Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
John8:211
John 8:2-6
Atdawn THEMES Jesusappearedagain inthetemplecourts, whereallthepeoplegatheredroundhim, andhesatdowntoteachthem. PHYSICAL MOVEMENT, TEACHING Theteachersofthelaw and thePhariseesbroughtawomancaughtinadultery. POLICING ADULTERY Theymadeherstandbeforethepeople PHYSICAL MOVEMENT and saidtoJesus, / POLICING ADULTERY Teacher,thiswomanwascaughtintheactofcommittingadultery. IntheLaw LAW Mosescommandedustostonesuchwomen. EXECUTION Nowwhatdoyousay? INTEROGATION Theywereusingthisquestionasatrap, TRAP inordertohaveabasisforaccusinghim. ACCUSATION
John 8:7-8
ButJesusstoopeddown PHYSICAL MOVEMENT andstartedtowriteontheground WRITING withhisfinger. Whentheykeptonquestioninghim, INTEROGATION hestraightenedup PHYSICAL MOVEMENT and saidtothem, Ifanyoneofyouiswithoutsin, INNOCENCE lethimbethefirsttothrowastoneather. SITTING IN JUDGEMENT Againhestoopeddown PHYSICAL MOVEMENT and wroteontheground. WRITING
John 8:9-11
Atthis, thosewhoheard, bytheirconsciencebeingconvicted, CONSCIENCE begantogoawayoneatatime, PHYSICAL MOVEMENT theolderonesfirst, untilonlyJesuswasleft, withthewomanstillstandingthere. Jesusstraightenedup PHYSICAL MOVEMENT and,havingseennoonebutthewoman, askedher, Woman,wherearethoseaccusersofyours? ACCUSERS Hasnoonecondemnedyou? JUDGING OTHERS Noone,sir,shesaid. ThenneitherdoIcondemnyou,Jesusdeclared. CONDEMNATION Go, PHYSICAL MOVEMENT andfromnowonsinnomore. STOP SINNING
The Themes
n n n n n n
Adultery? Judgementalattitudes? Hypocrisy? Tolerance? Lawv.Grace? Release? SubThemes Teaching(verbalandvisualaction) TheLaw(howtoapplyitsdemands?) Entrapment(whotrapswho?)
n n n
(Pharisees&TeachersoftheLaw)
n
TheWoman
John 8:9-11
Atthis, thosewhoheard, bytheirconsciencebeingconvicted, CONSCIENCE begantogoawayoneatatime, PHYSICAL MOVEMENT theolderonesfirst, untilonlyJesuswasleft, withthewomanstillstandingthere. Jesusstraightenedup PHYSICAL MOVEMENT and,havingseennoonebutthewoman, askedher, Woman,wherearethoseaccusersofyours? ACCUSERS Hasnoonecondemnedyou? JUDGING OTHERS Noone,sir,shesaid. ThenneitherdoIcondemnyou,Jesusdeclared. CONDEMNATION Go, PHYSICAL MOVEMENT andfromnowonsinnomore. STOP SINNING
John 8:9-11
Atthis, thosewhoheard, bytheirconsciencebeingconvicted, CONSCIENCE begantogoawayoneatatime, PHYSICAL MOVEMENT theolderonesfirst, untilonlyJesuswasleft, withthewomanstillstandingthere. Jesusstraightenedup PHYSICAL MOVEMENT and,havingseennoonebutthewoman, askedher, Woman,wherearethoseaccusersofyours? ACCUSERS Hasnoonecondemnedyou? JUDGING OTHERS Noone,sir,shesaid. ThenneitherdoIcondemnyou,Jesusdeclared. CONDEMNATION Go, PHYSICAL MOVEMENT andfromnowonsinnomore. STOP SINNING
John 8:9-11
