Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 72

United Arab Emirates University College of Engineering Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering Graduation Project II Second Semester

2007/2008

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior


Advisor: Dr. Ahmed Bushlaibi
Group members: Khamis Ahmed Khamis Khalid Haza Mansour Nasser Abdullah Alnaqbi Khaled Moussalli 199900588 200235841 200212673 200337587

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

contents
Introduction. The split cylinder test. The permeability test. The bending test. The flexural test. Conclusion.

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Introduction
Using silica fume as an enhancer for the concrete beams, slabs, columns and any other concrete structure. Concrete is very good material in compression however it is very week in tension so that is way we use reinforcement in it.

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Why Silica Fume ?

Cement grains (left), silica fume particles (right) at the same magnification. The ACI 234R-96 report estimates that for a 15 percent silica fume replacement of cement, there are approximately 2,000,000 particles of silica fume for each grain of portland cement

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Why Silica Fume ?


Change microstructure of the concrete
Physical aspect of silica fume :
Fills in the spaces between cement grains

Chemical contribution :
Cement releases calcium hydroxide. Silica has very high silicon dioxide.

Calcium hydroxide will react with silicon dioxide to form calcium silicate hydrate.
Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Introduction
Concrete solidifies and hardens after mixing and placement due to a chemical process known as hydration. The water reacts with cement which bonds the other components together eventually creating a stone-like material. Reinforcement is a good indication for failure because it gives us a warning.

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Introduction
In GPI the concrete compression test was done.
Was that enough ??!

Four more test were done.


The split cylinder test. The permeability test. The bending test. The flexural test.
Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

The split cylinder test The permeability test. The bending test. The flexural test.
Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Split Cylinder Test

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Split cylinder test


This test, often referred to as the split-cylinder test, indirectly measures the tensile strength of concrete by compressing a cylinder through a line load applied along its length.

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

10

The testing machine


This test can be completed in a standard concrete compression testing machine, with only one special requirement the hinged bearing that loads the specimen.

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

11

The Experiment

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

12

Results
7 days Results %0 261 258 250 Avg 256.33 Silica % %7.50 261 250 260 257 %10 327 300 315 314 %12.50 356 362 352 356.67

The results above are in MPa

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

13

Results
14 days Results %0 270 270 285 281.67

Silica Fume % %7.50 %10 351 333 343 342.33 342 347 342 343.67

%12.50 357 376 357 363.33

Avg

The results above are in MPa

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

14

Results

28 days Results %0 370 370 340 Avg 360 Silica Fume % %7.50 380 400 400 393.33 %10 450 435 445 443.33 %12.50 480 475 480 478.33

The results above are in MPa


Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

15

Results

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

16

The split cylinder test. The permeability test. The bending test. The flexural test.
Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Permeability
Permeability describes the ease by which any species (i.e. liquid or gas) can pass through concrete.

Objective : Effect of silica fume in permeability of concrete on different percentage (0%,7.5%,10%,12.5%)

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Permeability
Most popular fluid is water Most popular gas is O2 & CO2

Inflow

Flow path

Concrete Specimen

Water permeating through concrete

Outflow

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Permeability test
Shape: Cylinder
R=15cm

v=r2h
R=15cm=0.15m r=7.5cm=0.075m h=2cm=0.02m
V =( )*(0.075)2*(0.02) =0.00035m3 V for 16 cylinder = (16)*(0.00035) =0.0056m3
Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

h=2cm

Calculation
Water content for 16 cylinder=1.12Kg/m3 Cement content for 16 cylinder=3.3936kg
Coarse Aggregate: For 16 cylinder = 5.1072 Kg Fine Aggregate: For 16 cylinder = 3.3432 Kg Super plasticizer:

Sp=1.5 to 2 % of the total cement. SP= 1.65% * 3.3936 = 53 ml

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Experiment

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Curing

Water 25 days

Oven 3days
Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Transportation

To protect sample against air moisture


Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Air permeability device

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Line diagram for the oxygen permeability apparatus

