaic (6b). The study found that that the uplands within Argyll and Bute were of lowest landscape and visual sensitivity. These areas include the Craggy Uplands (7) and Upland Forest Moor Mosaic (6) which offer greatest scope for the large scale developments. Both these landscape character types already feature operational and consented wind farm developments. Cumulative impacts have therefore been identified as a potential constraint in the Kintyre Peninsula, Loch Awe and Loch Fyne areas. However, the study provides guidance on how best to accommodate additional wind energy developments within these areas whilst minimising the potential cumulative impacts, as these areas are generally considered to have the greatest potential to accommodate further onshore wind energy developments. 3.8 The majority of applications for small-medium and small turbines have been within the more settled coastal landscapes and islands of Argyll and Bute. The study found that those turbines between 35 and 50 metres high could be accommodated in limited parts of more settled coastal landscapes and islands. The most acceptable locations for turbines of this size is likely to be on the more extensive hill slopes set back from more sensitive lowland areas as this will limit landscape and visual impacts. These locations will also reduce the potential for cumulative landscape and visual impacts to occur between different sizes and designs of turbines. This will become particularly important as these areas are more likely to be in demand for Feed-in Tariff related development. However, monitoring of potential cumulative effects arising from smaller turbines will need to be kept under constant review. Consideration should also be given to the detailed design of smaller turbines, in order to prevent widely varying designs leading to visual clutter in some landscapes. 3.9 The assessment of landscape capacity of National Scenic Areas to accommodate wind turbine development was limited to small-medium and small scale turbines only in recognition of the protection afforded to them (from larger scale developments in SPP). The study concluded that these nationally recognised landscapes were highly sensitive and had no scope to accommodate the small-medium scale turbines. However it concluded that small turbines below 35m would have less of an effect on some NSAs provided these were sensitively sited. CONCLUSION 4.1 This study represents a major piece of work that has been done in partnership with SNH. Currently there is considerable demand for the siting of wind turbines in Argyll and Bute. In light of this it is recommended that the landscape strategy be adopted as a technical study with regard to on shore wind energy developments and landscape issues to help inform decisions in relation to applications for on shore wind energy applications. Once approved, the study will be able to be used as non statutory planning guidance and also be used to inform future land use policy in the proposed Local Development Plan including a new spatial strategy for wind farms. Any change of policy in light of this guidance will require subsequent council approval and then be consultated on as part of the LDP process. It is also intended to hold a workshop on the 20th of April to help introduce the content of the study to a wide range of stakeholders. The main findings of the study are detailed below. Protection of the most scenic of Argyll and Butes landscapes by avoiding designated landscapes and intrusion on Inventory listed designed landscapes. Maintaining the wild-land qualities of the mountainous landscapes by directing wind farm development away from these areas and avoiding developments that could impact on the wider landscape setting and appreciation of these landscapes. Protect the special qualities of the coastal landscapes, islands and wider seascape which form an essential part of the character of Argyll and Bute, by resisting larger scale developments in the complex coastal landscapes and where they could intrude on views from roads, settlement and recreational areas (including from the sea). Follow the established pattern of larger wind farm development associated with less sensitive upland landscapes where their more extensive
10

scale can better accommodate, and provide an appropriate wider setting, to large developments. Direct larger typologies away from settled coastal and loch fringes and limit intrusion on these areas by setting smaller turbines (below 50m) at the transition with the more extensive simpler upland landscapes. Smaller turbines would form more of an incidental feature in these sensitive landscapes while larger turbines would dominate and detract. Ongoing review of cumulative effects in the Craggy Upland Landscape Typology in the Loch Awe and Loch Fyne areas and the Kintyre Upland Forest Moor Mosaic principally in terms of views from Arran, will be necessary to ascertain when capacity is close to being reached. IMPLICATIONS The Landscape Capacity Study will help to inform and provide an evidence base for the development of policy in the forthcoming Local Development Plan and associated Supplementary Planning Guidance. There is increasing interest in wind energy development across Argyll and Bute, from Developers, Communities and general public, this study will help promote informed decisions, in response to these. For further information contact: Fergus Murray Tel.01546 604293

