Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 32

( )

1


.
, , ,
,
- ,
. -
, , :
-, , " ", ,
, , . -,
, ,
- {1}
. ,
. ,
. {2}
, , ,
. , , ,
, ,
, - ,
. , ,
- , .
,
,
.
, , ,
,
. ,
-
. ,
.
,
. ,
- , , ,
. ,
[-] ,
.
.
. to draw them more forcibly to the attention of the reader."

<bracketed> , .
,
. ,
.
, , ,
, ,
.
.
[1] - , Vol. 27, . 67, 1948.
[2] - , Vol. 6.
[3] - , . 1, 1939.
[4] - , Vol. 5.
[5] - , . ,
.
[6] - , K.S. Latourette,
.
[7] - , 1964.
[8] - , . 3, . 82, 1950.
[9] - , - , 1966.
[10] - , (
Lit,. , Am.Oriental
..), 1901.
[11] - , , Vol. 11.
[12] - , McGiffert, Vol. 1.
[13] - , 1965.
[14] - COLLIERS .
[15] - , , Vol. 1.

[16] - , .
[17] - , .
[18] - 1887 .
[19] - , McGraw Hill.
[20] - , K.S. Latourette - Sterling
-, 1953..
[21] - , . , Oxford Univ.
[22] - , Scribners.
[23] - , .
[24] - , , . .
[25] - , - , -
, Brombeck.
[26] - , ,
McCormick , .
[27] -
, . IV - -
, , 1892.
:
, by Ayer; and {1} - Monarchianism
( ) "Adversus
Praxean"; <A History> , <
, by McGiffert.">, McGiffert. , by James Hastings.""
, " - <Encyclopedia
Ethics>, .
{2} - "
, ,
( , tritheistic). , by Phillip Schaff."<History Church>, .
"... " ,
, ,
. "- < , by Phillip

Schaff." >, .
2

,
, 4- .
, ,
: , , , .
<held>, - , " .
Fons Origo" <from
generation>, . of the second and third from the
first; and (3) the consequent oneness of the divine nature of which"
: (1), (2)
<derivation> , (3)
, . [2]
"" , ,
, ,
, coeternal ,
, , .
indiscoverable , . .)."
, , ( ,
<one person>.). ,
, . [4]

,
. [11]
( ,
, ,
, ,
Modalistic Monarchianism).
3
Monarchianism
and in the first quarter of the second century Monarchianism"Modalistic Monarchianism
<at century>
Monarchianism
, , ,

, , , ,
, .

. [4]
( "Modalistic Monarchianism" "" {} "" {}
"" {} ).
,
,
. was the mounting suspicion that the were being endangered by
the new logos doctrine and by the efforts of theologians to represent the godhead as having
revealed itself in the economy as ."<what open> ,
truths> <former
, , , <tripersonal>. , ,
- , . [21]
.
peity . ,
, , , ,
. [12] , Monarchians
. .
. [16]
, Monarchian , ,
, Noetus, PRAXEUS, Noetus
190; Epigonus , Noetus
, 217. [5].
4

in its origin." <pre-Christian> .


,
, ,
, , , ,
. , :
, , , , .
,
, .
(), .
, .


, . ,
, , ,
, ,
, .
( 8:9-24) ".
, , (
) , .
,
. [5]
( , -
, , ,
,
,. , , ).
5

, ,
139, , , ,
.
, .
, $
10000, , ,
. , , 144.
. [5].
6
LOGOS-,
, , , ,
ACTIVE-
-
MOSES
-

. [2]
, ,
"-",

"", - Sabellian. [4]


LOGOS- -
ANATHANASTAN, , . [5]
,
: ,
.
-, ( )
Monarchianism [12] ( , ,
, , .).
: " ,
, ,
, , , ,
... " [5] LOGOS- , 167235, ,
, , , ,
. MONARCHIANS,
Noetus . ,
Zephyrinus (198 - 287) , , Monarchian SIDE.
, () (217-222),
, , (
Monarchianism Noetus).
WORSHIPPER . , , , .
, ; ,
. , ,
, , ,
.
, . (213-218),
.
WESTERN ,
, 240 250 . .. [5]
, , ,
( ) .
[2], , , , . ",
", : " , . "
", , ,
. [6] , ,
, : , ,
,
. ,
[5]. , , ... "",
.
, ,

