Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
RAN6.0
HSUPA Ph1 (1.44) HSDPA Ph3 (7.2) MBMS step1
RAN10 (RAN7.0)
HSUPA Ph2 (5.8) HSDPA Ph4 (14.4) MBMS Ph2
RAN5.1
HSDPA Ph2 (3.6) Iub over IP
RAN6.1
Iu/Iur over IP
RAN11 (RAN8.0)
HSPA+ Ph1
RAN12
HSPA+ Ph2
1Q 2Q 3Q 4Q 1Q 2Q 3Q 4Q 1Q 2Q 3Q 4Q 1Q 2Q 3Q 4Q 1Q 2Q 3Q 4Q 1Q 2Q 3Q 4Q
2008
Rumours around HSUPA 5.8 delays
2009
Knock-on effect? Originally 12 month release distance between RAN10 and RAN11 (and between RAN11 and RAN12)
2010
Spain, Hungary, Romania, Greece, Iceland Poland, Belgium, Romania, Slovakia, Moldova, Egypt
Australia, Czech Republic, France, Germany, Ireland Italy, Malta, New Zealand, Poland
France, Poland, Spain, Switzerland, UK, Egypt Austria, Croatia, Czech Republic, Germany, Netherlands, Poland, UK, USA Italy, Brazil, Argentina, Greece (now Wind) Germany, Mexico, Argentina, Chile, Brazil, UK, Spain, Ireland, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Colombia, Ecuador, Panama, Peru Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Mexico, Paraguay, Uruguay Russia incl. Moscow Saudi Arabia, Nigeria
None
Italy, Brazil
Brazil, Peru, Ecuador, Jamaica Russia incl. St. Petersburg UAE, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Nigeria
RNC450
RNC2600
OR
OR
Upgrade package
Secured investment with upgradeability Easy IP transport upgradeability RNC450 upgrade path to RNC2600
BBU3900 Baseband Box (8 slots for GSM, WCDMA, HSPA+ LTE, cards)
Smooth and extremely power efficient multiradio evolution GSM/WCDMA/LTE Concurrent mode operation (e.g. WCDMA/GSM) No capacity limitation based on running out of free slots for PIU Capacity and feature upgrade with SW
Huawei 4th gen. BTS is not future proof cabinet based solution with a lot of different cabinets and plug in units Huawei BBU3900 8 PIU slots frame always needs a cabinet both in OD and ID use RRU3908 RRU3804 RRU3004 RRU3008 Huawei 4th gen. BTS comprises of different RF / Multimode RRU WCDMA/LTE RRU GSM RRU BB plug in units and RRUs for different radio standards and is clearly missing a multiple sector RF module Huawei 4th gen. macro BTS not able to catch up in power consumption even with Flexi Rel.1 HW
ID Macro Cabinet
OD RF Cabinet
APM30
OD Mini Cabinet
daughter cards
600 mm
WCDMA/LTE capable in concurrent mode operation Seamless SW defined capacity upgrade No site visits, no spare part handling Extremely cost efficient approach
BBU3900 is just an indoor baseband frame that offers installation space for BB submodules Several different cards to support different radio standards (dedicated for GSM, HSPA+ 1, HSDPA+ 2, LTE) Protective cabinet always necessary Costly site visits, baseband logistics, spare part management,
APM30
450 mm
700 mm
NSN Flexi Platform System Module WCDMA, HSDPA, HSUPA, additional BB capacity, HSPA+ and LTE with SW only
WCDMA/LTE System Module (FSMD)
Flexi BTS Platform SW upgradeability reduces site visits by 2-15 times and requires up to 2 times less spare parts compared to Huawei
WRFU RF Unit
RRU3804 RF Unit
RAN6.1
Major Features
Clock over IP Iu/Iur over IP (for BSC6810) GE port UBR+ (for BSC6810)
RAN6.0
Major Features
Hub Node B (AAL2 switching) Iub IP Phase 2: ->DHCP ->VLAN ->PPP-Mux ATM/IP Dual Stack Node-B
RAN10.0
Major Features
IP transmission enhancement for BSC6810 Dynamic Bandwidth control IP transmission enhancement for Node B
RAN11.0
Major Features
IEEE 1588v2
HW Upgrade needed! Nokia Siemens supports this in RU10 with Dual Iub via SW UPGRADE !
Nokia Siemens brings Timing over Packet (IEEE1588v2) with Flexi FTIB in RU10 ! Huawei Solution delayed!
RAS06
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2
RU10
Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
2006
2007
2008
2009
Huawei
Long term experience with active participation to Std. (IEEE1588v2) First supplier with standardized solution on market Open market and leading industry alliances created for E2E Multi Vendor solutions Compatible for next Generation networks (WiMAX & LTE) Increased accuracy and less sensitive to bad ETH quality Works in all types of Packet networks (incl. IP/Ethernet)
Short term focus Proprietary solution creates supplier Lock-In Not Multi-Vendor network compatible Working only for 2G & 3G Working only with IP L3 networks Clock over IP Requires high quality Ethernet between Master & slave
Huawei HSUPA throughput is limited. Cat3 application layer theoretical maximum 1.17 Mbps
Stationary tests evaluated (drive tests done, but transmission capacity of different sites were often too low and took the results of each vendor clearly down) In tested European networks, NSN provides the fastest DL speeds
Avg DL speed
Huawei is behind!