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

The Permeability Cell

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Permeability
Permeability Coefficient (m/sec) Driving Force Pressure head (m)

h Q k A l
Volume Flow Rate (m3/sec) Cross Section (m2/sec) Flow Path i.e. specimen thickness (m) Pressure head gradient

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

0%
Volum P e t1 t2 t3 t_averag (bar) V(cc) (sec) (sec) (sec) (sec) 1.5 2 2.5 10 10 10 0.24 0.24 0.24 0.11 0.11 0.11 0.6 0.6 0.6 0.24 0.11 0.6 Q m3/sec A m2 l m h m 1.5 2 2.5 K m/sec 3.14388E-05 5.14454E-05 7.54532E-06 3.01432E-05

4.16667E-05 0.017671 0.02 9.09091E-05 0.017671 0.02 1.66667E-05 0.017671 0.02

7.5%
P Volume t1 (bar) V(cc) (sec) t2 (sec) t3 (sec) Q A l m3/sec m2 m 1.47131E- 0.01767 6.796667 06 1 0.02 3.56295E- 0.01767 2.806667 06 1 0.02 6.14754E- 0.01767 1.626667 06 1 0.02 t_averag (sec) h m

K m/sec

1.5
2 2.5

10
10 10

6.8
2.8 1.6

6.82
2.82 1.65

6.77
2.8 1.63

1.5
2 2.5

1.11015E-06
2.01627E-06 2.78311E-06 1.96984E-06

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

10%
P Volume t1 (bar) V(cc) (sec) 1.5 2 2.5 10 10 10 11.5 5.21 2.23 t2 (sec) t3 t_averag (sec) (sec) Q m3/sec A m2 l m h m K m/sec

11.5 11.52 11.50667 8.69061E-07 0.017671 0.02 1.5 6.55735E-07 5.23 2.31 5.25 5.23 1.91205E-06 0.017671 0.02 2 1.08202E-06

2.32 2.286667 4.37318E-06 0.017671 0.02 2.5 1.97982E-06 1.23919E-06

12.5%
P (bar) 1.5 2 2.5 Volume V(cc) 5 5 5 t1 (sec) 18.54 8.82 5.41 t2 (sec) 19.12 8.68 5.4 t3 (sec) 19.4 8.79 5.41 Q A l m3/sec m2 m 2.62881E19.02 07 0.017671 0.02 5.70559E8.763333 07 0.017671 0.02 9.24784E5.406667 07 0.017671 0.02 t_averag (sec) h m 1.5 2 2.5 K m/sec 1.98347E07 3.2287E-07 4.18657E07 3.13291E-07 Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

3.50E-05

3.00E-05
2.50E-05 K (m/s) 2.00E-05 1.50E-05 1.00E-05 5.00E-06 0.00E+00 0 2 4 6 % Silica Fume 8 10 12 14

The silica fume will effect on the permeability as shown in the chart, when the quantity of silica fume increase the permeability will decrease.
Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

The split cylinder test. The permeability test. The bending test. The flexural test.
Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Beam Design
Design of RC Section Requires Determination of: 1. Concrete Dimensions
Beam width b Depth of steel reinforcement d Section height h = d + cover-to-center of steel

2. Area of steel reinforcement As


3. Ensure safety requirements (As) min As (As) max
Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Beam Design
Step 1: Assume Concrete Dimensions (Beam width & Section height) and Section Length
Beam width b = 100 mm Section height h = 250 mm Section Length L = 1.8 m

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Beam Design
Step 2: Estimate Beam Height According to ACI Deflection Requirements

hmin = L/16 = 1800 / 16 = 113 mm hb = 250 mm > 113 mm

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Beam Design
Step 3: Assume bar size No. 10

For bar size No. 10, db = 9.5 mm


Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Beam Design
Step 4: Calculate depth of steel reinforcement (d)
Cover = concrete cover to steel center cc = clear concrete cover (20 mm for beams) ds = diameter of stirrups (bar size # 10) db = diameter of steel bar (bar size # 10)

