Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
As early as 1215 the English people extracted an assurance from King John for respect of their ancient liberties. The Magna-Carta is an evidence of their success which is a written document. Thereafter the King had to accede many rights to his subjects. In 1689 the bill of rights was enacted consolidating all basic right and liberties of English Citizens.
In
1789,
France
ordained
the
Declaration
of
Rights
of
Man
and
Citizen
which
declared
the
inalienable
sacred
rights
of
every
man.
In
1789,
the
American
Congress
also
incorporated
the
Bill
of
Rights
into
its
constitution.
The framers of the Indian Constitution, incorporated the Bill of Rights as a background for a whole chapter, that elaborately states that certain rights are inviolable under all conditions and cannot be interfered with by the legislature of the country. They are Fundamental Rights which are in accordance with the idea of a modern democratic thought, to preserve the condition of free right.
Definition
Fundamental Rights are assurance the every citizens has the right to liberties which are basic in nature for the harmonious growth of an individual and society. They are inviolable and cannot be interfered with through an amendment by the legislature of the country. Every law hence made should be in accordance with Fundamental Rights of every citizens, any law made that is violating fundamental is declared null and unenforceable. The vision of the framers
was to unite the people of the country, and is guaranteed to all irrespective of religion, caste, creed, place of birth, race or place of birth. There are seven fundamental rights which are right to equality, right to freedom, right to life, right to constitutional remedies, cultural and educational rights, right to life, right to exploitation, right to freedom of religion.
West
Virginia
State
Board
of
Education
vs.
Barnette
The action of a state made it compulsory for children to salute the flag of America and recite the allegiance pledge failing which could result in expulsion. A group of Jehovahs witness argued that forced flag salute conflicts with their religious beliefs against idol worship and engraved images which is thereby a violation of their first amendments rights. The Court that the compulsory rule violated the first and fourteenth amendment by compelling students.
The
court
reasoned
that
Chairman
authority
is
to
of
be
controlled
by
Railway
public
opinion
and
Board
not
public
vs.
opinion
by
authority.
Chandrima
Das,
Chandrima Das an advocate of the Calcutta High Court filed a petition against several members of the Railways including the Chairman of the Railways Board, demanding compensation for Smt. Hannuffa Khatun who was gangraped by employees of the railways. She was awarded a compensation of Rupees 10 lacs by the High Court, this was challenged by the appellants under the several grounds including the fact that there was no violation of
fundamental rights. But the court observed that rape was in fact the most heinous of crimes as it includes an emotional crises and a psychological destruction of the victim. It also held that certain rights are applicable to every person in the country which includes citizens and foreign nationals who come here for tourist or other purposes which is in accordance with Universal Declaration of Human Rights. The supreme court upheld the decision of the High
Court
and
ordered
compensation
Need
to
be
given
for
to
the
victim.
Fundamental
Rights
Fundamental Rights are essential for preserving and maintaining the union between a state and its citizens. It guarantees to the citizens certain inviolable personal liberties that cannot be meddled with by the state. There is a need for such fundamental to protect them from the actions of the state. The reasons for the need of fundamental rights are as follows:
1.Rule
of
Law-This
2.
Consequence
3.
Quantification
of
of
states
long
that
the
freedom
Freedom-This
is
law
guaranteeing
struggle-The
a
measurement
fundamental
citizens
of
of
how
the
free
the
rights
country
citizens
is
supreme
had
of
been
the
and
every
living
in
country
truly
government
subjugation
are.
For
for
example
body
a
must
very
people
adhere
long
living
in
strictly
time
the
with
on
Gulf
the
countries
them.
whims
also
This
of
have
is
the
to
protect
British
fundamental
the
Govt.
rights
but
citizens
These
these
from
rights
rights
any
transgressions
renewed
don't
extend
the
upto
on
beliefs
freedom
the
part
of
the
of
religion.
of
people
The
the
government.
to
citizens
hope.
