Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Study Guide
SPECPOL
Israel Palestine Conflict
1|Page
SPECPOL
Study Guide
Table of Contents
CHAIRS INTRODUCTION...................................................................................3 HISTORY OF THE COMMITTEE .......................................................................4 1. TOPIC AREA: THE ISRAEL PALESTINE CONFLICT .................................5 1.1. Statement Of The Problem: .............................................................................5 1.2. History Of The Problem: .................................................................................6 1.3. Israeli Independence: .......................................................................................8 1.4. Current Situation: .............................................................................................9 1.5. Jerusalem: ........................................................................................................9 1.6. Palestinian Refugees: .....................................................................................10 1.7. Security: .........................................................................................................11 1.8. Division Of Resources: ..................................................................................11 1.9. Israeli Settlements: .........................................................................................11 1.10. Borders And Issues Of Sovereignty: ...........................................................12 1.11. Bloc Positions And Proposed Solutions: .....................................................12 1.12. The States Of The Arab League And The Rest Of The World: ..................13 1.13. Recent Events: .............................................................................................13 1.14. Questions The Resolution Must Answer: ....................................................14 1.15. Further Links: ..............................................................................................14
2|Page
SPECPOL
Study Guide
CHAIRS INTRODUCTION
Dear Delegates, My name is Shayan Kazmi and along with Rao Junaid, I will be your Co- Committee Director for Special Political and Decolonization Committee (SPECPOL). I have completed my Bachelors in Business Administration (BBA) in Finance here from PAF-KIET. I started my MUNNING career from February 2009, making my first attendance in GIKI-MUN 2009. Then onwards my journey of MUN goes on and so far I have appeared in 15 MUNs as a Delegate and as Committee Director. I have also won the Outstanding Awards multiple times at different MUNs which include IBA and SZABIST. I am also the current President of the KIETMUN Society. As many of you will be attending this years KIET Intra MUN conference for the very first time, I would like to let you know that this activity is not just for those who have good English or for those who are really good in studies. This activity basically helps you not to just develop your diplomacy skills, but also improves your English, your presentation skills, your research skills and lets you understand & solve world issues. I for myself have experienced it too. I will urge you that if you feel shy to speak or feel that you cant speak, dont think about just let your mind be open and speak out. It will help you gain your confidence. Most importantly I will urge you all to please study this guide carefully and to carry out some research and clearly understand your countrys stance or position related to the topic as it is very important for you to proceed in the committee sessions. More over if you still dont understand how it works or do research on your countrys stance then contact any MUN personnel in KIET. They will all be helping you out so that you enjoy all the committee sessions with heated debate and loads of entertainment session. Oh! And by the way, I would highly appreciate those that will come out with something really good in the entertainment sessions. After all we wont be doing only debate over there. I wish you all the best and may you succeed. Looking forward to see you all, Regards, Shayan Kazmi. Committee Director (SPECPOL)
3|Page
SPECPOL
Study Guide
Distinguished Delegates, It is my distinct pleasure to welcome you to the Special Political and Decolonization Committee of KIET Model United Nations 2012! My name is M. Junaid Iqbal Rao, and I am thrilled to have the privilege to serve as your Chair along with Mr, Shayan Kazmi for this conference. A bit about myself I am a senior at PAF-KIET majoring in Engineering. I have been a part of Model United Nations since my 1st year of PAF-KIET and participated in 12 MUNs over all, and also won Out Standing Diplomacy award as well. The question of Palestine has plagued the international community for decades and continues to threaten the Middle Easts security. As you prepare for conference, I encourage you to keep in mind the viewpoint of your country as well as the global implications of the topics. The study guide is a great starting point for research, but I hope you will continue gathering information. I look forward to meeting all of you! Sincerely, M. Juanid Iqbal Rao Committee Director (Special Political and Decolonization)
4|Page
SPECPOL
Study Guide
5|Page
SPECPOL
Study Guide
SPECPOL
Study Guide
from the Arabs to topple them. Hussein demanded land for the Arabs where they could form their own independent nations. McMahon responded in kind stating that after the War would get over their demands would be met, subject to certain conditions. It is this that forms the basis of Arabic argument for Palestine. However, when, through the Bal four Declaration, Britain supported the establishment of Jewish homeland in Palestine the Arabs cried foul. The British countered by saying that they had not included the territory of Palestine in the correspondence. The Arabs had no choice but to accept the rising influx of Jewish people (remember this was the time when the idea of Israel was gaining popularity). Earlier in 1916, the French and the British had made secret plans for dividing the Ottoman Empire after the First World War for their own benefit. This was known as the SykesPicot Agreement. When this came to light, it further deteriorated the image of Britain. The Arabs were particularly angered with this because they considered this in direct violation of the HusseinMcMahon correspondence. Many historians consider this the turning point of Arab Western relations. The Palestine problem became an international issue towards the end of the First World War with the disintegration of the Turkish Ottoman Empire. The League of Nations was established at a historic meeting in the French suburb of Versailles. Article 22 of the Covenant of the League of Nations established the Mandates system and the area of Palestine, promised to both the Jews and the Arabs by the British were eventually returned to the British. The primary aim of the Mandates system was to facilitate the movement towards freedom of the Mandatory Territories, and, as expected all but one achieved their goal. The exception was Palestine. Instead of being limited to "the rendering of administrative assistance and advice" the Mandate had as a primary objective the implementation of the "Balfour Declaration" issued by the British Government in 1917, expressing support for "the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people". The period between the two World Wars was one of unrest, violence and hostility. Arabic and Jewish communities openly fought against each other and between the years of 193639 a massive Arabic rebellion took place against the British. The extremist Jews too were frustrated with Britains doublestandards and targeted the British. Intercommunal fighting broke out with Arabs targeting Jews and the Jews forming a Jewish Defense Force. Despite the upheavals and increasingly fragile political situation, the British continued to try to find a situation. However each of their proposed solutions either managed to anger one of the conflicting sides or make no difference at all. Adding to all this was the ever-increasing influx of Jewish immigrants trying to escape Nazi persecution which only worsened the situation. By 1947, the British decided it had enough. It abruptly decided to hand over the problem to the United Nations. The UNO decided to partition the land of Palestine into two nations one Jewish and the other Arabic. The Arabs rejected the idea because they were given lesser territory despite being the majority. On the last day of the mandate, that fateful day of the 15th of May 1948, Israel declared its independence.
