Humanities in Medical Education: Some Contributions

Prepared by R. Sjamsuhidajat Department of Medical Education, FKUI

excerpted from Humanities in Medical Education: Some Contributions K. Danner Clouser (1990) The Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 15:289-301
14 February 2013 Tutorials in The Humanities 1

Medicine is the most humane of sciences, the most empiric of arts, and the most scientific of humanities. (Pellegrino, 1970) The human arts are the good arts of Aulus Gellus, the liberal arts, those that free a mans mind from the tyranny of others. (Pellegrino, 1976)
14 February 2013 Tutorials in The Humanities 2

The plan is to describe five qualities of mind which are very important to medicine and which are distinctively contributed to by humanities in medical education. Qualities of mind is meant to include items like mind-set, attitude, awareness. perspective, and intellectual skills. It is hard to make a case of such nebulous characteristics in a vocational school setting.
14 February 2013 Tutorials in The Humanities 3

Introduction

Introduction-2
The qualities of mind engendered by the humanistic disciplines, which will be described briefly, are: critical abilities, flexibility of perspectives, non-dogmatism, discernment of values, and empathy and selfknowledge. They are very similar to each other, bearing a distinct family resemblance.
14 February 2013 Tutorials in The Humanities 4

A. Critical abilities - 1
In a medical school there seems to be an overwhelming amount of memorization, checklist, and cookbooks. This must be the most crippling, stupefying, and depressing feature of medical education to these bright and inquisitive young minds when they first arrive. And it never changes: the students simply adapt, they become molded.
14 February 2013 Tutorials in The Humanities 5

Critical abilities - 2
Vocation learning that is task oriented must simply go on with what works, with what is immediately needed whether it is a gadget, a business arrangement, a theory, or a therapy. The goal is clear - just learn the process and do it. By contrast, humanistic studies - art, philosophy, history, and literature - do not share this sense of immediacy.
14 February 2013 Tutorials in The Humanities 6

Critical abilities - 3
Without the press of immediate practicality or pay-off, there is opportunity to play around with ideas - to seek, invent, try out, explain. This is the atmosphere in which imagination and critical thinking develop and flourish. In focusing on a work of art, a literary classic, a historic period, one can try out different interpretations, looking at it from different points of view.
14 February 2013 Tutorials in The Humanities 7

Flexibility of perspectives is quite closely allied with critical ability , yet different enough to be described separately. Professional education is often described as a kind of conceptual ghetto. Each profession has its own ghetto. Its members get locked in a certain way of seeing the world, themselves, their relationship with that world, and their role within it.
14 February 2013 Tutorials in The Humanities 8

B. Flexibility of perspectives 1

Flexibility of perspectives - 2
That may be what is meant by being professionalized. It is a way of viewing everything - certain things and relationships are highlighted, others fade into the background; certain causal chains predominate, others are barely noticed. In other words, ones perspectives become highly specialized.
14 February 2013 Tutorials in The Humanities 9

Flexibility of perspectives - 3
This is strengthened and reinforced throughout our professional education - by teaching, by emphasis, by exam, by the concepts we use daily, by our special language, by the handed-down view of what is significant. We get locked in. Our perceptions , thoughts, and lines of reasoning get channeled; our circuitry gets etched in.
14 February 2013 Tutorials in The Humanities 10

Flexibility of perspectives - 4
Flexibility of perspectives is believed to be the most important contribution of the humanistic disciplines to medical education. The ability to quickly and easily shift perspectives when appropriate, to see with new eyes, is a valuable clinical as well as personal skill.

14 February 2013

Tutorials in The Humanities

11

C. Non-dogmatism - 1
This quality of mind bears close resemblance to the others and is nurtured by the same kind of intellectual exercises which train critical ability and flexibility of perspectives. Nothing promotes misguided certainty more than being locked into the kind of single perspective.
14 February 2013 Tutorials in The Humanities 12

Non-dogmatism - 2
Seeing no alternatives, unable to imagine other possibilities, one becomes dead certain of whatever it is he is perceiving within the parameters and categories of his own limited vision. That is why flexibility of perspectives works as a corrective to incipient dogmatism. But there are other ways to counteract it.
14 February 2013 Tutorials in The Humanities 13

Non-dogmatism - 3
Through history, for example, we can come to know, understand, and appreciate a belief system other than our own. And when through history we see how frequently the unquestioned truth of a prior time were the falsehoods and myths of a later time, some doubts must inevitably be cast on those matters of current confidence.
14 February 2013 Tutorials in The Humanities 14

Non-dogmatism - 4
We cannot help but be humblestruck, wondering what the next generation will do with things we are so cocksure of today. Particularly the history of science and medicine is helpful in this regard. We find gifted scientist being certain but wrong; we find unexamined assumptions; we find mistaken theories sometimes winning out; etc.

14 February 2013

Tutorials in The Humanities

15

Non-dogmatism - 5
Through history our students gain a sense of discovery and of openendedness of science. They acquire a mind-set ready to question, an openness to new clues, and a serious regard to recalcitrant data. In short, non-dogmatism.

14 February 2013

Tutorials in The Humanities

16

D. Discernment of values
Because this quality of mind is probably the most obvious and frequent contribution of the humanities, it must here receive the most intense attention. In fact, with the enormous emphasis on biomedical ethics from the early 1970s, it may seem downright commonplace. But values include far more than moral values.
14 February 2013 Tutorials in The Humanities 17

Discernment of values - 2
They include others, such as political, aesthetic, and personal values, which tend to be overlooked in the intense concentration on moral values. The humanistic disciplines are heavily value-laden. But they are self-consciously so. They have the vocabulary, conceptual apparatus, and strategies for dealing with values.
14 February 2013 Tutorials in The Humanities 18

Discernment of values - 3
Medicine, after all, is riddled with values. From its key concepts (disease, life, death, role of medicine, etc.) to diagnosis and therapy (what is indicated, tradeoffs, lab values) to the delivery of health care (allocation, rationing, research-funding, etc.) medicine is value-laden. Not to identify these values is to be manipulated by them.
14 February 2013 Tutorials in The Humanities 19

E. Empathy and selfknowledge

Empathy and self-knowledge, unlike the other qualities described, are more directed at interaction with persons than with observation, knowledge, and ideas. Literature is probably the most direct way to illustrate this phenomenon. In literature we vicariously live many other lives. We are led by the writers skill to see life of others through a completely different mind-set.

14 February 2013

Tutorials in The Humanities

20

Empathy and self-knowledge 2

Through such vicarious experience we surely learn about others in the most unique of all ways - by empathy, by becoming them, by taking on so many of their characteristics that we begin to think, act, and react like them. We learn what it is like to put ourselves in someones elses place, to see it from the other persons point of view.
14 February 2013 Tutorials in The Humanities 21

Empathy and self-knowledge 3

It is not only empathy and tolerance that flows from identifying with other persons, times, and beliefs. It is selfknowledge as well. We do not really know and understand ourselves until we see that, how, and why we differ from others. This, then, sets the agenda and motivation for selfinvestigation and reconstruction.
Tutorials in The Humanities 22

14 February 2013