NEW MOORINGS
Alasdair McPhee
FINANCIAL SERVICES

IFA

REVIEWING YOUR FINANCES? Areas of Financial Planning Protection - Personal, Mortgage, Business and Income. Savings / Investments - Annual ISA Allowance / Low interest rates, there are alternatives offering potentially greater Capital Growth and or Income. Pension Planning - Plans should be reviewed on a Annual Basis. Under the current Economic Climate reviewing your Finances should be seriously considered. We offer, in the privacy of your own home, a free Personal Review covering all the above, meetings can be arranged by calling:Contact numbers are 01586-552598 / 0779 857 4890 / or 0141 887 6778.
Alasdair McPhee, Financial Consultant was born in Carradale, lives and works in Campbeltown. Financial Planning Made Simple

THE CAMERA CLUB

Following Jason Standings Kintyre experience in last months Antler, and with news in the Campbeltown Courier that Carradale harbour will take another step on its transmission from historic fishing port to leisure craft stop-off point, does this postcard give credence to the possibility of moorings being grabbed by yachties escaping the drought, the Olympic Games and the Diamond Jubilee, and will visitors be tempted to follow the common local practice of not paying harbour dues, even with a secure cash box mounted at the pier specifically for the purpose?

ANNUAL DINNER & PRESENTATION OF AWARDS

This was our 11th annual dinner and was held at the Network Centre this year. The meal was excellent, as one would expect from Jos McKinnon who provided a beautifully mouth-watering buffet to everyones enjoyment with the help of Irene, Heather and Lesley; one additional pleasure was that we didnt have to tidy up after ourselves. Trish and Mike Hurst were our guests for the evening, as they had taken a great deal of time to really judge the 43 prints that were handed over to them in the middle of April. This must have been quite a challenge as I have not seen so many high quality prints sent in for several years. On the 18th of April Mike came to the Network Centre and went over each print, criticising them and giving us information on what was good and how we can improve our photographs; we all learned a great deal from his comments. All six beginners had excellent prints some were very good and our more experienced members could learn a lot from the new kids on the block; thank you Mike for your patience and expertise. At the end of the evening Chris and Martin Mears were presented with basket of flowers and a book token, as, sadly, there are moving to Berwick on Tweed. Martin has been a stalwart member of the camera club and Chris has always been a real backbone to him. We will miss them and I will miss both Martin and Chris as near-neighbours, especially when walking the dogs. Martin, please keep in touch. Christine Ritchie and her cousin from Canada were unable to attend the meal but managed to drop in so that Christine could present the Duncan Ritchie Quaich to David Byford for the best print of the year. This years camera club exhibition is to be held on Saturday the 11th and Sunday the 12th of August in Carradale Village Hall; afternoon tea is included - we hope to see you there. The full results were: Duncan Ritchie Quaich for the best print of the year, and the Wallis Hunter Quaich for the Best monochrome print: David Byford. Second best monochrome print: Julia Dancer. McLay Salver for Best colour print: Rachel Grant. Second best colour print: Margaret Richardson. Best beginners print: Alastair Bennett. Second best beginners print: Julia Dancer. Rachel S. Grant.
11

e-mail: amcphee@hotmail.com, St James Business Centre, Linwood Rd, Paisley PA3 3AT Tel: 0141 887 6778 Fax: 0141 887 6344
Alasdair McPhee Financial Services is an appointed representative of Personal Touch Financial Services Limited which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority

Principal Alasdair M. McPhee

Cert.PFS MLIA(dip)

ARTICLES, REPORTS, NEWS AND ADVERTISEMENTS WARMLY WELCOMED

TAKE-AWAY

MENU
DAILY 6pm - 8pm
Telephone Orders Welcome

All Suppers 7.95 Children's 4.95

American Style Chicken Fillet Burger* Battered Cod or Breaded Plaice* Crispy Chicken Fillet Bites. Tracy & Fiona would like to welcome you to the Munch Box - Garlic Bread, Potato Wedges, Onion Rings & Breaded Mushrooms *Excluding Chips. Bar Open Daily Homemade Chicken Curry. Quiz Night:- Thursday 8.30pm

Ashbank Hotel Carradale

En-suite rooms available with sea and golf course views Ala Carte Lunch & Evening Menus available Take away menu all items 7.95 or less Free Wifi, Car Parking, Beer Garden with stunning views Parties, Events & Outside Catering available to suit your needs

Chicken, Onion & Pepper Skewers.