Atthis, thosewhoheard, bytheirconsciencebeingconvicted, CONSCIENCE begantogoawayoneatatime, PHYSICAL MOVEMENT theolderonesfirst, untilonlyJesuswasleft, withthewomanstillstandingthere. Jesusstraightenedup PHYSICAL MOVEMENT and,havingseennoonebutthewoman, askedher, Woman,wherearethoseaccusersofyours? ACCUSERS Hasnoonecondemnedyou? JUDGING OTHERS Noone,sir,shesaid. ThenneitherdoIcondemnyou,Jesusdeclared. CONDEMNATION Go, PHYSICAL MOVEMENT andfromnowonsinnomore. STOP SINNING
John 8:9-11
Atthis, thosewhoheard, bytheirconsciencebeingconvicted, CONSCIENCE begantogoawayoneatatime, PHYSICAL MOVEMENT theolderonesfirst, untilonlyJesuswasleft, withthewomanstillstandingthere. Jesusstraightenedup PHYSICAL MOVEMENT and,havingseennoonebutthewoman, askedher, Woman,wherearethoseaccusersofyours? ACCUSERS Hasnoonecondemnedyou? JUDGING OTHERS Noone,sir,shesaid. ThenneitherdoIcondemnyou,Jesusdeclared. CONDEMNATION Go, PHYSICAL MOVEMENT andfromnowonsinnomore. STOP SINNING
John 8:9-11
Atthis, thosewhoheard, bytheirconsciencebeingconvicted, CONSCIENCE begantogoawayoneatatime, PHYSICAL MOVEMENT theolderonesfirst, untilonlyJesuswasleft, withthewomanstillstandingthere. Jesusstraightenedup PHYSICAL MOVEMENT and,havingseennoonebutthewoman, askedher, Woman,wherearethoseaccusersofyours? ACCUSERS Hasnoonecondemnedyou? JUDGING OTHERS Noone,sir,shesaid. ThenneitherdoIcondemnyou,Jesusdeclared. CONDEMNATION Go, PHYSICAL MOVEMENT andfromnowonsinnomore. STOP SINNING
Jesus Motive
DrRobertGagnonsuggestthatJesusresponsetothe Moralistsquestioninghadthefollowingeffect: n ItturnedtheembarrassmentintendedforJesusonto hisaccusers n IthighlightedthesinfulnessofeveryonebutJesus, whohasthepower,nottoacquit,buttopardon. n Itprovidedtimeforthewomantoavailherselfofthe GospelofGodsKingdom(stoningherwouldnot!)
Did Jesus Have a More Compassionate Attitude to Sexual Misdemeanours than the Moralist of His Time?
Matthew5:2730suggestsNo! Youhaveheardthatitwassaid,Youshallnot commitadultery.ButItellyouthatanyone wholooksatawomanlustfullyhasalready committedadulterywithherinhisheart. n Jesusinfactraisesthebar!
n
Did Jesus Have a More Compassionate Attitude to Sexual Misdemeanours than the Moralist of His Time?
n th Heexpoundsthe10 Commandment(Dont th covetyourneighbourswife!)andthe9 Commandment(Dontcommitadultery!) togethertoshowtheirconnection: Ifyouhavetheinwardattitude ofcovetingyourneighbourswife, thenyouareguiltyoftheexternalact ofadultery.
Did Jesus Have a More Compassionate Attitude to Sexual Misdemeanours than the Moralist of His Time?
Jesusnotonlyraisedthestandardofmorality GodrequiresinHispeoplessexualbehaviour n Healsowarnedof
n
thesevereconsequencesofimmorality,andof q thedrasticactionneededtodestroyitsgrip.