7|Page
SPECPOL
Study Guide
SPECPOL
Study Guide
controlling its sea access, its airspace, immigration and emigration and even its imports and exports. But, yes, it has no presence in it. The West Bank however is an Israeli-occupied territory. In 2006, Hamas won the elections to the Palestinian Authority. This created a major setback to the peace process as it is considered a terrorist organization by many countries. In fact, its stated aims are to wipe Israel off the face of the map. Indeed, chances for meaningful negotiations seem bleak. The situation in Palestinian territories was, and still is, bleak. After the elections, violent fighting broke out between the two major political parties, Fatah and Hamas. Hamas drove Fatah out of the Gaza Strip while Fatah maintains its position in the West Bank (known as the factional violence in Palestine in 2006-07) Fatah is only body which the international community deals with (technically it is the PLO and not Fatah but since Fatah is the largest faction in the PLO, the PLO virtually reflects the will of Fatah. Hamas is not a part of it) and its loss to Hamas was seen as catastrophic. We thus have a very tenuous political situation in Palestine. In addition to the massive mini civil war in Palestine, we have the fact that the two main parties in Palestine have divided it into two spheres of influence. Hope for reconciliation seem bleak and a change in ideology even dimmer. As if internal conflict wasnt enough, another conflict arose. This conflict, known as the Gaza Israeli conflict of 200708 was the result of the Firing of Quassam rockets into Israel from the Gaza Strip by various Palestinian militants. Israel retaliated severely and after a year of retaliation and counterretaliation, an end to the issue seems near.
1.5. Jerusalem:
No city in the world, not even Athens or Rome, ever played as great a role in the life of a nation for so long a time, as Jerusalem has done in the life of the Jewish people. David BenGurion, 1947. The area Jerusalem is a particularly delicate issue, with both Arabic and
9|Page
SPECPOL
Study Guide
Jewish claims. It is central to the religions of Islam and Judaism and compromise would be difficult to achieve. The very fact that Jerusalem plays a dominant role in religious and historical narratives of these two religions underlines its importance. Israel asserts that the city should not be divided, and should remain unified within Israel's political control. Palestinians claim at least the parts of the city which were not part of Israel prior to June 1967. As of 2005, there are more than 719,000 people living in Jerusalem; 465,000 are Jews (mostly living in West Jerusalem) and 232,000 are Muslim (mostly living in East Jerusalem). Israel has grave concerns regarding the welfare of Jewish holy places under possible Palestinian control. When Jerusalem was under Jordanian control, no Jews were allowed to visit the Western Wall. In 2000, a Palestinian mob took over Joseph's Tomb, a shrine considered sacred by both Jews and Muslims, looted and burned the building, and turned it into a mosque. There are unauthorized Palestinian excavations for construction on the Temple Mount in Jerusalem, which could threaten the stability of the Western Wall. Israel, on the other hand, has seldom blocked access to holy places sacred to other religions, and never permanently. Israeli security agencies routinely monitor and arrest Jewish extremists that plan attacks, resulting in almost no serious incidents for the last twenty years. Moreover, Israel has given almost complete autonomy to the Muslim trust (Waqf) over the Temple Mount. Palestinians have grave concerns regarding the welfare of Christian and Muslim holy places under Israeli control. They point to the several attacks on the Al-Aqsa Mosque (Masjid al Aqsa) since 1967, including a serious Eire in 1969, which destroyed the south wing, and the discovery, in 1981, of ancient tunnels under the structure of the mosque which some archaeologists believe have weakened the building structures on the Al Aqsa Mosque. Some Palestinian advocates have made statements alleging that the tunnels were reopened with the intent of causing the mosque's collapse. Israel considers these statements to be totally baseless and unfounded, and to be deliberately intended to incite aggression and public disorder, and stated this in a 1996 speech at the UN. The Israeli government claims it treats the Muslim and Christian holy sites with utmost respect.