2650 2600 2550 2500 2450 2400 2350 Avg DL speed 2458 2452 NSN Huawei Ericsson 2639
Stationary tests evaluated In drive tests NSNs higher HSUPA rates clearly seen (2.0 vs 1.45 Mbps)
Huawei is behind!
NSN has 30-40% lower latency than Live network measurement Live network 2008 Huawei today
NSN has 30% lower latency in live RNC-based HSPA network than Huawei See details on next slide
120 100 80 ms 60 40 20 0 Ping 32 B 69 95 NSN HUAWEI
Major operator measurement NSN has 40% lower latency in live RNC-based HSPA network than Huawei NSN is working on additional latency evolution in I-HSPA and in RNC
Latency <45 ms can be achieved with existing RNC HW and optimized SW on top 20 0 RAS06 Latency <30 ms with HSUPA 2 ms TTI
Majority of HSPA sessions are more sensitive to latency than to data rate"
Ping 32 B
305
NSN HSPA latency is clearly better to Huawei Huawei latency with 1400B is really bad, possible reason RLC ReTxs
NSN Huawei
Ping 1400B
NSN provides the best HSPA latency (also against Ericsson) Latency impacts directly application performance
For each measurement case, the good radio conditions used KPIs monitored: EcNo, RSCP, CQI Only when the above matched, results taken into account In each test location each web page downloaded 20 times over HSDPA/HSUPA NSN always faster, regardless of content size and location Huawei download times were slowest with small to medium size pages
Pictext 512kB
Pictext 1MB
google.com
Large size pages: Pictext 512 kB and Pictext 1 MB (HTTP test server in Finland) Small size page: www.google.com 5.7 kB Medium size page: www.poland.pl/education/index.htm 25 kB (popular polish page)
Huawei HSPA, findings in the field Huawei HSPA performance suffers from excessive amount of RLC reTxs measurements
NSN HSPA RLC reTx rate
6 NSN http
Huawei HSPA has excessive amount of RLC re-transmissions (reTxs). RLC reTxs impact latency and throughput Huaweis choice of implementation explains the unwanted RLC reTxs, for example: Huawei outer loop PC for HSUPA may not work very well, causing unnecessary RLC reTxs. Lack of congestion control on Iub in Huawei HSUPA could also cause additional RLC reTxs.
5 4 3 2 1 0 1 183 365 547 729 911 1093 1275 1457 1639 1821 2003 2185 RLC retransmission rate
Huaw ei http
0 1 245 489 733 977 1221 1465 1709 1953 2197 2441 2685 2929
Huawei has limited HSPA functionality Huawei has limited HSUPA service area
Figure from public Huawei conference paper Evolution towards HSPA and beyond
Huawei cannot have non HSUPA cells in the active set => fallback to DCH NSN stays on HSUPA as long as possible => maximum HSUPA service area
HSUPA
E-DCH
Non HSUPA
DCH
Non HSUPA
DCH
Non HSUPA
DCH
SF=64
SF=128
Rel-99 channels
AMR voice call released AMR voice call released RNC re-arranges two AMR codes, to make room for new HSDPA code.
HSDPA
AMR code HSDPA code
NSN code tree optimisation feature maximises available HSDPA codes => better throughput
NSN has unique 2G/3G functionalities and market leading implementation Fully fledged load based handovers Highest amount of ISHO triggers guarantee QoE
NSN do full scope IOT and MVI, only MVI MVI pre-IOTHuaweiIOT
Purpose Verify interoperability of NW SW under development with selected other vendor new NW SW (under development) E2+-E3 SW New SW under development Verify interoperability of new NW SW with released/launch ready other vendor NW SW according to market requirements E3-(E4)E5, E5-+10months/E5(n+1) Latest released SW/new SW to be released Other Vendor Selection Criteria -Customer requirement -Other vendor capability (2) -Technical value & feasibility (1) -Market share -Strategic & business reasons Strategy -Selected advanced major vendors focusing on new strategic features or business reasons -Customer requirement (1) -Other vendor capability -Technical value & feasibility -Market share -Strategic & business reasons (2) -Selected vendors according to customer requirements for customer case with more than one particular configuration -Customer selected vendors -Customer requirement (1) E5-E10 (Latest) released SW Verify interoperability of released NW SW to be used in customer network
Responsibility/
driver
NSN has run pre-IOT and IOT processes with all network and terminal vendors over 10 years, which guarantees best-in-class interoperability for all customers. Huawei doesnt have the same processes in place and lack experience Huawei customers will suffer from end-user quality issues