. [12]
[5], ,

- ,
. [4] ,
, ,
, .
,
TRI- ( ). [5] , (), ,
"" (),
, , ,
LOGOS. .
, , . , ,
, , , . [6]
.
[5]
, ,
-, , .
, ,
, . Monarchian, ,
. ,
- Monarchianism
.
. [11] ,
, TRINITY . [16]
, .
, (), . TIMES
.
. MONARCHIANS, ,
, .
MONARCHIANS, . [20]
, ,
, .
. SUNBEAM, , ,
, . [11].
7
SPLIT Monarchian
(190 . .., -
, , Monarchians,
, , annointed .

" Monarchianism").
Monarchian .
190 . .. , , ,
, ( )
.
( ), MONARCHIANS
MODALISTIC MONARCHIANS ,
,
.
MODALISTIC MONARCHIANS
"PATRIPASSIANS" (, ).
PATRIPASSIANism (190 . ..). ,
, (PATI) ,
(COPATI). .
[11]
( Patripassianism
, Patripassians.);
, PATRIPASSIAN. [16] ( , Patripassians
, . ,
, ?
).
8

Monarchianism Sabellianism, ,
[6] ,
215 . .. [5]
, , .
, , . ,
,
(
", ", ,
). , , , ,
(), , ,
. ,
, , ,
, , . ONE ,
, , ,
. SO ,

, .
DR. , VIEW Sabellian "
. ,
". [25] Sabellian
LOGOS- .
, , , "" ()
. ,
. ,
, ,
, , ,
LOGOS- . [5]
( , ( )
Monarchianism -
, , - ,
!)
, Monarchianism

, .
, ,
3 Sabellianism
. Monarchianism
6- ,
, , .
9

,
.
IRVINGITE .
,
.
.
, ,
. ,
-
-
, . MALICE
. , ,
. [11] ( ), , ,
,

.
.
, HYPER HYPER-.
, ,
. MONTANISTIC
, HEAVY ,
..
, ,
.
, ,
,
.

. ,
, [11] ( ).
, , ,
. , ,
. ,
- -
,
.
, Monarchians
. "" " ", ,
, , {
}.
?
, , ,
, celebacy, , , , ,
- ? ,
- , ,
!).
10

4- , ,
(
"-"). [5]
,
, . ORIGEN,
, , , .
Sabellianism , . [5,6]

, 320,
. Monarchian
[5] -
, LOGOS- . [4]
, ORIGEN, , ,
, . LOWER, .
, , .

, "Tertium Quid" . [5]

. " , PLINEY, , ,
". [15]

. , , , ,
.
321, . ,
NICODEMIA. ,
. , , ,
. [5] , ,
(325 .). [26]
,
( , ,
). , ,
Sabellianism , ,
, ,
(). [6] ,
, , ,
, . [5] , ,
, . OF WHAT HAS
BEEN KNOWN" , <BASIS> ,
.
[5] ,
, ,
.
, ,
.
.
.
, ,
. THEONAS

. [27]
Alpha
Alpha
, , , , , ,
( ,
, , , , .),
, , , ,
, . (
, - , )
- . ,
- :
. [5] (
: ,
, "
. ):
, , ,
, ,
, , , ,
, , ,
, , :
,
, , , ,
, . , "- ,
" " , ",
, ,
, . [12]
, .
ARIUS
. UNTHEOLOGICAL MIND
.