This
of
China
No
person
brings
don't
or
body
is
sense
of
have
freedom
of
above
fulfilment
right
these
rights.
and
satisfaction.
expression
and
speech.
nt. Thereafter the King had to accede many rights to his subjects. In 1689 the bill of rights was enacted consolidating all basic right and liberties of English Citizens.
State
State has been defined in the Indian Constitution under Article 12. The term state includes the the Government and Parliament of India and the Government and Legislature of each of the states. It also includes all local and or other forms of authority under the control of the Government of India. They are statutory and non statutory bodies that receive financial assistance from the government and have deep pervasive of control of government functions. There
are certain essential conditions that need to met before pronouncing a state agency or instrument as a state. They are 1. Financial resources of the state being the chief source of funding. 2. Functional nature should be one that is to be carried out by the government. 3. Plenary control residing with the government. 4. Prior history of the same activity having been carried on by government and made over to the new body. 5. Some element of authority or
command.
as
State
It is not explicitly mentioned in Article 12 of the Constitution whether judiciary is considered a part of the state. Hence, there is some reason for debate. It is well established that for non judicial functions, the judiciary is to be considered a state. But for Judicial decisions which have reached their finality could be challenged through a writ on the basis of violation of fundamental rights is open to debate.
Doctrine of Ejusdem Generis : The literal meaning of this is of the same kind. It is used as a method of statutory interpretation. It is applicable when a general term of wide scope is followed by specific terms with restrictive interpretation. There are certain conditions that need to be fulfilled in order for this doctrine to be valid. 1. The specific term should be followed by the general term. 2. The specific terms should fall under a class or group. 3. The category
hence
formed
should
not
be
exhaustive
and
should
not
be
against
the
legislative
intent
while
using
this
principle.
cannot be interfered with by the legislature of the country. They are Fundamental Rights which are in accordance with the idea of a modern democratic thought, to preserve the condition of free right.
Rajasthan
State
Electricity
Board
vs.
Mohanlal
The board argued that it was a corporate body and could not be put under the ambit of Article 12 under the grounds that under the doctrine of ejusdem generis, the common class or genus includes only those bodies carrying out governmental functions. The court rejected this argument under the grounds that there is no common class or genus running through article 12. Justice Shah concurred in the Judgement but differed on the reasoning, he believed that any
authority carrying sovereign powers of a state. The Board has invested in controlling electrical undertakings thereby fixing tariffs, issue directions for maximum economy and efficiency.
ot be interfered with through an amendment by the legislature of the country. Every law hence made should be in accordance with Fundamental Rights of every citizens, any law made that is violating fundamental i
ued that forced flag salute conflicts with their religious beliefs against idol worship and engraved images which is thereby a violation of their first amendments rights. The Court that the compulsory rule violated the f
n for Smt. Hannuffa Khatun who was gangraped by employees of the railways. She was awarded a compensation of Rupees 10 lacs by the High Court, this was challenged by the appellants under the several gro
or other purposes which is in accordance with Universal Declaration of Human Rights. The supreme court upheld the decision of the High Court and ordered compensation to be given to the victim.
eddled with by the state. There is a need for such fundamental to protect them from the actions of the state. The reasons for the need of fundamental rights are as follows:
gressions on the part of the government. No person or body is above these rights.
tates. It also includes all local and or other forms of authority under the control of the Government of India. They are statutory and non statutory bodies that receive financial assistance from the government and have
rior history of the same activity having been carried on by government and made over to the new body. 5. Some element of authority or command.
dicial functions, the judiciary is to be considered a state. But for Judicial decisions which have reached their finality could be challenged through a writ on the basis of violation of fundamental rights is open to debate
wed by specific terms with restrictive interpretation. There are certain conditions that need to be fulfilled in order for this doctrine to be valid. 1. The specific term should be followed by the general term. 2. The speci
includes only those bodies carrying out governmental functions. The court rejected this argument under the grounds that there is no common class or genus running through article 12. Justice Shah concurred in th