q
The End
A Commentary
n
n n
Weareallguiltyofadultery,atleastinthesensethatthebookofHoseauses theword.GodistheSpousewhohasgivenuseverythinganddeservesour exclusiveloyalty.WeshouldworshipthegroundHewalkson.Butinsteadwe've cheatedonHim,lookingforthrillsfromotherloverswhohavenotdeliveredwhat theypromised.GiventhatHeisthesourceofLifeitself,rejectingHimmeans choosingdeath. ItseemssoeasyforJesustosaytotheadulteress(andtoallofus)"neitherdoI condemnyou."Withthosewords,Hesavedherfromdeathandgaveheranew leaseonlife.Sowhatdiditcosther?"Goandsinnomore"isherprogram. Shemustchangeherlife. AfamousGermantheologianmurderedbytheNazis,DietrichBonhoeffer, pointedoutthedifferencebetween"cheapgrace"and"costlygrace."Graceis free.Itistheabsolutelyunmeritedgiftofpardonandlovingfriendshipextended tousbyGodinawaythattransformsusandmakesallthingsnew.Butsuch graceisnotcheap.ItwaspaidforbythesufferingofGod'sSon,sufferingthat Hewillinglyembracedoutofloveforus. Paulneededthisgracedesperately.Heoccupiedaconspicuousplaceamong theselfrighteous,amemberofthebloodthirstycrowdthatstoned Stephen.WhenontheroadtoDamascusherealizedwhohewasandwhathe deserved,hesawthegraceofferedtohimasmorepreciousthangold. Itwas thepearlofgreatprice.Inlightofthistreasure,allelseappearedastrash(he actuallyusesarathervulgarwordfor"compost"inPhil3:8) Dr.MarcellinoDAmbrosio,www.Catholicexchange.com
Thisactofwritingonthegroundisitselfverysignificant.KennethE.Baileyhas pointedout(inunpublishedform)thatitwasunlawfultowriteeventwoletterson thesabbathbutthatwritingwithdustwaspermissible(m.shabbat7:212:5).If thisweretheeighthdayofthefeast,whichwastobekeptasadayofrest,then Jesus'writingonthegroundwouldshowthatheknowswellnotonlythelawbut alsotheoralinterpretations. Furthermore,hiswritingechoesanOldTestamentpassage,therebyturningit intoasymbolicaction(Jeremias1972:228):"OLord,thehopeofIsrael,allwho forsakeyouwillbeputtoshame.Thosewhoturnawayfromyouwillbewritten inthedustbecausetheyhaveforsakentheLord,thespringoflivingwater"(Jer 17:13).Here"writteninthedust"probablymeanstheoppositeofbeingwritten inthebookoflife(Ex32:32Dan12:1)thosewhohaveturnedawayare consignedtodeathbecausetheyhaverejectedtheonewhoisthesourceofthe wateroflife.ThusitappearsthatJesusisassociatinghisopponentswiththose whomGodcondemnsforforsakinghimselfandwhomheconsignstodeath. ThejudgmentthattheysuggestJesusexecuteonthisadulterouswomanisin factthejudgmentthathevisitsuponthemfortheirrejectionofhimtheonewho hasofferedthemGod'slivingwater(7:3839).InrejectingJesus,theyare forsakingGod,andtherebycommittingamostshamefulact.Adulteryis shameful,certainly,buttheythemselvesareactinginashamefulwayworthyof death. IVPNTCommentaries(postedonBibleGateway.com)
WhenJesuscallsfortheonewithoutsintocastthefirststoneheaccomplishesseveral things:itrelieveshimfromthechargeofhavinginstigatedastoningitensurestherewill notbeastoning,sincenoneoftheaccuserswillwanttotakeresponsibilityforitandit causesthemtoreflectontheirownsinfulnessbeforeGodThosewhocametocondemn endedupcondemningthemselvesbynotcastingastone. Jesusisleftalone,sittingontheground,bentoverandwriting,withthewomanstanding beforehim...Hestraightensupandasksforareportofwhathappened,asifhehadbeen totallyoblivioustowhattookplaceasheconcentratedonhiswriting.Hedoesnotaskher aboutthechargesbutratheraboutthataspectofthesituationmosthearteningtothe woman:Wherearethey?Hasnoonecondemnedyou?