Loans to Directors Section 185 No company shall give loan, provide guarantee/ security to Director/ persons connected with Director Persons connected with Director: a) any director of the lending company, or of a company which is its holding company or any partner or relative of any such director; b) any firm in which any such director or relative is a partner; c) any private company of which any such director is a director or member; d) any body corporate at a general meeting of which not less than twenty-five per cent of the total voting power may be exercised or controlled by any such director, or by two or more such directors, together; or e) any body corporate, the Board of directors, managing director or manager, whereof is accustomed to act in accordance with the directions or instructions of the Board, or of any director or directors, of the lending company.
Private Companies are also covered
Two possible interpretation of Save as otherwise provided in the Act Section 185 not applicable to transactions permitted under Section 186(2) Will render Section 185 redundant Section 185 is prohibitory in nature and a code in itself. Permission u/s 186 available only for loans/ guarantee not otherwise prohibited u/s 185 Accustomed to act in accordance with the directions or instructions Regular or usual practice of issuing directions or instructions by the Board or Director of lending company Directions or instructions are followed by the Board of receiving entity
Exemptions Loans may be provided to MD/WTD as a policy for employees; or pursuant to scheme approved by special resolution Loans by company in its ordinary course of its business at a rate not less than the Bank Rate declared by RBI Loans/ guarantee/ security by holding company to its Wholly Owned Subsidiary Guarantee/ Security by holding company to its subsidiary is exempted Provided Loans are utilized by subsidiary for its principle business activities
Ordinary course of its business Complex test for determination Memorandum of Association may be decisive Transaction is in furtherance of the business objectives and has close proximity with the normal business of the company Recurring in nature - Previous instances to demonstrate that such activity is customary
Negative Test Transaction should not be of extraordinary or unusual nature
Loans, investments, guarantee - Section 186(2) Company can: a) Give loan to any person or body corporate b) Give guarantee or security in connection with Loan to any body corporate or person c) Acquire securities of any other body corporate upto 60% of share capital, free reserves and securities premium or 100% of reserves and securities premium with approval of the Board
Unanimous resolution at the Board meeting for loan, investment, guarantee or security Private companies are also covered Interest on loan not lower than G-sec
Prior Special Resolution required for loans, investment etc. exceeding the limit Special Resolution not required In respect of loans, investment, guarantee etc. to Wholly Owned Subsidiary/ Joint Venture company In respect of acquisition by holding company of securities of Wholly Owned Subsidiary However, such loans guarantee/ securities will be counted for calculating the limit, unlike earlier Section 372A
Special resolution to specify cap on loans, guarantee, security etc. Special resolution by existing companies To be passed within one year from notification i.e. by 31/03/2015 Particulars of loans, investment etc including the purpose of utilization by recipient to be disclosed in financial statement Company which has defaulted in repayment of Deposits or interest thereon are not eligible to give loan or provide guarantee/ security till default is subsisting Register to be maintained in Form MBP 2 (For entries after 1 st April, 2014)
Transaction Whether Section 185 or 186 attracted? 185 186* Loans to employees as a part of company policy (except MD/WTD) No Loans, guarantee, security by holding to wholly owned subsidiary No Yes But Special Resolution not required Loans by holding to subsidiary (If not connected to Director in anyway) No Special Resolution, if it exceeds limit Corporate Guarantee by holding company for term loan by subsidiary No (Rule 10) Special Resolution, if it exceeds limit Corporate Guarantee by holding company for Bank/ Performance Guarantee by subsidiary No No Related Party Transactions [Section 188] Approval of Board at a meeting required for following Related Party Transactions: Sale/ buy of goods or supply of services Sale/ buy any property Leasing of any property Appointment of any agent for purchase/ sale of goods etc. Appointment to any office or place of profit in company, its subsidiary or associate Underwriting of share or debentures
Approval of Audit Committee for all transaction with Related Party {Section 177(4)}
Conditions to enter into RPTs: Board Agenda shall disclose, names of related parties, material terms including value, nature/ duration of contract etc Director shall not be present at the meeting during discussions All RPTs to be reported in Board Report with justification Contracts entered without approval of Board or shareholders and ratified within 3 months Voidable at option of Board Prior approval of shareholders by Special Resolution: Company with share capital of Rs. 10 Cr or more Sale, purchase of goods & material exceeding 25% of turnover Selling, buying of any property exceeding 10% of net worth or 10% of turnover Lease contracts above 10% of networth or 10% of turnover Availing or rendering of Services exceeding 10% of networth Appointment to place of profit in company, subsidiary or associate at remuneration above Rs. 2.5 Lac p.m.