SPECPOL
Study Guide
support. Another controversial aspect of the refugee problem is the Right to Return of Palestinian refugees. Proponents of this right argue that Palestinians who had been displaced during the various wars should be allowed to return to their homes (currently in both Israeli and Palestinian territories). Naturally, Israel refutes this right with respect to Israeli territories as this would lead to massive influx of Arabs into Israel (estimated to become 40% of the population). They feel this right is limited to the areas of the West Bank and the Gaza Strip. However, Israeli doublestandards are clearly evident. Under the Israeli Law of Return any Jewish person of any nationality, anywhere in the world can gain citizenship in Israel if he or she wishes. Palestinians view this Act as deeply offensive and discriminatory. Palestinian refugee camps are filthy, bear with a severe lack of resources and are inhumane to say the least. They have been the breeding ground for many terrorists (it is important to note that the PLO and Fatah were started from these very refugee camps) and also cause a huge burden on the host nation. If we are to truly resolve the issue we must deal with the refugees first and look into their rights. Do they have the right to return? Must Israel be held responsible or the Arabs? Must they continue to survive of the generosity of the international community?
1.7. Security:
A major reason behind the reluctance of Israel to recognize Palestinian independence is its security. Without the West Bank, Israel would be extremely vulnerable to attacks from hostile nations. Similarly the Gaza Strip also acts a buffer zone and the recent conflict has further underlined its importance. Most importantly, with the advent of Hamas, Israeli fears have nearly doubled. Hamass avowed intent to destroy Israel leads to fears that in giving concessions to the Arabs, Israel is progressing on a selfdestruct path. It remains to be seen whether Fatah can deliver on its promise and maintain peace.
SPECPOL
Study Guide
international law. It is Gush Katif was a block of 16 Israeli settlements in the southern Gaza Strip. Its 8,000 residents were forced to leave and had their homes demolished in August 2005 as part of Israel's unilateral disengagement plan important to note that a number of international bodies such as the ICJ, EU, UNSC, Amnesty International and even Human Rights Watch view these settlements as illegal. In 2007 Israel decided to further construction near Bethlehem and was severely criticized by both the USA and the EU. Further the continued existence of Jewish settlements in the West Bank has lead to a lot of resentment among the Arabs. Their expansion, protection (as in the case of the building of the West Bank Wall) and even existence have led to widespread condemnations. It is for the Special Political and Decolonization Committee to decide what exactly should be done with these settlements, subject to Israeli approval of course.
SPECPOL
Study Guide
Arab countries, represented by the Arab League have for years been at loggerheads with Israel. They sympathize with Palestine and although tensions have watered down considerably with Israel, they have never fully disappeared. With regards to the present conflict the Arab countries have proposed the Arab Peace Initiative formulated by the Crown Prince of Saudi Arabia at first, Israel rejected it outright but now Prime Minister Olmert has welcomed it with reservations. Clamors for its acceptance have grown both in Israel and outside it. The Arab nations however have threatened to withdraw it completely unless accepted by the Israelis.
1.12. The States Of The Arab League And The Rest Of The World:
The Rest of the World: To the rest of the world, this issue is of paramount importance. Aside from the moral considerations, nations have realized that any crisis in the Middle East tends to destabilize the entire world, primarily because of that black gold i.e. oil. Of course, many nations do not have a direct say or side in the matter but when Israel threatens to bomb all of Gaza the world stands up and takes notice. A weak situation in IsraelPalestine does not bode very well for the world. What we must keep in mind that this present conflict is but a part of the much larger ArabIsraeli problem. Arabs in Palestine feel as threatened by Israel as the Arabs in Iran do. And they WILL stand up for each other. If suppose, the Arab states feel that the rights of Palestine are being compromised they will not hesitate to support Palestine. This could lead to ripples all around the world, considering that the Middle East supports the engine of the world economy. Another important player in this whole episode is Iran. The present Iranian government has very close ties with Hamas and its hatred for Israel and the USA is all but too well known. Iran is unpredictable and you never know what course it might take to protect its Palestinian brothers. All said and done, each individual nation has its own equation with IsraelPalestine. It is up to the delegates to adequately represent that view and still ensure that no calamity occurs.
SPECPOL
Study Guide
these buildings were used by combatants, and as storage spaces for weapons and rockets. Hamas intensified its rocket and mortar attacks against targets in Israel throughout the conflict, hitting previously untargeted cities such as Beersheba and Ashdod. On January 3, 2009, the Israeli ground invasion began. The operation resulted in the deaths of more than 1,300 Palestinians. The IDF released a report stating that the vast majority of the dead were Hamas militants. The Palestinian Centre for Human Rights reported that 926 of the 1,417 dead had been civilians and non-combatants.
14 | P a g e