ARIUS .
. ARIUS ,
.
, 22 , 337,
.
, ,

,
. [5]
ORIGINAL . ,
380, , ,
,
, DAMACUS ,
. , .
,
. Sabellianism .
381 MET, , 325,
.
, 451 . <IT
CREED:
"NICEAN" DAY.> [6]
( ,
, ):
1. : " " : "
".
2. : " " : ", ,
, , ".
:
LIGHT" , , ,
, ,
, <WHO AGES,>
LIGHT , , ,
, ;

,
, , , ,
,
, WHO ," , END;
, , <PROCEEDETH FATHER> <WITH
GLORIFIED>, ,
.
,
. [12]

IMPERIAL , IMPERIAL
. ."<DEPARTURE
CRIME>.
, , 412-444
"THEOLOKOS", " ", , "",
, ,
. 340 ,
, "
", " ". ,
. [6]
,
, ,
, ,
- - - ,
.
- ,
, . [12]
( ,
, ? -
, ).
, ,
,
, . [16]
11

,
. [8] ,
COMMAND 28:19. [3] (
,
28:19 . .
.
, ,
.
).
(<The Encyclopedia>, p.338, ): "

28:19 ,
. . THE LONGER FORMULA OF MTT.
28:" :
RITE <IN
USE, 'IN JESUS'> MTT 28...: 19

UNIVERSAL - ,
. : ,
, ,
." FORMULA
, , ,
. [3]
. 29:19, , FALSE
, " , ,
, , " . "

,
.
,
, . [22]
FEINE, Kattenbusch Conybeare , (
) 28:19 , , , NT
, . [3]
(ISBE ): ".
28:19 , ,
<NOT> <FORMULA> ". [3]
( , "" . 28:19 , ,
, . ,
: ".? ,
, , " - 6:3; "
, ", - 3:27; ...
" - 8:16), ...
? 28:19-20 : ".
<all>
, , (RV" ") , ,
, , : ,
".
:

1 -
. ." ,
, ,
- <BUT CHRIST'S MAN>.
" - <THE ,
name> <IN> "
( 2:8,9 RV) " ? "
( 24:26) "<All AUTHORITY> - <GO YE THEREFORE>!"
-
,
.
,
, " ( ).
, " ,
, , , <BUT CHRIST>."
,
. "(. 2:36,38)
,
:
1 - , .
2 - MAN .
3:13,16,19; 4:10-12; 5:31,32; 7:55,56,60; 10:42,43; 13:33,38;
17:3,7,30,31; 26:13,16,18. [23]
,
28:19
" , , , , ".
16:16-17, :
, , ,
;. <IN MY name> ,
.
.
24:47 :
<IN name> , ".
,
.
,
24:47. " : , <IN
CHRIST> ".

2:38.
." , WORD,
<IN JESUS>
. 8:16 "(, :.
)"

. 10:47-48. MAN FORBID ,
, , ?
". (" " - )
, ROM. 6:3-5 ", ,
,
: ,
, . ,
,
. "
. GAL 3:27. ", , <INTO
CHRIST> ".
(1 6:11), "
, , , <IN JESUS>
, ".
, , 1 . 1:13,
: " ? <IN PAUL>?" ,
, , ,
. , " , ,
", , .
,
. 3:17 " , ,
". 4:12: "
, , ,
."
,
. [24]

RECORD
: NO MENTION OF WATER BAPTISM, HE FURTHERMORE MAKES NO MENTION
OF THE TRINITY."<NICODEMUS>:

, . ,
THECIA, 9:6-9 ",
, THECIA
, , , , ,
, .
, , , ,
". , , ,
,
.
: SILENT ON BAPTISM, HIS EPISTLES REJECTED AS NOT TO DULY HONOR
TRINITY."<CLEMENT>: ,
TRINITY.
<BARNABAS>: , PAGE 157162: ,
CROSS, ,
: " , ,
, . "
: THERE ARE 15 EPISTLES DESIGNATED TO IGNATIUS, EIGHT OF WHICH ARE
KNOWN TO BE FORGERIES."<IGNATIUS>: 15 ,
, , , . ,
. : ".
, , , ,
" : " ,
, ".
WAS SILENT ON BAPTISM."<PAPIAS> .
WAS SILENT ON BAPTISM."<POLYCARP> .
<SHEPARD HERMAS>: 9:120, .255: , ,
, ". 151 153 154 158, . 258:
, , ,
. ,
. ,
, ".
" SEAL ,
, ". "
, ."
, ,
. ,
. [24].
12