(v.10).Theyhadofcourse condemnedherintheiraccusations,butbynotfollowingthroughonthechargetheyhad thrownouthercase. Butthereisoneleftwhocouldstillexecutethejudgmenttheonlyonepresentwhowas withoutsinandthuscouldthrowthefirststoneJesussaystoher,"NeitherdoIcondemn you.Go,andfromnowonnolongersin"(8:11).Shebecomesamemorableexampleofthe factthat"GoddidnotsendhisSonintotheworldtocondemntheworld,buttosavethe worldthroughhim"(3:17). Jesusgrantspardon,notacquittal,sincethecalltoleaveoffsinningshowsheknewshe wasindeedguiltyoftheadultery.Hisnoncondemnationisquitedifferentfromtheirs.They wantedtocondemnbutlackedtheopportunityhecouldhavedoneso,buthedidnot. Hereismercyandrighteousness.Hecondemnedthesinandnotthesinner(AugustineIn John33.6).Butmorethanthat,hecalledhertoanewlife.Thegospelisnotonlythe forgivenessofsins,butanewqualityoflifethatovercomesthepowerofsin(cf.8:32361 Jn3:46). IVPNTCommentaries(postedonBibleGateway.com)
Thisstoryraisesverysignificantpastoralissues.Thefirstissueisthe natureofthecommandmentsofScripture.WeseeJesusupholdingthe law'steachingthatadulteryissinwhilealsosettingasidethespecific regulationsconcerningthecommunity'senforcementofthatlaw.The implicationisthatthelawcontainsrevelationofrightandwrong,which istruethroughouthistory,aswellascommandmentsforembodying thatrevelationinthecommunityofGod'speople,whicharenottruefor alltimesandplaces.Tounderstandthisdistinctionwemustunderstand thatthelawasrevelationofrightandwrongisnotanarbitrarysetof rulesthatGodmadeuptotestourobedience.Rather,thelawisthe transpositionintohumansocietyofpatternsofrelationshipthatreflect God'sowncharacter.Adulteryiswrongbecauseitviolatesrelationships offaithfulness,andsuchviolationiswrong,ultimately,becauseGod himselfischaracterizedbyfaithfulness.ThemoralityofScriptureisa patternoflifethatreflectsGod'sownlife.Thisaspectofthelawis unchanging,butthelaw'sprescriptionforhowthecommunityisto embodyandenforcetherevealedvisionofrelationshipsmayvary. IVPNTCommentaries(postedonBibleGateway.com)
Thisstoryalsoillustratesanotherpastoralissue.AsAugustine noted(InJohn33.8),weareindangerfrombothhopeand despair.Thatis,wecanhaveafalseoptimismthatsays"Godis mercifulsoIcandoasIplease"oradespairthatsays"thereis noforgivenessforthesinIhavecommitted."Thisstoryshows weshouldkeepthesetwoinclinationsinbalance.Thereisnosin thatGoddoesnotforgive.Christ'sdeathatonedforallsin.The onlysinthatremainsunforgivenistheonethatisnotrepented of.But,ontheotherhand,God'scalltousistointimacywith himself,andsincannotbeinhispresenceanymorethan darknesscanbeinthepresenceoflight.Christ'satonement cleansesusfromsinaswerepentdaybyday,andhisSpiritis workinginusatransformationsothatintheendwewillcomeout pure,thoughnotinthislife(1Jn1:8).Butsinmustbecutoff.We musttakeitseriously.JesushimselfoftentellsustofearGod andhisjudgment. IVPNTCommentaries(postedonBibleGateway.com)
RichardBaxtersaidtowomen(nodoubtwith1Tim2:910 and1Pet3:34inmind):
Youmustnotlayastumblingblockintheirway, norblowofthefireoftheirlust, normakeyourornamentssnares butyoumustwalkamongsinfulpersons asyouwoulddowithacandleamongstraworgunpowder, orelseyoumayseetheflamewhichyouwouldnotforesee whenitistoolatetoquenchit.