Turnover or networth calculated as per last audited financial statement Related Party shall not vote on the transaction Special Resolution by Holding Company will be sufficient for entering into transaction with its Wholly Owned Subsidiary
Exemption Transactions entered in the ordinary course of business and at arms length Ordinary course of business - Refer discussion u/s 185
Arms length transaction between related parties conducted as if they were unrelated so that there is no conflict of interest Transfer pricing methods may be adopted Three stage compliances Transaction in ordinary course and at arms length Audit Committee Board Shareholders Below or above threshold X X Transactions not in the ordinary course or not at arms length Below threshold X Above threshold
Posers Illustrative list of transactions Whether Section 188 attracted? Providing loans, guarantee etc. to subsidiary No Equity contribution by holding in subsidiary No Leasing of premises/ Using joint premises Yes. Exempted if in the ordinary course of business Existing contract for 5 years No. Can continue till full tenure. Material contracts by listed company - Till first general meeting after 1 st October, 2014 if transaction is likely to continue beyond 31 st
March, 2015 Purchase of shares by KMP through Stock Exchanges No Appointment of Managing Director No Way out to comply with Section 188 Documents relating to past transactions Ordinary course of business Documents relating to pricings - Arms length Shared services Agreement Proper documentations like Lease Deeds/ Agreements for transactions with Related Party Policy frame work with terms of transactions for normal business transactions may be approved by Audit Committee Master Service Agreement to avail services/ goods instead of placing separate PO A related party transaction is a transfer of resources, services or obligations between a company and a related party, regardless of whether a price is charged
Parties are related if one party; Controls the other Exercises significant influence over the other Is a related party under Section 2(76) Is a key management personnel of the Company or of a parent company
An entity is related to a company if any of the following conditions applies: a) The entity and the company are members of the same group b) One entity is an associate or joint venture of the other entity c) Both entities are joint ventures of the same third party. d) Two entities are JV and associate, respectively of a third entity e) The entity is a post-employment benefit plan for the benefit of employees of either the reporting entity or an entity related to the reporting entity
Clause 49 of Listing Agreement [w.e.f. 1/10/2014] Listing Agreement Companies Act 2013 Wider definition of Related Party covering close family members, fellow group companies etc. Close relatives, companies in which Directors are interested, holding & subsidiary company etc. All RPTs to require prior approval of Audit Committee Approval or subsequent modification to all RPTs All material RPTs to be approved by shareholders through special resolution and related parties to abstain from voting Approval of RPTs exceeding prescribed threshold by special resolution and related parties to abstain from voting Company to formulate policy on material related party transactions and dealing with RPTs (Transaction(s) individually or collectively entered during FY exceeds 5% or turnover or 20% of net worth of company) - Policy on dealing with RPTs to be disclosed on website and also in Annual Report - Material RPTs to be disclosed to Stock Exchanges on quarterly basis alongwith CG Report All RPT to be reported in Board Report with justification Thank you Notifica tion not made public Section 2(76) Related party with reference to company means: Director, KMP or their relative Firm in which a director, manager or his relative is a partner Private company in which a director or manager is a member or director Public company in which a director or manager is a director and holds alongwith his relatives, more than 2% of its paid-up share capital Body corporate whose BOD, MD or manager is accustomed to act in accordance with advice, directions or instructions of a director or manager (except services provided in professional capacity) Any person under whose advice, directions or instructions (except services provided in professional capacity) of director or manager is accustomed to act Company which is; Holding, subsidiary or an associate company of such company Fellow subsidiary Director, KMP of holding company or his relative Section 2(77) Relative includes members of HUF and following relationship: Self & Spouse Father & Mother Children (Son/ Daughter) & their spouse Brother & sister