,
"<THE CONCEPT> CHRISTIAN
451 , EUTHYCHAS,
,
. [2]
.
. -ON
, .
, ,
, . [13]
ST. [14]
( -, 13 ..). ,
( 16 ),
. [17]
-
SIRIS, ISIS, : HINDU , , ETC.
, ,
. (
""
): " <THREE PERSONS> GOD> <ONE -
, - : , , ,
<FIRST, SECOND, THIRD> ". [10]
( ,
,
, .)
TRINITY .
. -
(600 . ..) : "TAO , ,
; ".
: , ,
, .
: " ,
, . ORACLE :
" ,
. TRINITY
" : Anos, ILLINOS, AOS, : ULOMUS,
ULOSURUS, ELIUN, , KREPH ( ), PITHAH, OSIRIS,

: KRISSAN, BIOSENA, , : THOR, WODEN, FRICCO.


, , , , ,
. MYTHOLOGERS
: URONAS, CHRONDOS, , :
, , ALDONEUS. [18]

( ):
, , "
, ,
...
, , , ,
, ". [18]
( , , , , ,
. , ,
, !)
( ): "

, , MIND
, . [18] (
!)
(ISBE ,
, , : "
,
, ". [4] (
!)
, , ,
.
:
,
. ST.

, , ,
,
, ,
- -
, - ,
, .
, OUT TRINITY .

, , , , GREGORIES,
, , .
, ,
,
.
, , ,
.
,
,
- .
,
. [16]
13

, "
", :
" ,
,
, .
,
,
, ,
. ,
" "
.
. ,
" ",
,
. ,
,
. ,
,
, ,
".
14

(1511-1553), , , ,
, ,
, .
. ,
, . ,

TRINITY , ,
. [20] (
).
, .
. [20] (
, ).
(, , - ,
- ,
, - ,
, ) .
, ,
, ANTI-.
. ANTI-
, Socinianism SOZINI
, , ,
.
.
.
.
(, ,
)
, 1550 .
,
. 1553
, 1575
.
,
. ( 15 .) ,
SOCINUS ( Socinians). Socinians
. ,
Remonstrants . 1659
Socinians .
,

, .
1780 , ,
. [20] (
Modalistic Monarchian Monarchian
,
.) , 1815 .
NAME . ( ""
SZKLERS , ,
). [20] Campellites 1800-
-. ,
.

1790, , AS
ARMENIANISM Socinianism.
, NEW . [20]
( ,. 1115
, CANON - Sabellianism [5] RAPIERLIKE , , , ;
. , ,
WORSTING ,
. .
1211 . 1140
SENS,
[20].
1,
. " , ,
, " " ,
. ,
, . -
, - ,
, . EUDORUS BELL, . GOSS, CO "" ". ROLL
150.
-. LOUIS (1916)
. ""
, <ALONE>
" ",
. , ,
.
, . ,
. ROSWELL . ,
,


PRINCIPLES." <TRADITIONAL
HISTORICO-THEOLOGICAL>. 156 ,
-
. [9]
""
. 1965 200000 (Spiritfilled,
) . [9]
( , , ,
,
. , , ,
, -.
, ,
), , , ,
, ,
, , - ! , ,
- . ,
, ,
, , , ,
, , .
() , ,
, , .
, ,
. NURTURED
, ", , , ,
ONE ", , , .
TO THE SATISFACTION OF ALL WHO BEAR THE CHRISTIAN NAME, IS THAT
OF THE ."<A , LONG CHURCH,
SOLVED> , , ,
<TRINITY>. ."<THE , ONE>.
, ,
, , . [20].
15

, Monarchianism
. ,

"" , , ,
. ,
.
-
. ,
, , Modalistic
, :
" ": ,
. "", , ",
, . ,
". [20]
, "",
, Monarchian . ,
, , ,
- . , .
, ,
-
, ,
. "", "Monarchianism" "Sabellianism"
" " , -
.
, Monarchianism - ,
, Monarchianism . ,
, , , ,
Monarchianism, .
, , , , ,
- , :
!
16

, .
(), .
, ,
, , .
, , , . .
, - , .
, , .
, , -

.