Hence, Cover = cc + ds + db/2 = 20 + 9.5 + 9.5/2 = 34 mm

d = h - cover = 250 - 34 = 216 mm

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Beam Design
Step 5: Assume grade of a steel reinforcing bar & area of steel reinforcement As Grade 420 (i.e. fy = 420 MPa) is the most commonly used steel Use 2 bars No. 10 (As = 142 mm2) Step 6: Compute steel ratio ()

As bd

= 142 / (100 * 216) = 0.00658

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Beam Design
Step 7: Ensure safety requirements () min () max

m in

1.4 fy Greater of fc' 4 fy

m ax (0.75 )

0.85 1 fc ' 600 ( ) fy 600 fy


for fc ' 30 MPa

1 1.06 0.007 fc '

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Beam Design
Step 7: Ensure safety requirements () min () max For fc' = 61.33 MPa 0.00466 0.03559

For fc' = 78.7 MPa


For fc' = 85.17 MPa For fc' = 90 MPa

0.00528 0.04567
0.00549 0.04943 0.00565 0.05223

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Experiment

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Strain Gauges

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Pouring the Concrete

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

The Smooth Concrete Surface

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Comparison of 0%, 7.5%, 10%, and 12.5% Silica Fume


70

60

50

Load (kN)

40

0% Silica Fume 7.5% Silica Fume 10% Silica Fume 12.5% Silica Fume

30

20

10

0 0 2,000 4,000 6,000 8,000 10,000 Strain 12,000 14,000 16,000 18,000 20,000

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Comparison of 0%, 7.5%, 10%, and 12.5% Silica Fume after 28 days
70

60

50

Load (kN)

40

0% Silica Fume 7.5% Silica Fume 10% Silica Fume 12.5% Silica Fume

30

20

10

0 0 2,000 4,000 6,000 8,000 10,000 Strain 12,000 14,000 16,000 18,000 20,000

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

The split cylinder test. The permeability test. The bending test. The flexural test.
Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

What is Flexural Strength ?

One measure of the tensile strength. Measure of an unreinforced concrete. Loading beams with tow concentrated load.

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Beam Details

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Flexural Strength Experimentally

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Flexural Strength Theoretically

fcu = 1.25 fc
fc = 0.8 fcu fr = 0.7 (0.8 fcu)

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Theoretical Load

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

cm d1(cm) d2(cm) L(cm) 15 15 50

mm 150 150 500

m 0.15 0.15 0.5

V(m3)

0.01125 0.07875

For 7 beams

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Our Trial Mix Data


Water content for 7 beams = 200 x V Cement content for 7 beams = 606 x V

Coarse Aggregate for 7 beams = 912 x V Grade 10_14 = 30% Grade 5_10 = 70%

Fine Aggregate for 7 beams = 597 x V Dune sand = 20% Black sand = 80 %

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Our Trial Mix Data

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Preparing

Weighting

Mixing

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

58

Mixing

Prism Preparing

Concrete casting

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

59

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

60

Concrete Compression Machine


Consist of: Two supporting rollers Two load-applying rollers Steel with circular cross-section Diameter of 20 mm to 40 mm At least 10 mm longer

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Doing the Experiment

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Doing the Experiment

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Doing the Experiment

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Result

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Result
Time Vs F
50 45 40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 Time ( Days )

F ( KN )

0% 7.50% 10% 12.50%

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Result

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Result
Time Vs F
7 6.5 6 5.5 5 4.5 4 3.5 3 2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 Time ( Days )

fr ( MPa )

0% 7.50% 10% 12.50%

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Comparison

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Conclusion
All the tests results were very encouraging. Adding the silica fume to any concrete mixture will enhance the properties of the concrete far beyond its initial properties.

Increasing the amount of silica fume will result in enhancing the concrete properties.
Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Conclusion
The silica fume is a very promising industry in the future. For the next semester it is recommended for one of the GPI groups to investigate the influence of fly ash on concrete and compare it with our results.

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Silica Fume influence on RC Beams Behavior Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering

Вам также может понравиться