Open Tuesday - Sunday for Evening Meals 6pm - 8pm

Booking advisable

Lunches & High Teas are available during School holidays and can be booked at other times

TAKE-AWAYS AVAILABLE TUESDAY TO SUNDAY

For further details please call 01583 431 650

E-mail: enquiries@ashbankhotel.com Web-site: ashbankhotel.com

Sausages. Homemade Chilli Con Carne. Smoked Sausage. Breaded Scampi. All served with Chips Extras Chips 2.00 Potato Wedges 2.50 Rice 2.50 Jacket Potato 2.50 Breaded Mushrooms 4.00 Onion Rings 2.50 Curry Sauce 2.00 Mushy Peas 1.50 Beans 1.50, Add Cheese 95p Drinks: Cans 1.10, Fruit Shoot 1.50, Tennents 2.50, Bottle of House Wine 12.50
Ala Carte Menu available as Take-Away

APRIL RAINFALL
The total rainfall for April was 109 mm. (just over 4 inches) As for it being the wettest April since records began as reported on the BBC weather forecast, our records certainly do not bear this out. We can only assume therefore that the statement as issued only applies to the south of England it certainly isnt applicable to us here in Kintyre. Over the past eleven years in April our statistics show six years with a total less than, and the other five years total with a total higher than, the 109 mm we recorded this month. The highest total for the month of April over the last 11 year period here in Grogport was 188 mm in 2005 whilst the lowest was just 54 mm in 2007. The monthly average is 104 mm, so for us, rainfall this month was almost exactly the average. The breakdown of the rainfall shows 13 dry days, and a further 7 with just a trace (1mm). We got April showers on 7 days with amounts varying between 2-6 mm. We recorded rain of 10 mm on the 10th, heavy rain of 17 mm on the 18th and exceptionally heavy rain of 45mm on the 17th. The two-day total of 62 mm (2 inches) over the 17th & 18th of April accounted for well over half the total for the month. Another notable feature of the weather were the exceptionally strong and cold winds from a north easterly or northerly direction. The gusts of 50 mph which we experienced were more reminiscent of stormy winter gales than the quieter weather we usually expect and get in Springtime. It all adds up to completely unpredictable weather so whats new!? Reality shows there being as many predictions and opinions as there are variations. Heres to Summer! M.L.

THE MEARS SUBMERGE

The image of a submarine moving down Kilbrannan Sound may be the last time the Goat and the Antler have the privilege of being party to Martin Mears over-sight of shipping off Kintyres east coast. With the earlier and significant loss of Duncan Ritchies watchful eye, shipping news may be in even shorter supply over the coming months unless some other keen spotter takes up the challenge. Martin and Chriss move to Berwick on Tweed will be a sad loss for both reporting agencies. We wish them well in their new home but hope they will keep us informed of other photographic and holiday travel events on the east coast of the UK and the African continent..

TORRISDALE ATTACK
Reports are coming in of an incident at the derelict Torrisdale Quay where a young girl is alleged to have stolen a camera and tripod from a member of the Carradale Camera Club who, according to other members of the Club, retaliated by shooting the girl in the back while still holding the stolen cameras twin. The outlook is black for for the victim and but hopefully the attacker will be granted leniency. Photo by J.D.

NO FLY-TIPPING ON HILLSIDE ROAD

Thanks to the efforts of at least two families on Hillside Road in Carradale, and the quick reaction by the staff of the Councils Environmental Department, the three contaminated bins have been replaced by two smaller and clearly marked bins for the sole use of Hillside residents. The notices on the bins state that action will be taken against anyone fly-tipping however it is still not clear whether the bins incorporate devices to photograph users - often a feature in some other areas of the United Kingdom. Photo by J.A.McL.

HOUSE FOR SALE IN WATERFOOT 4 bedrooms, 3 garages, acregarden. Owners down-sizing.

Ring 01583 431281 for details.

D.McNAIR & SON

Fuel Merchant
KINLOCH ROAD
CAMPBELTOWN PA28 6EG

THE PICTURE HOUSE

Sat 19 May 2012 for 6 days at 8.00pm

FAX: (01586 552039)

TELEPHONE
(01586)

BATTLESHIP (12A) Sat 26 May 2012 for 6 days at 8.00pm CABIN IN THE WOODS (15) Sat 2 June 2012 for 5 days at 8.00pm (Not Monday) MIRROR MIRROR (PG) Mon 4 June 2012 for 1 day at 8.00pm SALMON FISHING IN THE YEMEN (12A) Sat 9 Jun 2012 for 6 days at 8.00pm MARVEL AVENGERS ASSEMBLE (12A) 12

552020 - 552039
FREE DELIVERY (MONDAY TO FRIDAY)

QUALITY HOUSE COALS SMOKELESS & COOKER FUEL CENTRAL HEATING OIL - ROAD DIESEL & TRACTOR FUEL