, , {1}, . {2}
{3}, ,
,
. {4} :
1) . {5}
2) . {6}
3) . . {7}
4) , . {8}
5) , . {9}
6) . {10}
7) , , , , . {11}
, {12} (
""). {13} , , , {14}
. ,
{15}, {16}. {17},
{18}, , {19} ,
{20}, {21} .
, {22}, {23}, {24}.
(), {25} ( - "annointed One" -
"Annointer"). , , " " {26} " ".
{27} , ,
: , , . ,
{28}, , , {29}.
, :
1) " , ". {30}
2) " ". {31}
3) " , ". {32}
4) , . {33}

(), :
1) " , , ?" {34}
2) " ". {35}
3) " : , , ". {36}
, {37},
{38}, ,
{39}. ". {40}
{41} - ,
{42}, {43}. ,
, {44}, {45}, , ,
{46}.
( ) ,
, , ,
. , !
:
1 - 4:24
2 - 23:24
3 - 1:18
4 - ", ".
5 - 3:04
6 - Ex 13:21,22; 33:9-11
7 - Ex 33:18-23
8 - Gen 32:24,30 12:24
9 - 13:13,22
10 - Gen 18:1-3
11 - 3:25,28. : " ",
: " ". ,
- . "", "" 78 ,
16 . . . . 5:23,

"", "" "".


12 - Ex 6:03
13 - . 4.
14 - , , ""
, ""
"" (, ). O.T.
():
40:3 ----------- ------------ 3:03
24:8 ----------- ----------- 1 2:08
12:8,10 --------- ------- 19:18 1:11
44:6 ----------- --------- Rev 1:8, 2:08
43:10,11 --------- ----- 1:4 ( 1:21)
52:6 ----------- ------ 17:6,11,12, 5:43
3:13,14 --------- --------- 1 2:6-8
15 - 1 3:16
16 - 1:2. "", "", .
, "" : , Wuest, , ,
, , , ASV, ERV, , , ,
, Worrels.
17 - 9:06
18 - 14:9,10
19 - 1:23
20 - 43:10,11; 1:21; 1:04
21 - 1:10,11
22 - Ja 2:19; 10:30
23 - 42:5; (. 1:3,10,11)

24 - 43:10,11 (. 1:4)
25 - 2:36
26 - 1:01
27 - 9:06 - "", , "" (), ""
(""). .
28 - , " - " (1 2:05)..
29 - , ( 1:22) , , .
, .
30 - 18:20
31 - Rev 1:11
32 - 2:19
33 - 8:58
34 - 27:46
35 - 19:28
36 - 19:26
37 - 1 3:16
38 - 2 5:19
39 - 2:28 2:4,16,17
40 - 1:4,5
41 - 1:11; 16:07. , ,
, .
42 - : Orphanos (, )
43 - , ,
44 - 14:16
45 - 14:26

46 - 14:16-18.
17

, ,
, , ,
, , .
,
. ,
, -
, .
, - ,
,
( " Monarchianism"). ,
Monarchianism, 217 ,
.
-,
, , .
, ,
"" "", "".
. , ,
, ,
.
, : (1) Monarchians
- Monarchian ,
, . ,
Monarchianism, , . (2)
-
, ,
. Monarchianism, ,
- -
. , , , ,
, .

. ,
. ,
,
Monarchianism ( Sabellianism),
. .

, , ( ,
, ) .
Monarchianism ,
,
, .
381 . ,
, , .
, 451 ,
" Creed" , " ".
, , ,
, .
.
,

, , .
, , ,
.
, ,
: .
,
, " ,"
.
, - , ,
", " . ,
, , ,
, . .